Jaca, T.P. et al. Taxonomic studies of the genus Rhynchosia Lour. (Phaseoleae, Fabaceae) in
South Africa: A review of section Chrysoscias.
South African Journal of Botany, 117: 119 – 133.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.sajb.2018.05.012
Taxonomic studies of the genus Rhynchosia Lour. (Phaseoleae,
Fabaceae) in South Africa: A review of section Chrysoscias
T.P. Jaca, J.S. Boatwright and A.N. Moteetee
Abstract
Background: A taxonomic study of the genus Rhynchosia section Chrysoscias is
presented. The section (as classified by Baker) comprises five taxa (four species
and one variety). Previous revisions of the section by various botanists placed
emphasis on leaflet shape and number of flowers as the primary characters to
distinguish the species, however, these characters were found to be highly
variable even within species. In addition, species distribution overlaps and
therefore no conclusions can be made based on distribution patterns.
Objectives: The aim of this paper is to provide diagnostic features of the four
species of the section recognised in the current study, a key to the species,
correct nomenclature, complete synonymy, typification, description,
distribution maps as well as habitat notes.
Methodology: We studied herbarium specimens housed at BOL, JRAU, PRE, and
those loaned from NBG (including SAM) supplemented by extensive field work.
Morphological features were studied; measurements of characters recorded and
illustrations were drawn using a camera lucida attachment. Anatomical and
scanning electron microscopy studies were also carried out.
Results: The current study revealed that there are four species in this
section: Rhynchosia angustifolia, R. chrysoscias, R. leucoscias and R. microscias.
The distribution and type of trichomes, degree of fusion in the uppermost calyx
lobes and size of the standard petal are important taxonomic characters for
distinguishing between the species. Leaflet shape can only be used in
distinguishing R. angustifolia from the other species. The section is restricted to
the Core Cape Subregion of the Greater Cape Region of South Africa.
Conclusion: Four species are recognised, Rhynchosia angustifolia, R. chrysoscias,
R. leucoscias and R. microscias. R. leucoscias var. angustifolia is here synonymised
with R. angustifolia and the latter name is preserved to take Jacquin's earlier
name of Glycine angustifolia referring to the narrow leaflets. The distributions
and types of trichomes are reported here for the first time.
1. Introduction
The genus Rhynchosia Lour. (commonly known as snout bean) belongs to the
subtribe Cajaninae, tribe Phaseoleae, in the family Fabaceae. The genus is the
University of the Western Cape Research Repository
t.jaca@sanbi.org.za
largest in the subtribe, comprising about 232 species distributed throughout the
tropics and subtropics, and extending to North America from Mexico to some
parts of the United States as well as Africa and Madagascar where it is most
diverse (Schrire, 2005; Turner, 2011). About 73 species are native to southern
Africa, with one species [R. phaseoloides (Sw.) Kuntze] cultivated in the region
(Germishuizen et al., 2006; Glen, 2002; Schrire, 2005; Moteetee and Le Roux,
2016). Within Cajaninae, Rhynchosia is closely related to the genus Eriosema
(DC.) G.Don. (Moteetee et al., 2012), sharing mostly pinnately trifoliolate leaves
which are prominently-veined underneath, yellow flowers, and generally 2-seeded
fruits. The mode of funicular attachment of the seed in relation to the hilum is the
only distinguishing character between these two genera (Grear and Dengler,
1976; Moteetee and Van Wyk, 2006). In Eriosema the funicular attachment is at
the end of the hilum whereas in Rhynchosia the attachment is centric or subcentric
(Ramcharan et al., 1973). Rhynchosia is also closely related to Bolusafra Kuntze and
Flemingia Roxb. ex W.T.Aiton (Lackey, 1981; Verdcourt, 2001; Moteetee and Van
Wyk, 2006). Rhynchosia is similar to Bolusafra in that they both have similar
growth habit (twining), pinnately trifoliolate leaves with conspicuous veins
generally covered with glands beneath and yellow flowers. Rhynchosia is also
similar to Flemingia in growth form, leaves covered with glands beneath, yellow
flowers and two-seeded fruits. Rhynchosia differs from Bolusafra in that the
latter has prominent seed arils and turgid fruits as opposed to obsolete or almost
absent seed arils in the South African species of Rhynchosia and laterally
compressed fruits (with the exception of Rhynchosia section Chrysoscias where
fruits can be slightly turgid) which are often falcate (Verdcourt, 2001; Moteetee
and Van Wyk, 2006). Flemingia may be distinguished from Rhynchosia by its
digitately trifoliolate leaves and the very turgid fruits (Verdcourt, 2001).
De Candolle (1825) described a number (21) of South African species of Rhynchosia,
followed by Ecklon and Zeyher (1836) who described 11 species. Thereafter,
sectional classification of South(ern) African species was introduced by various
authors, in most cases with little overlap (summarised in Table 1). Meyer (1836)
distributed his 19 species in sections Orthodanum E. Mey. (2 spp.) and Copisma E.
Mey. (17 spp.). Harvey (1862) divided the South African species into four sections:
Chrysoscias Benth. (4 spp.), Polytropia (Presl.) Harv. (2 spp.), Orthodanum E. Mey.
(5 spp.) and Copisma E. Mey. (20 spp.). In their classification, Bentham and Hooker
(1865) placed the southern African species into five of their eleven sections:
Orthodanum (3 spp. – Harvey's section Chrysoscias), Chrysoscias (2 spp. – Harvey's
section Polytropia), Cyanospermum (Wight and Arnott) Benth. (1 sp.), Polytropia (2
spp.), and Copisma (4 spp.). Baker (1871) divided the southern African species into
three sections: Cyanospermum (2 spp.), Copisma (3 spp.) and Arcyphyllum Torrey and
Gray (1 sp.). Baker (1923) recognised 59 species in the genus; he based his
classification mainly on Harvey (1862) and Baker (1871) in preserving Arcyphyllum,
Cyanospermum, Chrysoscias, and Polytropia, but then lumped all of Orthodanum
and Copisma into his type section Eurhynchosia (correctly known as section
2
Rhynchosia). A revised sectional classification will be finalised once molecular studies
have been completed (Manyelo, 2014). Based on the ongoing studies of the South
African species of the genus, sect. Cyanospermum remains with one species (Moteetee
et al., 2012) while one new species has been added to sect. Polytropia (Moteetee et
al., 2014). Sect. Chrysoscias is the subject of the current study.
3
4
The name Chrysoscias is derived from the Greek words “chryso” for golden and
“scias” for shade-loving plant. Species in this section are characterised by golden
glands on the leaf surface and fruits, and golden bulbous-based hairs that are
variably distributed on the stems, leaflets, calyces, and sometimes on the pods;
they are mostly found creeping or twining in shady places although they can also
occur in full sun. Based on our observations, the species are restricted to the Core
Cape Subregion of the Greater Cape Region of South Africa.
In the last revision of the South African species of Rhynchosia, Baker (1923) used
leaflet shape and the extent of fusion of calyx lobes as diagnostic characters for this
section. The degree of fusion of the calyx lobes can only be used to distinguish R.
chrysoscias from the other species in this section. An examination of herbarium
specimens has indicated that there is confusion between R. chrysoscias and R.
leucoscias as these species are morphologically very similar, with overlapping
distributions. There is also confusion between R. angustifolia and R. leucoscias var.
angustifolia as they both have narrow-linear leaflets and solitary or sub-solitary
flowers. This clearly shows that there is extensive variation in morphological
characters in the section, which results in uncertainties when determining species
delimitations. Therefore, the aim of the present paper is to provide a revision of
section Chrysoscias with a key to the species, correct nomenclature, complete
synonymy, typification, descriptions, diagnostic features of the species, distribution
maps, and habitat notes. We recognise four species in this treatment of the section
(R. chrysoscias, R. leucoscias, R. angustifolia and R. microscias).
2. Materials and
methods
We studied herbarium specimens housed at BOL, JRAU, PRE, and those loaned
from NBG (including SAM) supplemented by extensive field work of almost all the
taxa throughout their known geographical distributions. Type specimens were
examined online at www.plants. jstor.org. Distribution data for all species were
gathered during field trips, from herbarium material and field notes. Leistner and
Morris (1976) was used to locate the quarter degree squares for the place names.
For floral dissections, flowers were rehydrated in boiling water and mounted in
glycerol. Illustrations were drawn using a camera lucida attachment. Images of leaf
surfaces and anatomical sections were taken using a Zeiss Stereo microscope, 6.3 ×
micro-lens and Zeiss compound microscope. For anatomical studies herbarium
material was first rehydrated by placing in boiled distilled water for about 24 h at 50
°C, the water was then completely drained and the material placed in FAA for a
minimum of 24 h. The material was subsequently treated according to a modification
(a five day final infiltration) of the method of Feder and O'Brien (1968) for
embedding in glycol methacrylate (GMA) and infiltrated with GMA over five days.
Sections were made using a 2045 Multicut Rotary Microtome. Staining was done
according to the periodic acid Schiff/toluidine blue (PAS/TB) staining method
(Feder and O'Brien, 1968). For Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) studies, leaf
5
and calyx surface appendages, air dried material was mounted on carbon stubs and
gold coated using an Emscope gold coater. These were then viewed with a Tescan
SEM at 8 kV using the Vega3TC software program, photographed with an Oxford
instruments X-Max camera and also viewed with Phenom Pro SEM at 5 kV using
the ProSuite software program, photographed with Phenom built in camera.
Description of vegetation types of all the species follows the standard vegetation
types in Mucina and Rutherford (2006).
3. Results
and discussion
3.1. Vegetative morphology
Species of Rhynchosia section Chrysoscias are climbing or twining creepers, or
spreading prostrate herbs from 0.2–1.0 m long (Fig. 1). Stems are slender,
suffruticose at the base, branches firm-herbaceous, shortly pubescent to densely
grey-pilose and sometimes glandular (especially in R. chrysoscias). Leaflets are
pinnately trifoliolate and their shape varies from linear, through narrowly linear,
linear-lanceolate and lanceolate to oblong-lanceolate, with revolute margins. The
leaflet shape is of limited diagnostic value but can be used to distinguish
between R. leucoscias (oblong-lanceolate or linear-lanceolate) and R.
angustifolia (leaflets narrowly-linear). Rhynchosia leucoscias has the largest
leaflets [(24.0–)32.0–58.0(− 70.5) × 7.5–15.0 mm] while R. angustifolia has
the smallest leaflets [15.0–30.0 × 1.0–3.0(− 3.5) mm]. Petiole length is variable
among species and although of limited diagnostic value, it can distinguish R.
leucoscias (8–20 mm) from the other species which all have shorter petioles [R.
angustifolia (2.2–4.5 mm), R. chrysoscias (3.5–7.8) and R. microscias [(3.0–)4.3–8.6
mm)]. Cross sections of petioles revealed that the petiole shape is somewhat
irregular and consists of one layer of uniseriate and orbicular epidermal cells and a
ring of five isolated vascular bundles (Fig. 2). Like most of the papilionoid taxa,
species in this section have persistent stipules, with shapes varying from broadly
oblong to ovate or ovate-lanceolate. In R. chrysoscias and R. microscias the stipules
are ovate-lanceolate while in R. leucoscias and R. angustifolia they are broadly oblong.
3.2. Reproductive
morphology
In this section the flowers are either borne in axillary umbels, or are solitary to subsolitary (R. angustifolia). The peduncles range from 15 to 60 mm, bearing 1-many
flowers.
6
7
Pedicels are shorter than the peduncles, ranging from 1 to 20 mm. Bracts are
caducous, broadly-oblong to ovate-lanceolate, acute and attached at the base of
each pedicel; bracteoles absent. The flowers are yellow in all species. The calyx
lobes are generally bilabiate with the upper lobes connate to the middle in R.
chrysoscias and connate to beyond the middle in the rest of the species. The calyx
lobes are lanceolate to linear-lanceolate and the upper ones equal to or slightly
shorter (4.5–13.0 mm) than the vexillum (8.0–15.5 mm). The standard petal is
generally large (8–15 × 6–15), ovate to broadly obovate, slightly emarginate,
glabrous, without appendages and shortly clawed (Fig. 3A1–A4). The wing
petals are oblong to obliquely-oblong, subcordate at the base and exhibit little
surface sculpturing. The wing petals are equal to or longer than the keel petals
in all species except in R. microscias, where they are slightly shorter than the keel
(Fig. 3B1–B4). The size of the wings ranges from 6 to 15 × 2–8 mm with a welldeveloped claw. The keel petals are generally uniform in shape throughout the
section and are shorter and slightly broader than the wings. They are generally
rostrate to rostrate-oblong or rostrate-obovate (Fig. 3C1–C4). In R. chrysoscias,
R. leucoscias and R. angustifolia the keels are larger than (7–14 × 5–14 mm) in
R. microscias where the keels are smaller, ranging from 4 to 8 × 3–4 mm.
8
Fruits with a caducous or persistent calyx, unilocular, oblong, broadly-oblong to
ovoid, mucronate, rarely compressed, slightly turgid, dehiscent, straight or slightly
curved and 1–2 seeded. The dehiscence of the valves is along both sutures, opening
apically with valves twisting downwards. Seeds are brown or black with brown
mottling, somewhat compressed, smooth and oblong-reniform to ovoid. The
mature seeds remain attached to the open fruits.
3.3. Leaf
vestiture and anatomy
The distribution and type of trichomes are important taxonomic characters for
distinguishing between the species in this section. The vestiture is composed of
both glandular and non-glandular trichomes (bulbous-based and uniseriate hairs)
[Figs. 4 and 5A–H]. The cross section of the leaf and SEM micrographs revealed
that there are four types of trichomes that occur in section Chrysoscias,
differentiated according to their shape (terminology adapted from Vargas et al.,
2015). The four types of trichomes are:
• Spherical capitate glands (S) with circular to semi-circular apical cells and
unicellular bases (Fig. 5A, B & G).
• Ellipsoid capitate glands (E) that are oblong in shape with unicellular bases (Fig.
5C).
• Bulbous-based hairs (BB) with rounded bases, apically elongated cells;
distributed on stems, both the abaxial and adaxial leaflet surfaces and petioles of R.
chrysoscias, and calyces of all other species in this section (Fig. 5A & E).
• Uniseriate hairs (U) comprising of one to three cells (Fig. 5D, F & H).
The non-branched uniseriate hairs are comprised of one to three cells. These
trichomes usually have terete cells at the base and elongated apical cells. Both
glandular and non-glandular trichomes are homogenously distributed on the
petiole surface. Details of trichome distribution and other epidermal features
are tabulated in Table 2.
9
10
Glandular trichomes are of the vesicular type, orange-yellow to golden or rarely
colourless (some specimens of R. angustifolia). Vesicular glands (E and S) consist
of a squat head of cells contained within a shallow depression of the epidermis
(Moteetee and Van Wyk, 2006). These glands are present on the leaflets in R.
chrysoscias, R. leucoscias and R. angustifolia and only on the stipules in R.
microscias. In R. chrysoscias they are distributed abundantly throughout the plant
on the stems, petioles, and leaflets (both surfaces); in R. leucoscias and R.
angustifolia they are on the upper surface of the stipules, abaxial surface of the
leaflets and only rarely on the adaxial surface of the leaflets.
There are two types of non-glandular trichomes, the bulbous-based hairs and the
uniseriate (simple) hairs. The bulbous-based hairs are present in all the species.
11
In R. chrysoscias they occur on the stems, stipules (upper surface), petioles,
leaflets (both surfaces), calyces and pods; while they are only present on the
calyces and pods in R. leucoscias, R. angustifolia and R. microscias.
The uniseriate hairs consistently occur throughout the plant (stems, stipules,
petioles, leaflets, bracts, calyces and pods) in all the species. In R. chrysoscias they
are villous on stems, petioles and pods, pilose to slightly pubescent on the stipules,
puberulous above and villous below on the leaflets and golden yellow on the calyces.
In R. leucoscias they are silky-silvery on the stems and calyces, tomentose on the
stipules and petioles, on the leaflets they are white tomentose on the lower and
puberulous on the upper surface, and villous on the pods. In R. angustifolia
they are silky-canescent on the stems, tomentose on the stipules and petioles, on
leaflets they are white tomentose on the lower surface and sparsely pubescent
on the upper surface, silky-silvery on calyces and villous on the pods. In R.
microscias they are silky-canescent on the stems and petioles, pubescent on
stipules and calyces, on the leaflets they are canescent-sericeous on the lower
surface, glabrescent on the upper surface and villous on pods.
In transverse sections of the leaf blade, in all species, the epidermis consists of a
single layer of cells and tends to have sinous cell outlines on the abaxial surface
and occasional stomata. On the adaxial surface the epidermis has larger cells with
polygonal outlines and no stomata. The stomata are always on the abaxial
surface of the leaf and each stoma has two subsidiary cells which are parallel to
the longitudinal axis of the pore and guard cells (paracytic).
4. Taxonomic
treatment
4.1. Rhynchosia section Chrysoscias
Benth. in Fl. Cap. 2: 249 (1862); Baker f. in Bothalia 1: 113–138; 117 (1923). Type
species: R. chrysoscias Benth. [Note: R. chrysoscias is herewith designated as the type
species for this section for the reason that the species holds the section name and
is the first listed species in Harvey's, 1862 treatment].
12
Plants subshrubs, stems twining. Stipules deciduous, broad to broadly oblong, ovate
to ovate lanceolate, glandular, slightly pubescent or slightly pilose above with
bulbous-based hairs (only in R. chrysoscias), acute. Leaflets pinnately trifoliolate;
lanceolate, oblong-lanceolate, linear, linear-lanceolate to narrowly linear with
slight to strongly revolute margins; glandular or non-glandular, tomentose,
sericeous, or villous below and puberulous to glabrescent above with reticulate
venation. Flowers yellow, solitary to sub-solitary or in axillary umbels bearing 1–8(−
10) flowers, peduncles longer (15–45 mm) than the petiole (2–20 mm); bracts
broadly-oblong to ovate-lanceolate, silky-villous to pubescent and glandular
above, acute to sub-acute or obtuse. Calyx bilabiate, golden yellow or silkysilvery with bulbous-based hairs, the two uppermost lobes somewhat connate
at the base, segments lanceolate. Standard petal broadly obovate, large (8–15 ×
6–15), without appendages, slightly emarginate; wing petals ovate to obovate,
subcordate at the base; keel petals rostrate, 4–11 × 3–14 mm, somewhat broader
than the wings (6–15 × 3–8). Stamens diadelphous (9 + 1), anthers
monomorphic, dorsifixed. Ovary narrowly oblong, subsessile, pubescent, 2ovuled; style hairy below (silky-silvery), glabrous and curved upwards. Pods
oblong to broadly-oblong or ovoid, villous or pilose, compressed to slightly turgid,
mucronate and somewhat dehiscent. Seeds 1–2, brown or black.
13
4.2. Key
to species
1a.
Leaflets
not
gland
dotted,
up
to
8
flowers
per
umbel
....................………………………………………………………………….4. R. microscias. 1b. Leaflets
gland-dotted, flowers in umbels with 3–5 flowers …….…2. 2a. Lower surface of the
leaflets with bulbous-based hairs on midrib, two uppermost calyx lobes connate to the
middle…………….2. R. chrysoscias. 2b. Lower surface of the leaflets without bulbousbased
hairs,
two
uppermost
calyx
lobes
connate
to
above
the
middle………………………3. 3a. Leaflets oblong-lanceolate; flowers in umbels with 2–5
flowers.....…………………………………………………………………..3. R. leucoscias. 3b. Leaflets
narrowly-linear;
flowers
solitary
to
sub-solitary
with
1–2
flowers………………………………………………………1. R. angustifolia.
4.2.1 Rhynchosia angustifolia
(Jacq.) DC., Prod. 2: 388 (1825); Baker f. in Bothalia 1:113–138; 117
(1923). Glycine angustifolia, Jacq. Schoenb. 2: 55–56, t. 231 (1797). Type: Jacq.,
Schoenb., t. 231 (1797), iconotype, here designated.
14
Cylista angustifolia Eckl. & Zeyh. Enum. Pl. Afric. Austral. 2: 258 (1836). Type: same
as above. Rhynchosia uniflora Harv. in Fl. Cap. 2: 249 (1862). Type: same as above.
Rhynchosia leucoscias var. angustifolia Harv. in Fl. Cap. 2: 249 (1862), syn. Nov. Type:
South Africa. Western Cape, Caledon (3419): River Zondereinde [Riversondereind]
(–BB), precise date unknown, Zeyher 2410 (S, lecto.!; here designated; SAM!,
isolecto.) [Note: The sheet with herbarium number S.12–9918].
Twining subshrub up to 0.7 m, stems silky-canescent. Stipules ovate, acute to
subacute, (3.5–)4–6 × 2–3 mm, glandular and tomentose to pubescent above.
Leaflets narrowly-lanceolate to linear, white to tomentose and glandular below,
sparsely pubescent above without bulbous-based hairs, (15–)27–34 × 1–3(−
3.5) mm long; margins strongly revolute; petioles (2.0–)3.5–5.0 mm long.
Peduncles 20–42 mm long, solitary to sub-solitary, bearing 1–2 flowers; pedicels
3.5–4.5 mm long. Flowers axillary, (11–)12–20 × 4–6 mm. Calyx silky-silvery,
upper lip equal to lower lip, 6–10 mm long, tube 2 mm long; the two
uppermost calyx lobes connate to beyond the middle. Standard 8–12 × 6–11 mm,
claw 2–3 mm long; wings 9–10 × 3–4 mm, almost equal to the keel, claw 3.5–5.0
mm long, longer than that of the standard petal and the keel; keel slightly larger
than wings, 8.0–11.0 × 3.5–4.0 mm, claw 2–3 mm long (Fig. 6). Pods oblong,
villous, 13–14 mm long; seeds black. Flowers from late winter through summer and
autumn: August–April.
4.2.1.1
Diagnostic characters.
Rhynchosia angustifolia has a similar growth form to that of R. leucoscias in that
they are both twining sub-shrubs (except that R. angustifolia is strongly twining)
and that they both have leaflets with glands. It can be easily distinguished from
R. leucoscias by its narrower leaflets [(15–)27–34 × 1–3(− 3.5) mm vs. (24–)32–
58(− 70.5) × 7.5–15.0 mm] that are strongly revolute, solitary to sub-solitary
flowers, and by its shorter peduncles (20–42 mm vs 20–60 mm long). It can be
distinguished from R. chrysoscias by the lack of bulbous-based hairs on the
leaflets.
4.2.1.2
Distribution and habitat.
Rhynchosia angustifolia is restricted to the Caledon area from Zwarteberg,
Helderberg (Grootvaderbosch), Viljoen Pass, Lebanon to Hermanus and extends
to the Riversonderend Mountains (Fig. 7) and a disjunct population further
east in the Langeberg area. It grows along river catchments in fairly moist to
well-drained sandy soils as well as on dry rocky mountain slopes in sandy loam
soils in Overberg Dune Strandveld (FS 7), South Sonderend Sandstone Fynbos
(FFs 14) and Central Ruens Shale Renosterveld (FRs 12) vegetation.
4.2.1.3
Nomenclatural notes.
Jacquin's illustration shows clearly the strongly twining growth habit
characteristic of R. angustifolia. The Cylista angustifolia specimen in TCD is chosen
15
as lectotype because it is part of Zeyher's collection with Ecklon and Zeyher's
Enumeratio label. Zeyher 2410 in S is a mixed collection of Cylista angustifolia
(R. leucoscias) and R. leucoscias var. angustifolia (R. angustifolia); the collection
referred to here is the branch in the upper right hand corner of the sheet with a R.
leucoscias var. angustifolia label and a herbarium number S.12–9918. The
specimen in S is chosen as lectotype because there are locality details on the sheet
and it is of good material.
When erecting Rhynchosia leucoscias var. angustifolia, Harvey (1862) noted that it
could be distinguished from the typical variety by its fewer flowers (sub-solitary)
and very narrow leaflets. He also mentioned that R. uniflora (now R. angustifolia) is
much like R. microscias and can only be distinguished by its constantly solitary
flowers on short pedicels. We observed a close similarity (strongly twining habit,
narrow-linear leaflets, and solitary to sub-solitary flowers) between R. leucoscias
var. angustifolia and R. angustifolia such that it is difficult to distinguish or
separate the two taxa. We believe that Harvey only saw one specimen of R.
uniflora (Zeyher 1689) and now with extensive collections from the type locality,
it is clear that there is only one species. Therefore R. leucoscias var. angustifolia is
16
here synonymised with R. angustifolia and the latter name is preserved to take
Jacquin's earlier name of Glycine angustifolia referring to the narrow leaflets.
4.2.1.4. Additional specimens examined.
South Africa. WESTERN CAPE PROVINCE: 3320 (Langeberg): Grootvadersbosch
State Forest (− DD), east of Barend Koen Road on southerly slopes of ridge
approaching Spitskop from southwest, 23 Sep 1985, McDonald and Morley 1045
(NBG, PRE). 3419 (Caledon): Grabouw (− AA), 9 Aug 1966, Kruger 107 (PRE),
Viljoens Pass (− AA), 26 Aug 1940, Compton 9213 (NBG), 26 Sep 1962, Taylor 4088
(PRE), 3 Oct 1972, Smith 33 (PRE), 5 Apr 1973; Lebanon State Forest, Jakkalsrivier
catchment (− AA), Hayness 795 (PRE), 13 Oct 1970, Kruger 1075 (PRE); Hermanus (–
AC), Vogelgat Nature Reserve, 1 Sep 1978, Goldblatt 4789 (PRE), 4 Dec 1980, Stirton
8455 (PRE), 9 Aug 1987, Williams 3800 (NBG); Vogelgat (− AD), east of Base Camp,
11 Sep 1978, Williams 2582 (PRE, NBG); Genadendal, Riviersonderend mountains
on Kanonberg north of Genadendal (–BA), 10 Oct 1995, Meyer 1034 (PRE), Oct
1950, Stokoe SAM55911 (PRE); Caledon, Riviersonderend (–BB), 2 Sep 1951,
Esterhuysen 18,775 (NBG, PRE), 9 Oct 1998, Oliver 11,186 (NBG).
4.2.2. Rhynchosia chrysoscias
Benth. ex Harvey and Sonder in Fl. Cap. 2: 248–249 (1862). Type: South Africa.
Precise locality unknown: Thunberg s.n. sub THUNB-UPS 16799 (UPS, lecto. - microfiche!, here designated); THUNB-UPS 16798 (UPS!, isolecto. - micro-fiche) Glycine
erecta Thunb., Prodr.: 131 (1800) & Fl. Cap.: 592 (1823). Type: same as above.
Cylista lancifolia Eckl. & Zeyh., Enum. Pl. Afric. Austral. 2: 259 (Jan, 1836). Type:
South Africa. Western Cape, Knysna (3423): Langekloof and Plettenbergsbay
[Plettenberg Bay] (–AB), precise date unknown, Ecklon and Zeyher 1690 (S, holo;
SAM!, iso.). Chrysoscias grandiflora E.Mey., Comm.: 139 (Feb, 1836). Type: South
Africa. Western Cape, George (3322): Kaijmansgat [Kaaiman's Gat] (–DC), 7 Sep
1831, Drége 3794 (P, holo.!; MO!, iso.)
17
Creeping subshrub, stems twining sometimes prostrate or sprawling, villous,
glandular, golden yellow when young, forming mats of about 0.5 m long, up to 2.0
m long when twining. Stipules broadly oblong, acute 5.8–8.2 × 2.6–5.3 mm,
glandular and slightly pilose above. Leaflets lanceolate to oblong-lanceolate,
puberulous above, with bulbous-based hairs on both surfaces, villous below,
glandular, margins revolute, 30–40 × 5–10 mm; petiole 3.5–7.8 mm long.
Peduncles 20–50 mm long, umbels bearing 3–5 flowers. Flowers axillary,11–
20(− 22) × 4–7 mm. Calyx golden yellow, upper lip 9.5–13.0 mm long, lower lip
11.5–15.0 mm long; tube 2 mm long; the two uppermost lobes connate to the middle.
Standard 10.0–15.5 × 7–15 mm, claw 2.0–3.5 mm long; wings narrower than the
keel 9.0–15.0 × 3.5–8.0 mm, claw 3–5 mm; keel larger than wings, 8.5–14.0 ×
5.0–14.0 mm, claw 3.0–6.5 mm long (Fig. 8). Pods oblong, villous, 14–15 mm long;
seeds black or brown. Flowers from late winter through spring and mid-summer:
late July–December.
4.2.2.1
Diagnostic characters.
Rhynchosia chrysoscias can be distinguished from other species in this section
by the golden bulbous-based hairs that occur on young stems, leaflets and
calyces and the vesicular glands that occur throughout the plant. In others species
18
the golden bulbous-based hairs only occur on the calyces. The standard petal is
much larger than those of R. leucoscias and R. microscias (10.0–15.5 × 7.0–15.0
mm vs. 8–11 × 6–9 mm in R. microscias and 9.5–13.0 × 7.5–12.5 mm in R.
leucoscias).
4.2.2.2
Distribution and habitat.
Rhynchosia chrysoscias has a widespread distribution in the Core Cape Subregion,
from the Western Cape to the Eastern Cape Province. It is widely distributed along
coastal areas from Bredasdorp easterly up to Port Elizabeth and is the most
widespread species in this section (Fig. 9). Rhynchosia chrysoscias and R. leucoscias
are sometimes confused with each other not only because of their similar
morphological characters but also due to their strongly overlapping distributions.
However, R. leucoscias grows in moist to dry sandy soils in Kouga Grassy Sandstone
(FFs 28) and Overberg Sandstone Fynbos (FFs 12) vegetation, while R. chrysoscias
prefers dry grassy vegetation from Eastern Little Karoo (Skv 11) through to Gamka
Karoo (NKI 1), Baviaanskloof Shale Renosterveld (FRs 18) and Central Ruens Shale
Renosterveld (FRs) vegetation at ± sea level and moist sandy soils in Potberg
Sandstone Fynbos (FFs 17) and Tsitsikamma Sandstone Fynbos (FFs 20)
vegetation. Both species seem to track recently burnt vegetation.
4.2.2.3
Nomenclatural notes.
Thunberg's specimen is chosen as lectotype for Rhynchosia chrysoscias because of all
the synonyms listed by Harvey (1862), Glycine erecta Thunb. is the oldest. Had the
name not been already taken by De Candolle's Rhynchosia erecta, this would be
the correct name for this species.
4.2.2.4
Additional specimens examined.
South Africa. WESTERN CAPE: 3321 (Ladismith): Langeberg, Garcia State Forest (–
CC), along path above Rooiwaterspruit to Stinkhoutbos, 21 Nov 1991, McDonald 2106
(NBG), Garcias Pass (–CC), 30 Aug 1923, Muir 2967 (PRE); Lebombo Mountains (–
CC), 30 Aug 1926, Muir 2344 (PRE). 3322 (George): Victoria Bay hillside (–BA), 19
Aug 1944, Compton 15,778 (NBG); Terblanchberg, Moordkuils catchment (–CC), 24
May 1983, Volk 596 (PRE), Ruytersbosch (–CC), 19 Sep 1951, Van Niekerk 81 (PRE);
Gradockberg (–CD), 30 Jul 1963, Taylor 3683 (PRE), Aug 1912, Rogers 4311 (PRE),
Montagu pass (–CD), Jun 1927, Fourcade s.n. (PRE), Outeniqua Pass at Telkom
substation at the start of Pass-to-Pass trail (–CD), 14 Sep 2011, Boatwright 597
(NBG); Kleinplaat (–DC), 28 Jul 1966 Lange 20 (PRE). 3323 (Willowmore): Knysna
division, Kranskop west station (–CC), Sep 1960 Horn s.n. sub PRE 55977 (PRE),
Natures Valley (–CC), 5 Jul 1949, Immelman 80 (PRE), 15 Dec 1959, Codd 9971
(PRE); 7.5 miles from Keurbooms River to Storms River (–DC), 24 Sep 1969, Marsh
1330 (PRE); Tsitsikamma Park, Elandsbosrivier (− DD), 8 Sep 1975, Bower 573
(PRE). 3324 (Steytlerville): Baviaanskloofrivier (–CA) 12 Sep 1973, Thompson 1905
(PRE). 3420 (De Hoop): Potberg Nature Reserve, in Boskloof at southern side of
Mountain (–BC), 7 Sep 1978, Burgers 1130 (PRE), 2 Apr 1985, Scott 549 (PRE), 14
19
Oct 1940, Pillans 9446 (PRE); Bredasdorp (–CA), 21 Sep 1962, Taylor 4014 (PRE).
3422 (Mossel): Groenvlei (–BB), 25 Dec 1953, Taylor 1073 (PRE, NBG). 3423 (Knysna):
27.2 km from Keurboom River mouth (–AB), 14 Oct 1928, Gillett 1574 (PRE), Spitskop
Fynbos Reserve (–AB), 17 Sep 1970, Geldenhuys 131 (PRE), Keurboomstrand, 5 Sep
1955, Theron 1781 (PRE), Plettenbergbaai, 13 Dec 1967, Grobbelaar 681 (PRE).
EASTERN CAPE: 3325 (Port Elizabeth): Suurberg [Zuurberg] pass (–BC), 13 Aug
1973, Bayliss 5901 (NBG), Alexandria District, Zuurberg Inn (–BC), 22 Sep 1953,
Archibald 740 (PRE), Zuurberg (–BC), 17 Sep 1933, Long 1097 (PRE); Uitenhage,
Groendal Wilderness, Farm Grootplaat (–CA), 4 Sep 1974, Scharf 1540 (PRE);
Zwartkops catchment, steep valley head (–CB), 18 Jul 1974, Scharf 1433 (PRE). 3424
(Humansdorp): near Clarkson (–AB), Aug 1926, Thode A814 (PRE); Coldstream, 11
Nov 1935, Laughton s.n. (PRE).
4.2.3. Rhynchosia leucoscias
Benth. in Fl. Cap. 2: 249 (1862). Type: South Africa. Eastern Cape, Port Elizabeth
(3325): ′Vanstaadensberg' [Van Stadensberg] (–CC), precise date unknown, Ecklon
20
and Zeyher 1688 (SAM, lecto.! here designated; M!, isolecto.) (See nomenclatural
note i).
Cylista argentea Ecklon and Zeyher (1836). Type same as above. (See
nomenclatural note ii). Cylista angustifolia E. Mey., in Linnaea, 7: 171 (1832). Type:
South Africa. Western Cape, Caledon (3419): Rivier Zondereinde (–BB), precise
date unknown, Zeyher 2410 (S, lecto! here designated) [Note: sheet with herbarium
number S.12–9920 is chosen as lectotype]. (See nomenclatural note iii).
Chrysoscias calycina E. Mey., in Comm., 140 (1836). Type same as above. (See
nomenclatural note iv). Twining subshrub, stems twining, occasionally creeping,
young stems silky silvery. Stipules broadly oblong, acute (4.0–)6.0–8.0 × (−
3.0)3.8–5.2 mm long, glandular and tomentose above. Leaflets oblonglanceolate to linear, white tomentose and glandular below, puberulous above,
without bulbous-based hairs on both surfaces, margins revolute, (24.0–)32.0–
58.0(− 70.5) × 7.5–15.0 mm; petiole 8–20 mm long. Peduncles 20–60 mm long,
subsolitary, umbels bearing 2–5 flowers. Flowers axillary, 12–20(− 25) × 4–5 mm.
Calyx silky-silvery; upper lip 7–10 mm long, lower lip 6–11 mm long, tube 2–3
mm long; the two uppermost lobes connate to above the middle. Standard
9.5–13 × 7.5–12.5 mm, claw 2–3 mm long; wings slightly shorter than the keel
(8–)9–10 × 3.5–4.0(− 6) mm, claw 3.5–5.0 mm; keel slightly larger than wing, 7.0–
11.0 × 3.5–5.0 mm, claw 2–3(− 4) mm long (Fig. 10). Pods broadly oblong, villous,
13–15 mm long; seeds black. Flowers from late winter through spring and midsummer: August–December.
21
4.2.3.1
Diagnostic characters.
Rhynchosia leucoscias is a twining sub-shrub, occasionally creeping, with stems
that are silky-silvery when young and grow from 0.5–2.0 m long if twining. It is
similar to R. chrysoscias in leaflet shape but differs markedly in its reticulate
white tomentose leaflets with glands on the lower surface but without bulbousbased hairs on the midrib. The standard petal is smaller than in R. chrysoscias
but much larger than that of R. microscias (9.5–13 × 7.5–12.5 mm vs. 10.0–15.5
× 7–15 mm in R. chrysoscias and 8–11 × 6–9 mm in R. microscias).
4.2.3.2
Distribution and habitat.
The species is restricted to the Core Cape Subregion from the Western Cape
Province to the Eastern Cape Province. It extends west to the Caledon area and
east from Knysna up to the Port Elizabeth area (Fig. 11). Rhynchosia leucoscias
and R. chrysoscias strongly overlap in distribution and may sometimes be confused
with each other. Rhynchosia leucoscias grows in moist to dry sandy soils in short
22
Kouga Grassy Sandstone Fynbos (FFs 28), Southern Afrotemperate Forest (FOz 1)
and Overberg Sandstone Fynbos (FFs 12) vegetation.
4.2.3.3
Nomenclatural notes.
i) The specimen in SAM is chosen as lectotype for Rhynchosia leucoscias because it is
likely to be part of Zeyher's collection acquired by Pappe. The sheet has Pappe's
label with which he replaced the original Enumeratio plantarum label of Zeyher
and Ecklon. Zeyher 2410 in S is a mixed collection of Cylista angustifolia and R.
leucoscias var. angustifolia (R. angustifolia). ii) The name R. argentea is not adopted
because it has been taken up by Rhynhcosia argentea Harv. iii) The collection
referred to here is the one on the bottom left of the sheet with a C. angustifolia
label and a herbarium number S.12–9920. iv) Rhynchosia calycina is not adopted
because it has been taken by Rhynchosia calycina Guill. & Perr.
4.2.3.4
Additional specimens examined.
South Africa. WESTERN CAPE: 3418 (Simonstown): Kogelberg Forest Reserve (–BD),
11 Jun 1986, Boucher 1525 (PRE); near Spinnekopnes jeep track, before crossing
second stream (–BD), 12 Oct 1989, Maitre 569 (NBG); Palmiet River track along jeep
track (–BD), 14 Sep 2011, Boatwright 668 (NBG); 50 m right of road up first and old
powers installation before reaching Oudenbosch (–BD), 12 Dec 1991, Kruger 170
(NBG). 3419 (Caledon): Vogelgat Nature Reserve (− AD), 15 Oct 1986, Stirton 11,168
(PRE); Vulture stream (− AD), 20 Sep 1986, Williams 3686 (PRE); 11 Sep 1978,
Williams 3297 (PRE, NBG); Riversondereind (–BB), without date, Zeyher s.n. (NBG).
3422 (Uitzicht): Brenton on Sea (–BB), 9 Nov 1979, Hugo 2051 (PRE). 3423
(Knysna): east of The Heads (− AA), 17 Dec 1919, Schönland 3387 (PRE); 12 Jan
1958, Story 2863 (PRE). EASTERN CAPE: 3324 (Steytlerville): Elandsberg
Mountains (–DB) 30 Sep 1984, Stirton 10,878 (NBG). 3325 (Port Elizabeth):
Vanstadensberg mountains (–CC), 30 Sep 1984, Stirton and Zantovska 11,610 (NBG);
Longmore Forest Station (–CC), 28 Sep 1978, Hugo 1415 (NBG); Uitenhage (–CD),
1860, Cooper 1497 (PRE); Port Elizabeth (–DC), Gordon PRE55958 (PRE). 3424
(Humansdorp): (–CD), Mar 1930, Thode A2532 (PRE). Without precise localities and
dates: Gordon s.n. sub PRE55958 (PRE), Marloth 9338 (PRE).
4.2.4. Rhynchosia microscias
Benth. in Fl. Cap. 2: 249 (1862); Baker f. in Bothalia 1: 116. (1923). Type: South
Africa. Western Cape, George (3322): mountain sides near George (–CD), Aug 1836,
Drége s.n. (S, holo.!; CGE!, K!, MO!, REG!, TUB!, iso.).
23
Chrysoscias parviflora E. Mey., Comm., 139 (1832). Type: same as above. See
nomenclatural note i). Twining subshrub up to 5 m long, stems silky-canescent.
Stipules ovate-lanceolate, acute 5.5–8.0 × 2.6–8.0 mm, pubescent above. Leaflets
lanceolate to linear-lanceolate, canescent and sericeous below, non-glandular,
glabrescent above without bulbous-based hairs, margins revolute, (30–)40–50
× 6–11 mm long; petioles (3.0–)4.3–8.6 mm long. Peduncles 15–45 mm long,
umbels bearing 4–8(− 10) flowers. Flowers axillary, 9.0–10.0 × (2.5–)3.0–4.0
mm. Calyx cano-pubescent; upper lip 4.5–9.5(− 12.5) mm long, lower lip 6.0–12.5
mm long; tube 2–3 mm long, the two upper most lobes connate beyond the
middle Standard 8–11 × 6–9 mm, claw 1.5–3.0 mm long; wings 6.0–8.0
× 2.0–3.5 mm, slightly narrower than the keel, claw 3.5–4.0 mm long; keel slightly
broader than wing, 4–8 × 3–4 mm, claw 2.5–3.0 mm long (Fig. 12). Pods ovoid,
villous, 12–14 mm long; seeds brown or black. Flowers from late winter through
spring: July–September.
24
4.2.4.1
Diagnostic characters.
Rhynchosia microscias is similar to both R. chrysoscias and R. leucoscias in leaflet
shape, from which it can be easily distinguished by its greyish sericeous, nonglandular leaflets as opposed to villous and glandular in R. chrysoscias, white
tomentose and glandular in R. leucoscias. It can also be distinguished from the
other species in the section by flowers that are noticeably smaller; 9–10 × (2.5–
)3–4 mm compared to 11–20(− 22) × 4–7 mm in R. chrysoscias, 12–20(− 25) × 4–
5 mm in R. leucoscias and (11–)12–20 × 4–6 mm in R. angustifolia.
4.2.4.2
Distribution and habitat.
Rhynchosia microscias occurs in the Core Cape Subregion from the Western Cape
Province to the Eastern Cape. It extends from Riversdale, east through Mossel Bay,
George to Knysna and Tsitsikamma (Fig. 13). This species prefers sandstone slopes
and moist mountainous areas in Mossel Bay Shale Renosterveld (FRs 14), South
Outeniqua Sandstone Fynbos (FFs 19) and North Outeniqua Sandstone Fynbos
(FFs 18) as well as Tsitsikamma Sandstone Fynbos (FFs 20) vegetation.
4.2.4.3
Nomenclatural note.
i) The name R. parviflora is not adopted because it has been taken up by Rhynchosia
parviflora (E. Mey.) Steud.
4.2.4.4
Additional specimens examined.
South Africa. WESTERN CAPE: 3321 (Ladismith): Hills above Langfontein (− DD),
without date, Muir 2343 (PRE); Cloete's Pass, 4 Jul 1948, Acocks 14,631 (PRE).
3322 (George): Near George (–CD), Aug 1830, Drége s.n. sub PRE27007 (PRE);
Montagu Pass, Jun 1943, Fourcade 6027 (NBG, PRE). 3323 (Jonkersberg): Gouna (–
CC), without date, Taylor 1310 (PRE); Aug 1942, Fourcade 5707 (NBG); Concordia (–
CC), 19 Aug 1970, Keet 558 (PRE); Tsitsikamma Lottering Bush (–DC), 16 Sep 1897,
Galpin 3989 (PRE). 3421 (Riversdale): Lebombo Mountains, Welgevonden near
Langeberg (–BA), Jul 1913, Muir 1114 (PRE). 3423 (Knysna): Kruisfont (− AA), 26 Mar
1979, Van Daalen 175 (PRE).
25
26
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to express their gratitude to the curators of PRE and NBG
(including SAM) for their assistance with herbarium material. Images of anatomy
sections were generated at the Biosystematics Microscopy Imaging Systems,
Biosystematics Division, Agricultural Research Council – Plant Protection
Research Institute. We thank the anonymous reviewers who provided useful
comments that improved the manuscript. The University of Johannesburg, the
National Research Foundation Thuthuka Programme (76177) and the South
African National Department of Environmental Affairs through its funding of
the South African National Biodiversity Institute Invasive Species Programme
are gratefully acknowledged for financial support.
27
References
Baker, J.G., 1871. Leguminosae. Flora of Tropical East Africa, p. 218.
Baker, E.G., 1923. Revision of the South African species of Rhynchosia.
Bothalia 1, 113–138.
Bentham, G., Hooker, J.D., 1865. Leguminosae. Genera Plantarum. Vol. 1(2).
Lovell Reeve, London, pp. 542–543.
De Candolle, A., 1825. Prodromus Systematus Naturalis. 2. Sumptibus Sociorum
Treuttel et Wurtz, Paris, pp. 384–389.
Ecklon, C.F., Zeyher, C.L.P., 1836. Enumaratio Plantarum Africae Australis
extratropicae 2. Perthes & Besser, Hamburg, pp. 252–256.
Feder, N., O'Brien, T.P., 1968. Plant microtechnique: some principles and new
methods. American Journal of Botany 55, 123–142.
A checklist of South African plants. In: Germishuizen, G., Meyer, N.L., Steenkamp,
Y., Keith, M. (Eds.), Southern African Botanical Diversity Network Report
No. 41. SABONET, Pretoria.
Glen, H.F., 2002. Cultivated Plants of Southern Africa. Jacana, Johannesburg,
p. 206.
Grear, J.W., Dengler, N.G., 1976. The seed appendage of Eriosema (Fabaceae).
Brittonia 28, 281–288.
Harvey, W.H., 1862. In: Thiselton-Dyer, W.T. (Ed.), Leguminosae. Flora
Capensis 2. Reeve and Co., London, pp. 247–258.
Lackey, J.A., 1981. Tribe 10. Phaseoleae DC. (1825). In: Polhill, R.M., Raven, P.H.
(Eds.), Advances in Legume Systematics Part 1. Royal Botanic Gardens,
Kew, pp. 301–327.
Leistner, O.A., Morris, J.M., 1976. Southern African Place Names: Annals of the
Cape Province Museum. Vol. 12.
Manyelo, T.S., 2014. A phylogenetic study of South African Species of
Rhynchosia (Phaseoleae, Fabaceae). M.Sc. (Botany) [unpublished].
University of Johannesburg. Available on: https://ujdigispace.uj.ac.za.
Meyer, E.H.F., 1836. Commentariorum de Plantis Africae Australioris 2.
Leopoldum Voss, Leipzig, pp. 131–140.
Moteetee, A.N., Le Roux, M.M., 2016. The Rhynchosia totta complex
(Phaseoleae, Fabaceae) in southern Africa, including the description of
a
new
variety
and
new
species.
Bothalia
46,
a2041.
https://doi.org/10.4102/abc. v46i1.2041.
Moteetee, A.N., Van Wyk, B.-E., 2006. A revision of the genus Bolusafra (tribe
Phaseoleae, Fabaceae). South African Journal of Botany 71, 604–608.
Moteetee, A.N., Boatwright, J.S., Jaca, T.P., 2012. A review of Rhynchosia
section Cyanospermum (Phaseoleae, Fabaceae) in South Africa. South
African Journal of Botany 81, 124–127.
Moteetee, A.N., Boatwright, J.S., Jaca, T.P., 2014. A review of Rhynchosia section
Polytropia (Phaseoleae, Fabaceae) and a new species from the Western
Cape Province, South Africa. Systematic Botany 39, 1127–1131.
28
Mucina, L., Rutherford, M.C. (Eds.), 2006. The Vegetation of South Africa,
Lesotho and Swaziland. Strelitzia 19. South African National Biodiversity
Institute, Pretoria.
Ramcharan, E.K., McAndrews, J.H., Grear, J.W., 1973. Pollen morphology of
Rhynchosia and Eriosema (Fabaceae). Canadian Journal of Botany 51,
2395–2399.
Schrire, B.D., 2005. Tribe Phaseoleae. In: Lewis, G.B., Schrire, B., Mackinder, B.,
Lock, M. (Eds.), Legumes of the World. Royal Botanical Gardens, Kew, UK,
pp. 409–410.
Turner, B.L., 2011. Systematics of the Rhynchosia senna complex (Fabaceae).
Lundellia 14, 27–31.
Vargas, W., Sartori, A.L.B., Dias, E.S., 2015. Novelties in secretory structures and
anatomy of Rhynchosia (Fabaceae). Annals of the Brazilian Academy of
Sciences 87, 83–93.
Verdcourt, B., 2001. Rhynchosia. In: Pope, G.V., Polhill, R.M. (Eds.), Flora
Zambesiaca. 3(5). Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, pp. 168–210.
29