This article was downloaded by: [Texas A&M University]
On: 10 June 2009
Access details: Access Details: [subscription number 784375697]
Publisher Taylor & Francis
Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House,
37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK
Grana
Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t713648917
Palynological assessment of Holocene mangrove vegetation at the American
Memorial Park, Saipan, Northern Mariana Islands
David M. Jarzen a; David L. Dilcher a
Florida Museum of Natural History, Paleobotany and Palynology Laboratory, Gainesville, Florida, USA
a
Online Publication Date: 01 June 2009
To cite this Article Jarzen, David M. and Dilcher, David L.(2009)'Palynological assessment of Holocene mangrove vegetation at the
American Memorial Park, Saipan, Northern Mariana Islands',Grana,48:2,136 — 146
To link to this Article: DOI: 10.1080/00173130902797188
URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00173130902797188
PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE
Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.informaworld.com/terms-and-conditions-of-access.pdf
This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or
systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or
distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents
will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses
should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss,
actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly
or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
Grana, 2009; 48: 136–146
Palynological assessment of Holocene mangrove vegetation at the
American Memorial Park, Saipan, Northern Mariana Islands
SGRA
DAVID M. JARZEN & DAVID L. DILCHER
Palynology of the Holocene mangrove on Saipan, N. Mariana Is.
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
Paleobotany and Palynology Laboratory, Florida Museum of Natural History, Gainesville, Florida, USA
Abstract
Pollen and spores recovered from three cores of Holocene to recent deposits from the island of Saipan indicate the presence
of mangrove vegetation, including Bruguiera and Acrostichum, on the island previous to World War II. The occurrence of
Casuarina equisetifolia Linneaus 1759, from cores elsewhere on the island of Saipan, at depths predating the arrival of
humans to the island, suggest that this tree species is endemic to Saipan rather than a recent invasive species. These findings will assist in replanting native vegetation once destroyed through wartime activities on the island.
Keywords: Fungal spores, pteridophytes, angiosperms, Bruguiera, Rhizophora, Acrostichum, Casuarina
The American Memorial Park (15°12¢59” N
145°42¢52” E), located on the island of Saipan,
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands
(CNMI), was established in 1977 to honor American
and Marianas people who gave their lives during the
Marianas Campaign of World War II. As a “living
memorial”, the park offers activities such as baseball, bicycling, tennis, picnicking, and swimming.
Within the 133 acre boundary are beaches, sports
fields, picnic sites, boat marinas, playgrounds, and a
30 acre wetland and mangrove forest.
The United States National Park Service initiated
an assessment of the ecological status and function
of mangroves within the American Memorial Park
boundaries. Mangrove communities are important
ecosystems generally recognised as reducing the
effects of land-based pollution on coral reef ecosystems and in providing nursery habitats for coral reef
fishes and invertebrate organisms.
Pollen analysis was incorporated within this
assessment to determine the presence or absence of
several mangrove associate species at or near the site
of the AMP in the historical past. The aim of this
study is to determine through pollen analysis of samples from three sediment cores the occurrence of
Casuarina, and mangrove taxa at selected locations
in or near the American Memorial Park (AMP).
Pollen analysis may help in the determination of
which mangrove tree species are native to the island,
and which taxa have been introduced or lost due to
the activities of humans, especially as a result of the
military activities of World War II. In addition to the
mangrove taxa (e.g. Bruguiera, Rhizophora, Acrostichum)
the determination of the status of Casuarina as an
introduction by humans, or as a native plant, will
have important implications for managing mangrove
communities at the AMP in the future.
Geology and history of Saipan
Saipan is the capital of the Commonwealth of the
Northern Mariana Islands, located in the region of
Micronesia in the western Pacific Ocean at 15°N
and 146°E (Figure 1). It is about 1600 km south of
Japan, 2400 km east of the Philippines, and 200 km
north of the island of Guam. It is part of a string of
15 volcanic and raised coral islands forming a
roughly north-south trending chain, most of which
are uninhabited. Saipan is approximately 20 km
long and 9 km wide.
Correspondence: David M. Jarzen, Paleobotany & Palynology, Florida Museum of Natural History, University of Florida, Dickinson Hall, PO Box 117800,
Gainesville, FL 32611-7800, USA. E-mail: dmj@flmnh.ufl.edu
(Received 8 September 2008; accepted 4 February 2009)
ISSN 0017-3134 print/ISSN 1651-2049 online © 2009 Collegium Palynologicum Scandinavicum
DOI: 10.1080/00173130902797188
Palynology of the Holocene mangrove on Saipan, N. Mariana Is.
137
Marianas in honor of Mariana of Austria, widow of
Philip IV of Spain. The islands were sold by Spain to
Germany in 1899 and so remained under the German flag until the start of World War I in 1914 when
the Japanese moved against the German administration in the islands and forced them out.
The Japanese occupied the island of Saipan from
1914 to 1944 when American forces gained control of
the island in July, 1944 and began the construction of
bases and airfields. In July, 1947 the area was recognised as a Trust Territory by the United Nations. The
United States Navy, and later the Department of
Interior, became the administrator under the Trusteeship Agreement with the United Nations Organization. Today the Northern Marianas are a selfgoverning Commonwealth of the United States.
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
Material and methods
Figure 1. Map of the island of Saipan showing the location of the
American Memorial Park (AMP).
Saipan is the second largest of the Mariana
Islands (Guam is larger), with a land area of about
124 square kilometres. It consists of a volcanic core
(Eocene?) surrounded by younger limestones
(Cloud et al., 1956). In the area of the AMP, and
including most of the west border of Saipan, the terrain is low and termed the Western Coastal Plain.
This area is composed of loose and recently deposited calcium carbonate sands, and reworked volcanic
materials. The surface rises landward to heights
generally not exceeding six metres, but may reach
elevations up to 30 metres. Parts of the Western
Coastal Plain are marshy year round, while others
are seasonally wet.
The early history of Saipan and the Mariana
Islands is uncertain; however, it is believed that the
Islands were first settled around 3000 B.C. by an
ancient seafaring prehistoric people who journeyed
in outrigger canoes to various Pacific islands and
eventually lost these navigational skills.
Magellan sighted the islands in 1521 when he
made his landfall at Guam during his voyage to
establish a western route to the “Spice Islands”
(http://net.saipan.com/cftemplates/humanities/index.
cfm?pageID=2). He claimed the islands for Spain
and christened the archipelago “Las Isles de las
Velas Latinas” (The Islands of the Latine Sails)
because the triangular shape of the sails used on
native canoes were similar to those on Mediterranean vessels. In 1668 the name was changed to Las
Three cores (Sadog, 0 to 40 cm depth; TR3, 0 to 60
cm depth and TR5, 0 to 50 cm depth) were collected by J. Starmer in 2005 (Figure 2), and stored
at -82°C until thawed for palynological processing.
The three cores were sampled at the Florida
Museum of Natural History (FLMNH), by cutting
discs from the core length at specified depths from
the top of each core. Core sampling depths and
lithology for the cores are given below. In each of the
cores the deepest sample was taken at the limestone
beach sand deposits at the base of the core.
SADOG CORE: Total length of core 40 cm.
Sampled at 5.0, 15.0, 25.0 and 35.0 cm.
TR3 CORE: Total length of core 60 cm. Sampled at
5.0, 15.0, 25.0, 35.0, 45.0 and 55.0 cm.
TR5 CORE: Total length of core 50 cm. Sampled at
5.0, 15.0, 25.0, 35.0, and 45.0 cm.
Figure 2. Map of the American Memorial Park, showing the
location of core TR3, and TR5. The Sadog core is located
approximately 2 km to the north-east.
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
138
D. M. Jarzen and D. L. Dilcher
Cutting of the discs was done using a fine-toothed
Delta™ band saw. Care was taken to clean the saw
blade and table between each cutting interval, in
order to avoid contamination from previous cuts.
The cut discs were then dried in an oven, and sampled for approximately 2 cm3 and placed in 5%
KOH and heated to near boiling. All samples were
oxidised using 10% HNO3 followed by treatment in
5% NH4OH to remove humates. The samples were
stained in safranin-O. Four slides were prepared
from each sample, using glycerine jelly as a mounting medium, and sealed with clear nail polish.
Slides, residues and unused portions of the samples
are stored at the Paleobotany and Palynology Laboratory, Florida Museum of Natural History, Gainesville, Florida as locality UF 19093. Photography was
done using a Nikon Coolpix 4500™ digital camera,
mounted on a Leitz Dialux 20™ research microscope.
Location of illustrated specimens is given by reference to the Florida Museum of Natural History,
Paleobotany and Palynology Locality (UF number)
followed by a specimen number, along with a slide
number (PY1….PY…n). Stage coordinates are given
as horizontal x vertical, followed by the England Finder
Slide (EFS) location. Palynomorphs were identified
using published pollen floras of the Pacific region
including especially Cranwell (1953), Huang (1981),
Moar (1993), Selling (1946, 1947), and the Modern
Pollen and Spore Reference Collection of 7100 slides
at the Paleobotany and Palynology Laboratory,
Florida Museum of Natural History, Gainesville,
Florida. Measurements of palynomorphs are taken
from the specimens recovered from the cores.
Results
Tables I – III provide absolute counts for the taxa
recovered, including algae, fungal, pteridophyte
spores and angiosperm pollen. For the most part,
Cores TR3 and TR5 contain similar pollen and
spore taxa, while the Sadog Core is less diverse.
Appendix 1 lists the identified taxa recovered from
each of the three cores.
Descriptions and remarks are provided for the
pteridophyte spores and angiosperm pollen forms
identified to genus and in some cases to species.
Many other spores and angiosperm pollen remain
unidentified and will be the subject of further
research. Figure 3 illustrates the palynomorphs
described in this report, as well as some that are yet
to be described, and some selected fungal elements.
Pteridophyte spores
Genus Acrostichum Linneaus 1753. – Acrostichum
aureum Linneaus (Figure 3A).
Table I. Sadog core relative abundance of palynomorphs. Taxa
arranged alphabetically.
Depth in centimetres
Taxon
5.0
15.0
25.0
35.0
Acrostichum aureum
Amaranthaceae
Bruguiera gymnorrhiza
Carya sp.
Casuarina cf. C. equisetifolia
Cocos nucifera
Compositae
Cyathea sp. 1
Cyathea sp. 2
Cyperus sp.
Poaceae (Gramineae)
Hibiscus tiliaceus
Inaperturate thin walled
Lycopodiella cernua
Pandanus sp.
Polypodiaceae
Tricolpites sp. 1
Tricolpites sp. 2
Tricolpites sp. 3
Tricolporites sp. 1
Tricolporites sp. 2
Tricolporites sp. 3
Triporate P3
Trilete Unidentified
6
—
—
—
—
1
1
2
—
2
1
—
149
—
9
—
1
—
—
—
—
—
1
1
6
1
—
—
1
—
—
39
—
1
3
—
40
3
1
1
1
—
—
1
—
3
2
6
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Sub-total
Algal
Fungal spores & hyphae
Insect egg case?
Scolecodont
Foram test
Dinoflagellate
174
14
475
11
—
10
—
109
35
128
11
—
2
1
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Sub-total
510
177
TOTAL COUNT
684
286
P – present in sample but not encountered in counts.
Description. – Spore trilete, amb rounded triangular, lasurae extending 2/3 or slightly more of the
distance to the amb; surface granulate, with granules
near lasurae somewhat larger; spore wall 2 – 3 mm
thick, diameter of amb 42 (51) 61 mm (13 spores
measured).
Remarks. – These spores are often folded or split
making identification difficult. Acrostichum is a genus
of three species of marsh ferns distributed throughout the tropics, often associated with mangrove communities and opportunistic in disturbed estuarine
areas (Tomlinson, 1986). In the Northern Marianas
Acrostichum occurs in moist ravines and on wet banks
and swampy places, especially near mangrove communities (Fosberg et al., 1975). Acrostichum aureum
Palynology of the Holocene mangrove on Saipan, N. Mariana Is.
Table II. Core TR3 Relative abundance of palynomorphs. Taxa
arranged alphabetically.
Table III. Core TR5 relative abundance of palynomorphs. Taxa
arranged alphabetically.
Depth in centimetres
Depth in centimetres
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
Taxon
139
5.0 15.0 25.0 35.0 45.0 55.0
Taxon
5.0
15.0
25.0
35.0
45.0
Acrostichum aureum
Amaranthaceae
Bruguiera gymnorrhiza
Carya sp.
Casuarina cf. C. equisetifolia
Cocos nucifera
Compositae
Cyathea sp. 1
Cyathea sp. 2
Cyperus sp.
Poaceae (Gramineae)
Hibiscus tiliaceus
Inaperturate thin walled
Lycopodiella cernua
Pandanus sp.
Polypodiaceae
Tricolpites sp. 1
Tricolpites sp. 2
Tricolpites sp. 3
Tricolporites sp. 1
Tricolporites sp. 2
Tricolporites sp. 3
Triporate P3
Trilete Unidentified
P
P
—
16
64
—
2
11
P
P
2
P
73
—
1
3
1
—
1
—
—
P
146
1
—
1
7
—
P
2
1
25
—
2
3
—
42
1
1
2
2
—
—
—
—
—
10
1
3
—
12
P
3
4
—
3
—
P
1
1
62
5
P
3
1
—
—
—
2
1
4
4
—
1
—
1
—
13
—
—
—
—
2
—
78
—
3
6
—
—
—
1
—
—
3
2
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Acrostichum aureum
145
Amaranthaceae
P
Bruguiera gymnorrhiza
—
Carya sp.
P
Casuarina cf. C. equisetifolia
—
Cocos nucifera
2
Compositae
12
Cyathea sp. 1
27
Cyathea sp. 2
—
Cyperus sp.
2
Poaceae (Gramineae)
5
Hibiscus tiliaceus
—
Inaperturate thin walled
11
Lycopodiella cernua
—
Pandanus sp.
6
Polypodiaceae
5
Tricolpites sp. 1
1
Tricolpites sp. 2
P
Tricolpites sp. 3
—
Tricolporites sp. 1
—
Tricolporites sp. 2
—
Tricolporites sp. 3
—
Triporate P3
51
Trilete Unidentified
3
348
P
—
P
P
P
2
16
—
—
—
—
5
—
—
3
—
—
—
—
—
—
9
1
203
16
30
—
1
—
—
17
—
2
—
—
16
1
—
12
2
—
—
1
1
1
10
3
97
11
4
—
3
10
—
25
—
4
1
—
49
—
1
17
—
—
—
—
—
1
4
4
—
—
—
—
—
11
—
—
—
113
3
—
76
1
P
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
1
1
0
2
—
6
14
—
—
—
2
2
—
60
—
2
5
1
—
—
—
—
—
2
3
Sub-total
Algal
Fungal spores & hyphae
Insect egg case?
Scolecodont
Foram test
Dinoflagellate
270
7
22
—
—
—
1
384
1
11
P
—
—
—
316
90
98
3
—
—
—
231
91
124
9
4
—
—
205
300
65
1
2
—
—
100
300
30
9
—
—
—
Sub-total
Algal
Fungal spores & hyphae
Insect egg case?
Scolecodont
Foram test
Dinoflagellate
321
24
241
4
1
—
—
100
156
185
10
—
—
—
109
172
135
4
—
3
P
110
56
63
1
—
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
30
12
191
228
368
339
Sub-total
270
351
314
125
—
300
396
507
459
573
439
TOTAL COUNT
591
451
423
235
—
Sub-total
TOTAL COUNT
P – present in sample but not encountered in counts.
The sample at 45.0 cm is dominated by algal cells. Counts were
made of the algal and fungal, etc., separately.
P – present in sample but not encountered in counts.
The barren sample at 45.0 cm is a sandy sample near the bottom
of the core.
occurs today in the American Memorial Park
(Raulerson & Rinehart, 1989). In core TR3, Acrostichum spores are the dominant form, accounting for
up to 90% of the total palynomorph sum (Table II).
The high frequency of Acrostichum is suggestive of a
wetland or pond environment.
씮
Figure 3. Selected Holocene palynomorphs from the Saipan cores. A. Acrostichum aureum UF 19093-TR3A-2, PY01A, 23.6 ´ 95.3, EFS
U23/4. B. Cyathea sp. 1. UF 19093-TR3A-2, PY01A, 27.2 ´ 93.1, EFS ´27. C. Cyathea sp. 2. UF 19093-TR5, PY01A, 5.0 cm, 26.1 ´
111.4, EFS D26/1. D. Lycopodiella cernua UF 19093-TR3A-2, PY01A, 22.3 ´ 109.2, EFS F22. E. Cyperus sp. UF 19093-TR5, PY01A,
5.0 cm, 27.5 ´ 93.1, EFS W27/4. F. Cocos nucifera UF 19093-TR3A-2, PY01A, 16.3 ´ 98.3, EFS R16/3. G. Pandanus sp. UF 19093TR3A-3, PY01A, 28.0 ´ 93.0, EFS W28. H. Bruguiera sp. UF 19093-TR3, PY01A, 35 cm, 33.2 ´ 109.3, EFS F33. I. Bruguiera sp. UF
19093-TR5, PY01A, 15.0 cm, 34.4 ´ 106.0, EFS J34/4. J. Carya sp. UF 19093-TR5, PY01A, 5.0 cm, 25.5 ´ 107.0, EFS H25/4.
K. Casuarina equisetifolia UF 19093-TR3A-1, PY02, 31.5 ´ 95.7, EFS U31/2. L. Hibiscus sp. UF 19093-TR5, PY01A, 5.0 cm, 30.9 ´
107.7 EFS H31. M. Hibiscus tiliaceus UF 19093-TR5, PY01A, 5.0 cm, 43.0 ´ 101.4, EFS O43/2. N. Poaceae (Gramineae) UF 19093TR3, PY01A, 45 cm, 20.8 ´ 94.1, EFS V20/4. O. Tricolporites sp.1 UF 19093-TR3A-2, PY02A, 20.9 ´ 106.1, EFS J20/4. P. Triporicellaesporites sp. UF 19093-TR3A-1, PY03A, 25.3 ´ 99.1, EFS Q25/4. Q. Dictyosporites sp. UF 19093-TR3A-1, PY03A, 24.2 ´ 103.6, EFS
M24. R. Phragmothyrites sp. UF 19093-TR3A-1, PY01A, 42.0 ´ 112.3, EFS C42/2. S. Mediaverrunites sp. UF 19093-TR3A-1, PY01A,
34.2 ´ 99.2, EFS Q34/4. T. Palaeocirrenalia sp. UF 19093-TR5, PY01A, 25 cm, 41.4 ´ 109.4, EFS F41/2. U. Frasnacritetrus sp. UF
19093-TR5, PY01, 15.0 cm, 22.3 ´ 110.4, EFS E22. Scale bars – 30mm (A, B, D–F, H–K, O and S–U); 50 mm (C, L); 25 mm (G); 6 mm
(M); 20 mm (P); 75 mm (R).
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
140
D. M. Jarzen and D. L. Dilcher
Palynology of the Holocene mangrove on Saipan, N. Mariana Is.
Genus Cyathea Smith 1793. –
(Figure 3B).
Cyathea sp. 1.
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
Description. – Spore trilete, amb rounded triangular, lasurae extending half to 2/3 the distance to
amb; surface psilate; spore wall about 2 mm thick;
diameter of amb 30 (40) 57 mm (8 spores
measured).
Remarks. – Variations of spore size may indicate the
presence of more than one species. Cyathea spores
occur commonly in the core samples. In the Sadog
core, Cyathea sp. 1 spores account for 35% of the
pollen and spores recovered. About 620 species of
Cyathea occur in tropical and warm regions of the
world. The Northern Mariana Islands endemic,
Cyathea aramaganensis Kanehira, is a common treefern on high open volcanic slopes above the forest
limit. Cyathea has not been reported within the
AMP Boundaries (Raulerson & Rinehart, 1989).
Genus Cyathea Smith 1793. – Cyathea
(Figure 3C).
sp.
141
Monocotyledon pollen
Genus. – Cyperus Linneaus 1735. cf. Cyperus sp.
(Figure 3E).
Description. – Pollen grains free, rounded to tetrahedral in shape; four-aperturate, apertures poorly
defined thinned areas in the exine, with ragged or
torn margins; three apertures lateral with one aperture
basal; exine thin, about 1.0 mm; longest dimension
31 (37.6) 57 mm (10 grains measured).
Remarks. – The 300 species of the genus Cyperus
are found throughout tropical and warm temperate
regions of the world associated with marine and
freshwater habitats. Cf. Cyperus pollen occurs in all
cores, reaching a maximum abundance of 55% in
core TR3 at 45.0 cm (Table II).
Genus. – Cocos Linneaus 1753. Cocos nucifera
Linneaus 1753 (Figure 3F).
2
Description. – Spore trilete, amb rounded triangular, lasurae extending half to 2/3 the distance to amb;
proximal surface psilate, distal surface variously rugulate; spore wall about 2 mm thick; diameter of amb
76 (82) 87 mm (6 spores measured).
Remarks. – This form of Cyathea is very similar to
Cyathea sp. 1 but differs in the rugulate distal face and
is larger in size. One or two specimens are very similar
to the extant fern genus Cheilanthes Swartz 1806. Cyathea sp. 2 occurs in core TR5 at 5.0 cm (Table III).
Lycophyte spore
Genus. – Lycopodiella Holub 1964. Lycopodiella cf. L.
cernua (Linneaus) Pichi Sermolli 1968 (Figure 3D).
Synonym. – Lycopodium cernuum Linneaus 1753.
Description. – Spore trilete, amb rounded triangular,
lasurae extending 2/3 or more of the distance to amb;
proximal surface psilate, distal surface rugulate; spore
wall about 1.4 mm thick; diameter of amb 26 (32) 38
mm (7 spores measured).
Remarks. – Lycopodiella is a genus of 40 species of
clubmosses (Lycophyta) distributed throughout moist
temperate and tropical environments. Lycopodium
cernuum occurs on the Northern Mariana Islands
often on lava or ash in open places (Fosberg et al.,
1975). Spores of Lycopodiella are infrequent to rare
in all cores.
Description. – Pollen grains free, monosulcate, sulcus extending nearly the full length of the long axis
of the grain, sulcus margin thickened and sinuous;
surface scabrate to granulate; exine two-layered 2.5
mm thick; longest dimension 49 (73.3) 106 mm (11
grains measured).
Remarks. – The large size and nature of the aperture
margins are comparable with pollen of Cocos nucifera
Linneaus 1753. The coconut palm is nearly ubiquitous throughout tropical coastlines of the world.
Cocos pollen occurs in nearly all samples in cores
TR3 and TR5. It is rare to absent in the Sadog core.
Genus. – Pandanus S. Parkinson 1773. Pandanus sp.
(Figure 3G).
Description. – Pollen grain free, spherical; monoporate, pore small often difficult to distinguish, circular; surface echinate, spines small 1.0 mm or less in
height; exine thin, about 1.5 mm thick; size 19 (25.5)
34 mm (15 grains measured).
Remarks. – Pollen of Pandanus is very distinctive and
is not easily confused with other monoporate, echinate grains (Jarzen, 1983). Pandanus is a large genus
of 700 or possibly more species distributed throughout the Old World tropics (Mabberley, 1997). Pandanus tectorius Parkinson ex J. P. du Roi 1774 (Screw
Pine) occurs on all islands in the Northern Marianas
(Fosberg et al., 1975) and within the park boundaries
of the AMP (Raulerson & Rinehart, 1989). The trees
are usually insect pollinated; however, Cox (1990)
considers P. tectorius, a coastal pandan, to be wind
142
D. M. Jarzen and D. L. Dilcher
pollinated, with the male inflorescences producing
copious amounts of dry pollen that are easily transported through frequent coastal air movements. Pandanus pollen occurs in low numbers, infrequently in
nearly all Saipan core samples.
Dicotyledon pollen
Genus. – Bruguiera Savatier 1798. Bruguiera sp.
(Figure 3H,I).
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
Description. – Pollen grains free, tricolporate, colpi
short extending only half the distance to the poles;
surface psilate to very finely scabrate; exine about
1.0 mm thick; diameter in polar view 15 (19) 23 mm
(10 grains measured).
Remarks. – Bruguiera (family Rhizophoraceae)
comprises six species distributed in east Africa and
the Pacific. B. gymnorrhiza (Linnaeus) Savatier
1798, the mangle lahi, is a mangrove tree abundant
within the park boundaries of the AMP (Raulerson
& Rinehart, 1989), but is rare or does not occur on
the smaller islands to the north of Saipan (Fosberg
et al., 1975). Bruguiera pollen occurs in cores TR5
and TR3, where it accounts for 9.5% of the relative
abundance of all pollen and spores (Table II).
Genus. – Carya Nuttall 1818. Carya sp. (Figure 3J).
Description. – Pollen grains free, outline more or
less circular to subcircular; triporate, pores circular
and situated off the equator onto one hemisphere
only, pore diameter 2.0 – 2.5 mm, about 5.0 mm
inside of the equator; surface psilate to finely granulate, some specimens show a thinning of the exine in
the polar regions; exine of uniform thickness, 1.5 –
2.0 mm; 34 (42) 49 mm.
Remarks. – It is odd that Carya pollen should occur
in the Saipan core samples; however, the trees of
Carya may have been or are still present today on
the island as an introduced cultivated species (R. M.
Bourke pers. comm., 30 September 2006). There is
a possibility of contamination during processing of
the samples; however, this is unlikely as this pollen
occurs in several samples from both TR3 and TR5
cores, processed on separate occasions. Carya
reaches a relative abundance of 5% in sample 5.0
cm of core TR5 (Table III).
Pecan nut [Carya illinoinensis (Wangenh) K.
Koch] has been introduced to Papua New Guinea
and several fruit-bearing trees have been noted
growing at 1400 – 1600 m on a plantation and a
research station (Aiyura) in Eastern Highlands
Province (Bourke, in press).
Genus. – Casuarina Linneaus 1759. Casuarina equisetifolia Linneaus 1759 (Figure 3K).
Description. – Pollen grains free, shape in polar view
circular to rounded triangular; triporate, pores
somewhat protruding, 2.5 – 3.5 mm diameter; surface psilate; exine two-layered, 2.0 – 2.5 mm thick;
size 23 (26.6) 34 mm (13 grains measured).
Remarks. – The 17 species of the genus Casuarina
occur from southeast Asia through the western
Pacific islands. Casuarina equisetifolia has been introduced to many tropical and subtropical coasts
throughout the world. Determination of its indigenous range is often very difficult to discern. Pollen of
Casuarina equisetifolia occurs with varying frequency
in all cores. It is most frequent in core TR5 at 5.0
cm. where it reaches a relative abundance of 20%
(Table III). The pollen is distinctive and not easily
confused with other Saipan pollen forms.
Genus. – Hibiscus Linneaus 1737. Hibiscus sp.
Linneaus 1753 (Figure 3L,M).
Description. – Pollen grains free, spherical, multiaperturate; apertures are pores, distributed evenly over
surface of grain, 9 – 10 mm diameter; surface echinate, spines 10 – 12 mm high; diameter 114 (148)
171 mm (3 grains measured).
Remarks. – The 300 species of Hibiscus are distributed throughout the tropical to warm temperate
regions of the world. The pollen recovered from the
Saipan samples is comparable to H. tiliaceus, a small
tree common along edges of freshwater swamps and
channels. Hibiscus tiliaceus is a pantropical species
(Moore et al., 1977). Pollen of Hibiscus sp. occurs
rarely and only in core TR5 at the 5.0 and 25.0 cm
levels (Table III).
Discussion
The presence of Acrostichum spores, often in very high
relative numbers, indicates a bog or marsh conditions (Athens & Ward, 1998). The ferns are understorey plants common in mangrove communities
and other wetland forests. The fronds of Acrostichum
aureum are long, measuring 1.2 – 1.8 metres in height
and are as broad as they are tall. The sporangia are
borne on the underside of the fertile fronds and
often cover the surface completely.
Considering the size and height of the fronds, the
spores of Acrostichum are probably carried for some
distance from the parent plant. The abundance of
Acrostichum spores in some of the core samples, especially TR3 at 15.0 and 25.0 cm, may reach as high as
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
Palynology of the Holocene mangrove on Saipan, N. Mariana Is.
90% relative frequency, indicating that those samples
may represent an Acrostichum-dense environment. The
ferns are aggressive and tend to become weedy in disturbed sites. In Vietnam this fern has suppressed the
regrowth of mangrove tree species that were destroyed
by military activity (Tomlinson, 1986, p. 314).
Athens and Ward (2004) note that although
Acrostichum is today common along some shorelines
on Saipan, it was not recorded in their pollen counts
of the modern flora, suggesting a much degraded
landscape from that represented in older sediments
which contain abundant Acrostichum spores.
Two distinctly different spore forms referable to
the extant genus Cyathea were recovered from
many of the samples. Cyathea sp.1 has a smooth
spore wall and is typical of several species of
Cyathea. The second species referable to Cyathea
has a regulate sculpture on the distal face of the
spore, and frequently measures somewhat larger
than Cyathea sp. 1.
The 620 species of Cyathea are tree ferns growing to
heights of 20 m or more, and distributed throughout
the tropics and warm regions of the world (Mabberley,
1997). C. aramaganensis Kanehira 1934 occurs in the
Northern Mariana Islands, but not on Saipan (Fosberg
et al., 1975). Athens and Ward (2005) reported Cyathea pollen in low numbers from only a few samples in
the core material from Lake Susupe. Cyathea tree ferns
were not reported in the extant flora from Saipan as
recorded by Moore et al. (1977).
The presence of Cyathea pollen in relative frequencies from 1% to 35% in the cores from the
AMP is interesting in that it shows an earlier presence
of the genus, but provides little ecological information other than supporting a tropical climate.
Palm pollen occurs in all samples from the cores.
Cocos nucifera, the Coconut palm, has distinctive,
rather large monosulcate pollen that is easily recognizable. Cocos nucifera pollen was recovered by Athens and Ward (2005) from core samples taken from
Lake Susupe, in sediments dated at 7800 years BP.
This occurrence suggests that Cocos nucifera is native to
Saipan and not introduced by humans who first came
to the islands in 4800 BP (Athens & Ward, 2005).
Pandanus pollen is identified by its monoporate,
densely spinate (echinate) surface. Pandanus occurs
in a variety of habitats from near sea level to montane
environments. Although never abundant, it occurs
in all cores. Most pandans are insect pollinated and
as such the pollen recovered from the cores may not
reflect the abundance of the parent plants.
The pollen of Casuarina occurs in varying frequency
in all three cores collected from Saipan. In the core
TR5, at the 5.0 cm level, it is one of the most frequent
palynomorph encountered (Table III). Casuarina equisetifolia, the Australian Pine, is an angiosperm tree
143
with elongate needle-like leaves, and cone-like fruiting
structures. These characters suggested to some botanists that the tree resembled those of the pine family.
Casuarina trees are found on nearly all tropical and
subtropical coastlines around the world. Casuarina is
native to south-east Asia and many islands of the western Pacific Ocean (Mabberley, 1997).
The pollen of Casuarina equisetifolia is triporate,
psilate (smooth) or very finely granulate and shows a
thickening around the pore margins providing a protruding appearance of the pores. The pollen is
present in most samples of the cores from the AMP.
These cores, however, do not provide sediment
dated as far back as the first arrival of humans. The
work of Athens and Ward (2004) from cored sediments does provide the necessary depth and age
control to conclude that the pollen of Casuarina
extends back at least to 8000 years BP, predating the
arrival of humans at 4300 years BP. The arrival of
Casuarina to Saipan and possibly other islands of the
South Pacific is probably the result of bird transport
(D. W. Steadman, pers. comm., 2008).
Mangroves play an important role in the ecology of
tropical islands. These communities comprise a variety of taxa, dependent upon their location in the new
world or old world tropics. Species of Rhizophora are
often associated with tropical coastlines; and indeed
the Northern Mariana Islands, including Saipan, once
were home to species of Rhizophora trees (Athens &
Ward, 1998, 2004, 2005). Rhizophora no longer
occurs on Saipan; instead it has been replaced by Bruguiera gymnorrhiza, another member of the mangrove
family Rhizophoraceae (Moore et al., 1977).
Bruguiera gymnorrhiza trees are evergreen, reach
a height of 30 m, and display buttressing of the
trunk (Tomlinson, 1986). Mangrove trees are
nearly exclusively animal pollinated, although there
is some evidence of wind pollination in Rhizophora
(Tomlinson, 1986). In Bruguiera gymnorrhiza, the
flowers are conspicuous and recurved back toward
the main axis of the tree, facilitating pollination by
birds (Davey, 1975), recently identified as two
species of honeyeaters (Kondo et al., 1991).
Through the activity of perching birds, the pollen
is literally thrown onto the head of the visiting
bird, and carried to another flower (Tomlinson,
1986). This efficient method of pollination probably leaves little pollen to be incorporated into the
mangrove sediments. The highest relative frequency
of Bruguiera pollen recovered from the Saipan
cores is from core TR3, sample 25.0 cm, where it
reaches 9.5% (Table II), and may be explained
through pollen “outwashing” (Graham, 1976), or
the entry of normally zoophillous pollen in sediments due to the action of heavy rainfall in tropical
environments.
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
144
D. M. Jarzen and D. L. Dilcher
Hibiscus tiliaceous, the Pago or Sea-Hibiscus, is a
small tree, with smooth grey bark, and long petioled
leaves. It is a member of the family Malvaceae, the
cotton family. The pantropical species is common
along the edges of freshwater swamps and river
channels (Moore et al., 1977). Pollen of the Malvaceae
is usually large and ornamented with large spines or
echinae. Pollen comparable to Hibiscus tiliaceous occurs
rarely in core TR5, at depths of 5.0 and 25.0 cm.
Pollen of the Poaceae (Gramineae) occur in all cores
in varying amounts (Tables I – III). The pollen is characteristically spherical, psilate, and with a single annulate pore (Figure 3N). The pollen of most grasses is
wind borne, making ecological interpretations difficult.
Several angiosperm pollen grains, as yet not formally described, were recovered from the cores (see
Tables I – III). A tricolporate, finely reticulate undescribed form is illustrated in Figure 3O.
Fungal elements including spores, fructifications
and mycelia are present in all core samples. In addition to the common fungal elements recovered, algal
cysts, insect eggs, scolecodonts, microforaminifer
tests and dinoflagellate cysts were also identified and
counted. These components often account for the
majority of palynomorphs present. See for example
core TR3 samples at 45.0 and 55.0 cm levels where
the algae alone account for 52 to 89% of all palynomorphs encountered in the counts. These high
percentages are probably due to specific circumstances of deposition that favoured the accumulation
of algal or fungal spores or mycelia, etc. The diversity
of the fungal element (Figure 3P–U) requires further
investigation and may prove helpful in elucidating
environmental conditions at the time of sedimentation. Such investigations are beyond the purpose of
this study.
Conclusions
Future work must include the identification of the
angiosperm pollen forms described here as morphotypes (e.g. Tricolpites, Tricolporites), or those
described only to family level (e.g., Poaceae, etc.).
Often identification to an extant genus is possible
through the careful microscopic comparison with a
reference pollen collection made from the plants living within a specific geographic region. In this case a
reference collection of pollen from plants growing
today on the Northern Mariana Islands and specifically on Saipan would provide adequate material for
future identifications. A survey of the vascular plants
growing today at the AMP lists 128 species, 10% of
which are ferns, with no gymnosperms present
(Raulerson & Rinehart, 1989). Even a small reference collection of these 128 species of angiosperms
and ferns would form the basis for a modest
comparative collection. The reference collection of
the Paleobotany and Palynology Laboratory at the
Florida Museum of Natural History comprises about
7100 prepared slides of pollen or spores of plants
from around the world. The species in the collection
are predominately tropical, especially from southeast Asia and Australasia. Representation of pollen
and spores from plants of the Pacific islands is not
strong, and that from the Marianas is nearly wanting.
Regardless of these limitations, pollen and spores of
the major common forms were available for comparison and identification.
The palynomorphs recovered and identified from
cores taken from the American Memorial Park,
Saipan, Northern Marianas, represent a part of the
terrestrial vegetation cover at and surrounding the
core sites from the Holocene to the present. The
occurrence of Casuarina equisetifolia (Australian
Pine) at depths predating the arrival of humans
(Athens & Ward, 2004) to the island suggest that
this tree species is endemic to Saipan. Rhizophora
pollen was not recovered from the cores; however,
Bruguiera gymnorrhiza pollen and the fern Acrostichum aureum, were identified, and indicate the
presence of mangrove vegetation at the core sites
during the Holocene. Future work must consider
the identification of several additional angiosperm
pollen taxa that may prove helpful in an elucidation
of the paleoenvironment of the island during the last
several millennia.
Acknowledgements
Appreciation is expressed to John Starmer for the
collection of surface and core samples from
Saipan. We thank the United States National Park
Service for financial support of the project. Susan
Jarzen helped with manuscript preparation and
some laboratory preparation. Nathan Bruce and
Pat Bennett of the FLMNH are thanked for their
expertise and courtesy in cutting samples from the
frozen core material. Lisa Wade and Harry Luther
of Marie Selby Botanical Gardens (Sarasota, Florida) allowed me to collect fresh pollen of Cocos
nucifera, and Scott Zona at the Fairchild Tropical
Gardens (Miami, Florida) provided information
and pollen of Cocos nucifera. We thank Owen
Davis (University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona)
and Mark Brenner (University of Florida) for valuable advice on sampling and processing procedures of Holocene material. Rona IkeharaQuebral, International Archaeological Research
Institute, Inc., Honolulu, HI, assisted in obtaining
United States Navy Reports on Saipan. We especially thank J. Stephen Athens (International
Archaeological Research Institute, Inc.) for
Palynology of the Holocene mangrove on Saipan, N. Mariana Is.
supplying important papers and reports regarding
the paleoenvironment of Saipan. Mike Bourke
provided comments on the status of pecan on
Saipan. We thank Vaughn Bryant Jr. and an anonymous reviewer for their improvements to the
manuscript. We especially thank David Cantrill
for his careful editorial skills and advice.
Tricolporate sp. 3
Amaranthaceae
Hibiscus tiliaceus
Sadog Core
Fungal
Frasnacritetrus sp.
Fusiformisporites sp.
Mediaverrunites sp.
Palaeocirrenalia sp.
Palaeomycites sp.
Appendix 1. Palynomorph composition for
Saipan cores
Core TR3
Spores
Acrosticum aureum
Cyathea sp.
Lycopodiella cernua
Polypodiaceae
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
Fungal
Frasnacritetrus sp.
Fusiformisporites sp.
Mediaverrunites sp.
Palaeocirrenalia sp.
Palaeomycites sp.
Phragmothyrites sp.
Scoleosporites sp.
Spores
Acrostichum aureum
Cyathea sp.
Lycopodiella cernua
Polypodiaceae
Pollen
Inaperturate thin-walled
Cyperus sp.
Poaceae (Gramineae)
Pandanus sp.
Cocos nucifera
Triporate unidentified
Carya sp.
Casuarina sp. cf. C. equisetifolia
Bruguiera gymnorrhiza
Asteraceae (Compositae)
Tricolporate sp.2
Amaranthaceae
Core TR5
Fungal
Frasnacritetrus sp.
Fusiformisporites sp.
Palaeocirrenalia sp.
Palaeomycites sp.
Spores
Cyathea sp.
Lycopodiella cernua
Pollen
Inaperturate thin-walled
Cyperus sp.
Poaceae (Gramineae)
Pandanus sp.
Cocos nucifera
Triporate unidentified
Carya sp.
Casuarina sp. cf. C. equisetifolia
Tricolpites sp. 3
Bruguiera gymnorrhiza
Compositae
145
Pollen
Inaperturate thin-walled
Poaceae (Gramineae)
Pandanus sp.
Cocos nucifera
Casuarina sp. cf. C. equisetifolia
References
Athens, J. S. & Ward, J. V. (1998). Paleoenvironment and prehistoric landscape change: A sediment core record from Lake Hagoi,
Tinian, CNMI. Report prepared for the Department of the
Navy, Pacific Division. Honolulu, HI: Int. Archael. Inst. Inc.
Athens, J. S. & Ward, J. V. (2004). Holocene vegetation, savanna
origins and human settlement of Guam. Rec. Aust. Mus.
Suppl., 29, 15-30.
Athens J. S., & Ward J. V. (2005). Holocene paleoenvironment of
Saipan: Analysis of a core from Lake Susupe. Prepared for Division of Historic Preservation, Department of Community and
Cultural Affairs CNMI, Saipan.
Bourke, R. M. (2005). Indigenous edible nuts in Papua New
Guinea. Paper presented at Papua New Guinea Fruit and Nut
Workshop, University of Vudal, (http://www.icuc-iwmi.org/files/
Publications/Bourke).
Cloud, P. E. Jr., Schmidt, R. G. & Burke, H. W. (1956). Geology
of Saipan, Mariana Islands, Part 1. General Geology. USGS
Prof. Pap. 280-A.
Cox, P. A. (1990). Pollination and the evolution of breeding systems in Pandanaceae. Ann. Mo. Bot. Gard., 77, 816–840.
Cranwell, L. M. (1953). New Zealand pollen studies. The
monocotyledons: A comparative account. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard Univ. Press. Auckland Inst. Mus. Bull. No. 3.
Davey, J. E. (1975). Notes on the mechanism of pollen release in
Bruguiera gymnorrhiza. S. Afr. J. Bot., 41, 269–272.
Fosberg, F. R., Falanruw, M. V. C. & Sachet, M.-H. (1975).
Vascular flora of the Northern Marianas Islands. Smithson.
Contrib. Bot. 22.
Graham, A. (1976). Late Cenozoic evolution of tropical lowland
vegetation in Veracruz, Mexico. Evolution, 29, 723–735.
Huang, T. (1981). Spore flora of Taiwan. Taipei: Bot. Dept. Press
Taiwan Natl Univ.
Jarzen, D. M. (1983). The fossil pollen record of the Pandanaceae.
Gard. Bull. Singapore, 36, 163–175.
Kondo, K., Nakamura, T., Piyakarnchana, T. & Mechvichai, W.
(1991). Pollination in Bruguiera gymnorrhiza (Rhizophoraceae) in Miyara River, Ishigaki, Island, Japan, and Phangnga,
Thailand. Plant Species Biol., 6, 105–109.
146
D. M. Jarzen and D. L. Dilcher
Downloaded By: [Texas A&M University] At: 01:55 10 June 2009
Mabberley, D. J. (1997). The plant-book. Cambridge: Cambridge
Univ. Press.
Moar, N. T. (1993). Pollen grains of New Zealand
dicotyledonous plants (p. 200). Canterbury: Maanaki Whenua
Press.
Moore, P., Raulerson, L., Chernin, M. & McMakin, P.
(1977). Inventory and mapping of wetland vegetation in
Guam, Tinian and Saipan, Mariana Islands. Prep. US
Army Corps Eng. Pacific O. Div. Fort Schafter.
Mangilao, Guam: BioSci Publ. UOG. Contr. No.
DACW84-76-C-0038.
Raulerson, L. & Rinehart, A. (1989). Vegetation of American
Memorial Park Saipan, Mariana Islands. Manoa, HI: Univ.
Hawaii/Natl. Park Serv. Techn. Rep. 70.
Selling, O. H. (1946). Studies in Hawaiian pollen statistics: Part I, The
spores of the Hawaiian Pteridophytes. Göteborg, Sweden/Honolulu, HI: Bishop Mus. B. P. Bishop Mus. Sp. Publ. 37.
Selling, O. H. (1947). Studies in Hawaiian pollen statistics: Part II,
The pollens of the Hawaiian Phanerogams. Göteborg, Sweden/
Honolulu, HI: Bishop Mus. B. P. Bishop Mus. Sp. Publ. 38.
Tomlinson, P. B. (1986). The botany of mangroves. Cambridge:
Cambridge Univ. Press.