127
Mycological Progress 2(2): 127–136, May 2003
Caloplaca erodens [sect. Pyrenodesmia], a new lichen species from
Italy with an unusual thallus type
Mauro TRETIACH1,*, Daniela PINNA2, and Martin GRUBE3
Caloplaca erodens is a new species of sect. Pyrenodesmia, characterised by an orbicular, sorediate, bluish-grey thallus
which is endolithic but emerges at the periphery with a white, K-, obscurely lobate prothallus. The species is frequent on
calcareous outcrops and walls of isolated churches and ruins of the Central Apennines (Sibillini, Gran Sasso), where it may
occur in large monospecific populations, from 1000 to 2500 m asl., and is also known from dry sites of the southern Alps.
It has been found with apothecia only in the type locality, being predominantly sterile. The reproduction of this lichen is
evidently linked to the release of fragments of clusters of photobiont cells and mycobiont hyphae which are continuously
exposed with the dissolution of the substratum. Readily distinguished from the apparently similar endolithic C. alociza
(which is characterised by numerous apothecia, black, K+ purple prothallus, and esorediate thallus), C. erodens probably
belongs to the C. circumalbata complex, whose taxa are always epilithic but have a white, K- prothallus. The phylogenetic position of the new species within sect. Pyrenodesmia as inferred by ITS sequences of the nuclear ribosomal DNA is
shortly discussed.
Taxonomic novelty: Caloplaca erodens Tretiach, Pinna et Grube
T
he growth of endolithic lichens on stone monuments
is a problem which, despite its frequency, has been
considered only in the last decades by researchers
working on cultural heritage conservation (ASCASO & WIERZCHOS 1995, BLÁZQUEZ, CALVET & VENDRELL 1995, CARBALLAL et al. 2001, EDWARDS et al. 1994). As these organisms
are actively involved in the weathering processes of the substratum (BACHMANN 1919, FRY 1922, DOPPELBAUR 1959,
GEHRMANN-JANSSEN 1995, PINNA, SALVADORI & TRETIACH
1998), studies on their anatomy and ecology are providing important information to solve conservation problems (PINNA &
SALVADORI 2000). In the present work, however, the novelty
consists in the discovery of a new species, which was previously
unnoticed probably because it is almost always sterile.
In 1990 the second author was asked to identify a bluishgrey crust which covered the facade and the perimetre walls
of the sanctuary of Macereto (Visso, Mts. Sibillini, Central
Italy; Fig. 1), at that time undergoing a restoration managed
by Ministry for Cultural Heritage. Interestingly, the crust was
observed only on the church and nearby buildings, not on the
Dipartimento di Biologia, Università di Trieste, Via Giorgieri 10, I34127 Trieste, Italy.
2 Soprintendenza per il Patrimonio Storico-Artistico, Via Belle Arti 56,
I-40126 Bologna, Italy.
3 Institut für Botanik, Karl-Franzens-Universität Graz, Holteigasse 6,
A-8010 Graz, Austria.
* Corresponding author: Prof. Dr Mauro Tretiach, Dipartimento di
Biologia, Via L. Giorgieri 10, I-34127 Trieste, Italy. Phone: +39 040
558 3886; fax +39 040 568 855. E-mail: tretiach@univ.trieste.it
1
surrounding natural outcrops, although they are of the same
rock type as the walls: a massive calcarenite (Grillini, Pinna
& Rossi Manaresi, unpubl.). For obvious reasons, only a limited quantity of material could be sampled. A first series of
laboratory examinations showed that the “crust”, consisting
of clusters of green algae surrounded by inflated, appressed
hyphae with a grey, K+ violet pigment, belonged to a sterile
lichen. PINNA & SALVADORI (2000) demonstrated the strong,
harmful deteriorative capability of this organism, able to dissolve the stone at the centre of its thallus for a depth of several
millimeters and forming, with ageing, confluent, moniliform
depressions. The restorers removed the lichen from the church
almost completely, but in the meantime the authors collected it – unfortunately always in sterile conditions – in several
localities in central Italy, mainly on the walls of isolated churches and ruins. Only once was a single, badly developed,
black, K+ violet apothecium found, containing a few, abortive
polar-diblastic spores, and therefore the connection of this
lichen to Caloplaca sect. Pyrenodesmia could be made (TRETIACH & PINNA 2000). Unfortunately, no permanent slides
were prepared, and the comparison with other taxa of this section remained based on a few hand-written notes. In summer
2001, a very large population of this lichen was found on some
natural outcrops of Mt. Sirente, and five fertile thalli were
collected. All together, only c. fifty apothecia were counted,
most of them sterile, but enough, however, to compare their
carpological and sporological characters with those of additional taxa of Caloplaca sect. Pyrenodesmia studied in the
meantime. It became evident that the lichen, found also in dry
© DGfM 2003
128
Caloplaca erodens sp. nova
Tab. 1. Specimens sequenced in this study, their locality data and Genbank accession numbers
Species
Specimen
Caloplaca alociza
Caloplaca alociza
Slovenia, Sneznik, SE Mali Sneznik, 04.10.1997, leg. A. Wilfling [3417] and U. Arup (GZU).
Slovenia, Sneznik, W of the peak, 04.10.1997, leg. A. Wilfling [3642] and U. Arup (GZU).
AY313973
AY313972
Caloplaca chalybaea
Italy, Campania, between M. Porco and M. La Gallinola, 16.4.2000, leg. P.L. Nimis and
M. Tretiach (TSB 32110).
Austria, Styria, Niedere Tauern, Planneralm, 13.9.1993, leg. A. Wilfling [318] and
Möslinger (GZU).
Italy, Marche, Sibillini Mts., 6.6.1999, leg. M. Tretiach (TSB 30970).
Austria, Steirisches Randgebirge, Stubalpe, Wölkerkogel, 13.08.1993, leg. A. Wilfling
[2323] (GZU).
AY313975
Caloplaca chalybaea
Caloplaca chalybaea
Caloplaca chalybaea
Genbank Nr.
AY313970
AY313974
AY313971
Caloplaca erodens
Italy, Abruzzo, prov. L’Aquila, Rovere, 23.6.2001, leg. M. Tretiach and D. Pinna (isotype, GZU).
AY313977
Caloplaca obscurella
Caloplaca obscurella
Italy, Campania, Passo di Miralago, 15.4.2000, leg. P.L. Nimis and M. Tretiach (TSB 32037).
Italy, Marche, Lago di Fiastra, 10.8.1999, leg. P.L. Nimis (TSB 31133).
AY313977
AY313976
Caloplaca peliophylla
Mexico, Baja California Norte, Guadalupe Island, 4.1.1996, leg. C.M. Wetmore
[75893] (GZU).
AY313965
Caloplaca variabilis
Caloplaca variabilis
Italia, Valle d’Aosta, Passo del Piccolo S. Bernardo, 9.1997, leg. P.L. Nimis (TSB 29427).
Russia, Lake Baikal, mouth of river Sharma, on moss (!), 19.7.1997, leg. P.L. Nimis
and M. Tretiach (TSB 28963).
Crete, Nom. Rethimnio, Agia Galini, 16.5.1997, leg. H. Mayrhofer [13809] and Ertl (GZU).
Italy, Molise, Monti del Matese, 16.4. 2000, leg. P.L. Nimis and M. Tretiach (TSB 32594).
AY313966
AY313967
Caloplaca variabilis
Caloplaca variabilis
sites of the southern Alps, differs notably from the other species of Pyrenodesmia exhaustively treated in a monograph by
WUNDER (1974). Its formal description is provided below, together with some critical notes on some other taxa of the same
section.
Material and methods
Specimens collected by the authors and preserved in TSB
and further material, obtained on loan from G, GZU, L, M,
MOD, NAP, RO, UPS, VER, W, WU (acronyms of herbaria
according to HOLMGREN, HOLMGREN & BARNETT 1990),
were studied.
Measurements were made on hand cut sections and squash
preparations mounted in glycerine or in water. Ascospores,
hamathecial filaments and other structures were measured at
1000x magnification. Measurements are given as: (mean-SD)
- mean - (mean+SD) (max.). Permanent slides, mounted in
glycerin or lactophenol-cotton blue (after treatment with 1 M
HCl) according to VOLKMANN-KOHLMEYER & KOHLMEYER
(1996), are preserved in the collection of the senior author.
A Zeiss Axioplan compound microscope was used for micrographs of squashes and hand-made sections of ascomata, and
a digital photocamera for habit photographs.
Polished cross-sections of colonised rocks were obtained
after embedding the samples in a polyester resin (New Basic).
They were stained with Periodic Acid Schiff (PAS), according to WHITLACH & JOHNSON (1974), and with ortho-toluidine-blue, and observed under stereo- and reflecting microscopes. For habit photographs, samples were sputter-coated
with gold under vacuum using an Edwards Sputter Coater
© DGfM 2003
AY313969
AY313968
S150B, and investigated with a scanning electron microscope
(SEM) (Philips SEM 505).
The morphology of hyphae was observed in samples
treated with 1 M HCl, in order to dissolve the calcareous rock,
and washed several times in tap water. The resulting biomass
was stained with lactophenol-cotton blue, mounted in glycerin and observed with the optical microscope.
The standardised method of thin layer chromatography
(TLC) (e.g. CULBERSON & AMMANN 1979) was employed
for checking the presence of lichen substances; three solvent
systems (A, C, and G) were used.
An investigation of the phylogenetic position of the new
species was carried out using ITS sequences of the nuclear
ribosomal DNA. Approximately 5 x 5 mm of the thallus of
the new species was scraped off the rock for DNA-isolation
according to the protocol of CUBERO et al. (1999). A horizontal
section (c. 50 x 50 x 20 µm) of the hymenia of all other species studied in sect. Pyrenodesmia was used directly for PCR,
except in Caloplaca peliophylla where a fragment of the thallus was used. PCR and sequencing followed ARUP & GRUBE
(1999), and the alignment was produced automatically using
BioEdit 5.0.6 (HALL 1999). The specimens used for molecular analyses are presented with their Genbank numbers in
Tab. 1. For the following species, additional sequences were
retrieved from Genbank and added to the alignment: Caloplaca demissa (AF353962, AF353960), C. cerina (AF353960),
C. chlorina (AF353959), C. variabilis (AF353963). Caloplaca cerina and C. chlorina were used as outgroups for the subsequent phylogenetic analyses.
The phylogenetic hypothesis was constructed using a
Bayesian approach as implemented in the program MrBayes
(HUELSENBECK & RONQUIST 2001). The general time rever-
129
Mycological Progress 2(2) / 2003
sible substitution model with among-site variation (GTR + γ,
rates for variable site were drawn from a gamma distribution
with 4 discrete categories) was used for likelihood calculations. The Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analysis was
run for 1000000 generations, with 4 chains starting from a
random tree, and using the default temperature of 0.2. Every
hundredth tree was sampled, while the first 50000 generations
were discarded as burn-in. A consensus phylogram based on
mean branch lengths was calculated with the sumt command.
The tree with posterior probabilities of topologies higher than
50 % is presented in Fig. 18.
Nomenclature of lichens follows NIMIS (2000).
Taxa studied for comparison
Caloplaca circumalbata (Delile) Wunder var. circumalbata: EGYPT,
„In deserto aegypt. Wadi Cherese“, leg. G. Schweinfurth (M - isotype of Blastenia melanocarpa Müll. Arg.). Ibid., Wadi Nehich, leg.
G. Schweinfurth (M). Ibid., Wadi Na-umieh, leg. G. Schweinfurth
(M). Ibid., Gebel Cheschen, leg. G. Schweinfurth (M). „Ad saxa calcarea deserti prope Bir Ammam“, leg. G. Ehrenberg (G - lectotype
of Callopisma aegyptiacum γ depauperatum Müll. Arg.). „Basse
Egypte“, Mars 1880, leg. W. Barbey (G - holotype of Callopisma interveniens Müll. Arg.). – TUNISIA, NW of Gafsa, Djebel ben Younes, 270–300 m, 18.04.1968, leg. J. Poelt, det. H. Wunder (GZU).
Road Sbeitla-Sfax, near Faid, 16 km W of Sidi-Bou-Zid, 18.04.1968,
leg. J. Poelt, det. H. Wunder (GZU). – GREECE, Rhodi, S of Rhodi, 2,5 km N of Phaliraki, 20 m, 08.09.1983, leg. J. Poelt (GZU). –
Caloplaca circumalbata var. candida (Stiz.) Wunder: SPAIN, Almeria, Serra Alhamilla, S of Nijar (25 km NE of Almeria), 02.08.1969,
leg. H. Hertel, det. H. Wunder (M). Greece, Agina island, coast near
Agia Marina, 15.04.1971, leg. J. Poelt, det. H. Wunder (GZU). Attika, near Atene, Likavito, Lykabettos, 04.04.1971, leg. J. Poelt, det. H.
Wunder (GZU). Ibid., Imittos, NW of the monastery of Kesariani,
05.06.1971, leg. J. Poelt, det. H. Wunder (GZU). Tunisia, 3 km SW
Thibar, 12.04.1968, leg. J. Poelt, det. H. Wunder (GZU). – Caloplaca
alociza (A. Massal.) Migula: ITALY, Ad saxa in op. Avesa (M. Ongarine), s.d., leg. A. Massalongo (VER - lectotype of Biatorina alociza A. Massal.). – GERMANY, „An umherliegenden Steinen bei
Obereichstätt“, leg. F. Arnold (M, lectotype of C. variabilis f. acrustacea Müll. Arg.). Jena, Mühltal, IX.1860, leg. Ahles (L - lectotype
of Catillaria fraudulenta Körb.). Jura, „Jachhausen oberhalb Riedenburg im Altmühltal, VIII.1858, leg. F. Arnold (M - holotype of Biatorina albopruinosa Arnold). Croatia, „Gravosa“, s.d., leg. Weis (L - lectotype of Blastenia paragoga Körb.). – GREECE, Epirus, PeristeriSpitze, 2290 m, s.d., leg. E.V. Halacsy (holotype of C. intercedens
(Trevis.) Steiner in Halacsy var. albomarginata Steiner in Halacsy).
Results
Caloplaca erodens Tretiach, Pinna et Grube sp. nova
Figs. 1-16
hoc loco
Thallus crustaceus, pro maxima parte endolithicus, in parte centrali
sorediatus, griseocaeruleus vel violaceus, depressus, prothallo albido, epilithico, obscure lobato, ad 0.8 mm lato limitatus, algas virides
cellulis 13.4–15.7–18.0(23.0) µm in diametro continens. Soralia diffusa sorediis griseis, K+ violaceis, N+ violaceis, C+ rubro-violaceis,
c. 43–56–69(75) µm in diametro. Apothecia rarissima, sessilia, c.
0.2–0.25–0.3(0.4) mm in diametro, disco griseocaeruleo vel nigro,
sparse pruinoso; margo thallinus evolutus, albidus, algas continens.
Hymenium ad 50–60 µm altum, hyalinum; hypothecium incolore.
Paraphyses simplices vel parce ramosae, laxae, saepe capitatae, apicibus usque ad 4–5 µm latis, pigmento griseo tectis, K+ violaceo, N+
violaceo, C+ rubro-violaceo. Asci (4)6–8-spori, clavati, typi „Teloschistes“ dicti. Ascosporae hyalinae, polardiblasticae, ellipsoideae,
10–11–12(19) x 6–7–8(9) µm, septo 3–4(5) µm longo. Conidiomata
ignota.
Ad saxa calcarea vel dolomiticola Italiae Peninsularis et Alpium
Citeriorum.
Caloplaca alociza similis, sed ab ea differt thallo sorediato prelunque sterili et margine albido, K-.
Typus: Italia, Abruzzo, prov. L’Aquila, Rovere, 1440 m,
massi calcarei presso la rocca diroccata, frequentissima e con
apoteci, 23.06.2001, M. Tretiach & D. Pinna. Holotype (TSB
34131), Isotypes (GZU, M, UPS, herb. D. Pinna), further sterile isotypes will be distributed in a forthcoming fascicle of A.
Vezda’s Lichenes rariores exsiccati).
Additional specimens examined
ITALY, Abruzzo, Prov. L’Aquila, Gran Sasso, below Corno Piccolo, 2350 m asl., dolomite, 09.08.1996, leg. P.L. Nimis and M. Tretiach (TSB 24708); below Rocca di Cambio, S. Lucia Abbey, c.
1300 m asl., limestone, 23.06.01, leg. M. Tretiach and D. Pinna (TSB
34129); Rocca di Mezzo, bell tower, 1280 m asl., limestone,
23.06.01, leg. M. Tretiach and D. Pinna (TSB 34130); Rocca Calascio, near the castle, 1400–1450 m asl., 06.04.1997, leg. P.L. Nimis
and M. Tretiach (TSB 26368); Ovindoli, loc. Rovere, c. 1400 m asl.,
limestone, 15.07.1994, leg. D. Pinna (TSB 19755, 28640). Marche,
Prov. Macerata, sanctuary of Macereto (Visso), c. 1000 m asl., calcarenite, 16.04.1994, leg. D. Pinna and M. Tretiach (TSB 31268);
ibid. 06.06.1999, leg. M. Tretiach and D. Pinna (TSB 34937); road
between Visso and Passo di Gualdo, Castelsantángelo, below Gualdo, ruins of a small church, c. 1000 m asl., 06.06.1999, leg. M. Tretiach and D. Pinna (TSB 34936). Piedmont, Prov. Cuneo, Alpi Cozie, ridge SE above Colle Valcavera, ca. 2470 m asl., limestone,
23.07.00, leg. P.L. Nimis and M. Tretiach (TSB 34524, 34527). Trentino, Prov. Trento, M. Bondone, Dosso d’Abramo, 2040 m asl.,
10.2002, leg. J. Nascimbene (TSB 35420). Valle d’Aosta, Prov.
Aosta, Monte Bianco (Mont Blanc) group, Val Veny W of Courmayeur, ridge W above Rifugio E. Soldini, ca. 2250 m asl., boulders
of Jurassic limestone, 30. 07. 2001, leg. M. Tretiach (TSB 35422).
Umbria, Prov. Perugia, Val Castoriana, church of S. Salvatore, c. 700
m asl., 06.06.1999, M. Tretiach and D. Pinna (not collected). Veneto, Prov. Vicenza, M. Grappa, Città di Roccia, 1600 m asl., 10.2002,
leg. J. Nascimbene (TSB 35421). Prov. Belluno, M. Faverghera, Botanical Garden, 1550 m asl., 08.10.2002, leg. J. Nascimbene (TSB
35419, CLU).
Thallus crustose, orbicular, up to 6–8 cm diam. (Fig. 2), in
the central part euendolithic (sensu GOLUBIC, FRIEDMAN &
SCHNEIDER 1981), ecorticate, sorediate, bluish-grey to violaceous, depressed, delimited at the periphery by a whitish, K-,
epilithic, obscurely lobate prothallus, c. 0.25–0.50(0.80) mm
thick (Figs. 4,7). Photobiont green, protococcoid, cells 13.4–
15.7–18.0(23) µm diam (n=50). Soralia diffuse on the thallus
surface, consisting of grey, K+ violaceous soredia, c. 43–56–
69(75) µm diam (Fig. 15), formed by small, irregular clusters
of photobiont cells surrounded by appressed, inflated hyphal
cells, c. 6–7(8) x 4–5 µm (Fig. 16), which emerge from the
rock surface (Fig. 8). Ascomata apothecia, extremely rare,
© DGfM 2003
130
slightly pruinose, marginate (Fig. 6), often irregularly shaped
or immature (Fig. 5), up to c. 0.2–0.25–0.3(0.4) mm diam.;
disc bluish-grey to almost black, thalline margin present
(Fig. 9). Exciple distinct, thick, coherent in K, formed by
strands of hyphae with irregularly ellipsoidal cells; outer part
of the exciple dark grey or grey-green, inner part of the exciple with minute crystals persisting in N. Hymenium up to
60–70 µm high, I+ strongly blue. Hypothecium hyaline.
Hamathecium of paraphyses, generally simple or slightly
branched, apices swollen, up to 4–5 µm diam., pigmented as
the outer part of the excipulum (Figs. 11,12). Asci (4)6–8-spored, clavate, Teloschistes-type (Fig. 13). Ascospores hyaline,
polardiblastic, non-halonate, ellipsoid, 10–11–12(19) x 6–
7.0–8(9) µm (n = 39; 20 apothecia examined) (Figs. 10, 14).
Conidiomata unknown.
Chemistry
Grey, acetone-insoluble pigment of epithecium, outer layer of
excipulum and exposed parts of thallus K+ violaceous, C+
red-violet, N+ vivid violaceous (Sedifolia-grey sensu MEYER
& PRINTZEN 2000: 581). No lichen substances detected by TLC.
Etymology
The epithet refers to the noteworthy deteriorative capability
of this lichen.
Ecology and distribution
The new species is found in rather dry sites, at altitudes between 1000 and 2500 m asl., in the montane and subalpine
belts of Apennines and southern Alps (Fig. 17). In some of
these localities, Caloplaca erodens is relatively frequent, growing on subvertical surfaces of sunny rock walls and boulders
of limestone and dolomite. Phytosociological relevés carried
out in sites where C. erodens was particularly common are reported in Tab. 2. The lichen is frequently associated with common crustose epi- or endolithic species such as Acarospora
glaucocarpa, Aspicilia calcarea, Caloplaca saxicola, Candelariella aurella, Diplotomma epipolium, Lecanora crenularia, L. muralis, Rinodina immersa, and R. bischoffii. This
community looks like a mosaic of yellow-orange (C. saxicola, C. flavescens), bluish-grey (C. erodens) and light grey
(heavily pruinose thalli of Lecanora muralis and Diplotomma
epipolium) spots. However, C. erodens often forms almost
Caloplaca erodens sp. nova
monospecific populations. At higher altitudes, the species was
found with C. coccinea and Xanthoria elegans.
Caloplaca erodens should be looked for in the calcareous
districts of other xerothermic valleys elsewhere in the Alps
and in the montane belt of the Mediterranean region.
Critical remarks
The thallus organisation of Caloplaca erodens in cross section differs considerably from that of other endolithic lichens
studied so far by the authors (PINNA, SALVADORI & TRETIACH
1998, TRETIACH & MODENESI 1999). In those organisms the
photobiont cells typically form small, irregular, solitary clusters arranged in bores formed by dissolution of the rock, and
are covered by an „outer layer“ of more or less densely conglutinated hyphae, often embedded by small crystals of
CaCO3 („lithocortex“ sensu PINNA, SALVADORI & TRETIACH
1998; see also DOPPELBAUR 1959, Abb. 1). In C. erodens this
„outer layer“ is absent, and the clusters of photobiont cells and
appressed, inflated hyphae, emerge directly from the substratum (Figs. 8, 15); being pigmented, they give to the thallus a
typical bluish-grey to violaceous colour, certainly unusual
among endolithic lichens.
When it became evident that the crust on the facade of the
sanctuary of Macereto was actually the thallus of a lichen, we
considered that it might belong to a trivial endolithic species
whose unusual morphology was caused by some chemicalphysical peculiarities of calcarenite: with its dissolution, the
upper thallus layer would be continuously exposed and lost,
thus delaying sexual maturity and causing the formation of
the typical depression of the central, older part of the lichen.
However, in a subsequent survey, we observed on the same
rock other lichens with „normal“ endolithic thalli growing side
by side with our lichen (e.g. Rinodina immersa, R. bischoffii: see relevés of Tab. 2), and emerging as islets from the surrounding thalli of C. erodens (as the Verrucuria sp. of Fig. 3).
We concluded therefore that calcarenite has only a limited influence on the morphology of our lichen. Furthermore, with
the discovery of samples occurring on other rocks (for instance
the hard, compact, crystalline limestone at the sites in Piedmont and Aosta Valley), it became evident that the dissolving
of the rock is related to the strong deteriorative capability of
this lichen more than to the chemical-physical properties of
the substratum, as already suggested by PINNA & SALVADORI
(2000). A strong dissolution of the rock, coupled by the ab-
Figs. 1-8. Caloplaca erodens. Lichen communities with Caloplaca erodens (Figs. 1-2): on the left column of the entrance to
the sanctuary of Macereto, where the species was observed for the first time (Fig. 1), and on a calcareous outcrop in the type locality (Fig. 2); the species is recognisable by the characteristic white prothallus. Large thallus surrounding an emerging Verrucaria sp. colonized by C. polycarpa (arrowhead) (Fig. 3; photo: J. Nascimbene). Closer view of two orbicular thalli (Fig. 4, isotype). Young (Fig. 5) and mature (Fig. 6) apothecia (holotype); the erosion of the substratum is visible. Fingerprint left by two
died thalli on the rock (Fig. 7). Polished cross section showing clusters of algae intermingled with hyphae emerging from the substratum (Fig. 8). Scale bar = 5 cm (Fig. 2), 12 mm (Fig. 3), 8 mm (Fig. 4), 0.5 mm (Fig. 5), 0.3 mm (Figs. 6-7), 0.1 mm (Fig. 8).
© DGfM 2003
Mycological Progress 2(1) / 2003
131
© DGfM 2003
132
© DGfM 2003
Caloplaca erodens sp. nova
133
Mycological Progress 2(1) / 2003
Nr. relevé
Exposure
Area (sq. dm)
Cover (%)
height above ground (cm)
Caloplaca erodens
Caloplaca saxicola
Aspicilia calcarea
Lecanora crenularia
Rinodina immersa
Candelariella aurella
Diplotomma epipolium
Lecanora muralis
Candelariella medians
Caloplaca polycarpa
Caloplaca flavescens
Kiliasia athallina
Rinodina dubyana
Caloplaca arenaria
Caloplaca erythrocarpa
Lecania turicensis
Rinodina bischoffi
Physcia adscendens
Verrucaria fuscula
Aspicilia radiosa
Lecanora agardhiana
Acarospora fuscata
Caloplaca velana
Xanthoria elegans
Caloplaca variabilis
Placocarpus schaereri
1
SW
12
50
20
2
WSW
3
90
60
3
WSW
5
90
70
4
WSW
5
60
70
5
SW
16
80
150
6
WSW
4
75
120
7
WSW
4
95
50
8
S
2
95
60
9
SE
6
70
40
10
SE
5
90
80
11
S
6
95
80
12
S
6
85
120
2
+
1
3
+
1
+
3
2
+
+
+
+
+
1
1
2
+
+
4
r
2
+
r
+
r
r
1
3
r
r
3
+
2
4
3
+
+
+
+
+
r
+
+
+
2
+
+
1
+
1
+
+
+
+
1
+
r
+
+
+
frequency
Tab. 2. Phytosociological relevés of lichen communities dominated by Caloplaca erodens
V
IV
IV
IV
III
III
III
III
1
+
+
+
+
r
+
+
+
r
+
1
+
+
r
+
+
+
+
r
+
+
+
+
r
r
+
+
1
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Localities of relevés: 1–5: walls of the sanctuary of Macereto, 1000 m; 6–7: ruins of small church near Gualdo, 1000 m; 8, 10–12: Rovere, calcareous outcrops, 1440 m; 9: Sibillini Mts.; between Sassotetto and Bolognola, calcareous outcrops, 1350 m.
Other species frequently observed with Caloplaca erodens: C. cirrochroa and C. inconnexa (Rocca Calascio); C. decipiens (church of S. Salvatore, valle Castoriana); Tephromela atra var. calcarea and Lecanora sulphurea (Rovere).
sence of a true lithocortex sensu PINNA, SALVADORI & TRETIACH (1998), is occasionally observed also in some forms of
C. alociza (WUNDER [1974: 46] efficaciously wrote: „[…] die
Gesteinsoberfläche an solchen Stellen porös verändert, wie
aufgetrieben.“), with the difference that in this case the depression, in the form of a deep furrow, is formed at the periphery of the thallus („thallus […] profunde decussatus“: JATTA
1910: 400; see also MASSALONGO 1855: 42). These forms of
C. alociza are always richly fertile (and esorediate), and therefore the „neothenic“ hypothesis explaining the low fertility of
C. erodens can be probably rejected.
Reproductive biology
Caloplaca erodens is almost always sterile. Pycnidia are unknown and the apothecia of the few fertile thalli collected so
far are often badly developed, with most producing abortive
or irregularly shaped spores. Notwithstanding this, the lichen
colonises large surfaces (as in the case of the facade of the
sanctuary of Macereto and at the type locality), forming monospecific populations, probably due to very effective vegetative reproduction. The most obvious means is via clusters
of algae surrounded by hyphae that protrude from the substratum and are presumably detached when the calcite crystals
Figs. 9-16. Anatomical features of Caloplaca erodens (holotype). Margin of apothecium with algae in the excipulum (Fig. 9).
Immature spores (Fig. 10). Tips of paraphyses (Fig. 11). Single paraphysis (Fig. 12). Young ascus (Fig. 13). Mature spores (Fig.
14). Closer view of the algal clusters of Fig. 8 (Fig. 15). Photobiont cell surrounded by inflated hyphae, stained by LPCB
(Fig. 16). Scale bar = 50 µm (Fig. 9), 20 µm (Fig. 15), 10 µm (Figs. 10-13, 16).
© DGfM 2003
134
are progressively dissolved. It may be questioned if these
structures, rather irregular in size and shape, are to be considered true soredia, i.e. symbiotic propagules which derive
from the proliferation of both algal and medullary layers (BÜDEL & SCHEIDDEGER 1996), or parasoredia, which are formed
from clumps of disintegrating cortical and photobiont material (see CODOGNO, POELT & PUNTILLO 1989). C. erodens
seems to be the first endolithic lichen known to reproduce in
this way.
Systematic remarks
Within sect. Pyrenodesmia, only two endolithic species were
accepted by WUNDER (1974), Caloplaca alociza and C. cretensis. A third taxon, C. agardhiana, related to C. alociza and
considered by WUNDER (1974) to be a synonym of the latter,
has been considered by many authors to be a further good species, characterised by the absence of crystals in the hymenium
(see e.g. CLAUZADE & ROUX 1985). All these taxa typically
occur on hard limestone and dolomite in exposed sites.
Caloplaca cretensis is well-characterised by the yelloworange crystals, reacting K+ purplish-red, deposited in the
epipsamma, which are intermingled with, and often obscured
by the dark, K+ violet pigments typical of the Pyrenodesmia
group (WUNDER 1974, MEYER & PRINTZEN 2000). Although
mostly coastal, at least in Italy (NIMIS & TRETIACH 1999), this
species also may form an epilithic thallus and is evidently not
closely related to our taxon.
The euendolithic C. alociza, considered by ROUX (1981)
to be a characteristic species of Verrucarietalia parmigerae
associations, is frequently found in open habitats from the warmest regions of southern Scandinavia (SANTESSON 1993) to
the Mediterranean zone where it is particularly common
(WUNDER 1974). It usually has a black, K+ purple prothallus
and numerous pycnidia, more frequent along the thallus margin, and epruinose to heavily pruinose apothecia. In this species, the peripheral part of the thallus often forms a furrow, as
in many other euendolithic lichens (see PINNA, SALVADORI
& TRETIACH 1998, TRETIACH & MODENESI 1999), and does
not show the characteristic depression in the central part of the
thallus, typical of C. erodens. For many years, the authors of
this paper wrongly considered the latter taxon as an aberrant
form of C. alociza s.lat. and therefore studied the large collections filed under this name in GZU (85 specimens), MOD
(15), NAP (3), and TSB (68). However, we never found any
specimens with the characters of C. erodens, or even intermediate forms, although it is not unequivocally dismissed that
some of the specimens of C. alociza „à thalle violacé“ cited
by ROUX (1981) might belong to C. erodens. In our opinion,
the relatives of the new species should be searched for in an
other group of sect. Pyrenodesmia, the so-called C. circumalbata complex (WUNDER 1974), which has a more southern
distribution, being frequent in the Southern Mediterranean
basin and the Middle East, and reaching the innermost regions
of Afghanistan (WUNDER 1974: 60). Caloplaca circumalbata,
characterised by a usually well-developed, white prothallus
© DGfM 2003
Caloplaca erodens sp. nova
(from which its specific epithet derives), comprises at least
four varieties, none of which, however, have a hemi- or euendolithic growth-form. When searching for available names,
we examined the type material of some taxa referred by WUNDER (1974) to C. circumalbata because some of the features
reported in their original diagnosis accord with those of C. erodens, namely the „poorly developed“ or „endolithic“ thallus
(e.g. Blastenia melanocarpa Müll. Arg., Callopisma aegyptiacum γ depauperatum Müll. Arg., C. interveniens Müll. Arg.,
Caloplaca aegyptiaca var. circinans Steiner). However, we
agree with WUNDER (1974) that these taxa are only aberrant
forms of C. circumalbata resulting from damage caused by
animals or wind-borne sand grains, and are of no taxonomic
value.
The type material of C. agardhiana var. granuligera, a taxon described by STEINER (1919) from Santorini (Greece), and
possibly related to our lichen, could not be traced in W (U.
Passauer, pers. comm.).
Caloplaca ayachina, described by Werner within sect. Pyrenodesmia in the same year of Wunder’s monograph, has an
epilithic thallus and different spores (WERNER 1974).
These observations are partly confirmed by the results of
the phylogenetic analysis shown in Fig. 18. The consensus
tree indicates that C. erodens can be a member of sect. Pyrenodesmia. Using C. cerina and C. chlorina as outgroups, Caloplaca demissa turns out at a basal position in sect. Pyrenodesmia. Caloplaca obscurella, a corticolous, sorediate species is
here the sister clade of a number of rock inhabiting species. In
our analysis, the sequence of the type specimen of C. erodens
is clearly supported at the base of this group, without indication that it would form a monophyletic group with C. alociza.
The thallus growth-form does not correlate with the results
obtained with the analysis of ITS sequences. In fact, the crustose epilithic C. chalybaea and the euendolithic C. alociza,
which are well supported as groups, are nested in a group that
also includes the crustose C. variabilis and C. peliophylla, a
North American species with lobulate thalli (WETMORE 1994).
Caloplaca variabilis, a highly polymorphic species (CLAUZADE & ROUX 1985), is genetically heterogeneous, and probably consists of several taxa, which might deserve to be treated at specific rank. From this analysis it seems clear, however,
that C. erodens is outside the large complex of C. variabilis,
and thus the previous hypothesis that the relatives of the new
species should be searched for in the C. circumalbata complex is supported. Unfortunately, no fresh material of C. circumalbata was available for this study, and therefore the relationship between C. erodens and the latter species remains
to be ascertained.
Acknowledgements
We are in debts with several fellow lichenologists who helped
us in several ways during these years. U. Arup, J. Hafellner,
H. Mayrhofer, P. Navarro-Rosinés, P.L. Nimis, C. Roux, C.
135
Mycological Progress 2(1) / 2003
Wetmore, and the late J. Poelt kindly examined sterile specimens of the new species, and discussed with the senior author
possible relationships. The curators of GZU, G, L, M, MOD,
NAP, RO, UPS, VER, W, WU, and J. Nascimbene are thanked for sending material in their care. We are grateful to J. Hafellner and C. Roux for providing rare literature and reading
critically the manuscript, and to G. Kantvilas for improving
the language. This study was partially funded by M.I.U.R. to
P.L. Nimis (project „Una rete di banche-dati sulla Biodiversità delle Crittogame terrestri d’Italia“).
References
ARUP U, GRUBE M (1999) Where does Lecanora demissa (Ascomycota, Lecanorales) belong? – Lichenologist 31: 419-430.
ASCASO C, WIERZCHOS J (1995) Study of the biodeterioration zone
between the lichen thallus and the substrate. – Cryptogamic
Botany 5: 270-281.
BACHMANN E (1919) Der Thallus der Kalkflechten. III. – Nova Acta
Leopoldina 100: 1-80.
BLÁZQUEZ F, CALVET F, VENDRELL M (1995) Lichenic alteration and
mineralization in calcareous monuments of northeastern
Spain. – Geomicrobiology Journal 13: 223-247.
Fig. 17. Distribution of Caloplaca erodens
BÜDEL B, SCHEIDEGGER C (1996) Thallus morphology and anatomy.
In Nash TH, III (ed) Lichen Biology, pp. 37-64. Cambridge
University Press Cambridge.
CARBALLAL R, PAZ-BERMÚDEZ G, SÁNCHEZ-BIEZMA MJ, PRIETO B
(2001) Lichen colonization of coastal churches in Galicia: biodeterioration implications. – International Biodeterioration
and Biodegradation 47: 157-163.
CLAUZADE G, ROUX C (1985) Likenoj de Okcidenta Europo. Ilustrita
Determinlibro. – Bulletin de la Société Botanique du CentreOuest, N. Ser., No. Spec. 7: 3-893.
CODOGNO M, POELT J, PUNTILLO D (1989) Umbilicaria freyi spec.
nova und der Formenkreis von Umbilicaria hirsuta in Europa
(Lichenes, Umbilicariaceae). – Plant Systematics and Evolution 165: 55-69.
CUBERO OF, CRESPO A, FATEHI J, BRIDGE PD (1999) DNA extraction and PCR amplification method suitable for fresh, herbarium-stored, lichenized, and other fungi. – Plant Systematics
and Evolution 216: 243-249.
CULBERSON CF, AMMANN K (1979) Standard-methode zur Dünnschicht-chromatographie von Flechtensubstanzen. – Herzogia 5: 1-24.
DOPPELBAUR HW (1959) - Studien zur Anatomie und Entwicklungsgeschichte einiger endolithischen pyrenocarpen Flechten. –
Planta 53: 246-292.
EDWARDS HGM, EDWARDS KAE, FARWELL DW, LEWIS IR, SEAWARD MRD (1994) An approach to stone and fresco lichen biodeterioration through fourier transform raman microscopic investigation of thallus-substratum encrustations. – Journal of
Raman Spectroscopy 25: 99-103.
FRY EJ (1922) Some types of endolithic lichens. – Annals of Botany
36: 541-562.
Fig. 18. Consensus tree obtained from the Bayesian analysis
of ITS sequences. Posterior probablities are shown at the nodes
GEHRMANN-JANSSEN CK (1995) On the biopitting corrosion by epilithic and endolithic lichens on carbonate rocks - biophysical
and biochemical weathering aspects. PhD Thesis, University
of Oldenburg.
© DGfM 2003
136
GOLUBIC S, FRIEDMAN I, SCHNEIDER J (1981) The lithobiontic ecological niche, with special reference to micro-organisms. –
Journal of Sedimentary Petrology 51: 475-478.
HALL TA (1999) BioEdit: a user-friendly biological sequence alignment editor and analysis program for Windows 95/98/NT. –
Nuclear Acids Symposium Series 41: 95-98.
HOLMGREN PK, HOLMGREN NH, BARNETT LC (1990) Index Herbariorum Part I: The Herbaria of the World. 8th edn. Regnum
Vegetabile 120. New York Botanical Garden, New York.
HUELSENBECK JP, RONQUIST F (2001) MrBayes: Bayesian inference
of phylogenetic trees. – Bioinformatics 17: 754-755.
JATTA A (1910) Flora Italica Cryptogama. Pars III: Lichenes. Fasciculus III. Cappelli, Rocca di S. Casciano, pp. 265-460.
MASSALONGO A (1855) Symmicta Lichenum novorum vel minus
cognitorum. Typis Antonellianis, Veronae.
MEYER B, PRINTZEN C (2000) Proposal for a standardized nomenclature and characterization of insoluble lichen pigments. –
Lichenologist 32: 571-583.
NIMIS PL (2000) Checklist of the Lichens of Italy 2.0. University of
Trieste, Dept. of Biology, IN2.0/2 (http://dbiodbs.univ.trieste.
it/).
NIMIS PL, TRETIACH M (1999) Itinera Adriatica - Lichens from the
eastern part of the Italian Peninsula. – Studia Geobotanica 18:
51-106.
PINNA D, SALVADORI O (2000) Endolithic lichens and conservation:
an underestimate question. In Fassina V (ed) Proceedings of
the 9th International Congress on Deterioration and Conservation of Stone, pp. 513-519.
PINNA D, SALVADORI O , TRETIACH M (1998) An anatomical investigation of endolithic lichens from the Trieste Karst (NE
Italy). – Plant Biosystems 132: 183-195.
ROUX C (1981) Étude écologique et phytosociologique des peuplements liquéniques saxicoles-calcicoles du Sud-Est de la
France. – Bibliotheca Lichenologica 15: 3-557.
© DGfM 2003
Caloplaca erodens sp. nova
SANTESSON R (1993) The lichens and lichenicolous fungi of Sweden
and Norway. SBT, Lund.
STEINER J (1919) Beiträge zur Kenntnis der Flora Griechenlands.
Bearbeitung der anlässlich der zweiten Wiener Universitätsreise im April 1911 in Griechenland gesammelten Pflanzen C. Lichenes. – Verhandlungen der zoologisch-botanischen
Gesellschaft in Wien 69: 52-101.
TRETIACH M, MODENESI P (1999) Critical notes on the lichen genus
Encephalographa A. Massal. (?Hysteriaceae). – Nova Hedwigia 68: 527-544.
TRETIACH M, PINNA D (2000) Considerazioni critiche su un taxon
endolitico di Caloplaca sect. Pyrenodesmia a distribuzione
appenninica. – Notiziario della Società Lichenologica Italiana 13: 21.
VOLKMANN-KOHLMEYER B, KOHLMEYER J (1996) How to prepare
truly permanent microscope slides. – Mycologist 10: 107108.
WERNER RG (1974) Mission scientifique dans le Grand Atlas marocain oriental. – Bulletin de l’académie et de la société lorraines des sciences 13: 55-70.
WETMORE CM (1994) The lichen genus Caloplaca in North and
Central America with brown or black apothecia. – Mycologia
86: 813-838.
WHITLACH RB, JOHNSON RG (1974) Methods for staining organic
matter in marine sediments. – Journal of Sedimentology and
Petrography 44: 1310-1312.
WUNDER H (1974) Schwarzfrüchtige, saxicole Sippen der Gattung
Caloplaca (Lichenes, Teloschistaceae) in Mitteleuropa, dem
Mittelmeergebiet und Vorderasien. – Bibliotheca Lichenologica 3: 1-186 + 9 plates.
Accepted: 11.3.2003