Phytopathologia Mediterranea
Firenze University Press
www.fupress.com/pm
The international journal of the
Mediterranean Phytopathological Union
New or Unusual Disease Reports
Leveillula lactucae-serriolae on Lactuca serriola
in Jordan
Citation: Lebeda A., Kitner M.,
Mieslerová B., Křístková E., Pavlíček T.
(2019) Leveillula lactucae-serriolae on
Lactuca serriola in Jordan. Phytopathologia Mediterranea 58(2): 359-367. doi:
10.14601/Phytopathol_Mediter-10622
Accepted: February 7, 2019
Published: September 14, 2019
Copyright: © 2019 Lebeda A., Kitner M., Mieslerová B., Křístková E.,
Pavlíček T.. This is an open access,
peer-reviewed article published by
Firenze University Press (http://www.
fupress.com/pm) and distributed
under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided
the original author and source are
credited.
Data Availability Statement: All relevant data are within the paper and its
Supporting Information files.
Competing Interests: The Author(s)
declare(s) no conflict of interest.
Editor: Pervin Kinay Teksür, Ege University, Bornova Izmir, Turkey.
Aleš LEBEDA1,*, Miloslav KITNER1, Barbora MIESLEROVÁ1, Eva
KŘÍSTKOVÁ1, Tomáš PAVLÍČEK2
1 Department of Botany, Faculty of Science, Palacký University in Olomouc, Šlechtitelů
27, Olomouc, CZ-78371, Czech Republic
2 Institute of Evolution, University of Haifa, Mount Carmel, Haifa 31905, Israel
Corresponding author: ales.lebeda@upol.cz
Summary. Jordan contributes significantly to the Near East plant biodiversity with
numerous primitive forms and species of crops and their wild relatives. Prickly lettuce
(Lactuca serriola) is a common species in Jordan, where it grows in various habitats.
During a survey of wild Lactuca distribution in Jordan in August 2007, plants of L.
serriola with natural infections of powdery mildew were observed at a site near Shobak (Ma’an Governorate). Lactuca serriola leaf samples with powdery mildew infections were collected from two plants and the pathogen was analyzed morphologically.
Characteristics of the asexual and sexual forms were obtained. Sequence analyses of
the rDNA ITS region and D1/D2 domains of the 28S rDNA were used to obtain phylogenetic data, and to reach taxonomic conclusions about these specimens. Molecular
determination, performed by sequencing of the ITS region, proved its identity with
the type material of Leveillula lactucae-serriolae. Sequencing of the 28S rDNA region
provided the first verified GenBank record of Leveillula lactucae-serriolae deposited in
this public nucleotide repository. This is the first taxonomically verified record of L.
lactucae-serriolae on L. serriola growing wild in Jordan, and one of the first records of
the fungus in the Near East.
Keywords. Lettuce powdery mildew, morphology, Near East, prickly lettuce, ITS and
and 28S rDNA region.
INTRODUCTION
Powdery mildews are biotrophic pathogenic fungi from the order Erysiphales, which mostly exhibit exoparasitic life strategies (Braun and Cook,
2012). On the genus Lactuca, at least three biologically and ecologically different genera of powdery mildews (Golovinomyces, Podosphaera, Leveillula)
are known (Lebeda and Mieslerova, 2011), and a Pseudoidium type of powdery mildew (without exact determination) was detected on L. viminea in the
south France (Lebeda et al., 2002). However, from this survey, it is also evident that the genus Leveillula is rare on Lactuca species. Leveillula has 40 species, and is an endoparasitic genus (Braun and Cook, 2012). It is considered
to be adapted to xerophytic conditions, and is mainly distributed in arid and
Phytopathologia Mediterranea 58(2): 359-367, 2019
ISSN 0031-9465 (print) | ISSN 1593-2095 (online) | DOI: 10.14601/Phytopathol_Mediter-10622
360
warm areas of Africa, Asia, southern Europe, and southern North America to South America (Braun and Cook,
2012). The most known and common pathogen is Leveillula taurica, which has a broad host range. Leveillula spp.
have been recorded on host 221 species in 78 genera of
the Asteraceae. As a result, there is high genetic diversity
in Leveillula spp. affecting Asteraceae (Palti, 1988).
Two different species concepts of Leveillula have
been previously applied (Braun and Cook, 2012). These
pathogens were regarded as highly specialized strains,
as well as races which were able to infect a wide range
of hosts belonging to various plant families. This ability
was recently confirmed by the phylogenetic examinations of Khodaparast et al. (2001). In the past, Salmon
(1900) recognized a single species, Erysiphe taurica sensu
latissimo. He reduced all related taxa to synonymy with
this species. Jaczewski (1927) divided L. taurica into
numerous “formae” – i.e., one forma for each host genus.
Golovin (1956) represented the other extreme in the
treatment of Leveillula. He tried to split Leveillula into
numerous species based on conidium shape and size
as well as host range. He proposed one species for each
host family, and his classification was, therefore, schematic and did not solve the phylo-taxonomic problems.
The detailed studies (including morphological and
molecular analyses) of Leveillula were conducted mainly
by Khodaparast and colleagues (Khodaparast et al., 2001;
Khodaparast et al., 2007; Khodaparast et al., 2010; Khodaparast et al., 2012). In the most recent work, Khodaparast et al. (2012) performed phylogenetic analyses of ITS
rDNA of 76 Leveillula specimens from different host families, and these suggested the maintenance of high phylogenetic variability in Leveillula on Asteraceae. The phylogenetic tree showed that powdery mildew on: a) Carthamus, Crepis, Gundelia and Helianthus established clade
No. 1; b) Cirsium, Lactuca serriola, Echinops formed clade
No. 2; c) Centaurea, Launaea, Picris, Thevenotia formed
clade No. 5, and d) Chondrilla, Acroptilon, Artemisia and
Lactuca orientalis were each in a separate clade. The phylogenetic variability confirmed that Leveillula spp. have
probably colonized the Asteraceae several times during
evolution, because isolates from this host family include
genetically divergent taxa comprising several independent
lineages (Khodaparast et al., 2001).
The study of Leveillula species solely on Asteraceae was done mainly by Khodaparast et al. (2010). They
evaluated Leveillula collections on Asteraceae from Iran
and recognized six species, namely L. guilanensis, L.
lactucae-serriolae, L. lactucarum, L. picridis, L. thevenotie and L. taurica s. lat., which could be separated into
three morphological groups. Braun and Cook (2012)
described nine Leveillula spp. on the family Asteraceae,
A. Lebeda et alii
namely L. asterisci, L. guilanensis, L. helichrysi, L. lactucae-serriolae, L. lactucarum, L. lappae, L. osteospermi, L.
picridis and L. thevenotiae. The occurrence of L. taurica
on Asteraceae was left as questionable. Among others, it
was established that Lactuca spp., not only in Iran, are
infected by at least two different Leveillula spp. (L. lactucae-serriolae and L. lactucarum) (Khodaparast et al.,
2010; Braun and Cook, 2012).
The Leveillula species known currently (Braun and
Cook, 2012) are distinguished from each other mainly
by features of the conidia, especially by the shape and
length/width ratio of primary and secondary conidia
and by the form of conidium surfaces determined using
scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The importance of
conidial features was also proposed by Braun (1995), and
before him by Golovin (1956), Rostam (1983), Durrieu
and Rostam (1984), Heluta and Simonyan (1987, 1988),
Simonyan and Heluta (1987, 1989). Voytyuk et al. (2009)
performed detailed SEM examinations of Leveillula
conidia and confirmed that variation in their surface
structures provided taxonomically relevant traits allowing differentiation between allied taxa. Later, Khodaparast et al. (2012) acknowledged that many collections
of Leveillula strains on different hosts showed conidial
morphology which was usually consistent for a strain on
a single host species. Besides the analyses completed by
Khodaparast et al. (2001, 2012) of the ITS region, Voytyuk et al. (2009) also used tub2 gene. However, resolutions in both ITS and tub2 gene trees were not fully
sufficient because taxa that are morphologically distinguishable are not well resolved genetically.
There is little known of the geographical distribution
of L. lactucae-serriolae. Voytyuk et al. (2009) reported
this pathogen on L. serriola from Armenia, Iran and
Israel. However, during field investigations in 2004–
2007, this species was not recorded in Israel (Voytyuk
et al., 2009). In recent publications (Braun and Cook,
2012), L. lactucae-serriolae is reported on Lactuca azerbaijanica, L. scarioloides and L. serriola from Asia (Iran,
Israel, Lebanon, Turkmenistan) and Caucasus (Armenia), but not from Jordan. Currently, only Qasem and
Abu-Blan, (1986) have reported a survey and identification of powdery mildews on economic and wild hosts
in Jordan. Only L. taurica was confirmed in this survey,
but this pathogen was not found on Lactuca spp. In the
1980s the taxonomy of powdery mildews and the possibilities of accurate species identification was generally
on a low scientific level. From this time the attention of
researchers in Jordan has been focused mainly on powdery mildews on economic crops (e.g., barley, tomato,
cucurbits, grapes) (e.g., Abu-Blan and Khalil, 2001;
Abdel-Ghani et al., 2008; Mansour et al., 2014).
361
Leveillula lactucae-serriolae in Jordan
The aim of the present study was to provide an accurate description and taxonomic position of Leveillula
spp. found on wild L. serriola in Jordan.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Plants naturally infected by powdery mildew were
observed at site 8 (Shobak). Leaf samples with powdery
mildew infections were collected from two different
plants at this site.
Morphological examination of powdery mildew
Lactuca spp. distribution
The character of the populations of wild Lactuca species in Jordan and the presence of powdery mildew on
plants in their natural habitats was monitored during
a field trip from 25–27 August 2007. Plants were studied at nine sites along a North (32°39’16,47’’N) to South
(30°19’48,59’’N) transect, oscillating around the latitude of 35°40’E (Table 1). All sites were in the Mediterranean bioclimatic region. However, Shobak is located
on its marginal part, near the Trans-Turanian region as
defined by Al-Jaloudy (2006). While sites 1 to 7 were in
northern areas with annual average rainfall of 200 to
400 mm, the annual average rainfall at site 9 (Petra) is
100 to 200 mm, and at site 8 (Shobak) is 50 to 100 mm
(Fanack Water Editorial Team, 2017).
Site 1 was in the Jordan Valley, sites 2 to 7 were in
the North of the Irbid Plateau, and site 9 (Petra) was in
the South. Sites 8 (Shobak) and 9 were both on the marginal part of Steppe, and were strongly influenced by the
Eastern Desert (Badiah).
Plants with morphological traits typical of L. serriola
were observed at all of the sites except site 8. Plants with
traits of L. aculeata, i.e., with dense and sharp spines on
stems and cauline leaves, were observed at sites 1, 2, 3, 6
and 7. Plants with traits of L. saligna, i.e., with acute leaf
apices and narrow lobes on cauline leaves, were observed
at sites 1, 4, 7 and 8 (Table 1).
Two powdery mildew samples collected on individual
plants of L. serriola were used. Pieces of severely infected
leaves were used for evaluation by light microscopy. As
only dry leaf samples were analyzed, the modified method of Shin (2000) was used, i.e., heating of ‘herbariumized’ plant tissues in fuchsine in lactic acid. For statistical analyses (means, standard deviations and ranges),
30 measurements of each characteristic were used where
possible (MS Excel, 2010).
Molecular examination
Genomic DNA was extracted from fungal mycelium
scraped from two herbarium specimens of L. serriola
(OL35561, OL35562) using the SDS extraction method
(Edwards et al., 1991). The ITS region (ITS1-5.8S rDNAITS2) and the 5´ end of the 28S rDNA region (including
D1 and D2 domains) were amplified separately by two
polymerase chain reactions (PCRs) with nested primer
sets. For amplification of the ITS region, the powdery
mildew specific PMITS1/PMITS2 primers (Cunnington et al., 2003) and ITS1-F/ITS4 primers (White et al.,
1990; Gardes and Bruns, 1993) were used. Amplification of D1/D2 domains of the 28S rDNA was performed
according to Takamatsu et al. (2013), using primer sets
PM3/TW14 and NL1/TW14 for the two nested PCR
Table 1. List of monitoring sites with wild Lactuca species in Jordan in 2007.
Site
number
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
a
Name of location
Umm Qais, Cadara
West from Jerash, Olive
Branch hotel
Old Jerash, entrance to
Roman City
Mount Nebo, monastery,
monument
Mount Nebo
Madaba
Madaba, archeological park
Shobak
Petra, Canyon
Latitude
Longitude
Altitude
Character of habitat
(m a.s.l.)
32°39´16,47´´N 35°40´45,72´´E
32°17´46,30´´N 35°51´17,01´´E
353
932
32°16´45,01´´N 35°53´13.32´´E
590
stony slope
stony slope, south
exposition
sandy soil
31°46´02,08´´N 35°43´33,21´´E
680
31°46´00,30´´N
31°43´12,22´´N
31°42´57,47´´N
30°31´30,45´´N
30°19´48,59´´N
35°43´42,60´´E
35°47´40,25´´E
35°47´44,71´´E
35°35´21,33´´E
35°26´26,77´´E
671
787
780
1304
877
Lactuca a forma
Number
of samples
1
2
near road
serriola
segregating serriola/
integrifolia
Lser, Lint
[as above]
Lser
near road
ruderal place
stony background
along the road
stony background
Lser
Lser
Lser
Lser
Lser
1
5
1
2
1
Taxonomic status confirmed: Lser – L. serriola f. serriola; Lint – L. serriola f. integrifolia
3
4
362
A. Lebeda et alii
runs. All PCR reactions were conducted in 15 μL reaction volume, containing 1.2 μL of DNA (50 ng μL-1), 0.3
μL of each primer (10 μM), 3 μL of 10× Reaction Buffer,
0.24 μL of 10 mM dNTP´s, 0.08 μL of GoTaq G2 DNA
Polymerase (Promega) and 9.88 μL of PCR grade water,
and were carried out in an Eppendorf Mastercycler ProS
(Eppendorf). The following conditions were used for the
PCRs: 5 min at 95°C; 35 cycles of 45 sec at 95°C, 45 sec
at 60°C for the first PCR or 55°C for the second PCR,
1 min at 72°C, and a final extension (7 min at 72°C).
PCR products were purified using the GenElute PCR
Clean-Up Kit (Sigma-Aldrich) and sequenced (Macrogene Europe) using the following primers: ITS1-F/
ITS4 for the ITS region and NL1/NL2/NLP2/TW14 for
28S rDNA (Takamatsu et al., 2013). Geneious 7.1.8 (Biomatters Ltd) was used for contig assembly from partial
reads, the editing of base calls and concatenation of partial genomic regions. The resulting nucleotide sequences
were deposited in the NCBI database (accession numbers
MG881818, MG881819, MG878434, MG878435) and used
to search against the NCBI database using BLAST. All
sequences having the similarity values equal or greater
than 99% for ITS and 97% for 28S rDNA were compared using MEGA 7 software (Kumar et al., 2016). Subsequently, Maximum Likelihood (ML) and Maximum
Parsimony (MP) phylogenetic trees were constructed to
trace the relationships among selected GenBank records
and sequences obtained in this study. Moreover, for the
ITS tree we used additional sequences representing the
main Leveillula groups outlined by Khodaparast et al.
(2012). The best-fit evolution model (Tamura-3 parameter
with gamma distribution) was selected with Find Best
DNA/Protein Models option implemented in MEGA 7.
Alignment gaps were treated as missing information.
RESULTS
Symptoms of infection
Symptoms of powdery mildew infection consisted of
extensive growth of white, superficial coatings on upper
and lower leaf surfaces. Newly infected leaves had sparse
coverings of powdery mildew. As the disease progressed,
white mycelia completely covered both leaf surfaces (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Symptoms of powdery mildew infections on lower sides
of leaves of A, Lactuca serriola f. integrifolia, and B, L. serriola f. serriola.
internal, which was hard to confirm because of the age
of the herbarium specimens. White, dense and persistent, mostly superficial mycelium occurred on leaves.
Two types of conidia were produced separately on conidiophores (Figure 2, A-J). Primary conidia were lanceolate, long with pointed apices and rounded bases,
and measured 39–56 × 11–13 μm, with length to width
ratios of 3.2–4.9. Secondary conidia were mostly clavate,
39–66 × 11–16 μm, with length/width ratios of 2.9–4.9.
Germtubes were recorded on primary and secondary conidia; arising mostly from an end of each germinating conidium, rarely from the side. Germinating
conidia usually had singly long germtubes, the apices of
which were mostly simple, but sometimes curved (Figure 2, K-N). Conidiophores with primary and secondary conidia were observed (Figure 2, O and P), and these
were 117–244 μm long, with foot cells measuring 46–175
μm long, 6–8.5 μm wide and mostly with 2–4 distal
cells. Chasmothecia were also observed, but these were
probably not mature. They were 92–219 μm in diameter,
with very short and few appendages, and without asci
(Figure 2, Q).
The shape of primary and secondary conidia of the
Leveillula found on the Lactuca spp. accessions in Jordan
were very similar to micrographs of primary and secondary conidia of L. lactucae-serriolae from Iran, published by Khodaparast et al. (2012).
Morphology of the fungus
Molecular identification of powdery mildew
The morphological features of both herbarium samples of powdery mildew on Lactuca spp. are summarized as follows. Mycelium was external and (probably)
The nucleotide sequences of the 28S rRNA gene and
ITS regions were determined for the two analysed speci-
363
Leveillula lactucae-serriolae in Jordan
et al. (2011). To inspect these records in more detail, we
aligned the above ITS sequences with selected sequences representing the main Leveillula groups outlined
by Khodaparast et al. (2012), and performed phylogenetic analyses. The resulting ML tree proved the identity of all Leveillula samples originating from L. serriola, which formed a separate sub-group within clade
No. 2, consisting of “type“ specimens of L. lactucaeserriolae AB044375 and the two specimens sequenced in
this study (Figure 3). On the other hand, the sequence
HQ821500 extracted from Hexinia polydichotoma by Xu
et al. (2011) fell within clade No. 1, together with Leveillula taurica samples originating from Korea and China.
The BLASTn search of part of the sequenced 28S
rDNA region revealed 99% similarity to 28S rDNA
sequences of different Leveillula species: L. lactucaeserriolae (HQ821501 ex Hexinia polydichotoma) reported by Xu et al. (2011); L. duriaei (AB080475 ex Salvia
nemorosa) and Leveillula sp. (AB080478 ex Chondrilla
juncea), reported by Takamatsu et al. (2008) (Figure 3).
DISCUSSION
Figure 2. Micrographs of Leveillula lactucae-serriolae. A-E, shape
variability of primary conidia; F-J, secondary conidia; K-N, germ
development from primary and secondary conidia; O, conidiophore
with primary conidia; P, conidiophore with secondary conidia; Q,
chasmothecium. Bars = 10 μm in A-N) and 50 μm in O-Q).
mens. Identical nucleotide sequences for both specimens
were obtained, with the total lengths of 673 bp for ITS
and 875 bp long contig for 28S rRNA.
Comparison of the ITS from this study with
sequences available in the GenBank database revealed
100% similarity with the “type“ record of L. lactucaeserriolae (Accession no. AB044375) infecting Lactuca
serriola from Iran (Khodaparast et al., 2001). There is
another ITS record in the GenBank database (Accession no. HQ821500) described as L. lactucae-serriolae,
which was extracted from Hexinia polydichotoma by Xu
As mentioned above, the only study of powdery
mildews occurring in Jordan was that of Qasem and
Abu-Blan (1986), where only Leveillula taurica was confirmed. However, occurrence of powdery mildew species is rarely limited by state borders. In surrounding
Near East countries, powdery mildews have been surveyed, but not with the same intensity in various countries. In the reviews of El-Kazzaz et al. (1989), Voytyuk
et al. (2009), Severoglu and Ozyigit (2012) and Kabaktepe et al. (2015), the most common powdery mildew on
Asteraceae was Leveillula taurica. However, in Turkey
L. lactucae-serriolae, L. lactucarum and L. picridis were
also recorded (Kabaktepe et al., 2015). Voytyuk et al.
(2009) reported Leveillula lactucae-serriolae, L. picridis
and Leveillula spp. on Asteraceae in Israel. Leveillula
spp. was separated into three species, and L. osteospermi
and L. wasseri were described as new species (Voytyuk
et al., 2009; Braun and Cook, 2012). Detailed studies of
powdery mildews in Iran were completed by Khodaparast et al. (2001, 2007, 2010, 2012, 2016), and the pathogens were mainly in Leveillula. These authors introduced
some new species of Leveillula, including L. guilanensis
and L. lactucae-serriolae, on Asteraceae (Khodaparast et
al., 2002).
According to our observations, the shapes of primary and secondary conidia of Leveillula found on Lactuca spp. accessions in Jordan are very similar to those
in micrographs of L. lactucae-serriolae published by
364
A. Lebeda et alii
Figure 3. Maximum-Likelihood tree based on ITS nucleotide sequences of 28 taxa of Leveillula and single outgroup taxa. Numbers above
branches indicate bootstrap values based on 1000 replications of ML and ME phylogeny (Bootstrap values less than 50% are not shown).
Numbers to the right indicate the clades designated by Khodaparast et al. (2012). *** indicates specimens analysed in the present study.
Khodaparast et al. (2012). Differences were found in size,
but not in shape, since in our observations (Table 2) the
sizes of both types of conidia were smaller than those
described by Khodaparast et al. (2012). Khodaparast
et al. (2002), who first introduced L. lactucae-serriolae,
described this species as morphologically very close to L.
taurica, since the primary conidia of the two species are
similar, but L. lactucae-serriolae differed in having more
distinctly clavate (widest in the upper half) secondary conidia. However, this species is genetically clearly
distinct, forming a separate clade (Khodaparast et al.,
2001), so it cannot be conspecific with Leveillula taurica.
According to Braun and Cook (2012), L. lactucae-serriolae occurs on Lactuca (L. azerbaijanica, L. scarioloides,
L. serriola) in Asia (Iran, Israel, Lebanon, Turkmenistan,
and Armenia).
Another newly described powdery mildew species on
Lactuca spp. in Jordan is Leveillula lactucarum, known
for 30 years, and described by Braun and Cook (2012)
on Chondrilla, Hexinia, and Lactuca (L. orientalis, L.
tatarica, L. viminea) in Asia (Afghanistan, China, Iran,
Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Armenia, and Azerbaijan), and Europe. These authors suspected that other collections belonged to this group. Leveillula lactucarum is well characterized as having subcylindrical primary conidia which are narrowed toward
pointed apices. This contrasts with the long, lanceolate
primary conidia and more or less subclavate secondary
365
154.1 ± 43.9
(92.7 – 219.6)
154.5 ± 13.8
(134.2 – 170.8)
187 – 225
2.7± 0.4
(2 – 4)
2.8 ± 0.8
(2 – 4)
n.a.
146 ± 38
70.7 ± 23.5
(117.1 – 200) (46.3 – 102.5)
190 ± 40.5
108.4 ± 32.6
(126.9 – 244) (53.7 – 175.7)
n.a.
n.a.
3.8 ± 0.5
(2.9 – 4.9)
3.9 ± 0.5
(2.9 – 4.8)
n.a. b
13.9 ± 1.1
(10.9 – 15.9)
13.2 ± 1.1
(11 – 15.9)
13 – 18
12.4 ± 0.5
(12.2 – 13.4)
12.1 ± 0.8
(11 – 13.4)
13 – 18
Lactuca serriola f.
50.8 ± 3.3
integrifolia (Jordan)
(43.9 – 53.7)
Lactuca serriola f. serriola
50.4 ± 4.6
(Jordan)
(39 – 56)
Lactuca serriola (Iran)
53 – 75
b
a Means
± SDs and ranges, where available.
Information not available.
4 ± 0.2
(3.6 – 4.2)
4.1 ± 0.4 (3.2
– 4.9)
3.1 – 5
52.8 ± 5.5
(39 – 61)
52.4 ± 5.5
(39 – 65.9)
49 – 75
Mean width
Mean length
Length/ Width
(μm) ± SD
(μm) ± SD
Ratio
(min – max)
(min – max)
Origin (host plant species
and country)
Mean length
(μm) ± SD
(min – max)
Mean width
Mean length Mean basal cell Mean number Mean diameter
Length/ width
(μm) ± SD
(μm) ± SD
(μm) ± SD of distal cells ± (μm) ± SD
Ratio
(min – max)
(min – max) (min – max)
SD (range)
(min – max)
Chasmotheciaa
Conidiophoresa
Secondary
Primary
Conidiaa
Table 2. The main morphological characteristics of Leveillula lactucae-serriolae samples originated from Jordan (collected by A. Lebeda, in 2007) and Iran (Khodaparast et al., 2002).
Leveillula lactucae-serriolae in Jordan
conidia of L. lactucae-serriolae. Furthermore, the micrographs of primary and secondary conidia of L. lactucarum on Lactuca (e.g. L. orientalis) presented by Khodaparast et al. (2012) show conidia that are very different
from our samples.
Leveillula lactucae-serriolae and L. lactucarum are
well supported molecularly and morphologically. The
taxonomic positions of several species were generally
well supported by morphology especially that of primary
conidia (Khodaparast et al., 2012). Leveillula lactucaeserriolae was placed in clade No. 2, while L. lactucarum
was placed in clade No. 10, different from Leveillula taurica (clade No. 1).
Nucleotide sequences of two genomic regions were
determined in the present study. ITS proved that all
Leveillula samples originating from L. serriola (including “type” material from Iran), formed a well resolved
L. lactucae-serriolae sub-clade on the ML phylogenetic
tree (Figure 3). In contrast, GenBank record HQ821500
deposited as L. lactucae-serriolae extracted from Hexinia polydichotoma fell within the L. taurica samples.
Although Xu et al. (2011) stated that the BLASTn search
of HQ821500 returned 99% similarity with “type” L. lactucae-serriolae record AB044375, these authors ignored
100% identity of HQ821500 to 11 Leveillula taurica ITS
records (JN861731, JQ885445). It is evident that the
taxonomic denomination of HQ821500 is doubtful and
should be corrected to L. taurica or Leveillula sp.
We cannot perform direct comparison of the 28S
rDNA sequence to the “type” material of L. lactucaeserriolae since it is not deposited in GenBank. Nevertheless, the inspection of 28S rDNA nucleotide alignment
of Leveillula sequences obtained in the present study
with the most similar GenBank records (i.e. HQ821501,
AB080475, AB080478 having 99% identity; alignment
not shown) proved that none of the analysed sequences
is identical with the two L. lactucae-serriolae specimens from Jordan. These differ from others in a single
SNP with record HQ821501 (L. lactucae-serriolae ex
Hexinia polydichotoma) and another SNP with L. duriaei (AB080475 ex Salvia nemorosa). The two deposited sequences (HQ821501 and AB080475) are also
not identical, and there is high probability that each of
these sequences represents a different taxon. Moreover,
the record of HQ821501 published by Xu et al. (2011) is
linked to the problematic ITS record of HQ821500 discussed above, and most likely does not represent 28S
rDNA of L. lactucae-serriolae. Therefore, it should be
corrected to Leveillula sp.
In conclusion, the sequencing of the ITS region of
powdery mildew obtained from two Lactuca serriola
plants in Jordan proved their identity with “type“ mate-
366
A. Lebeda et alii
rial of Leveillula lactucae-serriolae described by Khodaparast et al. (2012). Sequencing of 28S rDNA region
provided the first verified GenBank record of Leveillula
lactucae-serriolae deposited in a public nucleotide repository. The sequencing of both genomic regions clearly
throws doubt on the L. lactucae-serriolae record on Hexinia polydichotoma. This first record of L. lactucae-serriolae on wild Lactuca species in Jordan is, however, not
surprising because the environmental conditions in this
area favoured the occurrence of powdery mildew of this
genus.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Critical comments of Dr R.T.A. Cook (U.K.) on an
early draft of this manuscript are acknowledged. This
research was supported by project MSM 6198959215
(Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports), Internal
Grant Agency of Palacký University in Olomouc (Czech
Republic) grants IGA PrF 2017_001, IGA PrF 2018_001
and IGA PrF 2019_004.
LITERATURE CITED
Abdel-Ghani A.H., Al-Ameiri N.S., Krajeh M.R., 2008.
Resistance of barley landraces and wild barley populations to powdery mildew in Jordan. Phytopathologia
Mediterranea 47: 92–97.
Abu-Blan H., Khalil M., 2001. Sources of primary inoculum and survival of powdery mildew (Uncinula necator) in Jordan. Dirasat Agricultural Sciences 28: 131–
137.
Al-Jaloudy M.A., 2006. Country Pasture/Forage Resource
Profiles. Jordan. FAO, Rome, Italy. 22 pp. (http://
www.fao.org/ag/agp/agpc/doc/counprof/jordan/jordan.htm; 20 October, 2017).
Braun U., 1995. The Powdery Mildews (Erysiphales) of
Europe. G. Fischer Verlag, Jena, Germany, 337 pp.
Braun U., Cook, R.T.A., 2012. Taxonomic Manual of the
Erysiphales (Powdery Mildews). CBS Biodiversity
Series No. 11: 1–707.
Cunnington J.H., Takamatsu S., Lawrie A.C., Pascoe I.G.,
2003. Molecular identification of anamorphic powdery mildew fungi. Australasian Plant Pathology 32:
421–428.
Durrieu G., Rostam S., 1984. Spécificité parasitaire et
systématique de quelques Leveillula (Erysiphaceae).
Cryptogamie, Mycologie 5(4): 279–292.
Edwards K., Johnstone C., Thompson C., 1991. A simple and rapid method for the preparation of plant
genomic DNA for PCR analysis. Nucleic Acids
Research 19: 1349.
El-Kazzaz M.K., Fadel F.M., El-Kewey S.A., Ghoniem
K.E., 1989. Survey and taxonomy of Erysiphaceae in
Egypt on the basis of conidial state. Egyptian Journal
of Phytopathology 21: 1–12.
Fanack Water Editorial Team, 2017. Geography, Climate
and Population of Jordan. (https://water.fanack.com/
jordan/geography-climate-population/; 24 October
2017).
Gardes M., Bruns T.D., 1993. ITS primers with enhanced
specificity for basidiomycetes – application to the
identification of mycorrhizae and rusts. Molecular
Ecology 2: 113–118.
Golovin P.N., 1956. Morfologiceskij obsor roda Leveillula
Arnaud (mucnisto-rosjanye 11 gribysem Erysiphaceae). Trudy Botaničeskogo Instituta im. V. L. Komarova, SSSR, ser II, 10: 193–308.
Heluta V.P., Simonyan S.A., 1987. On the role of anamorphic stage in determining of the intrageneric structure of Leveillula Arnaud. Biologicheskii Zhurnal
Armenii 40: 20–26. (in Russian)
Heluta V.P., Simonyan S.A., 1988. Two new species of the
genus Leveillula Arnaud of Armenia and Ukraine. Biologicheskii Zhurnal Armenii 41: 816–821. (in Russian)
Jaczewski A., 1927. Karmannyj opredelitel’ gribov, II.
Mučnisto-rosjanye griby. Mikol. Lab. Im. Prof. A. A.
Jaczewski, Gos. Inst. Opyt. Agron., Leningrad, USSR.
Kabaktepe Ş., Heluta V.P., Akata, I. 2015. Checklist of
powdery mildews (Erysiphales) in Turkey. Biological
Diversity and Conservation 8: 128–146.
Khodaparast S.A., Takamatsu, S., Hedjaroude G., 2001.
Phylogenetic structure of the genus Leveillula (Erysiphales: Erysiphaceae) inferred from the nucleotide
sequences of the rDNA ITS region with special reference to the L. taurica species complex. Mycological
Research 105: 909–918.
Khodaparast S.A., Hedjaroude, G.-A., Takamatsu, S.,
Braun, U., 2002. Three new species of the genus Leveillula from Iran. Mycoscience 43: 459–462.
Khodaparast S.A., Niinomi S., Takamatsu S., 2007.
Molecular and morphological characterization of
Leveillula (Ascomycota: Erysiphales) on monocotyledonous plants. Mycological Research 111: 673–679.
Khodaparast S.A., Abbasi M., Samadi S., Fathi F., 2010.
The genus Leveillula on Asteraceae in Iran. Iranian
Journal of Plant Pathology 46: 121–134.
Khodaparast S.A., Takamatsu S., Harada M., Abbasi M.,
Samadi S., 2012. Additional rDNA ITS sequences
and its phylogenetic consequences for the genus
Leveillula with emphasis on conidium morphology.
Mycological Progress 11: 741–752.
Leveillula lactucae-serriolae in Jordan
Khodaparast, S.A., Takamatsu S., Shadlou A., Damadi
M., Pirnia M., Jahani M., 2016. Notes on the genus
Leveillula (Erysiphaceae): a new unrecorded species
and notes on Leveillula infecting Ficus, Cucurbita and
Tropaeolum in Iran. Phytotaxa 260: 267–275.
Kumar S., Stetcher G., Tamura K., 2016. MEGA7: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis version 7.0 for
bigger datasets. Molecular Biology and Evolution 33:
1870–1874.
Lebeda A., Mieslerová B., 2011. Taxonomy, distribution
and biology of lettuce powdery mildew (Golovinomyces cichoracearum sensu stricto). Plant Pathology 60:
400–415.
Lebeda A., Mieslerová B., Doležalová I., Křistková E.,
2002. Occurrence of powdery mildew on Lactuca
viminea subsp. chondrilliflora in south France. Mycotaxon 84: 83–87.
Mansour A., Al-Banna L., Salem N., Alsmairat N., 2014.
Disease management of organic tomato under greenhouse conditions in the Jordan Valley. Crop Protection 60: 48–55.
Palti J., 1988. The Leveillula mildews. Botanical Review
54: 423–535.
Qasem S., Abu-Blan H., 1986. Powdery mildew fungi in
Jordan: Study of species and hosts. Disarat Agriculture Science 13: 121–133.
Rostam S., 1983. Biologie, écologie, systématique de
quelques Leveillula (Ascomycetes, Erysiphacées).
PhD Thesis, Université Paul Sabatier, Toulouse,
France, 137 pp.
Salmon E.S., 1900. Monograph of the Erysiphaceae. Bulletin Torrey Botanical Club 9.
Severoglu Z., Ozyigit, I.I., 2012. Powdery mildew disease
in some natural and exotic plants of Istanbul, Turkey.
Pakistan Journal of Botany 44: 387–393.
367
Shin H.D., 2000. Erysiphaceae of Korea. National Institute Agricultural Science and Technology, Suwon,
Korea, 320 pp.
Simonyan S.A., Heluta V.P, 1987. New taxons in the
genus Leveillula Arnaud (Erysiphaceae). Biologicheskii Zhurnal Armenii 40: 458–463.
Simonyan S.A., Heluta V.P., 1989. New species of powdery mildew fungus of the genus Leveillula Arnaud
on the spiderflower. Biologicheskii Zhurnal Armenii
42: 480–482.
Takamatsu S., Inagaki M., Niinomi S., Khodaparast S.A.,
Shin H.D., … Havrylenko M., 2008. Comprehensive
molecular phylogenetic analysis and evolution of the
genus Phyllactinia (Ascomycota: Erysiphales) and its
allied genera. Mycological Research 112: 299–315.
Takamatsu S., Matsuda S., Grigaliunaite B., 2013. Comprehensive phylogenetic analysis of the genus
Golovinomyces (Ascomycota: Erysiphales) reveals
close evolutionary relationships with its host plants.
Mycologia 105: 1135–1152.
Voytyuk S.O., Heluta V.P., Wasser S.P., Nevo E., Takamatsu S., 2009. Biodiversity of the Powdery Mildew Fungi
(Erysiphales, Ascomycota) of Israel. A.R.A. Gantner
Verlag K.-G., Ruggell, Germany, 290 pp.
White T.J., Bruns T., Lee S., Taylor J., 1990. Amplification and direct sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA
genes for phylogenetics. In: PCR Protocols: A Guide
to Methods and Applications (M.A. Innis, , D.H. Gelfand, J.J. Sninsky, T.J. White, ed.), San Diego, CA:
Academic Press Inc., San Diego, CA, USA, 315–322.
Xu B., Song J.G., He G., Lv M.F., Zhang L.L., Zhao Z.Y.,
2011. First report of powdery mildew of Hexinia
polydichotoma caused by Leveillula lactucae-serriolae
in China. Plant Disease 95: 879.