Debrecen University
Centre for Agricultural Sciences
Faculty of Agriculture
ATC
4th International Plant Protection
Symposium at Debrecen University
(11th Trans-Tisza Plant Protection Forum)
Recent developments of IPM
PROCEEDINGS
Editors:
György J. Kövics – István Dávid
18-19 October, 2006
Debrecen, Hungary
Debrecen University
Centre for Agricultural Sciences
Faculty of Agriculture
4th International Plant Protection
Symposium at Debrecen University
(11th Trans-Tisza Plant Protection Forum)
Recent developments of IPM
PROCEEDINGS
Edited by:
György J. Kövics – István Dávid
18-19 October, 2006
Debrecen
Hungary
Organizers:
Debrecen University, Centre for Agricultural Sciences, Faculty of
Agriculture, Department of Plant Protection,
Foundation for Teaching and Developing of Plant Protection Education
Debrecen Commitee of Hungarian Academy of Sciences Agricultural
Subcommitee
Antal Gulyás Plant Protection Club of Students
Editoral Board:
Managing Editor: Kövics, György J. (Mycology)
Members:
Bozsik, András (Entomology, Ecology)
Dávid, István (Weed Biology, Weed Control)
Karaffa, Erzsébet (Molecular Biology)
Nagy, Antal (Entomology, Ecology)
Radócz, László (Weed Biology, Int. Pest Management)
Szarukán, István (Entomology)
Tarcali, Gábor (Weed Biology, Int. Pest Management)
Symposium Secretariat:
Kövics, György
DU CAS FA Department of Plant Protection
H-4015 Debrecen, POBox 36
Phone/fax: (36-52) 508-378, (36-52) 508-459
E-mail: kovics@agr.unideb.hu; davidi@agr.unideb.hu
INTERNET: http://www.agr.unideb.hu
Sponsors of the Symposium:
•
•
•
•
•
•
BASF Hungária Ltd, Budapest, Hungary
Dow AgroSciences Ltd, Budapest, Hungary
Rivendell Consulting Slovenia, Radomlje, Slovenia
Summit-Agro Hungaria Ltd, Budapest, Hungary
Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Budapest, Hungary
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Budapest, Hungary
ISBN 963 9274 98 4
Contents
Plenary Session
András Bozsik1 – Ramón González-Ruíz2 (1Department of Plant
Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary,
2
Department of Animal and Vegetal Biology and Ecology,
University of Jaén, Jaén, Spain): FIRST DATA ON THE
SIBLING SPECIES OF THE COMMON GREEN
LACEWINGS IN SPAIN (NEUROPTERA: CHRYSOPIDAE)
Ramón González-Ruiz1 – Paz Gázquez-Alcoba2 – Juan-Alberto
Pajares-Alonso3 (1Departmento de Biología Animal, Vegetal y
Ecología, Universiad de Jaén, Jaén, Spain, 2Departamento de
Bosques y Jardines de la Alhambra y el Generalife, Granada,
3
Spain,
Departamento
de
Producción
Vegetal
y
Silvopascicultura. Escuela Técnica Superior de Ingenierías
Agrarias, Palencia, Spain): INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
OF THE DUTCH ELM DISEASE IN ALHAMBRA AND
GENERALIFE FORESTS (GRANADA, SPAIN)
István Ujváry (Institute of Biomolecular Chemistry, Chemical
Research Center, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest,
Hungary):
RESEARCH
AND
DEVELOPMENT
IN
PESTICIDE CHEMISTRY. CURRENT STATUS AND A
GLIMPSE AT THE FUTURE
Susan Bardocz - Arpad Pusztai (Independent Consultants, 8262
Badacsonytördemic, Tatay S. u. 15, Hungary and The
Norwegian Institute of Gene Ecology /GenOK/ Tromso,
Norway): THE SAFETY OF FOOD PREPARED FROM
GENETICALLY MODIFIED PLANTS
3
12
27
39
Phytopathological Session
Péter Hertelendy1 – Mária Jakabné Kondor1 – László Gergely1
– Tibor Szabó2 (1National Institute for Agricultural Quality
Control, Department of Phytopathology, Budapest, Hungary,
2
National Institute for Agricultural Quality Control, Variety
Testing Station, Röjtökmuzsaj, Hungary): NEW VARIETY
TESTING METHOD TO THE FUSARIUM HEAD BLIGHT
OF WHEAT
Szabolcs Szlávik (National Institute for Agricultural Quality
Control, Budapest, Hungary): THE OBSERVATION A SLIME
MOULD – BADHAMIA FOLIICOLA – ON RAPE STEM
III
49
50
István Lenti1 – Ferenc Borbély2 – Sándor Vágvölgyi1
(1Nyíregyháza College, Technical and Agricultural Faculty,
Nyíregyháza, Hungary, 2Research Center of Debrecen
University, Nyíregyháza, Hungary): THE ANTHRACNOSIS
DISEASE OF THE TIGHT LEAF LUPIN (LUPINUS
ANGUSTIFOLIUS L.)
Marietta Petróczy1 − Géza Nagy1 − Rudolf Bánátfy2 − László
Palkovics1 (1 Corvinus University of Budapest, Department of
Plant Pathology, 2Aromax Inc., Budapest): IN VITRO
ANTIFUNGAL ACTIVITY OF ESSENTIAL OILS ON
PATHOGENS
Emil Pocsai1 - István Murányi2 - Tibor Horti2 (1Plant Protection
and Soil Conservation Service of Fejér County, Velence,
Hungary, 2Rudolf Fleischmann Research Institute of the Róbert
Károly College, Kompolt, Hungary): DOMINANCE OF THE
BARLEY YELLOW DWARF VIRUSES IN WINTER
BARLEY BREEDING MATERIALS OF KOMPOLT
Erzsébet Szathmáry1 – István Tóbiás2 – László Palkovics1
(1Corvinus University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural
Science, Department of Plant Pathology, Budapest, Hungary,
2
Plant Protection Institute of the Hungarian Academy of
Sciences, Budapest, Hungary): ANALYSIS OF SOME
RECOMBINANT PLUM POX VIRUS (PPV) ISOLATES
FROM BULGARIA, THE COUNTRY WHERE PPV WAS
FIRST RECORDED
Gabriela Juhasová1 - Marek Kobza1 – Katarína Adamčíková1 –
László Radócz2 – Gábor Tarcali2 (1Branch of Woody Plants
Biology Nitra, Institute of Forest Ecology SAS, Zvolen,
Slovakia, 2Department of Plant Protection, University of
Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary): RESULTS OF THE USE OF
CRYPHONECTRIA PARASITICA HYPOVIRULENT STRAINS
IN HUNGARY AND IN SLOVAKIA
Gábor Tarcali – László Radócz – István Dávid (University of
Debrecen, Centre for Agricultural Sciences, Department of Plant
Protection, Debrecen, Hungary): CHESTNUT BLIGHT
INFECTION ON SESSILE OAK (QUERCUS PETREA) IN
SOUTHERN-HUNGARY
IV
51
52
60
70
78
85
Kálmán Z. Váczy1 – Levente Karaffa2 – Erzsébet Fekete2 –
György J. Kövics3 – Lajos Gál1 – Erzsébet Sándor3
(1Research Institute for Viticulture and Enology, Eger, Hungary,
2
Department of Genetics and Applied Microbiology, Faculty of
Science, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary,
3
Department of Plant Protection, Faculty of Agriculture,
University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary): DISTRIBUTION
OF TRANSPOSONS IN BOTRYTIS CINEREA ISOLATES
COLLECTED FROM THE WINE REGIONS OF EGER AND
TOKAJ, HUNGARY
László Irinyi1 – György J. Kövics1 – Mahendra K. Rai2 –
Erzsébet Sándor1 (1Department of Plant Protection, Faculty of
Agriculture, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary,
2
Department of Biotechnology, SGB Amravati University,
Amravati,
Maharashtra,
India):
STUDIES
OF
EVOLUTIONARY RELATIONSHIPS OF PHOMA SPECIES
BASED ON PHYLOGENETIC MARKERS
91
99
Entomological and Integrated Pest Management Session
Adalbert Balog 1, 2 – Zoltán Néda3, 4 – Aranka Derzsi3 – Viktor
Markó2 (1Hungarian University of Transylvania, Faculty of
Technical and Human Sciences, Marosvásárhely/Tg-Mures,
Romania, 2Corvinus University of Budapest, Faculty of
Horticultural Science, Department of Entomology, Budapest,
Hungary, 3Babes-Bolyai University, Faculty of Physics,
Department of Theoretical and Computational Physics,
Kolozsvár/Cluj-Napoca, Romania, 4Los Alamos National
Laboratory, Center for Nonlinear Science, Los Alamos, USA):
ONE NEUTRAL MODEL IN SPECIES ABUNDANCE
DISTRIBUTION
OF
ARTHROPODS
IN
AGRO
ECOSYSTEMS
Gábor Jenser– Sándor Süle – Éva Szita – Judit V. Tarjányi
(Plant Protection Institute, Budapest, Hungary): ACTUAL
PROBLEMS IN PLANT PROTECTION OF PEAR
ORCHARDS
V
117
127
Ramón González-Ruiz1 – Samer Al-Asaad1 – András Bozsik2
(1Department of Animal and Vegetal Biology and Ecology,
University of Jaén, Jaén, Spain, 2Department of Plant Protection,
University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary): THE
INFLUENCE OF THE ADJACENT VEGETATION PATCHES
ON DIVERSITY AND ABUNDANCE OF GREEN
LACEWINGS ASSOCIATED TO THE OLIVE GROVES IN
SOUTH SPAIN. IMPLICATIONS IN THE NATURAL
CONTROL OF THE OLIVE MOTH, PRAYS OLEAE (LEP:
YPONOMEUTIDAE)
Bojana Zgonec (Rivendell Cosulting Radomlje, Slovenia): THE
RIVENDELL INTERNATIONAL
András Bozsik (Department of Plant Protection, University of
Debrecen,
Debrecen,
Hungary):
TRIALS
WITH
OVERWINTERING CHAMBERS AS CONSERVATION
TOOLS FOR COMMON GREEN LACEWINGS IN
HUNGARY
András Bozsik (Department of Plant Protection, University of
Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary): LACEWINGS’ OCCURRENCE
IN SOME HUNGARIAN HEDGEROWS AND FIELD EDGES
128
130
132
141
Weed Sciences Session
András Jung1 – Péter Kardeván2 – Péter Reisinger3 (1Corvinus
University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural Sciences,
Budapest, Hungary, 2Geological Institute of Hungary, Budapest,
Hungary, 3University of West-Hungary, Faculty of Food and
Agricultural
Sciences,
Mosonmagyaróvár,
Hungary):
DETECTION OF COMMON RAGWEED (AMBROSIA
ARTEMISIIFOLIA L.) REFLECTANCE SPECTRUM BY
MEANS OF FIELD MEASUREMENTS
András Kismányoky – Éva Lehoczky (Pannon University,
Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, Institute for Plant Protection,
Department of Herbology and Pesticides Chemistry, Keszthely,
Hungary): RESULTS OF WEED SURVEY IN WHEAT CROP
MANURING FIELD EXPERIMENT
Attila Kondor1 – István Lenti2 (1Ministry of Agriculture and
Rural Development, Nyíregyháza, Hungary, 2College of
Nyíregyháza, Department of Technology and Agriculture,
Nyíregyháza, Hungary): POTENTIALS OF CHEMICAL
CLEARING OF “ENERGY WILLOW” (SALIX VIMINALIS L.)
VI
153
161
167
András Horn – Ferenc Jáger (Summit-Agro Hungary Ltd.,
Budapest. Hungary): NEW POST EMERGENCE HERBICIDE
APPLICATION POSSIBILITY IN MAIZE USING THE
PROTOX-INHIBITOR
HERBICIDE,
FLUMIOXAZINE
®
(PLEDGE )
István Dávid1 – András Sági1 – Gábor Tarcali1 – László
Radócz1 – Imre Kovács2 (1Debrecen University, Department of
Plant Protection, Debrecen, Hungary, 2BASF Hungária Ltd.,
Budapest, Hungary): COMPETITION OF SUNFLOWER AND
MAIZE WITH SEVERAL WEED SPECIES
István Dávid (Debrecen University, Department of Plant
Protection,
Debrecen,
Hungary)
CHANGES
IN
ALLELOPATHY OF XANTHIUM ITALICUM MOR.
174
176
185
Poster Session
Izabella Csöndes – Sándor Kadlicskó (Pannon University,
Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, Plant Protection Institute,
Keszthely, Hungary): EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE ON THE
GROWTH OF MACROPHOMINA PHASEOLINA ISOLATES
El- Kazzaz, M. K.1 – El-Assiuty, E. M2. – Ghoniem, K. E1. – ElNaggar, A. A2 (1Department of Agriculétural Botany, Faculty of
Agriculture, Kafr El-Sheikh, University of Tanta, Egypt, 2Plant
Pathology Institute, Agricultural Research Centre Giza, Egypt):
USE OF RANDOM AMPLIFIED POLYMORPHIC DNA
(RAPD)
TO
DETERMINE
VARIATION
IN
PATHOGENICITY AMONG EXSEROHILUM TURCICUM
ISOLATES OBTAINED FROM MAIZE AND SORGHUM IN
EGYPT
Gabriela Juhasová – Katarína Adamčíková – Marek Kobza –
Slávka Bernadovičová – Katarína Pastirčáková – Helena
Ivanová – Róbert Sásik (Branch of Woody Plants Biology
Nitra, Institute of Forest Ecology SAS, Zvolen, Slovakia):
METHOD FOR BIOLOGICAL CONTROL ON CHESTNUT
TREES IN SLOVAKIA
Katarína Pastirčáková – Slávka Bernadovičová – Gabriela
Juhásová – Helena Ivanová – Katarína Adamčíková – Marek
Kobza (Slovak Academy of Sciences, Institute of Forest
Ecology, Branch of Woody Plants Biology, Nitra, Slovakia):
MICROSCOPIC FUNGI ASSOCIATED WITH HORSECHESTNUT LEAVES
VII
197
206
213
218
István Lenti1 – Ferenc Borbély2 – Sándor Vágvölgyi1 – Ágnes
F.-né Boronkay1 (1Nyíregyháza College, Technical and
Agricultural Faculty, Nyíregyháza, Hungary 2Research Center of
Debrecen
University,
Nyíregyháza,
Hungary):
THE
ANTHRACNOSIS DISEASE OF THE VARIABLE LUPIN
(LUPINUS MUTABILIS SWEET)
Klára Manninger¹ – István Murányi2 (¹Plant Protection Institute
Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary, ²„Rudolf
Fleischmann” Research Institute, Kompolt, Hungary):
OCCURRENCE OF PUCCINIA HORDEI ON WINTER
BARLEY IN HUNGARY IN 2006
Prajakta Deshmukh1 - Mahendra K. Rai1 - György J. Kövics2 László Irinyi2 - Erzsébet Sándor2 (1Department of
Biotechnology, SGB Amravati University, Amravati,
Maharashtra, India, 2Department of Plant Protection, Debrecen
University, Debrecen, Hungary): PHOMA – CAN THESE
FUNGI USED AS BIOCONTROL AGENTS AND SOURCES
OF SECONDARY METABOLITES? (A REVIEW)
Zsolt Varga1 – Bernhard Krautzer2 – Wilhelm Graiss2 (1Pannon
University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences,
Keszthely, Hungary, 2HBLFA Raumberg-Gumpenstein, Irdning,
Austria):
COMPARATIVE
SEED
PATHOLOGICAL
INVESTIGATIONS ON CULTIVATED GRASS SPECIES
Fawzeya Fadel1 – Magdy El-Naggar1 – Sobhi Tolba2 – Gamal
Farahat2 (1Agricultural Botany Department, Faculty of
Agriculture, Kafr El-Sheikh University, Kafr El-Sheikh, Egypt,
2
Plant Pathology Research Institute, Agricultural Research
Center, Giza, Egypt): INDUCTION OF DISEASE
RESISTANCE BY SALICYLIC ACID, SODIUM BENZOATE
AND
POTASSIUM
MONOPHOSPHATE
AGAINTS
USTILAGO MAYDIS IN MAIZE PLANTS
Devanand Dangre1 - Mahendra K. Rai1 – Reto Strasser2
(1Department of Biotechnology, SGB Amravati University,
Amravati, Maharashtra, India, 2Université de Genève,
Laboratoire de Bioénergétique, Chemin des Embrouchis 10,
Jussy / Genève, Switzerland): A NEW, RAPID AND NONDESTRUCTIVE
BIOPHYSICAL
METHOD
(CHLOROPHYLL A FLUORESCENCE) PROVES THAT
GROWTH PROMOTING ENDOPHYTES ALLEVIATE Cd
STRESS IN CICER ARIETINUM L.
VIII
222
223
224
233
240
251
Attila Stingli – Tímea Bíró – Attila Percze (Szent István
University, Institute of Crop Production, Gödöllő, Hungary):
INFLUENCE OF CONSERVATION TILLAGE AND
DIFFERENT NUTRIENT RATES ON THE LEAF DISEASES
OF WINTER WHEAT
László Nowinszky1 – György Bürgés2 – Béla Herczig3 – János
Puskás1 (1Berzsenyi Dániel College, Szombathely, Hungary,
2
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture,
Keszthely, Hungary, 3Komárom County Plant Protection
Service, Tata, Hungary): FLAYING HEIGHT OF INSECTS
CONNECTED WITH MOON PHASES USED THE LIGHTTRAP CATCH DATA
Péter Szarvas – András Bozsik (Department of Plant Protection,
University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary): ROLE OF
HEDGES IN PLANT PROTECTION
Kamilla Buzsáki – Imre Béres (Pannon University, Georgikon
Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Institute for Plant Protection
Keszthely, Hungary): INVESTIGATION ON THE EARLY
COMPETITION
BETWEEN
YELLOW
NUTSEDGE
(CYPERUS ESCULENTUS L.) AND MAIZE
Branko Konstantinovic, Maja Meseldzija, and Bojan
Konstantinovic (Faculty of Agriculture, Department for
Environmental and Plant Protection, Novi Sad, Serbia): AMBROSIA
ARTEMISIIFOLIA AND IVA XANTHIFOLIA SPREAD AND
DISTRIBUTION IN VOJVODINA REGION
Branko Konstantinovic1, Maja Meseldzija1, and D. Sunjka2
(1Faculty of Agriculture, Department for Environmental and Plant
Protection, Novi Sad, Serbia, 2Scholar of the Ministry of Science
and Environmental Protection of the Republic of Serbia,
Beograd,
Serbia):
STUDY
OF
WEED
SPECIES
ECHINOCHLOA CRUS-GALLI L. CROSS-RESISTANCE
Veronika Tóth – Éva Lehoczky (Pannon University, Georgikon
Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Institute of Plant Protection,
Department of Herbology and Pesticides): POSSIBILITIES OF
INTEGRATED WEED CONTROL AGAINST JOHNSONGRASS (SORGHUM HALEPENSE /L./ PERS.)
Gábor Wágner – Erzsébet Nádasy (Pannon University,
Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Institute for Plant
Protection,
Keszthely,
Hungary):
STUDY
OF
PHYTOTOXICITY OF HERBICIDES ON GREEN PEA
IX
257
263
272
273
281
288
298
307
John Grande - Edwin Dager - Henry Fischetti (Rutgers
University, New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station, Snyder
Research Farm, New Jersey, USA): MATCHING BACKPACK
SPRAYER APPLICATION TECHNOLOGY TO AN ARRAY
OF AGRICULTURAL PEST CONTROL PRODUCTS
László Radócz - György J. Kövics - István Szarukán (Debrecen
University, Department of Plant Protection, Debrecen,
Hungary): AN INTERREG PROJECT FOR THE EFFECTIVE
AND SAFE PLANT PROTECTION IN THE EU
Éva Lehoczky (Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of
Agriculture, Institute for Plant Protection, Keszthely, Hungary):
SIGNIFICANCE OF PESTICIDES IN THE INTEGRATED
PLANT PROTECTION
Diána Virág – Zoltán Naár – Attila Kiss (Károly Eszterházy
College,
Eger,
Hungary):
BIOLOGICAL
TEST
EXPERIMENTS ON MODELING EFFECT OF PESTICIDE
DECOMPOSITION PRODUCTS
X
315
322
324
334
PLENARY SESSION
2
FIRST DATA ON THE SIBLING SPECIES OF THE
COMMON GREEN LACEWINGS IN SPAIN
(NEUROPTERA: CHRYSOPIDAE)
(The taxonomic status of the most important cryptic species of
Chrysoperla carnea complex in Spain)
András Bozsik1 and Ramón González-Ruíz2
1
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen,
Hungary
2
Department of Animal and Vegetal Biology and Ecology, University of
Jaén, Jaén, Spain
Chrysopids have long attracted the attention of the applied
entomologist for they are good candidates for use in IPM programs. They
are distributed worldwide, have a wide host plant and prey range (Principi
and Canard, 1984), can be easily mass cultured (Ridgway et al., 1980),
manipulated using food sprays (Hagen and Tassen, 1980) and overwintering
boxes (McEwen et al. 2000), and pesticide tolerant populations have been
identified (Grafton-Cardwell and Hoy, 1985). Due to these characteristics in
response to a survey in 1992, members of the Association of Applied Insect
Ecologists ranked Chrysoperla ssp., the most important lacewings as
unrivaled on the list of commonly used, commercially obtainable
predaceous natural enemies (Tauber et al., 2000). Although a lot of work
has been carried out on Chrysopidae, but regarding the many gaps in their
natural history green lacewings are little known insects, and even their
taxonomic status – at least that of the most important taxon Chysoperla
carnea (Stephens) – is uncertain.
The systematic status of Ch. carnea has been changing, and instead
of a polymorphic single species, a complex of sibling or cryptic species, the
Chrysoperla carnea complex or carnea-group (Thierry et al., 1992; Thierry
et al., 1998; Henry et al., 2001) should be now considered whose members`
systematic status is not known enough (Tauber et al., 2000, Henry et al.,
2001). Several attempts of multiple approaches such as courtship
sonification (Henry, 1983, 1985), genetic studies with multilocus
electrophoresis (Cianchi and Bullini, 1992), nucleotide sequences of COII,
cytochrome oxidase I, cytochrome b and the large ribosomal subunit of the
mtDNA (Lourenço et al. 2006), morphological characterization of adults
and larvae (Thierry et al., 1992), ecophysiological variability (Thierry et al.,
1994; Canard et al., 2002) have been made.
They supported the existence of various cryptic species among
which one can find:
3
1) Ch. carnea former Chrysoperla kolthoffi (Navás, 1927) sensu Cloupeau
(Cc4 as song species), or “motorboat”(as song type) (Henry et al., 2002) or
Ch. affinis former Ch. kolthoffi (Thierry et al., 1998); 2) Chrysoperla
lucasina (Lacroix, 1912) (Henry et al., 2001) and 3) Chrysoperla carnea
sensu stricto (Thierry et al., 1998) or Cc2 (“slow-motorboat”) or
Chrysoperla pallida sp. nov. (Henry et al., 2002); 4) Chrysoperla agilis sp.
nov. (Henry et al., 2003) or Cc3 (Maltese).
In spite of the efforts made for clearing the taxonomic status of
Palearctic Ch. carnea the present situation of species demarcations cannot
be called satisfying because of the lack of agreement in reliable criteria
(Tauber et al., 2000; Henry et al., 2001, 2002; Canard et al., 2002; Canard
and Thierry personnel communication (= p.c.), 2003). There is a deep
controversy between the two main groups of researchers (one of them uses
mainly the substrate-born vibrational songs and certain morphological
characteristics like shape of the male genital “lip” and “chin”, another
prefers ecophysiological traits and subtle morphological differences (like
shape of the basal dilatation of the metatarsal claw, pigment distribution of
the stipes, etc.) for distinguishing the cryptic species of carnea-group)
because the first group concluded that the true Ch. carnea described by
Stephens in 1836 and to be found in The Natural History Museum, London,
must be Cc4 (Henry et al., 2002) which according to the other group is
another species, the Ch. affinis (Canard, 2003 p.c.). The other candidate
species for being the “true” Ch. carnea may be Cc2 mentioned above like
Ch. carnea s. str. (Canard, 2003 p.c.) but in contrast with it, this taxon was
assigned a new name, Chrysoperla pallida sp. nov. by Henry et al.,(2002).
Regarding the lack of perfect evidences and the somehow too complicated
illogical argumentation about the consideration of the decisive traits, the
validity of these names, however, has not been discussed and accepted by
the neuropterist community yet.
These are the theoretical or taxonomic troubles. But which are the
practical ones? It should not forget the natural enemy role of Ch. carnea,
because this taxon has been used in green houses and in the fields and
orchards. It has been reared, tested, qualified and sold worldwide. It is a
species about which a great deal of articles have been written. Main
questions: Which taxon was the object of these studies? Which taxon can
we buy at Koppert or Biobest? Which taxon’s natural populations help
growers in various countries? Regarding the study of the carnea group, there
are considerable gaps almost everywhere: in Europe, America, Asia,
Australia and Africa. We know only very little about the presence,
distribution, ecological demands, preferences, habitats of the taxon which
formerly was called as Chrysoperla carnea. However, there are some
countries where, due to the work of few neuropterists, the natural common
green lacewing populations have somehow been characterized. These
4
countries are France, the USA, Switzerland, England, Germany, Belgium,
Romania and Hungary. Reducing our examination only to the European
continent, it is a fact that the not mentioned European countries’ common
green lacewings represents white spots on the map of our knowledge. The
following study shows the first steps of common green lacewing research in
Spain.
Olive moth (Prays oleae (Bernard) is one of the most important
insect pests of olive groves in the Mediterranean basin and so is in Spain,
and Andaluzia (Spain is the biggest olive oil producer in Europe) as well.
The second generation females lay eggs on the small fruits in early summer,
and the emerging larvae bore within the olive fruit causing spectacular fruit
drop in July and August (Ramos et al., 2005). Various methods are used
against the moth population but in most cases insecticides are applied
(Ramos et al., 2005). Taking into consideration the environmental and
human feeding risks the development of integrated or biological control
methods would be necessary for the environmentally friendly or organic
production of olives. According to local observations the common green
lacewing (Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens) sensu lato) may be an efficient
predator of the olive moth eggs and caterpillars (Al-Asaad, 2004). However,
which sibling species is the really efficient taxon?
In some years when the density of lacewings is proper, the natural control is
efficient. However, in other years the density is small, and there is no
natural control by lacewing larvae (Ramos et al., 2005). That is why the
following questions can be raised: How is it possible to forecast the
lacewing density? How can we improve the density of natural populations?
Possible solutions:
- identification of the lacewing species (sibling species) controlling olive
moth caterpillars,
- measuring the predatory performance of lacewing larvae using in situ
observation and laboratory experiments,
- study of population dynamics of lacewings and its dependence on major
environmental factors
- determination the chrysopid fauna of some Andaluzian olive plantations
and characterization of their population dynamics,
- measuring the efficiency of food sprays and over-wintering boxes for
possible augmentation and conservation of common green lacewing adults,
- studying the impact of uncultivated areas for natural lacewing populations,
mainly for their maintenance, over-wintering and distribution.
On the basis of these data it will be possible to develop a conservation and
augmentation strategy for the natural populations as well as to select the
best fitted species for the control and the probable rearing procedures. The
possible utilization (a biological control technology can be developed for
Spanish olive producers) of results will help to reduce the plant protection
5
charges in olive production and diminish the environmental contaminations
by pesticides in the end products. With all these activities we can
considerably contribute to the production of healthier and better quality food
and also to the maintaining of declining biodiversity at European level.
Materials and Methods
Ch carnea s. l. adults were collected in 2003 and 2004 in olive
groves (growing area) in Jaén and Granada counties and in 2005 in the park
and adjacent orchards of Granada (in the southeast of Spain). Captures were
obtained by chromatic sticky traps (yellow and blue), olfactory traps, light
traps and sweeping net. Individuals were identified according to the
descriptions of Thierry et al., (1992), Canard, M. (2002 and 2003, pers.
comm.), Duelli, P. (1995 and 1999, pers. comm.) and also samples of
various morphological types (courtesy of Thierry, D.) and song morphs
(courtesy of Duelli, P.) have been used. In case of Ch. agilis and Ch. affinis
atypical specimens were excluded. The individuals captured by sticky traps
and light traps were collected, put into ethanol and identified several weeks
later. In case of the sweeping, living specimen were identified immediately
after catching. Table 1 contains the basic data of sampling.
Table 1. Basic data of collection in southern Spain
Site
Habitat
Year Catching
method
Ubeda
olive grove
2003
Mancha
Real
La Nava
olive grove
2004
olive grove
2004
Láchar
olive grove
2004
coloured sticky
traps
coloured sticky
traps
coloured sticky
traps
olfactory traps
coloured sticky
traps
coloured sticky
traps
sweep net
Fuerte del olive grove
2004
Rey
Granada
park,
mixed 2005
orchards
6
Number of
individuals
caught
207
203
367
63
24
76
Results and Discussion
Abundance values of the species caught in southern Spain are
presented in Table 2.
Table 2. Number and proportion of sibling species of common green
lacewings in Andaluzia
Ch.
Ch.
Sites
Ch.
Ch.
Ch.
affinis
carnea
agilis
carnea
lucasina
ind.
ind.
s. lato
ind.
s.
(%)
(%)
ind.
(%)
stricto
(%)
ind.
(%)
Ubeda 2003
125
44
25
9
4
(60.4)
(21.3)
(12.1)
(4.5)
(1.9)
Mancha
165
17
13
4
4
Real
(81.3)
(8.4)
(6.4)
(1.9)
(1.9)
2004
La Nava
287
11
14
1
54
2004
(78.2)
(3.0)
(3.8)
(0.3)
(17.7)
Láchar
57
1
5
2004
(90.5)
(1.6)
(7.9)
Fuerte del
20
1
1
2
Rey 2004
(83.3)
(4.2)
(4.2)
(8.3)
Granada
71
1
1
2
1
2005
(93.4)
(1.3)
( 1.3)
( 2.6)
(1 .3)
Total
725
74
55
16
70
(77.1)
(7.9)
(5.9)
(1.7)
(7.4)
Total
207
203
367
63
24
76
940
Ch. agilis predominates without question with its 77% value. It is followed
by Ch. carnea s.str. (8%), Ch. lucasina (6%), Ch affinis (2%). Ch. carnea
s.l. represents the undeterminable individuals whose identification because
of their morphological injury, the great quantity of unremovable glue
remains on their body or the considerable variability of their characteristic
traits was not possible (Table 2).
The four sibling species of the Ch. carnea complex have been found
mainly in the olive groves of Andaluzia. The species with the highest
number of individuals collected was Ch. agilis. It is one of the sibling
species that is the most difficult to diagnose from preserved or alive caught
individuals. As to their identification on the basis of vibrational patterns,
any of the European neuropterists – with the exception of a minority (mostly
American) of searchers creating the methodology – did not have the
7
facilities and opportunities to verify them. Ch. agilis is easily confused with
the most often occurring species of the carnea group, Ch. affinis and Ch.
carnea s.str. In addition, there is another possibility for confusion as these
dominant European lacewing taxa are named differently (see above).
Besides the systematic difficulty also their distribution and occurrence have
not been studied properly. The descriptors of the species analyzed 74
individuals whose origin is shown in Table 3. Our results based on 940
lacewings, the biggest number of Ch. carnea complex specimens ever
identified in Spain. According to these data and those of Henry et al.,
(2003), the occurrence of Ch. agilis is common in southern Spain, in the
Mediterraneum and the species occurs in Central-Asia (Iran) as well.
Besides Ch. agilis, Ch. lucasina, another rather Mediterranean or AtlantoMediterranean lacewing (Henry et al. 2002, Bozsik et al., 2003) and Ch.
carnea s.str and Ch. affinis, two in the mainland Europe dominant species
(Thierry et al. 1996, Bozsik et al., 2003) have been collected. Regarding the
number of captured specimens, it seems that Ch. agilis is the dominant
species whose impact on olive moth caterpillars can be the greatest. The
abundance and frequency (1.7%) of Ch. affinis was the smallest, and the
other sibling species with their 6-8% frequency can have only less
significant role in biological control of P. oleae.
Table 3. Collection sites of Ch. agilis (on the data of Henry et al., 2003)
(No data = the sites were indicated as collection places but the
number of collected specimens was omitted)
Local site
Country
Date
Number
of
individuals
Azores archipelago
Portugal
August 2000
16
Southern Spain
(Alicante, Granada)
Spain
July 2001
4
Southern France
(Carcès)
France
August 1994
5
The Alps (Ticino)
Switzerland 1981-94
10
Southern Italy and Sicily
Italy
July 1993
21
Malta
Malta
1991
4
Xilokastron, Kalentzi and
other sites
Greece
June 1994
10
Eilat
Israel
October199394
4
Northern Iran
Iran
June 2002
No data
Agadir
Morocco
1985
No data
Total number of individuals
74
8
Considering the planned research activity indicated in the introduction, all
the studies mentioned there should be done firstly on Ch. agilis.
References
Al-Asaad, D.S. (2004): Viabilidad de los chrisópidos (Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae) del olivar. Influencia del entorno forestal y del
tratamiento
ecológico
de
Prays
oleae
(Lepidoptera:
Yponomeutidae). Programa de doctorado: Análisis y Gestion de
Ecosistemas, Facultad de Ciencias Experimentales, Departamento de
Biología Animal, Vegetal y Ecología. pp. 49.
Aspöck, H., Aspöck, U. und Hölzel, H. (1980): Die Neuropteren Europas.
Vol.I. pp. 495., Vol.II. pp. 355. Goecke and Evers, Krefeld
Bozsik A., Mignon, J. et Gaspar, Ch.(2003): Le complex Chrysoperla
carnea en Belgique (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Notes fauniques de
Gembloux, n 50: 9-14.
Canard, M., Thierry, D., Cloupeau, R. (2002): Les chrysopes vertes
communes comme prédateurs dans les cultures: mais quelles
chrysopes? 23me Conférence Internationale sur les Moyens
Alternatifs de Lutte contre les Organismes Nuisibles aux Végétaux,
Lille, 4,5,6 et 7 mars, 2002, Imprimerie L’Artésienne, Liévin,
France, 572-578 (2002).
Cianci, R., Bullini, L. (1992): New data on sibling species in chrysopid
lacewings: The Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens) and Mallada
prasinus
(Burmeister)
complexes
(Insecta:
Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae), in Current research in Neuropterology, ed by Canard
M, Aspöck H. and Mansell M.W., Proceedings of the 4th
International Symposium on Neuropterology, Bagnères-de Luchon,
Haute-Garonne, France, 1991. SACCO, Toulouse, pp. 99-104.
Grafton-Cardwell, E.E., Hoy, M.A. (1985a): Intraspecific variability in
response to pesticides in the common green lacewing, Chrysoperla
carnea (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Hilgardia 53: 1-32.
Henry, Ch.S. (1983): Acoustic recognition of sibling species within the
Holarctic lacewing Chrysoperla carnea (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae).
Syst Entomol 8: 293-301..
Henry, Ch.S. (1985): Sibling species, call differences, and speciation in
green lacewings (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae: Chrysoperla). Evolution
39: 965-984.
Henry, Ch. S., Brooks, S.J., Duelli, P., Johnson, J.B. (2002): Discovering
the true Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens) (Insecta: Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae) using song analysis, morphology, and ecology. Annals
of the Entomological Society of America 95: 172-191.
9
Henry, Ch. S., Brooks, S.J., Thierry, D., Duelli, P., Johnson, J.B. (2001):
The common green lacewing (Chrysoperla carnea s. lat.) and the
sibling species problem. pp. 29-42. In: McEwen, P.K., New, T.R and
Whittington, A.E. (ed.) Lacewings in the crop environment.
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Henry, Ch. S., Brooks, S.J., Duelli, P., Johnson, J.B. (2003): A lacewing
with the wanderlust: the European song species ‘Maltese’,
Chrysoperla agilis, sp.n., of the carnea group of Chrysoperla
(Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Systematic Entomology 28: 131-147.
Lourenço, P., Brito C., Backeljau, T., Thierry D., Ventura, M.A. (2006):
Molecular systematics of the Chrysoperla carnea group (Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae) in Europe. Journal of Zoological Systematics and
Evolutionary Research, 44: 180-184.
Ramos, P., Ramos, J.M., González, R. (2005): La polilla del olivo, Prays
oleae Bern. (Lep. Hyponomeutidae): Biología y alternatives naturals
de control. pp. 307-328. In: Anta, J.L., Palacios, J., Guerrero, F
(eds.) La cultura del olivo. Ecología, economía, sociedad.
Universidad de Jaén, Jaén.
Ridgway, R.L., Morrison, R.K., Badgley, M. (1970): Mass rearing of green
lacewing. J. Econ. Entomol. 63: 834-836.
Thierry, D., Cloupeau, R., Jarry, M. (1992): La chrysope commune
Chrysoperla carnea sensu lato dans le centre de la France: mise en
évidence d’un complexe d’especes (Insecta: Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae), in Current research in Neuropterology, ed by Canard,
M., Aspöck, H. and Mansell, M.W., Proceedings of the 4th
International Symposium on Neuropterology. Bagnères-de-Louchon,
France 1991, SACCO, Toulouse, pp.379-392.
Thierry, D., Cloupeau, R., Jarry, M. (1994): Variation in the overwintering
ecophysiological traits in the common green lacewing WestPalearctic complex (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Acta Oecol 15: 593606.
Thierry, D., Cloupeau, R., Jarry, M., Canard, M. (1996): Distribution of the
sibling species of the common green lacewing Chrysoperla carnea
(Stephens) in Europe (Insecta: Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). In: Pure
and Applied Research in Neuropterology. ed by Canard, M., Aspöck,
H. and Mansell, M.W., Proceedings of the 5th International
Symposium on Neuropterology. Cairo, Egypt. SACCO, Toulouse,
pp. 233-240.
Thierry, D., Cloupeau, R., Jarry, M., Canard, M. (1998): Discrimination of
the West-Palearctic Chrysoperla Steinmann species of the carnea
Stephens group by means of claw morphology (Neuroptera,
Chrysopidae). Acta Zool Fennica 209: 255-262.
10
Tauber, M.J, Tauber, C.A.,. Danee, K.M., Hagen, S.K. (2000):
Commercialization of predators: Recent lessons from green
lacewings (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae: Chrysoperla). American
Entomologist 46: 26-37.
FIRST DATA ON THE SIBLING SPECIES OF THE COMMON
GREEN LACEWINGS IN SPAIN (NEUROPTERA: CHRYSOPIDAE)
A. Bozsik1 and R. González-Ruíz2
1
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
Department of Animal and Vegetal Biology and Ecology, University of Jaén, Jaén, Spain
2
Summary
Common green lacewings are good candidates for use in IPM programs because they are
distributed worldwide, have a wide host plant and prey range, can be easily mass cultured,
manipulated using food sprays and overwintering boxes, and pesticide tolerant populations
have been identified. Although a lot of work has been carried out on Chrysopidae, but
regarding the many gaps in their natural history, green lacewings are little known insects,
and even their taxonomic status – at least that of the most important taxon Chysoperla
carnea (Stephens) – is uncertain. It is instead of a polymorphic single species, a complex of
cryptic species, the Chrysoperla carnea complex or carnea-group. In present contribution
composition of the natural Ch. carnea population was investigated in order to establish
systematic bases for biological control studies in olive groves of Spain. Our results based
on 940 lacewings, represents the biggest number of Ch. carnea complex specimens ever
identified in Spain. Ch. agilis predominated with its 77% value. It was followed by Ch.
carnea s.str. (8%), Ch. lucasina (6%), Ch affinis (2%). Regarding the number of captured
specimens, it seems that Ch. agilis is the dominant species whose impact on olive moth
caterpillars the greatest can be. The abundance and frequency of Ch. affinis was the
smallest, and the other sibling species with their 6-8% frequency can have only more
modest role in biological control of P. oleae.
11
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT OF THE DUTCH ELM
DISEASE IN ALHAMBRA AND GENERALIFE FORESTS
(GRANADA, SPAIN)
Ramón González-Ruiz1 – Paz Gázquez-Alcoba2 – Juan-Alberto
Pajares-Alonso3
1
Departmento de Biología Animal, Vegetal y Ecología, Universiad de Jaén,
Jaén, Spain
2
Departamento de Bosques y Jardines de la Alhambra y el Generalife,
Granada, Spain
3
Departamento de Producción Vegetal y Silvopascicultura, Escuela Técnica
Superior de Ingenierías Agrarias, Palencia, Spain
Dutch elm disease, caused by the ascomycete Ophiostoma ulmi
Buisman, has been responsible for the disappearance of hundreds of
millions elms trees in the northern hemisphere (Brasier, 1990, 1991; Brasier
and Mehrotra, 1995). Since its appearance, at the start of the century, it has
produced two pandemics. The first of these began in North-Eastern Europe
around 1910 and the second owed its appearance -around 1940- to two races
of greater pathogenicity (North-American NAN and Eurasian EAN),
causing the original agent to be replaced by the newly named Ophiostoma
novo-ulmi Brasier.
The geographic isolation of Spain has resulted in a considerable delay in
the arrival of the agressive strain (NAN) of the elm disease, which only
appeared from 1980 onwards (Gil Sánchez, 1990). Due to the rapid
expansion of the disease, by 1990 healthy elms were already considered
rare. In the Granada province, elm infection appeared from 1992 onwards,
and the province is cited amongst the last affected by the disease in Spain
(González-Ruiz, 1990, 1995; González-Ruiz and Prieto Fernández, 1995).
The pathogenicity of O. novo-ulmi is caused as a result of the
penetration and development of the hyphae in the vessels of the xylem,
which generate thousands of conidia with blok the flow of water, as well as
by the produced toxins, which cause progressive dessication and death of
the tree (Ipinza Carmona et al, 1990).
As it is commonly known, the fungus is poorly adapted for any other
type of transport (Pajares Alonso, 1990), and it requires the participation of
species of Scolytidae family: Scolytus multistriatus and Scolytus scolytus,
which possess specific tegument adaptations for the transport of the fungal
spores, and consequently are well adapted to infect new healthy elms during
their feeding on the tree canopy during its dispersal flight. They reproduce
12
in weakened trees, and in sick branches, where they construct their
reproductive galleries. When the newly emerged adults begin their flight
dispersal, destined to seek out appropriate material for their reproduction,
they fed in twig feeding galleries on the forks of the canopies, thus causing
the formation of further infections.
The development of the infection causes progressive debilitation and
death of the affected elm, whilst the process of root grafting between trees,
accelerates the transmission of the disease over a short distance.
The presence of the scolytid beetle’s reproductive galleries in the
dead or ill trees, results in exponential growth of the disease in the affected
elm, increased by the transport and storage of the resulting timber.
DEFELOPMENT OF THE CONTROL PROGRAMME
Once the NAN aggressive strain was detected in the Alhambra and
Generalife forest, at the Spring of 1994, a Programme of integrated
management was rapidly set up, with the objective of reducing levels of
infection, and containing the expansion of both pathogen and insect vectors
(González Ruiz et al, 1998). The success of this programme mostly
depended on the adequate co-ordination of all its elements (Lanier, 1990;
Pajares Alonso and Martínez de Azafra, 1990), which will be now
described.
I. Elms inventory.
The first of the control elements involves the formation of an
inventory which will permit the identification of all the elm trees and which
will provide information on their characteristics (diameter, height), and
phytosanitary state. To get an easier handling of data, four different areas
have been considered : 1/ “Alamedas de Gomérez” wood, 2/ “Generalife”
woods, 3/ “Alhambra” gardens, and 4/ “San Pedro” woods. In each area,
elms were labeled and represented on a plan to the scale of 1: 300. Periodic
observations of the phenology of the elms are made, to adequately adapt the
different elements of the control programme. An initial number of 1955
elms (Figure 1) have been catalogued, the majority of them from the
Generalife and “Alamedas de Gomérez” woods, and a smaller proportion
from the S- Pedro woods and Alhambra woods. Considering the notable
elms, the majority are found in the “Alamedas” zone (Figure 2).
13
Figure 1. Elm abundance and distribution during the period of
control of DED in Granada forests
II. Inspections
Early detection of infections is achieved by means of a careful
inspection of the tree canopies, from the different angles (Cannon et al.,
1985). The possibility of being able to intercept the infection is improved
the earlier it is detected. To this, the use of cranes is important, to give better
access to hidden areas.
A total number of 396 trees have been affected in the period 1994/1998
(which represents 20,2% of the total number of trees) of which 141 in 1994;
60 in 1995; 43 in 1996, 68 in 1997 and 84 in 1998. The number of infected
elms as a percentage of the total number of trees was 7.2% (1994), 3.2%
(1995) ; 2.4% (1996), and 3,8 (1997) and 4.8% (1998).
The highest level of incidence was observed in the notable elms (initial
number was of 523) in which 165 examples (Figure 3) were affected. In
these elms, the annual levels of infection were 17% (1994), 6,7% (1995)
2,3% (1996), 3,5 (1997) and 4,2% (1998). The statistically significant
reduction was observed in the four areas during the study.
14
Figure 2. Notable elm abundance and distribution during the period of
control of the DED in Granada forests
Figure 3. Distribution of notable elm affected by DED during the control
programme.
15
III. Therapeutic pruning.
Their objective is the eradication of the pathogen by removing
infected parts of the tree (Hart, 1970). The success of the process is
inversely proportional to the size of the lesion in the xylem, hence the
necessity to make periodic inspections. Cranes are used to give access to the
canopies, as well as manual climbing techniques. The infected branch is
removed. The number of elms treated was 183, of which 84 in 1994, 24 in
1995, 6 in 1996, 33 in 1997 and 36 in 1998.
Therapeutic pruning has resulted in the recovery of 55, 19 and 4
elms affected in 1994, 1995 and 1996 respectively, nevertheless, the success
of therapeutic pruning has varied between 80% (infection less than 10%) , to
40% (infection between 10 and 20%) and 33% (infection greater than 20%).
When level of infection was greater than 20% of infected foliar
surface, the pathogen had progressed as far as the vascular bundles of the
trunk xylem. Initially (1994), the removal of the greater part of the canopy
and a variable length of the trunk of these affected trees, were carried out,
but in no case has this process resulted in the recovery of the tree. In fact it
is increased the risk of root transmission to neighbouring elms.
IV. Limiting root transmission.
The transmission of the pathogen trough root grafts is quite common
way of infection (Verral and Graham, 1935), being in our program
responsible for at least 20% of mortality in 1995, 70% in 1996, and 40% in
1997 It was especially prevalent in “Alamedas de Gomérez” zone, where it
was responsible for 25%, 90% and 100% of mortality (1995, 1996 and 1997
respectively).
a. Mechanical disruption of xylem vessels. A ring shaped incision
is made at the base of the trunk which affects the last rings of the xylem,
leaving the pathogen confined to the aerial part of the elm.
b. Chemical destruction of the root. The triclorade pirinidil oxiacetic acid was added in the incision. Satisfactory results were observed in
most of cases.
c. Mechanical destruction of the bridge-roots. The destruction of
root connections between elms is made by digging trenches manually or
mechanically, thus attempting to isolate different groups of elms or
individual trees. According to the depth of theses trenches, the effectiveness
ranged from 70% to 100% when depth was increased from 60 cm to 1.5 m.
V. Control of vectors.
In general lines, the scolytid elm bark beetles represent the main
transmission vehicle of the disease. Several measures have been used in
16
order to reduce the scolytids populations, and therefore, the frecuency of
aerial transmission of O. novo-ulmi.
a. Sanitation
This forms the principal element of vector control and consist of
removal of the material used for their reproduction (Van Sikle and Stern,
1976). Its importance becomes clear when we are into account, the fact en
adult elm may produce up to 500.000 individuals.
On those elms in which more than 25% of the canopy is affected, the
beetle's penetration holes, which correspond to their subcortical gallery
systems, are frequently observed. However, due to the secondary character
of these insects, every elm debilitated, either by desiccation, (suffered until
the end of 1995) , or as a result of work carried out on its surroundings,
becomes an optimal material for the beetles reproduction, despite the fact
that it doesn't show visible symptoms of the disease. in other causes the
existence of cavities and rot, aggravated by excessive humidity, cases the
proliferation of other pathogenic fungi such as Armillaria mellea
(responsible for white rot in roots), as well as an increasing frequency of
colonies of termites, which together cause cracking in the branches and
trunk. This debilitations provide an excellent substrate for scolytid beetle
reproduction. It is therefore necessary to fell these tress, When their size and
position permit, this is done directly from the base. However, more
frequently, in the case of larger, denser elm, they are gradually cut down
and chopped up later. During the time to complete this process, the remains
of the trees were provided with informative posters. Later, the remains of
the tree are removed as quickly as possible and incinerated. When there
were fire danger the timber was subjected to treatment with insecticides and
later covered with plastic to improve the efficacy of the treatment. After
felling, it is necessary to considerably reduce the height of the stump
because this might hold vital reservoirs of the pathogen.
The clearing up process in the Alhambra resulted in the felling a
total number of 265 elms, which represents a 13,5% of the original
population. Of these, 88 elms corresponded to 1994, 43 to 1995, 36 to 1996,
30 to 1997 and 68 to 1998. The percentages being 4.5% in 1994, 2,3% in
1995, 2% in 1996 and almost 1,6% in1997 and 3,6% in 1998.
However, considering only notable elms, the number of felled trees
was of 19,6% from the original population. From these, 64 trees were felled
in 1994, 17 in 1995, 12 in 1996, 3 in 1997 and 7 in 1998. The corresponding
mortality percentages being 12.2%, 3,7% 2,7%, 2.3 and 1.6% during the
study period (Figure 4).
17
Figure 4. Percentages of notables elms afected (whyte) and killed (yellow)
by DED during the period of application of control programme.
b. Pheromone Traps
A technique applied frequently in population monitoring of bark
beetles is the installation of flight interception traps containing synthetic
aggregation pheromones (Wood, 1982). For Scolytus multistriatus the
pheromone consists of a three fold mixture of a -multistriatin, 4-metil-3heptanol and a -alfacubebene. A total number of 8 traps (close to 1/ha) have
been installed on the periphery of the and suitably distanced from the tress.
These traps, periodically examined, showed the variation in densities of
flying beetles, and reveal the presence of close-by focus of dispersion, and
permitted to compare the population sizes in different years (Figures 5, 6, 7
and 8). Three complete generations and a partial fourth generation have
been observed, in accordance with the observations of Pajares Alonso
(1987) in central Spain. Generation length was 55 to 60 days for the first
generation and 45 to 50 days for the second and third generations. The
number of captured individuals was 3272 in 1995 and 4418 in 1996,
although this increase was not statistically significant different.
In the case of Scolytus scolytus, whose commercial pheromone
doesn't had a great attraction capacity, the pheromone was used together
with lures of trunks of recently felled elms, protected by an insecticide, as
18
well as the neighbouring tress. The volatile chemicals given off by the
trunk-lures improved the level of attraction of the synthetic pheromones.
c. Biological control of the elm bark beetles
A programme of biological control has also been applied, achieved by mass
rearing chalcidoidea parasitoids of S. multistriatus, (Cheiropachus quadrum,
Raphitelus maculatus, Dendrosoter protuberans as main species) was
carried out in an insectorium, by using the olive bark beetle Phloeotribus
scarabaeoides (Bernard.) as substitution host. For the mass rearing of
parasitoids, live tree timber is infested with bark beetles. Estimates of the
number of released individuals have been approximately 36.000 and 43.000,
being the estimated offspring is 24.000.000 individuals which corresponds
to the number of beetles normally produced in 50 notable elms. The test
carried out throughout 1996 showed levels of parasitism greater than 17%,
in respect to the 6,5% observed in material obtained in 1994, a statistically
significant increase (Figure 9).
Figure 5. Pattern of flight (no. of ind. per trap) of Scolytus multistriatus
during 1995
19
Figure 6. Pattern of flight (no. of ind. per trap) of Scolytus multistriatus
during 1996
Figure 7. Pattern of flight (no. of ind. per trap) of Scolytus multistriatus
during 1997
20
Figure 8. Pattern of flight (no. of ind. per trap) of Scolytus multistriatus
during 1998
Figure 9. Evolution of the density of emergence of S. multistriatus and level
of parasitization after mass release of its parasitoids in Alhambra and
Generalife elm woods
21
d. lnsecticide application
In spite the last element, it was absolutely essential to protect the
canopies of elms by means of insecticides application (Lanier et al., 1984;
Pajares Alonso and Arévalo, 1987). The system employed consisted of the
application of a piretroid insecticide a-cypermetrin 0.3% or lambdacyhalotrin.0.7%) achieved by spraying from the ground and sometimes from
the air. The applications were made during absolutely calm atmospheric
conditions to ensure maximal cover. The application of the insecticide was
carried out, taking into account the phenology of the elms, the phenology of
the beetles, and periods of rain, attempting to achieve an adequate and
regular temporal distance between them.
VI. Injection of Fungicides (Tiabendazol)
Systemic chemical treatments by means of injection of fungicides
was also carried out. Because of the high cost and inconveniences of this
type of treatment, it was only been used in less than 10% of the notable
elms. The application was used as a preventive measure in 50%, 97% and
100% of cases in years 1994, 1995, and 1996. Following the evolution of
the elms injected with tiabendazol has allowed us to verify its
ineffectiveness in cases with a high proportion of affected foliar surface
(elms lopped during 1994), as well as cases infected later via the roots.
Moreover, some of the preventive injected elms (1 injected in 1995, 3 elms
in 1996), have also show symptoms of foliar infection, which indicated its
relatively low efficacy as described by Shigo and Campana (1977).
VII. Induction of elm resistance by Verticillium dahliae
inoculations
With the objective of determining whether other pathogenic fungi
would be effective at inducing a resistance mechanism in the elm under
ecological conditions similar to whose in the Alhambra and Generalife, and
with the objective of possibly incorporating them into a control programme,
a trial was carried out during the summer of 1996 (Gázquez Alcoba and
González Ruiz, 1998). Inside a study area, 4 subgroups of 20 elms were
established and each of these groups was subjected to a different treatment:
Group A (distilled water, control group)
Group B (0. novo ulmi),
Group C (Verticillium dahliae WCS 859)
Group D (0. novo ulmi and Verticillium dahliae WCS 859).
The method used in the application of the biocontrol agent, crucial
for its efficacy, consisted of chiselling with a pouge, in accordance with the
technique supplied by Heidemij Realisatie (Aperdoorn, Netherlands).
22
The results obtained over the summer of 1996 reveal large
differences between the symptoms of the elms in the different groups
(Figure 10.). A total absence of symptoms was observed in the elms in the
control group (group A), in those injected with V. dahliae (Group C) and in
the injected with 0. novo-ulmi and V. dahliae.(Group D).
As was expected, an increase level of mortality occured in the elms
infected with 0. novo-ulmi (Group B). A later examination of the elms
carried out during the summer of 1997, clear the lack of effectiveness of the
treatment with V. dahliae, as it was expected.
The efficacy of treatment was therefore only maintained during a
temporary of the elms, making it necessary to renew the treatment every
year to induce resistance. Despite this, these results were highly satisfactory,
and opened up important routes for the improvement in the efficacy of
integrated control.
Figure 10. Elms evolution (foliar symptoms) during the experiment
References
Anonym (Delegación Provincial de Medio Ambiente de Granada.) (1995):
Informe Seguimiento de las olmedas de la provincia de Granada.
Informe Técnico, Agencia de Medio Ambiente, Consejería de Medio
Ambiente, Granada, 9 pp.
Brasier, C.M. (1990): China and the origins of Dutch elm disease: an
appraisal. Plant Pathology 39: 5-16.
23
Brasier, C.M. (1991): Ophiostoma novo-ulmi sp. causative agent of the
current Dutch elm disease pandemics. Mycopathologia 115: 151-161.
Brasier, C.M. and Mehotra A.M.D. (1995): Ophiostoma himal-ulmi sp.
nov., a new species of Dutch elm disease fungus endemic to the
Himalayas. Mycol. Res., 99 (2): 205-215.
Cannon, W.N., Barger, J.H. and Groth, L. (1985): Seasonal detection of
visible Dutch elm disease symptoms. Journal of Arboriculture 11:
233-235.
Epstein, A.H. (1978): Systemic chemical treatments of trees for protection
and therapy. En: Dutch elm disease, perspectives after 60 years (W. A.
Sinclair and R. J. Campana, eds), pp. 32-33. Cornell Univ. Agric. Exp.
Stat., New York
Fransen, J.J., and Buismann, C. (1935): Infectieproeven op verschillende
iepenosorten met behulp van iepen spintkevers. Tidjch. Plantenz. 41:
221-39.
Gazquez, P. y González, R. (1998): Control de la grafiosis, Ophiostoma
novo-ulmi, mediante inducción de resistencia en los olmos: ensayo
preliminar. Sanidad Forestal en España
Gibbs, J. N., y Dickinson, J. (1975): Fungicide injection for the control of
Dutch elm disease. Forestry 48: 165-176.
Gil Sánchez, L. (1990): Los olmos y la grafiosis en España. ICONA,
Colección Técnica, Madrid 300 pp.
González, R. (1990): Estudio bioecológico de Phloeotribus scarabaeoides
(Bernard, 1788) (Coleoptera, Scolytidae), en la peovíncia de Granada.
Tesis Doctoral, Universidad de Granada 450 pp.
González, R. (1995): Control Integrado de la grafiosis del olmo en la
Alhambra. Cuadernos de la Alhambra, 31-32: 207-224.
González-Ruiz, R. y Prieto Fernández, P. (1995): Grafiosis del olmo.
Arboledas de la Alhambra. Investigación y Ciencia 2: 23-24.
González, R.; Gazquez, P., y Pajares Alonso, J.A. (1998): La grafiosis del
olmo en la Alhambra y el Generalife (Granada). Resultados del
programa de control integrado (periodo: 1994/97). Sanidad Forestal en
España
Hart, J.H. (1970): Attempts to control Dutch elm disease by prunning. Plant
Dis. Reptr. 54: 985- 86.
Ipinza Carmona, R., Martínez de Azagra, A., Salvador Nemoz, M. L., y
Calonge, F.D. (1990): Consideraciones micológicas epidemiológicas
de Ceratocystis (Ophiostoma) ulmi (Buism.) Moreau. En: Gil, L. (ed.),
Los olmos y la grafiosis en España, pp. 121-164. Ministerio de
Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación -ICONA
Lanier, G.N. (1990): Consideraciones sobre los problemas en el control
municipal de la grafiosis. En: Gil, L. (ed.), Los olmos y la grafiosis en
24
España, pp. 215-241. Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación
-ICONA
Lanier, G.N.; Sherman, J.F.; Rabaglia, R.J., and Jones, A.H. (1984):
Insecticides for control of bark beetles that spread Dutch elm disease.
J. Arboric. 10: 265-72.
Pajares Alonso, J.A. (1987): Contribución al conocimiento de los escolítidos
vectores de la grafiosis en la Península Ibérica. Tesis Doctoral, ETSI
de Montes, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, Madrid 229 pp.
Pajares Alonso, J.A. y Arévalo, M.J. (1987): Protección de los olmos contra
insectos vectores de la grafiosis. Boletín de Sanidad Vegetal y Plagas
13: 311-325.
Pajares Alonso, J.A. y Martínez de Azagra, A. (1990): El control de la
grafiosis. En: Gil, L. (ed.), Los olmos y la grafiosis en España, pp.
215-241. Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación -ICONA
Pajares Alonso, J.A. y Gil Sánchez, L.A. (1990): Los escolítidos del olmo,
vectores de la grafiosis. En: Gil, L. (ed.), Los olmos y la grafiosis en
España, pp. 215-241. Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación
-ICONA
Shigo, A L., and Campana, R.J. (1977): Discolored and decayed wood
associated with injection wounds in American Elms. J. Arboric. 3:
230-35.
Van Sikle, G.A., and Sterner, G.S. (1976): Sanitation, a practical protection
against Dutch elm disease in Fredericton, New Brunswick. Plant Dis.
Rep., 60: 336-38.
Verral, A.F. and Graham, T.W. (1935): The transmission of Ceratostomella
ulmi trough root grafts. Phytopathology 25: 1039-40.
Wood, D.L. (1982): The role of pheromones, kairomones and allomones in
the host selection and colonization behaviour of bark beetles. Annual
Review in Entomology 27: 411-446.
25
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT OF THE DUTCH ELM DISEASE
IN ALHAMBRA AND GENERALIFE FORESTS (GRANADA,
SPAIN)
R. González-Ruiz1 , P. Gázquez-Alcoba2, J. A. Pajares-Alonso3
1
Departmento de Biología Animal, Vegetal y Ecología, Universiad de Jaén, Jaén, Spain
Departamento de Bosques y Jardines de la Alhambra y el Generalife, Granada, Spain
3
Departamento de Producción Vegetal y Silvopascicultura, Escuela Técnica Superior de
Ingenierías Agrarias, Palencia, Spain
2
Summary
Dutch elm disease, caused by the ascomycete Ophiostoma ulmi Buisman), has been
responsible for the disappearance of hundreds of millions elms trees in the northern
hemisphere. Since its appearance, at the start of the century, it has produced two
pandemics. The first of these began in North-Eastern Europe around 1910 and the second
owed its appearance -around 1940- to two races of greater pathogenicity (North-American
NAN and Eurasian EAN), causing the original agent to be replaced by the newly named
Ophiostoma novo-ulmi (Brasier). The geographic isolation of Spain has resulted in a
considerable delay in the arrival of the agressive strain (NAN) of the elm disease, which
only appeared from 1980 onwards. Due to the rapid expansion of the disease, by 1990
healthy elms were already considered rare. In the Granada province, elm infection appeared
from 1992 onwards, and the province is cited amongst the last affected by the disease in
Spain. The pathogenicity of O. novo-ulmi is caused as a result of the penetration and
development of the hyphae in the vessels of the xylem, which generate thousands of
conidia with block the flow of water, as well as by the produced toxins, which cause
progressive desiccation and death of the tree. As it is known, the fungus is poorly adapted
for any other type of transport, and it requires the participation of elm bark beetles
(Scolytidae): Scolytus multistriatus and Scolytus scolytus, which possess specific tegument
adaptations for the transport of the fungal spores, and consequently are well adapted to
infect new healthy elms. The development of the infection causes progressive debilitation
and death of the affected elm, whilst the process of root grafting between trees, accelerates
the transmission of the disease over a short distance. The presence of the scolytid beetle’s
reproductive galleries in the dead or ill trees, results in exponential growth of the disease in
the affected elm, increased by the transport and storage of the resulting timber. The paper
presents the heroic, many-sided fight (chemical, biological control) of the country’s
specialists against the disease and its vector in order to save the elm forests of Alhambra
and Generalife.
26
RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT IN PESTICIDE
CHEMISTRY
CURRENT STATUS AND A GLIMPSE AT THE FUTURE
István Ujváry
Institute of Biomolecular Chemistry, Chemical Research Center, Hungarian
Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary
Natural, synthetic and semi-synthetic crop protection chemicals and disease
control chemicals (altogether pesticides) have been one of the key
components of modern agriculture as well as of animal and human disease
vector control over the past century and will undoubtedly be used for
decades. For 2005, the global market of agrochemicals used for pest control
was US$33.6 billion (AGROW, 2006a), which is a 45% increase over
global sales in 1990. From 1990 pesticide export more than doubled to
about US$ 16 billion in 2005 (FAOSTAT, 2006), reflecting the impact of
international trade and globalization. These figures, however, do not truly
reflect the important changes that have happened in chemical terms in this
continuously evolving field.
Recent studies indicate that major agrochemical companies spend an
average of 7.5% of their annual sales on research and development of new
crop protection products and on improving the activity or safety of existing
ones (CropLife, 2005; Phillips McDougall, 2005). The development of a
new product from discovery to first sales typically takes 8-9 years and costs
roughly US$200 million. Of this, ca. US$67 million is spent on chemistryrelated research, ca. US$80 million on biological studies, and ca. US$53
million on toxicological and environmental fate studies. The following
chemically oriented overview will focus on research and development of
new pesticides emphasizing selected aspects.
Need for new compounds
The main driving forces behind the research for new pesticides are as
follows:
a) improvements over or replacement of existing products by new
compounds that are more environment-friendly and less toxic to nontarget organisms;
b) resistance towards currently used control agents;
c) new pests and diseases, including invasive species, necessitating novel
control methods;
d) economic incentives.
27
Of these, resistance is a challenging motive to develop new pesticides. The
continuous reliance on one particular compound class in a field inevitably
increases the risk of the development of resistance towards that particular
compound type. This resistance can extend to other, structurally different
classes having the same mode of action. Instances of resistance to at least
one pesticide active ingredient have been recorded for over 540 of insect
species (IRAC, 2005), for over 300 weed biotypes (Heap, 2006; HRAC,
2005), and for some 350 plant pathogen isolates (FRAC, 2005). While many
of these cases are from laboratory findings, field performance failures have
frequently been reported. Thus, resistance management has become an
essential part of crop protection and one of the promising ways of
decreasing the risk of its occurrence is the use of novel compounds, ideally
with a different mode of action.
Ways to find new bioactive compounds
It has recently been estimated that some 100,000 compounds have to be
tested to bring a new pest control agent to market. These new substances
could be obtained by:
a) natural product screening;
b) screening of randomly prepared synthetic compounds, e.g., in-house
or acquired compound libraries;
c) analogue design using structural modifications of natural products or
compounds developed by other companies;
d) enzyme inhibitor design based on vital biochemical reaction
mechanisms;
e) computer aided molecule design using the three-dimensional (3D)
structure of the target site;
f) serendipity.
The following paragraphs will discuss some of the above points.
Natural product-based pesticides. Natural products are exceptional sources
of structural diversity and of unique chemical scaffolds that, by virtue of
their ecological role, have proven to be capable binding to target proteins.
Although the currently used pest control agents are mostly synthetic
compounds, there are several pesticides obtained from plants,
microorganisms or animals (Ujváry, 2002, 2003). These sources are usually
renewable, and conventional breeding or genetic engineering can yield
strains that biosynthesize substances originally producing in economically
unacceptable low yields. Moreover, directed biosynthesis using non-natural
precursors (e.g. amino acid analogs) that are then incorporated
28
enzymatically into the final molecule can give rise to novel and complex
structures that would hardly be attainable by chemical synthesis. Systematic
screening of botanical or microbial extracts will certainly uncover novel
bioactive compounds from time to time.
A few pesticides are semi-synthetic substances obtained by appropriate
synthetic modifications of natural products. It is expected that the number of
such semi-synthetic derivatives with highly complex structure and with
optimized potency against pests which are not susceptible to the original
natural product, will increase. Some representative examples of structurally
diverse natural products and synthetic analogs derived from them are shown
in Figure 1.
CF3
O
CO2H
P
OH
F
NH2
O
H
N
OMe
O
H
N
I
N
MeO2C
azoxystrobin (fungicide)
O
O
O
CN
HN
glufosinate (herbicide)
N
N
CF 3
NO 2
HN
dinotefuran (insecticide)
O
O
S
O
O
N
H
N
flubendiamide (insecticide)
O
MeO
O
O
chromafenozide (insecticide)
O
O
HN
Me
O
OMe
O
O
O
OH
O
O
O
O
H
O
NMe 2
OMe
O
O
OH
eprinomectin B 1a (acaricide/parasiticide)
H
OMe
OEt
O
H
H
H
H
XDE-175 (insecticide)
Figure 1. Structural diversity of selected natural products and other
related pest control agents. For eprinomectin and XDE-175, only the
major component of the commercialized material is shown.
For agricultural use, a natural product should be: a) efficacious against
target species; b) safe and selective; 3) sufficiently stable in the field; c)
standardized for composition and formulation; and d) readily available. If
some of these criteria are not met, appropriate synthetic modifications or
analogue design can lead to marketable pest control agents, as happened
with the unstable natural strobilurins that served as models for a broad range
of synthetic fungicides (e.g., azoxystrobin, Figure 1). Eprinomectin is one of
the semi-synthetic derivatives of the parasiticide avermectin. Recently,
fermentation provided complex core structures for semi-synthetic
modifications affording XDE-175 (Figure 1), a second-generation version of
the microbial insecticide spinosad (AGROW, 2006b; Sparks et al., 2001). It
is expected that genetic engineering of complex biosynthetic pathways into
tractable host (micro)organisms will be increasingly used to produce
structurally complex chemicals on an industrial scale.
Discovery through screening of synthetics. Synthetic chemistry has long
been a most successful tool in pesticide discovery. The origin of several
29
current pesticides can be traced back to projects initiated purely on chemical
grounds, typically around structures of academic interest. Systematic
bioassays of novel synthetics can result in a resurgence of interest in a
forgotten mode of action. Thus, the discovery of imidacloprid revived
research in the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (Yamamoto and Casida,
1999) and within 15 years the neonicotinoids, exemplified by dinotefuran in
Figure 1, captured over 15% of the insecticide market. A recently
rediscovered insecticide site of action is the ryanodine receptor, the target of
the botanical Ryania insecticide. The recent discovery of flubendiamide, a
novel phthalic acid diamide (Figure 1), and the structurally related
rynaxypyr, a new anthranilic acid diamide derivative, both acting at this
receptor will certainly provide additional insecticides with novel mode of
action (Nauen, 2006).
This traditional line of research is still worth to be pursued because it can be
a source of new structures.
O
OMe
O
O
N
H
O
O
H
N
O
Cl
Cl
O
N *
H
Cl
carpropamid (fungicide)
bifenazate (acaricide)
spiromesifen (insecticide)
*
*
O
O
MeO
* O
*
H
N
* N
H
MeO
N
O
verbutin (insecticide
O
pyrazolecarboxamide (herbicide)
iprovalicarb (fungicide)
CF3
O *
*
N
O
O
N
N
N
H
O
OH
O
NH2
N
H
Cl
N
Cl
CN
O
N
Cl
N
CO2H
Cl
icaridine (insect repellent) flonicamid (aphicide) aminopyralid (herbicide) oxaziclomefone (herbicide)
Figure 2. Chemical structure of selected pest control agents with novel
structures. Asterisk (*) denotes chiral center.
Combinatorial chemistry. Combinatorial synthesis is an automated process
to rapidly prepare large sets (libraries) of structurally related compounds by
combining series of molecular building blocks. This technique generates,
typically within days, hundreds or even thousands of analogs around core
structures either in solution or on solid-phase. While early efforts were
aimed at quantity to produce tens of thousand of closely related substances,
often as unseparated mixtures, nowadays there is more emphasis on quality
and diversity. While combinatorial chemistry has had a major impact on
lead compound generation and optimization in the pharmaceutical industry,
reports on its application in pesticide research are still scarce (Kleschik et
al., 2003). The first successful example of the combinatorial approach was
30
the identification from a library of 8000 amides and esters of a
pyrazolecarboxamide (Figure 2) having herbicidal activity at 100 g/ha
(Parlow and Normansell, 1996). Recently, sets of 5-50 member libraries of
acylaminoketone ecdysteroid receptor agonists, as analogues of
dibenzoylhydrazine insecticides, afforded several compounds highly active
in vitro (Garcia et al., 2005). A broad-range, whole-organism pesticide
screen of a diverse set of heterocycles, designed to possess physicochemical
properties required for good uptake and translocation, afforded several
fungicidal compounds (Martínez-Teipel et al., 2005).
High-throughput screening. High-throughput screening is a miniaturized
and automated procedure in which a large number of compounds are
screened rapidly and in parallel for readily measurable biological responses.
In contrast to pharmaceuticals research where screening is typically done
not on the target species, that is in humans, but in animal models and/or in
vitro systems, pesticide research has the cost and risk saving advantage of
testing candidate substances directly on target species in vivo thus
minimizing problems due to unpredictable absorption and metabolism that
are more or less absent in in vitro assays.
Molecular modeling and structure-based design. Computer-aided design of
bioactive compounds using the 3D structure of small molecule ligands and
target enzymes or receptors has become a reality during the past decade
(Walter, 2002). However, there are only a handful of 3D structures of
complexes between pesticidal ligands and relevant proteins (Table 1). These
structures, usually obtained by X-ray crystallography, permit the
examination of interactions between ligand and target in atomic detail and
can also reveal novel binding sites. Importantly, 3D structural data allow
screening in silico of millions of molecules (virtual compound libraries)
within days.
The different binding of selective and non-selective compounds can also be
studied in silico if the relevant target site structure is available. Comparison
of the X-ray structures of plant (Arabidopsis thaliana) and rat 4hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenases complexing hydroxypyrazolyl
ketones that are structurally related to the herbicides mesotrione and
isoxaflutole revealed the structural basis for the selectivity of these
herbicides (Yang et al., 2004). Recent binding mode studies of the
cytochrome P450 inhibitor triazole fungicide metconazole utilized the
crystal structure of fluconazole bound to bacterial lanosterol 14αdemethylase (Ito et al., 2004). In the field of insect control, the recent
31
Table 1. Representative examples of the currently known X-ray crystal
structures of pesticidal compounds in complex with their target biopolymer
Target site
Complexed ligand
PDB Code1
Insecticidal
acetylcholinesterase2
ecdysone receptor
juvenile hormone esterase
nicotinic acetylcholine
receptor3
trifluoroacetophenone derivative
ponasterone A, bisacylhydrazine
trifluoromethyl ketone derivative
nicotine
1AMN
1R20
2FJ0
1UW6
Herbicidal
acetoxyhydroxyacid synthase
adenylosuccinate synthetase
acetyl-CoA carboxylase
carboxyltransferase
EPSP synthase5
fatty acid synthetase, type II
4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate
dioxygenase
imidazoleglycerol phosphate
dehydratase
chlorsulfuron
imazaquin
hydantocidin 5’-monophosphate
1YHZ
1Z8N
1SOO4
diclofop
glyphosate
triclosan
1UYR
1G6S
1D7O
hydroxypyrazolyl ketone
2-hydroxy-3-(1,2,4- triazolyl)propylphosphonate
1TFZ
2F1D
Fungicidal, bactericidal
CYP450 14α-sterol
demethylase
trihydroxynaphthalene
reductase
mitochondrial cytochrome bc1
ketoconazole6
pyroquilon
azoxystrobin
famoxadone
carpropamid
streptomycin
1JIP
1G0O
1SQB
1L0L
2STD
1NTB
scytalone dehydratase
RNA aptamer
1
Protein Data Bank accession code. The X-ray structure of and additional information for
the specified complex can be found at http://www.pdbj.org or http://www.rcsb.org.
2
From the electric ray Torpedo californica.
3
From the snail Lymnaea stagnalis.
4
From Escherichia coli. The PDB code X-ray structure for uncomplexed enzyme of A.
thaliana is 1DJ2.
5
From Escherichia coli.
6
Antifungal pharmaceutical structurally related to azole fungicides used in agriculture.
32
elucidation of the X-ray structure of the ecdysone receptor has paved the
way for computer-aided design of new receptor agonists (Nakagawa, 2005).
Based on the 3D structure of the acetylcholine-binding protein complexing
nicotine, the selectivity of and resistance to imidacloprid could be
interpreted (Matsuda et al., 2005).
Role of chirality in pesticide activity, toxicity and environmental
biotransformation
Numerically, about a quarter of all pest control agents listed in The Pesticide
Manual (Tomlin, 2003) are chiral compounds containing at least one
asymmetric carbon atom. Often only one of the stereoisomers is responsible
for the desired biological activity but, mostly for economic reasons, many of
the commercialized products are mixtures of isomers as produced by
chemical synthesis. It has long been recognized that the stereoisomers of a
particular compound can have different toxicological properties and their
biodegradation in the environment can also differ (Garrison, 2006;
Hegeman and Laane, 2002). The biologically inactive isomer can merely act
as a ballast. In the worst-case scenario, however, the inactive isomer
degrades slowly and can affect non-target species adversely. Thus, there is
an increasing need to market stereoisomerically enriched products,
especially if studies indicate health or environmental risks for the unwanted,
target-inactive isomer. In certain cases, proprietary reasons also stimulate
the development of a chiral version of an established racemic active
ingredient.
Green chemistry
The discovery of a promising pesticide has to be followed by the
development of a safe manufacturing process capable of producing the
material in the quantity and the highest quality required. On monetary terms,
the costs associated with process development and related analytical
methodologies could be commensurate with those devoted to discovery
(Phillips McDougall, 2005). Because pest control agents are applied to large
areas, environmental considerations such as selective toxicity and
degradation studies have always been required for the registration of the
active ingredient and the formulation. No such formal requirements exist for
manufacturing processes, which can involve hazardous or polluting reagents
and solvents. Due to health and environmental reasons, the chemical
industry should to adopt the principles of green chemistry for the innovative
design and production of materials to prevent and reduce pollution (Anastas
and Kirchhoff, 2002; US EPA, 2006). The principles of green chemistry
will increasingly be applied by the pesticide industry both for the production
33
of the active pesticide ingredient and for the development of environment
friendly formulation types.
Actually, many of the above principles had dominated pesticide chemistry
well before the early 1990s when the term green chemistry was coined. New
types of selective pest control agents had been developed and adopted in
pest control 10-15 years earlier. For example, originating from research
carried out in the 1970s, pyrethroids and juvenoids started to replace several
organophosphate and carbamate insecticides; sulfonylureas used at
application rates typically below 100 g/ha appeared in weed control. In
general, the application rates and non-target toxicity of pest control agents
being commercialized from the 1980s are much lower than of those
developed earlier. Again, advances in technology, market changes and
stricter regulations drive research and development.
Combination of chemical pest control with other crop protection
technologies
In 2005, the global market value of biotech crops was US$5.25 billion
corresponding to about 15% of the global agrochemical sales (James, 2005).
The growing adoption of crop biotechnology limits the market for chemical
pesticides, especially for synthetic insecticides that are replaced by
technologies based on Bt-producing plant varieties. The picture is less clear
for the herbicide market where herbicide-tolerant traits do require the
application of the given herbicide. While the global adoption of transgenic
herbicide-tolerant crops existing today will certainly continue, new
herbicide-resistance varieties are unlikely to be developed (Devine, 2005).
This is especially true for crops for the food and feed market. However, the
increasing demand for biorenewables, e.g. for plants grown for fuel or
polymer production, could result in the development of genetically modified
crop varieties, which might call for new, economically and environmentally
viable herbicides and other pest control agents to be used in these
cultivations.
Chemical means of insect control also supplement the so-called area-wide
integrated pest management control strategies. For example, the mass
release of sterile insects in isolated areas is typically preceded by initial
population suppression by insecticides (Dyck et al., 2005).
Conclusions
The combination of traditional and automated chemical synthesis with
biochemistry, metabolic engineering, and genomics offers exciting
34
possibilities to exploit the (bio)chemical diversity in the quest for new crop
protection chemicals. Such research and development should take place in
an economic era when there is no essential growth in pesticide sales.
Nevertheless, the substitution of many hazardous pest control agents by
safer ones will continue and new chemical and biochemical means of
industrial syntheses will emerge. Rapidly advancing technologies, on one
hand, and changing market demand, on the other, will continue to drive
innovation in the agrochemical industry to provide customers with
economically viable and safe crop protection and disease vector control
agents. Over the past four decades many novel chemical prototypes have
emerged. In spite of industry consolidations, the rate of introduction of new
active ingredients has not changed much (Phillips and McDougall, 2003).
Chemistry has played a decisive role in these developments either by
finding and optimizing entirely new structural prototypes or designing
analogues of natural products.
Paradoxically, the impressive advances in pesticide research do not seem to
be appreciated by the general public. The pervasive “chemophobia”
questions the mere necessity of the use of chemical pest control agents,
especially of those of synthetic origin, in spite of the fact that these have
been amongst the most thoroughly investigated, thus “transparent”
substances. Considering recent advances in our understanding of the
selective mode of action of many pesticides at the molecular level, and the
possibilities offered by structure-based methods of compound design, saying
that the time for chemicals in agriculture is over would be a mistake. The
present constrains in research and discovery of new chemical pest control
agents are not scientific but rather economic and political/social ones. One
could agree with the recent statement by Gro Harlem Brundtland
(Brundtland, 1997), currently director-general of the WHO: “Politics that
disregard science and knowledge will not stand the test of time. Indeed,
there is no other basis for sound political decisions than the best available
scientific evidence. This is especially true in the fields of resource
management and environmental protection.”
References
AGROW (2006a): Global agrochemical market flat in 2006. Agrow (No.
490), p. 15.
AGROW (2006b): Dow to debut new spinosad. Agrow (No. 491), p. 17.
Anastas, P.T. and Kirchhoff, M.M. (2002): Origins, current status, and
future challenges of green chemistry. Acc. Chem. Res: 35, 686-694.
Billas, I.M.L., Iwema, T., Garnier, J.-M., Mitschler, A., Rochel, N. and
Moras, D. (2003): Structural adaptability in the ligand-binding pocket of
the ecdysone hormone receptor. Nature 426: 91-96.
35
Brundtland, G.H. (1997): The scientific underpinning of policy. Science
277: 457.
CropLife International (2005): Crop Protection Stewardship Activities of
the Plant Science Industry. CropLife International, Brussels, Belgium.
Devine, M.D. (2005): Why are there not more herbicide-tolerant crops? Pest
Manag. Sci. 61: 312-317.
Dyck, V.A.; Hendrichs, J. and Robinson, A.S. (eds.) (2005): Sterile Insect
Technique - Principles and Practice in Area-Wide Integrated Pest
Management. IAEA – Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
FAOSTAT data, 2006. URL: http://faostat.fao.org/ (accessed: 23 May
2006)
FRAC (Fungicide Resistance Action Committee) (2005): FRAC Code List
2:
Fungicides
sorted
by
modes
of
action.
URL:
http://www.frac.info/frac/publication/anhang/FRAC_Code_List2.pdf
(accessed: 25 May 2006)
Garcia, J., Mata, E.G., Tice, C.M., Hormann, R.E., Nicolas, E., Albericio, F.
and Michelotti, E.L. (2005): Evaluation of solution and solid-phase
approaches to the synthesis of libraries of
, -disubstituted- acylaminoketones. J. Comb. Chem. 7: 843-863.
Garrison, A. W. (2006): Enantiomer-specific formulations could decrease
pesticide use and protect the environment from unintended effects.
Environ. Sci. Technol. 40: 16-23.
Heap, I. (2006): The International Survey of Herbicide Resistant Weeds.
URL: http://www.weedscience.org (accessed: 29 May 2006)
Hegeman, W. J. M. and Laane, R. W. P. M. (2002): Enantiomeric
enrichment of chiral pesticides in the environment. Rev. Environ.
Contam. Toxicol. 173: 85-116.
HRAC (Herbicide Resistance Action Committee) (2005): Classification of
herbicides according to mode of action. URL: http://www.iraconline.org/documents/moa/MoAv5_1.doc (accessed: 25 May 2006)
IRAC (Insecticide Resistance Action Committee) (2005): IRAC mode of
action classification. URL:
http://www.frac.info/frac/publication/anhang/FRAC_Code_List2.pdf
(accessed: 25 May 2006)
Ito, A., Sudo, K., Kumazawa, S., Kikuchi, M. and Chuman, H. (2005):
Three-dimensional modeling of cytochrome P450 14 -demethylase
(CYP51) and interaction of azole fungicide metconazole with CYP51.
In: Clark, J.M. and Ohkawa, H. (Eds.). New Discoveries in
Agrochemicals. Vol. 892. American Chemical Society, Washington,
DC, pp. 142-150.
36
James, C. (2005): Executive Summary of Global Status of Commercialized
Biotech/GM Crops: 2005. ISAAA Briefs No. 34. ISAAA: Ithaca, NY.
URL: http://www.isaaa.org (accessed: 23 May 2006)
Kleschik, W.A., Parker, M.H. and Turner, J.A. (2003): Combinatorial
chemistry as applied to the discovery of agrochemicals. In: J.R.
Plimmer (ed.). Encyclopedia of Agrochemicals, Vol. 1, John Wiley &
Sons, Hoboken, New Jersey, USA, pp. 381-386.
Martínez-Teipel, B., Teixidó, J., Pascual, R., Mora, M., Pujolà, J., Fujimoto,
T., Borrell, J. I. and Michelotti, E. L. (2005): 2-Methoxy-6-oxo-1,4,5,6tetrahydropyridine-3-carbonitriles: versatile starting materials for the
synthesis of libraries with diverse heterocyclic scaffolds. J. Comb.
Chem. 7: 436-448.
Matsuda, K., Shimomura, M., Ihara, M., Akamatsu, M. and Sattelle, D B.
(2005): Neonicotinoids show selective and diverse actions on their
nicotinic receptor targets: electrophysiology, molecular biology, and
receptor modeling studies. Biosci. Biotechnol. Biochem. 69: 1442-1452.
Nakagawa, Y. (2005): Nonsteroidal ecdysone agonists. In: G. Litwach (ed.).
Vitamins and Hormones, Vol. 73, Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 131-173.
Nauen, R. (2006): Insecticide mode of action: return of the ryanodine
receptor. Pest Manag. Sci. 62: 690-692.
Nicolaou, K.C., Hanko, R. and Hartwig, W. (Eds.) (2002): Handbook of
Combinatorial Chemistry. Drugs, Catalysts, Materials.Vols 1-2, WileyVCH, Weinheim.
Parlow, J.J. and Normansell, J.E. (1996): Discovery of a herbicidal lead
using polymer-bound activated esters in generating a combinatorial
library of amides and esters. Mol. Divers. 1: 266-269.
Phillips, M. and McDougall, J. (2003): Agrochemical product introduction
and re-registration: the challenge to the generic industry. Agrolook 4(2):
23-28.
Phillips McDougall (2005): Agrochemical Industry Research and
Development
Expenditure.
Midlothian,
UK.
URL:
http://www.croplife.org (accessed: 23 May 2006)
Sparks, T.C., Crouse, G.D. and Durst, G. (2001): Natural products as
insecticides: the biology, biochemistry and quantitative structureactivity relationships of spinosyns and spinosoids. Pest Manag. Sci. 57:
896-905.
Tomlin, C.D.S. (2003): The Pesticide Manual. Thirteenth Ed. British Crop
Protection Council: Alton, Hampshire, UK
Ujváry, I. (2002): Transforming natural products into natural pesticides experience and expectations. Phytoparasitica 30: 439-442.
Ujváry, I. (2003): Natural products pesticides. In: J. R. Plimmer (ed.).
Encyclopedia of Agrochemicals, Vol. 3, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken,
New Jersey, USA, pp. 1090-1104.
37
US
EPA (2006): 12 Principles of Green Chemistry. URL:
http://www.epa.gov/greenchemistry/principles.html (accessed: 31 May
2006)
Walter, M.W. (2002): Structure-based design of agrochemicals. Nat. Prod.
Rep. 19: 278-291.
Yamamoto, I. and Casida, J.E. (eds.) (1999): Nicotinoid Insecticides and the
Nicotinic Acetylcholine Receptor. Springer-Verlag: Tokyo
Yang, C., Pflugrath, J.W., Camper, D.L., Foster, M.L., Pernich, D.J. and
Walsh, T.A. (2004): Structural basis for herbicidal inhibitor selectivity
revealed by comparison of crystal structures of plant and mammalian 4hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenases. Biochemistry 43: 10414-10423.
RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT IN PESTICIDE CHEMISTRY.
CURRENT STATUS AND A GLIMPSE AT THE FUTURE
I. Ujváry
Institute of Biomolecular Chemistry, Chemical Research Center, Hungarian Academy of
Sciences, Budapest, Hungary
Summary
The global agrochemical market has been around US$30,000 million for recent years.
While there has been no essential growth in overall sales there have been important changes
in the chemistries of all pesticide categories over the last decade. The discovery of new
structural prototypes has provided new products that are able to replace some obsolete
pesticides. Natural products and traditional synthetic chemistry have continued to provide
valuable lead compounds for new pesticides. The biomolecular characterization of the
mode of action of many pest control agents at receptor and enzyme levels renders
computer-aided pesticide design in three dimensions a reality. Environmental
considerations should be crucial at the end-product level as well as in manufacturing
processes (green chemistry). Complementing biological and biotechnological tools,
chemicals used for the production of food and fiber, for disease vector control as well as for
potentially new markets (e.g., biorenewables for industrial raw materials and as energy
sources) will be essential in improving the welfare of the growing world population.
38
THE SAFETY OF FOOD PREPARED FROM
GENETICALLY MODIFIED PLANTS
Susan Bardocz - Arpad Pusztai
Independent Consultants, 8262 Badacsonytördemic, Tatay S. u. 15, Hungary
The Norwegian Institute of Gene Ecology (GenOK) Tromso, Norway
Introduction
Even a cursory look on the potential health and metabolic effects of GMplant derived feeds/foods revels a scarcity of published data. The regulators
in the USA use a decision tree approach in which they review the data
provided by the biotechnology companies but do not carry out safety
assessment of their own (Faust, 2002). In Europe also, the preferred
approach is to use compositional comparisons between the GM crop and its
traditional counterpart, and if these results show no significant differences
they are considered to be “substantially equivalent”, meaning that the GM is
as safe as the non-GM crop. Existing legislation does not require the testing
of GM crop-based feedstuffs with the target animals. Thus, the regulation of
GM-plants at present is based on a rather poor legislative and scientific
foundations.
The idea of substantial equivalence has outlived its usefulness.
Nevertheless, it is often claimed that as there are no biologically significant
compositional differences between the “substantially equivalent” GM and
non-GM crops, even when they are statistically significantly different.
Therefore, the definition of “substantial equivalence” is a concept without
any scientific or legal definition, as it is obvious from the following
statement: a BSE infected cow is substantially equivalent to a healthy one.
Therefore biological tests, based on scientifically validated experimental
methods and statistical analyses, which do not show any nutritional,
toxicological and physiological differences, are the real requirement for
determining the safety of any GMO, before one considers it to be safe as
human food or animal feed. Proper biological testing of foods/feeds derived
from GM-crops is made all the more urgent because without being aware of
it, the majority of the population is exposed to them, since proper labeling is
not being followed even in those countries, where it is required by law.
In this review we examine the only properly carried out and published
human experiment, and some animal studies, which ought to have been
taken into consideration before releasing any of the GM foods/feeds
presently on the market, or being considered for release.
39
Transgene survival in the alimentary tract and its possible
consequences
In genetic modification the intended gene is incorporated into the genome of
a crop using a vector containing several other genes/DNA sequences,
including as a minimum, viral promoters, transcription terminators,
antibiotic resistance- or other marker genes and reporter genes. According to
the submission of biotechnology companies to the competent authority, the
transgenic DNA degrades fully in the digestive tract, therefore it cannot
represent any danger to the public.
Therefore it is unfortunate that the possible physiological effects of these
genes and their expressed proteins on the digestive tract and the body are
seldom taken into account in spite convincing evidence that some of the
transgenes included in the vector may have an effect on safety. This is
particularly important, as it is now well established that DNA does not
always break down in the alimentary tract (Schubbert et al., 1997; 1998;
2002). This opens up the possibility that the antibiotic resistance marker
gene, in addition to others, may be taken up by bacteria in the digestive tract
and contribute to the spreading of antibiotic resistance (see Experiment with
Humans, below).
The observation, that a substantial proportion (6 to 25%) of a genetically
engineered plasmid survived a one hour exposure to human saliva (Mercer
et al., 1999) is being ignored. Partially degraded plasmid DNA also
successfully transformed Streptococcus gordonii, which lives in the human
mouth. Plasmid antibiotic resistance marker gene DNA exposed to ovine
saliva could transform competent Escherichia coli to ampicillin resistance in
vitro (Duggan et al., 2000) and when fed to chicks incorporated into GM
maize the plant-derived marker was shown to be present in their crop and
stomach (Chambers et al., 2002). The transfer of DNA derived from GM or
non-GM plant tissues to duodenal juice, lymphocytes, internal organs, etc.
of animals fed on feed rations containing these is now well established
(Chowdury et al., 2003), though their physiological significance for humans
is unclear.
40
Experiment with Humans
The only peer-reviewed human trial was carried out with GM soybean
(Netherwood et al., 2004), with the aim to determine the ability of the
antibiotic resistance marker gene to transfect live bacteria in the human
gastrointestinal tract. This human study (Netherwood et al., 2004)
confirmed the results of similar animal studies. It was shown that in the
digesta of seven ileostomy patients (people whose large intestine has been
surgically removed and replaced with an external pouch joined to the lower
end of their small intestine), who were given a single meal (in form of a
milkshake containing ROUNDUP-READY GM soybean), variable but
measurable amounts of the full length transgene construct survived, and
could be detected in their gut bacteria even after they were sub-cultured 4
times.
Figure 1. The survival of the full length transgene construct in the digesta of
humans
TRANSGENE SURVIVAL
4
Tran sgene recovery (%)
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
1
2
3
4
SUBJECT NO.
41
5
6
7
Redrawn by using the original data
Even more unfortunate was the finding, that in the “0 time” (control)
samples, taken before giving the patients the GM-soybean meal, the
transgene was already detectable in 3 of the 7 patients. This indicates that
30-50% of the British population was already carrying the transgene in their
gut bacteria, although GM-soy – in theory – was not available in Britain
(most food manufacturers and supermarkets pledged not to use GM
ingredients in their products).
In the same experiment with healthy individuals the transgene degradation
was assayed in the feaces and, since it did not contain any detectable
transgenic material, the ability of transfection was dismissed. However, this
part only proves that there is no environmental contamination by
undegraded transgenic DNA derived from this type of GM-soy, and
provides no evidence that the transgenic DNA is not being taken up by the
cells of the gut epithelium or by the gut bacteria. Therefore the prospect of
the uptake of functional vector genes, including the antibiotic resistance
gene, should be seriously considered and taken into account.
Experiments with Animals
The main stated objective of the GM regulation is to assure the human
population that GM foods are safe while animal safety is seldom discussed.
Most animal studies had limited, mainly commercial objectives, as it is
obvious from recent reviews (Faust, 2002; Aumaitre et al., 2002).
GM tomatoes
Indeed, historically the first such study (still unpublished) was carried out
on FLAVR-SAVRTM tomato at the instigation of the FDA (Food and Drug
Administration of USA). The studies, released following a court action
showed necrosis/erosion of the stomach in 4, (later upon re-examination 7)
out of 20 female rats fed the GM-tomato. No necrosis/erosion was found
with males fed the GM-tomatoes, or with males and females fed the parent,
non-GM tomatoes.
A GM tomato line developed using the Bacillus thuringiensis crystal protein
CRYIA(b) gene may have some general relevance to GM studies. In this
study (Noteborn et al, 1995) there was a commendable attempt to use
immunohistology to measure the binding of the gene product to the rat gut
surface in vivo rather than using spurious arguments why the gene product
should not bind. Unfortunately, instead of the Bt toxin isolated from GM
tomatoes, an Escherichia coli recombinant and potentially less stable form
of the gene product was tested, (this is a general practice with testing all
GM-derived proteins) that put a serious question mark over the results.
42
However, even with this recombinant form the in vitro binding of the Bt
toxin to gut sections, including the caecum and colon of humans and Rhesus
monkeys, was demonstrated by immunocytochemistry.
Herbicide-resistant soybean
In a safety study of glyphosate-resistant soybean, the feeding value,
wholesomeness (Hammond et al., 1996) and possible toxicity (Harrison et
al., 1996) of two GM-soy lines was compared to that of the parent line.
Processed GM-soy meal-based diets were fed to rats, broiler chickens,
catfish and dairy cows between four to ten weeks at the same concentrations
as in commercial non-GM soybean rations. According to the authors the
lines were substantially equivalent and the performance of the animals were
the same on all lines. The rat study (Hammond et al., 1996) had a wider and
more academic scope than the other more production-type studies. It
appears that the total protein content of the diets was adjusted to 24.7 g
protein/100 g diet to be iso-nitrogenous with Purina Laboratory Rat Chow
by the addition of 24.8 g of GM- and parent soybean meals respectively
(about 10% protein) to a base diet. All comparisons were made to rats fed
commercial Purina Chow. The protein concentration in this study therefore
was appreciably higher than the usual 10-16% crude protein, regarded as
optimal for the rat. This extra protein could have potentially masked any
possible transgene product effects. Thus, the GM-meal replaced only 8.5
and 17% respectively of the total protein of the diet. In other words, the GM
protein was diluted by other dietary proteins by 12 and 6 fold, respectively,
producing possible a masking effect. In spite of this, the Purina Chow-fed
control male rats grew significantly better than most of the three
experimental groups fed toasted soybeans (including the parental line).
There were no individual data for organ weights in the paper, but the kidney
weights of the raw GM-soy line-fed male rats were reported to be
significantly higher than those of the controls, while the testes of the
parental line-fed rats was significantly enlarged. No histology appears to
have been done apart from some qualitative microscopic observations on the
pancreas that has been described as showing some minimal to mild lesions.
The results of a separate studies (Teshima et al., 2000; 2002) with toasted
glyphosate-resistant GM soybean in which rats and mice were fed with this
GM soybean at 30% inclusion level in the diet for 15 weeks could not be
seriously considered because rat growth was minimal (less than 30 g over
105 days) and mice did not grow at all on either the test or control diets.
In a paper of Malatesta et al. (2002) it was shown that the liver of mice fed
on diets containing GM soybean in comparison with conventional soybeanbased diets underwent significant modifications in some nuclear features.
Hepatocytes in GM soybean-fed mice showed irregularly shaped nuclei,
indicating high metabolic rates, increased numbers of nuclear pores,
43
suggestive of intense molecular trafficking and more irregular nucleoli with
numerous small fibrillar centres, typical of increased metabolic rates.
Nucleoplasmic and nucleolar splicing factors were also more abundant in
GM-fed mice than in controls.
GM potatoes
In a mainly histology study of the ileum of mice fed with potatoes
transformed with a Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki CryI toxin gene and
as control, the effect of the toxin itself (Fares and El-Sayed, 1998) it was
shown that both the delta- endotoxin and, to a lesser extent the Bt-potato,
caused villus epithelial cell hypertrophy and multinucleation, disrupted
microvilli, mitochondrial degeneration and increased numbers of lysosomes
and autophagic vacuoles and the activation of crypt Paneth cells. This is an
important study because it showed that, in contrast to general belief,
exposure of the mouse gut (ileum) to the CryI gene product has caused
profound hypertrophic and hyperplastic changes in the cells of the gut
absorptive epithelium and these could lead to mucosal sensitization as it was
later demonstrated (Vazquez Padron et al., 1999; 2000).
The work concerning the effect on the histology of the different gut
compartments of feeding rats on diets based on GM potatoes expressing the
snowdrop (Galanthus nivalis) bulb lectin (GNA) gene (Ewen and Pusztai,
1999) revealed some major changes in gut structure and function. Young,
rapidly growing rats were strictly pair-fed on iso-proteinic and iso-caloric
diets supplemented with vitamins and minerals for 10 days. Histological
evaluation revealead mucosal thickening of the stomach, jejunum, caecum
and colon in rats fed GM-potatoes. The study showed significant differences
in growth rate, organ weight and the slowing down of the humoral immune
system. The most important observation was that the proliferative
hyperplastic growth of the rat gut was not a GNA lectin effect but was
probably either due to some other component of the gene vector used for the
genetic modification and/or the disruption caused by the incorporation of
the vector in the plant genome.
References
Aumaitre, A., Aulrich, K., Chesson, A., Flachowsky, G., and Piva, G.
(2002). Livest. Prod. Sci. 4, 223-238.
Chambers, P.A., Duggan, P.S., Heritage, J., Forbes, J.M. (2000). J. Antimic.
Chemother. 49, 161-164.
Chowdury, E.H., Kuribara, H., Hino, A., Sultana, P., Mikami, O., Shimada,
N., Guruge, K.S., Saito, M., and Nakayima, Y. (2003). J. Anim. Sci.
81, 2546-2551.
44
Duggan, P.S., Chambers, P.A., Heritage, J., Forbes, J.M. (2002). FEMS
Microbiol. Lett. 191, 71-77.
Ewen, S.W.B., Pusztai, A. (1999). Lancet 354, 1353-1354.
Fares, N.H., El-Sayed, A.K.(1998). Nat. Tox. 6, 219-233.
Faust, M.A. (2002). Livest. Prod. Sci. 74, 239-254.
Hammond, B.G., Vicini, J.L., Hartnell, G.F., Naylor, M.W., Knight, C.D.,
Robinson, E.H., Fuchs, R.L., Padgette, S.R. (1996). J. Nutr. 126,
717-727.
Harrison, L.A., Bailey, M.R., Naylor, M.W., Ream, J.E., Hammond, B.G.,
Nida, D.L., Burnette, B.L., Nickson, T.E., Mitsky, T.A., Taylor,
M.L, Fuchs, R.L., Padgette, S.R.(1996). J. Nutr. 126, 728-740.
Mercer, D.K., Scott, K.P., Bruce-Johnson, W.A., Glover, L.A., Flint, H.J.
(1999). Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 65, 6-10.
Malatesta, M., Caporaloni, C., Gavaudan, S., Rocchi, M.B.L., Serafini, S.,
Tiberi, C., Gazzanelli, G. (2002). Cell Struct. Function 27, 173-180.
Netherwood, T., Martin-Orúe, S.M., O'Donnell, A.G., Gockling, S.,
Graham, J., Mathers, J.C., Gilbert, H.J. (2004). Nature Biotech. 22,
204-209.
Noteborn, H.P.J.M., Bienenmann-Ploum, M.E., van den Berg, J.H.J., Alink,
G.M., Zolla, L., Raynaerts, A., Pensa, M., Kuiper, H.A. (1995).
Safety assessment of the Bacillus thuringiensis insecticidal crystal
protein CRYIA(b) expressed in transgenic tomatoes. In: Engel, K.H,
Takeoka, G.R., Teranishi, R. (Eds.), ACS Symposium series 605.
Genetically Modified Foods - Safety Issues American Chemical
Society, Washington, D.C. Chapter 12, pp. 135-147.
Schubbert, R., Renz, D., Schmitz, B., Doerfler, W. (1997). Proc. Natl. Acad.
Sci. USA 94, 961-966.
Schubbert, R. Hohlweg, U., Renz, D., Doerfler, W. (1998). Mol. Gen.
Genetics 259, 569-576.
Teshima, R., Akiyama, H., Okunuki, H., Sakushima, J-i, Goda, Y., Onodera,
H., Sawada, J-i., Toyoda, M.(2000). J. Food Hyg. Soc. Japan 41,
188-193.
Teshima, R., Watanabe, T., Okunuki, H., Isuzugawa, K., Akiyama, H.,
Onodera, H., Imai, T., Toyoda, M., Sawada, J.(2002). J. Food Hyg.
Soc. Japan 43, 273-279.
Vazquez Padron, R.I., Moreno Fierros, L., Neri Bazan, L., De la Riva, G.A.,
Lopez Revilla, R. (1999). Life Sciences 64, 1897-1912.
Vazquez Padron, R.I., Gonzalez Cabrera, J., Garcia Tovar, C., Neri Bazan,
L., Lopez Revilla, R., Hernandez, M., Morena Fierros, L., De la
Riva, G.A. (2000). Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 271, 54-58.
45
THE SAFETY OF FOOD PREPARED FROM GENETICALLY
MODIFIED PLANTS
S. Bardocz and A. Pusztai
Independent Consultants, 8262 Badacsonytördemic, Tatay S. u. 15, Hungary The
Norwegian Institute of Gene Ecology (GenOK) Tromso, Norway
Summary
The safety evaluation of food prepared from genetically modified plants (GM-plants, plants
made by recombinant DNA technology) is still based on the scientifically fraud concept of
substantial equivalence. The only human trial performed up to date provided evidence that
transgenic DNA material originating from Rounup-Reaady GM-soya can transfer into the
bacteria resident in the gastrointestinal tract of humans. Several animal experiments showed
that there are problems with feeding GM-plant containing foods. In spite of these, GM
foods are considered safe by the most authorities claming that there is no evidence of harm,
which of course does not mean that they are safe.
46
PHYTOPATHOLOGICAL SESSION
47
48
NEW VARIETY TESTING METHOD TO THE
FUSARIUM HEAD BLIGHT OF WHEAT
Péter Hertelendy1 – Mária Jakabné Kondor1 – László Gergely1 – Tibor
Szabó2
1
National Institute for Agricultural Quality Control, Departement of
Phytopathology, Budapest, Hungary
2
National Institute for Agricultural Quality Control, Variety Testing
Station, Röjtökmuzsaj, Hungary
The Fusarium Head Blight (FHB) is one of the most dangerous diseases of
wheat and relative crops in Hungary. Because of the fact that the European
Community introduced a new, obligatory limit to the deoxynivalenol (DON)
content (1,25 ppm) this year, its importance is getting higher and higher.
The hazard of a severe FHB epidemic depends on the large proportion of
cereals in the total agricultural area and the susceptible registered varieties.
According to the present practice of the National Institute for
Agricultural Quality Control (OMMI), one isolate of Fusarium culmorum
and F. graminearum is used, respectively for the inoculation. Seed infection
is detected by the so-called filter paper-frosting method. Due to the short
variety testing period of 2-3 years, and the rising significance of the disease,
the OMMI is planning to introduce a new, more complex and accurate
resistance testing method in the near future.
In 2006 a total of 114 winter wheat (Triticum aestivum and durum)
genotypes and FHB resistant check varieties were tested in a small-plot field
trial with 10 replications in Röjtökmuzsaj, Western Hungary. Inoculation
was carried out on the 6th June using 2 isolates of F. culmorum and F.
graminearum, respectively. Head infection was assessed 3 times, started 3
weeks after inoculation. Inoculum concentration was measured and AUDPC
values were calculated. Grain yield was measured using 25 heads / plot
samples with additional visual evaluation. DON content in the seed samples,
as the most important component of this method, will also be detected.
It is to be expected that the new resistance testing method will
provide more reliable and precise information on the resistance or
susceptibility of cereals, improving the variety testing process.
49
THE OBSERVATION A SLIME MOULD – BADHAMIA
FOLIICOLA – ON RAPE STEM
Szabolcs Szlávik
National Institute for Agricultural Quality Control, Budapest, Hungary
The slime mould (Badhamia foliicola) was found on a blackleg (Phoma
lingam) infected rape stem. The sample was collected in Röjtökmuzsaj 16.
06. 2006. This Myxomycetes is belonging in the order Physarales, where
calcium carbonate is present in the peridium or in the capillitium or in both.
The main mark of the family Badhamia is the three-dimensional capillitium
formed by chalky tubes. The sporangia of Badhamia foliicola are sessile,
purplish-grey. The peridium is poor in chalk. Spores are loosely aggregate.
Up to 20 spores are in a bunch.
Badhamia foliicola is saprophyte and common on grasses. The stem of the
rape was used in order to spread the spores further.
This slime mould is relatively rare in Hungary. There are six specimens in
the collection of the Hungarian Natural History Museum.
Acknowledgments
I would like to express my special thanks to Holger Müller for identification
Badhamia foliicola. Thanks for the aid of Kálmán Vánky and Ágnes Révay.
References
Bánhegyi, J.; Tóth, S.; Ubrizsy, G.; Vörös, J. (1985): Magyarország
mikroszkópikus gombáinak határozókönyve. Akadémiai Kiadó.
Budapest
Schleimpilze-Myxomyceten. http://www.nivicol.de/
50
THE ANTHRACNOSIS DISEASE OF THE TIGHT LEAF
LUPIN (LUPINUS ANGUSTIFOLIUS L.)
István Lenti1 – Ferenc Borbély2 – Sándor Vágvölgyi1
1
Nyíregyháza College, Technical and Agricultural Faculty, Nyíregyháza,
Hungary
2
Research Center of Debrecen University, Nyíregyháza, Hungary
In connection with the lupin (Lupinus L.) species (Lupinus albus, L. luteus,
L. angustifolius, L. mutabilis) which are grown in Hungary or used for plant
improvement, we have experienced a previously unknown disease since
2004, namely the anthracnose. The extent of damage caused is different for
each species, the biggest loss was experienced with regard to the white and
yellow flowered sweet lupins that are also grown on an industrial basis. To
provide a precise definition about the extent of the damage, further
observations are essential.
The tight leaf or blue flowered lupin species are – as far as we are concerned
– only infected by the Colletotrichum gloeosporioides.
To decrease the impact of this agent – on the basis of our fungicidesensitivity surveys – captan, mankoceb, copper(I)oxid as the most suitable
as well as the combinations of these with benomyl or methyl-tyophanate.
Our open-air small-parcelled experiments are to be settled according to this.
Effective protection is impeded by the fact that this pesticide also affects the
inside part of the seed in the case of the lupin species examined. Seed
pelleting is only able to provide a partial protection, which means that stock
treatments are assumed to have an important role in the future in the plant
protection of this species.
In relation to heat demand, the causative fungus agent belongs to the warm
demanding species. If the humidity and the temperature is high enough –
considered as an ecological condition – that may nourish the fungicid
infection of this lupin species, which migh be ”epidemic” as well.
51
IN VITRO ANTIFUNGAL ACTIVITY OF ESSENTIAL
OILS ON PATHOGENS
*Marietta Petróczy1 −*Géza Nagy1* −Rudolf Bánátfy2 −László
Palkovics1†
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Department of Plant Pathology
2
Aromax Inc. Budapest, Hungary
Applying conventional pesticides in plant protection means significant risk
to the environment and the human health. For this reason the permission of
several pesticides has been cancelled. Nowadays the demand of the use of
plant protection products containing natural agents e.g. plant extracts is
increasing. The possibility of applying essential oils against pests has got
into the focus of interest in the past decade.
In the literature several data can be found about the effect of essential oils
on plant pathogens. Among medicinal plants cultivated in Hungary as well,
the essential oils extracted from peppermint, thyme, sweet basil, coriander,
oregano, lavender, sage among others had fungistatic or fungicide effect
against Botrytis sp., Fusarium spp., Monilinia spp. and Sclerotinia sp.
(Arras and Picci, 1984; Shimoni et al, 1993; Caccioni and Guizzardi, 1994;
Pattnaik et al, 1996; Moretti et al, 1998; Edris and Farrag, 2003; Pankaj
Sharma et al, 2003; Plotto et al, 2003). However investigations were usually
carried out only in vitro and plant protection products against pathogens
have not been developed.
In Hungary very little knowledge is available about the effects of essential
oils on plant pathogens. Only a few researchers deal with the investigation
of this field.
Our main objective was to investigate 28 essential oils against Botrytis
cinerea, Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. cyclaminis, Monilinia fructigena, M.
laxa and Sclerotinia scerotiorum. As a first step in vitro screening was
made. The effective oils will be tested in vivo in laboratory and small scale
experiments on living plants or plant parts.
On the bases of our preliminary results the development of plant protection
products containing essential oils is perspective.
*
†
M. P. and G. N. equally contributed to this work
Corresponding author: L. P. laszlo.palkovics@uni-corvinus.hu
52
Materials and Methods
For testing the effect of essential oils five pathogens were chosen: Botrytis
cinerea, Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cyclaminis, Monilinia laxa, Monilinia
fructigena, and Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. During the research 28 essential
oils of medicinal and aromatic plants were investigated. For comparison
commercial fungicides were involved in practical dosage [Botrytis cinerea
and Sclerotinia sclerotiorum –Rovral 25 FW (0.3%), Fusarium oxysporum
f. sp. cyclaminis –Fundazol 50 WP (0.2%), Monilinia species –Chorus 75
WG (0.03%)].
Monilinia laxa and Monilinia fructigena were isolated from peach fruits,
Sclerotinia sclerotiorum from sunflower stems. Botrytis cinerea was
isolated from strawberry fruits and Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cyclaminis
from cyclamen roots. Pathogens were cultivated on Leonian malt agar
(LMA) and Potato dextrose agar (PDA) at 24ºC in the dark. Pathogenicity
of the isolates was confirmed by back inoculation.
The antifungal activity of the oils was compared on the basis of the
inhibition of the growth of mycelia and of the germination of conidia. The
inhibition of mycelial growth was tested by agar diffusion hole test and agar
dilution technique using different oil concentrations. In the first case three –
11 mm diameter – holes were bored into agar plates. 100μl essential oil was
placed into each hole. Petri-dishes were incubated in thermostat at 24ºC for
48 hours for the diffusion of the oils. For the agar dilution tests essential oils
in different doses – 1%, 0.5%, 0.1%, 0.05%, 0.01% - were metered to hand
warm PDA culture media. Then small agar disc – originated from 4-7 days
old pure culture of the pathogen – was placed into the centre of agar plates.
Petri-dishes were closed with parafilm, and put into thermostat. Evaluation
was carried out when the pathogens overgrew the control agar plates. The
growth of mycelia on treated plates was compared with that of the control.
The inhibition of the germination of conidia was examined in micro titration
plates.
Oil suspensions were placed into the wells in 1%, 0.5%, 0.1% and 0.05%.
To achieve better solubility Tween 20 (0.001%) was added. Suspension of
conidia was obtained from the pure culture of the pathogens. Microtitration
plates were incubated in thermostat at 24ºC for 24-36 hours. For the
evaluation of the efficiency of the oils the ratio of the germinated conidia
was counted and the length of germ tubes was measured at 100-100 conidia
by microscope. Result was compared with that of the untreated, and the
fungicides control.
Antifungal activity was expressed estimating the EC50 and EC90 (Effective
Concentrate) values in each experiments.
53
Results and Discussion
Inhibition of the growth of mycelia:
During the agar diffusion hole test almost all the oils in 1% concentration
caused total inhibition of the growth of the mycelia of all tested pathogens.
Thus this technique was not proved to be suitable for comparative study.
In case of agar dilution method great differences could be observed among
essential oils in effectiveness at the different concentrations (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Mycelial growth of Monilia fructigena on agar plates containing
0.1% of different essential oils (A=2, B=6, C=5, D=13).
Against Botrytis cinerea the 16, 21 and 27 oils against Fusarium oxysporum
f. sp. cyclaminis the 16, 21 and 23, against Sclerotinia sclerotiorum only the
27 oils gave remarkable inhibition of mycelial growth. The oils listed above
resulted an EC50 value less than 0.01%. However none of the oils gave total
inhibition in case of these pathogens. EC90 value ranged between 0.05 and
0.01%. In the case of Monilinia fructigena the growth of mycelia was
absolutely inhibited even in the lowest tested concentration by the following
essential oils: 2, 16, 21 and 23. (Figure 2). High inhibition level was
observed also at 7, 22 and 27 essential oils. All essential oils listed above
abolished the growth of mycelia of Monilinia laxa (Figure 3).
54
growth index
100,0%
90,0%
80,0%
70,0%
60,0%
50,0%
40,0%
essential oil
concentration
30,0%
20,0%
10,0%
0,0%
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11 12
13 14
15 16 17
18 19
20 21
22 23
24
0,01%
0,05
%
0,10%
0,50
%
1%
essential oils
25
26
27
28
Figure 2. Effects of essential oils on mycelial growth of Monilia fructigena.
growth index
90,0%
80,0%
70,0%
60,0%
50,0%
40,0%
30,0%
essential oil
concentration
20,0%
10,0%
0,0%
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11 12
13 14
15 16
17 18
19 20
21 22
23 24
0,01
%
0,05%
0,10
%
0,50
%
1%
essential oils
25
26
27
28
Figure 3. Effects of essential oils on mycelial growth of Monilia laxa.
55
germination index
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
essential oil
concentration
30%
20%
10%
0%
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11 12
13 14 15
16 17
18 19
20 21
22
essential oils
0,05
%
0, 1%
0,5%
23
24
1%
25
26
27
28
Figure 4. Effects of essential oils on conidial germination of Monilinia laxa
germination index
100,0%
90,0%
80,0%
70,0%
60,0%
50,0%
40,0%
essential oil
concentration
30,0%
20,0%
10,0%
0,0%
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11
12 13 14
15 16
17 18
19 20
21 22
essential oils
0,05
%
0, 1%
0,5%
23
24
1%
25
26
27
28
Figure 5. Effects of essential oils on conidial germination of Monilinia
fructigena
56
EC50 value was below 0.01% at
- Monilinia laxa: 2, 3, 7, 9, 11, 16, 21, 22, 23 and 27.
- Monilinia fructigena: 2, 3, 7, 8, 9, 11, 16, 18, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 and
27.
EC90 value was below 0.01% at
- Monilinia laxa: 2, 3, 7, 11, 16, 21, 22, 23 and 27.
- Monilinia fructigena: 2, 3, 7, 16, 18, 21, 22, 23 and 27.
Inhibition of conidial germination:
With the increasing of the concentration of the essential oils the number of
germinated conidia of Botrytis cinerea in most cases proportionally
decreased. In the higher concentrations the rate of conidia with short germ
tubes increased. In the case of Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cyclaminis
connection between the increasing oil concentrations and the germination
rate of the conidia was not consequent in many cases. Against Botrytis
cinerea nine oils (2, 7, 10, 11, 16, 21, 22, 27, 28), against Fusarium
oxysporum f.sp. cyclaminis five oils (16, 21, 24, 26, 27) resulted an EC50
value less than 0.05% concentration. The most effective oils were the 7, 16,
22 and 27 against Botrytis cinerea and the 16, 21 and 27 against Fusarium
oxysporum f. sp. cyclaminis. EC90 values were less than 0.05%
concentrations.
The germination of conidia of Monilinia laxa and Monilinia fructigena was
inhibited by almost all tested essential oils at 1% (except 1 and 22).
Remarkable differences were observed at further tested concentrations.
Total inhibition of the germination of Monilinia laxa conidia could be
noticed at 3, 16, 20 and 27 essential oils at the lowest concentration as well.
The 1, 2, 4, 6 and 25 oils resulted heavy inhibition (Figure 4).
Germination of Monilinia fructigena conidia was completely inhibited by
10, 16, 27 and 28 essential oils and there was strong inhibition at the 4, 7
and 21 oils (Figure 5).
EC50 value was below 0.05% at
- Monilinia laxa: 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 16, 20, 21, 25 and 27.
- Monilinia fructigena: 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, 16, 20, 21, 27 and 28.
EC90 value was below 0.05% at
- Monilinia laxa: 1, 3, 4, 6, 16, 20, 25 and 27.
- Monilinia fructigena: 4, 7, 10, 16, 21, 27 and 28.
The obtained results by the two experimental methods were similar. In the
case of Botrytis cinerea, Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cyclaminis and
Sclerotinia sclerotiorum the 16, 21 and 27 essential oils inhibited the most
the growth of mycelia and the germination of conidia.
57
The mycelial growth of Monilinia species was effectively inhibited by 2, 3,
7, 16, 21, 22, 23 and 27 oils. The germination of conidia was suppressed by
4, 16 and 27 oils in the highest extent.
On the bases of the results these oils are selected for further in vivo
experiments.
References
Arras, G. and Picci, V. (1984): Attivita fungistatica di alcuni olii essenziali
nei confronti dei principali agenti di alterazioni post-raccolta dei frutti
di agrumi – Rivista della Ortoflorofrutticoltura Italiana. 68(5): 361-366.
Caccioni, D.R.L. and Guizzardi, M. (1994): Inhibition of germination and
growth of fruit and vegetable postharvest pathogenic fungi by essential
oil components – Journal of Essential Oil Research 6(2): 173-179.
Edris, A.E. and Farrag, E.S. (2003): Antifungal activity of peppermint and
sweet basil essential oils and their major aroma constituents on some
plant pathogenic fungi from the vapor phase - Nahrung 47(2): 117-121.
Moretti, M.D.L., Peana, A.T., Franceschini, A. and Carta, C. (1998): In vivo
activity of Salvia officinalis oil against Botrytis cinerea – Journal of
Essential Oil Research 10(2): 157-160.
Sharma, P., Singh, S.D. and Rawal, P. (2003): Antifungal activity of some
plant extracts and oils against seed-borne pathogens of pea – Plant
Disease Research Ludhiana 18(1): 16-20.
Pattnaik, S., Subramanyam, V.R. and Kole, C. (1996): Antibacterial and
antifungal activity of ten essential oils in vitro - Microbios. 86: 237-246
Plotto, A., Roberts, D.D. and Roberts, R.G. (2003): Evaluation of plant
essential oils as natural postharvest disease control of tomato
(Lycopersicon esculentum) – Acta Horticulturae 628(2): 737-745.
Shimoni, M., Reuveni, R. and Ravid, U. (1993): Growth inhibition of plant
pathogenic fungi by essential oils - Hassadeh 74(3): 306-308.
58
IN VITRO ANTIFUNGAL ACTIVITY OF ESSENTIAL OILS ON
PATHOGENS
*Marietta Petróczy1 −*Géza Nagy1−Rudolf Bánátfy2 −László Palkovics1
1
Department of Plant Pathology, Corvinus University of Budapest,
2
Aromax, Inc. Budapest, Hungary
Summary
Twentyfour essential oils extracted from mediterranean, tropical and continental plant
species were tested for their effectiveness against 5 pathogens: Botrytis cinerea, Fusarium
oxysporum f. sp. cyclaminis, Monilia fructigena, M. laxa and Sclerotinia sclerotiorum.
Conventional fungicides were also involved as controls.
The antifungal activity of the oils was compared on the basis of the inhibition of the growth
of mycelia and of the germination of conidia. The inhibition of mycelial growth was tested
by agar diffusion hole test and agar dilution technique using different oil concentrations.
The inhibition of the germination of conidia was examined in micro titration plates.
Antifungal activity was expressed estimating the EC50 and EC90 (Effective Concentrate)
values. In reference all the 5 tested pathogens an excellent in vitro antifungal activity could
be observed in case of essential oils numbered 16, 21 and 27.
59
DOMINANCE OF THE BARLEY YELLOW DWARF
VIRUSES IN WINTER BARLEY BREEDING
MATERIALS OF KOMPOLT‡
Emil Pocsai1 - István Murányi2 - Tibor Horti2
1
Plant Protection and Soil Conservation Service of Fejér County, Velence,
Hungary
2
Rudolf Fleischmann Research Institute of the Róbert Károly College,
Kompolt, Hungary
Barley yellow dwarf viruses (BYDVs) are the most widely distributed and
the most economically important virus pathogens of cereal crops. BYDVs
are not mechanically transmissible, nor through the seeds, but are
transmitted by aphids as a persistent, circulative but non-propagative
manner. Aphids acquire and transmit BYDVs while feeding on the phloem
sieve tube elements of host plants.
BYDVs are restricted to the Poaceae (Gramineae). Cultivated hosts include
all the major cereal crops: barley, maize, oat, rice, rye and wheat, as well as
many annual and perennial cultivated and wild grasses. Symptoms caused
by BYDVs differ with the host species and cultivar, the age and the
physiological condition of the host plant at the time of infection, the strain
and the environmental conditions; and they can be easily confused with
nutritional and abiotic disorders.
In barley, the first symptoms are a diffuse or blotchy yellowing near the leaf
tip, bright yellow discoloration then extends towards the leaf base leaving a
strip of green along the side of the midrib. Plants are usually stunted, with a
decrease in tiller number and biomass and a weak root system. Suppressed
heading, sterility and failure to fill grains occur in the most severe cases. In
the field, symptoms usually appear as yellow patches of stunted plants.
Plants infected at the seedling stage suffer the most severe disease and may
die without flowering. Generally, the older the plant at the time of infection
less damaged by the disease. Susceptibility of plants and disease severity on
the great variety of cereal cultivars available today differ considerably.
Several strains or serotypes of BYDV have been differentiated on the basis
of vector specificity, the efficiency of transmission by aphids, serological
and molecular biological properties.
‡
This work was supported by the National Committee for Technological
Development (OMFB) and the Agency for Research Fund Manegement and
Research Exploitation (KPI).
60
Rochow (1969) differentiated four strains of BYDV by their relative vector
specificity in transmission to the oat, variety Coast Black and in virulence
on the host plant.
These strains were named relating to their predominant aphid vectors. One
strain (RPV) was specifically transmitted by Rhopalosiphum padi, the
second strain (MAV) specifically by Macrosiphum avenae and the third
strain (RMV) specifically by Rhopalosiphum maidis. The fourth strain
(PAV) was transmitted non-specifically by both Rhopalosiphum padi and
Macrosiphum avenae.
Two strains (RPV and RMV) were found to be weakly virulent, the MAV
strain was moderately virulent and the PAV strain was strongly virulent on
the oat variety Coast Black.
Gill (1969) described a fifth strain of BYDV in Manitoba, which was
specifically transmitted by Schizaphis graminum. This vector-specific strain
was weakly virulent on the oat variety Clintland 64.
The five known BYDV strains were differentiated based on the apparent
specificity of aphid transmission of each strain.
Lister and Rochow (1979) reported that the development of the enzymelinked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for BYDV eliminated the need for the
aphid transmission test for the detection of BYDV strains. Because of their
specificity, these assays quickly became a valuable tool for comparing and
classifying BYDV strains.
Rochow (1979,1982) compared the results of the aphid transmission test
with those obtained using ELISA. In comparison with the aphid
transmission test, the ELISA was more sensitive and took less time. The
ELISA was especially simplier for the diagnosis of mixed infection with the
BYDV strains.
There are many reports concerning the occurrence and strain dominance of
BYDV in cereals around the world. In North America, a cereal disease
characterised by yellowing, stunting and decreased yields was observed,
sometimes in epidemic proportions.
Widespread outbreaks with significant yield losses that were probably
caused by BYDV occurred in 1907 and 1949. Therefore, research on the
epidemiology of BYDV was begun on this continent.
There are many reports concerning the strain incidence and dominance of
BYDV strains in different cereal species in the United States.
Gildow et al.(1987) found that 82 % of the 300 plants testing positive for
BYDV contained the PAV strain alone or in mixed infection, compared
with 19 % for RPV, 9 % for MAV and 4 % for RMV strains. No SGV
strains were identified in Pennsylvania during 1984-1986.
In Illinois, Azzam and D’Argy (1989) reported that PAV was the prevailing
strain, with the RPV and MAV strains occurring at low frequency.
61
In Idaho, Foster et al.(1990) reported that the SGV strain appeared to play a
significant role in BYDV epidemiology during 1977 and 1985.
Hewings and Eastman (1995) reported that surveys on the incidence of
BYDV strains throughout North America suggested that PAV was the
dominant strain in most areas but that the incidence of the strain alone and
in mixed infections differed from region to region and year to year. In areas
where the PAV strain usually dominated, other strains occurred occasionally
in epidemic proportions.
It sould be mentioned that BYDV was first identified in Europe, in the
Netherlands by Oswald (1951), and was confirmed in the U.K. (Watson and
Mulligan, 1957).
Plumb (1977) and Holmes (1985) also stated that the PAV, RPV and MAV
strains could be found very often in perennial grasses. The strains are
subsequently transmitted to cereals are often determined by the prevalence
and feeding preference of the main aphid vectors rather than the availability
of virus strains.
The first report on the occurrence of BYDV in winter barley in Hungary
was made more than 40 years ago by Szirmai (1967). It was based on visual
observations and confirmed by aphid transmission tests. In 1982 a very
severe epidemic occurred in the Hungarian barley growing areas, with yield
losses caused by BYDV ranging from 27 to 100 % in the different barley
varieties (Pocsai and Kobza,1983).
Systematic work on the frequency of BYDV strains in cereals in Hungary
has been in progress since 1994.
Pocsai et al. (1995) reported that all the five BYDV strains were present in
Hungary. They demonstrated that, among the BYDV strains, the PAV strain
was dominant in cereals. In maize both RPV and RMV were present at high
rates.
Pocsai et al. (1996, 1997) found that BYDV-RMV was the dominant virus
identified in breeding materials of winter barley at Kompolt both in 1995
and 1996.
Pocsai et al.(2001) tested the yearly variation of the dominance BYDVs at
different locations of Hungary. Between 1996 and 2000 the virus dominance
in winter barley changed from year to year at Kompolt. In 1996 and 1997
BYDV-RMV was the most prevalent. In 1998 the BYDV-PAV occurred at
the highest rate. In 1999 the BYDV-MAV was present at the highest rate,
while BYDV-MAV was dominant virus in 2000.
The BYDV strains have been separated into two major subgroups based on
serological relationships, cytological effects and genome organisation. The
first subgroup includes the BYDV-MAV, BYDV-PAV and BYDV-SGV
strains. The second subgroup includes the BYDV-RPV, BYDV-RMV and
BYDV-RGV strains.
62
The taxonomy of BYDV strains has been modified several times since the
first classification based on vector specificity (Rochow, 1969). This
classification has proved very useful but the aphids on which this
classification was based were not endemic worldwide, thus in some areas
other aphids and strains occurred. It has become obvious that more than one
characteristic should be used to classify BYDV strains.
Pringle (1998) summarized the new taxonomic proposals approved by the
Executive Committee of the International Committee on the Taxonomy of
Viruses which included proposals for the family of Luteoviridae.
Fauquet and Mayo (1999) gave a list of virus names and their abbreviations
and assigned the family and genus to which the given virus belonged.
According to this list, BYDVs consist of five viruses, BYDV-GPV, BYDVMAV, BYDV-PAV, BYDV-RMV and BYDV- SGV, belonging to the
family Luteoviridae. Among these, BYDV-MAV and BYDV-PAV belong
to the genus Luteovirus. The remaining three viruses were classified as
unassigned within the family Luteoviridae. The name of the BYDV-RPV
strain was changed to Cereal yellow dwarf virus (CYDV-RPV) which
belongs to the genus Polerovirus within the family Luteoviridae.
In many countries where BYDV has been studied, efforts have focused on
reducing yield losses, and very little is known about the incidence and
dominance of BYDV strains or the role of particular aphid vector species.
Lack of this information may lead to false conclusions in some geographic
regions.
The aim of our study was to determine the dominance of BYDVs in barley
breeding materials of Kompolt.
Materials and Methods
In 2006, the incidence of Barley yellow dwarf viruses (BYDV-MAV,
BYDV-PAV, BYDV-RMV, BYDV-SGV) was studied in barley breeding
materials of Kompolt. Surveys were carried out in breeding lines showing
leaf yellowing and stunting symptoms. Altogether 490 samples were
collected for virus testing, viz. for determination of virus dominance. The
leaf samples collected were homogenized using a leaf pressing machine
with the addition of ELISA sample buffer solution at a ratio of 1:10. Virus
diagnosis was carried out using DAS-ELISA for the detection of Barley
yellow dwarf viruses (BYDV-MAV, BYDV-PAV, BYDV-SGV) from leaf
samples exhibiting symptoms. The diagnostic materials used for Barley
yellow dwarf viruses viruses (BYDV-MAV, BYDV-PAV, BYDV-SGV)
were made by Agdia and (BYDV-RMV) was a DSMZ (Deutsche
Sammlung von Mikroorganismen und Zellkulturen GmbH) product. The
serological reactions were evaluated using a Labsystems Multiscan Plus
photometer at 405 nm.
63
Results
Incidence of BYDV-MAV, BYDV-PAV, BYDV-RMV and BYDV-SGV in
breeding lines of winter barley collected in 2006 at Kompolt are illustrated
in Table 1.
According to the results of ELISA test, 337 plants of the 490 plants of
winter barley tested were found to be infected with BYDVs. It was found
that 66.7 % of the 337 plants testing positive for BYDVs contained the
BYDV-MAV alone or in mixed infection, compared with 24 % for BYDVPAV, 18.6 % for BYDV-RMV and 19.8 % for BYDV-SGV.
As the data show, BYDV-MAV occurred at the highest ratio in breeding
materials of winter barley.
Only 2 of the 49 breeding lines tested were free from BYDVs. These
breeding lines were K-99/16-5 and K-98/4-30. The infection degree of
BYDVs varied from 10 % to30 % in five breeding materials (K-00/10-13,
Plaisant,KH-03-24-6,K-98/16-28 and K-97/16-28), showing they had high
level of resistance against BYDVs. The majority of the breeding materials
proved to be very susceptable to BYDVs.
A contrasting tendency can be seen between the incidence rates of BYDVMAV and BYDV-PAV in breeding lines of winter barley. With a rise of
incidence in the BYDV-MAV, the proportion of BYDV-PAV decreased,
and vice-versa.
The virus dominance of BYDV is complex and influenced by many biotic
and abiotic factors. The interactions between dominant viruses and vectors
has a significant impact on virus epidemiology.
Several authors have reported some degree of interference competition
between BYDV-MAV and BYDV-PAV in infected post plants (Smith
1963, Jedlinski and Brown 1965, Aapola and Rochow 1971, Halstead and
Gill 1971, Wen et al. 1991). If a host plant acquires BYDV-MAV and
BYDV-PAV at the sama time, BYDV-PAV interferes with BYDV-MAV
replication, leading to lower BYDV-MAV concentration in the phloem.
Because of this lower concentration, there is a lower probability of BYVVMAV being acquired and transmitted by aphids (Gray et al. 1991)
In direct competition within the host plant, BYDV-PAV is the stronger
competitor.
Viruses also compete within aphid vectors. When both BYDV-MAV and
BYDV-PAV are present within aphids, BYDV-MAV inhibits the
transmission of BYDV-PAV. Within vectors, BYDV-MAV appears to be
the more effective competitor.
64
Table 1. Results of ELISA tests of the breeding lines of winter barley
selected from the virus nursery at Kompolt
Plot
numbers
Breeding lines
of winter barley
1
2
6
10
15
16
20
26
28
36
37
47
59
63
65
K-01/80-2
K-01/80-3
KH-03-24-6
K-00/178-9
Plaisant
Botond
K-00/10-10
K-96/80
K-00/186-2
Murcie
K-00/10-13
K-93/154-4/4
K-99/16-5
K-00/189-2
K-92/141-16/3-3
K-99/51
KH-03-24-6
K-92/173-3/2-4
AMÁ-1
K-97/16-2
GK-Puszta
K-00/22-2
K-01/154-3
K-94/166-117
K-01/179-2
K-99/109-3
K-94/166-11/2
Viktor
K-97/16-21
K-98/4-29
K-00/25
K-97/16-22
K-97/16-23
K-98/4-30
K-98/149-12
K-97/16-24
K-98/149-13
K-00/27-2
K-97/16-28
K-00/28-1
K-97/16-30
78
79
83
89
98
106
109
115
122
133
135
139
144
148
150
151
165
166
167
172
183
189
200
202
217
220
Numbers
of
samples
tested
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
BYDVMAV
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
65
Results of virological tests
BYDVBYDVPAV
RMV
BYDV
-SGV
1
7
8
9
2
9
3
8
0
9
0
7
0
0
0
5
2
2
0
1
2
5
9
4
7
1
7
0
4
5
7
0
6
2
0
2
1
0
0
6
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
1
0
2
1
0
0
0
10
1
8
8
0
10
10
5
6
4
7
9
0
0
10
0
9
6
0
0
1
10
6
6
3
4
2
5
7
4
5
5
2
5
7
6
1
9
3
3
0
0
4
1
1
6
1
3
3
0
0
0
3
3
3
2
1
0
3
0
0
5
5
6
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
2
3
2
2
3
0
0
5
4
0
1
0
1
0
8
0
5
1
5
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
3
5
Table 1. (continued)
223
231
232
238
250
256
277
295
K-00/134-8
Catánia
KH-Agria
K-97/16-33
Eszter
K-97/16-39
K-00/150-1
K-00/153-1
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
490
9
6
7
5
2
9
7
7
225
4
3
2
3
4
4
1
0
81
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
63
0
2
2
4
0
4
0
1
67
The relation between aphid vectors and infected host plants may heve also
influenced the decline of BYDV-PAV and the dominance of BYDV-MAV.
Host plant infection results physiological changes in host plants, including
changes in nitrogen metabolism, and aphids respond strongly to plant
nitrogen status. So, aphid population dynamics, host choice behavior could
all be affected by host plant infection.
The explanation for such changes involves a complex interaction between
the different vectors, the host plant for both vector and virus, and the
weather conditions. This study on the dominance of BYDVs in breeding
materials was aimed at a better understanding of the epidemiology of cereal
viruses.
References
Aapola, A.I.E. and Rochow, W.F. (1971): Relationship among three isolates
of barley yellow dwarf virus. Virology 46: 127-141.
Azzam, O.I. and D’Arcy, C.J. (1989): Survey of spring oats for barley yellow
dwarf viruses in Illinois. Plant Dis. 73: 610.
Fauquet, M.C. and Mayo, M.A. (1999): Abbreviations for plant virus names1999. Arch. Virol. 144: 1249-1273.
Foster, R.L, Bishop, G.W. and Sandvol, L.E. (1990): The 1985 barley yellow
dwarf epidemic in winter wheat involving barley yellow dwarf virus
transmitted by Schizaphis graminum and wheat streak mosaic. pp. 266 274. In: World Perspectives on Barley Yellow Dwarf. Burnett, P.A. (Ed.)
CIMMYT, Mexico D.F, Mexico
Gildow, F.E., Frank, J., Bingaman, D. and Powell, C. (1987): Barley yellow
dwarf viruses in small grains of Pennsylvania: isolate identification,
distribution and vector efficiency.-Plant Dis. 71: 922-926.
Gill, C.C. (1969): Annual variation in strains of barley yellow dwarf in
Manitoba, and the occurrence of greenbug-specific isolates. Can. J. Bot.
47: 1277-1283.
66
Gray, S.M., Power, A.G., Smith, D.M., Seaman, A.J. and Altman, N.S. (1991):
Aphid transmission of barley yellow dwarf virus: acquisition access
periods and virus concentration requirements. Phytopathology 81: 539545.
Halstead, B.E. and Gill, C.C. (1971): Effect of inoculation of oats with
paired combinations of barley yellow dwarf virus isolates. Can. J. Bot.
49: 577-581.
Hewings, A.D. and Eastman, C.E. (1995): Epidemiology of barley yellow
dwarf in North America. pp. 75-106. In: Barley yellow dwarf 40 years on
progress. D’Arcy, C.J. and Burnett, P.S. (Eds.) APS Press, St. Paul,
Minnesota
Holmes, S.J.I. (1985): Barley yellow dwarf virus in ryegrass and its detection by
ELISA. Plant Pathol. 34: 214-220.
Jedlinski, H. and Brown, C.H. (1965): Cross protection and mutual exclusion
by three strains of barley yellow dwarf virus in Avena sativa L. Virology
26: 613–621.
Lister, R.M. and Rochow, W.F. (1979): Detection of barley yellow dwarf virus
by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Phytopath. 69: 649-654.
Oswald, J.W. and Houston, B.R. (1951): A new virus disease of cereals,
transmissible by aphids. Plant Dis. Reptr. 35: 471-475.
Plumb, R.T (1977): Grass as a reservoir of cereal viruses. Ann. Phytopathol. 9:
361-364.
Pocsai, E. and Kobza, S. (1983): Epidemiological occurrence of barley yellow
dwarf virus in Hungary. P. Int. Conf. Integr. Plant Prot. Budapest, 4-9.
July 1, 50-57.
Pocsai, E., Kovács, G., Murányi, I., Orosz, M., Papp, M. and Szunics, L.
(1995): Differentiation of barley yellow dwarf luteovirus serotypes
infecting cereals and maize in Hungary. Agronomie 15: 401-408.
Pocsai E., Hadi G., Kovács Gy. és Murányi I. (1996): Az árpa sárga
törpeség luteovírus törzsek dominancia viszonyainak alakulása
árpában és kukoricában. Növényvédelmi Tudományos Napok.
Budapest, 1996. február 27-28. 129. (in Hungarian)
Pocsai E., Kovács Gy., Murányi I., Papp M. és Szunics L. (1997): Az árpa
sárga törpeség Luteovirus törzsek dominancia viszonyainak vizsgálata
gabonafélékben és kukoricában az ország különböző tájegységein.
Növényvédelmi Tudományos Napok ’97. Budapest 1997. 02. 24-25.
119. (in Hungarian)
Pocsai E., Szunics L., Vida Gy. Murányi I., Fónad, P., Papp M. és
Tomcsányi, A. (2000): Az árpa sárga törpeség Luteovirus törzsek
dominancia viszonyainak évenkénti változása. Növényvédelmi
Tudományos Napok 2000. Budapest, 2000. február 22-23. 116. (in
Hungarian)
67
Pocsai, E. (2001): The yearly variation of the dominance of Barley yellow
dwarf virus strains. Abstr. IXth Conference on Virus Diseases of
Gramineae in Europe, York, UK, 21-23 May, 2001.
Pringle, C.R. (1998): Virus taxonomy. Arch. Virol. San Diego 143: 1449-1459.
Rochow, W.F (1969): Biological properties of four isolates of barley yellow
dwarf virus. Phytopathology 59: 1580-1589.
Rochow, W.F (1979): Field variants of barley yellow virus: detection and
fluctuation during twenty years. Phytopathology 69: 655-660.
Rochow, W.F (1982): Identification of barley yellow dwarf viruses:
Comparison of biological and serological methods. Plant Dis. Reptr. 66:
381-384.
Smith, H.C.(1963): Interaction between isolates of barley yellow dwarf virus.
New Zealand Journal of Agric. Res. 6: 343-353.
Szirmai J. (1967): Új vírusbetegség gabonaföldjeinken: A sárga törpeség.
Magyar Mezőgazdaság 22, 19. (in Hungarian)
Watson, M.A. and Mulligan, T.E. (1957): Cereal yellow dwarf virus in Great
Britain. Plant Pathol. 6: 12-14.
Wen, F., Lister, R.M. and Fattouh, F.A. (1991): Cross-protection among
strains of barley yellow dwarf virus. Journal of General Virology 72:
791-799.
68
DOMINANCE OF THE BARLEY YELLOW DWARF VIRUSES IN
WINTER BARLEY BREEDING MATERIALS OF KOMPOLT
E. Pocsai1, I. Murányi2 and T. Horti2
1
2
Plant Protection and Soil Conservation Service of Fejér County, Velence, Hungary
Rudolf Fleischmann Research Institute of the Róbert Károly College, Kompolt, Hungary
Summary
In 2006, the incidence of Barley yellow dwarf viruses (BYDV-MAV,BYDV-PAV, BYDVRMV, BYDV-SGV) were studied in breeding materials of winter barley of Kompolt for the
determination of virus dominance. Surveys were carried out in breeding lines sown in virus
nursey showing leaf yellowing and stunting symptoms at Kompolt
Altogether 490 samples were collected for virus testing. Virus diagnosis was carried out
using DAS-ELISA for the detection of Barley yellow dwarf viruses (BYDV-MAV, BYDVPAV, BYDV-SGV) from leaf samples exhibiting symptoms. The diagnostic materials were
made by Agdia and (BYDV-RMV), a DSMZ (Deutsche Sammlung von Mikroorganismen
und Zellkulturen GmbH), respectively. The serological reactions were evaluated using a
Labsystems Multiskan Plus photometer at 405 nm.
According to the results of ELISA test, 337 plants of the 490 plants of winter barley tested
were found to be infected with BYDVs. It was found that 66.7 % of the 337 plants testing
positive for BYDVs contained the BYDV-MAV alone or in mixed infection, compared
with 24 % for BYDV-PAV, 18.6 % for BYDV-RMV and 19.8 % for BYDV-SGV. As the
data show, BYDV-MAV was the dominant virus in breeding materials of winter barley of
Kompolt.This study on the dominance of BYDVs in breeding materials was aimed at a
better understanding of the epidemiology of cereal viruses.
69
ANALYSIS OF SOME RECOMBINANT PLUM POX
VIRUS (PPV) ISOLATES FROM BULGARIA, THE
COUNTRY WHERE PPV WAS FIRST RECORDED
Erzsébet Szathmáry1 –István Tóbiás 2 –László Palkovics 1*
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural Science,
Department of Plant Pathology, Budapest, Hungary
2
Plant Protection Institute of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest,
Hungary
Plum pox virus (PPV), the casual agent of the Sharka disease, is the most
important viral pathogen of Prunus trees and poses a serious threat to stone
fruit plantations (Németh, 1986). The disease was first described in Bulgaria
(Atanasoff, 1932), since than PPV has spread throughout Europe (Roy and
Smith, 1994) and nowadays it presents all over the world except Australia
(Wetzel et al., 1991; Acuña, 1993; Thakur et al., 1994; Milius, 1999;
Damsteegt et al., 2001; Thomson et al., 2001).
PPV is a member of the Potyvirus genus within the Potyviridae family. It
has a single-stranded positive-sense genomic RNA of about 10,000
nucleotides with a single open reading frame encoding a polyprotein from
which 10 functional proteins are released (Riechmann et al., 1992).
Analysis of a large number of PPV isolates has permitted the identification
of three major (PPV-M, PPV-D, PPV-Rec) and two minor (PPV-EA, PPVC) PPV subgroups to date (Nemchinov et al., 1996; Wetzel et al., 1991;
Candresse et al., 1994; Glasa et al., 2004; Szemes et al., 2001). An unusual
PPV isolate reported from Canada (James et al., 2003) may present a third
distinct minor subgroup (PPV-W).
PPV-Rec subgroup corresponds to an ensemble of closely related isolates
characterized by a homologous ancestral recombination event between
PPV-M and PPV-D with a recombination break point located in the 3’ part
of the NIb gene, similar to that initially reported for the PPV-o6 isolate
(Cervera et al., 1993).
In order to achieve data about PPV subgroups of Troyan region, Bulgaria,
samples were taken from naturally infected plum (Prunus domestica L.)
trees.
Materials and Methods
PPV isolates were collected from different plum varieties showing the same
type of symptoms in the experimental field of the Research Institute of
Mountain Stockbreeding and Agriculture, Troyan, Bulgaria in 2004. The
70
isolates were sap-transmitted to Nicotiana clevelandii and N. benthamiana
indicator plants and investigated in this study.
Total nucleic acid (TNA) was extracted from two small leaf discs of
infected N. benthamiana test plants by the method of White and Kaper
(1989). cDNA was synthesized by reverse transcription (RT) of TNA using
M-MuLV reverse transcriptase and universal primer PolyT2. PCR
amplification was performed using Taq DNA polymerase and a Potyvirus
specific oligonucleotid primer-pair Poty7941 [5’-GGAATTCCCGCGG
(AGCT)AA(CT)AA(CT)AG(CT)GG(AGCT)CA(AG)CC-3’, sense primer,
contained a SacII restriction site (marked in bold)] and PolyT [5’-CGGGG
ATCCTCGAGAAGCTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT-3’,
antisense
primer
(Deborré et al., 1995), contained a BamHI site (marked in bold)] to amplify
the 3’ end of the nuclear inclusion b (NIb) gene, the whole coat protein (CP)
gene and the 3’ untranslated region (UTR) starts at the polyA tail of the
virus. The following conditions were used for the PCR: initial denaturation
at 94 ºC for 3 minutes, 40 cycles of 94 ºC for 15 s, 50 ºC for 30 s and 72 ºC
for 3 min and a final extension at 72 ºC for 10 min. The purified PCR
products were digested with SacII and BamHI restriction endonucleases and
the resulting fragments were inserted into plasmid pBluescript SK+
(Stratagene) digested with the same enzymes and were transformed into
Escherichia coli DH5α competent cells. The recombinant plasmids were
sequenced using by an automated DNA sequencer (Applied Biosystem
Gene Analyzer 3100). The partial genomic sequences were finally
assembled from the overlapping sequences of the cDNAs and sequence
analysis was carried out. Sequence comparisons were performed using the
GAP program of the Wisconsin Package Version 10.0 Genetic Computer
Group (GCG), Madison, Wisc. sequence analysis software. The alignment
achieved by GAP program was used as input data to construct phylogenetic
tree with the neighbour-joining distance method implemented in CLUSTAL
W. The tree was visualized using the program DRAWTREE.
Results and discussion
Six PPV isolates collected from different plum varieties showed typical
symptoms of PPV infection: chlorotic spots and/or rings on the leaves. Five
isolates out of six could be sap transmitted to test plants and were
investigated in this study (see Table 1.).
71
Table 1. PPV subgroup of isolates investigated in this study and accession
numbers of the partial sequences determined.
Isolate
Origin
Subgroup GenBank
accession
numbers
PPV-Troy1 P. domestica cv. Chachanska PPV-Rec
AM260933
rodna
PPV-Troy2 P. domestica cv. Stanley
PPV-D
AM260934
PPV-Troy4
P. domestica cv. Kjustendilska
PPV-Rec
AM260935
PPV-Troy5
P. domestica cv. Gabrovska
PPV-Rec
AM260936
PPV-Troy6
P. domestica cv. Hanita
PPV-Rec
AM260937
The (Cter)NIb–CP–3’UTR region of all isolates were amplified by RTPCR. The PCR products were cloned and sequenced.
The coat proteins (CPs) of all isolates were identical in size (330 aa residues
long) and the DAG motif associated with aphid transmission (Atreya et al.,
1995) was found in all sequences.
Amino acid sequence comparisons were done among each Bulgarian isolate.
The highest level of similarity was found between Troy4–Troy6 and Troy4–
Troy5. Significant homology was found also between Troy4–Troy1 and
Troy5–Troy6 isolates, while the lowest percent of similarity was found
between Troy2 and the other four isolates (see Table 2.).
Table 2. Percentage of nucleic acid sequence homology (above the
diagonal) and amino acid sequence homology (below the diagonal) of CP of
some PPV isolates.
PA
PA
Ran
SK68
PS
Pd4
BOR-3
Troy1
Troy2
Troy4
Troy5
Troy6
SoC
W
El-Amar
Ran
SK68
PS
Pd4
SoC
W
98.79
87.17
86.97
86.67
86.77
85.76
99.60
86.47
86.26
86.97
80.12
78.01
80.61
87.58
87.37
87.07
87.17
86.16
98.79
86.87
86.67
87.37
80.33
78.62
80.61
98.18
98.28
BOR-3 Troy1 Troy2 Troy4 Troy5 Troy6
91.82
92.73
92.12
93.03
99.39
92.12
93.03
97.88
97.88
91.82
92.73
97.88
97.88
99.09
89.70
90.60
95.76
95.76
96.97
97.27
99.09
98.49
92.42
92.73
92.73
92.42
90.30
91.52
92.42
97.58
97.58
98.79
99.09
97.58
92.12
90.60
91.52
96.67
96.67
97.88
98.18
96.67
91.21
98.49
92.12
93.03
97.58
97.58
98.79
99.09
96.97
92.73
98.79
97.88
85.02
85.63
87.46
87.77
87.16
87.16
84.50
85.63
87.16
87.08
87.46
85.93
85.37
86.89
86.59
85.71
85.71
85.67
86.85
85.71
84.80
85.71
83.69
86.02
86.63
87.27
87.88
87.27
87.88
86.36
86.63
87.58
86.67
86.97
82.48
El-Amar
96.87
96.77
95.68
87.27
96.36
96.36
96.77
80.65
78.62
82.32
96.36
96.26
95.25
87.07
95.96
95.96
96.36
80.04
78.42
82.02
98.18
86.97
98.99
98.99
98.89
80.14
78.22
82.32
98.08
87.07
98.89
98.89
98.99
80.24
78.42
82.53
86.06
97.98
97.98
97.68
79.53
77.81
81.41
86.77
86.57
87.27
80.43
78.12
80.81
98.49
79.74
78.12
82.02
98.49
79.74
78.01
82.02
80.45
78.32
80.63
80.97
76.03
99.49
99.19
79.05
85.76
Most of the differences in the CPs of these five isolates were located in the
amino terminal part of the CP. The core and C-terminal regions of all
isolates were highly homologous.
The amino acid sequences of these Bulgarian PPV isolates were compared
with amino acid sequences of other characterized PPV sequences available
72
from the GenBank database (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) presented in
Table 2. Four isolates, Troy1, Troy4, Troy5 and Troy6 were most similar to
BOR-3 (Glasa et al., 2004) (a representative member of PPV-Rec
subgroup), while Troy2 was almost identical to PA isolate (a representative
member of PPV-D subgroup). This result is in good agreement with the
phylogenetic analysis performed using the nucleotide sequence data of the
(Cter)NIb–CP regions. The phylogenetic tree clearly showed the clustering
of Troy1, Troy4, Troy5 and Troy6 isolates with other previously
characterized recombinant isolates, while Troy2 clustered with PPV-D
isolates (see Figure 1).
The nucleotide sequences reported in this work have been deposited in the
GenBank database and assigned the accession numbers: AM260933,
AM260934, AM260935, AM260936, AM260937.
The accurate identification of isolate subgroups is among the first steps in
the development of effective disease-control strategies. Formerly the vast
majority of the identified PPV isolates was assigned to either one of two
major subgroups, PPV-M and PPV-D (Bousalem et al., 1994). Recently a
number of recombinant PPV isolates have been detected in several
European countries and therefore a third major subgroup, PPV-Rec has been
determined (Glasa et al., 2004).
In this study, analysis of a limited number of Bulgarian PPV isolates
showed that with the exception of the Troy2 identified as belonging to PPVD, all other isolates could be classified as belonging to the PPV-Rec
subgroup on the basis of amino acid sequence homologies and the presence
of conserved amino acids in the CPs. Despite the fact that a relatively small
number of isolates were tested this is in good agreement with the results of
Kamenova et al. (2001) that PPV-D isolates are relatively rare (around 5 %)
in Bulgaria, while be in contrast with the observation that PPV-M is the
dominant strain (incidence of 88 %), however PPV-Rec subgroup is a
special branch in PPV-M subgroup. The CP of PPV-Rec isolates
corresponds to PPV-M due to the recombination point is upstream of the CP
in the NIb gene (Glasa et al., 2004).
It is mentionable that out of the five amino acids (K4, I38, T42, I58, T68) that
are specifically conserved in all recombinant sequences characterized to
date – except Pd4 isolate, which has A68 – in the 3’ end of the CP (Glasa et
al., 2004; Salamon and Palkovics, 2002) all could be found in Troy1, Troy4
and Troy5, while in the CP of Troy6 there was valine instead of isoleucine
at amino acid position 38. On the other hand our sequence data support the
observation that differences between the amino acid sequences of isolates
belong to different major PPV subgroups (PPV-M, PPV-D, PPV-Rec)
located mainly in the N-terminal part of the CP and there are two amino
73
D
PA
Troy2
Ran
M
PS
El-Amar
SK68
Troy6
Troy4
Troy5
BOR-3 Pd4
Troy1
Rec
W
SoC
Figure 1. Phylogenetic tree of PPV isolates derived using the Wisconsin
Package Version 10.0 Genetic Computer Group (GCG), Madison, Wisc.
from the nucleotide sequence of coat protein gene. The following isolates
were analysed: PA (GenBank accession no. AJ000340), Ran (GenBank
accession no. M21847), SK 68 (GenBank accession no. M92280), PS
(GenBank accession no. AJ243957), Pd4 (GenBank accession no.
AJ566344), BOR-3 (GenBank accession no. AY028309), SoC (GenBank
accession no. AY184478), W (GenBank accession no. AY912055), ElAmar (GenBank accession no. AY847269) and Bulgarian isolates: Troy1
(GenBank accession no. AM260933), Troy2 (GenBank accession no.
AM260934), Troy4 (GenBank accession no. AM260935), Troy5 (GenBank
accession no. AM260936), Troy6 (GenBank accession no. AM260937)
74
acid positions (58 and 68) that are able to differentiate between all three
major subgroups (Salamon and Palkovics, 2002).
Acknowledgements
The work was supported by the Hungarian National Scientific Research
Found (OTKA T043388) and GVOP-3.2.1-2004-04- 0134 / 3.0, László
Palkovics was awarded by the János Bolyai fellowship of the Hungarian
Academy of Sciences.
References
Acuña, R. (1993): Outbreaks of plum pox virus in Chile. Conference on
Plum Pox, Bordeaux, EPPO Bull. 23: 141-146.
Atanasoff, D. (1932): Plum pox a new virus disease. Jb. Univ. Sofia,
Agronom. Fak. 11: 49-70.
Atreya, P.L., Lopez-Moya, J.J., Chu, M., Atreya, C.D. and Pirone, T.P.
(1995): Mutational analysis of the coat protein N-terminal amino acids
involved in potyvirus transmission by aphids. J. Gen. Virol. 76: 265270.
Bousalem, M., Candresse, T., Quiot-Dourine, L. and Quiot, J.B. (1994):
Comparison of three methods for assessing plum pox virus variability:
further evidence for the existence of two major groups of isolates. J.
Phytopathol. 142: 163-172.
Candresse, T., Macquaire, G., Lanneau, M., Bousalem, M., Wetzel, T.,
Quiot-Douine, L., Quiot, J.B. and Dunez, J. (1994): Detection of plum
pox potyvirus and analysis of molecular variability using
immunocapture-PCR. EPPO Bull. 24: 585-594.
Cervera, M.T., Riechmann, J.L., Martin, M.T. and Garcia, J.A. (1993): 3’
terminal sequence of the plum pox virus PS and o6 isolates: evidence
for RNA recombination within the potyvirus group. J. Gen. Virol. 74:
329-334.
Damsteegt, V.D., Stone, A.L., Luster, D.G., Levy, L., Gildow, F.E. and
Welliver, R. (2001): Prelimitary characterization of a North American
isolate of plum pox virus from naturally infected peach and plum
orchards in Pennsylvania, USA. Acta Hort. 550: 145-152.
Deborré, G., Maiss, E. and Jelkmann, W. (1995): Biological and molecular
biological investigations of several Plum pox virus (PPV) isolates.
Acta Hort. 386: 253-262.
Glasa, M., Palkovics, L., Komínek, P., Labonne, G., Pittnerová, S., Kúdela,
O., Candresse, T. and Šubr, Z. (2004): Geographically and temporally
distant natural recombinant isolates of Plum pox virus (PPV) are
75
genetically very similar and form a unique PPV subgroup. J. Gen.
Virol. 85: 2671-2681.
James, D., Varga, A., Thompson, D. and Hayes, S. (2003): Detection of a
new and unusual isolate of plum pox virus in plum (Prunus
domestica). Plant Dis. 87: 1119-1124.
Kamenova, I., Lohuis, D. and Peters, D. (2001): Comparative amino acid
sequence analysis of the coat proteins of plum pox virus isolates.
BioTechnology and BioTechnological Equipment 1: 45-50.
Milius, S. (1999): First plum pox turns up in North America. Sci. News 21:
325.
Nemchinov, L., Hadidi, A., Maiss, E., Cabra, M., Candresse, T. and
Damsteegt V. (1996): Sour cherry strain of plum pox potyvirus (PPV):
Molecular and serological evidence for a new subgroup of PPV
strains. Phytopathology 86: 1215-1221.
Németh, M. (1986): Plum pox (sharka). In: Virus, Mycoplasma and
Rickettsia Diseases of Fruit Trees. Akadémia Kiadó, Budapest, pp.
463-479.
Riechmann, J.L., Laín, S. and García, J.A. (1992): Highlights and prospects
of potyvirus molecular biology. J. Gen. Virol. 73: 1-16.
Roy, A.S. and Smith, I.M. (1994): Plum pox situation in Europe. EPPO
Bull. 24: 515–525.
Salamon, P. and Palkovics, L. (2002): Characterization of Plum pox virus
PPV-BT-H isolated from naturally infected blackthorn (Prunus
spinosa L.) in Hungary. Eur. J. Plant. Pathol. 108: 903-907.
Szemes, M., Kálman, M., Myrta, A., Boscia, D., Németh, M., Kölber, M.
and Dorgai, L. (2001): Integrated RT-PCR/nested PCR diagnosis for
differentiating between subgroups of plum pox virus. J. Virol.
Methods, 92: 165-175.
Thakur, P.D., Bhardwaj, S. V., Garg, I.D., Kishore-Khosla Sharma, D.R.
and Khosla, K. (1994): Plum pox virus on stone fruits from India – a
new record. Plant Dis. Res. 9: 100–102.
Thomson, D., McCann, M., MacLeod, M., Lye, D., Green, M. and James,
D. (2001): First report of plum pox potyvirus in Ontario, Canada. Plant
Dis. 85: 97.
Wetzel, T., Candresse, T., Ravelonandro, M., Delbos, R. P., Mazyad, H.,
Aboul-Ata, A. E. and Dunez, J. (1991): Nucleotide sequence of the 3’terminal region of the RNA of the El Amar strain of plum pox
potyvirus. J. Gen. Virol. 72: 1741-1746.
White, J.L. and Kaper, J.M. (1989): A simple method for detection of viral
satellite RNAs in small tissue samples. J. Virol. Methods 23: 83-94.
76
ANALYSIS OF SOME RECOMBINANT PLUM POX VIRUS (PPV)
ISOLATES FROM BULGARIA, THE COUNTRY WHERE PPV WAS
FIRST RECORDED
E. Szathmáry1, I. Tóbiás2 and L. Palkovics1*
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural Science, Department of Plant
Pathology, Budapest, Hungary
2
Plant Protection Institute of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary
Summary
Troyan region is an important plum growing area in Bulgaria, the country where Plum pox
virus (PPV) was recorded for the first time. In an effort to characterize PPV strains of this
region six samples were collected from naturally infected plum (Prunus domestica L.)
varieties in 2004 in the experimental field of the Research Institute of Mountain
Stockbreeding and Agriculture in Troyan (Bulgaria).
PPV subgroup typing was performed using RT-PCR followed by sequence analysis of the
(Cter)NIb–CP–3’UTR region of each Bulgarian PPV isolate. Amino acid sequence
comparisons of the RT-PCR amplified part of the virus genome revealed that four isolates
out of the five belonged to the PPV-Rec subgroup. These recombinant isolates were almost
identical at the molecular level and shared the same recombination breakpoint in the NIb
gene as well as a typical signature in their amino-terminal CP sequence. While only one
isolate could be classified as a member of PPV-D subgroup.
77
RESULTS OF THE USE OF CRYPHONECTRIA
PARASITICA HYPOVIRULENT STRAINS IN HUNGARY
AND IN SLOVAKIA
G. Juhasová1 - M. Kobza1 – K. Adamčíková1 – L. Radócz2 – G. Tarcali2
1
Branch of Woody Plants Biology Nitra, Institute of Forest Ecology SAS,
Zvolen, Slovakia
2
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen,
Hungary
Cryphonectria parasitica (Murrill) Barr, the causal agent of the chestnut
blight disease was introduced into Europe around 1938 (Biraghi 1946) and
led to considerable destruction of the European chestnut (Castanea sativa
Mill.). Chestnut blight disease can be controlled by means of a biological
method. This biological control procedure is based on virulent and
hypovirulent forms of the fungus C. parasitica that occur in the nature.
The first application of a biological programme in Europe for the control of
the chestnut blight, using hypovirulent strains of the pathogen was
conducted in southern France in the years from 1967 to 1972. It yielded
surprisingly positive results. These were the first significant successes in
attempting to control this important disease (Grente and Berthelay-Sauret
1969, 1979).
The aim of this study was to treat cankers with hypovirulent strains
converted with French (INRA Clermont Ferrand) and Hungarian
hypoviruses and to evaluate the efficiency of biological control in the
monitored localities.
Materials and Methods
Treatments were performed on stems and branches of trees infected by
virulent strains of the fungus. Inoculation holes (5-8 mm x 5-10 mm,
depending on the bark thickness) were made using an auger with flat edges
so as to establish close contact between the hypovirulent mycelium of the
fungus and the virulent mycelium causing the canker. Pellets, containing the
hypovirulent mycelium, prepared specifically for our trials by the Fytofarm
(Phytofarm) of Bratislava, according to Grente (1965), were applied directly
into the inoculation holes. Cubes of malt agar with hypovirulent mycelium
were also used. The holes were then sealed with grafting wax.
Nontreated cankers in all localities (on the same stems and also on separated
trees) were used as controls to compare the effect of biological control and
to assess the natural spread of hypovirulence. The effect of treatment was
78
evaluated visually (callus formation; enlargement of cankers outside the line
of treatment). The size (width and length) of treated and nontreated cankers
was measured in mm. The degree of healing of the cankers was evaluated
once every year after the treatment.
As no hypovirulent isolates were previously detected in Slovakia, virulent
isolates of C. parasitica from Slovakia were converted into hypovirulent
forms with French hypovirulent isolates maintained in the «INRA-Station
d´Agronomie et Mycologie, Unité de Mycologie in Clermont Ferrand».
Four new hypovirulent isolates were thus obtained. These new hypovirulent
isolates (with dsRNA) were designated TchA, TchD, TchC and TchE
(Juhásová and Berthelay-Sauret 1993).
Slovakian virulent isolates were also transformed into hypovirulent forms
with Hungarian hypovirulent isolates (R5, C2, IHB2) and were used for
biological control.
Results and Discussion
European chestnut occurs in 5 subregions in 210 localities in Slovakia.
Chestnut blight was identified in 36 localities (Figure 1/A-B).
In 1992, only normal cankers (i.e. infected with virulent strains) were
identified in the studied localities. The number of cankers varied from 1 to
15 per tree. Also, new cankers continued to form on the study trees. The
results of the biological control using French hypovirus containing strains
performed in the localities are summarized in Table 1. The treated cankers
occurred on the stems and on branches. A total number of 4173 cankers
were treated within the 1992-1997. During the course of the study, from
22.6 to 68.5% of all the treated cankers were callused and callusing has been
started on the remaining treated trees.
Treatment with strains converted with Hungarian hypovirulent strains was
done in two localities (Bratislava, Modra) in 2005 (Tables 2, 3). The
evaluation of the success of the biological control programme will be
realized in this autumn.
In Hungary, a similar biological programme was initiated in two localities
(Ágfalva and Zengővárkony) in 1997, where Hungarian hypovirulent strains
were used. The rate of callusing of the treated cankers in these two localities
was 80-90%. Compared to the results of our first attempt to use
hypovirulent strains in Slovakia, the study in Hungary was more successful
(Radócz, 2001). Indeed, in our first tests the number of callusing cankers
was not more than 50%.
79
A
B
Locality
Arborétum
Mlyňany
Bojná
Bratislava
Duchonka
Grinava
H. Lefantovce
H. Plachtince
Hlohovec
Chľaba
Kovarce
Krnča
No. of locality
58
Locality
Pastúchov
No. of locality
208
33
7
39
9
47
93
171
212
204
207
128
10
191
38
89
151
32
170
213
92
Limbach
Lipovník
Modra
Modrý Kameň
Nitra
Nitrianska Streda
Žemberovce
130
152
11
83
31
205
72
Petrovce
Pezinok
Podhájska
Podhradie
Príbelce
Rača
Radošina
Senec
Solčany
Stredné
Plachtince
Súlovce
Svätý Jur
Svodín
Štitáre
Štúrovo
Tlstý Vrch
Veľké Lovce
214
8
211
209
194
79
215
Figure 1/A-B. The map (A) and localities (B) of occurrence of C. parasitica
in Slovakia in 2005
80
Up to the year 2002, no hypovirulent strains of C. parasitica were isolated
in Slovakia. However, in that year, we found cankers showing callus on
trees which has not been treated so far. It thus appeared the hypoviruses
would have spread to the strains of C. parasitica causing the cankers.
Hypovirulent strains grew and sporulated so poorly that their persistence
was limited. A combination of several favourable factors may be involved
in the natural spread of hypovirulence. The sporulation of hypovirulent
strains is much lower than the sporulation of virulent strains of C.
parasitica. As hypoviruses may be present in conidia and not in ascospores
(Bissegger et al., 1997), transmission of hypovirulence is mostly by means
of conidia. However, about 10 - 50% of the conidia produced by
hypovirulent strains do not contain the hypovirus and these can give rise to
virulent mycelium (Anagnostakis, 1995).
Table 1. Results of biological control of chestnut blight disease with
converted strain containing French hypovirus in Slovakia within the 19921997
Locality
Bratislava
Svätý Jur
Myslenice
Rača
Modra
Limbach
Duchonka
Lipovník
S. Plachtince
H. Plachtince
M. Kameň
Radošina
Number of evaluated
trees
Total
Infected
2847
88
2361
59
585
61
1144
181
890
110
878
138
2429
693
1030
1166
3063
313
1092
82
4962
97
1863
158
81
Number of cankers
Treated
238
103
96
227
176
490
1476
492
375
158
181
158
Callusing (%)
44.2
49.9
51.6
45.2
63.2
68.5
51.8
52,9
22.6
32.7
42.7
45.4
Table 2. Results of treatment of cankers on European chestnut with
converted hypovirulent isolates (Hungarian hypovirus) of C. parasitica in
Bratislava-Sliačska in 2005
No. of
tree
Trunk
in girth
Hypovirulent
isolate
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
9a
9b
10
10a
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
25a
348
322
462
278
297
309
219
176
175
14
12
215
18
72
185
255
420
220
132
62
270
210
120
40
330
330
85
220
80
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/C
BA-SL/R5
BA-SL/R5
BA-SL/R5
BA-SL/R5
BA-SL/R5
BA-SL/R5
BA-SL/R5
82
Treatment on trees
Trunk
Trunk
Branches
basis
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Table 3. Results of treatment of cankers on European chestnut with
converted hypovirulent isolates (Hungarian hypovirus) of Cryphonectria
parasitica in Modra – Gaštanka, in 2005
No. of
tree
Trunk
in girth
Hypovirule
nt isolate
1b
2
6
6a
6b
9
13
16b
20
27c
29
30b
41a
45
54a
55
58b
26
36
36
32
38
36
135
71
79
56
65
64
25
218
207
62
140
Mo-R5x2
Mo-R5x2
Mo-R5x2
Mo-R5x2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-R5x2
Mo-R5x2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-R5x2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-IHB2
Mo-IHB2
Treatment on trees
Trunk
Trunk
Branches
basis
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Acknowlegment
This work has been supported by the Grant Agency for Science, VEGA,
Grant no 2/4020/04, project APVT-51-015602 and bilateral project No.
10/2004.
References
Anagnostakis S.L. (1995): The pathogens and pests of chestnuts. Adv. Bot.
Res. 21: 125-145.
Biraghi A. (1946): Il cancro del castagno causato da Endothia parasitica. L´Italia
Agric. 7: 406.
Bissegger M., Rigling D. and Heiniger U. (1997): Population structure and
disease development of Cryphonectria parasitica in European chestnut
forests in the presence of natural hypovirulence. Phytopathology 87: 5059.
83
Grente J. (1965): Les formes hypovirulentes d´Endothia parasitica et les
espoirs de lutte contre le chancre du chataignier. C. R. Acad. Agric.
France 51: 1033-1037.
Grente J. and Berthelay-Sauret S. (1969): L´hypovirulence exclusive,
phénomene original en pathologie végétale. C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris (1)
268: 2347-2350.
Grente, J. and Berthelay-Sauret S. (1979): pp. 30-34 in Proceedings of the
American chestnut symposium, W.L McDonald., F.C. Cech, J. Luchok,
C. Smith (eds) West Virginia University Press, Morgantown, W.Va.
Juhásová, G. and Bethelay-Sauret S. (1993): Health conditions of Castanea
sativa Mill., incidence of the fungus Cryphonectria parasitica (Murr)
Barr and possibilities of its biological control in Slovakia. Biotechnologia
1: 55-58.
Radócz, L. (2001): Study of subpopulations of the chestnut blight fungus in
the Carpathian basin. Forest, Snow and Landscape Research 76(3): 368372.
RESULTS OF THE USE OF CRYPHONECTRIA PARASITICA
HYPOVIRULENT STRAINS IN HUNGARY AND IN SLOVAKIA
G. Juhásová1, M. Kobza1, K. Adamčíková1, L. Radócz2 and G. Tarcali2
1
Branch of Woody Plants Biology Nitra, Institute of Forest Ecology SAS Zvolen, Slovakia
2
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
Summary
Chestnut blight disease can be controlled by means of a biological method using
hypovirulent strains of the pathogen. Chestnut blight was identified in 36 localities in
Slovakia. Cankers were treated with hypovirulent strains converted with French (INRA
Clermont Ferrand) and Hungarian hypoviruses. A total of 4173 cankers were treated within
the 1992-1997. During the study from 22.6 to 68.5% of all the treated cankers were
callused and callusing has been started on the remaining treated trees. Up to the year 2002,
no hypovirulent strains of C. parasitica were isolated in Slovakia. However, in that year,
we found cankers showing calluses on trees which had not been treated earlier. Natural
spread of hypovirulence in Slovakia has been presented.
84
CHESTNUT BLIGHT INFECTION ON SESSILE OAK
(QUERCUS PETREA) IN SOUTHERN-HUNGARY
Gábor Tarcali – László Radócz – István Dávid
University of Debrecen, Centre for Agricultural Sciences, Department of
Plant Protection, Debrecen, Hungary
“Chestnut blight” disease caused by Cryphonectria parasitica (Murr.) Barr
(syn: Endothia parasitica [Murr.] And.) causes big damages of the chestnut
stands throughout the world. First at the beginning of the XX-th. century it
destroyed almost the whole American chestnut (Castanea dentata)
populations in the USA (Anagnostakis, 1987). In the middle of the XX-th
century the pathogen was transferred into Europe and infected the European
chestnut (Castanea sativa) populations in the West-European countries.
This infection was reported first in Italy, near Genova in 1938 (Biraghi,
1946).
Then the disease spread from Western-Europe towards the Central- and
Eastern-European chestnut territories and arrived to the Carpathian-Basin
too. “Chestnut blight” disease symptoms were reported on chestnut first in
Austria (Donaubauer, 1964), in Hungary ( Körtvély, 1970), in Slovakia
(Juhasova, 1976), in Romania (Florea, Popa, 1989) and in Ukraine
(Radócz, 2001). Chestnut stands in Hungary have already been seriously
dameged by this disease at the end of last century (Radócz, 1999).
This fungus is the most important disease for European chestnut, but the
importance of this parasite is increased because it is able to infect other tree
species of the Fagaceae family (oak, beech). Until 1998 the fungus was
only detected on Castanea sativa in Hungary. Then the blight symptoms
were also detected on some Quercus petrea trees in mixed chestnut forest
near Kőszeg and Zengővárkony (Radócz and Holb, 2002). Although
symptoms were not so serious in Quercus spp. than Castanea spp., it seems
that Cryphonectria parasitica frequently threatens the young Hungarian oak
trees mainly in infected chestnut forests. Therefore it could be a more
serious potential parasite for our forests. One of the most important species
of the Hungarian forestry is the sessile oak (Quercus petrea) which has been
threatened by Cryphonectria parasitica. These oak trees are important both
economically and ecologically aspects.
Literature
Chestnut blight fungus (teleomorph: Cryphonectria parasitica (Murrill)
Barr [syn.: Endothia parasitica (Murr.) P.J. Anderson and H.W. Anderson];
85
anamorph: Endothiella sp.) is an ascogenous pathogen causing blight on
some species of the family Fagaceae (Castanea spp., Fagus spp., Quercus
spp.).
Symptoms: On young stems, brown lesion forms on the smooth bark can be
found. Some discoloration occurs also when older stems are attacked,
mainly through wounds. Lesions become sunken as the bark and the
cambium are killed; there is swelling and cracking of the outher bark. Death
of the cambium of this ring-porous tree prevents formation of the xylem
vessels needed for liquid transport, and this causes wilting of the leaves
above (beyond) the canker. Pycnidia are very abundant on the cancered
bark, exuding spore tendrils in moist conditions. Pale brown, mycelial fan
formations can be found in the inner bark (Sivanesan and Holliday, 1981).
Appearance on Quercus spp.: C. parasitica caused bark necrosis on some
species of the genus Quercus (Torsello et al., 1994) in the USA and in a few
European countries. They reported that 15.5 % of the oaks in Pennsylvania
(mountain regions) were infected with the chestnut blight fungus. In
Hungary, the fungus was detected first on oak at Zengővárkony and Kőszeg
(Radócz and Holb, 2002). Symptoms were never higher in the infection
scale than disease grade 2 and dead parts of some of the oak branches due to
this parasite were observed. In 2003 infected oak trees with bark necrosis
were also found in Baie Mare, Romania. Laboratory identification showed
that Quercus spp. trees were infected by some of the same C. parasitica
strains that were detected from chestnut. It is supposed that Quercus petrea
infections were caused by the inoculum originated from fruit bodies of
chestnut bark cankers.
Materials and Methods
Main goals of our studies were the followings: to estimate the damages
caused by the Cryphonectria parasitica fungus on oak trees; laboratory
investigation and identification of the collected samples and isolates.
Our field examinations has been made at Bakonya (Mecsek-Mountain,
Southern-Hungary) in a young sessile oak plantation mixed with chestnut
several times, since 2003. At the beginning of the investigation we selected
a sample-field with 150 oak trees. The trees were 7-8 years of age with 2-5
m heights as the average. During the field examinations every trees were
checked. We found the symptoms of C. parasitica and we measured the
infection rates according to Table 1. Bark samples were collected from the
infected or suspicious looking trees by a disinfected sharp scalpel for further
laboratory identifications.
86
Table 1. Infection rate classification system
Degrees of
contamination
1
2
a
b
3
a
b
4
a
b
5
Healthy tree
Suspicious symtom
in the crown of the tree
on the trunk of the tree
1 cancer
symptoms in the crown
on the trunk
More cankers
symptoms in the crown
on the trunk
Killed tree by C. parasitica
During the laboratory examinations PDA (potato-dextrose-agar) media were
used. Surfice sterilized bark samples were cultivated on PDA media and the
isolates were incubated during 7 days in a climated chamber. After this
cultivation Cryphonectria parasitica was identifiable on the media.
Results and Discussion
Field examinations has done yearly, since 2003 (in 2004, 2005, 2006). We
learned that chestnut blight disease was spread through the territory, and
symptoms were observable well on several trees. Infection rate
examinations were done during every occasions. We can see the result of
the yearly examinations on Table 2. It was detected that C. parasitica
infection is more and more serious year by year.
Previous statement had been verified during the laboratory examinations,
that is chestnut blight fungus infected several young oak trees on the
sample-field as it is shown in Table 3.
Table 2. Results of infection rate in field examinations at Bakonya
Infection rate
Time of field
examination
Tree number
2004. 12. 07.
2005. 11. 10.
2006. 09. 28.
BAK. 1.
5.
6.
7.
8.
2b
5
-
2b
2b
3b
5
4ab,
2ab
4a
5
5
87
Table 2. (continued)
10.
12.
14.
17.
19.
20.
21.
23.
24.
30.
31.
33.
34.
35.
38.
41.
43.
49.
5052.
53.
55.
56.
62.
63.
65.
66.
67.
68.
73.
80.
81.
86.
87.
88.
89.
91.
93.
94.
96.
97.
99.
100.
109.
110.
116.
118.
119.
126.
132.
134.
137.
138.
145.
148.
149.
150.
2b
2b
2b
2b
3b
4b
2b
3b
4ab
3b
2b
3b
2b
4b
5
4ab
2b
4b
2b
4b
5
2b
2b
2b
4b
3b
4b
3b
5
3b
4b
2b
5
2b
3b
2b
2b
4b
2b
2b
2b
2b
2b
3b
4b
4b
2ab
3a
4ab
5
3b
4ab
5
4ab
2b
3b
2b
2b
3b
2b
4b
2b
3b
3b
3b
4ab
5
2b
2b
3b
4ab
3b
4b
3b
3b
4ab
5
3b
4b
5
4ab
2b
3b
4ab
2ab
2ab
2b
3b
2b
3ab
4ab
2ab
2b
3ab
2ab
3ab
4ab
5
3ab
2ab
5
5
4ab
3ab
3ab
2b
3b
4ab
4a
4b
4ab
3ab
4ab
3ab
5
3ab
2b
3ab
5
3b
4ab
3ab
3b
4ab
4ab
3ab
4ab
5
4ab
2a
3ab
4ab
Remark: Trees signed by numbers missing from the Table 2 were found healthy
88
Table 3. Results of C. parasitica identification on laboratory examinations
Infected isolates by C. parasitica according to the latest
laboratory test (2005 November)
BAK 6, 7, 8, 17, 20, 23, 24, 34, 35, 38, 41, 49, 53, 55, 56, 63,
67, 73, 80, 81, 86, 87, 88, 91, 93, 97, 99, 100, 109, 110, 116,
118, 119, 126, 132, 137, 145, 148, 149, 150
References
Anagnostakis, S.L. (1987): Chestnut blight: The classical problem of an
introduced pathogen. Mycologia 79: 23-37.
Biraghi, A. (1946) Il cancro del castagno da Endothia parasitica. Ital. Agric.
7: 406-412.
Donaubauer, E. (1964): Untersuchungen über den die Variation der
Krankheitsanfälligkeit verschiedener Pappeln. Mitt. FBVA Maria
Brunn. pp. 70-120.
Florea, S. and Popa, I. (1989): Diseases of the edible chestnut reported in
the fruit growing area of Baie Mare. In: Cercetarea stiintifica in
sluiba productiei pomicole 1969-1989. Bucuresti, Romania 1989:
365-372.
Juhasova, G. (1976): A summary of knowledge on fungal diseases of
Spanish chestnut in Slovakia. Forestry 38: 449-460.
Körtvély A. (1970): A gesztenye endotiás kéregelhalása. (Bark destruction
caused by Endothia parasitica /Murr./ Anderson on chestnut trees).
Növényvédelem 6: 38-361 (in Hungarian)
Radócz, L. (1999): Chestnut blight and the hypovirulence in the Carpathianbasin. Acta Horticulturae 494. ISHS Press, Leuven-Belgium: 501508.
Radócz, L. (2001): Study of subpopulations of the chestnut blight
(Cryphonectria parasitica) fungus in the Carpathian-basin. For.
Snow Landsc. Res. 76(3): 368-372.
Radócz, L. and Holb, I.J. (2002): Detection of natural infection of Quercus
spp. by the chestnut blight fungus (Cryphonectria parasitica) in
Hungary. Int. J. Hort. Sci. 8(2): 54-56.
Sivanesan, A. and Holliday, P. (1981): Incidence of Cryphonectria
parasitica cankers on scarlet oak (Quercus coccinea) in
Pennsylvania. Plant Disease 78: 313-315.
89
Torsello, M.L., Davis, D.D. and Nash, B.L. (1994): Incidence of
Cryphonectria parasitica cankers on scarlet oak (Quercus coccinea)
in Pennsylvania. Plant Dis. 78: 313-315.
CHESTNUT BLIGHT INFECTION ON SESSILE OAK (QUERCUS
PETREA) IN BAKONYA
Gábor Tarcali, László Radócz and István Dávid
University of Debcecen, Centre for Agricultural Sciences, Department of Plant Protection,
Debrecen, Hungary
Summary
Cryphonectria parasitica causes big damages of the chestnut-stads throughout the world.
The pathogen arrived to the Carpathian-Basin in the second part of the last century and
destroyed the chestnut populations. Later the symptoms of the disease appeared on sessile
oak trees in oak-chestnut mixed forests in Hungary and in other countries. The goals of our
studies were to estimate damages caused by Cryphonectria parasitica on oak trees in a
young sessile oak plantation mixed chestnut and to investigate the collected samples and
isoletes in laboratory. Our results showed that chestnut blight fungus infected several young
oak trees on the oak plantation in Bakonya. Therefore this disease is a new serious potential
danger for our oak forests.
90
DISTRIBUTION OF TRANSPOSONS IN BOTRYTIS
CINEREA ISOLATES COLLECTED FROM THE WINE
REGIONS OF EGER AND TOKAJ, HUNGARY
Kálmán Z. Váczy1 – Levente Karaffa2 – Erzsébet Fekete2 – György J.
Kövics3 – Lajos Gál1 – Erzsébet Sándor3
1
2
Research Institute for Viticulture and Enology, Eger, Hungary
Department of Genetics and Applied Microbiology, Faculty of Science,
University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
3
Department of Plant Protection, Faculty of Agriculture, University of
Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
Botryotinia fuckeliana (de Bary ex de Bary) Whetzel (anamorph: Botrytis
cinerea Pers.:Fr.) is a cosmopolitan ascomycetous fungus that causes grey
mould on a great number of plants in the temperate zone worldwide by
infecting various tissues (Jarvis, 1980). In grapevine, the frequent
occurrence of B. cinerea prior harvesting results in serious losses of fruits
and deterioration of wine quality. This is also the case in Eger, a major
Hungarian wine region in the North-Eastern part of the country, where B.
cinerea is considered to the third most important grapevine pathogen after
downy mildew (Plasmopara viticola /Berk. and Curt ex de Bary/ Berl. and
de Toni) and powdery mildew [Erysiphe necator Schwein. var. necator
(syn.: Uncinula necator /Schwein./ Burrill var. necator)], with an estimated
annual loss of up to 15-20 %. In contrast, some 100 km eastwards in the
Tokaj wine region, B. cinerea is also responsible for the phenomenon called
‘pourriture noble’ (noble rot). Under certain unique environmental
conditions, mycelia growing on the surface of the uninjured, healthy berry
drains water (but no substrates) via the fine infection hyphae. As a
consequence, the concentration of all the soluble compounds within the
berry significantly increase (Jarvis, 1980). Such berries yield the sweet,
special quality wine called „aszu”.
Literatute
Transposable elements (TEs) are fragments of DNA that can insert into new
chromosomal locations and often make duplicate copies of themselves in
the process (Feschottes et al., 2002). TEs were first discovered in maize
(McClintock, 1984) and later have been found in several eukaryotic,
eubacteria and archaea genome. In addition to the wide array of ‘hosts’, the
variety of transposons described also increased considerably (Finnegan,
1989). Fungal transposons were first identified in the yeast Saccharomyces
cerevisiae (Boeke, 1989), though the first indirect evidence for their
91
presence in filamentous fungi arose years earlier from conventional genetic
studies with Ascobolus immersus mutants (Decaris et al., 1978).
There are two main classes of TEs (Finnegan, 1989). Class I elements are
related to retroviruses and they transpose through the reverse synthesis of
DNA from template RNA, while class II elements move in the genome
through direct DNA to DNA transposition without an RNA intermediary.
Class I elements are known as retrotransposons and include TEs with or
without ‘long terminal repeated sequences’ (LTRs). Retroelements have
been found in a number of fungal species such as Alternaria alternata
(Kaneko et al., 2000), Ascobolus immersus (Goyon et al., 1996), Aspergillus
fumigatus (Neuvéglise et al., 1996), Aspergillus nidulans (Nielsen et al.,
2001), Neurospora crassa (Kinsey and Helber, 1989). DNA transposons are
also widespread and have been described among others in Agaricus
bisporus (Sonnenberg et al., 1999), Ascobolus immersus (Colot and
Rissignol, 1995), Aspergillus niger (Glayzer et al., 1995), Magnaporthe
grisea (Kachroo et al., 1994), Nectria haematococca (Enkerli et al., 1997),
Neurospora crassa (Yeadon, 1995), and Podospora anserina (Hamann et
al., 2000).
B. cinerea has been shown to possess two transposons. Boty is a class I
LTR-retro-transposon (Diolez et al., 1995), while Flipper is a class II
element (Levis et al., 1997). In this paper we will show that at least four
genotypes of isolates related to the presence or absence of these transposons
occur in the Eger wine region. Potential significance of this finding is
discussed.
Materials and Methods
Field strains of B. cinerea were collected from various locations of the Eger
and Tokaj wine districts. They were isolated from infected berries between
2003 and 2004 during the vintage period (September-October). Fungal
strains from both wine regions are numbered by the chronology of
collection, irrespective to the local provenance.
DNA was extracted from aerial mycelium of B. cinerea with Plant DNA
Purification Kit (QuiaGene). Transposons were detected with PCR reactions
described at Munoz et al., 2002. Presence or absence of the two transposons
was confirmed by agarose gel electrophoresis (Figure 1) using standard
protocols (Sambrook et al., 1989).
92
Samples
61
65
67
63
68
Flipper
1300 bp
1200 bp
Boty
700 bp
600 bp
Figure 1. Gel electrophoresis picture of transposon elements
Results
B. cinerea has been shown to possess a highly versatile genome reflected in
a considerable metabolic flexibility. Depending on the actual environmental
conditions (Martinez et al., 2003), the fungus is able to act both as a
saprophyte and a pathogen, and has developed resistance to most of the
fungicides used to control it (Faretra and Pollastro, 1991; Leroux et al.,
1999).
Studies on French and Chilean B. cinerea isolates have revealed the
presence of three distinct intrapopulation: (1) transposa, having transposable
elements Boty and Flipper, (2) vacuma, having none of the two and (3) boty
containing the transposable element Boty alone (Munoz et al., 2002). The
flipper intrapopulation, containing the transposable element Flipper alone
has thus far only been described in two separate isolates from the United
Kingdom and France (Albertini et al., 2002).
Boty and Flipper are both specific for B. cinerea. While proteins encoded by
transposable elements are supposed to be used exclusively for the purpose
of their own reproduction without any interference with the metabolism of
the host organism, a more rapid biomass formation in the vacuma
intrapopulation relative to boty and transposa was observed (Martinez et al.,
2003). It should also be noted that the level of fungicide resistance
significantly differed in transposa and in vacuma-type B. cinerea
populations in French isolates (Albertini et al., 2002). It is not yet known
whether the two events are related to each other, and if they are then it is a
cause or a consequence of the altered transposon pattern.
In the framework of this project 68 and 17 B. cinerea isolates have been
collected from the Eger and Tokaj wine regions, respectively. To the best of
93
our knowledge, this is the first Central-Eastern European collection of its
kind, and only the fourth worldwide. Two French studies from the
Champagne and Bordeaux wine regions, respectively analysed a collection
of 259 (Giraud et al., 1997) and 121 (Martinez et al., 2003) isolates, while a
Chilean study was based on 69 cases. Distribution of the Flipper and Boty
transposons in the Hungarian isolates are markedly different to those in
French and Chilean collections (Table 1).
Table 1. Distribution of transposons in Botrytis cinerea isolates collected from
the Eger and Tokaj vine regions, Hungary, and percentage of the transposa,
vacuma, flipper and boty intrapopulations in other countries as found in the
literature
Type of straina
No. of isolatesb
Percentage
Percentage
Eger
Tokaj
Eger
Tokaj
Chile(c)
France(d)
France(e)
transposa
flipper
boty
vacuma
12
51
1
4
0
17
0
0
17.64
75.00
1.47
5.89
0
100
0
0
79.71
0.00
11.59
8.70
75.00
0.00
0.00
25.00
61.34
0.00
0.00
38.66
All
68
17
100
100
100
100
100
a
transposa isolates contain both the Boty and Flipper transposable elements. Flipper and boty
are isolates containing Flipper or Boty, respectively, while vacuma are isolates without Boty
and Flipper.
b
all the isolates as well as viticultural and geographical details of their provenance are available
from the first author of this paper upon request.
c
Munoz et al.,2002; d Giraud et al., 1997; e Martinez et at., 2003
While genotype transposa is clearly prevalent in the French and Chilean
samples with some two-third of the isolates containing both transposons, the
percentage of this particular intrapopulation was less than 18 percent in Eger
and zero percent in Tokaj. While genotype boty was present in over 10
percent of the Chilean collection, we found only one single strain in Eger
(and none in Tokaj) that carried the Boty transposon alone. We note, while
the French studies indicated the presence of boty genotype in their
collections, no defined values were provided in either case.
Distribution of the genotype vacuma ranged between 8 and 38 percent in the
literature. Our investigations yielded only a handful of vacuma isolates in
Eger and none in Tokaj.
The most striking observation in our study is the appearance of the genotype
flipper, an intrapopulation of B. cinerea hitherto considered extremely rare.
However, this genotype is obviously prevalent in the two Hungarian wine
regions studied, with 75 percent of the isolates containing only flipper
94
transposon in Eger and all in Tokaj. None of the three collections cited in
this paper have reported on the appearance of this genotype.
Transposons are highly mobile genetic elements while B. cinerea is a truly
cosmopolitan fungus. Comparative analysis of transposon distributions in B.
cinerea isolates collected from all around the world may thus be a worthy
method to study fungal population genetics.
There are no tested hypothesises on the physiological role of transposons.
Mobility of transposons including those in the filamentous fungi
Magnaporthe grisea (Ikeda et al., 2001) and Fusarium oxysporum (Mes et
al., 2000) were reported to increase during certain stress conditions such as
substrate deficiency, drought, heat and exposure to γ -radiation. It remains to
be tested whether stress conditions will influence B. cinerea transposons in
anyway.
Discussion
This study showed that all of the four transposon-related genotypes of B.
cinerea ever described in the literature exists in the Eger wine region. Most
noteworthly, genotype flipper, considered extremely rare elsewhere in the
world is apparently dominant both in the Eger and Tokaj wine regions. In
fact in Tokaj, flipper was the only transposon found. It remains to evaluate
whether B. cinerea genotypes defined over transposon distribution are
relevant to the role the fungus plays in viticulture and enology.
This work was supported by grants from the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development
(33013/2003 and 46024/2004). Levente Karaffa’s Lab is grant-aided by the OTKA (Hungarian
Scientific Research Fund; F 042602). Erzsébet Fekete and Erzsébet Sándor are recipients of an
OTKA postdoctoral scholarship (D 048617) and a János Bolyai Scholarship (BO/00446/04),
respectively.
References
Albertini, C., Thebaud, G., Fournier, E. and Leroux, P. (2002): Eburicol 14αdemethylase gene (CYP51) polymorphism and speciation in Botrytis
cinerea. Mycol. Res. 106:1171-1178.
Boeke, J.D. (1989): Transposable elements in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, In:
Mobile DNA, Berg, D.E. and Howe, M. (Eds) ASM Press, Washington
DC, pp. 335-374.
Colot, V. and Rossignol, J.L. (1995): Isolation of the Ascobolus immersus spore
color gene b2 and study in single cells of gene silencing by methylation
induced premeiotically. Genetics 141:1299-1314.
Decaris, B., Francou, F., Lefort, C. and Rizet, G. (1978): Unstable ascospore
color mutants of Ascobolus immerses. Mol. Gen. Genet. 162:69-81.
95
Diolez, A., Marches, F., Fortini, D., and Brygoo, Y. (1995): Boty, a longterminal-repeat retroelement in the phytopathogenic fungus Botrytis
cinerea. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61:103-108.
Enkerli, J., Bhatt, G. and Covert, S.F. (1997): Nht1, a transposable element
cloned from a dispensable chromosome in Nectria haematococca. Mol.
Plant-Microbe Interact. 10:742-749.
Faretra, F. and Pollastro, S. (1991): Genetic Basis of resistance to
benzimidazole and dicarboximide fungicides in Botryotinia fuckeliana
(Botrytis cinerea). Mycol. Res. 95: 943-951.
Feschottes, C., Zhang, X. and Wessler, S.R. (2002): Miniature inverted-repeat
transposable elements and their relationship to established DNA
transposons, In: Mobile DNA II, .Craig NL, Craigie, R., Gellert, M. and
Lambowitz, A.M. (Eds) ASM Press, Washington DC, pp.1147-1158.
Finnegan, D.J. (1989): Eukaryotic transposable elements and genome
evolution. Trends Genet. 5: 103-107.
Giraud, T., Fortini, D., Levis, C., Leroux, P. and Brygoo Y. (1997): RFLP
markers show genetic recombination in Botryotinia fuckeliana (Botrytis
cinerea) and transposable elements reveal two sympatric species, Mol.
Biol. Evol. 14: 1177-1185.
Glayzer, D.C., Roberts, I.N., Archer, D.B. and Oliver, R.P. (1995): The
isolation of ant1, a transposable element from Aspergillus niger, Mol.
Gen. Genet. 249: 432-438.
Goyon, C., Rossignol, J.L. and Faugeron, G. (1996) :Native DNA repeats and
methylation in Ascobolus. Nucleic Acids Res. 24: 3348-3356.
Hamann, A., Felle, F. and Osiewacz, H.D. (2000): The degenerate DNA
transposon pat and repeat-induced point mutation (RIP) in Podospora
anserina. Mol. Gen. Genet. 263: 1061-1069.
Ikeda, K., Nakayashiki, H., Takagi, M., Tosa, Y. and Mayama, S. (2001): Heat
shock, coper sulfate and oxidative stress activate the retrotransposon
MAGGY resident in the plant pathogenic fungus Magnaporthe grisea.
Mol. Genet. Genomics 266: 318-325.
Jarvis, W.R. (1980): Taxonomy. In: The Biology of Botrytis. Coley-Smith,
J.R., Verhoeff, K. and Jarvis W.R. (Eds) Academic Press, London pp. 118.
Kachroo, P., Leong, A.S. and Chattoo, B.B. (1994): Pot2, an inverted repeat
transposon from the rice blast fungus Magnaporthe grisea. Mol. Gen.
Genet. 245: 339-348.
Kaneko, I., Tanaka, A. and Tsuge, T. (2000): REAL, an LTR retrotransposon
from the plant pathogenic fungus Alternaria alternata. Mol. Gen.
Genet. 263: 625-634.
Kinsey, J.A. and Helber, J. (1989): Isolation of a transposable element from
Neurospora crassa, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86: 1929-1933.
96
Leroux, P., Chapeland, F., Desbrosses, D. and Gredt, M. (1999): Patterns of
cross resistance to fungicides in Botrytinia fuckeliana isolates from
French vineyards. Crop Protection 18: 687-697.
Levis, C., Fortini, D. and Brygoo, Y. (1997): Flipper, a mobile Fot1-like
transposable element in Botrytis cinerea. Mol. Gen. Genet. 254: 674680.
Martinez, F., Blancard, D., Lecomte, P. Levis, C., Dubos, B. and Fermaud,
M. (2003): Phenotypic differences between vacuma and transposa
subpopulations of Botrytis cinerea. Eur. J. Plant Pathol. 109: 479488.
McClintock, B. (1984): The significance of responses of the genome to
challenge. Science 226: 792-801.
Mes, J.J., Haring, M.A.and Cornelissen, B.J. (2000):Foxy: An active family
of short interspersed nuclear elements from Fusarium oxysporum.
Mol. Gen. Genet. 263: 271-280.
Munoz, G., Hinrichsen, P., Brygoo, Y. and Giraud, T. (2002): Genetic
characterisation of Botrytis cinerea populations in Chile. Mycol.
Res. 106: 594-601.
Neuvéglise, C., Sarfati, J., Latgé, J.P. and Paris, S. (1996): Afut1, a
retrotransposon-like element from Aspergillus fumigatus. Nucleic
Acids Res. 24: 1428-1434.
Nielsen, M.L., Hermansen, T.D. and Aleksenko, A. (2001): A family of
DNA repeats in Aspergillus nidulans has assimilated degenerated
retrotransposons. Mol. Genet. Genomics 265: 883-887.
Sambrook, J., Fritsch, E. and Maniatis T. (1989): Molecular cloning: a
laboratory manual, 2nd ed. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press,
Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
Sonnenberg, A.S., Baars, J.J., Mikosch, T.S., Schaap, P.J. and
VanGriensven, L.J. (1999): Abr1, a transposon-like element in the
genome of the cultivated mushroom Agaricus bisporus (Lange)
Imbach. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 65: 3347-3353.
Yeadon, P.J. and Catcheside, D.E. (1995): Guest: A 98pb inverted repeat
transposable element in Neurospora crassa. Mol. Gen. Genet. 247:
105-109.
97
DISTRIBUTION OF TRANSPOSONS IN BOTRYTIS CINEREA
ISOLATES COLLECTED FROM THE WINE REGIONS OF EGER
AND TOKAJ, HUNGARY
K.Z. Váczy1 , L. Karaffa2 , E. Fekete2 , G.J. Kövics3 , L. Gál1 and E.
Sándor3
1
Research Institute for Viticulture and Enology, Eger, Hungary
Department of Genetics and Applied Microbiology, Faculty of Science, University of
Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
3
Department of Plant Protection, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Debrecen, Debrecen,
Hungary
2
Summary
Analysis of the distribution of the transposable genetic elements Boty and Flipper in
Botrytis cinerea (grey mould) isolates collected from the Eger and Tokaj wine regions,
North-Eastern Hungary is presented. We demonstrate the prevalence of a rare
intrapopulation called Flipper, and discuss the differences among B. cinerea populations
isolated from Western European and South American wine regions.
98
STUDIES OF EVOLUTIONARY RELATIONSHIPS OF
PHOMA SPECIES BASED ON PHYLOGENETIC
MARKERS
1
László Irinyi –1György J. Kövics – 2Mahendra K. Rai – 1Erzsébet Sándor
1
University of Debrecen, Centre of Agricultural Sciences, Department of
Plant Protection, Debrecen, Hungary
2
Department of Biotechnology, SGB Amravati University, Amravati,
Maharashtra, India
Introduction
Phoma is a cosmopolitan genus of coelomycetous fungi. Many species
have been reported from wide range of hosts, substrates, particularly as
pathogens from plants, as well as soil-borne but predominantly saprophytic and
opportunistic species have also been isolated. Almost 2000 Phoma species have
been reported throughout the world till now (Boerema et al., 2004).
There are several ways in the traditional and modern mycology to
contribute to taxonomical studies of fungi including morphology,
biochemistry, nucleic acid sequences and many others.
The three most commonly discussed species concepts are
morphological, biological, and phylogenetic ones. Since the beginning of
mycology, studies of species concept in fungi have been mainly based on
morphological elements. The most of the species and other taxa of Phoma
have so far been determined on the basis of morphology on standardized
media, and gene sequence analysis was only used as a confirmative or
distinctive complement. Thus, members of the genus are primarily defined
by the application of the Morphological Species Recognition (MSR). The
weakness of MSR is that species diagnosed by this often comprise more
than one species when diagnosed by Biological Species Recognition (BSR)
or Phylogenetic Species Recognition (PSR). Biological species concept
defines species as groups of actually or potentially interbreeding natural
populations which are reproductively isolated from other such groups
(Mayr, 1942). BSR is acceptable for many fungi, where sexual reproduction
occurs. But there are also fungal groups, where sexual reproduction has
never been discovered. Approximately 20% of fungi are morphologically
asexual and do not produce meiospores (Reynolds and Taylor, 1993). Since
strains of Phoma spp. apparently can not be crossed, the application of the
BSR concept is impracticable. Though, despite reproducing asexually, many
anamorphic fungi including Phoma spp. are known to possess a surprisingly
high level of genetic variation (Khon, 1995; Talhinhas et al., 2002).
99
The current advances in biochemical and molecular research have
provided mycologists with powerful tools that can be used for delineation of
fungal taxa. The PSR defines species as the smallest aggregation of
populations with a common lineage that share unique, diagnosable
phenotypic characters (Harrington and Rizzo, 1999). According to Taylor et
al. (2000) seems to be well suited for fungi and likely to become very
popular with mycologists, because it can be applied equally both to sexual
and to asexual organisms. Taylor et al. (2000) proposed the Genealogical
Concordance Phylogenetic Species Recognition (GCPSR) for species
defining, which could be an attractive alternative or complement to the
morphological species concept, but has not been widely applied to Phoma
spp. yet. It requires the analysis of several unlinked genes and implies that
the phylogenetic position of a true species is concordant in at least some of
them and can not be contradicted in the others.
Up to now the characterization of Phoma species has been mostly
applied on the basis of morphology, phenotype and physiology. Recently,
Boerema et al. (2004) published Phoma Identification Manual, based on
morphological studies which contains 223 cultural descriptions of specific
and intraspecific taxa of Phoma Sacc.
In the middle of 90s, due to the advances in molecular and biochemical
research of that time molecular markers were identified in Phoma. Some
isozyme analyses were applied to distinct some morphologically identical
Phoma species from each other (Kövics and Gruyter, 1995). Protein
polymorphisms comparing to DNA polymorphisms is unfavorable, because
protein electrophoresis assays the genotype indirectly, and a high proportion
of the variation occurs at the DNA level may not be detectable as it does not
alter the amino acid composition of the protein. Similarly, some changes in
amino acid composition do not change the electrophoretic mobility of the
protein, and remain undetected, leading to different genotypes being
assigned to the same allozyme allele.
DNA polymorphisms are based on differences in DNA sequences and
have three enormous advantages over protein polymorphisms. The first is,
that the sequence differences are detected directly. The second advantage is
that they occur in a genome at very high frequency, and finally, they are not
subject to selection pressure, in case they do not affect the phenotype. But
morphological characterization besides molecular tools will remain a basic
and powerful key in the identification of Phoma species.
One of the most commonly used molecular techniques for assessing
phylogenetic relationships is to evaluate the sequences of certain fungal
DNA regions. Phylogenetic sequence comparisons concentrate on a
comparison of the coding portions of the ribosomal genes and their RNA
products, allowing discrimination at different taxonomic levels. Many
phylogenetic works are based on the internally transcribed spacers (ITS),
100
which are one of the most widely used molecular markers due to their
highly variability in nucleotide sequences.
According to Lutzoni et al. (2004) 83.9% of fungal phylogenies are
based exclusively on sequences from the ribosomal RNA tandem repeats.
Because of it, there is a consequent trend toward inclusion of other gene loci
in the data sets, gathered for phylogenetic analysis. Among these genes,
protein-coding genes like β-tubulin and translation elongation factor (tef1)
can contribute greatly to resolving deep phylogenetic relationships with high
support and/or increase support for topologies inferred using ribosomal
RNA genes.
In this study we have obtained DNA sequences from ITS and translation
elongation factor coding genes to resolve phylogenetic relationships among
several Phoma species, since it has been shown that usage of multigene
datasets can increase the resolution of molecular phylogenetic analyses.
Ribosomal DNA (rDNA) has long been used as a potential marker for
phylogenetic studies (reviewed in Avise, 2004). rRNA genes are organized
in clusters of tandemly repeated units, each of which consists of coding
regions (18S, 5.8S, and 28S; Gerbi, 1985) and 2 internal transcribed spacers
(ITS) and intergenic spacer (formerly called the „ Non-Transcibed Spacer,
NTS) region. While the coding regions are evolutionarily conserved and
have been utilized for phylogenetic inferences for major phyla (reviewed in
Hills and Dixon 1990), the 2 ITS regions are appropriate for detecting
differences between co-specific individuals and are hence potentially useful
markers to study the relationships of populations and closely related species
in fungal, plant, and animal taxa due to their relatively rapid evolutionary
rates (Baldwin, 1992; Schlötterer et al., 1994; Mai and Coleman, 1997;
Weekers et al., 2001; Oliverio et al., 2002; Chen et al., 2000, 2002). In this
study we have obtained a region of nuclear rDNA, containing the internal
transcribed spacer regions 1 and 2 and the 5.8S rDNA (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Schematic structure of ITS region in Phoma spp. and
location of primers for phylogenetic analyses
101
Translation elongation factor 1 subunit alpha (EF1α=tef1) is part of the
cytosolic EF1 complex, whose primary function is to promote the binding of
aminoacyl-tRNA to the ribosome in a GTP-dependent process (Moldave,
1985). It is an essential component of the protein synthesis process in
eukaryotes and archeabacteria. Complexed with GTP, it carries the
aminoacyl-tRNA to the A site of the ribosome-mRNA–peptidyl-tRNA
complex; upon hydrolysis of GTP it leaves the ribosome as EF-1α-GDP.
Simultaneously, elongation factor 1α (EF-1α) is a highly conserved
ubiquitous protein that has been suggested to have desirable properties for
phylogenetic inference (Roger et al., 1999). EF-1α is well suited for
determining phylogenetic relationships, due to its universal occurrence and
presence typically as a single copy within the genome (Baldauf and
Doolittle, 1997). It has been proven to be a useful gene to resolve
phylogenetic relationships at species level as well as in deeper divergences
where amino acid substitutions provide phylogenetic resolution. Here we
have used primer pair which facilitates the PCR amplification of the large
intron of tef1 gene (Druzhinina and Kubicek, 2005, Figure 2).
Figure 2. Schematic structure of tef1 gene in Phoma spp. and
location of primers for phylogenetic analyses
Materials and Methods
Twelve isolates of eleven Phoma species were tested for phylogenetic
analyses in this present study (Table 1). All isolates were identified
morphologically according to Boerema et al. (2004) based on physiological
and morphological characteristics.
Mycelium from isolates were transferred to 100 ml Erlenmayer flasks
containing 50 ml malt broth (2% malt exract). The cultures were grown at
room temperature for 48 hours in the dark on a rotary shaker (125rpm). The
mycelium was harvested by vacuum filtration. Total genomic DNA was
extracted from freeze-dried mycelium and isolated using the E.Z.N.A.® TM
102
Fungal DNA Isolation Kit (Omega Bio-tek, Inc., USA) according to the
protocol (as following the manufacture instructions).
Primers used to amplify the ITS region containing the internal
transcribed spacer regions 1 and 2 and the 5.8S rDNA are based on
published composite sequences, SR6R and LR1 (White et al., 1990) with
the following amplification protocol: 3 min initial denaturing at 95°C,
followed by 5 cycles of 1 min at 95°C, 1 min annealing at 50°C, 1 min at
72°C and 25 cycles of 1 min at 90°C, 1 min annealing at 50°C, 1min at
72°C and 15 min final extension at 72°C. The large intron of the tef1 gene
was amplified by the EF1-728F and EF1-986R primer pair (Druzhinina and
Kubicek, 2005) according to the following program: 3 min initial denaturing
at 95°C, followed by 5 cycles of 1 min at 95°C, 1 min annealing at 59°C, 1
min at 72°C and 25 cycles of 1 min at 90°C, 1 min annealing at 59°C, 1min
at 72°C and 15 min final extension at 72°C. Purified amplification products
were sequenced by MWG Biotech Company in Germany.
The obtained DNA sequences were aligned first with ClustalX
(Thompson et al., 1997) and manually adjusted using Genedoc (Nicholas et
al., 1997). Single gaps were treated either as missing data or as the fifth base
and multistate characters were treated as uncertain.
Phylogenetic analyses were performed in PAUP*4.0b (Swofford, 2002).
The following settings were used: heuristic search with tree bisectionreconnection (TBR), with random addition of sequences with 1000
replicates. Stability of clades was assessed with 1000 bootstrap replications.
Results
Twelve isolates of eleven Phoma species were compared in this study.
The morphological identification of the isolates was done following the
descriptions of Boerama et al. (2004). The obtained results indicated that the
microscopical and cultural characteristics of the concerned Phoma isolates
fit to the identity of Phoma species given in Table 1.
103
Table 1. Isolates of Phoma species
Isolate number
Species
Host of
origin
Our collection
Original
Phoma eupyrena
D/058
CBS 375.91
Phoma destructiva
D/033
?
Phoma pinodella
D/035
D/035
Phoma foveata
D/048
PD 76/1021
Phoma herbarum
D/143
MTCC
2319
?
D/075
D/075
Glycine max
D/077
D/077
Glycine max
Phoma exigua var.
exigua
Phoma exigua var.
exigua
Phoma exigua var.
linicola
Phoma glomerata
D/071
PD 86/73
D/034
D/034
Phoma multirostrata
D/044
PD 77/508
Phoma plurivora
D/072
PD 75/907
Phyllosticta sojicola
(=Phoma exigua var.
exigua ?)
D/050
CBS 301.39
Phaseolus
vulgaris
Lycopersicon
esculentum
Glycine max
Chenopodium
quinoa
Linum
usitatissimum
Glycine max
Phylodendron
sp.
Medicago
sativa
Glycine max
Translation elongation factor
We amplified and sequenced a 0.2 kb fragment of the large intron of the
tef1 gene from twelve isolates of eleven Phoma species and subjected it
together with the ITS1-5.8Sr-DNA-ITS2 to a combined parsimony analysis
with PAUP.
For phylogenetic analyses of tef1 fragments we involved other Phoma and
Ascochyta species as well as Claviceps and Leptosphaeria species as
outgroup, all were downloaded from GenBank maintained by the NCBI
(Table 2). Didymella fabae and Didymella lentis are the teleomorph of
Ascochyta fabae and Ascochyta lentis, (Kaiser et al., 1997).
104
Table 2. Species involved in the phylogenetic analyses of tef1
fragments
Species
Leptosphaerulina trifolii
Ascochyta pisi
teleomorf: Didymella lentis
anamorf: Ascochyta lentis
Ascochyta fabae f. sp.
viciae
(= Ascochyta fabae)
teleomorf: Didymella lentis
anamorf: Ascochyta lentis
teleomorf: Didymella fabae
anamorf: Ascochyta fabae
Claviceps sorghi
Claviceps sorghi
Phoma pinodella
Phoma pinodella
Isolation
code
WAC 6693
AP2
Accession
number
AY831543.1
DQ386494.1
SAT AL
AY831546.1
AV11
DQ386498.1
AL1
DQ386493.1
AF1
DQ386492.1
?
?
CBS 318.90
WAC 7978
AY960837.1
AY960836.1
AY831542.1
AY831545.1
According to the phylogenetic tree based on tef1 sequences (Figure 3),
the Phoma species are well separated from their closely related Ascochyta
taxa.
As the identification of Phoma and Ascochyta genus based on
morphological characteristics is often problematic, this new phylogenetic
marker can be a useful tool for mycologists identifying an unknown species.
105
Figure 3. Phylogenetic relationships of Phoma strains inferred by the
parsimony analysis of tef1 sequences. The numbers above the lines
represent the bootstrap (bootstrap=1000) values. The columns on the right
side represent the Phoma sections based on morphological characterization
Most of Phoma species (P. plurivora, P. herbarum, P. desrtuctiva, P.
glomerata) are well separated from the other tested Phoma species. Some
Phoma species constitute clades but there are some species which can not be
distinguished on the basis of tef1 sequences (Phoma pinodella and Phoma
eupyrena as well as Phoma foveata and Phoma multirostrata). The species
represented by more than one isolate are classified in the same subgroup,
which proves that the tef1 sequences are well suited for delineating
phylogenetic relationships within the Phoma genus.
The Phyllosticta sojicola associates with the Phoma exigua var. exigua
subgroups which support the statement that the two species are identical
(Kövics et al., 1999).
106
The phylogenetic tree based on tef1 sequences does not support the
traditional Phoma sections based on morphological characterization
(Boerema et al., 2004).
On the basis of our investigation, carried out with tef1 sequences all
Phoma species form a well distinguishable group from the Ascochyta
species, which proves the monophyletic origin of Phoma genus.
Up to now, phylogenetic analyses within Phoma genus have only been used
for defining phylogenetic relationships among isolates within one species
(Mendes et al., 2003 and Balmas et al., 2005).
Here we have used the translational elongation factor to resolve
phylogenetic relationships within Phoma genus at higher taxonomic levels.
The present study has proved the tef1 region to be phylogenetically useful
tool for defining Phoma species but further investigations would be
necessary to clarify whether the tef1 gene sequence as phylogenetic
molecular marker is well suited for the classification of Phoma species.
ITS sequences
In the PCR reaction 0.6kb fragment of the rDNA gene containing the
internal transcribed spacer regions 1 and 2 and the 5.8S regions was
amplified.
For phylogenetic analyses of ITS region we involved other Phoma and
Ascochyta species as well as Didymella and Leptosphaeria species as
outgroup, all were downloaded from GenBank maintained by the NCBI
(Table 3).
The phylogenetic tree based on ITS sequences (Figure 4) is drawn by
parsimony analyis.
The difference between the different Phoma and Ascochyta,
Leptosphaeria and Didymella species was not significant, 23 sites were
considered as informative for the parsimony analysis. Moreover only 3
clades were supported by the bootstrap analysis with more than 80%
probability.
We can state from the parsimony tree that the Phyllosticta sojicola
grouped with the Phoma exigua, as we were able to state from the analysis
of tef1 sequences. Phoma foveata and Phoma multirostrata also grouped
together both in ITS and tef1 analysis.
ITS sequences should analyzed with other methods (like MEGA or
maximum likelihood), which may draw a much supported tree.
107
Table 3. Species involved in the phylogenetic analyses
of ITS fragments
Species
Isolation code
Phoma exigua var.
heteromorpha
Phoma exigua
?
Phoma exigua var.
populi
Phoma exigua var.
linicola
Phoma exigua
Phoma herbarum
Phoma herbarum
Phoma pinodella
Phoma pinodella
Phoma pinodella
Phoma pinodella
Phoma glomerata
Phoma glomerata
Phoma glomerata
Phoma eupyrena
Leptosphaerulina
trifolii
Ascochyta sp.
Ascochyta pisi
Ascochyta lentis
Didymella lentis
Didymella fabae
Accession
number
AY899262.1
CSL
20316964
CBS 100167
AY550992.1
CBS 113.28
AF268187.1
?
?
ATCC 12569
VPRI 32177
VPRI 32171
CBS 318.90
WAC 7978
?
?
?
Gr61
WAC 6693
AY927784.1
DQ132841.1
AY293803.1
DQ087402.1
DQ087400.1
AY831562.1
AY831556.1
AF126816.1
AY618248.1
AY183371.1
AJ890436.1
AY831558.1
Georgia6
AP1
MU AL1
AL1
AF1
DQ383955.1
DQ383954.1
AY131201.1
DQ383953.1
DQ383952.1
108
AF268189.1
Figure 4. Phylogenetic relationships of Phoma strains inferred by the
parsimony analysis of ITS sequences. The numbers above the lines
represent the bootstrap (bootstrap=1000) values. The columns on the
right side represent the Phoma section based on morphological
characterization.
Discussion
tef1 sequences are well suitable for phylogenetic analysis of Phoma species
similarly to other mycetous fungi (Druzhinina and Kubicek, 2005). The
phylogenetic analysis of ITS sequences by parsimony method has not given
a definite result. One possible reason for this can be that there were limited
variable sites in ITS sequences. This can mean that the evolutionary
distance by ITS sequences within Phoma species is too small to get well
based consequences for the phylogenetic relationships of Phoma genus. So
similarly to the Trichoderma genus we should involved other sequences in
phylogenetic analysis like tef1 or β-tubulin sequences.
109
Both sequence analyses confirmed that the Phyllosticta sojicola species is
identical to the Phoma exigua var. exigua species as Kövics et al., 1999
claimed.
References
Avise, J.C. (2004): Molecular markers, natural history, and evolution. 2nd
ed. Underland, MA: Sinauer Associates
Baldauf, S.L. and Doolittle, W.F. (1997): Origin and evolution of slime
molds (Mycetozoa). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94: 12007-12012.
Baldwin, B.G. (1992): Phylogenetic utility of the internal transcribed
spacers of nuclear ribosomal DNA in plants: an example from the
Compositae. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 1: 3-16.
Balmas, V., Scherm, B., Ghignone, S., Salem, A.O.M., Cacciola, S.O.,
Migheli, Q. (2005): Characterisation of Phoma tracheiphila by RAPDPCR, microsatellite-primed PCR and ITS rDNA sequencing and
development of species primers for in planta PCR detection. European
Journal of Plant Pathology 111: 235-247.
Boerema, G.H., Gruyter, J. de, Noordeloos, M.E., Hamers, M.E.C. (2004):
Phoma identification manual. CABI Publishing. CAB International
Wallingford, Oxfordshire, UK
Chen, C.A., Wallace, C.C., Wolstenholme, J. (2002): Analysis of mitochondrial
12S RNA gene supports a two-clade hypothesis of the evolutionary
history of scleractinian corals. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 23: 137-149.
Chen, C.A., Yu, J.K., Wei, N.W. (2000): Strategies for amplification by
polymerase chain reaction of the complete sequence of nuclear large
subunit ribosomal RNA-encoding gene in corals. Mar. Biotechnol. 6:
558-570.
Druzhinina, I. and Kubicek, C.P. (2005): Species concepts and biodiversity
in Trichoderma and Hypocrea: from aggregate species to species
cluster? J. Zhejiang Univ. Sci. 6B (2): 100-112.
Gerbi, S.A. (1985): Evolution of ribosomal DNA. pp. 419-517. In:
Molecular evolutionary genetics. Macintyre, R. J. (Ed.) Plenum, New
York
Harrington, T.C., and Rizzo, D.M. (1999): Defining species in the fungi. pp.
43-70. In: Structure and Dynamics of Fungal Populations. Worral, J.J.
(Ed.) Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht
Hillis, D.M., Dixon, M.T. (1991): Ribosomal DNA: molecular evolution
and phylogenetic inference. Q. Rev. Biol. 66: 411-453.
Kaiser, W.J., Wang, B.-C., and Rogers, J.D. (1997): Ascochyta fabae and A.
lentis: Host specificity, teleomorphs (Didymella), Hybrid analysis,
and taxonomic status. Plant Dis. 81: 809-816.
110
Khon, L.M. (1995): The clonal dynamic in wild and agricultural plantpathogen populations. Canadian Journal of Botany 73. (Suppl. 1): S
1231-1240.
Kövics, G.J. and Gruyter, J. de (1995): Comparable esterase isozyme
analysis of some Phoma species occur on soybean. (A szóján
előforduló néhány Phoma faj észteráz izoenzim mintázatainak
összehasonlító vizsgálata.) Proceedings of Debrecen Agricultural
University (DATE Tudományos Közleményei) 31: 191-207.
Kövics, G.J., Gruyter, J. de, Aa, H.A. van der (1999): Phoma sojicola comb.
nov. and other hyaline-spored coelomycetes pathogenic on soybean.
Mycol. Res. 103 (8): 1065-1070.
Lutzoni, F., Kauff, F., Cox, C.J., McLaughlin, D., Celio, G., Dentinger, B.,
Padamsee, M., Hibbett, D., James, T.Y., Baloch, E., Grube, M., Reeb,
V., Hofstetter, V., Schoch, C., Arnold, A. E., Miadlikowska, J.,
Spatafora, J., Johnson, D., Hambleton, S., Crockett, M., Shoemaker,
R., Sung, G.H., Lucking, R., Lumbsch, T., O’Donnell, K., Binder, M.,
Diederich, P., Ertz, D., Gueidan, C., Hansen, K., Harris, R.C., Hosaka,
K., Lim, Y.W., Matheny, B., Nishida, H., Pfister, D., Rogers, J.,
Rossman, A., Schmitt, I., Sipman, H., Stone, J., Sugiyama, J., Yahr,
R., Vilgalys, R. (2004): Assembling the fungal tree of life: progress
classi.cation and evolution of subcellular traits. Am. J. Bot. 91: 14461480.
Mai, J.C. and Coleman, A.W. (1997): The internal transcribed spacer 2
exhibits a common secondary structure in green algae and flowering
plants. J. Mol. Evol. 44: 258-271.
Mayr, E. (1942): Systematics and the origin of species from a viewpoint of a
zoologist. Columbia University Press, New York
Mendes-Pereira, E., Balesdent, M.-H., Brun, H., Rouxel, T. (2003):
Molecular phylogeny of the Leptosphaeria maculans-L. biglobosa
species complex. Mycol. Res. 107 (11): 1287-1304.
Moldave, K. (1985): Eukaryotic protein synthesis. Annu. Rev. Biochem. 54:
1109-1149.
Nicholas, K.B., Nicholas, H.B.Jr., Deerfield, D.W. II. (1997): GeneDoc:
Analysis and Visualization of Genetic Variation, Embnew. news 4:
14
Oliverio, M., Cervelli, M., Mariottini, P. (2002): ITS2 rRNA evolution and
its congruence with the phylogeny of muricid neogastropods
(Caenogastropoda, Muricoidea). Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 25: 63-69.
Reynolds, D.R., Taylor, J.W. (1993): The fungal holomorph: An overview.
pp. 15-25. In: The fungal holomorph: mitotic, meiotic and
pleomorphic speciation in fungal systematics. Reynolds, D.R. and
Taylor, J.W. (Eds.) CAB International, Wallingford, UK
111
Roger, A.J., Sandblom, O., Doolittle, W.F., Philippe, H. (1999): An
evaluation of elongation factor 1α as a phylogenetic marker for
eukaryots. Mol. Biol. Evol. 16: 218-233.
Schlötterer, C., Hauser, M., Haeseler, A. von, Tautz, D. (1994):
Comparative evolutionary analysis of rDNA ITS regions in
Drosophila. Mol. Biol. Evol. 11: 513-522.
Swofford, D.L. (2002): PAUP: Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony
(and other methods). Version 4b10. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland,
MA
Talhinhas, P., Sreenivasaprasad, S., Neves-Martins, J. Oliveira, H. (2002):
Genetic and morphological characterization of Colletotrichum
acutatum causing anthracnose of lupins. Phytopathology 92: 986-996.
Taylor, J.W., Jacobson, D.J., Kroken, S., Kasuga, T., Geiser, D.M., Hibbett,
D.S., Fisher, M.C. (2000): Phylogenetic species recognition and
species concepts in fungi. Fungal Genet. Biol. 31: 21-32.
Thompson, J.D., Gibson, T.J., Plewniak, F., Jeanmougin, F., Higgins, D.G.
(1997): The ClustalX windows interface: flexible strategies for
multiple sequence alignment aided by quality analysis tools. Nucleic
Acids Research, 24: 4876-4882.
Weekers, P.H.H., Jonckheere, F.J. de, Dumont, H.J. (2001): Phylogenetic
relationships inferred from ribosomal ITS sequences and
biogeographic patterns in representative of the genus Calopteryx
(Insecta: Odonata) of the West Mediterranean and adjacent west
European zone. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 20: 89-99.
White, T.J., Bruns, T., Lee, S., Taylor, J. (1990): Amplification and direct
sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes for phylogenetics. pp.
315-322. In: PCR protocols. A guide to methods and applications.
Innis, M.A., Gelfand, D.H., Sninsky, J.J., White, T.J. (Eds.) Academic
Press, New York
112
STUDIES OF EVOLUTIONARY RELATIONSHIPS OF PHOMA
SPECIES BASED ON PHYLOGENETIC MARKERS
1
L. Irinyi ,1G.J. Kövics , 2M.K. Rai and 1E. Sándor
1
University of Debrecen, Centre of Agricultural Sciences, Department of Plant Protection,
Debrecen, Hungary
2
Department of Biotechnology, SGB Amravati University, Amravati, Maharashtra, India
Summary
The cosmopolitan Phoma genus contains mainly phytopathogenic, opportunistic parasite,
and saprophyte fungal species. Up to now the characterization of Phoma species and other
taxa of Phoma has so far been determined on the basis of morphology on standardized
media, and gene sequence analysis was only used as a confirmative or distinctive
complement.
In this study we have tried to find molecular markers which can be used as phylogenetic
markers in the molecular based classification in the Phoma genus.
We employed a part of the translation elongation factor 1 subunit alpha (EF-1α=tef1)
containing both introns and exons and ITS region containing the internal transcribed spacer
regions 1 and 2 and the 5.8S rDNA, as a potential genetic markers to infer phylogenetic
relationships among different Phoma taxa. Twelve different Phoma species sequences were
analysed together with the closely related Ascochyta ones. The constructed phylogenetic
trees based on tef1 and ITS sequences, do not support the traditional Phoma sections based
on morphological characterization. However we have managed to distinct the Phoma
strains and Ascochyta species comparing their tef1 sequences by parsimony analysis. We
have proved that a tef1 can be a useful phylogenetic marker to resolve phylogenetic
relationships at species level in Phoma genus.
Both parsimony sequence analyses confirmed that the Phyllosticta sojicola species is
identical to the Phoma exigua var. exigua species as Kövics et al. (1999) claimed. However
the evolutionary distance by ITS sequences within Phoma species is too small to get well
based consequences for the phylogenetic relationships of Phoma genus.
Further investigations would be necessary to clarify whether the tef1 and ITS sequences as
phylogenetic molecular markers are well suited for the classification of Phoma species.
113
114
ENTOMOLOGICAL AND
INTEGRATED PEST MANAGEMENT
SESSION
115
116
ONE NEUTRAL MODEL IN SPECIES ABUNDANCE
DISTRIBUTION OF ARTHROPODS IN AGRO
ECOSYSTEMS
Adalbert Balog 1, 2 – Zoltán Néda3, 4 – Aranka Derzsi3 – Viktor Markó 2
1
Hungarian University of Transylvania, Faculty of Technical and
Humanities Science, Marosvásárhely/Tg-Mures, Romania,
2
Corvinus University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural Science,
Department of Entomology, Budapest, Hungary
3
Babes-Bolyai University, Faculty of Physics, Department of Theoretical
and Computational Physics, Cluj-Napoca, Romania,
4
Los Alamos National Laboratory, Center for Nonlinear Science, Los
Alamos, USA
The relative species abundances distribution (RSA) has been experimentally
studied for different plant and animal communities, inspiring theoretical
works and modeling efforts (Tokeshi, 1993, 1999; Harte et al., 1999; Harte
2000; Hubbell 2001; Sizling and Storch, 2004). Targeting neutral-like
communities where the individuals from different species compete with
each other solely for the limited amount of resources are especially
important nowadays for verifying the applicability of neutral macroecology
models (Dewdney, 2000; Moulliot et al., 2000; Hubbell 2001; Maguran and
Henderson, 2003; Norris, 2003). Most of the experimental data on RSA are
for such communities (trees in tropical forest, moths, birds etc.) (Dirks,
1937; Condit et al., 1996; Condit, 1998; Keitt and Stanley, 1998) and
confirm the prediction of neutral-like theories (Hubbel and Foster, 1983;
Price et al., 1995; McGill, 2003; Norris, 2003; Sauer et al., 2003; Sizling
and Storch, 2004; Ravasz et al., 2005; Néda et al., 2005). For the considered
experimental samples the shape of RSA suggests at a first glance a
qualitatively different behavior. Statistical methods on insect populations
have been used for a long time to predict population outbreaks, extinctions
or even endemics-area relationships (Pielou, 1977; Luff and Eyre, 1988;
Pueyo, 2006). Unfortunately the empirical correlative methods usually
failed to give satisfactory predictions as the unexplained or immeasurable
sources of variations (winter disappearance, hide larval stages or even the
collection methods) were large and not likely to be predicted. Most of the
methods have limited applications because they lack the flexibility to
incorporate in a dynamic way much of the relevant biology of the organisms
involved and the vagaries of population survival through time as influenced
by weather. For ecological and conservation purposes, it is thus of primary
interest to find statistical laws, that could yield additional information on the
117
whole community and which could be later correlated with parameters that
give information about the dynamics of the system. Apart of it’s
macroecological importance, obtaining information on the shape of the RSA
could be helpful for understanding universal or specific features of insect
communities and would give also an important testing ground for complex
models that aim to reproduce or predict the dynamics of such communities
(Luff and Eyre 1988).
Materials and Methods
Experimental data: Barro Colorado Island (BCI) data set Smithsonian
Tropical Research Institute - rainforest ecosystem studies.
Trees are sampled in a 50-ha region, the first census was completed in 1983,
with recensuses occurring every 5 years since. All stems greater than 10 mm
diameter were mapped (Figure 1.).
Figure 1. Barro Colorado Island experimental site.
Our data sets used were collected by us from agricultural environments
(apple and pear orchards). Predacious insects were sampled from soil to
canopy level in the periods 1998 and 2003 in Central-Europe - Hungary.
In apple and pear orchards for samples at the soil level, covered pitfall traps
(300 cm³ in size, 8 cm in diameter, half-filled with ethylene glycol 30%
solution) were used between 1998 and 2003. Ten pitfall traps were placed in
nine localities at 10-m intervals from each other. At the canopy level the
insects were collected with conventional beating method. The investigated
orchards were situated in three geographical regions and were surrounded
by different habitats. These were agricultural lowland environments,
regularly flooded area and woodland areas of medium height mountains.
The soil compositions in the investigated orchards were sand, sandy-loam
118
and clay, respectively. In some orchards intensive treatments were used and
the pest management was based on wide spectrum (mainly
organophosphorus) insecticides (Ultracid 50 WP, Zolone 35 EC, Dimecron
50 WP). The other orchards were treated with integrated pest management
methods (IPM) or were untreated, i.e. neither pesticides nor fertilizers were
used for five years before we started our investigations. We have to
emphasize here that our results suggested no significant differences in the
species composition and activity abundances for the differently managed
orchards. In these orchards the studied insect orders and families were rove
beetles (Coleoptera: Staphylinidae) collected from soil and canopy level
and ground beetles (Coleoptera: Carabidae) collected only from soil level.
The statistics of the species abundances were studied in different levels,
time-periods and spatial resolution, grouping or not different families. The
U(r) probability density characterizing the relative species abundances
distribution (RSA) was computed by the classical method: counting the
number Nk of species with sizes, r, between 2k and 2k+1 (k=1,2,3 ….), i.e.
constructing a histogram on intervals that are not of constant length, but are
exponentially increasing. In this manner the large statistical fluctuations
from the tail of the distribution function is greatly reduced. In order to
obtain the rigorously defined probability density, U(r), one must divide Nk
with the exponentially increasing size of the interval, 'r=2k, and by the
total number of species, N: U(r)=Nk/(N.2x). Constructing the distribution
functions in this manner one will obtain a monotonically decreasing
function, which for a good statistics can be usually well approximated with
a power-law that presents and exponential cutoff. Plotting it on a log-log
scale one obtains thus the characteristic tilted J-shape curve. The initial
slope of the U(r) curves (the power-law behavior) will characterize the
scale-invariant nature of the RSA.
Results
Our model is a complex, spatially extended model combine the essential
parameters of mean-field type approaches (birth, migration, death) and the
spatiality of Potts-type models. The square lattice definition - each lattice
site can be occupied by many individuals belonging to different species consequently a lattice site corresponds to an area in which the spatiality is
neglected.
Realistically the total number of individuals on a lattice site isn’t fixed, it
can fluctuate around a given N0 value that characterizes the limited amount
of available resources in a given territory. The death rate (d) depends on the
119
instantaneous number of individuals (N) in each lattice site according to the
1− d
following relation: d = d ( N ) = 1 − N − N 0
0
e
+1
If N>N0, the death probability increases (if an area become over-populated,
the birth/death rate decreases). d0 is the death rate when N=0. If N tends to
∞ the death rate tends to 1. The α parameter controls the steepness of the
curve: the smaller the value of α, the steeper the curve (Figure 2).
α
A
B
N0=1000, d0=0.2, α=50
N0=1000, d0=0.2, α=200
Figure 2. The graphs of the death-rate function in case of two different (N0,
d0, α) combinations.
Individuals in the system can give birth to individuals belonging to the same
or to a new species (mutation) with b probability and m respectively.
The spatiality of the model implies that the individuals can migrate to one of
the neighboring sites (cells). This migration is characterized by the q
migration rate.
With w probability an individual from a randomly chosen species can be
assigned to a randomly chosen lattice site – immigration of individuals from
the metacommunity. While in case of mutation a new species shows up, in
case of immigration the species of the immigrant individual is randomly
selected from the defined set of species.
The dynamics of the model
1. the size of the square lattice
2. the number of species in the metacommunity
3. the parameters of the model: d0, α, b, m, q and w
4. the initial number of individuals on the lattice: Z
5. Initialization of the system: Z individuals from randomly chosen
species are assigned to randomly chosen lattice sites
120
6. Starting the dynamics if the system: In each simulation step with
the initially fixed probabilities each individual can double itself,
give birth to an individual belonging to a new species, die or
migrate to one of the neighboring sites. With initially fixed
probability one individual from randomly chosen species can
enter into the system to a random position (immigration)
7. The dynamics goes on until the dynamical equilibrium sets in.
Simulation is done with the kinetic Monte Carlo method (BKL method).
The spatial distribution of the most abundant species was presented in
Figure 3, where the experimental dates (BCI) and the simulation dates are
compared.
a.
b.
Figure 3. Spatial distribution of the most abundant species, a. experimental
(BCI), b. simulation, simulation parameters: lattice size=15, initial number
of species=400, initial number of individuals=5000 b=0.3, m=10-5, q=5*104, w=10-5, d0=0.1, N0=1500, α=50
Application
First we present the results obtained for the RSA in apple and pear orchards
focusing on rove beetles (Coleoptera: Staphylinidae). Our statistics here is
based on total of 7310 individuals collected in nine different locations
during a five year period, with ten pitfall traps in each location.
On Figures 4a through 4c we consecutively consider larger and larger
samples including more and more locations and sampling time. On Figure
4a we have plotted on a log-log scale the RSA obtained in one year (2000)
for three different locations, considering for each location the rove beetles
collected in all pitfall traps (1289 individuals from 61 species). Studying the
RSA separately for each trap is not relevant, since the number of collected
individuals in one year and one trap is too small for a reasonable statistics.
Although the statistics for one year and one location is not impressive either
121
(in medium we have 430 individuals) the probability density suggest a
power-law behavior, with an exponent between -1.44 and -1.9. For guiding
the eye we have plotted the power-law with -1 exponent that usually
characterizes the RSA for neutral-like communities. On Figure 4b the RSA
is plotted for the same three locations but considering now the individuals
collected during the whole study period, i.e from 1998 to 2002 (3191
individuals from 162 species). The shape of the RSA suggests again a scalefree (power-law) behavior on an interval larger than two orders of
magnitude. The calculated scaling exponents are between -1.48 and -1.63.
Finally, on Figure 4c we have plotted the RSA obtained from the whole data
set, considering all the traps from all locations and for all the study years
(7210 individuals from 250 species). The result suggests again a power-law
nature, with a scaling exponent -1.51.
Figure 4. RSA for rove beetles (Coleoptera: Staphylinidae) sampled in
apple and pear orchards. Figure a presents results for a one year sampling
(2000) in three different location in Hungary (East Europe), using ten pitfall
traps in each location. Figure b presents results for the same three locations,
but considering a five year period sampling. Figure c presents the RSA for
the whole sampled community (nine locations during a five year sampling
period). On all graphs the dashed line indicates the power-law behavior with
scaling exponent -1.
In the same apple and pear orchards we have studied also the RSA for
ground beetles (Coleoptera: Carabidae). On figs 5a-5c the same type of
graphs are plotted as for the rove beetles in fig 4a-4c. The results are also
pretty similar, although for this insect family we had a much better statistics,
based on a total number of 25580 individuals from 172 species. This is
clearly visible on fig 5c, where a scaling law is visible for the shape of the
RSA extending on almost four orders of magnitude! The scaling exponent
for the whole sampled community is -1.35, somewhat smaller than the value
obtained for rove beetles.
122
Figure 5. RSA for ground beetles (Coleoptera: Carabidae) sampled in the
same apple and pear orchards. Figure a presents results for a one year
sampling (2000) in the same three different location in Hungary, East
Europe (the exponents of the power-law fit are between -1.34 to -1.64).
Figure b presents results for the same three locations, but considering a five
year period sampling (the exponents of the power-law fit are between -1.25
and -1.49). Figure c presents the RSA for the whole sampled community
(nine different locations during a five year sampling period). On all graphs
the dashed line indicates the power-law behavior with exponent -1.
Considering now together the two insect orders (32790 individuals of rove
and ground beetles from 422 species) and computing the RSA for the whole
sampled community (five year sampling period, nine different locations) we
already get a curve that resembles the tilted J shape observed in neutral-like
communities (Figure 6). The exponent for the initial part of the RSA, -1.3, is
however different from the usually observed -1 value.
Figure 6. RSA considering together rove and ground beetles (Coleoptera:
Staphylinidae and Carabidae, respectively), computed from a five year
sampling period in nine different apple or pear orchards. The dashed line
indicates the power-law behavior with exponent -1.
123
Preliminary results are encouraging and suggest that our approach is able to
describe all major statistical aspects of neutral systems.
The model has to be investigated for various parameters and the results of
the simulations have to be compared with other experimental databases.
Focusing on a specific insect family most of our data suggests a power-law
nature for the RSA curve. From the results on ground beetles and rove
beetles one can observe that the scaling can be valid on abundance intervals
up to three orders of magnitude, which is quite impressive! Combining
results for more years, more localities or traps does not destroy the apparent
power-law nature of the RSA, although the scaling exponent can change in a
broad interval ranging from -1.9 to -1.3. It is however too soon for
concluding that for a given insect family the RSA has a power-law nature
and sampling with even better statistics should be done. We believe that
most of the insect species and many of the specimens are invisible for our
sampling methods, especially the larval stage of many species could not be
sampled as the adults and we have studied thus only the “top of the
iceberg”. This incomplete sampling could be also responsible for the fact
that the scaling observed in the rare species limit does not show the 1/r –
type behavior (-1 scaling exponent) observed for other communities
(tropical trees, breeding birds).
The computer code is appropriate for pedagogical purposes, the software
can be found in the following site:
URL: htp:/atom.ubcluj.ro/ aderzsi/neutral.html
Acknowledgments
The present research was supported by the Institute of Research Programs of
Sapientia Foundation, and the Bolyai János research fellowship accorded by
the Hungarian Academy of Science.
References
Condit, R. (1998) Tropical Forest Census Plots, Springer. Verlag and R. G.
Landes Company, Berlin, Germany and Georgetown, Texas.
Condit, R., Hubbell, S.P. and Foster, R.B. (1996) Changes in tree species
abundance in a Neotropical forest: impact of climate change. Journal
of Tropical Ecology 12: 231-256.
Dewdney, A.K. (2000) A dynamical model of communities and a new
Species-Abundances Distribution. Biologycal Bulletin 198: 152-165.
Dirks, C.O. (1937) Biological studies of Maine moths by light trap methods.
The Maine Agriculture Experiment Station, Bulletin 389, Orono.
Harte, J., Kinzig A., and Green J. (1999) Self-similarity in the distribution
and abundance of species. Science 286: 334-336.
124
Harte, J. (2000) Scaling and self-similarity in species distributions:
implications for extinction, species richness, abundance and range.
In: Scaling in Ecology eds. Brown, J.H. and West, G.B., pp. 325342.
Hubbell, S.P. and Foster, R.B. (1983) Diversity of canopy trees in a
neotropical forest and implications for conservation. In: S.L. Sutton,
T.C. Whitmore, and A.C. Chadwick (eds.) Tropical Rain Forest,
Ecology and Management, pp. 25-41.
Hubbel, S.P. (2001) The Unified Neutral Theory of Biodiversity and
Biogeography. Princeton Univ.Press, Princeton, New Jersey
Keitt, T.H. and Stanley H.E. (1998) Dynamics of North American breeding
bird populations. Nature, 393: 257-260.
Luff, M.L. and Eyre, M.D. (1988) Soil-surface activity of weevils
(Coleoptera: Curculionidae) in grassland. Pedobiologia, 32: 39-46.
Magurran, A.E. and Henderson, P.A. (2003) Explaining the excess of rare
species in natural species abundance distributions. Nature 42: 714–
716.
McGill, B.J. (2003) A test of the unified neutral theory of biodiversity.
Nature 442, 881-885.
Moulliot, D., Lepretre, A., Andrei-Ruiz, M.C. and Viale, D. (2000) The
fractal model: a new model to describe the species accumulation
process and relative abundance distribution (RAD). Oikos, 90, 333–
342.
Néda, Z., Ravasz, M. and Balog, A. (2005) Species Abundance Distribution
in a Neutral Community model. Studia Universitatis Babeş-Bolyai,
Physica, L2, 63-79.
Norris, S. (2003) Neutral Theory, a New, Unified Model of Ecology.
BioScience 53: 124-129.
Pielou, E.C. (1977) Mathematical Ecology. John Willey & Sons, New York.
Price, J. Droege, S. and Price, A. (1995) The summer Atlas of North
American Birds. Academic Press, San Diego.
Pueyo, S. (2006) Self-similarity in species - area relationship and in species
abundance distribution. Oikos 112: 156-162.
Ravasz, M., Balog, A., Markó, V. and Néda, Z. 2005. The Species
Abundances Distribution in a new perspective, preprint,
http://www.arxiv.org/abs/q-bio.PE/0503026).
Sauer, J.R., Hines, J.E. and Fallon, J. (2003) The North American Breeding
Bird Survey, Results and Analysis. - 1966-2000 Version 2003.1
(USGS, Patuxent Wildlife Research Center, Laurel, Maryland).
Available at (ftp://pwrcftpr.er.usgs.gov/mp/bbs/DataFiles/).
Sizling, A.L. and Storch, D. (2004) Power-law species-area relationship and
self-similar species distribution within finite areas. Ecology Letters,
7: 60-68.
125
Tokeshi, M. (1993) Species abundance patterns and community structure.
Advances in Ecological Research 24: 111–186.
Tokeshi, M. (1999) Species coexistence. Blackwell, Oxford.
ONE NEUTRAL MODEL IN SPECIES ABUNDANCE
DISTRIBUTION OF ARTHROPODS IN AGRO ECOSYSTEMS
A. Balog1, 2, Z. Néda3, 4, A. Derzsi3 and V. Markó2
1
Hungarian University of Transylvania, Faculty of Technical and Humanities Science,
Marosvásárhely/Tg-Mures, Romania
2
Corvinus University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural Science, Department of
Entomology, Budapest, Hungary
3
Babes-Bolyai University, Faculty of Physics, Department of Theoretical and
Computational Physics, Kolozsvár/Cluj-Napoca, Romania
4
Los Alamos National Laboratory, Center for Nonlinear Science, Los Alamos, USA
Summary
In this work we present and discuss results for RSA on insect’s families, which are not
necessarily neutral. The relative species abundances (RSA) are investigated for two insect
families (rove beetles – Coleoptera: Staphylinidae, and ground beetles – Coleoptera:
Carabidae).
For a given insect group the results obtained for the shape of RSA calculated from the
rigorously defined probability density suggests a nontrivial scaling.
Studying the finite-size effects, we argued that accepting the form f0(x) for SAD, one can
derive also an interesting scaling relation between the size of the most abundant species
(Ns), the total number of individuals (NT) and the number of detected species (ST) in the
considered habitat: F(NT,NS,ST)=STNS/[NT(ln(NS)-1)]=2.
The observed trend is qualitatively different from the shape of the RSA computed from
previous studies in neutral-like communities (tropical trees or breeding birds).
We argue however that the apparently different trend is not necessarily a real effect and
could well be a consequence of the incomplete sampling. For a clear conclusion sampling
with even better statistics should be performed.
126
ACTUAL PROBLEMS IN PLANT PROTECTION OF
PEAR ORCHARDS
Gábor Jenser–Sándor Süle –Éva Szita – Judit V. Tarjányi
Plant Protection Institute of HAS, Budapest, Hungary
So far, the application of the insecticides and fungicides has been
determined by the requirement of the protection against the pear scab, pear
psylla, codling moth and summer fruit tortrix moth. Recently, changes had
to be made in the selection of fungicides and insecticides because
resistances have been developed in a few years in the case of pear scab
(Venturia pyrina) against fungicides and pear psylla (Cacopsylla pyri)
against the insecticides.
The appearance of fire blight (Erwinia amylovora) and pear phytoplasma, as
well as the withdrawal of the permission of numerous pesticides required
new approaches in the plant protection in the pear orchards.
In order to reduce the spread of the fire blight the application of the fungicides
containing copper active ingredient had to be increased, and the systematical removal
of the dead branches and twigs was required. To prevent the further infection of the
pear phytoplasma it is necessary to keep continuously at low level the density of pear
psylla population.
The use of the dinitro-orto-cresol insecticides provided an effective
protection against the pear psylla in early spring, however the permission of
their use was withdrawn. According to our experiences the paraffin oil
preparations could provide suitable protection against this pest, in this time.
It is possible to keep the population density of C. pyri in the vegetation
period at a low level by the repeated application of the paraffin oil
preparations, the IGR insecticides (diflubenzuron, fenoxicarb), but first of
all, by the use of Vermitec (abamectin).
Because of the consecutive ripening time of pear cultivars, the application
of the numerous insecticides, recommended for the integrated pest
management is not possible. Therefore, the prevention of damages of
codling moth, summer fruit tortrix moth and pear psylla needs particular
attention on the base of continuous observations.
127
THE INFLUENCE OF THE ADJACENT VEGETATION
PATCHES ON DIVERSITY AND ABUNDANCE OF
GREEN LACEWINGS ASSOCIATED TO THE OLIVE
GROVES IN SOUTH SPAIN. IMPLICATIONS IN THE
NATURAL CONTROL OF THE OLIVE MOTH, PRAYS
OLEAE (LEP: YPONOMEUTIDAE)
Ramón González-Ruiz1 - Samer Al-Asaad1 - András Bozsik2
1
Department of Animal and Vegetal Biology and Ecology, University of
Jaén, Jaén, Spain
2
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen,
Hungary
The olive moth, Prays oleae (Bernard) (Lep., Yponomeutidae) is responsible
of reductions in crop production of olive trees up to 60%. Amongst the natural
enemies of the olive moth, predation carried out by green lacewings larvae
(Chrysopidae) is frequently reported. They feed mostly on P. oleae eggs,
reaching usually very high levels of predation – greater than 90% – which
revealed that Chrysopidae are essential agents in the modern olive culture. In
the investigations carried out on the olive moth, a several lacewing species have
been observed, and the common green lacewing, Chrysoperla carnea s.l. was
dominant.
However, due to the trouble in the taxonomic status of Chrysoperla
carnea-complex, recent investigations, directed to the knowledgede of the
cryptic species present during the oviposition period of Prays oleae in south
Spain groves, showed that Chrysoperla agilis was the most abundant of the
carnea-group.
Preliminary studies suggested the existence of greater populations of
Chrysoperla carnea s.l. during the early spring in natural oak forest
vegetation bordering the olive groves. Are these patches of vegetation
important reservoirs to maintain lacewing populations? In such case, which
species of the carnea-group are mainly involved? Another important
objective of this study is to evaluate their role in the natural control of Prays
oleae and to compare it with a similar grove under different ecological
conditions: bordered by coniferous forests.
The four species of the carnea group – Chrysoperla agilis, Chrysoperla
lucasina, Chrysoperla carnea sensu stricto and Chrysoperla affinis - were
collected in the olive grove bordered by oaks, whereas only Ch. agilis and
Ch. lucasina were observed in the olive grove close to the pine forest (Pinus
halepensis), where not lacewings were collected. In contrast, in the oak
forest Chrysoperla agilis was collected even before the oviposition period
128
of Prays oleae, and it was also the dominant species in both olive groves
during the summertime (>75% of the total ind. caught).
The greatest diversity of lacewings was observed in the passing area
between grove and oak forest.
In relation to the big differences in diversity and relative abundance,
signifficant differences were also found in egg predation by lacewing larvae
betwen the two groves, as well as in the final level of infestation by Prays
oleae. In addition, relevant agronomical implications of these results will be
here discussed.
129
THE RIVENDELL INTERNATIONAL
Bojana Zgonec
Rivendell Cosulting Radomlje, Slovenia
The Rivendell is a consultancy company in the field of regulatory affairs for
the chemical industry, assisting manufacturing companies worldwide to
comply with national and international legislation in order to get and keep
their products on the market. Since the company was founded in early 1999,
Rivendell has focused its attention on European agro-chemical and biocidal
regulatory affairs, dealing with all relevant EU Directives and Regulations
as well as Member-State Regulations, from its headquarters in Ireland and
from the Spanish subsidiary, Rivendell España S.L. With the office in the
USA, opened in 2004, Rivendell has been able to offer additional services
for USA, Canada, all of Latin America, Australia, New Zealand and Asia
Pacific. More than 20 regulatory professionals work for Rivendell in the
three European and one USA office, with experts in scientific fields such as
chemistry, toxicology and environmental science. Rivendell does not
conduct laboratory testing or field trials, preferring to specialise in the
advice on requirements and preparation of submissions to regulatory
authorities. Rivendell offers services relating to the pending REACH
(Registration, Evaluation and Authorisation of CHemicals) programme
which will consolidate over 40 pieces of legislation into one EU Directive
for the registration of chemicals. Rivendell can assist you with initial
evaluation of the impact REACH will have for you and the subsequent
preparations to meet the legislative requirements.
With the launch of the new office in Slovenia, Rivendell are now offering
additional services covering countries including Poland, Hungary, Czech
Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia and Monte Negro, Bosnia and
Herzegovina, Bulgaria and Romania.
In that region agriculture is traditionally important economic factor and
there is a long tradition of the evaluation and registration of plant protection
products. This traditional ways are changing due to the transposition and
implementation of the directive 91/414/EEC and the ongoing process brings
lots of additional workload for authorities and applicants. Sometimes there
are also difficulties and problems arising in different fields of activities like
timelines of national re-evaluation, data requirements, allocation of
responsibilities between different expert workplaces and transitional
periods. Rivendell is strengthening their support to the applicants in this
region in their efforts to follow the changes.
130
Rivendell prides itself on providing a very high quality service at very
competitive rates, and is confident that this will also be seen in the new area
of business. Bojana Zgonec will be co-ordinating the development of the
business inside the CEE region, with the assistance of the Group Managing
Director, Dr. Irene Mc Grath, and Business Development Director, Seamus
O’Dowd, both of whom are based in the company headquarters in Ireland.
For information on Rivendell Consulting Slovenia, please contact Bojana
Zgonec on +386 1 729 71 83, mobile phone +386 40 432 738 or email
bojana.zgonec@rivendellslo.com.
131
TRIALS WITH OVERWINTERING CHAMBERS AS
CONSERVATION TOOLS FOR COMMON GREEN
LACEWINGS IN HUNGARY
András Bozsik
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
Under natural conditions the adults of common green lacewings
(Chrysoperla carnea s.l. (Stephens, 1836)) overwinter among leaf litter, in
rolled dry leaves, ivy tufts and unheated parts of buildings (Thierry et al.,
1994) where their surviving can be hazardous and mortality is high
(Şengonca and Frings, 1987). Lacewing overwintering chambers placed in
the field and orchard may be colonized by adult common green lacewings
(Şengonca and Frings, 1987, 1989; McEwen et al.,1999). These boxes can
augment the natural lacewing population by saving the hibernating adults
from the winter coldness and precipitation as well as the chambers - kept at
a dry and protected place during winter - placed in the field in the spring
may result in the earlier occurrence of adults and eggs (Şengonca and
Henze, 1992). The use of these hibernating shelters may increase the density
of natural populations of Ch. carnea s.l. and parallel enhances their
biological control performance. It is worth mentioning that the taxonomic
status of Ch. carnea has been changing, and instead of a polymorphic single
species, a complex of sibling or cryptic species, the Chrysoperla carnea
complex or carnea-group (Thierry et al., 1992; Thierry et al.,1998; Henry et
al., 2001) should be now considered whose members` systematic status is
not known enough (Tauber et al., 2000, Henry et al., 2001). According to
many-sided investigations we can distinguish in mainland Europe three
cryptic species: 1) Ch. affinis (Stephens, 1836) former Ch. kolthoffi (Thierry
et al., 1998); 2) Chrysoperla lucasina (Lacroix, 1912) (Henry et al., 2001)
and 3) Chrysoperla carnea sensu stricto (Thierry et al., 1998). The aim of
the following experiments is to prove the efficiency of the chambers in
Hungary and to study the overwintering behaviour of the sibling species of
Ch. carnea complex.
Materials and Methods
The wooden boxes (15 cm x 15 cm x 15 cm) used in the experiment
were made in Great-Britain according to the design of McEwen (1998). All
chambers were tightly packed with straw. The front and bottom side of the
boxes had louvred slats, three cm apart, through which lacewings can enter.
The boxes were placed with the louvred side facing away from the
132
prevailing winds, however, local topography and changeable wind
directions might influence results. Six chambers were placed in the field in
Hungary in August or September, two in a fruit orchard in Gödöllő about 25
km from Budapest, and four at Debrecen in the north-east of the country.
Chambers at the Gödöllő site were placed in an orchard in the garden suburb
of the town. The orchard (about 1000 m2) is surrounded by other orchards
and gardens. In the vicinity of the chosen orchard there is an extended
uncultivated semi-natural area covered by deciduous trees and shrubs and a
deciduous forest comprising oaks, maples and linden trees. The orchard
itself contains a variety of fruit trees and bushes. The chambers were fixed
on the top of fence posts (at a height of 150 – 160 cm), the distance between
chambers being about 30 m. The four chambers at Debrecen were placed in
the experimental area of the Agricultural Centre situated on the outskirts of
the town. This area (about 5 ha) is bordered by the University campus and
fields and is planted with a variety of fruit trees and other crops. Chambers
were mounted on wooden stakes at a height of 150 – 160 cm. Table 1 shows
mounting, collecting and emptying data.
Table 1. Dates of mounting, collecting and emptying of overwintering boxes
Site and date
No. of boxes
Debrecen 1997
4
Gödöllő 1997
2
Debrecen 1998
4
Gödöllő 1998
2
Debrecen 1999
4
Gödöllő 1999
2
Debrecen 2000
4
Debrecen 2004
4
Debrecen 2005
4
Mounting
30 08
28 08
02 09
04 09
14 09
19 09
27 08
14 09
21 09
Collecting
17 11
15 11
17 11
24 11
24 11
04 12
21 11
11 11
17 11
Emptying
17 11
15 11
17 11
24 11
24 11
16 12
2001 03 04
2005 22 03
2006 28 03
Results and Discussion
The number of lacewings that colonized the hibernation boxes at the
two sites are listed in Tables 2-7. Besides the lacewings other insects
(coccinellids (Adalia bipunctata), other small coleoptera, bugs (Miridae,
Anthocoridae), moths, flies (Syrphidae), wasps (Polistes gallicus,
Paravespula vulgaris), mosquitoes (Culex sp.) and spiders were found.
These data correspond to the former studies (McEwen et al., 1999;
Weihrauch, 2004).
133
Table 2. Common green lacewings colonizing overwintering chambers
(1997) (in brackets number of females)
Site
Ch. affinis
Debrecen 2 (1)
31 (14)
59 (22)
Total
92 (37)
Gödöllő 1 (-)
Total
1 (-)
Ch. carnea s.str.
1 (-)
1 (-)
1 (-)
-
Ch. carnea s.l.
2 (-)
3 (-)
5 (-)
-
Total
2 (1)
34 (14)
63 (22)
99 (37)
1 (-)
1 (-)
Table 3. Common green lacewings colonizing overwintering chambers
(1998) (in brackets number of females)
Site
Ch. affinis
Debrecen 4 (3)
9 (8)
3 (2)
2 (2)
Total
18 (17)
Gödöllő
Total
-
Ch. carnea s.str.
-
Ch. carnea s.l. Total
4 (3)
9 (8)
3 (2)
2 (2)
18 (17)
-
Table 4. Common green lacewings colonizing overwintering chambers
(1999) (in brackets number of females)
Site
Ch. affinis
Debrecen 4 (3)
2 (1)
23 (10)
Total
29 (14)
Gödöllő
Total
-
Ch. carnea s.str.
-
134
Ch. carnea s.l. Total
4 (3)
2 (1)
23 (10)
29 (14)
-
Table 5. Common green lacewings colonizing overwintering chambers
(2000) (in brackets number of females)
Site
Ch. affinis
Debrecen 4 (3)
Total
4 (3)
Ch. carnea s.str.
-
Ch. carnea s.l. Total
4 (3)
4 (3)
Table 6. Common green lacewings colonizing overwintering chambers
(2004) (in brackets number of females)
Site
Ch. affinis
Debrecen 21 (6)
13 (4)
1 (-)
9 (4)
Total
44 (14)
Ch. carnea s.str.
-
Ch. carnea s.l. Total
21 (6)
13 (4)
1 (-)
9 (4)
44 (14)
Table 7. Common green lacewings colonizing overwintering chambers
(2005) (in brackets number of females)
Site
Ch. affinis
Debrecen 3 (3)
3 (2)
4 (3)
Total
10 (8)
Ch. carnea s.str.
-
Ch. carnea s.l. Total
3 (3)
3 (2)
4 (3)
10 (8)
The number of individuals observed in the chambers was very variable from
year to year. The single constant result was that the number of lacewings
found in Gödöllő was minimal or nil. This could be due to the somehow
covered form of the habitat which could not allowed the lacewings to
discover the boxes. As to some of the Debrecen observations reasons for the
poor results are not really clear but they can be explained mainly by the
local environmental conditions (changeable wind direction, wet weather).
For example the weather in 1998 was very wet in both Debrecen and
Gödöllő, some boxes got soaked and the straw became wet inside the box.
135
Table 8. Common green lacewings colonizing overwintering chambers in
the period examined (n = number of overwintering chambers, in brackets
percentage of females)
Site and year
n
Debrecen 1997
Gödöllő 1997
Debrecen 1998
Gödöllő 1998
Debrecen 1999
Gödöllő 1999
Debrecen 2000
Debrecen 2004
Debrecen 2005
4
2
4
2
4
2
4
4
4
Common green
lacewings
Mean
Min Max
24.75 (37.4) 0
63
0.5
0
1
4.5 (94.4) 2
9
7.25 (48.3) 0
23
1
(75) 0
4
11
(31.8) 1
21
2.5 (80) 0
4
Table 9. Number of sibling species of Ch. carnea complex colonizing
overwintering chambers in the period examined (n = number of chambers,
in brackets percentage of dominance)
Site and year
n
Debrecen 1997
Gödöllő 1997
Debrecen 1998
Gödöllő 1998
Debrecen 1999
Gödöllő 1999
Debrecen 2000
Debrecen 2004
Debrecen 2005
Total
4
2
4
2
4
2
4
4
4
Sibling species
Ch. affinis Ch. carnea s.str. Ch. carnea s.l.
92 (93.9)
1 (1.0)
5 (5.1)
1 (100)
18 (100)
29 (100)
4 (100)
44 (100)
10 (100)
198 (97.5)
1 (0.5)
5 (2.5)
Interestingly, the poorest results were observed in 2000 when the autumn
and winter was not exceptionally wet. Until 1999 the boxes were emptied in
November or December immediately after demounting them so the
protecting efficiency of the boxes could not be assessed. However, in case
of the three last years, the boxes were placed in an unheated wooden
building and emptied only in the spring. These treatments showed a good
136
thermo-protecting effect of hibernating boxes. It should be stressed that in
2005 the winter was extremely cold, but the lacewings survived. In terms of
the number of attracted lacewings in other countries, the Hungarian results
are not unexpected. The lacewing average abundance per chamber differed
also in various countries. In France 13.8 (Thierry et al., 2002), Sweden 56.8,
Hungary 24.7, Finland 2.5, England 0.13-14 (McEwen et al., 1999)
individuals were collected averagely. The biggest average abundance was
harvested in Germany, 254 (Weihrauch, 2004) and 447 (Frings and
Şengonca, 1988) individuals. The big differences may be due to local
biodiversity, numbers of lacewings present, as well as local topography,
changeable wind directions and meteorological conditions but the reasons
for the considerable variations are not really apparent. In case of the first
German example the forest mimicking support structure of hops garden
could be attractive for the lacewings looking for overwintering sites
(Weihrauch, 2004). In Great-Britain (Wales) the poorest results (0.13
individual as a mean of 30 chambers, and with a maximal value of one)
were observed in an exceptionally wet autumn and winter (McEwen et al.,
1999).
Regarding the sibling species composition, Ch. affinis was the most
abundant species (97.5%) which was followed by Ch. carnea s.str. (0.5%).
Vis-à-vis the third cryptic species, Ch. lucasina, no specimen was
uncovered in the chambers. This can be explained with the rarity of Ch.
lucasina and also that this species prefers natural hibernation places
(Thierry et al., 1994). 2.5% of the individuals could not be identified
because of the considerable variability of their characteristic traits (Table 9).
The proportion of the species attracted was enormously similar to that of
found in other countries. 98% (1297 ind.) Ch. carnea (synonym for Ch.
affinis), 1.7% (23 ind.) Chrysoperla pallida (synonym for Ch. carnea s.str.)
and 0.23% (3 ind.) Ch. lucasina were observed in overwintering chambers
in Germany (Bavaria) (Weihrauch, 2004). The data in France (Loire valley)
are almost the same: 94.9% (111 ind.) Ch. kolthoffi (former name of Ch.
affinis), 4.3% (5 ind.) Ch. carnea s.str., 0.8% (1 ind.) Ch. lucasina (Thierry
et al., 2002). When summarising the results with hibernation chambers from
2002-2004 in Germany the species composition changes a bit: Ch. carnea
(synonym for Ch. affinis) amounted 89.5% (3183 ind.), Ch. pallida
(synonym for Ch. carnea s.str.) 10.1% (359 ind.) and Ch. lucasina 0.4 (14
ind.) (Weihrauch, 2005).The French authors investigated the preferred
hibernation sites of the sibling species and found that only Ch. affinis
favours artificial shelters (unheated buildings), the other taxa prefer rolled
dry leaves (Ch. carnea s.str.) and ivy tufts (Ch. lucasina) (Thierry et al.,
1994). The German and Hungarian data concerning the proportion of
specimens attracted in overwintering boxes correspond to the proportion of
the assessed natural population (Table 10).
137
Table 10. Comparison of assessed natural populations of Ch carnea
complex in Hungary and Germany
Country and
year
Ch.
affinis
Ch.
lucasina
Total References
ind.
83.0
Ch.
carnea
s.str.
12.1
Hungary
1996, 1998,
1999
Germany
2001
2.5
2010
Bozsik, 2000
(unpublished)
84.7
9.5
2.0
1279
Gruppe, 2002
Attractive power of overwintering chambers and/or conditions
influencing their attractiveness and the wandering of lacewings are not
known enough. Local biodiversity, numbers of lacewings present, as well as
local topography (coverage of chambers), changeable wind directions and
meteorological conditions can be the most important reasons for the
variations. In conclusion, thorough site selection respecting topography,
wind direction and lacewing abundance, use of wind-adjusting chambers
and attractants can contribute to the improvement of these devices that is
further work is required to learn more about lacewings, their ecology and
behaviour.
References
Çaldumbide, C., Faessel, L., Travers, M., Thierry et Rat-Morris, E. (2001) :
Les chrysopes communes, auxiliaires polyvalents. D’abord qui sontelles ? Et peut-on les protéger en hiver ? Phytoma, N˚ 540 14-19.
Frings, B. und Şengonca, Ç. (1988): Untersuchungen über die
Anwendungsmöglichkeiten von Florfliegenhäuschen im Freiland.
Mitteilungen der deutschen Gesellschaft für allgemeine und
angewandte Entomologie, 6: 233-237.
Gruppe, A. (2002): Verbreitung der Taxa des Chrysoperla carnea Komplex
in Südbayern. Galathea, Supplement13: 15-19.
Henry CS, Brooks SJ, Thierry D, Duelli P, Johnson JB, 2001: The common
green lacewing (Chrysoperla carnea s. lat.) and the sibling species
problem. In: Lacewings in the crop environment. Ed. by P.K.
McEwen, T.R.
McEwen, P.K. (1998): Overwintering chambers for the common green
lacewing (Chrysoperla carnea): Influence of chemical attractant,
material and size. J. Neuropt. 1: 17-21.
138
McEwen, P.K., Akerberg, C., Bozsik, A., James, C.J., Eccleston, L.,
Lenartsson, M., Rossiter, P. and Tuovinen, T. (1999): Artificial
overwintering chambers for green lacewings: results of international
trials and implications for pest control. J. Appl. Ent. 123: 525-527.
Şengonca, Ç. and Henze, M. (1992): Conservation and enhancement of
Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens) (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae) in the
field by providing hibernation shelters. J. Appl. Ent. 114: 497-501.
Şengonca, Ç. und Frings, B. (1987): Ein künstliches Überwinterungsquartier
für die räuberische Florfliege. DLG Mitteilungen, 102: 656-657.
Şengonca, Ç. and Frings, B. (1989): Enhancement of the green lacewing
Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens) by providing artificial facilities for
hibernation. Turk. Entomol. Derg. 13: 245-250.
Tauber, M.J., Tauber, C.A., Daane, K.M., Hagen, K.S. (2000):
Commercialization of predators: recent lessons from green lacewings
(Neuroptera: Chrysopidae: Chrysoperla). Am. Entomol. 46: 26-38.
Thierry, D., Cloupeau, R., Jarry, M. (1992) : La chrysope commune
Chrysoperla carnea sensu lato dans le centre de la France: mise en
évidence d’un complexe d’especes (Insecta: Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae). In: Current research in Neuropterology. Ed. by M.
Canard, H. Aspöck and M.W. Mansell. Proceedings of the 4th
International Symposium on Neuropterology. Bagn3res-deLouchon, France 1991, SACCO, Toulouse, France, 379-392.
Thierry, D., Cloupeau, R., Jarry, M. (1994): Variation in the overwintering
ecophysiological traits in the common green lacewing WestPalearctic complex (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Acta Oecol 15: 593606.
Thierry, D., Cloupeau, R., Jarry, M., Canard, M. (1998): Discrimination of
the West-Palearctic Chrysoperla Steinmann species of the carnea
Stephens group by means of claw morphology (Neuroptera,
Chrysopidae). Acta Zool. Fennica 209: 255-262.
Thierry, D., Rat-Morris, E. and Çaldumbide, C. (2002): Selective
attractivity of artificial overwintering chambers for the common
green lacewing species of the Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens)
complex in western Europe (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Acta. Zool.
Acad. Sci. Hung. 48 (Suppl.2): 351-357.
Weihrauch, F. (2004): Überwinterungsraten von Chrysoperla-Arten in
“Florfliegenhotels“ im Hopfenanbaugebiet Hallertau (Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae). 7. Treffen deutschsprachiger Neuropterologen,
Tagungsbericht, Galathea, Supplement, 15: 1-6.
Weihrauch, F. (2005): Versuche zum Management von Florfliegen in der
Sonderkultur Hopfen: Stand der Dinge (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae).
Zusammenfasung der Vorträge der 8. Tagung des AK Neuropteren
139
vom 29.4.-1.5.2005 auf dem Schloss
www.dgaae.de/html/ags/akneurz8.pdf
Schwanberg.
http://
TRIALS WITH OVERWINTERING CHAMBERS AS
CONSERVATION TOOLS FOR COMMON GREEN LACEWINGS
IN HUNGARY
A. Bozsik
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
Summary
Under natural conditions the common green lacewings (Chrysoperla carnea s.l.) overwinter
among leaf litter, in rolled dry leaves, ivy tufts and unheated parts of buildings where their
surviving can be more hazardous. Their surviving rates may be increased by overwintering
chambers placed in the field. The chambers can augment the natural lacewing population
by saving the hibernating adults from the winter coldness and precipitation as well as the
chambers placed in the field in the spring may result in the earlier occurrence of adults and
eggs. The boxes placed in two different regions during six years protected efficiently the
lacewings in winter, however, results must have been influenced strongly by local
topography and changeable wind directions. Presence of Chrysoperla affinis individuals
(97.5%) predominated in the boxes, but a few Chrysoperla carnea s.str. (0.5%) were found,
too. Regarding the third cryptic species, Chrysoperla lucasina, any specimen was not
uncovered in the chambers. 2.5% of the individuals could not be identified because of the
considerable variability of characteristic traits.
140
LACEWINGS’ OCCURRENCE IN SOME HUNGARIAN
HEDGEROWS AND FIELD EDGES
András Bozsik
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
The relevant literature shows that the more heterogeneous vegetation
bordering or surrounding cultivated areas supply sites for reproduction,
overwintering and feeding for beneficial organisms, serving them as refugia,
from which they can colonize/recolonize the cultivated areas (Van Emden and
Williams, 1974; Horn, 1981). The most important bordering semi-natural
vegetational formations are in Europe the hedges or hedgerows. Although the
importance of lacewings as natural enemies of serious pests is entirely high,
only a few studies have been carried out concerning their presence in hedges
and influence of vegetation on these insects (Horn, 1981; Pantaleoni and
Sproccati, 1987). In addition, though there are a lot of information on hedges
and their relationship with natural enemies in northern or western European
countries, in states with post-communist history these reports are rarities. For
that reason, the objective of this study was to describe and compare the
cenological characteristics of lacewing assemblages investigated in four
hedges with different vegetational diversity.
Materials and Methods
Four different areas were studied in the north of Hungary from late
April until late August in 1990-92. Two of the areas were situated in Gödöllő
and the others in Kartal. The town of Gödöllő is located on the western slope
of the watershed line of Cserhát mountain range and on both side of Rákos
brook. It lies about 30 km from Budapest. The town has to be considered as
the town of parks having in its center a huge park system and being rich in
deciduous and coniferous trees.
The first area (Gödöllő1) was an about five km long coherent
uncultivated territory (semi-natural wooded hedge in Gödöllő) grown over
with diverse herbaceous, shrubby and woody vegetation, but the woody
vegetation predominated (Acer campestris, Acer negundo, Acer pseudoplatanus, Eleagnus angustifolius, Juglans regia, Prunus domestica, Prunus
spinosa, Ulmus campestris, Tilia cordata, Crataegus monogyna, Evonymus
europeus, Rosa canina, Sambucus nigra, Quercus sp., Populus sp.). The site
was surrounded from the north and west by the railway line and a high way.
The garden-city of Gödöllő was situated on the opposite side of high way. In
the south and east the area was bordered by a meadow and cereal fields.
141
Beyond the fields ca. 1.5 km south-east of the first sampling site lay a
deciduous forest.
The second area (Gödöllő2) was an about 400 m long hedgerow in the
agricultural area of Gödöllő, which contained robinia trees (Robinia pseudoacacia) and harboured a variegated weed flora. The acacia stand was very
dense. The site was surrounded by cultivated field crops (potato, alfalfa,
sunflower, barley). It was located ca. 6 km south-west from the first area.
The third site (Kartal1), an about 300 m long field border north from
Kartal (small village situated 15 km from Gödöllő), composed of singly and
thinly grown trees and bushes (R. pseudo-acacia, Populus sp., R. canina, S.
nigra) and some weedy plants.
The fourth area (Kartal2), another, a 500 m long field border near
Kartal1, was characterized by sparsely grown trees (fals-acacias: R. pseudoacacia) with less considerable herbaceous vegetation, and it was surrounded
by cereal fields.
The localities were sampled weekly by sweeping net with 34 cm
diameter and 100 strokes were made at shrub and crown level. No insecticide
treatments were carried out during the study period.
When characterizing the chrysopid assemblages of the 4 different
areas, the community structure parameters and indices like species richness,
number of specimens, the Shannon-Weaver's diversity index (H = - Σ pi log pi,
where pi is the proportion of i-th species in the sample; Southwood, 1984), and
equitability were used. Equitability was calculated according to the formula: e
= H/lnS, where H was the value of diversity and S the number of species. The
values of structure parameters mentioned above were analyzed by using two
tailed t-test and regression analysis. The Rényi diversity as scale dependent
diversity characterization (Ha = [log Σpia]l(1-a) was also calculated. Similarity
values were processed by hierarchical cluster analysis using the group average
clustering strategy (UPGMA) and Matusita distance. Also principal
component analysis (PCA, standardized, centered) was calculated. In case of
the vegetation only species presence and absence (binary) data were available,
consequently their similarity by hierarchical cluster analysis (group average
clustering strategy (UPGMA), Jaccard distance) was assessed. For the
calculations the NuCoSa program (Tóthmérész, 1996) was employed.
Only the adults were considered in the material because of the paucity
of larvae collected.
Results and Discussion
Results are presented in Table 1, 2, 3, 4. In Gödöllő1 site seven
species were caught among which two were relatively frequent. Almost all of
them (Chrysoperla carnea, Chrysopa perla, Chrysopa formosa, Dichochrysa
prasina, Chrysopa pallens) belonged to the lacewings of a wide ecological
142
range and species favouring generally habitats with deciduous trees and shrubs
(Chrysopa viridiana). The first two species (Ch. carnea, Ch. perla)
predominated, amounting roughly 80% of the captured individuals. The
seventh species (Chrysopa phyllochroma), species of low vegetation
(especially in field crops) occurred only singly and very rarely. The species
profile of Gödöllő2 was similar to the above. Seven species were captured
consisting of species of wide ecological range (Ch. perla, Ch. carnea, Ch.
formosa, D. prasina) and the woody vegetation preferring ones, Dichochrysa
flavifrons, Nineta flava. At this place also Ch. perla and Ch. carnea prevailed,
making out more than 75% of the individuals. Also Ch. phyllochroma was
found singly. At Kartal1 site there were only two species, Ch. carnea and
Ch. formosa. At Kartal2 occurred only Ch. carnea (Table 1).
The Gödöllő sites’ individual density, species richness were much
higher than those of Kartal. Their diversity and equitability values were also
more important than the Kartal’s estimates. The values of Gödöllő in case of
abundance, species richness, diversity and evenness differed significantly
from those of Kartal’s. The Gödöllő sites’ values do not differ significantly
from each other and that is true also for the comparison of the Kartal sites
(Table 2). Regarding the weekly catches, the diversity values are quite low
but in case of the yearly estimates (calculated from summarized data) they
are considerably higher. Considering the annual diversity the Gödöllő
values differ significantly from those of Kartal, and the Katral values differ
also from each other. Taking into account the scale dependent diversity
characterization (Rényi diversity) the Gödöllő values are more diverse than
those of Kartal in case of the frequent and the rare species. However, the
Gödöllő assemblages cannot be separated, Gödöllő1 is more diverse in case of
the rare, Gödöllő2 is more diverse in event of the frequent species (Figure 1).
The similarity values processed by hierarchical cluster analysis showed a
comparable picture like the diversity values: the assemblages of Gödöllő sites
are alike to each other, and the relationship between those of the Kartal borders
is analogous however, the Gödöllő hedges’ assemblages at annual level differ
remarkably from the lacewings of Kartal borders (Figure 2). The PCA gave a
more detailed picture about the relationship of the lacewing assemblages.
The similarity of the Kartal borders is indisputable but because of the
divergent species composition, and dominance the Gödöllő lacewing groups
differ considerably from each other (Figure 3). The dominance of Ch. perla
is a new phenomenon because according to previous investigations made in
Gödöllő and Budapest, this species’abundance was clearly more lower in
semi-natural areas and gardens (Bozsik, 1994).
The influence of vegetation might have been substantial. Comparing the
presence/absence values of the plant species found at the study places the
cluster analysis verifies some inconsiderable similarity between the Gödöllő
sites, and between the Kartal sites (Figure 4). Regarding the relationship of
143
the sites on the basis of the tree and bushy species another image appears
which is more diverse, and which did not reflect the relationships of
assemblages depicted above, where the biggest difference were found
between the Gödöllő sites (Figure 5). There is one moment which may
influence to a great extent the species richness and the abundance. This is
the density of trees and bushes independently of the species composition. At
the Gödöllő sites the tree density was considerable and similar which
contributing to the various and favourable micro-climatic conditions could
cause the greater species richness and abundance of the lacewing
assemblages. In case of the Kartal sites where the woody vegetation was
very scarce the variety of micro-climatic conditions could not be so wide,
thus the values of structure parameters (species richness, abundance,
diversity, evenness) were much smaller. It is difficult to compare these data
with those of former reports because of the paucity of published information
about lacewings in hedges. However, Duelli et al., (2002) showed that forest
borders are real hotspots of lacewings, where their species richness and
abundance can be considerable. They studied the relationship between the
structure of forest edge and the catches of lacewing adults, from which they
constructed the habitat preference categories of some Swiss lacewings.
Unfortunately, only three categories could be applied for the Hungarian
lacewings: ubiquist species (similar presence in most structures) for Ch.
carnea s.l., contact zone species (presence in most peripheral structure) for
D. prasina., canopy species (presence in topmost height) for N. flava. The
other species have not been classified because their too rare or erratic
distribution like that of Ch. perla or Ch. pallens (Table 4.).
Table 1. List of lacewing adults collected in the four sites in 1990-1992
(a
= percent of dominance values, - = species not found)
Species
Gödöllő1 Gödöllő2 Kartal1 Kartal2
42.46a
35.07
75.00
100
Chrysoperla carnea
36.99
40.30
Chrysopa perla
4.79
19.40
25.00
Chrysopa formosa
2.74
0.75
Dichochrysa prasina
6.16
Chrysopa pallens
5.48
Chrysopa viridana
1.37
2.98
Chrysopa phyllochroma
0.75
Nineta flava
0.75
Dichochrysa flavifrons
Total number of species
7
7
2
1
Total number of individuals
146
134
8
29
144
Table 2. Mean values of the structure parameters of lacewing assemblages in
four hedgerows. (n = 16, samples of weekly catches. In brackets standard
deviation. Means followed by the same letter within a column are not
significantly different at P = 0.05 by two tailed t-test)
Sites
Number of
individuals
Gödöllő1 9.00a 6.088)
Gödöllő2 8.37a (6.956)
Kartal1
0.50b (1.155)
Kartal2
1.81b (5.089)
Species
richness
2.44a
(±.413)
2.50a
(1.265)
0.31b
(0.704)
0.19b
(0.403)
Diversity
Evenness
0.6016a
(0.4889)
0.6363a
(0.4823)
0.0785b
(0.2157)
0.0000b
0.5969a
(0.3901)
0.5710a
(0.4064)
0.1132b
(0.3113)
0.0000b
Table 3. Annual structure parameters of lacewing assemblages in four
hedgerows. (Means followed by the same letter within a column are not
significantly different at P = 0.05 by two tailed t-test)
Sites
Gödöllő1
Gödöllő2
Kartal1
Kartal2
Number of individuals
146
134
8
29
Species richness
7
7
2
1
145
Diversity
1.3655a
1.2664a
0.5623b
0.0000c
Evenness
0.7017
0.6508
0.8113
0.0000
Figure 1. Rényi diversity of lacewing assemblages of study sites (small
values of scale parameter correspond to rare species, big values to frequent
species); 1: Gödöllő1; 2: Gödöllő1; 3: Kartal1; 4: Kartal2).
Figure 2. Similarity of lacewing assemblages of study sites (hierarchical
cluster analysis; fusion: group average (UPGMA); quantitative distance:
Matusita equation; 1: Gödöllő1; 2: Gödöllő1; 3: Kartal1; 4: Kartal2).
146
Figure 3. Principal component analysis of the lacewing assemblages of
study sites (standardized, centered); 1: Gödöllő1; 2: Gödöllő1; 3: Kartal1; 4:
Kartal2)
Figure 4. Similarity of the vegetation of study sites (hierarchical cluster
analysis; fusion: group average (UPGMA); binary distance: Jaccard
equation ; 1: Gödöllő1; 2: Gödöllő1; 3: Kartal1; 4: Kartal2)
147
Figure 5. Similarity of tree and shrub stand of study sites (hierarchical
cluster analysis; fusion: group average (UPGMA); binary distance: Jaccard
equation; 1: Gödöllő1; 2 : Gödöllő1; 3: Kartal1; 4: Kartal2).
It has been shown that the presented hedges lacewing richness and
abundance significantly surpassed those of the field borders with scarcely
grown trees and shrubs. The very impact of hedgerows might be
implemented rather by their structure (dense tree and shrub stand) than their
tree and bush composition. This impact can be due to the hedge structure
(forest edge mimicking structure with a herbaceous fringe) offering
favourable micro-climatic conditions, sites for refugia, mating, oviposition,
overwintering and wider choice of food as well as ecologic corridor for
lacewings. As a consequence of these beneficial influence the maintaining and
planting of agricultural hedgerows is a key question for the conservation and
augmentation of lacewing biodiversity.
148
Table 4. Habitat preference of the lacewings collected. (aafter Aspöck et al.,
(1980), bconsidering the forest edge structure /Duelli et al., 2002/)
Species
Types of habitat
preferencea
Chrysoperla carnea
s.l.
Chrysopa perla
Chrysopa formosa
Dichochrysa prasina
Chrysopa pallens
Chrysopa viridana
Chrysopa
phyllochroma
Nineta flava
all kinds of vegetation, eurytopic
Types of
habitat
preferenceb
ubiquist
shrub belt, eurytopic
shrub belt
tree and shrub, eurytopic
tree canopy
tree and shrub (Quercus sp.)
herbaceous vegetation
not classified
not classified
contact zone
not classified
not classified
not classified
tree and shrub (Quercus sp.),
eurytopic
tree and shrub, eurytopic
canopy
Dichochrysa
flavifrons
contact zone
References
Aspöck, H., Aspöck, U. and Hölzel, H. (1980): Die Neuropteren Europas. Vol.
1-2. Goecke und Evers, Krefeld, 1: pp. 495; 2: pp. 355.
Bozsik A. (1994): Impact of vegetational diversity on structure parameters
of chrysopid assemblages. REDIA, 77 (1): 69-77.
Duelli, P., Obrist, M.K. and Flückener, P.F. (2002): Forest edges are
biodiversity hotspots – also for Neuroptera. Acta Zool. Acad. Sci.
Hung. 48 (Suppl. 2): 75-87.
Van Emden, H.F., Williams, G.F. (1974): Insect stability and diversity in
agroecosystems. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 19: 455-475.
Horn, D.J. (1981): Effect of weedy backgrounds on colonization of collards by
green peach aphid, Myzus persicae, and its major predators. Environ.
Entomol. 10: 285-289.
Pantaleoni, R.A., Sprocatti, M. (1987): I Neurotteri delle colture agrarie: study
preliminari circa l'influenza di siepi ed altre aree non coltivate sulle
popolazioni di Crisopidi. Boll. Ist. Ent. Univ. Bologna, 42: 193-203.
Southwood, T.R.E. (1984): Ökológiai módszerek - különös tekintettel a
rovarpopulációk tanulmányozására. Mezőgazdasági Kiadó, Budapest,
pp. 315.
149
Tóthmérész B. (1996): NuCoSA: Programcsomag botanikai, zoológiai és
ökológiai vizsgálatokhoz. Synbiologia Hungarica 2 (1), Scientia
Kiadó, Budapest, pp. 84.
LACEWINGS’ OCCURRENCE IN SOME HUNGARIAN
HEDGEROWS AND FIELD EDGES
A. Bozsik
Department of Plant Protection, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
Summary
The most important bordering semi-natural vegetational formations are in Europe the hedges or
hedgerows. Their heterogeneous vegetation bordering cultivated areas supply sites for
reproduction, overwintering and feeding for beneficial organisms, serving them as refugia,
from which they can colonize the cultivated areas. Despite the importance of lacewings as
natural enemies, only a few studies have been carried out concerning their presence in hedges
and influence of vegetation on these insects. The study has shown that the presented hedges
lacewing richness and abundance significantly surpassed those of the field borders with
scarcely grown trees and shrubs. The very impact of hedgerows might be implemented
rather by their structure (dense tree and shrub stand) than their tree and bush composition.
This impact can be due to the hedge structure (forest edge mimicking structure with a
herbaceous fringe) offering favourable micro-climatic conditions, sites for refugia, mating,
oviposition, overwintering and wider choice of food as well as ecologic corridor for lacewings.
As a consequence of these beneficial influence the maintaining and planting of agricultural
hedgerows is a key question for the conservation and augmentation of lacewing biodiversity.
150
WEED SCIENCES SESSION
151
152
DETECTION OF COMMON RAGWEED (AMBROSIA
ARTEMISIIFOLIA L.) REFLECTANCE SPECTRUM BY
MEANS OF FIELD MEASUREMENTS
András Jung1 – Péter Kardeván2 – Péter Reisinger3
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural Sciences,
Budapest, Hungary
2
Geological Institute of Hungary, Budapest, Hungary
3
University of West-Hungary, Faculty of Food and Agricultural Sciences,
Mosonmagyaróvár, Hungary
The paper describes measurements carried out by ASD Filed Spec in two
different Hungarian regions (Jánossomorja, Tiszakécske). We tried to
specify the reference spectra of common ragweed (Béres 2003) and
background vegetation and results of analysis. The main scope of the
experimental measurements was the detection and mapping of the
reflectance spectrum of common ragweed in order to elaborate the airborneremote sensing methodology for weed monitoring. First element of the
methodology was to specify the reference spectra of the target object. The
reflectance measurements were taken in the wavelength range of 0.35–2.5
microns comprising the visible- and near-infrared wave bands (VIS-NIR).
The elaboration of the methodology involves a feasibility study of
hyperspectral imaging and the adaptation of hyperspectral methods for using
them in the classification of multispectral images taken by satellites
(Itzerott–Kadenn 2006, Lichti et al. 1997).
The measurements were carried out in cooperation with the University of
Natural Resources and Applied Life Sciences (Institute for Surveying,
Remote Sensing and Land Information) also in 2006. Main aims of the
measurements were to define typical reflectance spectrum for common
ragweed (Kardeván et al. 2004) and sunflower in order to study spatial
heterogenity of by ragweed “polluted” agricultural areas in two different
phenological states: at the beginning and end of July. The processed
measurement results were used to “teaching” classification algorithms for
images (to find end-member spectra) sensed by satellites (LANDSAT5,
SPOT5, ASTER). To fulfil our aims we measured in pure by common
ragweed covered- and by sunflower covered spots and by random sampled
areas (totally 16 spots). We analysed the weed-sunflower-soil components
in percent distribution. The relative distribution of weed-soil-culture plant
were evaluated with the method of Balázs-Újvárosi (Tóth–Spilák 1998,
Reisinger 2001, Reisinger et al. 2001). Last three years we have build a
153
common ragweed spectral library for different phenological states that may
be a very good scientific background for others to analyse ragweed.
Our future plan is to be able to detect invasive weeds by satellites or
airborne hyperspectral remote sensors in high spatial resolution (Vrindts
2000). Of course by this way the first investigations are and will be focused
on common rag weed. During digital image processing the following
methods were applied: supervised classification, clustering, target detection,
image transformation (Cruse et al. 1993, Tamás 2004, Burai–Pechmann
2005, Jung et al. 2005, Kis Papp–Jung 2005).
Materials and Methods
•
•
•
•
In the year of 2003: Application of supervised classification (with
teaching points) without atmospheric correction. Connecting DGPS
measurements with by sensor calibrated satellites images.
In the year of 2004: Studying of reflectance spectra for agricultural
plants and typical weeds in order to distinguish them.
In the year of 2005. Defining representative spectra by field
spectroradiometers for agricultural areas in different classification
categories for different phenological periods of common ragweed.
In the year of 2006. New technological and methodological
experiment to understand the atmospheric effect on the field
measurements.
The used spectroradiomer was an ASD Field Spec Pro FR in the wavelength
range of 0.4-2.4 μm. The IFOV of the spectroradiometer was 28˚. In the
IFOV the projected or sensed area was 2-5 m in diameter depended on
height.
To calculate the reflectance factor for the target object we used a white
spectralon. For every measurement we defiend the plant-soil cover in
relative distribution by the Balázs-Újvárosi Method. During sampling we
made photos according to IFOV of spectrometer for every spot for afterprocessing feedback. This feedback was of great importance at desktop
analysis to decide where shadow or other disturbing effect was.
There was a new methological approach in our investigation. We combined
the so called “subjective” Balázs-Újvárosi Method with a spectrometric
measurement process. This combination delivered good result at final
comparisons. The simple target detection was complemented with a sundisc
measurement that was very promising in atmospheric correction but it is
behind the scope of the present paper.
154
Spectral measurements in 2005, 2006 were supported by FÖMI (Institute of
Geodesy, Cartography and Remote Sensing). The project was sponsored in
the framework of NKFP named ‘Elaborating of Pollen Information System’.
Results
In Figure 1 can be seen that common ragweed has a typical reflectance
spectra and spectral anomalies are strongly influenced by the existence of
other plants in sensed areas. This phenomenon is well known and can be
recognised in our experiments as well. At the right site of Figure1 there is a
list of different relative plant distribution (evaluated with the BalázsÚjvárosi Method) where ‘Pf’ means ragweed and other symbols refer to
other weeds that have effect on ragweed spectrum also.
Figure 1. Vegetation spots in different relative distribution with dominant
ragweed population (Pf refers to Ambrosia)
Figure 2 shows the real differences between common ragweed and
sunflower in the case when sensed area was homogeneous. So we can see
that there is a very good chance to find a gap in the spectra to distinguish
ragweed from sunflower by means of remote sensing.
155
Figure 2. Reflectance spectra of homogeneous sunflower and ragweed
canopy
It is good sign to be able to automate a pattern recognition process because
this difference is well recognisable. It is widely known that homogeneous
population are very seldom in the nature and heterogenity is more typical
but in a theoretical approach it is recommended to clarify the differences.
In Figure3 we collected reflectance spectra for four situations. It is very
interesting to state that a sunflower population with and without weeds how
rapidly decreases in reflectance, especially in the spectral range 600-1400
nm. It is the visible and near-infrared segment of the spectrum (Gitelson et
al. 1996). For our investigations it was of increasing importance to map the
spectral properties of different vegetation.
Figure 3. Differences in homogeneous and heterogenic reflectance spectra
In Figure 4 was presented the most important result for the practice or
precision farming because in detecting common ragweed we were seeking
for unique signs in the spectra. Spatial and temporal properties were the
keys for recognising ragweed in mixed vegetated area. After our results we
156
concluded that the phenological state was a very promising factor in
detection and recognition of common rag weed in a sunflower population.
The spectral differences were much more expressed on 26.06., than on
06.06.
Figure 4. Differences in reflectance spectra caused by phenology (06.06 and
06.26.2006)
According to our future plans we would like to detect common rag weed by
satellites. In our investigation we used ENVI 4.0 software that had a buildin algorithm that could recalculate the original hyperspectral database and
resampled it to a given satellite band distribution. We resampled the
measurements for three satellites: ASTER, SPOT5, LANDSAT5.
After resampling can be stated, that phenological differences in reflectance
spectra can be well distinguished by space-borne sensors also. The graphical
result are shown in the Figure5.
Figure 5. Spectral resampled spectra for ASTER, SPOT5 and LANDSAT5
satellites.
157
In our investigation we found unique spectral signs for detecting common
rag weed in a sunflower population. Our measurements were carried out by
field spectroradiometer that had very high spectral resolution. Our best
results were found to be on 26.06.2006 so the right phenological point has
priority in the successful detecting process. This technology can be
commonly known, used and relatively cost effective when measurements
will be taken by satellites. For satellites resampled results we concluded also
that phenology is very relevant but applicable in the decision process.
We would like to continue the field measurements and to involve more
satellite images. As present problem muss be mentioned that atmospheric
effect is very disturbing in the field also and real atmospheric correction
solution are in process nowadays.
References
Béres I. (2003): Az ürömlevelű parlagfű (Ambrosia artemisiifolia L.)
elterjedése, jelentősége és biológiája. Növényvédelem 39 (7): 293302.
Burai P. és Pechmann I. (2005): Különböző spektrális felbontású távérzékelt
adatforrások alkalmazási lehetőségei az agrár-környezetvédelemben.
Debreceni Egyetem Agrártudományi Közlemények (Acta Agraria
Debreceniensis) 13.
Cruse, F.A., Lefkoff, A.B., Boardman, J.W., Heidebrecht, K.B., Shapiro,
A.T., Barloon, O.J. and Goetz, A.F.H. (1993): The spectral Image
Processing System (SIPS)– Interactive Visualisation and Analysis of
Image Spectrometer Data. Remote Sensing of Environment 44, 145163.
Itzerott, S. and Kaden, K. (2006): Spekrale Normkurven –eine notwendige
Voraussetzung für die Klassifizierung der Fruchtartenverteilung aus
Fernerkundungsdaten. PFG 3/2006, 205-216.
Jung, A., Tőkei, L., Kardeván, P., and Nagy, Zs. (2005): Investigation of
plant reflectance spectrum between 623 nm and 780 nm with
hyperspectral airborne imaging technology. Erdei Ferenc III.
Tudományos konferencia. II. kötet. 23-24. August 2005. Proceeding
880-884.
Kardeván, P., Jung, A., Resinger P. és Nagy S. (2004): A parlagfű
(Ambrosia
artemisiifolia
L.)
reflektancia
spektrumainak
meghatározása terepi mérésekkel. Magyar Gyomkutatás és
Technológia (1) 15-31.
Reisinger, P. (2001): Weed surveys on farmlands in Hungary (1947-2000).
Magyar Gyomkutatás és Technológia (1) 3-15.
158
Reisinger P., Kőmíves T., Lajos M., Lajos K. és Nagy S. (2001): Veszélyes
gyomfajok táblán belüli elterjedésének térképi ábrázolása a GPS
segítségével. Magyar Gyomkutatás és Technológia (2) 25-33.
Tamás J. (2004): Könyezetinformatika az agrar-környezetvédelemben.
Szaktudás Kiadó, Budapest 190.
Tóth Á. és Spilák K. (1998): A IV. Országos gyomfelvételezés tapasztalatai.
Növényvédelmi Fórum, Keszthely 49.
Vrindts, E. (2000): Automatic Weed Detection with Optical Techniques as a
Basis for Site-Specific Herbicide Application, PhD Thesis, Katholieke
Universiteit Leuven.
Kis Papp, L. and Jung, A. (2004): Using of high spectral airborne images in
data gathering for GIS (In Hungarian), Geo2004 Magyar
Földtudományi Szakemberek VII. Világtalálkozója, Szeged,
2004.08.28–09.02. 82.
Gitelson, A., Merzlyak, M.N. and Lichtenthaler, K. (1996): Detection of red
edge position and chlorophyll content by reflectance measurements
near 700 nm. Journal of Plant Physiology (148): 501-508.
Lichti, C., Stickel, E. und Maidl, F.X. (1997): Feldspektrometrische
Messungen
als
Hilfsmittel
für
eine
teilschlagbezogene
Bestandesführung.
Mitt.
des
Gesselschaft
für
Pflanzenbauwissenschaften 10 271-272.
DETECTION OF COMMON RAGWEED (AMBROSIA
ARTEMISIIFOLIA L.) REFLECTANCE SPECTRUM BY MEANS OF
FIELD MEASUREMENTS
A. Jung1, P. Kardeván2 and P. Reisinger3
1
Corvinus University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural Sciences
2
Geological Institute of Hungary
3
University of West-Hungary, Faculty of Food and Agricultural Sciences
Summary
We specified the reference spectra of common ragweed and background vegetation and
presented the results of analysis.
In our investigation we found unique spectral signs for detecting common rag weed in a
mixed sunflower population. Our measurements were carried out by field spectroradiometer
that had very high spectral resolution. Our best results were found to be on 26.06.2006 so
the right chosen phenological state has priority in the detecting process. The technology
will be commonly known, used and relatively cost effective when measurements will be
taken by satellites. For satellite images resampled results we concluded that phenology is
very relevant in the decision process.
159
We would like to continue the field measurements and to involve more satellite images. As
present problem muss be mentioned that atmospheric effect can be very disturbing in the
field also and real atmospheric correction solution are in process nowadays.
We hope that our investigations offer new perspectives in weed monitoring and
management.
160
RESULTS OF WEED SURVEY IN WHEAT CROP
MANURING FIELD EXPERIMENT
András Kismányoky – Éva Lehoczky
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, Institute for Plant
Protection, Department of Herbology and Pesticides Chemistry, Keszthely,
Hungary
The most important component of the plant production technology is the
proper subsequent delivery of nutrients. The winter wheat is one of the
cereals, which have the highest requirements and which most reacts to the
nutrient supply (Szentpétery et al., 2005). The nutrient demands of weeds,
and their capacity for self-accommodation to the differing nutrient levels is
considerably different.
The weeds, just like the cultivated plants absorb the nutrients and water
from the soil to build up their organism. A competition will develop for the
basic growing and developing conditions. The weeds take up big amount of
water during their growing. Also their transpiration rate is very high (Kádár,
1983). A competition takes place when two or more organisms seek after a
given factor to satisfy their special demands in a situation, when the supply
of this factor is lower than the summarized demand of the organisms (Milne,
1961). That is why the cultivated plants are able to tolerate the weeds for a
certain time. If we could keep a crop weed free for an adequate time, the
crop then would be able to shadow and suppress the emerging weeds
(Rademacher, 1966). The competitive ability of the cultivated plants can be
increased by better agrotechnique and by plant breeding (Berzsenyi, 2000).
The soil fertility of a field will be determined mainly by its organic matter
content. The organic matter mineralization, and by this the mobilization of
nitrogen can be influenced by a proper soil use, plant rotation and soil
management. After all, the continuous sustaining of soil fertility, good soil
condition can be promoted by a proper way used agrotechnique
(Kismányoky, 1994).
The proper nutrient delivery, or rather fertilization may promote the
development, competition ability and weed suppressing ability of the
cultivated plant. The biodiversity of weeds makes possible for them using
both the nutrient-poor and nutrient-rich soils. An unwork-menlike
fertilization may be a weed propagating factor if it results in decreasing of
shadowing ability of the cultivated plant, since from the wide weed
spectrum those weeds start to develop and grow, which are most able to use
the extreme nutrition situation. The skilled fertilizing results in a better
covering of the soil by cultivated plant and a minimalized weed presence
(Kádár et al., 1999). The aim our trial was to investigate the weed presence
161
in a long term fertilizing trial in wheat, in relation to the way of nutrient
supply (NPK, NPK+FYM, NPK+haulm rest) and to the nitrogen level.
Materials and Methods
The weed survey were made on a long term fertilizer trial of the
Experimental Station of University of Pannonia, Department of Plant
Protection and Soil Science. This long term bifactorial trial with split-plot
arrangement in three repetition were started in 1983. The plot size was 6×8
m = 48 m2. The test plants were maize, winter wheat and barley.
Treatment A: nutrient: NPK, NPK+35t/ha FYM, NPK+haulm rest.
Treatment B: N kg/ha-1 N0 - N4 (0, 50, 100, 150, 200), and 100 kg P2O5 ha1
and 100 kg K2O. The time of wheat sowing was October 10, 2005. No
weed killing were made up to the time of our investigations, which made
possible the examination of early weed density in relation to the nutrient
delivery (NPK, NPK+FYM, NPK+haulm rest), and level of N-delivery. The
weed survey were made using the Balázs-Ujvárosi method (Reisinger,
2001).
Results
We have found altogether 15 weed species in the trial. In the NPK
treatments were 13 species (Table 1), in the treatment NPK+organic manure
11 species (Table 2), and in the NPK+haulm rest treatment 9 species (Table
3) found.
Table 1. The dominance order of weed species on the plots of NPK
treatment
Weed species
Covering
value*
Frequency of
occurrence
1 Veronica hederifolia L.
2 Abutilon theophrasti MEDIC.
3 Chenopodium album L.
4 Consolida regalis S. F. GRAY
5 Ambrosia artemisiifolia L.
6 Sonchus asper (L.) HILL.
7 Bilderdykia convolvulus (L.) A. LÖVE
8 Stellaria media (L.) VILL.
9 Chenopodium hybridum L.
10 Taraxacum officinale WEB.
11 Raphanus sativus var. Oleiformis
12 Polygonum persicaria L.
13 Cirsium arvense (L.) SCOP.
Total weed covering:
0.81
0.20
0.18
0.11
0.03
0.03
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
1.45
14
14
10
9
5
4
3
3
2
2
2
1
1
-
*in the average of the N-treatments
162
Table 2. The dominance order of weed species on the plots of NPK+FYM
treatment
Weed species
1 Abutilon theophrasti MEDIC.
2 Veronica hederifolia L.
3 Chenopodium album L.
4 Consolida regalis S. F. GRAY
5 Ambrosia artemisiifolia L.
6 Stellaria media (L.) VILL.
7 Polygonum aviculare L.
8 Taraxacum officinale WEB.
9 Chenopodium hybridum L.
10 Oxalis europae JORD.
11 Raphanus sativus var. Oleiformis
Total weed covering:
*in the average of the N-treatments
Covering
value*
Frequency of
occurrence
1.45
1.35
0.92
0.06
0.05
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.01
0.01
3.91
15
14
13
9
5
3
3
3
1
1
1
-
Table 3. The dominance order of weed species on the plots of NPK+ haulm
rest treatment
Weed species
1 Veronica hederifolia L.
2 Chenopodium album L.
3 Abutilon theophrasti MEDIC.
4 Ambrosia artemisiifolia L.
5 Raphanus sativus var. Oleiformis
6 Taraxacum officinale WEB.
7 Bilderdykia convolvulus (L.) A. LÖVE
8 Chenopodium hybridum L.
9 Consolida regalis S. F. GRAY
Total weed covering:
*in the average of the N-treatments
Covering
value*
Frequency of
occurrence
3.46
2.73
0.58
0.20
0.12
0.05
0.05
0.03
0.03
7.24
15
15
13
5
4
3
2
2
2
Most of the weeds (8 species) were belonging to the T4 life cycle type
group. The first in the order of dominance was V. hederifolia on the
treatments fertilizers+haulm rests, while on the treatment fertilizer+FYM
the A. theophrasti was dominant. Considerable differences between the
treatments existed in the weed density and weed dominance sequence. It has
to be noted, that in all the three fertilizing treatments the same three weed
163
species occupied the first places, but their order were not the same. In the
treatment fertilizer only and fertilizer+haulm rest V. hederifolia was the
first, while in treatment fertilizer+FYM the A. theophrasti.
In the NPK treatment the V. hederifolia was the dominant weed species with
an average covering value of 0.81%, the second was the A. theophrasti, and
the third was C. album. In the treatment with FYM the A. theophrasti
showed the highest covering value, 1.45%. The second was again the V.
hederifolia and the third the C. album with 0.92% covering. On the plots of
treatment NPK+haulm rest, similar to that of the treatment NPK only, the V.
hederifolia was the most dominant, here with a value of 3.46%, the second
was C. album (3.46%), and third the A. theophrasti (0.58%).
We observed statistically verified differences in the weed density in relation
to the different ways of fertilizing (Table 4). The highest average weed
covering value (7.24%) was observed on plots of the treatment NPK+haulm
rest. The second highest average value (3.91%) was on plots of treatment
NPK+FYM, while the smallest (1.45%) in the case of treatment with only
NPK.
Table 4. Average weed coverings of the treatments
Weed covering values
NFertilizer treatments
treatments NPK NPK+FYM NPK+haulm rest
N0
1.6
1.96
3.26
N1
1.12
4.7
4.37
N2
1.64
3.6
9.1
N3
1.16
4.87
9.77
N4
1.74
4.43
9.68
average 1.45
3.91
7.24
LSD5%
1.14
The differences among the treatments were significant. The average weed
covering value of the treatment NPK+FYM was 2.7 times higher, than that
of treatment NPK only, and the value of NPK+haulm rest was nearly 5times higher. The difference between NPK+FYM and NPK+haulm rest was
nearly doubled.
Within the different fertilizing treatments only the treatment NPK+haulm
rest was, where the different N-doses caused significant differences in the
weed covering rate. In relation to the N0 and N1 doses, the doses N2, N3 and
N4 caused significant, twofold, threefold higher weed covering rates.
Between the N0 and N1 treatment there was no significant difference in
weed covering, and the differences among N2, N3, N4 treatments were also
small. We can state, that in these last treatments the weed covering had an
164
increasing tendency, as a result of increasing amount of N-doses, and this
tendency was in some case statistically verified.
Conclusions
Based on the results it can be stated, that the extent of weed covering
increased on those plots, where also organic matter (farmyard manure or
haulm rest) were plugged into the soil. In the time of the end of wheat
tillering the difference is considerably bigger – 2.7 to 5-fold – in relation to
the values of plots getting mineral fertilizers only. Within the main
treatments the increasing doses of N resulted in significant weed covering
increase in that treatment, where the haulm rest were plugged into the soil.
The plots getting higher amounts of N-fertilizer, showed higher weed
covering.
Acknowledgements
Thanks are due to professor Dr. Tamás Kismányoky for giving the
possibility to join to his long-term field trial. This research work was
supported by the program of the National Fund for Scientific Research, No.
OTKA K60314 and T 46845.
References
Berzsenyi Z. (2000): Gyomszabályozási stratégiák a fenntartható
növénytermesztésben. Magyar Gyomkut. és Technol. I. (1): 3-21.
Kádár A. (1983): Gyomirtás - Vegyszeres termésszabályozás.
Mezőgazdasági Kiadó, Bp. 9-201.
Kádár I., Kismányoky T., Németh T., Pálmai O. és Sarkadi J. (1999):
Tápanyaggazdálkodásunk az ezred fordulón. Agrokémia és Talajtan
48 (1-2): 193-202.
Kismányoky T. (1994): Trágyázás. In Ragasits I. (szerk.):
Növénytermesztés. Mezőgazda Kiadó, Budapest 53.
Milne, A. (1961): Definition of plant competition among animals.
„Mechanism in Biological Competition” Symp. Soc. Exp. Biol., 15:
40-61.
Rademacher, B. (1966): The current status and achievements of
agrochemical and agrobiologocal research. 13. Weed control in
cereals viewed as a problem of soil fertility. Land Forschung
(Sondech, 20.), 21-30.
Reisinger, P. (2001): Weed surveys on farmlands in Hungary (1947-2000).
Magyar Gyomkut. és Technol. 2 (1): 3-13.
Szentpétery Zs., Jolánkai M. és Szöllősi G. (2005): Nitrogénfejtrágyázás
hatása a búza termésmennyiségére és minőségére. In Pepó P.
165
(szerk.): Korszakváltás a hazai mezőgazdaságban: A modern
növénytermesztés alapjai. Debreceni Egyetem, Debrecen 37-42.
RESULTS OF WEED SURVEY IN WHEAT CROP MANURING
FIELD EXPERIMENT
A. Kismányoky and É. Lehoczky
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, Institute for Plant Protection,
Department of Herbology and Pesticides Chemistry, Keszthely, Hungary
Summary
The weed survey were made on a long term fertilizer trial of the Experimental Station of
University of Pannonia, Department of Plant Protection and Soil Science. This long term
bifactorial trial with split-plot arrangement in three repetition were started in 1983. The plot
size was 6×8 m = 48 m2. The test plants were maize, winter wheat and barley.
Treatment A: nutrient: NPK, NPK+35t/ha FYM, NPK+haulm rest.
Treatment B: N kg/ha-1 N0 - N4 (0, 50, 100, 150, 200), and 100 kg P2O5 ha-1and 100 kg K2O
The time of wheat sowing was October 10, 2005. No weed killing were made up to the
time of our investigations, which made possible the examination of early weed density in
relation to the nutrient delivery (NPK, NPK+FYM, NPK+haulm rest), and level of Ndelivery. The weed survey were made using the Balázs – Ujvárosi method at the end of
wheat tillering.
Based on the results it can be stated, that the extent of weed covering increased on those
plots, where also organic matter (farmyard manure or haulm rest) were plugged into the
soil. In the time of the end of wheat tillering the difference is considerably bigger – 2.7 to
5-fold – in relation to the values of plots getting mineral fertilizers only. Within the main
treatments the increasing doses of N resulted in significant weed covering increase in that
treatment, where the haulm rest were plugged into the soil. The plots getting higher
amounts of N-fertilizer, showed higher weed covering.
166
POTENTIALS OF CHEMICAL CLEARING OF “ENERGY
WILLOW” (SALIX VIMINALIS L.)
Attila Kondor1 – István Lenti2
1
Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Nyíregyháza, Hungary
2
College of Nyíregyháza, Department of Technology and Agriculture,
Nyíregyháza, Hungary
Because of the decrease of the fossilic energy resources and the threats and
unresolved problems of atom energy, efficiency of renewable energy
resources are becoming more and more prominent. Despite of the fact that
renewed energy resources consumption has a relatively long history, its
contribution to the global energy utilization is still fairly moderate.
According to conditions in Hungary in 2003, renewed energy consumption
represents a 3,6% partial produce within the total energy use (Tar et al.,
2003). Under Kyoto Protocol and European Union accession Hungary
agreed on doubling this value by the year of 2010.
It is essential to recognize that these co-national commitments are accord
with our own national aspirations, particularly in decreasing the level of
environmental pollution resulting from energy processing by exploiting
renewable energy resources. Thus, we could also temper the economical
dependency on energy resource import of our country.
One of the greatest potentials of renewable energy resources in Hungary is
that of biomass (Gonczlik et al., 2005), since our land show off very
distinguished natural endowment for the energetic employment of this
resource material.
A plant species bearing outstanding energy-providing qualities amongst
biomass energy resources is “energy willow” (Salix viminalis L.).
A hybrid plant has been improved in Japan which answers a certain floral
attribute characterizing plants with alternative energy resource potentials; it
grows most vigorously. Hence the name “stick willow” used among
cultivators. As far as we know this plant grows 3-5 cm daily, and its specific
yield is 20-40 TN/ha/Y. Its high salicylic alcohol content provides excellent
heat value, and the combustion heat of its twig is 29,2 MJ/kg (Kiss, 2005).
willow plantations are often elements of softwood parks and juvenile
coppices in flooded and shelfy river-flat areas. Plant associations in these
areas show off a relatively plain and bare specific assortment. They
frequently constitute complexes with other plant species on riverbank zones.
Condition of survival for willow are assured by overflowing, however it
develops fairly well on extreme vegetative sites as well – e.g. in case
immersed in water in springtime or growing on arid lands with short water
167
supply (Borhidi A. 2003). Soó (1951) classified poplar (Populus) and
cottonwoods (Salix) genii into willows family Salicaceae reciting individual
species within it referring to their variants and hybrids. In his taxonomic
work Borhidi (1995) placed poplars genus within Salicales order and
willows family Salicaceae. Simon (2000) treated willows family Salicaceae
and Salix genus similarly in which he enumerated 13 species.
Materials and Methods
Our research of cultivation technology or more specifically plant reservation
was accomplished in „Szalka-Pig Ltd.” in Mátészalka. After necessary
professional consideration its proprietor in 2005 decided to procure Salix
viminalis L. willow species by import for a plantation on his humid and
waterish plough lands for energy accumulation purposes. He enlarged this
area with another 43 ha in 2006. The owner then decided to plant the species
in not only adherent (KA 70), but also more loose structured and sandy soils
(KA 30-35).
The applied planting system was the following: 75 x 45-50 cm stem and bed
space in twin rows, followed by a 110 cm width bed space, then again 75 x
45-50 cm planting space in twin rows followed by a 260 cm width
cultivation path. Thus 18-20 thousand plants were settled on 1 ha (see
Figure 1, 2.)
stem space: 45-50 cm
75 cm
110 cm
75 cm
220 cm
75 cm
110 cm
cultivation path
Figure 1. Applied planting system in a Salix viminalis L. plantation
168
75 cm
Figure 2. Bunched willow-cuttings ready for implantation
While inventing growing technology for this plant species, we faced up
challenges in two problematic matters; plant reservation and gathering. This
very essay intents on outlining plant reservation problems of clearing.
The most problematic question is clearing, which is consequent to the act of
planting. We took up as responsibility to elaborate a pre-emergent clearing
method for this willow species, as a clearing treatment completed during
this phase would solve duties alike for a whole planting year.
For pre-emergent clearing experiments we marked out 500 m2 areas of
either loose and sandy, or adherent alluvial soils.
Applying the under-mentioned herbicidal agents, we calibrated the postplantation field experiments for a pre-emergent clearing:
In 2005;
1. terbutilazine
Gold 960 EC
2. mezotrione
Gold 960 EC
3. pendimetaline
Gold 960 EC
4. oxyfluorfen
Gold 960 EC
+S-metolachlor,
Click FL
+
Dual
+S-metolachlor,
Calisto 4 SC +
Dual
+S-metolachlor,
Stomp 330
+
Dual
+S-metolachlor.
Goal 2 E
+
Dual
169
In 2006;
1. terbutilazine
Gold 960 EC
2. mezotrione
Gold 960 EC
3. pendimetaline
Gold 960 EC
+S-metolachlor,
Click FL
+
Dual
+S-metolachlor,
Calisto 4 SC +
Dual
+S-metolachlor,
Stomp 330
Dual
+
On selecting appropriate agent combinations we inquired notable specialists,
whose observations and suggestions were essential in the matter.
We selected the adopted herbicides according to the permission certificate;
in a low value on sandy areas and in a high value in case of adherent soils.
We find it necessary to mention that there is no available licensed herbicide
for clearing willows.
We assessed treatments in 3 occasions fortnightly. The first assessment took
place on 30th July. We took weeds samples and compared the data with one
another and also with those mechanically treated plantations.
Results
It was established that clearing treatments accomplished pre-emergently did
not spoil cultivated crops in any combination or dosage. The effect of
herbicides showed different results.
Dominant weed variants planted on loose, sandy soils as a treatment thinned
out but did not decay. Applying high rate dosages on more adherent soil
ended up in better results.
Several effects of different chemicals are contained in Figure 1. On the basis
of all three treatments we can state that bearbind (Convolvulus arvensis)
does appear, moreover that, compared to the control, pre-emergent clearing
generated good results (see Figure 3).
170
Table 1. Clearing effect of different herbicidal combinations on „energy
willow” plantations
chemical combinations
Click FL + Dual Gold 960 EC
Calisto 4 SC + Dual Gold 960
EC
Stomp 330 + Dual Gold 960 EC
observation 1.
Appeared:
goosefoot family,
ragweed.
Did not appear:
monocotyledonous
weeds.
observation 2.
Appeared:
monocotyledonous
weeds in traces,
ragweed sparsely,
goosefoot family
on an average
coverage.
Appeared: Of
monocotyledonous
weeds: Setaria
glauca.
Did not appear:
dicotyledonous
weeds.
Appeared:
hungry rice in a
great amount. Of
monocotyledonous
weeds: goosefoot
family.
Did not appear:
ragweed.
Appeared:
ragweed.
Did not appear:
monocotyledonous
weeds.
Appeared:
ragweed on a
considerable scale.
Did not appear:
monocotyledonous
weeds were still
not trackable.
171
Figure 3. The control (kontroll) and the treated (kezelt) area
After the first treatment monocotyledonous weeds appeared in traces on the
area, while ragweed (Ambrosia artemisiifolia) appeared scarcely beside the
coverage of the members of the Chenopodiaceae family (Chenopodium
spp.) hungry rice (Digitaria sanguinalis) scattered on a large scale on the
plantation after the second treatment. Of the diphyllous plants goosefoot
family appeared. Ragweed could not be tracked down. The treatment
repeated for the third time ragweed appeared in a considerable amount.
Monocotyledonous weed could not be tracked down.
Summary
Agent combinations used in pre-emergent clearing field experiments with
“energy willow” (Salix viminalis L.):
1. terbutilazine + S-metolachlor,
2. mezotrione + S-metolachlor,
3. pendimetaline + S-metolachlor,
4. oxyfluorfen + S-metolachlor.
These complete clearing experiments did not harm the cultivation plants in
any combination or dosage. Treated on loose and sandy soil, dominant weed
172
species, though thinned out, did not decay. The applied higher dosage on
more adherent soil resulted in fine outcome. Herbicides employed in this
experiment were suitable for a chemical clearing of the willow. This
experiment must be reinforced by long-term experiments.
Relatively resistant weed species in willow plantations:
- bindweed (Convolvulus arvensis),
- ragweed (Ambrosia artemisiifolia),
- marijuana or hemp (Cannabis sativa),
- goosefoot species (Chenopodium spp.).
Based on these results, recorded field experiments could establish the
elaboration of chemical clearing methodology of the willow.
References
Borhidi A. (1995): A zárvatermők fejlődéstörténeti rendszertana.
NemzetiTankönyvkiadó, Budapest 250-251.
Borhidi A. (2003): Magyarország növénytársulásai. Akadémiai Kiadó,
Budapest 383-392.
Kiss E. (2005): Mérési jegyzőkönyv. Dunaújvárosi Főiskola,
Természettudományi és Környezetvédelmi Tanszék, Dunaújváros. 3.
Konclik A., Kazai Zs. és Kőrös G. (2005): Új utak a mezőgazdaságban.
Energia Klub Környezetvédelmi Egyesület, Budapest 6 pp.
Simon T. (2000): A magyarországi edényes flóra határozója. Nemzeti
Tankönyvkiadó, Budapest 657-660.
Soó R. (1951): A magyar növényvilág kézikönyve II. Akadémiai Kiadó,
Budapest 826-833.
Tar F., Kárpáti Z. és Marticsek J. (2005): Megújuló energiaforrások
termelésének és felhasználásának lehetőségei a mezőgazdaságban.
FVM, Budapest. 45 pp.
POTENTIALS OF CHEMICAL CLEARING OF “ENERGY
WILLOW” (SALIX VIMINALIS L.)
Attila Kondor1 – István Lenti2
1
Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Nyíregyháza
College of Nyíregyháza, Department of Technology and Agriculture, Nyíregyháza
2
Summary
A paper about weed control possibilities of energy willow (Salix Viminalis L.)
173
NEW POST EMERGENT HERBICIDE APPLICATION
POSSIBILITY IN MAIZE USING THE PROTOX®
INHIBITOR HERBICIDE, FLUMIOXAZINE (PLEDGE )
András Horn – Ferenc Jáger
Summit-Agro Hungary Ltd., Budapest, Hungary
It is well known that the herbicide active ingredient flumioxazine (Pledge,
Sumi-Soya) belonging to the mode of action: protox-inhibitors, is widely
used in several crops, among other in maize (corn) as preemergent
herbicide.
Flumioxazine is effective mainly against dycotyledonous weeds. Based on
this, under Hungarian conditions it is applied in tankmixture with
graminicide herbicides, most of them belonging to the cloracetanilid group
(acetochlor, dimetenanid, pethoxamid).
Considering several factors, Summit-Agro started trials to check the
possibility to use Flumioxazine not only as preemergent but also as
postemergent herbicide in maize(corn).
---- Under praxis condition several time the preemergent application is
delayed. It was recommended to check the risk of postemergent application.
---- Postemergent application is used on more than 50 % of the total
territory.
---- The cost/hectare of the presently used postemergent herbicides is rather
high.
Based on several information trials, and registration trials in Hungary the
results can be summarized as follows:
A. Flumioxazin (Pledge 50 WP ) can be used as postemergent herbicide in
maise(corn) with the dosage: 80 g/ha at the fenological stage of 3-5 leaves
of maize(corn).
B. Slight phytotoxicity on maize can be observed always after the treatment,
but this damage never influenced the yield.
Full recovery of maize( corn) can be expected within 1- 2 weeks.
C. Merit of the treatment:
------Reasonable cost/ha.
------Flumioxazine (Pledge) is killing (as contact herbicide) all , already
germinated weeds.
174
------Flumioxazine (Pledge) is forming a herbicide –layer (film) on the soil
surface, and it is killing also the weeds germinating after the treatment.
Due to the fact that :
---in Hungary the sown area of maize and sunflower is extremely large.
---Furthermore, Flumioxazine is used preemergent and postemergent in
sunflower.
Flumioxazine is selective on sunflower under Hungarian conditions.
Based on above facts in case of sowing maize after sunflower, sunflower
can be one of most dangerous weed in maize.
To solve this problem Summit Agro developed postemergent (also
Flumioxazine containing) tank mixture in maize, to kill weed sunflowers as
well.
175
COMPETITION OF SUNFLOWER AND MAIZE WITH
SEVERAL WEED SPECIES
István Dávid1 – András Sági1 – Gábor Tarcali1 – László Radócz1 – Imre
Kovács2
1
Debrecen University, Department of Plant Protection, Debrecen
2
BASF Hungária Ltd., Budapest
Weeds endanger safety of crop production reducing seed yield volume and
quality in every year. Their effects depend on crops, weeds associations,
several environmental factors and cropping systems.
Dominance conditions of weeds are depending on cultivated crops and other
local factor, furthermore changing during years or tens of years. These
changings can be followed, so future processes could be forecasted. There
were significant changing in dominance conditions both in arable lands and
plantations (Szőke 2001, Solymosi 2005, Dancza et al. 2006): Occurrence of
some weed species was multiplied in the past tens of years, while other
species were repressed. These invasive weeds are very competitive and able
to decrease yield of crops more often than those were dominant twenty or
thirty years ago. However, there is an increasing demand to protect crops
using less herbicides and minimize environmental pollution and costs of
protection.
Under these circumstances development of more affective methods and
reasonable use of them are necessary to control dominant weed species.
For more effective and economical use of several weed control methods it is
essential to have knowledge about competitiveness of dominant weeds in
the certain area and reasonable degree of weed control.
Ragweed (Ambrosia artemisiifolia), jimsonweed (Datura stramonium),
velvetleaf (Abutilon theophrasti), cocklebur species (Xanthium strumarium,
X. italicum), panic species (Panicum miliacem, P. capillare) and some other
continuously spreading weed species (Molnár and Précsényi 1996, Szőke
2001, Solymosi 2005) have become dominant species of weed associations
of arable lands in Hungary and determine weed controlling processes.
There are a lot of results about competitiveness of these weeds from several
parts of the World, but there are not enough datas in Hungary to use them in
weed control processes successfully.
Beckett et al. (1988) investigated competition of maize with several weed
species. Cockleburs were studied in densities ranging 0.4-6.6 plant/m2. As
result of their investigations it was found that increases in common
cocklebur density caused corn yields to decrease curvilinearly in some
years, and yields decreased linearly as cocklebur density increased in other
176
years. They observed 10-27% maximum yield losses at density of 6.6
plant/m2 in several years. Intraspecific interference among cocklebur plants
increased and the individual effect of each additional weed on yield
diminished at higher weed densities, so the rate of reduction in maize seed
yield declined with increased density.
Bloomberg et al. (1982) studied competition of cocklebur with soybean, and
observed that the full season competition of cocklebur at the density of 1
plant/3m of row can reduce the yield of soybean. Soybean seed yield
increased at a declining rate as the length of time from soybean emergence
to cocklebur emergence increased. They found that when water availability
was not unusually limited soybean seed yield was affected most by
cocklebur competition, but under conditions of limited water availability
soybean vegetative growth was affected most. In their opinion the economic
return on the cost of control of cocklebur may depend on water availability
during the growing season.
Weber and Staniforth (1957), Cartter and Hartwig (1963) found that
common cocklebur plant often form a canopy over the soybean crop while
soybean plants are flowering and the resulting shade may increase pod
abortion and reduce seed yield.
Barrentine (1974) reported a soybean seed yield reduction of 52% from
season-long competition with 26000 cocklebur plants/ha, but removal of
weeds within 4 weeks after soybean emergence prevented seed yield
reductions. Gossett (1971) observed 50% yield reduction as a result of
competition of 14 cocklebur plants/3.1m of soybean row. McWorther and
Hartwig (1972) found yield losses ranging from 63 to 75% for six soybean
varieties from season-long competition with 7400-16500 cocklebur
plants/ha.
Norsworthy (2004) studied cocklebur emergence under soybean and in
absence of soybean. Canopy formation (50% light interception) reduce
magnitude of daily soil temperature fluctuation from 10-15 oC to 5 oC
compared to absence of soybean at 2.5 cm depth. The red/far red ratio of
light available to seed on or near the soil surface was reduced from as much
as 1.2 in full sunlight to less than 0.1 in the presence of a dense soybean
canopy.
He found that cocklebur emergence diminished after soybean canopy
formation, a small portion of its seedbank emerged beneath the canopy. In
his opinion its enough to fill up seedbank. It is confirmed by Regnier et al.
(1988), who reported a good shade tolerance of cocklebur.
Tranel et al. (2003) call attention to differences of effects of several
cocklebur populations. They examined the effect of seven populations from
several parts of USA on soybean on the same habitat, which caused yield
losses of soybean ranging from 25 to 42%.
177
Kovács et al. (2006) investigated velvetleaf competition with maize at weed
density of 1, 2, 5, 10 plant/m2. They found that the competition between
maize and velvetleaf was not considerable, not even at the highest weed
density, because of extreme high amount of rainfall during the vegetation
period.
Schweizer and Bridge (1982) studied competition of velvetleaf with sugar
beet, and they found 14, 17, 25 and 30% root yield losses at weed density of
6, 12, 18, 24 plants/30m of row, respectively.
Hagood et al. (1980) investigated competition between velvetleaf and
soybean at velvetleaf densities ranging from 2.5 to 40 plants/m2.
Materials and Methods
Field experiments were conducted to study competition of Italian cocklebur,
velvetleaf and ragweed with maize and sunflower in experimental sites of
the Department of Plant Protection, Debrecen University in 2005 and 2006.
All treatments were established in small plots (25 m2), in three replications.
Maize and sunflower were seeded in rows spaced 70 cm apart. Plots
consisted of seven rows of maize or sunflower, 5 m long. The area of
experiments was infected by the studied weed species. The three weed
species were hand-thinned 10-15 days after emergence to give densities of
1, 2, 5, 10 plants/m2 in plots of competition study. These plots were
maintained free of other species.
There were established herbicidal weed control experimental plots in which
weeds were controlled by one or two herbicidal treatments, and plots which
were hoed once, as well.
In 2005 weeds sprouted with crops or in 3-4 days, in 2006 cockleburs and
ragweed sprouted with crops but significant part of velvetleaf emerged 1020 days after maize emergence.
Treatments in maize and sunflower are shown by Tables 1 and 2.
Dominant weed species of the area were ragweed, Italian cocklebur,
common lambsquarter, redroot pigweed and velvetleaf.
178
Table 1. Treatments in maize in 2005 and 2006
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Treatments
Weed free control
Weedy control
Hoed at 3-4 leaves stage
Hoed at 6-7 leaves stage
1 plant/m2
2 plant/m2
5 plant/m2
10 plant/m2
pendimetalin+dimetenamid(pre)
bentazon+dicamba (post)
nicosulphuron
+
bentazon+
dicamba+ Dash (post)
2005
+
+
+
+
velvetleaf
velvetleaf
velvetleaf
velvetleaf
+
2006
+
+
+
+
velvetleaf
velvetleaf
velvetleaf
velvetleaf
+
+
+
Table 2. Treatments in sunflower in 2005 and 2006
Treatments
2005
1 Weed free control
+
2 Weedy control
+
3 Hoed at 4 leaves stage
+
4 Hoed at 8 leaves stage
+
5 1 plant/m2
velvetleaf
6
2 plant/m2
velvetleaf
7
5 plant/m2
velvetleaf
8
10 plant/m2
velvetleaf
9
pendimetalin+dimetenamid(pre)
imazamox (post)
+
2006
+
+
+
+
cocklebur
ragweed
cocklebur
ragweed
cocklebur
ragweed
cocklebur
ragweed
+
Precipitation was more than enough for maize and sunflower during
growing season in both years (Figure 1), temperature was optimal for crops
and weeds in 2005 but it was below average in the beginning of the season
in 2006, and it may effect on emergence of velvetleaf.
Heights of crops were measured in flowering and seed yield was measured
after harvest.
179
140
2005
Precipitation, mm
120
2006
100
80
60
40
20
0
April
May
June
July
August
September
Figure 1. Precipitation on experimental area in 2005 and 2006
Results and Discussion
The height of maize reduced only in weedy control plots compared to weed
free control by 12 and 33% in 2005 and 2006, respectively. Other treatments
have not significant effects on the height of maize (Figure 2).
120%
120%
100%
Yield, t/ha
100%
80%
80%
60%
60%
40%
yield 2006
40%
Height, cm
140%
yield 2005
20%
height 2006
20%
0%
SD5%
wing+cambio
10ABUTH
5ABUTH
2ABUTH
1ABUTH
Hoed 6-7l
Hoed 3-4l
Weedy control
Weed free
0%
MotivellTD
height 2006
Figure 2. Yield and height of maize in 2005 and 2006
Effects of velvetleaf were significant on seed yield in 2005 in some cases,
but it did not reduce yield of maize at any level of competition in 2006.
180
In 2005, yield was reduced by 47% in weedy control plots. Effects of
density of 1 and 2 velvetleaf plants/m2 were not significant, but 5 and 10
plants/m2 reduced seed yield by 28 and 31%, respectively. Yield losses
could be avoid by hoeing once at 3-4 or 6-7 leaves stages of maize and both
of the herbicidal treatments. Good competitiveness of maize and good
effects of one-time hoeing in this year may be accounted by plentiful
precipitation and optimal temperature, so the growth of maize was very
intensive at the beginning of the season when weeds not delayed it that time.
In the second part of the growing season weeds were less competitive with
the 300 cm height maize.
In 2006, yield was reduced by 74% in weedy control plots, but yields of
maize were not influenced significantly in other treatments. One-time
hoeing and herbicidal treatments proved seed yield similarly to former year.
Most of velvetleaf plants sprouted 10-20 after maize emergence because of
below-average temperature in the beginning of the growing season. This
may be the main reason that velvetleaf could not reduce yield at any level of
competition in this year (Figure 3).
4,5
250
4,0
150
2,5
2,0
100
1,5
0
SD5%
Hoed 6-7l
Hoed 3-4l
Weedy control
Weed free
0,0
wing+pulsar
height
50
10ABUTH
0,5
5ABUTH
yield
2ABUTH
1,0
1ABUTH
Yield, t/ha
3,0
Height, cm
200
3,5
Figure 3. Height and yield of sunflower as results of competition with
velvetleaf
181
3,00
250
200
2,00
150
1,50
100
1,00
yield
0,50
50
SD5%
0
wing+pulsar
10XANIT
5XANIT
2XANIT
Hoed 6-7l
Hoed 3-4l
Weedy control
Weed free
1XANIT
height
0,00
Height, cm
Yield, t/ha
2,50
Figure 4. Height and yield of sunflower as results of competition with
cocklebur
3,00
250
200
2,00
150
1,50
100
1,00
yield
0,50
Height, cm
Yield, tha
2,50
50
height
SD5%
wing+pulsar
10AMBEL
5AMBEL
2AMBEL
1AMBEL
Hoed 6-7l
Hoed 3-4l
Weedy control
0
Weed free
0,00
Figure 5. Height and yield of sunflower as results of competition with
ragweed
Height of sunflower was not influenced significantly by hoeing and the
herbicidal treatment and in weedy control, but sunflower plants elongated
by 10-15 cm as results of velvetleaf competition in 2005 (Figure 3).
In 2006, heights of sunflower were reduced only in weedy control of area of
cocklebur-competition experiments and by 2 and 5 cocklebur plants/m2 by
182
17, 8 and 10 cm, respectively. Other treatments did not influence the height
of sunflower (Figures 4 and 5).
In 2005, yield of sunflower were reduced only by 10 velvetleaf plants/m2
and in weedy control plots up to 62 and 64% of weed free control (Figure
3).
In 2006, one-time hoeing and herbicidal treatments proved seed yield of
sunflower, and 1 cocklebur or ragweed plants/m2 did not reduced seed yield.
2, 5 and 10 cocklebur or ragweed plants/m2 decreased yield by 14, 34, 43
and 27, 31, 32%, respectively. Seed yield of weedy control plots were 28
and 46% of weed free plots on cocklebur-competition and ragweedcompetition areas (Figure 4, 5).
References
Barrentine, W.L. (1974): Common cocklebur competition in soybeans.
Weed Science 22: 600-603.
Beckett, T., Stoller, E.W., and Wax, L.M. (1988): Interference of four
annual weeds in corn. Weed Science 36: 764-769.
Bloomberg, J.R., Kirkpatrick B.L., Wax, L.M. (1982): Competition of
common cocklebur (Xanthium pensylvanicum) with soybean
(Glycine max). Weed Science 30: 507-513.
Cartter, J. L., Hartwig, E. E. (1963): The management of soybean. In: The
soybean, Ed.: Norman, A. G., Academic Press, New York, 162-221.
Dancza I, Tóth Á, Bencséné B. G., Dellei A., Doma Cs., Gara S., Godáné B.
M., Graca L., Gyulai B., Hartmann F., Hódi L., Hoffmann É.,
Hornyák A., Kadaravek B., Kőrösmezei Cs., Madarász J., Molnár F.,
Nagy M., Novák R., Péter J., Szabó L., Szentey L., Ughy P., Varga
L. (2006): A szőlő- és gyümölcsültetvények legfontosabb
gyomnövényei az országos gyomfelvételezés eredményei alapján.
52. Növényvédelmi Tudományos Napok, Budapest, 2006. február
23-24. Összefoglalók, 81.
Gossett, B.J. (1971): Cocklebur – soybean’s worst enemy. Weeds Today 2:
9-11.
Hagood E.S., Bauman T.T., Williams J. L., and Schreiber M.M. (1980):
Growth analysis of soybean (Glycine max) in competition with
velvetleaf. Weed Science 28: 729-734.
Kovács I., Béres I., Kazinczi G., Torma M. (2006): Competition between
maize and Abutilon theoprasti (Medik.) in additive experiments.
Zeitschrift für Pflanzenkrankheiten und Pflanzenschutz, Sonderheft
20: 767-771.
McWhorter, C.G., Hartwig, E.E. (1972): Competition of johnsongrass and
cocklebur with six soybean varieties. Weed Science 20: 56-59.
183
Molnár I., Précsényi I. (1996): Kukoricavetések gyomnövényeinek
változása Kelet-Magyarországon a Bihari tájegységben, 1994-1995.
Növénytermelés 45: 265-270.
Norsworthy, J.K. (2004): Soybean canopy formation effects on pitted
morningglory (Ipomoea lacunosa) common cocklebur (Xanthium
strumarium), and sicklepod (Senna obtusifolia) emergence. Weed
Science 52: 954-960.
Regnier, E.E., Salvucci, M.E., and Stoller, E.W. (1988): Photosynthesis and
growth responses to irradiance in soybean (Glycine max) and three
brodleaf weeds. Weed Science 36: 487-496.
Solymosi P. (2005): Az éghajlat változásának hatása a gyomflórára a hazai
kutatások tükrében, az 1969 és 2004 közötti időszakban.
Növényvédelem 41: 13-24.
Schweizer, E.E. and Bridge, L.D. (1982): Sunflower (Helianthus annuus)
and velvetleaf (Abutilon theophrasti) interference in sugarbeet (Beta
vulgaris). Weed Science 30: 514-519.
Szőke L. (2001): A melegigényes gyomfajok gyors terjedése és a
klímaváltozás összefüggése. Növényvédelem 37: 10-12.
Tranel, P.J., Jeschke, M.R., Wassom, J.J., Maxwell, D.J., and Wax, L.M.
(2003): Variation in soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) interference
among common cocklebur (Xanthium strumarium L.) accessions.
Crop Protection 22: 375-380.
Weber, C.R., Staniforth, D.W. (1957): Competitive relationships in variable
weed and soybean stands. Agronomy Journal 49: 440-444.
COMPETITION OF SUNFLOWER AND MAIZE WITH SEVERAL
WEED SPECIES
I. Dávid1 , A. Sági1 , G. Tarcali1 , L. Radócz1 and I. Kovács2
1
Debrecen University, Department of Plant Protection, Debrecen, Hungary
2
BASF Hungária Ltd., Budapest, Hungary
Summary
Field experiments were cunducted to sudy competition of maize and sunflower with
velvetleaf, Italian cocklebur and ragweed in Deberecen, Hungary in 2005 and 2006. Weed
densities were 1, 2, 5 and 10 plants/m2.
In 2005, velvetleaf emerged with maize reduced seed yield by 28 and 31% at the density of
5 and 10 plants/m2, respectively. In 2006, velvetleaf emerged 10-20 days after maize did
not reduced seed yield at any level of competition. The height of maize was not influenced
by velvetleaf competition. In 2005, velvetleaf emerged with sunflower reduced seed yield
by 38% at density of 10 plants/m2, but lower densities of the weed species could not reduce
seed yield. In 2006, cocklebur reduced seed yield of sunflower by 14, 34 and 43% at the
densities of 2, 5, 10 plants/m2, respectively, ragweed reduced yield by 27, 31 and 32% at
the same densities. The height of sunflower were decreased only by the densities of 2 and 5
cocklebur plants/m2.
184
CHANGES IN ALLELOPATHY OF XANTHIUM
ITALICUM MOR.
István Dávid
Debrecen University, Department of Plant Protection, Debrecen, Hungary
All over the world cocklebur species cause severe problems mainly in row
crops, but their damage can be considerable on pasturelands and as invasive
species in natural communities as well. Therefore, several authors studied
the biology, competitiveness and the regulation potentials of the Xanthium
genus.
Besides the widespread examination of competition ability, a relatively less
intensively studied area is the allelopathy of cocklebur, although its
existence has been identified for a long time. Therefore, the role of
allelopathy in the competitiveness of the species has not yet been clarified.
The actual role of allelopathy is controversial not only in cockleburs, but in
other allelopathic weed species as well. The reason for this is the fact that
allelopathy is influenced by several environmental factors and their
heterogenicity affected research results as well.
Rice (1964) is one of the first investigators studying allelopaty of
cockleburs. He studied the effect of Xanthium spp. and other species on
nitrogen-fixing and nitrifying bacteria (Azotobacter, Rhizobium,
Nitrobacter, Nitrosomonas).
Extracts of cockleburs inhibited several Azotobacter, Rhizobium,
Nitrobacter strains. He found also that effect of cocklebur samples are
different depending on collecting dates, however, he did not observe
differences in phenological stages of plants. He hypothetised that
environmental factors modified the allelopathy.
He found inhibitory effect not only in case of extracts but in case of soil of
cockleburs.
Rice also observed that effects of extracts depended on the age of the plat
organs were used for tests.
Bushra et al. (1987) studied effects of extracts of several organs of
cocklebur on germination and growth of lettuce, Brassica campestris, maize
and Pennisetum americanum. Both residues and leachates of plants were
effective in their experiments. They determined caffeic acid, p-hidroxibenzoic acid, p-coumaric acid, klorogenic acid as allelopathic agents.
Einhelling et al. (1985) examined the effects of allelochemicals and
allelopatic plants (common cocklebur) on plant-water relationships.
Cinnamic acid derivatives increased leaf diffuse resistance, decreased water
potential, osmotic potential and dried weight of grain sorghum. Cocklebur
185
residues decreased only dried weight significantly compared to the untreated
plants.
Chon et al.(2003) studied extracts of 16 Compositae plants. The results
showed the highest inhibition for the extracts from Lactuca sativa,
Xanthium occidentale and Cirsium japonicum. They identified transcinnamic acid, chlorogenic acid, coumarin, coumaric-acid from extracts of
cocklebur.
Casini (2004) examined extracts and residues of cockleburs on maize. He
found strong inhibitory effect of either extracts or residues, but his results
differ from those observed by Bushra et al. (1987).
He examined several maize hybrids, and found differences among
sensitivity of them against allelopathy of cocklebur.
Cutler and Cole (1983) studied allelopathic affects of atractylozide and
carboxyatractylozide. These compounds can be found in young cocklebur
plants, and cause poisoning mainly in sheep, cattles and pigs. They observed
inhibition and necrotic symptoms on maize, wheet and tobacco.
Materials and Methods
Study on allelopathy in biotests
The allelopathy of Italian cocklebur was studied in several biotests from
2002 to 2005, for which we used fresh and dried (at 60 oC for 48 hours)
weed sprouts and roots separately. We used the remnants of sprouts and
roots separately and in a mixture as well. During the preparation of extracts,
for 100 ml of solvent we used fresh sprout or root of 4, 8, 16, 20g, or the
respective amount of dried parts.
The applied solvent was tap water or ethanol (96%). Extraction took place at
room temperature for 24 hours in darkness. The test plants used in biotests
were garden cress (Lepidium sativum L.), sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.),
spring barley (Hordeum distichon L.) and maize (Zea mays L.), which were
germinated in Petri-dishes (diameter: 11cm). We evaluated the germination,
root and sprout growth of sugar beet, as well as the root and sprout growth
of the other three test crops.
We examined the following influences of factors affecting allelopathy: the
means of lighting during donor plant production, the development stage of
donor plants, the density and water supply of their population, the effect of
precipitation, the preparation of samples for extraction (using fresh or dried
and ground plants) and the type of the extracting agent.
186
The quantitative measurement of allelochemicals
Besides germination trials, we followed-up the quantitative changes in
cinnamic acid derivatives, which are known as allelochemicals detected
earlier from cockleburs, i.e. chlorogenic acid, coumarin, p-coumaric acid
and trans-cinnamic acid.
For the quantitative determination of the 4 compounds we prepared an
extract from dried crop samples with distilled water, using a sample of 4 g
and distilled water of 100 cm3, which was shaken for 2 hours. After filtering,
the agents were identified with Merck-Hitachi HPLC equipment. The
circumstances of separation were the following:
column: Lichrospher 100RP-18, 125x4mm;
12:15:1 mixture of eluent: water: methanol: acetic acid;
flow: 1ml/minute.
Detecting was performed with a L-4500 Diode Array Detector at a wave
length of 275 nm. For quality identification we used a comparative solvent
liquid containing chlorogenic acid (SIGMA), p-coumaric acid (SIGMA),
coumarin (SIGMA) and trans-cinnamic acid (ALDRICH).
The quantitative identification of allelochemicals took place in the Regional
Agro-Instrument Centre, Centre of Agricultural Sciences, University of
Debrecen.
The gained values were compared with the findings of biotests.
Results and Discussion
We tested the allelopathy of Italian cockleburs grown in fields and in
greenhouses on cress, maize and spring barley.
Extracts prepared from the fresh and dry parts, the root and sprout remnants
of Italian cocklebur affected the test plants and their vital processes
(germination, growth) in a different way; however, all test crops verified the
allelopathic effect in the performed biotests. Treatments affected the
germination and growth of sugar beet, whereas they influenced only the
growth of the other three test crops.
However, the rate and means of allelopathy depended not only on the
species of the test crop, but on other factors as well, which supposedly
influence the production, secretion and solubility of allelochemicals.
• The way and rate of the effect changed depending on the used plant
organs.
• Biotest results were determined by the fact, whether extracts were
prepared from live plants or from plant remnants.
• The effect was influenced by the solvent (water, ethanol) on certain
test crops.
187
•
Extracts prepared from the same parts of plants grown in fields and
in greenhouses resulted in different effects.
• The inhibitory effects of extracts prepared from cockleburs grown in
greenhouses also depended on the fact, whether the weeds were
produced in short or long day circumstances.
• The effects of cocklebur grown in fields were affected by the water
supply of the weeds before sample taking, by the amount of
precipitation before sample taking, the phenological stage of the
weeds and the density of their population.
• The primary material of samples (fresh, dried and ground) also
affected allelopathy.
• Germination temperature also influenced the end result of biotests.
The effects of extracts prepared from fresh plant parts for test crops can be
summarized in the following way:
Italian cocklebur extracts inhibited the germination of sugar beet test crops
in a smaller or greater level, however, factors mentioned earlier affected the
power of the inhibitory effect and the rate of effect loss. In general, it can be
concluded that the effect of sprout extracts was greater than that of root
extracts. In 2003 the germination inhibiting effect of young plant extracts
was stronger than that of blooming plants, whereas such difference could
not be detected in 2004. As a result of heavier precipitation, extracts had a
greater germination inhibiting effect in both years. Out of the two years, this
effect of precipitation was less significant in 2004, in which year the
weather was more favourable and received more balanced precipitation.
As long as extracts were effective, they affected the growth of the test crops
positively, but in some cases inhibitory effects also emerged. Extracts were
more effective on the root growth of the crops than on their sprout growth.
In the case of cress, only some extracts of great concentration could cause
the large-scale inhibition of germination. However, their effects on growth
varied on a large scale in relation to the antecedents and circumstances of
extract preparation. Regarding the crop parts used for extract preparation we
experienced that sprout extracts were mostly of greater inhibitory effect than
root extracts. In sprout extracts, the inhibitory effects exercised on test crops
were greater before precipitation than after it, when in several cases
inhibition did not take place or the extracts had stimulating effects.
In root extracts this phenomenon could not be observed; moreover, several
cases showed exactly its opposite. However, the effect was influenced not
only by precipitation, but by other factors as well. The growth of garden
cress was inhibited by the extracts of blooming plants more significantly in
both years, than those of 4-5 leaf plants. Nevertheless, the effect of
cocklebur population density was only significant in the case of some
188
140%
fresh samples 6th day
120%
dried samples 6th day
100%
80%
60%
40%
RD 07.10
RT 07.10
RD 07.06
RT 07.06
R 06.07
R 06.01
R 05.28
R 05.26
SD 07.10
ST 07.10
SD 07.06
S 06.07
S 06.01
S 05.28
0%
ST 07.06
20%
S 05.26
Growth in percentage of control
samples in 2004. Extracts affected the sprout growth of test plants less, than
their root growth.
Maize was usually less sensitive to the same extracts than the above
mentioned two test crops, but precipitation, population density and the
phenology of donor plants influenced allelopathy in this case as well.
Extracts from cockleburs grown in fields inhibited maize growth solely in
the case of root samples from dense populations in July, but after
precipitation this effect could not be experienced.
In the case of cress and sugar beet we compared the effects of extracts from
fresh crop parts with the effect of extracts from the dried and ground pieces
of the samples. In the case of cress the effects of extracts from fresh and
dried parts were similar (on the 6th day: R=0.709), but the latter was more
effective (Figure 1). However, the composition and solubility of
allelochemicals effecting on sugar beet modified in the course of drying and
grinding so much that there was no correlation between the effects of
extracts from fresh and dry samples on day 10th in respect of germination
R=0.049, and root growth R=-0.262 (Figure 2).
Figure 1. Effects of extracts made from fresh and dried samples of
cocklebur on root growth of cress at 6th day
S: shoot extract; R: root extract; T: extract made from thin stand of cocklebur; D: extract
made from dense stand of cocklebur.
(Concentration of extract made from fresh cocklebur is 12g/100ml, made from dried
cocklebur is equivalent to the fresh cocklebur extract.)
189
fresh samples 10th day
dried samples 10th day
200
150
100
RD 07.10
RT 07.10
RD 07.06
RT 07.06
R 06.07
R 05.28
SD 07.10
ST 07.10
SD 07.06
ST 07.06
S 06.07
S 06.01
S 05.28
0
S 05.26
50
Control
Growth in percentage of control
250
Figure 1. Effects of extracts made from fresh and dried samples of
cocklebur on root growth of sugar beet at 10th day
S: shoot extract; R: root extract; T: extract made from thin stand of cocklebur; D: extract
made from dense stand of cocklebur.
(Concentration of extract made from fresh cocklebur is 12g/100ml, made from dried
cocklebur is equivalent to the fresh cocklebur extract.)
The effects of cocklebur remnants on test crops were determined by the
temperature of germination. Inhibitory effects on test crops were more
significant at a lower temperature, which was less favourable for
germination. The growth of cress was inhibited by extracts in a greater
extent at a lower temperature than at room temperature.
In fact, extracts could not inhibit the germination of sugar beet at room
temperature, but at 8-10 oC it was inhibited by each extract containing root
remnants. However, there was no significant difference in the stimulating
effect on sugar beet growth, depending on the temperature of germination.
Maize proved to be sensitive to extracts containing sprout remnants at
temperatures unfavourable for germination; however, at room temperature
all extracts were ineffective for this test crop.
In the sprouts and roots of cockleburs growing under natural field
conditions, as a result of the changeability of allelopathy, we could followup the quantitative changes of four allelochemicals: that of trans-cinnamic
acid, coumarin, p-coumaric acid and chlorogenic acid. The concentration of
190
the given compounds showed a modification of 4.6-15.5 times in sprouts,
and that of 2.6-29.8 times in roots in the vegetation period (Figures 3 and 4).
5,500
Shoot, chlorogenic acid
5,000
Shoot, cinnamic acid
4,500
Root, chlorogenic acid
4,000
Root, cinnamic acid
mg/g
3,500
3,000
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
0,500
0,000
26 May
28 May
01 June
07 June 06 July T 06 July D 10 July T 10 July D
Figure 3. Changes in amounts of chlorogenic acis and trans-cinnamic acid in
shoots and roots of cocklebur
T: extract made from thin stand of cocklebur; D: extract made from dense stand of
cocklebur
Although allelopathy is mostly influenced by the joint effects of several
compounds, the quantitative changes of p-coumarin acid and trans-cinnamic
acid showed a correlation with the effects of extracts on cress. The
correlation between the quantity of p-coumaric acid and the early sprout
growth of cress was: y=-7.0535+(-3.3198*lnx) (R2=0.811); the correlation
with root growth was: y=-11.009+(-5.7628*lnx) (R2=0.775).
The quantitative changes of cinnamic acid showed a correlation with the
root growth of cress, which was experienced at a later measurement (R=0,743). However, in other cases we could not draw conclusions from the
quantitative changes of any compounds on the growth and germinating
power of the test crops, which denoted that the effects of other
allelochemicals in cockleburs might be significant.
191
1,300
1,200
Shoot, coumarin
1,100
Shoot, p-coumaric acid
1,000
Root, coumarin
0,900
Root, p-coumaric acid
mg/g
0,800
0,700
0,600
0,500
0,400
0,300
0,200
0,100
0,000
26 May
28 May
01 June
07 June 06 July T 06 July D 10 July T 10 July D
Figure 4. Changes in amounts of coumarin and p-coumaric acid in shoots
and roots of cocklebur
T: extract made from thin stand of cocklebur; D: extract made from dense stand of
cocklebur
The changeability of allelopathy caused by cockleburs, which can be
experienced on test crops and the significant quantitative differences of
allelochemicals depending on external and internal factors make it necessary
to find out the factors which are responsible for the changes, to quantify
their effects and to take them into consideration in studying allelopathy so
that we can use research findings more extensively.
On the basis of our findings, the roles of the studied and other factors can be
significant in many cases. Further investigations are needed to find out the
effective factors in certain cases of allelopathy and to identify their exact
effects. The factors which mostly influence research findings are to be
identified, e.g. from the quantity and intensity of precipitation before sample
taking, we can only draw direct conclusions concerning the extraction of
allelochemicals from crop sprouts. Crop water supply and its changes are
caused, besides the effects of occasional precipitation, by the water supply
capacity of soil before and after rain, atmospheric dryness etc., so
considering these facts, the effect of precipitation can only be considered
indirect. In these cases, the measurement of qualities which reflect crop
water supply better, such as water potential could be suggested for further
examinations.
192
References
Bushra, I., Farruk, H., Farhat, B. (1987): Allelopathic effects of Pakistani
weeds. Xanthium strumarium L. Pakistan Journal of Scientific and
Industrial Research 30: 530-533.
Casini, P. (2004): Allelopathic influences of common cocklebur (Xanthium
italicum Moretti) on maize. Allelopathy Journal 11: 189-199.
Chon, S.U., Kim, Y.M., and Lee, J.C. (2003): Herbicidal potential and
quantification of causative allelochemicals from several Compositae
weeds. Weed Research 43: 444-450.
Cutler, H.G., Cole, R.J. (1983): Carboxyatractyloside: a compound from
Xanthium strumarium and Atrachtylis gummifera with plant growth
inhibiting properties. The probable „inhibitor A”. Journal of Natural
Products 46: 609-613.
Einhelling, F.A., Stille M.M., and Schon, M.K. (1985): Effects of
allelochemicals on plant-water relationships. In: The chemistry of
allelopathy. Ed.: Thompson, A. C. American Chemical Society,
Washington, D.C. pp. 179-196.
Rice, E.L. (1964): Inhibition of nitrogen-fixing and nitrifying bacteria by
seed plants. Ecology 45: 824-837.
193
CHANGES IN ALLELOPATHY OF XANTHIUM ITALICUM MOR.
I. Dávid
Debrecen University, Department of Plant Protection, Debrecen, Hungary
Summary
Cockleburs are noxious weeds in the World and in Hungary, as well. Its allelopathy is one
of the reason that it was examined in several studies. Extract’s and residues of the weed
were found to be effective against crops and other weeds, and some chemicals were
determined which can play role in it. In some cases results of investigation of allelopathy
don’t reproducible exactly. The reason is, that there are some factors wich can modify the
outcome of allelopathy but these are not taken into consideration. Several biotest were
conducted to study modifying factors of allelopathy, and some allelochemicals were
quantified in relation with these factors. The way and rate of the effect changed depending
on the used plant organs. Biotest results were determined by the fact, whether extracts were
prepared from live plants or from plant remnants. The effect was influenced by the solvent
(water, ethanol) on certain test crops. Extracts prepared from the same parts of plants grown
in fields and in greenhouses resulted in different effects. The inhibitory effects of extracts
prepared from cockleburs grown in greenhouses also depended on the fact, whether the
weeds were produced in short or long day circumstances. The effects of cocklebur grown in
fields were affected by the water supply of the weeds before sample taking, by the amount
of precipitation before sample taking, the phenological stage of the weeds and the density
of their population. The primary material of samples (fresh, dried and ground) also affected
allelopathy. Germination temperature also influenced the end result of biotests. The
concentration of the four compounds (trans-cinnamic acid, coumarin, p-coumaric acid and
chlorogenic acid) showed a modification of 4.6-15.5 times in sprouts, and that of 2.6-29.8
times in roots in the vegetation period. Although allelopathy is mostly influenced by the
joint effects of several compounds, the quantitative changes of p-coumarin acid and transcinnamic acid showed a correlation with the effects of extracts on cress.
194
POSTER SESSION
195
196
EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE ON THE GROWTH OF
MACROPHOMINA PHASEOLINA ISOLATES
Izabella Csöndes and Sándor Kadlicskó
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, Plant Protection
Institute, Keszthely, Hungary
The economic importance of charcoal rot disease caused by Macrophomina
phaseolina (Tassi) Goidanich [synanamorf: Rhizoctonia bataticola
(Taubenhaus) E.J. Butler] is still considerable. This polyphagous pathogen
infects more than 300 plant species. In Hungary it causes serious damage –
especially in dry, hot seasons – on sunflower, maize, legumes, paprika and
many other plants (Békési, 1970; Varga et al., 1997). The damage
influenced mainly by the season, location, water and nutrient supply. The
disease can be diagnosed on the basis of the symptoms: ash grey spots on
the stems and small, black microsclerotia developed in the pith and root
tissues. The effect of temperature on the growth of Macrophomina has been
investigated earlier by Das (1988), who found that the optimal temperature
of for mycelia growth and microsclerotia development was 30 °C in India.
The aim of our study was to investigate the effect of temperature on
growing pattern of 35 Macrophomina phaseolina isolates from different
Hungarian locations.
Materials and Methods
The experiments have been made under the same conditions for all
Macrophomina phaseolina isolates, except the different temperatures, where
the growing pattern of the fungal colonies were measured. Initial testmaterial was collected from 32 different sunflower fields in September,
2005 (Table 1 and 2). From one site (Cserkeszőlő), two samples were
collected, one from cultivated sunflower and the other one from a volunteer
sunflower. From three sites (Bóly, Iregszemcse, Keszthely) samples were
collected from soybeans, too. Scrapings from the infected plant debris were
taken to potato dextrose agar (PDA) medium, at 25 °C. Pure cultures were
made by threefold passage. PDA medium were poured into 9 cm diameter
sterilized Petri dishes. 5 mm in diameter agar discs with overwintering
propagules were taken from the well growing cultures kept on 25 °C and
transferred to agar media. Following the inoculation Petri dishes were taken
in darkness into thermostats adjusted to 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40 °C,
respectively. The effect of temperature on growing patterns of
Macrophomina was tested in four replications. Colony diameters were
197
measured after 3, 5 and 6 days followed the inoculations, respectively.
Statistical analysis was made by Microsoft Excel programme. Because of
the large extent of the samples this work shows only representative results.
Results
It is typical for this pathogen, that first the mycelia start to growth and then
follows the formation of microsclerotia. The heat tolerance of isolates
showed a wide range of differences. The average of mycelium colonies in
diameters are given in the Table 1, and the diameter of microsclerotial
colonies are summarized in the Table 2. Considerable differences among the
isolates can be seen in both cases. Significance values were given on LSD
for 5 % probability.
At 10 °C no mycelia growth was observed, therefore no data are present in
the tables. Even on the 5th day some of the isolates showed a small
mycelium growth, at 10 °C was very slow one, the highest daily growth rate
was only 0.71 mm/day at soybean isolate (Iregszemcse).
At the 3rd day at 15 °C only two isolates started to grow, one from
sunflower (Tordas) and the other one from soybean (Iregszemcse). In the
average of four replication the growing rate of Tordas isolate was only 1.0
mm/day, and that of Iregszemcse was 4 mm (value of SD 5% was 0.33).
The 5th day slow growing rates were observed in nine isolates of all ones
(Bize, Dunaföldvár, Hódmezővásárhely, Kaposvár-Toponár, Keszthely,
Lepsény, Nyíregyháza, Szederkény and Székkutas) from sunflower, and one
(Keszthely) from soybean. On the 6th day seven other isolates started their
mycelial growth. At 15 °C the Iregszemcse isolate showed the highest
average daily growth rate (2.04 mm).
Because of the lack of microsclerotia formation on the 3rd day at 10, 15, 20
and 40 °C, and on the 5th and 6th day 10, 15, and 40 °C, data are not
included in the Table 2. The Table 1 does not show the values of the 5th and
6th days mycelium colony in diameters at 25, 30 and 35 °C because all have
reached the sides of Petri dishes (90 mm), except the soybean isolate of
Iregszemcse. This value on the 5th day at 25 °C was 45.75 mm, at 30 °C
was 47.25 mm, and at 35 °C was 41.75 mm. On the 6th day at 25 °C the
diameter of the colonies was 54.25 mm, at 30 °C 56.50 mm, and at 35 °C
46.0 mm, respectively, that means, that this isolate significantly differed
from the other isolates. The Table 2 does not show the values of
microsclerotial diameters at 25, 30 and 35 °C, at the 5th and 6th days
because these isolates have already reached a value of 90 mm, except the
soybean isolate of Iregszemcse. The Iregszemcse isolate showed a
microsclerotial value on the 5th day at 25 °C was 31.25 mm; at 30 °C 33.50
mm; at 35 °C 32.0 mm. On the 6th day at 25 °C was 42.00 mm; at 30 °C
198
47.25 mm; at 35 °C 35.0 mm. This isolate significantly differed from the
other ones.
Table 1. Average colony growing in diameters of Macrophomina isolates
Site of collection
Colony in diameters (mm)
3rd day
5th day
25
30
35
40
10
15
72.00 90.00 90.00 1.75 2.00 2.00
78.50 87.00 89.75 31.25 1.5.
1.50
79.50 89.25 90.00 15.25 0.00 0.00
78.25 90.00 90.00 10.25 0.00 0.00
67.75 74.75 90.00 1.25 1.50 2.00
69.25 74.75 89.00 3.25 0.00 0.00
55.75 76.00 71.25 2.00 0.00 0.00
62.75 72.50 80.25 0.00 0.00 0.00
69.25 76.25 89.25 11.00 0.00 1.50
68.25 79.00 76.00 4.00 1.50 1.75
61.75 69.00 82.75 0.75 0.00 2.00
76.25 87.00 87.75 7.00 0.00 0.00
77.50 89.25 90.00 21.75 0.00 0.75
63.25 76.75 75.75 1.25 1.75 1.00
64.50 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
65.75 81.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 1.75
69.50 81.00 89.00 62.25 0.00 0.00
66.50 75.75 90.00 9.00 0.00 0.00
70.00 88.00 78.75 0.00 0.00 0.00
77.75 90.00 90.00 2.00 0.00 2.00
84.00 89.25 90.00 0.25 1.50 1.25
61.25 85.00 80.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
61.00 69.75 75.50 0.25 0.00 0.50
64.00 88.75 87.00 4.75 0.00 0.00
64.25 73.75 72.75 0.00 1.50 1.00
80.25 81.75 90.00 25.25 0.00 0.00
66.00 68.25 83.00 2.75 0.00 1.75
65.50 81.75 90.00 1.00 0.00 0.00
60.00 66.00 73.00 2.00 0.00 1.75
85.25 83.25 88.00 1.00 0.00 0.00
69.50 82.25 90.00 0.25 0.00 0.00
59.25 65.75 70.25 0.00 0.00 2.50
52.50 82.25 71.75 0.00 0.00 0.00
31.00 29.00 29.50 0.00 3.75 8.75
70.00 89.25 81.50 0.00 0.00 0.75
67.65 79.24 82.62 6.33
0.43
0.99
4.78
5.09
5.07
3.38
0.65
0.93
20
30.00
26.25
29.00
26.75
33.25
26.00
20.75
17.75
28.75
30.00
24.25
29.00
30.00
17.25
38.75
30.25
29.00
28.25
29.00
28.75
29.25
27.00
20.00
28.25
18.00
32.25
27.25
19.75
30.00
27.00
22.25
28.75
18.00
13.75
23.75
26.24
2.51
* volunteer sunflower, ** soybean
Balatonújlak
Bize
Boda
Bóly
Böhönye
Cserkeszőlő
Cserkeszőlő*
Debrecen
Dunaföldvár
Gyulafirátót
Hódmezővásárhely
Kadarkút
Kaposvár-Toponár
Karcag
Kecskemét
Keszthely
Kéthely
Kunszentmárton
Lakitelek
Lepsény
Mesztegnyő
Nagykanizsa
Nyíregyháza
Pogányszentpéter
Röjtökmuzsaj
Sármellék
Szederkény
Szentes
Székkutas
Szigetvár
Tiszakürt
Tordas
Bóly **
Iregszemcse **
Keszthely **
Average
LSD 5%
199
Table 1. (continued) Average colony growing in diameters of
Macrophomina isolates
Site of collection
Balatonújlak
Bize
Boda
Bóly
Böhönye
Cserkeszőlő
Cserkeszőlő *
Debrecen
Dunaföldvár
Gyulafirátót
Hódmezővásárhely
Kadarkút
Kaposvár-Toponár
Karcag
Kecskemét
Keszthely
Kéthely
Kunszentmárton
Lakitelek
Lepsény
Mesztegnyő
Nagykanizsa
Nyíregyháza
Pogányszentpéter
Röjtökmuzsaj
Sármellék
Szederkény
Szentes
Székkutas
Szigetvár
Tiszakürt
Tordas
Bóly **
Iregszemcse **
Keszthely **
Average
LSD 5%
Colony in diameters (mm)
5th day
6th day
20 ° C 40 ° C 10 ° C 15 ° C 20 ° C
73.00 2.00
2.25
2.25 90.00
70.25 37.00 1.50
3.00 90.00
71.00 29.75 0.00
2.75 88.75
72.00 35.75 0.00
1.50 90.00
72.25 24.75 2.25
2.25 90.00
69.75 4.00
0.00
0.00 90.00
53.75 6.25
0.00
0.00 71.00
52.25 13.25 0.00
1.00 80.75
68.75 15.25 0.00
3.25 88.75
66.00 19.00 2.75
3.50 90.00
59.25 16.75 0.00
4.50 89.00
64.00 12.75 0.00
1.00 90.00
73.25 25.25 0.00
1.25 90.00
55.75 16.00 2.25
1.50 86.00
78.75 2.25
0.00
0.00 90.00
73.25 18.75 0.00
3.25 90.00
63.75 66.25 0.00
0.00 86.00
66.25 11.25 0.00
0.00 80.00
74.00 3.75
0.00
0.00 90.00
75.00 3.00
0.00
5.25 90.00
80.00 4.25
1.75
1.50 90.00
71.00 2.75
0.00
0.00 90.00
62.25 3.00
0.00
1.50 90.00
68.25 40.25 0.00
1.25 86.75
41.00 0.00
1.75
2.25 51.75
71.75 41.25 0.00
1.75 90.00
63.75 20.00 0.00
3.00 88.25
55.75 12.25 0.00
0.00 72.00
68.75 16.25 0.00
5.25 90.00
73.25 41.75 0.00
0.00 90.00
59.75 7.25
0.00
0.00 75.75
67.00 0.00
0.00
4.25 85.25
57.25 0.00
0.00
2.25 76.00
25.00 0.00
4.25 12.25 33.25
56.75 4.75
0.00
1.75 85.00
64.96 15.91
0.54
2.09
84.12
3.96
8.23
0.68
0.71
3.70
* volunteer sunflower ** soybean
200
40 ° C
6.00
39.75
31.75
37.75
27.25
13.75
22.25
24.75
17.00
21.25
18.75
17.25
30.25
18.25
8.25
32.00
68.75
14.00
14.75
4.25
7.00
5.25
9.25
43.25
0.00
53.25
22.75
14.00
19.25
57.25
12.75
0.00
0.00
0.00
11.75
20.68
9.07
Table 2. Average microsclerotial colony growing in diameters of
Macrophomina isolates
Site of collection
Balatonújlak
Bize
Boda
Bóly
Böhönye
Cserkeszőlő
Cserkeszőlő *
Debrecen
Dunaföldvár
Gyulafirátót
Hódmezővásárhely
Kadarkút
Kaposvár-Toponár
Karcag
Kecskemét
Keszthely
Kéthely
Kunszentmárton
Lakitelek
Lepsény
Mesztegnyő
Nagykanizsa
Nyíregyháza
Pogányszentpéter
Röjtökmuzsaj
Sármellék
Szederkény
Szentes
Székkutas
Szigetvár
Tiszakürt
Tordas
Bóly **
Iregszemcse **
Keszthely **
Average
LSD 5%
25 ° C
51.00
58.50
61.75
59.00
54.00
49.50
42.50
48.25
55.75
51.75
45.50
56.25
61.00
45.00
50.00
46.75
47.50
48.75
49.75
57.25
61.75
43.00
49.25
44.75
45.50
65.25
51.25
50.00
45.50
60.75
51.25
42.25
37.00
13.25
50.00
50.01
4.19
Colony in diameters (mm)
3rd day
5th day
30 ° C
35 ° C
20 ° C
89.00
77.25
52.00
70.25
88.25
48.00
80.00
82.25
47.75
88.75
88.25
46.75
65.00
85.75
49.25
56.75
56.00
41.75
60.75
56.25
35.00
54.00
61.00
18.25
64.25
63.00
48.00
64.25
66.25
50.00
57.25
63.75
38.75
70.75
79.00
42.75
88.25
86.00
52.00
63.75
63.00
35.25
82.50
88.25
29.75
68.00
67.00
50.00
73.00
86.25
43.00
59.75
67.25
40.00
81.00
76.25
50.75
73.25
90.00
48.25
82.00
88.00
50.25
73.25
59.75
46.00
51.25
61.00
16.25
75.25
77.75
44.75
52.75
55.75
29.75
69.25
86.00
50.00
55.75
59.75
42.00
62.75
67.25
35.00
53.00
61.75
48.00
74.25
63.00
51.25
63.25
85.25
30.25
53.75
59.00
45.25
68.00
64.50
41.25
16.25
17.00
14.00
87.75
65.25
42.25
67.11
70.34
41.53
5.67
9.02
4.31
* volunteer sunflower ** soybean
201
6th day
20 ° C
80.00
76.00
74.25
77.25
79.75
71.00
58.00
51.75
77.75
75.00
61.25
72.25
78.25
59.75
68.25
79.75
71.00
60.75
81.75
85.25
85.00
75.75
62.50
63.25
44.00
78.75
67.00
58.25
76.25
83.00
63.75
69.25
64.75
23.00
62.75
69.04
6.92
On the 3rd day the Kecskemét isolate had the highest growing rate (38.75
mm in diameter). Most of the isolates showed a full (90 mm diameter)
mycelium size 5th day after inoculation. It means a growth rate of 15
mm/day. First microsclerotia formation was observed at the 5th day at 20
°C. It is typical that even at the 6th day the microsclerotia did not reach the
side of the Petri dishes. The sunflower isolate from Lepsény showed the
largest diameter (85.25 mm) with a daily growth rate of 14.21 mm.
On the 3rd day the Szigetvár sunflower isolate showed the largest mycelium
colony in diameter (85.25 mm) at 25 °C, while the largest microsclerotial
diameter (65.25 mm) was observed by the sunflower isolate of Sármellék.
Mycelium colony diameter of the isolates of Balatonújlak, Bóly, Kecskemét
and Lepsény from sunflower at 30 °C reached the maximal diameter on the
3rd day. The microsclerotial diameter of the isolate from Balatonújlak
showed just one mm smaller value. The Iregszemcse isolate from soybean
showed the slowest growth both at 20 and 25 °C. Except this isolate mycelia
and microsclerotial colony diameters of all reached the side of Petri dishes
on the 5th day (90 mm), and the same growth was observed at 30 and 35 °C
too.
As it is shown in the Table 1, the 3rd day at 35 °C colonies of thirteen
isolates from sunflower reached the side of the Petri dishes. At this
temperature, as well as at 30 °C, the Tordas isolate showed the slowest
growing rate (70.25 mm diameter).
Ten isolates showed no mycelia growth at 40 °C on the 3rd day. Isolates
of Röjtökmuzsaj and Tordas from sunflower, and the isolate of Iregszemcse
from soybean did not start growth neither on the 5th nor on 6th day. A wide
growth interval could be observed on the 6th day. The largest diameter had
the isolate of Kéthely (68.75 mm), and lowest daily growth rate was
observed by the isolate of Lepsény (0.71 mm/day).
It is interesting to note that while the isolate of Iregszemcse from soybean
had the best growing at 10 and 15 °C, it could not grow larger as 60 mm at
20, 25, 30 and 35 °C at a temperature range which all other isolates reached
90 mm mycelium in diameter. Also its microsclerotial diameter was about
50 % of the others even on the 6th day. This difference can be seen well on
Figure 1. Upwards of the figure (A) is the Szigetvár isolate from sunflower,
and at the bottom the Iregszemcse isolate from soybean, left at 30 °C (B),
and right at 35 °C (C).
202
Figure 1. Macrophomina colonies at the 6th day. Isolate from Szigetvár (A) at
35 Co, Iregszemcse at 30 °C (B), and at 35 °C (C)
The Figure 2 shows the average colony diameters of 35 isolates measured at
different temperatures on the 3rd, 5th and 6th day.
Diam. of the colonies (mm)
100
90
80
10 °C
70
15 °C
60
20 °C
50
25 °C
40
30 °C
30
35 °C
20
40 °C
10
0
3. day 5. day 6. day
3. day 5. day 6. day
Mycelium
Microsclerotium
Figure 2. Mycelial (A) and microsclerotial (B) colony in diameters
depending on the temperature and incubation time
The most favourable temperature regime for the development of the isolates
were between 25 to 35 °C. At 20 °C the isolates were growing relatively
well. However the low temperatures as 10 and the high 40 °C was not lethal
for the isolates: giving back them to 25 °C, they started to grow.
203
Discussion
Effect of temperature on the growth of 35 Macrophomina isolates was
studied. Their growth at 10 and 15 °C was very slow, the average daily
growing rate was only 0.71 and 2.04 mm/day, respectively. Macrophomina
phaseolina did not developed microsclerotia at the too low and at too high
temperatures, however at 20 °C on the 5th day they did. The most
favourable temperature regime was between 25 and 35 °C for all the
isolates. On the 5th day at favourable temperatures all the isolates grown
well. Microsclerotial colonies reached the 90 mm in diameter, except for
one isolate (Iregszemcse).
References
Békési, P. (1970): Appearance of Macrophomina phaseoli (Maubl.) Ashby
in Hungary and its damages on sunflower. Növényvédelem (7) 304307. (in Hungarian)
Das, N. D. (1988): Effect of different sources of carbon. nitrogen and
temperature on the growth and sclerotial production of
Macrophomina phaseolina (Tassi) Goid., causing root rot/charcoal
rot disease of castor. Indian Journal of Plant Pathology 6 (2): 97-98.
Varga, P., Kadlicskó, S. and Simay, E. I. (1997): The charcoal rot and
withering of soybean caused by Macrophomina phaseolina (Tassi)
Goid. with especial regard to sunflower (I.). Növényvédelem (4):
205-208. (in Hungarian)
204
EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE ON THE GROWTH OF
MACROPHOMINA PHASEOLINA ISOLATES
I. Csöndes and S. Kadlicskó
Plant Protection Institute, Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, Keszthely,
Hungary
Summary
The charcoal root disease caused by Macrophomina phaseolina (Tassi) Goidanich may
cause considerable damages in a hot as well as in dry seasons. The effect of temperature
was investigated on the growing patterns of 35 Macrophomina phaseolina isolates.
collected from different districts of Hungary. The fungal cultures in 90 mm Petri dishes
held on 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40 °C were measured in four replications. For the isolates
the most favourite temperature regime was 25 to 35 °C. At these temperatures mycelium
and microsclerotial growing in diameter of all isolate colonies reached 90 mm on the 5th
day. Mycelia growth of this pathogen was very low at 10, 15 and 40 °C, and they did not
form microsclerotia. The cultures were well grown at 20 °C, their colony size on the 3rd
day were 14 times larger than at 10 and 15 °C. Even the extreme temperatures (10 and 40
°C) were not lethal, cultures started to grow when were kept to 25 °C.
205
USE OF RANDOM AMPLIFIED POLYMORPHIC DNA
(RAPD) TO DETERMINE VARIATION IN
PATHOGENICITY AMONG EXSEROHILUM TURCICUM
ISOLATES OBTAINED FROM MAIZE AND SORGHUM
IN EGYPT
El- Kazzaz, M. K.1 – El-Assiuty, E. M2. – Ghoniem, K. E1. – El- Naggar,
A. A2.
1
Dept. of Agric. Botany, Fac. Of Agriculture Kafr El-Sheikh, University of
Tanta, Egypt.
2
Plant Pathology Institute, Agricultural Research Centre Giza, Egypt.
Maize (Zea mays L.) and sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L. Moench) are
two of the most important cereal crops in Egypt. Maize and sorghum are
subject to infection by some leaf spotting diseases, that reduce the ability of
the plant to grow in a normal manner affecting the productivity. One of
these diseases is northern corn leaf blight, caused by Exserohilum turcicum
(Pass.)K.J. Leonard and E.G. Suggs syn. Helminthosporium turcicum Pass.
(perfect stage is Steosphaeria turica). This disease is considered the most
important leaf disease in Egypt (El-Shafey, 1978 and Gouda, 1996). Crop
losses may exceed 50% if infection becomes severe prior to flowering
(Raymundo and Hooker, 1981).
Molecular techniques based on the polymerase chain reaction (PCR)
have been used as a tool in genetic mapping, molecular taxonomy,
evolutionary studies and diagnosis of several fungal species (Williams et al.
1990 and McDonald, 1997). Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD)
analysis also may be useful in identifying races and subgroups of plantpathogenic fungi (Assigbetse et al., 1994). A comparative study of genetic
diversity in S. turcica populations in tropical and temperate climates
revealed a higher level of diversity in the tropics (Borchardt et al., 1998a).
To investigate the pathogen`s population genetic structure in central Europe,
Borchardt et al. (1998b) sampled 80 isolates of Setosphearia turcica from
Germany, Switzerland, France, Austria, and Hungary, using 52 random
amplified polymorphic DNA(RAPD) markers. Among the 73 isolates from
maize, there were 26 different RAPD haplotypes. Haplotype shared by most
members was represented by 22 isolates from Germany, Switzerland, and
France, indicating high fitness and substantial migration.
The main aim of this investigation is to investigate the variability in
the fungal population prevailing in the farmer's fields and realize the relation
206
between pathogen isolates from different sources of hosts (maize and
sorghum) and locations using RAPD technique.
Materials and methods
Molecular marker analysis
DNA isolation:
Eleven Exserohilum turcicum isolates ( five from maize namely
,Nub.TCL; Sak.5TC; Sam.ITC; Man.TC and Giz.4TC and 6 from sorghum
namely, Sak.3TS; Nub.9TG; Qal.TS; Sam.TS; Man.TS & Sed. TS) were
devided into four groups according to their pathogenicity reaction to both
maize and sorghum.These isolates included two races ,one of them broke
down the monogenic resistance gene of maize Pioneer single cross 3080
while the other did not (previous data of the authors) . Method of Murray
and Thompson (1980) was used for Fungal DNA isolation.
Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD):
Random amplification of DNA sequences was performed with a seven
10-mer primers obtained from Pioneer Company:
A: 5` GGT GCG GGA G 3`
B: 5` GTT TCG CTC C 3`
C: 5` GTA GAC CCG T 3`
D: 5` AAC AGC CCG T 3`
E: 5` AAC GCG CAA C 3`
F: 5` CCC GTC AGC A 3`
G: 5` GGA AGG CTG T 3`
A modification of the RAPD method of Williams et al. (1990) was
used to perform the amplification.
Analysis of RAPD data:
Digital pictures of RAPD fingerprints were scored manually as “1” for
the presence of a band and “2” for the absence of a band, assuming that
bands with the same molecular size in different individuals were identical.
Each band was treated as a single independent locus with two alleles and
unresolved band or missing data were scored as "0". The unweighted pair
grouping by mathematical averages (UPGMA) of TFPGA 1.3 (Miller, 1997)
was used to construct phenograms (dendrograms) and to estimate genetic
distance among isolates using option "Nei (1978) unbiased minimum
distance". Cluster analysis was conducted for each primer individually at
first and pooled data from all tested primers were analyzed for evidence of
sub grouping. Bootstrap analyses (1000 iterations) were conducted on the
resulting UPGMA to assess support for any resulting sub groupings.
207
Results
RAPD analysis of eleven E.turcicum-isolates, 5 from maize and 6
from sorghum, was carried out to study the genetic diversity. A total of 66
loci resulted from DNA amplifications of the eleven E. turcicum isolates
using seven RAPD primers were scored (Figure1). A little more than 71%
(47 loci) of the amplified loci were polymorphic where 19 loci (28.8%)
were invariant among all isolates in 1:3 ratio. Trees generated from each
primer data using UPGMA cluster analysis had very characteristic patterns
which are not similar to each other (Figure 2). While, tree constructed from
pooled data were more phylogenetically informative (Fig 2H). UPGMA
cluster analysis separated the maize isolate; Nub.TCL (group IV) from
examined isolates at approximately 43% dissimilarity, and divided the
remaining isolates into two clusters, A (group I&II) and B (group III).
Although, group III was separated from cluster A at lesser than 30%
dissimilarity, it contained two isolates; Man.TC from maize and Sak.3TS
from sorghum, with more than 22% dissimilarity. Also, cluster A was
divided at about 20% dissimilarity to two groups I and II. Group I gathered
three isolates from maize; Sak.5TC, Sam.TC and Giz.4TC, with 15%
dissimilarity, while group II contained five isolates, all from sorghum;
Qal.TS, Sed.TS, Nub.9TG, Sam.TS, and Man.TS, with similarity of about
85% (Figure2H).
208
Figure1. Random amplified polymorphic DNA(RAPD) profiles of 11 E. turcicum
isolates obtained by using primers: A, B, C, D, E, F and G, respectively. Lanes contain: M,
DNA 1KB ladder (Biolab) for A, B, C, D, E and F; and φX174 DNA/HaeIII (Promega) for G;
maize isolates 1, Nub.TCL; 2, Sak.5TC; 3, Sam.1TC; 4, Man.TC & 5, Giz.4TC; and sorghum
isolates 6, Sak.3TS; 7, Nub.9TG; 8, Qal.TS; 9, Sam.TS; 10, Man.TS & 11, Sed.TS.
M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
209
Figure2 Dendrogram generated from cluster analysis of eleven isolates of E. turcicum,
isolated from maize (1-5) and sorghum (6-11), using UPGMA, unbiased minimum distance
(Nei 1978). Trees A, B, C, D, E, F, and G are generated from individual RAPD primer data,
while H represents all previous data combined.
A
C
E
B
D
F
A
B
C
D
E
F
Discussion
G
H
210
In RAPD analysis of E. turcicum, the seven 10 mere primers used
produced 66 loci of which 47 (71%) were informative (Polymorphic).
Therefore, the large number of useful RAPD markers permits a more robust
statistical analysis and, presumably represents a greater coverage and
dispersal of markers across the genome. RAPD polymorphism analysis of
individual primer data set was shown to has poor correlation with most
isolate characteristics (i.e. geographic distribution, mating type …etc.);
although the sample size was small for such analysis. However, based on
RAPD polymorphic pooled data, four distinct groups were identified within
the eleven E. turcicum tested isolates. Group I gathered three maize isolates;
Sak.5TC, Sam.1TC and Giz.4TC (Figure 2), all of which were capable of
causing more than 40% disease severity on the TWC 310 maize hybrid. On
the other hand, the sorghum isolates; Qal.TS, Nub.9TG and Sam.TS that
were incapable to attack TWC 310 with more than 4.2% disease severity
were separated in group II (Figure 2H). Group III gathered 2 isolates which
have different degrees of aggressiveness on maize and sorghum, 1 from
maize which could infect maize weakly but was unable to infect sorghum,
and the other from sorghum, which severely attacked both hosts. Group IV,
however, included just one isolate from maize. This isolate has the
efficiency to break down the monogenic resistance SC30809(obtained data
by the authors, under publication ). Accordingly, this work separated clearly
a new race (group IV) from the other isolate groups.
These results are consistent with some extent to those obtained and
discussed by Ferguson and Carson (2004) . Similarities and differences in
banding patterns obtained by RAPD could be a useful molecular tool in
evolutionary studies of the new race (group IV) (Fig 2H).
References
Assigbetse, K. B., Fernandez, D., Dubois, M. P., and Geiger, J. P. 1994.
Differentiation of Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. Vasinfectum races on
cotton by random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analysis.
Phytopathology 84: 622-626.
Borchardt, D. S., Welz, H. G., and Geiger, H. H. 1998a. Genetic structure of
Setosphaeria turcica populations in tropical and temperate climates.
Phytopathology 88: 322-329.
Borchardt, D. S., Welz, H. G., and Geiger, H. H. 1998b. Molecular marker
analysis of European Setospaeria turcica populations. E. J. of Plant
Path. 104: 611-617.
El-Shafey, H. A. 1978. A comparison of three types of resistance to
Helminthosporium turcicum in maize. Agric. Res. Rev., Min. Agric.,
56: 8-85.
211
Ferguson, L. M., and Carson, M. L. 2004. Spatial diversity of Setosphaeria
turcica sampled from eastern United States. Phytopathology 94: 892900.
Gouda, M. I. 1996. Studies on maize leaf blight disease in Egypt. M.Sc.
Thesis, Fac. of Agric., Minofia Univ. 9
McDonald, B. A. 1997. The population genetic of fungi: Tools and
Techniques. Phytopathology 87: 448-453.
Miller, M. P. 1997. Tools for population genetic analyses (TTPGA) 1.3: A
Windows program for the analysis of allozyme and molecular
population genetic data. Computer software distributed by auther.
Murray, M. G., and Thompson, W. F. 1980. Rapid isolation of high
molecular weight plant DNA. Nucleic Acids Res. 8: 4321-4325.
Nei, M. 1978. Estimation of average heterozygosity and genetic distance
from a small number of individuals. Genetics 89: 583-590.
Raymundo, A. D., and Hooker, A. L. 1981. Measuring the relationship
between northern corn leaf blight and yield losses. Plant Dis. 65: 325327.
Williams, J. G. K., Kubelik, A. R., Livak, K. J., Rafalski, J. A., and Tingey,
S.V. 1990. DNA polymorphisms amplified by arbitrary primers are
useful as genetic markers. Nuclic Acid Res. 18: 6531- 6535.
USE OF RANDOM AMPLIFIED POLYMORPHIC DNA (RAPD) TO
DETERMINE VARIATION IN PATHOGENICITY AMONG
EXSEROHILUM TURCICUM ISOLATES OBTAINED FROM MAIZE
AND SORGHUM IN EGYPT
El- Kazzaz, M. K.1 – El-Assiuty, E. M2. – Ghoniem, K. E1. – El- Naggar,
A. A2.
1
Dept. of Agric. Botany, Fac. Of Agriculture Kafr El-Sheikh, University of Tanta, Egypt.
2
Plant Pathology Institute, Agricultural Research Centre Giza, Egypt.
Summary
Northern corn leaf blight caused by Exserohilum turcicum is considered the most
important foliar disease of maize and sorghum in Egypt. Eleven isolates of E.turcicum
from maize and sorghum which were previously evaluated for their pathogenicity against
maize and sorghum by the authors, were used for RAPD analysis. Tree constructed from
pooled data of seven RAPD primers using UPPGMA cluster analysis divided the examined
isolates of E. turcicum into 4 groups. The fourth group contained a new race which
overcome the monogenic resistance gene in maize single cross 3080.
212
METHOD FOR BIOLOGICAL CONTROL ON
CHESTNUT TREES IN SLOVAKIA
G. Juhásová – K. Adamčíková – M. Kobza – S. Bernadovičová – K.
Pastirčáková – H. Ivanová – R. Sásik
Branch of Woody Plants Biology Nitra, Institute of Forest Ecology SAS
Zvolen
Chestnut blight disease, caused by the fungus Cryphonectria parasitica
(Murrill) Barr can be controlled by means of a biological method based on
the use of hypovirulent strains of the pathogen. This method is used in many
regions of Europe to protect Castanea sativa Mill. against the pathogen.
Hypovirulence comprises all abnormal conditions which reduce the fitness
of the pathogen, including infection by hypoviruses (Elliston, 1982).
Cryphonectria parasitica, the chestnut blight fungus occurs in the nature in
two forms: virulent and hypovirulent. Hypovirulent strains have different
physiological and morphological properties (Grente 1965). Hypovirulent
isolates are discoloured (white mycelia in cultures), practically without
reproduction organs (lower sporulation), and with significantly less
virulence to Castanea sativa, compared to the virulent isolates. The trees
respond to the hypovirulent strains by promoting callus formation and
healing of the cankers and development of the callus. Abnormal cankers
from which the hypovirulent strains of the fungus are isolated consist of
exposed sapwood bordered by vigorous callus, with superficial infections
radiating from the margins of the openings (Elliston, 1985). Cytoplasmic
hypovirulent strains consistently containing dsRNA (Anagnostakis and Day
1979). The final effect of the hypovirulent agent (dsRNA hypovirus) is to
reduce mortality of infected trees. The chestnut blight has recently been
controlled by means of a biological method based on the use of these
hypovirulent strains of C. parasitica.
Materials and Methods
Bark samples (4–5 cm) were cut from chestnut blight cankers. The samples
were immersed in 0.15% NaClO solution for 20 minutes for surface
disinfection, and subsequently washed in distilled water. Small pieces of
bark chips (cca 0.5 x 0.5 cm) were placed on 3% malt agar. The isolates
were incubated at 25–27 °C in the dark.
According to Grente (1981), Grente and Berthelay-Sauret (1969a, b),
virulent and hypovirulent isolates of C. parasitica are morphologically
different in culture and distinguishable to the naked eye. Mycelium of the
213
virulent isolates is white, later turning to yellow or orange-yellow. About
96–140 hours after subculturing, globose red-orange pycnidia are seen in the
culture. They are produced abundantly. In the hypovirulent isolates, the
mycelium remains white and the production of pycnidia is very low.
Conversion of virulent isolates of C. parasitica with hypovirulent strains
was done on malt agar. One pair of media cubes with mycelium (one
virulent and one hypovirulent) was placed in contact on the medium in a
Petri plate, about 5 mm from the edge of the plate. The conversion is
successful when the white mycelium is divided in virulent mycelium close
to the interface with hypovirulent strain. The test was replicated 10 times.
The aim of this test was to transfer dsRNA hypovirus from the hypovirulent
strains into the virulent isolates and, in such a way, to obtain domestic
hypovirulent isolates that can be used in biological control of chestnut
blight.
Results and Discussion
The samples were taken from different parts of infected trees (from attacked
bark, from mycelium and also from pycnidia). All isolates had at first whitecoloured mycelium. Later it turned to light yellow and orange-yellow, some
weeks later, to red-orange. After 5 days, pycnidia were formed in cultures.
They were produced abundantly. Based on phenotype of this culture, all
isolates were considered to be virulent. No hypovirulent isolates has been
detected in Slovakia so far.
Slovak virulent isolates were transformed into hypovirulent forms with
French hypovirulent isolates (Table 1) and with Hungarian hypovirulent
isolates, (described by Radócz, 2001) (Table 2) and were used for biological
control of chestnut blight in Slovakia.
In 2004 53 isolates with morphological properties of hypovirulent strains
were obtained from naturally healing cankers. Present of dsRNA using
molecular method was confirmed in eight of them. It means that hypovirus
was spreading to normal cankers in the natural way, and an important
success in chestnut protection against chestnut blight has been achieved.
Table 1: Results of conversion of Slovakian virulent isolates with French
hypovirulent strains within the 1990-1993.
French hypovirulent strains
Locality
Radošina
Bratislava
Myslenice
Pezinok
2022
2029
2079
2099
2100
+
+
+ successful conversion of virulent isolates
- unsuccessful conversion of virulent isolates
214
2103
+
2104
2106
+
+
+
+
-
2113
2073
-
-
Table 2: Results of conversion of Slovakian virulent isolates with Hungarian hypovirulent strains within the 2004-2006.
Locality
Hungarian hypovirulent strains
Pernek
Petrovce
Hlohovec
Stredné Plachtince
Modra
Príbelce
Senec
Arborétum Mlyňany
Horné Plachtince
Dolné Štitáre
Horné Lefantovce
Párovské Háje
Veľké Lovce
Krnča
Sv. Jur
Modrý Kameň
Bratislava
Horňany
Stráne
Svodín
A3xBF
C
C-2
R-6
R-5
R5x2
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+ successful conversion of virulent isolates
- unsuccessful conversion of virulent isolates
215
FS8
W31
+
-
FS4
146
+
+
-
R11
V4
IHB 2
R-2
B1xBF
+
+
-
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
-
+
-
+
+
+
Acknowlegment
This work has been supported by the Grant Agency for Science, VEGA, Grant No.
2/4020/25, project APVT 51 015602 and bilateral project No. 10/2004.
References
Anagnostakis S.L. and Day P.R. (1979): Hypovirulence conversion in
Endothia parasitica. Phytopathology 69:1226-1229.
Elliston J.E. (1982): Hypovirulence. Pages 1-33 in Advances in plant
pathology. Ingram I.D.S., Williams P.H. (eds). Academic London Press,
London. 220 pp.
Elliston J.E. (1985): Characteristics of dsRNA-free and dsRNA-containing
strains of Endothia parasitica in relation to hypovirulence.
Phytopathology 75: 151-158.
Grente J. (1965): Les formes hypovirulentes d´Endothia parasitica et les
espoirs de lutte contre le chancre du chataignier. C. R. Acad. Agric.
France 51: 1033-1037.
Grente J. (1981): Les variants hypovirulents de l´Endothia parasitica, et la
lutte biologique contre le chancre du chataignier. INRA, Clermont
Ferrand, France. 194 pp.
Grente J. and Berthelay-Sauret. S. (1969) : L´hypovirulence exclusive,
phénomene original en pathologie végétale. C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris (1)
268: 2347-2350.
Radócz, L. (2001): Study of subpopulation of the chestnut blight fungus
Cryphonectria parasitica in the Carpathian basin. Forest, Snow and
Landscape Research Vol.76, Issue 3. p. 368-372.
216
METHOD FOR BIOLOGICAL CONTROL ON CHESTNUT TREES
IN SLOVAKIA
G. Juhásová, K. Adamčíková, M. Kobza, S. Bernadovičová, K.
Pastirčáková, H. Ivanová and R. Sásik
Branch of Woody Plants Biology Nitra, Institute of Forest Ecology SAS Zvolen
Summary
Cryphonectria parasitica, the chestnut blight fungus occurs in the nature in two forms:
virulent and hypovirulent. The hypovirulent strains have different physiological and
morphological properties. Hypovirulent strains of the pathogen can be used in biological
control against the diseases. All strains of the fungus isolated from different parts of
infected trees were considered to be virulent based on phenotype of culture. No natural
hypovirulent isolates has been detected so far in Slovakia. Slovakian virulent isolates were
transformed into hypovirulent forms with French and Hungarian hypovirulent isolates, and
were used for biological control of chestnut blight in Slovakia. In 2004 isolates with
morphological properties of hypovirulent strains were obtained from naturally healing
cankers.
217
MICROSCOPIC FUNGI ASSOCIATED WITH
HORSE-CHESTNUT LEAVES
K. Pastirčáková – S. Bernadovičová – G. Juhásová – H. Ivanová – K.
Adamčíková – M. Kobza
Slovak Academy of Sciences, Institute of Forest Ecology, Branch of Woody
Plants Biology, Nitra, Slovakia
Leaf surfaces are an important habitat for the growth of microorganisms. The leaf
surface mycofloras of various plants have been extensively reviewed (Preece,
Dickinson 1971, Dickinson, Preece 1976). Many studies dealing with the distribution
patterns of fungal communities have been performed in recent decades: host
specificity in fungal populations have been widely surveyed (Boddy, Griffith 1989,
Petrini, Fisher 1990, Kowalski 1991, Collado et al. 2000). Comparative studies of
fungal populations in healthy and symptomatic tissues have been performed (Hata,
Futai 1995, Radócz, 1999, Ragazzi et al., 2003). The presence of fungi in healthy plant
tissues has been commonly observed (Carroll 1988). The main aim of the present
study was to determine the composition of the fungal assemblages of healthy or
symptomatic horse-chestnut leaves.
Materials and Methods
Living leaves of European horse-chestnut (Aesculus hippocastanum) were
collected during the vegetation period to isolate microscopic fungi. After
surface sterilization the leaves were cut into several fragments that were
then placed in Petri-dishes containing 2% Malt extract agar (MEA). The
plates were incubated at 22±2°C. After incubation for 15 or more days,
individual fungal colonies were picked from the edge with a sterile fine
tipped needle and transferred onto 2% MEA plates. The fungi were
identified based on cultural and morphological characteristics. The isolation
frequency (IF) of a single fungal taxon was calculated by the following
formula: IF = Ni / Nt × 100, where Ni and Nt are the number of segments
from which the fungus was isolated and the total number of segments
cultured, respectively.
Results and Discussion
A total of 12 species were isolated from horse-chestnut leaf samples (Table
1). These fungi included members of two genera of Ascomycetes and ten
genera of Deuteromycetes. In leaves they were (in order of decreasing
frequency): Phyllosticta sphaeropsoidea, Phomopsis carposchiza,
Colletotrichum gloeosporioides, Asteromella aesculicola, Trichothecium
218
roseum, Alternaria alternata, Cladosporium cladosporioides, Epicoccum
nigrum, Phoma sp., Chaetomium sp., Diaporthe padi and Trichoderma
polysporum.
Table 1: Isolation frequencies (IF)1 of fungal species in horse-chestnut leaf
samples
Fungal species
IF
Fungal species
IF
11.0
6.0
Alternaria alternata
Epicoccum nigrum
16.5
Phoma sp.
4.0
Asteromella aesculicola
6.5
18.5
Cladosporium cladosporioides
Phomopsis carposchiza
Colletotrichum gloeosporioides 17.0
Phyllosticta sphaeropsoidea 47.5
Chaetomium sp.
2.0
1.0
Trichoderma polysporum
1.5
13.5
Diaporthe padi
Trichothecium roseum
1
The isolation frequencies for each species are the percentages with respect to total
number of fragments cultured.
A majority of the fungal species were recovered from necrotic tissues.
Furthermore, Alternaria alternata, Cladosporium cladosporioides,
Epicoccum nigrum, Phomopsis carposchiza and Trichothecium roseum
were also recovered from healthy ones. Phyllosticta sphaeropsoidea, wellknown horse-chestnut pathogen and with a potential for causing severe
damage to horse-chestnut leaves (Zimmermannová, 2001), was very
frequently isolated in most of the sampling sites and was recovered from
necrotic plant tissues.
Changes in diversity and equitability with increasing leaf age could be due
to various factors. Weathering of leaf cuticle, wounds, insect attack and
increased exposure time have been suggested to account for the increase in
diversity as leaves age (Carroll 1979, Forster 1977). The host specificity
among endophytes is expressed at the family level. However, some
endophytic genera such as Phyllosticta, Phomopsis and Colletotrichum
occur in a wide variety of distantly related host species (Toofanee,
Dulymamode 2002).
The use of the two different approaches (sterilized and unsterilized
fragments) may detect the living conditions of the different species: whether
it lives as an epiphyte or as an endophyte; whether the fungus inhabits only
the surface of the tissue or grows within the tissue. According to
Santamaría, Diez (2005) the isolation frequencies from necrotic and healthy
plant tissues were significantly different between collection sites and
isolation methods. Several workers have recognized that leaf age exerts
great influence on the composition of leaf surface microorganisms
(Dickinson 1967, Sharma, Mukerji 1973).
219
Our results show that horse-chestnut leaves have a diverse fungal flora.
Further investigations on the fungal species associated with horse-chestnut
leaves during different seasons and increased sampling effort could yield
more fungal taxa.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by projects APVT-51-032604 and VEGA no.
2/4020/04.
References
Boddy L., Griffith G.S. (1989): Role of endophytes and latent invasion in
the development of decay communities in sapwood of angiospermous
trees. Sydowia 41: 41-73.
Carroll G.C. (1979): Needle microepiphytes in Douglas Fir canopy: biomass
and distribution patterns. Canadian Journal of Botany 57: 1000-1007.
Carroll G.C. (1988): Fungal endophytes in stems and leaves: from latent
pathogen to mutualistic symbiont. Ecology 69 (1): 2-9.
Collado J., Platas G., Peláez F. (2000): Host specificity in fungal endophytic
populations of Quercus ilex and Quercus faginea from Central Spain.
Nova Hedwigia 71: 421-430.
Dickinson C.H. (1967): Fungal colonization of Pisum leaves. Canadian
Journal of Botany 45: 915-927.
Dickinson C.H., Preece T.F. (1976): Microbiology of aerial plant surfaces.
Academic Press, New York, London, 669 pp.
Forster G.F. (1977): Effect of leaf surface wax on the deposition of airborne
propagules. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 68: 245250.
Hata K., Futai K. (1995): Endophytic fungi associated with healthy pine
needles and needles infested by the pine needle gall midge,
Thecodiplosis japonensis. Canadian Journal of Botany 73: 384-390.
Kowalski T. (1991): Oak decline: I. Fungi associated with various disease
symptoms on overground portions of middle-aged and old oak
(Quercus robur L.). European Journal of Forest Pathology 21: 136-151.
Petrini O., Fisher P.J. (1990): Occurrence of fungal endophytes in twigs of
Salix fragilis and Quercus robur. Mycological Research 94: 1077-1080.
Preece T.F., Dickinson C.H. (1971): Ecology of leaf surface
microorganisms. Academic Press, London, New York, 640 pp.
Radócz, L. (1999): Chestnut blight and the hypovirulence in the Carpathianbasin. Acta Horticulturae 494. p. 501-508.
Ragazzi A., Moricca S., Capretti P., Dellavalle I., Turco E. (2003):
Differences in composition of endophytic mycobiota in twigs and
220
leaves of healthy and declining Quercus species in Italy. Forest
Pathology 33: 31-38.
Santamaría O., Diez J.J. (2005): Fungi in leaves, twigs and stem bark of
Populus tremula from northern Spain. Forest Pathology 35: 95-104.
Sharma K.R., Mukerji K.G. (1973): Microbial colonization of aerial parts of
plants – a review. Acta Phytopathologica Academiae Scientiarum
Hungaricae 8: 425-461.
Toofanee S.B., Dulymamode R. (2002): Fungal endophytes associated with
Cordemoya integrefolia. Fungal Diversity 11: 169-175.
Zimmermannová K. (2001): Fungal disease of leaves of Horse chestnut
(Aesculus hippocastanum L.) and its occurrence in Slovakia. Folia
oecologica 28 (1-2): 153-165.
MICROSCOPIC FUNGI ASSOCIATED WITH
HORSE-CHESTNUT LEAVES
K. Pastirčáková, S. Bernadovičová, G. Juhásová, H. Ivanová,
K. Adamčíková and M. Kobza
Slovak Academy of Sciences, Institute of Forest Ecology, Branch of Woody Plants
Biology, Akademická 2, SK-94901 Nitra, Slovakia
Summary
In this study, leaves of Aesculus hippocastanum were screened for composition of fungal
communities. The most prevalent fungi associated with healthy and symptomatic horsechestnut leaves were (in order of decreasing frequency): Phyllosticta sphaeropsoidea,
Phomopsis carposchiza, Colletotrichum gloeosporioides, Asteromella aesculicola,
Trichothecium roseum, Alternaria alternata, Cladosporium cladosporioides, Epicoccum
nigrum, Phoma sp., Chaetomium sp., Diaporthe padi and Trichoderma polysporum.
Phyllosticta sphaerospoidea was found to be the dominant species. Phomopsis carposchiza
and Colletotrichum gloeosporioides were also present in great abundance. Our results
suggest that the mycoflora of horse-chestnut leaves is heterogeneous.
221
THE ANTHRACNOSIS DISEASE OF THE VARIABLE
LUPIN (LUPINUS MUTABILIS SWEET)
István Lenti1 – Ferenc Borbély2 – Sándor Vágvölgyi1 – Ágnes Ferencné
Boronkay1
1
Nyíregyháza College, Technical and Agricultural Faculty, Nyíregyháza
2
DE ATC Research Center, Nyíregyháza
In connection with the lupin (Lupinus L.) species (Lupinus albus, L. luteus,
L. angustifolius, L. mutabilis) which are grown in Hungary or used for plant
improvement, we have experienced a previously unknown disease since
2004, namely the anthracnosis. The extent of damage caused is different for
each species, the biggest loss was experienced with regard to the white and
yellow flowered sweet lupins that are also grown on an industrial basis. To
provide a precise definition about the extent of the damage, further years of
observation are essential.
The variable lupin – as far as we know – is only infected by the C.
gloeosporioides. The tight leaf or blue flowered lupin species are – as far as
we are concerned – only infected by the Colletotrichum gloeosporioides.
To decrease the impact of this agent we find – on the basis of our fungicidsensitivity surveys – captan, mankoceb, copper(I)oxid as the most suitable
as well as the combinations of these with benomyl or methyl-tyophanate.
Our open-air small-parcelled experiments are to be settled according to this.
Effective protection is impeded by the fact that this pesticide also affects the
inside part of the seed in the case of the lupin species examined. Seed
pelleting is only able to provide a partial protection, which means that stock
treatments are assumed to have an important role in the future in the plant
protection of this species.
In relation to heat demand, the causative fungus agent belongs to the warm
demanding species. If the humidity and the temperature is high enough –
considered as an ecological condition – that may nourish the fungicid
infection of this lupin species, which, migh as well be ”epidemic”!
222
OCCURRENCE OF PUCCINIA HORDEI ON WINTER
BARLEY IN HUNGARY IN 2006
Klára Manninger¹ – István Murányi²
¹Plant Protection Institute Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest,
Hungary
²„Rudolf Fleischmann” Research Institute, Kompolt, Hungary
Cultivated barley ranks as fourth in world cereal production, and is the third
important agricultural species in Hungary.
The aim of barley breeding at Kompolt is to develop high yielding cultivars
resistant to diseases for malt and feed. One of diseases of barley, the leaf
rust, caused by Puccinia hordei G. Otth., widespread around the world, but
occurs not every year in Hungary.
We surveyed the occurrence of Puccinia hordei in Hungary in 2006, and
tested 28 winter barley cultivars for resistance to leaf rust.
We noticed, leaf rust was an important disease on winter barley in WestHungary at Szombathely, and occurred in traces in North-Hungary at
Kompolt.
The level and type of resistance against leaf rust were determined in
cultivars. Disease susceptibilities of winter barley cultivars ranged from
very susceptible to resistant. Among the cultivars, few showed high
resistance (e.g. Botond, Lambic) and some were very susceptible (e.g. KH
Agria, KH Turul, Petra). The leaf rust was in traces on few cultivars.
This study presents the first results about resistance to leaf rust of barley
cultivars in Hungary. These data help the Hungarian barley breeders in rust
resistance breeding program.
223
PHOMAS – CAN THESE FUNGI BE USED AS
BIOCONTROL AGENTS AND SOURCES OF
SECONDARY METABOLITES? (A REVIEW)
Prajakta Deshmukh1 - Mahendra K. Rai1 - György J. Kövics2 - László
Irinyi2 - Erzsébet Sándor2
1
Department of Biotechnology, SGB Amravati University, Amravati-444
602, Maharashtra, India
2
Department of Plant Pathology, Debrecen University, H-4032 Debrecen,
Hungary
Introduction
Phoma is a genus containing more than 2000 described species. This genus
traditionally refers to simple stem inhabiting pycnidial fungus with small
hyaline, unicellular pycnidiospores (Sutton, 1980). Phomas cause various
serious diseases to plants as well as to humans (Rai 1989, 2000). Besides
these harmful aspects, certain Phoma species also contains antibiotic
potential and economically useful secondary metabolites.
As widespread plant pathogens around the world occur on a broad range of
plant species, e.g. P. glomerata has been reported on grape, potato, wheat,
pear, mango, rice and many other crops. Some important example include
Phoma lingam that causes the very serious blackleg disease in canola. It is
also found on other cruciferous crops such as cabbages, cauliflower and
summer rape. P. medicaginis var. medicaginis is the causal agent of spring
black stem of alfalfa. P. pinodella causes foot rot in peas and black stem in
clovers. All of these pathogens can overwinter in crop debris and are often
seedborne. Development of disease symptoms caused by these Phoma spp.
will often be enhanced in wet and cool conditions. Within this genus large
pathogenic variations are shown which often complicates the control of
Phoma, especially in legumes.
The present review paper is aimed to discuss the role played by Phoma
species as biocontrol agents and their potential for the production of
secondary metabolites.
224
Phomas as biocontrol agents in weed control
Weeds are serious problems not only for agricultural and forestry fields, but
also responsible for several major problems to human and animal health
around the world including India. Synthetic chemical herbicides have been
the mainstay for weed control practices since the end of World War II and
no doubt are responsible for much of the unparalleled increased crop
productivity that has occurred during this period. The high costs involved in
developing and registering chemical herbicides and recent trends in
environmental awareness have prompted researchers to investigate
alternative systems of weed control. Ideally, such a system would control
target weeds at or near the same levels as that achieved with chemical
herbicides while not poisoning a threat to either the environment or nontarget organisms at the same time (Pandey et al., 2001).
The science and technology of weed control by using plant pathogens more
especially fungal pathogens as an effective alternatives to chemical
herbicides have gained significant attention and momentum in 1970.
Century old concept in weed control and plant disease epidemiology were
successfully put to text and few economically important weeds were
controlled by fungal pathogens used under classical and mycoherbicidal
strategies. With the advancement in the knowledge biorationals and
integrated management strategies have also came into foray. Biological,
technological and economical perspectives of various strategies have been
extensively reviewed in several publications (Auld, 1990; Charudattan,
1991, 1996; Abbas and Duke, 1995, 1997; Boyette and Abbas, 1995; Hasija
et al., 1994; Hoagland, 1990; 1999, 2001; Pandey 1999, 2000; Pandey et al.,
1996a,b, 1997, 2001; Saxena and Pandey 2000; Saxena et al., 2001).
As a matter of fact, Phoma spp. could be the novel agents for many weed
problems. They have both mycoherbicidal and biorational properties.
Looking to the number of known species, species associated with weeds are
very less. This might be because of ignorance of weed pathogens.
Mycologists as well as plant pathologists in the past have given attention to
economically important plant diseases. Therefore, urgent attention towards
herbicidal potential of Phomas is needed.
It is surprising that despite of excellent phytopathogenic potential shown by
various species or varieties of the genus, their mycoherbicidal potential has
been ignored significantly. There are only few scanty attempts have been
made to evaluate them as mycoherbicides. Heiny (1990, 1994) isolated a
highly host specific strain of Phoma proboscis from diseased parts of field
bindweed (Convolvulus arvensis). Heiny and Templeton (1991) have
225
reported very high mycoherbicidal effect when the agent applied to the
seedling of the weed and atmospheric temperature ranged from 16-28oC and
more than 9 hrs dew period. Heiny (1994) has extensively evaluated the
compatibility of synthetic herbicides for integration with the mycoherbicidal
agent.
Rajak et al. (1990) isolated a strain of P. herbarum from diseased leaves of
Parthenium hysterophorus L. collected from Central India. The fungus caused
more than 90% inhibition in seed germination, seedling mortality and leaf
damage followed by reduction in height of Parthenium (Pandey et al., 1991).
Pandey and Pandey (2000) recovered three strains of P. herbarum
(LC#32,37,39) from diseased leaves and stem of Lantana camara. All the
three strains incite severe infection in the weed, especially at seedlings stage
(Pandey, 2000). Pandey (2002) also isolated a strain of P. herbarum
FGCC#70 from disease seedlings of an invasive weed, Hyptis suaveolens (L.)
Poit. He recorded very high mycoherbicidal potential when seedlings were
treated. Several other species viz. Phoma campanulata on Cassia fistula
(Rajak and Rai, 1982), P. exigua on Sesamum indicum (Singh and Agarwal
1973), P. eupyrena on Achyrenthus aspera (Khanna and Chandra, 1977), P.
glomerata on Crotalaria juncea (Pathak and Chauhan, 1976), and Parthenium
hysterophrous (Padmbai, 1976), P. lantanae on Lantana camara (Singh and
Agarwal, 1974), P. palmarum on Calotropis procera (Khanna and Chandra,
1977; Kamal and Singh, 1979), P. tridocis on Tridex procumbens (Wehmeyer,
1964), P. herbarum var. ipomoeae (Kamal and Singh, 1979 ), and P.
euphorbiae on Euphorbia hirta (Rangaswami et al., 1970) have been reported
for various parts of India.
Production of anthraquinone pigments by Phoma species
There are many fungi which produce anthraquinones (Figure 1A) as
secondary metabolites. Fungal anthraquinones as polyketide-derived
secondary metabolites occur widely in many genera of fungi. Compared
with the commercially available hydroxyanthraquinones most possess an
additional methyl substitution in position three, e.g. emodin and this allows
a study of the effect of such a group on the dyeing properties of dyestuffs
derived from them. A fungal anthraquinone was cynodontin (Figure 1B)
produced in sufficient purity to allow it to be transformed using a simple
chemical step to a dye product and this was compared with a commercially
available close analogue (Hobson et al., 1997).
226
A/
B/
Figure 1. A/ Chemical structure of anthraquinone (anthracene-9,10-dione)
and B/ cynodontin (1,4,5,8-tetra hydroxy-3-methylanthraquinone)
The chemical synthesis of anthraquinones require the use of strong acids at
high temperature and heavy metal catalysts, as a consequence of which
environmentally hazardous effluents and byproducts are produced. With
increasing awareness of the environment degradation by industry the
disposal of industrial effluent is becoming more costly and strictly
regulated. A return to dyes extracted from molluscs, insects, fungi or plants
grown in their environment is not the intention.
Phoma exigua Desm. varieties produces pigments. Bick and Rhee (1966)
have reported that P. exigua var. foveata (=P. foveata) contains many
anthraquinone pigments, such as pachybasin (Figure 2), chrysophanol
(Figure 3), emodin (Figure 4) and phomarin. In acid condition this complex
of pigments becomes yellow, and in alkaline conditions red. This character
is based on ammonia test described by Logan and Khan (1969). On maltagar, P. exigua var. foveata gives pinkish colour after exposure to ammonia.
This is due to reaction of diffusible anthraquinones and their reaction with
ammonia. In old cultures, anthraquinone pigments crystallize out as yellowgreen crystals. Tichelaar (1974), found that the fungicide thiophanatemethyl accelerates and increases the crystallization process of the pigments.
Both P. exigua var. exigua and P. exigua var. inoxydabilis produce
cytochalasin B, which are also known as “phomine” (Bousquet and Barbier,
1972; Scott et al., 1975).
Figure 2. Pachybasin
(1-hydroxy-3-methylanthraquinone)
Figure 3. Chrysophanol
(1,8-dihydroxy-3methylanthraquinone)
227
Figure 4. Emodin (1,6,8-trihydroxy-3-methyl-anthracene-9,10-dione)
Some isolates of P. exigua var. foveata (=P. foveata) produce antibiotic
substance (‘E’ metabolite) similar to isolates of the ubiquitous P. exigua var.
exigua (Boerema and Höweler, 1967). It is a colourless substance and can
easily be demonstrated in cultures by sodium hydroxide test. On application
of a drop of sodium hydroxide at the margin of colonies on malt agar
oxidation takes place and pigment alpha (∝) converts into pigment beta (β).
Pigment alpha (∝) is red-purple at pH <10.5 and blue-green at pH >12.5.
Pigment beta (β) is yellow at pH <3.5 and red at pH >5.5.
Recently, three known anthraquinones have been isolated and identified by
Borges and Pupo (2006), 1,7-dihydroxy-3-methyl-9,10-anthraquinone
(Figure 5), 1,6-dihydroxy-3-methyl-9,10-anthraquinone (Figure 6) and 1hydroxy-3-methyl-9,10-anthraquinone (Figure7), one new anthraquinone
(1,7-dihydroxy-3-hydroxymethyl-9,10-anthraquinone), and two new
hexahydroanthra-quinone derivatives, dendryols E and F (Figure 8), were
isolated from the culture of the endophytic fungus Phoma sorghina, found
in association with Tithonia diversifolia (Asteraceae). Their structures were
identified on the basis of spectroscopic data, mainly 1D and 2D NMR.
O
OH
HO
CH3
O
Figure 5. 1,7-Dihydroxy-3-methylmethyl-9,10-anthraquinone
Figure 6. 1,6-Dihydroxy-39,10-anthraquinone
228
Figure 7. 1-Hydroxy-3-methyl-9,10-anthraquinone
Figure 8. Antraquinone derivates produced by the endophytic fungus P.
sorghina, the main correlation observed in the NOE different experiments
for dendryol E and F (5-6) (after Borges and Pupo, 2006).
References
Abbas, H.K. and Duke, S.O. (1995): Phytotoxins from plant pathogens as
potential herbicides. J. Toxicol. Toxin Review 14: 523-543.
Abbas, H.K. and Duke, S.O. (1997): Plant pathogens and their phytotoxins
as herbicides. pp. 1-20. In: Toxins in Plant Diseases Development
and Evolving Biotechnology. Upadhyay, R.K. and Mukherjee, K.G.
(Eds.) Oxford and IBH Publishing Co. Pvt. Ltd. New Delhi
Auld, B.A. (1990): Mycoherbicides: One alternative to chemical control of
Weeds, In: Alternatives to the Chemical Control of Weeds. pp. 7173. In: Basset, C., Whitehouse, L.G. and Zabkiewicz, J.A. (Eds.)
Proc. In. Conf. Roturcia, New Zealand, Ministry of Forestry,
No.155.
Bick, I.R.C. and Rhee, C. (1966): Anthraquinone pigments from Phoma
foveata Foister. Biochem. J. 98: 112-116.
Boerema, G.H. and Höweler, L.H. (1967): Phoma exigua Desm. and its
varieties. Persoonia 5: 15-28.
Borges, W. de Souza and Pupo, M.T (2006): Novel anthraquinone
derivatives produced by Phoma sorghina, an endophyte found in
229
association with the medicinal plant Tithonia diversifolia
(Asteraceae). J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 17 (5): 929-934.
Bousquet, J.F. and Barbier, M. (1972): Sur l’activite’ phytotoxique de trois
souches de Phoma exigua presence de la cytochalasine B (ou
phomine) dans leur milieu de culture. Phytopathologische Zeitschrift
75: 365-367.
Boyette, C.D. and Abbas, H.K. (1995): Weed control with mycoherbicide
and phytotoxins: A nontraditional applications of allelopathy. pp.
280-299. In: Allelopathy organisms,processes and applications. K.
Inderjit, M.M.Dakhini and F.A. Einhelling (Eds), ACS Symp. Ser.
No. 582, Washington DC.
Hasija, S.K., Rajak, R.C and Pandey, A.K. (1994): Microbes in the
management of obnoxious Weeds. pp. 82-104. In: Vistas in Seed
Biology. Singh T. and Trivedi, P. C. (Eds.). Print Well, Jaipur
Heiny, D.K. and Templeton, G.E. (1991): Effects of Spore concentration,
temperature and dew period on disease of field bindwind caused by Phoma
proboscis. Phytopathology 81: 905-909.
Heiny, D.K. (1990): Phoma probocis sp. nov. pathogenic on Convoulus arvensis.
Mycotaxon 36: 457-471.
Heiny, D.K. (1994): Field survival of Phoma proboscis and synergism with
herbicides for control of field bindweed. Plant Disease 78: 1156-1164.
Hoagland, R.E. (1990): Microbes and Microbial Products as herbicides: An
overview. Amer. Chem. Symp. Ser. No. 439, Washington, D.C.,
American Chemical Society. 2-52.
Hoagland, R.E. (1999): Plant pathogens and microbial products as agents
for biological weed control. pp. 214-255. In: Advances in Microbial
Biotechnology. Tiwari, J.P., Lakhanpal, T.N., Singh, J., Gupta, R.
and Chamda, B.P. (Eds.) APH Publishing Co., New Delhi, India
Hoagland, R.E. (2001): The genus Streptomyces. A rich source of novel
phytotoxins. pp.139-169. In: Ecology of Desert Environments.
Ishwari Parkash (Ed.) Scientific Publishers, Jodhpur, India
Hobson, D.K., Edwards, R.L, and Wales, D.S. (1997): Cynodontin: a
secondary metabolite and dyestuff intermediate. J. Chem. Tech.
Biotechnol. 70: 343-348.
Kamal, S. and Singh, S. (1979): Fungi of Gorakhpur IX. Indian Phytopath.
29: 188.
Kanaujia R.S. (1979): Notes on a new fungal disease of Alocacia indica.
Indian Phytopath. 32: 463-464.
Khanna, K.K. and Chandra, S. (1977): Some new leaf spot disease II. Proc.
Nat. Acad. Sci. India 47(B): 251-253.
230
Logan, C. and Khan, A.A. (1969): Comparative studies of Phoma sp.
associated with potato gangrene in Northern Ireland. Trans. Br.
Mycol. Soc. 52: 9-17.
Padmbai, L. (1976): Fungi in the root region of Parthenium hysterophorus
L. Curr. Sci. 45: 631-632.
Pandey, A.K. (1999): Herbicidal potential of microorganism: Present status
and future prospects. pp. 87-105. In: Microbial Biotechnology for
Sustainable Developments and Productivity. Rajak, R.C. (Ed.)
Scientific Publications, Jodhpur, Rajsthan, India
Pandey, A.K. (2000): Microorganism associated with weeds: Opportunities
and challenges for their exploitation as herbicides. Int. J. Mendel 17
(1-2): 59-62.
Pandey, A.K., Chandla, P. and Rajak, R.C. (2002): Herbicidal potential of
secondary metabolites of some fungi against Lantana camara L. J.
Mycol. Plant Pathol. 32 (1): 100-102.
Pandey, A.K., Gaythri, S., Rajak, R.C. and Hasija, S.K. (1996a):
Possibilities, problems and prospects of microbial management of
Parthenium hysterophorus L. in India. pp. 253-269. In: Perspectives
in Biological Science. Rai, V., M.L. Naik and Manoharachary, C.
(Eds.) Dazale Offset Printers, Raipur (M.P.)
Pandey, A.K., Luka, R.S. Hasija, S.K. and Rajak, R.C. (1991):
Pathogenicity of some fungi to Parthenium and obnoxious weed in
Madhya Pardesh. J. Biol. Control 5: 113-115.
Pandey, A.K., Mishra, J., Rajak, R.C. and Hasija, S.K. (1996b): Potential of
indigenous strains of Sclerotium rolfsii Sacc. for the management of
Parthenium hysterophorus L. A serious threat to biodiversity in
India. pp. 104-138. In: Herbal Medicines, Biodiversity and
Conservation Strategies. Rajak, R.C. and Rai, M.K. (Eds.)
International Book Distributors, DehraDun
Pandey, A.K., Rajak, R.C. and Hasija, S.K. (1997): Potential of indigenous
Colletotrichum species for the management of weeds in India. pp.
59-85. In: Achievements and Prospects in Mycology and Plant
Pathology. Chahal, S.S., Parashar, I.B., Randhawa, H.S., and Arya,
S. (Eds.) International Book Distributors, DehraDun, India
Pandey, A.K., Rajak, R.C. and Hasija, S.K. (2001): Biotechnological
development of ecofriendly mycoherbicides. pp. 1-21. In: Innovative
approaches in Microbiolog. Maheshwari, D.K. and Dube, R.C.
(Eds.) Bisen singh Mahendra pal singh, Dehra Dun, India
Pandey, S. and Pandey, A.K. (2000): Mycoherbicidal potential of some
fungi against Lantana camara L.: A preliminary observation.
Journal of Tropical Forestry 16: 28-32.
231
Pathak, P.D. and Chauhan, R.K.S. (1976): Two new leaf spot disease of
Crotalaria juncea L. caused by Pleospora infectoria Fuckel and
Phoma glomerata Corda. Curr. Sci. 45: 206.
Rai, M.K. (1989): Phoma sorghina infection in human beings. Mycopath.
105: 167-170.
Rai, M.K. (2000): Phoma research in India: A review. In: Integrated
Management of Plant Resources. Rai, M.K., Varma, A. and Rajak,
R.C. (Eds.) Scientific Publisher, Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India
Rajak, R.C and Rai, M.K. (1982): Species of Phoma from legumes. Indian
Phytopat. 35(4): 609-611.
Rajak, R.C., Farkya, S., Hasija, S.K and Pandey, A.K. (1990): Fungi
associated with congress weed (Parthenium hysterophorus L.). Proc.
Nat. Acad. Sci. India 60: 165-168.
Rangaswami, G, Seshadri, V.S. and Lucky Channamma, K.A. (1970): Fungi
of South India. University of Agricultural Sciences, Bangalore 193
pp.
Saxena, S. and Pandey, A.K. (2000): Preliminary evaluation of fungal
metabolites as natural herbicides for the management of Lantana
camara. Indian Phytopath. 53(4): 490-491.
Saxena, S. and Pandey, A.K. (2001): Microbial metabolites as ecofriendly
agrochemical for the next millennium. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol.
55: 395-403.
Scott, P.M., Harwig, J., Chen, Y.K. and Kennedy, B.P.C. (1975):
Cytochalasins A and B from strains of Phoma exigua var. exigua
and formation of cytochalasin B in potato gangrene. J. Gen.
Microbiol. 87: 177-180.
Singh, S.M. and Agarwal, G.P. (1973): On some foliicolous
Sphaeropsidales. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. India 43(B): 73-80.
Singh, S.M. and Agarwal, G.P. (1974): Some Sphaeropsidales new to India.
Indian Phytopath. 27: 244-246.
Sutton, B.C. (1980): The Coelomycetes. CAB International Mycological Institute, Kew
696 pp.
Tichelaar, G.M. (1974): The use of thiophanate-methyl for distinguishing
between the two Phoma varieties causing gangrene of potatoes.
Neth. J Plant Pathol. 80: 169-170.
Wehmeyer, L.E. (1964): Some fungi imperfecti form Punjab and Kashmir.
Mycologia 55: 313-335.
232
COMPARATIVE SEED PATHOLOGICAL
INVESTIGATIONS ON CULTIVATED GRASS SPECIES
Zsolt Varga1 – Bernhard Krautzer2 – Wilhelm Graiss2
1
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences,
Keszthely, Hungary
2
HBLFA Raumberg-Gumpenstein, Irdning, Austria
The grass area of Austria amounts to 2 million hectare, of which 47 % is
cultivated included the fodder-plant production. The other part is extensive
grass (alpine pastures, mountainous areas). In average a yearly 86.000 ha
new grass area will be made by sowing, oversowing and intercropping. For
these purposes 5.545 tons of grass seed has been used between 2002 and
2004. For a high level production it is necessary to have healthy, pathogen
free seed with excellent quality. However we have not enough information
on seed contaminating fungal pathogens, and about their effect on the
germination. The aim of our work was to investigate the seed pathology of
common bent-grass (Agrostis capillaris L), yellow oat-grass (Trisetum
flavescens L.) and the crested dog’s-tail (Cynosorus cristatus L.) with
special respect toward the connection of fungal contamination and
germination of the seeds. These three grass species constitute just a small
part of the grass seed production, still they play an important role in the
plant community (phytocoenosis) of the higher mountain areas.
Simay (1989, 1990, 1991) investigated seed pathology of a number of
plant species, but among them only oat and maize belong to the Poaceae
family (Simay 1992a, 1992b). He did not investigate grass seed pathology.
Walcz and Horváth (1976) made seed pathology tests of three grass species
(smooth brome, red fescue and tall fescue) in some years. They used
different test methods, and found, that the occurrence of Alternaria
alternata is the most important pathogen on grass seeds. Tagenko (1974)
found also Alternaria alternata on seeds of smooth brome. Beside A.
alternata and A. tenuissima Gannibal (2004) identified A. infectoria on
seeds of different grass species. He reported also data on occurrence of
Ulocladium and Embellisia genus, genera near to that of Alternaria. Varga
et al. (2004) investigated seeds of 30 cultivars from 11 grass species. They
pointed out dominance of Alternaria genus as seed pathogens. Within the
genus Alternaria alternata and A. tenuissima were identified and the
occurrence of Ulocladium genus on seeds of perennial ryegrass also was
reported. Similarly, genera of Embellisia and Septonema were identified
from seeds of perennial ryegrass (Varga and Fischl 2005). Makela (1972)
found in his investigations a number of grass species, where the seed of
233
common bent-grass was partly contaminated. Papp et al. (1986) found
fungal species of Fusarium graminearum, Bipolaris sorokiniana, Septoria
graminum, Colletotrichum graminicola and Mastigosporium album to have
an importance on yellow oat-grass seeds. Radulescu and Negru (1971) also
mentioned these pathogenes from yellow oat grass seeds. They referred to
the presence of Fusarium nivale, F. insidiosum, Drechslera erythrospila and
beside them Curvularia lunata on seeds of common bent, and verified also
the presence and distribution of more Tilletia and Ustilago species. The
above mentioned authors did not give data on fungal pathogenes distributed
and spread by crested dog’s-tail seeds.
Materials and Methods
The investigations were made at the area of HBLFA RaumbergGumpenstein Research Institute, in Austria. The tested seed lots of common
bent-grass (Agrostis capillaris L), yellow oat-grass (Trisetum flavescens L.)
and the crested dog’s-tail (Cynosorus cristatus L.) were collected from the
2000, 2001, 2002 year’s harvests. The seed samples were stored in paper
bags in refrigerated room at 4-6 °C. The samples were not surface sterilized
and tested with two different methods considered the prescriptions of the
ISTA. Four times 400 seeds were taken onto filter paper in a germination
cabinet and also 4 x 400 seeds of each species were tested on a Jacobsen
table. Filter papers were moistened with a 0,3 % KNO3 solution, and in the
case of yellow oat grass a cold treatment for 7 days at 4-6 °C were made to
overcome their dormancy. During the germination in the cabinet 12 hs light
and 12 hs darkness was given and a temperature of 20 °C. During the
germination at the Jakobsen table also 12 hs illumination was given, and 30
°C water temperature for the crested dog’s-tail and yellow oat grass seeds,
and 20 °C in case of common bent-grass. The mycological observations
were made twice at the same times of the germination estimations. The
observations took place in case of the common bent grass on the 7th and 28th
day, in the case of yellow oat grass on the 7th and 21st day, while in the case
of crested dog’s tail on the 10th and 21st day. Each seed were viewed using a
stereomicroscope, and those showing symptoms of fungal contamination,
also by a light microscope at 780 x magnification. For the determination of
the fungal genus and species the morphology, color, and size of fungal body
parts were taken into consideration according to the descriptions of Ellis
(1971), Booth (1971), Chidambaram et al. (1973), Sutton (1980) and
Sivanesan (1987). Some microphotos were also taken on the different fungal
pathogens.
234
Results and Conclusions
We have found that germination rate of the tested seed samples were
excellent, despite the fact that they originated from different harvesting
years. The tested grass species showed their germination potential already at
the first observation date, and at the second observation time there was just
a minimal difference as compared to the first observation for all the three
grass species. We have found, that using the Jakobsen table the germination
rates of the three species were 2-6 % higher than at the filter paper method.
The fungal contamination rate was found to be higher at the Jakobsen table
method, as compared to the other one (Figure 1 and 2). We had to notice
however, that only contamination rates at the first observation can be
considered as real, since in most cases, especially using the Jakobsen table,
for the time of the second observation a later infection of the test material by
the saprotrophic Stachybotrys atra caused the higher data. The fungal
contamination rate in case of crested dog’s tail was higher, and in case of
yellow oat grass and common bent grass was lower. We identified from the
seed surfaces 21 fungal genera and their species. The species of the
saprophytes genera, Alternaria alternata, A. tenuissima, Cladosporium
cladosporioides, C. herbarum, Stachybotrys atra, Epicoccum nigrum proved
to be the most dominant. From the plant pathogenic genera the Bipolaris,
Drechslera, and Fusarium caused considerable infection rate (Table 1. and
2). In many cases more pathogenes could be identified from a single seed
surface. The Bipolaris sorokinina were identified from the seeds of common
bent grass and crested dog’s tail. Drechslera species could be identified in
case of crested dog’s tail and yellow oat grass seeds. Within the Fusarium
genus the F. avenaceum and F. semitectum were identified, the infected
seeds did not germinate or their sprouts became brown and died. From the
seeds of common bent grass we could identify peritheciums of Gibberella
sp.. Other fungal species occurred also were Physarum nutans, Stemphylium
botryosum, Torula graminicola, Gonatobotrys sp. and Phoma epicoccina.
On seeds of crested dog’s tail we have found the above mentioned fungal
species and beside there Septoria sp., Ascochyta sp., Myrothecium
gramineum, Acremoniella atra and Oedocephalum glomerulosum. Both in
Hungary and Austria the occurrence of Ulocladium sp. and Pithomyces
chartarum identified from seeds of yellow oat grass and crested dog’s tail,
as well as Culvularia lunata, Septonema sp. and Embellisia sp. from seeds
of crested dog’s tail are considered new data.
235
germination rate
(germination cabinet)
germination rate
(Jakobsen table)
contamination rate
(germination cabinet)
contamination rate
(Jakobsen table)
110
100
90
80
70
60
%
50
40
30
20
10
0
common bent grass 2000
yellow oat grass 2001
crested dog’s tail 2002
Figure 1. Germination and fungal contamination rate of the grass seeds of
species tested at the first observation.
th
Note: on the 7 day in case of common bent grass and yellow oat grass, 10th
day at crested dog’s tail.
germination percentage
(germination cabinet)
germination percentage
(Jakobsen table)
contamination rate
(germination cabinet)
contamination rate
(Jakobsen table)
110
100
90
80
70
60
%
50
40
30
20
10
0
common bent grass 2000
yellow oat grass 2001
crested dog’s tail 2002
Figure 2. Germination and fungal contamination rate of the grass seeds of
species tested at the 2nd observation.
236
Note: 21st day in the case of yellow oat grass and crested dog’s tail, and 28th
day at common bent grass.
Table 1. Rate of fungal genera and species found on seeds at the first
observation (%)*
common
yellow oat crested dog’s
bent grass grass
tail
(Agrostis
(Trisetum
(Cynosorus
capillaris)
flavescens)
cristatus)
Fungal genera/species
Gc
J
Gc
J
Gc
J
Alternaria spp.
8,3
0,0 17,1 22,5 75,0
69,7
Cladosporium spp.
58,3 25,0 92,1 57,5 26,1
18,0
0,0
0,0
0,0
2,5
0,0
4,4
Stachybotrys atra
8,33
0,0
0,0
12,5
1,1
24,8
Epicoccum nigrum
Bipolaris, Drechslera spp.
0,0 25,0 0,0
0,0
5,0
5,1
Fusarium spp.
0,0
25,0
0,0
0,0
0,5
0,0
Note: Gc: germination cabinet, J: Jakobsen table
*: 7th day at common bent grass and yellow oat grass, 10th day at crested
dog’s tail.
Table 2.Rate of fungal genera and species found on seeds at the 2nd
observation (%)*
common
yellow oat
crested dog’s
bent grass
grass
tail
(Agrostis
(Trisetum
(Cynosorus
capillaris)
flavescens)
cristatus)
Fungal genera/species
Gc
J
Gc
J
Gc
J
Alternaria spp.
8,7
0,0 26,9 13,8 77,6
45,5
Cladosporium spp.
30,4
0,0
74,2
8,8
21,5
6,4
21,7 98,4 13,4 79,0
3,6
74,5
Stachybotrys atra
0,0
0,0
0,0
3,8
1,2
14,6
Epicoccum nigrum
Bipolaris, Drechslera spp.
21,7 0,0
0,0
0,4
1,2
2,6
Fusarium spp.
13,0
0,4
0,0
0,0
1,6
0,0
Note: Gc: germination cabinet, J: Jakobsen table
*: 21st day at yellow oat grass and crested dog’s tail, and 28th day at
common bent grass.
The correlation calculation of the data show, that there was no correlation
between the germination rate and fungal contamination rate (r1= -0,80,
237
r2= 0,37), that means that the fungal contamination of the seeds did not have
an effect on the germination rate. However, some of the identified
pathogens (like Alternaria spp., Fusarium spp., Bipolaris spp., Drechslera
spp. and Stemphylium sp.) may cause seedling killing, may hinder the
development of young plant. Also the occurrence of the large-scale presence
of the seed contaminating throphic fungi, or rather weakening parasites may
result in a weaker germination (Neergaard 1979), or they may even damage
the developed plants (Eken et al. 2006).
References
Booth, C. (1971): The genus Fusarium. Comm. Mycol. Inst., Kew, Surrey,
England.
Chidambaram, P., Mathur, S. B. and Neergaard P. (1973): Identification of
seed-borne Drechslera species. Friesia, Copenhagen, 10: 165-207.
Eken, C., Jochum, C. C. and Yuen, G. Y. (2006): First report of leaf spot of
smooth bromegrass caused by Pithomyces chartarum in Nebraska.
Plant Disease, 90: 108.
Ellis, M. B. (1971): Dematiaceous Hyphomycetes. Comm. Mycol. Inst.,
Kew, Surrey, England.
Gannibal, F. B. (2004): Melkoszporovüje vidü roda Alternaria na zlakah.
Mikologia i Fitopatologia, 38: 19-28.
Makela, K. (1972): Seed borne fungi on cultivated grasses in Finland.
Soum. Matal. Seur. Julk., 2: 1-33.
Neergaard, P. (1979): Seed pathology. Vol. I & II. Macmillian Press Ltd.
London.
Papp, E., Szabó, L. GY. és Walcz, I. (1986): Vetőmag - ismereti zsebkönyv.
Mezőgazdasági Kiadó, Budapest. 192-194.
Radulescu, E. – Negru, A. (1971): Magkártevők és betegségek határozója.
Mezőgazdasági Kiadó, Budapest. 1-292.
Simay, E. I. (1989): A csicseriborsón (Cicer arietinum L.) 1985. és 1988.
évek között megfigyelt gombák. Növénytermelés, 38: 435-442.
Simay, E. I. (1990): Paradicsom (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.)
magtételeken 1987 és 1989 között megfigyelt gombák.
Kertgazdaság, XXII/6: 64-73.
Simay, E. I. (1991): Keserűfűfélék (Polygonaceae) magpenészedését okozó
gombák. Kertgazdaság, XXIII/5: 37-44.
Simay, E. I. (1992a): Magvizsgálatok eredményei. XXI.-Zab penészes
magvain megfigyelt néhány gomba. Növényvédelem, 5-6: 228-232.
Simay, E. I. (1992b): Magvizsgálatok eredményei. XXII.-Kukorica
penészes magvain megfigyelt gombák. Növényvédelem, 7-8: 285290.
238
Sivanesan, A. (1987): Graminicolous species of Bipolaris, Curvularia,
Drechslera, Exserohilum and their teleomorphs. CAB Intern. Mycol.
Inst., Mycological Papers 158. 1-261.
Sutton, B. C. (1980): The Coelomycetes. Comm. Mycol. Inst., Kew, Surrey,
England.
Tagenko,V.P. (1974): A rozsnok magvak gombabetegségei (Gribnüe
bolezni szemjan koszta). ZASCS. Raszt., Moszkva, 11: 47-48.
Varga, Zs. – Fischl, G. (2005): Infection rates of perennial ryegrass seeds
(Lolium perenne L.) with different fungi. Comm. Appl. Biol. Sci.,
70/3: 345-350.
Varga, Zs., Dongó, A. és Fischl, G. (2004): Termesztett fűfajok
szemtermésén előforduló mikroszkopikus gombák. Növénytermelés,
53: 37-41.
Walcz, I. - Horváth L. (1976): Három fűfaj magkórtani vizsgálata. Alkotó
Ifjúság Pályázat, Tápiószele. 1-24.
COMPARATIVE SEED PATHOLOGICAL INVESTIGATIONS ON
CULTIVATED GRASS SPECIES
Zsolt Varga1 , Bernhard Krautzer2 and Wilhelm Graiss2
1
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Keszthely, Hungary
2
HBLFA Raumberg-Gumpenstein, Irdning, Austria
The authors investigated comparative seed pathology of the species of common bentgrass, (Agrostis capillaris L), yellow oat-grass (Trisetum flavescens L.) and the crested
dog’s-tail (Cynosorus cristatus L.) using two different methods. Besides the mapping of
fungal species occurring on seeds of the grass species tested, they also investigated effect of
fungal contamination on the germination rate of the seeds. They identified from seeds of the
three grass species 21 fungal genera belonging to the Deuteromycota. Among them the
saprotrophic Alternaria, Epicoccum, Cladosporium and Stachybotrys proved to be
dominant. They identified in many cases also the plant pathogenic genera of Bipolaris,
Drechslera, Fusarium, Septoria, and Ascochyta. The occurrence of Curvularia,
Ulocladium, Embellisia, Septonema, Pithomyces genera from seeds of crested dog’s-tail,
and Ulocladium and Pithomyces from seeds of yellow oat grass are considered new data.
239
INDUCTION OF DISEASE RESISTANCE BY SALICYLIC
ACID, SODIUM BENZOATE AND POTASSIUM
MONOPHOSPHATE AGAINST USTILAGO MAYDIS IN
MAIZE PLANTS
Fawzeya Fadel1, Magdy El-Naggar1, Sobhi Tolba2 and Gamal Farahat2
1
Kafr El-Sheikh University, Faculty of Agricultue, Agric. Botany Dept.,
Kafr El-Sheikh, Egypt
2
Agricultural Research Center, Sakha Agricultural Research Station, Giza,
Egypt
Plants can be induced locally and systemically to become resistant to
disease through various biotic or abiotic stresses. Pretratment of susceptible
plants with avirulant pathogens (biotic inducers) or certain chemicals
(abiotic inducers) such as salicylic acid (SA) can enhance resistance to
subsequent attack, not only at the site of treatment, but also in tissues distant
from the initial treatment sites. Cohen (2002) added that biotic and abiotic
agents may induce resistance in plants against pathogens. Abiotic agents
may be synthetic or natural ones.
As an alternative to fungicide application, it may be possible to
utilize a scheme for inducing plant defences in order to provide protection
against pathogens. Such an induced defence response known as a systemic
acquired resistance (SAR) could provide a sufficient protection against
pathogens (Spletzer and Enyedi, 1999). They also added that challenge
inoculation of 200 mM SA treated tomato (root feeded) using conidia of
Alternaria solani resulted 83% fewer lesions per leaf and 77% reduction in
blight leaf area compared to control (plants did not received SA.). The cited
data indicate that root feeding of 200 mM SA to tomato plants can (i)
significantly elevated foliar SA levels, (ii) induced PR-IB gene expression,
and (iii) activated SAR that was effective against A. solani. White (1979)
showed that exogenous application of SA and certain other benzoic acid
derivatives induce rsistance to TMV virus and accumulation of pathogenesis
related (PR) proteins. Yalpani et al. (1991) and Klessing and Malamy
(1993) added that level of endogenous SA had been closely correlated to the
induction of PR-proteins. Moreover, exogenous application of SA induces
the same sets of SAR genes that were expressed following biological SAR
induction. These observations had led to the idea that SA could be an
endogenous signal responsible for triggering resistance (Ward et al. 1991;
Uknes et al. 1992, 1993). Many researchers supported these observations i.e.
Rasmussen et al. (1991), Shulaev et al. (1995), Chasan (1995) and Molders
240
et al. (1996) who showed that SA accumulation was essential for the
development of SAR. It had been postulated that SA was the phloem-mobile
long distance signal that travels through the plant and induces systemic
resistance. Morris et al. (1998) added that both of SA and benzothiadiazole7carbothioic acid (BTH) were capable inducing the expressions PR1 and
PRs genes in maize. Treatment by BTH at 1 g/kg of corn seeds reduced the
incidence of downy mildew disease from 39% to 17%, this induced level of
protection was similar to the genetic resistance. Moreover Ward et al.
(1991) showed that evocation of SAR response causes rapid accumulation
of several PR proteins both in the intra- and extracellular regions of the leaf.
Metraux et al. (1991) and Vernooij et al. (1995) added that expression of PR
genes and the induction of SAR can occure in the absence of pathogens by
way of the application of synthetic compounds such as 2,6
dichloroisonicotinic acid (DNA) and BTH. Ward et al. (1991) and Palva et
al. (1994) also added that exogenous application of SA to plants can
effectively induce SAR.
Kumar et al. (2003) reviewed that field experiments on six resistance
inducer chemicals, benzoic acid was better than other chemicals in reducing
stem rot disease incidence and severity in rice (caused by Sclerotium oryze)
followed by naphthalene acetic acid and SA. Elad (1992) tested 18 free
radical scavengers (antioxidants) for their ability to control grey mould
(caused by Botrytis cinerea) and white mould (Sclerotinia sclerotiorum) in
various crops. Most of the compounds significantly reduced the disease
levels in at least one on the tested hosts, i.e. tomato, pepper, bean and rose.
Tannic acid and ascorbic acid controlled grey mould of tomato fruits,
benzoic acid improved the control activity on tomato leaves. Kataria et al.
(1997) showed that among 16 chemicals known as resistance inducers
(antioxidants), ascorbic acid and benzoic acid efficiently controlled both
pre- and post-emergence damping off in Phaseolus vulgaries caused by
Rhizoctonia solani. El-Ganaieny et al. (2002) added that using of salicylic
acid against three Fusarium spp., viz. F. oxysporum, F. moniliforme (= F.
verticillioides) and F. solani which causes damping off and basal rot of
onion was more effective when applied as seed and transplant treatment
than when applied as soil treatment under greenhouse conditions.
The aim of the present work is to study the effect of three inducer
chemicals, viz. salicylic acid, sodium benzoate and potassium
monophosphate on induction of maize common smut disease resistance
using two induction periods and two application methods.
241
Materials and Methods
I. Effect of induction period on resistance of common smut under
greenhouse conditions
Maize cv. Balady were sown in pots 30 cm in diameter each
contaning 8 kg soil/pot by 15 seeds/pot. Three pots were used for each
treatment as repetition. After 10 days of sowing, the emerged seedlings
were thined to 10 plants/pot. Three inducer chemicals viz. salicylic acid
(SA), sodium benzoate (BA), potassium monophosphate (KH2PO4) at
concentration 10 mM were used. After 15 days from sowing the upper
and lower surfaces of the leaves were smeared by each of the inducer
chemicals separetly by helping a piece of cotton. The treated plants were
left for two different induction periods, 8 and 16 days respectively, and
then inoculted by Ustilago maydis. Seedlings which were inoculted only
by U. maydis were used as control. All treatments were kept under
natural conditions during July and August 2004. The same expriment was
repeated and all treatment were also kept under the natural condition
during July and August 2005. After 30 days of inoculation by U. maydis,
disease incidence was estimated as percentage of diseased plants
(infection %) and disease severity which were expressed as disease index
(DI). Disease index was estimated according to the size and numbers of
galls which were classified into 8 classes: 0 = no infection, 1 = galls less
than 1 cm in diameter, 2 = galls ranged from 1 to 2 cm in diameter, 3 =
ranged from 2 to 3 cm in diameter, 4 = ranged from 3 to 4 cm in
diameter, 5 = from 4 to 5 cm in diameter, 6 = from 5 to 6 cm in diameter,
7 = ranged from 6 to 7 cm in diameter, 8 = from 7 to more than 8 cm in
diameter. Consequently, the following equation was set for disease index
estimation:
∑(NPC x CR)
DI = ____________ x 100
NIP x MSC
Where: NPC = Number of plants in class rate
CR = class rate
NIP = Number of inoculted plants
MSC = Maximum severity class rate
Fresh weight (g) and plant height (cm) were also measured.
242
II.- Effect of smearing and injection of maize leaves by inducer
chemicals on resistance of common smut disease under greenhouse
conditions
Maize cv. Balady was shown in pots as mentioned above. The same
inducer chemicals which were used as in the formerly mentioned
experiment in two different concentrations, 10 and 20 mM. After 18 days of
sowing, upper and lower surfaces of leaves were separetly smeared and
injected in the midvein by 1 ml of the two concentrations of the three
inducer chemicals. After 16 days of treatments, the seedlings were
inoculated by U. maydis. Seedlings inoculated by U. maydis were used as
control. Three pots each containing 8-10 seedlings were used as replicates.
Disease severity was estimated as mentioned earlier. The experiment was
performed during July and August in two successive seasons of 2005 and
2006 under greenhouse conditions.
Results
I. Effect of induction periods of three inducer chemicals on disease
incidence and disease severity of common smut disease of maize plants
under greenhouse conditions
Data presented in Table 1 and 2 showed that no significant differences
has been observed between the two induction periods 8 and 16 days, using
the three tested inducer chemicals viz. SA, BA and KH2PO4 on disease
incidence of common smut disease of maize plants. The most effective
treatment on the disease incidence (infection %) were BA (9.3%) and
KH2PO4 (6.7%) compared to control (21.7%) after 16 days induction period
in the first season, and KH2PO4 (29.3%) compared to control (63.7%) in the
second one. On the other hand, a significant difference was found between
the two induction periods, 8 and 16 days using the three inducer chemicals
on disease severity (DI %) in the two testes seasons with an exception of SA
after induction period of 8 days and KH2PO4 after 16 days. The most
effective inducer chemicals on disease severity (DI %) were BA (6.34%)
and KH2PO4 (5.83%) compared to control (13.28%) after 16 days induction
period in the first season and BA (15.27%) and KH2PO4 (15.33%) in
comparison with control (42.85%) after 8 days induction period in the
second one.
243
Table 1. Effect of induction periods of three inducer chemicals on disease
incidence (infection %) and disease severity (DI %) of common smut
disease of maize plants (cv. Balady) under greenhouse conditions during
2004 season
Inducer
chemicals
SA
BA
KH2PO4
Control
Induction
period
(days)
Disease incidence
(infection %)
Disease severity (DI %)
8
16
8
16
8
16
8
16
15.3 abc
22.7c
12.0ab
9.3ab
18.3bc
6.7a
21.7c
21.7c
10.12c
15.93e
9.37b
6.34a
12.87d
5.83a
13.28d
13.28d
Table 2. Effect of induction periods of three inducer chemicals on disease
incidence (infection %) and disease severity (DI %) of common smut
disease of maize plants (cv. Balady) under greenhouse conditions during
2005 season
Inducer
chemicals
SA
BA
KH2PO4
Control
Induction
period
(days)
8
16
8
16
8
16
8
16
Disease incidence
(infection %)
Disease severity (DI %)
29.0a
36.0a
40.7ab
58.3bc
20.7a
29.3a
63.7c
63.7c
22.3c
22,7c
15.27a
28.13d
15.33a
18.51b
42.85e
42.85e
244
II. Effect of leaf smearing of three inducer chemicals on disease
incidence and disease severity of common smut disease of maize
plants as well as on fresh weight and plant height under greenhouse
conditions
Data in Table 3 and 4 illustrated a positive effect on decreasing
common smut disease by smearing leaves with the inducer chemicals SA,
BA and KH2PO4 at two different concentrations 10 and 20 mM after 16
days incubation period. All tested inducer chemicals significantly decreased
disease incidence and disease severity compared to control in the two tested
seasons with an exception of BA at 10 mM and KH2PO4 at 20 mM in the
first season. The most effective inducer chemicals were SA and BA at 20
mM. All inducer chemicals showed an increase in the fresh weight (g)
during the two season and plant hight in the second season compared to
control.
Table 3. Effect of leaf smearing of three inducer chemicals at two different
concentrations on disease incidence and disease severity of common smut
disease of maize plants (cv. Balady) as well as on fresh weight and plant
height under greenhouse conditions during 2005 season
Inducer
chemicals
SA
BA
KH2PO4
Control
Conc.
(mM)
10
20
10
20
10
20
Disease
incidence
(infection %)
36.30b
25.00ab
58.30c
15.00a
29.30ab
35.30b
63.70c
245
Disease
severity (DI
%)
22.68c
17.50b
28.13d
5.10a
18.51b
27.38d
42.85e
Fresh
weight
(g)
351.7e
421.7f
266.7b
348.3e
298.0c
333.3d
231.7a
Plant
height
(cm)
95.3ab
111.7b
105.0ab
105.7ab
93.3ab
10.3ab
69.3a
Table 4. Effect of leaf smearing of three inducer chemicals at two different
concentrations on disease incidence and disease severity of common smut
disease of maize plants (cv. Balady) as well as on fresh weight and plant
height under greenhouse conditions during season 2006
Inducer
chemicals
SA
BA
KH2PO4
Control
Conc.
(mM)
10
20
10
20
10
20
Disease
incidence
(infection %)
08.66a
08.67a
19.66b
09.66a
19.17b
39.66c
63.08d
Disease
severity (DI
%)
04.76a
13.63c
18.75d
06.66b
13.46c
18.15d
43.01e
Fresh
weight
(g)
250.84c
255.60c
293.50e
285.74e
276.17d
248.26c
201.3 a
Plant
height
(cm)
79.86bc
85.70c
84.36c
88.90c
73.33bc
73.70 bc
56.80a
III. Effect of leaf injection of three inducer chemicals on disease
incidence and disease severity of common smut disease of maize
plants as well as on fresh weight and plant height under greenhouse
conditions
Data presented in table 5 and 6 showed that the injection of SA and
BA into midvein of maize seedlings leaves significantly decreased the
common smut disease by decreasing the gall size (DI %) in both tested years
and the disease incidence (infection %) in the second year. All inducer
chemicals showed increase in the fresh weight (g) and plant hight both in
tested years compared to control. Generally, the three used inducer
chemicals increased the fresh weight and plant hight.
246
Table 5. Effect of leaf injection of three inducer chemicals at two different
concentrations on disease incidence and disease severity of common smut
disease of maize plants (cv. Balady) as well as on fresh weight and plant
height under greenhouse conditions during 2005 season
Inducer
chemicals
SA
BA
KH2PO4
Conc.
(mM)
Disease incidence
(infection %)
10
20
10
20
10
20
36,00ab
38.0ab
61.0bc
21.0a
64.76c
53.0abc
63.7bc
Control
Disease
severity (DI
%)
23.43c
19.79b
28.75d
15.78a
52.17f
30.0d
42.85e
Fresh
weight
(g)
431c
318.3b
463.7c
344.0b
550.3b
316.3b
249.7a
Plant
height
(cm)
117.3c
99.0b
121.0c
98.7b
93.0b
95.3b
69.3a
Table 6. Effect of leaf injection of three inducer chemicals at two different
concentrations on disease incidence and disease severity of common smut
disease of maize plants (cv. Balady) as well as on fresh weight and plant
height under greenhouse conditions during 2006 season
Inducer
chemicals
SA
BA
KH2PO4
Control
Conc.
(mM)
10
20
10
20
10
20
Disease
incidence
(infection %)
45.86b
35.00a
46.67b
43.33ab
35.49a
35.54a
67.67c
Disease
severity (DI
%)
25.00c
23.55ab
34.85d
25.00c
22.59a
24.10bc
43.01e
Fresh
weight
(g)
250.6d
221.2c
207.73b
220.60c
213.51b
200.63b
201.56b
Plant
height
(cm)
76.40ab
75.80ab
81.86ab
84.13b
83.0ab
91.66b
56.80a
Discussion
Induced resistance has been described in a wide variety both of dicots
and monocots. Under our test conditions leaf smearing by SA, BA and
KH2PO4 decreased the infection and disease index percentage significantly
compared to control in the two tested years, 2005 and 2006. The inducer
247
chemicals increased the fresh weight and plant height. Injection of inducer
chemicals into midvein of maize seedling leaves decreased the common
smut disease by decreasing the gall size (disease index). Such inducer
chemicals did not were phytotoxic to maize seedlings and restricted U.
maydis infection, indicating that the three compunds may act synergistic.
Thus resistance inducers can achieve a significant reduction of common
smut disease incidence.
Our results showed also, that pretreatments of maize by SA, BA, and
KH2PO4 respectively, 16 days before pathogen infection was much better in
reducing U. maydis infection development than 8 days before. These results
are similar to those obtained by Malolepsza (2005) who showed that the
pretreatments of tomato with BTH and HER and cucumber with SA, BTH
and INA before pathogen infections (24 hrs) reduced Botrytis cinerea and
Colletotricum lagenarium (= C. orbiculare, Kövics, 2000) infection
development in tomato and cucumber at 6 and 12 hrs, respectively.
The present results could be interpreted by those obtained by White
(1979) who showed that exogenous application of BA (benzoic acid)
derivatives induces resistance to TMV and accumulate PR proteins. Klessing
and Malony (1993) added that SA could be an endogenous signal responsible
for triggering resistance and closely correlated to the induction of PR
proteins. Rasmussen et al. (1991), Shulaev et al. (1995), Chasen (1995) and
Molders et al. (1996) also showed that SA accumulation was essential for the
development of SAR. It had been postulated that SA was the phloem-mobile
long distance signal that travels through the plant and induces systemic
resistance. Moreover, Elad (1992) and Morris et al. (1998) reported that
application of SA reduced the early blight in tomato, root rot in cowpea,
bacterial blight in cotton, grey mould in various crops (tomato, pepper and
bean) and anthracnose in maize.
Acknowledgement
The facilities supported by Dr Amro Mousa Emran, lecturer of plant
pathology, Fac. of Agric. Kafr El-Sheikh Univ., Egypt, throught the
course of this investigation is aknowledged by the last author.
References
Chasan, R. (1995): SA: source or signal for SAR? Plant Cell 7: 1519-1521.
Cohen, Y. (2002): Systemic induced resistance. Plant Prot. Sci. 38 (1): 122125.
248
Elad, Y. (1992): The use of antioxidants (free radical scavengers) to control
white mold (Sclerotinia sclerotiorum) in various crops. Plant
Pathology 41: 417–426.
El-Ganaieny, R.M.A., El-Sayed, A.M. and Gebrial, M. (2002): Induced
resistance to fusarial disease in onion plants by treatment with
antioxidants. Assiut J. of Agric. Sci. 33: 133-147.
Kataria, H.R., Wolmsmeier, B. and Buchenauer, H. (1997): Efficacy of
resistance inducers, free-radical scavengers and an antagonostic strain
of Pseudomonas fluorescens for control of Rhizoctonia solani AG-U
in bean and cucumber. Plant Pathology 40: 897-909.
Klessing, D. and Malamy, J. (1993): Salicylic acid and plant disease
resistance. Plant J. 2: 643–654.
Kövics, G. (2000): Dictionary of disease names of phytopathogenic fungi.
(Növénybetegséget okozó gombák névtára. Mezőgazda Kiadó,
Budapest 255 pp.(in Hungarian)
Kumar, A., Ram Singh and Jalali, B.L. (2003): Manegement of stem rot of
rice with resistance inducing chemicals and fungicides. Indian
Phytopath. 56: 226-269.
Malolepsza, U. (2005): Induction of disease resistance by acibenzolar-Smethyle and Q-othorutin against Botrytis cinerea in tomato plants.
Crop Prot. 25: 956–962.
Metraux, J.P., Ahl-Goz, P., Stamb, T. Speich, J., Steinemman, A., Razls, J.
and Ward, E. (1991): Induced resistance in cucumber in response to
2,6 dichloroisonicotinic acid and pathogens. Mol. Gen. of Plant
Microb. Interact. 1: 432-439.
Molders, W., Bauchala, A. and Metraux (1996). Transport salicyilic acid in
tobacco necrosis virus-infected cucumber plants. Plant Physiol. 112:
787-792.
Morris, S.W., Vernooij T.S., Starrett, M., Bhandhufalck, A. and Hulbart, S.
(1998): Induced resistance responses in maize. Mol. Plant Microb.
Interact. 11: 642-658.
Palava, T.K., Hurtig, M., Saindrenan, P. and Palva, E. (1994): Salicylic acid
induced resistance to Erwinia carotovora subsp. carotovora in
tobacco. Mol. Plant Microb. Interact. 7: 356-363.
Rasmussen, J.B., Hammerschmidt, R. and Zook, M.N. (1991): Systemic
induction of salicylic acid accumulation in cucumber after inoculation
with Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae. Plant Physiol. 97: 1342–
1347.
Shulaev, V., Leon, J. and Raskin, I. (1995): Is salicylic acid a translocated
signal of systemic resistance in tobacco? Plant Cells 7: 1691–1701.
Spletzer, M.F. and Enyedi, A.J. (1999). Saliciylic acid induces resistance to
Alternatia solani in hydroponically grown tomato. Phytopath. 89.
249
Uknes, S., Mauch-Mani, B., Moyer, M., Potler, S. and Williams, S. (1992):
Acquired resistance in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 3: 645–656.
Uknes, S., Winter, A., Delaney, T., Vernooij, B. and Friedrich, L. (1993):
Biological induction of systemic acquired resistance in Arabidopsis.
Mol. Plant Microb. Abstract 6: 692-698.
Vernooij, B., Friedrich, L., Ahl-Goz, P., Staub, T., Icessman, H. and Razls,
J. (1995): 2,6 Dichloroisoniccotinic acid-induced resistance to
pathogens without the accumulation of salicylic acid. Mol. Plant
Microb. Interact. 8: 228-234.
Ward, E.R., Uknes, S.J., Williams, S.C., Dincher, S.S. and Wiedernold,
D.Z.(1991): Coordinate gene activity in response to agents that
induce systemic acquired resistance. Plant Cell 3: 1085–1094.
Whie, R.F. (1979): Acetyl salicylic acid induces resistance to tobacco
mosaic virus in tobacco. Virology 99: 410–412.
Yalpani, N., Silverman, P., Wilson, T.M.A., Kleier, D.A. and Raskin, I.
(1991): Salicylic acid is a systemic signal and an inducer of
pathogensis related proteins in virus-infected tobacco. Plant Cell 3:
809–818.
INDUCTION OF DISEASE RESISTANCE BY SALICYLIC ACID,
SODIUM BENZOATE AND POTASSIUM MONOPHOSPHATE
AGAINST USTILAGO MAYDIS IN MAIZE PLANTS
Fawzeya Fadel1, Magdy El-Naggar1, Sobhi Tolba2 and Gamal Farahat2
1
Kafr El-Sheikh University, Faculty of Agricultue, Agric. Botany Dept.,
Kafr El-Sheikh, Egypt
2
Agricultural Research Center, Sakha Agricultural Research Station, Giza,
Egypt
An attempt was made to study the effect of three inducer chemicals, salicylic acid, sodium
benzoate and potassium monophosphate on induction of disease resistance against Ustilago
maydis causing common smut disease of maize plants. Two induction periods, 8 and 16
days, as well as two application methods, viz. leaf smearing and leaf injection, were studied
for the three inducer chemicals. No significant effect has been observed between the two
induction periods using the three inducer chemicals on disease incidence (infection %) of
common smut. On the other hand, a significant difference was found among the two
induction periods using the three inducer chemicals on disease severity (DI %). In general,
the three inducer chemicals decreased the disease incidence and disease severity using both
induction periods. As to the two application methods, leaf smearing and leaf injection, a
significant decrease in disease incidence and disease severity of common smut disease as
well as significant increase in plant weight and height was observed using the three inducer
chemicals by both methods of application.
250
A NEW, RAPID AND NON-DESTRUCTIVE
BIOPHYSICAL METHOD (CHLOROPHYLL A
FLUORESCENCE) PROVES THAT GROWTH
PROMOTING ENDOPHYTES ALLEVIATE CD STRESS
IN CICER ARIETINUM L.
Devanand Dangre1 - Mahendra Rai1 – Reto Strasser2
1
Department of Biotechnology, SGB Amravati University, Amravati –444
602, Maharashtra State, India
2
Université de Genève, Laboratoire de Bioénergétique, Chemin des
Embrouchis 10, Jussy / Genève, CH-1254 Switzerland
Introduction
In India, the concentration of cadmium (Cd) into the soil is increasing day
by day, due to the application of chemical fertilizers especially phosphate
fertilizers. This is one of the major problems for the Indian farmers.
Cadmium exerts a toxic effect to the plant and results in leaf chlorosis and
necrosis with some of the morphological changes like decrease in growth in
size and tissues (Becerril et al., 2002). In plants, Cd toxicity indirectly
affects the photosynthetic apparatus of the leaf and can be evaluated by
analysis of chlorophyll a fluorescence. Chlorophyll a is used as a rapid and
non-destructive biomarker for the assessment of stress caused by different
environmental factors (Srivastava et al., 1999). The availability of Cd to
plants and, thus its toxicity depends on complex rhizospheric reactions,
involving not only exchange processes between soil and plants but also
microbial activities. In this respect, mycorrhizal fungi appear to play a
central modulating role.
To overcome all these problems and to protect the plant against toxic
metals, arbuscular-vesicular mycorrhiza fungi (AMF) and Piriformospora
indica may play a promising role due to their growth promoting
characteristics.
Mycorrhizae (fungus root) enter into a mutualistic relationship with plant
roots, in which the fungi actually become integrated into the physical
structure of the roots. The fungus derives nutritional uptake from the plant
roots, without causing any plant disease.
Chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) is an ancient crop of India which supplies 70
to 90 % of the worlds chickpea. It can grow in low rain fall and poor soils.
251
The main aim of the present study was to analyze and evaluate the
cadmium-stress tolerance of chickpea after colonization of roots by
Piriformospora indica, Glomus mosseae and G. caledonium.
Materials and Methods
Photobionts
Cicer arietinum cv. Chafa
Mycobionts
(i) Piriformospora indica, (ii) Glomus mosseae, (iii) G. caledonium
Culture medium for Piriformospora indica
P. indica was grown on Kaefer’s medium (Kaefer, 1977).
Multiplication of inocula of Glomus caledonium and G. mosseae
The multiplication of AMF was carried out in Zea mays. The maize seeds
were sown in sterile soil. The pot mixture (soil:sand in 3:1) was sterilized
three times to inactivate the spores which were already present in the soil.
After 3 months, inocula were assessed for colonization and preserved for
further studies. The used inocula were Piriformospora indica, Glomus
mosseae and G. caledonium. Proper controls were also maintained.
The seeds of two varieties of chickpea were obtained from Dr. Panjabrao
Deshmukh Krishi Vidyapith, Akola, Maharashtra state, India. The healthy
seeds of chickpea were surface sterilized by treating with 0.1% HgCl2 and
water for 2 minutes. Then kept overnight at room temperature for incubation
in sterile distilled water. These seeds were ready for sowing.
Eighteen pots were filled with 3 kg of pot culture (soil:sand in 3:1) with 1-2
cm layer of mycorrhizal culture. Proper controls (without AMF) were also
maintained. Twelve pots were used for chickpea Chafa including a control
(only with Cd without cultures and without Cd and culture). In each pot, 3
plants were grown. The experiments were carried out in triplicate.
The surface sterilized seeds were sown on first day of October 2004. The
seeds were germinated on the third day at the temperature 29-30oC.
Fluorescence were measured periodically at the interval of 7 days by using
Handy PEA.
Cadmium stress was induced to each plant after 14 days from cultivation,
excluding control. The initial concentration of cadmium was 10 μg/g of soil.
At the interval of fifth day, the concentration of cadmium was increased by
252
10 μg, so that the stress was increased by 10 μg Cd/g of soil. The same
procedure was continued up to November 2 and the stress was increased
upto 40μg/g of soil. But phenotypically the plants did not show any
significant change. So the stress (Cd concentration) was increased from
10μg to 100 μg/g of soil by adding 60μg Cd/g of soil. On every 5th day
stress was increased by 100 μg upto the 400 μg/g of soil.
Measurement of Chlorophyll a fluorescence
Handy PEA (Plant Efficiency Analyzer, from Hansatech Instruments Pvt.
Ltd, UK) is a fluorimeter which has high resolution. The measurement
process starts with the placement of lightweight plastic leaf clips at the
measuring sites. The leaf clip shutter blade was closed to prevent the entry
of light and the clip left in place for several minutes to provide dark
adaptation.
During the measurement, PEA sensor unit was attached to the clip. The
shutter blade of the clip can then slide back to expose the dark-adapted leaf
to the sensor unit. This contains both a custom array of red light-emitting
diodes (LEDs) providing saturating light levels for accurate Fm
determination, and a fast response, low noise fluorescence detector for
accurate determination of Fo.
On completion of a measurement the parameters Fo, Fm, Fv and Fv/Fm are
automatically calculated from the recorded data. These parameters or the
original data then transferred in a computer for further analysis. The data
then analyzed by using a computer software program, Biolyzer and can be
viewed on the display before deciding whether to retain or discard them.
This flexible data storage system allows the user to decide on the most
appropriate utilization of available memory.
To stain the roots the method suggested by Phillips and Hayman (1970) was
followed and for assessment of colonization, the slide method proposed by
Giovanneti and Mosse (1980) was applied.
Statistical Analysis
To analyze whether there is any significant difference between the
performance of each culture with the control, we used ‘one way ANOVA’
for the relative variability within the separate classes of the experiment.
Results and Discussion
The endophytes Piriformospora indica, Glomus caledonium and G. mosseae
improve the growth and biomass production of chickpea. These endophytes
colonized roots of the host plant (Figure 1D, E, F).
253
The possible benefits include increased crop yield, protection against stress
condition by increasing tolerance to heavy metal and against pathogen and
leaf diseases upto a certain level. Spores of the endophytes were used for the
growth promotion of chickpea after giving Cd stress. P. indica showed the
maximum performing index output in chickpea as compared to G.
caledonium and G. mosseae. This demonstrates that cd treated plants are in
stress and endophytes helps in mitigation of effect of Cd.
The percentage of colonization and height of the plants were also improved
as compared to control and Cd treated plants (Table 1). Cadmium is a heavy
metal and exerted toxic effect to these plants, resulted in chlorosis and
necrosis (Fig 1C). At low concentration the plants did not show the
significant phenotypic changes but physiological changes were observed.
When the concentration of cadmium was increased upto 100 μg/g of soil, it
exerted its toxic effects and have shown the symptoms like yellowing of
leaves. These symptoms were observed much greater in Cd treated plants
than the Cd + P. indica , Cd + G. caledonium and Cd + G. mosseae treated
plants.
254
Table 1. Percentage colonization and height of Cd treated plants after
inoculation with different endophytes
Treatment
%Colonization
Height
(in cm)
Control
No
19.00
(±3.80)
Cd treated
No
Cd + Gc
75.0 %
(±1.52)
70.0 %
(±2.08)
85.0 %
(±1.63)
14.25
(±1.97)
28.12
(±6.38)
24.12
(±4.56)
26.00
(±5.70)
Cd + Gm
Cd + Pi
All values are mean ± S.D. Mean values are significantly different at P<0.05
When the Cd concentration was increased upto 200 μg/g of soil, the
branches of Cd treated plants turned to brown. But the branches of the Cd +
endophytes treated plants did not turn brown. Later, after increasing the
concentration (300 μg/g of soil) the chlorosis and necrosis took place. At
this stage, the growth of Cd treated plants was stopped. The Cd treated
plants of ‘Chafa’ variety were died at this stage.
The test endophytes – Piriformospora indica, Glomus mosseae and Glomus
caledonium – promote the growth and increase the heavy metal tolerance in
plants by forming symbiotic association with roots of plants. These
endophytes also increases the nutrient uptake of the plant through the roots
and photosynthetic activity with height and branching of the plants.
Acknowledgement
The authors are thankful to Professor Ajit Varma, director, Amity Institute
of Herbal and Microbial Studies, Noida, India for supplying of P. indica.
References
Becerril, F.R., Calantzis, C., Turnau, K., Caussanel, J.P., Belimove, A.A.,
Gianinazzi, S., Strasser, R.J. and Gianinazzi-Pearson, V. (2002):
Journal of Experimental Botany 53 (371): 1177-1185.
Giovannetti, M. and Mosse, B. (1980): New Phytol. 84: 489-500.
255
Kaefer, E. (1977): Adv. Genet. 19: 33-131.
Phillips, J.M. and Hayman, D.S. (1970): Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc. 55: 158161.
Srivastava, A., Strasser, R. J. and Govindjee (1999): Photosynthetica 37:
365-392.
Strasser, R.J. (2004): Environmental Pollution. 115: 49-64 (201).
A NEW, RAPID AND NON-DESTRUCTIVE BIOPHYSICAL
METHOD (CHLOROPHYLL A FLUORESCENCE) PROVES THAT
GROWTH PROMOTING ENDOPHYTES ALLEVIATE CD STRESS
IN CICER ARIETINUM L.
D. Dangre1, M. Rai1 and R. Strasser2
1
Department of Biotechnology, SGB Amravati University, Amravati –444 602,
Maharashtra State, India
2
Université de Genève, Laboratoire de Bioénergétique, Chemin des Embrouchis 10, Jussy /
Genève, CH-1254, Switzerland
Summary
Cadmium stress was induced in Cicer arietinum (chickpea), which is the third important
crop of India after wheat and rice. The measurements of chlorophyll a fluorescence were
recorded after 10 days of inoculation with the help of Handy PEA (Plant Efficiency
Analyzer). Cadmium stress was given to each plant after 14 days from sowing, excluding
control (without stress) of each variety. The concentration of cadmium was increased after
a period of 5 days by 10 μg to increase stress. We used endophytes, viz. Piriformospora
indica, Glomus caledonium and G. mosseae to evaluate their effect on Cicer arietinum
under Cd stress. The main aim of the present study was to assess the efficiency of
endophytes on chickpea exposed to Cd stress. The tested endophytes promoted the growth,
increased the heavy metal tolerance, the nutrient uptake, and photosynthetic activity with
height and branching of the plants.
256
INFLUENCE OF CONSERVATION TILLAGE AND
DIFFERENT NUTRIENT RATES ON THE LEAF
DISEASES OF
WINTER WHEAT
Stingli Attila1 − Bíró Tímea2 − Percze Attila1
1
Szent István University, Faculty of Agriculture and Environmental
Sciences, Institute of Crop Production
Department of Soil Tillage Management
2
Szent István University, Faculty of Agriculture and Environmental
Sciences, Department of Plant Protection
In Hungary, the history of conservation tillage goes back to the beginning
of the last century when Pethe, in 1818, constructed the “Hungarian plowplant”, which was used for seedbed preparation, seeding and harrowing, all
in one operation. The advantages of the Hungarian plow-plant were
elimination of trampling, higher yields and reduced consumption of time
and energy. Conventional tillage dominated up to the end of the 1970s in
Hungary. Introduction of new soil tillage systems was stimulated by reduced
energy costs, soil protection, and a more economic soil moisture
management.
Birkás et al (1989) gave an extensive survey of conventional and reduced
tillage in Hungary, emphasizing that new methods of soil tillage were
applied where they could result in lower production costs without any
hazards to yields. (Butorac, 1994) Giving up conventional methods is
necessary in order to improve moisture management, as well as to reduce
dusting, CO2 emission and organic matter reduction. (ECAF 1999, Birkás
2000, Gyuricza 2000)
Stringent measures of soil- and environment protection require less
pesticide utilization, so agrotechnical and soil management possibilities will
be of great importance. (Lehoczky és Percze, 2006)
Conservation tillage is practised on 45 million ha world-wide,
predominantly in North and South America but its uptake is also increasing
in South Africa, Australia and other semi-arid areas of the world. It is
primarily used as a means to protect soils from erosion and compaction, to
conserve moisture and reduce production costs. In Europe, the area
cultivated using minimum tillage is increasing primarily in an effort to
reduce production costs, but also as a way of preventing soil erosion and
retain soil moisture. (Holland, 2004) The Soil Conservation Service, USDA,
has predicted that as much as 95 % of United States cropland will be
cultivated by conservation tillage by the year 2010. (Myers, 1983)
257
In Hungary, little is known about the effect of crop residues on the
pathogens, probably the amount of residues left on soil surface is related to
the severity of the disease.
Materials and Methods
Tillage treatments:
1. conventional tillage, ploughing as control (22-25 cm) (PL),
2. no-till (NT),
3. shallow cultivator use (14-16 cm) (SC),
4. cultivator use, leaving mulch (16-18 cm) (CLM),
5. disking (14-16 cm) (D),
6. loosening (35-40 cm) (L).
Plots have been fertilized on the 22nd of March 2006 at right angles to
tillage treatments with four different nutrient rates in two replications, which
meant 3x, 2x, 1x and 0x 34 kg/ha N. The assessment of the severity of leaf
diseases was carried out on 31st of May 2006, in full flowering of winter
wheat. The precipitation was 60 mm in March, 35 mm in April, 110 mm in
May, totally 205 mm.
The assessment is applied during diffuse- or local type disease processes
of resistance investigations, when the rate of infection is estimated. There
are two methods for the evaluation of surface pathogen infection, relative
and absolute evaluation. There are two types of absolute evaluation: with
non-linear and linear scale.
The infection with appropriate intensity after spontaneous or provocated
infection should be evaluated in optimal time. The infection rate is
considered to be optimal, when the disease is developed, but the plants’
senescence is not started yet.
At surface diseases, in order to determine the rate of infection, a 0-5
absolute evaluation scale is used with 0.5 units (0 = no infection, 5 = 100 %
infection). The scale is linear, so the evaluation rate multiplied by 20, equals
the infected surface % (for e.g. 1.5 = 30 %).
Results and discussion
Pathogens and symptoms of leaf spots
Leaf spots of winter wheat have come into the centre of interest in the
last two decades. One reason is that pyrenophora tan spot damage is known
since 1988 (septoria blotch was known before). The changes in the structure
of agriculture had major roles, as well as the drastic reduction in fertilizer
258
application and heterogenity of the level of crop production. Extensive
farming replaced intensive farming in many places. The scale of wheat
monoculture and non-inversion tillage increased. These changes have
clearly favoured necrotrophic fungi (pathogens of pyrenophora tan spot,
septoria blotch and ear fusarium). (BASF, 2006)
Septoria leaf blotch can be caused by two pathogens: Septoria tritici Rob.
ex Desmaz. and Phaeosphaeria nodorum (E. Müller) Hedjaroude. The
anamorph form of the latter one is Septoria nodorum or as new scientific
name is Stagonospora nodorum (Berk.) Castellani and Germano. Both
species causes leaf spots mainly, but Phaeosphaeria nodorum infects the
glumella of the ear as well, causing browning. Septoria tritici is more
frequent in Hungary, but occasionally Phaeosphaeria nodorum occurs, too.
In the case of Septoria tritici leaf spots are long-shaped in the beginning,
while at S. nodorum are oval. Later the spots are merged, in serious
infection the leaves become dry. Identification of leaf symptoms with
unaided eye is facilitated by the round, rough to the touch, black picnidia
(sometimes perithecia) on the drying spots.
Pyrenophora tan spot is called as yellow spot, as well. The pathogen of
this disease is Pyrenophora tritici-repentis (Died.) Drechs., anamorph form
(conidial) is Drechslera tritici-repentis (Died.) Schoemaker, previously
known as Helminthosporium tritici-repentis Died.
The typical initial symptom of pyrenophora on the leaf is the dark-brown
dot and surrounding yellow blotch (the place of conidial infection), due to
the spreading toxin of the fungus. The spots are getting larger, merged and
brown, in the case of severe infection leaves become dry. (BASF, 2006)
Influence of different tillage treatments and nutrient rates on the leaf
diseases of winter wheat
During the evaluation leaf spot (septoria and pyrenophora), powdery
mildew, leaf rust and take-all was found. Highest infection rate was
determined for septoria and pyrenophora leaf spot, powdery mildew and leaf
rust was found rarely. Take-all was detected under direct-drilling only.
Powdery mildew occurred in traces under 3x nutrient rates in all tillage
treatments, except direct drilling. Leaf rust was detected only under 3x N
rate under conventional ploughing and shallow cultivation. Due to bacterias,
physiological changes have been detected on lower leaves of the plants.
259
Table 1. Averages of leaf spot rates (0-5 scale) under four different N rates
Tillage treatments
Conventional ploughing (PL)
Disking (D)
No-till (NT)
Shallow cultivator (SC)
Cultivator leaving mulch (CLM)
Loosening (L)
Average
0.5
0.9
1
1.1
1.6
1.8
Our results proved that burying (PL) is an effective means of destroying
plant pathogens and thus, an important means of plant disease control.
Today, crop producers are shifting to surface-tillage systems to offset the
rapidly rising costs of fuels, labour and soil erosion. (Phillips et al., 1980)
According to the fact, that the investigation has been carried out after a 4year winter wheat monoculture, the results are quite promising when
adopting soil conversation tillage systems.
The aforementioned fact is proved by the leaf spot infection of 20 %
under direct-drilling. The healthy state of winter wheat can be due to the
favourable plant protection effect of catch-crops (pea, mustard and rye).
Table 2. Effect of tillage treatments and decreasing N rate on the average
value of leaf spot rates
Tillage treatments and N rate
PL, NT, SC, CLM, D, L 3x rate
PL, NT, SC, CLM, D, L 2x rate
PL, NT, SC, CLM, D, L 1x rate
PL, NT, SC, CLM, D, L 0x rate
Average
1
1.06
1.25
1.4
We stated that with decreasing nutrient rate, the average value of leaf
diseases was increasing. Nitrogen makes plants more toughen against
necrotrophic pathogens (fusarium, pyrenophora, septoria). Nitrogen
application enhances the juvenility of winter wheat (inhibits ethylenesynthesis, so the senescence of plant tissues) and keeps the plant juvenile
longer. If plants are well-provided with N, they are protected to a certain
degree against fusarium, pyrenophora and septoria leaf spots. (BASF, 2006)
Leaf spot rates under decreasing N rate in the same tillage treatment did not
show clear tendency, for e. g. under disking 3x N rate 0.5; 2x N rate 0.5; 1x
N rate 2; 0x N rate 0.5 leaf spot rates were detected.
At 3x N rate septoria was dominant, with decreasing N dose pyrenophora
occurrence increased, regarding the whole stand.
260
The results of leaf spot evaluation carried out in the long-term soil tillage
experiment are remarkable for some reasons. It can be stated that in the
rainy growing season of 2006, tillage treatments as well as different nutrient
rates influenced the incidence rate of leaf spot diseases. This fact can not be
generalized as our results presumably do not tally with others’, which were
carried out in other places under different circumstances and different plant
protection- and soil conditions. This makes prediction of future disease
problems difficult because observations from one area may not necessarily
be applicable to others. Taking into consideration, that the investigation has
been carried out after a 4-year winter wheat monoculture, the results are
quite promising when adopting soil conversation tillage systems.
According to Bailey (1996), over the long term, leaf spot diseases of
cereals may be more affected by local environmental conditions than by
changes in tillage practice.
Acknowledgement
This research is supported by the Hungarian National Scientific
Foundation (OTKA-49.049 and F046.670), KLIMA-05 and NKFP6/00079/2005 programs and SZIE GAK Kht. Józsefmajor Experimental and
Training Farm.
Literature
Bailey, K. L. 1996. Diseases under conservation tillage systems. Can. J.
Plant Sci. 76:635-639
BASF (2006). Őszi búza levélfoltosságok. Gombabetegségek sorozat BASF
kiadvány, Budapest.
Birkás M. 2000. A talajtömörödés helyzete Magyarországon.
Következményei és enyhítésének lehetőségei. MTA Doktori
Értekezés, Budapest.
Butorac, A., Carter M. R. 1994. Conservation tillage in Eastern Europe.
In: Conservation tillage in temperate agroecosystems, 357-374.
ECAF. 1999. Conservation Agriculture in Europe: Environmental,
economic and EU policy perspectives. European Conservation
Agricultural Federation, Brussels.
Gyuricza Cs. 2000. Az értékőrző és hagyományos talajművelés egyes
fizikai és biológiai hatásainak értékelése. Doktori (Ph.D) értekezés,
Gödöllő, p. 148.
J. M. Holland 2004. The environmental consequences of adopting
conservation tillage in Europe: reviewing the evidence. Agriculture,
Ecosystems and Environment 103 (2004) 1-25.
261
Myers, Peter C. 1983. Why conservation tillage? J. Soil Water Conserv.
38: 136. In: R. L. Burton, O. R. Jones, J. D. Burd, G. A. Wicks, E. G.
Krenzer Jr. (1987). Damage by Greenbug (Homoptera: Aphididae) to
Grain Sorghum as Affected by Tillage, Surface Residues, and Canopy.
Journal of Economic Entomology Vol:80 792-798 (1987).
Lehoczky, É., Percze, A. (2006) Gyomszabályozás. In: Földművelés és
földhasználat (Szerk. Birkás M.) p. 303.
Országos Mezőgazdasági Minősítő Intézet (2003). A növénykórtani
osztály 2002. évi munkája. Kiadvány, Budapest, p. 15.
Phillips, R. E., Blevins, R. L., Thomas, G. W., Frye W. W., Phillips, S.
H. (1980). No-tillage agriculture. Science 208:1108-1113. In: No
tillage and surface tillage agriculture. The tillage revolution (Ed.
Sprague, M. A.) 1986., pp. 389-408.
INFLUENCE OF CONSERVATION TILLAGE AND DIFFERENT
NUTRIENT RATES ON THE LEAF DISEASES OF
WINTER WHEAT
A. Stingli1, T. Bíró2 and A. Percze1
1
Szent István University, Faculty of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences
Institute of Crop Production, Department of Soil Tillage Management
2
Szent István University, Faculty of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences
Department of Plant Protection
Summary
The aim of our research in 2006 is to investigate the effects of different conservation
tillage methods and nutrient rates on the leaf diseases of winter wheat. The investigations
are carried out on the long-term soil tillage experimental field in József-major, which was
established in 2002. Tillage methods were as follows: 1. conventional tillage, ploughing as
control (22-25 cm), 2. no-till, 3. cultivator use (14-16 cm), 4. cultivator use, leaving mulch
(16-18 cm), 5. disking (14-16 cm), 6. loosening (35-40 cm). Plots have been fertilized at
right angles to tillage treatments with four different nutrient rates in two replications, which
meant 3x, 2x, 1x and 0x 34 kg/ha N.
In order to evaluate leaf disease infection, a 0-5 scale was used. The evaluation was
carried out on the 31st of May 2006 in full flowering. Septoria and Pyrenophora infection
was dominant, leaf rust was rarely detected. We stated that with decreasing nutrient rate,
the rate of leaf diseases was increasing. At 3x N rate was 1, at 2x N rate 1.06, at 1x N rate
1.25 and at no N 1.4 average infection value was detected under different tillage methods.
Taking into consideration, that the investigation has been carried out after a 4-year winter
wheat monoculture, the results are quite promising when adopting soil conversation tillage
systems.
This research is supported by the Hungarian National Scientific Foundation (OTKA49.049 and F046.670), KLIMA-05 and NKFP-6/00079/2005 programs and SZIE GAK Kht.
József-major Experimental and Training Farm.
262
FLAYING HEIGHT OF INSECTS CONNECTED WITH
MOON PHASES USED THE LIGHT-TRAP CATCH DATA
L. Nowinszky1 – Gy. Bürgés2 – B. Herczig3 – J. Puskás1
1
2
Berzsenyi Dániel College, Szombathely, Hungary
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, Keszthely, Hungary
3
Komárom County Plant Protection Service, Tata, Hungary
Great many researchers have been studying the question of the
height at which insect’s fly. A clarification of the issue from the point of
view of plant protection prognosis assumes special significance if there is
sufficient evidence to prove that the height of flight is affected by the phases
of the Moon. El-Ziady (1957) believes in the likelihood of insects flying
higher at the time of a full Moon, so the catch is lower at this time than at
other Moon quarters. He backed his assumption by the catch results of a
suction trap placed at a height of 10 m. Earlier Williams (1936) found lower
catch at full Moon. He thought it was because of the smaller gathering
distance or moonlight has a direct influence on activity and reduces the number
of flying insects. After more decades, there is not any recognised answer to
this question.
Williams (1939) who used light-traps placed at distances of 2 and 10
m from the surface of the ground was a forerunner in examining the vertical
dispersion of nocturnal insects. Taylor and Brown (1972) have found that
some species fly in greater numbers to a light-trap placed higher (12m),
while others prefer traps at a lower height (1 m). Callahan et al. (1972)
collected insects with 15 UV light-traps positioned at different levels going
up to 320 m of a television tower. The highest number of moths was trapped
at heights of 7 - 25 m. From 83 - 320 m, the dispersion was close on even,
but a remarkably higher number of moths were trapped in zones between
the red light signals. More than halves of the insects of the 35 families of 9
orders of insects trapped were Helothis zea Boddie specimens. The ratio of
this species at 320 m was 82%, stunningly high. Sorry their results were not
examined in relationship with Moon phases. Taylor et al. (1979) captured
migratory moths with light-traps of an identical type placed at heights of 0.6
and 24.5 m respectively from ground surface in Kenya. The catch of the trap
placed high was but a fraction of the one placed low. This proportion is
1:11.4 in the case of the turnip moth (Scotia segetum Schiff.).
Aly (1990a) operated two Robinson type light-traps. These traps
were put in 1.5 m and 18.5 m height from the ground. He examined the
success of light trapping of Paederus alfierii Koch (Staphylinidae:
263
Coleoptera) in connection with the four moon quarters. The catch of lower
trap was better at the time of new moon than full moon, but the difference
was not significant in the higher one. Aly (1990b) showed in the catch of
Gryllus domesticus L. (Gryllidae: Orthoptera) on the 1.5 m height trap, the
light-trap catch is higher at new moon than full moon in summer of 1983.
This event can not be seen in the catch of 18.5 m high trap. Aly and Shafi
(1991) did not notice significant difference at the different moon quarters in
the catch of Componotos maculatus aegyptiacus Em (Formicidae:
Hymenoptera) at 1.5 m height. The light-trap catch was more successful
during fall months at full moon in 18.5 m height.
There were operated two Jermy-type light-traps by Vojnits and
Voigt (1971) at Tarcal at experimental yard of Research Institute for
Viticulture and Aenology. The light source was a 100 W normal electric
bulb in both trap. One trap was put between to the grape line, the height was
about 1.5 m and the other was at the end of the line in 2.5 m height. The
distance was about 15 m between these traps. There were determined not
only grape moths, but also other Microlepidoptera species. Generally, the
lower trap caught more specimen as the higher one, but the European corn
borer (Ostrinia nubilalis Hbn.) was caught in higher number by the upper
trap.
There were three fractional light traps in operation between 1967
and 1969 in Kecskemét operated by Járfás. These traps were put in three
different heights and there were separated in every hour. The light sources
of fractional light-trap were three fluorescent lamps (F-33 type, 40 W).
Their length was 120 cm, and they were above one another. Járfás published
the catch of different levels of several species, but he did not examine the
causes of differences (Járfás, 1979).
It was shown in a latter study (Bürgés et al., 2003) the specimen
number of migrant moths is highest just at full moon in low trap, so their flight
activity is high during this time. Bürgés (1997) published separately the
Macrolepidoptera catch for each family using the data in lower and higher trap
at Rezi. Most of species were caught in both traps, but the higher caught more
number of insect as the lower one. The exception was only in case of
Geometridae and Notodontidae families. Herczig and Bürgés (1981)
operated two light-traps in a closed stand of chestnut and oak in the vicinity
of the village of Rezi, in the mountain range of Keszthely. Both traps were
outfitted with 125 W HGL bulbs. One of the traps was placed at a height of
2 m from ground surface, the other at a height of 10 m in the canopy of a
chestnut tree. The two traps worked at a distance of 100 m from each other.
The trap working at 10 m captivated four times as many migratory moths
than the one operating at 2 m. The trap high up also caught species not
breeding in the surroundings.
264
Materials and Methods
We could use the whole Microlepidoptera data of traps at Tarcal. We
thank for these data to Zoltán Mészáros.
Earlier József Járfás gave the fractional trap data of KecskemétKatonatelep (between 1967 and 1969) to use in our corporate studies. There
are data of fall webworm (Hyphantria cunea Drury), turnip moth (Scotia
segetum Schiff.) and European corn borer (Ostrinia nubilalis Hbn.) in it
hourly separated according to the levels (Table 1).
Table 1. The catch data of examined species at different levels of fractional
light-trap in Kecskemét between 1967 and 1969
Hyphantria cunea
Scotia segetum
Ostrinia nubilalis
Species
Drury
Schiff.
Hbn.
Levels
Number
%
Number
%
Number
%
Lower
1439
45.41
2349
41.28
394
27.94
Median
1178
37.17
2045
35.93
544
38.58
Higher
552
17.42
1297
22.79
472
33.48
Together
3169
100.00
5691
100.00
1410
100.00
Hours
875
950
702
We used the whole Macrolepidptera catch data traps at Rezi (in
1976, 1978 and 1979), but only those nights were examined when both traps
were in operation.
We used in earlier study (Nowinszky, 2003) 30 phase angle groups,
calculated 360 phase angle values of the full lunation. Now we made only
10 phase angle groups, because we had less light-trap catch data. There
were 12 phase angle in every phase angle groups in former study. Now we
had 36 ones, because we contracted three groups, but the notation was the
same so we could compare with the former results. The notation of phase
angle group with full moon (0º, or rather 360° ± 18° ) is 0. There are group
notations -3, -6, -9 and -12 from this one to new moon through the first
quarter. There are group notations 3, 6, 9 and 12 from full moon to new
moon through the last quarter. The phase angle group containing new moon
is ±15. The first moon quarter belongs to -6 group and last moon quarter
belongs to +6 one.
We took into consideration only those hourly data from Kecskemét
light-trap during the examination, which had successful catch at least one
265
trap. The number of caught specimen on each level was calculated hourly as
a percental value of the whole number of insect was caught in the three
traps. The percental data of examined species were categorized hourly and
for every level into the above mentioned phase angle groups, then they were
summarized and averaged. The catch results were very similar in median
and upper level so they were contracted and after it we made a comparison
between these results and catch in the lower trap.
We worked up according to the same method the Microlepidoptera
and Macrolepidoptera data caught by light-traps at Tarcal and Rezi. We
made the examinations using the contracted data of all species and not with
separated for each species, because of the relatively not too much catch. We
used only those data, when both traps were in operation. We assigned the
number of caught individuals to the phase angle group of that night. We
summarized the number of trapped individuals belonging to each phase
angle group. We calculated the percental rate of individual number of lower
and higher trap. We illustrated the results in the same way in all cases.
Results and Discussion
There are shown the specimen rate of fall webworm (Hyphantria cunea
Drury), turnip moth (Scotia segetum Schiff.) and European corn borer
(Ostrinia nubilalis Hbn.), caught by the lower and higher light-traps, in
Table 1, 2 and 3 connected with phases angle groups of Moon. The
percentage of individuals of Microlepidoptera species, caught in lower and
higher light-trap at Tarcal, is shown in Table 4. The percentage of
individuals of Macrolepidoptera species, caught in lower and higher lighttrap at Rezi, is shown in Table 5.
Our results, got from the data of Kecskemét light-trap, prove the
proportion of caught samples both of fall webworm (Hyphantria cunea
Drury) and turnip moth (Scotia segetum Schiff.) is the most equable at the
lower and higher levels at the time of full moon. These species fly in high
proportion to 121 and 360 cm levels during full moon, than at the time of
other moon phases. The proportion of caught specimen of European corn
borer (Ostrinia nubilalis Hbn.) is highest just at full moon time in lower and
higher levels. One reason can be insects fly in the air above 360 cm this
time, but it can be also supposed they fly in great number near the ground
level. We can not decide from these data which reason is correct.
The proportion of Microlepidoptera individuals, caught by lower and
higher light-traps at Tarcal, is the highest at new moon, but it is higher at
full moon than at first and last quarter and the proportion of caught species
number is also similar.
266
The proportion of Macrolepidoptera individuals, caught by lower
and higher traps is highest in the last quarter, the lowest in first quarter and
at full moon. The proportion of caught species shows similar but more
strikingly marked picture.
Of course the behaviour of some Microlepidoptera and
Macrolepidoptera species can differ from the results got from the
summarised data. It would be very important to put into operation lighttraps in different higher levels at some observing stations and during longer
period. It can be taken into consideration during making the plant protection
forecast if there would be a proof, the individuals of several species fly in
higher number in various heights during the time of different moon phases.
Fig. 1
Percentages of the individuals of the fall webworm moth (Hyphantria cunea Drury) at the low
and high levels of Jásfás-type light-trap in connection with the phases groups of the Moon
(Kecskemét, 1967-1969)
Percentages of the individuals caught
0,800
0,700
0,600
0,500
0,400
0,300
0,200
0,100
0,000
15
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
Phases groups of the Moon
Low
267
High
6
9
12
15
Fig. 2
Percentages of the individuals of turnip moth (Scotia segetum Schiff.) at low and high
levels of Járfás-type light-trap in connection with the phases groups of the Moon
(Kecskemét, 1967-1969)
Percentage of individuals caught
0,700
0,600
0,500
0,400
0,300
0,200
0,100
0,000
15
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
15
Phases groups of the Moon
Low
High
Fig. 3
Percentages of the individuals of European corn borer (Ostrinia nubilalis Hbn.) at the low
and high levels of Járfás-type light-trap in connection with the phases groups of the Moon
(Kecskemét, 1967-1969)
Percentages of individuals caught
0,800
0,700
0,600
0,500
0,400
0,300
0,200
0,100
0,000
15
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
Phases groups of the Moon
Low
268
High
6
9
12
15
Fig. 4
Percentages of Microlepidoptera individuals caught at low and high light-traps in conection
with the phases groups of the Moon (Tarcal, 1965-1968)
Percentages of individuals caught
0,70
0,60
0,50
0,40
0,30
0,20
0,10
0,00
15
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
15
Phases groups of the Moon
Low
High
Fig. 5.
Percentages of Macrolepidoptera individuals at low and high light-traps in connection with
the phases groups of the Moon (Rezi, 1976, 1978, 1979)
Percentages of the Macrolepidoptera
individuals
0,80
0,70
0,60
0,50
0,40
0,30
0,20
0,10
0,00
15
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
Phases groups of the Moon
Low
269
High
6
9
12
15
Refrences
Aly, M.Z.Y. (1990a): Seasonal effect of moonlight on the vertical
distribution of Paederus alfierii Koch, (Staphylinidae: Coleoptera).
Bull. Soc. Ent. Egypte. 69: 1: 1-9.
Aly, M.Z.Y. (1990b): Seasonal fluctuation and the effect of moonlight on
the flight activity of Gryllus domesticus L. (Gryllidae: Orthoptera).
Bull Fac. Sci. Assiut. Univ. 19 (2-E): 165-175.
Aly, M.Z.Y., Shafi, M.R.A. (1991): Seasonal distribution and influence of
moonlight on the flight activity of Componotus maculates
aegyptiacus Em. (Formicidae: Hymenoptera). Bull. Fac. Sci. Assiut.
Univ. 20 (1-E): 39-49.
Bürgés Gy. (1997): A fény erőssége, színe, kihelyezés magassága és a
fogott rovaranyag közötti összefüggés vizsgálata. IV. Magyar
Ökológus Kongresszus, Pécs. 43.
Bürgés Gy., Nowinszky L., Herczig B., Tóth Gy. és Puskás J. (2003): A
rovarok vertikális eloszlása. In: Nowinszky, L. [Ed.] (2003): A
Fénycsapdázás kézikönyve. Savaria University Press. pp. 193-196.
Callahan, Ph.S., Sparks, A.N., Snow, J.W., and Copeland, W.W. (1972):
Corn earworm moth: vertical distribution in nocturnal flight.
Environ. Entomol. 1: 497-503.
El-Ziady, S. (1957): A probable effect of the moonlight on the vertical
distribution of Diptera. Bull. Soc. Ent. Egypte. 41: 655-662.
Herczig B. és Bürgés Gy. (1981): Rovaretológiai megfigyelések fénycsapdák
segítségével (Lepidoptera: Macroheterocera). Növényvédelem 17 (6):
269-273.
Járfás J. (1979): Kártevő lepke-fajok előrejelzése fénycsapdákkal. Kandidátusi
értekezés. Kecskemét. 127 pp.
Nowinszky L. (2003): A Hold. In: Nowinszky L. [Ed.] (2003): A
Fénycsapdázás kézikönyve. Savaria University Press. 108-124.
Taylor, L.R. and Brown, E.S. (1972): Effects of light-trap design and
illumination on samples of moths in the Kenya highlands. Bull. Ent.
Res. 62 (1): 91-112.
Taylor, L.R.., Brown, E.S., Littlewood, S.C. (1979): The effect of size on
the height of flight of migrant moths. Bull. Ent. Res. 69: 605-609.
Vojnits, A. and Voigt, E. (1971): A comparative study of Microlepidoptera
deriving from light-traps at low and high altitudes (in Hungarian). Fol.
Ent. Hung. 24 (19): 219-228.
Williams, C.B. (1939): An analysis of four years captures of insects in a
light-trap. Part I. General survey: sex flight. Trans. Roy. Ent. Soc.
London 89: 79-132.
270
FLAYING HEIGHT OF INSECTS CONNECTED WITH MOON
PHASES USED THE LIGHT-TRAP CATCH DATA
L. Nowinszky1, Gy. Bürgés2, B. Herczig3 and J. Puskás1
1
Berzsenyi Dániel College, Szombathely, Hungary
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, Keszthely, Hungary
3
Komárom County Plant Protection Service, Tata, Hungary
2
Summary
Great many researchers have been studying the question of the height at which insect’s fly.
A clarification of the issue from the point of view of plant protection prognosis assumes
special significance if there is sufficient evidence to prove that the height of flight is
affected by the phases of the Moon. We analysed light-trap data on Macrolepidoptera and
Microlepidoptera species from three locations (Kecskemét, Tarcal and Rezi) in order to
study the connection between moon phases and insect flight.
The effect of moon phases on the flying-height of studied taxa was proved. Of
course the behaviour of some Microlepidoptera and Macrolepidoptera species can differ
from the results got from the summarised data. It would be very important to put into
operation light-traps in different higher levels at some observing stations and during longer
period. It can be taken into consideration during making the plant protection forecast if
there would be a proof, the individuals of several species fly in higher number in various
heights during the time of different moon phases.
271
ROLE OF HEDGES IN PLANT PROTECTION
Péter Szarvas – András Bozsik
University of Debrecen, Centre of Agricultural Sciences, Faculty of
Agronomy, Department of Crop Protection, Debrecen, Hungary
The present agricultural practise is not sustainable and not efficient. It needs
too much energy and material – as chemicals. It increases the environmental
pollution and load; damages the soil, the living being – especially the
benefitial organisms which consume pests.
Working out a sustainable, long term process the hedges can be used well.
They give shelter to the pest’s natural enemies and they have a windbreak
function, they help the plants to keep humidity. The used chemicals can be
cut. The environmental pollution can be reduced. The biotop-nets give
migration way for plants and animals, and they develope the area’s
diversity.
In this work we examine the weight of grain to show the impact of hedges
on yield of winter wheat.
272
INVESTIGATION ON THE EARLY COMPETITION
BETWEEN YELLOW NUTSEDGE (CYPERUS
ESCULENTUS L.) AND MAIZE
Kamilla Buzsáki – Imre Béres
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Institute for
Plant Protection Keszthely, Hungary
Yellow nutsedge (Cyperus esculentus) is a cosmopolitan, tropical,
subtropical plant. On the basis of Ujvárosi life-form it is a G2 perennial
plant, overwintering with tubers in the soil. Because of its rapid spreading
by its extensive tuber- and seed production, yellow nutsedge is a strong
competitor of the cultivated plants by causing severe yield losses. It causes
severe yield losses of hoed crops. The importance of yellow nutsedge is
characterized by the fact, that it was considered to be the 16th most
important weed in the world in 1970. On the basis of EPPO IAS Panel at
present this weed species is considered as one of the most harmful plant
invaders of the world, due to its severe economic injury. It occurs in every
continents.
Yellow nutsedge origins from the subtropical districts of North-Africa. It
belongs to the Cyperaceae plant family. Botanists separate its cultivated
type (Cyperus esculentus L. var. sativus (Boeck) from its four weedy
variations. The occurrence of the weed variations are: Cyperus esculentus L.
var esculentus in Southern Europe, Asia, and Northern America, Cyperus
esculentus L. var leptostachyus (Boeck.) in Western Europe, North- and
South-America, Cyperus esculentus L. var. heermanni (Kükenth.) and var.
macrostachyus (Boeck.) in the United States and in the Netherlands (Dancza
1994).
The weedy variations are serious plant invaders in Europe, causing
considerable damages in Europe only from the early 1970’s. Their
identification and investigation of its spreading is in progress from the early
1990’s. Spontaneous occurrence of the weedy form of yellow nutsedge
(Cyperus esculentus L. var. leptostachyus) were observed at first time by
István Dancza in Hungary in August 1993 in the vicinity of KeszthelyHévíz in maize crop on calcareous moor soil.
At present it occurs in four regions of Hungary, on the confines of 20
habitations. Somogy county is the most infected area, where it occurs on
10000 hectares. On 2500-3000 ha a constant control of this weed is now
necessary.
273
Cyperus esculentus can be especially harmful in the spring sown thin-type
root crops, mainly of maize, sunflower, potato and sugarbeets (Dancza et al.
2005).
According to Hunyadi and Almádi (1981) the most important interference
between weeds and maize is the competition. The competition is an effort of
two or more individuals to acquire the same factor in the same time.
Competition can take place between different species (interspecific
competition), within the species (intraspecific competition), between
genotypes (intergenotypic competition) and within the genotype
(intragenotypic competition). The maize plant, like any other plants, is
sensitive to compete with weeds in its young phenological stage (Hunyadi et
al., 2000). The aim of our investigation was to collect data on competition
between maize and yellow nutsedge.
Materials and Methods
In the trials we used the substitution method. In these tests the two plant
species are sown together, mixed in different rates, while the density of the
mix is always the same. By this the behavior of a clean cropped species can
be compared with the differently weed-mixed crops, and the mutual
agressivity can be measured. Moreover the interspecific, and the
intraspecific competition can be also observed.
Maize and yellow nutsedge were sown in different rate. The mutual effects
on their growing patterns in the first 4 weeks were observed. Since we
watered the plants, competition for the light and nutrient could be observed.
We also tested the competition between the shoot and roots.
A pot trial in four replications was conducted in a glasshouse, June 2006.
The pots were filled with 1 kg sandy loam, with a humus-content of 1,5 %,
collected from a field of Sávoly. In each of the pots 5 seeds or tuberlets
were sown and planted in different combinations (Table 1). Since the
germination rate of maize was 95 %, one more seed were sown in every pot,
and later on thinned to the planned plant number. The tuberlets of the
yellow nutsedge were presprouted, because the sprouting rate of the tubers
was not known. The tuberlets of yellow nutsedge were collected from a field
of Somogytúr, cleaned, and presprouted in petridishes on wet filter paper
before planting. The plants were grown for four weeks in the pots, every day
watered, as they needed, and once a week according to their weight. After
four weeks, when maize plants were at 5-6 leaves stage, the plants were
harvested, leaf number, the shoot length, root length, fresh weight and dry
weight of the plant shoot, and separately also of the roots were measured.
274
The maize cultivar was a hybrid KWS 328, a new cultivar, ripening when
the plant is still green. It has a good stress tolerance and a good resistance to
lodging. Date of release: 2003.
Table 1. The treatments and their designations were as follows (these
designations are used also in the diagrams)
Treatments (plant numbers in the plots)
Designations
5 maize (control)
5M
5 yellow nutsedge (control)
5Y
4 maize and 1 yellow nutsedge
4M+1Y
3 maize and 2 yellow nutsedge
3M+2Y
2 maize and 3 yellow nutsedge
2M+3Y
1 maize and 4 yellow nutsedge
1M+4Y
Results
Shoot length
Range of shoot length of maize was between 67 cm and 87 cm. Values of
the treatments were significantly higher than that of the check plants (5
maize). Range of shoot length of yellow nutsedge was between 28 cm and
32 cm. Values were similar to that of the check plants (5 yellow nutsedge),
there were no significant differences. The maize plants reacted with a higher
shoot length to the increasing number of yellow nutsedge, suggesting the
strong competition for light (Figure 1).
Shoot length cm/plant
100,00
87,75
81,12
80,58
79,88
80,00
67,16
60,00
maize
yellow nutsedge
40,00
29,63
30,56
28,19
32,40
29,61
20,00
0,00
5M
5Y
4M-1Y
3M-2Y
2M-3Y
1M-4Y
SzD5%M=9,52
SzD5%Y=8,38
Figure1. Changes of sprout lengths as an effect of plant combinations
Leaf numbers
The leaf number of the maize plants at harvest of the trial was 5-6. Leaf
number of the treatment 4maize+1yellow nutsedge and 3maize+2yellow
nutsedge was lower than that of the control plants (5 maize), while in the
275
treatment 2maize+3yellow nutsedge and 1maize+4yellow nutsedge it was
higher, in the latter case it was significantly higher. Average leaf number of
yellow nutsedge was also about 5, treatments caused no significant
difference from the controls (5 yellow nutsedge). Higher values could be
observed only at the treatment of 2maize+3yellow nutsedge. Leaf numbers
of yellow nutsedge in the treatments 4maize+1yellow nutsedge,
3maize+2yellow nutsedge and 2maize+3yellow nutsedge were higher than
that of maize, but in the treatment 1maize+4yellow nutsedge leaf number of
maize was higher (Figure 2).
6,20
Leaf number/plant
6,00
6,00
5,80
5,80
5,60
5,40
5,50
5,48
5,25
5,14
5,20
maize
5,37
5,28
5,18
5,15
yellow nutsedge
5,00
4,80
4,60
5M
5Y
4M-1Y
3M-2Y
2M-3Y
1M-4Y
SzD5%M=0,44
SzD5%Y=0,75
Figure 2. Changes of leaf numbers as an effect of plant combinations
Fresh weight of shoots
The fresh weight of maize shoots changed between 7,91 g and 16,25 g. As a
consequence of longer shoot with more leaves, the fresh weight of all maize
plants of the combinations exceeded the fresh weight of control maize plants
(5 maize). This increase however only at the treatment 1maize+4yellow
nutsedge was significant. The fresh weight of yellow nutsedge – similar to
the shoot length – was lower than that of the maize plants: ranged between
0,85 g and 1,23 g per plant. Only in the treatment 2maize+3yellow nutsedge
was the fresh weight higher than that of control (5 yellow nutsedge) plants.
Here there was no significant difference (Figure 3).
276
Fresh weight g/plant
18,00
16,00
14,00
12,00
10,00
8,00
6,00
4,00
2,00
0,00
16,25
maize
10,33
10,22
10,07
yellow nutsedge
7,91
0,85
0,94
1,23
0,89
4M-1Y
3M-2Y
2M-3Y
1M-4Y
1,17
5M
5Y
SzD5%M=2,99
SzD5%Y=0,44
Figure 3. Changes in fresh weights of the shoot as an effect of plant
combinations
Dry weights of shoots
The dry weight of the shoots followed the range of the fresh weights. The
dry weight of maize shoot changed between 1,06 g and 2,55 g per plant,
where the increase in the case of 1maize+4yellow nutsedge was significant.
The dry weight of yellow nutsedge shoot ranged between 0,12 g and 0,17 g
per plant. The treatments of 4maize+1yellow nutsedge and 2maize+3yellow
nutsedge were nearest to the controls (5 yellow nutsedge) in this respect.
(Figure4).
3,00
Dry weight g/plant
2,55
2,50
2,00
1,63
1,61
1,48
maize
1,50
yellow nutsedge
1,06
1,00
0,50
0,18
0,16
0,12
0,17
0,12
4M-1Y
3M-2Y
2M-3Y
1M-4Y
0,00
5M
5Y
SzD5%M=1,0
SzD5%Y=0,09
Figure 4. Changes in dry weights of the shoot as an effect of plant
combinations
Root length
The root length of maize was between 26 cm and 34 cm. The root lengths in
the treatments exceeded that of controls (5 maize), these values were
however not significant. Root length of yellow nutsedge ranged between 16
and 27 cm, those of the treatments were lower than those of control plants (5
yellow nutsedge). Root length of yellow nutsedge exceeded that of maize
only in case of the controls (Figure 5).
277
Root length cm/plant
40,00
30,00
34,25
33,25
35,00
32,01
26,49
32,25
27,94
25,00
maize
20,00
17,50
16,79
16,25
16,65
15,00
yellow nutsedge
10,00
5,00
0,00
5M
5Y
4M-1Y 3M-2Y
2M-3Y
1M-4Y
SzD5%M=9,21
SzD5%Y=4,72
Figure 5. Changes of root lengths in the trials
Root fresh weights
The root fresh weights of maize in the trial changed between 2,87 and 5,28
g/plant. Lower value than that of the control plants (5 maize) was in the
treatment 3maize+2yellow nutsedge, while treatments 4maize+1yellow
nutsedge, 2maize+3yellow nutsedge and 1maize+4yellow nutsedge
exceeded the control value, in the case of the last one it was significantly
higher. Root fresh weights of yellow nutsedge ranged between 0,17 g and
0,65 g/plant. In one treatment, 2maize+3yellow nutsedge this value was
higher than that of the control (5 yellow nutsedge), but it was not
significantly higher. In the case of other treatments the values were lower,
and in the case of 3maize+2yellow nutsedge significantly lower. The fresh
weights of yellow nutsedge roots were much lower than that of the maize
plants (Figure 6).
Root fresh weights g/plant
6,00
5,28
5,00
4,00
4,46
3,97
3,43
maize
2,87
3,00
yellow nutsedge
2,00
1,00
0,55
0,52
0,65
0,47
2M-3Y
1M-4Y
0,17
0,00
5M
5Y
4M-1Y
3M-2Y
SzD5%M=1,78
SzD5%Y=0,36
Figure 6. Changes of root fresh weights as an effect of plant combinations
Dry weights of roots
Root dry weights of maize plants ranged between 0,28 and 0,38 g/plant. The
treatments 4maize+1yellow nutsedge and 3maize+2yellow nutsedge showed
278
lower values than that of the controls (5 maize), and 2maize+3yellow
nutsedge and 1maize+4yellow nutsedge showed higher values, still all these
differences were not significant. Root dry weights of yellow nutsedge
ranged between 0,03 and 0,05 g/plant. Similar to root fresh weight, plants of
2maize+3yellow nutsedge treatment showed higher value than controls (5
yellow nutsedge), the other were lower. No differences were significant.
Similar to the root fresh weights, the root dry weight values of yellow
nutsedge were much lower than that of maize dry root weights (Figure 7).
0,38
Root dry weights g/plant
0,40
0,35
0,38
0,33
0,29
0,28
0,30
0,25
maize
0,20
yellow nutsedge
0,15
0,10
0,04
0,05
0,04
0,03
4M-1Y
3M-2Y
0,05
0,04
2M-3Y
1M-4Y
0,00
5M
5Y
SzD5%M=0,13
SzD5%Y=0,02
Figure 7. Changes of root dry weights as an effect of plant combinations
Conclusions
It can be stated, that the cultivated plant could successfully compete with the
weed. The maize reacted with a vigorous shoot- and root growing to the
presence of higher weed density. The growing values of the maize plants in
the maize-nutsedge combinations definitely exceeded the growing values of
the control plants (5 maize) in all the tested parameters, like shoot length,
shoot and root fresh weight, shoot and root dry weight. The values of shoot
length, leaf number, shoot fresh and dry weight, and root fresh weight were
significantly higher. The intraspecific competition was stronger in the case
of the maize plants, since the maize plants showed lower values alone, than
in the mixtures.
In the case of the yellow nutsedge the measured values were near to that of
the controls (5 yellow nutsedge). Higher values were observed in the
treatment 4maize+1yellow nutsedge for shoot length, and in the treatment
2maize+3yellow nutsedge for shoot length, leaf number, shoot fresh weight,
fresh and dry root weight. The root length and root fresh weight of the
nutsedge significantly decreased in the combinations. In the case of the
yellow nutsedge the interspecific competition proved to be stronger.
References
279
Dancza I. (1994): A mandulapalka (Cyperus esculentus L.) előfordulása
Keszthely-Hévíz határában, Növényvédelem 30: 10.
Dancza I., Hoffmanné P. Zs. és Doma Cs (2005): Mandulapalka (Cyperus
esculentus) in: Benécsné B.G. et al.: Veszélyes 48. Mezőföld
Agrofórum Kft., Szekszárd
Hunyadi K. és Almádi L. (1981): Szántóföldi gyomfajok csíranövényei és
herbicidérzékenységük. Mezőgazdasági Kiadó, Budapest. 154-171.
Hunyadi K., Béres I. és Kazinczi G. (2000): Gyomnövények, gyomirtás,
gyombiológia, Mezőgazda Kiadó, Budapest
INVESTIGATION ON THE EARLY COMPETITION BETWEEN
YELLOW NUTSEDGE (CYPERUS ESCULENTUS L.) AND MAIZE
K. Buzsáki and I. Béres
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Institute for Plant
Protection Keszthely, Hungary
Summary
The yellow nutsedge is a tuber bearing perennial weed plant. It spreads quickly by its huge
amount of seeds and tuberlets, and may present a big concurrence to the cultivated plants,
causing yield and quality damages. It occurs mainly in root crops.
We investigated, that maize and yellow nutsedge sown in different rate, what like mutual
effect have on the growing patterns in the first 4 weeks. A pot trial in four replications was
conducted in a glasshouse. In each of the pots 5 seeds or tuberlets were sown and planted in
different combinations. Four weeks later we counted the leaf number, and measured the
shoot length, root length, fresh weight and dry weight of the plant shoot, and separately also
of the roots.
Summarized it can be stated, that the cultivated plant could succesfully compete with the
weed. The maize reacted with a vigorous shoot- and root growing to the presence of higher
weed density. The growing values of the maize plants in the maize-nutsedge combinations
definitely exceeded the growing values of the control plants (5 maize) in all the tested
parameters, like shoot length, shoot and root fresh weight, shoot and root dry weight. The
intraspecific competition was stronger in the case of the maize plants, since the maize
plants showed lower values in clean crop, than in the mixed treatments.
In the case of the yellow nutsedge the measured values were near to that of the controls (5
yellow nutsedge). Only the root length and root fresh weight of the nutsedge were
significantly lower in the combinations. In the case of the yellow nutsedge the interspecific
competition proved to be stronger.
280
AMBROSIA ARTEMISIIFOLIA AND IVA XANTHIFOLIA
SPREAD AND DISTRIBUTION IN VOJVODINA
REGION
B. Konstantinovic – M. Meseldzija – Bo. Konstantinovic
Faculty of Agriculture, Department for Environmental and Plant Protection, Novi
Sad, Serbia
In the last four years, due to the high influence of Ragweed pollen as
allergen to human health and working capability in the region of the City of
Novi Sad a project of its control was established. During project
accomplishment, Iva xanthifolia Nutt. presence and spread was also
confirmed. Therefore, along with Ragweed control in the phase before
flowering and it’s mapping, in the frame of the project, the same method
was established for allergenic Iva xanthifolia Nutt.
Literature
Ambrosia artemisiifola L. (Family Asteraceae), commonly called
"Ragweed" is weedy ruderal species of fast and intensive spreading. It has
been transferred from neighboring European countries into ours
(Konstantinovic, 1999). It belongs to adventive floristic elements, and it was
introduced from North and Middle America into Europe in 1800 together
with clover seed (Priszter, 1960? Hansen, 1976). In USA and Canada it is
considered to be one of the most significant weeds and its eradication is
regulated by numerous acts of low. While spreading, Ragweed began to
adapt also to open vegetation on non-agricultural land, mostly of ruderal
type, on degradated meadows. It can be found in almost all crops and
plantations. It is fast spreading and becomes cosmopolitan. Due to the wide
ecological valence it easily becomes dominant weed in different conditions.
In it's life form it is terophyte, which means that unfavourable life period
survives in the form of seed (Soó, 1970). It is thermophile species, sprouting
through all spring and summer. Emergence begins with favourable soil
temperatures and lasts until harvest. However, on ruderal sites it emerges
even until September. It fructifies abundantly with 150 000 seeds per plant
annually, thus making its control extremely difficult and expensive.
Ragweed seed can maintain germination capacity in soil for over 40 years,
which indicates extremely high reproductive potential and permanent seed
bank in soil (Levente et al., 2003).
Iva xanthifolia Nutt. (Family Asteraceae), Marsh elder, False
ragweed is annual, termophyl native Canadian weed (Scoggan, 1978).
281
Marsh elder is a robust plant of over 2m in height , highly competitive with
abundant seed production of more than 80.000 seeds/plant. During 2nd half of
19th century Marsh elder began to spread in Europe (Hejny, 1958). In 1966
the first report of Marsh elder presence in four localities of Vojvodina, near
Novi Sad was issued. During 70th years of the last century, it continued spreding
and its presence was recorded in 21 localities, predominantly along roads and
tracks (Sajinovic and Koljadzinski, 1978). Since 1990 the first reports on
Marsh elder presence were also given for arable crops. (Veljkovic, 1996.).
Marsh elder already causes problems in agricultural crops, specially in row
ones.
Materials and Methods
During vegetation period 2004 and 2005, on areas under horticultural plants
a combined evaluation of Ragweed and Marsh elder number and coverage
was accomplished by Braun-Blanquet method (1951).The most efficient and
the lowest toxical measures of chemical control of this allergentic species
were established along with use of efficient low toxicity herbicides that are
sanitary and environmentally sound, as well as mechanical control measures
by mowing.
Results
Ragweed has been found on both banks of the river Danube, near the suburbs of
Petrovaradin, Sremski Karlovci and the city of Novi Sad, as well as in Bogojevo,
Odzaci, Bac, Backa Palanka. The weed has also been spreading northwards
towards Kula, Begec and Futog of the Backa Region and toward central and
south Banat Region. During 2004.godine the studies were performed in the City
of Novi Sad, the capital of Vojvodina (Table 1) on over 90 ha of non-agricultural
land. Ragweed has been found on over 100 locations in 21 city zones. Invasive
species Iva xanthifolia Nutt. was determined at one locality in the city Zone
Salajka with 6 individuals per m2.
During 2005 about 400 ha of non-agricultural land was studied in surrounding
suburbs of Novi Sad in which Ragweed was recorded in over 200 locations
(Table 2), and Iva xanthifolia Nutt. in 23 locations.
282
Table 1. Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. number and coverage in the city of Novi Sad
City zone
2004
Liman
Detelinara
Donji Ribnjak
Kej
Novo Naselje
Mali Beograd
Avijatičarsko naselje
Industrijska zona
Sremska Kamenica
Petrovaradin
Dunavac-Ribarsko ostrvo
Stari grad
Gradsko groblje
Institut za topolarstvo-Kaćka šuma
Highway Novi Sad-Beograd
Veternik
Salajka
Mišeluk
Telep
Kamenjar
Adice
2.2
4.4
1.1
2.1
2.3
1.1
4.4
4.4
2.3
3.4
4.4
1.1
3.2
3.3
5.5
4.4
3.2
3.4
3.3
2.2
1.1
283
Table 2. Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. number and coverage in suburbs of the city of
Novi Sad
City zone
2005
Pejićevi Salaši
Čenej
Futog
Veternik
Begeč
Kisač
Stepanovićevo
Rumenka
Bukovac
Petrovaradin
Budisava
Kovilj
Šangaj
Kaćka šuma-Kaćki atar
Kać
Rafinerija
Novo Naselje
Kamenjar
Industrijska zona
Nemanovci
4.2
5.3
4.3
4.3
5.3
4.3
4.3
4.3
1.1
3.2
2.3
3.4
4.4
4.3
3.4
4.4
3.3
2.3
3.3
3.3
284
In Table 3 number and coverage of Rugweed at the territory in suburbs of the
city of Novi Sad during 2006 is presented. Iva xanthifolia presence was
recorded at 32 locations.
Table 3. Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. number and coverage in suburbs of the city of
Novi Sad
City zone
2006
Rumenka
Kisac
Stepanovicevo
Cenej
Sangaj
Begec
Pejicevi Salasi
Crossroad with a highway, approach
to Novi Sad
Kovilj
Highway / City disposal area
3.3
3.3
3.3
4.4
4.4
3.1
3.2
3.4
5.4
5.2
In last two years systematic monitoring of Rugweed occurrence has been
perfomed for the territory of the Community of Zrenjanin in which in 2005 this
species was determined and control in the area of 93 090 m2, and in 2006 in the
area of 93 750 m2.
Discussion
Weedy ruderal species Ambrosia artemisiifolia L., is wide spread in
whole Vojvodina. It often builds huge, compact communities mostly in
ruderal sites. In cooperation with the Administration of the City of Novi
Sad, Department for Municipal Business, in the frame of the project,
mapping, determination of number and coverage, as well as control of the
allergenic species Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. and Iva xanthifolia Nutt. in the
city of Novi Sad and it’s suburbs. Occurrence of new generations, i.e.,
monitoring of this species, as well as retro vegetation which is more
frequent after mowing on rough terrains were permanently recorded.
During vegetation period, these allergenic species have been controlled by
repeated mowing, while in ruderal sites inconvenient for mowing such as
road and railway sides and non-agricultural land in suburbs were sprayed by
herbicides based on glyphosate in the quantity of 4 l ha-1. Two years of A.
artemisiifolia L. monitoring and control resulted in significant reduction in
285
its number. As Ragweed and Marsh elder are weedy ruderal species that
also spread in the nearest surrounding of the city on agricultural land under
crops, it is necessary to suppress it to fructification. Recommended cultural
practices for its control include harrowing in the phase of emergence,
keeping crops free of weeds and mowing in non-agricultural land.
Depending upon crop variety various herbicides may also be applied. In
regard to previous year, in 2005 monitoring of Ragweed pollen quantity in
the air showed reduced pollen quantity per 1m3. The average number of
pollen grains was 143 per m3, while in 2003 it was 657 grains per m3. In
some localities presence of newly introduced ruderal species in our country
Iva xanthifolia Nutt., was also been determined and monitored. Danger of
this species is perceived in strong concurence, huge seed production, and in
immense allergic features.
Application of combined mechanical and chemical control measures
in the area of the city of Novi Sad and it's suburbs led to reduction of
Ambrosia artemisiifolia L.and Iva xanthifolia Nutt. species. However,
problem of this invasive species spreading is not permanently solved, for
remaining non-agricultural and agricultural land in Vojvodina represents
constant seed bank that endangers the city and its surronding. Due to this,
Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. and Iva xanthifolia Nutt. are necessary to be
controled in soybean, sugarbeet, maize and sunflower crops by application
of contact herbicides. On non-agricultural land they should be controled by
mechanical measures such as mowing or by chemical control.
References
Braun-Blanquet, J. (1951): Pflanzensoziologie. Wien.
Hansen, A. (1976): Ambrosia L. in Tutin, T.G. et al. ed. Flora Europaea,
4.142-143. Cambridge University press. Cambridge.
Hejny, S.(1958): Iva xanthifolia Nutt. v CSR. Acta Fac. Nat. Rerum
Univ.Comenianae, Botanica, Pracha 2 (7-9): 323-342.
Hirst, J.M. (1952): An automatic volumetric spore trap.Ann.App.Biol.39:
257-265.
Konstantinovic, B. (1999): Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. (A.elatior). Biljni
lekar. 4. 370-372. Poljoprivredni fakultet, Novi Sad.
Kiss L., Vajna L.,és Bohár Gy. (2003): A parlagfű (Ambrosia artemisiifolia
L.) elleni biológiai védekezés lehetőségei. Növényvédelem, 39: 319331.
Priszter Sz. (1960): Adventív gyomnövényeink terjedése. A Keszthelyi
Mezőgazdasagi Akadémia Kiadványai. Mezőgazdasági Kiadó,
Budapest
286
Sajinovic, B., Koljadzinski, B. (1978): Prilog proucavanju procesa
naturaliyacije adventivnih biljnih vrsta Ambrosia artemisiifolia L.
1753. i Iva xantifolia Nutt. 1818 (Asteraceae) u Vojvodini.
Biosistematika 14 1 (81/92).
Scoggan, H.J. (1978): The flora of Canada Natural Museum Nat. Cci
(Ottawa) Publ. Bot. 7 (1)/7 (4): 1711.
Soó R. (1970): A magyar flóra és vegetáció rendszertani növényföldrajzi
kézikönyve, IV. Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest.
Veljkovic, B. (1996): Rasprostranjenost novounesenih korovskih vrsta
Ambrosia artemisiifolia L. i Iva xanthifolia Nutt. u Jugoslaviji.
Ybornik radova Petog kongresa o korovima 351-363.
AMBROSIA ARTEMISIIFOLIA AND IVA XANTHIFOLIA SPREAD
AND DISTRIBUTION IN VOJVODINA REGION
B. Konstantinovic, M. Meseldzija and Bo. Konstantinovic
Faculty of Agriculture, Department for Environmental and Plant Protection, Novi Sad, Serbia
Summary
During last years, relatively reduced crop rotation, shallow tillage, inadequate pre-sowing
cultivation and use of the same or identical herbicide groups enabled spread and domination
of the weed species Ambrosia artemissifolia L., Iva xanthifolia Nutt. and Xanthium
strumarium L. In last years Iva xanthifolia Nutt., newly introduced weed species in our
country, represents great problems especially in row crops. From the aspect of the human
health this species is very dangerous, for it is, like the species Ambrosia arthemisiifolia L.
particularly allergenic. It is naturalized in central-east and south-east Europe and France,
and in other regions it is of sporadic occurrence. In 1800, Ambrosia artemisiifolia L.,
ruderal weed species of fast and intensive spread that belongs to adventive floristic element
was introduced to Europe from North and Middle America. While spreading, it began to
adapt to open vegetation on mostly of ruderal or weed type terrains. Now it invades natural
vegetation of semi-closed type, such as degraded meadows. It weeds almost all crops and
plantations it is fast spreading and becomes cosmopolitan. In our country it has been
determined in greater number of localities.
287
STUDY OF WEED SPECIES ECHINOCHLOA CRUSGALLI L. CROSS-RESISTANCE
B. Konstantinovic1 – M. Meseldzija1 – D. Sunjka2
1
Faculty of Agriculture, Department for Environmental and Plant Protection, Novi
Sad, Serbia
2
Scholar of the Ministry of Science and Environmental Protection of the
Republic of Serbia, Beograd, Serbia
Herbicide resistance is acquired plant ability to survive herbicide
rate that is normally lethal for wild biotypes and to continue reproduction.
The most important factor that causes evolution of herbicide resistant weed
species is selection pressure of the applied herbicide (Jasieniuk et al., 1996).
This pressure is increased by use of higher herbicide rates, high efficiency
and/or persistency and in cases in which there is no rotation of herbicides
with different mode of action (Shaner, 1995). Expansion of use of
herbicides based on ALS inhibitors caused resistance development and new
problem in weed control. Until 1993 number of confirmed ALS resistant
cases was 14, and in 1999 it numbered even 58 cases (Heap, 1999). Today
in the world 310 resistant biotypes of 183 weed species of which even
almost 95 are ALS resistant ones have been determined. (HRAC, 2006).
Cross resistance, incidence of which lately has become more frequent
represents resistance to more herbicides of the identical action mechanism.
Extremely high number of cases has been determined for chemical family of
sulfonylureas.
Results of biological studies of weed resistance to herbicide exclude
use of inefficient herbicides, which reduces expenses in agricultural
production and prevents spread of resistant biotypes.
Literature
Since the beginning of ALS inhibitors use in 1982, they represent
one of the most significant herbicide classes. Low quantity of use, wide
spectrum of weeds that they control, flexible application time and low
toxicity contributed to fast acceptance of these herbicides. Today there are
even five, structurally different chemical classes of ALS inhibitors:
imidazolinones, sulfonylureas, triazolopyrimidines, pyrimidinylthiobenzoates and sulfonylaminocarbonyltriazolinones (Tranes and Wright,
2002) of which imidazolinones and sufonylureas are of the widest use.
Primary action site of these herbicides is the enzyme of acetolactate
288
synthesis that is responsible for synthesis of amino acids valine, leucine and
isoleucine (Babczinski, 2002). Due to their continuous use in subsequent
years, the greatest disadvantage of this herbicide group is extremely fast
development of resistant biotypes (Duran-Prado et al., 2004).
The primary action site of cross-resistance is between sufonylureas
and triazolopirimidines is mutation at Proline197 (Saari et al., 1990).
However, primary action site of cross-resistance effect between
imidazolinones and sufonylureas is more difficult to find out, for it is based
on multiple mutation sites (Foes et al., 1999). Occurrence of cross-resistance
to ALS inhibitors in weed species Echinochloa crus-galli L. has not yet
been determined (HRAC, 2006); while in 1988 cross-resistance was
established for biotype Datura innoxia to imidazolinones and sufonylureas.
(Saxena and King, 1988).
The aim of these studies was to identify resistance of Echinochloa
crus-galli L. biotypes from different localities in Vojvodina to
imidazolinones and assessment of the existing cross-resistance to
sufonylureas.
Materials and Methods
For resistance studies to herbicides, seed of Echinochloa crus-galli
L. was collected from various localities in Vojvodina (localities A, B and
C). Susceptible referent population was collected from untreated sites (SS –
susceptible standard). Resistance study to imidazolinones (herbicide
imazethapyr) and sufonylureas (herbicide nicosufluron) was performed by
application of two methods, Petri dish bioassays (Clay and Underwood,
1990) and by whole plant studies (Moss, 1995). Herbicides were applied in
the range of rates: 0.04; 0.08; 0.10; 0.15; 0.20; and 0.40 kg a.i imazethapyr/l
and 40; 50; 80; 120; 160 and 240 g a.i. nicosufuron/l; control remained
untreated. Resistance level determination was performed upon resistance
index (IR) which is calculated according to the following formula:
IR = ED50R/ ED50SS
R – Resistant population
SS – susceptible population
where ED50 is for the rate that causes reduction of the measured parameter
for 50% in regard to untreated control (Moss et al., 1998). IRs’ are
presented for all morphological parameters, such as epicotyls and
hypocotyls shoots length, stem height, foliage fresh weight. Resistance level
was determined also upon reduction of foliage fresh weight by scale
according to Moss et al. (1999) (Table 1).
289
Table 1. Scale of susceptibility level (Moss et al., 1999)
susceptibility
level
S
1*
susceptibility to the applied herbicide
early indication of resistance, possibility of reduction in
herbicide action
confirmed resistance, possibility of reduction in
herbicide action
confirmed resistance, slight possibility of poor herbicide
action
2*/3*
4*/5*
Statistical processing of the measured parameters values was
performed by variance analysis (ANOVA) and significance difference was
evaluated by t-test (Hadzivukovic, 1991). Results of the measured
parameters are presented graphically and in tables.
Results
In Figures 1 and 2 shoots epicotyl’s lengths of Echinochloa crusgalli L. are given at series of imazethapyr and nicosufluron rates, whereas
on Figures 3 and 4 are presented shoots hypocotyls lengths from the studied
localities.
45
A
epycotil lenght (mm)
40
35
B
30
25
C
20
15
10
SS
5
0
0
0,04
0,08
0,1
0,15
0,2
0,4
kg a.m.imazethapyr/l
Figure 1. Epicotyl’s length of Echinochloa crus-galli L. shoots given at
series imazethapyr rates
290
40
A
epycotil length (mm
35
30
B
25
20
C
15
SS
10
5
0
0
40
50
80
120
160
240
g a.m.nicosulfuron/l
Figure 2. Epicotyl’s length of Echinochloa crus-galli L. shoots given at
series nicosufluron rates
hypocotyl lenght (mm)
30
A
25
B
20
C
15
S
S
10
5
0
0
0.04
0.08
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.4
kg a.m.imazethapyr/l
Figure 3. Hypocotyls length of Echinochloa crus-galli L. shoots given at
series imazethapyr rates
291
hypocotyl lenght (mm)
25
A
20
B
15
C
10
SS
5
0
0
40
50
80
120
160
240
g a.m.nicosulfuron/l
Figure 4. Hypocotyls length of Echinochloa crus-galli L. shoots given at
series nicosufluron rates
Stem height of Echinochloa crus-galli L. plants was measured at
various rates of the applied herbicides (Figures 5 and 6).
45
stem height (mm)
40
A
35
30
B
25
C
20
15
SS
10
5
0
0
0.04
0.08
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.4
kg a.m. imazethapyr/l
Figure 5. Stem height of Echinochloa crus-galli L. plants at series
imazethapyr rates
292
stem height (mm)
80
70
A
60
B
50
40
C
30
20
SS
10
0
0
40
50
80
120
160
240
g a.m.nicosulfuron/l
Figure 6. Stem height of Echinochloa crus-galli L. plants at series
nicosufluron rates
Resistance level based upon fresh foliage weight was measured
according to scale by Moss et al. (1999) that implies several possible
resistance levels of the studied population - 1*, 2*, 3*, 4* and 5* (Table 2).
Table 2. Resistance level of the studied Echinochloa crus-galli L. biotypes
according to the scale by Moss
Biotype
A
B
C
Resistance level
imazethapyr
4*
4*
3*
Resistance level
nicosufluron
5*
2*
4*
Resistance of Echinochloa crus-galli L. biotypes to herbicides
imazethapyr and nicosufluron is presented by resistance index (Tables 3 and
4).
293
Table 3. Resistance index to herbicide imazethapyr of the studied
Echinochloa crus-galli L. biotypes
Biotype
Epicotyl
A
B
C
1.72
1.27
1.05
IR
Hypocotyl
Stem height
1.90
1.65
1.5
1.38
1.27
1.19
Foliage fresh
weight
1.42
1.33
1.25
Table 4. Resistance index to herbicide nicosufluron of the studied
Echinochloa crus-galli L. biotypes
Biotype
A
B
C
Epicotyl
Hypocotyl
∞
0.0
∞
∞
0.0
∞
IR
Stem height
1.31
0.80
1.05
Foliage fresh
weight
1.59
0.62
1.41
Statistically significant differences (p<0,05) between biotypes from
all studied localities and biotype used as susceptible standard were
determined by analysis of imazethapyr effect to morphological parameters
of the species Echinochloa crus-galli L. (t test), and values of the studied
parameters from localities A and C were perfomed by analysis of
nicosulfuron effect to morphological parameters.
The lowest percentage of germinated seed was established for
biotype Echinochloa crus-galli L. from locality B, after treatment by
herbicides imazethapyr and nicosulfuron (Figures 1 and 2). Biotypes from
localities A and C germination capability after both of the applied herbicides
had values 75-100%. Good development of shoots after imazethapir
treatment was determined for all biotypes from all studied localities, while
after nicosulfuron treatment biotypes from localities A and C were well
developed and had the highest values for epycotil and hypocotyl lenghts.
Significantly heigher persentage of emerged plants of biotypes from
localities A and C was determined after nicosulfuron treatment, while
emergence of plant biotypes from locality B afther both of the applied
herbicides had low values. Resistance to the herbicide imazethapyr of
biotype Echinochloa crus-galli L. from the studied localities was confirmed
by values for stem height, while nicosulfuron resistance was d determined
by measurement of the same parameter for biotypes from localities A and C.
294
There was no decay of plants from these localities even at nicosulfuron rates
of 240 g a.m. nicosulfuron/l, which is six times heigher from usually applied
rates.
Based upon values given in Table 2, resistance to imazethapyr was
confirmed for biotypes from localities A and B (4*), with a slight
probability that herbicide exibited poor action. Resistance for biotype from
locality C was confirmed with a probability of herbicide action reduction.
Nicosulfuron resistance, based upon fresh foliage weight was confrimed for
biotypes from localities A (5*) and C (4*). Resistance of biotype from the
locality B was confrimed, with a possibility of herbicide action reduction.
Based upon IR of all measured parameters (Table 3), the highest
resistance to the applied imazethapyr rates was determined for biotype
Echinochloa crus-galli L. from the locality A (1.38-1.90), while somewhat
lower IR values were determined for biotype from the locality B (1.27-1.67)
and C (1.05-1.25). Such IR values indicate resistance evolution to
imazethapyr of biotypes from all of the studied localities.
For biotype from the locality B (Table 4), susceptibility to the
applied nicosulfuron rates (IR=0-0.80) was determined. IR values for stem
height and fresh foliage weight of biotypes from localities A (1.31;1.59)
and C (1.05; 1.41) indicate outbreak of resistance. According to IR of these
biotypes, determined upon epycotil and hypocotyl lenghts, resistance to the
herbicide nicosulfuron was established.
By the comparative analysis of the presented results, outbreak of
resistance development to imazethapyr (imidazolinones) was determined for
biotypes of the weed species Echinochloa crus-galli L. from localities A, B
and C, and to the herbicide nicosulfuron (sulfonilureas) for biotypes from
localities A and C. Biotype of Echinocholoa crus-galli L. from locality B
remaind susceptible to the herbicide nicosulfuron.
References
Babczinski, P. (2002): Discovery of the lead structure for propoxycarbazone
-sodium (BAY MKH 6561). Pflanzenschutz-Nachrichten-Bayer, 55:
5-14.
Clay, D.V. and Underwood, C. (1990): The identification of triazine and
paraquat resistant weed biotypes and their response to other
herbicides. Importance and perspectives on herbicide resistant
weeds. Luxemburg 47-55.
Duran-Prado, M., Osuna, M.D., De Prado, R. And Frano, A.R. (2004):
Molecular basis of resistance to sulfonylureas in Papaver rhoeas.
Pesticide Biochemistry and Physisology 79: 10-17
295
Foes, M.J., Liu, L., Vigue, G., Stoller, E.W., Wax, L.M. and Tranel, P.J.
(1999): A kochia (Kochia scoparia) biotype resistant to triazine and
ALS-inhibiting herbicides. Weed Science 47: 20-27.
Hadživuković, S. (1991): Statistički metodi s primenom u poljoprivrednim i
biološkim istraživanjima. Poljoprivredni fakultet, Novi Sad
Heap,I. (1999): International Survey of Herbicide Resistant Weeds [WWW
document]. URL http://www.weedscience.org
HRAC (2006): Online. Internet. Available on www.weedscience.org
Jasieniuk, M., Brule-Babel, A.L. and Morrison, I.N. (1996): The evolution
and genetics of herbicide resistance in weeds. Weed Science, 44,
176-193.
Moss, S.R. (1995): Techiniques for determinig herbicide resistance.
Proceedings of the Brighton Crop Protection Conference-Weeds,
547-556.
Moss, S.R. et al. (1998): Screening for herbicide resistance in black-grass
(Alopecurus myosuroides): a ′ring rest′. Proceedings of the 50th
International Symposium on Crop Protection, Gent, Belgium, Part
III, 671-679.
Mos, S.R., Clarke, J.H., Blair, A.M., Culley, T.N., Read, M.A., Rayn, P.J.,
Turner, M. (1999): The occurence of herbicide resistant grass-weeds
in the United Kingdom and new system for designating resistance in
screening assay. Proceedings Brighton Crop Protection ConferenceWeeds 179-184.
Saari, L.L., Cotterman, J.C. and Primiani, M.M. (1990): Mechanism of
Sulfonylurea Herbicide Resistance in the Broadleaf Weed, Kochia
scoparia. Plant Physilogy 93: 55-61.
Saxena, P.K. and King, J. (1988): Herbicide resistance in Datura innoxia. Crossresistance of sulfonylurea resistant cell lines to imidazolinones. Plant
Physiology 86: 863-867.
Shaner, D.L. (1995): Studies on mechanisms and genetics of resistance:
their contribution to herbicide resistance management. Brighton
Crop Protection Conference-Weeds 537-545.
Tranel, P.J. and Wright, T.R. (2002): Resistance of weeds to ALS-inhibiting
herbicides: What have we learned? Weed Science 50: 700-712.
296
STUDY OF WEED SPECIES ECHINOCHLOA CRUS-GALLI L.
CROSS-RESISTANCE
B. Konstantinovic1, M. Meseldzija1 and D. Sunjka2
1
Faculty of Agriculture, Department for Environmental and Plant Protection, Novi Sad, Serbia
2
Scholar of the Ministry of Science and Environmental Protection of the Republic of
Serbia, Beograd, Serbia
Summary
Long lasting use of the herbicide or herbicides with the identical action mechanisms causes
selection of resistant and elimination of the susceptible biotypes of different weed species.
During 2005 and 2006 weed species Echinocloa crus-galli L. resistance was studied to
ALS inhibitors. Seed of the studied weed species were collected from different sites of
Vojvodina with a long history of ALS inhibitor’s use. Population from ruderal site was
used as a susceptible standard. Study was performed according to Clay and Underwood
(1990) and Moss (1995) method. Resistance level was determined by resistance index for
morphological parameters such as epicotyls and hypocotyls length, stem height, foliage
fresh weight.
Initial development of imazethapyr resistance (imidazolinones) was determined for
biotypes of the weed species Echinochloa crus-galli L. from locality Kamendin (A), Bac
(B) and Kozarica (C) by comparative analysis of the obtained data. Biotype of Echinochloa
crus-galli L. from locality B remained susceptible to the herbicide nicosufluron.
297
POSSIBILITIES OF INTEGRATED WEED CONTROL
AGAINST JOHNSON-GRASS (SORGHUM HALEPENSE
/L./ PERS.)
Veronika Tóth – Éva Lehoczky
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Institut of
Plant Protection, Department of Herbology and Pesticides, Keszthely,
Hungary
The Johnson-grass (Sorghum halepense /L./ Pers.) is a perennial
monocotyledon. Its gen centre is in the Near East. Botanically this weed
belongs to the monocotyledone class, Poaceae (Gramineae) family and
within this, together with the maize to the Andropogonoideaei subfamily
(Simon, 2000).
Pál Kitaibel mentioned its occurrence as early as 1800. Though it was
present in the first decades of the 20 century, it was not an important weed.
It was living mainly on ruderal areas, and on the arable fields only thread by
thread. Its importance later on represented by its order in the weed survey
lists made in the previous century. At the time of the First National Weed
Survey (1947 – 1953) it has not been found in Hungary. In the periods of
the 2nd (1969 – 1971), 3rd (1987 – 1988) and 4th Survey it occupied the
94th, 18th and 10th place of importance, respectively (Tóth and Spilák,
1998). Because of its rapid multiplication and spreading after the second
weed survey (1969-1971) and because of its very complicated and difficult
control, the Plant Protection Division of our Ministry of Agriculture ranged
it in 1974 into the category of „Dangerous weed” (Hunyadi et al., 1994).
Damages by this weed was observable from the first part of the 20th century
on. Still, Miklós Újvárosi, a weed scientist did not think the weed will
propagate in Hungary. He supposed, the cold winters and hard frosts will
hinder its spreading. Újvárosi (1973) as written in his book „Weeds, weed
control” (Gyomnövények, gyomirtás) considered it to be only a ruderal
weed, and mentioned its frost sensitivity as a natural hindrance of its
distribution. Results of later biological findings however disproved this
meaning. But the book edited by Hunyady (Szántóföldi gyomnövények és
biológiájuk, 1988) on weeds and their biology on arable fields, states, that
„according to present research results frost tolerance of the overwintering
rhizomes is good”. This statement has been proved later on by the rapid
spreading of Johnson-grass from the middle of the 1960s.
The big farm sizes played a role in the spreading of this weed, since the
tilling and harvest machines spreaded its seeds on the large fields during a
relatively short period. As another important factor can be mentioned
298
onesided using of atrazin, which do not kill Johnson-grass, but suppresses
broadleaves weeds, which could prevent development of Johnson-grass by
shading and occupation of the place. Deeper pluggings also helped the
overwintering of the root-stocks (Hunyadi et al., 2005). Up to the present it
became obvious, that if this weed settled, practically it is impossible to
destroy its rooot and branches. Using present herbicides one can restraint
the damages on the infected fields, or keep it on an economically acceptable
level. Still, we have to live together with it.
According to experts the main causes of its fast distribution in Hungary are:
- the relatively mild winters of the last decades,
- introduction of its seeds by seeds and machines,
- the relatively deep ploughings in the big farms, cooperatives,
- frequent using of atrazine,
- the allelopatical character of the plant,
- its apical dominance,
- since it can propagate themselves both from seeds and rhizomes,
the double protection against it can not be made easily.
The protection against this weed is significally hindered by the fact, that in
his propagation both rhizomes and seeds play nearly the same importance.
The life cycles of the plants are very similar in both types of propagation,
though on the fields the propagation by rhizomes mostly precedes that of
from seeds, since the growing of sprouts is faster from the rhizomes. Three
weeks after emergence starts tillering and growing of lateral shoots. The
intensive rhizome formation takes place during the flowering, lasting from
the 7th week of the life cycle up to the end of the vegetation (Hunyadi et al.,
1994). A plant may produce cca 80.000 seeds. Its seed yield may be as
much as 900 kg/ha (Mc Whorter, 1973). The seeds have a primary
dormancy. The seed viability in soil lasts for 3 – 6 years. The plants
emerging from seeds start to initiate rhizomes just three weeks later, it
means that only a short time they need to achieve their perennial character
(Kovács, 2002). The spreading of this weed takes place mainly by seeds.
The stability and agressivity of the plant following its settlement will be
ensured by its rhizomes growing in the 5 – 20 cm depth of the cultivated soil
layer. It has an unbelievable ability to propagate, since the amount of
rhizome may be 7 – 9 metric tons per hectares (Szabó, 1972). Growing of
rhizomes is intensive during the flowering. 90 % of the finger-thick rhizome
mass are placed in the upper 15 – 20 cm soil layer (Hunyady et al., 1979).
The Johnson-grass decreases yields of the cultivated plants mainly through
the direct concurrence (Takács, 1973), and at the same time it may be host
of virus diseases, like maize dwarf virus /MCDV/, (Thorneberry, 1966),
sugarcane mosaik virus /SMMV/, (Arceneaux, 1967), potato virus Y /PVY/.
299
The most effective way of protection is the prevention of its introduction.
The only chance to do it is the knowledge and keeping all elements of field
hygiene. Among them is important the cleaning of all machines, implements
used on an infested field. The introduction by seeds can be avoided by using
controlled pure seeds of the cultivated plant. However if it appeared, it has
to be killed immediately, since the effectivity of the control in case of seeds
is much better, then in case of settled rhyzomes. This weed should be killed
by using every possible way. The protection of the cultivated plant against
this weed needs an integrated activity, using of all possibilities (Mikulás,
1979).
1. Preventive protection
The prevention is a definitive element of the integrated regulation. Its aim is
hindering of spread from uncultivated fields, hindering its introduction by
seeds, by harvest wastes, machines, by stable manure, implements.
1.1. Biological protection
Presently it has a small role in the protection, but for a long term by making
perfect the methods, using of this method may come into the foreground.
For this purpose a species-specific powdery smut were used in form of
suspension sprayed onto the stubble. This infected systematically the
Johnson-grass, making it dwarf. After a two-years application the Johnsongrass lost its competition ability and agressivity (Quimly, 1982). Mikulás
determined applicability of the of the microorganism Pseudomonas syringae
var. syringae on Johnson-grass, and this method has been admitted into the
possible biologic al methods. The use this method in the practice, still needs
further investigations. Application of allelopathia for plant protection would
be possible, if this phenomenon would exist in the wild form of the
cultivated plant, and this could be introduced into cultivated forms, modern
varieties. It was supposed earlier, that all the cultivated species have had
their allelopathy, but this character has been lost during their breeding
(Walker, 1982).
1.2. Defoliation
Consecutive defoliations of the Johnson-grass from rhyzome (e.g. with
diquat-dibromid) is impracticable, that is why this method can be used
succesfully only on emerging plantlets (Mikulás, 1976).
2. Agrotechnical methods
2.1. Mechanical protection
This method is not effective for itself, it will complete the other protecting
methods. It can be made by mowing on ruderal areas, or by mechanical soil
preparation on arable fields and on stubble-fields. The mowing aims
300
exhausting of nutritive materials stored in the rhyzome. That is why
frequent mowing or soil preparation is necessary, since the recreated plant
able to replace exhausted nutritions within three weeks after the treatment if
regrowed the sprout. By this method the further plant propagation or its mild
suppression can be achieved in case of rhyzome originated plants. The
mowing effectively prevents the spread by seeds. The soil preparation
implements cut rhyzomes into little bits, and by this the axial buds get rid of
the hindering effect of the apex, and develop more new sprouts. By this the
nutrition consumption of the plants increases, otherwise the leaf area grows
in relation to the rhyzome amount, and by this the killing effectivity of the
later treatments increases. The plug takes rhyzomes onto the soil surface,
they will die because of drying out and by frost. The complete fallowing and
using disc-tiller and cultivator in periods of 4 – 5 weeks has a secondary
effect onto the decreasing of nutrition and water household of the Johnsongrass, since the disc-tiller cut the rhyzomes into pieces (Verma and
Bhardwaj, 1965). The advantage of the cultivator, that it lifts more rhyzome
onto the soil surface (Kádár, 1974). The methods of stifling into the soil and
exhausting is based on the theory, that disc-tillering in criss-cross will broke
rhyzomes into small pieces, which plugged down to 20 cm and ring rollered
with a heavy implement, at anaerobic environment will die. The drying out
of the rhyzomes is an important part of the control. Shorter rhyzomes in a
dry soil dry out easier than longer ones, that is why the frequent treatment is
better (Mc Whorter, 1972a). Rhyzomes of Johnson-grass will die when the
soil humidity is lower than 30 % of the absolute moisture capacity (Kiselev,
1971). Utilizing of this method depends on the wheather, since dying of the
rhyzomes presume a long dry period early spring or following the harvest,
and this is occurs seldom in Hungary.
2.2. Crop changes, crop rotation
The Sorghum halepense has high demand on light, heat and nutritions,
therefore when the cultivated plant grow faster and higher, it will give a
shadow, and the Johnson-grass will be suppressed (Újvárosi, 1970). A
proper crop rotation will decrease the damages made by moderate grass
infection. A crop rotation, which ensures a concurrence against development
of the rhyzome, will suppress the rhyzome (Kőrösmezei, 1982). The market
posibilities determines the range of cultivated plants. The presence of
Johnson-grass however restricts it: according to the degree of infestation it
decreases the number of plant species to be cultivated, and also their
economy, partly because of yield losses, or by increasing of production
costs (Kőrösmezei, 1994).
3. Physical methods of protection
301
3.1. Burning
This method is able to destroy the plant parts above the soil surface on
cultivated plant free fields. The Johnson-grass can be restricted on a stubble
by repeated burning, but nowadays this method is not recommended
because of its natural protection drawbacks.
3.2. Inundation
The effect of inundation has been investigated by Mc Whorter (1972b). He
found, that the rhyzomes did not die always even after a long-lasting
inundation.
4. Chemical methods of protection
The protection possibilities by chemicals on an infested field will be
determined basically by the cultivated plant.
4.1. Protection possibilities in case of the cultivation of a monocotyledone
plant (maize).
4.1.1. Protection of seed-borne Johnson-grass.
The risk of chemical protection at using pre- or early postemergent usable
product is, that to have an economically good effect the products need 10-20
mm precipitation following their spraying out. In the last years the choice of
chemicals to be used in maize for basic treatment became wider (with
pendimetalin, S-metolachlor, acetochlor, dimetenamid izoxaflutol) (Bihari,
2005). To investigate the effect of some preemergent usable chemicals
(pendimetalin, S-metolachlor, acetochlor, dimetenamid izoxaflutol) on
emerge of Johnson-grass the authors conducted a pot trial and a field trial in
2005 and 2006. Based on the results authors concluded, that all the four
chemicals have a good effect against seedborn plantlets of Johnson-grass
(Tóth and Lehoczky 2005, 2006). Even the modern newer active substance
containing chemicals can not fully solve the problem of Johnson-grass just
by a single treatment. In most cases – depending on the environment
circumstances – a second treatment is necessary to kill the perennial,
rhizome-born weed plants, eventually in another crop.
4.1.2.Weed control treatment in maize
The development of sulfonilurea containing products made possible the
chemical protection against weeds in maize crops. These herbicides
(nicosulphuron, rimsulphuron, tifensulphuron-metil) can be used up to the
7-8 leaves stage of the maize plants. For the effectivity of the products 1-3
leaf stage of the Johnson-grass is the best favourable, while in case of
rhizome-born their height of 12-20 cm, at this stage are they most sensitive
to the products. Extreme circumstances (temperature below 10°C or above
30°C, drought) caused stress and treatment of overdeveloped maize (8 or
more leaves) increases the danger of phytotoxicity. Late treatment causes
302
damage of the maize plants, beside that the effectivity of the treatment is
hindered also by shading of the weeds. Since the developmental stage of
seedlings and that of rhyzome differs, moreover the emergence of the same
forms may be long-lasting, we can only achieve the most proper treatment
date nearest to the right weed development stage, if we use a share treatment
(Tóth, 2006). Portitioning of adjuvants to the spray solution is necessary. If
the product does not contain also surface-active component, its completion
may not be neglected.
4.2. Treatments against rhyzomal Johnson-grass on stubble
This is the time period in which the systemic active substances quickest
translocate. The most suitable active substance to be used against the
Johnson-grass on a stubble is the gliphosate. Since it has a total effect it can
be succesfully used against all perennial mono- and dicotiledons. The using
of selective monocotiledone-killing products on stubble is economically not
favourable, and also because of other problems not recommended, and not
widely used.
4.3. Protection of Johnson-grass in dicotiledone cultures
A widely used protection practice on dicotiledone cultures is the basic
treatments with soil herbicides against Johnson-grass seedlings, followed by
a crop treatment against rhizomal plants, which herbicide however kills well
also those plantlets which escaped or survived the basic treatment.
4.3.1. Basic treatment
To kill broad-leaf weeds exists a choice of different groups of herbicides. In
the group of dinitroanilids mainly the trifluralin or benefin containig
products have good effect. After spraying out they have to be mixed in the
soil, soon after, or at the same time. These herbicides kill the emerging
seedlings. Products of this group have a short active time, therefore it is
important, to ensure favourable circumstances for emerging of mass of the
seeds (loose, fine soil structure, proper soil humidity, and higher soil
temperature). The group of imidazolines have equally good effect whether
absorbed through leaves or soils. They can be used ppi (applied before
sowing and mixed in the soil), presowing or postemerge, too. The best
results can be achieved when sprayed onto 2-3 leaves weeds (early
postemergent). Spraying their higher doses they have good effect on better
developed seedlings or even rhizomal plants, but since they need a larger
time to break down, less succeeding crops may follow their use.
4.3.2. Crop treatment
303
Johnson-grass and other rhizomal or stolony type difficult weed can be
killed easier, cheaper and more effectively in broad-leave cultures than in a
maize crop. There is a choice of special monocotiledone killer in circulation
in the last years (the ariloxi-fenoxi-propionates). The most proper time of
application is, when the Johnson-grass plants are 20-25 cm high. In this
stage the foliage is big enough to absorb the necessary amount of herbicide
to kill the plant, and also the plants are most sensitive at this stage. At the
application also the fenological stage of the cultivated crop has to be taken
into consideration. Crops with large shading surface may hinder also the
effectivity of higher doses used. Spraying under the foliage may have a
satisfactory effect even at later sprayings. The killing effect can
considerably be increased by a proper application technology (using
adjuvants, better droplet formation, proper choice of nozzles). An important
condition for a good success is the choice of optimal time of spraying
(optimal wheather). Most succesful treatment can be made in a whether
following a rainy, warm, humide period, since the metabolism of the weeds
is then most active.
Conclusions
Herbicides usable against the Johnson-grass have an effectivity above 90 %.
No one product exist by which a field could be cleaned from Johnson-grass
with a single treatment or even during a year. The basic of decision could
be, whether we want to kill or restrain this weed in a shorter period, or how
much is endangered the crop we intend to produce. Beside the detailed
analysis of those practical stand-points, the cost-relations can be the basic of
the decision (cost per hectares).
References
Arceneaux, G. (1967): Weed control, a problem in plant technology. Sug. J.,
29: 29-31.
Bihari F. (2005): Gyomirtó szerek In: Kádár A. (szerk.): Vegyszeres
gyomirtás és termésszabályozás. Factum BT, Budapest pp. 80-91.
Holm, L.G., D.L. Plucknett, J.V. Pancho, J.P. and Herberger (1977): The
World’s Worst Weeds. University Press of Hawaii, Honolulu
Hunyadi K. (1980): Vegyszeres gyomirtás. Egyetemi jegyzet. Keszthely 66
pp.
Hunyadi K., Szatala Ö. és Mikulás J. (1979): A Sorghum halepense (L.)
Pers. axiális rügyaktivitásának évi ritmusa. XXI. Georgikon Napok,
Keszthely 256-258.
304
Hunyadi K. (1988): Szántóföldi gyomnövények és biológiájuk.
Mezőgazdasági Kiadó, Budapest
Hunyadi K., Gara S. és Nagy L. (1994): Veszélyes tizenkettő. A
fenyércirok. Agrofórum, 5 (7): 14 – 25.
Hunyadi K., Gara S. és Nagy L. (2005): Veszélyes 48. Mezőföldi
Agrofórum Kft., Szekszárd 250-259.
Kádár A. (1974): A Sorghum halepense gyomnövény magyarországi
terjedésével járó problémák. Növényvédelem 10 (8): 373-375.
Kiszelev, A.N. (1971): Szornue rasztyenyijá i meri borbü sz nyimi.
Uzgyatyelsztvo Kolosz, Moszkva
Kovács I. (2002): Fenyércirok - Sorghum halepense (L.) Pers. - biológiája
és az ellene való védekezés egyik módja kukoricában. Növényvédelem
38 (4): 189-194.
Körösmezei Cs. (1982): A fenyércirok (Sorghum halepense (L.) Pers.) elleni
védekezés komplex technológiája. MAE Növényvédelmi Szakosztály.
Körösmezei Cs. (1994): Néhány technológiai elem a fenyércirok irtásában.
Agrofórum 5 (7): 26-27.
Mc Whorter, C.G. (1972a): Factors affecting Jhonsongrass rhizome
production and germination. Weed Sci. 20 (1): 41-45.
Mc Whorter, C.G. (1972b): Flooding for Jhonsongrass control. Weed Sci.
20 (3): 238-241;
Mc Whorter, C.G. (1973): Johnsongrass as a weed. Fmrs. Bull., 2.
Mikulás J. (1976): A fenyércirok (Sorghum halepense (L.) Pers.) Elleni
védekezési kísérletek. Magyar Vegyipari Egyesülés, Budapest, 55-85.
Mikulás J. (1979): A fenyércirok (Sorghum halepense (L.) Pers) biológiája
és a védekezés lehetőségei. Kandidátusi értekezés. MTA Kutató
Intézet, Martonvásár.
Ujvárosi M. (1970): Megjegyzések a fenyércirok (Sorghum halepense (L.)
Pers.) kérdéséhez. Növényvédelem 6 (12): 552-557.
Ujvárosi M. (1973): Gyomnövények. Mezőgazda Kiadó, Budapest
Ujvárosi M. (1973): Gyomirtás. Mezőgazda Kiadó, Budapest
Quimly, P.C. and Walker, H.L. (1982): Pathogens as mechanism for
integrated weed management. IWMS Symp. Weed Sci. Suppl. 1
Simon T. (2000): A magyarországi edényes flóra határozója. Nemzeti
Tankönyvkiadó, Budapest
Szabó, J.L. (1972): A Sorghum halepense és irtása. A Mezőgazdaság
kemizálása Ankét 2. Nehézvegyipari Kutató Intézet, VeszprémKeszthely 40-46.
Takács L. (1973): A fenyércirok (Sorghum halepense) és a zártrendszerű
kukoricatermesztés.
Tolna
Megyei
Mezőgazdasági
és
Élelmiszertudományi Szemle 2 (16): 3.
305
Thorneberry, H.H. (1966): The relationship of Johnsongrass and other
perennial hosts of maize dwarf mozaic virus to disease spread and
control. Abstr. Meet. Weed Soc. Am. 7.
Tóth Á. és Spilák K. (1998): A IV. Országos Gyomfelvételezés
tapasztalatai. Növényvédelmi Fórum, Keszthely 49.
Tóth V. és Lehoczky É. (2006): A magról kelő fenyércirok (Sorghum
halepense (L.) Pers.) herbicid érzékenységének vizsgálata. XVI.
Növényvédelmi Fórum, Keszthely 117-121.
Tóth V. és Lehoczky É. (2006): Néhány herbicid összehasonlító vizsgálata a
fenyércirok (Sorghum halepense /L./ Pers.) ellen kukoricában.
XLVIII. Georgikon Napok, Keszthely.
Tóth V., Gara S., és Lehoczky É. (2006): A fenyércirok (Sorghum
halepense /L./ Pers.) elleni hatékony védekezés lehetőségének
vizsgálata kukoricában. Növényvédelem 42. évf.- Megjelenés alatt
Verma, R.D. and Bhardwaj, R.B.L. (1965): A study on the control of
Sorghum halepense (L.) Pers. with 2,4 D, 5- T, TCA and cultivations.
Indian J. Agric Sci., 35 (2): 120-133.
Walker, R.H. and Buchanan, G.A. (1982): Manipulation in integrated weed
management system. IWMS. Las Vegas Weed Sci. Supp., l.
POSSIBILITIES OF INTEGRATED WEED CONTROL AGAINST
JOHNSON-GRASS (SORGHUM HALEPENSE /L./ PERS.)
V. Tóth and É. Lehoczky
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture, H-8360 Keszthely,
Institute for Plant Protection, Department of Herbology and Pesticide Chemistry
Summary
The Johnson-grass (Sorghum halepense) belongs to those weeds causing considerable
damages in Hungary. According to Holm et al. (1977) Johnson-grass is the 6th most
important weed worldwide. The extreme wheathers of the last years made clear, that not a
single year or possibility may be omitted during the control of this weed. We have no
chance to kill it without thorough knowing of the biology of this species. An important
element of the protection is the hindering of the settlement of the Johnson-grass. If it is
present on the field, the protection methods have to be coordinated. A new possibility to
detect and identify infested field spots is the using of precision place determination
instrument and method, which helps also to reduce considerable the amount of herbicide to
be sprayed out.
306
STUDY OF PHYTOTOXICITY OF HERBICIDES ON
GREEN PEA
Gábor Wágner – Erzsébet Nádasy
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences,
Institute for Plant Protection, Keszthely, Hungary
The size of pea crop area will be determined partly by the demands of
canning and deep-freezing industry and partly by the demands on dry peas.
In the last years the green pea crop area was between 20 to 30 thousand
hectares in Hungary, and that of the pick pea area between 10 and 20
thousand hectares (Hornyák, 2005).
The pea crop is especially sensitive to the weed damage; therefore
much attention has to be paid for its cultivation. The correct weed control
helps the continuous development and ripening of the pea crop, makes
possible to conduct an easier harvest and enhance preceding crop value,
since it results in weedless stubble. The herbicides with different mode of
biological action may have different effect on the life processes of the pea
plant, they may hinder of its development, may cause damages. The plant
may compensate these effects later on, but also may suffer of lasting
damages leading to yield reduction. (Nádasy and Wágner, 2005).
Weed control in the pea crop may be done pre-sowing, pre-emergence
or using post-emergence herbicides. In the green pea production mostly preemergence herbicides are used. The reason of its is that they kill weeds
during the critical, early development stage of the pea plants, and put an end
to the competition between cultivated plant and the weeds. Its successful
application combined with agro technical and mechanical methods will
make unnecessary later crop treatments (Nádasyné and Wágner, 2004).
The different pea cultivars differently tolerate the herbicides because of
the thickness of their waxy layer. Using a new cultivar one has to get
information on its sensitivity against the different herbicides (Kádár, 2005).
Benécsné (1994) tested 25 cultivars using 5 herbicides resp. herbicide
combinations. She estimated the phytotoxicity using the 1 to 9 scores of the
EWRC scale. In the case of Igran 500 FC and Bladex 50 SC she observed
light phytotoxicity, the plants showed leaf yellowing, necrotic spots starting
from the leaf lamina edges. The recommended dose of chloracetanilide
group belonging propizochlor-containing Proponit 840 EC caused different
toxicity on 80 % of the cultivars tested, while its provocative double dose
caused high toxicity on all the tested cultivars. The Stomp 330 EC caused
typical leaf necroses, and by this differently strong damage.
307
Singh and Wright (2002) studied effects of three herbicides in
glasshouse conditions, using two pea cultivars, and investigated the effects
of herbicides on node number, on the growing patterns of pea and on the
yield. The double doses of Basagran (active ingredient: bentazon) caused
chlorosis of the plants. The numbers of node were decreased mostly by the
double doses of Basagran and Gesagard, and all herbicide decreased dry
matter of the shoots and legumes.
The flumioxazine inhibits the growing of pea plant and causes leaf
necroses, still do not decrease yield loss (Boydston et al,. 2002, Boydston,
2002). Al Khatib et al. (1999) used low-concentrated sulfonylurea products
pre- and post-emergently and bentazon combined with detergent for weed
control in green pea crop (Al Khatib et al., 1995).
Materials and Methods
Based on results of earlier glasshouse tests, we made a field experiment
with four replications in spring 2006, using 5 herbicides of different mode
of action. We tested their effect onto the growing of vegetative parts of the
pea plants. Four of the products were pre-emergence and one postemergence (Table 1.). Among them the Pledge 50 WP is not permitted in
pea culture in Hungary yet.
Table 1. Herbicide treatments in the experiment
Herbicide
Ingredient
Afalon Dispersion linuron
Single rate
Double rate
2 Lha-1
4 Lha-1
Mode of
application
Pre
0,2 Lha-1
0,4 Lha-1
Pre
Command 48 EC
klomazon
Pledge 50 WP
flumioxazin 0,08 kgha-1
0,16 kgha-1
Pre
Sencor 70 WG
metribuzin
0,35 kgha-1
0,7 kgha-1
Pre
Basagran
bentazon
3 Lha-1
6Lha-1
Post
Two doses were used, the recommended one according to the
permission document, and its double. The pre-emergence treatments were
made two days following the sowing. The post-emergence herbicide was
sprayed out two weeks following the emergence. The experiment took place
on a brown forest soil of the training farm of the Pannon University. The
cultivar used was the early ‘Karlos’.
308
To estimate the phytotoxicity we collected samples in two different
dates, and made a visual observation. The first sampling was made at 2-3
leaf-stages, the second at flowering. Each of the samples contained 10 plants
collected random from the plots, along a diagonal line of the plot. The
lengths, fresh and dry weight of the shoots were determined.
Results
The Figure 1. shows the length of shoots following the herbicide
treatments at the two samplings. At the first sampling the average length of
the untreated plants was 14.4 cm. Recommended doses of Command 48 EC,
Pledge 50 WP and Sencor 70 WG did not influence significantly the shoot
length. Post-emergently used Basagran a little bit increased the length of
shoot. Both concentrations of Afalon Dispersion significantly decreased
shoot length: the recommended doses decreased the length more than 20%,
while the double doses with 40%. Doses of Command 0.4 l/ha, Pledge 50
WP 0.16 kg/ha and Sencor 70 WG 0.7 kg/ha also inhibited shoot length.
At the second sampling the double dose of Command 48 EC, Pledge 50
WP and Sencor 70 WP significantly decreased shoot length. Both
concentration of Afalon Dispersion significantly hindered the growth (10%
and 35% respectively).
40
sampling 1
34,1
33,57
31,5
31,25
30,6
30
lenght of shoots (cm)
sampling 2
33,93
35
30,77
28,65
30,37
28,5
25
22,1
20
15,94
15
14,4
15,08
13,827
12,59
11,48
12,03
11,83
12,02
10,84
8,86
10
5
3,14
1,52
ra
n
sa
g
Ba
LS
D5
%
1
6
3
n
ra
Ba
sa
g
Figure 1. Effect of herbicides on length of green pea shoots
309
Lh
a-
-1
Lh
a
-1
kg
ha
-1
r0
,7
r0
,3
Se
nc
o
5
kg
kg
6
Se
nc
o
Pl
ed
ge
0,
1
0,
0
ge
ha
ha
ha
kg
8
0,
4
Pl
ed
an
d
-1
-1
-1
Lh
a
-1
Lh
a
0,
2
Co
m
m
Di
an
d
sp
.
Co
m
m
n
Af
al
o
n
al
o
Af
Lh
a1
4
Lh
a1
2
sp
.
Di
Co
nt
ro
l
0
Figure 2 shows changes of the fresh weight of shoots: the treatments
caused considerable differences. At the time of the first sampling a small
decrease could be observed as an effect of recommended dose of Pledge 50
WP and double dose of Sencor 70 WP. The double concentration of
Command 48 EC and Pledge 50 WP significantly decreased the fresh
weight. Both doses of Afalon Dispersion caused a decrease, the double dose
even 60%. For the Basagran treatment the plants reacted with a small fresh
weight increase.
At the time of the second sampling the concentrations of Sencor 70 WP
0.35 l/ha and of Basagran 3 l/ha caused a little, but no significant increase.
The other herbicides differently (2-57%) decreased the fresh weight of the
shoots. A significant change could be observed in case of Command 48 EC
0.4 l/ha and Afalon Dispersion 4 l/ha doses. These herbicides decreased
fresh weight 34% and 57% respectively.
80
sampling 1
sampling 2
70,87
70,07
70
63,85
62,71
60
57,19
54,49
fresh weight of shoots (g)
54,21
51,42
51,03
50
42,36
40
28,58
27,62
30
26,05
22,71
22,66
22,13
18,71
17,67
20
15,93
15,02
18,08
15,5
9,13
10
4,68
LS
D
5%
kg
Se
ha
nc
-1
or
0,
35
kg
ha
Se
-1
nc
or
0,
7
kg
ha
B
-1
as
ag
ra
n
3
Lh
B
aas
1
ag
ra
n
6
Lh
a1
-1
0,
16
0,
08
kg
ha
Pl
ed
ge
Pl
ed
ge
0,
4
Lh
a1
Lh
a1
an
d
0,
2
C
om
m
D
an
d
C
om
m
is
p.
4
Lh
a1
Lh
a1
A
fa
lo
n
A
fa
lo
n
D
is
p.
2
C
on
tr
ol
0
Figure 2. Effect of herbicides on fresh weight of green pea
Examination the effects of herbicides on the dry weight, it has been
found, that the effects were very differing. At the first sampling the highest
dry weight were measured in case of Basagran 3 l/ha, this significantly
differs from that of the untreated plants. The recommended doses of
Command 48 EC, Pledge 50 WP and Sencor 70 WG did not cause notable
change, but their double doses significantly decreased the dry weight of the
plants. Considerable decrease could be observed at both concentrations of
310
the Afalon Dispersion. In case of the recommended dose the dry weight
decreased with 34%, and at the double dose with 64%.
Similar results were shown at the second sampling, too. The
recommended dose of Basagran somewhat increased the dry weight, that of
Sencor did not make a change, the other herbicides differently decreased the
dry weight. The most severe decrease of the dry weight – 56,5 % - caused
the double dose of Afalon Dispersion. This can be explained with the
photosynthesis hindering effect of the linuron, which means consequently
assimilation- and growing inhibition, too.
18
sampling 1
16
sampling 2
16,17
15,27
15,02
13,47
14
12,93
12,85
12,71
dry weight of shoots (g)
12,05
11,46
12
10,55
10
8
6,65
6
4,04
4
3,47
2,97
3,1
2,53
2,44
2,12
2
3,68
3,17
2,99
2,73
1,25
0,55
LS
D5
%
6
Lh
a1
Lh
a1
3
kg
ha
Ba
sa
gr
an
Ba
sa
gr
an
-1
-1
0,
7
Se
nc
or
0,
35
Se
nc
or
0,
16
kg
ha
kg
ha
-1
-1
kg
ha
Pl
ed
ge
0,
08
Pl
ed
ge
an
d
0,
4
Lh
a1
Lh
a1
0,
2
Co
m
m
an
d
Co
m
m
Di
sp
.4
Lh
a1
Lh
a1
Af
al
on
Di
sp
.2
Af
al
on
Co
nt
ro
l
0
Figure 3. Effect of herbicides on dry weight of green pea
During the experiment, three weeks after emergence also visual
observation were made to determine (Table 2.) the effects of phytotoxicity
in percentage (Dancza, 2004). No symptoms of damage could be observed
in case of Sencor 70 WG and Basagran treatments. After the treatment with
Pledge 50 EC recommended dose very mild symptoms could be observed:
light deformation and light dwarfing. The double concentration caused
however small brown spots, leaf deformation, dwarfing, weaker growing in
relation to the plants of the untreated plots. The recommended dose of
Command 48 EC caused definite symptoms: first yellowing leaf spots at he
borders, which became later on white, occupied the third, then the half of
the leaf lamina. In the case of double dose the symptoms were more definite
and there was also a light deformation.
311
The plants treated with Afalon Dispersion showed the most definite
symptoms. Using the recommended dose the treatment caused chlorotic
symptoms on the leaves, some plants emerged deformed, at further growing
they were also deformed, and remained smaller than the others. Some
seedling died because of the herbicide. The double dose caused definite
yellowing, deformation and dwarfing. Many plants became white after
emergence, wilted, drooped, dried out and died. To the end of the season
more than 50% of the crop died out.
Table 2. Phytotoxic effect of herbicides on green pea
Treatments
Afalon Dispersion 2 Lha-1
Afalon Dispersion 4 Lha-1
Command 48 EC 0.2 Lha-1
Command 48 EC 0.4 Lha-1
Pledge 50 WP 0,08 kgha-1
Pledge 50 WP 0.16kgha-1
Sencor 70 WG 0.35 kgha-1
Sencor 70 WG 0.7 kgha-1
Basagran 3 Lha-1
Basagran 6 Lha-1
Phytotoxic effect%
25
50
5
5
5
10
1
0
0
0
Characteristics
strong damage
heavy damage
definite symptom
definite symptom
definite symptom
damaged
very light symptom
without symptom
without symptom
without symptom
Based on the results it can be established, that the linuron containing
Afalon Dispersion damaged most the growing of the pea plants, causing
severe phytotoxic symptoms. The double doses of Pledge 50 WP and
Command 48 EC had also a damaging effect on the pea plants. The products
Sencor 70 WP and Basagran did not cause symptoms on the pea cultivar
tested in this field experiment.
References
Al Khatib, K., Kadírand, S. and Libbey, C. (1995): Effect of adjuvants on
bentazon efficacy in green pea (Pisum sativum). Weed Technology
9: 426-431.
Al Khatib, K. and Tamhane, A. (1999): Pea (Pisum sativum) response to
low rates of selected foliar- and soil-applied sulfonyl-urea
herbicides. Weed Technology 13: 753-758.
Boydston, R. (2002): Managing nightshade in green pea with sulfentrazone
and flumioxazin. Proceedins of the Pacific Northwest Vegetable
Association, Pasco, Wa, Nov. 2002 10-14.
312
Boydston, R., Miller, T. and Yennish, J. (2002): Pea tolerance and
nightshade control with flumioxazin and sulfentrazone. Proceedins
of the 52nd Annual Washington State Weed Conference 32.
Dancza I. (Ed.) (2004): Herbicid vizsgálati módszertan. Mezőgazdasági és
Vidékfejlesztési Minisztérium, Növény- és Talajvédelmi Főosztálya,
Budapest 47. p.
Hornyák A. (2005): A borsó és a kalászosok gyomszabályozási lehetőségei.
Agro Napló (2) 12.
Kádár, A. (2005): Vegyszeres gyomirtás és termésszabályozás.
Magánkiadás, Budapest.
Nádasyné Ihárosi E. és Wágner G. (2004): A borsó herbicidérzékenységének vizsgálata. Magyar Gyomkutatás és Technológia,
5. 1. 55-62. pp.
Nádasy, E. and Wágner, G. (2005): Dry matter production of green pea
influenced by herbicides, Cereal Research Communications,
Proceedings of IV. Alps-Adria Scientific Workshop, Portoroz,
Slovenia, 377-380. pp.
Reisinger, P. (2000): Borsó. In: Hunyadi K. – Béres I. – Kazinczi G.:
Gyomnövények, gyomirtás, gyombiológia. Mezőgazda Kiadó,
Budapest pp. 516 – 518
Singh, G. and Wrigth, D. (2002): Effect of herbicides on nodulation and
growth of two varieties of peas (Pisum sativum). Acta Agronomica
Hungarica 50 (3): 337 – 348.
313
STUDY OF PHYTOTOXICITY OF HERBICIDES ON GREEN PEA
G. Wágner and E. Nádasy
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences,
Institute for Plant Protection, Keszthely, Hungary
Summary
The pea crop is especially sensitive to the weed damage; therefore much attention has
to be paid for its cultivation. The correct weed control helps the continuous development
and ripening of the pea crop, makes possible to conduct an easier harvest.
We made a field experiment with four repetitions in spring 2006, using 5 herbicides
of different mode of action. We tested their effect onto the growing of vegetative parts of
the pea plants. Afalon Dispersion (linuron), Command 48 EC (klomazon), Pledge 50 WP
(flumioxazin), Sencor 70 WG (metribuzin) was used pre-emergence and Basagran
(bentazon) post-emergence. Among them the Pledge 50 WP is not permitted in pea culture
in Hungary yet. To estimate the phytotoxicity we collected samples in two different dates,
and made a visual observation. The first sampling was made at 2-3 leaf-stage, the second at
flowering. Each of the samples contained 10 plants collected random from the plots. The
length, fresh and dry weight of the shoots was determined.
Based on the results it can be stated, that the linuron containing Afalon Dispersion
damaged most the growing of the pea plants, causing severe phytotoxic symptoms. The
double doses of Pledge 50 WP and Command 48 EC had also a damaging effect on the pea
plants.
314
MATCHING BACKPACK SPRAYER APPLICATION
TECHNOLOGY TO AN ARRAY OF AGRICULTURAL
PEST CONTROL PRODUCTS4
John Grande - Edwin Dager - Henry Fischetti
Rutgers University, New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station
Snyder Research Farm, New Jersey, USA
Introduction
Small-scale horticultural farmers grow a diversity of crops requiring an
array of products for pest control, most frequently applied as liquids.
Backpack sprayer's are evaluated and reviewed in this study for application
of pesticides by small-scale horticultural producers. A review of
conventional pesticides and approved pest control products used in organic
farming indicates significant deficiencies a) in many cases detailed
application instructions are not provided by chemical manufacturers, only
use rates; b) product formulations vary widely in viscosity and particle size.
This study examines “deployable” resources for small scale farmers.
Literature
The application of liquid products to horticultural crops by small-scale
agricultural producers is generally problematic in terms of accurate and
cost-effective sprayer application systems. Examination of the issues reveals
there is a disconnect between the companies that are involved in
manufacturing the sprayer application components and products utilized by
farmers. This project is designed particularly to address this specific need
for small-scale horticultural crop farmers.
More specifically, there are companies that manufacture sprayers who
usually do not supply an adequate range of accessories to apply the
multitude of various products. There are companies that specialize in
manufacturing sprayer components such as nozzles, screens, strainers, check
valves, filters, specialized speedometers, etc. For instance, there are over 60
nozzle and strainer parts that fit a Solo model 475 backpack sprayer listed in
TeeJet catalog #73 (Spraying Systems, Catalog #73). The Solo on-line
catalog lists three choices and would be inadequate to handle an array of
4
This work was funded by the United States Department of Agriculture Northeast Region, Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education Program
315
agricultural liquid application products (Solo Sprayers). The third type of
company involved manufactures the array of liquid application products that
address pest control. The three companies involved lack a “systems”
approach to address the farmers’ requirements. Farmers are left in a
quandary of having to integrate the components on their own, adding to the
already overburdening array of equipment and management issues.
Examination of the “directions for use” of crop protection/production liquid
products in the OMRI approved list reveals everything from precise to
vague application directions. The DiPel DF label has specific spray
application directions while the OmegaGrow label provides limited
application parameters (DiPel DF Crop Label, 2005; OmegaGrow Crop
Label, 2005). Farmers are caught in the middle; they purchase a sprayer and
products then make critical applications that can be the difference between
success and failure. A recent publication by the New York Agricultural
Experiment Station (Caldwell et al., 2006) addresses the use of OMRI listed
products for insect and disease control. Details pertinent to spray
applications are not thoroughly addressed. A personal communication with
Rosen indicated the authors had an interest in further application technology
information. Agricultural crop production requires “precise window of
opportunity” applications based upon roadblocks such as wind, rain and
field conditions. In order to meet the application timing criteria given the
impediments, it is important that application equipment operates adequately
so farmers are not stymied in their attempts to meet crop production goals.
Clogged nozzles in the middle of an application can require an extraordinary
amount of the farmer’s time to rectify leading to application errors and lost
productivity. This jeopardizes overall farm profitability, impacting the
lifestyle of the family as well as leading to potential food safety issues for
consumers.
Fortunately, appropriate spray equipment to handle the array of liquid
agricultural products such as fish emulsions, powdered nutrients, insect,
disease and weed killing products derived from soaps, oils, compost tees,
etc. is available from a multitude of sources. Many small sprayers are
manufactured in countries that utilize various standards such as metric and
British standards making compatibility an issue. Farmers have to be
prepared to deal with incompatibility issues of required spray components
(nozzles, screens, pressure regulators, etc.) that may not be available locally.
This project will train agricultural educators on the many variables related to
products and equipment required by farmers to address the noted issues.
316
Materials and Methods
Ten different backpack sprayers representing four distinct operating
characteristics were evaluated at a constant pressure and flow rate of 30
pounds per square inch operating pressure and a nozzle flow rate of 0.52
gallons per minute at the noted operating pressure. The four operating
characteristics were represented as follows: 1) hand operated piston pump
sprayers, 2) hand operated diaphragm pump sprayers, 3) electric motor
powered diaphragm pump sprayer, 4) gasoline engine powered centrifugal
pump sprayer. The hand powered piston pump and diaphragm pump
sprayers noted above were also evaluated at 15 pounds per square inch
operating pressure and a nozzle with a flow rate of 0.37 gallons per minute.
Each sprayer was operated in order to produce 1 gallon of spray material
and the time required in the number of hand strokes recorded (except for
electric and gasoline powered sprayers).
Overall backpack sprayer performance evaluation was also determined by
selecting for experienced backpack sprayer operators to apply spray material
to four different vegetable crops including peppers, eggplant, tomatoes, and
summer squash. These four crops represented leaf surface areas varying
from “low” to “high” volumes. The greatest leaf area treated was mature
summer squash and the least leaf area was peppers. 100 feet of row of each
crop were treated by each person. They spray equipment operators were
asked to independently evaluate each of the 10 sprayers with an overall
rating from 1 to 10 with one equaling the worst performance and 10
equaling the best performance. Operators combined several factors
including physical exertion, comfort and spray application characteristics.
Each sprayer was equipped with a 30 pounds per square inch pressure
regulator and a spray nozzle producing 0.52 gallons per minute. In addition,
gasoline powered air assisted misting sprayer and a gasoline powered
centrifugal pump sprayer and an electric motor powered sprayer were
included in the evaluation. These sprayers were operated without the
pressure regulating valve and the 0.52 nozzle. Original equipment nozzles
were utilized.
Results and Discussion
Hand operated backpack sprayer's varied substantially in performance as
noted in Table 1, when evaluated at equal volume outflow and constant
pressure. A pressure regulating valve (CF valve) was utilized to control
pressure. The CF valve does not operate at pressures below 30 pounds per
square inch nor above 30 pounds per square inch as opposed to other types
of pressure regulating devices that do not allow pressure to exceed the upper
317
set limit but still allow spray outflow at lower pressures. As can be noted in
Tables 1 and 2 the time to apply 1 gallon of spray material varied
substantially which should not have been the case with the pressure
regulating valve. This variability can be accounted for by operator fatigue
and slight errors in pressure regulating valve characteristics (but that was
not the main cause of variability). In some of the hand operated sprayer's
operator fatigue attempting to maintain operating characteristics became the
limiting factor. The data in Tables 1 and 2 indicate that for the hand
powered sprayers the piston pump models outperformed the diaphragm
pump models likely due to pump chamber volume, with the larger pump
chambers outperforming smaller pump chambers. Mechanical leveraging
devices on some sprayers reduced human fatigue.
Table 1. Backpack sprayers with high (30 P.S.I.) pressure
318
Table 2. Backpack sprayers with low (15 P.S.I.) pressure
In the Table 3 the average value of sprayer performance assigned by the
four individuals supports the points noted above comparing hand operated
piston pump sprayers to diaphragm pump designs. The gasoline powered
misting sprayer and the gasoline powered pump sprayer rated highly in
operator performance but generally equal to the best of the hand powered
piston pump sprayers. The electric motor powered diaphragm pump sprayer
provided medium performance in the comparison ratings. This is a relatively
new design and approach to backpack sprayer design.
The overall cost of each sprayer as purchased in the United States in US
dollars is listed in the Table 4. Considering sprayer cleanup and multiple
uses the cost and performance of the sprayer should be carefully weighed.
Several lower-cost sprayers can be purchased for the price of some of the
higher cost units. Farmers growing several different crops on a small scale
may benefit substantially in time savings by maintaining several backpack
sprayer's each utilized for separate operations such as the application of
herbicides, insecticides and fungicides reducing the potential for crop injury.
319
Table 3. Backpack sprayers’ performance
Table 4. The prices of backpack sprayers
320
References
Caldwell, B., Rosen, E.B., Sideman,E., Shelton, A.M. and Smart, C.D.
(2006): Resource Guide for Organic Insect and Disease
Management. New York State Agricultural Experiment Station
CF Valve, GATE Technologies (www.cfva;ve/cp). Vero Beach, Florida.
DiPel DF Crop Label (2005): “Directions for Use” (www.valent.com) 7.0:2.
Valent USA Corporation, PO Box 8025, Walnut Creek, CA.
OmegaGrow Crop Label (2005): (www.omegagrow.com) 1-2. Omega
Protein, PO Box 1799, Hammond, LA.
Organic Materials Review Institute (2005): OMRI Brand Name Products
List. 88-118. OMRI, Box 11558, Eugene OR.
Resource Guide for Organic Insect and Disease Management. NYSAES,
Cornell University.
(www.nysaes.cornell.edu/pp/resourceguide/index.php)
Solo Sprayers. Online catalog. (www.solousa.com). 5100 Chestnut Avenue,
Newport News, VA.
Spraying Systems. TeeJet Spray Products, Catalog #73. PO Box 7900,
Wheaton, IL.
321
AN INTERREG PROJECT FOR THE EFFECTIVE AND
SAFE PLANT PROTECTION IN THE EU
László Radócz – György J. Kövics – István Szarukán
Public Utility Foundation for Development of Plant Protection Teaching
(NOFKA), Debrecen, Hungary
The aim of this project is to develop regional, post-gradual plant
protectional courses and connecting extension services (databases) in the
areas of Hajdú-Bihar county (Hungary) and Bihor county (Romania) with
locations of Debrecen and Oradea (mirror projects). The programme
provides special post-gradual courses in the field of plant protection for
farmers in the region (25-25 persons in Debrecen and in Oradea) and can act
as models for further developments. In these projects EU-related curriculum
as well as handbooks, power point presentations (in Hungarian and
Romanian languages) planned to be developed in close collaboration.
Professional training books and CD-ROMs will be purchased to develop the
educational infrastructure. The results of the projects and continuous
professional education are not only more precise pesticide application or
less pesticide use in the agricultural sector but more healthy (and human
safe) agricultural products and positive impact on environmental-pollution
parameters. The information will be provided via fax, bulletins and special
WEB-pages for the target groups. At the end of the projects final evaluation
conferences (in Hungary and in Romania) will be held for the end-users.
The number of the project: INTERREG III/A HU-RO-SCG-1/329
The duration of the project: 28.02.2006-31.03.2007.
Areas of the project activity is covered:
- Human resource development with special courses for Hungarian
and Romanian agricultural producers.
- Economical development in agricultural production systems based
on post-gradual courses and extension services.
- Protection of the environment and consumers by up-to-date
knowledge based, more precise or reduced pesticide application.
- Development of institutional cooperation in creating special up-todate WEB sites, databases between the partners.
Project Locations: Hungary, Hajdú-Bihar county, Debrecen Romania, Bihor
county, Oradea
322
Amount requested from the Contracting Authority:
Total eligible cost
of the action
12.512.600 HUF
Amount requested from
the Contracting Authority in this
proposal
11.883.216 HUF
323
% of total cost
of action
94.97%
SIGNIFICANCE OF PESTICIDES IN THE INTEGRATED
PLANT PROTECTION
Quantitative and Qualitative Characteristics of the Pesticide Usage
Éva Lehoczky
University of Pannonia, Georgikon Faculty of Agriculture,
Institute for Plant Protection
Introduction
The continuous increase of the population on the Earth makes the
production of more food necessary. The per capita arable area decreased
substantially, the world average is about 0.1 ha. Among the available natural
sources of energy soil has a determining role with respect to food
production. Soil is a conditionally renewable natural resource, therefore the
maintenance and enhancement of its fertility is of great importance.
During the food production and its storage the different pests may cause
considerable losses, and damage. The amount of losses caused by living
organisms comes to 35% on average worldwide. That is, why plant
protection experts have such a highly responsible mission.
The materials, tools and technologies used during food production have
an influence on the quality of the products and their processed forms. A
number of different methods (agrotechnical, physical, mechanical,
biological, chemical and integrated) are available, their use and effect may
be very different.
The need for a chemical plant protection has an old history. The first
chemicals were arsenic, quicksilver, copper salts, elementary sulphur and
plant extracts like nicotine, pirethrum and neem. The research on plant
protecting chemicals and their development has got big success in the 1960s
(Table 1).
324
Table 1. Number of plant protection products in Hungary
(Source: Növényvédő szerek és termésnövelő anyagok /Pesticides
and regulators 2006/)
Years
Product
1960
1966
1974
1978
1985
1990
1999
2002
2006
50
238
256
334
488
613
750
823
795
Active
ingredient
99
173
227
278
330
337
281
Pesticides played an important role in the development of the
agricultural production, the high yielding plant production systems with
their high yields unimaginable earlier could not be developed. Industrialized
food production does not belong to those environment saving procedures
which could meet the requirements of the principle of sustainability. The
rate and costs of the artificially introduced inputs of the production are too
high.
Materials and Methods
The author based his investigations on using the statistical data issued by
the European Union and Hungary regarding the pesticid usage, quantities
and quality.
Results
The aim of the farmers was to achieve the highest yields, both in Europe
and in Hungary in the 1970s. For the 1980s they realized, that the
economical effectivity and profit is not determined only by the highest
yields. High rate of inputs was typical, and in Hungary, with its large fields
it was not possible to take the local differences and their special demands
into consideration.
Increasing food production have its restrictions, too. The biodinamical,
ecological and integrated farming system, and within these the integrated
plant production system can only comply with the requirements of
sustainable development (Ángyán and Menyhért, 1997).
325
The wide range and, big amount of pesticides used in the last decades
(Figure1) and realizing its effects on the environment draw the attention to
the fact that other methods of plant protection have to be used.
In Hungary, in the 1990s, the amount of pesticides considerably
decreased, this is also shown by the data of Figure 1. The background of it
was not only ecological (changes in the proprietorship, increasing prices),
but also the fact, that in the meantime new, ultra low volume and especially
effective pesticides (for example sulphonilcarbamide herbicides,
pirethroids) were developed, and used throughout the country.
Figure 1. Pesticide usage in Hungary (Source: AKII)
70000
60000
Tonnage
Tons/year
50000
40000
Fungicide
Fungicides
28.4%
28.4%
Insecticide
Insecticides
16.5%
16.5%
Herbicide
Herbicides
43.7%
43.7%
Other
Others
11.4%
11.4%
30000
20000
2004
2003
2002
2001
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1990
1985
1980
1975
1970
1965
0
1960
10000
The member countries of the European Union have drawn up the
document „Toward sustainability”. This document circumstantially analyses
the environmental effects of industry, energy utilization, traffic, agriculture
and of tourism. In the case of the agriculture, the considerable decrease of
pesticide use and the application of integrated plant protection procedures
were assigned as a direct target. (Lehoczky, 1999).
326
Figure 2. Pesticide usage of some countries in 1995 in relation to 1985
(100%) (Source: OECD Environment Data, 1997)
1995.
180
40
1985
Sweden
Spain
Poland
Holland
Ireland
France
Hungary
60
Finland
% 80
Denmark
100
Austria
120
USA
140
Czech Republic
Korea
160
20
0
The amount of pesticides used in Hungary shows a favourable picture in
comparison with international data (Figure 2). Since the time of the
intensive chemical use of the 1980s, the amount of pesticides used has fallen
back to about its quarter for the 1990s (Lehoczky, 2003).
For the measurement of environment pollution in a country the amount
of pesticide given for an area unit is important data. This will be shown in
Table 2 for the year 2002. According to this Portugal, Belgium and The
Netherlands belong to the group of countries, who use the highest amount of
pesticides. In Austria however pesticide usage has decreased considerably.
(Figure 2).
In Austria more than 95% of the farms joined the announced agrarenvironment-saving programs on the arable land and gardening, and by this
they enjoy and have the highest amount of assistence per hectare (Pálmai,
2003).
The pesticide usage of Hungary is considerably less than that of the
average of the European Union, which is in concordance with the EU
proposals, and it is favourable. According to the present comprehensions the
sustainable development should be followed, which can meet the present
demands as it does not hinder the interests of the future generations. A part
of this is the integrated plant production, including integrated plant
protection.
Sustainable agriculture intends to use the modern, effective,
environment saving plant protection methods, considering all the diversities
and specialities of the environment. (Kuroli, 1999).
327
Integrated plant protection is an element of the integrated plant
production, which is a sustainable way of farming. It means a complex
farming system, which includes profitable plant production taking not only
all local relations of soil, climate and economy into consideration, but also
the environment. This system preserves the natural resources. By its
application waste formation can be decreased, energy utilization can be
improved, and environment pollution is minimized.
Table 2. Pesticide usage in Europe and Hungary, in 2000
(Source: Eurostat, KSH)
Country
France
Spain
Germany
United Kingdom
Italy
Irland
Portugal
Greece
Austria
Sweden
Danmark
Finland
The Netherlands
Belgium
European Union
Hungary
active substance
metric tons
94693
38027
28010
18231
46068
1518
24868
11131
3193
1624
2802
1157
9707
5425
286454
8798
usage
kg/ha
3.4
1.5
1.6
1.1
3.2
0.4
6.3
0.9
0.9
0.5
1.0
0.5
4.9
4.1
2.3
1.5
Integrated plant protection system is not a strictly determined method,
but a system, using the newest scientific results, technologies,
recommendations and experiences and uses all these to prevent and
moderate eventual damage. Realizing integrated plant protection results in
the unanbiguous decrease of chemical protection, but at the same time the
chemical method still remains a determining part of plant protection
(Gáborjányi et al., 1995).
In terms of the law (2000. XXXV) „Integrated plant protection is
rational combination of possibilities of effective methods (plant sanitary,
agrotechnical, physical, biological, chemical) which take care of the
environment and especially of natural antagonists of pests”.
Integrated protection needs the integration of professional factual
knowledge and also of its high-level cultivation.
In Hungary, special education conditions concerns to the trade, buying
and using of pesticides. According to a decree of the Ministry of Agriculture
and Country Development (5/2001. (I. 16), farmers without proper plant
328
protection education are allowed to buy pesticides if they have a
prescription from a higher educated expert, and chemicals, belonging to the
I. and II. categories of circulation are allowed to be used only under the
supervision of a plant protection engineer.
In Hungary pesticides are classified into three categories. Pesticides of
the first category may only be used by higher qualified experts (with
university or high school certificate), the pesticides of the 2nd category can
be used by experts educated in a secondary school for plant protection (at
least 80-hour-course on chemical plant protection), and those of the 3rd
category belong to the freely usable pesticides.
From Table 3 it can be seen, that in Hungary the usage of more than half
of the pesticides (58%) is bound to qualification.
Table 3. Number and categories of authorized pesticides, 2006
Herbicides
Fungicides
Insecticides
Others
Total
Trade categories
II.
III.
44
56
122
86
69
46
100
11
335
199
I.
162
18
25
56
261
Total
262
226
140
167
795
The distribution of pesticides according to their biological effects will be
shown on Figure 3.
Figure 3. Distribution of pesticides according to their biological effect, 2006
(Source: Engedélyezett növényvédő szerek, termésnövelő
anyagok /Pesticides and regulators 2006/)
egyéb
Others
21%
21%
szer
Herbicides
33%
33%
gombaölő
Fungicides
szer
28%
28%
ovarölő szer
Insecticides
18%
18%
The full amount of pesticides sold in Hungary in 2004 was 19880 metric
tons, among them herbicides were the biggest part (44%), followed by
329
fungicides (28 %), insecticides (16.5%), while other chemicals amounted to
11.5% (AKI, 2005).
The application of pesticides ensures a more effective agricultural
production, higher yields, but at the same time there is a risk of environment
pollution, mainly soil and surface water pollution.
As a part of the Information and Monitoring System of Environment
Saving (KIM), in 1992 a subsystem, the Information and Monitoring
System for Soil Protection (TIM) was organized. The TIM has 800
sampling areas in Hungary representing all the arable fields, and in 1993
samples were taken from 106 places, from the three upper genetical layers
of the soil, and tested. In 1996 and 1997 further 130 samples were examined
for pesticide rests. In 1993 and 1996 the determination was made to see
phenoxi-acetic-acid and triazine content, in 1997 also the phosphorus acidesters and carbamates as well.
In 1996-97 as much as 130 soil samples were tested, 7150 measurings
were made, and in 4.6% of the measurings showed pesticide rests, while
higher value than the planned limit was found only in 5 cases, that is 0.07%
of all the measurings. This result shows, that the Hungarian soils are
practically free from pesticide pollution.
The active ingredients of the pesticides differ in their way of effectivity,
in their chemical construction, but also in the time and method of using and
technics, and they have different effects on the environment. Their presence,
persistence, their metabolism and degradation may cause different
biological reactions in the biotops, living organisms, and may cause
differently severe environment pollution.
The high-level plant protection education has a three-decade long
tradition in Hungary. The number of experts is almost 3000, who possess
the high-level knowledge needed for the effective realization of integrated
plant protection, and who acquire the new knowledge in obligatory courses.
The integrated plant protection system also applies the natural biotic
regulation factors of the agrobiocoenosis to decrease the number of pest
individuals under the economically acceptable level. This approach requires
the consideration of the fact, that in case of every plant protection activity,
especially of chemical usage, that beside pests, useful living organisms are
also active in the same time and place.
In the integrated environment saving technology those products are
allowed to use, which comply with the requirements of the European Union
prescriptions (IOBC/WPRS, ISHS) and also of the national requirements.
The detailed regulations of claiming of agricultural environmental
management assistence is described in the 150/2004. (X.12) decree of the
Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development. The appendix of its
modification decree 20/2006 (III.7.) FVM reviews in details the products
330
allowed or prohibited to use in the different crops in the agricultural
environmental management program.
Nowadays it has become clear, that an average treatment (the same
treatment) of a production unit or a large field may result in an uneven
technology, since the soils, the fertilizer distribution, weed colonization,
relief and microclimate are uneven, that means, that even within a field the
plant protecting products and fertilizers has specifically to be given.
For the future precision agricultural methods have to be worked out.
This is in progress, specialists and scientists are working on its possibilities
cooperatively, who use modern place localization instruments (DGPS), and
geographic information systems. The elaboration and application of
precision methods of plant protection could considerable contribute to
environment saving and economical pesticide use, and could give new
possibilities to lower the amount of pesticides used in practice.
References
Agrárgazdasági Kutató Intézet (2005): A mezőgazdasági termelőeszköz
kereskedelmi szervezetek növényvédő szer értékesítése és
zárókészlete szercsoportonként, cikkelemes bontásban 2004. év.
Agrárgazdasági Kutató Intézet, Statisztikai Osztály, Budapest
Ángyán J. és Menyhért Z. (1997): Alkalmazkodó növénytermesztés,
észszerű környezetgazdálkodás. Mezőgazdasági Szaktudás Kiadó,
Budapest
Győrfi L. (2002): A növényvédőszer-maradék vizsgálati eredmények
értékelése növényi termékekben és környezetvédelmi mintákban,
1998-2001. Növényvédelmi Tanácsok, 11 (10): 31-36
Gáborjányi R., Kőmíves T. és Király Z. (1995): A fenntartható
mezőgazdaság növényvédelme. Növényvédelem 31 (2): 49-56
Király Z. (1997): A növényvédelem környezetre gyakorolt hatása, szerepe a
minőségi
termelésben
és
a
fenntarthatóságban.
MTA
Agrártudományok Osztálya, Budapest
Kuroli G. (1999): Inszekticidek és bioinszekticidek a növényvédelemben. In
A növényvédelem integrált, környezetbarát fejlesztési lehetőségei.
MTA Agrártudományok Osztálya, Budapest 91-101
Lehoczky É. (1999): A növényvédelem szerepe a fenntartható
mezőgazdaságban. 167-207. In Németh T. (szerk.): Talajhasználat,
környezetkímélő tápanyag-gazdálkodás és növényvédelem a
fenntartható mezőgazdasági fejlődés tükrében. Jegyzet, Tempus JEP
GATE, Gödöllő, 207.
Lehoczky É. (2003): A kémiai növényvédelem szerepe a fenntartható
mezőgazdaságban. Növényvédő szer felhasználás napjainkban és az
331
elmúlt évtizedekben. In Szabó T., Bártfai I. és Somlai J. (szerk.):
Környezeti ártalmak és a légzőrendszer. XIII. kötet, ISBN 963-043904-2, F & F Press Bt., Zalaegerszeg, 227-238
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (1997):
Agriculture, pesticides and the environment. Policy Options. OECD
publications, Paris.
Pálmai O. (2003): A kemikália felhasználás lehetőségei és korlátai az
élelmiszerbiztonság feltételeinek kielégítésével. In Antal G. és Nagy
B. (szerk.): Fejér megye éghajlata. Fejér Megyei Agrárkamara,
Székesfehérvár
Szabadi G. (Ed.) (2006): Növényvédő szerek, termésnövelő anyagok 2006,
I. kötet. Pesticides and regulators. Vol. I. Földművelésügyi és
Vidékfejlesztési Minisztérium, Agrinex Bt., Budapest
2000. évi XXXV. törvény a Növényvédelemről
5/2001. (I.16.) FVM rendelet a Növényvédelmi tevékenységről
20/2006. (III. 17.) FVM rendelet a Nemzeti Vidékfejlesztési Terv alapján a
központi költségvetés, valamint az Európai Mezőgazdasági
Orientációs és Garancia Alap Garancia Részlege társfinanszírozásában
megvalósuló
agrár-környezetgazdálkodási
támogatások
igénybevételének részletes szabályairól szóló 150/2004. (X. 12.) FVM
rendelet módosításáról
332
SIGNIFICANCE OF PESTICIDES IN THE INTEGRATED PLANT
PROTECTION
Quantitative and qualitative characteristics of the pesticide usage
É. Lehoczky
Pannon University, Georgikon Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Institute for Plant
Protection, Keszthely, Hungary
Summary
As a consequence of technical and scientific development of agriculture, the number of
authorized pesticides has increased 15-fold since 1960 (now near to 800), and the number
of active ingredients takes near to 300. Sustainable agriculture demands experts to choose
and use from the wide choice of pesticides and active ingredients which least pollute the
environment. This concerns to choosing the technological method, to the pesticides, to their
dose, as well as to the technological discipline. In Hungary the situation is favourable with
respect to the active substance amount per hectare, that is 1.5 kg, while that amounts to 2.3
kg/ha on the average in the European Union. This however does not mean, that experts
have nothing to do for the decrease of environment pollution. Integrated plant protection,
the special spraying technology using precision plant protection and by this the skilled use
of pesticides have a determining importance in the maintenance of public health, in saving
of environment, and last, but not least also in the economy. The test results of Information
and Monitoring System for Soil Protection show, that the Hungarian soils are free from
polluting pesticide residues.
It is important to keep this situation, which can also be helped by the place specific
plant protection.
333
BIOLOGICAL TEST EXPERIMENTS ON MODELING
EFFECT OF PESTICIDE DECOMPOSITION PRODUCTS
Diána Virág – Zoltán Naár – Attila Kiss
Károly Eszterházy College, Eger, Hungary
Herbicides sprayed mostly on the soil surface are exposed to the destruction
by UV of the sun light. The toxicity of degradation products to the soil
microorganisms is mainly unexplored. The growth inhibitory effect of the
basic compound of carbendazim, acetochlor, simazine, chlorpyriphos and
EPTC was compared with their photodegradation products (254 nm, 15 W).
Common soil microbes, three bacteria (Bacillus subtilis, Pseudomonas
fluorescens, Mycobacterium phlei) and three filamentous fungi (Fusarium
oxysporum, Penicillium expansum, Trichoderma harzianum) were applied
as test organisms. The antifungal effect of carbendazim significantly
decreased as a function of UV-treatment time. However, the last remnant
after the total elimination of basic compound markedly inhibited the growth
of T. harzianum. The antibacterial activity of acetochlor degradation mix
gradually increased, the transition products showed moderate antifungal
activity, too. The degradation products of simazine were strongly hindered
the proliferation of M. phlei; however, the test fungi were not sensitive to
these compounds. Products of various antimicrobial spectrum appeared
during the degradation of chlorpyriphos. The marked antibacterial effect of
EPTC rapidly disappeared due to UV-light, but the end-product had strong
and specific inhibitory effect against P. expansum.
334