Academia.eduAcademia.edu
EXPERIMENTAL PROVING OF QUERCUS DILATATA Introduction Quercus dilatata (in Hindi – Moru, English – Green Oak, Holly Oak) is a species of Oak, native of sub-Himalaya. It ranges from Afghanistan, India (Jammu and Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand), Nepal and Pakistan from 2000-3000 m. Pharmacology: - Local Name – Mohru Botanical Name- Quercus dilatata Royle Family - Fagaceae Synonyms - Quercus himalayana It is a tree having young shoots and maximum plant height = 30 m and diameter 1 m 40 cm was recorded in Mohru oak forest soil. The seeds (kernels) are used in urine troubles and the decoction of the wood is used in Scabies and the skin diseases. Varieties of oak - Mohru, Kharsu Part employed - Fresh leaves Methodology – Drug proving is mentioned in the theory of syllabus of Pharmacy of B.H.M.S. of C.C.H. regulation 1983, until starting of M.D. (Homoeopathy) Course by Rajasthan University, Jaipur. Period of Drug Proving - 1 November, 2017 to 30 December, 2017 Place - Chandola Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital, Rudrapur, Uttarakhand. Reliable Preparations- Q was prepared in the Pharmacy lab of the college as per modern method. From Q, 30 potency was developed as per norms generally adopted. Total 15 volunteers (one Doctor, 11 Students of 4th Prof. B.H.M.S. and 3 Interns) took part in drug proving; as they were found physically fit and considerably healthier. Since the drug had not been proved in the past by any one, the name of the drug was not kept secret. Procedure Adopted - (A) Mother Tincture (Q) - 5 drops dose of Q was taken by all 15 provers at about 10 AM on 6 November, 2017. All took Q in water. Then again at about 5 PM, 6 drops of Q was taken by all in the similar way. Likewise 1 drop of Q was added in the previous drops dose every subsequent time fixed at 10 AM in forenoon and 5 PM in afternoon till number of drops went to 20 in afternoon on 13 November, 2017. Since, some of the provers developed drug’s /disease’s (suppressed) symptoms, they stopped taking the drug on 10 November, 2017. Only 9 provers were left to take the drug on 14 November, 2017. (B) 30 Potency- 2 drops were taken by the provers on 21 November, 2017 at about 10 AM. They again took it at about 5 PM. Likewise drug was taken twice a day on 21st November to 25th November, 2017. i.e. first five days. 26th November 2017 onwards till 30th November 2017 i.e., last 5 days, 2 drops dose of the drug was taken thrice a day that is at 9 AM, 1 PM & 5 PM. N.B.- 1 - As given in the books of Pharmacy and Organon of Medicine, the dose of the drug being proved should be in the increasing order. Keeping in view this guideline, the amount of dose in case of Q was increased every time with addition of 1 drop. This thing was possible only in case of Q, since Q being the material dose. But in case of 30 Potency, the amount of dose remained the same, only frequency of drug intake was increased from 2 to 3 times a day. 2- As far as the time duration for the taking of the drug in Q and 30 was concerned, it was pre-conceived that those who would be considerably healthier and susceptible, would develop drug’s/disease’s (in case of suppression) symptoms in a week time. But the rest, who were not susceptible, would not develop symptoms of any kind even if the time duration of 1 week is increased. 3- Utmost care had been taken for such provers by deleting their drugs/diseases pathogenisity while analysing the symptoms. Although symptoms of remaining provers were tested on symptoms traits: location, time modalities and extension by repeated questioning to individual prover while compiling and analysing the symptoms. I am of this opinion that these symptoms should again be verified either on the basis of clinical proving or the drug should again be reproved for the thorough experimental proving by the most sincere, educated and dedicated persons, who should be considerably healthier and in the healthy season, preferably by homoeopathic doctors, who should be well acquainted with the minute observations of sensation and feelings produced during drug proving and noting expressing them. Until such time, the proving done on the students and other volunteers would remain imperfect, doubtful and unauthenticated. Pathogenesis Mind - Anxiety, irritability, restlessness, mood swing, feeling of joy, delusion as if he is flying in the sky. Vertigo – During headache, feels as if drunk, sensation lasted for few minutes. Head – Bursting pain in frontal and occipital region with heaviness in eyes associated with vertigo and nausea especially in the morning. Hair fall, <noise> pressure. Eyes – Burning, straining in the eyes with watery discharge. Ear – Earache at night. Nose – Coryza, sneezing, watery discharge at noon persisted all night along with dyspnea. Obstructed nostrils, breathing from mouth, tip of the nose red. Throat – Burning in throat with mucus secretion, <morning, when empty stomach. Stomach – Appetite increased, then diminished associated with nausea and burning in stomach. <morning, noon and evening after cold drinks. Abdomen – Burning pain in whole abdomen <night, evening. Desire to pass stool, pain is relieved after passing stool. Rectum – Intense burning pain and itching in anus. <walking and sitting in the afternoon. Constipation, desire to pass stool with tenesmus and mucus discharge, ineffectual urging for stool. Urine – Offensive urine. Female Genitalia – Dysmenorrhea, menses scanty and watery. Cough – Loose cough at night with scanty expectoration associated with vomiting. Chest – Itching with burning on the upper region at night. Back – Spasmodic pain in lumbar region at night, pain appears gradually and ceases suddenly. Extremities – Itching in upper and lower extremities at night, burning pain, numbness in lower limbs at 3 PM. Quivering in arms, restlessness, stiffness in all small and big joints, <morning, afternoon and evening, difficult movement. THE FOLLOWING PERSONS TOOK PART IN DRUG PROVING S.No. Name Sex Age Potency 1 Bhanu Yadav M 22 YEARS Q, 30 2 Bipin Tiwari M 23 YEARS Q 3 Dikshita Pandey F 23 YEARS Q 4 Jyoti Gaur F 28 YEARS Q 5 Manmeet Kaur F 23 YEARS Q 6 Pooja Gariya F 22 YEARS Q 7 Saumya Sharma F 22 YEARS Q 8 Priyanka Sarkar F 24 YEARS Q, 30 9 Najmee Khan F 25 YEARS Q 10 Dr. P.S. Rawat M 70 YEARS Q, 30 11 Rubina F 23 YEARS Q 12 Shivani Dawas F 24 YEARS Q 13 Sonika Jaiswal F 23 YEARS Q, 30 14 Vivek Bahuguna M 23 YEARS Q 15 Priyanka Semwal F 25 YEARS Q Note – I am extremely thankful to the following persons who helped me in the preparation of the mother tincture of Quercus dilatata for experimental proving (drug proving) and in compilation work. 1 - Dr. Anand Partap Singh, Former Reader, Department of Pharmacy. 2 - Student of B.H.M.S. 4th prof. Batch-2013-14 and Interns who took part in the experimental proving of the said drug. 3 – Apart from these students of 4th prof. B.H.M.S. (Batch 2014-15) Dr. Priyanka Semwal, Ms. Pooja Gariya, Akshay Joshi, Himanshi Gonia, Ananya Gupta and Aparna Mishra helped me in the compilation work of the symptoms proved by the provers. Prof. (Dr. P.S. Rawat) Master Prover Department of Repertory Chandola Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital dr.psrawat47@gmail.com 63969 25144