STUDIES ON STALK ROT DISEASE OF
GRAIN SORGHUM
By
Ahmed Amer Ali Mahmoud
B. Sc. Agric., Sic. (Plant Pathology)
Al-Azhar Univ –Assuit Branch., 2000
THESIS
Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of The
Requirements for the Degree
OF
MASTER OF SCIENCE
IN
PLANT PATHOLOGY
Under supervision of
Dr. Zekry A. Shihata
Prof. of Plant Pathol., Fac. of Agric., Minia Univ.
Dr. Anwar A. Galal
Prof. of Plant Pathol., and Vice Dean for post graduate
students and Researches, Fac. of Agric., Minia Univ.
Dr. Ali. Z. Mohammed
Chief Res. of Plant Pathol. Res. Inst., Agric. Res. Center,
Giza.
Dept. of plant pathology
Faculty of Agriculture
Minia University
2010
APPROVAL SHEET
Studies on stalk rot disease of
Thesis entitled :
grain sorghum
Candidate :
Ahmed Amer Ali Mahmoud
Approved by :
Dr. Mohammed S. Mohammed
...……………………
Prof. of Plant Pathol.,
Fac. Agric., Assiut Univ.
Dr. Ali A. El-Bana
…………………….…
Prof. of Plant Pathol.,
Fac. Agric, Minia Univ.
Dr. Zekry A. Shihata
…………………………
Prof. of Plant Pathol.,
Fac. Agric, Minia Univ.
Dr. Anwar A. Galal
Prof. of Plant Pathol., and Vice Dean
for Post graduate Students and Researches
Fac. Agric., Minia Univ.
Examining date : 5 / 8 / 2010
………………………..
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all, I do thank Allah for all gifts have given me.
The author wishes to express his deep thanks and sincere appreciation
to Dr. Zekry A . Shihata , Prof. of
Plant Pathology, Dept. of Plant
Pathology, Fac. Agric., Minia University for his advice and precious
supervision.
Similar thanks to Dr. Anwar A . Galal, Prof. of Plant Pathology
Vice Dean for Post graduate Students and Researches Fac. Agric., Minia
University for his continues guidance and valuable supervision.
In addition the author is grateful to Dr. Ali Z . Mohammed Chief
Researcher, Plant pathology Res. Inst. Agric. Res. Center (ARC), Giza.
Thanks to all staff members of Plant Pathology Dept., Fac. Agric., Minia
University for encouragement and assistance.
I am deeply indebted to my family specially my parents , my wife and
my daughter for their supports and patience throughout the study period.
CONTENTS
iii
page
INTRODUTION ……………………………………………………………….1
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
………………………………………………..2
MATERIALS AND METHODS ………………………………………………
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
25
…………………………………………… 36
I-Pathological studies :- ………………………………………………
36
1.1- Survey of grain sorghum stalk rot/wilt diseases ………………
36
1.2-Isolation of the casual pathogen. ……………………………….
36
1.3- Pathogenicity test of the isolated fungus………………………..
38
1.4- Disease assessment. …………………………………………….
38
1.5- Identification of the casual pathogen. …………………………
38
1.6- Response of grain sorghum cultivars to Acremonium strictum
……infection……………………………………………………….
42
1.7- Host range. …………………………………………………….
45
II- Laboratory studies ……………………………………………………. 45
2.1- Effect of temperature on the growth of A. strictum. ……………….. 45
2.2-Effect of antioxidants and calcium chloride on the linear growth
of A. strictum. ………………………………………………….
50
2.3-Effect of antioxidants and calcium chloride on mycelial dry
weight of A. strictum……………………………………………
50
2.4-Effect of antioxidants and calcium chloride on spore production
of A. strictum……………………………………………………..
53
2.5- Antagonistic potentiality of Bacillus subtilis and Trichoderma
harzianum against A. strictum in vitro……………………………
53
2.6- Effect of antioxidants and Calcium chloride on antagonistic
potentiality of Bacillus subtilis and Trichoderma harzianum
against A. strictum. ……………………………………………..
57
III- Possible management of grain sorghum damping-off and stalk
diseases : ……………………………………………………. 57
3.1. Using seed soaking in resistance inducers……………
57
3.1.1. Possible management of grain sorghum damping..off……………………………………………………
3.1.2. Possible management of grain sorghum stalk
……rot…………………………………………………….
61
61
3.2. Using seed coating by commercial bio control products Rhizo-N
Plant-Guard………………………………………………… 65
3.2.1. Control of damping-off………………………………….
3.2.2. Control of stalk rot……………………………………..
65
65
DISCUSSION ……………………………………………………… 71
SUMMARY …………………………………………………… 78
REFERENCES …………………………………………………
81
ARABIC SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
Grain sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L.) is considered to be one of the most
important cereal crops in Egypt. It serves as a staple food for a considerable
population of Upper Egypt. The total cultivated area of sorghum in Egypt in year
2008 were 353810 feddans, produced 843840 tons of grain ( Department of
statistics, Ministry of Agriculture, A.R.E., 2009 ) . About 80% of this area in
Upper Egypt, especially in Assuit, Sohag and Qena governorates. For several
years, the smuts were regarded as the most serious and widespread diseases on this
crop. In recent years, however, stalk rot conditions have been increasingly
observed in the sorghum fields. This investigation was carried out to survey the
grain sorghum crop for the detection and identification of the stalk rots prevailing
in this country and the pathogen(s) involved.
The disease was first described in Egypt by El-Shafey et al. (1979) as a new
vascular wilt caused by Cephalosporium acremonium Corda. Gams (1971) . The
disease was described earlier by El-Shafey and Refaat (1978) as a stalk-rot
caused by C. acremonium . Later, Frederiksen et el. (1980) and Natural et al.
(1982) reported Acremonium wilt in the USA caused by Acremonium strictum .
Subsequently, the disease was reported in Argentina ( Forbes and Crespo, 1982) ,
in Mexico and Sudan ( Frederiksen, 1984 ).
This work was initiated to:
1- Survey the stalk rot/wilt diseases which affect of the yield of grain sorghum.
2- Determine frequency of fungi associated with grain sorghum stalk rot/
wilt.
3- Carry out some laboratory studies on the isolated phytopathogenic
fungus.
4- Possible management of grain sorghum stalk- rot/wilt through different manners
i.e., , chemical application and intercropping systems.
1
Review of Literature
Casual organism :
Acremonium wilt is one of the more described diseases of
sorghum ( Natural et al., 1982). In Egypt El-shafey et al., (1979) have
described a wilt of sorghum caused by Cephalosporium acremonium
cord. Gams (1971) reduced this species to synonymy Acremonium
strictum Gams. Both diseases are presumed to be caused by the same
pathogen.
In Egypt, reports suggest that the pathogen is soil borne and
colonizes the root prior to invading vascular tissue (El-Shafey and
Refaat, 1978).
Duncan (1985) reported that damage caused by A. strictum was
estimated by eye on a 1-5 scale in 226 entries in disease screening
nurseries, breeding plots and hybrid evaluation plots near Griffin in 1984
. Lines SC279-14, SC437, SC24 and SC805 showed no damage ( score
1) from this cause and in 48 others there was slight vascular bundle
discoloration but no necrosis (score 1.5-2.0). Acremonium strictum was
isolated from stems of wilted sorghum plants collected in Pantnagar,
Uttar Pradesh , India, and its pathogenicity was established in the
greenhouse. Of several inoculation methods examined, drenching soil in
pots containing 10 days old plants of the susceptible cultivar IS 18442
with a conidial suspension of the pathogen resulted in > 70% disease
incidence.
2
Disease symptoms in the greenhouse were similar to those in the
field. Grain from diseased plants were small and shrunken with reduced
wt., germination and seedling vigour. A. strictum was isolated from all
parts of infected plants, indicating systemic colonization. Infected seeds
produced diseased plants when sown in autoclaved soil. The disease was
first noticed 40 days after emergence as isolated, distinctly pale yellow,
stunted plants. Severely infected plants didn't produce panicles
(Mughogho et al., 1987).
As the disease progresses, whole leaves die and disease symptoms
appear as the pathogen spreads into the younger leaves. The disease
often results in discoloration of vascular tissue in leaves and stalks.
Acremonium strictum was isolated consistently from stalks, leaf sheaths,
and leaves of diseased plants. Several sorghum entries were resistant to
the pathogen following natural infection or foliar clipping in the field.
However, drenching around injured roots with inoculum and injecting a
conidial suspension at the base of the plant increased their susceptibility.
Grain production was reduced by 50% in affected plants ( Frederiksen
et al., 1982).
Fusarium moniliforme ( Gibberella fujikuroi ) , Cephalosporium
acremonium (Acremonium strictum) and Macrophomina phaseolina are
the cause of stalk rot disease in sorghum. F. moniliforme caused the
highest percentage of infection followed by the other two fungi. Of 4
sorghum cultivars evaluated for resistance to F. moniliforme isolate 7 in
the greenhouse and field conditions using the soil infestation and
toothpick technique, respectively, Dorado gave a resistance reaction to
the disease while Line-113 was highly susceptible, Giza 15 and Pioneer
8319 were intermediate in their disease reactions.(Hassan et al., 1996).
3
Eight methods of inoculation were tested to identify a reliable ,
efficient and large-scale inoculation technique for the evaluation of
sorghum genotypes in the field and in the greenhouse . Soil inoculation
(infestation) was effective , uniform ,and can be used for greenhouse
evaluations ,and probably for a small disease nursery. Stalk –inoculation
using the tooth-pick technique was not effective in the greenhouse, but
was effective, uniform and more practical for field evaluation. Stalkinoculation using the toothpicks technique was have given rise to
excessively high estimates of Acremonium damage in some cases. ( ElShafey et al., 1999).
Jin-Cheol et al., (2002) recorded that a strain of Acremonium
strictum, showed strong antifungal activities both in vitro and in vivo
against several phytopathogenic fungi : an antifungal substance was
purified from the liquid cultures of A. strictum and identified as
verlamelin by instrumental analysis, verlamelin exhibited in vitro
antifungal activity against some phytopathogenic fungi such as Magena
porthe grisea. Bipolaris maydis, and Botrytis cinerea, while it was not
active against all the bacteria tested. In vivo, verlamelin exhibited strong
protective and curative activities, particularly against barley powdery
mildew.Gisela et al., (2007) associated endophytic Acremonium species
are capable of interacting with the host plant and altering its response
towards pathogens and pests. Specialized root-colonizing Acremonium
spp. Can achieve biocontrol effects based on induced disease resistance I
whole plant assays. However these Fungi are head to detect and to study
in root tissue by classical methods of light microscopy or microbiology.
To enable further progress I investigations of induced mechanisms of
defense in the plant, better visualization of the entophytic symbiont
Acremonium strictum was attempted by use of auto fluorescent GFPtrans formants. Subculture of three stable transformed A.
strictum
isolates were used in agar plate assays which sterilized flax seedlings to
document.
Rivera et al.,(2007) Found in vitro studies demonstrated that A.
strictum significantly reduced sporulation of Helmenthosporium solani
isolates from 65 to 35%, spore germination from 53 to 43%, and mycelial
growth from 40 to 32% compared with non contaminated cultures of H
.solani. And that Acremonium strictum is antagonistic to H. solani, and
can be considered a mycoparasite.
Acremonium strictum reduced H. solani conidia production on mini
tubers, thereby reducing inoculum for infection. However, treatment with
A. strictum does not reduce silver scurf of previously infected tubers.
Further studies are warranted to determine the full potential of A. strictum
as a biological control agent of H. solani-incited silver scurf of stored
potato tubers and the most effective manner of use.
Gyung et al., (2009) examined biological control activity of
Acremonium strictum strain BCP was examined against six plant
diseases such as rice blast, rice sheath blight, cucumber gray mold,
tomato late blight, wheat leaf rust, and barley powdery mildew in growth
cucumber the spore suspension of strain BCP showed strong control a
activities against five plant diseases except against wheat leaf rust. On
the other hand, the culture filtrate of A. strictum BCP was effective in
controlling only cucumber gray mold and barley powdery mildew, this
results indicate that A .strictum BCP could be developed as a bio
fungicide for Botrytis diseases under green house conditions.
5
Host range :
Frederiksen, (1984) found difference in pathogencity between
two isolates of A. strictum based on symptoms and determined that their
isolates infected maize. Pearl millet, and oats in greenhouse studies.
Acremonium strictum was unable to infect wheat and barley with these
isolates.
Cephalosporium acremonium grew on the root surface of the
wheat plant with out causing any under or above ground symptoms.(
Garrett, 1970).
Giza 70 variety of cotton was not affected in any way by any of
the used isolates of Cephalosporium acremonium (Mansour et al.,
1984). By artificial inoculation, A. strictum could , infect sorghum ,
Maize , Foxtail millet (Setaria italica) and pearl millet (Pennisetum
glacum). as reported by ( Xu-Xiude et al., (1995).
Factors affecting fungal growth and disease development :
Effect of temperature on the linear growth of the tested fungus:The optimum temperature for vegetative growth is 30 C o for A.
strictum
(Mansour et al., 1984). Plates which containing Potato-
Dextrose Agar plus streptomycin at 200 ppm were incubated at 28-30 Co
and it's the optimum temperature for growth of the organisms
(Frederiksen et al., 1982).
6
The pathogen was isolated and identified as A. strictum. It could
grow well in 25-30Co and ph 5-8 and it's conidia germinated at 23-28
Co and ph 5-7 (XU – Xiude et al., 1995). Leininger et al., (1999)
found that Acremonium wilt is favored by hot weather (>30 Co).
Faramarzi et al., (2008) found that pest
fermentation
conditions was found to be 5 days incubation at 25-30 Co and ph value
of 6 according to TLC profiles.
Effect of antioxidant compounds and calcium chloride :
Effect of salicylic acid (SA) on the growth of some phyto pathogenic
fungi:
Some antioxidant compounds (free radical scavengers) were
toxic to the fungal growth of Phytophthora infestans (Arnoldi et al.,
1989 and Quintanilla and Brishammar, 1998), Aspergillus spp.,
Penicillium spp and Fusarium spp. (Thompson, 1992 ), Botryis cinerea
(Elad,1992), F. graminearum, F. moniliforme, F. oxysporum, F. poae,
F.
roseum and
F. sporotrichioides (Thompson et al., 1993),
Peronospora tabocina (Cohen, 1994),Colletotrichum gleiosporiodes
(Prusky et al., 1995 ), F. moniliforme, F. oxysporum, and F. solani
(Galal and Abdou 1996) Puccinia helianthi (Galal et al., 1997),
Alternaria radicina and A. tenuissima (Galal et al., 1999), A. solani and
F. oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici (Moustafa,1999), F.oxysporum, F.
solani and Rhizoctonia solani (Shahda, 2000), F. oxysporum, F. solani
and F. moniliforme (El-Ganaieny et al., 2002) and F. verticillioides and
F. proliferatum Reynoso et al., 2002).
(Abd El-Hai et al., 2009) reported that Salicylic acid alone or in
combination with citric acid completely inhibited the linear growth of
both pathogens i.e., Macrophomina phasoliana and R. solani in vitro.
7
Effect of salicylic acid on plant diseases:
In contrast, non-phytotoxic levels of SA did not
affect
ethylene formation in soybeans cuttings (Pennazio and Roggero, 1991).
SA is thought to act as an endogenous signal in induction of pathogenesis
related proteins (PR) and some components of systemic acquired
resistance SAR (Yalpani et al., 1991). Injection of SA into cucumber
tissues found in phloem exudates induced resistance to disease caused by
Pseudomonas syringae and increased peroxidase activity (Rasmussen et
al., 1991 ). In fact, SA is a natural compound and its concentration in
plant tissue increased up to 50 times after infection with viral, bacterial or
fungal pathogens in Nicotiana infected by TMV (Malamy and Klessig,
1992).
(SA) belongs to diverse group of plant phenolics usually defined as
substances that process an aromatic ring bearing a hydroxyl group or its
functional denotative and the highest levels of SA were found in plants
infected by necrotizing pathogens (Raskin, 1992).
Floryszek and Wieczorek (1993) induced resistance in potato
plants against the late blight Phytophthora infestans using SA. Reduction
in develoment of the disease was greatest in leaves 4-6 adjacent of the
induced lower leaves. The identification of catalase as a SA-binding
protein led to the hypothesis that inhibition of catalase by SA led to the
accumulation of H2O2 which then induced resistance response (Conrath
et al., 1995).
8
Shulaev et al., (1995) demonstrated that SA is transported to the
upper leaves of tobacco and cucumber plants from the infected leaves for
systemic acquired resistance (SAR) induction is most likely a
combination of SA synthesized by inoculated leaf and SA synthesized
systemically, possibly in the vascular tissue.
Brigitte and Alan (1996) studied that SA, supplied to Alp-treated
plants, restored resistance and both pathogen induced lignification and
activation of the PAL1 promoter. These results provide evidence of the
control role of SA in genetically determined plant disease resistance and
show that lignification per se, although providing a component of the
resistance mechanism, is not the deciding factor between resistance and
susceptibility.
.
Ferrarese et al., (1996) investigated the effect of SA on leaf
abscission in peach cv. Red haven and peppers (Capsicum annuum var.
logum). Petiole abscission of debladed leaves was reduce following SA
treatment. Biochemical analyses revealed that the activity and content of
enzyme usually involved in abscission (cellulose, EC 3.2.1-4) did not
increase in these plants. In contrast, control plants showed a marked
increase in the levels of both enzyme activity and cellulose protein.
Penninckx et al., (1996) indicated that systemic pathogen- induced
expression of the plant defensin gene in Arabidopsis is independent of
salicylic acid but requires components of the ethylene and jasmonic acid
response. Seah et al., (1996) pointed out that an increased in SA concn.
applied as foliar dip, foliar wipe or root drench increase the resistance in
wheat seedling-root against Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici. It
became apparent recently that SA is an endogenous compound that
operates in signaling pathway for plant defense (Durny et al. 1997).
9
Nawrath and Metraux (1999) in Arabidopsis, systemic acquired
resistance against pathogens has been associated with accumulation of
SA and the expression of the pathogenesis-related proteins PR-1, PR-2
and PR-5. They reported in this investigation here the isolation of two
non allelic mutants impaired in the pathway leading to SA biosynthesis.
These SA induction and were more susceptible to both virulent and a
virulent forms of Pseudomonas syringae and Peronospora parasitica.
Both root and leaf of barley responses to infection after SA treatment at
low concentration lead to significant reduction of necrotic lesions caused
by F. culmorum on barley seedlings (Wisniewska and Chelkowski,
1999).
Clarke et al., (2000) found that disease resistance in
Arabidopsis is regulated by multiple signal transduction pathways in
which salicylic acid (SA), jasmonic acid (JA) and Ethylene function as
key signaling molecules. Epitasis analyses were performed between
mutants that disrupt these pathways (npr1, eds5, ein2, and jar 1) and
mutants that constitutively activate these pathways (cpr1, cpr5, and cpr6),
allowing exploration of the relationship between the SA-and JA/ETmediated resistance responses.
Borsani et al., (2001) reported that SA is an essential component
of the plant resistance to pathogens. They showed that SA plays a role in
the plant response to adverse environmental conditions, such as salt and
osmotic stresses. They have studied the responses of wild-type
Arabidopsis and an SA-deficient transgenic line expressing a salicylate
hydroxylase (NahG) gene to different a biotic stress conditions in media
supplemented with 100 mM NaCl or 270 mM mannitol showed extensive
necrosis in the shoot. In contrast, NahG plants germinated under the same
conditions suggests that SA potentates the generation of reactive oxygen
species in photosynthetic tissues during salt and osmotic stresses.
El-Bana et al., (2002) found that soaking wheat seeds in SA
solution significantly reduced root rot severity caused by Fusarium
equiseti infection from 46% to 20.4% and from 35% to 18.6% under F.
solani infection. As for foliar spraying with SA neither once nor twice
application had any effect to reduce root rot severity.
Abdou et al., (2004) mentioned that SA seed treatment affected
incidence of wilt and root rot of sesame incited by Fusarium oxysporum
f. sp. sesami, Macrophomina phaseolina, Theilaviopsis basicola and
Mucor haemalis.
Esmail et al., (2008) studied possible effect of using salicylic acid
(SA) in host resistance. Induction against tomato stem canker was
investigated. Foliar applications of salicylic acid with two concentrations
of 200 and 400mm were tested against fungal pathogen. The results
demonstrated that use 200mm dosage of SA was insufficient for inducing
disease resistance. However, applications of SA in concentration 400mm
significantly reduced disease index as compared with infected control.
Gehan et al., (2009). Found that the systemic acquired resistance to
powdery mildew disease in two pepper species (Capsicum annuum &
Capsicum frutescens) by using different concentrations of salicylic acid.
The application methods were by soaking seeds or spraying foliar.
Different SA treatments succeeded to decrease pathogenicity level and
increase pepper yield in both cultivars. The results showed also that
spraying method for one or two times was more effective than soaked
method. Moreover, 0.3 mM and 0.5 mM of SA were the most effective
concentrations.
11
The results showed that fungus infection induced a significant
decrease in proline contents, while SA treatments induced a significant
increase in proline and ascorbic acid content and glutathione GSH ( A
polypeptide, consisting of glycine, cysteine and glutamic acid that occurs
wildly in plant tissues) activity in both species. In C. frutescens SA
treatments induce a significant increase in peroxidase activity and keep
catalase activities in values near that of negative control by spraying
method. .
Role of ascorbic acid (AA):
Ascorbic acid plays a key central role in detoxification of activated
oxygen (Foyer et al., 1991). It can react directly by reducing superoxide,
hydrogen peroxide, and hydroxyl radical, or quenching singlet oxygen.
Alternatively, it can react indirectly by regeneration α-tocopherol from αoxy radical, or in the synthesis of zeaxanthin in the xanthophylls cycle .
Elad (1992) revealed that ethylene production which has been
shown to induce susceptibility of host tissues to Botrytis cinerea was
inhibited in tomato leaves treated with propylgallate, ascorbic acid and
benzoic acid. The author showed also that, some combinations of
antioxidant were found to be more effective than either compound when
applied alone when tested on pepper or tomato.
The effective concentration of antioxidants varied between 0.1 and
10.0 mM. The synergists ascorbic acid and citric acid improved the control
activity of butylated hydroxyl toluene (BHT),
propylgallate, benzoic acid and tetrabutylh droquinone on tomato
leaves but not pepper leaves. Citrin and ascobin as natural and organic
antioxidant compounds have auxinic action, since they contain citric acid
and ascorbic acid, respectively, (Raskin,1992).
12
Prestamo and Manzano (1993)
showed
that ascorbic
acid
inhibited peroxidase activity in extracts of kiwifruits, potato tubers, carrot
roots, tomato, fruits, cauliflower heads, green bean pods and horse radish.
Peroxidase activity did not depend on the number of isoenzyme present.
Gonzalez et al., (1995) showed
that
ascorbate
free
radical
stimulated root growth of onion at 15 and 20˚C in addition to stimulating
root elongation if culture condition allowed its oxidation. When ascorbate
oxidation was inhibited, no stimulation of root growth was found. The
effect of the fully oxidized form, dehydroasorbate, was inhibitory. It was
also show that ascorbate free radical generated by ascorbate oxidation was
reduced back, probably by a transplasmalemma reductase.
Zhang et al., (1997) reported that in a field study
in
Solanum tuberosum cvs. Atlantic and Superior tubers were
potato
analysed
for ascorbic acid (AA) and total glycoalkaloid (TGA) concentrations
within one month of harvest and after to 5 months of storage at 10°C.
(AA) concentration was significantly higher in cv. Superior than cv.
Atlantic at harvest and after storage.
Total glycoalkaloid (TGA) concentration was consistently higher in
cv. Atlantic than cv. Superior. Irrigation tended to slightly reduce (AA)
and increased alpha-solanine concentration when applied too late in the
season for yield benefits. They concluded that potato cultivar type,
growing environment and storage time play much more stronger roles in
determining tuber (AA) and TGA levels than do irrigation and soil
management programes. They showed also a negative relationship
between average tuber size and (AA) concentration in autumn sampling.
13
Bruggemann et al., (1999) showed that the mehler-ascorbateperoxidase cycle is a protection system against reactive oxygen species
(ROS) occurring during over-excitation of photosynthetic apparatus.
However, the antioxidant compounds particulary ascorbic acid has a
stimulatory effect on rooting and improving growth productivity of tomato
hybrids (Abdel-Ati et al., 2000).
Shaat et al., (2000) showed that ascorbic acid at 100 ppm was
affective on controlling the infected apple leaves with Botryosphaeria
ribis as compared to the tested fungicides (Benlate, Mancoper and
Topsin).
Abdou et al., (2001) reported that application of ascorbic acid (AA)
or salicylic acid (SA) to seeds and/or plants reduced the number of the
diseased sesame seedling/plants. Treated seeds plus twice irrigation with
either AA or SA caused the best control against Fusarium oxysporum f.
sp. sesami infection as compared to the treatment by the fungicide Benlate.
Meantime, AA and SA had less effect to control sesame damping-off and
root rot/wilt diseases caused by infection with Macrophomina phaseolina,
Mucor haemalis or Thielaviopsis basicola as compared to benlate
fungicide.
Shaat and Galal (2004) reported that application of antioxidants,
i.e., AA and SA to citrus trees acquired resistance in their fruits against
infection by either Alternaria alternata or Penicillium digitatum. Since
AA reduced green mold severity from 50.25% to 14% followed by SA
(19.25%). Increasing antioxidant concentration increased the inhibition of
growth of both tested fungi.
14
El-Samawaty et al.,(2008) showed that systemic acquired
resistance in cotton plants against infection with Fusaraium oxysporum
f.sp.vasinfectum (Atk) snyd. and Hank ). (FOV) was expressed when
cotton seeds of genotype Giza 80 X Australian genotype 19199 were
soaked in solution of various resistance elicitors (Res). All Res, Ascorbic
acid (AA),benzoic acid (BA) , benzothiadizole (BTH), citric acid (CA),
cinnamic acid (CIA), hydroquinone (HQ), salicylic acid (SA), sodium
citrate (NaC), sodium metbisulfate (NaMS) and thiourea (THU) induced
resistance that increased with increasing Res. concentrations.
BTH was the most efficient elicitor in inducing resistance in cotton
plants . Efficiency of BTH was highly affected by the concentration and
by cotton genotype . the most susceptible cotton genotype Giza 80 X
Australian genotype 19199 showed the highest response to the application
of BTH at all concentrations . A significant positive correlation was
observed between susceptibility of cotton genotype to FOV infection and
efficiency of BTH in inducing resistance .
in other words , susceptibility of the genotype positively correlated
with the magnitude of response to the elicitors . Thus , infection accounted
for 73 and 64% of the total variation in BTH efficiency when it was
applied at 50 and 100 ppm , respectively.
El-Samawaty and Galal
.,(2009) reported that the resistance
elicitors Benzothiadiazole (BTH) has no significant inhibitory effects on
seed germination of cotton cultivars Giza 86 and Giza 90 or on mycelial
growth of the tested fungi i.e. Fusarium solani .F. oxysporum, F.
moniliforme, Sclerotium rolfsii, Macrophomina phaseolina, Pythium sp
and Rhizoctonia solani. BTH seed treatment (seed soaking) resulted in
resistance cotton plants against infection by all pathogenic fungi tested
.Efficiency of BTH to induce resistance in cotton seedlings varied with
BTH concentration and fungi tested.
Increasing BTH concentration enhanced resistance capacity of
cotton cultivars . In addition . When the concentration was increased to
100 ppm . BTH significantly increased plant height from 8,36 to 26,07%
and from 8,93 to 28,82 % for cvs . Giza 86 and Giza 90 , respectively .
Also , it increased dry weight from 2,87 to 53,26 % and from 9,85 to 31,16
% for cvs. Giza 86 and Giza 90.
Role of calcium salts (Ca) :
In the peanut, Hallock and Garren (1968) showed that pod rot,
caused with Pythium myriotylum and
Rhizoctonia solani, is closely
related to the calcium content of the pod tissues and can be kept at a low
level by the soil application of calcium (eg., as gypsum).
The susceptibility of plants to infection
with such parasites is
therefore inversely related to the calcium content of the tissue. In
soybean, increasing the calcium suppresses fungal infection caused by
Sclerotium spp and stem (Muchovej and Muchovej, 1982), symptoms,
which are apical meristem necrosis and loss of apical dominance, and that
the fungal infection is a secondary event.
Also, Corden (1965) showed that the plants were severely infected
when the calcium concentration in the xylem sap was below about 5mM
at low external supply. Nearly all plants were healthy, however at night
external calcium supply when the calcium content ratio in the xylem sap
was raised to about 25mM.
16
High calcium content in fruit-tissues has been shown to reduce
disorders (Sharples and Johnson, 1977), retard softening and inhibited
decay (Conway et al., 1992). In addition to strengthening cell walls and
membranes. Calcium also regulates some physiological processes that
may directly or indirectly affect the quality of fruits (Poovaiah, 1988).
Chloride fertilizer application leading to the suppression of various
soil diseases, such as take all in wheat (Christensen et al., 1986), or root
rot caused by Cochliobolus sativus in barley (Timm et al., 1986) and leaf
rust caused by Puccinia recondite in wheat (Fixen et al., 1986 a, b).
Berry et al., (1988) revealed that the bacterial canker in tomato
appeared inversely correlated with the calcium content in shoot tissue. The
author showed that calcium is effective in both the susceptible and the
resistant cultivar, indicating that the resistance of a cultivar is dependent
on adequate calcium supply.
There are close correlation between calcium content and both
bacterial soft rot disease in potato (Kelman et al., 1989) and internal
brown spot in potato, s tubers (Mc Guire and Kelman, 1984).
Erwinia carotovora sub sp carotovora can be effectively suppressed
by increasing calcium content in the peel (Cheour et al., 1990).
Demonstrated that foliar application of CaCl 2 on the strawberries, 3-9
days before harvest, caused an increase in Ca content of the tissues,
delayed ripening, delayed mold development (Botrytis cinerea) and
prolonged storage life. Similar effects have been observed with apple
(Paliyath et al., 1984), pear (Richardson and Al-Alani, 1982), and
avocado (Tingwa and Young, 1974).
17
8 However, the progression of several signs ripening, i.e. anthocyanin,
free sugar and organic acid content, is evidence for the role of calcium in
the regulation of cell biochemistry in strawberry. Evidence is presented
which indicates that the preharvest application of calcium compounds, a
common practice for increasing the storage life and maintaining the
quality of fruits, may predispose mango fruit to Rhizopus arrhizus and
Botryodiplodia theobromae by 69.5 and 56.6 %, respectively, in vitro,
checked mycelial growth and reduced the protein content and production
of pectinolytic and cellulolytic enzymes.
When mango fruits were dipped in the extract the severity of rot
caused by these fungi, respectively, was only 20 and 15 % compared with
70 and 40 % in untreated fruits (Ray et al., 1993).
Wisniewski et al., (1995) assumed that calcium salts have been
reported to play an important role in the inhibition of post harvest decay of
apples and in enhancing the efficacy of post harvest biocontrol agents. The
effects of calcium and magnesium salts on the germination and
metabolism of the post harvest pathogens, i.e. Botrytis cinerea and
Penicilium expansum, were examined and compared, also, the effect of
these salts on the biocontrol activity of 2 isolates (182 and 247) of the
yeast, Candida
oleophila, was determined. The greatest effect was
observed in the case of B. cinerea.
The inhibitory effect could be overcome of glucose to the
germination medium. MgCl2 (25-175 mM)
had no effect on the
germination or germ-tube growth of either pathogen, indicating that
calcium action rather than the chloride anion was responsible for the
inhibition.
18
El-Ganieny et al., (1997) reported that onion seedlings cv. Giza
20 has greater lengths, fresh and dry weights and less infection by
Urocystis cepulae when CaCl2 or KCL was applied especially at 0.36 %
(w/v) concentration.
In 1999, Biggs reported that, when calcium salts solutions i.e.
calcium chloride, calcium propionate, and calcium silicate, at 1000 µg of
calcium/ml were applied to wounded apples prior to inoculation, fruit
treated with calcium chloride and calcium propagate exhibited, smaller
lesions than those treated with calcium silicate or the control, which were
similar. These experiments demonstrate that calcium salts have
suppressive activity against the bitter rot pathogens and could be used as
part of a disease management programme.
Hussein et al., (2002) found that calcium salts were used to control
white mold of bean pod caused by Sclerotinia sclerotiorum
El-Bana et al., (2006) studied the effects of calcium salts on
growth, sclerotia productions, carpogenic germination and infectivity of
Sclerotia sclerotiorum (Lib) de Bary ascospores. Morphological and
pathological variability was induced to the fungus by calcium salts,
calcium acetate was the most effective to inhibit growth of the fungus,
which expressed as linear growth on agar medium or mycelial dry weight
onto liquid media.
19
On the other hand, calcium phosphate showed the highest
inhibitory effect toward sclerotia production by tested fungus grown on to
either solid or liquid media. Since it caused 75% inhibition for sclerotia
production at 4000ppm and completely prevented sclerotia production at
8000ppm. Otherwise calcium chloride provided highest inhibitory effect to
carpogenic germination.
Abd El-Ghany (2007) . found that chemical compounds exhibited
various inhibitory effects on the sporulation of B. spicifera and F.
moniliforme isolates.Calcium chloride at 200 ppm caused complete
inhibition toward spore formation of B. spicifera isolate.
Biological control:
Cho (1989) found that B. polymyxa and Bacillus sp. together
suitable soil amendments of organic compost and Ca fertilizer provide
promising control to Phytophthora nicotianae var parasitica on sesame,
Fusarium oxysporum on cucrbits and Aphanomyces raphani on Chinese
cabbage.
Thomashow (1996) found that isolates of Trichoderma, Bacillus
and Streptomyces obtained from the soil rhizosphere of sesame plants
were antagonistic to Fusarium oxysporum and Rhizoctonia solani. The
antagonistic effect was due to lyses of cell wall of the fungal hyphae and
reducing the formation of macro conidia and chlamydo spores.
21
Zahra (1990) isolated five micro-organisms from the rhizosphere of
Giza-15 sesame cultivar, that were identified as Bacillus subtilis,
Trichoderma sp., Streptomyces sp. and Bacillus spp. that were antagonistic
to the wilt fungus ( Fusarium oxysporum f.sp sesame ). Also showed
antagonistic effect and suppressed the growth of Rhizoctonia bataticola (
Macrophomina phaseoli ).
El-Goorani and Hassanein (1991) tried to use Bacillus subtilis in
controlling the fire blight of pear caused by Erwinia amylovora.
Ziedan (1993) found that Bacillus megaterium showed strong
antagonistic effect to Fusarium oxysporum F.sp. sesami the casual agent
of sesame wilt.
Gabr et al., (1998) found that wilt and root rot disease sesame
caused by F.oxysporum F.sesami and M. phaseoli could partially
controlled by soil amendment with Bacillus subtilis ( isolated from
rhizosphere).
Ahmed (Hoda) et al.,(2000) concluded that, in vitro,T. harzianum
inhibited the mycelial growth of Rhizoctonia solani Kuhn, Macrophomina
phaseolina (Tassi) Goid and Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. Vasinfectum
(Aktinson) , the casual pathogens of root-rots and wilt disease of cotton.
They also stated that, under greenhouse conditions ,T.harzianum was the
most effective biocontrol agent which reduced the percentage of infected
plants and severity of the disease.
22
Ayaad, Hanaa (2000) found that Bacillus megaterioum showed
strong antifungal effects against of F.oxysporum F. sp. vasinfectum and M.
phaseolina in vitro and caused high reduction in disease incidence in vitro.
Ziedan (2000) Found that Plant –Guard ( a formula of T. harzianum
) and Rhizo-N ( a formula of B.subtilis ) have the ability to reduce the
percentage of root and pod in Peanut in both greenhouse and field
experiments.
Sonawane and pawar (2001) studied the antagonism between
Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. ciceris the caused of chickpea wilt and T.
harzianum and T. hamatum. They reported that T. harzianum was very
effective in controlling vegetative growth of the pathogen followed by T.
hamatum.
El-Deeb et al., (2002) Found that Plant –Guard ( a formula of T.
harzianum ) and Rhizo-N ( a formula of B.subtilis ) have the ability to
reduce the percentage of root and pod in Peanut in both greenhouse and
field experiments.
Abd-Elmonaim (2002) isolated two bacterial isolates of Bacillus
Spp. from the rhizosphere of lentil which showed strong antagonistic
effect in vitro against Rhizoctonia solani and Fusarium oxysporum.
23
Singh and Singh (2003) studied the effect of culture filtrate of
Trichoderma viride-1 , T. viride -2, T. harzianum , Gilocladium virens,
Chaetomium globosum and B. subtilis against Fusarium udum using
poisoned food technique. The highest reduction (26.1%) in the redial
growth of F. udum was obtained with T. harzianum, followed by B.subtilis
(22.2%) C. globosum (20.9%) , T. viride-1 (19.7%) ,T. viride -2 (14.4%) ,
and G . virens (10.4%).
Badran (2006) found that the biocide agent Trichoderma
harzianum (biocontrol agent of the commercial biocide Plant Guard) into
nutrient agar medium showed overgrowth that led to suppression of the
tested fungi. Trichoderma harzianum was very effective against Fusarium
oxysporum f. sp. cumini. Again the author added that the fungus was
greatly affected by Bacillus subtilis (the biocontrol agent of the
commercial biocide Rhizo-N). The results obtained by the author showed
that both ascorbic acid and Salicylic acid enhanced the potentiality of
either Rhizo-N or Plant Guard in controlling damping- off and root
rot/wilt caused by Fusarium oxysporum F . sp. cumini and Acremonium
egyptiacum.
24
Materials and Methods
І- Pathological studies :
1.1- Survey of grain sorghum stalk rot/wilt diseases:
Stalk rot disease of grain sorghum that grown at Sohag, Qena ,and A
governorates were surveyed during summer 2005. Three fields per
village were investigated. Sampling sites were determined with a field m
sampling sites were designated per field tested.
One of each of the four corners plus one in the center of the field
dates were used to calculate disease incidence ( the frequency of infect
plant) for each sampling site, from which the field average was calculated
least means of the three fields per each village were calculated.
1.2- Isolation of the causal pathogen :
The diseased plants of grain sorghum that were suffering from stal
were collected from different localities in Assuit, Sohag ,and
Governorates. Infected stalks were cut into small pieces and dipped briefl
1% sodium hypochlorite solution for 2 minutes, then they were pass
several changes of sterile water and plotted on Potato-Dextrose Agar (PD
medium( 200gm Potato,10gm Dextrose,20gm Agar and 100 ml dis
water) with or without antibiotics ( penicillin 25 mg/ml) in Petre dishes
plates were incubated at 30 Co for 5 days.
Hyphal tip and single spore isolation techniques was used to obtain
culture of the developed fungus. Pure cultures of the isolated fungus were
on PDA slants for further works.
25
1.3- Pathogenicity test of the isolated fungus :
1.3.1.Preparation of inocula:
Conical flasks (250 ml) each contanined about 100g barely and 120 ml
of tap water were autoclaved at 30 minutes. Flasks were subsequently
inoculated with either of the fungal isolates using 1cm fungal disc ( grown on
PDA medium for 5 days ). Incubation of inoculated flasks were performed at
30 Co for about 2 weeks.
1.3.2.Preparation of soil and pots :
Soil sterilized by 0.5% commercial formalin solution by drenching
Formalin to soil. Treated soil was covered with polyethylene sheet for one
week, and then irrigated for 2weeks. The fungal inoculum's was used for soil
infestation at rate of 2.5% of soil weight of each pot.
Inoculated pots (35 cm in diameter) were irrigated and left for a week to
ensure even distribution of fungus in pots. In control pots autoclaved Barley
Medium was mixed with soil at same rate. Ten grain sorghum seeds of variety
Giza-15 were sterilized with sodium hypochlorite 0.5% for 3 minutes then
washed several times with sterilized water and then were sown for each pot.
Three pots were used as replicates and three pots were used for stalk
inoculation without soil infestation.
All pots were kept under careful observation in the open field of Plant
Pathology Dept., Fac. Agric., Minia University. and examined for preemergence damping – off, post-emergence damping-off at 1week and 2weeks
after sowing .
26
1.4- Disease assessment :
Emergence at 2 weeks from planting was estimated for pre-and postemergence damping-off, respectively. At 7 weeks from planting,
grain
sorghum plants were estimated for stalk rot discoloration for each replicates
at disease severity index ( DSI ) as described by Liu et al., (1995) was
calculated as follows:
DSI= [ Σd / (d max X n ) ] X100
Where as : d is the disease rating possible and n is the total number of plants
examined in each replicates.
Numerical
Degree of infection
grade
1.0
Most or all of one internode discolored with no penetration of
nodal areas.
2.0
More than one internode but not more than two affected;
infection must have spread through at least one internode.
3.0
Infection passed through two or more inter-nod.
4.0
Extensive invasion of plant but not killed.
5.0
Death of plant due to stalk-rot as shown in fig.(1).
1.5- Identification of the casual pathogen:
Identification of the pathogenic fungal isolates (A1-A8) were
performed according to the morphological, cultural and microscopical
characteristics according to (Barnet and Hunter, 1972) Then three isolates
(A1, A2 and A3 ) were confirmed by Assuit University Mycological Center
(AU MC).
27
1
2
3
4
5
Fig. 1 : Degrees of infections
Numerical
Degree of infection
grade
1.0
Most or all of one internode discolored with no penetration
of nodal areas.
2.0
More than one internode but not more than two affected;
infection must have spread through at least one internode.
3.0
Infection passed through two or more inter-nod.
4.0
Extensive invasion of plant but not killed.
5.0
Death of plant due to stalk-rot.
28
1.6. Response of grain sorghum to cultivars to Acremonium strictum
infection:
Preparation of inocula , soil and pots was conducted as described in
pathogenicity tests. Ten grain sorghum seeds of 7 cultivars (Shandwel-2,
Shandwel-6, Giza-113, Hors, Mina, Dorado and Giza-15) were sterilized and
save similarly as described in pathogenicity test. Acremonium strictum isolate
A1(the highly pathogenic isolate) was used in this experimented. Average of
percentage damped off plants and stalk rot severity recorded as mentioned
above.
1.7- Host range :
Seeds of maize, (Zea maize), sugar cane (Saccharum officinarum),
wheat (Triticum estivum vulgaris L.), pear-millet (Pennistum glacum) and
okra ( Abelmoschus esculantus). were surface sterilized as before with 0.5
Sodium hypochlorite solution for 3minutes. Then they were passed in several
changes of sterile tap water to remove any toxic remains. Ten seeds were
sown in each pot that previously infested with the tested fungus A. strictum
isolate A1 and three replicates were used for each host. one pot used for stalk
inoculation using the tooth-pick technique without soil infestation in 3
replicates. Control treatment was 3 pots without soil infestation for every
replicate. Average percentage of dampped –off seedlings was calculated 21
days after sowing , while stalk rot severity was measured 20 days after stalk
inoculation.
29
II. Laboratory studies:
2.1.Effect of temperature on growth of A. strictum isolate No.A1:
The effect of different degrees of temperatures on the linear growth of
Acremonium strictum isolate A1 was investigated on Czapek's media. Three
replicates were used for each tested temperature. Petri dishes (9cm diam) were
inoculated with 0.5 cm fungal disc (grown on Czapeck's media for four days)
and kept at 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40oc. Incubation continued until fungal
growth of individual fungus at any tested temperature covered completely the
whole surface of Petri dishes. Effect of temperature degrees on mycelial
growth ( estimated on mycelial dry weight ) was conducted using Czapeck's
liquid media . Three replicates were used for each tested temperature . Flasks
of (250ml) containing 50 ml of Czapek's liquid media and inoculated using
1cm fungal disk and kept at 10,15,20,25, 30, and 35oc for 7 days then mycelial
mass was collected by filtration through known weight filter papers. It was
then dried in an oven at˜ 80oc for 10 hours and then was weighted.
2.2- Effect of antioxidant and calcium chloride (CaCl2) on the growth of
the tested fungus : Ascorbic acid (AA), salicylic acid (SA), and calcium
chloride(Cacl2) were used separately at 50.100 and 200ppm compared with
the fungicide vitavax-thiram at 50,100 and 200 ppm for studying their effect
on growth of isolate No.A1. Flasks (250ml), each containing 200ml Czapeck's
agar medium (pH7) were prepared and amended with each concentration of
each compound, then each flask was poured in 10 sterilized Petri-dishes (9 cm
diam).In control, plates non-amended medium were used. Plates were
inoculated separately in the center with disks (5mm diam.) of the tested
30
fungus and incubated at 30co till one fungal growth reached the plate edge.
The linear growth of fungus was measured in mm.
2.3. Effect of antioxidants and Calcium chloride on the mycelial dry
weight of isolate No.A1:
Flasks of (250ml) containing 50 ml of Czapeck's liquid media were
prepared and amended with each concentration of each compound, and
inoculated using 1cm fungal disk and kept at 30 oc for 7 days then mycelial
mass was collected by filtration through known weight filter papers. It was
then dried in an oven at 80oc for 10 hours and then was weighted.
2.4. Effect of antioxidants and calcium chloride on spore production of A.
strictum isolate No.A1:
Spores production was estimated on Czapeck's solid media amended
with 50,100 and 200 ppm of ascorbic acid (AA) , salicylic acid (SA) and
calcium chloride (CaCl2), compared with vitavax-thiram. Estimation of spore
numbers was carried out 7 days after incubation at 30 oc (after measuring the
linear growth) for Acremonium strictum. From each treatment one disk
(10mm diameter) was taken at random from the outer and mid surface of the
growth.
Disks were transferred to test tube containing (5ml) of sterilized
distilled water. Tube was shaken for abut 3 minutes and left for further 1 hour.
Hemocytometer slide was used for counting spores. The number of spores was
counted in 16 squire chosen at random (1/400mm2) using light microscope.
Three replicates were used, then average of three slides was taken in to
account ( Tzeng and De Vay, 1989 ).
2.5.Antagonistic potentiality of Trichoderma harzianum and Bacillus
subtilis against isolate No.A1 of A. strictum in vitro:
Antagonistic capability of T. harzianum and B. subtilis against the
tested fungus was carried out in vitro as provide by (Badran, 2006). In Petridishes ( 9 cm in diam. ) containing PDA medium (pH 7), at the periphery of
plate, one disk ( 5mm in diam.) of certain fungus was placed on a side and a
disk in T. harzianum case, or a line ( 3 cm ) in B. subtilis case was placed on
the opposite side of the same plate. In control plates one disk of certain fungus
was placed in a side of the plate . Inoculated plates were incubated at 30Ċ .
The diameters of fungus colonies was measured when the growth completely
covered the plate surface in control treatment . Percentage of inhibition was
calculated as mentioned by
Abdel-Latif (1976) :
Diameter of control – diameter of treated
Growth inhibition =
Diameter of control
X100
2.6.Effect of antioxidants and Calcium chloride on antagonistic
potentiality of Trichoderma harzianum and Bacillus subtilis against isolate
No.A1 of A. strictum:
Ascorbic acid, salicylic acid and calcium chloride at 100 and 200 ppm
were tested for their effect on antagonistic potentiality of Trichoderma
harzianum and Bacillus subtilis against the tested fungus in vitro. Flasks
(250ml) containing 200 ml Czapeck's agar medium (pH7) were amended with
each concentration of each compound, then each flask was poured in 10
sterilized Petri-dishes (9 cm diam.), one disk (5mm in diam.) of the tested
32
fungus was placed on a side and a disk of Trichoderma harzianum or a
line (3cm) in Bacillus subtilis was placed on the opposite side of the same
plate. In control, medium free of antioxidants was used. Inoculated plates
were incubated at 30oc, then diameters of fungal colonies were measured even
the growth
completely covered the plate surface in control treatment.
Percentage of inhibition was calculated as mentioned above.
III- Possible management of grain sorghum damping -off and stalk rot
disease:
Chemical and / or biological control trials were studied in Plant
Pathology Greenhouse, Minia University. during season 2007 and 2008.
Inocula were prepared from 2 weeks old culture grown on barley medium at
30oC. Soil was infested separately with inocula of A. strictum of the isolate
No.A1. Un infested soil used as a control treatment. Pots were irrigated and
left for 4 days before planting.
3.1- Chemical control :
3.1.1- Seed Soaking :
Ascorbic acid (AA),Salicylic acid (SA), and calcium chloride ( CaCl2)
were tested separately at 50,100 and 200 ppm and used for controlling grain
sorghum damping – off and stalk rot / wilt diseases compared with the
fungicide vitavax-thiram at the same rate of ppm as a positive control, while
distilled water was performed as a negative control. Two cultivars of grain
sorghum ( Giza-15& Dorado ) were tested. Seeds were soaked in the test
solutions for 12 hr. (300seeds per 100 ml test solution), then 10 seeds were
sowed in each pots , 10 pots were used for each test as replicates. Percentage
of damping-off were recorded at 2 weeks after planting.
33
3.2. Biological control :
Commercially available bio control products Rhizo-N, ( a formula of
Bacillus subtilis contain 1.2x105 cell/ml ) , and Plant-Guard ( a formula of
Trichoderma harzianum contain 1.2x105 cell/ml ) were tested separately for
controlling grain sorghum damping- off and stalk rot diseases caused by the
certain fungus A. strictum under artificial inoculation compared with the
fungicide vitavax-thiram at 50,100 and 200ppm as a positive control, while
distilled water was performed as a negative control. Seeds were dressed in the
test suspensions for 12hr at 1gm, 2gm and 4gm / liter distilled water, (300
seeds per 100 ml test suspension) then 10 seeds were sowed in each pots, 10
pots were used for each test as replicate. Percentage of damping - off was
recorded at 2 weeks after planting.
3.3. Using combination of biological and chemical control:
Seeds of sorghum cultivars Giza-15 & Dorado were soaking 12 hr. in
certain solutions of resistance inducers as described above, air dried then
singly dressed by bio-control products Rhizo-N and Plant-Guard similarly as
mentioned before. Treated seeds were sowed. Percentage of damping-off was
recorded as above described . Only the highest concentrations ( 4mg/liter
distilled water of the bio-logical control product and 200ppm of resistance
inducers ) were tested in this experiment . This experiment was conducted in
sorghum cv. Dorado with 3 replicates at one season 2008.
34
Statistical analysis :
Data were subjected to statistical analysis of variance. The experimental
design(s) of all studies was a completely randomized with three replications,
analysis of variance of the data was performed with the MSTAT-C statistical
package (A) micro-computer program for the design, management, and
analysis of agronomic research experiments. Michigan State Univ., USA.
Least significant difference ( LSD) was used to compare treatment means
(Gomez and Gomez, 1984). Otherwise the experiment of using combination
of resistance inducers and bio-control products was analyzed using Duncan
procedure ( Duncan,1955 ).
35
EXPERMENTAL
RESULTS
I-Pathological studies:
1.1- Survey of grain sorghum stalk rot/wilt diseases:
Generally, stalk rot / wilt diseases of grain sorghum were observed in
each location examined. However, the percentage of diseases was varied
with location. At Bani Helal, Assuit governorate the least percentage
……………
(4.0%) has been recorded, (Table 1).
Of eight locations, only 2 (El-Hedayat) and (EL-Zawaida) Qena
governorate gave the highest incidence of stalk rot / wilt diseases (24%).
However, stalk rot / wilt of grain sorghum are characterized as
progresses, whole leaves die and disease symptoms appear as the
pathogen spreads into the younger leaves. The disease often results in
discoloration
of
vascular
tissue
in
leaves
and
stalks.
.
1.2- Isolation of the causal pathogen:.
Acremonium strictum was isolated consistently from stalks, leaf
sheaths, and leaves of diseased plants. Several sorghum entries were
resistant to the pathogen following natural infection or foliar clipping in
the field. However, drenching around injured roots with inoculum and
injecting a conidial suspension at the base of the plant increased their
36
susceptibility. .
Table 1: Average percentage of stalk rot/wit disease affecting grain sorghum
(Sorghum bicolor L.) during 2005 season at various regions of Assuit,
Sohag and Qena governorates.
Governorate
Cultivar
locations
Stalk rot
Bani- Helal
04.00
Assuit
Giza113
Giza-15
El-Gazira
09.00
Assuit
Giza-15
Bani Mohamed
13.00
Sohag
Giza-15
Awlad yahia
14.00
Sohag
Al-Eesawia
14.00
Sohag
Giza113
Giza-15
Bardees
15.00
Qena
Giza-15
El-Hedayat
24.00
Qena
Giza113
El-Mahrosa
22.00
Qena
Giza-15
El-Zawaida
24.00
Assuit
Mean
15.44
* Values are means of three fields per region.
1.3. Pathogenicity test:
Eight fungal isolates disputed A1, A2, A3---A8 were subjected for
pathogenicity test to grain sorghum cv. Giza-15 (Table 2). Isolates varied
in their infectivity to grain sorghum, in soil infests isolate A1 gave the
highest percentages of dampped off grain sorghum (60 %), followed by
A2 and A3, while A8 showed the least number of damped-off grain
sorghum.
1.4. Disease assessment :
Stalk inoculation gave the highest disease severity (33.12 and 36.17% )
by isolate A1 followed by isolate A2 and A3 (40.08% ), while least stalk
rot severity was obtained ( 18% ), ( 14.22% ) by isolate A5 and A8.
However, all isolates are similar in their morphological and
microscopical characters. Thus, the highest 3 virulent isolates (A1, A2
and A3) were identified.
.
1.5. Identification of the casual pathogen:
Identification treats revealed that all isolates examined are belong to
Acremonium genus according to Barent and Hunter, (1972).
Furthermore, identification was confirmed by Assuit University
Mycological Center (AUMC) and declared that all isolates A1, A2 and
A3 are Acremonium strictum. (Fig.3).
.
38
Fig. 3: Morphological (A) and microscopical (B) characters of Acremonium strictum
isolate A1.
Pathogenicity test :
Table 2: Pathogenicity of fungus isolated from stalks of grain
sorghum varieties.
%Dampping-off
% Stalk
infection
60.00
44.00
Giza-15
40.08
33.12
stalk
Giza-15
44.67
36.17
A4
stalk
Giza-15
38.17
31.97
A5
stalk
Giza-15
18.00
A6
stalk
Giza-15
24.83
34.03
A7
stalk
Giza-113
29.11
20.07
A8
stalk
Giza-113
22.85
14.22
Source
varieties
stalk
Giza-15
A2
stalk
A3
Isolates
A1
Control
00.00
Mean
32.63
00.00
24.90
L.S.D (0.05):
Variety
A
06.91
02.67
Isolates
B
04.00
01.88
Reaction A.B
05.40
03.24
41
26.67
a1.6. Response of grain sorghum cultivars to Acremonium
strictum infection:
Response of 7 grain sorghum cultivars to infection by Acremonium
strictum isolate A1, infection was tested under soil infestation and stalk
inoculation (Table 3 and Fig.4).
A significant difference was exhibited among grain sorghum
cultivars. Under soil infestation, grain sorghum cv. Giza-15 gave the
highest susceptibility (60.67% dampped off seedlings) followed by Giza113 cultivar (51.83 % dampped off seedlings). ……………………..
Contrary, grain sorghum cultivars Dorado showed the least
susceptibility to infection by Acremonium strictum (32%dampped off
seedlings). Other tested cultivars (Shandawel-2, Shandawel-6, Hors and
Mina) reacted as moderate susceptible to A. strictum infection.
By stalk rot inoculation, highest stalk rot severity (58%) was
provided with cultivar Giza-15 followed by Giza-113, while the least
stalk rot severity was expressed by cv. Dorado (13.33%) followed by
Hors (33.30%).
.
42
Table3:Varietals response to infected by stalk rot caused by Acremonium
strictum isolate A1 during season 2006.
Cultivars
%Damped off
seedlings
plants
%Stalk infection
Shandwel-2
Shandwel-6
47.17
47.17
43.00
42.60
Giza-113
51.83
50.00
Hors
44.23
33.30
Mina
46.00
43.33
Dorado
32.00
13.33
Giza-15
60.67
58.00
Mean
41.14
35.28
L.S.D (0.05) :
Cultivars A
02.86
02.00
Pathogen B
01.97
02.13
Reaction A.B
02.88
02.92
43
% Damping-off seedlings
Sh
an
dw
el
-6
Sh
an
dw
el
-2
-1
13
Gi
za
Ho
rs
M
ina
Do
ra
do
Gi
za
-1
5
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
% Stalk rot severity
Sh
an
dw
el
-6
Sh
an
dw
el
-2
-1
13
G
iza
H
or
s
M
ina
D
or
ad
o
G
iza
-1
5
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Fig.4: Vertial response to infected by sorghum stalk rot pathogen Acremonium
strictum
.
44
1.7- Host range:
All tested plants were infected by A. strictum isolate A1 (Table 4 and
Fig. 7). The highest percentage of dampped –off seedlings was recorded
by maize (55%) and pear-millet (54%) whereas, the least percentage of
dampped –off seedlings (25%) was expressed by okra and sugarcane
(30%). On the other hand, stalk rot severity varied with different plant
species. Maize plants gave the highest stalk rot severity (50%) followed
by pear-millet (40.83%). Sugarcane plants showed least stalk rot severity
(10.33%) followed by okra plants that exhibited (20.24%) stalk rot
severity.
.
II- Laboratory studies:
2.1. Effect of temperature on the growth of A. strictum:
Growth of A. strictum isolate A1 expressed as linear growth (mm)
was significant affected by temperature (Table 5 and Fig. 8). Since no
growth for A. strictum was measured at 10 Ĉ and maximum linear growth
was exhibited by 35Ĉ (82.33) and 30Ĉ (80.00). Temperature less than
30Ĉ and more than 35Ĉ significantly decreased linear growth. As for
mycelial dry weight, similar results were obtained, (Table 5 and Fig. 8).
Since at 35Ĉ, maximum mycelial dry weight (498) was provided
followed by 30 Ĉ (483) and least mycelial dry weight (157) by 15 Ĉ.
45
Table 4 : Incidence of damping-off and stalk rot for some Gramenacae plants a
okra inoculated with stalk rot pathogen Acremonium strictum isolate No. A1
Plants
Damped-off
seedlings%
Stalk rot
severity%
Maize
( Zea maize cv. Giza-
55.00
50.00
30.00
10.33
44.67
38.47
54.00
40.83
25.00
20.24
41.73
31.97
33)
Sugar cane
(Saccharum officinarum
cv. G 80/36)
Wheat
(Triticum estivum
vulgarisl cv. G 168)
Pear – millet
(Pennistum glaucum
cv.G 40)
Okra
(Abedmoschus
esculantus cv. G 80)
Mean
L.S.D (0.05) :
Plants
(A)
02.87
01.49
Pathogen (B)
01.68
01.30
Reaction A.B
03.13
01.90
46
% Damping-off seedlings
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Okra
Pear-millet
Wheat
Sugarcane
Maize
% Stalk rot severity
50
40
30
20
10
0
Okra
Pear-millet
Wheat
Sugarcane
Maize
Fig.5:Incidence of damping –off and stalk rot for some
Gramenaceae plants and Okra, inoculated with grain sorghum
pathogen Acremonium strictum.
47
Experimental Results
Table 5: Effect of different degrees of temperature on linear
growth (mm) and dry weight (mg) of A .strictum grown on Czapeck's
medium7days after incubation (for dry weight) in vitro.
Temperature
Linear growth (mm) Mycelial dry
weight (mg)
10 C
00.00
00.00
15 C
22.00
157
20 C
67.00
397
25 C
74.90
420
30 C
80.00
483
35 C
82.33
498
40 C
75.67
441
57.41
342.28
Mean
L.S.D (0.01):
Temperature
A
0 2.57
01.94
Pathogen
B
0 2.68
01.39
Reaction
A.B
48
0 3.88
0 2.77
A
Linear growth (mm)
100
80
60
40
20
40 Cْ
35 Cْ
30 Cْ
25 Cْ
20 Cْ
15 Cْ
10 Cْ
0
B
Mycelial dry weight (mg)
500
400
300
200
100
40 Cْ
35 Cْ
30 Cْ
25 Cْ
20 Cْ
15 Cْ
10 Cْ
0
Fig 6: Effect of different degrees of temperature on (A) linear growth
(mm) , (B) dry weight (mg) of A .strictum isolate A1.
49
2.2. Effect of antioxidants and calcium chloride on linear growth of
Acremonium strictum isolate No.A1:
Data obtained in Table (6) showed significant reduction in linear
growth of Acremonium strictum by either AA or SA and by CaCl2 .
Increasing concentrations of AA or SA enhanced inhibitory effects
towards linear growth of Acremonium strictum. Calcium chloride at
tested concentrations showed insignificant reduction in the linear growth
of A. strictum. Meanwhile, AA and SA showed insignificant reduction in
the linear growth of Acremonium strictum at concentration 50 ppm.
Using 100 ppm concentration for AA or SA gave 0.7% inhibition,
respectively. SA showed more inhibitory effect towards A. strictum than
AA. However, fungicide vitavax-thiram showed inhibitory effect towards
linear growth of A. strictum even at lowest concentration tested (50 ppm),
since it caused 71% inhibition and exhibited 76 and 88% inhibition at
100 and 200 ppm concentrations, respectively.
.
.
2.3. Effect of antioxidants and calcium chloride on mycelial dry
weight of Acremonium strictum isolate No.A1:
The recent results show the significant inhibitory effects of either
AA or SA towards mycelial dry weight of Acremonium strictum
especially at 100 and 200 ppm concentrations ( Table 7). Calcium
chloride gave no inhibitory effect towards A. strictum. The fungicide
vitavax-thiram showed the highest inhibition to mycelial dry weight of A.
strictum.
.
50
.
Table 6: Linear growth (mm) of A. strictum isolate No.A1 as influenced by different
concentrations (ppm) of two antioxidants, ascorbic acid (AA) and salicylic acid (SA
and calcium chloride (CaCl2) compared with the fungicide vitavax-thiram (VT) i
vitro.
Chemical
Conc.(ppm)
Linear growth (mm)
% inhibition
AA
50
84.00
05.00
AA
100
82.00
07.00
AA
200
80.00
09.00
82.00
07.00
Mean
SA
50
83.00
06.00
SA
100
82.00
07.00
SA
200
78.00
10.00
81.00
07.66
Mean
CaCl2
50
83.00
06.00
CaCl2
100
81.00
08.00
CaCl2
200
80.00
08.33
81.33
07.44
50
25.00
71.00
100
20.00
76.00
200
10.00
88.00
Mean
18.33
78.33
Control
85.00
00.00
Mean
69.53
18.20
Mean
Vitavaxthiram
Vitavaxthiram
Vitavaxthiram
L.S.D (0.01):
Chemicals
A
07 .33
04.24
Concentration
B
08.09
05.11
A.B
10.78
05.87
Interaction
51
Table 7: Mycelial dry weight (mg/50 ml liquid media) of A. strictum as affected by
different concentrations (ppm) of two antioxidants, ascorbic acid (AA) and salicylic
acid (SA) and calcium chloride (CaCl2) compared with the fungicide vitavax-thiram
(VT) in vitro.
Chemical
Conc.(ppm)
Mycelial dry weight (
mg/50 ml liqiud media
)
% inhibition
AA
50
648.00
00.30
AA
100
311.00
52.00
AA
200
236.00
63.00
398.33
32.00
Mean
SA
50
620.00
04.60
SA
100
283.00
56.00
SA
200
198.00
69.00
367.00
30.00
50
650.00
00.00
CaCl2
100
645.00
00.80
CaCl2
200
645.00
00.80
646.66
07.66
50
313.00
52.00
100
158.00
76.00
200
112.00
83.00
194.33
78.33
650.00
00.00
451.26
29.59
Mean
CaCl2
Mean
Vitavaxthiram
Vitavaxthiram
Vitavaxthiram
Mean
Control
Mean
L.S.D (0.01):
Chemicals
Concentration
Interaction
A
11 .57
01.94
B 13.88
01.39
A.B
18.68
52
02.97
2.4. Effect of antioxidants and calcium chloride on spore production
of Acremonium strictum isolate No.A1:
A significant reduction in spore formation by Acremonium strictum
was provided when antioxidants amended to Czapeck's medium (Table
8). Calcium chloride gave no effect towards spore formation even at 200
ppm concentration as compared with cheek treatment. Suppression of
spore formation was enhanced by increasing antioxidants concentrations.
Salicylic acid was more effective to suppress spore formation at 200 ppm
concentration than AA. To be mentored, vitavax-thiram showed the most
suppressive to certain compounds tested.
.
2.5. Antagonistic potentiality of Trichoderma harzianum and Bacillus
subtilis against Acremonium strictum isolate No.A1 in vitro:
Both of biocontrol agents used i.e., Trichoderma harzianum and
Bacillus subtilis showed significant antagonistic potentiality against A.
strictum in vitro (Table 9). Trichoderma harzianum showed more
antagonistic potentiality (75% growth inhibition) than B. subtilis (56.24%
growth inhibition).
.
53
Table 8 : Spore production (x 105 per 1 cm2 medium) of Acremonium strictum as
affected by different concentrations (ppm) of two antioxidants ;
ascorbic acid (AA), salicylic acid (SA) and calcium chloride (CaCl2)
compared with fungicide vitavax-thiram (VT) in vitro.
Sporulation ( spores number
x105 per 1 cm2 medium)
Compounds
Conc. (ppm)
AA
50
34.00
±
0.52
100
29.00
±
0.12
200
26.00
±
0.10
50
31.00
±
0.41
100
29.00
±
0.30
200
23.00
±
0.05
50
40.00
±
0.80
100
39.00
±
0. 50
200
39.00
±
0. 43
50
08.6
±
0.10
100
08.1
±
0.13
200
04.00
0
40.6
SA
CaCl2
Vitavax-thiram
Control
± 0.03
±
0.145
* Values are means of three replicates per treatment ± Standard Error (SE).
54
Table 9: Antagonistic potentiality of Trichoderma harzianum and Bacill
;;;;;;;;subtilis against Acremonium strictum isolate No.A1 in vitro.
Linear growth
(mm)
35.00
Treatments
B. subtilis
Growth
inhibition %
56.24
20.00
75.00
Control
80.00
00.00
Mean
45.00
43.74
T. harzianum
L.S.D at (1%):
Treatment
A
0.103
Pathogen
B
1.142
Interaction
A.B
1.246
55
Fig. 8: Antagonistic capability of Bacillus subtilis and Trichoderma harzianum
against the tested fungus Acremonium strictum in vitro .
A
B
C
Control
T.harzianum
B. subtilis
56
2.6. Effect of antioxidants and calcium chloride on antagonistic
potentiality of Trichoderma harzianum and Bacillus subtilis against
Acremonium strictum :
All chemicals tested provided insignificant effects towards the
potentiality of either B. subtilis or T. harzianum against A. strictum
.
compared to non amended plates (Table 10).
III- Possible management of grain sorghum damping-off and stalk
rot diseases :
3.1. Using seed soaking in resistance inducers :
3.1.1. Possible management of grain sorghum damping- off :
Soaking seeds of grain sorghum in solutions of resistance inducers
resulted significant reduction in dampped off seedlings (Table 11and 12).
Reduction in dampped of seedlings was varied with resistance inducers,
sorghum cultivars and chemical concentrations used. The least percentage
of damping-of was recorded by AA (35%) at 200 ppm for Giza-15 cv.
and (16%) for Dorado cv., the least percentage of damping-off was
recorded by CaCl2 (25%) for Giza-15 cv. and (11%) for Dorado cv. at the
first season. While the least percentage of damping-off at the second
season was recorded by AA (32.33%) and the least percentage of
damping-off was CaCl2 (26.10%) for Giza-15 cv. and the least percentage
of damping-off by AA (16%) and the least percentage by CaCl2 (10.67%)
for Dorado cv. Increasing concentration of certain chemicals increased
protection of sorghum against damping off causing by Acremonium
strictum. In general a significant highest protection pronounced by
fungicide vitavax-thiram, followed by CaCl2 . Lowest protection was
provided by AA, while SA caused moderate protection. Resistance was
more induced in Dorado cultivar than Giza-15 cv.
.
.
57
Table 10 : Antagonistic potentiality of Trichoderma harzianum and Bacil
subtilis against Acremonium strictum as affected by ascorbic acid (A
salicylic acid (SA) and calcium chloride (CaCl2) in vitro.
Chemicals
Conc.ppm %Growth inhibition
caused by,
B. subtilis T. harzianum
AA
100
200
56.4±2.1
61.2±2.8
70.3±3.2
73.2±2.2
SA
100
200
54.8 ±3.2
65.2±3.6
71.8±1.7
77.5±2.6
CaCl2
100
200
58.4±2.0
59.6±1.6
69.8±3.1
80.7±2.8
55.00±2.4
77.00±3.2
Control
(free of antioxidants or
CaCl2)
* Data are means of 3 replicates ± standard error (SE).
58
Table11: Average percentage of damped off sorghum seedlings of two cultivars cause
by A. strictum isolate No.A1 as influenced by 12hr seed-soaking in various
concentrations of ascorbic acid (AA), salicylic acid (SA) and calcium chloride (CaCl
compared with fungicide vitavax-thiram (VT) during season 2007.
Sorghum cultivars
Chemicals
Giza-15
Conc.ppm
50
100
200
AA
Mean
SA
%damping%damping%protection
%protection
off
off
40.00
09.10
19.00
24.00
38.00
35.00
13.60
20.40
37.66
14.36
18.00
16.00
30.70
34.60
17.66
29.76
50
38.00
13.60
18.00
30.70
100
35.00
20.40
18.00
46.10
200
30.00
31.80
13.00
50.00
16.33
42.26
Mean
CaCl2
Dorado
34.33
21.93
50
34.00
22.70
13.00
50.00
100
31.00
29.50
13.00
50.00
200
25.00
43.20
11.00
57.70
30.00
31.80
12.33
52.56
Mean
Vitavax -
50
25.00
43.20
12.00
53.80
thiram
100
15.00
66.00
08.00
61.50
200
08.00
81.80
00.00
70.00
16.00
63.66
06.66
61.76
44.00
00.00
26.00
00.00
15.79
37.26
Mean
0
Control
(Water)
Mean
32.39
26.35
L.S.D:.05
Vareities
A
1.77
A.B
1.46
Chemicals
B
2.23
A.C
2.23
B.C
A.B.C
2.40
2.65
Concentration C 1.16
Table 12: Average percentage of damped off sorghum seedlings of two cultivars cause
by A. strictum isolate No.A1 as influenced by 12hr seed-soaking in various
concentrations of ascorbic acid (AA), salicylic acid (SA) and calcium chloride
(CaCl2) compared with fungicide vitavax-thiram (VT) during season 2008.
Sorghum cultivars
Chemicals
Giza-15
Dorado
%damping%dampingConc.ppm
%protection
%protection
off
off
50
39.11
10.16
17.83
26.67
100
200
AA
Mean
SA
13.67
22.33
36.25
15.38
17.00
16.00
32.11
35.00
16.94
31.26
50
38.16
14.24
17.00
28.00
100
35.00
22.80
17.00
34.00
200
30.67
32.00
11.33
52.17
Mean
CaCl2
37.33
32.33
34.61
23.00
15.11
38.05
50
36.67
28.00
12.24
49.83
100
30.16
31.11
12.00
54.33
200
26.10
44.00
10.67
58.00
30.97
34.37
11.63
54.05
10.00
55.83
Mean
Vitavax -
50
22.43
46.67
thiram
100
17.16
68.00
00.00
70.00
200
09.67
80.67
00.00
100.00
Mean
0
Control
16.42
65.11
03.33
75.27
43.83
00.00
25.33
00.00
14.46
39.72
(Water)
Mean
32.41
27.57
L.S.D:.05
Vareities
A
2.38
A.B
3.19
Chemicals
B
2.23
A.C
1.11
B.C
A.B.C
2.08
2.88
Concentration C 0.90
3.1.2. Possible management of grain sorghum stalk rot :
A significant reduction in sorghum stalk rot severity was obviously
provided by seed soaking for 12 hr., resistance inducer reduction tested
(Table 13 and 14). Protection against stalk rot causing fungus A. strictum
varied with resistance inducers and their concentrations tested, and
sorghum cultivars as well. Hundred protections were achieved by
fungicide vitavax-thiram only (100%) for the sorghum cultivars Giza-15
and Dorado at season1 and season2 by the same concentration (200ppm).
.
At concentration at 200ppm, CaCl2 gave the highest protection (after
fungicide) it gave (41.70% protection) for Giza-15 cv. and (86.90%
protection) for cv. Dorado at first season, as compared with AA or SA.
While at second season CaCl2 recorded protection (44.43%) for cv. Giza15 and (88%) for cv. Dorado. The least protection was recorded by AA it
gave (25% protection) for Giza-15 cv. and (34.60%) for cv. Dorado, at
first season, while it recorded at second season (Table 14) 23% protection
for cv. Giza-15 and 35% for cv. Dorado.
.
Increasing concentrations of chemicals enhanced resistance ability of
grain sorghum plants. Salicylic acid was more effective than AA. Dorado
cultivar was more responded to resistance elicitors than Giza-15 cv.
61
Table 13: Stalk rot severity caused by A. strictum infection to grain sorghum plants a
affected by 12hr seed-soaking in ascorbic acid (AA), salicylic acid (SA) and
calcium chloride (CaCl2) compared with fungicide vitavax-thiram (VT) during
season 2007.
Sorghum cultivars
Chemicals
Giza-15
Conc.ppm
AA
14.20
100
200
22.70
21.00
18.90
25.00
22.56
19.36
11.10
27.43
50
22.30
20.30
11.00
28.10
100
21.00
25.00
05.70
62.70
200
20.00
28.50
03.30
78.40
21.10
24.60
50
28.60
28.10
34.60
06.66
56.40
08.00
47.70
17.60
37.10
07.70
49.60
200
16.30
41.70
02.00
86.90
50
17.96
35.80
05.90
61.40
08.30
76.30
00.00
100.00
100
06.30
77.50
00.00
100.00
200
00.00
100.00
00.00
100.00
04.86
84.60
00.00
100.00
28.00
00.00
15.30
00.00
07.79
49.04
Mean
0
Control
20.00
11.00
10.00
100
Mean
Vitavax -thiram
%Stalk
rot
%protection
severity
12.30
19.60
24.00
Mean
CaCl2
%Stalk rot
%protection
severity
50
Mean
SA
Dorado
(Water)
Mean
18.89
32.87
L.S.D:.05
Vareities
A
1.09
A.B
1.22
Chemicals
B
1.85
A.C
2.03
Concentration
C 3.93
B.C
A.B.C
0.90
2.77
Table 14: Stalk rot severity caused by A. strictum infection to grain sorghum plants as
affected by 12hr seed-soaking in ascorbic acid (AA), salicylic acid (SA) and calcium
chloride (CaCl2) compared with fungicide vitavax-thiram (VT) during season 2008.
Sorghum cultivars
Chemicals
Giza-15
Dorado
%Stalk
%Stalk rot
Conc.ppm
%protection
%protection
rot
severity
severity
50
22.11
16.33
11.67
18.33
100
200
AA
21.83
20.00
18.67
23.00
22.56
19.36
50
21.43
22.66
11.33
27.40
100
20.00
25.33
06.00
68.00
200
18.16
28.00
03.33
79.33
21.10
24.60
Mean
SA
Mean
50
CaCl2
06.66
56.40
27.60
08.00
33.33
38.00
06.66
50.00
200
14.80
44.43
04.33
88.00
17.96
35.80
05.90
61.40
50
07.50
48.80
00.00
100.00
100
04.43
79.16
00.00
100.00
200
00.00
100.00
0
Mean
100.00
84.60
00.00
100.00
28.00
00.00
15.30
00.00
07.79
49.04
18.89
32.87
Vareities
A
2.48
A.B
2.20
Chemicals
B
3.16
A.C
0.98
B.C
A.B.C
1.10
3.19
2.97
00.00
04.86
L.S.D:.05
Concentration C
27.43
17.83
Mean
Control (Water)
11.10
30.33
35.00
100
Mean
Vitavax -th
20.00
10.33
10.00
Table 15: Average percentage of dampped off sorghum seedlings of two cultivars
caused by A. strictum isolate No.A1 as influenced by 12hr seed-soaking in various
concentrations of biocides Rhizo-1N and Plant-Guard compared with fungicide
vitavax-thiram (VT) during season 2007.
Chemicals
Sorghum cultivars
Conc.
1gm/liter
Rhizo-N
2gm/liter
32.00
39.24
14.30
53.83
4gm/liter
30.00
43.87
14.00
65.60
31.66
38.47
Mean
Plant-Guard
Giza-15
Dorado
%damping%damping%protection
%protection
off
off
33.00
32.30
16.00
37.00
14.76
52.14
1gm/liter
28.00
39.50
10.00
54.67
2gm/liter
20.00
53.66
08.00
63.18
4gm/liter
17.00
68.33
06.00
83.40
08.00
67.08
Mean
Vitavaxthiram
21.66
53.83
50
26.00
43.40
10.00
59.67
100
17.00
67.00
08.67
81.83
200
08.00
82.00
00.00
100.00
Mean
17.00
64.13
06.22
80.50
Control (water)
48.00
00.00
29.33
00.00
Mean
29.58
39.10
14.57
66.57
* Concentrations of biocontrol products were 1,2, and 4 gm / liter
distilled water.
L.S.D:.05
Vareities
A
Chemicals
B
2.14
A.B 3.89
3.87
A.C 3.38
Concentration C 2.28
B.C 4.40
A.B.C 05.09
64
Table 16: Average percentage of dampped off sorghum seedlings of two cultivars
caused by A. strictum as influenced by 12hr seed-soaking in various
concentrations of biocides Rhizo-N and Plant-Guard compared with fungicide
vitavax-thiram (VT) during season 2008.
Chemicals
Sorghum cultivars
Conc.ppm
1gm/liter
Rhizo-N
2gm/liter
30.16
31.80
15.00
55.00
4gm/liter
28.44
44.00
14.16
62.00
30.13
32.06
Mean
Plant-Guard
Giza-15
Dorado
%damping%damping%protection
%protection
off
off
31.80
20.40
15.33
38.18
14.83
51.72
1gm/liter
28.00
29.33
11.33
52.80
2gm/liter
21.33
55.00
10.00
61.40
4gm/liter
18.11
70.18
07.67
83.33
09.66
65.84
Mean
22.48
Vitavaxthiram
51.50
50
26.33
44.00
10.33
62.18
100
18.10
66.00
07.50
81.00
200
07.67
83.33
00.00
100.00
Mean
17.36
64.44
05.94
81.06
Control (water)
47.66
00.00
26.83
00.00
Mean
29.40
37.00
14.31
49.65
* Concentrations of biocontrol products were 1,2, and 4 mg / liter
distllised water.
L.S.D:.05
Vareities
A
3.04
A.B
3.89
Chemicals
B
2.23
A.C
3.75
Concentration C
1.95
B.C
2.24
A.B.C 6.44
65
3.2. Using seed coating by commercial biocontrol products:
3.2.1. Control of damping-off:
Planting of dressed seeds of sorghum with biocontrol products ,
Rhizo-N and Plant-Guard resulted resistant sorghum seedlings against A.
strictum infection along two growing seasons tested as percentage of
damped-off seedlings ( Table 15 and 16 ) .
.
Sorghum Dorado cv. gave higher resistance than Giza-15 cv. as
response to biocontrol products. Plant-Guard was more effective to
control damping-off than Rhizo-N, Plant-Guard gave (68.33% protection
at concentration 4gm/liter distilled water) for cv. Giza-15 and (83.40%)
for cv. Dorado at first season.
.
Plant-Guard at second season gave (70% protection ) for cv. Giza-15
and (83.33% protection) for cv. Dorado. Increasing biocontrol
concentrations increased the reduction in damped-off seedlings.
3.2.1. Control of stalk rot:
Sorghum stalk rot was significantly reduced using biocontrol products
as seed dressing among 2 growing seasons tested (Table 17 and 18).
Sorghum cultivar Dorado gave higher resistance than Giza-15 cv.
Rhizo-N gave lower protection compared with Plant-Guard as achieved
52 and 67% protection for Giza-15 and Dorado cultivars, respectively.
However complete protection against stalk rot caused by A. strictum was
obtained by 100 ppm vitavax-thiram using cv. Dorado.
66
.
Table 16: Average percentage of dampped off sorghum seedlings of two cultivars
caused by A. strictum as influenced by 12hr seed-soaking in various
concentrations of biocides Rhizo-N and Plant-Guard compared with fungicide
vitavax-thiram (VT) during season 2008.
Chemicals
Sorghum cultivars
Conc.ppm
1gm/liter
Rhizo-N
2gm/liter
30.16
31.80
15.00
55.00
4gm/liter
28.44
44.00
14.16
62.00
30.13
32.06
Mean
Plant-Guard
Giza-15
Dorado
%damping%damping%protection
%protection
off
off
31.80
20.40
15.33
38.18
14.83
51.72
1gm/liter
28.00
29.33
11.33
52.80
2gm/liter
21.33
55.00
10.00
61.40
4gm/liter
18.11
70.18
07.67
83.33
09.66
65.84
Mean
22.48
Vitavaxthiram
51.50
50
26.33
44.00
10.33
62.18
100
18.10
66.00
07.50
81.00
200
07.67
83.33
00.00
100.00
Mean
17.36
64.44
05.94
81.06
Control (water)
47.66
00.00
26.83
00.00
Mean
29.40
37.00
14.31
49.65
* Concentrations of biocontrol products were 1,2, and 4 mg / liter
distllised water.
L.S.D:.05
Vareities
A
3.04
A.B
3.89
Chemicals
B
2.23
A.C
3.75
Concentration C
1.95
B.C
2.24
A.B.C 6.44
67
Table 17: Stalk rot severity caused by A. strictum infection to grain sorghum plants
as affected by 12hr seed-soaking in various concentrations of biocides Rhizo-N
and Plant-Guard compared with fungicide vitavax-thiram (VT) during season
2007.
Chemicals
Sorghum cultivars
Conc.ppm
1gm/liter
Rhizo-N
2gm/liter
18.00
21.24
10.67
39.30
4gm/liter
12.00
32.67
08.83
48.91
17.66
24.03
Mean
Plant-Guard
Giza-15
Dorado
%Stalk rot
%Stalk rot
%protection
%protection
severity
severity
23.00
18.20
13.00
20.00
10.83
36.07
1gm/liter
18.00
22.60
10.00
40.68
2gm/liter
10.00
58.67
08.43
77.67
4gm/liter
07.00
75.83
04.40
85.00
07.61
67.78
Mean
Vitavaxthiram
11.66
52.36
50
10.00
73.18
08.00
93.83
100
07.83
81.20
00.00
100.00
200
00.00
100.00
00.00
100.00
Mean
05.94
84.79
02.66
97.94
Control (water)
29.13
00.00
14.33
00.00
Mean
17.00
40.29
08.85
50.44
* Concentrations of biocontrol products were 1,2, and 4 gm / liter distilled water.
L.S.D:.05
Vareities
A
02.14
A.B
Chemicals
B
0 3.87
A.C 0 3.38
Concentration C 0 2.28
B.C
B.C 01.90
02.77
04.40
A.B.C 0 3.89
A.B.C 05.32
68
Table 18: Stalk rot severity caused by A. strictum infection to grain sorghum plants
as affected by 12hr seed-soaking in various concentrations of biocides Rhizo-N
and Plant-Guard compared with fungicide vitavax-thiram (VT) during season
2008.
Chemicals
Sorghum cultivars
Conc.ppm
1gm/liter
Rhizo-N
2gm/liter
19.80
22.10
11.33
40.83
4gm/liter
13.11
33.00
09.83
49.00
19.17
24.70
Mean
Plant-Guard
Giza-15
Dorado
%Stalk rot
%Stalk rot
%protection
%protection
severity
severity
24.60
19.00
13.00
21.33
11.66
37.05
1gm/liter
19.33
22.67
10.00
40.00
2gm/liter
13.00
59.33
09.33
78.00
4gm/liter
08.67
78.00
04.00
84.83
07.77
67.61
Mean
13.66
Vitavaxthiram
53.33
50
09.16
71.00
08.66
95.00
100
07.00
82.16
00.00
100.00
200
00.00
100.00
00.00
100.00
Mean
05.38
84.38
02.88
98.33
Control (water)
28.67
00.00
15.43
00.00
Mean
16.72
40.60
09.43
50.74
* Concentrations of biocontrol products were 1, 2 , and 4 gm / liter
distilled water.
L.S.D:.05
Vareities
A
Chemicals
B
Concentration C
03.28
04.18
03.01
A.B
03.25
A.C
04.61
B.C
03.22
A.B.C 06.49
69
3.3. Possible management of damping-off and stalk rot of sorghum
Using combinations of resistance inducers and biocontrol products:
Data summarized in Table 19 showed significant reduction in either in
damping-off or stalk rot of sorghum (cv. Dorado) infected by A. strictum
as result of seed treatment resistance inducers or bio control products.
Combining resistance inducers with bio control products gave various
results.
.
Combining AA with biocontrol products gave significant reduction in
damping-off and stalk rot more than application of AA alone or
biocontrol alone. As for SA, combining it with Rhizo-N reduced dampedoff seedling more than each alone it gave (11% damping-off) and
protection 62% with Rhizo-N, and (6%dampping-off) and protection
gave 79.30% with Plant-Guard. While AA+Rhizo-N gave 8% stalk rot
severity and protection 42.80% and it gave with Plant-Guard 2% stalk rot
severity and protection 85.70%. While Plant-Guard combined with SA
gave protection lower than PG alone but more than SA alone.
.
CaCl2 enhanced the potentiality of Rhizo-N to control damping-off
while it reduced PG ability. CaCl2 gave the same percentage of dampingoff with Rhizo-N or with Plant-Guard (10% damping-off).The difference
between CaCl2+Rhizo-N and CaCl2+Plant-Guard in the percentage of
stalk rot severity , CaCl2+Rhizo-N gave (10% stalk rot severity and
protection 28.50%), while CaCl2+Plant-Guard gave ( 4% stalk rot
severity and protection 71.90%).
.
70
Table 19: Average percentage of damping-off and stalk rot of sorghum cv
Dorado caused by A. strictum infection as affected by combination of resistance
inducer [ascorbic acid(AA), salicylic acid(SA) and calcium chloride (CaCl2)] with
biocontrol products (Rhizo-N,R and Plant- Guard,PG).
Treatment %Damping- %Protection %Stalk %Protection
off
rot
AA only
AA+R
AA+PG
16.00 B
11.00 C
06.00 E
44.8
62
79.3
10.00 B
8.00 C
02.00 D
28.5
42.8
85.7
SA only
SA+R
SA+PG
11.50 C
10.00 CD
60.43
65.5
3.00 D
08.00 C
64.2
42.9
69.9
09.00 B
35.7
D
85.7
CaCl2 only
CaCl2 +R
CaCl2+PG
R
PG
Vitavaxthiram
Water
09.00
D
11.00
C
62
02.00
10.00 CD
10.00 CD
65.5
65.5
10.00 B
04.00 D
28.5
71.9
14.00 B
06.00 E
00.00 F
51.7
79.3
100
09.00 B
04.00 D
00.00 E
35.7
71.9
100
00.00 F
100
00.00 E
100
29.00 A
0
14.00A
0
* Data are means of 3 replicates.
71
DISCUSSION
Sorghum ( Sorghum bicolor ( L.) Monech ) is an important field
crop that cultivated in a large area. However, sorghum plants are
attacked by several diseases such as smuts ( Marley and Aba, 1999 ),
downy mildew ( Frederiksen, 1980 ) , stalk rot/wilt and root rot (
Nyvall , 1989 ).
Different studies were concentrated towards smuts under Upper Egypt
conditions ( Mahmoud, 1989 and Botros, 1993 ) , but less attention had
payed to otherwise diseases. Observations showed the occurrence of
sorghum stalk rot.
Thus, the percent study was planned to gain some
information related to sorghum stalk rot / wilt under Upper Egypt
conditions.
A survey study showed the occurrence of sorghum stalk rot / wilt
diseases in each locations examined at a governorates of Upper Egypt
( Assuit, Sohag and Qena ) . The highest percentage ( 24% ) was
recorded in Qena governorate, while the least percentage ( 4% ) was
presented in Assuit governorate .
Data confirm the occurrence of stalk rot ⁄ wilt diseases affected grain
sorghum grown in Upper Egypt similarly as reported previously ( Hassan
et al.,1996 ; El-Shafey et al ., 1999). Likewise, sorghum stalk rot ⁄ wilt
diseases were recorded in different countries all over the world (Horne
and Berry 1980; Hundekar and Anahosur 1994 and Pande et
al.,1997) . However, several phytopathogenic fungi such as (
Colletotrichum graminicola ,Harman et al .,2004),( Macrophominia
71
phaseolina , Viswanathan and Francis , 2002 ) and ( Fusarium
moniliforme , Tesso et al ., 2004).
The present work was showed that the fungus Acremonium strictum
was only stalk rotting pathogen during this work. Results were
consistented with those reported elsewhere ( Mahalakshmi and
Bidinger , 2001 ). The obtained isolates were identified in Plant
Pathology Dep., Fac.Agric, Minia University as Acremonium spp
according to (Gams.1971).
Further identification for detecting fungus species was conducted in
AUMC where they identified the 3 isolates ( A1, A2 and A3 ) as
Acremonium strictum ( McGee et al., 1991). Pathogenisity test revealed
that all the tested fungal isolates were caused damping off and stalk rot
toward sorghum seedlings and plants, respectively. However, isolates
were varied in their virulence isolate No.A1 gave the highest percentage
of damping-off and stalk rot, while isolate No.A8 gave the least
percentage of damping-off and stalk rot. This agree with the finding of (
Lin and Huang ,1998 and Agrios , 1997 ).
Response of grain sorghum cultivars to A. strictum was varied. Since
sorghum cv. Giza-15 showed the highest susceptibility ( 60.7% damping
off seedlings ), while Dorado cv. appeared least susceptibility to A.
strictum ( 32% damping off seedlings) under soil infestation. Likewise,
Giza-15 exhibited highest stalk severity ( 58 % ) and cv. Dorado showed
least stalk rot severity ( 13.33 % ) .
72
Using resistance cultivars still the cheapest method to control several
plant diseases as confirmed by several researchers in various countries
with different plant-pathogen interaction ( Thakur et al ., 1996
;
Tesfaye et al ., 2004 and El-Bramawy and Shaban .,2007 ).
On the other hand, data showed that A. strictum was non-specific
pathogen. Since it has ability to infect other plant species beside grain
sorghum, maize, sugarcane, wheat, pear-millet and okra , plants were
infected by A. strictum that exhibited damping off and stalk rot . However
, maize and pear-millet showed highest infection and okra showed least
infection. Non-specific pathogen gave more problem to control it than the
specific one ( Armengol et al.,1998 ).
Laboratory studies provided an important information about factors
affecting growth of A. strictum. Growth of A. strictum was significant
affected by temperature . A . strictum failed to grow at 10 Ĉ , while it
showed maximum linear growth and mycelial dry weight by 35Ĉ and 30
Ĉ ( 82.33 and 80.00 mm linear growth and 498 and 483mg mycelial dry
weight , respectively ) . Antifungal, effects of antioxidants towards
fungal growth varied depended on fungal species and type of antioxidants
and their concentrations (Galal and Abdou, 1996; Mandavia et al.,
2000 and Abdou et al., 2001). Amborabe et al., (2002) showed
fungicidal effect for SA against fungus Eutypa lata the causal agent of
grape Eutypa dieback.
Similar results were obtained when the growth of A .strictum was
monitored as mycelial dry weight . Data are on line with these obtained
else where ( Leininger et al. ,1999). The obtained results proved that
either linear growth or mycelial dry weight were significantly reduced by
73
some chemical inducers especially AA and SA but not CaCl2 . AA was
inhibited A. strictum growth more than SA. Also SA and AA expressed
inhibitory affect against spore formation of Acremonium strictum.
Antioxidant compounds such as AA and SA showed antifungal
effects towards several phytopathogenic fungi as reported previously., i,e
Accordingly data could recommended using antioxidants seed treatment
for controlling grain sorghum damping-off and stalk rot/wilt. Results are
agree with many investigators who recommended antioxidants
application to control several plant diseases, i.e.cowpea fusarial disease (
Galal and Abdou,1996 ), potato late blight caused by Phytophthora
infestans (Quintanilla and Bishammauer,1998 ), tomato early blight
caused by Alternaria solani (Galal et al.,2000 ), sunflower rust caused by
Puccinia helianthi (Galal et al.,1997), tomato and cucumber grey molds
caused by Botrytis cinerea (Elad 1992), barley Fusarium blight
(Wisnieska and Chelkowski,1999), pear leaf spots caused by Alternaria
radicina and A.tenuissima (Galal et al.,1999), sesame root rot/wilt caused
by Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. sesame, Macrophomina phaseolina,
Theilaviopsis basicola and Mucor haemalis (Abdou et al.,2004 and
Shalaby et al., 2001 ) and citrus moulds caused by Penicilium digitatum
and Alternaria alternata (Shaat and Galal , 2004). While CaCl2 even at
200 ppm concentration showed insignificant effect against A. strictum
growth . However, at high concentration ( 100 and 200 ppm ) , CaCl2
showed inhibitory effects against Sclerotinia sclerotiorum ( El-Bana et al
., 2006) .
74
Using micro-organisms against plant pathogen has been approved
several years ago ( Aghnoom et al ., 1999 ; Sonawane and Pawar ,
2001 ; Caron et al ., 2002 ; Vyas et al ., 2002 ; Abou-Zeid et al ., 2002
and Singh and Singh , 2003 ). In vitro studies reveled that both bio
control agent ( bacterium B. subtilis and fungus T. harzianum ) have
antagonistic effects towards A. strictum growth . Trichoderma harzianum
was more suppressor ( 75 % growth suppression ) than B . subtilis that
inhibited A . strictum growth by 56.24 % . Data are consistitution with
these obtained previsions ( Duffy and Defago , 1997 and Raffaello et al .,
2003 ) . To be mentioned adding certain chemical inducers to growth
medium appeared insignificant effects towards the potentiality of either B
. subtilis or T . harzianum against A . strictum growth , similarly as
reported by Badran (2006).
Possible management of grain sorghum damping-off and stalk rot that
caused by A . strictum isolate No.A1 has been conducted using chemical
inducers and / or bio-control products . Application of chemical inducers
for controlling plant diseases took great attention during the last 2
decades ( Dmitrier and Jorin , 2003 and El-Baz , 2007 ) to avoid or
minimize fungicide application ( Rai et al.,2002 ; Singh and Goswami
,2003 ). The present study showed that AA , SA and CaCl2 are benefit to
control grain sorghum against A .strictum infection.
CaCl2 was most effective to induce resistance in grain sorghum
seedlings / plants against damping off or stalk rot causing fungus A.
strictum as compared to 2 antioxidants tested , AA and SA. Grain
sorghum cv. Dorado was most responded by chemical inducers than
Giza-15 cv. Calcium salts have been approved for controlling several
plant diseases such as bacterial plant diseases ( Abd-Alla, 2003 ) or
fungal plant diseases (Hussien et al. ,2002)
Both AA and SA showed their benefit for inducing plant resistance
against many diseases such as Phytophthora infestans (Arnoldi et al.,
1989 and Quintanilla and Brishammar, 1998), Aspergillus spp.,
Penicillium spp and Fusarium spp. (Thompson, 1992), Botryis cinerea
(Elad, 1992), F. graminearum, F.moniliforme, F.oxysporum, F.poae,
F.roseum and F. sporotrichioides (Thompson et al., 1993), Peronospora
tabocina (Cohen, 1994), Colletotrichum gleiosporiodes (Prusky et al.,
1995 ), F. moniliforme, F. oxysporum, and F.solani (Galal and Abdou
1996) Puccinia helianthi (Galal et al., 1997), Alternaria radicina and A.
tenuissima (Galal et al., 1999), A. solani and F. oxysporum f.sp.
lycopersici (Moustafa, 1999), F. oxysporum, F. solani and Rhizoctonia
solani (Shahda, 2000), F. oxysporum, F. solani and F. moniliforme (ElGanaieny et al.,
2002) and F. verticillioides and F. proliferatum
Reynoso et al., 2002).
.
Results are agree with many investigators who recommended
antioxidant application to control several plant diseases, i.e. cowpea
fusarial disease (Galal and Abdou, 1996), potato late blight caused by
Phytophthora infestans (Quintanilla and Bishammauer, 1998), tomato
early blight caused by Alternaria solani (Galal et al., 2000), sunflower
rust caused by Puccinia helianthi ( Galal et al., 1997), tomato and
cucumber grey molds caused by Botrytis cinerea (Elad, 1992), barley
Fusarium blight (Wisniewska and Chelkowski, 1999), pear leaf spots
caused by Alternaria radicina and A. tenuissima (Galal et al., 1999),
sesame root rot/wilt caused by Fusarium oxysporium f. sp. sesame,
76
Macrophomina phaseolina, Thieilaviopsis basicola and Mucor haemlais (Abdou et
al., 2004) and citrus moulds caused by Penicilium digitatum and Alternaria alternata
Shaat and Galal, 2004).
Inducing the systemic resistance in the host plant became a good target for
minimizing disease incidence or severity with least cost and without environmental
pollution.
.
There are several reports in the literature on using salicylic acid, ascorbic acid
and other antioxidant compounds as tool inducing resistance in the host plant (Elad,
1992; Galal et al., 1994, Shaat, et al., 2001; Abdou et al., 2001; Kuzniak, 2001;
El-Ganaieny et al., 2002 and Galal et al., 2002). Likewise, biocontrol trails became
a fungicides alternatives (El-Mohamedy,2009).
Both biocontrol products Rhizo-N and Plant-Guard gave significant reduction in
damping-off and stalk rot diseases. Plant-Guard was more effective to control dampingoff and stalk rot compared to Rhizo-N. Grain sorghum Dorado cv. was more responded
by treatments than Giza-15 cv. During 2 grown seasons. Data are on line with these
reported, previously (Ouf et al., 2002).
Third possible management experiment was studied the role of combination of
resistance inducers and biocontrol products for controlling sorghum damping-off and
stalk rot diseases caused by A. strictum. Various results were obtained in this respect.
Combining AA with biocontrol products showed synergistic effects. Since significant
reduction in sorghum damping-off and stalk rot more than application of AA or
biocontrol products alone. Data agree with those recorded by ( Abd-El-Kareem et a l.,
2001 ). Meantime, SA or CaCl2 gave synergistic effect with Rhizo-N but not with PlantGuard.
.
77
SUMMARY
The obtained results throughout the present work could be summarized as
fallows:
-Sorghum stalk rot disease were occurred wherever sorghum
grown in Upper Egypt (Assuit, Sohag and Qena governorates). Since the
highest percentage (24.00%) for variety Giza-15 followed by variety
Giza- 113 was reported in El-Hedayat and El-Zawaida locations in Qena
governorate, while in Assuit governorate, the least percentage (4.00%) for
variety Giza-15 followed by Giza-113 by the same value was obtained in
Bani-Helal location.
.
-Isolation and identification traits showed that the fungus Acremonium
strictum was only stalk rotting pathogen.
-Sorghum cultivars were variously responded to Acremonium strictum
infection. Cultivar Giza-15 appeared highest susceptibility (60.7%
damping off seedlings), while Dorado cv. gave least infection (32%
damping off seedlings) under soil infestation. Similarly, cv. Giza-15
expressed highest stalk rot severity (58%) and Dorado cv. was the least
affected (13.3% stalk rot severity) under stalk inoculation by tooth-pick.
.
78
-The fungus Acremonium strictum reacted as a non-specific pathogen,
since it has ability to infect other plant species such as maize, sugar cane,
wheat, pear-millet and okra.
-Laboratory studies revealed that growth of Acremonium strictum was
significantly affected by temperature. No growth was recorded at 10Ĉ.
While maximum was obtained by 35Ĉ. Also, growth of Acremonium
strictum was affected by chemical inducers, ascorbic acid (AA) and
salicylic acid (SA) but not by calcium chloride (CaCl2).
-Bio control agents,i.e., Bacillus subtilis and Trichoderma harzianum
showed antagonistic effects towards Acremonium strictum under
laboratory conditions. Trichoderma harzianum was more effective to
.suppress A. strictum growth than Bacillus subtilis. Furthermore,
potentiality of the bio control agents was not affected by adding
chemical inducers to the growth medium.
-Management experiments gave promising results to control sorghum
stalk rot / wilt diseases using chemical inducers and / or bio control
.products.
-Among chemical inducers, CaCl2 was the most effective to induce
. resistance in sorghum plants against Acremonium strictum infection
. followed by AA and SA.
79
.
- Both bio control products, Rhizo-N and Plant-Guard were reduced
sorghum damping-off and stalk rot / wilt that caused by A. strictum.
Plant-Guard was more effective to control sorghum damping-off / stalk
rot than Rhizo-N.
- In addition, combining chemical inducers with bio control products
showed various results. Ascorbic acid gave synergistic effect to control
sorghum damping-off / stalk rot when combined with either Rhizo-N
or
Plant-Guard.
80
REFERENCES
Abd-Alla, M. A. 2003. Effect of different salts on sour rot disease of
lime
.
fruit .Egypt.J.Appl.Sci.,18:89-101.
.
Abdel Ati, Y. Y.; Gad El-Hak, S. H.; Galal, A. A. and Moustafa, Y.
M. M. 2000. Effect of some antioxidant compounds on some
horticultural characters of four new F1 hybrids of tomato. J. Agric.
Sci. Mansoura Univ., 25(3):1649-1668.
Abd El-Ghany, M. M. O. 2007. Studies on some diseases of sugarcane
in Egypt.M.Sc.Thesis,Fac.of Agric,El-Minia,Univ.pp.56.
Abd El-Hai, K. M;EL-Metwally, M. A. ;El-Baz, S. M. and Zeid A.
M. .2009. The Use of Antioxidants and Microelements for
Controlling Damping-Off Caused by Rhizoctonia solani and
Charcoal Rot Caused by Macrophomina phasoliana on Sunflower.
Plant Pathology Journal. Vol. 8. Issue: 3. Page No.: 79-89.
Abd-El-Kareem, F.; Abd-Alla , M. A ; and El-Mohamedy , R. S. R.
2001. Induced resistance in potato plants for controlling late blight
disease under field conditions . Egypt. J. Phytopathol., 29:29-41.
Abd El-Latif, M. R. 1976. Studies on some fungi causing pod rot of
peanut in El-Minia Governorate. M. Sc. Thesis, Fac.of Agric, ElMinia, Assuit Univ.1-150.
Abd El-Monaim, M. F. 2002. Studies on root rot and damping-off
diseases of lentil (Lens esculenta L.) in Minia Governorate. M. Sc.
Thesis Facultyu of Agric. Minia Univ. pp.101.
Abdou, El-S.; Abd-Alla, H. M. and Galal, A. A. 2001. Survey of sesame
root rot/wilt diseases in Minia and their possible control by ascorbic
and salicylc acids. Asssiut J. Agric. Sci., 32(3):135-152.
Abdou, El-S.; Hanaa, H. M. Abd Alla.; Hassan, M. M. and Galal, A.
A. 2004. Effect of salicylic acid and yeast seed treatments on root
rot/wilt diseases of sesame. Assiut J. Agric Sci., 35 (2): 29-42.
81
Abou-Zeid, N.M.; El-Garhy, A. M. and (Sohir) A. Mokhtar. 2002.
Biological and chemical control of root-rot/wilt diseases in some
legume crops under greenhouse conditions in Egypt. Egyptian J.
Agric. Res.,80(4):1493-1501.
Aghnoom, R.; Falahati-Rastegar, M. and Jafarpour, B.. 1999.
Comparison of chemical and biological of cumin wilt ( F.
oxysporium f.sp.cumini) in lab. and greenhouse conditions . Iranian
J. Agric. Sci., 30 (3):619-630.
Agrios, N. G. 1997. Plant Pathology, 3rd ed. Academic Press Inc. San
Diego, CA.
Ahmed (Hoda), A. M.; K. AbdEl-Moneem; A. D. Allamand F. G. M.
Fahmy 2000. Biological control of root-rots and wilt disease of
cotton. Assuit J. Agric. Sci.,31 (2):269-286.
Amborabe, B. E.; Lessard, P. F.; Chollet, J. F. and Roblin, G. 2002.
Antifungal effects of salicylic acid and other benzoic acid
derivatives towards Eutypa lata: structure-activity relationship.
Plant Physiol. Biochem., 40: 1051-1060.
Armengol, J.; Martinez-Ferrer ,G.; E. Sanz; Bruton, B. D. and
Garcia-Jimenes, J. 1998. Host range of Acremonium
cucurbitacearum, cause of Acremonium collapse of muskmelon.
Plant Pathpl.47:29-35.
Arnoldi, A.; Carughi, M.; Farina, G.; Merlini, L. and Parrino, M.
G.
1989. Synthetic analogues of phytoalexins: Synthesis and antifungal
activity of potential free radicals scavengers. J. Agric and Food
Chemistry, 37: 505-512.
Ayaad, Hanaa, H. A. 2000. Studies on some cotton diseases. M. Sc.
Thesis Fac. of Agric., Minia Unive.pp.1-107.
Badran, W. E. 2006. Studies on some cumin diseases. M. Sc. Thesis Fac
.of Agric. Minia Unive. Minia, Egypt.pp1-95.
Barnet, H. L. and Hunter, B. B. 1972. Illustrated genera of imperfect
fungi. Burgess Pub. CC. Minneapolis, Minnesota, pp. 241.
82
Berry, S. Z.; Madumadu, G. G. and Uddin, M. R. 1988. Effect of
calcium and nitrogen nutrition on bacterial cancer disease of
tomato. Plant Soil., 112:113-120.
Biggs, A. 1999. Effect of calcium salts on apple bitter rot caused by two
Colletotrichum spp. Plant Disease. 83: 11, 1001-1005.
Borsani, O. B.; Victoriano, V. and Miguel, A. B. 2001. Evidence for a
role of salicylic acid in the oxidative damage generated by NaCl
and osmotic strees in arabidopsis seedlings. Plant Physiology On
Line Abstracts: 126 (3) : 1024.
Botros, S. A. 1993. Studies on kernel smut of sorghum in upper Egypt.
Ph.D. thesis, Fac. Of Agric., Assuit Univ., 129 pp.
Brigitte, M. M. and Alan, J. S. 1996. Production of salicylic acid
precursors is a major function of phenylalanine ammonia lyase in
the resistance of Arabidopsis to Peronospora parasitica. The Plant
Cell 8: 203-212.
.
Bruggemann, W.; Beyel, V.; Brodka, M.; Poth, H.; Weil, M. and
Stochaus, J. 1999. Antioxidant and
antioxidative enzymes in wild-type and transgenic Lycopersicon
genotypes of different chilling tolerance.Plant Science Limerick.,
140: 145-154.
Caron, J. ; Laverdiere, L.; Thibodeau, P . O. and Belanger, R. R .
2002. Use of an indigenous strain of Trichoderma harzianum
against five
plant pathogens on greenhouse cuccmber and
tomato in Quebec. Phytoprotection, 83(2):73-78.
Cheour, F.; Willemot, C.; Arul, J.; Desjardins, Y.; Makholuf, J.;
Charest, P. M. and Gosselin, A. 1990. Foliar application of
calcium chloride delays post harvest ripening of strawberry. J.
Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci., 115:789-792.
Cho, E. K. 1989.Strategies for biological control of soil borne diseases in
economic crops in Korea. Rev. Plant pathol.54-68.
83
Christensen, N. W.; Roseberg, R. J.; Brett, M. and Jackson, T. L.
1986.Chloride inhibition of nitrification as related to take-all disease of .
.
……….wheat. In: "Special Bulletin on Chloride and Crop
Production"
………(T. L. Jackson, ed.), No. 2, pp. 22-39. Potash & Phosphate
Institute, Atlanta , Georgia.
………………………………………………………………
Clarke, D. J. ; Sigeid, M. V. ; Heidi , L. ; Frederick, M. A. and
Xinnian, D. 2000. Roles of salicylic acid, jasmonic acid, and
ethylene in preinduced resistance in arabidopsis. The Plant Cell.
12:2175-2190.
Cohen, Y. 1994. 3-Aminobutyric acid induces systemic resistance
against Peronospora tabacina. Physiol. Mol. Plant Pathol., 44 :
273-288.
Conrath, U.; Chen, Z. X.; Ricigliano, J. R. and Klessig, D. F. 1995.
Two inducers of plant defense responses, 2,6-dichloro iso nicotinic acid
and salicylic acid inhibit catalase activity in tobaco. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences USA, 92: 7143-7147.
Conway, W. S.; Sams, C. E.; McGuire, R. G. And Kelman, A. 1992.
Calcium treatments of apples and potatoes to reduce postharvest decay.
Plant Disease, 76 : 329-334.
Corden, M. E. 1965. Influence of calcium nutrition on Fusarium wilt of
tomato and polygalacturonase activity. Phytopathology, 55:222-224.
Dmitrier, A.; Tena, M. and Jorrin, J . 2003. Systemic acquired
resistance in sunflower ( Helianthus annus L. ) . Tsitologiya -1- Genetika
, 37(3):9-15.
Duffy, B. K. and De´fago, G. 1997. Biocontrol of Fusarium crown and
root rot of tomato by Pseudomonas fluorescens and represses the
production of pathogen metabolites inhibitory to bacterial antibiotic
biosynthesis. Phytopathology 87, 1250–1257.
Duncan, D. B. 1955. Multiple range and multiple F test ., 11:1-42.
84
Duncan, R. R .1985. Reaction of selected sorghum genotypes to
Acremonium wilt. Sorghum News letter.,99-101;1 ref.
.
Durny, J.; Shah, J. and Klessig, D. F. 1997. Salicylic acid and diseases
resistance in plant. Treends in Plant Science, 2: 266-274.
Elad, Y. 1992. The use of antioxidants (free radical scavengers) to
control gray mould (Botrytis cinerea) and whit mould (Sclerotinia
sclerotiorum) in various crops. Plant Pathol., 41: 417-426.
El-Bramawy ,M. A. S and Shaban, W. I. 2007. Nature of gene action for
yield, yield components and major diseases resistance in seasame
(Seasmum indicum L.).Res. J. of Agric. and Biological siciences ,
3(6): 821-826.
El-Bana, A. A.; Hassan, (Hana) M. M.; Abdou, El-S. and Galal, A. A.
2006. Effects of calcium salts on growth sclerotia and infectivity
of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Assiut J. of Agric. Sci. 37: 175-187.
El-Bana, A. A.; Ismail, A. A.; Nageeb, M. N. and Galal, A. A. 2002.
Effects of irrigation intervals and salicylic acid treatments on
wheat root rot and yield components. Proc. Minia 1 st Conf. For
Agric. & Environ. Sci., Minia, Egypt, March 25-28, pp. 229-240.
El-Baz,S.M.2007. Induction of resistance in some soybean varities against
root diseases by some chemical inducers . Egypt. J. Applied Sci.,
22:68-80.
El-Deeb, A. A.; S. M. Abd El-Momen. and (Awatef) A. Hanafi (2002).
Effect of some fungicides and alternative compounds on root and
pod rots in Peanut. Egypt. J. Agric. Res., 80(1):71-82.
El-Ganaieny, R. M. A; Shalaby, S. I. M. and Galal, A. A. 1997.
Effects of calcium, magnesium, potassium and sodium cations
onion smut disease. Proceeding of the First Scientific Conference
of Agricultural Sciences, Faculty of Agric. Assiut Univ. Assuit,
December., 13-14, 1: 527-538.
85
El-Ganaieny, R. M. A.; El-sayed, A. M. and Gebraiel, M. Y. 2002.
Induced resistance to Fusarial diseases in onion plants by treatment
with antioxidants. Assiut J. Agric. Sci., 33: 3, 133-147.
El-Goorani, M. A. and Hassanein, F. M. 1991.The effect of Bacillus
subtilis. On in vitro growth and pathogenicity of Erwinia
amylovora .J. Phytopathology.133:134-138.
El-Mohamedy, R. S. R . 2009. Efficiency of different application
methods . of bio control agents and biocides in control of Fusarium
. some citrus rootstocks. Archives of Phyto pathology
root rot on
.
and Plant .Protection , vol. 42, Iss. 9, Sept. pp 819-828.
.
EL-Samawaty, M. A. ;M. R. Omar and. Galal, A. A. 2008. Systemic
acquired resistance in cotton genotypes against vascular wilt
disease caused by Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. vasinfectum. Egypt J.
Agric. Res., 86 (4) .
EL-Samawaty, M. A., and Galal, A. A. 2009. Use of Benzothiadiazole
(BTH) for inducing systemic resistance in cotton seedlings against
some soil-borne pathogenic fungi. J. Agric. Sci. Mansoura Univ.,
34 (4): 3305-3315.
El-Shafey, H. A., and M. M. Refaat . 1978. Studies on stalk –rot disease
of grain sorghum in Egypt.Agric.Res.Rev.,Egypt,56:71-79.
El-Shafey, H. A. ; Abd-El-Rahim ,M. F.. and Refaat, M. M. 1979.
Anew Cephalosporium wilt of grain sorghum in Egypt. Proc. of the
Third Egypt. Phytopath. Congress, P.514-532.
El-Shafey, H.A. ; Mahmoud, S. A. Z. El-Brolousy; M.; El-Azhary ,T.
M. and Ibrahim, T. F.. 1990. Biological control of late - wilt disease by
……….inoculation with Bacillus subtilis and manuring
………..Egypt.J.Appl.Sci.,5:182-191 .
86
El-Shafey, H. A.; El-Assuity, E. M.; A. Zein El-Abedeen.; Thanaa
F.Ibrahim and Zienab M. Fahmy. 1999. Further studies on
Acremonium wilt of grain sorghum. Egypt. J. Agric.
Res.,77(2).533-547.
Esmail, M. Zadeh.; Soleimani ,M. J. and Rouhani, H. 2008. Exogenous application
of Salicylic acid for inducing systemic acquired resistance tomato stem
canker disease. J. Biological sci. vol.8.iss:6.1039-1044.
F.A.O: Statistics. 2009. Retrieved from http://www.fao.org .
Faramarzi , M. A .; Mohamed .Y .;Mohamed . A. and Ahmed. S .
2008. Prednisolone bio-transformation in the culture of
filamentous fungus Acremonium strictum . Bio-technology
7(2):343-346.
Ferrarese, L.; Moretto, P.; Trainotti, L.; Rascio, N. And Casadoro,
G. 1996. Cellulase involvement in the abscission of peach and
pepper leaves affected by salicylic acid. J. of Exp. Bot., 47: 251257.
Fixen, P. E.; Geldrman, R. H.; Gerwing, J. And Cholick, F. A. 1986a.
Response of spring wheat, barely and oats to chloride in potassium
chloride fertilizers. Agron. J., 78:664-668.
Fixen, P. E.; Buchenau, G. W.; Gelderman, R. H.; Schumacher, T.
E.; Grwing, J. R.; Cholik, F. A. and Faeber, B. G. 1986b.
Influence of soil and applied chloride on several wheat parameters.
Agron. J., 78:736-740.
Floryszek, K. and Wieczorek, J. 1993. Induced systemic resistance of
the potato leaves to Phytophthora infestans. Phytopathologica
Polonica, 18:39-44. [C.F. database of CAB International].
Forbes, G. , and Crespo, L. B. 1982. Marchitamiento sorgo causado por
Acremonium strictum Gams. Inf. Tec. 89. Estac. Exp. Agropec.
Manfredi INTA Arg. 4pp.
87
Foyer, C. H.; Lelandais, M.; Edwards, E. A. and Mulineawx, P. M.
1991. The role of ascorbate in plants, interactions with
photosynthesis and regulatory significance. In: Active oxygen
oxidative stress and plant metabolism. Pell, E. J., and Society of
Plant Physiologists, Rockville, MD. Pp. 131-144.
Frederiksen, R. A. 1980. Sorghum downy mildew in the united states:
overview and out look. Plant Disease 64: 903-908.
Frederiksen, R. A. 1984. Sorghum root and stalk rots:Acremonium wilt.
Proc.of the Consulatative Group Discussion on Res. Needs and
Strategies for control of sorghum root and stalk rot disease.
Bellagio, Italy, pp.49-51.
Frederiksen, R. A.; Marina, P. Natural, D. T. Rosenow, J. B. and
Mort G.N.Odvody. 1980. Acremonium wilt of sorghum.
Sorghum Newsletter, 23:134.
Frederiksen, R. A.; Marina P. Natural . , and Rosenow, D . T. 1982.
Acremonium wilt of sorghum. Plant Disease,66:863-865.
Frederiksen, R. A., 1984. Anthracnose stalk rot. In: Sorghum root and
.
stalk rots, a Critical Review. Proceedings of the consultative Group
. .
.
sorghum . .
discussion on research needs and strategies for control of
.
Bellagio, Italy. . . .
root and stalk rot diseases. 27 Nov. - 2 Dec. 1983.
.
ICRISAT, Patancheru, AP 502 324, India.
pp. 34 - 42.
Gabr, M. R. ; Saleh, O. I.; Hussein, N. A. and Khalil, M. A. 1998.
Physiological studies and cell-wall degrading enzymes of
Fusarium oxysporium f. sp. sesamin and Macrophomina phaseolii:
The casual organisms of wilt and root rot diseases of sesame
.Egyptian Journal of Microbiology ,33:595-610.
88
Galal, A. A. and Abdou, El-S. 1996. Antioxidant for the control of
Fusarial diseases in cowpea. Egypt. J. Phytopathol., 24: 1-12.
Galal, A. A.; Abd El-Latif.; M. R. Hussien.; N. A. and ArmaniousHanaa.; A. H. 2001. Some agricultural factors affecting cotton
damping-off, root rot and wilt diseases. Proceeding of the Annual
Conference Sustainable Agricultural Development, Fayoum
Faculty of Agriculture., March 28-30.
Galal, A. A.; Abdel-Aziz- Nabila, A.; Hassanien, M. H. and
Shaat, M. N. 1997. Induction of systemic resistance in squash
plants against cucumber mosaic virus by ascorbic acid. 7 th Nat.
Conf. of Pest and Dis. of Vegetables and Fruits in Egypt ., 25-26
Nor. 1997. pp170-180.
Galal, A. A.; Abdel-Gawad, T. I. and El-Bana, A. A. 2002. Postharvest decay of garlic cloves caused by Bacillus polymyxa and
Fusarium monaliaforme. Egypt. J. Microbiol., 37 (1) : 71-88.
Galal, A. A.; Gad El-Hak, S. H.; Abdel-Ati, Y. Y. and Moustafa, Y.
M. M. 2000. Response of new tomato hybrids to some antioxidants
and early blight. The 2nd Sci. Conf. of Agric. Sciences, Assiut, Oct.
2000, pp. 673-686
Galal, A. A.; Manninger, Barna, K. B. and Adam, A. L. 1994. Effect
of allopurinal treatment on the development of rust disease of
kidney bean.broad-bean and wheat plants. Proceeding of the Royal
Society of Edinburgh, 102: 495-500.
Galal, A. A.; Shaat, M. M. N. and El-Bana, A. A. 1999. Control of
Alternaria-leaf spot on pear by using antioxidants. The 8 th Nat.
Conf. Pests and Diseases of Vegetables and Fruits in Egypt.
Ismailia, Egypt. 9-10 Nov. 1999., 2 : 293-303.
89
Gams,W. 1971. Cephalosporium-Artige Schimmelpilze(Hyphomycetes).
Stuttgart, Germeny :G.Fisher, 242pp.
Garrett, S. D. 1970. Pathogenic Root-infecting Fungi. Cambridge :
.
Cambridge University Press.
Gehan H. Amin.; Dina Z. Abdel-Kader.; Metwally Baraka and Heba
M. Hassan. 2009. Role of salicylic acid in the machinery of
acquired tolerance in two Capsicum species infected with
powdery mildew disease. Australian Journal of Basic and Applied
Sciences, 3(3): 2078-2096.
Gisela, Grunewaldt-Stöcker.; Nadine, Riediger and Christof Dietrich
2007 . Suitability of GFP-transformed isolates of the fungal
root endophyte Acremonium strictum W. Gams for studies on
induced Fusarium-wilt resistance in flax . Plant Root 1: 46-56 .
Gomez, K. A. and Gomez, A. A. 1984. Statistical Procedures for
Agricultural Research. A. Willey- Interscience Publication. New
York pp. 678.
Gonzalez, R. J.; Alcain, F.; Caler, J.; Serrano, A.; Cordoba, F. and
Navas, P. 1995. Stimulation of onion root elongation by ascorbate
and ascorbate free radical in (Allium cepa L.). Protablasma, 184 :
1-4, 31-35. (c.f. database CAB international).
Gyung, J.; Choi,Jin-Cheol.; Kim,Kyoung, Soo.; Jang,Myeong, Hyeon
Nam.; Seon-Woo Lee and Heung, Tae Kim.2009. Biocontrol activity of
.
.
Acremonium strictum BCP against Botrytis diseases.
.
Archive Detail.
Volume 25, No 2, pp. 165-171.
Harman, G, E.; Petzoldt, R.; Comis, A. and Chin, J. 2004. Interaction
between Trichoderma harzianum strain T22 and maize inbred line
Mo17 and effects of these interactions on diseases caused by
Pythium ultimum and Colletrichum graminicola .
Phytopathology,94(2):147-153.
90
Hallock, D. l. and Garren, K. H. 1968. Pod breakdown, yield and grade
of virginia type peanuts as affected by Ca, Mg and K sulphates.,
Agron. J. 60 :253-257.
Hassan ,M. H. A , Sallam, M. A. and Asran, M. R. 1996. Influence of
certain factors on severity of stalk rot disease of grain sorghum in
upper Egypt. Assuit. J. of Agric. Scie. 27:4, 179-190;17 ref.
Horne, C.W. and R.W. Berry. 1980. Sorghum disease atlas. The Texas
A & M Univ. System, Texas Agriculture Extension Serv. Bull. B1323. 16pp.
Hundekar , A . R and Anahosur , H. 1994. Pathogenicity of fungi
associated with sorghum stalk rot .J. Agric. Sci. 7: 291-295.
Hussien, N. A.; El-Bana, A. A.; Abd-El Aziz, N. A. and Galal, A. A.
2002. Effects of calcium salts on growth, Polygalacturonase
activity and infection of bean pods by Sclerotinia sclerotiorum.
Minia Journal of Agricultural Research and Development., 22 (2):
243-254.
Jin-Cheol kim, K. ;G. J. Choi. ; H. Ju. Kim. ; D. W. Ahn and K. Y.
Cho. 2002. Verlamelin, an antifungal compound produced by a
mycoparasite, Acremonium strictum . Plant Pathol. J. 18(2):102105 .
Kelman, A.; Mc Guire, R. G. and Tzeng, K. C. 1989. Reducing the
severity of bacterial soft rot by increasing the concentration of
calcium in potato tubers. In ‘‘ Soil borne plant pathgens:
Managements’’ (A. W. Engelhard, ed.), pp. 102-123. APS Press,
The American Phytopathological Socity, St. Paul, Minnesota.
Kuzniak, E. 2001. Effects of fusaric acid on reactive oxygen species and
antioxidant in tomato cell cultivares. J. Phytopathology, 149: 10,
575-582.
91
Leininger, T.D; Solomon, J.D.; Wilson, A. Dan; Schiff, N.M. 1999. A
Guide to Major Insects, Diseases, Air Pollution Injury, and
Chemical Injury of Sycamore. Gen. Tech. Rep. SRS-28. Asheville,
NC: USDA Forest Service, Southern Research Station. 44 p.
Lin,H.J. and Huang,J.W.1998. Formulation of semi selective medium
for detection of Acremonium sp. From soil . Plant Pathology.
Bull.7:211-212 .
Liu, I.; Kloepper, J. W. and Tuzun, S . 1995 . Induction of systemic resistance in
cucumber against fusarium wilt by plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria.
Phytopathology, 85: 695-698.
Mahalakshmi , V. and Bidinger , F. R . 2001 . Evaluation of Stay-green
.
………sorghum
germplasm lines at ICRISAT. Crop Sci.38:793-798.
Mahmoud , A . H . 1989. A study of the morphological forms of Sphacelotheca
sorghi (Link) Clint. Arab. J. of plant protection, 8 (1): 8-15.
Malamy, J. and Klessig, D. F. 1992. Salicylic acid and plant disease
resistance. The Plant J., 2(5): 643-654.
Mandavia, M. K.; Khan, N. A.; Gajera. H. P.; Andharia, J. H. and M.
Parameswaran. 2000. Inhibitory effects of phenolic compounds on
fungal metabolism in host-pathogen interactions in Fusarium wilt
of cumin. Allelopathy Journal, 7 (1): 85-92.
Mansour, I. M.; Ragab, M. M..; Effat A.Zaher, and Maysa
A.Moursy. 1984. Pathogenic variation in Cephalosporium
acremonium,the cause of wilt and black-bundle disease of sorghum
and maize. Egypt. Soc. of Appl. Microbiol., Proc.Vi. Conf.
Microbiol,. Cairo,Vol. II-part VI, Plant pathology.
.
Marley, P.S. and Aba, D.A. 1999. Current status of sorghum smuts in
Niegeria. J. of Sustainabe Agric. 15(1/2): 119-132.
McGee, P.A.; Hincksman, M.A.; and White, C.S. 1991. Inhibition of
growth of fungi isolated from plants by Acremonium strictum.
Aust. J. Agric. Res. 42: 1187–1193.
92
Mc Guire, R. G. and Kelman, A. 1984. Reduced severity of Erwinia
soft rot in potato tubers with increased calcium content.
Phytopathology, 74:1250-1256.
Moustafa, Y. M. M. 1999. Improving the productivity of tomato by
producing F1 hybrids and using some antioxidant treatments. M.
Sc. Thesis, Fac. Agric., Minia Univ., Egypt.
Muchovej, R. M. C. and Muchovej, J. J. 1982. Calcium suppression of
Sclrotium induced stem abnormality of soybean. Soil Sci.,
134:181-184.
Mughogho, L.K.; yopadhyay , R. B.; and Satyanarayana, M.V. 1987.
Systemic infection of sorghum by A. strictum and its transmission
through Seed. Plant Disease 71:647-650.
Natural, M. P.; Frederiksen, R. A., and Rosenow, D. T. 1982.
Acremonium wilt of sorghum. Plant Dis.66:863-865.
Nawrath, C. and Metraux, J. 1999. Salicylic acid induction –deficient
mutants of arabidopsis express PR-2 and PR-5 and accumulate
high levels of camalexin after pathogen inoculation. The Plant Cell,
11: 1393-1404.
Nyvall, R.F. 1989. Field crop diseases hand book, 2 nd ed. Van Norstrand
Reinhold, New York, 817 pp.
Ouf, S. A.; Ali, M. I. and Ibrahem, A. E. 2002. In vitro evalution of the
biocontrol activity of some bio fungicides on Sclerotium
cepivorum. Int. J. Agric. Biol., 10. 241-248.
Paliyath, G.; Poovaiah, B. W.; Munske, G. R. and Magnuuson, J. A.
1984. Membrane fluidity in senescing apples: Effects of
temperature and calcium. Plant Cell Physiol., 25: 1083-1087.
Pande, S.; Bock, C. H.; Bandyopadhyay, R.; Narayana, Y. D.; Reddy,
B.V.S.; Lenne, J. M and Jeger, M. J. 1997. Downy mildew of
sorghum. ICRISAT, Patancheru, India. Publication No. 51.
93
Pennazio, S. and Roggero, P. 1991. Effect of exogenous salicylate on
basal and stress-induced ethylene formation in soybean. Plant, 33:
58-65.
Penninckx, J. A.; Eggermont, K.; Terras, F. R.; Thomma, B. P.;
DeSamblanx, G.W.; Buchala, A.; Metraux, J. P.; Monners, J.
M. and Broekaert, W. F. 1996. Pathogen-induced systemic
activation of a plant defense gene in arabidopsis follow a salicylic
acid independent pathway. The Plant Cell, On line, Abstracts., 8
(12) :2309.
Poovaiah, B. W. 1988. Calcium and senescence, p 369-389. In: L.
Nooden and A. C. Leopold (eds) Senescence and Aging in Plants.
Academic, New York.
Prestamo, G. and Manzano, P. 1993. Peroxidase of selected fruits and
vegetables and the possible use of ascorbic acid as an antioxidant. Hort
Science., 28 : 48-50.
Prusky, D.; Ohr, H. D.; Campbell, S.; Kobiler, T.; Zauberman, D. G.
and Fuchs, Y. 1995. Evaluation of antioxidant butylated
hydroxyanisole and fungicide prochloraz for control of postharvest anthracnose of avocado fruits during storage. Plant Dis., 79
: 797-800.
Quintanilla, P. and Brishammar, S. 1998. Systemic induced resistance
to late blight in potato by treatment with salicylic acid and
Phytophthora cryptogea. Potato Research, 41 (2) : 135-142.
Raffaello Castoria, Leonardo Caputo, Filippo De Curtis, and
Vincenzo De Cicco. 2003. Resistance of post harvest biocontrol
yeasts to oxidative stress: A possible new mechanism of action
.Volume 93, Number 5 Pages 564-572.
Rai, B.; Kumar, S. and Kumar, B. 2002. Evaluation of fungicides
against seedling blight disease in sugarcane. Annals of Biology.,
18 (2) : 143-146.
94
Raskin, I. 1992. Salicylic acid, A new plant hormone. Plant Physiol., 99:
799-803.
Rasmussen, J. B.; Hammerschmidt, R. and Zook, M. N. 1991.
Systemic induction of salicylic acid accumulation in cucumber
after inoculation with Pseudomonas syringae. Plant Physiol., 97:
1342-1347.
Ray, S.; Singh, R.; Kabir, J.; Dhua, R. and Kaiser, S. 1993. Effect of
pre-harvest treatment of calcium compounds on the incidence of
Diplodia stem-end rot of mango in storage. Crop Research Hisar. 6
(3) : 419-422.
Reynoso, M. M.; Torres, A. M.; Ramirez, M. L.; Rodrigues, M. I.;
Chulze, S. N. and Magan, N. 2002. Efficacy of antioxidant
mixtures on growth, fumonisin production and hydrolytic enzme
production by Fusarium verticillioides and F. proliferatum in vetro
on maize-based media. Mycological Res., 106 (9): 1093-1099.
Richardson, D. G. and Al-Alani, A. M. 1982. Calcium and nitrogen
effects on d, Anjou pear fruit respiration and ethylene evolution.
Acta Hort., 124:195-201.
Rivera-Varas, V.V., Freeman, T.A., Gudmestad, N.C., Secor, G.A.
2007. Mycoparasitism of Helminthosporium solani by Acremonium
strictum.Phytopathology Vol.97(No.10.
Seah, S.; Stivasithamparam, K. and Turner, D.W. 1996. The effect of
salicylic acid on resistannce in wheat (Triticum aestivum) seedling
roots against the take all fungus Gaeumannomyces graminis var
tritici. Australian J. Bot., 44: 499-507.
Shaat, M. M. N. and Galal, A. A. 2004. Response of citrus fruits to
preharvest antioxidant spraying and infection with Alternaria fruit
rot and Green Mold. Annals Agric. Sci., Ain Shams Univ., Cairo,
49 (2): 747-758.
95
Shaat, M. M. N.; El-Bana, A. A. and Galal, A. A. 2000. Canker dieback
of apple trees in El- Minia Governorate of Egypt. Zagazig J.
Agric. Res., 22 (2): 425-439.
Shaat, M. M. N.; El-S. Abbou and Galal, A. A. 2001. Variability of
Alternaria radicina and A. tenuissima caused by superoxide onion
treatments. Egypt.J. Phytopathol., 29 (2): 43-56.
Shahda, W. T. 2000. Bilogical control of damping-off of seedlings.
Alex. J. Agric. Res., 45 :1.317-329.
Shalaby, I. M. S.; EL-Ganaieny, R. M. A.; Botros, S. Al. D. and El
Gebally, M. M. 2001. Effect of some natural and synthetic
compounds against charcoal rot caused by Macrophomina
phaseolina of seasame and sunflower plants. Assiut. J. Agric. Sci.,
32 : 547-556.
Sharples, R. O. and Johnson, D. S. 1977. The influence of calcium on
senescence changes in apples. Ann. Applied Biol., 85:450-453.
Shulaev, V.; Leon, J. and Raskin, I. 1995. Is salicylic acid a
translocated signal of systimic acquired resistance in tobaco?. The
Plant Cell, 7: 1691-1701.
Singh,S.K. and Singh, R.H. 2003. Effects of culture filtrate of bioagents and bio-pesticides on Fusarium udum. Annals of plant
protection Sciences,11(2):387-388.
Singh, S. N. and Goswami , G. P. 2003. Management of sugarcane wilt
disease caused by Fusarium moniliforme through chemical and
physical set-treatment. Cooperative Sugar., 34(5)381-384.
Sonawane ,S.S and Pawar, N.B. 2001. Studies on biological
management
of
chickpea
wilt.
J.Maharshtra
Agric.Universities,26(2):215-216.
Tesso. T.; Clafin, L.E. and Mitchell, R.Tuinstra . 2004 . Estimation of
combining ability for resistance to Fusarium stalk rot in grain
sorghum. Crop Sci.44:1195-1199.
96
Thakur, R. P.; Frederiksen, R. A..; Mutry , D. S..; Reddy, B. V. S..;
Bandyoadnyay, R..; Giorda, L. M. and Calfin, L. E. 1996.
Breeding for disease resistance in sorghum. p303-315. In Proc. of
the international Conf. on Genetic improvement of sorghum and
pear-millet, Lubbock, TX. 23-27 Sept. 1996. ICRISAT,
Patancheru, AP, India.
Timm, C. A.; Goos, R. J.; Johnson, B. E.; Sobolik, F. J and Stack, R.
W.1986. Effect of potassium fertilizers on malting barley infected
with common stalk rot. Agron. J.78:197-200.
Tingwa, P. O. and Young, R. E. 1974. The effect of calcium on the
ripening of avocado (Persa ameicana Mill.) fruit. J. Amer. Soc.
Hort. Sci., 99:540-542.
Thomashow, L. S .1996 . Biological-control of plant-root pathogens.
Curr. Opin. Biotechnol.7: 343 – 347 .
Thompson, D. P. 1992. Inhibition of mycelial growth of mycotoxigenic
fungi by phenolic antioxidants. Mycologia, 84: 791-793.
Thompson, D. P.; Metevia, L. and Vessel, T. 1993. Influence of pH
alone and in combination with phenolic antioxidants on growth and
germination of mycotoxigenic species of Fusarium
and
Penicilium. J. Food Protection, 56: 134-138.
Tzeng , D. D. and De Vay, J. E.1989 . Biocidal activity of mixture of .
methionine and riboflavin against plant pathogenic fungi and
.bacteria and possible modes of action. Mycologia 81: 404Viswanathan, M. and Francis , R. B. 2002. Evaluation of stay-green
sorghum germplasm lines at ICRISAT.Crop sciences 42:965-974.
Vyas, R. K.; Kusum-Mathur and Mathur, K. 2002. Distribution of
Trichodrema spp. In cumin rhizosphere and their potential in
suppression of wilt. Indian Phytopatho; ogy, 55(4):451-457.
Wisniewska, H. and Chelkowski, J. 1999. Influnce of exogenic salicylic
acid on Fusarium seedling blight reduction in barley. Acta
Physiolo. Plant., 21: 63-66.
97
Wisniewski, M.; Droby, S.; Chalutz, E. and Eilam, Y. 1995. Effects of
Ca2+ and Mg2+ on Botrytis cinerea and Penicilium expansum in
vitro and on the biocontrol activity of Candida oleophila. Plant
Pathology, 44 (6): 1016-1024.
Xu, Xiude.; Zhao, T. C. and Liu. Zh. 1995. Study on Acremonium wilt
in sorghum. Acta.Phytophylacica.Sinica.22:2,123-128;1 ref.
Yalpani, N.; Silverman, P.; Wilson, T. M. A.; Kleier, D. A. and
Rasking, I. 1991. Salicylic acid a systemic signal and inducer of
pathogenesis related proteins in virus infested tobaco. The Plat
Cell, 3:809-818.
Zahra,A. M. K. 1990. Studies on Fusarium wilt disease of sesame in
Upper Egypt. ph. D. Thesis, Plant pathology Dep. Assuit Univ.,
Egypt.
Zhang, L.; Porter, G. A.; Bushway. R. J. and Zhang, L. Q. 1997.
Ascorbic acid and glycoalkoid content of Atlantic and Superior
potato tubers as affected by supplemental irrigation and soil
amendments. Amer. Potato J., 74: 285-304.
Ziedan, E .H . E . 1993. Studies on Fusarium wilt disease of sesame.
Egypt. M. Sc. Thesis, Faculty of Agric. Ain. Shams Univ. Egypt.
Ziedan , E . H . E . 2000 . Soil treatment with biofertilizers for
controlling
. peanut root and pod rot diseases in
Nobaria province. Egypt J. Phytopathol., 28 (1-2): 17-26.
.
98
(الملخص العربي)
تتلخص أهم النتائج التي تم التوصل البها في هذه الدراسة على النحو التالى-:
-أظهرت نتائج حصر أمررض
ضلسرا ضلترت يصرنب ناايرات ضلر
عفر ذبور)
ضلرفنعرة فرت
محافظات قنا ،س)هاج وأسن)ط .و أن أعلى نساة إصاوة سجلت فت منطقة ضلزوضيد و ضلهردضيات
ثر ياعرا ضلصرنف جنرز 113-حنر أعطرى
فت محافظة قنا ٪ 24.00للصنف ذ جنز 15-
نفس ضلنساة فت نفس ضلمنطقة ,وننما ضقل نساة إصاوة سجلت فت منطقة ونت هال فت محافظرة
أسن)ط للصنف جنز 15-حن سجل ٪4.00ث ياعا ضلصنف زز جنز 113-ونفس ضلنساة.
ضلتجررا أ أوتررحت أن ضلفطررر أ رم)ننرر)س سررتر ت)س ذ Acremonium strictumهرر)ضلمساب لعف وبو) س) ناايات ضل
ضلرفنعة يحت ظروف ضلعردو ضلصرناعنة .وضلتعريرف
لثالث عزالت ممرتة أشا إلى أنها ينتمت إلى جنس . Acremonium strictum
-ين)عت أصناف ضل
ضلرفنعة فى أستجاوتها لالصاوة والفطر أ رم)نن)س سرتر ت)س والعردو
ضلصناعنة ,حن أظهر ضلصنف جنز 15-أستجاوة عالنة لالصاوة وسق)ط ضلااد ضت ذ60.7٪
وننما ضلصرنف دو ضدو ران أقرل أسرتجاوة لالصراوة وسرق)ط ضلاراد ضت ذ 32٪يحرت ظرروف
عدو ضلتروة .ووالمثل فان ضلصنف جنز 15-أوتح ضسرتجاوة عالنرة لإلصراوة لمرر
عفر
ضلسا ذ ، 58٪وننما ان ضلصرنف دو ضدو ضقرل قاولنرة لالصراوة وعفر ضلسرا ذ 13.3٪عنرد
عدو ضلسا وسال ات ضألسنان.
أظهرت ضلد ضسة أن ضلفطر ضلممررغنر متخصص فت إصاوة ضل
أ رم)ننر)س سرتر ت)س ذAcremonium strictum
ضلرفنعة فقط ولكنا ضحردث إصراوة لعردد مر ضألنر)ضب ضلنااينرة
ضألخر مثل ناايات ضلعائلة ضلنجنلنة ذضل
ضلشرامنة -قصرب ضلسركر -ضلردخ -ضلقمرح ووعر
ناايات ضلعائالت ضألخر ذضلاامنة ين)عرت فرت ضسرتجاوتها لإلصراوة وعرزالت ضلفطرر ضلمسراب
يحت ظروف ضلعدو ضلصناعنة
1
ضلد ضسات ضلمعملنة أشا ت إلرى أن نمر) ضلفطرر ضلمختارر ران عنرد د جرات حررضزززو º35س مرا وجرد ضن د جرة ضلحررض
زززد جة ضلحرض
-
30 ، 25
ضلمثلررت لنمر) ضلفطرض رم)ننر)س سرتر ت)س ران عنررد
º35س .ول ينم) ضلفطر على د جة حرض
º 10س.
مررا يرراثر ضلفطررر ومر اررات مدررادضت ضأل سررد ضلمختاررر ذحم
ضالسررك) ون ،حمرر
ضلسالنلسنل ،وننما ل يظهر ل) يد ضلكالسن)س ياثنرض وضتحا على نم) ضلفطر ضلمختارر .وننمرا
ثاط ضلماند ضلفطري فنتافا س-ثنرضس نم) ضلفطر ضلمختار.
ضستخدضس عناصر للمكافحة ضلان)ل)جنة مثل وكتريا واسنلس ساتلس Bacillus subtilisوفطريرضيك)د ما ها زيان , Trichoderma harzianumأظهرت ضختالفا وضتحا نحر) يراثنر
يدادها ضلحن)ي يجاه ضلفطر ضلمختار يحرت ضلظرروف ضلمعملنرة .يرضيك)د مرا ها زيران ران
ياثنره أ ار لتداد نم) ضلفطر ضلمختار ع ضلاكتريا واسنلس ساتنلس .وم ناحنرة أخرر فران
ضلتداد ضلحن)ي لعناصر ضلمقاومة ضلان)ل)جنة ذضلحن)ية ل يك لا ياثنر على نم) ضلفطرر عنرد
إتافة محفزضت ضلمقاومة ذمثل حم
ضالسك) ون ,حم
ضلسالسنل ,ل) يدضلكالسن)س إلى
ونئة ضلنم) للفطر ضلمختار .
ضستخدضس محفزضت ضلمقاومة ذحمأعطت نتائج متفاوية لمكافحة أمرض
ضألسرك) ون ،حمر
ضلسالنسرنل و ل) يرد ضلكالسرن)س
عف /بو) ضلسا لناايات ضل
ضلرفنعة فت ضلتجا أ
ضلحقلنة.
م خال ضلمحفرزضت ضلكنمائنرة ،ران ل) يرد ضلكالسرن)س ضأل ثرر يراثنرض فرت يحفنرز ضلمقاومرةلناايات ضل
ث حم
ضلرفنعة تد ضإلصاوة والفطر أ رم)نن)س ستر ت)س متاعا وحمر
ضألسرك) ون
ضلسالسنل .
ضلماند ضلحن)ي يزو-إن و ل ضلماند ضلحن)ي والنرت-جرا د ،ران لهمرا ضلتراثنر ضل)ضترح فرتخفر
ضإلصرراوة وررامرض
سررق)ط ضلارراد ضت وعفر ضلسررا ضلتررت يسررااها ضلفطررر أ رم)ننرر)س
سررتر ت)س ،ضلمانررد ضلحنرر)ي والنررت – جررا د رران أ ثررر فاعلنررة ويرراثنرض فررت مكافحررة سررق)ط
ضلااد ضت وعف ضلسا أ ثر م ضلماند ضلحن)ي يزو-ضن.
2
إتافة ضلمحفزضت ضلكنمنائنة للمقاومة مع ضلماندضت ضلحن)ية ذوالنت-جا د و يزو-ضن أظهرتنتائج متعدد ومتن)عرة ،حنر أعطرى حمر
ضألسرك) ون يراثنرض عالنرا لمكافحرة أمررض
سق)ط ضلااد ضت وعف ضلسا وبل عند إتافتا إلى أي م ضلماندضت ضلحن)يرة سر)ضب والنرت-
جا د أو يزو-ضن.
3
دراسات على مرض عفن الساق في الذرة الرفيعة
رسالة مقدمة من
أحمد عامر على محمود
بكالوريوس العلوم الزراعية (أمراض النبات)
جامعة األزهر-فرع أسيوط 2000
الستيفاء متطلبات الحصـول على درجة
الماجستير في العلوم الزراعية
( أمراض النبات )
دكتور
تحت إشراف
زكرى عطية شحاتة
أستاذ أمراض النبات – كلية الزراعة – جامعة المنيا
دكتور
أنور عبد العزيز جالل
أستاذ أمراض النبات ووكيل الكلية لشئون الدراسات العليا
والبحوث -كلية الزراعة – جامعة المنيا
دكتور على زين العابدين محمد
رئيس بحوث أمراض النباتات -معهد بحوث أمراض النبات-
مركز البحوث الزراعية بالجيزة
2010
-