IOBC
Working Groups
″Integrated fruit protection in fruit crops″
Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Integrated Fruit
Production
At
Avignon (France)
October 27-30, 2008
Edited by
J Cross, M Brown, J Fitzgerald, M Fountain, D Yohalem
i
Foreword
Dear Colleagues
It was with the great pleasure we welcomed you to the 7th IOBC conference on Integrated
Fruit Production at Avignon in 2008.
The programme for this meeting was exceptionally rich and diverse and contained many
interesting and exciting contributions. The numbers of offered oral and poster presentations
(>200) was quite exceptional and well beyond our expectations. It demonstrated that
Integrated Plant Protection in Fruit Crops remains an area of strong interest in the WPRS and
beyond. We greatly appreciated the strong representation at the conference by delegates from
the USA and Canada. We are sorry that we were not been able to accommodate all the offered
oral papers in the programme. This has meant that we requested >30 offered oral papers to be
presented as posters. Furthermore, the number of posters was so great that 2 separate poster
sessions were necessary.
This was the 4 yearly meeting of our whole IOBC Working Group which comprises 5 subgroups (pome fruit arthropods, pome fruit diseases, soft fruits, stone fruits and IFP
guidelines). The decision to have parallel sessions for pests and diseases was taken to ensure
that both entomologists and pathologists attended this conference.
Our working group, formerly named the ‘Orchards Working Group’ is near to celebrating its
50th anniversary. Our group was a pioneer in Integrated Pest and Disease Management and
has come a long way from its historical roots. We welcomed Ernst Boller, Honorary member
of the IOBC, and a person with a strong interest in and with good links with our past, who
gave a historical review of our Working Group’s origins, founder members and activities.
The IOBC council provided substantive funds to support this conference and these funds
mainly to support the attendance of 8 students and young persons starting their career at this
conference who otherwise would have been unlikely to attend. We hope that their attendance
at this conference will cement their interest in our subject.
Finally, we are especially indebted to our colleagues from INRA Avignon who hosted this
conference.
Jerry Cross (Convenor), Claudio Ioriatti, Christian Linder, Fabio Molinari, Carlo Malavolta,
Jesus Avilla, Arne Stensvand, Benoît Sauphanor.
Conference Scientific Committee
ii
Contents
Plenary Session 1:
Integrated Production: where is it and where is it going?
Jesus Avilla Ernst Boller, Carlo Malavolta, Frank Wijnands, Robert Baur ...................................1
Disease management in organic apple orchards is more than applying the right product at the correct
time.
Marc Trapman ..................................................................................................................................2
Designing cropping systems to achieve Integrated Fruit Production goals Subtitle:
Françoise Lescourret, Benoît Sauphanor ................................................................................... 3-6
Developing a Protocol and a Marketing Niche for EcoApples in NY State
W. Harvey Reissig, Arthur Agnello, Daniel Cooley, Jon Clements, Michael Rozyne, Thomas Green
7-10
Analyzing the results of a biodiversity experiment: Enhancing parasitism of Platynota idaeusalis
(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae)
Mark Brown, Clarissa R. Mathews and Greg Krawczyk ...............................................................11
Genetic modification of apple to control diseases
Cesare Gessler, Giovanni Broggini, Gabriella Parravicini, Paolo Galli, Iris Szankowski, Roberta
Paris, Andrea Patocchi............................................................................................................. 12-13
Entomology Session 1: Arthropod pests- tree fruits
Dispersal estimates of codling moth fertilized females in a French farm based on kinship assessments
Frank Pierre, Jérôme Olivares, Hubert Defrance, Sylvaine Simon, Claire Lavigne................ 14-18
Observations on the phenology of codling moth in untreated orchards in the Netherlands and Belgium
Herman Helsen, Matty polfliet, Marc Trapman..............................................................................19
Differences among Cacopsylla melanoneura Förster (Homoptera: Psyllidae) insight from molecular
markers
Valeria Malagnini, Frederico Pedrazoli, Chiara Papetti, Valeria Guilandri, Elisa Bozza, Federica
Fiamingo, Rosaly Zasso, Claudio Ioriatti ......................................................................................20
Whole-farm infestation trends and management programs for obliquebanded leafroller in apples
Arthur Agnello, Harvey Reissig ................................................................................................ 21-24
Population dynamics of Anarsia lineatella and their relation to crop damage in Northern Greece IPM
peach orchards: towards the development of EIL
Petros Damos, Matilta Savopoulou-Soultani ........................................................................... 25-26
Pathology Session 1: Brown spot of pear and modelling of pear scab
An update on brown spot of pear
Emilio Montesinos, Isidre Llorente.................................................................................................27
Basis for new strategies in integrated control of brown spot of pear (Stemphylium vesicarium,
teleomorph Pleospora allii)
Isidre Llorente, C Moragrega, L Ruz, G Santamaria, A Vilardell, P Vilardell, E Montesinos.. 28-31
Drought and oxidative stress determine the sensitivity of the pear towards Brown spot infections
Stijn Vanlaer, M. Höfte, P Creemers ...............................................................................................32
Evaluation of ascospore maturity models to estimate seasonal ascospore discharge of pear scab
(Venturia pirina)
Håvard Eikemo, D M Gadoury, R A Spotts, O Villalta, P Creemers, A Stensvand ................... 33-36
Entomology Session 2: Arthropod pests – soft fruits
Developing an effective trap and lure to monitor Lygus rugulipennis
iii
Michelle Fountain, Jerry Cross, Gunnhild Jaastad, Dudley Farman, David Hall, .................. 37-41
Interactions among predatory insects in strawberry production
Jean Fitzgerald, Chantelle Jay .......................................................................................................42
Developing Integrated Pest Management programmes for protected strawberry crops in Southern
France
Amelie Boullenger, Marion Turquet, Stéphanie Girou, Clare Sampson ................................... 43-46
Pathology Session 2: Storage diseases
Alternative means to reduce storage decay in organic apple production; time of harvest and calcium
applications
Jorunn Børve, Dag Røen, Arne Stensvand ............................................................................... 47-50
Sources of inoculum for Colletotrichum acutatum in cherry and apple
Arne Stensvand, Dag Røen ...................................................................................................... 51-53
Early season control of storage rots of apple
Angela Berrie, B.E. Ellerker, K. Lower, J D Robinson ...................................................................54
Entomology Session 3: Semiochemicals
Utilization of Mating Disruption and Codling Moth Granulosis virus (CMGV) in Conventional
Commercial Apple Orchards in Pennsylvania, USA.
Greg Krawczyk, Larry A. Hull, and Eric Bohnenblust ........................................................ 55-58
Pheromone-Based Management Strategies for the Dogwood Borer, Synanthedon scitula (Harris)
(Lepidoptera: Sesiidae)
Tracy Leskey, Christopher Bergh, James F. Walgenbach, Aijun Zhang .........................................59
Volatiles initiate egg-laying in common green lacewings
Gunnhild Jaastad, Liv Hatleli, Geir K. Knudsen, Miklos Tóth ............................................ 60-65
Sucrose as an apple tree resistance inducer against Cydia pomonella L.
Sylvie Derridj, François Moulin, Eric Ferré, Hubert Galy, Arnaud Bergougnoux, Ingrid Arnaud,
Jacques Auger .......................................................................................................................... 66-70
Attractiveness of Mixtures of Pheromone and Host Plant Volatiles to Cydia molesta (Busck)
(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae)
Nelia Varela, Jesús Avilla, César Gemeno......................................................................................71
Improving the effectiveness of mating disruption for tree fruit pests
Larry Gut, Peter McGhee, Piera Siegert, Michael Reinke, James Miller ......................................72
Assessing efficacy of mating disruption in apple orchard by release and recapture of males in netcages
Marco Tasin, Carmela Sicher, Stefano Contrini, Silvia Schmidt and Claudio Ioriatti ...................73
Pathology Session 3: Organic and integrated disease control in apple orchards
Recent progress in integrated sanitation practices to manage apple scab
William E. MacHardy ............................................................................................................... 74-77
Fungicide sprays during the window of germination. A special tool for control of apple scab in
organic and integrated apple production
Peter Triloff............................................................................................................................... 78-83
Assessment of fungicide protection strategies in experimental apple orchards
Laurent Brun Guinaudeau J., Gros C., Parisi L., Simon S....................................................... 84-87
Brown rot disease development and management perspectives in organic apple orchards
Imre Holb........................................................................................................................................88
Repco results on the control of scab in organic apple cultivation
Bart Heijne, Peter Frans de Jong...................................................................................................89
iv
Effect of Cladosporium cladosporioides H39 on conidia production of Venturia inaequalis under
orchard conditions
Jürgen Köhl, Wilma Molhoek ................................................................................................... 90-94
Entomology Session 4: Biocontrol, biodiversity
Biological control strategy of codling moth with entomopathogenic nematodes in organic and
conventional farming
Delphine Juan Jean-Baptiste Rouvière, Sandrine Mouton and Philippe Coulomb................ 95-100
Mass releases of Trichogramma minutum to control the obliquebanded leafroller, Choristoneura
rosaceana, (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) in apple orchards
Daniel Cormier, Gérald Chouinard, Francine Pelletier, Franz Vanoosthuyse.............................101
Assessing the role of Syrphidae in the suppression of woolly apple aphid in Virginia, USA
Chris Bergh........................................................................................................................... 102-105
Habitat and prey preferences of the two predatory bugs Anthocoris nemorum (L) and A. nemoralis
(Fabricius) (Anthocoridae: Hemiptera-Heteroptera)
Lene Sigsgaard .............................................................................................................................106
Does windborne pollen mediate the effects of pesticides on predatory mites?
Mario Baldessari Gino Angeli, Vincenzo Girolami, Alberto Pozzebon, Paola Tirello,
Carlo Duso ...........................................................................................................................................107
Pathology Session 4: Sooty blotch and flyspeck, and fire blight
A new view of the sooty blotch and flyspeck fungal complex on apples
Mark Gleason, Jean Batzer ..........................................................................................................108
Fireblight research: Warming up to new ideas and solutions
Vincent Philion .............................................................................................................................109
Entomology Session 5a: Earwigs
The complex life history of a predator: sibling species, variability of side-effect and enigmatic
disappearances of the earwig
Bruno Gobin, Rob Moerkens, Herman Helsen, Kurt Jordaens, Herwig Leirs, Gertie Peusens...110
Side effects of pesticides on the European earwig Forficula auricularia L. (Dermaptera: Forficulidae)
Gertie Peusens, Herman Helsen, Bruno Gobin............................................................................ 111
Impact of four insecticides on the European earwig, Forficula auricularia L., in an apple orchard
Heidrun Vogt, Jürgen Just & Anderson Grutzmacher ...........................................................112-116
Control of the woolly apple aphid (Erisoma lanigerum Hausm.) by releasing earwigs (Forficula
auricularia L.) and support oil applications
Ina Toups Jürgen Zimmer, Martin Trautmann, Nicole Fieger-Metag,, Sascha Buchleither, Horst
Bathon....................................................................................................................................117-120
Population modelling of the European earwig as a decision tool for orchard management
Rob Moerkens Bruno Gobin, Gertie Peusens, Laurent Crespin, Herman Helsen, Herwig Leirs .121
Entomology Session 5b: Pesticide resistance
Codling Moth Insecticide Resistance Management in North Carolina Apples
James Walgenbach, Leonardo Magalhaes, Vonny Barlow, Michael Roe .....................................122
A new CpGV isolate overcoming Cydia pomonella resistance to Granulovirus: improvement of the
virus efficiency by selection pressure on resistant hosts
Marie Berling, Christine Blachere-Lopez, Olivier Soubabère, Jean-Baptiste Rey, Sophie-Joy
Ondet, Yannis Tallot, Miguel Lopez Ferber, Benoît Sauphanor, Antoine Bonhomme........... 123-127
Resistance Management: A Global Industry Response from the Insecticide Resistance Action
Committee
v
Andrea Bassi.................................................................................................................................128
Pathology Session 5: Fungicide resistance, disease resistance, and diseases of small fruits
Molecular aspects of QoI and DMI fungicide resistance in NY populations of the apple scab pathogen
Venturia inaequalis
Kerik Cox, S.A. Villani, W. Köller.................................................................................................129
Practical aspects of QoI and DMI fungicide resistance in Northeastern US populations of the apple
scab pathogen Venturia inaequalis
Kerik Cox, S.A. Villani, W. Köller.................................................................................................130
Can Venturia inaequalis populations show a reduced sensitivity to a multisite fungicide? The case
study of captan in French orchards
Luciana Parisi, Expert Pascale, Nock Isabelle, Louis-Etienne Tania, Bourdoiseau Noëllie,
Didelot Frédérique ............................................................................................................... 131-134
Validation of an apple scab fungicide spray action threshold to help reduce captan residue levels on
fruits
Vincent Philion .............................................................................................................................135
Breeding high quality disease resistant apple varieties
Markus Kellerhals, Andrea Patocchi, Brion Duffy, Jürg Frey ............................................. 136-140
Recent advances in epidemiology of strawberry powdery mildew
David Gadoury, A. Stensvand, R. C. Seem, C. Heidenreich, M. L. Herrero, M. Welser, A. Dobson,
H. Eikemo, B. Asalf.......................................................................................................................141
Integrated protection of table-grape from powdery mildew in Southern Italy
Agostino Santomauro, Crescenza Dongiovanni, Claudia Giampaolo, Michele Di Carolo,
Francesco Faretra ................................................................................................................ 142-149
A multiphasic approach to evaluating the effects of biofumigation for management of wilt in
strawberries
David Yohalem, Tom Passey ................................................................................................. 150-153
Armillaria root rot on highbush blueberry in Northern Italy: monitoring, identification and inoculum
sources
Daniele Prodorutti, Alberto Pellegrini, Davide Gobbin, Thalia Vanblaere, Ilaria Pertot ... 154-157
Plenary Session 2: 50th Anniversary lecture and IOBC business
The Working Group „Integrated Protection of Fruit Crops“ is celebrating its 50th Anniversary
Ernst Boller Albert K. Minks, Jerry V. Cross, Joop C. van Lenteren, Theo Wildbolz ........... 158-159
Entomology Session 6: Integrated Fruit Production
Peach orchard management strategies: aphid communities as a case study
Servane Penvern, Stéphane Bellon, Joël Fauriel, Benoît Sauphanor...........................................160
Adapting to New Control Strategies and Area-Wide Management for Cherry Fruit Flies in British
Columbia, Canada
Howard Thistlewood, Noubar Bostanian, Sue Senger, Naomi DeLury ................................ 161-166
Plant protection in organic apple production of two North-East Spanish regions
Mariano Vilajeliu, Adriana Escudero, Pere Vilardell, Lluís Batllori, Simó Alegre, Georgina Alins,
M Dolores Blázquez, Marcos Miñarro, Enrique Dapena..................................................... 167-170
Pathology Session 6: Nectria Canker
Field efficacy of slaked lime against European fruit tree canker and introduction into practice
Bart Heijne, Peter Frans de Jong, Pieter Jans Jansonius............................................................171
Relation of duration of wet period and number of Nectria cankers for leaf scars and pruning wounds
Peter Frans de Jong, Adrie Boshuizen, Marcel Wenneker ...........................................................172
vi
Detection of latent infections of fruit tree canker (Nectria galligena) in planting material of apple
Marcel Wenneker, Nina Joosten....................................................................................................173
Plenary Session 3:
Development of semiochemical attractants, lures and traps for raspberry beetle, Byturus tomentosus at
SCRI; from fundamental chemical ecology to testing IPM tools with growers
Nick Birch, Stuart Gordon, Tom Shepherd, Wynne Griffiths, Graham Robertson, Trefor Woodford,
Rex Brennan.......................................................................................................................... 174-176
Prospect for crop protection in Europe: vision from the ENDURE Network
Pierre Ricci, Marco Barzman .......................................................................................................177
Poster Session 1 : Arthropod Pests
State of the Art of Control Strategies of Codling Moth, Apple Scab and Brown Spot in Europe
Jesus Avilla, Daniel Casado, Andrea Patocchi, Jörg Samietz, Klaus Paaske, Claire Lavigne,
Benoît Sauphanor, Luciana Parisi, Bart Heijne ...........................................................................178
Investigations on the bark beetle species (Coleoptera: Scolytidae) in cherry and peaches in the East
Mediterranean Region of Türkiye.
Hazir Adalet, Naim Öztürk, M. Rifat Ulusoy........................................................................ 179-183
The incidence and control of cranberry tipworm Dasineura vaccinii S. and its control in cranberry
plantations in Latvia
Ilze Apenite ...................................................................................................................................184
Preliminary trials for a continuous rearing of Bactrocera oleae (Rossi) on its natural host Olea
europaea L. in laboratory and future perspectives
Valentina Baratella, Antonio Franco Spanedda................................................................... 185-189
The current issue Codling moth control in the Croatian apple orchards
Božena Baric, Ivana Pajac, Dinka Grubišic ................................................................................190
Loquat and pomegranate thrips in the eastern Mediterranean region of Turkey
Refik Bozbuga, Naime Z. Elekçioğlu .................................................................................... 191-194
Two Spotted Mite, Tetranychus urticae , a new pest in Persimmon Orchards, to Reduce its Density
Bu-Keun Chung, Mitsuhiro Kawashima, Chuleui Jung................................................................195
Autumn control of aphid pests of tree and bush fruit crops
Jerry Cross, Michelle Fountain, Adrian Harris, Richard Harrington.................................. 196-199
New infestation outbreaks of Panonychus ulmi Koch (Acari: Tetranychidae) in apple orchards of
North-West Italy
Daniele Demaria, Marco Pagani, Graziano Vittone, Fabio Molinari ................................. 200-202
Ostrinia nubilalis Hübner (Lepidoptera, Pyralidae) as a threat for apple
Daniele Demaria, Graziano Vittone, Fabio Molinari ......................................................... 203-206
Investigations on the occurrence of the quarantine fruit fly species Rhagoletis cingulata and
Rhagoletis indifferens on Prunus avium and Prunus cerasus in Austria
Alois Egartner, N. Zeisner, H. Hausdorf, C. Lethmayer, S. Blümel .......................................207
Population evolution of Ceratitis capitata (Wied.) in the NE of Spain and its implications in the
establishment of control methods
Adriana Escudero-Colomar, Mariano Vilajeliu, Esther Peñarrubia-María, Lluís Batllori .........208
Preliminary studies about the effect of ‘Candidatus Phytoplasma mali’ on the psyllid Cacopsylla
melanoneura (Homoptera: Psyllidae)
Claudio Ioriatti, Valeria Malagnini Federico Pedrazzoli, Valeria Gualandri, Flavia Forno,
Alberto Pozzebon..........................................................................................................................209
New insights into management of the white grub Polyphylla olivieri in fruit orchards of Iran
Aziz Kharazi-Pakdel, Javad, Karimi ............................................................................................210
First evidence of the walnut husk fly (Rhagoletis completa) in Austria
Christa Lethmayer ........................................................................................................................211
vii
The occurrence of leaf rollers in Polish apple orchards and possibilities of their integrated control
Remigiusz.W. Olszak, Zofia Pluciennik ........................................................................................212
Control of Cacopsylla pyri L. (Sternorrhyncha, Psyllidae) in pear orchards in the Czech Republic
Jana Ourednickova ............................................................................................................... 213-216
Geographical distribution and population dynamics of the European cherry fruit fly, Rhagoletis cerasi
(Diptera: Tephritidae) in Greece
Nikos Papadopoulos, M. Kleopatra1, S. Papanastasiou, A. Diamantidis, I. Kounatidis, P.
Mavragani, K. Bourtzis, B. I. Katsoyannos ..................................................................................217
Population Dynamics and Damage Analysis of Cetonia aurata / Potosia cuprea in Croatian peach
orchards
Josip Razov, Bozena Baric, Miklós Tóth............................................................................... 218-221
Spatial patterns and Sampling of predatory mites (Acari: Phytoseiidae) on apple orchards
J.Raul Rodrigues, Laura M Torres ...............................................................................................222
An inventory of tortricids (Lepidoptera, Tortricidae) in Swedish apple orchards as a basis for future
management strategies
Patrick Sjöberg, Christer Tornéus, Birgitta Rämert, Ylva Hillbur...............................................223
Spread of European stone fruit yellows in Piedmont (northwestern Italy) and presence of Cacopsylla
pruni Scopoli in plum and apricot orchards
Rosemarie Tedeschi, Daniele Demaria, Alessandro Cesano, Federica Tota, Graziano Vittone,
Alberto Alma......................................................................................................................... 224-227
Observations of Rhagoletis cingulata, an invasive species from North America, on cherry in Germany
Heidrun Vogt, Kirsten Köppler, Werner Dahlbender, Günter Hensel ................................... 228-232
Poster Session 1 : Biocontrol Agents
Selectivity of phytossanitary products used on citrus orchards to Chrysoperla externa (Hagen, 1861)
(Neuroptera: Chrysopidae)
César Carvalho, Geraldo Andrade Carvalho....................................................................... 233-237
First record of the parasitoid Copidosoma varicornis (Nees) (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae) in Greece
Petros Damos, Matilda Savopoulou-Soultani....................................................................... 238-239
Behaviour and biological control of two-spotted spider mite (Tetranychus urticae) in floricane red
raspberry plantations
Alberto Grassi, Romano Maines........................................................................................... 240-243
Natural regulation of the rosy apple aphid (Dysaphis plantaginea) in organic apple orchards
Hazem Dib, Yvan Capowiez, Sylvaine Simon, Benoît Sauphanor ........................................ 244-247
Pest management practices and environmental factors affect natural regulation of the codling moth
Lino Monteiro, Dor C, Franck P., Lavigne C., Sauphanor B. .............................................. 248-251
A geostatistical approach to evaluate the side effects on non target species using a non repeated plot.
Edison Pasqualini, M. Melandri., G. Pradolesi ., S. Civolani, V. De Luigi, G. Burgio .................252
The effect of rosy apple aphid and beneficial insect dynamics in an orchard
Sylvaine Simon, Karine Morel, Hubert Defrance, Alan Garnier, Emilie Durand,
Maude Le Corre ........................................................................................................................... 253-256
Susceptibility of codling moth populations originated from Czech Republic to Cydia pomonella
granulovirus (CpGV)
Jitka Stará, Tereza Zichová, Vladan Falta, František Kocourek, Jiban Kumar ................... 257-260
Poster Session 1 : Biodiversity
Indicators to assess the environmental impact of protection practices in apple orchards
Benoit Sauphanor, Camille Picard, Sylvaine Simon, Daniel Plénet..................................... 261-264
viii
Poster Session 1 : Pathology
Potential new storage rot problems in UK Cox apples
Angela Berrie, B.E. Ellerker, J.D. Robinson ................................................................................265
Is it possible to predict the aerial concentrations of Venturia inaequalis ascospores in apple orchards?
Laurent Brun, Frédérique Didelot, Freddy Combe, Gilles Orain, Cécile Payen, Arnaud
Lemarquand, Luciana Parisi ................................................................................................ 266-269
Efficiency of association of scab control methods on resistance durability of apple: the case study of
cultivar Ariane
Valerie Caffier, Frédérique Didelot, Gilles Orain, Arnaud Lemarquand, Luciana Parisi ... 270-273
Control of Oriental Fruit Moth, Cydia molesta Busck., by Isomate OFM-Rosso Dispensers in Peach
Orchards of Bulgaria – Preliminary Results
Hristina Kutinkova, Jörg Samietz , Vasiliy Dzhuvinov , Vittorio Veronelli , Andrea Iodice... 274-278
An Integrated Approach for Reducing Fungicide Sprays Against Scab in Organic Apple Orchards
Imre J. Holb, Barbara Balla, Ferenc Abonyi ....................................................................... 279-282
Searching inoculum sources of brown spot of pear
Jürgen Köhl, Lia Groenenboom-de Haas, Helen Goossen-van de Geijn, Richard van Hoof, Pieter
Kastelein, Cees Waalwijk..............................................................................................................283
The initiative: Monitoring of Venturia inaequalis virulences
Andrea Patocchi ................................................................................................................... 284-285
Late winter climatic conditions influence ascospore production and release in Venturia inaequalis
Vincent Philion, Arne Stensvand, Håvard Eikemo, David M. Gadoury........................................286
Efficacy of fungicides mixtures to avoid apple scab fungus resistance in integrated apple orchards
Regina Rancane, Maija Eihe ........................................................................................................287
Use of the A-scab model for rational control of apple scab
Vittorio Rossi, Simona Giosuè, Riccardo Bugiani, Tito Caffi, Gian Franco Pradolesi,
Massimiliano Melandri, Tullio Bevilacqua .......................................................................... 288-292
Monitoring of Venturia inaequalis strains sensitive to strobilurin fungicides and occurrence of apple
scab on resistant cultivars in the Czech Republic
Radek Vávra, Jana Kloutvorová, Stanislav Boček, Antonín Svoboda................................... 293-298
Apple Proliferation phytoplasma in South Tyrol – an Integrated Approach
Robert Wiedmer, Marcus Prant, Josef Österreicher, Michael Unterthurner ........................ 299-301
Poster Session 1 : Pesticides & Resistance
Development and validation of a rapid method testing of CpGV susceptibility in codling moth
populations
Johannes Jehle, Stefanie Schulze..................................................................................................302
Effect of a growth enhancer Carbon Kick Booster® on mites and natural mite enemies in apple
Tuomo Tuovinen.................................................................................................................... 303-306
Biological Efficacy of Botanical Insecticides in the Control of Green Apple Aphid (Aphis pomi De
Geer)
Slobodan Milenkovic, Snežana Tanasković ......................................................................... 307-310
Evolution of apple surface metabolites throughout the season and codling moth (Cydia pomonella L.)
egg-laying behaviour.
Nadia Lombarkia..........................................................................................................................311
Poster Session 1 : Population Modelling
Evaluation of integrated management scenarios of the peach tree-Myzus persicae system using a croppest model
Françoise Lescourret, Isabelle Grechi, Benoît Sauphanor, Nadine Hilgert, Michel Génard,
Rachid Senoussi, Marie-Hélène Sauge, Arnaud Chapelet, Jean-Philippe Lacroze ............. 312-315
Modelling codling moth damage as a function of adult monitoring and crop protection
ix
Benoît Ricci, Olivier Martin, Pierre Franck, Jean-François Toubon, Rachid Senoussi, Claire
Lavigne ................................................................................................................................. 316-319
Poster Session 1 : Semiochemicals
A Comparative Study on Auto-Confusion by Exosex2 Gvm-Lb and Mating Disruption by Isonet-L
against European Grapevine Moth, Lobesia botrana Den.-Schiff. (Lep.: Tortricidae) in Turkey
F. Olzem Altindisli, F. Ozsemerci, P. Hıncal, A. Derin, İ. Çınarlı, G. Pease, T. Ray,
T. Wardley ..................................................................................................................................... 320-321
Identification of the female sex pheromone of the pear midge, Contarinia pyrivora
Lakmali Amarawardana, David Hall, Jerry Cross, Michelle Fountain, Gunnhild Jåstad322-327
Raspberry beetle Byturus tomentosus: flight monitoring with semiochemical traps
Catherine Baroffio, Charly Mittaz........................................................................................ 328-331
Control of the Plum Fruit Moth, Cydia funebrana (Treitsch.) (Lepidoptera, Tortricidae), by false-trail
following
Roberto Bruni, Paola Rioli, Cappella Luigi, Rama Franco, Nunzio Isidoro ........................ 332-335
Eight years of practical experience with mating disruption to control grape berry moth, Lobesia
botrana, in Porto Wine Region
Cristina Carlos, Fernando Alves, Laura Torres ................................................................... 336-340
Use of Sprayable Pheromone Formulations in Europe
Enzo Casagrande.................................................................................................................. 341-343
Cells responding to pheromone components and plant volatiles could affect semiochemical based
control strategies of insect pests in agriculture ecosystems
Antonio De Cristofaro, Gianfranco Anfora, Giacinto Salvatore Germinara, Claudio
Ioriatti,Valerio Mazzoni, Giuseppe Rotundo ................................................................................344
Integrating pear ester into direct management programs for codling moth
Alan Knight, Janet Haworth, Bill Lingren, and Vince Hebert .............................................. 345-348
Using Insect Behavior to Facilitate Precision Agriculture: Odor-Baited Trap Trees For Management of
the Plum Curculio, Conotrachelus nenuphar (Herbst) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae)
Tracy C. Leskey, Starker E. Wright, Jaime C. Piñero, Ronald J. Prokopy ..................................349
Cage test to assess the mating disruptant activity for different pheromone blends and formulations on
Peach Twig Borer (Anarsia lineatella Zeller) in the orchards
Fabio Molinari, Manuela Cigolini, Andrea Iodice, Vittorio Veronelli.................................. 350-353
Comparison of different pheromone lures to monitor the flight of Cydia pomonella
Denis Pasquier, Patrik Kehrli............................................................................................... 354-355
Effectiveness of mating disruption and granulovirus against codling moths in Central Bulgaria
Penka Peeva, Nyonka Velcheva, Olia Karadjova, Vittorio Veronelli, Denis Pasquier, Radoslav
Andreev, Katia Radeva ......................................................................................................... 356-360
Control of codling moth (Cydia pomonella) under the aspects of active mating disruption, different
application systems and varieties
Barbara Schildberger, Lothar Wurm, Eva Vogl, Manfred Kickenweiz ................................. 361-364
Mating disruption across the peach/apple interface
Peter Shearer, Kris Tollerup, Ann Rucker Rutgers .......................................................................365
Exploring the potential for using peripheral treatments with pheromone dispensers for controlling the
grape berry moth (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) by mating disruption
Mitch Trimble, D B Marshall................................................................................................ 366-369
Control of codling moth, Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera Tortricidae), with EcoTape pheromone
dispensers
Federica Trona, Mario Baldessari, Gianfranco Anfora, Valerio Mazzoni, Enzo Casagrande,
Claudio Ioriatti, Gino Angeli........................................................................................................370
Poster Session 2 : Arthropod Pests
Two Spotted Mite, Tetranychus urticae Koch, Emerged as a New Pest in Persimmon Orchards and
x
Approaches to Their Control
Bu-Keun Chung, Mitsuhiro Kawashima, Chuleui Jung................................................................371
Observations on the relation between the induction and termination of diapause in codling moth in
Dutch and Belgian populations
Marc Trapman, Matty Polfliet, Herman Helsen ...........................................................................372
Practical results of a Stacked Control Strategy for Codling Moth (Cydia pomonella L ) management
Marc Trapman, Herman Helsen, Matty Polfliet ...........................................................................373
Poster Session 2 : Biocontrol Agents
Biological aspects and predatory capacity of Chrysoperla externa (Hagen, 1861) (Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae) fed Planococcus citri (Risso, 1813) (Hemiptera: Pseudococcidae)
César Carvalho, Gerane C. D. Bezerra, Brígida Souza, Lenira V. C. Santa-Cecília........... 374-379
The Effect of Floral Strips on the Abundance of Hymenopteran Parasitoids in Apple and Olive Organic
Orchards
Hazem Dib, Gilles Libourel, François Warlop ..................................................................... 380-383
Side effect of selected insecticides on Aphidius colemani, Amblyseius cucumeris and Neoseiulus
cucumeris as model species of natural enemies
Jitka Stará, Josef Havlík, Kamil Holý, František Kocourek ................................................. 384-387
Poster Session 2 : Biodiversity
Avian biodiversity: impacts of phytosanitary practices and landscape in South-Eastern French apple
orchards
Jean-Charles Bouvier, Julia Agerberg, Benoît Ricci, Claire Lavigne .................................. 388-391
Is the distribution of beneficial arthropods influenced by mixed hedgerows
Jean-François Debras, Rachid Senoussi, René Rieux, Elise Buisson, Thierry Dutoit .................392
Changes of entomophauna in orchards under different pest management regimes
Vladan Falta, Jitka Stará, Fratišek Kocourek ..............................................................................393
Arthropods and mycorrhizal fungi associated to the rhizosphere of grapevine in Sicily
Alessandra Martorana, L. Torta, G. Lo Verde, E. Ragusa, S. Burruano, S. Ragusa Di Chiara....394
Mixed deciduous hedgerows as sources of anthocorids and other predators of pear psyllid in the UK
Csaba Nagy, Jerry Cross, Martin Luton, Caroline Ashdown ............................................... 395-401
Species diversity, dominance and frequency of leaf-eating Lepidoptera in plum biocenose in Bulgaria
Nionka Velcheva.................................................................................................................... 402-405
Poster Session 2 : IFP
Hazelnut quality and sensory evaluation in organic and conventional growing systems
Valerio Cristofori, B. Pancino, C. Bignami, E. Rugini, S. Gasbarra.................................... 406-409
Flash grazing of hogs in apple orchards for pest management
David Epstein, M Grieshop ..........................................................................................................410
The sterile insect technique as a component of area-wide integrated pest management
Andrew Jessup, Marc Vreysen ......................................................................................................411
Softpest: a website on the usage of pesticides & biocontrol agents in soft fruits
Christian Linder,Janet Allen, Catherine Baroffio, Agata Broniarek-Niemiec, Victoria Brookes5,
Jerry Cross, Cathy Eckert, Rudolf Faby, Bruno Gobin, Alberto Grassi, Adrian Harris, Barbara
Łabanowska, Emilie Lascaux, Carlo Malavolta, Vincent Michel, Slobodan Milenkovic, Thilda
Nilsson, Paivi Parikka, Klaus Paaske, Jean-Jacques Pommier, Daniele Prodorutti, Lene
Sigsgaard, Arne Stensvand, Christer Torneus, Nina Trandem, Tuomo Tuovinen, Gábor Vétek412-414
Organic Raspberry Production in Serbia
Slobodan Milenkovic, Snežana Tanasković, Dušica Sretenović ........................................... 415-418
Is organic hazelnut cultivation profitable?
Barbara Pancino, Valerio Cristofori .................................................................................... 419-422
xi
Further observation on hazelnut yielding and fruit quality under organic and conventional
management.
Alessandro Roversi, Gian Luca Malvicini ............................................................................ 423-429
Codling moth proof hail nets
Benoit Sauphanor, G. Severac, L. Romet, E. Esberard, J.F. Toubon, S. Maugin ..........................430
Building up, management and evaluation of orchard systems: a three-year experience in apple
production
Sylvaine Simon, Benoît Sauphanor, Sophie Buléon, Johanny Guinaudeau, Laurent Brun . 431--434
Effect of different type row mulches on the success of biological control of strawberry tarsonemid
mite
Tuomo Tuovinen, Isa Lindqvist, Pirjo Kivijärvi............................................................................435
Poster Session 2 : Pathology
The OrganicA Project: Organic Disease Management in Orchards with ‘Newer’ Cultivars
Lorraine Berkett, M. Garcia, R. Moran, H. Darby, R. Parsons, J. Hayden, T. Bradshaw, S.
Kingsley-Richards, M. Cromwell .......................................................................................... 436-440
Investigation on survival and viability of cankers of Nectria galligena following removal from apple
trees and pulverisation on the orchard floor
Angela Berrie, B E Ellerker, K Lower, G Saunders .............................................................. 441-444
Inventory of European canker in southern Sweden and Nectria galligena as a soil pathogen.
Boysen Bengt ................................................................................................................................445
Integrating scab control methods with partial effects in apple orchards: the association of cultivar
resistance, sanitation and reduced fungicide schedules
Valérie Caffier, Frédérique Didelot, Maël Baudin, Gilles Orain, Arnaud Lemarquand, Luciana
Parisi .................................................................................................................................... 446-449
Application of thermo- and chemotherapy in vitro for elimination of some viruses infecting fruit trees
and small fruits
Miroslawa Cieslinska ........................................................................................................... 450-454
In vivo antagonism of Acremonium byssoides, endophyte in Vitis vinifera, towards Plasmopara viticola
Gaetano Conigliaro, Valeria Ferraro, Alessandra Martorana, Santella Burruano ............. 455-458
Preliminary investigation on the endophytic communities in Olea europaea L. in Sicily
Valeria Ferraro, Gaetano Conigliaro, Livio Torta, Santella Burruano, Giancarlo Moschetti459-463
Population variability of strawberry powdery mildew (Podosphaera aphanis) in different geographical
regions
Nick Harvey, Angela Berrie, Xiangming Xu ......................................................................... 464-472
Evaluation of fruit genetic resources for disease resistance
David Szalatnay, Kaspar Hunziker, Brion Duffy, Jürg E. Frey, Markus Kellerhals ............. 473-476
Activity of Physpe (laminarin) in control of strawberry diseases
Beata Meszka, Anna Bielenin ............................................................................................... 477-481
Prediction of Xanthomonas harboricola pv. pruni infection on peaches
Vittorio Rossi, Riccardo Bugiani, Simona Giosuè, Ceredi Gianni ....................................... 482-486
Monitoring of virus and phytoplasma diseases by laboratory diagnostic methods (PCR, RT-PCR,
DAS-ELISA) in apple and pear after sanitation process
Lubos Talacko ....................................................................................................................... 487-491
Eutypa dieback as an important disease in red currant (Ribes rubrum) and gooseberry (Ribes uvacrispa) in the Netherlands
Marcel Wenneker Peter Vink, Ilse Heurneman, Marcel van Raak, Anne Sophie van Bruggen ....492
Poster Session 2 : Pesticides and Resistance
Chlorantraniliprole (DPX-E2Y45, Rynaxypyr®) (Coragen®20SC and Altacor®35WG) - a new
diamide insecticide for control of codling moth (Cydia pomonella) and other top fruit
Lepidoptera. Product features with regards to IFP criteria.
xii
Andrea Bassi, Axel Dinter, Kristin Brugger, Niels-Martin Frost, John Wiles, Jean Luc Rison ....493
No evidence in codling moth for cross-resistance between chemical insecticides and Cydia pomonella
granulovirus
Johannes Jehle, Annegret Schmitt, Isabella Bisutti, Benoît Sauphanor, Jürg Huber....................494
Can delayed flight activity serve as an indicator for insecticide resistance?
Patrik Kehrli, Denis Pasquier, Pierre-Adrien Roux ............................................................. 485-497
Cydia pomonella (Lep: Tortricidae) resistance and cross-resistance to various classes of insecticides in
Central Europe
František Kocourek ......................................................................................................................498
Efficacy of chlotianidyna (neonicotinoid group) in the control of the strawberry root weevil
(Otiorhynchus ovatus) on strawberry
Barbara Labanowska ........................................................................................................... 499-502
Trials for the development of alternative control strategies against the codling moth (Cydia pomonella)
in pome fruits in Austria in 2007
Christa Lethmayer, H. Hausdorf, J. Altenburger..........................................................................503
Microencapsulation and PBO: a tool in resistance management of the green peach aphid
Emanuele Mazzoni, Carlotta Gobbi, Ferdinando Pavesi, Valerio Borzatta, Piero Cravedi 504-507
Susceptibility to abamectin of pear psylla, Cacopsylla pyri (L.) (Hemiptera: Psyllidae) in pear
orchards of north-east Spain
Xavier Miarnau, Miquel Artigues, Maria José Sarasúa...............................................................508
Plant infusions to limit the development of pests or diseases : results on Aphis pomi
Sophie-Joy Ondet..........................................................................................................................509
Comparison of susceptibility and nychtemerals rhythms between reared insects of Mediterranean fruit
fly (Ceratitis capitata) and wild population of Algeria treated with a fenthion insecticide
Salah Oukil, Renè Causse.............................................................................................................510
Preliminary resistance screening of abamectin on pear psylla (Hemiptera: Psyllidae) in Northern Italy
Edison Pasqualini, S. Civolani, R. Peretto, C. Chieco, M. Chicca, M. Leis.................................511
Strategies and timing of protection practices against Cydia pomonella (L.) in apple orchards
Daniel Plénet, Camille Picard, Jean-François Toubon, Olivier Martin, Rachid Senoussi, Benoît
Sauphanor............................................................................................................................. 512-515
Insecticide Resistance of Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) Eggs and First Larval
Instars in Spanish Field Populations
Marcela Rodriguez, Dolors Bosch, Tânia Marques, Jesús Avilla ................................................516
Molecular detection of pest resistance to insecticides
Myriam Siegwart, Juliette Goussopoulos, Jérôme Olivares................................................. 517-520
New isolates of CpGV overcome virus resistance of codling moth
Daniel Zingg .................................................................................................................................521
Poster Session 2 : Plant-Pest Interactions
Evaluation of technical scenarios for the peach-brown rot system using a virtual fruit model simulating
quality and storage potential
Caroline Gibert, Pierre Rouet, Claude Bruchou, Gilles Vercambre, Michel Génard, Daniel Plénet,
Philippe Nicot, Joël Chadœuf, Françoise Lescourret........................................................... 522-526
Codling moth (Cydia pomonella L.) egg-laying behaviour on two Malus sp. preferred and non
preferred for egg-laying and leaf surface metabolite signals
Nadia Lombarkia, Sylvie Derridj ......................................................................................... 527-530
Apple resistance to arthropod herbivores: genetic basis and modification by environmental factors
Karsten Mody, Sibylle Stoeckli, Cesare Gessler, Silvia Dorn ............................................... 531-535
Peach breeding for multiple resistances to pests and diseases contributes to integrated fruit production
Thierry Pascal, P. Lambert, J.L. Poëssel, V. Decroocq, M.H. Sauge ...........................................536
xiii
Poster Session 2 : Plant-Pest Interactions
GEP, a tool for helping decision making for pest control advisers in Lleida (Spain)
Jesus Avilla, Manel Ribes-Dasi, Ramon Torà...............................................................................537
MRV-Carpocapsa: a phenological model as decision support system for Codling Moth (Cydia
pomonella L.) in Emilia-Romagna (Italy)
Alda Butturini, Rocchina Tiso, Mauro Boselli, Simona Giosuè, Giovanni Burgio............... 538-542
Development of a dynamic population model as a decision support system for Codling Moth (Cydia
pomonella L) management
Marc Trapman, Herman Helsen, Matty Polfliet ...........................................................................543
Impact of flower strip establishment in apple orchards on natural enemy populations
Daniel Cormier, Jennifer De Almeida, Éric Lucas ............................................................... 544-547
COSMOS, a spatially explicit model to simulate the epidemiology of Cosmopolites sordidus in banana
fields
Françoise Lescourret, Fabrice Vinatier, Philippe Tixier, Christophe Le Page, Pierre-François
Duyck, Claude Bruchou........................................................................................................ 548-551
Effects of thermoperiodic conditions on the developmental rate of the codling moth larvae of resistant
and non-resistant strains to chemical and viral (CpGv) insecticides
Ana Scomparin, Marc Saudreau, Hervé Sinoquet, Benoit Sauphanor, Marie Berling, Odair
Fernandes, David G. Biron ................................................................................................... 552-555
Poster Session 2 : Semiochemicals
Raspberry cane midge Resseliella theobaldi: 3 years of flight monitoring in Swiss raspberry cultures
Catherine Baroffio, Charley Mittaz ...................................................................................... 556-558
Management of Oriental Fruit Moth and Codling Moth with spray application of microencapsulated
sex pheromone
Daniele Demaria, Manuela Cigolini, Graziano Vittone, Fabio Molinari ............................ 559-562
Isomate C Plus Dispensers as an Alternative Means for Control of Codling Moth, Cydia pomonella L.,
in Apple Orchards of Bulgaria
Hristina Kutinkova, Jörg Samietz , Vasiliy Dzhuvinov , Vittorio Veronelli,Andrea Iodice .... 563-568
A field unit for automatic monitoring of insect behaviour
Federica Trona, Gianfranco Anfora, Roberto Oberti, Ezio Naldi, Claudio Ioriatti,
Gino Angeli...................................................................................................................................569
Correlation between maturity of female R. cerasi, oviposition, larval development and ripeness of
cherries
Kirsten Köppler, Barbara Féjoz, Heidrun Vogt.................................................................... 570-574
xiv
Integrated Production: where is it and where is it going?
Jesús Avilla, Ernst Boller, Carlo Malavolta, Frank Wijnands, Robert Baur
IOBCwprs Commission “Integrated Production: Guidelines and Endorsements”
Abstract: The objective of this presentation is to give an overview of the present status of Integrated
Production worldwide, from a conceptual rather than from a quantitative approach, and to present
some ideas for discussion on the future of IP. There is no doubt that Integrated Production systems are
now well established worldwide, and implemented and applied by growers, from the “old Europe”,
where the first attempts began in the 1970s, to the “new world”, with Brazil probably being the best
example of a very dynamic organization. Brazilian IP guidelines and projects, based on IOBC
guidelines, do not only cover most of the crops grown, but also animal production. In many European
countries, IP has become the minimal standard for an agriculture that is considered sustainable enough
to be eligible for state subsidies. However, are IP-based commodities certified and sold as such and
known by the consumer? The answer to this question might be “not enough”. IP has always had a
problem of communication. The implementation of IP has not only enhanced the sustainability of
agricultural cropping systems (but, as yet, not of animal husbandry), but has also facilitated the
acceptance of techniques and processes that increase human health, food safety, and respect for
environmental and ethical issues. These achievements, however, are not perceived by the public.
Recently, the impact on production of controlling systems developed by private stakeholders, such as
GlobalGAP, has been very strong. Is there a need and a future for IP under these circumstances? From
the scientific point of view, it is clear that the answer is positive, as IP will continue to be a driving
force to improve cropping systems. From the commercial point of view, the answer is not so clear,
unless it becomes clear to the consumer in the future that IP is a label of total quality, not only taking
into account extrinsic or intrinsic quality, but also environmental, social and ethical quality.
Integrated Production, Present status, Perspectives
1
Disease management in organic apple orchards is more than applying
the right product at the correct time.
Marc Trapman
Bio Fruit Advies, Dorpsstraat 31, Zoelmond, the Netherlands
Abstract: The relative importance of diseases of apple varies with cultivar, management, time, and
climate. Many aspects of the cropping system influence the development of diseases and offer
possibilities for management. The choice of the variety determines the disease management for the
lifetime of the orchard. As apple scab is the dominant disease, the choice to plant commercially
attractive Vf resistant and low susceptible varieties is a logical step in more arid production regions. In
2008, Vf resistant varieties made up 30.8 % of the Dutch organic apple production, and 10.7 % of the
European organic apple production. Cultural practices affect the growth and nutrial status of the tree,
and therewith directly and indirectly influence the susceptibility to diseases. Sanitation measures are
common practise for most organic fruit growers and help to make other measures more effective by
reducing infection inoculums. Hot water treatment is embraced as an effective technique to reduce
losses by storage diseases. Despite all preventive measures, disease control in organic orchards at an
economically feasible level still largely depends on the application of fungicides. Decision support
systems like RIMpro are an important tool for growers to optimize the application of fungicides.
Measures that allow reduction of fungicidal applications on key diseases can lead to the development
of a secondary disease complex that can cause severe losses when not managed effectively. In
research, advisory and practical decision making and disease management in organic orchards should
always be seen in the perspective of the management of the total growing system. With all factors that
contribute to disease management optimized, we are able to successfully implement new materials and
methods that may not be as effective as common fungicides in themselves, but add to the effectiveness
of the disease management system as a whole. This total system approach makes organic fruit growing
what it is.
Apple, Organic production, Disease management, Vf resistance
2
Designing cropping systems to achieve Integrated Fruit Production
goals
Françoise Lescourret, Benoît Sauphanor
INRA, French National Institute for Agricultural Research, UR 1115 Plantes et Systèmes de
culture Horticoles, Domaine Saint-Paul, site Agroparc, F-84914 Avignon, France
Abstract: Orchards encounter strong protection problems, because of both the demand of high
standards of visual quality that requires an intensive use of pesticides, and the current adaptation of
pests and diseases to those pesticides. Facing these problems while preserving production and quality
and being attentive to the preservation of the environment, supposes designing cropping systems for
integrated fruit production. In this contribution, we expose the two ways of this design: expert-based
and model-based. Then, we point out the areas of research that should be strengthened to design IFP
cropping systems on sound bases. The first is the analysis of current protection practices. The second
is the study of crop-pest-enemies interactions under the influence of crop and pest management. The
third is landscape studies. We conclude on the multidisciplinary nature of research for IFP purposes.
Key words: IFP, cropping system, cultural practice, expert-based design, model-based design
Introduction
To face the environmental problems caused by the intensive use of chemical pesticides in
orchards (Aubertot et al, 2005), the reasoning of chemical interventions has been the subject
of thinking and research for many years. However, the corresponding progress in the eighties
were rapidly countered by the adaptation of pests and diseases (resistance to pesticides, to
biological control agents, to resisting cultivars), which is favoured by the perenniality of
orchard systems and the concentration of fruit crops in production basins. Moreover, fruit
crops are subjected to high quality standards, and the pest/disease pressure is likely to
influence many quality traits. The definition of IFP by IOBC in 2002 considers that the
“priority to ecologically safer methods” should not impair the quality of the production on
which its economical value relies. Reaching such objectives requires thinking together
production and protection, considering the crop as a whole, i.e. a set of plants, soil,
pests/diseases and their enemies and a network of interactions between them, how this ‘crop
as a whole’ changes under the influence of various management choices, and finally designing
cropping systems beyond protection systems.
In the following lines, we summarize the two ways of cropping system design as they
emerge from the works of agronomists (Doré et al, 2006), and point out the areas of research
that should be strengthened to design IFP cropping systems on sound bases.
Two ways of designing cropping systems
The first way is what can be called “expert-based design” because the core of the design is
expert knowledge on the ‘crop as a whole’ (see above). Amongst possible experts, research
workers, advisers, and stakeholders are able to provide complementary viewpoints and
information. The central idea is to formalise a cropping system prototype to be tested in the
field. Basically, this is the prototyping methodology (Vereijken, 1997) adapted by Lançon et
al (2007; but see also Debaeke et al, 2009). After Lançon et al (2007), four main steps can be
3
defined for expert-based design. First, the main constraints, i.e. limiting factors such as a high
pressure of a given pest or manpower, and the broad classes of criteria to be examined to
assess the performance and costs of the prototype, have to be defined. Second, a theoretical
prototype, as well as assessment indicators, is elaborated. The prototype may combine “IfThen-Else” and simpler rules (Debaeke et al, 2009). According to the choices at step 1, the
indicators may concern the agronomic and economic performances and the sustainability of
the system. Since the nineties, many agri-environmental indicators have been developed to
assess the adverse effects of cropping systems (Bockstaller et al, 2009), and biological groups
are also consistent indicators especially with respect to pest management (e.g. Simon et al,
2007). The third step is on station evaluation of the prototype which becomes, at this time, an
experimental prototype suffering local adaptations. The fourth and last step is that of on farm
evaluation of what has become, following the previous steps, a farmer prototype. Of course,
the methodology is not just top-down and linear and it requires many adjustments and loops
(Debaeke et al, 2009).
Model-based design is the second way of designing cropping systems. The core of the
design is a model representing the ‘crop as a whole’ (see above). Of course, it is a prerequisite. Designing the model means, since exhaustiveness is impossible, a lot of choices
about the constraints, the elements of the cropping system to consider, and the output criteria.
We shall not develop these aspects to rather concentrate on the model use. The central idea is
create or select in silico (using the model and a computer and the diagnosis of appropriate
experts during simulations!) prototypes of innovative cropping systems to be adjusted, then
tested during on station and on farm evaluation stages and triggering loops just as in the case
of the expert-based design. This relies on a dialogue between a model and a virtual cropping
system defined as a set of rules (see above; “If-Then-Else” rules entail a closer interaction
between the model and the virtual cropping system than “Do-That” rules that just provide an
input to the model). Searching solutions (“good” cropping systems) means looking for the
“good” parameters of the rules, e.g. the threshold for spraying or releasing biological agents.
The search space can be very wide (as in Tixier et al, 2008 with a model of plant-soilnematode interactions in banana) or narrowed to satisfy a set of constraints (as in Loyce et al,
2002a with a model of ethanol wheat encompassing the effect of fungal diseases). Then,
multi-criteria analysis is the key tool to assess the simulated results of the cropping systems.
Depending on the number of possible solutions, it can belong to the family of decision-aid
methods (Sadok et al, 2008) that is convenient to compare and rank a limited number of
solutions (see Loyce et al 2002a,b for an application), or to the family of multi-objective
optimisation, with exact algorithms (e.g. dynamic programming) or heuristic methods (e.g.
evolutionary algorithms: see deVoil et al, 2006 for an application), depending on the
complexity of the problem and model. In all cases, and with or without criteria aggregation,
the question of weighing the different criteria to rank or optimise solutions is crucial. The case
studies of Loyce et al (2002b) and Tixier et al (2008) showed the consequences of different
sets of weights on the appreciation of “good” cropping systems. IFP is a good case study to
search trade-offs between competing objectives such as fruit quality and environmental
preservation by using such sets of weights.
Which areas of research to strengthen to design IFP cropping systems?
The first area is the analysis of current practices. How to imagine new ways of doing without
referring to what is currently done? The objects of this analysis are the diversity and internal
consistency of practices, the objective reasons (van Mele and van Lenteren, 2002) as well as
the constraints, conceptions and influences behind the technical systems (Nesme et al, 2006).
Also, the potential for changing should be analysed by examining not only the conditions for
4
adoption of new systems, but also the existing trajectories (Lamine and Bellon, 2009).
The second area is the study and modelling of crop-pest-enemies interactions under the
influence of cropping systems, including cultural methods and chemical or biological
protection treatments. This network of interactions is at the core of expert or model-based
design of cropping systems. Some joint studies of production and health performances have
shown the interest of innovative management methods for both fruit quality and pest/disease
control. In the peach-brown rot case study, new tree training and regulated deficit irrigation
promoted sugar in fruit and storage potential and lowered the disease incidence (Mercier et al,
2008). Research on the underlying mechanisms revealed the major contribution to host
susceptibility of cuticular cracking, which follows fruit growth and generates entry sites for
the fungus, and the way of modulating it by irrigation and fruit thinning (Gibert et al, 2007).
Similarly, studies on peach-green aphid interactions have shown that moderate winter pruning
can contribute to aphid control because favouring “rosettes” (short shoots) at the expense of
long axes preferred by aphids (Grechi et al, 2008).
The third area is that of landscape studies. Though pests, diseases and their enemies
spread over the landscape, till now few studies have considered this, especially for fruit crops
and pests (but see Ricci et al, 2009). Detailed data should supply the controversial question of
the effects of landscape complexity on pests, beneficials and natural pest control (Bianchi et
al, 2006). Landscape traits, including not only those dealing with allocation of crops and noncrops, but also distribution of crop management practices (Ricci et al, 2009), open the way to
extend the cropping system concept. Accordingly, landscape design is the new paradigm of
landscape ecology (Nassauer and Opdam, 2008), and the above-cited methods of cropping
system design should apply to landscape design as well.
Conclusion
Designing cropping systems and landscapes to implement IFP requires several things that are
illustrated by contributions in this issue. First, a set of methodologies to perform system
experiments, models and multicriteria analysis. Second, a network of stations and pilot farms
to evaluate prototypes emerging from expert or model-based proposals. Third, knowledge on
fruit crops ‘as a whole”, the interactions between their components and the upscaling at the
landscape level. This means that multidisciplinary is the key word of the approach.
References
Aubertot, J.N., Barbier, J.M., Carpentier, A., Gril, J.J., Guichard, L., Lucas, P., Savary, S.,
Savini, I. & Voltz, M. (eds) 2005: Chapitre 4 : stratégies de protection des cultures. In :
Réduire l’utilisation des pesticides et limiter leurs impacts environnementaux. Report of a
scientific collective expertise Inra-Cemagref Pesticides, agriculture et environnement, ch.
4, 104 pp.
Bianchi, F.J.J.A., Bookj, C.J.H. & Tscharntke, T. 2006: Sustainable pest regulation in
agricultural landscapes: a review on landscape composition, biodiversity and natural pest
control. Proc. Royal. Soc. B 273: 1715-1727.
Bockstaller, C., Guichard, L., Keichinger, O., Girardin, Ph., Galan, M.B. & Gaillard, G. 2009:
Comparison of methods to assess the sustainability of agricultural systems. A review.
Agron. Sustain. Dev. 29: 223-235.
Debaeke, Ph., Munier-Jolain, N., Bertrand, M., Guichard, L., Nolot, J.M., Faloya, V. &
Saulas, P. 2009: Iterative design and evaluation of rule-based cropping systems:
methodology and case studies. A review. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 29: 73-86.
deVoil, P., Rossing, W.A.H. & Hammer, G.L. 2006: Exploring profit-sustainability trade-offs
5
in cropping systems using evolutionary algorithms. Environ. Model. & Software 21:
1368-1374.
Doré, T., Le Bail, M., Martin, P., Ney, B. & Roger-Estrade, J. 2006: L’agronomie aujourd’hui.
Editions Quae, Versailles: 367 pp.
Gibert, C., Chadoeuf, J., Vercambre, G., Génard, M. & Lescourret, F. 2007: Cuticular
cracking on nectarine fruit surface : spatial distribution and development in relation to
irrigation and thinning. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 132: 583-591.
Gibert, C., Chadoeuf, J., Nicot, P., Vercambre, G., Génard, M. & Lescourret, F. to appear:
Modelling the effect of the cuticular crack surface area and the inoculum density on the
probability of nectarine fruit infection by Monilinia laxa. Plant Pathol. (in revision).
Grechi, I., Sauge, M.H., Sauphanor, B., Hilgert, N., Senoussi, R. & Lescourret, F. 2008: How
does winter pruning affect peach tree–Myzus persicae interactions? Entomol.
Experiment. Applic. 128: 369-379.
Lamine, C. & Bellon, S. 2009: Conversion to organic farming: a multidimensional research
object at the crossroads of agricultural and social sciences. A review. Agron. Sustain.
Dev. 29: 97-112.
Lançon, J., Wery, J., Rapidel, B., Angokaye, M., Gérardeaux, E., Gaborel, C., Ballo, D. &
Fadegnon, B. 2007: An improved methodology for integrated crop management systems.
Agron. Sustain. Dev. 27: 101-110.
Loyce, C., Rellier, J.P. & Meynard, J.M. 2002a: Management planning for winter wheat with
multiple objectives (1): The BETHA system. Agric. Systems 72: 9-31.
Loyce, C., Rellier, J.P. & Meynard, J.M. 2002b: Management planning for winter wheat with
multiple objectives (1): ethanol wheat production. Agric. Systems 72: 33-57.
Mercier, V., Bussi, C., Plénet, D., Lescourret, F. 2008: Effects of limiting irrigation and of
manual pruning on brown rot incidence in peach. Crop Protection 27: 678-688.
Nassauer, J.I. & Opdam, P. 2008: Design in science: extending the landscape ecology
paradigm. Landscape Ecol. 23: 633-644.
Nesme, T., Bellon, S., Lescourret, F. & Habib, R. 2006: Survey-based analysis of irrigation
and N fertilisation practices in apple orchards. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 26: 215-225.
Ricci, B., Franck, P., Toubon, J.F., Bouvier, J.C., Sauphanor, B. & Lavigne, C. 2009. The
influence of landscape on insect pest dynamics: a case study on the impact of hedgerow
network design and spatial distribution of orchards on codling moth population densities
in southeastern France. Landscape Ecol. On-line first (doi:10.1007/s10980-008-9308-6).
Sadok, W., Angevin, F., Bergez, J.E., Bockstaller, C., Colomb, B., Guichard, L., Reau, R. &
Doré, T. 2008: Ex ante assessment of the sustainability of alternative cropping systems:
implications for using multi-criteria decision-aid methods. A review. Agron. Sustain. Dev.
28: 163-174.
Simon, S., Defrance, H. & Sauphanor, B. 2007: Effect of codling moth management on
orchard arthropods. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 122: 340-348.
Tixier, Ph., Malézieux, E., Dorel, M. & Wery, J. 2008: SIMBA, a model for designing
sustainable banana-based cropping systems. Agric. Systems 97: 139-150.
Van Mele, P. & van Lenteren, J.C. 2002: Survey of current crop management practices in a
mixed-ricefield landscape, Mekong Delta, Vietnam – potential of habitat manipulation
for improved control of citrus leafminer and citrus red mite. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 88:
35-48.
Vereijken, P. 1997: A methodological way of prototyping integrated and ecological arable
farming systems (I/EAFS) in interaction with pilot farms. Eur. J. Agron. 7: 235-250.
6
Developing a protocol and a marketing niche for Eco Apples in NY
State
Harvey Reissig1, Arthur Agnello1, Daniel Cooley2, Jon Clements3, Michael Rozyne4,
Thomas Green5
1
Department of Entomology, Cornell University, New York State Agricultural Experiment
Station, Geneva, NY, USA 14456; 2 Microbiology Department, University of Massachusetts,
Amherst, MA, USA 01003; 3 University of Massachusetts Cooperative Extension,
Belchertown, MA, USA 01007; 4 Red Tomato Inc, Canton, MA, USA 02021; 5 IPM Institute of
North America, Madison, WI, USA 53726
Abstract: In 2007, Cornell University, University of Massachusetts, Red Tomato™ (a nonprofit
produce marketing corporation), and the IPM Institute of North America, Inc. received a 2-year grant
to develop a protocol for producing and marketing “Eco Apples™” in the Northeast. Red Tomato’s
mission is connecting farmers and consumers through marketing, trade and education and a belief in
family-farms, and a locally-based, ecological, fair trade food system. The goal is to create a market
niche for “Eco Apples™” that will result in premium prices and access to high-quality markets such as
Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s. Red Tomato’s apple sales grew from $130,000 in 2004 to $1.9 million
in 2008. The program grew from 6 New England growers with 475 acres in 2005 to 635 acres and 9
growers in 2008. Participating growers complete a self-assessment, pay an annual certification fee and
submit scouting and pesticide application records. The protocol is adjusted annually by Red Tomato
employees, participating growers, and university personnel. Pesticides are classified into 3 categories:
Green, use with justification; Yellow, use when Green materials are not available or effective; and Red,
do not use. In 2007 and 2008, pest control in Eco Apple orchards was generally as effective as that in
growers’ standard blocks. Economic costs and returns to participating growers have not yet been
calculated.
Keywords: IPM, reduced risk pesticides, marketing apples, Red Tomato™, Eco-Apple™
Introduction
Organic apple production is nearly impossible in the Northeastern United states because the
complex of insect and disease pests is much more formidable than in many other apple
production areas of the world. However, recent studies in a multi-state RAMP (Risk
Avoidance and Mitigation Program) grant have shown that Northeastern apple growers can
adequately control insect pests and diseases using IPM programs that utilize only reduced risk
pesticides, which are less toxic to humans and safer for the environment. However, these
programs are more expensive than growers’ standard control programs using conventional
pesticides. Apple growers in this region would be more likely to adopt these types of IPM
programs if they could receive premium prices for apples grown using these techniques to
help offset increased costs of materials, and sampling and monitoring programs. In 2007,
Cornell University, the University of Massachusetts, and Red Tomato™, a private non-profit
corporation, started a research program to determine if a multi-state market niche could be
created for Northeastern apples grown under IPM programs using reduced risk pesticides that
would provide growers with premium prices and market access that is similar to that currently
utilized by organic fruit.
Red Tomato was founded in 1996 by Michael Rozyne and is based in Canton, MA. It is a
7
non-profit corporation that is funded through grants and donations. This organization
connects farmers with markets and consumers with fresh fruits and vegetables. Red Tomato’s
mission is "connecting farmers and consumers through marketing, trade, and education, and
through a passionate belief that a family-farm, locally-based, ecological, fair trade food
system is the way to a better tomato." This corporation has developed a marketing concept in
which “Eco Apples™” are equal to organic apples in prices and access to high quality market
outlets. Eco Apples are grown using ecological farming methods by family farms in the
Northeastern US. The prototype program was developed in 2003 by Red Tomato in
conjunction with the University of Massachusetts, two commercial growers, and New
England Fruit Consultants. This group analyzed pest management options and economics,
and developed marketing procedures. The goals of this Eco Apple project are: 1) To
eliminate or minimize the use of organophosphate and carbamate insecticides; 2) To
eliminate or minimize the use of potentially carcinogenic fungicides; 3) To develop a
marketing plan that increases revenues sufficient to offset the increased costs of an intensive
pest management programs that uses reduced risk pesticides. The program has been refined
and expanded from 2004-08.
Red Tomato has gradually been expanding sales of Eco Apples since the program began.
The following marketing benchmarks have been reached by the company: 2004, Eco Apple
sales of $130,000; 2005, sales of $400,000; 2006, sales of $600,000; 2007, sales of $1.3
million; 2008, sales of $1.9 million. The acreages and numbers of growers has also expanded
from 475 acres of apples and 6 growers in 2005-06 to 635 acres and 9 growers in 2008. The
primary markets for Red Tomato are upscale specialty stores such as Whole Foods, Trader
Joe’s and a collection of independent chains throughout the Northeast.
Materials and methods
Tom Green, Director of the IPM Institute of North America, is responsible for the
classification of pesticides that can be used by growers in the program. Pesticides are
classified according the their overall hazard rating. "Green" pesticides can be used with
justification. "Yellow" pesticides can be used, with justification, when Green list or other
alternatives are not adequate, and those pesticides on the "Red" list cannot be used in the
program. Pesticides are classified within the program according to the following criteria:
acute toxicity to wildlife, fish and birds; acute toxicity to humans; possible/likely/probable
carcinogen; reproductive/developmental toxin; toxicity to pollinators, natural enemies,
secondary pests; toxicity to wildlife; suspected endocrine disruptor; broad-spectrum pesticide;
resistance risk; potential or known groundwater contaminant. Examples of insecticides
classified as Green in the program are: Assail (acetamiprid), Dipel (Bacillus thuringiensis,
Surround (kaolin clay), oil, Spintor (spinosad), mating disruption, and Esteem (pyriproxyfen).
Insecticides classified as Yellow are:
Proclaim (emamectin benzoate); Provado
(imidacloprid); Intrepid (methoxyfenozide); Sevin (carbaryl) – for thinning only); Calypso
(thiacloprid) – only for plum curculio; and Asana (esfenvalerate) – only for rosy apple aphid,
as a special case in Pennsylvania. Some examples of Red insecticides are: Guthion
(azinphosmethyl) – acute toxicity, AChE inhibitor, broad spectrum; Apollo (clofentezine) –
possible carcinogen, suspected endocrine disruptor); Savey (hexythiazox) – possible
carcinogen, moderate aquatic toxicity; Rimon (novaluron) – acute toxicity; Warrior (lambda
cyhalothrin) acute toxicity, beneficials, endocrine disruptor; Actara (thiamethoxam) – likely
carcinogen (although now placed in the Yellow category following an EPA review of further
toxicology data).
Participating growers in the project are located in the Northeast, with 2 in New
Hampshire, and 1 each in Vermont, Massachusetts and Connecticut. Currently, NY has 4
8
participating farms with 62 acres. Two of the NY participating growers are wholesale
marketers, and 2 are direct marketers. In New England, the 5 farms are participating with a
total of 500 acres. The NE cooperators include both direct and wholesale producers.
Results and discussion
During the two seasons of the project, pest control has been similar to standard growers’
conventional programs both in NY and in New England. New England growers have always
obtained higher levels of clean fruit than those in NY. Two of the NY orchards (Stone Ridge
and Ten Eyck) had lower percentages of clean fruit at harvest than some of the other blocks at
harvest in 2007, because of ineffective scab control programs. Disease control in all NY
blocks was much better in 2008.
Table 1. Percent clean fruit at harvest in participating Eco Apple Grower orchards.
State/Orchard
Vermont / Sunrise
Connecticut / Lyman
New Hampshire / Alyson
Massachusetts / Clark
Vermont / Scott
2007
95.3
96.2
93.1
90.1
90.4
2008
New York Orchards
Apple Acres
Stone Ridge
Ten Eyck
Truncali Home
Truncali Bingham
Knight
89.8
73.5
83.0
87.4
-
97.2
82.2
88.2
90.5
96.5
It has been somewhat difficult to directly determine the prices of fruit that growers have
sold within the program, but growers were surveyed to determine how they perceived the
benefits of an association with Red Tomato. The growers generally agreed that the prices they
received were better than that from other apple brokers and that they received the prices
promised. They also believed that they had a good relationship with Red Tomato, and that
communication in the project was quite transparent. The growers felt that Red Tomato has
been understanding when they were unable to reach set targets, and consequently they would
not be interested in going elsewhere. They recognized that Red Tomato is interested in
working with smaller growers and because of that they didn’t have to market entire tractortrailer loads of apples. Other brokers were cited as being erratic in their dealings with
growers, even when high quality produce was being marketed. Growers were relieved that
Red Tomato was doing the “footwork” with potential markets so that growers were not
pressured into selling prematurely. They appreciated Red Tomato’s contacts and their ability
to deal with logistics. Finally, the growers were satisfied with the added value of the Eco
Apple brand, and the dependability of the market even in this niche arena.
Despite the relative success of this short-term project, there are still problems and
potential limitations to developing a value-added marketing concept such as the “Eco Apple”
approach. It is very important for grower participants in this type of program to obtain both
9
access to selective markets and also premium prices. Unfortunately, many selective marketers
tend to continually raise the bar of certain criteria that growers must follow to gain access to
their markets and sometimes do not raise prices to reimburse growers for additional effort and
expenses. If these types of programs are to succeed in the future, it will be necessary to
attempt to persuade market outlets to pay premium prices to reimburse growers and, if
necessary, to pass on the additional expenses to consumers. Also, in this project, some key
new reduced risk pesticides are not approved for use in the current protocol. Certainly, in
moving forward in classifying pesticides, it is necessary to be sufficiently flexible to allow the
use of certain products in this program that might not be perfect for each classification
category, but still have an overall profile that is better than standard materials that are
currently used by growers. Even though this project has been gradually expanding, both in
terms of sales, and numbers of growers and acreage, it is still a relatively small operation.
Often it is inherently difficult to occupy a specialized market niche and expand a program so
that large numbers of growers can participate. Currently this project focuses primarily on
growers marketing to wholesale outlets, and benefits for growers directly marketing apples in
local farm stands have not yet been optimized. Direct-market growers often have long-term
clients that already trust their current pest management practices and appreciate the quality of
their products. Therefore, the only benefit from participating in a program such as Eco Apple
marketing for small direct marketers might be in attracting new customers. However, in
adopting a niche marketing program, the direct marketer must put the whole farm in the
project to avoid negative perception by his consumers of any non-certified fruit that might be
grown on the farm. These growers also run the risk of eroding confidence of long-term
customers who might perceive that the adoption of a new program indicates that previous
practices were not adequately protecting consumers and the environment.
Finally, it is important to continue to promote this project in such a way that other
powerful interest groups such as growers using conventional pesticides and organic growers
are not threatened by this style of niche marketing. Organic growers have traditionally been
opposed to production practices that use non-organic pesticides in spite of their desirable
toxicity, selectivity, and safety to the environment. Often, conventional growers have a deepseated fear that the promotion of a niche market for Eco Apples implies that conventional
growing practices are detrimental to the environment and unhealthy for the consumer.
Consequently, they feel that promotion of such niche markets could lower the demand and
price for their conventional products.
Acknowledgements
We thank the following participants in this project: W. Blackler, Apple Acres; J. Knight,
Knight Farms; P. Ten Eyck, Indian Ladder Farms; V. Truncali, W. Truncali, & J. Truncali,
Truncali Farms; M. Biltonen, Stone Ridge Orchards; P. Jentsch, Cornell's Hudson Valley Lab;
J. Carroll, NYS IPM Program; R. Koch, Apple Leaf, Inc. This work supported by a USDACAR grant.
References
Eco Apple Protocol can be viewed on the Red Tomato Eco Apple home page:
http://www.redtomato.org/ecoapples.html
10
Analyzing the results of a biodiversity experiment: Enhancing
parasitism of Platynota idaeusalis (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae)
M. W. Brown1, Clarissa R. Mathews2 and Greg Krawczyk3
1
Appalachian Fruit Research Station, 2217 Wiltshire Road, Kearneysville, WV 25430 USA;
fax: 304-728-2340; mark.brown@ars.usda.gov
2
Institute for Environmental Science, Shepherd University, Shepherdstown, WV 25443 USA;
cmathews@shepherd.edu
3
The Pennsylvania State University, Department of Entomology, Fruit Research and
Extension Center, Biglerville, PA 17307, USA; gxk13@psu.edu
Abstract: A common goal of conservation biological control is to enhance biodiversity and increase
abundance and effectiveness of predators and parasitoids thus increasing sustainability of pest
management. Although many studies report an increase in abundance of natural enemies, it has been
difficult to document increases in rates of biological control. To enhance parasitism of the leafroller,
Platynota idaeusalis (Tortricidae), alternate food was provided by interplanting peaches with
extrafloral nectaries into apple orchards. Laboratory studies showed that the presence of peach
extrafloral nectar increased longevity and parasitism rates by Goniozus floridanus (Bethylidae), the
dominant parasitoid in West Virginia, USA. In orchard studies we found the total number of
Hymenopteran parasitoids was higher on peach trees than on adjacent apple trees. Abundance of
Hymenoptera was also significantly higher on the side of traps facing away from rather than toward
peach trees, indicating attraction to peach trees producing extrafloral nectar. However, total parasitism
rates of P. idaeusalis by all species of parasitoids were not affected by the presence of peach
extrafloral nectar in any field studies. Insect injury to fruit at harvest showed that fruit from orchards
with interplanted peach trees had less injury from San Jose scale (Quadraspidiotus perniciosus) and
stink bugs (Pentatomidae) than fruit from an apple monoculture control orchard. Although
interplanting with peach trees did not result in detectable increased biological control, the experiment
did have beneficial results for pest management. By collecting data on the response of an ecosystem
service (e.g., fruit quality) we were able to document a reduction in damage of two pests by the
interplanting of peach trees with extrafloral nectaries into apple orchards. This demonstrates the need
for a more holistic approach to evaluating habitat manipulation experiments. Without information on
the response of yield quality we would have concluded that the experimental addition of peaches had
no effect on insect pest damage. But, the yield data showed that pentatomids and scales responded
with decreased damage, through an as yet undetermined mechanism, from the experimental
manipulation. A cost:benefit analysis of the habitat manipulation is needed before recommendations
can be made. It appears promising, however, that the sustainability of apple ecosystems can be
enhanced by increasing its biodiversity with the addition of peach trees with extrafloral nectaries.
Key Words: apple, conservation biological control, Goniozus floridanus, Bethylidae, habitat
manipulation, extrafloral nectar, ecosystem service
11
Genetic modification of apple to control diseases:
Cesare Gessler1, Giovanni Broggini1, Gabriella Parravicini1, Paolo Galli1, Iris
Szankowski2, Roberta Paris3, Andrea Patocchi4
1
Plant Pathology, Institute of Integrative Biology, ETH-Z, Universitaetstrasse 2, CH 8092
Zurich, Switzerland 2Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz University of Hannover, Institute of Biological
Production Systems, Fruit Science Section, Herrenhaeuser Str. 2, D-30419 Hannover,
Germany 3Dipartimento Colture Arboree, Università degli Studi di Bologna, Via Fanin, 46,
40127 Bologna, Italy 4Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil (ACW), P.O. Box 185, CH-8820
Wädenswil, Switzerland
Abstract: Apple scab is controlled by a high number of fungicide applications. Fireblight control is
difficult and in some situations and up to three Streptomycin applications are necessary. The
application of such pesticides is highly questioned because of their potential environmental impact and
residues. Classical breeding has produced scab resistant cultivars and in the near future also fireblight
resistant cvs. However, their popularity is limited as the traditional market dominant cvs have quality
characteristics for producers, storage and consumers difficult to equal, and contrary to most other
crops, apples are recognized as a cultivar, e.g. Gala, Golden Delicious, and not as a crop e.g. Bananas.
In order to maintain the cultivar, single genes coding for enzymes and other proteins which can inhibit
or at least reduce the development of scab and fireblight can be introduced by DNA-technology. A
large range of foreign genes e.g. encoding lysozymes from bacteriaphages, fungi and animals have
been used and in some cases reduce fireblight and /or scab susceptibility. Pathogen derived genes or
pathogen induced promotors may also contribute. In all cases, all of the incorporated genes and control
sequences are foreign and the marker genes needed for the selection of the transformed cells are
antibiotic (e.g. nptII) or herbicide resistance genes (Bar). However such transgenic plants are currently
unacceptable in Europe, especially as apple is mostly a fresh consumed product and consumers are
highly sensitive to the issue. Even if legislation would permit such transgenic apple cultivars, no
producer will take the risk of not being able to sell his product. Moreover, his personal profit includes
the reduction of the number of treatments. Objection of the consumers, opinion makers and sometime
policy makers are very broad, ranging from ethical issues (we should not manipulate genes in a way
which nature does not, e.g. across natural barriers) to potential risks of outcrossing, vertical gene
transfer and others. Therefore an approach which delivers to plant only genes (including promotors
and terminators) originating from a crossable donor plant avoids most of the product oriented
objection and could be an interesting alternative to transgenesis. This, however, does not eliminate the
general objections to the technology itself. Such plants are defined as cisgenic. To create a cisgenic
plant, firstly the apples own resistance genes and promoter sequences need to be cloned, and,
secondly, a technology which eliminates the selection genes needs to be implemented. Both are
currently available. We introduced HcrVf2, one of the open-reading-frames present in the genomic
region introgressed in Malus x domestica from Malus floribunda 821, conferring Vf resistance against
scab into the cvs. Gala and Elstar. The gene is constitutively expressed at a high level under the control
of its own promoter and gives full resistance to an equal level and interaction as the Vf resistance
introgressed by classical breeding. For the development of cisgenic plants, marker genes are necessary
as they are for the development of transgenic plants. However, a system of post selection elimination
of the marker genes has been implemented in strawberry and is currently applied to apple. A further
system is reported to deliver ‘marker gene free’ in tomato and tobacco plants. We are currently testing
the two systems and developing a third, all using, as a target, the HcrVf2 gene with its own promoter.
The final result will be a plant of the target cv. into which the HcrVf2 has been introduced by DNArecombinant technology corresponding to the definition of cisgenic. Concurrently, we are identifying
further scab resistance genes and fireblight resistance regions with the final scope of obtain a cisgenic
12
apple cv. with fireblight resistance and scab resistance based on several functional different
resistances. Plants of popular cvs. with resistance to the two diseases can contribute to a reduction of
environment contamination and fruit residues avoiding the major critics against transgenic plants.
Cisgenic, Transgenic, Malus
13
Dispersal estimates of codling moth fertilized females in a French farm
based on kinship assessments
Pierre Franck 1*, Jérôme Olivares 1, Hubert Defrance 2, Sylvaine Simon 2, Claire
Lavigne 1
1
INRA, UMR 1115 Plantes et Systèmes de culture Horticoles, Agroparc, F-84914 Avignon
Cédex 9, France
2
INRA, UE de recherches intégrées, Gotheron F-26320 Saint-Marcel-les-Valence, France
*pfranck@avignon.inra.fr
Abstract: Until now, population dynamics of Lepidoptera pests were mainly inferred from the
monitoring of adult males using pheromone traps. Here, we analysed the dynamics of dispersal of
codling moth fertilized females, which is more closely connected with the agronomic attacks. The
dispersal of the fertilized females was estimated using genetic inferences of full-sibs among their
offspring. We collected 6824 larvae using geo-referenced band traps in nine orchards (differing in
host-plants and insecticide practices) from an experimental farm (90 ha) for five generations (20032006). Heterogeneity in the densities of larvae was mainly explained by inter-generation (twice higher
for the diapausing larvae generation) and inter-orchard (50 times higher in untreated apple orchards)
differences. A sub-sample of 1064 individuals was genotyped with a set of 13 microsatellite loci for
kinship inferences. Three hundred forty pairs of individuals were unambiguously determined as fullsibs. Ninety-six % of the full-sibs were collected within orchards, either on the same tree or on
relatively distant trees. The remaining 4% pairs of full-sibs were collected at all the inter-orchard
distances (80 to 700 m) including different host-plants. These results confirm the relatively sedentary
behaviour of the codling moth females in spite of their ability to disperse over very long distances and
to lay their eggs on different host-plants.
Keywords: Cydia pomonella, population dynamic, kinship inferences, dispersal, microsatellite
Introduction
Understanding the population dynamics of insect pests is an important issue for improvement
of their control, notably in the context of insecticide reduction. This is particularly true for the
codling moth, the major insect pest in apple and pear orchards, which is responsible for most
insecticide treatments in European and North American orchards. Despite intensive
insecticide pressures, codling moth can have locally dramatic impact on fruit production,
notably because of the development of insecticide resistances (Reyes et al 2007). Damage
caused by the codling moth is due to fruit perforation by its larvae, which prevent fruit
commercialisation. The whole larval development occurs within the fruit. Fifth instar larvae
pupate on the tree where they develop either directly or after overwintering. Consequently, the
distribution of the codling moth larvae represents the distribution of the laying sites. We can
assess the dispersal of the laying of each female analysing the spatial distribution of its
offspring. This dispersal is more connected with the agronomic attacks than that of males,
which is generally measured. So far, there have been almost no direct measures of female
dispersal, notably for long distance flight, due to the lack of suitable trapping method, such as
pheromone trap used for males (Mani & Wildbolz 1977). Here, genetic inferences of full-sib
pairs using microsatellite loci among geo-referenced larvae samples were performed to assess
the dispersal of fertilized females in the field.
14
Materials and methods
Sampling sites and trapping
Samplings were performed in nine different orchards at Gotheron INRA research station,
France. These orchards include different host plants (apple, pear, walnut and apricot) for the
codling moth and they were managed with different phytoprotection practices (non-treated,
organic and conventional). Samplings were performed in autumn 2003, 2004, 2005 and 2006,
and in spring 2005 in order to collect samples across two successive generations in 2005.
Fifth instar larvae were caught in corrugated cardboard traps wrapped around tree trunks. Five
to 45 traps were set per orchard depending on their characteristics (Table 1).
Table 1: Orchard characteristics
Area
Orchard Species
Variety
Protection Number of trees (m2) Number of traps
1
Apple
Multiple Non-treated
37
1575
15
2
Apple Smoothee
Organic
233
2500
30
3
Apple
Multiple
Organic
313
4800
30
4
Apple
Multiple Conventional
169
2500
30
5
Apple
Multiple Conventional
718
10500
45
6
Apple
Golden Conventional
123
2300
30
7
Pear
Multiple Conventional
485
5000
35
8
Walnut Franquette Conventional
370
21600
35
9
Apricot Multiple Non-treated
14
230
5
Genetic inferences
A total of thirteen microsatellite loci (Cp1.60, Cp1.62, Cp2.39, Cp2.129, Cp2.131, Cp3.169,
Cp3.180, Cp4.129, Cp4.S, Cp5.24, Cp5.M, Cp6.32, Cp6.46) were scored for 1064 individuals.
Primers of microsatellite loci had been identified from a partial genomic library of C.
pomonella (Franck et al 2005). Amplifications were carried out in 10 µL reaction volumes
containing 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 9, 50 mM KCl, 200 µM each dNTP, 0.4 µM each primer, 1.5
mM MgCl2, 0.5 units Taq DNA polymerase, 0.1 mg/ml BSA with two µL of DNA template.
The reverse primer for each pair was labeled with 700 or 800 IRDye™. We visualized PCR
products on 6.5% polyacrylamide denaturing gels on a Licor 4200 automatic DNA sequencer
using Saga™ software (Li-Cor).
Kinship assignments were performed between individual pairs from each generation
based on likelihood ratio tests (Queller & Goodnight 1989). We tested the hypothesis that
pairs were full-sibs versus the alternative hypothesis they were unrelated based on the alleles
they shared at each locus. For several loci, the likelihood ratio is the product of likelihood
ratios at each locus. The sum of the decimal logarithms of the likelihood ratios over all the
loci (lodscore) was the statistic used to compare the individual pairs. We used lodscore
threshold values high enough to consider that the number of unrelated pairs misclassified as
full-sibs in our data set was null at each generation.
Estimates of the dispersal of fertilized females
Since larvae do not disperse among trees during their development, the geographic
distribution of full-sibs provide estimates of the dispersal of their mother. The dispersal curb
of these fertilized females was estimated based on the distribution of the geographic distances
between full-sibs pairs. This distribution was compared to a random distribution of the fullsibs obtained by re-sampling the same number of distances as the number of observed full15
sibs pairs in all distances between all pairs of individuals genotyped at each generation.
Results
Codling moth trapping
We collected a total of 6824 larvae over the five generations. Table 2 shows the mean number
of captures per tree. The densities of larvae captured per tree were on average higher for the
second generation than the first generation. Differences among orchards were mainly
explained by higher densities of captures in orchard 1, the untreated apple orchard and lower
densities of capture in conventional orchards, in particular orchard 5. We also collected very
small numbers of codling moths in orchard 9, a non-treated apricot orchard.
Table 2: Number of captures per orchard along the 2003-2006 period.
Number of larvae per
Orchard
tree
min
mean
max
1
14.7
52.3
92.2
2
0.2
1.3
2.8
3
0.3
0.9
1.9
4
0.3
0.8
1.7
5
0.1
0.2
0.3
6
0.7
1.7
2.4
7
0.1
0.4
0.6
8
0.3
3.8
10.7
9
0.0
0.9
1.1
Estimation of the dispersal of fertilized females
The threshold lodscore value taken into account to estimate the laying dispersal was seven at
each generation. At this threshold level, a total of 340 pairs were classified as full-sibs among
the 1064 individuals genotyped. The distribution of the full-sib pairs significantly differed
from a random distribution at almost all the classes of distances. Twenty-three % of the fullsibs were found on the same tree. The mean distance of the dispersal curve was 35 m, the
median 80 m and its mode 20 m. The inter-orchard dispersal of the laying was around 4%. It
did not depend apparently on the distances between orchards or on host-plants. The longest
distances of dispersal were recorded between orchards 5 and 7 (691 m) and between orchards
1 and 6 (698 m). No inter-orchard dispersal was observed among the samples collected in
spring 2005, which may represent different migratory behavior between the first and the
second generations. The distribution of the distances between full-sibs was also
heterogeneous within the orchards. With regard to the random distribution of the distances
between full-sibs, we observed an excess of sibs on the same tree and at the longest intraorchard distances.
Discussion
In this study we found that codling moth females frequently laid their eggs on the same tree.
However, in around 3/4 of the cases they laid their eggs on different trees. They usually laid
their eggs within the same orchard, but they were also capable of long distance flights
between orchards between two sequences of egg-laying. Our results extend previous results
based on mark-release-recapture methods established using pheromone or bait traps to
measure male and female dispersals, respectively. Captures of marked males with pheromone
traps indeed suggested that male dispersal occurs over relatively short distances, but that rare
16
cases of long distance dispersal are possible -- up to 11 km (Mani & Wildbotz 1977) in
agreement with the high flight ability of the pest (Schumacher et al 1997) and the low genetic
differentiation among populations (Franck et al 2007). Mark-release-recapture experiments
performed with alimentary baited traps (Steiner 1940) also indicated that females disperse
over relatively short distances (mean 200 m, up to 650m). Measured dispersal distances
depend largely on the experimental protocol used and on the landscape characteristics. Using
kinship analyses to determine dispersal overcame some difficulties posed by classical
protocols such as the possible impact of baits on dispersal, the possibly different behaviour of
laboratory strains as compared to wild populations, or the artificial environment used to
measure flight ability. Nevertheless, our results are probably highly dependent on the
landscape in which dispersal was estimated. First, the maximum distance between two
sampling points was 856 m, which made it impossible to measure larger dispersal distances.
Second, hedgerows or large amounts of open field are supposed to act as barriers to dispersal
for codling moth (Tyson et al 2007) and the windbreaks surrounding the orchards may limit
movement between orchards in this study. Third, the small area of each orchard in this study
may explain the relatively low distances between two sequences of egg-laying since females
rarely disperse between orchards.
Mating disruption is now frequently used to control codling moth in apple and pear
orchards. The flight of fertilized females within the area under mating disruption has been
suggested as being one cause of the lack of efficiency of this control method, in particular at
the border of the area under mating disruption. Here, half of the fertilized females flew more
than 80 m. This indicates that, for mating disruption to be efficient, mating disruption area
should be separated from non-disrupted orchards by a few hundred meters. The minimum
orchard area under mating disruption should be larger than the typical French
recommendation of 3 ha.
Acknowledgement
We are very grateful to Karine Morel, Freddy Combes and Jean-François Toubon for their assistance
in collecting codling moth larvae. We thank Benoît Sauphanor for his helpful comments in defining
the project. The project was funded by INRA (department “Santé des Plantes & Environnement”) and
the ECOGER program “Ecco des vergers”.
References
Franck, P., Guérin, F., Loiseau, A., Sauphanor, B. 2005: Isolation and characterisation of
microsatellite loci in the codling moth Cydia pomonella L. (Lepidoptera, Tortricidae). Molecular
Ecology Notes 5:99-102.
Franck, P., Reyes, M., Olivares, J., Sauphanor, B. 2007: Genetic architecture in codling moth
populations: comparison between microsatellite and insecticide resistance markers. Molecular
Ecology 16:3554–3564.
Mani, E. & Wildbolz, T. 1977: The dispersal of male codling moths (Laspeyresia pomonella L.) in
the Upper Rhine Valley. Journal of Applied Entomology 83:161-168.
Queller, D. C. & Goodnight, K. F. 1989: Estimating relatedness using genetic markers. Evolution
43:258-275.
Reyes, M., Franck, P., Charmillot, P.-J., Ioriatti, C., Olivares, J., Pasqualini, E., Sauphanor, B. 2007:
Diversity of insecticide resistance mechanisms and spectrum in European populations of the
codling moth, Cydia pomonella. Pest Management Science 63:890-902.
Schumacher, P., Weyeneth, A., Weber, D. C., Dorn, S. 1997: Long flights in Cydia pomonella L.
(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) measured by a flight mill: influence of sex, mated status and age.
Physiological Entomology 22:149-160.
17
Steiner, L. F. 1940: Codling moth flight habits and their influence on results of experiments. Journal
of Economic Entomology 33:436-440.
Tyson, R., Thistlewood, H., Judd, G. J. R. 2007: Modelling dispersal of sterile male codling moths,
Cydia pomonella, across orchard boundaries. Ecological Modelling 205:1-12.
18
Observations on the phenology of codling moth in untreated orchards
in the Netherlands and Belgium
Hermann Helsen1, Matty Polfliet2, Marc Trapman3
1 Wageningen UR, PPO, Sector Fruit, Postbus 200, NL-6670 AE Zetten 2 Fruit Consult,
Zetten, The Netherlands 3 Bio Fruit Advies, Zoelmond, the Netherlands
Abstract: Effective control of codling moth, Cydia pomonella, requires a good knowledge of the
periods of egg laying and hatching of the larvae. Observations were done in a large number of
untreated apple orchards in the Netherlands and Belgium to get an insight in the egg laying behaviour.
At regular intervals all codling moth damaged fruits were collected from marked plots in insecticidefree orchards. Larvae were removed from the fruits and the age of each larva was determined from its
length and the width of the head capsule. For the individual larvae their approximate date of egg
deposition was back-calculated from temperature records. In this way, frequency distributions of egg
laying and hatching of successful codling moth larvae in local populations could be generated. Egg
laying and subsequent egg hatch showed patterns with distinct peaks. Egg laying in different regions
showed similar patterns within years. The consequences of these patterns for effective codling moth
control strategies will be discussed.
Codling moth, Cydia pomonella, Apple, Phenology
19
Differences among Cacopsylla melanoneura Förster (Homoptera:
Psyllidae) insight from molecular markers
Valeria Malagnini1, Federico Pedrazzoli1, Chiara Papetti2, Valeria Gualandri1, Elisa
Bozza1, Federica Fiamingo1, Rosaly Zasso1, Claudio Ioriatti1.
1FEM-IASMA Research Centre, Plant Protection Department, via E. Mach, 1, 38010 San
Michele all’Adige (TN), Italy; 2University of Padua, Department of Biology, via U. Bassi,
58/B, 35121 Padova, Italy
Abstract: The psyllid Cacopsylla melanoneura (Föster) is one of the vectors of ‘Candidatus
Phytoplasma mali’, the causal agent of apple proliferation disease (AP). In northern Italy,
overwintering adults of C. melanoneura can be found both on apple (Malus domestica L.) and on
hawthorn (Crataegus monogyna L.) from the end of January. Eggs are laid on the two host plants
around March and the neanids complete their development at the end of April. Around mid-June the
new generation adults move to shelter plants. Adults of the new generation can be found on conifers
(especially Picea abies L.) at high altitudes from the end of the summer to the winter. The presence of
AP phytoplasma was assessed by PCR in overwintering adults collected on the three host plants
(apple, hawthorn and Norway spruce). The genetic variations among populations of C. melanoneura
collected on the different host plants and in different localities were analyzed using microsatellites
markers developed for C. melanoneura and COI sequences. ‘Candidatus Phytoplasma mali’ was
found in most of C. melanoneura populations with differences in the percentage and titre. Data
obtained from microsatellite analyses indicate differences among populations, which could explain the
differences in the efficiency of acquisition and transmission of AP phytoplasma by the different
populations.
Psyllids, Apple, Hawthorn, Microsatellites, DNA markers
20
Whole-farm infestation trends and management programs for
obliquebanded leafroller in apples
Arthur Agnello, Harvey Reissig
Department of Entomology, Cornell University, New York State Agricultural Experiment
Station, Geneva, NY, USA 14456
Abstract: Because of an incomplete understanding of the role of habitat, alternate hosts, and adult
movement in NY fruit infestations by obliquebanded leafroller (OBLR), we wished to obtain a
temporal and spatial picture of summer larval re-infestation patterns. In 2007, an unrealistically
aggressive early season spray program was used to eradicate overwintered larvae on 3 commercial
farms (17–32 acres) with a history of OBLR injury. Summer generation adults were monitored using
a network of pheromone traps located at different orchard strata on all 4 ordinal sides. Weekly
terminal and fruit samples were taken at each station. Although large numbers of adults were caught,
larval terminal infestations and fruit damage remained low in all blocks. There were no substantial
differences in adult catches, larval infestations or fruit damage in the different orchard strata. This
suggested the utility of developing a sampling plan for the summer OBLR generation based on fruit
damage rather than the traditional sampling of larvae on growing terminals. In 2008, methods above
were repeated on 6 farms (20–40 acres) and participating growers agreed to leave small plots untreated
with no sprays against summer larvae until the first damaged apple was observed. These small plots
and at least two other areas being treated with standard programs were sampled 2 times/week until
damage was detected. After a recommended spray, sampling continued but additional sprays were not
recommended unless fruit damaged exceeded 1.5%. Pesticide spray recommendations were followed
in only 6 of the 12 total sample-based plots, owing to cutbacks in some growers' pest management
programs resulting from early season hail damage to the crop. Nevertheless, fruit damage at harvest
showed no significant differences between the sample-based program and the grower standard
preventive program, either in total percent damage or in any USDA grade categories (X-Fancy, Utility,
and Cull). A partial budget analysis will be conducted to determine grower returns in the standard vs.
research plots.
Keywords: obliquebanded leafroller, Choristoneura rosaceana, pheromone trap monitoring, larval
infestation, fruit damage inspection, apple
Introduction
Obliquebanded leafroller (OBLR) is the most challenging fruit-feeding, or direct pest, of
apple in New York State. Its life cycle is out of sync with that of most other orchard pests, as
it overwinters as a partially grown larva and begins feeding immediately in the spring as
temperatures warm. This necessitates extra pesticide applications specifically targeting
summer populations. Additionally, OBLR has developed resistance to many conventional
pesticides (e.g., OPs and pyrethroids), so effective management requires the use of selective,
speciality materials (such as B.t., IGRs, microbials, etc.). Even so, it is still very difficult to
completely eliminate damage from this pest. In high-pressure situations, 1–3% fruit damage
at harvest is common. It has the capacity for long flight, plus other behavioral traits that
render it unsuitable for pheromone mating disruption.
Furthermore, there has always been an incomplete understanding of the role of such
factors as habitat, alternate hosts, adult movement, natural enemies, etc. in the incidence of
fruit infestation. For instance, overwintered larvae can often be found in unmanaged or feral
21
sites, but the subsequent summer populations are negligible. This is essentially the opposite
of the situation seen in commercial orchards. Larval sampling is not always a reliable
indicator of population pressure. In previous studies, we attempted to eradicate the
overwintered generation in 5-A plots in order to eliminate summer population damage.
Despite obtaining extremely low larval numbers at bloom and during the July sampling
period, fruit damage at harvest occurred as before.
In 2007, a study was set up on 3 commercial farms (18–33 A, total size) with a history of
OBLR injury. To eradicate the overwintered larvae, an unrealistically aggressive early season
spray program was used. Summer generation adults were monitored using a network of
pheromone traps located at different orchard strata: edge, mid-interior and center on all 4
ordinal sides (N, S, E, W). Weekly terminal- and fruit-infestation samples were taken at each
station. Although large numbers of adults were caught in all the orchards, subsequent larval
terminal infestations and fruit damage remained low during the season in all blocks. There
were no substantial differences in adult catches, and larval infestations or fruit damage in the
different orchard strata. Results suggested that large-scale or whole-farm OBLR management
might reduce damage from summer generation OBLR more effectively than treating
individual blocks or small plots; sampling of fruit might better determine initial timing and
treatment need than the traditional practice of timing preventive sprays for 1st egg hatch and
then sampling terminals for larvae.
Materials and methods
In 2008, trials were set up in 20–40-A plots on 6 commercial farms having a history of OBLR
infestation in Wayne, Saratoga and Onondaga Counties of New York State: Jerry Knight
(Burnt Hills), Apple Acres (Lafayette), Todd Furber (Sodus), Van Fleet (Wolcott), Debadts
(Sodus), and G&S Orchards (Macedon). Management of the overwintered generation was
accomplished by a grower-applied spray of Proclaim at the petal fall stage, to attempt to
reduce populations of overwintering OBLR to very low levels. Pheromone traps were
deployed in the orchards and checked weekly to determine when the summer brood of OBLR
emerged. Participating growers agreed to apply standard treatments against the summer
generation of larvae in most of the originally treated area, but to leave two small plots
untreated with no sprays to be applied against summer larvae until the first damaged apple
was observed. The two small research plots and two other areas being treated with standard
programs were sampled separately during each sampling session.
Weekly samples were taken for larval infestations at each farm starting 28 May; 50 foliar
terminals were examined for OBLR larvae from each of 20 trees located in each of the four
main quadrants of each farm plot, for a total of 4000 samples per site. This was repeated the
next week, and beginning the week of 23 June, the sampling focused on both terminals (200
per quadrant per farm) and developing fruits (1000 per quadrant per farm). This sampling
protocol was followed until the weeks of 10 August and 18 August, when only fruits were
sampled. After a spray was recommended in any of the small research plots, sampling
continued, and additional sprays were not recommended unless fruit damage exceeded 1.5%.
On Sept. 8–12, fruit damage was compared just before harvest in the research and standard
plots, by examining 500–1500 fruits randomly sampled from each treatment at each farm,
depending on how many separate plantings or varieties constituted each of the treatment plots.
These were sorted into USDA grade categories based on presence and extent of OBLR
summer feeding damage found. Results were transformed by arc-sine square-root and
subjected to analysis of variance and Fisher's protected lsd test for means separations (P =
0.05).
22
Results and discussion
The pheromone traps caught peak numbers of adults during the period from 13–26 June, with
the highest catches recorded at the Furber and Knight sites (Fig. 1). The first flight subsided
by the beginning of August, and the second flight was tracked until 18 August, and had peak
numbers considerably lower than those of the first brood.
OBLR Captures in Pheromone Traps 2008
25
Apple Acres
Craft
DeBadts
Furber
Knight
VanFleet
Avg. # moths/trap
20
15
10
5
0
6/3
6/13
6/23
7/3
7/13
7/23
8/2
8/12
8/22
Fig. 1. Pheromone trap catches in commercial orchards receiving insecticide applications for
control of obliquebanded leafroller on a sample-based vs. standard protective schedule.
Initial sampling of clusters and foliar terminals after petal fall indicated that the Proclaim
treatments were generally successful, and almost no live OBLR larvae were found in
examining 1,000 samples per plot at each site. Terminal infestations by the first summer
brood started to be detected by the final week in June, however, reaching maximum levels of
0.8–3.3% starting with the 8 July samples, although in some sites (Furber, Knight) persisting
until early August. Fruit damage from this brood was first detected in samples taken on 26
June (Knight), 8 July (Apple Acres, Van Fleet), 14 July (DeBadts), 29 July (Furber) and 4
August (Craft). Maximum levels noted were generally between 0.3–0.5%, except at Knight,
where 2.0% was recorded on 10 August.
Growers made their own decisions about the need for pesticide sprays to control the
summer generation of OBLR larvae, taking into account the information provided to them
after each of our weekly fruit damage samples. Because a number of early summer hail
events had caused significant fruit damage in most NY orchards this season, many growers
elected to cut back on their management sprays to economize on fruit that was not expected to
be worth as much at harvest. Consequently, OBLR programs in 2008 were not necessarily
representative of what would normally have been implemented. For example, at Apple Acres,
no OBLR sprays were applied all summer, as the grower used only organophosphates as a
low-maintenance program. At Van Fleet, Warrior plus Dipel was applied on 8 July, but all
plots were treated without regard for the presence or absence of damaged fruit in the samples
examined by that date. Similarly, Delegate was used in directed OBLR management sprays at
the other sites, although not necessarily on timings corresponding to our sampling-based
information. Overall, only 6 of the 12 total Sampling-based Management Program plots
received sprays according to the fruit damage information gathered from our samples.
Harvest fruit evaluations revealed generally low levels of damage caused by the summer
23
generations of OBLR larvae, ranging from 0.3–2.6% in the Sample-based program, and 0.0–
1.9% in the Preventive program (Table 1). No significant differences between the
management programs were found in these values or in any USDA Grade category. A partial
budget analysis eventually will be conducted to determine grower returns in the standard vs.
research plots, using estimates of pesticide program costs and packout returns for each of the
farms where these trials were conducted.
Table 1. Percent larval fruit damage and USDA grades in plots where OBLR was managed
using a preventive vs. a sample-based spray decision program, NY.
USDA Grade
% fruit
Utility
Cull Clean
Farm
OBLR Mgt Program
damage X-Fancy
Apple Acres
Preventive
0.0
0.3
0.2
0.0
99.5
Sample-based
0.3
0.1
0.2
0.0
99.7
Craft
Preventive
0.2
0.1
0.1
0.0
99.8
Sample-based
0.7
0.2
0.4
0.1
99.3
DeBadts
Preventive
0.9
0.3
0.5
0.0
99.1
Sample-based
0.8
0.4
0.3
0.1
99.2
Furber
Preventive
0.2
0.1
0.1
0.0
99.8
Sample-based
0.4
0.0
0.4
0.0
99.6
Knight
Preventive
1.5
0.4
1.0
0.1
98.5
Sample-based
2.6
0.6
2.0
0.0
97.4
VanFleet
Preventive
1.9
0.7
0.9
0.3
98.1
Sample-based
1.1
0.4
0.4
0.3
98.9
(No significant differences between management programs in any damage category.)
These results suggest that sampling the fruit for damage might be a better way to
determine the treatment need and initial timing than our traditional practice of timing
preventive sprays for 1st egg hatch and then sampling foliar terminals for larvae. If fruit
damage actually does tend to occur relatively uniformly anywhere throughout these larger
blocks, then it should be possible to sample any representative portion of a whole-farm
planting as a basis for developing a fruit damage threshold to optimize the economics of
making OBLR management decisions on this scale.
Acknowledgements
We thank the following growers for allowing us to conduct this research on their farms: W.
Blackler, Apple Acres, Lafayette; G. Craft, G&S Farms, Macedon; R. DeBadts, Lake Breeze
Fruit Farms, Sodus; T. Furber, Cherry Lawn Farms, Sodus; J. Knight, Knight Orchards, Burnt
Hills; D. Van Fleet, Van Fleet Orchards, Wolcott. We also thank J. Eve Consulting, Naples,
for assistance in coordinating with grower program schedules, and for the following technical
assistants' efforts in plot setup, maintenance, and sample collection and processing: Ashley
Blackburn, Dave Combs, Justin Eveland, Kate Fello, Leslie Mitchell, Nicole Gottschall, and
James Watt. Contributions of crop protectants and trapping supplies were made by: Dow
AgroSciences (B. Olson); Syngenta (J. Zelna); and Trécé (W. Lingren). This work was partly
supported by a grant from the USDA RAMP Program (Project No. 2006-51101-03604).
24
Population dynamics of Anarsia lineatella and their relation to crop
damage in northern Greece IPM peach orchards: towards the
development of EIL
Petros Damos and Matilda Savopoulou-Soultani
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Agriculture, Laboratory of Applied Zoology
and Parasitology, 54124, Thessaloniki, Greece, matilda@agro.auth.gr/damos@agro.auth.gr
Extended Abstract
The peach twig borer Anarsia lineatella Zeller (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) is one of the major
economic pests of stone fruits worldwide (Balachowsky et Mesnil 1935, Jones 1935, Bailey 1948,
Summers 1955, Balatchowsky 1966, Damos and Savopoulou-Soultani 2008a). In Northern Greece, a
great variety of peach (Prunus persica) cultivars (early, middle and late ripening, table and industrial)
are cultivated and exported worldwide, so that peach production is considered to be essential for the
economy. Efforts are made to improve pest control using Integrated Pest Management (IPM) in order
to achieve high standards in products. In northern Greece, A. lineatella has 3 or usually 4 generations
per year depending on prevailing temperatures (Damos and Savopoulou-Soultani 2007). During the
past few years A. lineatella has been increasingly damaging to peach cultivation and, along with
Grapholitha molesta (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae), they have been key targets for implementation of
effective control strategies in terms of IPM in northern Greece. Larvae feed primarily on buds and
tender shoots of the host tree after emergence from hibernacula, where they overwinter as larvae
(Balachowsky et Mesnil 1966, Damos and Savopoulou-Soultani 2008b). Sustainable crop productions
try to minimize energy input flows in agroecosystems in order to maintain a long term benefit for all
enabling parts: agroecosystems, biodiversity, farmers, consumers, as well as society in general. As far
as specific plant protection strategies are concerned, it is common sense that the application of
insecticides would also lead to better pest management and to lower production cost only when
economically justified. However, early warning and forecasting systems, which are indispensable in
pest management strategies, have not been fully developed for A. lineatella in peach orchards. What is
not clear is the population density of these species sufficient to cause economic injury to the plant.
Under this framework, field studies were conducted for three successive years (2005, 2006 and 2007)
in peach orchards of northern Greece in order to examine relationships between densities of A.
lineatella populations and peach (Prunus persica) yields. Moreover, natural populations of A.
lineatella were observed in order to assess crop response to the presence of the pest. Field population
dynamics of A. lineatella were evaluated by using indirect measures (i.e. adult moth flight using
pheromone traps), while injury on plant and fruit damage were estimated by absolute measures (i.e.
counting injury on shoots as well as on fruits caused by larvae during the season). Regression analysis
was used, first to determine if injury could be predicted from A. lineatella males captured on
pheromone traps and second, if early shoot flagging caused by larvae of the first generation was
correlated with fruit damage of the forthcoming generations (Knight and Croft 1987, Knight and Hull
1989, Savopoulou et al. 1989). Numbers of moths captured on sex pheromone traps and fruit damage
varied during the 3 years of observation, ranging from 50 to 250 individuals per trap (F=5.563,
df=2.11, P<0.05 and F=50.299, df=2.11, P<0.05, for first and second flight respectively). Shoot
flagging and fruit damage was significantly lower in 2006 when compared to 2005 and 2007
(F=2.772, df=2.11, P<0.05 and F=14.809, df=2.11, P<0.05, for shoot flagging and fruit damage
respectively). Mean shoot strike injury ranged from 5-15%, while fruit damage levels ranged from 510% during the three years of observation. According to the linear model, the increase in moth density
25
during the first flight should result in a significant reduction in yield (y=0.436x+10.22, R2=0.635,
P<0.05). Regression of male moths captured during the second flight and observed yield loss was also
significant (y=0.5231x+17.204, R2=0.792, P<0.05). Moreover, according to the linear model derived
by counting the number of shoot strikes, during the first observation period, a forthcoming yield loss
can be estimated (y=27.389x-6.304, R2=0.711, P<0.05). Finally, a significant relationship was also
observed between the numbers of second generation larvae and yield loss (y=163x, R2=0.890,
P<0.05). The slope from the above regression can be used in the calculation of EIL and the fixed ET
(Higley and Pedigo 1993, 1996). Results suggest that relative damage on fruits caused by A. lineatella
can be estimated using either male trap captures or by observing early shoot flagging symptoms.
Additionally, pesticides should not be applied if population of A. lineatella causing damage is lower
than management cost. Developing a relationship between pest abundance and damage to crops is
essential for the calculation of EIL leading to informed management decisions.
References
Balachowsky, A., S., 1966. Entomologie Applique a l’agriculture. Traité. Tome II.
Lepidoptères. Masson et Cie éditeurs, Saint Germain, Paris.
Damos, P. and M. Savopoulou-Soultani. 2007. Flight patterns of Anarsia lineatella
(Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) in relation to degree–days heat accumulation in northern
Greece . Comm. Appl. Biol. Sci. Ghent University, 72: 465-468.
Damos P. and M. Savopoulou-Soultani 2008. Diapause termination in overwintering larvae of
the peach twig borer Anarsia lineatella (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae). In proceedings of
XXIII International Congress of Entomology, 6 - 12 July, South Africa, Dourban, ICE
section 6, pp 266
Damos, P. and Savopoulou-Soultani. 2008. Temperature dependent bionomics and modeling
of Anarsia lineatella (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) in the laboratory. J. Econ. Entomol.
Higley, G. and L. P. Pedigo. 1993. Environmental aspects of insect pest
management. Economic injury level concepts and their use in sustaining
environmental quality. Agric. Ecosyst. and Environ. 46: 233-243.
Higley, L.G., and L.P. Pedigo. 1996. The EIL Concept. 17-20 In : Economic
Thresholds for Integrated Pest Management.
Knight, A. L. and B. A. Croft. 1987. Regional population dynamics and seasonal
spatial patterns of Argyrotaenia citrana (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) as measured
by pheromone trap grid and larval sampling. Environ. Entomol. 16: 59-67.
Knight, A. L. and L. A. Hull. 1989. Predicting seasonal apple injury by tufted apple
bud moth (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) with early-season sex pheromone trap
catches and brood I fruit injury. Environ. Entomol. 18: 939-944.
Savopoulou-Soultani M., Angelakis E.A., Hatzivassiliadis M., Tzanakakis E. and
Stavridis D.G. 1989. Captures of Lobesia botrana in traps and their relation to
crop damage. In Cavaloro R. (ed.): Plant Protection Problems and Prospects of Integrated
Control in Viticulture. Proccedings of the CEC/IOBC International Symposium, 6-9 June,
Lisboa-Vila Real, Portugal. Commission of the European Communities Joint Research
Centre, Ispra, pp. 47-56.
26
An update on brown spot of pear
Emilio Montesinos, Isidre Llorente
Institute of Food and Agricultural Technology- CeRTA-CIDSAV, University of Girona, Av.
Lluís Santaló s/n, 17071 Girona (Spain)
Abstract: Brown spot of pear is caused by the fungus Stemphylium vesicarium (Wallr.) Simmons. (f.
asc. Pleospora allii) and cause severe economic losses in pear-growing areas in Europe. Pear cultivars
differ in susceptibility to the disease, being the most affected Abate Fetel, Passe Crassane, Alexandrine
and Conference. Disease control is achieved with several fungicides (mainly dithiocarbamates,
dicarboximides and strobilurins) at fixed spray schedules from petal fall to preharvest, and often 10 to
24 treatments are needed. A forecasting system has been developed (BSPcast) and validated as an
advisory tool to schedule fungicide sprays, maintaining efficacy of disease control as in the fixed spray
schedule, but with savings of fungicide treatments from 20 to 70%. However, disease control is still
insufficient under high inoculum pressure or favorable conditions. Since the fungus overwinters as P.
allii, in fallen infected leaves or fruits, factors affecting pseudothecia development were studied to
refine control programs addressed to decrease the primary inoculum. A forecast model (PAMcast)
which related the proportion of mature pseudothecia to cumulated degree-days was developed and
validated in field trials, and used to forecast the development of the ascigerous state that ends in the
subsequent spring with the release of ascospores. Control of the primary inoculum is critical for
management of brown spot of pear because a reduction of levels or a delay in its production decrease
considerably disease intensity in the subsequent year. Biological, chemical, and mechanical methods
for decreasing overwintering inoculum of P. allii and disease intensity have been evaluated, and
different efficacies have been obtained. Future research should be focused to key stages of the
biological cycle, quantitative specific analysis of inoculum, and novel control methods, including
biological control, in order to develop an efficient integrated system for disease management.
27
Basis for new strategies in integrated control of brown spot of pear
(Stemphylium vesicarium, teleomorph Pleospora allii)
I. Llorente*, C. Moragrega, L. Ruz, G. Santamaría, A. Vilardell, P. Vilardell, E.
Montesinos
Institute of Food and Agricultural Technology- XaRTA-CIDSAV, University of Girona, Av.
Lluís Santaló s/n, 17071 Girona (Spain). * isidre.llorente@udg.edu
Abstract: Brown spot of pear is caused by the fungus Stemphylium vesicarium (Wallr.) Simmons, and
produces high economical losses in several pear-growing areas in Europe including Spain, Italy,
France, The Netherlands, Belgium and Portugal. The management of the disease is based on protective
fungicides applied at fixed schedule or according to the BSPcast model. But, the efficacy in disease
control is limited, especially when disease pressure is high. In order to reduce the disease pressure,
additional methods focused to reduce the inoculum may be incorporated in the integrated control. To
characterize the inoculum, populations of S. vesicarium from different pear orchards in Girona (Spain)
were characterized for their pathogenical activity. Additionally, the dynamics of S. vesicarium
inoculation under natural conditions were determined. On the other hand, S. vesicarium overwinters on
pear in fallen infected leaves or fruits as pseudothecia of its teleomorph Pleospora allii, the
relationship between disease levels at leaf fall and the production of pseudothecia was determined.
Keywords: Inoculum, pathogenical activity, potential dose
Introduction
Brown spot of pear (Pyrus communis L.) is a disease caused by the fungus Stemphylium
vesicarium (Wallr.) E. Simmons that produces important economic losses in several fruit tree
growing areas of Europe including Spain, Italy, France, The Netherlands, Portugal and
Belgium (Montesinos et al. 1995a; Rossi et al., 2005a; Llorente and Montesinos, 2006a).The
control of brown spot of pear is based on the application of protective fungicides and requires
a high number of fungicidal sprays during the pear growing season according to a fixed
schedule (every 7 to 15 days) or timed according to the BSPcast forecasting system (Llorente
et al., 2000). The efficacy of control using the BSPcast guided schedule of fungicide sprays is
similar to the fixed schedule and provides 30 % savings in fungicide sprays. But, the efficacy in
disease control is limited, especially when the disease pressure is high. S. vesicarium overwinters as
pseudothecia of its teleomorph Pleospora allii (Rabenh.) Ces. & De Not. on the ground in the
orchard on fallen infected leaves and fruits of pear (Llorente and Montesinos, 2004) or on
dead herbaceous plants growing in the grass sward (Rossi et al., 2005a; Rossi et al., 2008). In
order to improve the integrated control of brown spot of pear, strategies and methods oriented
to decrease the overwintering inoculum have been tested. Mechanical methods based on pear
leaf removal and application of biocontrol agents based on Trichoderma spp. reduced the
number of ascospores released and the effect on brown spot of pear progress was significant.
These sanitation practices may be incorporated in an integrated brown spot management
system but the use of methods to reduce the inoculum of P. allii did not improve the efficacy
in disease control of current fungicides applied according to the BSPcast model. The general
objective of this work was to increase the efficacy of brown spot of pear control using new
strategies to improve the reduction of the inoculum. These strategies must be focused at
28
reduction of both kinds of inoculum (Pleospora allii and Stemphylium vesicarium), not only
the overwintering inoculum. With this purpose the determination of the inoculum potential is
critical. The inoculum potential is a function of the density of the pathogen, but also of the
virulence of this pathogen. The objectives were to determine i), the dynamics of S. vesicarium
inoculation under natural conditions, ii) the characterization of natural S. vesicarium / P. allii
populations for their pathogenical activity and iii) to establish the relationship between the
levels of disease at leaf fall (S. vesicarium) and the production of overwintering inoculum (P.
allii).
Material and methods
Determination of the dynamics of S. vesicarium inoculations under natural conditions
Two trials were performed in 2006 and 2007 in Girona (Spain). Pear plants of the cultivar,
Conference, were transported to an experimental pear orchard naturally affected by brown
spot from May to September. Then, these plants remained during 10 days under field
conditions with the objective to trap the inoculum of S. vesicarium. After this period, the
plants were returned to the laboratory and, with the purpose to induce the infection, these
plants were incubated for 24 hours with wetness under 22.5 ºC. Thereafter, plants were dried
and placed in a controlled environment chamber for the expression of symptoms for 4 to 6
days and, finally, disease incidence (% affected organs) and severity (affected area in a leaf)
was evaluated. Also, the BSPcast model was used, considering the meteorological data of the
orchard, to forecast the level of infection risk (Montesinos et al. 1995a; Llorente et al., 2000).
Characterization of natural S. vesicarium / P. allii populations for their pathogenicity
A collection of more than 100 S. vesicarium and P. allii isolates was obtained from different
sources in 27 pear orchards in Girona (Spain) during 2007 and 2008. Periodically, samples
were collected from infected and symptomless pear leaves and fruits, non-hosts, such as,
herbaceous plants, pear leaf debris from the soil and air inoculum by using spore traps.
Cultures of fungi obtained from these samples where grown on PDA or V8 medium. Then
colonies were examined under an optical microscope and those morphologically similar to S.
vesicarium were isolated. Finally, monoconidial cultures were grown and identified as S.
vesicarium according to Simmons (1965, 1989). The pathogenicity of isolates was evaluated
by inoculation of immature pear fruits (Conference, Abate Fetel and Passe Crassane cv.) and
young pear leaves (Conference cv.) (Montesinos et al., 1995b).
Relationship between the disease levels at leaf fall (S. vesicarium) and the production of
overwintering inoculum (P. allii)
Six trials were performed during 2004, 2005 and 2006 in two pear orchards (Passe Crassane)
in Girona (Spain). These orchards were naturally affected by brown spot. Just before leaf fall
pear leaves and the disease level was determined (lesions/cm2 of leaf). From October to May
leaves were analyzed (more than 200 leaves/trial) by using an optical microscope and the
number of pseudothecia/lesion and number of lesions/cm2 of leaf were determined
Results and discussion
Determination of the dynamics of S. vesicarium inoculations under natural conditions
In the three years, the inoculation under natural conditions in the two orchards was produced
from May to September, but especially during July and August (Fig. 1). In most of days the
high levels of infection risk predicted by BSPcast model agreed with the periods with a high
level of inoculation. But, the dynamics also showed that in some periods the inoculation was
29
Infe ction risk
(BSPc ast)
Disease severity
(lesions/leaf)
produced in non-favourable environmental conditions. Studies focused to determine the
viability of this inoculum are necessary. Conversely, at the beginning of the epidemics,
fungicide treatments may be unnecessary because the population of pathogen is very low. In
order to avoid these unnecessary treatments, information related to the inoculation must be
incorporated in brown spot management.
6
5
4
3
2
1
1.2
0.8
Ac tion thre shold
0.4
0.0
May
June
July
August
September
Figure 1. Disease severity in a pear orchard with natural pathogen inoculations during 2006
(above). Each point corresponds to the infections produced by the S. vesicarium inoculum
deposited on previous period. Bars correspond to mean standard error. Infection risk predicted
by BSPcast is also presented (below), the level of action threshold (CR≥0.4) is indicated.
Characterization of natural S. vesicarium / P.allii populations for their pathogenicity
Isolates showed different patterns of disease progress. The 22% of isolates were nonpathogenic, explained by the saprophytic ability of S. vesicarium. Among the pathogenic
ones, 18% showed a slow disease progress and 10% of isolates showed slow disease progress
at the beginning, but fast at the end. Most isolates showing these disease patterns were
obtained from pear leaf debris, indicating that they probably need a period of latency before
infection. Finally, in 50 % of isolates the disease progress corresponded to those obtained
from infected organs. The non-pathogenic group included 60% of air isolates, 70% of non
host isolates, 15% of leaf debris isolates and 6% of pear infection isolates. Therefore, the
direct measurements of inoculum quantity on air using a volumetric spore traps may
overestimate the real pathogenic population.
It was observed that pathogenic S. vesicarium isolates were able to produce mycelium,
conidia and pseudothecia on infected pear leaves. But non-pathogenic S. vesicarium isolates
were also able to produce mycelium, conidia and pseudothecia on dead pear leaves. It was
determined that inoculum was also produced in other places out of the orchard. This
information must be incorporated in control strategies focused to decrease the inoculum
production (Llorente, et al., 2008).
30
Relationship between the levels of disease at leaf fall (S. vesicarium) and the production of
overwintering inoculum (P. allii)
The relationship between the disease level of brown spot at leaf fall and the production of P.
allii pseudothecia was linear (R2: 0.959), with a mean of 1.3 pseudothecia/lesion. At leaf fall,
the number of lesions/leaf may be evaluated and these data used to determine the inoculum
potential of P. allii in the next spring. According to results presented above, the majority of
this inoculum may be pathogenic, so the information related the level of P. allii inoculum
must be incorporated in brown spot disease management to establish the appropriate strategy.
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by grant AGL2006-04987/AGR from MEC (Government of
Spain)
References
Llorente, I., & Montesinos E. 2004: Development and field evaluation of a model to estimate
the maturity of pseudothecia of Pleospora allii on pear. Plant Dis. 88:215-219.
Llorente, I. & Montesinos, E. 2006a: Brown spot of pear: an emerging disease of economic
importance in Europe. Plant. Dis 90:1368-1375
Llorente, I. & Montesinos, E. 2006b: Infection potential of Pleospora allii and evaluation of
methods for reduction of the overwintering inoculum of brown spot of pear. Plant Dis.
90:1511-1516.
Llorente, I., Vilardell, P., Bugiani, R., Gherardi. I, Montesinos E. 2000: Evaluation of BSPcast
disease warning system in reduced fungicide use programs for management of brown spot
of pear. Plant Disease, 84:631-637
Llorente, I., Vilardell, A., Vilardell, P., Montesinos, E. 2008: Evaluation of new methods in
integrated control of brown spot of pear (Stemphylium vesicarium, teleomorph Pleospora
allii). Acta Horticulturae 800:825-832.
Montesinos, E., Moragrega, C., Llorente, I., Vilardell, P., Bonaterra, A., Ponti, I., Bugiani, R.,
Cavanni, P., & Brunelli, A. 1995a: Development and evaluation of an infection model for
Stemphylium vesicarium on pear based on temperature and wetness duration.
Phytopathology 85:586-592.
Montesinos, E., Moragrega, C., Llorente, I., Vilardell, P. 1995b: Susceptibility of selected
European pear cultivars to infection by Stemphylium vesicarium and influence of leaf and
fruit age. Plant Disease, 79:471-473.
Rossi, V., E., Pattori, S., Giosue, & Bugiani, R. 2005: Growth and sporulation of Stemphylium
vesicarium, the causal agent of brown spot of pear, on herb plants of orchard lawns. Eur. J.
Plant Pathol. 111:361-370.
Rossi, V., Pattori, E., Bugiani, R. 2008: Sources and seasonal dynamics of inoculum for
brown spot disease of pear. Eur. J. Plant. Pathol 121:147-159.
Simmons, E. G. 1969: Perfect States of Stemphylium. Mycologia 61:1-26.
Simmons, E. G. 1985: Perfect States of Stemphylium. II. Sydowia, Annales Mycologici Ser.
II. 38:284-293.
31
Drought and oxidative stress determine the sensitivity of the pear to
Brown spot infections
S. Van Laer1, M. Höfte2, P. Creemers1
(1) Proefcentrum Fruitteelt v.z.w., Fruittuinweg 1, 3800 Sint Truiden, Belgium (2) University
Gent, Laboratory of Phytopathology, Faculty of Agricultural and Applied Biological Sciences,
Coupure Links 653, B-9000 Gent, Belgium
Abstract: A survey among Belgian fruit growers carried out in 2006 revealed that Brown Spot is not
equally spread in Belgium. The absence of Brown Spot is linked to the presence of loam. It is thought
that the specific drainage properties of a loam soil are responsible for the absence of Brown Spot. An
epidemiological study carried out in 2005 and 2006 supports this idea. In this study different orchards
with a wide range of infection intensities were examined. An analysis of the soils in those orchards
revealed that soil drainage conditions play a role in determining the sensitivity of the tree for
Stemphylium infections. During the growth season of 2005, 2006 and 2007 actual Stemphylium
infection risk was determined by means of window treatment experiments and fruit encapsulating
experiments. An in-depth analysis of the occurrence of the actual Stemphylium infection risk moments
revealed a close relation with the occurrence of drought stress during these growth seasons. The
sensitivity of the pear towards brown spot infections is not only linked to drought stress, but also to
high radiation, ozone and temperature. In the 2008, chlorophyll fluorescence measurements were
performed to determine the relative importance of the different factors that contribute to the oxidative
stress on pears during the growing season. Non photochemical quenching (NPQ) was used as a
measure of oxidative stress damage and protection against this type of stress. A correlation analysis
indicates that ozone is probably the largest contributor to oxidative stress damage on pear.
Brown spot, Oxidative stress, Drought
32
Evaluation of ascospore maturity models to estimate seasonal
ascospore discharge of pear scab (Venturia pirina)
H. Eikemo1*, D. M. Gadoury2, R. A. Spotts3, O. Villalta4, P. Creemers5 and A. Stensvand1
1
Norwegian Institute for Agricultural and Environmental Research, Plant Health and Plant
Protection Division, 1432 Ås, Norway 2 Department of Plant Pathology, Cornell University,
New York State Agricultural Experiment Station, Geneva, NY 14456, USA 3 Oregon State
University Mid-Columbia Agricultural Research and Extension Center, Hood River, OR
97031, USA 4 Biosciences Research Division, Department of Primary Industries, Knoxfield,
Victoria, Australia 5 Proefcentrum Fruitteelt – Applied Scientific Research, Department of
Mycology, B-3800 Sint-Truiden, Belgium *haavard.eikemo@bioforsk.no
Abstract: Estimates of ascospore maturity generated by models developed for Venturia pirina in
Victoria, Australia (V-NV, V-SV), Oregon, USA (S), or for Venturia inaequalis in New Hampshire,
USA (NH-1 and NH-2) were compared to observed ascospore release of V. pirina in 21 site/yr
combinations. When plotted against degree-days, the lag phase and slope of all model estimates
differed from observed release. The S model and V-SV model fit well with the data from Southern
Victoria, while the data from Norway, Belgium and most years from Northern Victoria show a lag
phase in the beginning of the season that was not present in the two models. In particular, data from
the high-rainfall region of southern Victoria showed more variation between years than the other sites.
Identifying the precise biofix (bud break) to initiate degree-day accumulation for the NH-2 model was
problematic at both Australian sites, as regions with warm winters and minimal chilling exhibit
protracted bud break. Linear regressions generated similar R2 values for the various models in many
cases, but where differences were noted they more often favored the most recent model developed for
V. inaequalis (NH-2). The NH-2 model also provided the most accurate estimates of 95% ascospore
depletion (a key event in many disease management programs) for Norway, Belgium, and the higher
rainfall areas of southern Victoria. Although developed for use in management of apple scab, the NH-2
model appears a reasonably accurate tool for predicting the release of ascospores by the pear scab
pathogen, in particular in regions with moderate rainfall and colder winters.
Keywords: Apple scab, biofix, bud break, epidemiology modelling
Introduction
Pear scab, caused by Venturia pirina Aderhold, is an important disease of pear worldwide
(Shabi, 1990). The fungus survives primarily as pseudothecia in leaf litter in the orchards, or
as mycelium on shoots and buds. Ascospores are released from infected leaf litter by rain or
heavy dew beginning around bud break and for 3 to 4 months thereafter, with a peak in
release between early bloom and petal fall. If rain is continuous, most ascospores will be
released during daylight hours (Villalta, 2001). Many of the most common methods of
studying development of pseudothecia (squash mounts, spore traps, etc) are too tedious and
time consuming for use on more than a limited basis in advisory programs for disease
management. Thus, for both V. pirina and the related pathogen V. inaequalis, degree-day
driven mathematical models of ascospore maturation have been developed. Such
environmentally-driven models have several advantages for advisory programs. They can be
inexpensively applied over broad areas and can provide site-specific estimates of ascospore
maturity and release if coupled with on-site weather observations. Furthermore, if driven by
33
forecasted weather, the models can provide true forecasting of ascospore maturity and release.
However, although several such models exist, none have been evaluated for V. pirina outside
of the geographical region in which the specific model was developed. Our objective in the
present study was to internationally evaluate several existing models developed for V.
inaequalis and V. pirina to estimate the cumulative maturity and release of ascospores by V.
pirina.
Materials and methods
Spore trapping data of V. pirina from Norway (7 years), Belgium (5 years), and Australia (5
years from 2 sites) were used to evaluate the models. For all sites, Burkard 7-day recording
volumetric spore traps (Burkard Manufacturing Co Ltd., Rickmansworth, Hertfordshire, UK)
were installed during the primary inoculum season. Heavily infected, overwintered pear
leaves surrounded the spore traps. Number of ascospores recorded was adjusted for the
volume of air sampled and recorded as spores per m3 air.
Electronic data loggers provided hourly records of precipitation, temperature, RH, and
leaf wetness. Temperature and RH were measured 1.5 to 2 m above ground in weather
shelters or radiation shields. The first model of Villalta et al (2001) based on data from
southern Victoria (V-SV) uses all degree days, accumulated from first ascospore. The second
is based on data from northern Victoria (V-NV), and uses degree days accumulated only on
days with ≥0.2 mm rain, starting from first ascospore. For the New Hampshire model ((NH-1;
Gadoury et al, 1982), bud break is used as a biofix, and either all degree days were counted,
or degree day accumulation was halted when the number of rain-free days exceeded 7 (NH-2;
Stensvand et al. 2005). For the model (S) described by Spotts et al (2000), all degree days
from detection of the first ascospore were included. All models are shown in Fig. 1. The
different degree days (base 0°C) were calculated based on daily average temperatures and put
into the models described above.
Overwintered pear leaves collected at bud break, heavily infected with pear scab, were
used to simulate seasons of ascospore discharge in the lab. Samples were stored at 20°C, and
ascospores were collected at regular intervals (2 times per week). Eight samples from 3
different countries were tested, including 1 from France, 3 from Belgium and 4 from Norway
in the period between 2002 and 2006.
The percentages estimated by the models were regressed against observed (trapped)
number of ascospores, and results from the lab tests. The concordance correlation coefficient
(CCC; Lin, 1989) is shown for each pair of observed versus predicted values, and the slope
and intercept of the regression line were tested for equality to 1 and 0, respectively, by
Students t- test.
Results and discussion
Table 1 shows the regression equation and CCC of numbers of discharged/mature spores
estimated by the different models regressed against actual number of spores trapped. The
results show that the distributions of the data points differed between the models. This
variation is correlated with what the models use as biofix, and how degree days were
accumulated. The NH-models use bud break as biofix and, especially for the data from
Australia, the date of bud break seemed not to agree that well with first ejected ascospore.
Identifying the precise biofix (bud break) to initiate degree-day accumulation can be
problematic, as regions with warm winters and minimal chilling exhibit protracted bud break.
Overall, the NH- models give a good prediction of when the season started and ended, as
shown in Table 1.
34
The V-NV model gave a good prediction of both the start and the end of the season.
But when accumulating degree days only on days with more than 0.2 mm precipitation, the
early lag phase seemed to be eliminated in most years, and the model underestimated the
percentage of spores released in the middle of the season.
The S-model and V-SV model both overestimate the number of spores released in the
beginning of the season. Both models fit well with the data from southern Victoria, while the
data from Norway, Belgium and most years from northern Victoria show a lag phase in the
beginning of the season. The reason why this lag phase was only seen in some places may be
caused by a combination of amount of rain and how the biofix was determined.
Table 1. Linear regressiona of observed versus predicted number of ejected/mature ascospores
of Venturia pirina.
Spore
Models evaluated
trap data
NH-1
NH-2
V-SV
V-NV
S
fromb
Norway
Belgium
Australia
SV
Australia
NV
Australia
all data
All sites
Lab data
a
y = 0.99x + 2.65
CCC = 0.96
a=0, P=0.06
b=1, P=0.50
y = 0.94x + 11.0
CCC = 0.91
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P=0.04
y = 0.95x - 3.03
CCC = 0.77
a=0, P=0.49
b=1, P=0.36
y = 0.95x - 5.03
CCC = 0.83
a=0, P=0.13
b=1, P=0.29
y = 0.95x - 4.3
CCC = 0.80
a=0, P=0.11
b=1, P=0.20
y = 0.96x + 1.8
CCC = 0.88
a=0, P=0.19
b=1, P=0.03
y = 1.02x - 0.58
CCC = 0.98
a=0, P=0.75
b=1, P=0.53
y = 1.05x - 12.3
CCC = 0.90
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.08
y = 0.99x + 1.83
CCC = 0.98
a=0, P=0.14
b=1, P=0.52
y = 0.94x - 2.94
CCC = 0.77
a=0, P=0.50
b=1, P=0.33
y = 0.90x - 4.80
CCC = 0.81
a=0, P=0.14
b=1, P=0.03
y = 0.93x - 4.16
CCC = 0.79
a=0, P=0.12
b=1, P=0.05
y = 0.98x - 5.00
CCC = 0.87
a=0, P=<0.001
b=1, P=0.22
n.a.
y = 0.72x + 31.2
CCC = 0.84
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.77x + 27.2
CCC = 0.86
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.91x + 5.37
CCC = 0.91
a=0, P=0.036
b=1, P=0.011
y = 0.67x + 35.0
CCC = 0.74
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.75x + 23.0
CCC = 0.82
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y =0.75x + 26.5
CCC = 0.83
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.89x + 19.0
CCC = 0.87
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P=0.036
y = 1.11x - 15.36
CCC = 0.90
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.94x + 6.84
CCC = 0.92
a=0, P=0.003
b=1, P=0.056
y = 1.01x - 6.59
CCC = 0.77
a=0, P=0.14
b=1, P=0.94
y = 0.89x + 0.27
CCC = 0.88
a=0, P=0.92
b=1, P=0.004
y = 0.94x - 2.60
CCC = 0.83
a=0, P=0.30
b=1, P=0.096
y = 0.99x - 3.81
CCC = 0.87
a=0, P=0.008
b=1, P=0.47
n.a.
y = 0.65x + 27.94
CCC = 0.87
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.70x + 24.32
CCC = 0.89
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.80x + 6.94
CCC = 0.88
a=0, P=0.002
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.61x + 31.40
CCC = 0.78
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.67x + 21.54
CCC = 0.82
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.67x + 24.12
CCC = 0.85
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
y = 0.70x + 21.30
CCC = 0.89
a=0, P<0.001
b=1, P<0.001
Results from linear regressions of observed versus predicted values, shown as concordance
correlation coefficients. The slope and intercept of the regression line was tested for equality
to 1 and 0, respectively, by Students t- test (P<=0.05 = significant difference)
b
Spore trap data from one site in Norway, two sites in Australia (southern and northern
Victoria) and one site in Belgium.
35
Figure 1. Graphic illustration of the models evaluated
References
Gadoury, D. M. & MacHardy, W. E. 1982: A model to estimate the maturity of ascospores of
Venturia inequalis. Phytopathology. 72: 92-95
Lin, L. I-K. 1989: A concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate reproducibility.
Biometrics 45: 255-268.
Shabi, E. 1990: Pear scab. In: Compendium of Apple and Pear Diseases, eds. Jones, A. L. and
Aldwinckle, H. S.: 168-190. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, Mn.
Spotts, R. A., Cervantes, L. A., & Niederholzer, F.J.A. 2000: Pear scab: components of potential
ascospore dose and validation of an ascospore maturity model. Plant Dis. 84:681-683.
Stensvand, A., Eikemo, H., Gadoury, D. M. & Seem, R. C. 2005: Use of a rainfall threshold to
adjust a degree-day model of ascospore maturity of Venturia inaequalis. Plant Dis. 89: 198202
Villalta, O. N., Washington, W. S., Rimmington, G. M. & MacHardy W. E. 2001:
Environmental factors influencing maturity and release of ascospores of Venturia pirina
in Victoria, Australia. Aust. J. Agric. Res. 52: 269-277
36
Developing an effective trap and lure to monitor Lygus rugulipennis
Michelle Fountain1, Jerry Cross1, Gunnhild Jaastad2, Dudley Farman3 and David Hall3
1
East Malling Research, New Road, East Malling Kent ME19 6BJ UK
Bioforsk, Norwegian Institute for Agricultural and Environmental Research, N-5781 Lofthus
3
Natural Resources Institute, University of Greenwich, Chatham Maritime, Kent ME4 4TB
UK
2
Abstract: Lygus rugulipennis, the European tarnished plant bug (Miridae), is an important pest of
strawberries, raspberries and cucumbers causing malformation of fruit. Ordinarily mirids are
controlled with sprays or chlorpyrifos. However, increasing demand for zero residues fruit and the
eradication of effective pesticides from IPM programmes is rendering crops more susceptible to attack
from mirids. The overall aim of this project is to develop a long-lived, practical lure, attractive to
these species, in order to monitor populations so that effective spray timings and spray applications
can be made to control the pests in fruit crops. Male L. rugulipennis are attracted to traps baited with
live virgin females. Volatiles produced by virgin female L. rugulipennis have been identified as, hexyl
butyrate, (E)-2-hexenyl butyrate, and (E)-4-oxo-2-hexenal and these elicit electroantennographic
(EAG) responses from males in analyses by linked gas chromatography–electroantennography (GCEAG). Using ratios similar to those produced by the female at the time of ‘calling’, when males are
attracted to females, we have demonstrated the attractiveness of the volatiles to male L. rugulipennis
in the field. We also tested a number of home-made and commercially available traps for monitoring
mirids. Green cross-vane funnel traps were the most effective and practical of those tested.
Key words: capsid, European tarnished plant bug, Lygus rugulipennis, mirid, pheromone, raspberry,
strawberry
Introduction
Mirid pests (capsids), are common and important pests of many horticultural crops. Crop
damage caused by Lygus rugulipennis is sporadic and unpredictable resulting in severe
economic losses at low population densities, particulary in strawberry (Cross, 2004). In
conventional crops it is controlled by sprays of broad-spectrum insecticides (Garthwaite &
Thomas, 2001), organophosphorus insecticides being the most effective and frequently used.
However, there is a reduction in available organophosphorus insecticides, and neonicotinoids
and other modern insecticide groups are only partially effective or ineffective against this
pest. Insecticides used in organic crops are inadequate and of short persistence. Because of
this mirid pests present a bottle neck in the development of IPM programmes. In addition,
insect sampling methods (sweep-net or beating-tray sampling) are time consuming and
unsuitable for use by growers.
Traps baited with virgin females of L. rugulipennis (Innocenzi, et al., 1998; Glinwood, et al.,
2003) have been shown to attract conspecific males, but attraction to a synthetic lure has
never been demonstrated. Sex pheromone identification in mirids has been hampered by the
abundant defensive secretions, of which, certain compounds can function both as components
of the pheromone and as defensive secretions (cf. Blum, 1981, 1996; Groot, et al., 2001
Zhang et al., 2007). Previous research on L. rugulipennis (Cross & Hall, 2003) identified
three female-specific pheromone components, hexyl butyrate, (E)-2-hexenyl butyrate and (E)4-oxo-2-hexenal. This paper outlines studies aimed at monitoring mirid pests, by engineering
37
an effective lure with the correct ratio and release rate of the female sex pheromone
compounds and enhancing trap catch by effective trap design.
Materials and Methods
Field trial 1 – based on daytime entrainments
The previously estimated ratio of HB:E2HB:KA released by a single L. rugulipennis female,
based on whole day entrainments, was 1.5:1.0:0.08 (Innocenzi et al., 2003). In 2007 field
trials showed that female L. rugulipennis were attracting males in the morning. Based on
volatile collections (entrainment) from female L. rugulipennis at 3 times of day (daytime,
evening, night) a small scale randomised block experiment comparing catches of capsids in
white cross vane funnelled bucket traps, baited with the newly calculated blend, was set up in
the weed field at EMR. The two treatments were microcapillary reservoir lures containing; 1)
10% 3-component mix (HB: E2HB:KA) in sunflower oil, release rate approx. 1 µg h-1, and 2)
sunflower oil only. There were 10 replicates of each treatment positioned alternately and
spaced 10 m apart. Numbers, sex and species of mirid were recorded.
Field trial 2 – trap design
To test the efficacy of different trap designs for capturing mirids, small scale randomised
block field experiments comparing trap designs were set up in the weed field, at EMR.
Green, 20 x 20 cm, delta traps with a sticky base were compared to bucket traps with 250 ml
water and a drop of detergent added. The traps were positioned at weed flower height.
Mature virgin females were contained in a cage (hair roller with gauze around the outside and
a lid at either end, holding the gauze in place) with damp paper to maintain humidity and a
section of bean as food. A cage was placed into the top (lid) of each trap. Cypermethrin was
sprayed onto the surface of the sticky base at 0.35 l ha-1 for treatment C. The clear delta trap
was made of vinyl sheets held together with a paper binder (Table 1).
A second field trial compared green delta traps, clear delta traps, sticky stake traps and white
cross vane funnelled bucket traps (Agrisense) with commercially available pre-mounded
different coloured cross vane bucket traps (Agralan) (Table 2). There were 4 replicates of
each trap, spaced more than 10 m apart. Traps were checked and females changed every
week. Numbers, sex and species of mirid were recorded. Count data for all trials were Log10
transformed for ANOVA.
Table 1. Trap designs used in first trial, 27 June – 11 July.
Code Trap
Capture device
A
Green delta
original sticky base
B
Green delta
‘new’ base
C
Green delta
original base with cypermethrin sprayed on
D
Green delta
original sticky base + ecotac
E
Cross vane funnel bucket trap Water with detergent
F
Cross vane funnel bucket trap llambda-cyhalothrin cross veins + water with
detergent
G
Clear delta trap
Sticky base
38
Table 2. Trap designs used in second trial, 27 August – 1 September.
Code Trap
Capture device
H
Green delta
sticky base with
Ecotac
I
Clear delta trap
sticky base with
Ecotac
J
White cross vane funneled bucket (Agrisense)
water with detergent
K
Premoulded green cross vane funnel bucket trap
water with detergent
(Agralan)
L
Premoulded white cross vane funnel bucket trap
water with detergent
(Agralan)
M
Premoulded yellow cross vane funnel bucket trap
water with detergent
(Agralan)
N
Sticky stake trap
Ecotac
Results and Discussion
Field trial 1 – based on daytime entrainments
Significantly more male L. rugulipennis males were captured in traps baited with pheromone
lures compared to the control (P=0.018, LSD=0.2009, Fig. 1). Numbers of female L.
rugulipennis were not significantly higher in the pheromone treated baited traps (P=0.502,
LSD=0.1465, Fig. 3), indicating that the new blend of compounds, based on daytime
collections of volatiles, was functioning as a female sex pheromone. Numbers of capsids had
begun to decline in the field by this time so further work is needed to confirm these results.
18
male ruguilpennis
16
female rugulipennis
Number of mirids
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Control
Treatment
Figure 1. Numbers of male and female Lygus rugulipennis trapped (27 August – 1 October) using the
new pheromone blend based on daytime entrainments.
39
30
25
20
15
10
white cross
vane bucket
extra ecotac
cypermethrin
sticky base
‘new’ base
sticky base
0
clear delta
5
llambdacyhalothrin bucket
number of male L. rugulipennis
35
Green delta traps
Figure 2. Comparison of the number of male L. rugulipennis in the different trap types; first trial.
100
80
60
40
sticky stake
premould
yellow xvane
premould
white x-vane
green delta
clear delta
0
premould
green xvane
20
white x-vane
number of male L. rugulipennis
Field trial 2 – trap design
Although there were no significant differences between trap types (P=0.360, LSD=0.1934),
the funnel traps (white or llambda-cyhalothrin cross vanes) captured more male L.
rugulipennis than the green delta sticky trap. However, the llambda-cyhalothrin cross vane
trap only caught mirids in the 4th (final) week of the experiment (Fig. 2). There were
significantly more mirids captured in the green cross vane funnelled bucket traps compared to
the green or clear delta traps (P=0.121, LSD=0.7541, Fig. 3). Green traps (sticky cylinders)
were also effective at capturing Lygus males in trails by Blackmer, et al., (2008).
Funnelled bucket traps
Figure 3. Comparison of the number of male L. rugulipennis in the different trap types; second trial.
Acknowledgements
Thanks to Defra, Horticultural Development Company, GlaxoSmithKline Blackcurrant Grower’s
Research Fund, GlaxoSmithKline, East Malling Trust, East Malling Ltd., Agrisense, Cucumber
Growers Association, K G Growers Ltd. and Donald J Moor for funding this project (HortLINK
project HL0184). We owe gratitude to the Project Co-ordinator, Mr Tom Maynard and other
researchers on the project, Ms L Amarrawardana (NRI) and Mr A L Harris, (EMR).
References
Blum, M.S. 1981: Chemical defences of arthropods. Academic Press Inc., New York.
40
Blum, M.S. 1996: Semiochemical parsimony in the arthropoda. Annual Reviews of Entomology 41:
353-374.
Cross, J.V. & Hall, D.R. 2003: Pheromones of strawberry blossom weevil and European tarnished
plant bug for monitoring and control in strawberry crops. Final report of Defra project HH1939SSF
issued August 2003: 30pp.
Cross, J.V. 2004: European tarnished plant bug on strawberries and other soft fruits. Horticultural
Development Council Fact Sheet 19/04, pp 6.
Garthwaite, D.G. & Thomas, M.R. 2001: Pesticide useage survey report 181: Soft fruit in Great
Britain, 42 pp.
Glinwood, R., Pettersson, J., Kularatne, S., Ahmed, E. & Kumar, V. 2003: Female European tarnished
plant bugs, Lygus rugulipennis (Heteroptera: Miridae), are attracted to odours from conspecific
females. Acta Agric. Scand. Sect. A 53: 29032.
Groot, A.T., Drijfhout, F.P., Heijboer, A., van Beek, T.A. & Visser, J.H. 2001: Disruption of sexual
communication in the mirid bug Lygocoris pabulinus by hexyl butyrate. Agriculture and Forest
Entomology 3: 49-55.
Innocenzi, P.J., Hall, D.R., Cross, J.V., Masuh, H., Phythian, S.J., Chittamuru, S. & Guarino, S. 2004:
Investigation of long-range female sex pheromone of the European tarnished plant bug Lygus
rugulipennis: chemical, electrophysiological and field studies. Journal of Chemical Ecology 30:
1509-1529.
Innocenzi, P.J., Hall, D.R., Sumathi C., Cross, J.V. & Jacobson, R.J. 1998: Studies of the sex
pheromone of the European tarnished plant bug, Lygus rugulipennis (Het. Miridae). Brighton Crop
Protection Conference – Pests and Diseases 8: 829-832.
Zhang, O-H., Chauhan, K.R., Zhang, A., Snodgrass, L.G., Dickens, J.C. & Aldrich, J.R. 2007:
Antennal and behavioral responses of Lygus lineolaris (Palisot de Beauvois) (Heteroptera: Miridae)
to metathoracic scent gland compounds. Journal of Entomological Science 42(l): 92-104.
41
Interactions among predatory insects in strawberry production
Jean Fitzgerald, Jay Chantelle
East Malling Research, New Road, East Malling Kent ME19 6BJ UK
Abstract: A range of pest species are important in strawberry and can cause serious damage to the
plants and the fruit. Several species of thrips are found on strawberry, and western flower thrips,
Frankliniella occidentalis, is particularly difficult to control as it is resistant to most available
insecticides. The strawberry aphid, Chaetosiphon fragaefolii, is a virus-vector and honeydew produced
by the aphids also causes fruits to become sticky and unmarketable. Feeding by the capsid Lygus
rugulipennis on developing fruits causes severe malformation of the fruit. Many predatory insects
found in strawberry plantations consume a range of prey species and can thus contribute to biocontrol
of pests. However, the availability of ‘alternative’ prey species may affect the degree of control the
predators exert over particular pest species. In this project we examined the interactions among aphid,
capsid and thrips and predatory arthropods in strawberry, to provide the basic information needed to
optimise the biological components of pest management systems, thus reducing pesticide use. In
laboratory experiments to determine the biocontrol potential of predators, 1st instar C. carnea larvae
and adult female O. laevigatus consumed similar numbers of 3rd instar C. fragaefolii. 1st instar C.
carnea consumed fewer F. occidentalis than did O. laevigatus adults. C. carnea and O. laevigatus
consumed similar numbers of 1st instar L. rugulipennis. The potential of C. carnea and O. laevigatus
to significantly reduce numbers of C. fragaefolii, F. occidentalis and L. rugulipennis when each pest
was presented alone was demonstrated in laboratory experiments. However, when combinations of
predators were present, biocontrol of pest species was reduced in some cases due to predator
interactions.
Frankliniella occidentalis, Chaetosiphon fragaefolii, Lygus rugulipennis, Biocontrol
42
Developing Integrated Pest Management programmes for protected
strawberry crops in Southern France
1
Amélie Boullenger, 2Marion Turquet, 3Stéphanie Girou, 4Clare Sampson
BCP Certis, Newbury House ,Court Lodge Farm, Hinxhill, Ashford, Kent TN25 5NR, UK
boullenger@ certiseurope.co.uk, sampson@certiseurope.co.uk
1,4
2, 3
Hortis Aquitaine, Maison Jeannette, 24 140 Douville, France. marion.turquet@hortis.fr
Abstract: Integrated Pest Management (IPM) strategies which have been effective in the UK were
tested in tunnel grown strawberry crops at Hortis Aquitaine, Southern France, from March to October
2008. The cost and pest control effect of two IPM strategies were compared in separate tunnels, one
equipped with a misting system and the other not. Thrips, Frankliniella occidentalis, were effectively
controlled by either Amblyseius cucumeris combined with Orius laevigatus in the misted tunnel or A.
swirskii and Orius laevigatus in the non-misted one. Neither tunnel required chemical intervention
against thrips, and control was very good compared to chemical programmes. Spider mites,
Tetranychus urticae, were effectively controlled in both tunnels by Phytoseiulus persimilis together
with a single treatment of hexythiazox (Nissorun®). Four different aphid species occurred in the trials.
Aphidius colemani achieved some control of Aphis gossypii but Aphidoletes aphidimyza failed to
establish and a single pirimicarb (Pirimor G®) was used. Further trials are recommended to develop
effective aphid control. The use of selective chemicals in the IPM programmes allowed the invasion of
naturally occurring predators which helped control pests. All pests were effectively controlled in the
IPM tunnels and fruit quality was good. The numbers of chemical treatments were significantly
reduced in comparison to an adjacent tunnel where pests were controlled using insecticides. In this
tunnel, pest numbers increased rapidly and ten insecticide treatments were required over two months
to achieve some control. Different rates and timings were proposed to ensure an economic programme
for growers.
Key words: Biological Control, protected strawberries, France, thrips, spider mites, aphids, Integrated
Pest Management.
Introduction
Strawberry growing systems are very varied in France, from open field to crops on hanging
gutters under glass. In the South West, the main production region, there are around 1500 ha
of strawberries, including approximately 350 ha on hanging gutters. Growers tend to be small
with an average of 1.5 ha of strawberries, grown mainly under tunnels. Most growers
distribute to specific wholesalers via their "grower organizations". A lack of chemicals is
forcing them to move towards IPM (Trottin-Caudal et al, 2002). Fewer products are registered
in strawberries and registered products are becoming less effective due to resistance.
Consumer pressure for pesticide-free produce also has a major influence on growers.
In 2008, as part of the BCP Certis European wide trials programme, IPM strategies that
have been effective in the UK (Sampson, 2007) were tested in tunnel-grown everbearer
strawberry crops at Hortis Aquitaine, in the South of France. Thrips, aphids and spider mites
are the most common and damaging pests. The small-scale trial compared the cost and
effectiveness of two IPM strategies in two tunnels; tunnel A, equipped with a misting system
and tunnel B, without. The objective of this trial was to see whether UK strategies achieve
cost effective pest control in South West France and to determine whether Amblyseius swirskii
43
establishes and achieves thrips control in the warmer and drier conditions found there.
Materials and methods
The trial was carried out in two 200m² tunnels, each planted on 18th March 2008, with six
rows of everbearer strawberries (cvs. Mara des Bois, Charlotte and Cirafine) grown in peat on
hanging gutters. Only tunnel A was equipped with a misting system.
The timing and numbers of pest control treatments are detailed in Table 1. The generalist
aphid predator Aphidoletes aphidimyza was released preventatively against all aphid species
and the parasitoid Aphidius colemani was released once Aphis gossypii was observed.
Phytoseiulus persimilis was released once Tetranychus urticae was observed. Thrips predators
were released preventatively.
Table 1. The timing and numbers of pest control treatments.
Pest
Date(s)
Beneficials/spray
Thrips
09/04/08
16/04/08
16/04/08
14/05/08, 18/06/08
29/05/08, 16/07/08
29/05/08, 16/07/08
09/05/08 to 09/07/08
20/05/08 to 09/07/08
27/06/08
14/05/08 to14/07/08
Hypoaspis miles
Amblyseius cucumeris (sachets)
Amblyseius swirskii (sachets)
Orius laevigatus
Amblyseius cucumeris (sprinklers)
Amblyseius swirskii (sprinklers)
Aphidoletes aphidimyza
Aphidius colemani
Pirimor G® (pirimicarb)
Phytoseiulus persimilis
04/07/08
Nissorun® (hexythiazox)
Aphids
Spider
mites
Tunnel A
(misted)
150/m²
1 /2 linear m
1.25 /m² x 2
125 /m² x 2
2.5 /m² x 7
1.25 /m² x 5
Spot treatment
2.5 /m² x 3
1.25/m², 5/m²
Treatment
Tunnel B
150/m²
1 /2 linear m
1.25 /m² x 2
50 /m² x 2
2.5 /m² x 7
1.25 /m² x 5
Spot treatment
2.5/m²x2, 5/m²
7.5/m² x 2
Treatment
In each tunnel, 25 plants were selected at random and monitored weekly. One flower and two
leaves (one old, one young) were selected per plant and the numbers of thrips and beneficials
counted. Aphids, spider mites and whiteflies were recorded using a scale: 0 : 0 individual ; 1 :
1 to 3 individuals ; 2 : 4 to 10 individuals ; 3 : 11 to 30 individuals ; 4 : >30 individuals.
Presence and absence of all species was recorded on cores, flowering stems and white fruits.
Results and discussion
Thrips control
Thrips and predator numbers are shown in Figures 1 (Tunnel A) and 2 (Tunnel B). Thrips
numbers were higher in the drier, non misted tunnel with A. swirskii, but both Amblyseius
cucumeris and Amblyseius swirskii established in the separate tunnels to control thrips and
prevent fruit damage. A. swirskii built up more rapidly than A. cucumeris, confirming that
lower release rates are required. Orius laevigatus took longer to establish than expected. This
was probably because there were no flowers and few thrips at the time of the first release,
leading to starvation or dispersion. It is probably advantageous to wait for flowering before
Orius release so that they can survive by feeding on pollen.
Hypoaspis miles were not recovered after release. In the U.K., Hypoaspis is released in
glasshouse crops to reduce sciarid fly and thrips numbers. However they are not usually
44
needed in shorter season tunnel grown crops. Further trials will be done without Hypoaspis,
to reduce costs.
Predators successfully controlled this major pest without the need for insecticides. No
damage was observed on fruits, which were of good quality. In contrast, in an adjacent tunnel
where no predators were released, three insecticide treatments were required to control thrips
and the crop had to be stopped early in mid July due to pest damage and poor quality plants.
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
9-4
23-4
7-5
21-5
4-6
18-6
2-7
16-7
30-7
Mean No. per flower .
% flowers with
Amblyseius
Figure 1. Thrips and beneficial populations in the misted tunnel A, with A. cucumeris.
13-8
Introduction Amblyseius cucumeris (sachets)
Introduction Amblyseius cucumeris (sprinkler)
Introduction Orius laevigatus
% flowers with Amblyseius sp.
Total no.of thrips per flower (larvae + adults)
Total no.of Orius per flower and fruits (larvae + adults)
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
15-4
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
29-4
13-5
27-5
10-6
24-6
8-7
22-7
5-8
Mean No. per flower .
% flowers with
Amblyseius
Figure 2. Thrips and beneficial populations in the unmisted tunnel B, with A. swirskii.
19-8
Introduction Amblyseius swirskii (sachets)
Introduction A. swirskii (sprinkler)
Introduction Orius laevigatus
% flowers with Amblyseius
Total no. of Orius par flower and fruit (larvae + adults)
Total no. of thrips per flower (Larvae + adults)
Aphid control
The most common aphid species were Macrosiphum euphorbiae, Rhodobium porosum, Aphis
gossypii and Aulacorthum solani. Despite natural enemy releases, aphid numbers built up
during May and June, and a spray with pirimicarb was required (Figure 3). The pattern was
similar in both tunnels, so only Tunnel B is shown. Although Aphidius colemani established,
it is host specific and did not control the potato aphids (Macrosiphum and Aulacorthum spp.).
Aphidoletes aphidimyza was released to control these species, but no larvae were recovered.
This was probably because night temperatures were exceptionally low in 2008. Minimum
temperatures remained < 10°C in April and < 15°C in May. A failure to establish was also
observed at nearby growers, where Aphidoletes usually establishes. The fungicides used in
these trials (penconazole, myclobutanil, azoxystrobin, thiophanate-methyl) should only have
had a limited impact on Aphidoletes establishment. From July, natural enemy numbers
increased rapidly and all aphid species were controlled for the rest of the crop. Aphid control
was aided by natural invasions of lacewings (Chrysoperla) and hoverflies (Syrphids).
45
50
0,5
40
0,4
30
0,3
20
0,2
10
0,1
0
0
No. of beneficials/plant
% cores infested with aphids
Figure 3. Aphid and natural enemy numbers in the non-misted Tunnel B.
15-4 29-4 13-5 27-5 10-6 24-6 8-7 22-7 5-8 19-8
% of cores infested with aphids
Treatment
Introduction of Aphidoletes aphidimyza (pupae)
Introduction of Aphidius colemani (mummies)
Hoverflies (eggs, larvae and pupae)
Lacewings (eggs, larvae and pupae)
Aphidius (mummies)
Aphidoletes (larave)
Spider mite control
Spider mites were first seen at the beginning of May. They increased more rapidly in the nonmisted tunnel B, affecting 50% of plants (12% with 11-30 mites per plant) when numbers
peaked in early July, compared to 14% of plants (2% with 11-30 mites per plant) in the misted
tunnel A. Phytoseiulus persimilis established and reduced spider mite numbers in both
tunnels, but a single spray with hexythiazox (Nissorun ®) was necessary to reduce numbers.
In this trial, Phytoseiulus was released into hot-spots, but experience suggests that blanket
treatments would achieve better control. This will be trialed in 2009.
Cost of control
The total costs were 1.4 € /m² and 1.6 € /m² for the A. cucumeris and A. swirskii strategies
respectively. These costs could be reduced by 0.5 € /m² by removing Hypoaspis miles and
reducing the Orius and Aphidoletes releases. The resulting 0.9 € /m² to 1.1 € /m² would be
acceptable for growers.
The trials demonstrated that thrips and spider mites can be controlled effectively and
economically in S. France using biological control agents. Together with O. laevigatus, both
A. swirskii and A. cucumeris established and controlled thrips without the need for chemical
intervention. P. persimilis controlled spider mites with the aid of a single insecticide
treatment although blanket rather than spot treatments should improve control. The numbers
of chemical treatments were reduced from ten to two, in comparison to an adjacent tunnel
where plants were grown without biological control. Further trials are needed to fine tune the
programme and to improve biological control against the range of aphid species present.
References
Sampson, C. 2007. Integrated Pest Management in protected strawberry crops; Increased
returns, fewer pests and reduced pesticide use. IOBC/wprs Bulletin. In Press.
Trottin-Caudal, Y., Trouvé,C., Capy, A. 2002. Integrated control of glasshouse crops:
comprehensive management of strawberry – an overview of the 2001 test results.
Infos-Ctifl, No 178, pp 41-44.
46
Alternative methods to reduce storage decay in organic apple
production; time of harvest and calcium applications
Jorunn Børve1, Dag Røen2, Arne Stensvand3
1
Norwegian Institute for Agricultural and Environmental Research, Ullensvang, 5781
Lofthus, Norway
2
Njøs Fruit and Berry Centre, Njøsavegen 5, 6863 Leikanger, Norway
3
Norwegian Institute for Agricultural and Environmental Research, Plant protection
Division, 1432 Ås, Norway
Abstract: In Norway, organic apple growers only have sulphur available as a fungicide. When
organically grown apples are stored, growers must thus rely entirely on alternative means to reduce the
amount of storage decay. It is known that harvest time and calcium content may affect fruit rots in
apple. The effect of harvest time on storage decay was assessed during three years. After storage there
was a clear increase in fruit decay from the earliest to the latest picking times, both recorded as total
decay and for the important storage diseases bitter rot (caused by Colletotrichum acutatum) and
lenticell rot (caused by either Phlyctaena vagabunda or Cryptosporiopsis curvispora). In mean of
three years apples of cv. Aroma harvested 2 or 1 week prior to normal harvest time, at normal harvest
or 1 or 2 weeks afterwards and stored for three months in a ventilated cold store, had 6, 14, 35, 33, and
35% bitter rot, respectively. Similar numbers for lenticell rot (in mean of two years) were 6, 10, 11, 16
and 24%, respectively. Applications of calcium at different times prior to harvest reduced the amount
of storage decay in some trials, but not consistently.
Keywords: Bitter rot, Colletotrichum acutatum, Cryptosporiopsis curvispora, lenticell rot, Phlyctaena
vagabunda
Introduction
The most important storage diseases in apple in Norway are bitter rot, caused by
Colletotrichum acutatum, and lenticell rot, caused by either Phlyctaena vagabunda or
Cryptosporiopsis curvispora. In organic apple production in Norway sulphur is the only
available fungicide, and alternatives are needed in order to control storage decay. Harvest time
is known to influence development of storage decay. Late harvested apples of a cultivar
generally develop more fruit rot than earlier harvested apples of the same cultivar. However,
results obtained in experiments have varied depending on cultivar tested, location, year and
diseases present (Gulanduzzi et al., 2005; Landfald, 1981, Neri et al., 2005; Valiuskaite et al.,
2006; Wilkinson & Sharples, 1967). In England, development of lenticell rot on apples
inoculated with Gloeosporium perennans (Cryptosporiopsis curvispora) was promoted by
delayed harvest time (Edney, 1964). It has been shown that applications of calcium may
prevent fruit decay due to fungal diseases. Apples treated three times with calcium chloride in
the growing season developed less bitter rot (Colletotrichum spp.) after storage than if not
treated (Biggs, 1999). The main cultivar in organic and in convention apple growing in
Norway is Aroma. Cv. Aroma is scab tolerant but very susceptible to storage decay. The
objectives of the present experiments were to evaluate the effects of harvest time and calcium
applications on storage decay in organically grown apples of cv. Aroma.
47
Materials and methods
Harvest time
During 2004-2006 apples of cv. Aroma were picked over a five week period in an organic
orchard. There were regular treatments with sulphur against apple scab in spring and early
summer, but no other treatments against storage rots. Harvest started 2 weeks prior to optimal
harvest date according to prognoses from the advisory service in the area. Fruits were then
harvested 1 week before normal harvest time, at normal harvest, or 1 or 2 weeks after normal
harvest. Each time three replicates of 65 apples in each were picked at different locations in
the orchard. Sixty apples were laid separately in boxes and stored in a ventilated cold store
(4°C). The other 5 apples from each replicate were used to measure fruit quality; fruit
firmness, background and cover colour, sugar content, and starch content. Streif indexes
(Streif, 1996) were calculated as firmness/(starch*sugar). Monthly (four times) during storage
the fruits were assessed for symptoms of storage diseases. Each time five apples were taken
out from each replicate for measurement of fruit quality as mentioned above, but now also
including titratable acid content. February 1 the remaining 45 apples were taken out of cold
store and assessed for storage diseases after 2 weeks at 20°C.
Calcium experiments
In 2005 three or six applications with calcium chloride was compared with an apple scab
spray programme with dithianon (Delan WG, BASF Agro BV, Arnhem, The Netherlands) in a
conventional field where other fungicide applications ceased at time of bloom (May 23). In
2006, applications with sulphur in spring and early summer against scab were combined with
three applications with either calcium hydroxide (350g of 95% CaOH /100l water) or calcium
chloride (500g of 77% CaCl2/100L) against storage diseases. Controls were either sulphur
applications against scab in spring and early summer or unsprayed. Experiments were carried
out in an organic orchard. Both years the apples were picked at time of optimal harvest
according to fruit quality measures and stored for 4 months at 4°C and 2 weeks at 20°C.
Quality and disease assessments were done as in the harvest time experiment.
Results and discussion
Harvest time
Harvest started between September 12 and 20, from 1656 to 1794 degrees days after full
bloom all three years. Background colour increased from first to last picking in the first two
years. In the third year the background colour was not measured at the last picking, and no
difference was found from first to fourth picking. Cover colour was significantly higher on the
last picking compared to the first all three years. Difference in calculated Streif-index at
harvest from first to last picking was 0.04, 0.13 and 0.22 in 2004, 2005 and 2006, respectively
(Fig. 1). At end of storage no or only minor differences in fruit quality parameters were
detected, and apples from all picking times had fruit quality within the limits for eating
quality at end of storage (data not shown). Data for monthly assessments of Streif-index
during the storage period are not included here.
In mean of three years fruit decay at end of cold storage was 3 % for the first picking and
20% for apples picked 2 weeks after normal (Fig. 2). Apples picked one or two weeks after
normal harvest time developed significantly more decay than apples picked at normal harvest
time or before (Fig. 2). Most of the decayed apples at that time could still have been used for
juice production, because the lesions were small. Total fruit decay after two weeks at room
temperature in mean of the three years was 18 and 64% on apples from first and last picking,
respectively (Table 1). There was a gradual increase in total fruit rot from the first to the last
48
picking date. Incidence of bitter rot was significantly higher on apples picked after and at
normal picking time compared to the two earliest harvests. For lenticell rot there was a
significant difference between the first and the last picking time. Organically grown apples are
rarely stored over long time, because of the risk of storage decay (Maxin et al., 2005). These
trials show that such apples can be stored over several months in a normal cold store if they
are picked early enough, but also that they may have to be consumed relatively quickly after
they are brought out of storage.
Calcium experiments
Different calcium treatments performed over two years did not give a consistent effect against
storage decay. Experiments will be carried out in several more orchards, and number and
timing of applications need to be further investigated before we can recommend calcium
sprays as a management strategy against storage diseases.
Acknowledgements
The Norwegian Ministry of Agriculture and Food supported the experiments financially. Jan
Ove Nes kindly let us pick apples in his orchards. Thanks also to technicians at Ullensvang
and Njøs research stations for valuable assistance.
References
Biggs, A. R. 1999. Effects of calcium salts on apple bitter rot cuased by two Colletotrichum
spp. Plant Dis. 83:1001-1005.
Edney, K.L. 1964. Some factors affecting the rotting of stored apples by Gloesporium spp.
Ann. Appl. Biol. 53:119-127.
Gualanduzzi, S., Neri, F., Brigati, S., Folchi, A. 2005. Storage of ’Pink Lady®’ apples:
Quality and Bio-pathological aspects. Acta Hort. 682:2077-2084.
Landfald, R. 1981. Fruktråte i eplekultivaren ‘Aroma’[Fruit decay in cv. Aroma]. Meldinger
fra Noregs landbrukshøgskole 60 (25):8pp. In Norwegian.
Maxin, P., Klopp, K., Huyskens-Keil, S., Ebert, G., 2005. Control of postharvest decay in
organic grown apples by hot water treatment. Acta Hort. 682:2153-2157.
Neri, F., Gualanduzzi, S., Brigati, S. 2005. Effect of harvest maturity on quality, physiological
and pathological disorders during storage of ‘Gala’ apples. Acta Hort. 682:2069-2076.
Streif, J. 1996. Optimum harvest date for different apple cultivars in the ‘Bodensee’ area, p.
15-21. In: A. de Jäger, D. Johnson and E. Hohn (Eds). 1996. COST 94: The postharvest
treatment of fruit and vegetables-Determination and prediction of optimum harvest date
of apples and pears. Proc. of June, 1994 workshop, Lofthus, Norway.
Valiuskaite, A., Kvikliene, N., Kviklys, D., Lanauskas, J. 2006. Post-harvest fruit rot
incidence depending on apple maturity. Agron. Res. 4 (Special issue):427-431.
Wilkinson, B. G. & Sharples, R. O. 1967. The relation between time of picking and storage
disorders in Cox’Orange Pippin apple fruits. J. Hort. Sci. 42:67-82.
49
Table 1. Fruit decay in organically grown apples of cv. Aroma stored 4 months at 4°C and 2
weeks at 20°C. Mean of three years with trials; three replicates of 40 apples for each harvest
time; 2 or 1 week before normal harvest time, at normal harvest, or 1 or 2 weeks after normal
harvest.
Time of picking as
related
to
normal
harvest time
Total fruit rot (%)
Bitter rot (%)
Lenticell rot (%)
2 weeks before
18.3 d
6.1 b
4.2 b
1 week before
32.8 c
13.6 b
8.6 ab
Normal
46.4 b
33.3 a
7.8 ab
1 week after
57.5 ab
35.0 a
9.2 ab
2 weeks after
63.9 a
33.3 a
15.6 a
P-value
0.0001
0.0001
0.001
Figure 1. Streif-values at harvest of organically grown apples of cv. Aroma harvested over 5
weeks in 2004-2006. Mean of three years of trials; three replicates of 5 apples for each harvest
time; 2 or 1 week before normal harvest time, at normal harvest, or 1 or 2 weeks after normal
harvest.
Figure 2. Incidence (%) of fruit decay in organically grown apples of cv. Aroma harvested
over 5 weeks and stored for 4 months at 4°C; assessments made directly after the apples were
brought out of cold storage. Mean of three years with trials; three replicates of 40 apples at
each harvest time; 2 or 1 week before normal harvest time, at normal harvest, or 1 or 2 weeks
after normal harvest.
50
Sources of inoculum of Colletotrichum acutatum in cherry and apple
Arne Stensvand1*, Jorunn Børve2
1
Norwegian Institute for Agricultural and Environmental Research, Høgskoleveien 7, 1432
Ås, Norway; 2Norwegian Institute for Agricultural and Environmental Research, Ullensvang,
5781 Lofthus, Norway
Abstract: Colletotrichum acutatum causes bitter rot (often named anthracnose) in cherry and apple. It
is the most important fruit decay in sour cherry in Norway and may give severe losses also in sweet
cherry and apple. We have found the fungus in all fruit and berry crops grown commercially in the
country and on many ornamentals and a few weeds. Single spore isolates frequently developed the
ascigerous stage of the fungus (Glomerella acutata) in culture, but it was not detected on apple or
cherry plant material. If still attached to the tree, fruits and fruit stalks of sour cherry infected the
previous year produced conidial inoculum throughout the entire following season. Also newly infected
sour cherry flowers produced conidial inoculum until harvest. Up to 80% of the fruit spurs on sweet
cherry had buds infected with C. acutatum in spring. Apple buds also contained the fungus, but to a
much lower extent. More than 90% of the sweet cherry leaves could be infected with C. acutatum
around harvest in heavily infected orchards. Symptoms on leaves never appeared in the orchards. We
also found such asymptomatic leaf infections in apples. Most of the inoculum seemed to be present on
the fruit trees themselves. However, initial inoculum in newly established, disease free plantings may
be introduced from older fruit trees, ornamentals and weeds in or in close vicinity to the orchards.
Key words : Anthracnose, bitter rot, Glomerella acutata
Introduction
Anthracnose, often named bitter rot, may cause complete yield loss in sour cherry (Prunus
cerasus) in Norway, but severe losses have also occurred in sweet cherry (P. avium) and apple
(Malus domestica). The disease is caused by the ascomycete Glomerella acutata (imperfect
stage: Colletotrichum acutatum). The sexual stage has only been documented once in nature,
on highbush blueberry in Norway (Talgø et al., 2007). The fungus may attack all fruit and
berry species and is commonly found in many ornamental and weed species. In cherry, bitter
rot develop fruit symptoms very late, often just prior to or even after harvest, and its ability to
ruin the crop after harvest may have negative implications for the marketing (Børve &
Stensvand, 2008). In warmer fruit growing regions bitter rot typically develops during mid to
late summer in apple (Crusius et al., 2002; Everett et al., 2006; Sutton, 1990), while in
Norway it is mostly known as a storage disease although it may appear prior to harvest (Børve
et al., 2008). The present work took place over several years to investigate how C. acutatum
overwinters and what inoculum sources are present under Norwegian orchard conditions.
Some of these findings have been presented elsewhere (Børve & Stensvand, 2006; 2007;
2008; Børve et al., 2008; Stensvand & Børve 2006, Stensvand et al., 2006; 2008).
Materials and methods
Various cherry and apple plant material was collected and either incubated directly in
saturated air at 20-25°C for 1 to 3 weeks (dormant leaf and flower buds, old infected fruits
and fruit stalks, flowers, fruits, shoot pieces) or treated with paraquat (Cook 1993, EPPO
51
2004) or freezing (Mertely & Legard, 2004) before incubation (green leaves).
Results and Discussion
C. acutatum on different plant species
In Norway, we have detected C. acutatum in all fruit and berry species grown commercially in
the country, i.e. apple, pear (Pyrus communis), sweet cherry, sour cherry, plum (Prunus
domestica), strawberry (Fragaria × ananassa), raspberry (Rubus idaeus), blackberry (Rubus
fruticosa), black currants (Ribes nigrum) and highbush blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum).
Furthermore, we have found it on the following genera of ornamentals: Aesculus, Alnus,
Forsythia, Ilex, Juglans, Laurocerasus, Maespilus, Magnolia, Populus, Rhododendron,
Sorbus and Tilia. Finally, the fungus has been detected in the following genera of
herbs/weeds: Geum, Rumex, Taraxacum and Urtica. It has been most damaging in sweet and
sour cherry, apple and strawberry.
Glomerella acutata
Approximately 10% of our single spore isolates have developed perithecia, the ascigerous
stage of the fungus in culture. Most of these were originally isolated from apple. When
looking at genetic variation among isolates, we also see that a group of isolates, mainly from
M. domestica, showed large variability, indicating that sexual reproduction also occurs in
nature. We have not detected the perfect stage of the fungus on apple or cherry plant material.
We thus anticipate that the predominant inoculum source is conidia.
Buds
We have detected C. acutatum in bud scales of sweet and sour cherry and apple. When
investigating 13 different site/cultivar/year combinations in commercial and research sweet
cherry orchards, we found that a mean of 43% (varied from 4 to 80%) of the fruit spurs
contained one or more buds with C. acutatum. In 13 site/cultivar/year combinations in sour
cherry, we found a mean incidence of 37% (varied from 5 to 72%) flower and leaf bud
infections. In apple, the frequency of infected buds was much lower, but it was detected in 7
of 17 site/cultivar/year combinations. Nine (1.3%) of a total of 689 apple flower buds were
infected.
Old fruits and fruit stalks
Old infected fruits and fruit stalks were collected in late autumn and either placed on the
ground in autumn or spring or left hanging in the trees. From time of bud break until after
harvest, fruits and fruit stalks were collected at two-week intervals and investigated for
quantity of conidia of C. acutatum. Experiments took place over three years. By mid June
there were very few conidia left in plant material on the ground. For fruits and fruit stalks left
hanging in the trees, a substantial quantity of conidia was formed beyond harvest. If not
removed during harvest or pruning, old fruits and fruit stalks may remain attached for a long
time into the next growing season.
Flowers and green leaves
Newly infected flowers of sour cherry produced conidia until harvest. Green leaves of sweet
cherry, sour cherry and apple all contained asymptomatic infections of C. acutatum. In three
different sweet cherry orchards observed over three years, a mean of 45 and 34%,
respectively, of leaves on fruit spurs and vegetative shoots contained C. acutatum. There was
a gradual build-up of both incidence and severity on sweet cherry leaves during two months
52
prior to harvest. In the most severely attacked orchard more than 90% of the leaves were
infected.
Wood
We observed infections in one year old wood tissue in all three fruit crops.
Potential inoculum sources
Old fruits, fruit stalks, wood, bud shells and green leaves all have asymptomatic infections
and may be easily overlooked as important sources of inoculum. They all produce inoculum
in close vicinity to the new susceptible tissue. A conidium only needs to travel a few
millimetre or centimetre from the source to the new tissue. Thus inoculum from within the
trees and the orchards are probably the most important source of inoculum in orchards where
the fungus is already established. For newly established disease free orchards, outside sources
like old orchards of all fruit species, berry crops, many ornamentals and weeds should be
considered potential inoculum sources.
References
Børve, J., Djønne, R.T. & Stensvand, A., 2008: Colletotrichum acutatum; a post harvest
pathogen on apple in Norway. Journal of Plant Pathology 90(2, Supplement): 387.
Børve, J. & Stensvand, A. 2006: Colletotrichum acutatum overwinters on sweet cherry buds.
Plant Disease 90: 1452-1456.
Børve, J. & Stensvand, A. 2007: Colletotrichum acutatum found on apple buds in Norway.
Online. Plant Health Progress doi:10.1094/PHP-2007-0522-01-RS.
Børve, J. & Stensvand, A. 2008. Anthracnose – an emerging disease on sweet cherry. Acta
Horticulturae 795: 905-908.
Cook, R.T.A. 1993: Strawberry blackspot caused by Colletotrichun acutatum. Pages 301-304
in: Plant Health and the European Single Market. D. Ebbels, ed. BCPC Monograph 54.
Crusius, L.U., Forcelini, C.A., Sanhueza, R.M.V. & Fernandes, J.M.C. 2002: Epidemiology of
apple leaf spot. Fitopatologia Brasileira 27: 65-70.
EPPO. 2004: Glomerella acutata. EPPO Bulletin 34: 193-199.
Everett, K.R., Timudo-Torrevilla, O.E., Shaw, P., Wallis, R., Mundy, D., Scheper, R., Wood, P.
& Butcher, M. 2006: Sustainable solutions for Colletotrichum apple fruit rot. Waikato
Fruitgrowers Newsletter (August), pp. 13-15.
Mertely, J. & Legard, D.E. 2004: Detection, isolation, and pathogenicity of Colletotrichum
spp. from strawberry petioles. Plant Disease 88: 407-412.
Stensvand, A., Aamot, H.U., Strømeng, G.M., Talgø, V., Elameen, A., Børve, J. & Klemsdal,
S.S., 2008: Colletotrichum acutatum from Norway frequently develops perithecia in
culture. Journal of Plant Pathology 90(2, Supplement): 93.
Stensvand, A. & Børve, J. 2006: Colletotrichum acutatum on cherry and apple buds.
Phytopathology 96: S110.
Stensvand, A., Talgø, V., Strømeng, G.M., Børve, J., Sletten, A. & Klemsdal, S.S. 2006:
Colletotrichum acutatum in Norwegian strawberry production and sources of potential
inoculum in and around strawberry fields. IOBC wprs Bulletin 29(9): 87-91.
Sutton, T.B. 1990: Bitter rot. Pages 15-16 in: Compendium of Apple and Pear
Diseases. A.L. Jones & H.S. Aldwinckle, eds. APS Press, St. Paul, MN.
Talgø, V. Aamot, H.U., Strømeng, G.M., Klemsdal, S.S. & Stensvand, A. 2007: Glomerella
acutata on highbush blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum L.) in Norway. Online. Plant
Health Progress doi:10.1094/PHP-2007-0509-01-RS.
53
Early season control of storage rots of apple
A.M. Berrie, B.E. Ellerker, K. Lower, J.D. Robinson
East Malling Rsearch, East Malling, Kent, ME19 6BJ, UK
Abstract: Fungal rots cause significant losses in stored apples. Until recently rotting in stored apples
was controlled primarily in the UK by post harvest fungicide drenches. This practice is no longer
acceptable because of the likely presence of a fungicide residue in the fruit, which, although usually
below the MRL, is not acceptable to consumers. In addition, Nectria and other rots are poorly
controlled by post-harvest fungicide drenches. Alternative approaches for control of Nectria rots are
based on identifying rot risks. Fruits are stored only short term whenever a high risk is predicted.
Alternatively, protectant fungicides are applied in July/August, which may also lead to detectable
residues in fruit. The results of limited orchard trial in the 1990s, however, indicated that application
of carbendazim during blossom and petal-fall significantly reduced the incidence of Nectria rot in
store. The mechanism for this is not understood but could be due possibly to the reduction in Nectria
inoculum from cankers or to the protection of fruit at a key infection stage. The purpose of this work
was to understand this mechanism and examine whether other potential rots (e.g, Gloeosporium or
Botryosphaeria) could also be controlled similarly. Orchard trials were also established to identify
alternative fungicides to carbendazim. Effective control of Nectria and other rots by application of
fungicides at blossom and petal fall would also minimise the risk of residues in fruit at harvest.
Apple, canker, Nectria galligena, storage rot, fungicide
54
Utilization of Mating Disruption and Codling Moth Granulosis Virus
(CpGV) in Commercial Apple Orchard in Pennsylvania, USA.
Greg Krawczyk, Larry A. Hull, and Eric Bohnenblust
The Pennsylvania State University, Department of Entomology, Fruit Research and Extension
Center, Biglerville, 290 University Drive, PA 1730. E-mail: gxk13@psu.edu
Abstract: During the last five years, codling moth, Cydia pomonella L., reestablished itself as the
dominant direct fruit pest in most apple orchards in Pennsylvania, USA. Together with the Oriental
fruit moth, Grapholita molesta (Busck), and the eastern USA leafroller complex, the codling moth has
become the driving force for insecticide treatments applied in orchards. When the codling moth
developed resistance to older insecticides, it forced growers to seek new methods to control this pest
and adopt newer methods such as mating disruption or bio-rational compounds to provide adequate
control. Although both tactics have been used for a long time in organic orchards, no experience
existed in conventional orchards in Pennsylvania. Therefore, a multi-year project was initiated to
evaluate such methods in conventional orchards where both methods were incorporated into standard
pest control practices. During three consecutive seasons, various rates and combinations of the
codling moth granulosis virus (CpGV) and mating disruption were utilized in orchards and provided
excellent control of internal fruit feeders, even when CpGV was applied as alternate row middle
applications. CpGV laboratory and field bioassays conducted on apples and nectarines revealed a
toxicity of the codling moth granulosis virus against neonates of Oriental fruit moth.
Key words: fruit pests, biological control, Oriental fruit moth,
Introduction
During the last five years, the codling moth (CM), Cydia pomonella L., reestablished itself as
the dominant fruit pest in most apple orchards in Pennsylvania, USA. Together with the
Oriental fruit moth (OFM), Grapholita molesta (Busck), the codling moth has become the
driving force for insecticide treatments applied in orchards. Since 1998, multiple loads of
apples destined for the processing markets were rejected by USDA inspectors for the presence
of CM and OFM in the fruit (Krawczyk 2006).
The main reasons cited for this continuous pest outbreak include insecticide resistance
(i.e., organo-phosphates), the loss and/or restrictions on insecticides due to the Food Quality
Protection Act, or issues related to the efficient applications of insecticides (Krawczyk 2006).
In order to overcome some of these issues, new approaches were extensively evaluated during
the last few years. One management tactic that has succeeded in controlling CM and OFM
throughout the U.S. while minimizing the use of insecticides is mating disruption (MD) using
synthetic sex pheromones to control pest insects (Hull and Krawczyk 2006).
Another novel technology that has become available for both conventional and organic
growers to manage CM is a naturally occurring CM granulosis virus (CpGV) commercially
available in two products – Cyd-X® (Certis USA) and Carpovirusine® (Arysta LifeScience).
Recently, CpGV became widely utilized in many conventional orchards. Once the larva
ingests the virus, the occlusion bodies are dissolved. The virus penetrates the gut lining,
replicates itself and then spreads to other organs (Lacey and Shapiro-Illan 2008).
In this report we discuss the results of field evaluations of the CM granulosis virus and
55
mating disruption products in commercial orchard settings in Pennsylvania, USA from 2005
to 2007. Also, due to the continuous pressure in Pennsylvania orchards from OFM, we
present results of laboratory/field bioassays evaluating the effect of CpGV on this pest.
Materials and methods
Field trials 2005-2007
An apple orchard near Arendtsville, PA was selected for this study. Prior to the study, the
orchard had a history of problems with internally fruit feeding Lepidopteran larvae, primarily
CM but also OFM. The orchard was divided into three blocks with continuous, although
yearly changing, treatments. In 2005, Block 1 (about 4.9 ha) was treated with Cyd-X, at the
rate of 150 ml/ha/side for both broods (total 11 applications, 1650 ml per season) in
combination with Isomate CM TT (CBC America) at the rate of 500 dispensers/ha; Block 2
(about 4.5 ha) was treated with Isomate CM TT plus conventional insecticides; and Block 3
(2.8 ha) was treated with conventional insecticides only. In the 2006 season, Block 1 was
treated with a low rate of Cyd-X (37.5 ml/ha/side) for both broods of CM (total 10
applications; 375 ml per season) and an application of dual dispensers Isomate CM/OFM TT
(CBC America) (500 dispensers/ha); Block 2 was treated with a higher rate of Cyd-X (75
ml/ha/side) for both broods of CM (10 applications, 750 ml/season) and Isomate CM/OFM
TT; and the Block 3 was treated with a conventional program. In the 2007 season, Block 1
received Cyd-X at the rate of 75 ml/ha/side applied for the second brood of CM (2
applications; 150 ml/season) and Isomate CM/OFM TT; Block 2 received Cyd-X for both
broods of CM (5 applications; 375 ml/season) also in combination with Isomate CM/OFM
TT; and Block 3 was treated with a grower’s choice insecticide program.
All applications were applied with an airblast sprayer calibrated to deliver 472 liters of
solution. All Cyd-X and insecticide sprays were made as alternate row middle (ARM)
applications and the amount of Cyd-X applied is listed as the amount/ha/side of the tree. The
Isomate dispensers were hung in the top one-third of the trees within 10 days of CM biofix.
The trees in Block 1 and 2 were 2.5-3.5 m high; in Block 3 were about 3.5- 4 m in height.
Various combinations of large plastic Delta-style pheromone traps (Pherocon VI) baited
with either CM 1X Long-Life® lures, or CM-DA combo lures, or CM 10X Megalures®
(Trece Inc., Salinas, CA) were deployed in each block. All CM traps were hung in the top
20% of the tree canopies, about 70 meters apart. For OFM monitoring, two Delta-style
pheromone traps with Trece OFM Long-Life® lures were also hung in the center of each
block. OFM traps were hung at a height of 2 m above the ground. Traps for each species
were placed in the orchard before expected biofixes. Traps were monitored weekly.
Numbers of CM injured fruit were estimated based on in situ evaluations within each
treatment block during the mid-season and at harvest. At each sampling date a group of 100
or 200 apples were examined on 25-50 trees per block. A total of 4000 to 5000 apples were
examined per treatment during each visual search. All larvae found within injured fruit were
identified to species.
Field/laboratory bioassays: Three apple and three nectarine trees were sprayed to the point
of drip with a solution of Carpovirusine prepared at the equivalent rate of 1 liter/ha using a
Solo backpack sprayer at a pressure of 60-80 psi. Control trees were sprayed with water.
Fruit from each treatment were collected at 2 hours, 3 days and 7 days after application.
Treated fruit were placed in 473 ml clear plastic containers and 5 neonates of CM or OFM
were placed on each fruit. At each collection time, 15 fruit were used per treatment (75
larvae). Mortality readings were conducted at 7-8 days after the placement of larvae on fruit
recording the number of entries per fruit and then by searching for live larvae.
56
Results and Discussion
During each year of the project the combination of CpGV and mating disruption treatments
provided effective control of CM and OFM (Table 1). During the first year of the project the
treatment of Isomate CM TT plus insecticides (Block 2) had the fewest fruit injured by CM.
The treatment of Isomate CM TT plus Cyd-X (Block 1) was the next most effective treatment.
All of the larvae found during the harvest were CM. From the 2006 study, we found that both
Cyd-X and Isomate CM/OFM TT combination treatments were the most effective treatments.
The conventional insecticide block was again the least effective treatment. The treatment of
Cyd-X at the 37.5 ml/ha rate and MD in 2006 was intentionally placed in the block that had
the lowest level of CM fruit injury in 2005. From the 2007 study, we concluded that the
combination of five ARM Cyd-X sprays for first and second broods along with MD was the
most effective treatment for minimizing injury from CM and OFM. The treatment of only
two ARM Cyd-X sprays for 2nd brood CM along with MD was also very effective, although a
slightly higher amount of fruit injury was found. The conventional insecticides for the control
of CM and OFM continued to be less effective. (Table 1).
Table 1. Efficacy of CM granulosis virus CpGV (Cyd-X) and Isomate CM/OFM TT against
codling moth and Oriental fruit moth in a PA apple orchard during 2005-2007.
Year/block % injured fruit
Retrieved
Mean no.
mid-season harvest CM/OFM larvae* of CM adults **
2005/B1
0.00 a
0.43 b
6/0
25.0
2005/B2
0.00 a
0.04 a
0/0
29.5
2005/B3
0.00 a
1.52 c
17/0
99.5
2006/B1
0.00 a
0.00 a
0/0
9.0
2006/B2
0.00 a
0.18 a
1/0
10.5
2006/B3
0.03 a
0.43 b
3/0
104.7
2007/B1
0.00 a
0.15 a
1/1
6.0
2007/B2
0.00 a
0.03 a
0/0
1.0
2007/B3
0.40 b
1.08 b
8/0
135.0
Mean percent of injured fruit within the same column for the same year followed by the same letter are
not significantly different (Fisher’s Protected LSD, P≤ 0.05). * – Number of live CM /OFM larvae
retrieved during the harvest fruit evaluations. ** - Average cumulative seasonal number of CM adults
collected in traps baited with a CM 1X lure in each block.
After three years of CpGV and MD use in this orchard to manage both CM and OFM we
found very encouraging results for using these two tactics in combination to control these two
pests even when applying CpGV as ARM applications. Block 2 over the three-year period
received the most applications of Cyd-X (2005 – 11 ARM applications; 2006 – 10 ARM
applications, 2007 – 5 ARM applications). This treatment regime has continually reduced
CM and OFM adult populations over time while maintaining very low levels of fruit injury.
The treatment regime for CM and OFM in Block1 also continued to reduce the adult
populations of these two pests over time while maintaining excellent fruit protection. In
2005, Block 1 received MD and insecticides during the season – no CpGV, but in 2006 and
2007 it received MD and ARM applications of Cyd-X under a different rate and timing
regime. In 2006, this block received 10 ARM applications of Cyd-X, and in 2007, this block
received only 2 ARM applications of Cyd-X during the second brood of CM.
The bioassays evaluating the effect of CpGV on both OFM and CM and the persistence
57
of the virus in the orchard revealed high efficacy of an applied field rate on both pest species
(Tab.2). While the toxic effect of CpGV on CM neonate larvae was expected, mortality of
OFM was unexpected, especially at the standard field rate. On both fruits, apple and
nectarine, the OFM larvae exposed to field aged residues of CpGV exhibited mortality
compared to the control treatment. In another study, not reported here, no mortality of OFM
was observed after exposure to CpGV residue on peach fruit (Krawczyk, unpub. data).
Table 2. Survival of CM and OFM neonate larvae after exposure to field aged residues of
CpGV (Carpovirusine) during field/laboratory bioassays.
Number of survived larvae*
Pest
Crop
Treatment 1 DAT*** 3 DAT
7 DAT
CpGV**
0.07 a
1.13 b
1.71 b
Cydia
Control
3.40 a
3.67 a
3.47 a
pomonella Apple
CpGV
0.93 a
1.73 b
2.53 c
Grapholita
Apple
molesta
Control
3.00 a
3.40 a
3.47 a
CpGV
0.47 a
0.67 a
1.47 b
Nectarine
Control
2.80 a
3.01 a
2.93 a
Means within the same row followed by the same letter are significantly different (Fisher’s protected
LSD, P≤0.05). * - mortality reading at 7 days after larval placement on treated fruit; ** - CpGV
applied at a equivalent field rate of 1 liter/ha in 937 liters of solution (Carpovirusine); *** - DAT –
days after treatment.
The results from these studies show that CpGV and MD can be successfully integrated in
different ways to combat annual CM and OFM pest problems, especially where resistance to a
number of conventional insecticides is present or pest populations are high.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Mr. Brian Knouse for allowing us to use his orchard to
conduct this study and his cooperation with making the necessary applications. We also
would like to thank Certis USA, Arysta Lifescience, CBC America and State Horticultural
Association of Pennsylvania for their support of this project.
References
Hull, L. A. and G. Krawczyk. 2006. Novel approaches to manage codling moth and Oriental
fruit moth populations in PA apple orchards. Pennsylvania Fruit News. 86(2): 39-48.
Krawczyk, G. 2006.Monitoring insecticide resistance in field populations of Oriental fruit
moth and codling moth collected from Pennsylvania fruit orchards. Pennsylvania Fruit
News. 86(2): 31–35.
Lacey, L. A. and D. I. Shapiro-Illan. 2008. Microbial control of insect pests in temperate
orchard systems: potential for incorporation into IPM. Ann. Rev. Entomol. 53: 121-144
58
Pheromone-Based Management Strategies for the Dogwood Borer,
Synanthedon scitula (Harris) (Lepidoptera: Sesiidae)
Tracy C. Leskey,1 J. Christopher Bergh,2 James F. Walgenbach,3 and Aijun Zhang4
1
USDA-ARS, Appalachian Fruit Research Station, 2217 Wiltshire Road, Kearneysville, WV
25430-2771
2
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Alson H. Smith, Jr. Agricultural Research
and Extension Center, Winchester, VA 22602
3
North Carolina State University, Mountain Horticultural Crops Research and Extension
Center, Fletcher, NC 28732
4
USDA-ARS, Invasive Insect Biocontrol and Behavior Laboratory, BARC-W, 10300 Baltimore
Ave, Beltsville, MD 20705
Abstract: The dogwood borer is a serious wood boring pest of apple in eastern North America. The
increased severity of dogwood borer infestations in apple orchards is similar to that of the apple
clearwing moth, S. myopaeformis Brkh, which became serious pest of apple following the introduction
of size-controlling rootstocks in Europe. These rootstocks promote the formation of burr knots on
exposed portions of the rootstock and on the trunk and scaffold limbs. Burr knots are an excellent food
resource for S. myopaeformis larvae and also serve as the primary point of infestation by dogwood
borer. Historically, the organophosphate insecticide chlorpyrifos has been the material growers have
relied upon for control of dogwood borer in apple orchards. However, interest in promoting more
sustainable management practices and recent restrictions and cancellations of organophosphates within
the USA highlight the importance of developing alternative management tactics for this pest. Our
recent identification of the sex pheromone, an 88:6:6 v/v/v (Z,Z)-3,13 octadecadienyl acetate
(ODDA):(E,Z)-2,13-ODDA:(Z,E)-3,13-ODDA, and a behavioral antagonist of dogwood borer ,(E,Z)3,13-ODDA, provided us with the opportunity to evaluate pheromone-based management strategies
such as mass trapping and mating disruption. We evaluated the potential of pheromone-based mass
trapping of males to reduce dogwood borer infestations and evaluated an antagonist-based pheromone
blend for disruption of dogwood borer mate-finding in commercial apple orchards in North Carolina,
Virginia, and West Virginia. We removed large numbers of males from orchards at all locations from
high and low density mass trapping plots over two years. However, infestation in high and low density
mass trapping plots was not reduced to the level of chlorpyrifos-treated plots. The most promising
approach for pheromone-based management of dogwood borer appears to be mating disruption. An
antagonist-based dispenser deployed at a rate of 250/ha effectively disrupted mate-finding by male
dogwood borer. In plots with mating disruption dispensers, captures in pheromone-baited traps were
virtually eliminated and no males were captured in traps baited with virgin females. We are currently
evaluating the efficacy of disruption formulations for dogwood borer based on the sex pheromone
blend and the antagonist.
59
Volatiles initiate egg laying in common green lacewings
Gunnhild Jaastad, Liv Hatleli, Geir K. Knudsen, Miklos Tóth
Norwegian Institute of Agricultural and Environmental Research – Bioforsk Ullensvang, N5781 Lofthus, Norway; The Norwegian University of Life Sciences, N-1432 Ås, Norway;
Norwegian Institute of Agricultural and Environmental Research – Bioforsk Plantehelse, N1432 Ås, Norway; Plant Protection Institute, HAS, Budapest Pf 102, H-1525 Hungary
Abstract: Adults and larvae of the common green lacewing Chrysoperla carnea feed on many insect
pest species and are important predators in biological control of many crop plants. Previous work has
shown that adults are attracted to chemicals occurring in the scent of flowers, and that the presence of
aphids on crop plants enhances oviposition by adults. In the present study, the effect of a three
compound blend of phenylacetaldehyd, acetic acid and methyl salicylate was tested for its effect on
oviposition by C. carnea in two areas in Norway. In both 2007 and 2008 a significantly higher number
of C. carnea eggs were laid inside delta traps with the ternary blend compared to control traps. From
16 May to 15 June 2007 a total of 110 and 177 eggs were found inside 5 baited delta traps in each of
two orchards in Western Norway. No eggs were found in control traps. Similar results were obtained in
one orchard in Eastern Norway. When lures with the ternary blend were attached directly to the tree,
the number of eggs did not significantly increase. Use of attractive volatiles to enhance egg laying, and
to increase biological control by lacewings are discussed.
Key words: Green lacewing, attractive volatiles, oviposition, biological control
Introduction
Larvae of the common green lacewing Chrysoperla carnea feed on many insect pest species,
and are one of the most important predators in biological control for many crop plants (Senior
& McEwen 2001).
The common green lacewing hibernates as adults and start feeding and egg laying
after 2-3 nights of compulsory migration flight in early spring (Duelli 1980). Previous work
has shown that adults locate habitats and food sources by responding to semiochemicals. Ltryptophan, a component of some artificial honey dews, increased concentration of adult C.
carnea when sprayed onto tree canopies (McEwen et al. 1994). Ballal & Singh (1999) found
in a wind tunnel study that for both males and females, C. carnea flight towards sunflower
was significantly higher compared to the control. In trap tests in Hungary phenylacetaldehyde
was found to be attractive to both male and female C. carnea (Tóth et al. 2006). Further,
Reddy (2002) found that lacewings were more attracted to plants damaged either by mites or
mechanically damaged plants compared to healthy plants in wind tunnel studies.
Previous works also indicate that lacewings use volatiles to locate oviposition sites. A
significant difference in number of eggs laid by C. carnea was found between different host
plants in a study by Ballal & Singh (1999). Kungel & Cottrell (2007) found that adult C.
rufilabris laid significantly more eggs in aphid infested pecan compared to uninfested pecan,
and that food spray incorporating both protein and carbohydrates increased numbers of
lacewing eggs in an area.
Augmentative release of lacewing larvae is a well known control method against many
insect pest species (Easterbrook et al. 2006). Lacewing eggs and larvae are produced and sold
by several companies. However, experiments with augmentative release as a control method
60
show varying results (Michaud 2001, Easterbrook et al. 2006). The use of volatiles that
initiate and increase number of eggs laid might be a more powerful and cheaper control
method compared to augmentative release of lacewings. Based on previous work (Tóth et al.
2006) we have investigated the effect of a ternary blend of volatiles on oviposition in C.
carnea.
Material and methods
Trials were conducted in two areas in Norway in both 2007 and 2008. A ternary blend of
phenylacetaldehyde, acetic acid and methyl salicylate, previously reported to be attractive to
adult lacewings (Tóth et al. 2006), was tested as attractant for green lacewing oviposition. A
bait composition of 100 mg of each compound was loaded onto a 1 cm piece of dental roll
(Celluron®, Paul Hartmann Ag. Heidenheim, Germany), which was put into a polyethylene
bag (ca 1.0 x 1.5 cm) made of 0.02 mm linear polyethylene foil. Lures were placed in delta
traps, and each trap was placed in a single tree 1.5 – 2.0 m above ground.
In 2007, 5 delta traps with lures and 5 delta traps with no lure (control) were placed in
each of two sweet cherry orchards in Western Norway on 16 May. The distance between traps
was at least 10 m. Traps in orchard 1 were removed on 12 September, and traps in orchard 2
were removed on 15 June. In order to not kill too many adults, sticky plates in two of the traps
in orchard 1 were removed 15th June. Lures in delta traps in orchard 1 were changed once
during this period. Traps were inspected for eggs and adults every week. In an apple orchard
in eastern Norway 5 traps with lures and one control trap were checked for eggs and adults
from 3 June until 8 August. Traps were checked 10 times during this period.
In 2008, trials were set up in two orchards, sweet cherry and plum, in Western
Norway. Delta traps with lures, without lures and delta traps with lures and sticky bases were
compared for effect on number of eggs deposited. In addition, lures were also attached to
branches to evaluate whether the same effect was found when placed directly on to a tree.
Treatments are as follows: 1) delta trap with lure, 2) delta trap with lure and sticky plate, 3)
delta trap with sticky plate (delta trap control), 4) one dispenser on each tree, 5) four
dispensers on each tree and 6) no dispenser (dispenser control). The number of eggs in
different treatments was compared as follows; counting the number on 10 evenly distributed
branches on each of the treatments with lures on the tree and the control tree (treatment 4-6),
counting the number of eggs on branches with lures (treatment 4 and 5) and counting number
of eggs inside traps (treatment 1-3).
In Eastern Norway, five traps with lures and five control traps placed in an apple
orchard were compared for effect on deposition of eggs during the season.
Data from trials in Western Norway in 2008 were analysed by analysis of variance
(GLM ANOVA) (SAS Institute Inc. 2005). For variables that explained a significant part of
the variance, Tukey’s test was used to analyse differences between means (Zar 1984).
Results
The ternary blend clearly affected the number of lacewing eggs deposited in both areas and all
fields. Eggs were found inside delta traps baited with the ternary blend in all fields, both areas
and both years. At most a total number of 118 and 71 eggs were found at one recording on
five traps in each of the fields in Western Norway in 2007 (Figure 1). Similar results were
found in Eastern Norway in both 2007 and 2008 (Figures 2 and 3). In 2008 the number of
eggs found in delta traps was lower compared to 2007 in Western Norway; at most, 12 eggs
were found at one recording in eight traps.
No eggs were found in control traps in Western Norway. In Eastern Norway a total of
61
two and three eggs were found in control traps in 2007 (one trap) and in 2008 (five traps),
respectively.
Figure 1. Total number of eggs and adults C. carnea in five delta traps at each recording in
field 1 and field 2 in Western Norway in 2007.
Figure 2. Total number of eggs and adults C. carnea in 5 delta traps at each recording in one
field in Eastern Norway in 2007.
62
Figure 3. Total number of C. carnea eggs in 5 delta traps at each recording in one field in
Eastern Norway in 2008
In 2008 the effect of placement of dispensers were investigated. No effect of neither
field nor treatment on number of eggs deposited on 10 evenly distributed branches with one,
four or no dispensers was found (F = 0.91, df = 3, P = 0.45). Further, no effect of field was
found when the number of eggs deposited in delta traps and on branches with lures was
analyzed (F = 0.22, df = 1, P = 0.64), however a clear effect of treatment was found (F =
13.79, df = 4, P < 0.0001). Significantly more eggs were found inside traps with lures
compared to the other treatments (Figure 4). No significant effect of placement of lure in the
tree canopy on number of eggs deposited was found.
Figure 4. Mean number of eggs on branches with lures attaced to it on trees with one lure
(South side) or 4 lures (South, East, West and North) and traps with either lure, lure and sticky
base or only sticky base (control). Both fields combined (n = 8).
63
Discussion
Because of their great ability to prey on small insects and mites and high reproductive
potential, lacewing larvae have a high potential in biological control (Klingen et al. 1999,
Corrales & Campos 2004, Easterbrook et al. 2006). Augmentative release of lacewing larvae
or eggs increases the population of this predator. However, a method that clearly increases
oviposition by naturally occurring adult lacewings in an area might be an alternative to
augmentative release. Tóth et al. (2006) show that phenylacetaldehyde is attractive to adult
lacewings and suggest that this component might be part of the chemical information C.
carnea use to locate feeding sites. Our study confirms this, and also show that a combination
of phenylacetaldehyde, methyl salicylate and acetic acid placed in delta traps increase adult
oviposition by more than 150 times during the season.
Our data indicate that delta traps are more attractive as oviposition sites compared to
leaves; we found significantly more eggs deposited in traps compared to branches with lures
attached to it. The shelter provided by the delta trap may increase the time adults spend to
oviposit, or may reflect the innate preference to place eggs on sheltered places.
For volatiles that are attractive to ovipositing females to be used in biological control,
the presence of food for the newly hatched larvae is essential. Mean longevity of C. carnea
larvae with no food or with only leaves was about 1.5 days in laboratory studies (Hoddle &
Robinson 2004). In orchards with annual aphid or mite problems, attractive volatiles initiating
oviposition might give successful biological control.
In the future we want to find a suitable design for using volatiles for attraction and
ovipoition of lacewings. Where and how lures should be placed in tree canopies must be
investigated. Further, the possible effect of the ternary blend on biological control on pest
population development must be investigated.
References
Ballal C.R. & Singh S.P. 1999: Host plant-mediated oriental and ovipositional behaviour of
three species of Chrysopids (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Biol. Control 16, 47-53.
Corrales N. & Campos M. 2004: Populations, longevity, mortality and fecundity of
Chrysoperla carnea (Neuroptera, Chrysopidae) from olive-orchards with different
agricultural management systems. Chemosphere 57: 1613-1619.
Duelli P. 1980 : Preovipository migration flights in the green lacewing, Chrysopa carnea
(Planipennia, Chrysopidae). Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 7 :239-246.
Easterbrook M.A., Fitzgerald J.D.& Solomon M.G. 2006: Suppresion of aphids on strawberry
by augmentative release of larvae of the lacewing Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens).
Biocontrol Science and Technology 16: 893-900.
Klingen I., Johansen N.S. & Hofsvang T. 1996: The predation of Chrysoperla carnea
(Neurop., Chrysopidae) on eggs and larvae of Mamestra brassicae (Lep., Noctuidae). J.
Appl. Ent. 120: 363-367.
Kungell B.A. & Cottrell T.E. 2007: Oviposition response of green lacewings (Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae) to aphids (Hemiptera: Aphididae) and potential attractants on pecan.
Environ. Entomol. 36: 577-583.
McEwen P.K., Jervis M.A. & Kidd N.A.C. 1994: Use of a sprayed L-tryptophan solution to
concentrate numbers of the green lacewing Chrysoperla carnea in olive tree canopy.
Entomol. Exp. Appl. 70: 97-99.
Michaud J.P. 2001: Evaluation of green lacewings, Chrysoperla plorabunda (Fitch) (Neurop.
Chrysopidae), for augmentative release against Toxoptera citricida (Hop., Aphididae) in
citrus. J. Appl. Ent. 125: 383-388.
64
Reddy G.V.P. 2002: Plant volatiles mediate orientation and plant preference by the predator
Chrysoperla carnea Stephens (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Biol. Control 25: 49-55.
Senior L.J. & McEwen P.K. 2001: The use of lacewings in biological control. In: Lacewings
in the crop environment, eds. McEwen, New and Whittington: 296-302.
Tóth M., Bozik A., Szentkirályi F., Letard A., Tabilio M.R., Verdinelli M., Zandigiacomo P.,
Jeksi J. & Szarukán I. 2006: Phenylacetaldehyd: a chemical attractant for common
green lacewings (Chrysoperla carnea s.l., Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Eur. J. Entomol.
103: 267-271.
65
Sucrose as an apple tree resistance inducer against Cydia pomonella L.
Sylvie Derridj1, François Moulin2, Eric Ferré3, Hubert Galy3, Arnaud Bergougnoux4,
Ingrid Arnaud5, Jacques Auger5.
1
INRA, UMR 1272: Insect Physiology, signals and communication. Route de St Cyr, 78026
Versailles, France.; 2ENSP, Le Potager du Roi, 10 rue du Maréchal Joffre BP 914, 78009
Versailles;3ANADIAG SA16 rue Ampère, 67 500 Haguenau, France ;4Station
d'Expérimentation Fruitière Nord Loire La Morinière 37 800 Saint Epain, France ; 5CRITT
INNOPHYT, Université de Tours, avenue Monge, Parc Grandmont, 37200 Tours , France.
Abstract: The studies of plant insect relationships are necessary for research of new control methods.
We showed that the soluble carbohydrates and sugar alcohols exuded on the leaf surface influence
Cydia pomonella L. egg-laying and neonate larval behaviour. The metabolite pattern and quantities
can explain apple tree resistance to egg-laying. The plant resistance can be obtained by modifying the
pattern with spraying sucrose solutions on apple tree. This was done in several orchards and varieties,
over three years alone and/or in association with chemical or biological controls.
The spraying of 100 ppm sucrose or 10 ppm did not differ, and the addition of sucrose to treatments,
leads to increase the practical efficacy and the ABBOTT one. The practical efficacy = (% of damage
on the treatment reference - % of damage with sucrose addition)/% of damage on the treatment
reference, was 30% over three years and several varieties. These results open a research field on
pesticide alternatives and on improvement of biological controls. Enhancement of this technology
should be obtained by studies of dose effects, duration and time period efficacy. Knowledge of genes
concerned in this induction would be helpful for resistance selection.
Key words: pests, apple tree, leaf surface, sugars.
Introduction
On the leaf surface there are primary metabolites coming from photosynthesis which pass
through the cuticle. Their ratios and quantities (ng/cm²) are linked to the molecules and to the
permeability of the cuticle (Stammitti et al 1999) which is plant species specific. These
metabolites can give informations on leaf physiology, stage and also plant species (Fiala et al.,
1990). We have shown that soluble carbohydrates and/or sugar alcohols influence host
acceptance and egg laying after alighting ( Derridj et al., 1989, Lombarkia and Derridj, 2002)
and also neonate locomotion on leaf surface on two Lepidoptera (Ostrinia nubilalis and Cydia
pomonella). Females detect these molecules by gustatory sensillae present on their legs and
their ovipositor. We have related the ratio between three soluble carbohydrates and three sugar
alcohols to susceptibility and resistance to C. pomonella egg laying (Lombarkia and Derridj,
2008).
Foliar spraying on maize of low quantities (1 to 10mg per liter) of sucrose have a
systemic effect on the plant and reduced O. nubilalis egg laying. We used this result to reduce
damages on apple of an other lepidopteran, C. pomopnella. The experiments in semi-field
conditions showed that a sucrose treatment of 10 ppm (10mg/L) changed the leaf surface
composition of apple trees and the egg distribution of C. pomonella within the tree twenty
days after the treatment.
Here we relate orchard experiments (garden, experimental and open fields) carried out
over 3 years in several countries and geographical regions from France and from Europe. The
66
single effect of sucrose could be estimated in open fields and in association with chemical and
biological insecticide treatments in all the situations.
Material and methods
Insect rearing
Experiments were performed in orchards. In the north of France they were carried out
throughout the season during two insect generations. In the south of France, in Greece and
Italy they began after the first flight at the beginning of male captures of the second
generation. These studies were conducted up to harvest through the two last generations of the
insect.
Sugar and insecticide treatments
Sucrose used was from SIGMA (S 1888, 99.5% purity) and used at 10ppm (1g per 100 liters)
dilution. It was sprayed every twenty days throughout the season on the whole tree in the
north of France from March to September.
The sucrose and fructose treatments were applied in tank mix with several insecticides
according to the trial: Phosmet 50%, Malathion 440g/L, Phosalone 500g/L, Chlorpyrifos ethyl
480g/L and the bio-insecticide granulovirus Carpovirusine.
Apple tree varieties:
In France several varieties were evaluated experimentally: Golden Delicious, JonaGold, New
Jonagold, Gloster, Melrose and PinkGold and in Greece and Italy: Mondial Gala and, in one
orchard,Golden Delicious.
Orchards of experimentation
Experimentations began in 2005 and continued until 2008. In France, the orchard garden was
located in Versailles at the Potager du Roi (five varieties, half rows of about 14 trees were
treated with insecticide and sucrose vs insecticide alone, one or two rows per variety), in La
Morinière an experimental orchard with two varieties, four rows treated with sugar and
carpovirusine and six with carpovirusine, arranged in 4 blocks of 3 trees was used.
ANADIAG open field studies took place in commercial ochards in France, Greece and Italy
from 2006 to 2008. The experimental design used in all the trials was a randomized complete
block with four blocks, the size of the plots varied between 2 and 4 trees depending on the
tree sizes, assessments were only performed on the central part of each plot.
Damage estimation: Damage on apples was estimated at harvest. The mean of practical
efficiency = (% of damage on the treatment reference - % of damage with sucrose addition)/%
of damage on the treatment reference, was calculated over three years. In the potager du Roi
each tree is considered as a unit, all apples from each tree and from the soil were observed,
their numbers varied with the variety and pruning from 22+/-8 for Melrose to 204.5 +/-41 for
Golden. At La Morinière 500 fruits were sampled from trees per treatment for each variety
and apples from the soil were also sampled.
In the ANADIAG trials the damage were also assessed at harvest on both retained and fallen
fruit. The ABBOT efficacy= (100xT0-Tt)/T0, T0= % of infested fruits in control plots, Tt=%
of infested fruits in treated plots, was based on the % of infested fruits at harvest.
Depending on the trials between 1.02% and 44.35% of infested fruit were assessed at harvest.
Results and discussion
ABBOTT efficacy and sucrose single effect
ANADIAG experiments in open fields permit the evaluation of the effect of sucrose alone at
10 and 100 ppm vs untreated trees. The sugar alone reduced C. pomonella damages (Table1).
The mean ABBOTT efficacies throught the trials conducted with sucrose alone were 42.69%
67
+/- 12.22 at 10ppm and 37.93% +/- 17.38 at 100ppm dose rates. The mean ABBOTT efficacy
value reached by the fructose at 10ppm was 37.21% +/- 14.58. Neither significant dose rate
nor sugar type effects have been detected in any of the trials. No significant difference
between the insecticide treatments and the sugar applied alone has been detected in six trials
out of seven.
The insecticide Abbott efficacy was increased of about 10% by the addition of sucrose. The
effect was not additive and probably in the formulation of commercial product substances
with similar activity as sucrose may be present.
Table 1. Mean Abbott efficacy levels (Efficacy level in percent vs. Untreated control damage
level) for sucrose, insecticides (chemical and bio-insecticides), and sucrose + insecticides.
Untreated
Fructose 10ppm
Sucrose 10ppm
Sucrose 100ppm
Insecticide
Insecticide + Sucrose
07/FR RY
07/ITA015
(1.02) a
(1.75) a
36 a
38.1 b
61.9 c
80.95 c
92.86 c
54.63 a
45.14 a
06/FR EL
(22.26) a
36.6 b
47.12 b
08/GR ML
07/GR11
07/FR GA
08/ITA ML
(24.93) a
33.35 a
31.34 a
21.23 a
54.63 a
(37.58) a
19.52 b
(40.67) a
(44.35) a
60.04 b
63.33 b
37.98 b
30.66 bc
41.55 bc
61.34 d
46.53 cde
50.66 de
78.9 c
Means followed by the same letter do not significantly differ (P<0.05, Student-NewmanKeuls test performed in each trial individually).
Data in brackets corresponds to the % of infested fruits in the untreated control at harvest.
Untreated
Fructose 10ppm
Sucrose 10ppm
Sucrose 100ppm
Insecticide
Insecticide + Sucrose
Number of
trials
7
4
4
3
7
5
Mean
SE
(24.65)
37.76
42.69
37.93
50.10
59.42
17.80
11.65
14.12
21.29
17.44
19.71
Data in brackets corresponds to the % of infested fruits in the untreated control at harvest.
Practical efficacy of sucrose added to chemical and biological treatments
When gathering all the data from the different geographic regions, treatments, varieties and througout
the 3 years, the correlation between the proportions (%) of apple damaged treated with insecticides
and treated with insecticide amended with sucrose shows a linear curve (figure 1). The distinction
between the doses 10 and 100 ppm of sucrose did not show any different relationship. On the basis of
the equation of the correlation we can calculate the general practical efficicacy = (% of damage on the
treatment reference - % of damage with sucrose addition)/% of damage on the treatment reference. It
is on the order of 30%. There is no link between the efficacy of sucrose and the potential for
damage (susceptibilty) of the variety, but variety is the main source of variation. Jonagold and
NewJonagold were particularly and constantly unaffected by the sucrose treatment.
68
Figure 1. Correlation between apple damage treated with insecticide and insecticide + sucrose at
10 and 100 ppm in experiments over three years and three European countries. Correlation
equation conducted on the mean practical efficacy of 30% = (% of damage on the treatment
reference - % of damage with sucrose addition)/% of damage on the treatment reference, due to
addition of sucrose to different insecticides
We induced plant protection against C. pomonella by spraying sucrose in tiny quantities. The
phenomenon seems both general and reproducible. The chemical analysis of the metabolites on
the leaf surface of apple trees (Ferré et al., 2008) which showed that the sucrose treatment mostly
induced changes (quantities and ratios) in metabolites; the signals for the insect for host
acceptance and egg laying are changed. It should present the advantage of avoiding plant damage
due to neonate larvae. Knowledge about the mechanisms induced will open new directions for
research in crop protection.
Acknowledgements
To Josep Blay, Stefano Bergaglio, Sotiris Pantazis respectively Directors of Anadiag Iberica,
Anadiag Italia et Anadiag Hellas for their participation to the open field studies.
ENSP of Versailles all people who harvested apples at the Potager du Roi.
References
Derridj S., Gregoire V., Boutin J.P. Fiala V. 1989 : Plant growth stages in the interspecific
oviposition preference of the european corn borer and relations with chemicals present on
the leaf surfaces. Entomol. Exp. appl 267-276.
Ferre E., Galy H., Moulin F., Clement G; Derridj S. 2008: Le saccharose inducteur de
résistance du pommier contre Cydia pomonella l.. AFPP – 8ème Conference
Internationale sur les ravageurs en agriculture, Session arboriculture fruitière,
Montpellier 22-23 octobre 2008.
Fiala V., Glad C., Martin M., Jolivet E., Derridj S. 1990 : Occurrence of soluble carbohydrates
69
on the phyllplane of maize (Zea mays L.), variations in relation to leaf heterogeneity and
position on the plant. New Phytol.. 115, 609-615.
Lombarkia N., Derridj S. 2002: Incidence of apple fruit and leaf surface metabolites on Cydia
pomonella oviposition. Entomol. Exp.appl. 104: 79-87
Lombarkia N., Derridj S. 2008: Resistance of apple trees to Cydia pomonella egg-laying due
to leaf surface metabolites. Entomol. Exp. appl. 128: 57-65.
Stammitti L., Garrec J.P., Derridj S. 1995: Permeability of isolated cuticles of Prunus
laurocerasus to soluble carbohydrates. Plant Physiol. Biochem. 33, 3, 319-326.
70
Attractiveness of mixtures of pheromone and host plant volatiles to
Cydia molesta (Busck) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae)
Nélia Varela, Jesús Avilla, César Gemeno
Department of Crop and Forest Sciences, and Center UdL-IRTA for R+D, University of
Lleida, Av. Rovira Roure 191, 25198 Lleida, Spain.
Abstract: In the Oriental Fruit Moth (Cydia molesta) the role of the female pheromone blend has
been very well studied in the behaviour of males, but only a little in the behaviour of females. On the
other hand, the role of host plant volatiles has been recently studied in the behaviour of females, but it
has not yet been studied with respect to male behaviour. From these recent studies, a blend of five host
volatiles - three green leaf volatiles and two aromatics - has been shown to affect female behaviour. In
this work we studied the effect of the five host volatiles on the behaviour of C. molesta males. By
doing wind tunnel experiments we have demonstrated that there is an effect of host plant volatiles on
male behaviour but only when mixed with a sub-optimal dose of pheromone. No effect was found
when the blend was tested alone. A variety of responses were found when one compound was removed
from the five host volatile blend, or when the host plant volatile was placed alone. Nonetheless, male
landing was always higher when exposed to the mixtures than with the pheromone alone. We could
also see that when the aromatic compounds were removed from the blend, male landing was lower and
no difference was found when removing any of the green leaf volatiles. The best landing response was
achieved when the sub-optimal dose of pheromone was mixed with the complete blend of five host
volatiles that is known to affect the behaviour of females.
Cydia molesta, Wind tunnel, Plant volatiles, Pheromone
71
Improving the effectiveness of mating disruption for tree fruit pests
Larry Gut, Peter McGhee, Piera Siegert, Michael Reinke, James Miller
Department of Entomology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, USA, 48824
Abstract: Over the past five years, we have been exploring ways to achieve mating disruption of
tortricid moth pests of fruit superior to that provided by current formulations. Different release
devices, distributions, and active ingredients may be called for, depending upon the mechanism(s) of
disruption to which a particular pest species or population size is most vulnerable. Several lines of
evidence indicate that competition between pheromone dispensers and females is the primary
mechanism of communicational disruption of tortricid moths in the field, especially for hand-applied
formulations. From a practical standpoint, the best disruption will be achieved when dispensers are
highly attractive and numerous point sources are distributed uniformly within the orchard. Wax
formulations applied at high point source densities have provided outstanding disruption of some key
fruit pests, including Oriental fruit moth. However, achieving a very high level Codling moth (CM)
disruption has proved more challenging. Recent efforts to develop more effective and economical
disruption formulations for CM have been guided by a series of experiments conducted in replicated
plots consisting of large field cages constructed over 12 apple trees. A series of experiments using
various types of dispensers revealed that attraction alone was insufficient for achieving a high level of
disruption. Outstanding results were only achieved when CM males were prevented from making
multiple orientations to pheromone sources. The high cost of mating disruption is often cited as a
major impediment to broader adoption of the tactic. Attract-and-kill technologies offer the possibility
of a cost-effective option for CM disruption. The economics of point-source dispensers could be
improved through more efficient use of the precious active ingredient.
IPM, Codling moth, Mating disruption, Apple, Pheromone
72
Assessing efficacy of mating disruption in apple orchards by release
and recapture of males in net-cages
Marco Tasin, Carmela Sicher, Stefano Contrini, Silvia Schmidt and Claudio Ioriatti
Research and Innovation Centre, FEM-IASMA, Via E.Mach 2, 38010 S.Michele a/A, Italy;
marco.tasin@iasma.it
Abstract: Codling moth Cydia pomonella (L.) is regarded as a major pest of pome fruit worldwide.
The implementation of mating disruption for its control has been increasing during the last two
decades (Witgall et al., 2008; Angeli et al., 2007). Due to increased regulatory restrictions of
conventional insecticides and other environmental issues, in some fruit growing districts mating
disruption is now deployed on well over 50% of the pome fruit area and it is considered an integral
part of pest management programs for this species (Thomson et al., 2009). The evaluation of the
efficacy of the commercial formulation used for mating disruption appears to be a relevant factor for
further support the use of this technique. In this work we evaluate the use of net-cages (Doye & Koch,
2005) as a field method for the evaluation of the efficacy of mating disruption. A pheromone treated
plot and an untreated area were provided with four 2 mc net-cages each equipped with a trap. No
plants were included in the cage. Codling moth males were released in the cages and caught in
unbaited or female baited delta trap. In each of the four cages, a fixed number of males (5, 10, 15, and
20) were released with the aim to evaluate the effect of male density on trap catch. Release of males
was replicated three times. As a general result, the number of males captured in the female baited traps
was dependent on the number of released males in the cage (Linear regression, R2=0.996; ANOVA,
P<0.001). A different pattern was, however, observed between the untreated and the pheromone
treated plot. While in the control plot the captures could be represented by a linear curve with no
apparent saturation (R2=0.959), in the pheromone plot we observed a logarithmic trend with a
tendency to saturation (R2=0.968). Although the treatment did not affect the number of males caught in
the blank traps (ANOVA, P>0.05), a higher proportion of males was trapped with the lowest male
dose in the control plot indicating that this dosage may be strongly biased by accidental captures. The
efficacy of the pheromone formulation was calculated as catch inhibition by comparing the fraction of
males caught by female baited traps in the treated and control plots. The inhibition of captures due to
the treatment was 68% with a release of 20 males and 96% with the dose of 5 males. From these
preliminary results it appears that a dose of 20 males per cage is necessary to highlight behavioural
differences of searching males due to a pheromone treatment. Further research on factors such as trap
architecture, presence of plants in the cage and volume of the cage may be of help for the optimization
of this method.
Key words: codling moth, Cydia pomonella, field test, pheromone.
References
Angeli G., Anfora G., Baldessari M., Germinara G.S., Rama F., De Cristofaro A. and Ioriatti C.
2007. Mating disruption of codling moth Cydia pomonella with high densities of Ecodian
sex pheromone dispensers. – Journal of Applied Entomology 131(5): 311-318.
Doye E. and Koch U.T. 2005. A reliable field test for the efficiency of mating disruption
techniques. – IOBC wprs Bulletin 28(7): 325-328.
Thomson D., Brunner J., Jenkins J. and Gut L. 2009. Commercial use of Codling moth mating
disruption: A success story despite the limitations. – IOBC wprs Bulletin 41: 53-60.
Witzgall, P., Stelinski, L., Gut, L. & Thomson, D. 2008: Codling moth management and
chemical ecology. – Annu. Rev. Entomol. 53: 503-522.
73
Recent progress in sanitation practices to manage apple scab
William MacHardy
Department of Biological Sciences, University of New Hampshire, Spaulding Hall, Durham,
NH 03824, USA
Abstract: Sanitation practices to control apple scab, caused by Venturia inaequalis (Cke.) Wint., are
aimed at reducing the primary inoculum, with the expectation that there will be an approximate
reduction in primary scab, but the reduction in primary scab may be much less than expected. Two
recent publications are reviewed that allow an analysis of the major factors that influence the
relationship between the reduction in ascospores trapped and leaf litter (the source of ascospores) and
the reduction in primary scab on spur leaves and on older leaves and fruit in sanitized compared to
non-sanitized plots. Suggested guidelines for sanitation trials based on the analyses are presented.
Key words: apple scab, Venturia inaequalis, sanitation, IPM, integrated control
Introduction
Several sanitation methods reduce the primary inoculum and, as a consequence, increase
fungicide efficacy to control scab and have the potential to reduce the fungicide dose to
control scab (MacHardy, 1996). However, few scab management programs have successfully
incorporated these methods into practice, even in organic orchards where high ascospore dose
and the application of less efficacious fungicides approved for organic apple production often
result in unacceptable levels of scabbed fruit. Sanitation trials are conducted to garner
additional support for including sanitation in scab management programs, but the results may
show great disparity between expected and actual reductions in scabbed leaves and fruit. This
disparity may be interpreted as a failure of sanitation to meet its expected effect on the
pathogen and the leaf litter, but the results may be deceptive due to factors that lessen or mask
the actual reductions in ascospores and the leaf litter. Two recent publications are analyzed to
explain why it is important to consider these factors when designing sanitation trials and
interpreting trial results.
Investigation 1
Holb (2006), in Hungary, investigated the potential of four sanitation treatments to reduce the
leaf litter, trapped ascospores and scab on spur clusters, older leaves and fruit (Table 1). There
was general agreement between the reductions in leaf litter density (LLD) and trapped
ascospores and significant reductions in scab depending on year, cultivar susceptibility and
sanitation treatment, but the reductions were often considerably less than expected. For
example, the LLD and ascospores trapped were reduced 56 to >95% in three of the sanitation
treatments, but significant reductions in scabbed leaves and fruit were only 18-37%. Most
noticeably, reductions in spur scab were markedly less than expected in the leaf
removal/plastic foil plots in which trapped ascospores and the leaf litter were reduced more
than 95%. Several factors associated with increased disparity between reductions in
ascospores and leaf litter and reductions in scab incidence (Table 2) help explain the results.
1. High predicted potential ascospore dose (PAD): PAD (ascospore/m2 orchard floor) ranged
from 923 to 3,549 in the two integrated orchards and from 54,598 to 164,047 in the two
74
organic orchards.
2. Numerous infection periods: 14 and 37 infection periods in the two organic orchards and
20 and 35 infection periods in the two integrated orchards from mid-Mar. to mid-Oct. in
2003 and 2004, respectively.
3. Scab susceptible and moderately scab susceptible cultivars planted in each orchard.
4. Non-sanitation control plots and unsuccessful sanitation plots, i.e., plots not significantly
different from control plots, in each orchard.
Table 1. Selected data from recent publications that investigated the relationship
between reductions in leaf litter and trapped ascospores and reductions in scab
incidence.
% Reduction in
Scab incidence
Trapped
LLD
Spur
Older
ascospores
leaves
leaves
Fruit
Sanitation practice
Holb, 2006
Collect fallen leaves 56-79
56-79 (I)
61-65 (O)1
18-37% significant
reduction compared to
Collect fallen leaves 72-92
72-92 (I)
–3
non-sanitized plots.
+ straw mulch
72-79 (O)
Collect fallen leaves
+ plastic foil cover
>95
>95
Straw mulch
24-38
No significant difference
2
Holb, 2007
Remove fallen
83-89
42-47
leaves
Disc cultivation
50-58
7-26
Shred leaves
43-50
23-36
Cover orchard floor
>99
56-68
17-25; 20-274
with plastic foil
1
I = integrated orchard management; O = organic orchard management.
No significant difference in LLD among treatments; plastic foil was the only treatment
with leaf scab significantly different from non-sanitized control.
3
Each trial was significantly different to non-sanitized control plots depending on year,
cultivar susceptibility and orchard management program.
4
2002 and 2003 data.
2
Investigation 2
A second study by Holb (2007) evaluated the relationship between the reduction in LLD
caused by four sanitation treatments applied to the leaf litter and the reduction in primary
(spur cluster) scab and scab on older leaves and fruit in two organic orchards (Table 1).
Removing fallen leaves mechanically in autumn reduced the LLD 83-89% by mid-Apr, but
spur leaf scab was reduced only 42-47%. Similar discrepancies between reductions in LLD
and spur leaf scab occurred with the other sanitation treatments. Several factors listed in Table
2 help to explain the discrepancies.
1. High ascospore dose indicated by ~14% and ~23% spur scab in both organic orchards in
2002 and 2003, respectively, after the fourth infection period.
75
3. Many early season infection periods: 9 and 8 infection periods at one organic orchard and
8 and 6 infection periods at the second organic orchard from 1 Mar until 25 May in 2002
and 2003, respectively.
3. Small scale sanitized and non-sanitized plots and highly susceptible cultivars Jonagold and
Mutsu (in addition to the moderately susceptible test cultivars Jonathan and Elstar) in each
orchard may have resulted in inter-plot transport of ascospores.
1
Table 2. Factors that alter the relationship between the percent reduction in ascospores
and LLD caused by sanitation and the percent reduction in primary scab, compared to
non-sanitized plots.
Conditions favoring close relationship
Conditions increasing disparity
1. Sanitation had been employed three or
1. No previous sanitation program
more years
2. Inhibitory post infection fungicides
2. No post infection fungicides that
3. Non-effective sanitation treatments
inhibit the pathogen1
and non-sanitized control plots in the
3. One sanitation treatment only in an
same orchard
orchard
4. High PAD
4. Low PAD2
5. Test orchard/plot is <15 m from an
5. Test orchard/plot is >15 m from an
untreated or severely scabbed
untreated or severely scabbed orchard
orchard
6. Conditions unfavorable for conidia
6. Conditions that favor conidia
overwintering on shoots and buds
overwintering on shoots and buds
7. Few primary infection periods
7. Many, primary infection periods
8. Low/moderate scab susceptible
8. High scab susceptible cultivars in the
cultivars in the sanitized orchard/plot
sanitized orchard/plot
9. Large plot size
9. Small plot size
10. Conditions favorable for earthworms
10. Conditions favorable for earthworms
and antagonistic microorganisms
and antagonistic microorganisms
11. Effective fungicide program
11. Ineffective fungicide program
Infections stopped by post infection fungicides that do not kill the fungus may become active in
autumn resulting in development of the sexual stage and ascospore production after leaf fall that
will not be counted in an autumn assessment of scab lesions to predict PAD.
2
PAD (potential ascospore dose): ascospores per m2 orchard floor.
Guidelines for sanitation trials
In broad terms, primary scab in a sanitized plot is the product of several factors: actual
ascospore dose (predicted PAD - reduction in PAD caused by sanitation), number, timing
and severity of primary infection periods, level of cultivar susceptibility to scab and
neighboring sources of ascospores. Earthworms and microorganisms that remove or
degrade the leaf litter or are antagonistic to the pathogen also reduce PAD, but their effects
are not easily measured so are not included here. PAD is the most important measureable
factor to consider in evaluating the performance of a sanitation practice because it can vary
greatly from orchard to orchard and from year to year in an orchard. Holb (2007), for
example, found that in plots treated with straw mulch (alone or in combination with leaf
collection), the greater the PAD the lower the effect on trapped ascospores.
Sanitation will always increase fungicide efficacy to control scab and, thus, is
recommended for every orchard, especially organically managed orchards for reasons
76
stated above. Integrating sanitation with strategies to reduce the recommended fungicide
dose to control scab depends largely on ascospore dose, and it is clear that sanitation
applied for this purpose will fail in some orchards. For example, the PAD assessed by Holb
(2007) was ~164,000 in one organic orchard and 923 in one integrated (traditionally
managed) orchard. Assuming that the straw mulch/plastic foil treated plots reduced trapped
ascospores by 80%, the adjusted ascospore dose in those plots would be ~32,000 and 164
ascospores per m2 orchard floor in the integrated and organic orchards, respectively.
Sanitation would increase fungicide efficacy in both orchards, but the 32,000 PAD in the
organic orchard would still be well above the threshold for reducing early season fungicide
dose, whereas the 164 PAD in the integrated orchard would be well within the low-risk
threshold category for considering a reduction in fungicide dose (MacHardy, 1996, 2000).
Summary
Sanitation will be most successful in achieving its expected effect on primary scab when
only one sanitation practice is tested, PAD is low, few, less severe primary infection
periods occurred, the orchard is planted with low to moderate scab susceptible cultivars
and has been well managed for scab (i.e., overwintering conidia on wood and buds
unlikely), and there is no potentially high source of ascospores within 20 m. A commercial
orchard will not have all of these ideal conditions, so each factor must be considered in
selecting a sanitation method and deciding how to best utilize sanitation in the scab
management program.
References
Holb, I. J. 2006: Effect of six sanitation treatments on leaf litter density, ascospore
production of Venturia inaequalis and scab incidence in integrated and organic apple
orchards. Eur. J. Plant Pathol. 115: 293-307.
Holb, I. J. 2007: Effect of four non-chemical sanitation treatments on leaf infection by
Venturia inaequalis in organic apple orchards. Eur. J. Hort. Sci. 71: 60-65.
MacHardy, W.E. 1996. Apple Scab: Biology, Epidemiology and Management. The
American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, MN,USA. 545.
MacHardy, W.E. 2000. Action thresholds for managing apple scab with fungicides and
sanitation. Proc. Int. Conf. on Integrated Fruit Prod. Eds. Muller, Polesny, Verheyden,
Webster. Acta Hort. 525:123-131.
77
Fungicide Sprays During the Window of Germination,
A Special Tool for Fungicidal Control of Apple Scab in Organic and
Integrated Apple Production
Peter Triloff
Marktgemeinschaft Bodenseeobst eG, Friedrichshafen, Germany
Abstract: The most frequent factors responsible for failures in controlling apple scab
(Venturia inaequalis) are the amount of fungal inoculum, poor strategy and timing of
fungicide spray applications and the intrinsic, incomplete efficacy of the fungicides. Despite
the progress made in apple scab control fungicides remain a highly underestimated risk
because their less than 100% efficacy in the field is not gradable enough to match the
enormous variation of inoculum, resulting in a high risk of poor control as the inoculum
increases. The application of more than one fungicide spray per infection period is the only
effective way of adapting the efficacy of scab control to high inoculum levels. A protectant is
applied shortly before rain and a curative compound after the rain event if a severe infection
has built up. The curative compound controls the spores which passed the protectant fungicide
resulting in a significant increase of efficacy compared to just the protectant before the rain.
When curatives are not available, a protectant may be applied during the window of
germination, a time period when the ascospore relaease of the day has almost terminated but
no, or just a few, spores have infected. The time window is determined using the simulation
software RIMpro in conjunction with the weather forecast. This method has been introduced
in organic fruit production (OFP) at Lake Constance area in 2002 and has improved the
results of primary scab control to, or above, the level obtained in IFP. After having become
standard in OFP, the method is also used in IFP after the detection of wide spread resistance to
Anilinopyrimidines at Lake Constance area in 2005.
Key words: Apple scab, double spray, window of germination, organic fruit production,
inoculum related control
Introduction
When analysing failures of control of apple scab (Venturia inaequalis, Cooke, Wint.) during
the primary season in commercial fruit farms, there are four major reasons:
i) until recent years the fungal inoculum did not play any role for the control strategy which
was very much focused on the sole use of fungicides. Although the potential ascospore
dose in commercial orchards may vary by a factor of up to 106, this difference in risk is
still only marginally reflected by the present control strategies, indicating a lack of
dynamic in the response. The result is that in relation to the genereal level of scab attack
in an indivdual year in a certain region, success usually is poor in high inoculum orchards.
ii) the common response following a year with high scab attack is the combination of a search
for new fungicides or mixtures which gave good results in fungicide trials (not strategy
trials), more frequent sprays and probably also higher dose rates and spray volumes.
iii) missing the incorporation of the development of the host into the timing of fungicide
sprays. Since a protectant fungicide may cover a rosette leaf area expansion of no more
78
than approximately 80% (Knaus, 2001) which may be exceeded within 2 days, common
fungicide spray intervals of 7 to 10 days during this period give a good imagination of the
poor adaptation of the fungicide spray schedules to the development of the host.
Table 1: The theoretical effect of the inoculum on the scab attack
Orchard
Inoculum
1
2
3
low
medium
high
Ascospores landed Efficacy of Lesions/m² Efficacy required
on leaves/m²
the
of orchard for 1 lesion/m² of
orchard floor
fungicide %
floor
orchard floor
100
99
1
99
1.000
99
10
99,9
10.000
99
100
99,99
iv) although scab control has been very much focused on the use of fungicides, it has been
overlooked, that under field conditions fungicides have an intrinsic, incomplete efficacy
below 100%. In the theoretical calculations (Table 1) it becomes clear, that the success of
fungicide sprays is very closely related to the inoculum. To obtain the same attack in
orchard # 2 and orchard #3 as in orchard #1 given in the example in Table 1, the fungicide
theoretically needs to be 10 x and 100 x, respectively, more effective as in orchard #1
which is impossible with any of the classic “concepts” like new products, reduced spray
intervals, increased dose rates and water volumes or adjuvants. Because the efficacy of a
fungicide cannot be increased as required to compensate for a high inoculum, the scab
attack may reach an unacceptable level although the fungicide worked properly.
Increasing fungicidal efficacy
In recent years much progress has been made by integrating the reduction of the inoculum
through sanitation practices into the control strategy. Also sophisticated simulations of the
behavior of the host and the pathogen have been developed, which in combination with
weather forecast data allow real predictions. With these tools and new information
technologies problems caused by poor timing of fungicide sprays can mostly be eliminated.
Despite all this progress the fungicides have remained a highly underestimated risk
because of their incomplete efficacy in the field which in their classic use is not gradable
enough to match high inoculum levels. The only way for a substantial increase is a double
treatmant on the same infection, which has been proven by Trapman (pers. comm., 1996) in a
field trial (Figure 1). Trapman applied different dose rates of a protectant before any rain
event during the primary season and in a second set of blocks additionally to the protectant
sprays three applications of a curative fungicide after the three severe primary infections. In a
third block only three curative treatments after the severe infections were carried out.
The additional curative sprays increased the total efficacy of the fungicide strategy by a factor
of 5,6 compared to the pure protectant fungicide strategy. But even this improvement is not
high enough to compensate for a high inoculum shown in Table 1 for orchard #3 where an
increase of a factor of 100 is required to compensate the high inoculum relative to orchard #1.
This demonstrates again the importance of the sanitary treatments.
The purpose of these double sprays is to kill the ascospores that have survived the
protectant fungicide, thus accumulating efficacy yielding in a lower scab attack in high
inoculum orchards (Figure 2). This strategy has been recommended by the author at Lake
Constance area since the early 1990´s and has become standard in the area in 1996, after
resistance to DMIs was detected and the Anilinopyrimidines were registered. After 10 years of
use when in 2005 wide spread resistance to Anilinopyrimidines has been detected at Lake
79
Constance area, this strategy could no more be applied since no more curative compounds
without resistance had been available.
105
Scab Control Strategies:
The Effect of Double Treatments
100
99
100
98
96
96
% efficacy
98
95
94
95
91
90
protectant
protectant + 3 x curative
3 x curative
85
82
82
80
0,065 l/ha
0,125 l/ha
0,25 l/ha
0,375 l/ha
0,5 l/ha
dose rate protectant
protectant
protectant (no effect)
curative
protectant (no effect)
protectant (active)
curative (active)
curative (no effect)
When true curative fungicides are not available as in organic fruit production or in case
of resistance, there exists an alternative for using the potential of double treatments. When
following the development of an infection in a simulation program like RIMpro (Figure 2) the
ascospre release is triggered by threshold levels of light and rain. Assuming the rain event
starts at night and continues throughout the whole day ascocpore release peaks around noon
time and finishes in the evening. As the spores are released throughout daylight (Figure 2;
white peaks), a fraction lands on leaves, increasing in number with a similar pattern as the
release, and starts germinating. Under optimum temperature and continuous leaf wetness, the
germination process ends after approximately 6 hours. The number of primary structures
inside the leaf tissue increases according to the pattern of the ascospore release, in reality
80
being modified by temperature and leaf wetness (Figure 2, black sigmoid line).
In Figure 3 a time gap is shown from the end of spore release on May 5 until the first
ascospore has established a stable structure in the leaf on May 6. During this time window of
13 hrs all the ascospores that landed on the leaves are under germination. Although highly
modified by actual weather conditions, this time window occurs at any day with an ascospore
release. Protectant fungicides, which kill germinating spores as long as no stable primary
structure inside the leaf is established, can be applied as a regular cover spray prior to rain but
also between the moment the last ascospore of the day landed on the leaf has started
germination until the moment when the first ascospore of the day landed on the leaf
establishes a stable primary structure inside the host. Applied at increasing time after the first
ascospores have infected the leaf, the efficacy of the protectant will decrease and has no more
effect when all germinating spores have completed infection prior to the time of application.
This use of protectant fungicides is closely related to the Mills Warning System aiming at the
application of lime sulfur and sulfur sprays and dusts also in the rain event during which an
infection was expected (MacHardy, 1996). As with the curative fungicides the protectant
fungicides are applied as a second treatment after a regular cover spray put on before the
onset of rain events during which a heavy ascospore release is expected.
X
protectant
protectant 1
protectant (no effect)
protectant 2
protectant(active)
protectant (no effect)
the window of germination
A greenhouse test was conducted to prove that the activity of protectant fungicides
applied in the window of germination is not negatively affected by rain during the application.
For testing various protectants, potted and untreated trees were inoculated with 105
conidia ml-1 and kept wet with 2 mm of artificial rain for 5 hrs to allow sufficient germination.
After 5 hrs of rain fungicides were applied during the rain. Immediately after the application,
artificial rain was intensified to 10 mm within 30 min to wash off the products. The trees were
kept moist forr 20 hrs at 18°C after the inoculation and then under dry conditions until lesions
appeared. The results (Table 2) indicate a significant inhibiting effect. Even sulfur at a
concentration of 0,2%, equivalent to a dose rate of 2 kg/ha, inhibited the development of the
lesions completely. Trifloxystrobin and Mancozeb also showed complete inhibition. Lime
sulfur and Dithianon yielded very good activity while the two Captan-formulations displayed
the lowest activities.
81
Table 2:
Efficacy of protectant fungicides applied into the window of germination during
rain. Different letters indicate a signficant difference according to the Dunn
multiple comparison test (p< 0,05).
Fungicide
Untreated
Captan WDG (0,125%)
Captan WP (0,12%)
Dithianon (0,05%)
Lime sulfur (1,5%)
Attack
(%)
6,8 a
2,2 ab
0,5 b
0,2 b
0,1 b
Efficacy
(%)
68
93
97
99
Attack
(%)
Sulfur (0,2%)
0,0 b
Sulfur (0,5%)
0,0 b
Trifloxystrobin (0,01%) 0,0 b
Mancozeb (0,2%)
0,0 b
Fungicide
Efficacy
(%)
100
100
100
100
Implementation
The use of protectant fungicides in the window of germination during peak ascpospore
releases of apple scab in high inoculum orchards has become standard in the past few years as
a tool to improve the efficacy of regular protectant fungicides. Because of the mainly weaker
fungicides available in organic fruit production the method significantly improved scab
control during the primary season, which has been impressively demonstrated in the years
2007 - 2009 where primary scab control was as good, or better, in high inoculum organic
orchards compared to blocks on integrated fruit farms.
A worst case example of the method is presented in Figure 4, which shows the peak ascospore
release in 2006 during a 5 day rain event with up to 70% of the season´s total release. In the
graph the white line represents the ascospore releases and the black line the progress of the
infection. The three most important windows of germination are marked with the bright
arrows and the corresponding time periods by the squares underneath. All growers have put
on a regular protectant fungicide as a basic protection on April 25 or in the morning of April
26, before the rain event started in the afternoon. Most organic growers and a few IP-growers
put on at least the first two of the three recommended sprays during the respective windows of
germination and by doing so could keep their high inoculum blocks almost scab free. The
infection incidence ranged from 0 - 2% infected shoots at the end of primary season.
Additionally the graph shows three incorrect responses of other growers. A first group which
did not want to apply a second spray in their high inoculum blocks on the same day waited
until the next morning when they put on a protectant. As can be seen by the left crossed arrow,
this spray was too late for the release of the first day because these spores already had
completed infection indicated by the high RIM-values. This spray was also too early for the
release on the same day (April 27), because this fungicide was already washed off before the
spore release started in the early afternoon. A second group waited until Friday and put on a
spray in the morning, which also gave poor results in high inoculum blocks because it was
again too late for the previous release and too early for the following release on the same day.
Finally a third group applied an Anilinopyrimidine on Saturday, April 29 or Sunday, April 30,
but these sprays also did not give satisfying results because of the widespread resistance to
this chemical group.
82
Apple Scab, Lake Constance, 2006
Primary Infection 26. - 30.4. LI
300
Spray too
late resp.
too early
250
2nd window of
germination;
germination; recom.
recom.
2000
1750
curative:
curative: ineffecineffective (resistance)
resistance)
1500
200
1250
X
150
Basic
protectant
RIM-Value
Ascospore Release
1st window of
germination ;recom.
recom.
Ascospore release
RIM-Values
Spray too
late resp.
too early
3rd window of
germination;
germination; recom.
recom.
1000
X
100
X X
750
500
50
250
0
0
26.4 26.4 26.4 26.4 26.4 26.4 26.4 26.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 28.4 29.4 29.4 29.4 29.4 29.4 29.4 29.4 29.4 30.4
Tuesday
. 00 . 03 . 06 . 09 . 12 . 15 . 18 . 21 . 00 . 03 . 06 . 09 . 12 . 15 . 18 . 21 . 00 . 03 . 06 . 09 . 12 . 15 . 18 . 21 . 00 . 03 . 06 . 09 . 12 . 15 . 18 . 21 . 00
Wednesday
Thursday
Date
Friday
Saturday
Saturday
The method was introduced in organic fruit production at Lake Constance area in 2002
and has improved the results of primary scab control to or even above the level obtained in
IFP. After having become standard in organic fruit production, the method is also used in
integrated fruit production since after the detection of wide spread resistance to
Anilinopyrimidines at Lake Constance area in 2005 no more curative compounds are
available.
References:
MacHardy W.E. 1996: Apple Scab Biology, Epidemiology and Management. APS Press, The
American Phytopathological Society; St.Paul, Minnesota, 386 p.
Knaus C. 2001: Bestimmung der Dauerwirkung von Kontaktfungiziden gegen Apfelschorf
(Venturia inaequalis) in Abhängigkeit des Streckungswachstums der Rosettenblätter von
Apfelbäumen. Diplomarbeit, Hochschule Wädenswil, Fachhochschule Zürich, 64 p.
83
Assessment of fungicide protection strategies in experimental apple
orchards
Brun L.*, Guinaudeau J., Gros C., Parisi L., Simon S.
INRA (National Institute of Agricultural Research), UERI, Domaine de Gotheron, F-26320
Saint-Marcel-lès-Valence, France
*lbrun@avignon.inra.fr
Abstract: In order to protect apple trees against scab, powdery mildew and post-harvest diseases, a
large number of fungicides are applied in apple orchards from green-tip stage to harvest. To satisfy
society’s demand to decrease the number of plant protection treatments, innovative protection
strategies were assessed over four years in experimental orchards. In the case of apple scab, fungicide
protection management takes the primary inoculum level and the means for reducing this inoculum, as
well as the cultivar susceptibility, into account, in order to define a climatic risk level (according to
Mills) as the intervention threshold. The decision to use fungicides against powdery mildew is based
on the assessment of disease levels present in the orchard (use of a percentage threshold of leaves
infected with powdery mildew). The application of these decision rules makes it possible to reduce
the number of fungicide applications against scab and/or powdery mildew by more than 50%, while
keeping these two diseases under control. In organic farming systems, the cultivar most susceptible to
scab had scab damage on fruits despite careful reduction of the inoculum at fall and a large number of
fungicide treatments during the season. No fungicide protection treatment for post-harvest diseases
was applied in organically grown orchards nor in the low-input system for the two cultivars considered
not to be highly susceptible to these diseases. These different protection strategies are assessed in
terms of disease control and economic costs.
Key-words: apple orchard, disease, fungicide, protection strategy, sanitation practice, cultivar
susceptibility
Introduction
The control of apple fungal diseases in French orchards is mainly based on chemical control.
To satisfy society’s demand to decrease the number of plant protection treatments, it is
necessary to reduce the high number of fungicide applications in apple orchards. An orchard
system trial was designed (Simon et al., this volume) in order to test several pest and disease
management regimes that were based on patterns of decision rules.
The aims of this study were (i) to test integrated disease control strategies, based on
the combination of validated methods (cultivar resistance, sanitation, restricted chemical
control), and (ii) to carry out a multi-criteria (agronomic, economic) assessment of these
integrated strategies.
Materials and methods
Experimental site
The experimental orchard was planted in January 2005 at the INRA experimental unit of
Gotheron. Located in Southern France in the middle Rhône Valley, the area has a continental
climate with summer Mediterranean influences. The specific disease context on the
experimental site is the absence of fireblight and of Vf-virulent strains. Lastly, copper
84
applications against Nectria canker are not necessary at fall.
Experimental design
The experimental design includes 3 orchard systems with different weed, pest and disease
management regimes (Simon et al., this volume). The frames for disease management are:
-Supervised (SV): «supervised chemical control of diseases»,
-Low-input (LI): «reduction of the use of fungicides»,
-Organic (OG): «no synthetic fungicide, reduction of the use of mineral fungicides ».
Three apple cultivars were planted in each of these three systems:
-Smoothee 2832T®: susceptible to scab, powdery mildew and Gleosporium spp. diseases;
-Melrose: low-susceptibility to scab and Gleosporium spp. diseases, susceptible to powdery
mildew;
-Ariane: scab resistant (Vf gene), susceptible to powdery mildew, low-susceptibility to
Gleosporium spp. diseases (Giraud et al., 2006).
The combination of systems and cultivars creates a nine plots (each of 0.37 ha)
experimental design. All the plots have been planted on the same rootstock (PI80) and at the
same planting density. Except for plant protection strategies, the plots have the same cultural
practices. Only the OG system differs for fertilization (organic inputs) and thinning (handthinning only). Orchard and tree training aim at lowering disease incidence: low planting
density (5 m between row by 2 m within row) and centrifugal training favouring canopy
aeration and growth stop in summer (Simon et al., 2006).
Sanitation practices and fungicide strategies
Sanitation practices and fungicide strategies that were applied are presented in table 1 and 2.
For scab management, the leaf ploughing in / removal sanitation practice consists in
the removal of litter leaves from the alley with a lawn sweeper combined with leaf ploughing
in within the row with a cultivator (Gomez et al., 2007). Olivier proposals consist in the use
of a Mills curve as a threshold for fungicide applications (Olivier, 1986). For example, for a
low-susceptibility cultivar, with a low autumn inoculum, the threshold is the severe Mills risk
during the period of high ascospore ejections (Brun et al., this volume). The Vf fungicide scab
strategy consists in the protection of moderate and severe Mills risks during the period of high
ascospore ejections. The standard one consists in the protection of any risk of contamination
during the primary period of ascospore ejections (Table 1). At the end of the primary
contamination period, fungicide applications are stopped unless more than 1% shoots are
scabbed (except in OG Melrose, OG Smoothee® and LI Melrose where the threshold is 2% of
scabbed leaves).
Table 1: Disease management strategies against scab.
Supervised
Low-input
Organic
Sanitation
Optional leaf
Ploughing in
Ploughing in
Smoothee®
practice
shredding*
/removal
/removal
Fungicide
strategy
Standard
Standard
Standard
Sanitation
Optional leaf
Ploughing in
Ploughing in
Melrose
practice
shredding*
/removal
/removal
Fungicide
Olivier
Olivier
strategy
Standard
proposals
proposals
Sanitation
Systematic leaf
Ploughing in
Ploughing in
Ariane
practice
shredding
/removal
/removal
Fungicide
strategy
Vf strategy
Vf strategy
Vf strategy
85
* only when the autumn scab inoculum is at a moderate or high level
For powdery mildew management (Table 2), the removal of infected shoots is realised at
pruning in winter. Between green tip and bloom, the removal of primary infected buds is
realised at performing centrifugal tree training (artificial extinction procedure). The fungicide
strategy is based on Audemard et al. (1993) proposals (SV system) or on simplified Audemard
et al. proposals (LI and OG systems). After blooming, leaf assessments of powdery mildew (5
unrolled leaves at the top of 100 shoots) are carried out every 14 days and/or when the
previous fungicide application is no more effective against the disease. When the treatment
threshold is reached, one fungicide treatment is applied, followed by a second one when it is
no more effective (Table 2). The protection against powdery mildew stops at the end of the
growth period of shoots (generally at the end of June).
Before harvest, fungicide applications against storage disease are applied in the SV
system and in LI Smoothee® only.
Table 2: Disease management strategies against powdery mildew
Supervised
Low-input
Organic
Sanitation practices
Winter
Removal of infected shoots at pruning
Between green tip and
No bud removal
bloom
(Audemard et al., 1993)
Fungicide strategy
Systematic fungicide
Before bloom
application
< 2% infected leaves:
no fungicide application
After bloom From 2 to 5%: sulphur
application
≥ 5% infected leaves:
synthetic fungicides
Removal of primary infected
buds
(simplified Audemard et al.
proposals)
No fungicide application
< 5% infected leaves:
no fungicide application
≥ 5% infected leaves:
synthetic
sulphur
fungicides
application
Results and discussion
From 2005 to 2008, a good efficacy of the fungicide strategy against powdery mildew was
observed for all of the plots. From 2007 to 2008, there was no development of post-harvest
diseases at storage. From 2005 to 2008, no scab protection was necessary after the primary
period of ascospore ejections (generally at end-May) except for OG Smoothee® which
required sulphur applications during summer 2007 and 2008. At harvest 2006 and 2007, there
were no scabbed fruits except 0.3% in the OG Smoothee® plot in 2007. But, in 2008, 8%, 4%
and 1% of scabbed fruits were observed in OG Smoothee®, OG Melrose and LI Melrose,
respectively. The year 2008 was an exceptional rainy year with 33 Mills risks (among which 8
severe ones) observed from green tip stage to harvest.
The annual mean number of fungicide applications (2006-2008 period) ranged from 5
(LI Melrose) to 18 (OG Smoothee®) (Figure 1).
For the French context, the annual mean cost of disease protection (including input,
labour, and machinery) ranged from 380 €/ha (SV Ariane) to 1200 €/ha (OG Smoothee®).
These results show that the combination of validated management strategies against
apple diseases make it possible to strongly reduce the number of fungicide applications while
keeping diseases under control and protection costs at an acceptable level.
86
2006-2008 period
20
Mean number of fungicides
18
Post-harvest diseases
Powdery mildew
16
Scab
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
OG Ariane
OG Melrose
OG Smoothee
LI Ariane
LI Melrose
LI Smoothee
SV Ariane
SV Melrose
SV Smoothee
0
Figure 1. Annual mean number of fungicide applications per target disease according to
decision rules.
References
Audemard, H., Gendrier, J.P., Grosclaude, C. & Marboutie, G. 1993: Lutte raisonnée contre
l’oïdium du pommier. Compte rendu de la réunion du bureau et de l’équipe technique du
programme Protection Intégrée du verger de l’an 2000, Avignon, France, 10 février 1993.
Ed. INRA, 2 p.
Brun, L., Didelot, F., Combe, F., Orain, G., Payen, C., Lemarquand, A. & Parisi, L. 2009: Is it
possible to predict the aerial concentrations of Venturia inaequalis ascospores in apple
orchards? In: IOBC, VII International Conference on Integrated Fruit Production,
Avignon, France, 28-30 October 2008: this volume.
Giraud, M., Baudry, O., Orts, R., Gendrier, J.P. & Darthout, L. 2006: Protection intégrée
pommier – Poirier, 2e édition. Ctifl, Paris, France: 144-145.
Gomez, C., Brun, L., Chauffour, D. & De Le Vallée, D. 2007: Effect of leaf litter management
on scab development in an organic apple orchard. Agriculture, Ecosystem & Environment
118: 249-255.
Olivier, J. M. 1986: La tavelure du pommier, conduite d'une protection raisonnée.
Adalia 1: 3-19.
Simon, S., Lauri, P.E., Brun, L., Defrance, H. & Sauphanor B. 2006: Does manipulation of
fruit-tree architecture affect the development of pests and pathogens ? A case study in an
organic apple orchard. The Journal of Horticultural Science & Biotechnology 81: 765773.
Simon, S., Sauphanor, B., Buléon, S., Guinaudeau, J. & Brun, L. 2009: Building up,
management and evaluation of orchard systems: a four-year experience in apple
production. In: IOBC, VII International Conference on Integrated Fruit Production,
Avignon, France, 28-30 October 2008: this volume.
87
Brown Rot Disease Development and Management Perspectives in
Organic Apple Orchards
Imre J. Holb
University of Debrecen, Centre for Agricultural Sciences and Engineering P.O. Box 36, H4015 Debrecen, Hungary and Plant Protection Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, P.
O. Box 102, H-1525 Budapest, Hungary
* holb@agr.unideb.hu
Abstract. Brown rot of apple, caused by Monilinia fructigena, is a serious disease in organic orchards
especially if preceded by severe fruit injuries caused by codling moth. Therefore, the aims of this
three-year study were first, to monitor and analyze summer disease development of brown rot in time;
second, to investigate environmentally friendly disease control approach against brown rot; and third,
to develop an overall brown rot management strategy for organic apple production. Brown rot
monitoring showed that epidemics started 3 to 4 weeks earlier on the ground than in the tree, then
continuously increased up to harvest. Analyses of disease progress curves showed that the threeparameter logistic function gave the best fit to brown rot over four non-linear growth functions. Data
analyses demonstrated an overall description of fruit rot development by relative rate of disease
increase (β), area under disease progress curve (AUDPC), and final disease incidence (Yf). Yf in the
tree was highly correlated with incidence on dropped fruit on the orchard floor, showing strong
evidence of vertical inoculum movement from the orchard floor to the tree. Based on this result,
efficacy of fruit drop removal on fruit rot incidence was studied in integration with Bacillus
thuringiensis treatments against codling moth and/or reduced use of sulphur fungicide compounds.
Treatments with an integrated control approach resulted in a significantly lower fruit rot incidence on
all cultivars compared with general brown rot management schedules. The above epidemiological and
control results were incorporated into a novel brown rot management strategy for organic apple
orchards.
Keywords : organic production, brown rot, apple, epidemiology, management strategy
88
Repco results on the control of scab in organic apple cultivation
Bart Heijne, Peter Frans de Jong
Wageningen UR/Applied Plant Research (PPO), P.O. Box 200, 6670 AE Zetten, The Netherland
Abstract: Apple scab, caused by Venturia inaequalis, is mainly controlled by sulphur and
copper containing products in organic cultivation of apple. It is EU policy to phase out the use
of copper products. Therefore, the aim of the EU project Repco was to find alternatives for
copper in organic cultivation of apple. Three years of field experiments were done on the scab
susceptible cultivar Jonagold. We report on the efficacy of potassium bicarbonate and yuccaextracts in comparison with sulphur and copper. Applications were made according to the
RimPro warning system and the weather forecast during the ascospore season. Then all plots
were treated weekly with sulphur till harvest. The efficacy of the treatment schedule of 6 to
7.5 kg potassium bicarbonate plus 4 kg sulphur as a tank mix was as effective as 0.2 kg
copper in two years and even as effective as 0.5 kg copper in a third year of experiments.
Similarly, the treatment schedule of 7.5 l yucca extract plus 4 kg sulphur as a tank mix was as
effective as the copper schedules. It is concluded that both potassium bicarbonate and yucca
extract both in combination with sulphur can replace copper treatments to control apple scab
in organic cultivation.
Apple scab, Copper, Organic culture, Potassium bicarbonate, Venturia inaequalis, Yucca extract
89
Effect of Cladosporium cladosporioides H39 on conidia production of
Venturia inaequalis under orchard conditions
Jürgen Köhl and Wilma Molhoek
Plant Research International, Droevendaalsesteeg 1, NL-6708 PB Wageningen, The
Netherlands
Abstract: New methods for control of apple scab during summer epidemics are needed for organic
farming, since the use of copper fungicides will be restricted in the future. The fungal antagonist
Cladosporium cladosporioides H39, pilot-formulated as a water dispersible granule, was applied in an
apple orchard during summer 2008. Applications of C. cladosporioides H39 significantly reduced
conidia production by the apple scab pathogen Venturia inaequalis by up to 67 %. Applications of
sulphur were less effective with a maximum reduction of V. inaequalis conidiation by 27 %.
Key words: apple scab, biological control, Cladosporium cladosporioides, Venturia inaequalis,
sporulation
Introduction
Multiple fungicide applications for control of apple scab (Venturia inaequalis) are common in
world-wide apple production (MacHardy, 1996). Fungicides based on copper or sulphur are
currently used in organic farming (Holb et al., 2003). The use of copper will be restricted in
the European Union in the near future (European Commission, 1991). Biological control may
be an alternative to the use of fungicides.
Research on biological control of apple scab until now has mainly focussed on reduction
of the primary inoculum in overwintering leaves (Andrews et al., 1983; Carisse et al., 2000).
New methods are needed to reduce the spread of the disease during the summer season when
the disease is progressing in multiple cycles of infection and sporulation, especially in organic
farming. Such summer epidemics are driven by conidia of V. inaequalis produced in colonies
of V. inaequalis developing biotrophically on infected leaves (MacHardy et al., 2001).
The fungal antagonist Cladosporium cladosporioides H39, isolated from a V. inaequalis
colony on an apple leaf, has been selected for its potential to suppress conidiation of V.
inaequalis on apple seedlings (Köhl et al., 2009). Applications of conidia of the antagonist C.
cladosporioides H39, pilot-formulated as water dispersible granules (WG), reduced conidia
production of V. inaequalis under orchard conditions in experiments carried out in 2006 and
2007 conditions. The objective of the experiment carried out in 2008 was to confirm these
results in another season and to obtain first insights into the best timing of antagonist
applications after predicted infection periods for V. inaequalis.
Material and methods
Production of conidia of H39
For applications in the orchard, conidia of C. cladosporioides H39 were produced in a Solid State Fermentation (SSF) system by PROPHYTA Biologischer Pflanzenschutz GmbH,
Germany. The harvested conidia were formulated as a water dispersible granule (WG). For
the preservation of product quality, the final product was stored at 4 °C. Viability of dried
90
conidia was determined on malt extract agar (1 g malt extract l-1) before the beginning of the
field experiment. Conidia incubated for 24 hours at 20 °C with germ tubes longer than half of
the minimum diameter of a conidium were considered to be viable.
Orchard assay
The experiment was carried out in the organically managed orchard at Applied Plant
Research, Randwijk, The Netherlands on 8 year-old trees cv Jonagold. The aim of the
experiment was to control the summer epidemic of apple scab by antagonist applications.
Therefore, it was essential to allow an initiation of an epidemic in the orchard during the
primary season. Weather conditions during the primary season of 2008 favoured scab
development and many scab symptoms were found in the orchard by the beginning of June. A
severe hail event seriously damaged the orchard on June 22. On June 24 and 26, Topsin-M
(a.i. 500 g thiophanate methyl l-1, Certis Europe B.V., Maarsen, The Netherlands) was applied
at of rate of 140 ml per 100 litre water (applied at 1000 l ha-1) on the entire orchard and the
neighbouring orchards to prevent wound infections by European fruit tree canker (Nectria
galligena). No further fungicide treatments were carried out to reduce the progress of the scab
epidemic before or during the experiment. During the following weeks, trees produced
abundant new shoots with new leaves. Such newly formed leaves, not damaged by hail nor
reached by the fungicide sprays, were used in the experiment.
The experiment was arranged in a design with 6 blocks, with 2 blocks in the same tree
row. Each block consisted of 3 plots, each with 4 trees. Between plots, 2 untreated trees
served as a buffer. The following 3 different treatments were randomly allocated to the plots:
(1) untreated as control; (2) conidial suspension of pilot-formulated H39 (2 x 106 viable
conidia ml-1; 2 l per plot). The spray additive Trifolio S-forte (Trifolio-M GmbH, Lahnau,
Germany) was added to the suspension at a rate of 2 ml l-1 to improve the spray layer on the
leaf surface. Biweekly applications of H39 were carried out on July 22, July 24, July 28, July
31, August 05, August 07, August 11, and August 18. (3) The third treatment consisted of
weekly application of sulphur (Thiovit-Jet, Syngenta Crop Protection B.V., Roosendaal, The
Netherlands; a.i. 80 % sulphur) at a rate of 0.4% (400 gram per 100 litre water at 1000 l ha-1).
Sulphur treatments were applied on July 22, July 28, August 5, and August 11.
The number of scabbed leaves and the number of scab spots per leaf were assessed for
the leaves of 10 shoots of each of the 4 trees per plot before the experiment started on June 11.
In total 227 to 239 leaves were examined per plot. On September 19, scab symptoms were
assessed on 177 to 232 leaves per plot which had been produced after the beginning of the
experiment. Disease severity (% leaf surface covered with scab symptoms) was estimated
using following classes: 1: No scab; 2: 1 – 10 % coverage; 3: 11 – 50 % coverage; and 4: 51 –
100 % coverage. A severity index was calculated using the formula:
DS = (0 x N1 + 1 x N2 + 2 x N3 + 3 x N4) / Ntotal * 100
In which N1, N2, N3, and N4 is the number of leaves grouped in the classes 1, 2, 3, and 4,
respectively, and Ntotal is the total number of leaves assessed per plot.
Conidia production of V. inaequalis was assessed on susceptible young leaves developed
during the course of the experiment on 3 sampling dates. Sampling dates were chosen so that
sets of susceptible leaves present during a predicted infection period were sampled
approximately 5 weeks after the infection period. The Mills table, based on leaf wetness
duration and temperature, was used to predict infection periods. The second youngest just
unfolded leaf was labelled 1 to 3 days after a predicted infection period on a set of 3 twigs
belonging to the same tree in each plot. The period between predicted infection and first
91
application of C. cladosporioides H39 as well as the number of sprays and period of
protection by sprays differed with sampling date (Figure 1). After 35 days, the 2 leaves just
unfolded at the date of labelling and the next 2 younger leaves, unfolded after labelling but
expanded during the course of the experiment, were sampled, resulting in a sample consisting
of 12 leaves per plot. Sampling dates were August 22 (of leaves labelled on July 18), August
26 (of leaves labelled on July 22), and September 04 (of leaves labelled on August 1). The 12
leaves per sample were pooled and put into 250-ml glass bottles. Within 2 h, 100 - 150 ml
(depending on leaf mass) of tap water with 0.01 % Tween 80 was added and bottles were
shaken with a flask shaker at 700 OCS min-1 for 10 min. From the obtained suspensions, subsamples of 6 ml were stored at -18 °C. The concentration of conidia of V. inaequalis was
determined for each suspension with the aid of a haemocytometer. The leaf surface of all
leaves per sample was measured with an area meter.
Infection periods
Sulphur application
Application of H39
p
4Se
-A
u
g
g
28
-A
u
g
21
g
-A
u
14
7Au
-J
ul
31
24
-J
ul
17
S
-J
ul
L
Sampling 1
-J
ul
S
L
Sampling 2
10
S
L
Sampling 3
Figure 1. Predicted infection periods, dates of spray applications of Cladosporium
cladosporioides H39 and sulphur, and sampling dates (L: Labelling of new leaves; S:
Sampling).
Results and discussion
Before the experiment started, scab incidence on leaves did not differ for plots belonging to
the different treatments. The mean incidence was 81.7 % in plots used as control, 84.6 % for
plots later treated with H39, and 84.3 % for plots later treated with sulphur. Also the number
of leaf spots per leaf did not differ statistically, so that it can be assumed that scab
development was similar in the different plots before the experiment started.
On leaves sampled on August 22, August 26 and September 04 from untreated trees
35,242 (11,447 to 74,870), 30,242 (18,926 to 59,497) and 32,533 (19,698 to 46,350) conidia
of V. inaequalis cm-2 leaf surface were produced on average (backtransformed means, range
for 6 replicates in brackets) (Figure 2). On leaves of trees treated with C. cladosporioides
H39, the number of spores was statistically significantly lower with 11,499 conidia of V.
inaequalis cm-2 leaf surface (67 % reduction based on backtransformed values) on the first
sampling date and 15,139 conidia cm-2 leaf surface (50 % reduction) on the second sampling
date. For the last sampling date, no significant effect was observed for applications of C.
92
cladosporioides H39 with 21,163 conidia cm-2 leaf surface (35 % reduction) on treated
leaves. Applications of sulphur resulted in a reduction of the number of conidia of V.
inaequalis produced per cm-2 leaf surface by 2, 16, and 26 % for the different sampling dates
(Figure 2). Scab severity, assessed on September 19, one month after the last treatment with
H39, was 2.2 for the control treatment, but statistically significantly lower with 1.8 for H39treated plots (Figure 3). In sulphur treated plots, scab severity was 2.0 which did not differ
significantly from the other treatments.
40000
a
control
Number of conidia cm
leaf surface
-2
a
H39
a
30000
a
sulphur
a
a
a
20000
b
b
10000
0
Aug 22
Aug 26
Sept 04
Sampling date
Figure 2. Effect of treatments with conidia of Cladosporium cladosporioides H39 or sulphur
on conidia production of Venturia inaequalis. Bars of the same sampling date with a common
letter do not differ significantly (LSD-test; α = 0.05).
Scab severity (0-3)
3
a
2
b
ab
1
0
Control
H39
Sulphur
Figure 3. Effect of treatments with conidia of Cladosporium cladosporioides H39 or sulphur
on scab severity. Bars with a common letter do not differ significantly (LSD-test; α = 0.05).
During the orchard experiment environmental conditions resulted in a high number of
infection periods and scab development was favoured. Also, the exceptional development of
new shoots after the hail event supported the summer epidemic. Under such a severe disease
pressure treatments with sulphur often are not sufficient to achieve disease control as was
found in our experiment. Treatments with the antagonist H39 reduced conidia production of V.
inaequalis under such severe conditions, confirming results from orchard experiments carried
93
out in 2006 and 2007. The strongest effect was found for the first sampling date, when
treatments with H39 started after the predicted infection, but were continued until 4 days
before sampling. For the third sampling date, multiple treatments with H39 had been carried
out before the predicted infection period but the last treatment had been applied 17 days
before sampling. In this situation, conidia production of V. inaequalis was reduced by 35 %.
Since the effect of the antagonist may also depend on environmental factors which differed
before the different sampling dates, more data are needed from repeated orchard experiments
before conclusions on optimum timing of antagonist applications can be drawn.
For the first time scab severity has been assessed after treatments with the antagonist
H39. The reduced scab severity at the high scab level observed in the orchard demonstrated
that C. cladosporioides H39 has a high potential to control scab epidemics.
Acknowledgements
This work is funded by the European Commission (Project No 501452; REPCO) and the
Dutch Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and Food quality. We thank B. Heijne and R. H. N.
Anbergen, Applied Plant Research, and M. Trapman, Bio Fruit Advies, for fruitful
discussions and U. Eiben, Prophyta Biologischer Pflanzenschutz GmbH, for encouraging
collaboration.
References
Andrews, J.H., Berbee, F.M. & Nordheim, E.V. 1983: Microbial antagonism to the imperfect
stage of the apple scab pathogen, Venturia inaequalis. Phytopathology 73: 228-234.
Carisse, O., Philion, V., Rolland, D. & Bernier, J. 2000: Effect of fall application of fungal
antagonists on spring ascospore production of the apple scab pathogen, Venturia
inaequalis. Phytopathology 90: 31-37.
European Commission 1991: Council regulation (EEC) No 2092/91 of 24 June 1991 on
organic production of agricultural products and indications referring thereto on
agricultural products and foodstuffs. Official Journal of the European Union L 198,
22.7.1991: 1-89.
Holb, I.J., de Jong, P.F. & Heijne, B. 2003: Efficacy and phytotoxicity of lime sulphur in
organic apple production. Annals of applied Biology 142: 225-233.
Köhl, J., Molhoek, W.M.L., Groenenboom-de Haas, B.H. & Goossen-van de Geijn, H.M.
2009: Selection and orchard testing of antagonists suppressing conidia production of the
apple scab pathogen Venturia inaequalis. European Journal of Plant Pathology (in press).
MacHardy, W.E. 1996: Apple Scab: Biology, Epidemiology, and Management.
MacHardy, W.E., Gadoury, D.M. & Gessler, C. 2001: Parasitic and biological fitness of
Venturia inaequalis: Relationship to disease management strategies. Plant Disease 85:
1036-1051.
94
Biological control strategy of codling moth with entomopathogenic
nematodes in organic and conventional farming
Delphine Juan, Jean-Baptiste Rouvière, Sandrine Mouton and Philippe Coulomb1
1 Enigma, Hameau de Saint Véran, F-84190 Beaumes de Venise, France
Abstract: The emergence of resistant codling moth strains to the Cydia pomonella Granulosis Virus is
a threat to control this pest in organic farming. The research of new biocontrol agents is a high stake to
propose alternative solutions to farmers.
On one hand, the efficacy of two entomopathogenic nematode species (Steinernema feltiae and
Steinernema carpocapsae) was evaluated using different exposure methods, against various life stages
of the codling moth. In order to simulate the exposure of larvae in apple, young apples were soaked in
solutions of various concentrations of each nematodes species at several dates after the sting oo f 1st
instar larvae. This study was completed in 2008 with a test under natural conditions. 5th instar larvae
in cocoons were exposed within cardboard strips on which nematode solutions were sprayed under
laboratory conditions to check the importance of temperature on the control of codling moth with
entomopathogenic nematodes. This test under laboratory conditions was completed with a spray
application on the ground in an orchard, where 5th instar larvae in cardboard strips had been buried. S.
feltiae has caused a higher mortality on larvae in apples under laboratory and natural conditions. On
fifth instar larvae and at temperature <20°C, the mortality rate was higher with S. feltiae ( 55% ) than
with S. carpocapsae (40%). The application on orchard soil confirmed this.
On the other hand, the toxicity of several plant protection products used in orchard has been evaluated
using the method developed by the IOBC working group on “Pesticides and Beneficials”. Three
insecticides including Carpovirusine® and two fungicides have been evaluated. The carpovirusine
exhibited the lowest toxicity level among the tested products. The main life history parameter of
nematodes affected by the tested products was fecundity. However, nematode mortality and infectivity
were not reduced significantly.
These trials allow consideration of integration of entomopathogenic nematodes in a codling moth
control strategy, with foliar and ground application. The selected nematodes species would be S.
feltiae. As a “cruiser” it has significantly controlled the target stages of the codling moth under natural
conditions. This organism can be used in parallel with other plant protection products of orchard
farming taking care of the contact duration and of the exposure level.
Key-words: entomopathogenic nematodes, Steinernema feltiae, Steinernema carpocapsae, codling
moth, Cydia pomonella, side effects, plant protection products.
Introduction
The codling moth Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera : Tortricidae) is able to develop
resistance against chemical and organic plant protection products. Entomopathogenic
nematodes have shown an interesting efficacy under natural conditions against codling moth
diapausing larvae (Lacey et Unruh, 1998 ; Unruh et Lacey, 2001 ; Lacey et al., 2006).
Nematodes efficacy against others codling moth stages has been studied as well as their
susceptibility to plant protection products which are commonly used in apple growing.
Materials and Methods
Organisms used
The nematodes used for these tests were formulated as packages of 50 million infective
95
juveniles. Two species were used in each test: Steinernema carpocapsae (Weiser) and
Steinernema feltiae (Filipjev).
Codling moths were supplied by the zoology experimental unit of the INRA Magneraud
(France, 17) as eggs and as diapausing larvae reared on an artificial diet.
Entomopathogenic nematodes against codling moth larval stage in apple under laboratory
conditions
Using the method of Charmillot (1994) two neonate larvae were set up at T0 on apples (3-5
cm in diameter from the variety Gala harvested in Saturargues (France,34)). Several dates
after the set up (T0 + 1, 3, 6, 10, and 14 d) 40 apples were soaked in a nematodes solution at a
corresponding rate of 100 million nematodes /ha (Charmillot et al., 1994). Apples were kept
under controlled conditions (25±2°C, 75±15% HR). Codling moth larvae stage and mortality
was assessed 48 hours later. The observation of the damage on the apples was done following
the method of Baggiolini and Grob (ECB method N°18, AFPP, 1987).
Entomopathogenic nematodes against codling moth larval stage in apple under natural
conditions
In an apple orchard (Gala variety, 1988, France, 34), seven treatments were performed: a
water treated control and three rates of each nematodes species (5, 15.81 and 50 nematodes
/cm2). The orchard was artificially infested with codling moth black head stages distributed
homogeneously in the orchard. Each replicate corresponded to an elementary plot of twelve
apple trees (72 m2). Apples of the 6 central trees were infested. Three replicate plots have
been set up per treatment group.
A counting to assess the damages and the level of infestation was performed three days after
the set up of the eggs. The damage observed was at the level 1a-2a (following the scale of
Bagglioni and Grob), caused by codling moth first and second larval stages. The application
was performed at a volume of 500L/ha. Mortality was assessed 7 days later. Temperature
conditions during the exposure period (07/06/2008 to 17/06/2008) were between 9.8°C and
29.2°C.
Entomopathogenic nematodes against codling moth diapausing larval stage under
laboratory conditions
Using the method developed by Lacey and Unruh (1998), diapausing larvae of codling moth
were exposed through corrugated cardboard strips where they had spun their cocoons, at a rate
of 10 entomopathogenic nematodes/sq.cm and at the following temperature conditions: 15,
20, 25, and 30 °C. 4 replicates of 10 larvae were established for each treatment group.
Entomopathogenic nematodes against codling moth diapausing larval stage under natural
conditions
In an apple orchard (Gala variety, 1988, France, 34), seven treatments were performed: a
water treated control and three rates of each nematodes species (5, 15.81 and 50 nematodes
/cm2). The orchard was artificially infested with codling moth diapausing larvae in corrugated
cardboard strips in the soil (2 cm depth). Ten larvae were placed in each strip of corrugated
cardboard. Each replicate corresponded to an elementary plot of 12 apples trees (72 m2).
Codling moth larvae were placed at the bottom of the 6 centered trees. Three elementary it is
unclear what you mean by ‘elementary plots’. Please revise. plots have been set up per
treatment group.
The strips were collected two days later and brought back to the laboratory to be observed
seven days after the application.
96
Side effects of plants protection products on entomopathogenic nematodes
Side effects of selected PPP used in apple growing were studied using the IOBC method of
Peters (2003).
Table 1: List of the PPP tested
Commercial name
Use
Carpovirusine ®
Insecticide
Suprême ®
Insecticide
Syllit ®
Fungicide
Teppeki
Insecticide
Topaze
Fungicide
Active substance
CpGv
Acetemipride
Dodine
Flonicamide
Penconazole
Recommended rate
1 L/ha
250 g/ha
169 g/ha
140 g/ha
250 g/ha
Results and discussion
Entomopathogenic nematodes against codling moth larval stage in apple under laboratory
conditions
Correspondence between the soaking date, the level of damage and the codling moth stage in
the apples is shown in Table 2. Mortality results are presented in Table 3.
Table 2: Larval instars of the codling moth at the nematode infestation time (t = 0 sting of the
neonate larvae)
Soaking
date
t +1
t+3
t+6
t + 10
t + 13
Codling moth
stage
L1
L2
L2 – L3
L3 – L4
L4 – L5
Location in the apple and damage observed
Some mm under the skin / 1a
Some cm under the skin / 2a
Pips nearly reached / 3a
Tunnel to the pips / 3a, 4 a
Pips eaten, larvae in the center of the apple / 4 a
Table 3: Mortality of codling moth larvae in the apples soaked after several time after the
infestation of the larvae
Soaking date
Control*
S. carpocapsae*
S. feltiae*
T+1
5.40 b
13.70 b
42.08 a
T+3
10.80 b
33.81 a
49.01 a
T+6
5.00 b
29.64 a
36.73 a
T+10
16.07 b
46.48 ab
75.00 a
* Numbers followed by the same letter within a column are not significantly different at the
significance threshold of 5% following the results of the Newman and Keuls multiple mean
comparison test performed after the analysis of variance.
S. feltiae efficacy is greater on L1 and L3-L4 codling moth stages. As a “cruiser”, this species
is more effective on less motile hosts (Kaya and Gaugler, 1993) compared with S.
carpocapsae which is an ambusher and which does not move to meet its host. The difference
between host-searching behaviors of these nematodes species can explain this phenomenon.
97
Entomopathogenic nematodes against codling moth larval stage in apple under natural
conditions
100
90
80
Mortality (%)
70
60
47,78 a
49,81 a
S.carpocapsae
S.feltiae
control
50
40
32,41 b
30
31,87 b
28,65 b
20,81 b
20
4,51 c
10
0
5/sq.cm
15,8/sq.cm
50/sq.cm
eau
Figure 1: Mortality of larvae collected in apple after the exposure under natural conditions
(numbers followed by the same letter are not significantly different at the threshold of 5%)
The rate of nematodes used has a significant effect on the mortality of codling moth larvae in
apple.
Table 4: Results of the probit analysis (lethal doses and confidence interval at the threshold of
5%, resistance ratio) of tests under natural conditions on larvae in apples
Nematodes
species
LR10
Nematodes
/sq.cm
0.16
LR50
LR90
nematodes/sq.cm
RR50
nematodes/sq.cm
(CI 95%)
2.11
S.
143.70
123416.65
carpocapsae
(45.82-8752499)
S. feltiae
2.55
68.10
1821.99
(29.19-40.45)
LR =lethal rate, 95% of confidence interval
CI = confidence interval
RR = resistance ratio, 95% of confidence interval.
RR90
67.74
No good dose response effect could be determined for S. carpocapsae from the probit
analysis. S. carpocapsae is less effective than S. feltiae on codling moth larvae in fruits. To
obtain 90% larval mortality a 68-fold rate of S. carpocapsae has to be used compared with S.
feltiae. This confirmed what was already observed under laboratory conditions.
Side effects of plants protection products on entomopathogenic nematodes
Table 6: Impact of the tested products on Steinernema carpocapsae
98
Level of
exposure
Mcorr
(%)
Carpovirusine® 5.15
Suprême®
12.92
Tank
Syllit®
12.35
Teppeki®
7.52
Topaze®
10.23
Carpovirusine® N.A
Suprême®
N.A
Susbtract Syllit®
N.A
Teppeki®
N.A
Topaze®
N.A
N.A = not assessed
Tested products
Rinf (%) Rfec (%)
13.79
8.87
0.00
9.85
-2.96
5.91
-2.46
5.42
5.91
-9.33
42.83
91.65
86.85
92.42
93.33
90,69
93,18
92,90
94,34
73,89
Table 7 : Impact of the tested products on Steinernema feltiae
Level of
exposure
Tank
Substract
Mcorr
(%)
Carpovirusine® 6.71
Suprême®
5.42
Syllit®
21.37
Teppeki®
9.90
Topaze®
26.99
Carpovirusine® N.D
Suprême®
N.D
Syllit®
N.D
Teppeki®
N.D
Topaze®
N.D
Tested product
Rinf (%)
-5.29
-2.62
3.14
39.27
6.28
-1.05
12.18
7.33
14.66
6.28
Rfec
(%)
-107.14
94.95
76.46
86.44
83.24
91.87
80.78
90.14
91.13
77.82
N.D = not assessed
Mcorr%= corrected mortality,
Rinf% = reduction of infectivity from the control,
Rfec% = reduction of fecundity from the control,
The only life history parameter of entomopathogenic nematodes which has been affected was
the fecundity.
These studies revealed an interesting potential of entomopathogenic nematodes to control
codling moth larvae at several stages including stages located in fruits. Moreover, in short
term strategies, this method could be compatible with conventional and organic farming as
low impact on nematodes mortality or infectivity of PPP has been reported.
Acknowledgements
We thank E-Nema and Arne Peters for the supply of nematode strains to perform the test.
References
CEB, AFPP, 1987: Méthode d’essai d’efficacité pratique des préparations destinées à lutter
contre le carpocapse des pommes (Cydia pomonella L.). Méthode n°18, annexe 4 :
99
méthode d’interprétation des dégâts du carpocapse de Baggiolini et Grob (1968).
Charmillot, P.J, Pasquier, D., Alipaz, N.J., 1994: Le tébufénozide, un nouveau produit sélectif
de lutte contre le carpocapse Cydia pomonella L et la tordeuse de la pelure Adoxophyes
orana F.v.R. Revue Suisse Viticulture Arboriculture Horticulture 26 (2): 123-129.
Kaya, H.K. and Gaugler, R., 1993: Entomopathogenic nematodes. Annu.Rev.Entomol 38:
181-206.
Lacey, L.A. and Unruh, T.R., 1998: Entomopathogenic nematodes for control of codling
moth, Cydia pomonella (Lepidoptera : Totricidae) : effect of nematode species,
concentration, temperature and humidity. Biological Control 13: 190-197.
Lacey, L.A., Arthurs, S.P., Unruh, T.R., Headrick, H., Fritts, R., 2006: Entomopathogenic
nematodes for control of codling moth (Lepidoptera:Tortricidae) in apple and pear
orchards: Effect of nematode species and seasonal temperatures, adjuvants, application
equipment, and post-application irrigation. Biological Control 37: 214-223.
Lacey, L.A., Neven, L.G., Headrick, H.L., Fritts, R., 2005: Factors affecting
entomopathogenic nematodes (Steinernematidae) for control of overwintering codling
moth (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) in fruits bins. Journal of economic entomology 98(6):
1863-1869.
Peters, A., 2003: Pesticides and entomopathogenic nematodes – current status and future
work. IOBC/WPRS bulletin 26(5): 107-110.
100
Mass releases of Trichogramma minutum to control the
obliquebanded leafroller, Choristoneura rosaceana, (Lepidoptera:
Tortricidae) in apple orchards
Daniel Cormier, Gérald Chouinard, Francine Pelletier, Franz Vanoosthuyse
Institut de recherche et de développement en agroenvironnement, 335, chemin des Vingt-cinq
Est, Case postale 2,4 Saint-Bruno-de-Montarville (Québec) J3V 4P8, Canada
Abstract: Control of the obliquebanded leafroller (OBLR) represents a challenge for apple
growers because all stages of this multivoltine pest can be simultaneously present on apple
fruits and leaves during summer. In order to establish a new control strategy that targets the
pest eggs, we evaluated the impact of repeated mass releases of the egg parasitoid,
Trichogramma minutum, on OBLR populations and damage compared to conventional
(chemical) and control treatments. Approximately, 1 million egg parasitoids/ha/week were
released during 11 weeks in high-density plots of commercial apple orchards. More than 80%
of sentinel egg masses were parasitized in the release plot from the second week after the first
release. Sentinel egg masses in trees in which T. minutum were released were not more
frequently parasitized than those placed at mid-distance between two trees but the number of
parasitized eggs/egg masse differed significantly between those trees. The impact of
treatments was evaluated by sampling 100 annual shoots and 200 apples per treatment plot.
An average of 8.7 larvae per sampling unit was observed in the release plot and was not
significantly different from the chemical treatment (11 larvae) and the control (10 larvae)
plots. Damage made by OBLR larvae on apples was similar between treatments but damage
made by total tortricids was significantly lower in the release (1.8%) and the chemical control
(2.1%) plots than in the control (3.1%) plot. Results suggest that mass releases of
Trichogramma minutum should be used with a complementary control measure to
significantly reduce OBLR population and damage.
Mass release, Egg parasitoid, Trichograms, Biological control, Oblique banded leafroller
101
Assessing the role of Syrphidae in the suppression of woolly apple
aphid in Virginia, USA
J. Christopher Bergh
Virginia Tech, Alson H. Smith Jr. Agricultural Research and Extension Center, 595 Laurel
Grove Road, Winchester, Virginia, USA 22602
Abstract: The fate of individual woolly apple aphid colonies on the branches of potted apple trees
deployed in an experimental and a commercial orchard or held in a screened cage was recorded at 2day intervals over 14 days from late May to early June, 2008, in Virginia, USA. Colonies on trees in
the orchards either became extinct or were severely disrupted by predation by day 14. Two syrphid
species, Heringia calcarata and Eupeodes americanus were the predominant arthropod predators
recorded in colonies. Colonies on trees in the cage showed no decline, despite the presence of large
numbers of the parasitoid, Aphelinus mali.
Key words: Eriosoma lanigerum, predation, hover flies
Introduction
Although the woolly apple aphid, Eriosoma lanigerum (Hausmann) is common and
widespread in apple orchards in eastern North America, its populations reach economically
important levels only infrequently and unpredictably. In most seasons, a guild of arthropod
natural enemies consisting mainly of the parasitoid, Aphelinus mali (Haldeman) and several
species of Syrphidae (Brown and Schmitt 1994) appear to provide levels of biological control
sufficient to prevent outbreaks. Occasionally however, outbreaks of the aphid occur,
sometimes on a regional scale, causing significant injury.
Short and Bergh (2005) showed that the eggs of the three most prominent hover fly
predators of woolly apple aphid, Heringia calcarata (Loew), Eupeodes americanus
(Weidemann) and Syrphus rectus Osten Sacken, can be readily differentiated, based on the
surface sculpturing on the exochorion of the egg. Using this method to separate species, Short
and Bergh (2004) found that eggs of H. calcarata were recovered only from colonies of
woolly apple aphid and that eggs of E. americanus and S. rectus were recovered from
colonies of woolly apple aphid, spirea aphid and rosy apple aphid occurring in the same apple
orchards in Virginia, USA. Larval H. calcarata fed preferentially and survived best on woolly
apple aphid, compared with spirea aphid or rosy apple aphid (Short and Bergh 2004). In
combination, these data led Short and Bergh (2004) to conclude that H. calcarata is a
specialized predator of woolly apple aphid in the apple ecosystem. Bergh and Short (2008)
sampled eggs from woolly apple aphid colonies on the branches of potted apple trees
deployed in an experimental apple orchard for 48-h intervals weekly from early April through
late September from 2003-2005. Eggs of E. americanus were always present earliest, showing
a pronounced peak in April or May, a decline in numbers from June through August and a
minor secondary peak in September. Eggs of H. calcarata appeared somewhat later, typically
in May and were present throughout the season. Eggs of S. rectus were least abundant and did
not show a consistent pattern of abundance among the three seasons.
Our working hypothesis is that regulation of woolly apple aphid populations, which
typically peak in June in the mid-Atlantic states (Brown and Schmitt 1994), occurs through
102
the effects of natural enemies relatively early in the season and that disruption of these effects
can lead to damaging outbreaks later. As one of several first steps toward understanding the
temporal dynamics of the relationship between the pest and its enemies and the relative role
of each biological control agent, we examined the fate of individual woolly apple aphid
colonies on potted apple trees deployed in apple orchards.
Material and methods
‘Gala’ apple trees on M.26 rootstock were grown in 19 liter plastic pots and infested with
woolly apple aphids from colonies on other potted trees. When relatively small, discrete
colonies had formed on the branches of the trees, they were transported to a research orchard
at the Virginia Tech station and to a commercial orchard nearby. On 25 May, 2008, 5 trees
were placed in holes in the ground beneath the canopy of randomly selected, mature trees in
each orchard so that the soil was flush with the rim of the pot containing the tree. Five trees
were also placed in a 1.8 x 1.8 x 3.6 m screened field cage at the research station. Five
colonies on each tree were flagged and numbered. Beginning on 27 May and at 2-d intervals
through 8 June, the status of each colony was rated by visual observation, according to the
following scale: 5) colony in pristine, undisturbed state, 4) colony showed some signs of
disturbance but was mostly intact, 3) colony showed about 50% of original integrity, 2)
colony showed about 25% of original integrity, 1) colony nearly completely eliminated but
contained a few live aphids, 0) colony was extinct. At each 2-d interval, the number of
syrphid eggs near each colony was counted, using a 16x lens. As well, hover fly larvae and
other predators in each colony were counted and the presence or absence of adult A. mali was
noted. After 14 days (on 8 June), a short section (about 3 cm) of branch containing each
colony was pruned and placed individually in small, clear plastic cups. In the laboratory, the
number of hatched and unhatched eggs of each syrphid species in each colony was counted
and recorded under a microscope. Each colony was then returned to the covered, clear plastic
cup and held in a controlled environment chamber at 25ºC and a 14:10 light:dark regime. At
intervals over about 3 weeks, adult A. mali that had emerged from each colony were counted
and removed from each cup.
Results and discussion
Female syrphids oviposited in 44% of colonies on trees in each orchard during the first 48
hours of exposure. By day 14 (8 June), 96% and 100% of colonies on trees in the commercial
and research station orchards, respectively, contained ≥1 hatched and/or unhatched egg, while
no hover fly eggs were recovered from colonies on trees in the screened field cage. During the
study, hover fly larvae were observed in 52% of colonies in each orchard. The only other
predators recorded were lacewings; their eggs and larvae were recorded from 24% and 8% of
colonies in the research station orchard.
Examination of excised colonies on day 14 revealed that eggs of H. calcarata comprised
60.8% and 79.6% of eggs on trees in the research station and commercial orchards
respectively. Eggs of E. americanus comprised 39.2% and 13.9% of those in the research
station and commercial orchards, respectively, while eggs of S. rectus represented 6.5% of
those from the commercial orchard. No unhatched eggs were found in colonies on trees in the
research station orchard while a few unhatched eggs of H. calcarata were found in the
commercial orchard. The mean total number of hatched and unhatched eggs per colony
recorded on day 14 ranged from 1.4 to 2.6 and from 2.0 to 5.4 on trees in the research station
and commercial orchard, respectively. H. calcarata eggs were the only eggs recorded from
38% and 50% of colonies at the research station and commercial orchards, respectively. Only
103
E. americanus eggs were found in 24% of colonies at the research station. S. rectus eggs were
never found by themselves. Both H. calcarata and E. americanus eggs were found in
individual colonies on trees at the research station (33%) and commercial orchard (32%).
Both H. calcarata and S. rectus eggs were found in 5% of colonies at the commercial orchard
and eggs of all three species were found in 5% and 14% of colonies at the research station and
commercial orchard, respectively.
Recovery of adult A. mali from the excised colonies revealed significantly higher
numbers of parasitoids per tree from colonies on caged trees (358.6 ± 24.2 SE) than from
colonies on trees in the research station (2.6 ± 1.7 SE) or commercial (36.6 ± 13.1 SE)
orchards.
Colony decline was not observed on trees held in the screened field cage and the average
colony status rating remained at 5 (undisturbed, pristine state) for the duration of the study. In
fact, many colonies showed an increase in size, although this was not quantified. An unknown
predator, likely birds or an insectivorous mammal caused a very rapid decimation of many
colonies on trees in the research station orchard on day 4 of the study and consequently it was
not possible to adequately interpret the effects of arthropod natural enemies on colony
collapse in that orchard. In the commercial orchard, the decline of colonies was first noted on
day 8 (2 June), and the average colony rating on each tree showed a continuous reduction
through 8 June, at which time the average rating was 2.2, 0.2, 0.2, 1.6 and 0.6 for trees 1
through 5, respectively.
These data reveal that, under the conditions of this study, hover fly larvae appeared to be
responsible for the collapse of woolly apple aphid colonies. While H. calcarata was most
numerous, it is likely that both it and E. americanus played an important role in colony
decline. H. calcarata larvae are smaller than those of E. americanus and while the voracity of
E. americanus larvae feeding on woolly apple aphid has not yet been determined, it is likely
that they consume more aphids than does H. calcarata. The common observation of multiple
eggs per species in a given colony and multiple species per colony concurs with our previous
findings (Bergh and Short 2008) and raises questions about the interactions among the
predatory syrphid species. Intraguild predation by larvae of one species on another or
intraspecific cannibalism of younger larvae by older ones may influence the dynamics of
woolly apple aphid biocontrol, particularly considering the generalist versus specialist habits
of the different guild members. Very importantly, our confirmation that A. mali was present in
colonies on trees in both orchards suggests strongly that aphid predation by hover flies is
influencing the population dynamics of A. mali by predation on parasitized aphids, by
reducing the number of aphid hosts, or both. The large numbers of A. mali recovered from
colonies on trees in the field cage, in combination with our findings that the parasitoid did not
influence colony status during the study, shows that the role of A. mali in early season
population suppression of woolly apple aphid needs to be reassessed.
While these data reveal the role of syrphid larvae on the suppression of established, albeit
relatively small, woolly apple aphid colonies introduced into apple orchards, they do not
provide needed information on the role of natural enemies in aphid suppression during the
earlier stages of colony establishment and growth. Hover fly females are known to select host
aphid colonies based on a number of criteria, one of which is colony size. Preferential
response to and selection of colonies, based on their size, may differ for the specialist and
generalist species, but remains undocumented. Furthermore, although A. mali may not be as
discriminating as some of the predators, its activity is more adversely affected by cool
temperatures than its host. As well, Bergh and Short (2008) showed that the syrphid predators
are active earlier in the season than when A. mali is considered to be an important natural
enemy. We intend to implement studies similar to that reported here, involving deployment of
potted apple trees known to support root colonies of woolly apple aphid. By deploying trees
104
early in the season, before the aphids have established arboreal colonies, and by following the
establishment, growth and fate of those colonies through time, we expect to significantly
improve our understanding of the relative roles of the members of this natural enemy guild
and the influence of disturbing them at critical periods in the growing season.
References
Bergh, J.C. & B.D. Short. 2008: Ecological and life-history notes on syrphid predators of
woolly apple aphid in Virginia, with emphasis on Heringia calcarata. BioControl 53:
773-786.
Brown, M.W. & Schmitt, J.J. 1994: Population dynamics of woolly apple aphid (Homoptera:
Aphididae) in West Virginia apple orchards. Environ. Entomol. 23: 1182-1188.
Short, B.D. & Bergh, J.C. 2004: Feeding and egg distribution studies of Heringia calcarata
(Loew) (Diptera: Syrphidae), a specialized predator of the woolly apple aphid
(Homoptera: Eriosomatidae) in Virginia apple orchards. J. Econ. Entomol. 97: 813-819.
Short, B.D. & Bergh, J.C. 2005: Separation of three common hover fly predators of woolly
apple aphid based on the exochorionic sculpturing of eggs. Can. Entomol. 137: 67-70.
105
Habitat and prey preferences of the two predatory bugs Anthocoris
nemorum (L) and A. nemoralis (Fabricius) (Anthocoridae: HemipteraHeteroptera)
Lene Sigsgaard
University of Copenhagen, Faculty of Life Sciences, Department of Agriculture and Ecology,
Thorvaldsensvej 40, 1871 Frederiksberg C, Denmark
Abstract: The annual occurrence and distribution of the predatory bugs Anthocoris nemorum
and A. nemoralis between apple, pear and herbal vegetation was assessed. In the laboratory
anthocorid prey preference was assessed in two-choice experiments with key pests of apple
and pear including pear psyllid, apple psyllid, green apple aphid, rosy apple aphid and red
spider mites. Anthocorids were the dominant early season predatory bugs, co-occurring with
spiders. Anthocoris nemorum dominated in apple, while A. nemoralis dominated in pear. A.
nemorum was also common in herbal vegetation, especially in midsummer. Anthocorid
numbers were correlated with numbers of collembola, psyllids and aphids in apple, and with
numbers of psyllids in pear. A. nemoralis preferred pear psyllid to green apple aphid, while A.
nemorum preferred green apple aphid. Both species preferred psyllids to spider mites. In the
two years studied, A. nemorum had two generations proving that it can be bivoltine under
Danish climate conditions. In the mid summer the higher density of annual vegetation,
simultaneous with lower density in trees, suggests that herbal vegetation may maintain A.
nemorum in orchards at times of low prey numbers in the trees. Habitat and prey preferences
of the two anthocorid species identify A. nemorum as a biological control agent of special
importance in apple, whereas A. nemoralis is of importance in pear.
Anthocoris nemorum, Anthocoris nemoralis, Voltinism, Orchard, Psyllids, Cacopsylla pyri, Cacopsylla
mali, Aphis pomi, Dysaphis plantaginea, Panonychus ulmi, Preference, Behaviour
106
Does windborne pollen mediate the effects of pesticides on predatory
mites?
Mario Baldessari¹, Gino Angeli¹, Vincenzo Girolami², Alberto Pozzebon², Paola Tirello²,
Carlo Duso²
AD: 1 FEM-IASMA Research Center, Plant Protection Department, Via E. Mach 1. I-38010 San Michele all’Adige (TN) Italy ; 2 Department of Environmental Agronomy and Crop
Science, University of Padova, 35020 Legnaro, Padova, Italy
Abstract: Generalist predatory mites belonging to the family Phytoseiidae can persist in
European apple orchards when prey is scarce by feeding on pollen and other alternative foods.
It has been reported that grass management can affect pollen availability on apple leaves with
implications for phytoseiid persistence. The use of pesticides is a major factor affecting
phytoseiid abundance in apple orchards. In this study we compared the effects of a number of
pesticides on populations of Kampimodromus aberrans in two apple orchards with a different
grass management, i.e. a high or a low grass mowing frequency. Reducing grass mowing
frequency resulted in higher predatory mite numbers probably because of a higher pollen
availability on apple leaves. A laboratory study was planned to demonstrate the role of pollen
availability in mediating interactions between pesticides and phytoseiids.
Phytoseiidae, Pollen, Pesticides, Kampimodromus aberrans, Grass management
107
A new view of the sooty blotch and flyspeck fungal complex on apples
Mark Gleason, Jean Batzer
Department of Plant Pathology, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa 50011, U.S.A.
Abstract: Fungi in the sooty blotch and flyspeck (SBFS) complex blemish the epicuticular
wax layer of apple fruit. Recent studies combining molecular techniques with morphological
characterization revealed that the SBFS complex is far more diverse than previously realized.
Surveys of orchards in 14 eastern U.S. states in 2000 and 2005 uncovered 62 SBFS species in
five taxonomic orders. Orchards with fungicide-spray programmes had lower diversity in
their SBFS assemblages than non-sprayed orchards. Some SBFS species occurred in almost
all orchards, whereas other species were regional in distribution or were found in only one or
two orchards. Collaborations with other laboratories have revealed patterns of SBFS diversity
in Germany, Serbia and Montenegro, Brazil, China, Florida, and Costa Rica, and have led to
the discovery of many new species. Using an RFLP method for HaeIII digests of rDNA, we
found distinctive banding patterns for 14 genera and species. With our library of RFLP
banding patterns and ITS and LSU sequences, we documented consistent phonological
patterns among SBFS species in timing of colony appearance on apples, and identified several
new reservoir host species. These tools have the potential to further clarify SBFS ecology,
etiology, and taxonomy. In adapting a SBFS warning system from the Southeast U.S. for use
in the Midwest, we found that cumulative hours of relative humidity greater than 97% was
more accurate than cumulative hours of leaf wetness in predicting the initial appearance of
SBFS colonies on apples.
IPM, Sooty blotch and flyspeck, Genetic diversity, Biogeography, Disease-warning systems
108
Fireblight research: Warming up to new ideas and solutions.
Vincent Philion
Laboratoire de production fruitière intégrée de l’IRDA, Mont-Saint-Bruno, Québec
Fire Blight (caused by Erwinia amylovora) remains a big concern in apple
production regions around the world. Every three years, researchers meet for an international
workshop dedicated to this disease. In 2007, the Portland (Oregon) meeting brought forward
recent findings in pathogen biology, genomics, host-pathogen interactions and disease
management. This talk will attempt to link the important findings reported at the meeting and
see how novel detection techniques, reduction in host susceptibility, and new disease control
methods can impact future disease management at the farm level.
Abstract:
Fire Blight, Disease management
109
The complex life history of a predator: sibling species, variability of
side-effects and enigmatic disappearances of the earwig
Bruno Gobin1, Rob Moerkens2, Herman Helsen3, Kurt Jordaens2, Herwig Leirs2, Gertie
Peusens1
1pcfruit, Zoology Department, Fruittuinweg 1, B-3800 Sint-Truiden ²University of Antwerp,
Evolutionary Ecology Group, Groenenborgerlaan 171, B-2020 Antwerpen ³Wageningen UR,
PPO, Sector Fruit, Postbus 200, NL-6670 AE Zetten
Abstract: The common earwig (Forficula auricularia), plays an important role in reducing
summer pest pressure. However, large inter-orchard and even inter-annual variation in earwig
densities jeopardizes biocontrol reliability. To boost populations of univoltine earwigs we
need a more detailed knowledge on presence, life history and interactions with orchard
management. Detailed population monitoring and experimentation revealed some critical
issues for biocontrol: (1) F. auricularia consists of two different phylogenetic species with
different reproductive strategies (timing of egg-laying and number of broods). Which type
inhabits an orchard determines population development and recovery potential after
catastrophic events. (2) Earwig populations show high variability in responses to specific
orchard management. Repetitive field trials aiming to determine side-effects of insecticide
treatments and mechanical weeding showed wide ranges of effects. This is due to exposure
level and rigidity of the earwigs rather than migration or mobility. To determine true sideeffects, long-term (up to 1 month) monitoring is essential. (3) Earwig populations crash at two
critical periods. Losses of nesting females during hibernation are very high, a factor most
important in limiting population development. A second loss of substantial amounts of
earwigs occurs at the moult from 4th instar nymphs to adults, a phenomenon that is perhaps
linked to intraspecific competition. Breaking down the complexity of earwig populations in
orchards into smaller components provides insights on how to increase populations and
biocontrol efficacy of earwigs.
Earwig, Forficula auricularia, Pests, Orchard, Populations
110
Side effects of pesticides on the European earwig Forficula auricularia
L. (Dermaptera:Forficulidae)
Gertie Peusens1, Herman Helsen2, Bruno Gobin1
1 pcfruit, Zoology Department, Fruittuinweg 1, B-3800 Sint-Truiden, 2 Wageningen UR,
PPO, Sector Fruit, Postbus 200, NL-6670 AE Zetten
The European earwig Forficula auricularia L. (Dermaptera: Forficulidae), a
generalist predator in organic and integrated orchards, can contribute to the biological control
of woolly apple aphid and pear sucker only when populations are numerous. As earwigs have
a single generation per year, a potential side effect of crop protection is likely to influence
population dynamics and size. Therefore we studied the effect of 31 plant protection products
sprayed at registered dose rates on larvae and adult earwigs using a standardised laboratory
test. Earwigs were exposed to fresh dried residue on bean leaves for 5 days and then
transferred to rearing units (with additional, untreated food and water) under controlled
conditions for another 30 days. Lethal and sub lethal effects were assessed during the entire
test period. As the earwigs were collected in Belgian and Dutch orchards populations of both
countries were tested separately and exchanged between institutes for independent test
validation. Results revealed that 20 compounds proved to be harmless and 5 slightly harmful.
The remaining products were moderately harmful till toxic of which some induced abnormal
behaviour. We selected 5 of these (abamectine, indoxacarb, spinosad, thiacloprid and
flufenoxuron) for dose response testing and demonstrate that registered dose rates of some
products hover between harmless and harmful.
Abstract:
Forficula auricularia, Insecticides, Beneficial
111
Impact of four insecticides on the European earwig, Forficula
auricularia L., in an apple orchard
Vogt, Heidrun1, Jürgen Just1 & Anderson Grutzmacher1,2
1
Julius Kühn-Institut (JKI), Fed. Res. Centre for Cultivated Plants, Institute for Plant Protection in Fruit Crops and Viticulture, Dossenheim, Germany ; heidrun.vogt@jki.bund.de
2
Faculty of Agronomy ‘‘Eliseu Maciel’’(FAEM), Federal University of Pelotas - UFPel,
Pelotas, RS - Brazil
Abstract. The European earwig Forficula auricularia (Dermaptera: Forficulidae) is an important
predator of psyllids and aphids, including the woolly apple aphid. Resurgence of the latter pest is often
connected to the use of pesticides which harm earwigs. A field test was carried out in 2008 with four
new-generation insecticides (thiacloprid, spinosad, indoxacarb and flonicamid) used in apple
production, to study their effects on earwig populations. Earwigs are nocturnal and hide in shelters
during the day. We installed bamboo tubes as artificial shelters at the end of May, for sampling
purposes. Once the shelters were clearly occupied by earwigs, and when earwigs were in the 4th instar,
the insecticides were applied (4 replicates of 7 trees per plot); control plots were left untreated. The
numbers of earwigs in the shelters of 5 trees per plot were assessed for up to 10 weeks postapplication, by knocking the earwigs out of the tubes, collecting them in a plastic bag and
photographing them for later counts from the digital images. Immediately afterwards, the earwigs
were released back to the appropriate tree. All of the insecticides caused significant reductions
(Henderson & Tilton method) in the earwig numbers as compared with control populations. Within
two weeks post-application reductions were most pronounced for indoxacarb with a maximum of
76%, followed by thiacloprid with 60 %, spinosad with 59 % and flonicamid with 48 %. Six weeks
post-application, the population effects were still about –50 % for indoxacarb and thiacloprid, and
were reduced to about –30% for flonicamid and spinosad.
Keywords: Forficula auricularia, insecticides, integrated plant protection, side effects
Introduction
During the last years an increase in abundance of woolly apple aphid (Erisoma lanigerum
Hausmann) (Hemiptera: Aphididae) populations has been observed in apple orchards in
Germany and neighbouring countries. The European earwig Forficula auricularia L.
(Dermaptera: Forficulidae) is known to be an important predator of E. lanigerum as well as of
other aphids and psyllids (e.g. Mueller et al., 1988; Nicholas et al., 2005; Lahusen et al., 2006,
Höhn et al. 2007, Helsen & Simonse, 2006). The question is, if outbreaks of woolly apple
aphids might be connected to a reduction of the earwig population due to unintended effects
of modern insecticides used against main orchard pests, especially against codling moth
(Cydia pomonella)(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae). We chose four modern insecticides for a field
test on side-effects on the earwig.
Material and Methods
Experimental orchard
We used an orchard from the field site of our institute in Dossenheim: variety ‘Golden
Delicious’ on M 9, planted in 1994 as spindle bush trees.
112
Experimental design
The trial was established as a randomized complete block with four replicates per treatment,
seven trees per replicate and the five inner trees used for sampling. The blocks were separated
by an untreated apple row. For the assessment of the earwigs, shelters were made from three
bamboo tubes glued together. The bamboo tubes had a length of 20 cm, and an inner diameter
of ~ 1,6 cm. The shelters were fixed to the tree trunk in vertical position using a wire and
with contact to at least one branch. The tubes were open at the lower end and closed by the
node at the upper end, thus being well protected against rain. One shelter was installed per
tree. The installation of the shelters took place three weeks before treatment. A pre-treatment
count was carried out 10 days before the treatment. After treatment counts took place 7, 14,
28, 42 and 72 days after treatment. With regard to methodical aspects, we also compared
shelters made from 1, 2 and 3 bamboo tubes.
To assess the earwigs, the shelters were carefully demounted and the earwigs knocked
out of the shelter into a plastic bag painted with a black grid. The plastic bag was carefully
spread in a box and photographed for later count of the earwigs from the digital image.
Immediately afterwards, the earwigs were released back to the appropriate tree and the
shelters re-installed. At each assessment date, 30 to 70 earwigs were collected for the
determination of the development stage in the laboratory.
Insecticides
Four new-generation insecticides were tested (Table 1). The insecticides were applied with a
spray gun connected to a commercial sprayer. The application rate was calibrated and
measured with a water meter (4.2 litre of spray solution were applied per replicate; the trees
were treated from both sides of the row). The application took place on 17.06.2008.
Table 1: Insecticides used in the test.
Brand Name
Active ingredient
Calypso
SpinTor
Steward
Teppeki
480 g/l thiacloprid
480 g/l spinosad
300 g/kg indoxacarb
500 g/kg flonicamid
g or ml/ha per
1 m canopy height
100
150
85
70
Statistical Analysis
Data were analysed with the Simulate Procedure, SAS 9.1 (proc mixed). Efficacy values were
calculated according to Henderson & Tilton (1955).
Results
The shelters were quickly accepted by the earwigs. Two weeks after the installation high
numbers were caught (162 on average per shelter) (Fig. 1). With regard to the developmental
stages, on 13th June 2008, four days before the application of the insecticides, 97 % of the
earwigs were L4, 3 % were adults. With the first check after the treatment onwards, only
adults were present.
All insecticides caused significant reductions in the earwig numbers compared to the
untreated control (Fig. 1). Within two weeks post-application reductions according to
Henderson & Tilton were most pronounced for indoxacarb with a maximum of 76 %,
followed by thiacloprid with 60 %, spinosad with 59 % and flonicamid with 48 %. Six weeks
post-application, the population effects were still about –50 % for indoxacarb and thiacloprid,
113
mena no. of earwigs per shelter (±std)
and were reduced to about –30% for flonicamid and spinosad (Table 2). Reductions caused by
indoxacarb were mostly significantly worse compared with the other insecticides.
220
Control
200
Spinosad
180
Thiacloprid
160
140
Flonicamid
120
Indoxacarb
100
80
60
40
20
0
Before
treatment
7 DAT
14 DAT
28 DAT
42 DAT
72 DAT
Fig. 1. Mean number of earwigs per shelter before and after the treatments.
mean no. of earwigs per shelter (± std)
Significant differences: Before treatment: P<0.05 for control compared to thiacloprid and
indoxacarb; 7 DAT: P<0.0001 for control compared to all treatments and Indoxacab compared to
flonicamid; 14 DAT: P<0.01 for control compared to all treatments and indoxacarb compared to
thiacloprid and flonicamid; 28 DAT: P<0.0001 for control compared to indoxacarb, indxocarb
compared to flonicamid and P<0.05 for indoxacarb compared to spinosad; 42 DAT: P<0.01 for control
compared to thiacloprid and indoxacarb, P<0.05 for indoxacarb compared to spinosad and flonicamid.
200
180
Bamboo-1
160
Bamboo-2
140
Bamboo-3
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
11.6.08
23.6.08
1.7.08
14.7.08
28.7.08
26.08.
Fig. 2. Mean number of earwigs in different shelter sizes, made from 1, 2 or 3 tubes.
Significant differences: 11.6.08: P<0.01 for b2 compared to b1 and b3; 14.7.: P=0.02 for b2
compared to b3; 26.08: P=0.02 for b2 compared to b3.
Shelter sizes
The different shelter sizes were comparable in trapping success (Fig. 2). There were no
consistent significant differences between the sizes.
Table
2. Reduction of earwig population according to Henderson & Tilton (%) and IOBC
classification (1=harmless (<25%), 2=slightly harmful (25-50%), 3=moderately harmful (51114
75%); 4=harmful (>75%) (Hassan 1994), (DAT=Days After Treatment).
Flonicamid
Spinosad
Thiacloprid
Indoxacarb
Henderson & Tilton (%)
DAT 7 DAT 14 DAT 28
DAT 42
48,3
58,7
60,5
70,6
27,9
24,3
49,4
51,8
46,8
53,3
51,3
76,3
25,6
31,7
41,8
58,4
IOBC Classification
DAT 7 DAT14 DAT28
2
3
3
3
2
3
3
4
2
2
2
3
Discussion
With the small plot design it was possible to detect significant toxicity effects caused by the
insecticides. The most severe effect was observed with indoxacarb, followed by thiacloprid
and spinosad. Flonicamid was the only insecticide where the reduction stayed below 50%.
The decrease in population reduction after 4 weeks and later in our field study is probably due
to movement of the earwigs between the plots, especially from untreated areas into treated
plots. If a study requires longterm observations (e.g. in the case of insect growth regulators)
bigger plot sizes are recommended. Toxicity to earwigs have also been reported by Lahusen et
al. (2006) and Höhn et al. (2007) for neonicotinoids and by Cisneros et al. (2001) for
spinosad. As the local earwig population produce only one generation per year, the observed
impact is serious. Concerning shelter size, all three sizes can be recommended for use.
Acknowledgments
We thank Dr. E. Moll, JKI Kleinmachnow, and Dr. D. Stephan, JKI Darmstadt, for their
support in the statistical evaluation with SAS.
References
Cisneros, J., Goulson, D., Derwent, L. C., Penagos, D. I., Hernandez, O. & Williams, T. 2002:
Toxic effects of spinosad on predatory insects. Biological Control 23: 156-163.
Hassan, S.A. 1994: Activities of the IOBC/WPRS Working Group “Pesticides and Beneficial
Organisms”. IOBC/wprs Bulletin 17(10): 1-5.
Helsen, H. & Simonse, J. 2006: Earwigs help the fruit grower. Fruitteelt (Den Haag) 96: 1415.
Henderson, C. F. & Tilton, E. W. 1955: Test with acaricides against the brown wheat mite.
Journal of Economic Entomology 48: 157-161.
Höhn, H., Lahusen, A., Eder, R., Ackermann, T., Franck, L., Höpli, H. & Samietz, J. 2007:
Control of the European pear psylla. Results and observations in Eastern Switzerland in
2002-2006. Revue Suisse de Viticulture, Arboriculture et Horticulture 39: 169-176.
Lahusen, A., Höhn, H. & Gasser, S. 2006: Der Birnblattsauger und ein in Vergessenheit
geratener Gegenspieler. Schweiz. Z. Obst- Weinbau 142: 10-13.
Mueller, T. F., Blommers. P. J. & Mols, P. J. M. 1988: Earwig (Forficula auricularia)
predation on the woolly apple aphid Eriosoma lanigerum. Entomol. exp. appl. 47, 145152.
Nicholas, A. H., Spooner-Hart, R. N. & Vickers, R. 2005: Abundance and natural control of
the woolly aphid Eriosoma lanigerum in an Australian apple orchard. BioControl 50 [2],
271-291
115
SAS, Statistical Analysis System, version 9.1
116
Control of the woolly apple aphid (Erisoma lanigerum Hausm.) by
releasing earwigs (Forficula auricularia L.) and support oil
applications
Ina Toups1, Jürgen Zimmer1, Martin Trautmann2, Nicole Fieger-Metag,3, Sascha
Buchleither4, Horst Bathon5
1
DLR Rheinpfalz, Kompetenzzentrum Gartenbau, Walporzheimer Str. 48, D-53474 Bad Neuenahr-Ahrweiler
Kompetenzzentrum Obstbau Bodensee, Schuhmacherhof 6, D-88213 Ravensburg
3
Öko-Obstbau Norddeutschland Versuchs- und Beratungsring e.V., Moorende 53, D-21635 Jork
4
Beratungsdienst Ökologischer Obstbau e.V., Schuhmacherhof 6, D-88213 Ravensburg
5
Julius-Kühn Institut Darmstadt, Institut für biologischen Pflanzenschutz, Heinrichstr. 243, D-64287 Darmstadt
2
Abstract: The woolly apple aphid (Erisoma lanigerum Hausm.) has been recognised as a serious pest
in organic fruit growing where it may cause severe economic damage due to a lack of control
strategies. Based on preliminary results a research project funded by the Federal Office for Agriculture
and Food, Germany runs from 2007 to 2009 in cooperation with different research facilities in
Germany to develop an on-farm strategy to control the woolly apple aphid in organic fruit growing.
Earwigs (Forficula auricularia L.), as natural predators of woolly apple aphids, climb the trees when
they turn into L3-Larvae in the end of May/beginning of June. By then the population of woolly apple
aphid may reach high infestation levels. To control the woolly apple aphid until the earwigs appear in
the trees oil applications were made in addition to the release of earwigs. We present preliminary
results of the first and second year of the project’s field trials. They showed good efficacies for
applying oil preparations by brush in the first year. The efficacy of releasing earwigs is inconsistent
and depended on the infestation intensity. In the second year the trials have been expanded by a
comparison of oil application by spaying and by brush in combination with releasing earwigs. On high
infestation levels the oil application by brush proved to be more effective.
Key words: woolly apple aphid, Erisoma lanigerum Hausm., earwig, Forficula auricularia L., oil
Introduction
Several experiments trying to regulate the woolly apple aphid (Erisoma lanigerum Hausm.)
with the parasite Aphelinus mali Hald. were performed in recent years but did not produce
satisfactory results for a practical fruit growing strategy (Hetebrügge et al. 2006). The
common earwig (Forficula auricularia L.) is endemic and widespread throughout Central
Europe. It is a nocturnal omnivore feeding on animals and plant materials. Earwigs are
therefore important natural antagonists of the woolly apple aphid, and they should be
encouraged as beneficial organisms in organic orchards. Field trails were set up to investigate
woolly apple aphid control by releasing earwigs. In addition, the application of oil was
evaluated as a supporting measure to retard woolly apple aphid population growth prior to the
release of earwigs. The earwigs overwinter in the ground and the females lay their eggs and
raise the brood in nests in the ground. Therefore we investigated if the mechanical soil
management typical for organic orchards affects the earwig population.
The project’s trials have been established in cooperation with several partners: At the
“DLR Rheinpfalz, Kompetenzzentrum Gartenbau” in Ahrweiler (West Germany), with the
“Ökoobstbau Norddeutschland Versuchs-und Beratungsring e.V.”(ÖON) in Jork (‘Altes
Land’, North Germany), and at the “Kompetenzzentrum Obstbau Bodensee” (KOB)
117
(Bodensee, South Germany). Additionally round-robin tests in practical growing situations
were started in 2007 under coordination of the “Beratungsdienst Ökologischer Obstbau”
(Bodensee, South Germany). The health status of the earwigs from all sites were examined in
the laboratory of the “Julius-Kühn-Institut” (JKI) in Darmstadt. Considering the complexity
of the project, we focus only on selected results of the field trial in this publication.
Material and methods
In three different orchards trials with five different variants (Tab. 1) were established in 2007.
In variants 2 and 3 different numbers of earwigs, which differed between the three sites
depending on their availability, were released in the orchards in June 2007 (Tab. 1). In
variants 4 and 5 additionally two different oil preparations, Promanal Neu and TS-forte,
respectively, were applied undiluted by brush in April 2007 (between BBCH 57 - 65) when
the colonies just started to produce wool (Tab. 1). A brush whose bristles were cut in half to
exploit also the mechanical effect was used to apply the oils. Rolls of corrugated board
(Ahrweiler, Altes Land) and coffee filters with wood wool (Bodensee) were hung into the
trees and were monitored after a few days to determine the earwig population before the
release of new earwigs in the orchards. The hideouts were left in the trees throughout the
whole season and were used to estimate the population monthly by counting the contained
individuals. The infestation with woolly apple aphid colonies was also determined monthly by
investigating the infestation in cm² per tree.
Table 1: Overview of variants and number of released earwigs at all sites in 2007
variant ID
1
2
3
4
5
number of released earwigs per tree
Ahrweiler
Altes Land
Bodensee
title
0
50
100
50
50
control
earwig 1
earwig 2
TS-forte + earwig 1
Promanal Neu + earwig 1
0
20
40
0
0
0
50
100
50
50
In 2008 the trials were expanded by a comparison between the oil application by brush
and application by spraying (variants shown in Table 2). Pipes made of bamboo were used as
hideouts in the field trial sites at Ahrweiler and Altes Land. The assessments of woolly apple
aphid infestation, the monitoring of the hideouts to investigate the earwig population and the
oil application by brush were the same as in 2007. The spraying was done in March before the
colonies began producing wool. To examine the influence of mechanical soil management the
orchard where the trials were set up in 2007 were used. One row was covered with plastic foil
(Maypex) while the other row was treated conventionally with mechanical soil management.
Table 2: Overview of variants and number of released earwigs at all sites 2008
variant ID
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
title
control
earwig 1
earwig 2
spraying + earwig 1
brushing + earwig 1
brushing
spraying
118
Number of released earwigs per tree
0
50
100
50
50
0
0
Results and Discussion
Although the infestation in the plots of variants 2 and 3 started at a lower level than the
control plot an influence of the earwigs as a single measure against the woolly apple aphid
colonies was significant in the orchard at Lake Constance in 2007. As Fig. 1 shows the
increase of the infestation level in the control continued until mid July while the increase in
the plots of variant 2 and 3 was stopped after releasing the earwigs in mid June. The efficacies
(Henderson & Tilton calculation) were 42 % for 50 earwigs in variant 2 and 52 % for 100
earwigs in variant 3. The combined treatments of oil and earwigs increased the efficacies to
83% for TS-forte plus earwigs and to 95 % for Promanal Neu plus earwigs.
woolly apple aphid infestation [cm²]
100
site: Bodensee
year of trial 2007
earwigs released on 21. and 29.06.2007
control
90
+ 50 earwigs
80
+ 100 earwigs
infestation [cm²]
70
60
TS-forte + 50
earwigs
50
Promanal + 100
earwigs
40
30
20
10
0
08.05.07 18.05.07 28.05.07 07.06.07 17.06.07 27.06.07 07.07.07 17.07.07 27.07.07 06.08.07 16.08.07 26.08.07
Fig. 1: Woolly apple aphid infestation in the different variants at Bodensee in 2007
In 2008 the woolly apple aphid colonies, especially in the orchard in Ahrweiler, increased
to a massive infestation until the end of June. Here a decreasing effect to the woolly apple
aphid colonies by earwigs did not manifest in the orchard (Fig. 2). A single adult earwig may
devour up to 120 aphids per night (Lohrer 2008). We observed a slight correlation between
the number of earwigs and the infestation level of the trees so we assume that the earwigs
migrated to trees with high infestation levels. Despite the high eating potential and the
presence of earwigs in highly infested trees the amount of released earwigs seemed not to be
sufficient to control the massive infestation in Ahrweiler. In addition, we observed a high
number of other beneficial organisms, such as ladybeetles, Aphelinus mali and the larvae of
lacewings and hoverflies which all feed on woolly apple aphid. Oil application by brush
showed better efficacies compared to spraying. Brushing allows a more targeted application
and exploits additional mechanical effects. Efficacies were 24% for spraying and 70% for the
application by brush independent of releasing earwigs.
119
woolly apple infestation [cm²]
site: Ahrweiler, West Germany
year of trail: 2008
control
50 earwigs
earwigs released on 24.06.2008
200
100 earwigs
180
spraying + 50 earwigs
infestation [cm²]
160
140
spraying
120
brushing + 50 earwigs
100
application
80
60
40
20
0
22. Apr
12. Mai
01. Jun
21. Jun
11. Jul
31. Jul
20. Aug
09. Sep
29. Sep
Fig. 2: Woolly apple aphid infestation in the different variants at Ahrweiler in 2008
To determine the influence of the mechanical soil management typical for organic orchards
we sampled the earwig population in two rows of Jonagold one of which was covered with a
plastic foil (Maypex). The results after one testing season do not show significant difference
between the number of earwigs in the trees of the covered and uncovered rows. Earwigs can
make their soil nests up to 20 cm below the surface or between the roots of grass and herbs in
the alleyways so that the mechanical soil management may not affect them.
Conclusion
Earwigs climb the trees in the beginning of June (Gobin et al. 2006) so that there is the same
lack of woolly apple aphid control in spring as is known for Aphelinus mali Hald..
Furthermore the trials showed that earwigs as a single measure against the woolly apple aphid
are not sufficient to keep the woolly apple aphid at reasonable levels. Therefore an additional
oil application seems to be indispensable. We found higher efficacies for the oil application by
brush than by spraying for high infestation levels. The mechanical soil management in
organic orchards seems to have no negative influence on the earwig population (one year
results). The project will be continued in 2009 to confirm the trial results.
References
Gobin, B., Marien, A., Davis, S., Leirs, H. (2006): Enhancing Earwig Population in Belgian
Orchards, Comm. Appl. Biol. Sci, Ghent University, 71/2b.
Hetebrügge, K., Fieger-Metag, N., Kienzle, J., Zebitz, C.P.W., Zimmer, J. (2006): biol.
Bekämpfung der Blutlaus durch Freilassung von Blutlauszehrwespen (Aphelinus mali L.)
aus Massenzucht; Ecofruit - 12th International Conference on Cultivation Technique and
Phytopathological Problems in Organic Fruit-Growing: Proceedings to the Conference
from 31st January to 2nd February 2006 at Weinsberg/Germany; pp. 36-42.
Lohrer, T. (2008): Ohrwurm; Infoblätter;
http://www.infoblaetter.fagw.info/kurzinfo.php?id=22
(19.01.2009).
120
Population modelling of the European earwig as a decision tool for
orchard management
Rob Moerkens1, Bruno Gobin2, Gertie Peusens2, Laurent Crespin1, Herman Helsen3,
Herwig Leirs1
1
University of Antwerp, Evolutionary Biology Group, Groenenborgerlaan 171, BE-2020
Antwerp, Belgium 2 Zoology Department, pcfruit TWO, Fruittuinweg 1, Belgium
Abstract: Earwigs, Forficula auricularia (L.) (Dermaptera: Forficulidae) are beneficial predators in
apple and pear orchards where they are capable of maintaining several pest species below economic
thresholds. Earwigs thus play an important role in integrated fruit orchards and are essential in organic
top fruit cultures. Numbers of earwigs show large interannual variations in densities in both organic
and IPM orchards, this limits their practical use. All practical attempts for re-establishing earwig
populations have failed. These problems indicated that a theoretical approach was necessary. In order
to develop strategies for increasing earwig populations we have built a population model. This enables
the prediction of earwig phenology throughout the season while a sensitivity analysis allows us to
identify key factors and critical periods in the earwigs’ life cycle. The European earwig is a complex of
two sibling species. The timing of oviposition, before and after winter respectively, is a big difference
in life history characteristics between these species. A day-degree model was constructed and validated
with existing field data from several European and non- European populations. Results show
remarkable differences between regions regarding both oviposition strategies. Oviposition timing can
cause either large variation in earwig phenology or not. First sensitivity analyses reveal that the
numbers of nests during winter have a very big impact on the population in relation to spring or
summer survival. However more knowledge about the interactions between species and limiting and
regulating processes is required for developing specific and effective orchard management strategies.
Such work is currently underway.
Population dynamics, Day-degree model
121
Codling moth insecticide resistance management in North Carolina
apples
James Walgenbach1, Leonardo Magalhaes2, Vonny Barlow1, Michael Roe2
1
Department of Entomology, Mountain Horticultural Crops Research and Extension Center,
NC State University, Mills River, NC. 28759 2 Department of Entomology, NC State
University, Raleigh, NC. 27695
Abstract: In recent years the codling moth has become the major pest of apples in North Carolina.
The emergence of this pest coincided with the widespread adoption of insect growth regulators and
neonicotinoids as primary control tools. A resistance monitoring program was conducted in 2006 and
2007 that used a novel 16-well plasticware containing lyophilized codling moth diet that was
rehydrated with insecticide solutions to assay neonates. Resistance was detected to the IGR’s
methoxyfenozide and novaluron, and the neonicotinoid acetamiprid. In 2008, codling moth resistance
management programs were initiated that relied on the use of mating disruption and targeted
applications of two new insecticides, spinetoram and rynaxypyr. Codling moth damage in commercial
orchards declined to its lowest levels in recent years, and overall insecticide use was also reduced.
Cydia pomonella, Insecticides, Mating disruption
122
A new isolate overcoming Cydia pomonella resistance to Granulovirus:
improvement of its efficiency by selection pressure on resistant hosts.
Marie Berling1, Christine Blachere-Lopez1 Olivier Soubabère2, Jean-Baptiste Rey3,
Sophie-Joy Ondet3, Yannis Tallot2, Miguel Lopez Ferber1, Benoît Sauphanor4, Antoine
Bonhomme2
1
EMA, centre LGEI, 6 avenue de Clavières 30100 ALES, France
2
NPP (Arysta LifeScience), 35 avenue Léon Blum 64 000 Pau, France
3.
GRAB. Agroparc, 84914 Avignon Cedex 9. France
4
INRA, unité PSH, Agroparc, 84914 AVIGNON Cedex 9, France
Abstract: Since 2004, some codling moth (Cydia pomonella) populations resistant to the
Mexican isolate of Cydia pomonella granulovirus (CpGV-M) were detected in different
organic orchards in Western Europe. A resistant laboratory colony of codling moth (RGV)
was built by introgression of the resistance character in a susceptible laboratory colony (Sv).
The resistance of the RGV colony to the CpGV-M came over 60,000-fold when compared to
the susceptible laboratory colony (to Sv). To overcome this resistance, the efficiency of CpGV
isolates from various origins was investigated. Two of them (I12 and NPP-R1) presented an
increased activity on RGV larvae. NPP-R1 reduces the resistance factors of RGV to 7-fold
and 46-fold at the LC50 and LC90. Genetic characterization showed that NPP-R1 is a mixture
of at least two prevalent genotypes, one of them being similar to CpGV-M. The 2016-r8
isolate obtained from eight cycles of selection of NPP-R1 on RGV larvae had a sharply
reduced proportion in the CpGV-M genotype and an increased efficiency on RGV.
Carpovirusine samples were formulated with these isolates for field experiment. Results from
Germany, Italy and France gave promising results, showing that the 2016-r8 isolate is a good
candidate to control CpGV-M resistant codling moth populations.
Key words: Cydia pomonella, granulovirus, CpGV, resistance, selection, genetic diversity
Introduction
The baculovirus family is divided in two genus, the nucleopolyhedrovirus (NPV) and the
granulovirus (GV). In contrast with large genetic and molecular knowledge on
nucleopolyhedrovirus (NPV), up to recently limited information was available on the genetic
variability of granulovirus isolates. The prototype of the genus, the Cydia pomonella
granulovirus (CpGV) has been extensively studied, and three main genotypes were identified,
namely, the Mexican type (CpGV-M), from the original isolate, the English type (CpGV-E)
and the Russian type (CpGV-R) (Crook et al., 1985). Baculoviruses are widely used for the
control of insect pests. The use of a single purified genotype that can be characterized in deep
versus the use of a natural virus isolate has been object of debate. In the case of CpGV, as no
variability was detected in the natural isolate originated from Mexico (Tanada, 1964) , this
question has not been addressed. All the virus preparations used in Europe contain this isolate.
In 2004, codling moth populations resistant to the virus preparations were detected in
Germany and in France. Since then, a more careful analysis of other virus isolates confirmed
that they are often composed by more than one genotype (Rezapanah et al., 2008) and they
123
possess different biological properties, as some are able to replicate in the CpGV-M resistant
hosts. Here we present the analysis of a virus isolate, NPP-R1, able to replicate in such
resistant host, its genetic heterogeneity and the importance of these genotypes for the final
efficacy of the virus in the field.
Material and Methods
The CpGV-M strain, usual active ingredient in the commercial formulations was
systematically included as a control for the activity. The natural virus isolate NPP-R1 strain is
able to partially overcome the resistance in the laboratory colonies. The NPP-R1 isolate was
also subjected to selection through successive passages on RGV insects as described
previously (Berling et al., 2009). The eighth passage (NPP-R1.8) was used for the 2008 field
trials.
All virus isolates were amplified on resistant insects from the original inoculums, to
constitute a stock for the test production. Mass production was made on susceptible insects in
the same conditions as the industrial production of Carpovirusine®. The different virus
isolates were formulated by Natural Plant Protection in the same way as the Carpovirusine®,
at a final concentration of 1x1013 OBs/L, and used at 1 L/Ha.
These formulated virus preparations were called Carpovirusine 2000 for the standard
formulation using CpGV-M, Carpovirusine R1 for the NPP-R1 formulation, and
Carpovirusine R1.8 for the NPP-R1.8 formulation. Each of these formulations was tested for
its ability to control both Sv and RGV larvae in standard bioassays.
Results and Discussion
The RGV colony originates from larvae collected in an orchard where CpGV-M was not able
to control codling moth. It was selected to genetic homogeneity for the resistance character
and for its homogeneous genetic background. CpGV-M LC50 for the susceptible laboratory
colony (Sv), that has the same genetic background as RGV is 24 OB/µl. In contrast, for RGV,
it is 1.38x106 OB/µl. That is, a factor of 60 000. The NPP-R1 isolate performed as well as
CpGV-M on Sv larvae (LC50 = 25.8), but was able to replicate on RGV (LC50 =166) (Table 1).
Although the pathogenic effect is relatively high it does not reach the same level on both
hosts.
Table 1. Pathogenicity (measured as LC50 and LC90) on susceptible (Sv) and resistant (RGV)
laboratory colonies for the virus isolates CpGV-M and NPP-R1.
Min
CL50 (GV/µl) Max
Min
CL90 (GV/µl) Max
14,1
35,9
177
512
CpGV-M/Sv
24
275
3,17×10
4,91×10
/
/
CpGV-M/RGV 5
1,38.106
/
6
NPP-R1/Sv
14.5
25.8
39.9
NPP-R1/RGV
91,2
166
278
197
329
5,95×10
1,28×104
3
703
3,80×10
4
Restriction enzyme length polymorphism analysis revealed that NPP-R1 is composed of at
least two genotypes, one similar to CpGV-M and the second, characteristic of NPP-R1, called
CpGV-R1 type. CpGV-M alone was not able to produce a pathogenic effect on RGV. As there
was a difference in the LC50 for NPP-R1 in Sv and RGV, cycles of replication in both hosts
124
have been set up to analyse the possible modification of the relative proportions of each
genotype in the two alternative hosts. Four successive cycles of replication of NPP-R1 in
RGV larvae conducted to the reduction to undetectable levels of the CpGV-M like genotype,
and to an increase of the efficacy of the virus isolate. In contrast, no modification was
observed when NPP-R1 was amplified on Sv larvae neither in the proportion of the genotypes
nor in their biological activities. Both the LC50 and the LC90 on RGV were reduced when such
cycles of replication were carried out (Figure 1). Up to the 4th passage (NPP-R1.4), this
change might be related to the reduction of the CpGV-M component, but both LC50 and LC90
decreased after the following passages. Selection of a better adapted genotype is obviously
taking place, even if no modification has been detected using RFLP analysis (data not shown).
The different in the shape of both curves can be noticed, LC90 changes faster than LC50 in the
first passages, suggesting again the effect of the CpGV-M like genotype in the global efficacy.
Evolution of the LC50 through successive passages on
resistant larvae RGV
Evolution de la CL90 en fonction du nombre
de passages sur RGV
300
12 0 0 0
250
SV
RGV
SV
RGV
10 0 0 0
200
8000
15 0
6000
10 0
4000
50
2000
0
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
0
18
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
Nb of passages
Nb of passages
Figure 1. Evolution of the LC50 and LC90 of NPP RI isolate on susceptible (Sv) and resistant
(RGV) larvae after successive passages on RGV larvae.
Probably the codling moth populations that host virus infections have variable susceptibility
to the virus if there is not a high external pressure, like repeated virus treatments. In such
conditions, the genetic diversity of the virus would be an advantage, as the CpGV-M
component clearly has higher activity on susceptible larvae, and the CpGV-R1 type performs
better on resistant larvae. However, if both genotypes act in a completely independent way, it
could be expected the disappearance of CpGV-M in only one passage through RGV larvae.
This does not happen. It can be concluded that both genotypes interact during their replication
in RGV. Their behaviour in Sv is more difficult to analyse as each genotype alone is able to
replicate in this host.
In contrast with NPVs, a single OB in GVs carries only one virion, and consequently,
only one genotype. Maintain of the genetic diversity implies that multiple infection is also the
rule on GVs, even in the LD50 in the laboratory has been estimated to be lower than five OB
(Sheppard and Stairs, 1977). In biological control conditions, most of the host population
must be killed for an acceptable reduction of damages, implying a systematic multiple
infection.
Large plot field trials with NPP R1 were conducted in 2007 in orchards where resistance
was previously confirmed (Berling et al., 2009b). Although good control of codling moth
population was not achieved, a significant reduction of the overwintering larvae was obtained.
2008 field trials were carried out using the virus isolate obtained after eight passages, called
NPP R1.8. Again, the number of larvae collected in the corrugated cardboard traps decreased
in the plots treated with Carpovirusine R1.8 compared to those treated with CpGV-M.
In locations with no resistance occurred, both CpGV-M and NPP R1.8 reduced the
125
overwintering populations (Table 2). In locations with resistance, the reduction is only
significant in parcels treated with Carpovirusine R1.8. In addition, the number of infected
larvae collected is lower in parcels treated with the latter, suggesting that the final issue of the
infection is the quick death of the larvae, while with CpGV-M, some infected larvae survive at
least to the last larval stage, and might produce adults. Would these adults carry a persistent
infection similar to that observed for NPV (Cory and Myers, 2003)? And what will be the
importance of this vertical transmission in the regulation of the populations? Specific studies
will be required to address these questions.
The results obtained by allowing a continuous adaptation of a genetically variable virus
isolate to a host clearly confirmed the potential of this method. As more insect generations per
year can be obtained in laboratory conditions than in the field (about 10 compared to 3), it can
be expected that any new host resistance could be used to select appropriate virus isolates as
far as a continuous survey of codling moth field populations could be implemented.
Table 2. Mean number of larvae collected in corrugated cardboard traps in the parcels treated
with CpGV-M or NPP-R1.8 formulated as Carpovirusine (Carpovirusine 2000 and
Carpovirusine R1)
Host
population
Susceptible
(Spinimbeco,
Italy)
Resistant
(St Aubin,
France)
Virus
formulation
Untreated
C2000
R1.8
Untreated
C2000
R1.8
Infected
Healthy
0.5
1.8
0.3
6.5
1.8
0
3.3
2.3
0.5
0.3
0
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the French Research Agency (ANR- 06-RIB-003-02) and by
NPP. Marie Berling received a fellowship from the Ecole des Mines d’Alès.
References
Berling, M., Blachère-Lopez, C., Soubabere, O., Léry, X., Bonhomme, A., Sauphanor, B., and
López-Ferber, M. 2009. Cydia pomonella granulovirus (CpGV) genotypes overcome
virus resistance in the codling moth and improve virus efficiency by selection against
resistant hosts. App. Env. Microbiol. 75 (4) : 925-930
Berling, M., Rey, J.-B., Ondet, S.-J., Tallot, Y., Soubabère, O., M., Bonhomme, A.,
Sauphanor, B., Lopez-Ferber, M. Field trials of CpGV virus isolates overcoming
resistance to CpGV-M. Virologica Sinica, in press
Cory, J.S. and Myers, J.H. (2003). The ecology and evolution of insect baculoviruses. Annual
Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics. 34: 239-272.
Crook, N. E., Spencer, R. A., Payne, C. C., and Leisy, D. J. 1985. Variation in Cydia
pomonella granulosis virus isolates and physical maps of the DNA from three variants.
J. Gen. Virol. 66:2423–2430.
Rezapanah, M., Shojai-Estabragh, S., Huber, J., and Jehle, J. 2008. Molecular and biological
characterization of new isolates of Cydia pomonella granulovirus from Iran. J. Pest.
126
Sci. 81:187-191.
Tanada, Y. 1964. A granulosis virus of the codling moth, Carpocapsa pomonella (Linnaeus)
(olethreutidae, Lepidoptera). J. Insect Pathol. 6:378-380.
Sheppard, R. F. & Stairs, G. R. (1977). Dosage-mortality and time-mortality studies of a
granulosis virus in a laboratory strain of the codling moth, Laspeyresia pomonella. J
Invert Pathol 29, 216-221.
127
Resistance Management: A Global Industry Response from the
Insecticide Resistance Action Committee
Andrea Bassi
Insecticide Resistance Action Committee (IRAC)
Abstract: IRAC was formed in 1984 to provide a co-coordinated crop protection industry response to
prevent or delay the development of resistance in insect and mite pests. The main aims of IRAC are
firstly to facilitate communication and education on insecticide resistance and secondly to promote the
development of resistance management strategies in crop protection and vector control so as to
maintain efficacy and support sustainable agriculture and improved public health. It is IRAC’s view
that such activities are the best way to preserve or regain the susceptibility to insecticides that is so
vital to effective pest management. In general, it is usually easier to proactively prevent resistance
occurring than it is to reactively regain susceptibility. IRAC is an inter-company organisation that
operates as a Specialist Technical Group under the umbrella of CropLife International. IRAC is also
recognised by The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) and the World Health Organization
(WHO) of the United Nations as an advisory body on matters pertaining to resistance to insecticides.
The group’s activities are coordinated by the IRAC Executive and Country or Regional Committees
with the information disseminated through conferences, meetings, workshops, publications,
educational materials and the IRAC website (www.irac-online.org). The Executive Committee
supports resistance management project teams and also provides a central coordination role to
regional, country and technical groups around the world. Insecticide resistance remains one of the
greatest challenges in modern agriculture and public health pest management, and it is crucial that it is
tackled effectively. Indeed, resistance is everyone’s problem and by working together, insecticide
resistance can be successfully managed. IRAC is playing a major role in this effort.
IRAC, Resistance management, IPM, IRM, Vectors, Public health
128
Molecular aspects of QoI and DMI fungicide resistance in NY
populations of the apple scab pathogen Venturia inaequalis
K.D. Cox, S.A. Villani, W. Köller
Cornell University, Department of plant pathology and plant-microbe biology, Geneva, NY,
14456
Abstract: Apple producers in the northeastern US are strongly reliant on sterol demethylation
inhibitor (DMIs) and Quinone outside inhibitor (QoIs) fungicides to manage yearly epidemics of apple
scab. DMI resistance in NY populations of Venturia inaequalis has been observed for several years,
but the mechanisms of resistance are not completely understood. Similar to what was described
previously, 32 NY V. inaequalis isolates representing a range of DMI sensitivities had anomalous
insertions containing promoters upstream of the CYP51A1 gene. Unlike previous reports, several
baseline sensitive isolates lacked inserts all together, while highly resistant isolates provided
indications of larger previously uncharacterized insertions. At the range of DMI sensitivities tested, a
clearer pattern for this mechanism of DMI resistance is beginning to emerge. In 2007, we detected five
isolates in a western NY orchard displaying the qualitative resistance phenotype to QoI fungicides. On
sequencing the target site region in the cytochrome b gene, we found that all five isolates had the
G143A target site mutation associated with QoI qualitative resistance in Europe. The mitochondrial
mutation appeared to be at a homoplastic state on QoI-amended media. However, after three
successive transfers on non-QoI-amended media over the course of four months, two of the five
isolates reverted to the wildtype genotype, raising questions as to mutation stability in the absence of
selective pressure.
Sterol demethylation inhibitor, Quinone outside inhibitor, Fungicide resistance, Apple scab, Venturia
inaequalis
129
Practical aspects of QoI and DMI fungicide resistance in Northeastern
US populations of the apple scab pathogen Venturia inaequalis
K.D. Cox, S.A. Villani, W. Köller
Department of plant pathology and plant-microbe biology, Cornell University, Geneva, NY,
14456 Address Correspondence to: Kerik Cox, kdc33@cornell.edu 1-315-787-2401
Abstract: Sterol demethylation inhibitor (DMIs) and quinone outside inhibitor (QoIs) fungicides are
essential for managing apple scab and other early season apple diseases in the northeastern United
States. Moreover, a second generation of DMI fungicide chemistries is on the verge of being released
for apple disease management in the US. Shifts toward DMI and QoI resistance have been observed in
Northeastern US populations of Venturia inaequalis over the past five seasons as use of these
fungicide chemistries continues. In 2007 & 2008, we surveyed a minimum of 25 commercial, 4
research, and 3 baseline apple orchards for sensitivity to myclobutanil (DMI), trifloxystrobin (QoI),
and dodine (guanidines). We found that all of the commercial orchards were strongly shifted above
baseline sensitivity to myclobutanil and trifloxystrobin. We also found that more than 75% of the
orchards had a myclobutanil sensitivity level reduced beyond the point in which we achieved apple
scab control in our research orchard with DMI-resistant V. inaequalis populations. Interestingly,
several orchards have dodine sensitivities approaching that of V. inaequalis populations from baseline
orchards. Field testing of DMI and QoI fungicides in DMI-resistant and QoI-shifted orchards suggests
that the new chemistries could overcome practical resistance in varieties less susceptible to apple scab,
but not in highly susceptible varieties that contribute to high levels of V. inaequalis inoculum.
However, it remains to be seen if dodine resistance will quickly re-emerge during a season of renewed
use.
Sterol demethylation inhibitor, Quinone outside inhibitor, Fungicide resistance, Apple scab, Venturia
inaequalis
130
Can Venturia inaequalis populations show a reduced sensitivity to a
multisite fungicide? The case study of Captan in French orchards.
Parisi Luciana1, Expert Pascale, Nock Isabelle, Louis-Etienne Tania, Bourdoiseau
Noëllie, Didelot Frédérique.
INRA (National Institute for Agricultural Research), UMR INRA/INH/Université Pathologie
Végétale, 42 rue G. Morel, 49071 Beaucouzé Cedex, France; 1 Present address: INRA, UERI,
Domaine de Gotheron, 26320 Saint-Marcel-lès-Valence, France.
Abstract: Since 2000, the control of apple scab, which is mainly based on chemicals in French
orchards, has faced several cases of control failure. One of the causes of this situation could be the
emergence of a reduced sensitivity of V. inaequalis to multisite fungicides. As multisite fungicides are
not known to induce resistance in fungal pathogens, such a possibility has not been investigated.
Between 2002 and 2006, different experiments showed an in vivo reduced efficiency (27.6 to 48 % on
incidence and severity of the disease) of Captan for the control of a V. inaequalis population from an
orchard in which this fungicide failed to control scab. This efficiency was lower than that for
Mancozeb (96.5 to 100 %) on the same population, and lower than the efficiency of Captan on other
populations less exposed to the fungicide. The variability in sensitivity to Captan of V. inaequalis
strains collected in 5 orchards differently exposed to Captan was assessed in vitro, and a significant
difference of ED50 values, which ranged between 5.2 and 51.9 mg/l, was displayed. These results show
consistent elements, but not clear evidence of a reduced sensitivity of V. inaequalis to multisite
fungicides. They support the need for applied and basic research on this question.
Key words: apple scab, chemical control, fungicide resistance.
Introduction
In 2008, after 2 years of favourable climatic conditions for the development of the disease,
scab remains the main problem in French apple orchards, despite protection strategies based
on intensive chemical control. Numerous fungicide treatments were applied following a
strategy of preventive and curative treatments to flank the main contamination periods. In
fact, since 2000, the control of apple scab has faced several cases of failure. The high
susceptibility of the most planted cultivars, weather conditions and the emergence of
resistance to strobilurin and anilinopyrimidine fungicides probably contributed to this
situation. However, another hypothesis, namely the emergence of a reduced sensitivity of
Venturia inaequalis to multisite fungicides, could explain some failure cases. As multisite
fungicides are not known to induce resistance in fungal pathogens, such possibility has not
been investigated. Here we present results obtained within the frame of work aimed at testing
this hypothesis.
Materials & Methods
This work started with the study of a case of unexplained treatment failure reported in a
French orchard (orchard 1). Unexplainable scab problems had been reported for 4 years in this
isolated 10 ha orchard, where 2 protectant fungicides, captan and mancozeb, had been used
131
for 40 years. In the 5 years preceding our work, this orchard received 50 captan and 31
mancozeb treatments. More than half of captan treatments were eradicant treatments, applied
at double rate. For the tests made in vivo, the efficiency of captan and mancozeb was tested
on the inoculum from orchard 1 and from an INRA experimental orchard (orchard 2), which
received, during the same period, 26 captan and 4 mancozeb applications (no eradicant
treatment). The tests were done in a growth chamber, on apple seedlings from the cross
Golden Delicious x Granny Smith. The 2 fungicides were applied 48 or 72 h before
inoculation (preventive applications) at French full (1.5 and 1.6 kg/ha) and half registered
rate, on 12 plantlets for each treatment. At treatment date, the last unrolled leaf was labelled.
The incidence and severity of the disease were assessed 21 days after the inoculation. The
protocol of the test and the scale for severity assessment (from 1 to 7) are described in Parisi
et al. (1993). For the in vitro tests, monoconidial strains from 5 other French orchards were
assessed by a classical mycelium growth test in the presence of 8 doses of captan. The results
were expressed as the mean ED 50 of the 13 to 16 strains tested per orchard. The orchards had
different exposures to captan (in brackets):
• Orchard 3: untreated plot in a moderately treated farm (low)
• Orchard 4: abandoned for many years (low)
• Orchard 5: commercial orchard treated with captan and problems of scab control
(moderate)
• Orchard 6: intensively treated experimental orchard (high)
• Orchard 7: organic orchard, never exposed to captan but treated with copper and sulphur
for 20 years (not exposed)
For all the tables, letters indicate homogeneous groups (H.g.) (ANOVA, LSD test, P=0.05).
Results and Discussion
The efficiency of captan to control the inoculum from orchard 1 was low (Table 1). No
significant difference was found between the incidence of the disease on the control (sprayed
with water) and the treated plants. For the severity, the efficiency of the full dose treatment
was 48 %. Conversely, the efficiency of mancozeb, tested in the same conditions, was very
good (Table 1). The comparison of the efficiency of these 2 fungicides on 2 inoculums with
different exposure to captan showed that the low efficiency of captan on the inoculum from
orchard 1 was reproducible (Tables 2 and 3) while this efficiency was higher, but partial, on
the inoculum from orchard 2 (50 to 58.7 % on incidence and severity, respectively).
Mancozeb displayed a good efficiency on these 2 inoculums (Tables 2 and 3).
Table 1. Efficiency of preventive treatments with captan and mancozeb on incidence and
severity of apple scab (inoculum from orchard 1)
Inoculum
Orchard 1
Water
Captan ½ reg. rate
Captan reg. rate
Water
Mancozeb ½ reg. rate
Mancozeb reg. rate
Incidence
% scabbed
leaves
22.6
18.4
15.7
21.6
0
0
H.g.
Efficiency %
a
a
ab
18.6
30.3
100
100
132
Severity
Mean score
labelled leaf
5.2
3.1
2.7
5.2
0
0
H.g.
a
b
b
Efficiency
%
40.4
48
100
100
Table 2. Efficiency of preventive treatments with captan and mancozeb on the incidence of
apple scab (inoculum from orchards 1 and 2).
Inoculum :
Orchard 1
Water
Captan ½ reg. rate
Captan reg. rate
Mancozeb ½ reg. rate
Mancozeb reg. rate
Incidence
% scabbed
leaves
29
24
21
6
1
H.g.
Efficiency %
ab
abc
bc
d
e
17.2
27.6
79.3
96.5
Orchard 2
Incidence
% scabbed
H.g. Efficiency
leaves
%
34
a
20
c
41.2
17
c
50
1
e
97.1
2
e
94.1
Table 3. Efficiency of preventive treatments with captan and mancozeb on the severity of
apple scab (inoculum from orchards 1 and 2).
Inoculum :
Orchard 1
Water (control)
Captan ½ reg. rate
Captan reg. rate
Mancozeb ½ reg. rate
Mancozeb reg. rate
Severity
Mean score
labelled leaf
5.6
3.1
3.5
0.5
0.17
H.g.
Efficiency %
a
bc
b
d
d
44.6
37.5
91
96.9
Orchard 2
Severity
Mean score H.g. Efficiency
labelled leaf
%
6.25
a
2.33
c
62.7
2.58
bc
58.7
0.08
d
98.7
0.17
d
97.3
The in vitro test showed significant differences between the log mean ED 50 of the
strains from the different orchards (Table 4). The strains from orchards less exposed to captan
were more sensitive, while the moderately and highly exposed orchards had the less sensitive
strains, with one exception: the strains from the organic orchard (not exposed) showed the
highest value of ED 50 (Table 5).
Table 4. Mean ED50 of strains from 5 French orchards differently exposed to captan
Orchard
Captan selective pressure
3
4
5
6
7
Low
Low
Moderate
High
Not exposed (organic)
Nb of
strains
16
13
16
14
14
Mean
ED 50
13,8
14,7
20,5
31
33,7
Log mean
ED 50
2,6 a
2,6 a
2,9 b
3,3 c
3,4 c
Variation
7,7-19,6
5,2-31,5
12,5- 41,5
12,8-50,6
15,1-51,9
The results suggest that an intensive exposure to captan can lead to a decreased
sensitivity of the treated V. inaequalis population, with a significant decrease in the efficiency
of the fungicide, as observed in orchard 1. However, two years without treatments permitted
the recovery of a high efficiency of the fungicide (Table 5).
Table 5. Efficiency of preventive treatments with captan and mancozeb on incidence and
133
severity of apple scab (inoculum from orchard 1 after 2 years without captan applications)
Orchard 1
Water (control)
Captan ½ reg. rate
Captan reg. rate
Mancozeb ½ reg. rate
Mancozeb reg. rate
Incidence
% scabbed
leaves
17.1
6.4
2.6
9.0
0
H.g.
Efficiency
%
a
c
de
bc
e
62.6
85
47.4
100
Severity
Mean score
labelled leaf
5.4
2.1
1.2
2.6
0
H.g.
Efficiency
%
a
c
cd
b
e
61.1
77.8
51.8
100
The in vitro test confirmed that a differential sensitivity to captan exists in French
orchards, and seems related to the exposure to the fungicide. The organic orchard, initially
supposed to have a sensitive population because not exposed to captan, showed a population
similar to that of a highly exposed orchard. This suggests that exposure to a multisite
fungicide can induce a decrease in sensitivity to a multisite fungicide belonging to another
family.
It was not possible to collect a population never exposed to captan or any other multisite
fungicides to obtain consistent data on the baseline sensitivity of V. inaequalis to captan, so,
this preliminary work cannot bring the proof that multisite fungicides can also induce
population modifications which could explain recently reported cases of treatment failure. As
resistance to captan has been reported for Botrytis cinerea and Macrophomina phaseolina
(Anitha et al., 1989, Barak et al., 1984, Diánez et al., 2002) and cannot be excluded for V.
inaequalis, we need further investigations to test this hypothesis. The pathosystem apple/V.
inaequalis is a good support for this study, as the multisite exposure of the fungal populations
can be very high in some old orchards.
In France, taking into account these results and the difficulties of controlling the disease,
the recommendations are to apply no more than 3 treatments per year with each of these
multisite families.
Acknowledgments
We thank the technicians and researchers of different French regions for sending us V.
inaequalis inoculum. A special thought for Roger Orts (CTIFL La Morinière) for his help.
References
Anitha, R., Sugunakar Reddy, M. & Chandrasekhara, Rao K. 1989: Studies on acquired
fungicide tolerance in Macrophomina phaseolina (Tassi) Goid, to mancozeb and captan,
and their cross-tolerance to other fungicides. Indian J. Plant Prot. 17: 155-158.
Barak, E. & Edgington, L.V. 1984: Cross-resistance to captan, thiram, chlorothalonil, and
related fungicides. Can. J. Plant Pathol. 6: 318-320.
Diánez, F., Santos, M., Blanco, R. & Tello, J.C. 2002: Fungicide resistance in Botrytis cinerea
isolates from Strawberry Crops in Huelva (Spain). Phytoparasitica 30: 529-534.
Parisi, L., Lespinasse, Y., Guillaumès, J. & Kruger, J. 1993: A new race of Venturia inaequalis
virulent to apples with resistance due to the Vf gene. Phytopathology 93: 533-537.
134
Validation of an apple scab fungicide spray action threshold to help
reduce Captan residue levels on Fruits.
Vincent Philion
Laboratoire de production fruitière intégrée de l’IRDA, Mont-Saint-Bruno, Québec
Abstract: Although most fungicide applications targeting apple scab aim to control primary
infections in spring, sprays are also routinely applied during the summer to avoid any potential fruit
infection. The objective of this project was to validate an action threshold for summer sprays based on
the incidence of summer foliar scab that could help refine the spray approach thus minimizing the
presence of fungicide residues on harvested fruit. The experiment was carried from 2006 to 2008 in a
McIntosh/M9 orchard with a planting distance of 3.65m x 1.25m. Replicated plots of 40 trees were set
up with different scab levels, all within the range of that observed in well maintained orchards. This
was done by skipping either one or two treatments in early spring or based on the inoculum level
present from the previous year. There were 2 plots per inoculum level and per treatment and 6 or 7
blocks depending on year for a total of 36 to 42 plots. Treatments were: no summer fungicide
application, current grower standard, sprays based on the proposed threshold of 5 scab-infested leaves
per 100 shoots. Although fruit scab at harvest often remained low in plots with foliar scab levels below
threshold, fruit scab observed after 12 weeks of storage was consistently at commercially unacceptable
levels.
Apple scab, Maturation Model, Spray timing
135
Breeding high quality disease resistant apple varieties
Markus Kellerhals, Andrea Patocchi, Brion Duffy and Jürg Frey
Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil, P.O. Box,, CH-8820 Wädenswil, Switzerland
Abstract: Breeding for high quality apples combined with excellent agronomic features and durable
disease resistance is a highly relevant approach for sustainable production systems. This includes
multi-disease resistance against the most important apple problems: scab (Venturia inaequalis),
powdery mildew (Podosphaera leucotricha) and fire blight (Erwinia amylovora). A promising strategy
to develop apple cultivars with durable multi-disease resistance is the pyramiding of major genes. The
presence of pyramided resistance can be detected by marker-assisted selection. For many known apple
scab resistance genes, molecular markers are available. We focus on new achievements for breeding
scab and mildew resistant and fire blight tolerant apple cultivars.
Key words: apple breeding, marker-assisted selection, fire blight, disease resistance
Introduction
To achieve durable disease resistance several functionally different resistances against the same
pathogen can be combined. This approach can be followed thanks to molecular markers.
Marker-assisted selection (MAS) facilitates and accelerates the selection of novel cultivars.
Markers linked to the Vf, Vh2, Vh4, Vbj and other apple scab resistance genes (reviewed in
Gessler et al. 2006) and the Pl1, Pl2, Pld and Plw mildew resistance (Markussen et al. 1995;
Seglias and Gessler 1997; James and Evans 2004) are available. To breed for fire blight
resistant apple cultivars, genetic variation in the breeding material and in Swiss and
international apple germplasm collections and in wild species is exploited.
Fire blight reached epidemic proportions in Switzerland in 2007 and other parts of Europe as
well (Duffy et al., 2007). Early, warm weather was conducive for fire blight infections during
a long synchronous bloom, exposing many more blossoms than usual to the causal pathogen,
Erwinia amylovora. The use of antibiotics is not a desired sustainable approach for
horticultural production in Europe. Among the options for alternative management strategies
there is scope for breeding fire blight resistant apple cultivars by exploiting genetic variation
in the germplasm and by using markers associated with resistance QTLs (Szalatnay et al. this
volume). For fire blight almost no major resistance genes have so far been found. However,
Peil et al. (2007) assumed a major resistance gene for fire blight on linkage group 3 of Malus
x robusta 5. QTLs for fire blight resistance in the apple progeny ‘Discovery’ x ‘Fiesta’ have
been mapped and molecular markers linked to the ‘Fiesta’ linkage group 7 major QTL have
been developed (Khan et al. 2006)
Material and Methods
Crosses were performed to pyramid genes related to disease resistance. Potential parents are
tested for the presence or absence of the expected resistance genes and crosses designed
accordingly. Seeds of the progenies are stratified for two month at 2°C in humid sand and raised
in the greenhouse in spring. At the 4-leaf stage they are inoculated with a liquid scab suspension
of 350,000 conidia per ml. Seedlings are kept under high humidity and at a temperature of 1820°C. Evaluation of the scab symptoms is carried out after 2 weeks using the scale of Chevalier
136
et al.. (1991).
The phenotypic screening of promising advanced selections for relative fire blight tolerance was
conducted in the quarantine glasshouse at ACW. Scion material was grafted onto M9 rootstock.
Trees were planted in early spring in plastic deep-pots 60 from Stuewe & Sons (Corvallis, US)
with a length of 35.5 cm and a diameter of 7 cm and grown in the glasshouse for several weeks
prior to inoculation. For each variety, 6 to 10 replicate trees were inoculated by puncturing the
distal tip of shoots 15-30 cm long with a syringe containing an E. amylovora suspension of 106
cfu/ml of strain FAW 611. Spreading of disease symptoms was evaluated in weekly intervals
over three weeks by measuring the expansion of the necrotic lesion from the shoot tip in relation
to the total shoot length.
Molecular analysis for scab and mildew resistance genes was performed with potential parents
for the 2008 crosses and with selected progenies according to methods described by Frey et al.
(2004). The molecular SCAR-markers AE 10-375 and GE 8019 flanking the ‘Fiesta’ linkage
group 7 major QTL for fire blight tolerance and developed by Khan et al. (2006) were used to
characterize the advanced selections.
Results and discussion
Phenotypic and molecular scab screening
Figure 1 shows the segregation of four seedling progenies in different scab resistance and
susceptibility classes. In progeny 1 (‘Ariane’ x ‘Fuji’) only the Vf scab resistance is present in
one parent. The expected ratio of 50% susceptible (class 0-3b) and 50% susceptible progeny
plants (class 4) is obvious. In progeny 2 both parents carry the Vf resistance and the expected
ratio of 75% resistant to 25% susceptible plants was perfectly detectable. 25% of the progeny
should carry Vf in a homozygous state. Combining Vh2 and Vf (progeny 3) resulted in a
slightly higher share of resistant plants compared to progeny 2. In progeny 4, 3 different genes
were involved and with this genetic setup only 12.5 % of the progeny individuals should be
susceptible, corresponding perfectly well with the phenotypic scoring. In progenies 3 and 4 no
plants in classes 0 (no symptoms) and 1 (pin point pits) were detected.
1: Ariane (Vf) x Fuji
n=1949
2: FAW 10444 (Vf) x FAW 15423 (Vf)
n=410
3: FAW 11561 (Vh2) x FAW 13652 (Vf)
n=325
4: FAW 11567 (Vh2, Vh4) x FAW 12556 (Vf)
n=512
0%
10%
20%
30%
Class 0
40%
Class 2
Class 3a
50%
Class 3b
60%
70%
Class 0-3b (total)
80%
90%
Class 4
Figure 1: Segregation of four different progenies in the glasshouse screening for scab
resistance. Classification of leaf symptoms according to Chevalier et al. 1991.
Table 1 presents advances achieved at ACW in breeding selections with pyramided scab
resistance combined with mildew resistance. Marker analysis allows us to verify expected
genetic constitution. For hybrids 16102 and 16208 molecular analysis has shown that instead
of two expected scab resistance genes, three scab resistance genes were present: Vf, Vh2 and
Vh4. According to Bus et al. (2005), the Russian apple R 12740-7A carries three major
resistance genes: Vh2, Vh4 and Vr. Additionally, the genotypes 16102 and 16208 carry Pl1
and Pl2 mildew resistance, respectively. However, selection 16254 did not carry the expected
137
100%
Pl1 resistance. Fruit quality is reasonably good in these selections. Selection for tree and fruit
characteristics will continue in this material in order to find the genotypes with the best
overall performance.
Table 1: Molecular analysis of hybrids carrying pyramided resistance against scab with at
least two different genes (Vf, Vh2, Vh4) and a mildew resistance (Pl1 or Pl2); + = marker
present, - = marker absent * = SSR marker, **SCAR marker).
Hybrid
16208
Cross
Genes
expected
FAW 8259 x
FAW 11561
Ariwa x Reka
Ariwa x Regia
16254
16102
Marker for
Vf, Vh2, Pl2
Vf Vh2* Vh2** Vh4 Pl1 Pl2
+
+
+
+
+
Vf, Vh2, Pl1
Vf, Vh4, Pl1
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Fruit
quality
medium
-
good
good
Phenotypic fire blight screening
Glasshouse screening of advanced selections with a shoot inoculation test for fire blight
resistance highlighted considerable differences among selections (Figure 2). Genotypes such
as FAW 8159, FAW 14995 and FAW 14959 displayed low susceptibility to fire blight. They
are promising as parents and as cultivars. Two individuals of the progeny ‘Florina’ x ‘Nova
Easygro’ (F x N 3535 and F x N 3529) displayed good resistance as well, as can be expected
considering the known fire blight tolerance of the parents. ‘Gala’ was used as susceptible
reference cultivar.
100
90
Lesion length in %
80
70
60
% LL1
50
% LL2
40
%LL3
30
20
10
FAW 15425 (7)
Milwa(7)
Gala (10)
La Flamboyante (9)
FAW 11640 (6)
FAW 16208 (8)
FAW 8099 (8)
FAW 10442 (6)
FAW 15221 (9)
FAW 14503 (9)
Iduna (9)
FAW 15115 (9)
Galmac (7)
Spartan (7)
FAW 11303 (9)
FAW 16102 (9)
F x N 3529 (7)
FAW 15097 (9)
FAW 14959 (9)
F x N 3535 (9)
FAW 14995 (5)
FAW 8159 (n = 9)
0
Figure 2: Fire blight glasshouse test with advanced selections and cultivars evaluated 1, 2 and
3 weeks after inoculation (LL1, LL2, LL3). The genotypes carrying the flanking markers AE
138
and GE for the QTL identified on LG7 of ‘Fiesta’ are indicated with arrows (Nb of plants in
brackets, bars represent standard deviation).
Molecular analysis
Analysis of 38 potential parents and advanced selections revealed seven genotypes amplifying
both the SCAR-markers AE 10-375 and GE 8019. They should carry the QTL allele identified
on linkage group 7 of ‘Fiesta’ conferring increased resistance to fire blight. Among the 22
genotypes displayed in Figure 2, 4 carried the markers AE and GE flanking the fire blight
resistance QTL. Obviously they were less susceptible to the disease than the other genotypes.
Besides parents, progeny plants also were analysed for the presence of the above mentioned
fire blight QTL. The cross Enterprise x FAW 11546 revealed 58 out of 102 plants carrying
both the AE and GE markers, respectively. The parental variety Enterprise carries both
markers in a heterozygous state and FAW 11546 carries only the GE marker. The same
segregation pattern, close to 50:50, was detected with progeny plants of the cross FAW 11567
(Vh2, Vh4, AE-, GE+) x FAW 12556 (Vf, PlD, AE+, GE+) where 13 out of 29 plants carried
AE and GE. Only one plant carried the pyramided resistances of Vf, Vh2, Vh4, PlD and
AE+GE. Vf, Vh2 and Vh4 confer scab resistance and PlD resistance to powdery mildew.
Plants carrying pyramided resistances will be preferentially selected.
Conclusions
Progress was achieved in breeding new apple varieties with durable disease resistance and
high fruit quality. We consider the strategy to pyramid resistance factors towards the same
pathogen and to integrate scab, mildew and fire blight resistance in the same genotype as
being a promising approach.
References
Bus, V.G.M., Rikkerink, E.H.A., van de Weg, W.E., Rusholme R.L., Gardiner, S.E., Bassett,
H.C.M., Kodde, L.P., Parisi, L., Laurens, F.N.D., Meulenbroek, E.J. & Plummer, K.M.
2005: The Vh2 and Vh4 scab resistance genes in two differential hosts derived from
Russian apple R 12740-7A map to the same linkage group of apple. Mol. Breeding 15:
103-116.
Chevalier, M., Lespinasse, Y. & Renaudin, S. 1991 : A microscopic study of the different
classes of symptoms coded by the Vf gene in apple for resistance to scab (Venturia
inaequalis). Plant Pathol. 40: 249-256.
Duffy, B., Vogelsanger, J., Schoch, B. & Holliger, E. 2007: Swiss situation and the 2007 fire
blight epidemic. 11th International Workshop on Fire Blight, Paper p101.
Frey, J.E., Frey, B., Sauer, C. & Kellerhals, M. 2004: Efficient low-cost DNA extraction and
multiplex fluorescent PCR method for marker-assisted selection in breeding. Plant
Breeding 123: 554-557.
Gessler, C., Patocchi, A., Sansavini, S., Tartarini, S. & Gianfranceschi, L. 2006: Venturia
inaequalis resistance in apple. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 25: 473-503.
James, C.M. & Evans, K. 2004: Identification of Molecular Markers linked to the Mildew
Resistance Genes Pl-d and Pl-w in Apple. Acta Horticulturae 663: 123-128.
Khan, M.A., Duffy, B., Durel, C.E., Gessler, C. & Patocchi A. 2006: QTL mapping of fire
blight resistance in apple. Mol. Breed. 17: 299-306.
Markussen, T., Krüger, J., Schmidt, H. & Dunemann, F. 1995: Identification of PCR-based
markers linked to the powdery mildew resistance gene Pl1 from Malus robusta in
cultivated apple. Plant Breed. 114: 530-534.
139
Peil, A., Garcia-Libreros, T., Richter, K., Trognitz, F.C., Trognitz, B., Hanke, M.V. &
Flachowsky, H. 2007: Strong evidence for a fire blight resistance gene of Malus robusta
located on linkage group 3. Plant Breeding 126: 470-475.
Seglias, N.P., & Gessler, C. 1997: Genetics of apple powdery mildew resistance derived from
Malus zumi (Pl2). IOBC/WPRS BULL. 20(9): 195-208.
Szalatnay, D., Hunziker, K., Duffy, B., Frey, J. & Kellerhals, M., 2009. Evaluation of fruit
genetic resources for disease resistance. IOBC Bulletin, this volume.
140
Recent advances in epidemiology of strawberry powdery mildew
D. M. Gadoury1, A. Stensvand2, R. C. Seem1, C. Heidenreich1, M. L. Herrero2, M. Welser
1
, A. Dobson2, H. Eikemo2, B. Asalf3
1 Department of Plant Pathology, Cornell University, New York State Agricultural Experiment
Station, Geneva, New York, USA; 2 Norwegian Institute for Agricultural and Environmental
Research, Plant Health and Plant Protection Division, 1432 Ås, Norway; 3 Norwegian
University of Life Sciences, Department of Plant and Environmental Sciences, 1432 Ås,
Norway
Abstract: Cleistothecia on leaves of deciduous perennials are often dispersed before leaf fall to other
substrates. In contrast, strawberry leaves remain attached during winter, and cleistothecia of
Podosphaera macularis remained attached to these leaves. Release of overwintered ascospores was
coincident with renewed plant growth, and pathogenicity of ascospores was confirmed. Upper and
lower surfaces of emergent leaves were similarly susceptible, but upper surfaces were obscured by
folding in emergent leaves. Emergent leaves exposed to airborne inoculum developed severe infection
of the lower surface, but not the obscured upper surface. Emergent leaves acquired ontogenic
resistance during unfolding, and the upper leaf surface thereby escaped infection. We found no
evidence that the pathogen survives winters in New York, USA or Norway within crown tissue. Plants
stripped of infected leaves remained mildew-free when forced after overwintering, while mildew
colonies commonly developed on emergent leaves of plants not stripped of mildewed leaves.
Unsprayed plots established using mildew-free plants either remained asymptomatic or developed
only traces of powdery mildew during one growing season, even when located within 100 to 150
meters of severely diseased plots. In summary, our results suggest the following: (i) sanitation, use of
disease-free plants, and eradicative treatments could contribute greatly to management of strawberry
powdery mildew; (ii) cleistothecia represent a functional source of primary inoculum; and (iii) the
common observation of higher mildew severity on lower leaf surfaces may reflect escape of the upper
epidermis due to the combined effect of leaf folding and rapid acquisition of ontogenic resistance.
Powdery mildew, Small fruit diseases, Strawberry diseases, Epidemiology, Ontogenic resistance,
Cleistothecia
141
Integrated protection of table-grape from powdery mildew in
Southern Italy
Crescenza Dongiovanni1, Claudia Giampaolo1, Michele Di Carolo1, Agostino
Santomauro2, Francesco Faretra2
1
Centro di Ricerca e Sperimentazione in Agricoltura “Basile Caramia” - Via Cisternino, 281
70010 Locorotondo (Bari - Italy)
2
Dipartimento di Protezione delle Piante e Microbiologia applicata, Università degli Studi di
Bari - Via Amendola, 165/A 70126 Bari (Italy)
Abstract Powdery mildew (Erysiphe necator Schw.) is one of the most severe diseases of grapevine
wherever the crop is grown, especially under hot and dry climate like that occurring in the
Mediterranean area. Two field trials were conducted on table-grape in Southern Italy in 2007 and
2008, to evaluate the effectiveness of different spray schedules based on the following fungicides:
boscalid, either alone or in mixture with kresoxim-methyl; metrafenone; myclobutanil, either alone or
in mixture with sulphur or meptyldinocap; penconazole; proquinazid; pyraclostrobin+metiram;
quinoxyfen, either alone or in mixture with sulphur; sulphur; tebuconazole; trifloxystrobin. The
climatic conditions during both the trials were particularly favourable to the pathogen, so that
prevalence values of 97-100% of infected bunches in the untreated plots were reached at the end of
both trials. Under such disease-conducive conditions, all the tested spray schedules always allowed a
statistically significant reduction of disease incidence as compared to the untreated check. In
particular, the best results were obtained when kresoxim-methyl+boscalid, pyraclostrobin+metiram,
proquinazid or quinoxyfen had been applied during the periods of highest disease pressure.
Keywords: powdery mildew, table-grape, IPM
Introduction
Powdery mildew, caused by Erysiphe necator Schw., is one of the most common and severe
diseases of grapevine wherever the crop is intensively grown, and especially under hot and
dry climate, like that occurring in the Mediterranean area. It costs millions dollars annually to
vine growers, due to crops losses and the intensive usage of fungicides for its control.
Nowadays, several classes of fungicides are available for the control of powdery mildew,
although the use of some of them like DMIs and QoIs are challenged with the risk of acquired
resistance. Decreased effectiveness of DMIs due to acquired resistance has been reported in
Portugal (Steva et al., 1988, 1989b), France (Steva et al., 1989a), Italy (Garibaldi et al.,
1990), California (Ogawa et al., 1988; Gubler et al., 1996; Ypema et al., 1997) and New York
State (Erickson and Wilcox, 1997). In 2007, following the monitoring activity carried out by
the Fungicides Action Resistance Committee (FRAC), the presence of E. necator populations
resistant to QoIs was confirmed in Eastern Austria and in Hungary. Cases of resistance were
also detected, in a few locations, in the Czech Republic and Slovakia
(http://www.frac.info/frac/index.htm).
The management of resistance includes the setting up of spray programmes with an
appropriate alternation of fungicides with different mode of action. In the last several years,
new fungicides with novel modes of action have been authorised for the use on grapevine in
Italy against powdery mildew and offer new opportunities for crop protection and more
142
appropriate resistance management. The fungicides currently allowed in Italy on grapevine
against powdery mildew are listed In Table 1.
Table 1. Fungicides and microbial antagonists allowed in Italy against grapevine powdery
mildew.
Class
Anilides
Benzophenones
Dinitrophenoles
DMIs
Hydroxypyrimidines
Phenoxyquinolines
QoIs
Quinazolinones
Spiroketalamines
Sulphur
Microbial antagonists
Active ingredients
Boscalid
Metrafenone
Meptyldinocap
Cyproconazole, difenoconazole, fenbuconazole,
myclobutanil, penconazole, propiconazole,
tebuconazole, tetraconazole, triadimenol
Bupirimate
Quinoxyfen
Azoxystrobin, kresoxim-methyl, pyraclostrobin,
trifloxystrobin
Proquinazid
Spiroxamine
Sulphur
Ampelomyces quisqualis
The present paper reports the results of two field trials, carried out on table-grape in
Southern Italy in 2007-2008, aimed at evaluating the effectiveness of spray schedules based
on different fungicides for the control of powdery mildew.
Materials and methods
Both trials were carried out in an arbour vineyard cv. Victoria located in Puglia (Southern
Italy), in an area where table-grape growing is very common, and climatic conditions are
highly favourable to powdery mildew.
The experimental design of 4 randomised blocks, with plots of 8-10 plants surrounded by
1- row untreated border area, was adopted in both the trials. Sprays were carried out at 8-11 d
intervals, depending on disease pressure and fungicide persistence. Spays after véraison were
aimed at preventing late infections on the rachis. Fungicides were applied with motorised
knapsack sprayers delivering a water volume of 1,000 l ha-1.
The tested fungicides, employed either alone or in alternation in spray programmes, are
listed in Table 2.
143
Table 2. Fungicides and formulate rates employed in the trials.
Fungicides
Formulates (% a.s.)
Company
Basf Crop
Protection
Basf Crop
Metrafenone
Vivando SC (42.37)
Protection
Basf Crop
Pyraclostrobin+metiram
Cabrio Top WG (5+55)
Protection
Basf Crop
Boscalid
Cantus WG (50)
Protection
Systhane 4.5 Plus EO
Du Pont De
Myclobutanil
(4.5)
Nemours
Du Pont De
Proquinazid
Talendo EC (20.53)
Nemours
Basf Crop
Sulphur
Kumulus Tecno WG (80)
Protection
Syngenta Crop
Penconazole
Topas 10 EC EC (10.2)
Protection
Bayer
Trifloxystrobin
Flint WG (50)
CropScience
Dow
Quinoxyfen
Arius SC (22.58)
AgroSciences
Bayer
Tebuconazole
Folicur SE (4.35)
CropScience
Meptyldinocap+myclobutanil GF 1831 L (11.3 + 4.8)
Sipcam
Quinoxyfen+sulphur
Macho SC (3.6+46.7)
Sipcam
Kresoxim-methyl+boscalid
Collis SC (18,2+9,1)
Formulate
rates
(g or ml/ha)
400
250
1500
1200
1250
250
5000
200
150
300
2300
1250
1600
Symptom severity on berries and rachis was assessed by evaluating 250-300 bunches per
plot. An empirical scale with 8 classes of infection [0 = healthy bunch; 1 = bunch with 1-5
infected berries (ib) or 1-5% infected rachis surface (irs); 2 = 6-10 ib or % irs; 3 = 11-15 ib or
% irs; 4 = up to 25% ib or irs; 5 = 26-50% ib or irs; 6 = 51-75% ib or irs; 7 = 76-100% ib or
irs] was used to calculate, in addition to the disease prevalence (percentage of infected
bunches), the disease severity and its weighted mean value, according to McKinney (1923),
by using the following formulas:
v⋅ f
v⋅ f
Disease severity = ∑
McKinney’s Index = ∑
⋅100
n
N⋅X
where: v = numerical value of each class of the empirical scale; f = frequency of bunches in
each class; n = number of infected bunches; N = number of observed bunches; X = the highest
class value of the empirical scale.
All data, were transformed in arcsine square root percent according to Bliss (1937), were
submitted to ANOVA; mean values were separated by Duncan’s Multiple Range Test
(Duncan, 1955).
The spray programmes tested in the trials are shown in Table 3 and 4.
144
Results
Trial A (2007)
Weather conditions were very favourable to E. necator and the first symptoms appeared in the
first week of June in untreated plots. On 12 June, the infections were observed on 47% of
bunches of untreated plants, with a McKinney’s index of 13% (Table 3). Thereafter, the
disease pressure increased markedly so that, on 27 June, all bunches showed symptoms on
berries in untreated plots, with a McKinney’s index value of 85%. On 20 July, 7 days after the
last application, a further increase of the disease was recorded on untreated plants, and the
McKinney’s index reached 91%.
Under such disease-conducive conditions, all the tested spray schedules always induced a
statistically significant reduction of the disease incidence, as compared to the untreated check.
In particular, the best results were obtained when the earliest sprays (beginning and end of
blossoming), before symptom appearance, had been carried out with kresoximmethyl+boscalid or pyraclostrobin+metiram, which showed the high preventive effectiveness
of such fungicides. Applications with kresoxim-methyl+boscalid for the whole duration of the
trial and the alternation of kresoxim-methyl+boscalid and metrafenone yielded a disease
control significantly higher as compared to the sole usage of metrafenone, in the presence of
the highest disease pressure.
Trial B (2008)
The trial was conducted in the same vineyard as Trial A. For this trial, two early applications
with sulphur were carried out before the beginning of blossoming on all the plots, except the
untreated one, because of the high levels of infections occurred during the previous year and
of the high susceptibility of the cultivar to powdery mildew. During the trial, disease
incidence was quite high. The first infections appeared on berries in the second week of June
in untreated plots. On 19 June, 40% of bunches on untreated plants showed symptoms of
powdery mildew, with a McKinney’s index of 7% (Table 4). Later, the pathogen’s activity
continued and, at the time of the assessments carried out on 2 and 30 July, the percentages of
infected bunches were 89% and 97% with McKinney’s index values of 40% and 66%,
respectively (Table 4). Under such conditions, all the tested spray programmes allowed a
significant control of the disease on berries, without showing any appreciable differences
among them. In the presence of the highest levels of disease pressure, the lowest values of
infected berries were observed on the theses treated with the alternation of proquinazid and
myclobutanil or with quinoxyfen and myclobutanil. Similar results were observed in the plots
treated with pyraclostrobin+metiram and metrafenone. On 30 July, rachis infections were also
observed on 94% of bunches in untreated plots. No rachis symptoms were observed in the
treated plots for the whole duration of the trial.
145
Table 3. Trial A (2007) - Disease incidence on berries.
Protection schedules
Sprays
12 June
27 June
20 July
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 McKinney Infected Severity
McKinney
Infected Severity McKinney
Infected
Severity
Index
bunches
Index
bunches
Index
bunches
%
%
%
Untreated check
- - - - - - - 12.8 a A
47.3 a A 1.8 a A 84.9 a A
100.0 a A 5.9 a A 91.4 a A
100.0 a A 6.4 a A
Kresoxim-methyl+boscalid x X x x x x x 0.2 b B
1.2 c B 0.5 b B
3.1 de D
15.9 e D 1.3 b B
3.0 e E
17.4 d E 1.1 c BC
Metrafenone
x X x x x x x 0.4 b B
3.0 bc B 0.8 b B 11.6 bc BC
57.1 c BC 1.4 b B 15.6 c BC
65.2 c C 1.6 bc BC
Kresoxim-methyl+boscalid x X x
0.1 b B
0.7 c B 0.5 b B
2.4 e D
15.7 e D 1.0 b B
2,6 e E
16,1 d E 1,1 c C
Metrafenone
x x x x
x Xx
Pyraclostrobin+metiram
Metrafenone
x
x x 0.1 b B
0.7 c B 0.5 b B
4.3 de CD
25.2 de D 1.2 b B
4,6 de DE
25,4 d DE 1,3 c BC
Boscalid
x
Penconazole
x X
Trifloxystrobin
x x x
0.7 b B
5.0 b B 1.0 b AB 15.4 b B
80.7 b B 1.3 b B 25.8 b B
90.7 b B 2.0 b B
Quinoxyfen
x x
Myclobutanil
x X
x
Proquinazid
x x
x
0.8 b B
4.6 bc B 1.1 b AB 7.7 cde BCD 38.7 cd CD 1.2 b B 13.1 c CD
51.1 c C 1.6 bc BC
Myclobutanil
x
Kresoxim-methyl+boscalid x X
Metrafenone
x x
x
0.3 b B
1.4 c B 0.3 b B
7.8 cd BCD
40.1 cd CD 1.3 b B 11.1 cd CDE 46.8 c CD 1.5 bc BC
Tebuconazole
x
x
Dates of sprays: 1) 23 May (start of blossoming); 2) 31 May (end of blossoming); 3) 11 June; 4) 19 June; 5) 27 June (beginning of berry-touch); 6) 5 July; 7) 13
July.
146
Table 4. Trial B (2008) - Disease incidence on berries.
Protection schedules
Sprays
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 McKinney
0
Index
19 June
Infected
bunches
%
40.1 a A
Severity
2 July
McKinney Infected Severity McKinney
Index
bunches
Index
%
40.3 a A
89.2 a A 3.1 a A 65.5 a A
30 July
Infected Severity
bunches
%
97.0 a A 4.7 a A
Untreated check
- - - - - - - - - - 7.0 a A
1.2 a A
Sulphur
Xx
x
Proquinazid
x x
x
0.0 c B
0.0 c B
0.0 b B
1.5 b B
10.1 b B 1.0 b B
2.7 b B
18.6 c B 1.0 b B
Myclobutanil
x
x x x
Sulphur
Xx
x
Quinoxyfen
x x
x
0.0 c B
0.2 bc B 0,3 b AB 1,5 b B
10,4 b B 1,0 b B
2,8 b B
18,7 c B 1,0 b B
Myclobutanil
x
x x x
Sulphur
Xx
x
Metrafenone
x x
x
0.1 bc B
0.5 bc B 0.5 ab AB 3.2 b B
21.7 b B 1.0 b B
5.9 b B
39.3 b B 1.0 b B
Myclobutanil
x
x x x
Sulphur
Xx
x
Metrafenone
x
x x x
0.2 bc B
1.2 bc B 0.8 ab AB 1.5 b B
10.6 b B 1.0 b B
3.3 b B
22.0 bc B 1.0 b B
Kresoxim-methyl+boscalid
x x x
Sulphur
Xx
x
Tebuconazole
x x x
0.5 b B
3.4 b B
0.8 ab AB 3.0 b B
16.7 b B 1.2 b B
5.4 b B
32.5 bc B 1.1 b B
Trifloxystrobin
x x x x
Sulphur
Xx
x
Metrafenone
x
x x x
0.2 bc B
1.5 bc B 0.8 ab AB 2.3 b B
16.2 b B 1.0 b B
3.2 b B
21.7 bc B 1.0 b B
Pyraclostrobin+metiram
x x x
x
Xx
Sulphur
x
x x
Meptyldinocap+myclobutanil
0.1 bc B
0.8 bc B 0.5 ab AB 1.9 b B
12.8 b B 1.0 b B
6.1 b B
36.1 bc B 1.2 b B
Myclobutanil
x
Quinoxyfen+sulphur
x x x
Dates of sprays: 1) 5 May; 2) 12 May; 3) 19 May (start of blossoming); 4) 29 May (end of blossoming); 5) 9 June; 6) 19 June; 6) 19 June; 7) 27 June; 8) 7 July;
9) 17 July; 10) 25 July.
147
Discussion
The protection strategies for table-grape from powdery mildew in Southern Italy must be
addressed to prevent the outbreak of the disease, due to its high frequency and damaging
effects under the environmental conditions of that area. In fact, beyond direct damages, the
disease can also induce the development of the causal agents of bunch rots, settling down on
berries through the injuries caused by the pathogen. Therefore, bunches need to be
continuously protected for a long period: at least from the start of blossoming until véraison
and even later, against infections on the rachis. This results in a high number of sprays
needing to be carried out during the season, with the risk of inducing resistance to fungicides
in the target pathogen.
During recent years, a number of new active substances have been permitted for use
against powdery mildew on grapevine, some of which have been tested in field trials in
Southern Italy (e.g. Santomauro et al., 1997, 2003; Faretra et al., 1997, 1998; Giampaolo et
al., 2006; Dongiovanni et al., 2008).
The field trials reported in this paper were aimed at evaluating the effectiveness of
protection strategies based on the alternation of different fungicides with different modes of
action. The results showed that, even under a high level of disease pressure, all the tested
spray schedules always caused a significant reduction in disease incidence, as compared to the
untreated check. In particular, the best results were obtained when kresoxim-methyl+boscalid,
pyraclostrobin+metiram, proquinazid or quinoxyfen were applied during the periods of
highest disease pressure.
It seems reasonable to specify that the high incidence of the disease was caused by both
the environmental conditions favourable to the pathogen and by the considerable inoculum of
E. necator coming from the untreated rows surrounding the plots. It is clear that higher levels
of efficacy may be expected under normal field conditions with uniform applications on large
vineyard surface.
In conclusion, the availability of new fungicides with novel modes of action allows the
establishment of more suitable protection strategies, with particular regard to the management
of resistance in the target pathogen. On the other hand, the choices to be made by the farmers
for the correct positioning of the different fungicides through the season are made more
difficult, particulalrly in consideration of important aspects such as their pre-harvest interval,
residual activity etc. Therefore, it becomes increasingly evident that there is a need for
qualified technical assistance that should transfer updated information coming from research
and experimentation to the farmers.
References
Bliss, C.I. 1937: Analysis of field experimental data expressed in percentages. Plant
Protection, 12: 67-77.
Dongiovanni C., Giampaolo C., Di Carolo M., Santomauro A., Faretra F. 2008: Italia
meridionale: tre anni di prove con proquinazid. Terra e Vita, 14 (Suppl.): 6-7.
Duncan, D.B. 1955: Multiple range and multiple F tests. Biometrics, 11: 1-42.
Erickson, E.O., and Wilcox, W.F. 1997: Distribution of sensitivities to three sterol
demethylation inhibitor fungicides among populations of Uncinula necator sensitive and
resistant to triadimefon. Phytopathology, 87, 8: 784–791.
Faretra F., Santomauro A., Piglionica, V. 1997: Novità nella protezione della vite ad uva da
tavola dalle malattie fungine. L’Informatore Agrario, 50 (53): 46-50.
Faretra F., Santomauro A., Polizzi G., Catara A., D’Ascenzo D., Grande C., Abbruzzetti G.,
Caputo A.R., Catalano V., Masi G., Colasurdo G., Vallillo E., Romualdi G. 1998:
148
Protezione antioidica con azoxystrobin e kresoxim-methyl in vigneti dell’Italia centromeridionale. Atti Giornate Fitopatologiche, Vol. 1, 569-574.
Garibaldi, A, McKenzie, L.I., Gullino, M.L. 1990: Comparsa in Italia di una popolazione di
Uncinula necatrix (Schw.) Burr. che presenta ridotta sensibilità verso alcuni inibitori
della biosintesi degli steroli. Atti Giornate Fitopatologiche, Vol. 2, 143-150.
Giampaolo C., Dongiovanni C., Tauro G., Silletti M.R., Pollastro P., Santomauro A., Faretra F.
2006: La difesa antioidica: le esperienze in Italia – In Puglia, nelle province di Brindisi e
Taranto. Terra e Vita, 6: 37-39.
Gubler, W.D., Ypema, H.L., Ouimette, D.G., Bettiga, L.J. 1996: Occurrence of resistance in
Uncinula necator to triadimefon, myclobutanil and fenarimol in California grapevines.
Plant Disease, 80: 902-909.
McKinney, H.H. 1923: Influence of soil temperature and moisture on infection of wheat
seedlings by Elminthosporium sativum. Journal of Agricultural Research, 26: 195-218.
Ogawa, J.M., Gubler, W.D., Manji, B.T. 1988: Effect of sterol biosynthesis inhibitors on
diseases of stone fruits and grapes in California. In: Sterol biosynthesis inhibitors pharmaceutical and agrochemical aspects. Eds. Berg D.and Plempel M.: 262–287.
Santomauro A., Faretra F., Tauro G., Lospalluti M., Lasorella V. 1997: Miglioramenti nella
protezione dell’uva da tavola dall’oidio (Uncinula necator). La Difesa delle Piante, 20
(3-4): 117-141.
Santomauro A, Tauro G., Dongiovanni C., Giampaolo C., Abbatecola A., Miazzi M., Hajjeh
H., Faretra F. 2003: A four-years experience with trifloxystrobin against powdery mildew
on table grape in Southern Italy. Pflanzenschutz Nachrichten Bayer, 56 (2): 373-386.
Steva, H., Cartolaro, P., Clerjeau, M., Lafon, R., Gomes Da Silva, M.T. 1988: Une résistance
de l’Oidium au Portugal? Phytoma, 402: 49-50.
Steva, H., Cartolaro, P., Clerjeau, M., Lafon, R., Gomes Da Silva, M.T. 1989a: Premier cas de
résistance de l’Oïdium à un traitement fongicide. Vitis, 137: 124-125.
Steva, H., Clerjeau, M., Gomes Da Silva, M.T. 1989b: Reduced sensitivity to triadimenol in
portuguese field population of Uncinula necator. Chemical Control Newsletters, 12: 3031.
Ypema, H.L., Ypema, M., Gubler, W.D. 1997: Sensitivity of Uncinula necator to benomyl
triadimefon, myclobutanil and fenarimol in California. Plant Disease, 81: 293-297.
149
A multiphasic approach to evaluating the effects of biofumigation for
management of wilt in strawberries
David Yohalem, Tom Passey
East Malling Research, New Road, East Malling, Kent ME19 6BJ UK
david.yohalem@emr.ac.uk
Abstract. The use of isothiocyanate-releasing plant materials has been proposed as a method for
replacing methyl bromide for reduction of inoculum densities of Verticillium dahliae, causal agent of
wilt in strawberry. We have documented reductions in numbers of V. dahliae propagules in both
microcosm tests and in the field. In addition to the benefits of reduced pathogen inoculum, we are
evaluating non-target affects of the strategy in the field: plant health and yield; changes in functional
and taxonomic community profiles in both bulk and rhizosphere soils; changes in culturable bacterial
and fungal populations (both taxonomic and functional); and colonisation by arbuscular mycorrhizal
fungi. Preliminary data will be presented for each of these indicators.
Keywords: Verticillium dahliae, biofumigation, Brassicaceae, Cruciferae, Fragaria, strawberry,
non-target effects
Introduction
Verticillium wilt of strawberries can reduce yields by up to 75%. Most commercial varieties
are highly susceptible to the disease, which has been managed, until recently, by soil
sterilization with methyl bromide. This has encouraged a dependence on soil sterilization, as
soils frequently become infested with pathogens as primary colonists, a consequence of the
vacuum effect and monocultures. With the banning of methyl bromide, alternative strategies
are being sought to alleviate the problem of wilt. Among these strategies is the use of green
manure plants that release fungitoxic chemicals upon decay – so-called biofumigation. East
Malling Research has taken the leadership role in the technical and scientific aspects of
exploring green manure alternatives to chemical soil sterilization, a joint industry-government
sponsored HorticultureLINK project.
The multiphasic nature of the project is illustrated in Figure 1. The agronomy of two
biofumigant green manures: Brassica juncea, brown or Dijon or Indian mustard, and Sinapis
alba, white mustard, are being evaluated, as well as their impact on the viability of the
pathogen in soil and disease expression in the host. In addition, the use of BioFence seed
meal, produced from B. carinata, Ethiopian mustard, and of lavender-based materials are
being investigated. Also being studied are the effects on disease in strawberry and effects on
yield and marketability. Chemists from the Natural Resources Institute, Chatham, are
elucidating the production and fate of chemicals produced after incorporation of green
manures in soil, both in laboratory microcosms and in the field. The pathology of the system
is being studied in laboratory and field-based tests on Verticillium dahliae viability and in
disease expression in strawberry at two sites – a conventionally managed site and one where
strawberries are being produced under organic management. The microbiology of the soils
after biofumigation is also being studied in order to determine if this mode of disease
management has possible non-salient, non-target effects. Finally, the economics of
biofumigation are being evaluated in terms of costs of using the technology and value-added
use of several materials.
150
Biofumigation
Agronomy
Pathology
Economics
Microbiology
Chemistry
Biofumigants
Strawberry
Pathogen
Microcosms
Field
Disease
Community
Prokaryotes
Mycorrhiza
Eukaryotes
Individuals
Bacteria
Fungi
Figure 1. The areas being investigated in the project
Materials and methods
Design of field experiments
All experiments have been designed as complete randomized blocks. Those using cruciferous
biofumigants involved four treatments: untreated control; Brassica juncea cv. ISCI 99;
Sinapis alba; and BioFence seed meal pellets, all supplied by Plant Solutions, UK.
Experimental units were either 8.1 or 9 m wide (depending on site) and either 10 m or 50 m
long (depending on experiment). Two sites were used: a conventionally managed site in
Mereworth, Kent on Marlowe series soil, a typic paleo-argillic brown earth; and an
organically managed site in Tuesley, Surrey on Fyfield 2 series soil, a typic argillic brown
earth.
Experiments with lavender (Lavandula angustifolia cv Minette), lavandin (L. x
intermedia cv. Grosso) and their wastes were established at East Malling Research, Kent, on
Marlow series sandy silt loam. These experiments were performed on raised (ca. 30 cm) beds,
with each bed representing a block and five blocks, each block comprised of six treatments:
untreated control; BioFence pellets; the fresh lavender and lavandin and post-extraction
wastes of lavender and lavandin added at approximately 10% by volume.
Parameters evaluated and methods for their evaluation
Inoculum density of V. dahliae is estimated using the wet-sieve method developed by Harris
and co-workers (1973). Community properties, both metagenomic (ribosomal DNA intergenic
transcribed spacer regions) (Steele and Streit, 2006) and community-level physiological
profiles using BIOLOG eco-plates (TechnoPath, IR) (Garland and Mills, 1991) are being
evaluated for both bulk soil and strawberry rhizosphere microbial communities.
We are also characterizing the identities (Rademaker and De Bruijn, 1997) and several of
the properties of microorganisms recovered from the bulk and rhizosphere soils used in the
experiments, including activities associated with biological control of plant pathogens and
plant growth promotion; and the infection of roots by mycorrhizal fungi under the various
151
treatment regimes.
Results and discussion
To date, we have demonstrated marked reductions in pathogen population density in
biofumigated soils, on the order of 50% or more. However, because we performed these
experiments in highly infested areas, we have not yet shown a decrease in disease on
strawberry. We are continuing to investigate several of the materials under conditions of lower
inoculum pressure in order to find out if their is a meaningful reduction in disease incidence
when biofumigant materials are applied where the threat exists but is not so great.
We have begun studies to investigate possible non-target or undesirable effects of
biofumigation (Figure 2).
SOIL SAMPLE
Community properties
‘Individual’ properties
Pure cultures
CLPP
[Biolog ECO]
Metagenomic
Analyses
[rDNA ITS]
Fingerprinting
[REP-PCR]
Identification
[16 S rDNA]
Dual culture
[antagonism]
Biocontrol properties
[chitinase, cellulase,
protease, siderophore]
PGPR properties
[siderophore, auxin]
Figure 2. The strategy for investigation of non-target effects of biofumigation (the various
terms and acronyms are defined in the text)
Mycorrhiza are important in nutrient uptake, particularly P, in water use efficiency and
disease tolerance. Strawberries are highly mycorrhizal while Brassica spp. are not. The spores
of mycorrhizal fungi are of unknown sensitivity to isothiocyanates, chemicals identified in
disease suppression that are derived from members of the Brassica family.
Among the materials examined in our early screening experiments, lavender was the
most effective. Later, we discovered that lavandin, a hybrid species, and both lavender and
lavandin wastes were as effective in reducing Verticilllium inocula as fresh lavender.
Incorporation of this waste material into strawberry beds is currently being investigated and
achieves added value for what is, essentially, a waste material with no present use. Should
lavender and lavandin wastes prove non-viable due to lack of sufficient supply, an abundance
of other materials with similar chemistry remain to be evaluated and exploited.
By examining the profiles of soil communities and the properties of the culturable
fraction it may be possible to identify complementary methods to biofumigation that either
increase the activity of beneficial microbes or result in smaller perturbations of the resident
microflora.
152
Acknowledgements
This project is funded by Defra, the Horticultural Development Company and industry
partners: KG Growers, Berry World, Marks and Spencer, the East Malling Trust, East Malling
Ltd and supported by contributions from Hugh Lowe Farms, Hall Hunter Enterprises, FAST
and Plant Solutions. The research was performed by East Malling Research, Natural
Resources Institute, and Garden Organic.
References
Garland, J.L. and Mills, A.L. 1991. Classification and characterization of heteroptrophic
microbial communities on the basis of community level sole-carbon-source utilization.
Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 57: 2351-2359.
Harris, D.C. Yang, J.R. and Ridout, M.S. 1993. The detection and estimation of Verticillium
dahliae in naturally infested soils. Plant Pathology 42: 238-250.
Rademaker, J.L.W. and De Bruijn, F.J. (1997). Characterization and classification of microbes
by REP-PCR genomic fingerprinting and computer-assisted pattern analysis. In: DNA
Markers: Protocols, Applications and Overviews, eds. Caetano-Annolés and Greshoff.
151-171.
Steele, H.L. and Streit. W.R. 2006. Metagenomics for the study of soil microbial
communities. In: Molecular Approaches to Soil, Rhizosphere and Plant Microorganism
Analysis, eds. Cooper and Rao, 42-45.
153
Armillaria root rot on highbush blueberry in Northern Italy:
monitoring, identification and inoculum sources
Daniele Prodorutti1, Alberto Pellegrini1, Davide Gobbin2, Thalia Vanblaere2, Ilaria
Pertot1
1
FEM-IASMA Research Centre, Plant Protection Department, S. Michele all’Adige TN 38010,
Italy; 2SafeCrop Centre, S. Michele all’Adige TN 38010, Italy
Abstract: Highbush blueberry plants infected by Armillaria spp. were reported in north-eastern Italy
(Province of Trento). After inspection, 13 blueberry orchards were found to be infected in the
Valsugana valley. Armillaria sp. samples were collected from blueberry plants, from bark spread on
the blueberry rows and from infected trees and stumps in the orchard surroundings. The species
determination was performed using a species-specific multiplex PCR approach. Efficacy trials with
potential biocontrol agents against Armillaria sp. were carried out on young blueberry plants. The
average percentage of stunted plants in the infected fields was 11%, while the percentage of dead
plants was generally very low (average of 1.5%). The most frequent species infecting blueberries were
A. gallica and A. mellea: in each field one species largely dominated the other. The tested Trichoderma
strains, especially T. atroviride SC1, were the most effective biocontrol agents against A. gallica and
A. mellea.
Key words: Armillaria mellea, Armillaria gallica, Vaccinium corymbosum, mulching barks.
Introduction
Highbush blueberry plants infected by Armillaria sp. were found in north-eastern Italy
(Province of Trento) (Prodorutti et al., 2006a). Three Armillaria species (A. gallica, A. mellea
and A. ostoyae) were reported on highbush blueberry (Caruso, 1995; Prodorutti et al., 2006b).
These three species are also present in the forests of the Province of Trento (La Porta et al.,
2006). Disease symptoms observed on blueberry roots were white mycelium between the bark
and the hardwood, and rhizomorphs developing inside and around the rotted wood. In this
region blueberries are cultivated in an area of 70 ha, mainly located in Valsugana valley.
Blueberry plants are usually mulched on rows with a layer of coniferous bark collected by the
growers in the forest, where the logs are peeled.
Armillaria spp. can survive for a long time in the soil, on wood and root debris, even in
the absence of any living host (Fox, 2000). Mycelium and rhizomorphs assignable to
Armillaria sp. were found in the bark heaps and in the bark spread in the orchard rows, as
well as in stumps and old trees near the orchards. Therefore infected root residues of forest
and old fruit trees and infected mulching barks may represent a possible source of inoculum
for blueberries planted on the same site.
The aims of this study were: i) the determination of the Armillaria species infecting
blueberry orchards and the spreading of the disease in Trentino region; ii) the assessment of
potential inoculum sources in and around blueberry orchards; iii) the determination of the
efficacy of some microbial biocontrol agents (BCAs).
Material and methods
Highbush blueberry orchards with aerial symptoms of Armillaria infections (poor shoot
154
growth, premature reddening of leaves and dieback), initially identified according to
notifications from growers and advisors, were accurately investigated. The percentage of
stunted and dead plants was recorded in each orchard. In addition, two infected orchards were
monitored from 2003 to 2006 to assess disease increase over time.
Armillaria spp. samples were collected from infected blueberry plants, from bark spread
along the blueberry rows and from old infected trees/stumps and bark heaps in the orchard
vicinity. The determination of Armillaria spp. was performed using a species-specific
multiplex PCR reaction that allowed the discrimination among A. mellea, A. gallica and A.
ostoyae (Prodorutti et al., 2009).
The efficacy of several BCAs against Armillaria spp. was evaluated on one-year-old
potted blueberry plants, under greenhouse controlled conditions. The BCAs tested in this
study were: Trichoderma harzianum T22 (Koppert, The Netherlands), T. harzianum T39 (Y.
Elad, Israel), T. atroviride SC1 (FEM, Italy), Phlebiopsis gigantea CBS 935.70
(Centraalbureau voor Schimmelcultures, The Netherlands), Bacillus subtilis F77 (FEM),
Gliocladium catenulatum (Verdera, Finland). Trials were carried out by inserting wood pieces
artificially inoculated with A. gallica and A. mellea between blueberry roots and treating the
soil at the same time with the BCAs grown in Potato Dextrose Broth (Oxoid, UK). The
percentage of infected blueberry plants was assessed one year after inoculation.
Results and discussion
Thirteen out of 350 Valsugana orchards were found to be infected by Armillaria spp. The
average percentage of stunted plants in these fields was 11%, reaching a maximum of 20% in
two orchards. The percentage of dead plants was generally very low (0.2-2.5%), with an
average of 1.5% and values higher than 5% only in two orchards.
In both the two fields monitored annually, the percentage of stunted plants increased
from 10 to 20% during the four-year survey. Dead plants increased from 1.5 to 2.5 % in the
first orchard and from 4.5 to 5.5 % in the second one. The disease usually started from
individual blueberry plants placed inside and/or at the borders of the orchards and developed
in patches.
The dominant species were A. gallica and A. mellea. In each orchard a single species largely
dominated over the other: A. gallica and A. mellea were the most widely distributed species in
eight and five orchards, respectively. A. gallica was identified on blueberry plants, on bark
spread on rows, on bark heaps and on fruit/forest trees at the field margins. A. mellea was found
on blueberries and on fruit trees in the orchard surroundings but not on bark spread on the rows.
No A. ostoyae was identified in infected fields; therefore in the biocontrol efficacy trials only A.
gallica and A. mellea were used.
Experiments carried out on potted blueberry plants showed that T. atroviride SC1 was the
most effective BCA, both against A. gallica and A. mellea. One year after inoculation, it
significantly reduced the percentage of infected plants from 60-80% (untreated controls) to
20% (SC1 treatments). T. harzianum T39 was also effective against A. mellea (Figure 1).
This study demonstrates that highbush blueberry is susceptible to Armillaria root rot and
that infected mulching barks as well as infected roots of old trees can act as a dangerous
inoculum source. T. atroviride SC1 was effective on blueberry plants against A. gallica and A.
mellea and could be applied directly on blueberry roots and/or on mulching barks to prevent
Armillaria infections in the new orchards. Agronomical practices and sanitation procedures
before and after planting (i.e. removal of infected roots and rhizomorphs, inspection and heat
treatment of barks) are also important in order to reduce the risk of infection to young
blueberry plants.
155
100
infected plants (%)
90
A. mellea + BCAs
a
80
70
a
60
a
50
ab
40
30
b
20
ab
b
10
0
100
A. gallica + BCAs
infected plants (%)
90
80
a
70
a
a
60
a
50
a
ab
40
30
b
20
10
0
Untreated
(Armillaria only)
T. harzianum T. harzianum T. atroviride
T22
T39
SC1
P. gigantea
B. subtilis G. catenulatum
BCAs
Figure 1. Percentage of infected blueberry plants after treatment with some biocontrol agents
and artificial inoculation carried out by inserting Armillaria mellea or A. gallica infected
wood pieces between roots. The assesments were done one year after inoculation. The
experiments were carried out on potted plants, under greenhouse controlled conditions.
Different letters indicate significant differences (P≤0.05) according to the Kruskal-Wallis test.
Acknowledgements
The research was supported by Safecrop Centre, funded by Fondo per la ricerca, Autonomous
Province of Trento. Authors thank Y. Elad, Koppert and Verdera for providing the BCAs.
References
Caruso, F.L. 1995: Armillaria root rot. In: Compendium of blueberry and cranberry diseases,
eds. Caruso, F.L. & Ramsdell, D.C. APS Press, St. Paul, USA: 22-23.
Fox, R.T.V. 2000: Armillaria Root Rot: Biology and Control of Honey Fungus. Intercept,
Andover, UK.
La Porta, N., Grillo, R. & Korhonen, K. 2006: Identificazione delle specie di Armillaria in
Trentino ed interazioni tra specie di Armillaria ed Heterobasidion. Proceedings of the
XVI Convegno Nazionale di Micologia, Firenze, Italy, 4-6 December 2006: 33.
Prodorutti, D., Palmieri, L., Gobbin, D. & Pertot I. 2006a: First report of Armillaria gallica on
highbush blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum L.) in Italy. Plant Pathol. 55: 583.
Prodorutti, D., Palmieri, L., Gobbin, D. & Pertot I. 2006b: Armillaria root rot on highbush
156
blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum L.) in North-eastern Italy (Trentino region).
IOBC/WPRS Bull. 29 (9): 75-80.
Prodorutti, D., Vanblaere, T., Gobbin, D., Pellegrini, A., Gessler, C. & Pertot, I. 2009. Genetic
diversity of Armillaria spp. infecting highbush blueberry in northern Italy (Trentino
Region). Phytopathology. 99: 651-658.
157
The Working Group „Integrated Protection of Fruit Crops“is
celebrating its 50th Anniversary
Historic Review by: Ernst F. Boller1, Albert K. Minks2, Jerry V. Cross3, Joop C. van
Lenteren4 & Theo Wildbolz5
1
IOBC archives, c/o Swiss Federal Research Station of Horticulture, Agroscope ACW,
CH-8820 Waedenswil, Switzerland; 2 Nansenstraat 6, NL-6671 BB Zetten, The Netherlands;
3
East Malling Research Station, East Malling, Kent, ME19 6BJ, U.K.;4 Wageningen
University, Laboratory of Entomology, NL-6700 EH Wageningen, The Netherlands;
5
Neugutstr.8, CH-8820 Wädenswil, Switzerland
Abstract: The Working Group looks back at 50 years of successful work. The fruit entomologists are
the pioneers within WPRS with respect to the development of integrated plant protection (IPP) and
integrated production (IP) and their introduction into practice.
Developments occurring during the early 1970s brought a change in the general approach
reflected in the change of name in 1974 from “Integrated control in orchards” to the broader term
“Integrated plant protection in orchards”. A further milestone was the establishment of the holistic
concept of Integrated Production as has been described in the “Message of Ovronnaz” which should
be considered as a historic landmark for IOBC as a whole.
The publications of the WG reflect the broad range of its activities and its important function as
scientific platform for information exchange and joint programs: 13 proceedings of International
Symposia on Integrated Plant Protection and Production in orchards, 14 technical handbooks
(brochures) and 41 WPRS Bulletins covering specific topics of the various subgroups. The first
international symposium organised by the working group took place in Wageningen in 1961 with 36
participants from 9 countries, the most recent symposium was held in Avignon in 2008 with 250
participants and celebrating the 50th anniversary. Hundreds of experts have participated in the WG’s
activities over the past 50 years. The impact of these activities on the development and application of
IPP and IP in practise was and still is significant. Concepts and tools developed by the WG became not
only general WPRS standards but have influenced significantly the international standards for
Integrated Plant Protection. The WG has generated the approach and practical implementation of
Integrated Production in the major crops of the WPRS region.
A summary of important events is given in the following table. The full text of this historic
review is published on the IOBC/WPRS homepage www.iobc-wprs.org
Year
Name of Working
Group (Convenor)
1959
Integrated control in
orchards
(H.J. de Fluiter/NL)
Important events
February: Establishment of WG “Lutte intégrée dans les vergers » in
Wageningen/NL by representatives of The Netherlands, Germany, Switzerland
and France.
1961
First meeting and colloquium on integrated control in orchards at
Wageningen, (NL), 5-9 September.
1963
2nd colloquium at Stuttgart, (D), 11-13. September.
1964
Week of applied research in Saxon (CH) on faunistic monitoring
1965
3rd Symposium at Montreux (CH), 13-15 September.
1968
(H. Steiner/D)
Establisment of WG on “Genetic Control of Carpocapsa & Adoxophyes” (Th.
Wildbolz/CH
J. de Wilde/NL becomes chairman of Commission “Integrated Control”.
158
1969
4th Symposium at Avignon (F), 9 - 12 September.
1973
25 May–1 June. Meeting in Lana (I) with decisions to split WG into SG pome
fruits and SG stone fruits. June: Joint EPPO/IOBC/FAO meeting on IPP
concepts
1974
Integrated plant
protection in orchards
5th Symposium at Bolzano.(I), 3 – 7 September. Establishment of ad hoc
“Commission” on “Guidelines for integrated control” (H. Steiner) as subunit of
the WG (transformed in 1976 to Commission with new topics).
1975
Establishment of WG “Pheromones” (A.K. Minks/NL)
1976
Important meetings on potential IC labels for fruit. Message of Ovronnaz (birth
of the IP concept)
Establishment of ad hoc Commission on “IP endorsement” (M. Baggiolini/CH)
as subunit of WG. WG on “Genetic Control of Carpocapsa & Adoxophyes “
merged with orchard group.
1979
6th Symposium at Vienna, 8-12 October in the frame of the 25th anniversary
celebrations.
1981
Meeting at Colmar: proposal to produce a list of selective pesticides for
orchards. General Assembly at Antibes: The IP Commission becomes
independent of the WG (J.P. Bassino/F & A. Stäubli/CH).
1984
New Subgroup “Pear” (T. X. Nguyen/F)
1985
(E. Dickler/D)
7th Symposium "Integrated Plant Protection in Orchards” at Wageningen, 2629 August . New Subgroup “Diseases” (D.Butt);
1986
New Subgroup “Package-apple” (L.Blommers/NL) recommending choice of
pesticides for IPP.
1988
New Subgroup “Peach” (H. Audemard/F).
1989
New Subgroup “Integrated Fruit Production Guidelines” (E. Dickler /D).
1990
8th International Symposium on Integrated Plant Protection in Orchards at
Gödöllö (H), 31 July 31 - 5 August.
1991
1st edition of “Guidelines for IP of Pome Fruits in Europe”.
1993
(F. Polesny/A)
Transformation of “peach” subgroup into independent WG “Stone fruits”.
2nd edition of pome fruit IP guidelines
1995
3rd International Conference on Integrated Fruit Production at Cedzyna
(PL), 28 August - 2 September.
1996
New Subgroups “Arthropod Pests” (M. Solomon/UK), and “Soft Fruits” (D.
Gajek/PL)
1998
4th International Conference on Integrated Fruit Production (10th
Symposium on Integrated Plant Protection in Orchards) at Leuven (B), 27 July
-1 August. (Joint IOBC-ISHS International Conference).
2000
5th International Conference on Integrated Fruit Production at Lleida
(Spain), 22 - 26 October. 1st edition of Guidelines for IP of Soft Fruits
2001
(J. Cross/UK)
2002
3rd edition of IP guidelines of Pome Fruits.
2003
WG “Stone fruits” (P. Cravedi/I) merged with orchard group.
2004
Integrated protection
of fruit crops
2008
(C. Ioriatti /I)
6th International Conference on Integrated Fruit Production at Baselga di
Piné (I), 26 - 30 September.
7th International Conference on Integrated Fruit Production at Avignon (F),
26 - 30 October.
159
Peach orchard management strategies: aphid communities as a case
study
Servane Penvern1, Stéphane Bellon1, Joël Fauriel1, Benoît Sauphanor2
1 Ecodéveloppement, INRA, Site Agroparc Cedex 9, 84914 Avignon, France, 2 Plantes et
Systèmes de culture Horticoles, INRA, Site Agroparc Cedex 9, 84914 Avignon, France
Abstract: Because of the various negative side effects of intensive chemical pest control practices,
there is a shift in horticulture towards the adoption of alternative approaches for crop protection. In
order to characterise and evaluate management strategies being used, we carried out comprehensive
interviews to obtain details of the peach orchard protection schedules of 20 organic and conventional
fruit farms in south-eastern France. It appeared that besides the regular use of direct control, farmers
also used cultural and/or alternative methods and indicators to optimize their orchard management.
Combining the latter methods with IOBC’s technical guidelines for plant protection, four strategies
have been identified. Their efficacy on aphid communities was then evaluated through visual
monitoring of aphids and of beneficial populations at plot level. Brachycaudus persicae and Myzus
varians were the most frequent species. The two most efficient strategies were dominated by chemical
treatments, whereas the two others, less detrimental to aphid antagonists, were predominantly used by
organic farmers and in agreement with IOBC’s guidelines. Variations in aphid communities could be
explained by: (i) the use of efficient and therefore toxic products, correlated with low infestations and
low abundance and diversity of antagonists; (ii) the link between pre-blooming treatments, cultural
and alternative methods (as weed strips management and manual pruning of infested branches) and
high populations of aphid communities. Against all expectations, such communities were neither
related with kaolin applications, nor with management of vigour and nearby environment. According
to the literature, the strategies identified can be interpreted as steps towards a redesign of orchards’
protection.
Aphid, community, Antagonist, Peach orchard, Integrated pest management, Crop protection, Organic
production
160
Adapting to New Management Strategies for Cherry Fruit Flies in
British Columbia, Canada
Howard Thistlewood*, Noubar Bostanian, Sue Senger, Naomi DeLury*
*Pacific Agri-Food Research Centre, Agriculture & Agri-Food Canada, PO Box 5000,
Summerland, B.C., V0H 1Z0, Canada; Horticulture Research and Development Centre
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, 430 Gouin Blvd., St. Jean-sur-Richelieu, Quebec, J3B
3E6, Canada; Landscope Consulting Corp., PO Box 198, Lillooet, B.C., V0K 1V0 Canada
Abstract: The western and black cherry fruit flies (CFF), Rhagoletis indifferens and R. fausta, are
serious risks to production of sweet cherries Prunus avium in British Columbia and Canada, particularly
to late-season or high-value export crops with zero tolerance for pest infestation. The availability of new
reduced risk chemicals and of “soft” formulations, such as GF-120® NF Naturalyte® Fruit Fly Bait, has
led to adaptations and changes in several aspects of crop protection. At the same time, there is interest in
the development of an area-wide program using “soft” techniques. Information is being gathered from
commercial and organic orchards, private gardens, and abandoned sites within the mixed urban-rural
landscapes that are common in Canada. We present some recent results from experiments and
experiences of fruit-growers. These include the compatibility of reduced risk pesticides with the key
predatory mites of fruit-growing in western and eastern Canada, of the use of GF120 Fruit Fly Bait, the
importance of alternate host plants, and new knowledge of CFF flight and movement.
Key words: IPM, cherry fruit fly, insecticide, control strategy, bait, phytotoxicity, movement, non-target
Introduction
The movement of western cherry fruit fly, Rhagoletis indifferens Curran (Diptera: Tephritidae)
and black cherry fruit fly, R. fausta (Osten Sacken) (Diptera: Tephritidae) from native hosts
onto cherries occurred recently in British Columbia (B.C.): changes in host range and species
distribution were observed in the 1960s. Control by organo-phosphate insecticides, primarily
dimethoate, was implemented sucessfully. However, by 1999, crop protection from cherry
fruit flies was the major challenge of cherry-growers. In 2001, packing houses and agencies
reported record levels of damage at harvest. Management of a cherry fruit fly complex
(Rhagoletis species) was by then a challenge world-wide, owing in large part to the
withdrawal of most organophosphate and carbamate insecticides. Also, major changes in
cherry-growing have occurred in western Canada including an emphasis on high-value export
crops, aided by the introduction of varieties with late season harvest dates, and causing a shift
in land use from apple or pear.
In response to similar changes, governments across North America and Europe restarted
research on cherry fruit flies from approximately 2001. At that time, the control techniques
were for (a) organic growers to avoid the insect by having very early cultivars and pick them
before the insects become apparent, sometimes combined with mass trapping with yellow
sticky traps; or (b) conventional growers to apply “old-generation” insecticides against adults
or larvae. Western Canadian growers, in particular, are export-oriented and because of
quarantine restrictions, there is a critical need for management techniques which are
acceptable to the international marketplace. The success of the B.C. industry is founded upon
the development of increasingly late-maturing cultivars, so early picking is impossible;
average picking dates of new varieties have increased from early July to mid-August.
161
Insecticide use is thereby complicated by the need for frequent entry into small orchards for
picking. Also, the existence of an area-wide management program (Thistlewood & Judd
2003) for the key pest of pome fruit, Cydia pomonella, has aroused interest for fruit flies.
Since 2002, we conducted research to enable area-wide management of these flies in
many habitats, not only commercial orchards. The studies have covered key aspects of use of
novel “reduced-risk” insecticides and GF-120 Naturalyte bait spray, or biology and flight of
fruit flies. As significant differences now exist between European and North American
industries, we describe below some of our results and the grower experience to date.
Related Studies
Compatibility of new insecticides with mite predator
In Canada, information about the effect on beneficial species of pesticides is not required for
registration and is often absent. The western predatory mite Galendromus occidentalis
(Nesbitt) is the main predator of spider mites in dry parts of B.C. Since 1968, crop protection
has been based on the selective use of pesticides that are relatively harmless to this predator.
We are conducting laboratory studies to examine the toxicity of new compounds and report on
seven to date: imidacloprid (Admire 240), thiacloprid (Calypso 480SC), acetamiprid (Assail
70WP), methoxyfenozide (Intrepid 240F), spinosad (Tracer 44.2%), thiamethoxam (Actara
25WG) and the acaricide spirodiclofen (Envidor 240SC). We compared different types of
toxic effects using various bioassays (Bostanian et al. 2009).
Of four neonicotinoids evaluated, acetamiprid and imidacloprid were rated as extremely
toxic to adult predators. The label rate of acetamiprid was 5.6-fold the LC50, the estimated
concentration that killed 50% of the population. Imidacloprid was even more toxic with a
label rate 10.3-fold the estimated LC50 value. By contrast, two other neonicotinoids,
thiamethoxam and thiacloprid, as well as spirodiclofen, methoxyfenozide, and spinosad, were
rated as harmless to adults. When we examined the effect on reproduction and egg-laying of
female predators, we noted again that acetamiprid and imidacloprid were toxic, whereas no
effect on egg-laying was obvious within 3 days after treatment with the other five pesticides.
None of the seven new pesticides were toxic to freshly laid eggs within 6 days after treatment.
An important aspect of modern pesticides can be their repellency, causing predators to avoid
treated surfaces. We found imidacloprid, acetamiprid and thiacloprid to be highly repellent,
thiamethoxam and spinosad slightly repellent, and spirodiclofen and methoxyfenozide to be
non-repellent (Bostanian et al. 2009).
Compatibility of new fungicides with mite predator
We also examined in the laboratory (Bostanian et al. 2008) the impact of seven fungicides on
G. occidentalis: microscopic sulphur 92WP, fenbuconazole (Indar 75WSP), boscalid (Lance
70WDG), fenhexamid (Elevate 50WDG), pyraclostrobin (Cabrio F500), propiconazole
(Topas 250E) and myclobutanil (Nova 40W). Using recommended label rates of each product
and a water control, we examined their effects on adults and on immature stages, on female
egg-laying, and on the number of treated eggs that hatch successfully. We used the “worst
possible” conditions and applied each material to leaves containing all stages of the predatory
mite and its prey, spider mites (Bostanian et al. 2008).
The synthetic fungicides fenbuconazole, propiconazole, and myclobutanil, are triazoles
that work on a biochemical pathway that is not common in the animal kingdom. The mortality
of eggs, larvae, and adult stages of predators within six days after treatment with them was no
greater than with distilled water (1-7% by stage). The other three synthetic fungicides all act
differently on fungi but were similar in causing no greater mortality of eggs, larvae, and adult
stages of predators than distilled water. By contrast, microscopic sulphur (92%WP) was
162
relatively harmless to eggs and adults, but killed 72.4% of the young larvae within six days,
which would cause plant-feeding mites to increase very significantly. When we examined the
effect on egg-laying of female predators, we found that none of the products significantly
increased or reduced the numbers of eggs laid for three days after treatment, compared with a
distilled water spray (Bostanian et al. 2008).
Observations on bait spray use and improvements
GF-120 Naturalyte bait spray was developed originally for tropical flies (e.g., Moreno &
Mangan 2002), and the combination of a bait matrix and insecticide is unusual for temperate
fruit orchards. It was tested on cherry in western Canada by growers and researchers in 2005
and permitted for commercial use since 2006.
In 2005, it was noted in every study that the first bait application must be earlier than
expected. Generally, some growers had difficulty in adjusting to reapplication of the material
after each rain-fall, which is critical. However, the application of bait sprays for fruit fly
control has become widespread. Application is usually by a low-pressure modified herbicide
sprayer mounted on an all-terrain vehicle, emitting two streams of 4-6 mm droplets of a 4:1
mixture of water to bait concentrate, at 1-2.5 L per hectare (described by Smith 2009). It is
fast, often 20 minutes per hectare, or seven-fold that of a typical orchard sprayer. Grower
reports and research studies have shown control to be near 100% in formerly “clean”
orchards, and typically 95% or more in gardens or single trees when applied by hand.
As expected, the movement of flies from extra-orchard hosts into fruit trees is important.
By 2008, growers reported concern with the importance of sources of flies outside orchards
and some damage that was being observed at orchard edges, where fertile flies were active
and lay eggs. By contrast, a prediction of increased injury from other insects has not yet been
noticed, despite the relatively selective nature of the bait spray, and although likely pests (e.g.
Grapholitha packardi) are found adjacent to some orchards.
Our research has examined the best placement of a small amount of material within trees
relative to fly activity, and phytotoxicity and leaf-feeding that was observed at the bait
droplets. DeLury et al. (2009) tested six sweet cherry cultivars with GF-120 containing
spinosad (0.2 g L−1 spinosad bait) or without it (blank bait). Spinosad bait and blank bait did
not differ significantly with respect to damage observed. Leaf damage was found almost
exclusively on the undersides of leaves at the doses (0, 17, 20, 25 or 40%) and cultivars
tested. The effects of the bait on lower leaf surfaces increased from 24 to 168 h, and with
dose, in terms of the proportion of droplets (0, 0.4, 0.5, 0.75 or 0.94) and area (0, 18.7, 23.5,
40.5 or 91.6 mm) burned. In addition, chlorophyll level was reduced with increasing dose on
undersides of leaves, but not on upper surfaces. The chlorophyll level in undamaged leaves
(upper surfaces) differed by cultivar. Cherry leaves were less damaged by a 20% bait
application in June (0.26) than in July (0.46) and August (0.50). Incidental insect leaf feeding
at bait locations occurred at a low rate and was highest on lower leaf surfaces.
Host plants
Many unmanaged trees occur in fruit-growing areas of the B.C. interior. Surveys enabled us to
evaluate the importance of wild hosts, abandoned orchards, and unmanaged trees. We visited 30
sites from May to September of 2002 and 2003, and an additional 40 sites in more remote
locations in 2004. In all years, yellow sticky card traps (Pherotech Inc., Delta, B.C., Canada)
with ammonium carbonate lures were hung by hand, as high as possible from the ground or
using a two-step ladder, in suitable host trees. Beginning in 2003, some sites also received a
matching Rebell trap (Andermatt Biocontrol, 6146 Grossdietwil, CH) with ammonium carbonate
lure. Larvae were collected from fruit or berries, permitted to pupate into sand, and pupae reared
in subsequent years for identification of species and any parasitoids.
163
Both R. indifferens and R. fausta were caught on traps around pin cherry Prunus
pensylvanica and bitter cherry Prunus emarginata. Pin Cherry was always associated with R.
fausta, and in fruit collections was host to proportionally more R. fausta than was Bitter
Cherry, but both were very suitable reproductive hosts for R. indifferens. About half of the
Mahaleb cherry, Prunus mahaleb, sites were reproductive hosts of R. indifferens. By contrast,
numerous R. indifferens were found on traps inside the plant canopies of Red and Black
Chokecherry, Prunus virginiana, but these were rarely (1 of >20 samples) reproductive hosts.
Movement of flies
Flight is the main dispersal method in R. indifferens, but the movement of these flies between
hosts is difficult to quantify in the field. Two of us (Thistlewood, Senger, unpublished) have
measured the movement and dispersal of R. indifferens in and around fruit orchards. One
series of studies (Thistlewood, unpublished) used a grid of 28 yellow sticky traps placed
across an area of mixed land use from 2002-2004 and monitored weekly each growing
season. It revealed that R. indifferens flies moved regularly but at relatively low numbers over
distances of approx. 200m. The flies moved more readily through contiguous orchard blocks
of different fruits than across open spaces. In apple blocks to the South of an infested cherry
orchard, about 26% of flies were found 10-20m away, and 3% about 75 m away, compared
with 0.9% the same distance away from the cherry orchard but across an open area. However,
a 5m roadway was no barrier to significant fly movement. Simultaneous mark-releaserecapture (Thistlewood, unpublished) of flies occurred from two release sites placed in an
open area and in a young cherry block. We found that flies (15% of those released) were
recaptured in cherry orchards within two days at up to 150m from both of the release sites. In
other orchards, R. indifferens was captured on yellow sticky traps that were within the canopy
of apple and peach trees located 140m from the nearest cherry trees, but not captured on traps
placed above and below the canopy of those trees.
A tethered flight mill system was used in the laboratory to examine the flight behaviour
of sexually mature flies exposed to different levels of conspecific contact and resource
availability (Senger et al. 2007). A 2×2×3 factorial experiment compared the relative
influence of the factors ‘context’ (crowded, isolated), ‘sex’ (female, male), and ‘resources’
(low = food only; medium = food + leaf; high = food + leaf + cherries) on flight performance
including distance flown, net trial time, and stopping patterns. Of 160 flies tested, 86.9% flew
<500 m on the flight mill. Individuals from both sexes were capable of maximum flights of
ca. 3 km. Distance flown was significantly influenced by ‘context’ such that crowded
individuals flew >1.5-fold farther than isolated individuals. Sex influenced the frequency and
duration of stops made, with females stopping more often and longer than males. Although
females and males in high resource treatments had the shortest net trial times, the factor
‘resources’ did not produce any highly significant main effects, but did generate significant
interaction terms with the factors ‘context’ and ‘sex’, suggesting that past experience with
‘resources’ modifies individual flight behaviour. Senger et al. (2007) showed using a flight
mill that R. indifferens flight behaviour is context dependent and sensitive to adult crowding.
The implications for dispersal are discussed further in Senger et al. 2007. In a related study,
Senger et al. (2008), showed how R. indifferens females can develop their egg load in
response to host availability. Egg counts varied significantly with ‘crowded’ females and
those in the ‘cherry’ resource treatments producing the most mature eggs. Although the
average mature egg count for females from the ‘leaf ’ and ‘food’ resource treatments was
similar, these two groups differed in the proportion of females that produced no mature eggs
at all. They concluded that the effect of social interactions and resources on the maturation of
eggs is additive in R. indifferens, and that egg load may trade off with dispersal ability in R.
indifferens.
164
Discussion
The removal of most organophosphate and carbamate insecticides from the market, and
changes in cherry-growing practices, are leading to the rapid adoption of new materials and
methods in western Canada. Novel pesticides are undergoing some local evaluations in
laboratory and field trials. The insecticide study by Bostanian et al. (2009) suggests that
spinosad and methoxyfenozide may be used in IPM programs without concern. Thiacloprid,
thiamethoxam and spirodiclofen should be evaluated by growers and advisors in the field for
their effects before being used generally in an IPM program. They did not recommend the use
of imidacloprid or acetamiprid. Unfortunately, results from the limited field evaluations of the
latter have been contradictory to date, under our conditions.
The fungicide study of Bostanian et al. (2008) concluded that, from a grower perspective,
none of the seven fungicides were harmful to the adult stage of predators, nor affected
significantly their egg production, nor egg hatch. Although the larvae (young stages) were
unaffected by the six new synthetic products, microscopic sulphur was lethal. Bostanian et al.
concluded that use of sulphur should be avoided in favour of less toxic alternatives in order to
conserve predatory mites. This finding agrees with several studies, e.g. Prischmann et al.
(2005) which recommended that sulphur be replaced by less toxic fungicides in wine grapes
and other perennial crops so as to avoid mite outbreaks. Bostanian et al. (2008)concluded that,
apart from microscopic sulphur, the other six materials (fenbuconazole, boscalid, fenhexamid,
pyraclostrobin, propiconazole and myclobutanil) appear to be a good fit for IPM programs
where the western predatory mite is an important predator of leaf-feeding mites. The studies
were conducted with a predator population from the interior of B.C., and experience shows
that the location of the orchard and historical pest management practices can have an effect on
the predatory mite population and the outcome of any control program. Therefore, these
reports are more of a guide when developing pest management strategies rather than a
recommendation for all Canadian regions
The widespread and generally successful introduction of the Naturalyte GF120 bait
formulation of spinosad was enabled by earlier work conducted in the USA. Thistlewood
(unpub.) more commonly trapped and observed flies in the upper parts of the canopy than
elsewhere within, above, or below, the canopy. One conclusion is to apply the relatively small
amounts of bait materials as high up the tree as possible. DeLury et al. (2009) concluded that
application to the upper leaf surface, or at doses of ≤20%, will minimize leaf phytotoxicity.
Unmanaged cherry trees are common in the B.C. interior, and a problem for area-wide
management programs because of emigration of fertile flies each year, However, growers are
familiar with these trees and they can be located, mapped, and removed or treated as required.
Surveys revealed the relative importance of other species of concern. Mahaleb cherry, P.
mahaleb, is a reproductive host of R. indifferens, but in the arid interior of B.C. this bush is
often un-noticed by fruit-growers. By contrast, although numerous R. indifferens are found on
bushes of Red and Black Chokecherry, P. virginiana, the latter were rarely a reproductive host.
Research is continuing into the flight and movement of Rhagoletis species attacking
cherry in B.C. Better knowledge of fly dispersal and movement leads to understanding of the
risk posed by urban or abandoned trees in the mixed land use areas found in fruit-growing
areas. From trap catches, it appears that relatively small numbers of flies moved long
distances every year out of the cherry trees and throughout the entire area of mixed land use.
When released in an open area (centre of alfalfa field) with no immediate fruit trees nearby, as
might happen the year following removal of a cherry tree, flies moved quickly into the main
cherry block or smaller groups of cherry trees. Small numbers of R. indifferens can be
expected to fly at least 150m in any given season and there is no evidence that a line of flight
distance of 250m would be a barrier to establishment of small populations. Even such a short
165
distance causes difficulty in B.C., requiring treatment of many cherry trees and abandoned
sites. In other fruit trees, flies were captured only within the canopy. In general, the flies
appeared to move more easily through contiguous fruit tree canopies than across open spaces.
Acknowledgements
We thank Gaétan Racette for technical assistance, Heidrun Vogt for many discussions in our
Germany-Canada collaboration, and the Pesticide Risk Reduction and Minor Use Programme,
Pest Management Centre of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, for additional funding.
References
Bostanian, N.J., Thistlewood, H.M.A., Hardman, J.M., & Racette G. 2008. Toxicity of six novel
fungicides and sulphur to Galendromus occidentalis (Acari: Phytoseiidae). Experimental &
Applied Acarology. DOI 10.1007/s10493-008-9191-5
Bostanian, N.J., Thistlewood, H.M.A., Hardman, J.M., Laurin, M.-C., & Racette G.. 2009. Effect
of seven new orchard pesticides on Galendromus occidentalis in laboratory studies. Pest
Management Science. In Press.
DeLury, N.C., Thistlewood, H.M.A., & Routledge, R. 2009. Phytotoxicity of GF-120® NF
Naturalyte® Fruit Fly Bait Carrier on Sweet Cherry (Prunus avium L.) Foliage. Pest
Management Science. 65 (1): 52-59
Dow AgroSciences. 2006. Facts on GF-120 NF Naturalyte fruit fly bait: high-performance,
highly attractive bait for cherry fruit flies – OMRI registered. Dow AgroSciences Technical
Bulletin 0506–2703
Moreno, D.S. & Mangan, R.L. 2002. A bait matrix for reduced-risk insecticides used against fruit
flies (Diptera: Tephritidae). In: Invasive Arthropods in Agriculture, eds. Hallman and
Schwalbe: 333–362
Prischmann, D.A., James, D.G., Wright, L.C., Teneyck, R.D. & Snyder, W.E. 2005. Effects of
chlorpyrifos and sulfur on spider mites (Acari: Tetranychidae) and their natural enemies.
Biol. Control 33:324–334
Senger, S.E., Roitberg, B.D. & Thistlewood, H.M.A. 2007 Relative flight performance of
Rhagoletis indifferens (Diptera: Tephritidae): influence of crowding, sex and resources.
Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata. 123: 91-100.
Senger, S., Roitberg, B. D., & Thistlewood H.M.A. 2008. Ovarian response to host cues in
female Rhagoletis indifferens (Diptera: Tephritidae). Entomologia Experimentalis et
Applicata 129 (1): 26-31
Smith, T.J. 2009 (last access). Bait application. Chelan County Extension Office, Washington
State University, WA, USA http://www.ncw.wsu.edu/treefruit/BAITAPPLICATION.htm
Thistlewood, H. & Judd, G. 2003. Area-wide management of codling moth, Cydia pomonella, at
very low densities. Integrated Plant Protection in Fruit Crops “Arthropod Pests”. IOBC/
wprs Bulletin 26 (11): 103-109
166
Plant protection in organic apple production of two North Spanish
regions
Mariano Vilajeliu1, Adriana Escudero1, Pere Vilardell1, Lluís Batllori2, Simó Alegre3,
Georgina Alins3, Mª Dolores Blázquez4, Marcos Miñarro4, Enrique Dapena4
(1) IRTA - Estació Experimental Agrícola Mas Badia, Canet de la Tallada, 17134 La Tallada
d’Empordà, Girona; mariano.vilajeliu@irta.cat, adriana.escudero@irta.cat,
pere.vilardell@irta.cat.
(2) Servei de Sanitat Vegetal, DAR, Aiguamolls de l’Empordà, 17486 Castelló d’Empúries,
Girona; lluis.batllori@irta.cat. (3) IRTA-Estació Experimental de Lleida, Avinguda Alcalde
Rovira Roure, 191, 25198 Lleida; simo.alegre@irta.cat, georgina.alins@irta.cat. (4) Servicio
Regional de Investigación y Desarrollo Agroalimentario (SERIDA), Apdo. 13, 33300
Villaviciosa, Asturias; mdblazquez@serida.org, mmiñarro@serida.org, edapena@serida.org
Abstract. Researchers of two Spanish research institutes, IRTA in Catalonia (North-East region with
Mediterranean climate) and SERIDA in Asturias (North-West region with Atlantic climate) have been
working in collaboration on projects involving organic apple production since 2002, with the aim of
finding optimum production methods. In this paper, trials for the control of apple scab (Venturia
inaequalis (Cke.) Wint.), rosy apple aphid ((Dysaphis plantaginea Pass.) (Homoptera: Aphididae)) and
codling moth ((Cydia pomonella L.) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae)) are described. These common pest
species were successfully controlled by products and methods allowed by the European organic rules
(EC 834/2007).
Key-words: organic apple, plant protection, apple scab, rosy apple aphid, codling moth.
Introduction
Between 1995 and 2007 there was a significant increase in the size and number of operators
engaged in organic farming throughout the European Union (Willer and Jussefi, 2007). At
present, Spain is the second country of the European Union in organic acreage (988,923
hectares), but organic fruit growing occurred on a very small scale mainly due to the scarcity
and dispersion of information (Descombres et al., 2006) and technical difficulties such as:
knowledge of resistant cultivars; thinning; fertilization; weed control, and, pest and disease
management. Since 2002, two Spanish research institutes, IRTA (Catalonia) and SERIDA
(Asturias), have joined forces and combined their expertise to provide more effective research
aimed at furthering the development of organic apple farming.
Materials and methods
The potentially harmful agents most likely to affect apple production include the pathogenic
micro-organism Venturia inaequalis (Cke.) Wint., which causes apple scab, and two insect
pests: the rosy apple aphid (Dysaphis plantaginea (Passerini)) and the codling moth (Cydia
pomonella (L.) which both cause direct damage to the fruit. Several experiments took place
between 2001 and 2008 and were located in either Catalonia (IRTA-Mas Badia en Girona; or
IRTA-EE Lleida en Lleida) or Asturias.
167
Apple scab
In 2004, trials were conducted in Asturias, using the cultivars ‘Reineta Encarnada’ (RE) and
‘Reineta Blanca de Canada’ (RBC) to explore alternatives to copper for controlling apple
scab: (i) lime sulphur (Luqsa S.A.) at 2%, the clays (ii) Mycosan (Andermatt Biocontrol) at
0.8% with the pine oil Nufilm-17 (Agrichem) at 0.1 %, (iii) Mycosin (Andermatt Biocontrol)
at 0.5% together with wettable sulphur (Bayer 80% pp, at 0.4%) and Nufilm-17 (0.1%) and
(iv) B-Ulmasub (0.5%) with wettable sulphur (0.4%) and Nufilm-17 (0.1%). In 2007-08,
trials were carried out in microplots at the IRTA-Mas Badia (Girona) on the cultivar
Brookfield Gala with a copper salt Kdos (DuPont) at 2 kg / ha and lime sulphur (Sulfoluq
(Luqsa)) at a dose of 10 l/ha.
Rosy apple aphid
At SERIDA, the effectiveness and optimal application time of various neem-based botanical
insecticides were evaluated,. At IRTA-EE Lleida, trials were aimed preventing the autumn
colonization with two strategies: (i) alteration of the recognition of the host plant (defoliation,
garlic extract and kaolin sprayings) and (ii) reducing or eliminating oviparous females
(potassium soap and pyrethrum sprayings).
Codling moth
Trials aimed at reducing infestation and consisted of applying bioinsecticides such as the
codling moth granulosis virus (CpGv) or products allowed in Organic Farming, alone or in
combination with mating disruption methods.
Results and discussion
Apple scab
In Asturias, damage in the untreated plots reached the 30.7% of the leaves in RE and 11.2% in
RBC. Damage was drastically reduced by the application of Mycosan (1.1%), lime sulphur
(2.2%), Mycosin (3.3%) and Ulmasub-B (5.6%). In IRTA-Mas Badia (2007), the lowest
incidence of pre-harvest lesions was obtained using copper hydroxide (6.5% affected leaves
and no lesions to the fruits) and lime sulphur (13.5% affected leaves and 0.3% of the fruits)
while in the control, 20% of leaves and 2.1% of the fruit presented symptoms. Similar results
were obtained in the 2008 trial.
D3
E2 / H
E2
H/I
H
Control
D3 / E2
Damage level (0-5)
2,5
b
2,0
b
b
1,5
1,0
a
a
a
a
0,5
28
/0
5
21
/0
5
14
/0
5
07
/0
5
30
/0
4
23
/0
4
16
/0
4
09
/0
4
0,0
Figure 1. Effective control of damage by the rosy apple aphid observed in Asturias, with
single and double applications of NeemAzal-T/S in different phenological stages. (D3/E2: one
application in D3 and another in E2; E2/H: one application in E2 and another in H; H/I: one
168
application in H and another in I).
Rosy apple aphid
Of the seven products tested in Asturias, only NeemAzal-T/S (Trifolio-M GmbH) was
effective. In our study, it proved very effective when applied in preflowering (phenological
stages D3 and E2), whereas efficacy was reduced significantly when applied after flowering
(Figure 1). In some trials, there was good aphid control with a single application.
With regard to treatments designed to alter the insects’ recognition of the apple trees,
only defoliation prevented the colonization of the host plant in the fall and the resulting
infestation during the following spring (Figure 2). As for treatments aimed at reducing
colonization, potassium soap application in no case controlled spring infestations. In contrast,
the pyrethrum significantly reduced colonization in autumn in each of the three years studied.
100
20
D(1)
Population density
(% shoots with viviparous)
Population density
(% shoots with oviparous)
D(1) Autumn 2005
T ab
15
A a
C cd
10
S bc
P cd
D d
5
0
15-10
25-10
4-11
15-11
25-11
5-12
15-12
Date (dd-mm)
80
Spring 2006
T a
A a
60
C a
S a
40
P b
D b
20
0
15-3
30-3
14-4
30-4 15-5 31-5
Date (dd-mm)
15-6
30-6
Figure 2. Population density of the rosy apple aphid (% of apple tree leaves occupied by
oviparous (autumn 2005) and viviparous (spring 2006)). D(1) indicates the mean separation
after the analysis of repeated measurements in time. Treatments followed by the same letter
are not significantly different according to Duncan's Multiple Range Test (p< 0.05). In the top
line of the autumn graph, c indicates when kaolin and garlic extract was applied, while •
indicates when potassium soap and pyrethrum were sprayed. T: Control group, A: garlic
extract, C: kaolin, S: potassium soap Q: pyrethrum, D: defoliation.
Codling moth
In Asturias, with six to eight applications of two trademarked granulovirus, Madex
(Andermatt Biocontrol) and Carpovirusine (Arysta, formerly Calliope) succeeded in lowering
the percentage of infested fruit from 25% to less than 2%. The method of mating disruption as
the basic defence, coupled with initial applications of granulovirus, gave similar results. In
Girona, efficacy trials were carried out in microplots with granulovirus (Madex) and Spinosad
(Spintor 48, Dow AgroSciences); at the end of the first generation Spinosad had significantly
greater capacity to control codling moth compared to CpGV and the control.
In terms of plant health protection in apple orchards, ecological management is achieving
a satisfactory degree of control of diseases and pests for production of commercial varieties.
After several years of tests, we can conclude that preventive applications of lime sulphur, clay
and copper derivatives, either in sequence or in repetition in each case, has proved effective in
controlling apple scab in susceptible varieties (bearing in mind the incompatibility of lime
sulphur with mineral oils and the negative side effects of applying copper salts in those
varieties susceptible to russeting, a physiological disorder). Preflowering applications of
169
NeemAzal-T/S were effective in controlling rosy apple aphids. For the control of the codling
moth, mating disruption is considered sufficient when the pressure of infestation is low, but
should be reinforced with aptly timed treatment by CpGV or, in areas where infestation
pressure is high, by Spinosad. Using only CpGv was also, on occasions, effective in
controlling codling moth infestation.
Acknowledgments
Most of the work presented here was carried out with the framework of the following
projects: INIA RTA-2006-00156, INIA RTA02-050, FICYT PC04-056 and Interreg IIIa -I3A5-222-E CEPROPAE.
References
Descombres, C.A.; Madaula, F.; Martínez, I.; Maynou, M.; Pérez, X.; Pujol, M.. 2006: Llibre
blanc de la producció agroalimentària ecològica a Catalunya. [White Paper on
Ecological Agrofood production] Departament d’Agricultura, Ramaderia i pesca de la
Generalitat de Catalunya.
Willer, H. and Yussefi, M. 2007: The World of Organic Agriculture. Statistics and Emergings
Trends 2007. IFOAM & FiBL. Rolandsecker, pp. 251.
170
Field efficacy of slaked lime against European fruit tree canker and
introduction into practice
Bart Heijne1, Peter Frans de Jong1, Pieter Jans Jansonius2
1 Wageningen UR/Applied Plant Research (PPO), P.O. Box 200, 6670 AE Zetten, The
Netherlands; 2 Louis Bolk Institute, Hoofdstraat 24, 3972 LA Driebergen, The Netherlands
Abstract: Fruit tree canker, caused by Nectria galligena, is an increasing problem in fruit growing
areas with wet periods during the leaf fall period. Several effective fungicides against the disease, such
as benzimidazoles, will be banned in future in Europe. There is an urgent need for environmentally
friendly solutions for this disease. Several field experiments were done to determine the efficacy of
slaked lime (calcium hydroxide) against European fruit tree canker. Pieces of wood with sporulating
canker were suspended in the top of trees during leaf fall to secure a high inoculum pressure. Infection
was through natural wounds like leaf scars and no artificial wounds were made. Newly formed cankers
were counted in the following spring. Three spray applications of 100 kg/ha slaked lime at 10, 50 and
90 % leaf fall reduced the number of newly formed cankers by 57 % compared to untreated plots. The
number of newly formed cankers was reduced by 60 % when 50 kg/ha of slaked lime was applied in a
comparable experiment in the following year. A comparison between 25, 50 and 100 kg/ha of slaked
lime resulted in a reduction of 34, 53, 37 % of newly formed cankers. Slaked lime was applied through
the overhead sprinkler system in experiments at commercial growers’ sites. The average efficacy was
60 and 62 % in two years respectively. Further demonstrations resulted in the regular use of slaked
lime by commercial growers.
Calcium hydroxide, Fruit tree canker, Nectria galligena, Slaked lime
171
Relation of duration of wet period and number of Nectria cankers for
leaf scars and pruning wounds during the summer
Peter Frans de Jong1, Adrie Boshuizen2, Marcel Wenneker1
1 Wageningen-UR, Applied Plant Research, Lingewal 1, 6668 LA Randwijk, P.O. Box 200,
6670 AE Zetten, the Netherlands; 2 Bodata, AgroBussinesspark 42, P.O. Box 592, 6700 AN,
Wageningen, the Netherlands
Abstract: Fruit Tree Canker (Nectria galligena Bres.) is an important fungal disease in apple (Malus
X domestica Borkh) in the Netherlands. The fungus causes cankers on the shoots, main branches and
trunks of apple trees. It takes a lot of effort to control the disease and when infection takes place whole
trees can be lost especially when they are young. This makes the pathogen a problem not only for fruit
growers but also for fruit tree nurseries. Some of the most effective fungicides no longer permitted in
the Netherlands. Therefore, interest from fruit tree growers is increasing for a warning system to
optimize the use of the remaining less effective fungicides. This model should be used during the
whole year because on several occasions wounds are made. To build this model data about the
infection conditions are needed. Detailed information of these conditions during the summer is
lacking. Therefore an experiment was done with potted trees in the summer. To investigate a possible
difference in susceptibility, two types of wounds were made, a pruning wound and a leaf scar. Trees
received different length of wet periods at 20°C after inoculation with N. galligena spores. It was
found that no wet period was needed to get a successful infection in the summer. Also no relation
between the duration of the wet period and the amount of canker formation was found. Finally, it was
found that pruning wounds were more susceptible than leaf scars in summer.
Warning system, Nectria galligena, Apple, Fruit
172
Detection of latent infections of fruit tree canker (Nectria galligena) in
planting material of apple
Marcel Wenneker, Nina Joosten
Applied Plant Research, Wageningen University & Research Centre, P.O. Box 200, 6670 AE
Zetten, the Netherlands
Abstract: Fruit tree canker (Nectria galligena) is a serious problem in (organic) apple production.
Infections cause direct loss of yield by damage to productive shoots and branches, often leading to tree
death. Control measures are applied to protect infection sites, notably leaf scars from external inocula.
Young apple trees can be infected symptomlessly during propagation (latent infections). A test was
developed for screening young apple trees from tree nurseries for latent infection by fruit tree canker
caused by Nectria galligena, prior to planting in the orchard. Under specific conditions (high
temperature and relative humidity) it was possible to induce symptoms in infected planting material
within 8 weeks. Tests were performed with artificial inoculations to determine the sensitivity of the
test. Screening of commercial planting lots with the newly developed method revealed infection
incidences that were higher than recorded after planting in the orchard. The developed method is
suitable for screening apple planting material for fruit tree canker infections before planting. The
method also detects infections that initially stay latent under field conditions. The method seems valid
to screen organically and conventional apple trees. However, the method is destructive; therefore an
adequate sampling strategy needs to be developed.
Apple canker, Propagation material, Disease control, Screening method
173
Development of semiochemical attractants, lures and traps for
raspberry beetle, Byturus tomentosus at SCRI; from fundamental
chemical ecology to testing IPM tools with growers
Nicholas Birch, Stuart Gordon, Tom Shepherd, Wynne Griffiths, Graham Robertson,
Trefor Woodford, Rex Brennan
SCRI, Invergowrie, Dundee, DD2 5DA
Abstract: Raspberry beetle adults are attracted to flowers of their hosts primarily by colour and odour
(floral volatiles). SCRI scientists have investigated this chemical ecology interaction for several years,
using a multi-disciplinary approach involving phytochemistry, insect behaviour, and GC-EAG
electrophysiology. We will present a historical overview, explaining how these techniques have
allowed us to identify the key flower attractants from a complex mixture of volatiles emitted by
raspberry flowers. We will then go on to explain how recent (EU-CRAFT, Horticulture Development
Council) and current (Defra HortLINK) work has progressed the optimization of raspberry beetle traps
for U.K. growers needing IPM solutions due to demands for zero pesticide residue levels on fruit. We
will explain how we are developing and testing slow release lures and different trap designs, together
with collaborators at East Malling Research, Natural Resources Institute, AgriSense Ltd and also with
Norwegian scientists, testing prototype traps on organic soft fruit farms.
Key words: raspberry beetle, trapping, host attractant, semiochemicals, IPM
Introduction
The raspberry beetle, Byturus tomentosus (Degeer) causes severe damage to raspberries by
both the adults (which feed on buds and flowers) and by larvae (which feed inside the
developing fruit). The threshold for damage is very low in fresh raspberries because the
presence of only a few larvae can mean that the whole consignment is rejected by the fruit
marketing agents (Gordon et al., 1997). Due to ongoing reductions in allowable pesticide
residues on fresh raspberries to a point that is effectively zero in the U.K. and a large increase
in protected raspberry production (under plastic tunnels) there is a strong demand for
alternative means to control this pest using semiochemical-enhanced trapping methodologies.
At SCRI, we have developed a novel trap, based on the key visual and olfactory
characteristics of the raspberry flower. This trap is now being tested on commercial farms in
Scotland and England (conventional/IPM).and on organic smallholdings in Norway (see
Trandem et al., this volume). Previous research at SCRI successfully identified the most
active floral attractant volatiles from raspberry flowers using a combination of GC-EAG (gas
chromatogram linked to electro-antennogram) and behavioural bioassays using linear track
olfactometers and a wind tunnel (Woodford et al., 2003; Birch et al., 2004; Mitchell et al.,
2004).
Materials and methods
Sites and duration of on-farm experiments in Scotland
The trials were conducted at two farms in Eastern Scotland from 1 May – 11 July 2007.
Two commercial Scottish plantations were chosen. Each were growing cv. Glen Ample under
174
Spanish type tunnels covered with polyethylene sheeting from flowering to after harvest and
each plantation was approximately 1 hectare in size. These sites were chosen as they were
thought to have low to moderate populations of raspberry beetle due to previous use of
insecticides.
Site 1 details
Wester Essendy, Blairgowrie, Perthshire, Scotland
Field name
NGR
E1
NO 135 435
E2
NO 135 435
E3
NO 135 435
Site 2 details
Blairgowrie, Perthshire, Scotland
Cultivar
Glen Ample
Glen Ample
Glen Ample
Age (years)
2
5
3
Field name
J1
J2
J3
Cultivar
Glen Ample
Glen Ample
Glen Ample
Age (years)
8
8
8
NGR
NO 216 462
NO 216 462
NO 216 462
Treatments
Devices were modified AgriSense bucket traps with white Correx cross-vanes and with a
polythene vial dispenser containing initially 2.5 ml of attractant coded ‘B’. The funnel traps
contained 3 cm of 25% antifreeze (ethylene glycol) in water with a drop of detergent
(Teepol® ) to reduce surface tension. The trap treatments were applied at least two weeks
before flowering commenced in each plantation. Three trap deployment treatments were used:
perimeter, lattice and control. Perimeter trapping consisted of the traps being suspended from
the top wire at the outer most position in the plantation at 8 m spacing around the entire
perimeter of the plantation (50 traps / hectare around the edge of each 1 ha plantation). The
traps in the lattice trapping treatment were positioned regularly through out the plantation,
suspended from the top wire, at a density of 50 traps per hectare. The control treatment
contained no buckets traps but did contain a small number of sticky traps for monitoring local
raspberry beetle numbers in untreated areas.
Assessments
Eight bucket traps per treatment were checked weekly and the number of beetles recorded.
Sampling of all the traps for adult raspberry beetles was undertaken at flowering and at the
end of the trial. The number of non-target insects was also recorded.
Standard white sticky traps were positioned in all three treatments to allow weekly monitoring
of the raspberry beetle populations in control areas without traps.
Results and discussion
Up to the green fruit stage the lattice treatment (within crop) was x 6 more effective for
trapping raspberry beetles than the perimeter layout at one site, but not different at the other
site (due to a lower raspberry beetle population following previous seasons’ pesticide
175
applications). After the green fruit stage, both spatial layouts worked equally well in terms of
catching adult raspberry beetles, but catch numbers were lower than in the pre- green fruit
stage. In control plots (without bucket traps) numbers of raspberry beetles were variable
between sites but more were caught around the edges than in the middle. The numbers of
raspberry beetle eggs found on sampled flowers was very low in all trap treatments, which
was also reflected in the very low incidence of larvae and damage to berries. Although some
non-target insects were caught (mainly bees, wasps, flies and other beetle species), the
numbers were low and had no obvious effect on pollination or biocontrol within the crop.
These first year results indicate that the enhanced bucket traps are effective in trapping (for
monitoring pest numbers and temporal activity) and possibly also for controlling damage
caused by raspberry beetle in protected raspberry plantations with low-moderate populations.
However, because pest numbers were low due to previous crop management history (pesticide
usage), climate and local habitat, trials will be continued at sites in the UK, Norway,
Switzerland and France with higher pest populations. The aim is to investigate alternative
usage of the enhanced traps and lures for control of the pest and fruit damage. The most
effective time to use the traps is pre-flowering of the raspberry crop, when there is no
competition from raspberry flowers, although the traps continue to trap raspberry beetles
during the flowering period and may help to reduce populations in subsequent years. Further
trials will be undertaken to fine tune the spatial deployment under different environmental
conditions. Collaborative trials in France and Switzerland, to complement the ongoing trials
in Norway, are providing a wider range of pest pressures (organic and conventional
producers) and growing conditions to optimise trap deployment strategies for monitoring
and/or pest control via a ‘lure and kill’ approach.
Acknowledgements
We thank Defra HortLINK and RERAD for providing funding and our project collaborators,
particularly at East Malling Research, Agrisense Ltd, Natural Resources Institute, ADAS and
consortium growers, for help with these experiments.
References
Gordon, S.C., Woodford, J.A.T. & Birch, A.N.E. 1997: Arthropod pests of Rubus in Europe: pest
status, current and future control strategies. Journal of Horticultural Science 72: 831-862.
Woodford, J.A.T., Birch, A.N.E., Gordon, S.C., Griffiths, D.W., McNicol, J.W. & Robertson, G.W.
2003: Controlling raspberry beetle without insecticides. Integrated Protection of Fruit Crops (Soft
Fruits) IOBC/wprs Bulletin 26(2): 87.
Birch, A.N.E., Gordon, S.C., Fenton, B., Malloch, G., Mitchell, C., Jones, A.T., Griffiths, D.W.,
Brennan, R.M., Graham, J. & Woodford, J.A.T. 2004: Developing a sustainable IPM system for
high value Rubus crops (raspberry, blackberry) for Europe. Acta Horticulturae 649: 289-292.
Mitchell, C., Gordon, S.C., Birch, A.N.E. & Hubbard, S.F. 2004: Developing a 'lure and kill'
system for raspberry beetle, Byturus tomentosus, in Rubus production. IOBC/wprs
Bulletin 27(4): 113-118.
176
Prospect for crop protection in Europe: vision from the ENDURE
Network
Pierre Ricci1, Marco Barzman2
1 INRA, Institut Sophia Agrobiotech, BP 167, 06903 Sophia Antipolis, France ; 2 Coordinator
and Assistant coordinator of the Network of Excellence ENDURE
Abstract: The IOBC has been a pioneer in defining and promoting the Integrated Pest Management
and Integrated Production concepts. Despite a wide theoretical recognition of these concepts, the
extent to which they are translated into practice at the field level is quite variable, so that European
agriculture is still largely relying on pesticide use. Under increasing pressure from public concern on
the consequences on human health and on the environment, a more stringent policy is being elaborated
at the EU level that will reduce the range of available pesticides and impose a rapid shift towards IPM.
In this context, research and extension have to engage even more than before in elaborating and
implementing innovative solutions. As practical solutions are generally devised at national or local
levels, there is an immediate benefit in comparing them, considering their transferability between
countries, identifying their performance and shortcomings, exploring their potential for combination
and detecting the gaps and needs for additional knowledge. ENDURE (www.endure-network.eu) - a
Network of Excellence gathering 18 institutions from 10 European countries – takes advantage of its
multinational point of view to perform such analyses. It also explores new technologies such as
precision spraying and early detection of pests and pathogens which have not been much developed
yet to assess their potential for reducing pesticide use. In the mid-term, however, introducing
technologies for mitigating pesticide impacts and some alternative methods may not suffice to meet
the expectation of a sustained crop protection reconciling low impacts and high productivity. With the
objective of reducing the vulnerability of crops to pests, pathogens and weeds altogether, changes in
the farming system must be considered, as well as the role of the whole food chain from input
providers to retailers and consumers. Thanks to the large range of disciplines gathered in this Network,
ENDURE is in a unique position to adopt this holistic approach and to take into account the
interactions between crop protection, agronomy, ecological and landscape factors as well as the socioeconomic framework in which innovative crop protection strategies need to be implemented. Work is
in progress on some agricultural systems most representative of European agriculture. As a typical
perennial cropping system subject to multiple pest and disease constraints, pomefruit orchards are one
of them. Current results on this system will be emphasised.
IPM
177
State of the Art of Control Strategies of Codling Moth, Apple Scab and
Brown Spot in Europe
Daniel Casado1, Jesús Avilla1, Andrea Patocchi2, Jörg Samietz2, Klaus Paaske3, Claire
Lavigne4, Benoît Sauphanor4, Luciana Parisi5, Bart Heijne6
1
Departament de Producció Vegetal I Ciència Forestal, Universitat de Lleida, Av. Rovira
Roure 191, 25198 Lleida, Spain. 2 Agroscope Wädenswil, P.O. Box 185, 8820 Wädenswil,
Switzerland. 3 Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences, Department of Horticulture,
Research Centre Aarslev, Kirstinebjergvej 10, P.O. Box 102, 5792 Aarslev, Denmark. 4
Plantes et Systèmes de culture Horticoles, INRA, Site Agroparc Cedex 9, 84914 Avignon,
France. 5 INRA, Site Gotheron, 26320 St Marcel-les-Valence, France. 6 Applied Plant
Research, P.O. Box 200, 6670 AE Zetten, the Netherlands
Abstract: ENDURE (www.endure-network.eu) is a European Network of Excellence which aims to
the reduction of insecticide use in European agriculture, and the identification of gaps of knowledge in
pest control science. Among the diverse actions of this network, a survey of the state of the art of
control strategies of codling moth, apple scab and brown spot in Europe was conducted. These are 3
key pests of pome fruit production all over Europe, and they are responsible for most of the
phytosanitary treatments applied in these crops. The survey was conducted at least in 5 European
regions, Rhône Valley (France), The Netherlands, Emilia Romagna (Italy), Lake Constance
(Switzerland and Germany), and Lleida (Spain); and in some cases additional regions were surveyed.
The survey was carried out by means of a questionnaire for each pest that was filled in by regional
experts with close relationship with growers. Questionnaires requested information on monitoring,
decision support systems, sanitation practices, use of environmentally friendly products, pesticide
resistance management, cultural methods, emerging secondary pests, functional biodiversity, and
bottlenecks; all considered basic elements to define a pest control strategy. The results of the survey
are shown and discussed regarding specially durability of the strategy, major actual control tools,
important bottlenecks, and discrepancy and heterogeneity among regions, for the control of the
different pests.
IPM, codling moth, apple scab, brown spot, pomefruit, control strategy
178
Investigations on the bark beetle species (Coleoptera: Scolytidae) in
cherry and peaches in the East Mediterranean Region of Türkiye
Adalet Hazır¹, Naim Öztürk¹, M. Rifat Ulusoy²
¹
Plant Protection Research Institute, P.B. 21, 01321, Yüreğir – Adana/Türkiye
²
Çukurova University, Faculty of Agriculture, Plant Protection Department, Adana/Türkiye
adalethz01@yahoo.com
Abstract. This two-year long study was carried out in cherry and peach orchards in Adana, Mersin,
Osmaniye and Kahramanmaraş provinces in the East Mediterranean Region of Türkiye in 2004-2005.
In this study the species of bark beetles -Scolytid spp.-, the distribution and the infection rates of this
pest were determined.
As a result of this study, five species of the Scolytidae family, which are one of the major pests
of cherry and peaches in the region, were found. These species were Scolytus rugulosus Müller,
Scolytus amygdali Guerin, Xyloborus dispar Fabricius, Taphrorynchus villifrons Dufour and Scolytus
pygmaeus Fabricius. S. rugulosus was found to be the most common species followed by S. amygdali.
It was determined that the first adults appeared in the beginning of May (3rd-5th of May) and survived
until mid-September. It was found that all provinces in the study area were infected by the pest at
different rates. The infection rates of bark beetle species in Mersin, Adana, Osmaniye and
Kahramanmaraş were determined to be 4.3, 5.6, 7.0 and 7.4 % respectively. The area where the survey
was conducted was found to be infected at an average of 5.8 %.
Key words: cherry, peach, pest, bark beetle species
Introduction
In 2007, Türkiye had 398,141 tons of crop obtained from 12,048,104 cherry–bearing trees.
The East Mediterranean Region of Türkiye produces 5.2 % of the total cherry production of
the country. In this region, the provinces of Mersin, Adana, Kahramanmaraş and Osmaniye
produce 9,637; 5,991; 2,375 and 1,940 tons respectively (Anonymous, 2007).
Peach production, another export product which is important for the economy of Türkiye,
is concentrated in the Marmara, Aegean, Black Sea and Mediterranean regions. In 2007, the
peach production was 539,435 tons in the country (Anonymous, 2007). The East
Mediterranean Region produces 16.5 % of the total peach production of the country.
There are many pests causing problems to stone fruits in Türkiye. Among these pests,
Scolytidae species is one of the major pests causing economic losses in cherry and peach trees
(Naredran et al., 1995; Tezcan and Civelek, 1996; Ben-Yahuda et al., 2002; Çınar et al.,
2004). Most of these Scolytidae species are considered as “secondary” insects because they
require a weakened or stressed host for successful colonization and development. In spring,
the emerging adults bore an entrance hole in the bark to excavate a brood gallery in the inner
bark or phloem. The adults feed and reproduce inside of the gallery. As a result of their
feeding inside of the phloem tissue, lack of development in the leaf and flower buds occur
which, in turn, causes crop losses. If the measures to prevent the build up of the pest aren’t
taken, starting from the thin branches, the whole tree may eventually die (Nizamlıoğlu, 1961;
Malavolta et al., 1995; Kaplan and Yücel, 2000).
In this study, it was determined which bark beetle species caused damage in cherry and
peach trees. The distribution and infection rates of these species in cherry trees in the East
179
Mediterranean Region were also determined.
Materials and methods
The main materials of this study were bark beetle species, cherry and peach trees, Steiner
funnel, aspirator, pruning scissors, killing jar, and culture boxes.
The determination of bark bettle (Scolytid spp.) species
This study was conducted mainly in cherry orchards in the East Mediterranean Region
provinces of Adana, Mersin, Osmaniye and Kahramanmaraş. The provinces were separated
into districts [Adana: (Pozantı, Saimbeyli, Feke); Mersin: (Arslanköy, Güzelyayla, Fatih);
Kahramanmaraş: (Andırın); Osmaniye: (Hasanbeyli, Bahçe)] based upon the production
amount of cherries. Some of the peach orchards adjacent to cherries were also investigated
and bark beetle samples were also taken from those orchards. The studies in the orchards were
done non-periodically between April and September in 2004 and 2005. Monitoring and strike
methods were used to collect the adult bark beetles.
The spreading and the infection status of the bark beetle species
In this study, samplings were done in at least three and at the most nine orchards which were
selected randomly and could represent the region. Each district was visited non-periodically
two times in the first year and once in the second year. The numbers of trees monitored were
decided according to Lazarov and Grigorov’s (1961) method. The trees which showed
infection symptoms were checked according to the method to see if they contained bark beetle
adult or larva. The trees which had beetles (adult or larva) under the bark were accepted as
infected. The spread and the infection status of the pest in cherry orchards were determined by
the number of infected trees.
Results and discussion
The determination of bark bettle (Scolytid spp.) species.
At the end of this study, the names of the species determined, the location where they were
found, and the name of the plant which they were found on are given in Table 1.
Table 1. The bark beetle species determined in cherry and peach orchards in the region.
Class
Family
Species
Scolytus amygdali Guerin
Xyloborus dispar Fabricius
Locations
Pozantı
Tarsus
Bahçe
Andırın (Çokak)
Mersin (Arslanköy)
Pozantı (Ömerli)
Andırın
Hasanbeyli
Saimbeyli
Bahçe (Y.Karderesi)
Seyhan
Tarsus (Yenice)
Kozan
Plants
Cherry
Peach
Cherry
Cherry
Cherry
Cherry
Cherry
Cherry
Cherry
Cherry
Peach
Peach
Cherry
Taphrorynchus villifrons Dufour
Kozan
Cherry
Scolytus pygmaeus Fabricius
Andırın (Çokak)
Cherry
Scolytus rugulosus Müller
Coleoptera Scolytidae
180
It can be seen in Table 1 that a total of five Scolytus species belong to Scolytidae family
of Coleoptera order were found in cherry and peach orchards. It was discovered that the adult
population of the pest was low in quantity in the beginning of the vegetation but increased
over time (July-August). It was also found that overwintering larva was affected negatively by
the hard winter conditions and the cultural upkeep processes applied in autumn and spring. It
also seems that pesticide applications done in early growing season reduces the beginning
population of the pest (Tezcan and Civelek, 1996).
As a result of this study, S. rugulosus was found the most abundant species and was
followed by S. amygdali. It was noted that S. rugulosus was a significant and abundant
species in the cherry orchards in Elazığ - Mardin (Çınar et.al., 2004) and in Niğde - Ulukışla
(Ulusoy et.al., 1999). Kaplan and Yücel (2000) declared that S. rugulosus prefers cherry,
plum, apricot and peach in sequence among other stone fruits. Mustaga (1991) suggested that
S. rugulosus prefers primarily cherry, peach and plum species. In some studies it was
determined that S. amygdali causes serious damage on stone fruits in Mediterranean and
South Europe countries by adult feeding on the buds and the larva feeding under the bark
(Anonymous, 2007a). In another study, it was noted that Xyloborus dispar species caused
serious damage on Populus spp., Acer spp., Betula spp., Fagus spp., Quercus spp., Salix spp.,
Castanea sativa, Malus domestica, Pirus communis, Prunus armeniaca, Prunus cerasus,
Prunus domestic, and Prunus persicae (Anonymous, 2007b).
The spreading and the infection status of the bark beetle species
This study was conducted simultaneously with the study to determine the species. The
infection percentages of bark beetles in the cherry orchards in the East Mediterranean Region
were calculated and the results are given in Table 2. The first adults appeared in the beginning
of May (3rd-5th of May) in the orchards of Pozantı (Adana). After the beginning of May, bark
beetles were found during every orchard examination.
Table 2. The infection rates of bark beetles in the cherry orchards in region (%)
Provinces
Districts
Checking
dates
No. of
infected
trees
6
6
6
5
9
4
3
Infection
rate (%)
03.05.2004
12.08.2004
04.05.2005
20.05.2004
08.09.2004
19.07.2005
05.05.2004
No. of
trees
checked
103
91
97
141
130
88
110
05.08.2004
134
8
6.0
08.06.2005
145
6
4.1
31.05.2004
21.06.2004
12.09.2004
18.05.2005
05.07.2004
03.09.2004
30.06.2005
22
73
106
122
117
109
113
1701
2
4
7
8
10
8
7
99
9.1
5.5
6.6
6.6
8.6
7.3
6.2
5.8
(dd.mm.yyyy)
Adana
Mersin
Osmaniye
Kahraman
maraş
Total
Pozantı
Pozantı
Pozantı
Saimbeyli-Feke
Saimbeyli-Feke
Saimbeyli-Feke
GüzelyaylaArslanköy-Fatih
GüzelyaylaArslanköy–Fatih
GüzelyaylaArslanköy-Fatih
Bahçe
Hasanbeyli
Hasanbeyli-Bahçe
Bahçe-Hasanbeyli
Andırın
Andırın
Andırın
181
5.8
6.6
6.2
3.6
6.9
4.6
2.7
Average
infection
rate
5.6
4.3
7.0
7.4
When Table 2 is checked it is seen that the rate of infecton is varied between 2.7 and 9.1
% with an avarage of 5.8 %. The infection rates of Mersin, Adana, Osmaniye and
Kahramanmaraş were 4.3, 5.6, 7.0 and 7.4 % respectively. According to the table, the most
extensive infection rates were seen in the orchards in Bahçe (9.1 %) and the lowest rates were
seen in Güzelyayla-Arslanköy-Fatih (2.7 %). In a study conducted by Kaplan and Yücel (2000),
in the East and Southeast Anatolia region it was determined that the infection rates of S.
rugulosus in Diyarbakır, Elazığ, Adıyaman, Mardin, and Malatya were 9.1, 6.7, 4.7, 4.4 and
4.1 % respectively and it was also determined that the infection rate of the region was 5.8 %.
As a result of this study, five species of bark beetles were determined with S. rugulosus
being found the most widespread one. Although the infection rate of bark beetles in the region
was found to be 5.8 %, it was determined that this rate wasn’t high enough to necessitate
pesticide application. Pesticide usage during unsuitable periods must be avoided because the
pest has many predator and parasitoits. Healthy, vigorous trees that are well cared for are less
subject to attack. Keeping the trees healthy and removing the infected trees and debris (such
as the cut branches) will be the best measures to prevent the pest to build up.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to the expert Prof. Dr. Erdal SELMİ (İstanbul University, Forestry
Faculty, Bahçeköy/Istanbul) who identified the specimens of bark beetles.
References
Anonymous, 2007. Devlet İstatistik Enstitüsü, Ankara. www.tuik.gov.tr
2007a. Almond bark beetle , Scolytus amygdali Guerin (Coleoptera: Scolytidae). Fact
sheet: www.padil.gov.au
2007b. Overview of Forest Pests Mongolıa. www.fao.org
Ben-Yahuda, S., T. Tolasch, W. Francke, R. Gries, G. Gries, D. Dunkelblum & Z. Mendel,
2002. Aggregation pheromone of the almond bark betle Scolytus amygdali (Col.:
Scolytidae). IOBC wprs Bulletin vol.: 25. www.phero.net
Çınar, M., İ. Çimen & H. Bolu., 2004. Elazığ ve Mardin illeri kiraz ağaçlarında zararlı olan
türler, doğal düşmanları ve önemlileri üzerinde gözlemler. Türk.entomol.derg., 2004, 28
(3): 213-220.
Kaplan, C. & A. Yücel, 2000. Doğu ve Güneydoğu Anadolu Bölgesinde sert çekirdekli
meyvelerde zararlı Scolytus rugulosus Müller (Col.:Scolytidae)’un biyolojisi, zarar şekli
ve yayılış alanlarının belirlenmesi. Türkiye 4. Ent. Kong. Bildirileri, 12 - 15 Eylül 2000,
Aydın. s.: 137 - 144 .
Lazarov, A. & Grigorov, P., 1961. Karantina na Rastenijata. Zemizdat, Sofia, s. 258.
Malavolta, C., I. Ponti, A. Pollini, T. Galassi, P. Cravedi, F. Molinari, A. Brunelli, F. Pasini, D.
Missere, D. Scudellari & M. Pizzi, 1995. The application of integrated production on
stone fruits in Emilia-Romagna (Italy). IOBC / WPRS Working Group Meeting
integrated plant production in stone fruits, Nimes (France) 6–8 September, 55-63 p.
Mustaga,T.M., 1991. Host response and life history of the fruit tree bark borer, Scolytus
mediterraneus Eggers (Coleoptera: Scolytidae) in Jordan. Giornale Italiano di Entologia,
5: 27, 199-202.
Narendran, T.C., A. Tezcan & H.S.Civelek., 1995. A new species of Eurytoma Illiger
(Hymenoptera, Eurytomidae) parasitic on Scolytus rugulosus Ratzeburg (Coleoptera,
Scolytidae) in Turkey and some notes about it. Türk entomol.derg., 19 (2) : 81-86
Nizamlıoğlu, K., 1961. Türkiye ziraatine zararlı olan böcekler ve mücadelesi. Meyve ağacı
182
zararlıları, bölüm II. Ankara, s: 68 – 69.
Tezcan, S. & H. S. Civelek, 1996. Kemalpaşa (İzmir) Yöresi kiraz ağaçlarında zararlı Scolytus
rugulosus (Müller, 1818) (Col.: Scolytidae)’un biyolojisi ve zararı üzerinde araştırmalar.
Türkiye 3. Entomoloji Kong. Bild., 24 – 28 Eylül 1996, Ankara, s.: 135 – 142.
Ulusoy, M.R., G. Vatansever ve N. Uygun, 1999. Ulukışla-Pozantı Yöresi Kirazlarında Zararlı Olan
Türler. Türk. entomol. derg., 23 (2): 111-120.
183
The incidence and control of cranberry tipworm, Dasineura vaccinii
S., in cranberry plantations in Latvia
Ilze Apenite
Latvian Plant Protection Research Centre, State Ltd, Lielvardes iela 36/38, Rīga LV-1006,
Latvia
Abstract: The commercial cultivation of American large-fruited cranberry (Oxycocccus macrocarpus
(Ait.) Pers.) began in Latvia in the last decade of 20th century, because the area of natural cranberry
(O. palustris Pers. and O. microcarpus Pers.) had decreased.The spread, development and progress of
the most harmful pests were regularly monitired in a field trial located in the Aluksne region in the
north-eastern part of Latvia. Mainly teh cranberry variety ‘Stevens’ was observed. One of the most
important reasons for cranberry yield loss is insect damage. After three years (2004-2006) it was
concluded that the most widespread and harmful pest of this crop in Latvia is cranberry tipworm D.
vaccinii. At the beginning of the experiment it was established in north-eastern part of Latvia (2004,
2005) but in 2006 the cranberry tipworm appeared also in other regions. In North America cranberry,
tipworm is controlled with flooding, sanding and chemical control (insecticide treatments). In Latvia
in many cranberry plantations it is difficult to perform flooding and sanding treatments (intensive
growth of weeds- neutral soil). Therefore it was necessary to carry out experiments to test the effects
of insecticide treatments. Currently no insecticide is registered for cranberry in Latvia. One of the
tasks was to test the efficacy of the insecticide Fastac, 10% EC (a.i. -cypermetrin) for control of
cranberry tipworm at different dosages and treatment times and to compare the efficacy with an
untreated control. The experiment was carried out from 2005 to 2006. Higher efficacy was obtained
with two treatment times with the highest dosage of Fastac applied.
Insects, Development, Weeds, Insecticide, Treatments
184
Preliminary trials for a continuous rearing of Bactrocera oleae (Rossi)
on its natural host Olea europaea L. in the laboratory and future
perspectives
Antonio Franco Spanedda, Valentina Baratella
Dipartimento di Protezione delle Piante, Facoltà di Agraria, Università della Tuscia, 01100
Viterbo, Italy
Abstract: A simple and affordable small-scale rearing technique to supply olive fruit fly (Bactrocera
oleae Rossi) instars continuously throughout the year, even when fresh fruits are not available
naturally to oviposit, is essential to optimize biological studies. Olive fruits came from a typical olive
grove of northern Lazio (Cura di Vetralla, VT, central Italy), organically managed. Cages, feeders and
instruments were specially designed. The fruits were kept fresh for more than 1 year in special “muffs”
of straw and tulle, assembled directly on fruiting branches. The rearing started in 2005, as soon as
emergences occurred. Adults were collected from the field and moved to the rearing cages with a
bunch of sound and fresh fruits, to allow egg laying. Thereafter, every time a new lab generation
started emerging, a bundle of fresh fruits was moved from the field into the cages to let new
ovidepositions occur. Temperature and RH were maintained at standard lab conditions, 20°C ± 2°C,
60% ± 5% RH, and natural photoperiod. From 11 October 2005 to 22 January 2007, the fly gave 13
continuous reproductive cycles in the lab, 1 generation every 40 days on average. An exception was
the 9th generation (27 August - 27 September) which lasted 31 days because of accidental high
temperatures (26-27°C). This is the first method which has succeeded in obtaining olive fly
generations continuously on its natural host. Fine tuning this technique will make it suitable for every
other study (i.e. physiological, biological and behavioural studies, parasitoid rearing and release,
sterile insect technique, etc.).
Key words: olive, olive fruit fly, life-cycles, biocontrol
Introduction
Several attempts have been made in the past in order to rear olive fly ex-situ with the aim of
studying different bioecological and behavioural aspects. Most of the studies carried out under
laboratory conditions referred to only one generation (Economopoulos et al., 1976; Remund
et al., 1977; Pucci et al., 1982; Tzanakakis & Koveos, 1986; Koveos & Tzanakakis, 1990;
Raspi et al., 1997). Other investigations on multiple generations relied on artificial diets
(Tsitsipis, 1977).
It seems that genetic changes occur when olive flies are reared on artificial diet causing
adverse effects on their performance and fitness if compared to wild individuals (Tsakas &
Zouros, 1980; Kostantopoulou et al., 1986). For this reason, researchers are now focussing on
obtaining laboratory colonies and maintaining them on their natural host (Genç & Nation,
2008).
The aim of this work was to design a simple and affordable small-scale rearing technique
to supply olive fly instars continuously throughout the year, even when fresh fruits are not
available for oviposition. This is essential to optimize biological studies as well as for mass
rearing in sterile insect techniques.
185
Material and methods
Olive fruits came from a typical olive grove of northern Lazio (Cura di Vetralla, VT, central
Italy), organically managed. All trees are of Canino cv, and 40 years old. To provide fresh
fruits year-round, some fruiting branches were wrapped in special “muffs” of straw and tulle,
assembled directly on fruiting branches starting from late July-early August (as soon as the
fruits reach the right size and before the pit’s hardening). Securing both the olives’ soundness
and slow ripening, this method usually provides fresh, healthy fruits through 13 months and
over. Every 10 days some branches were picked from the ‘muffs’, deprived of leaves to
prevent a quick dehydration of fruits, then placed into the cages.
Cages, feeders and other tools were specially designed. Rearing cages are cylindrical
(diameter = 30cm, h = 40cm), made of plexiglass with a removable bottom and a little sidewindow. The cage top is closed with a 0.5 mm-mesh tulle (Figure 1). Feeders are made from a
cylindrical glass container (diameter=3cm and h=10cm) with a plastic screw top. As soon as
the container is filled, the nutritional solution pours, through a bottom connection, into a little
tray (diameter=4cm, h=1cm) (Figure 2). The tray is plugged up with a porous material to let
solution surface slowly and allow adults to feed comfortably. To avoid overflowing, a pipe
(not capillary) must traverse the container’s cap, with a free end outside the container (see
Figure 2). Feeders were washed once a week using sodium hypochlorite, then soaked in water
for 3 hours, and again washed in plenty of water. Cages were cleaned when needed, using a
common detergent. A proper displacement of the adults from a rearing cage to others (shifting
cages) allowed us to separately maintain individuals of each generation. At least 3 cages are
necessary to maintain population in every generation.
The rearing started in 2005, from wild emergences, collecting and moving adults from
the field to the cages with a bunch of sound and fresh fruits, to allow egg laying. Thereafter,
every time a new lab generation emerged, a bundle of fresh fruits was moved into the cages to
let new ovidepositions occur. Temperature and RH were maintained at standard lab
conditions, 20°C ± 2°C, 60% ± 5% RH, and natural photoperiod.
Results and discussion
From 11 October 2005 to 22 January 2007, we succeeded in maintaining 13 continuous fly
reproductive cycles in the lab, 1 generation every 40 days on average. An exception was the
9th generation (27 August - 27 September) lasted 31 days because of accidental high
temperatures (26-27°C).
Figure 3 shows part of the lab generation emergence series. Emergences are reported as
percentage of flies per sex per generation versus date. Net mortality is also displayed (bar
charts) as % of dead individuals per sex per generation versus date.
The tested method appears to be both practical and cost-effective, for the first time
enabling the continuous lab rearing of B. oleae on its natural host without interruptions,
thanks to the year-round availability of olive fruits. Several possible improvements could be
made to fine tune the method, such as for example administering a refined diet to adults or
providing a more comfortable media to pupate (we tested successfully moistened paper towels
as well as layers of moistened fine sand).
The rearing technique reported succeeded for the first time in obtaining olive fly
generations continuously on its natural host and, after standardization, it appears to be very
promising for optimizing further studies (i.e. physiological, biological and behavioural
studies, parasitoid rearing and release, sterile insect technique, etc.).
186
Figure 1 Scheme of the rearing cage (different components and flies are not in scale)
Figure 2 Scheme of the feeder (olive fly not in scale)
187
188
% emergence
% mortality
lab gen V
lab gen VI
lab gen VII
lab gen VIII
lab gen IX
% emergence MALE
% emergence FEMALE
% net mortality MALE
% net mortality FEMALE
l
l
l
l
r
r
ar
ar
pr
ay
ay
ay
ay
pr
pr
pr
a n Ja n Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Ma Ma
un Jun Ju n Ju n Ju n -Ju
Ju
Ju
Ju
ug
ug
ug
ug
-J
-M 9-M 5-A 2-A 9-A 6-A 4-M 1-M 8-M 5-M 1-J
37- 3-A 0-A 7-A 4-A
06
2
5
9
6
9
8
7
8
2
8
1
5
2
5
2
2
1
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
2
2
1
2
2
1
2
1
1
2
1
1
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
lab gen IV
Figure 3 Emergence and mortality of generations from IV to VIII
References
Economopoulos, A.P., Voyadjoglou, A.V., Giannakis, A. 1976: Reproductive behaviour and
physiology of Dacus oleae: fecundity as affected by mating, adult-diet, and artificial
rearing. Ann. Ent. Soc. Amer. 69: 727-729.
Genç, H. & Nation, J.L. 2008: Maintaining Bactrocera oleae (Gmelin.) (Diptera: Tephritidae)
colony on its natural host in the laboratory. J. Pest Sci. 81 (3): 167-174.
Kostantopoulou, M.A., Economopolous, A.P., Manoukas, A.G. 1996: Olive fruit fly (Diptera:
Tephritidae) ADH allele selected under artificial rearing produced bigger flies than other
ADH alleles. J. Econ. Ent. 89 (6): 1387-1391.
Koveos, D.S. & Tzanakakis, M.E. 1990: Effect of the presence of olive fruit on oarian
maturation in the olive fruit fly, Dacus oleae, under laboratory conditions. Ent. Exp.
Appl. 55: 161-168.
Pucci, C., Forcina, A., Salmistraro, D. 1982: Incidenza della temperatura sulla mortalità degli
stadi preimmaginali, sull’impupamento all’interno delle drupe e sull’attività dei parassiti
del Dacus oleae (Gmel.), Frust. Entom. NS 4: 143-155.
Raspi, A., Canale, A., Felicioli, A. 1997: Relationship between the photoperiod and the
presence of mature eggs in Bactrocera oleae (Gmel.) (Diptera: Tephritidae), Bulletin
OILB/srop 20 (8): 46-54
Remund, U., Beller, E.F., Economopoulos, A.P., Tsitsipis, J.A. 1977: Flight performance of
Dacus oleae reared on olives and artificial diet. Z. Angew. Ent. 82: 330-339.
Tzanakakis, M.E. & Koveos, D.S. 1986: Inhibition of ovarian maturation in the olive fruit fly
Dacus oleae (Ditera: Tephritidae), under long photophase and an increase of temperature.
Ann. Ent. Soc. Am. 79: 15-18
Tsakas, S. & Zouros, E. 1980: Genetic differences among natural and laboratory-reared
populations of the olive-fruit fly Dacus oleae (Diptera: Tephritidae). Ent. Exp. Appl. 28:
268-276.
Tsitsipis, J.A. 1977: An improved method for the mass rearing of the olive fruit fly, Dacus
oleae (Gmelin) (Diptera: Tephritidae). Z. Angew. Ent. 83: 919-926.
189
The current issue of codling moth control in Croatian apple orchards
Božena Baric, Ivana Pajac, Dinka Grubišic
Faculty of Agriculture, Department of Agricultural Zoology, 10 000 Zagreb, Svetošimunska
cesta 25. Croatia
Abstract: In recent times, high populations of codling moth (Cydia pomonella) have been observed
in Croatian apple orchards. The appearance of large populations of this pest is in accordance with data
from other parts of Europe and the world. In the last ten years in orchards in which monitoring of
codling moth by pheromone traps is conducted increasing daily moth catches and earlier appearance of
the pest have been observed. More than ten years ago codling moth was caught to the end of July.
Today adult flight lasts until the end of September. The number of treatments against codling moth has
increased seven times. Reasons for the increased number of treatment are complex; global warming,
resistant strains of codling moth, a third generation of the pests. Monitoring the appearance of the first
generation of adults and efficient temperature sums in field conditions indicate the emergence of pests
with a lower temperature requirement. The extended flight of adults to September and the dynamics of
adult catches on pheromone traps indicate the presence of a third generation of the pest. Integrated
protection measures against codling moth are encountering a series of problems. Environmentally
more favourable measures of protection against codling moth, like the mating disruption technique,
which is applied in Western Europe has not shown satisfactory results in Croatia because of the small
size of orchards. Biological products such as those based on the virus are not available on the Croatian
market. The number of insecticides registered for codling moth control is small, with only a few active
substances, which will lead to a greater number of applications per year and increase the rate of
development of resistant strains of the pest.
IPM, Codling moth, Apple, Resistant types
190
Loquat and Pomegranate Thrips in the Eastern Mediterranean Region
of Turkey
Refik Bozbuğa, Naime Z. Elekçioğlu
Entomology Lab., Plant Protection Research Institute, Kışla Cad. Pk.21, Köprüköy, 01321
Adana –Turkey. E-mail: rbozbuga@yahoo.com; nelekcioglu@yahoo.com
Abstract: A thrips survey was conducted during 2006-2007 in pomegranate and loquat trees in the
Eastern Mediterranean Region of Turkiye which includes Adana, Mersin, Hatay and Osmaniye
provinces. For the extraction of thrips in the laboratory, new shoots with terminal buds and flowers
were collected and 400 pomegranate and 1000 loquat fruits were randomly checked visually for any
damage. A total of 511 adult thrips were collected. Seven species of thrips were identified:
Frankliniella occidentalis Pergande (loquat, pomegranate), Thrips tabaci Lindeman (loquat,
pomegranate), Thrips major Uzel (loquat, pomegranate), Pezothrips kellyanus Bagnall (pomegranate),
Frankliniella intonsa Trybom (pomegranate), Thrips meridionalis Priesner (loquat), Melanthrips
fuscus Sulzer (loquat). Among these species, T. major was the most widely distributed species
(90.6%), occurring throughout all loquat growing districts in the Eastern Mediterranean Region
followed by T. meridionalis (3.5%) in both years. However, F. occidentalis was the most widely
distributed species (94%), occurring throughout all pomegranate-growing districts in the Eastern
Mediterranean Region followed by T. tabaci (3%) in both years. Thrips are presently of little economic
importance as pests of pomegranate (little damage) and loquat (damage rate % 17) in the region.
Key words: Loquat, pomegranate, thrips, pests
Introduction
Loquat, Japanese plum (Eriobotrya japonica), a small or medium sized tree is native to China
and Japan. It was introduced into Japan and became naturalized there in very early times. It
has been cultivated in Japan for over 1,000 years. It has also become naturalized in India and
many other areas. The loquat is adapted to a subtropical to mild-temperature climate. Well
established trees can tolerate a low temperature of -11° C(Anonymous, 2007a). It is estimated
that loquat came to Turkey about 150-200 years ago. China (200,000 tons production and
42,000 ha) is the leading producer of loquats, followed by Pakistan (28,800 tons production
and 11,000 ha), Spain (41,487 tons production and 2,914 ha) and Japan (10,245 tons
production and 2,420 ha) (FAO, 2003). Turkey is an important world producer of loquat.
According to 2003 data; production of loquat 13,000 tons. Turkish loquat production of
97.5% is ensured from Mediterranean region of Turkey (Anonymous, 2007b). In Turkey, the
Mediterranean region has the most suitable ecological conditions for growing loquat. Within
the Eastern Mediterranean region, Mersin, Hatay and Adana provinces are the major
producers.
Pomegranate (Punicae granatum L.), can be grown in almost every regions of Turkey.
This plant is resistant to dry climate conditions and can easily adapt to various soil types.
Turkey is accepted as the homeland of pomegranate and takes the first place in growth
quantity among the other grower countries (Özgüven and Yılmaz, 2000). Recently many
pomegranate orchards were planted, especially in Mediterranean, Aegean and southeast
Anatolia regions of Turkey, owing to increasing export demands. As a result of this increase in
191
growing areas, in addition to cultivation problems, various plant protection problems that
cause economical loses in pomegranate occur every year (Öztürk and Ulusoy, 2006). Total
production of pomegranate 106,560 tons (t) in Turkey. The Eastern Mediterranean region is
one of the most important areas of pomegranate production (Hatay (4090t), Adana (2962t),
Osmaniye (1217t), Mersin (8705)) and has increased in recent years (Anonymous, 2007b).
After the economic value of loquat was realized, demand for commercial production
rapidly increased. Further future expansion of the loquat and pomegranate growing areas is
expected. Parallel to this increase the pests incidences have also increasedincluding thrips.
The aim of this study is to identify thrips species and their damage to loquat and pomegranate
in the eastern Mediterranean region.
Material and methods
Sampling was done in loquat orchards in the eastern Mediterranean region. Loquat flowers
and shoots were collected from three sites; Adana, Mersin, Hatay. Flowers and shoots were
also collected from pomegranate from different sites; Adana (Seyhan, Yüreğir, Karataş),
Mersin (Erdemli, Silifke, Mut), Hatay (Erzin, Dörtyol, Samandağ, Arsuz), Osmaniye
(Merkez), during 2006-2007. In the laboratory, all other pests on leaves and flowers were
discarded. To determine the damage caused by thrips, pomegranate leaves and 400
pomegranate fruits were assessed. To determine damage by thrips on loquat, 1000 fruits were
checked. All the thrips species were identified by Prof. Dr. İrfan Tunç (Akdeniz University,
Agricultural Faculty, Plant Protection Department, Antalya, Turkey).
Results and discussion
Loquat thrips
During 2006-2007, five Thysanoptera species were identified (Table 1). Thrips major was the
most dominant species (91%) and was the main thrips species on found on loquat flowers
from December to February. Fewer T. major (231 individuals - highest number) were
collected from loquat leaves and fruits were few. (Table 1). Cravedi and Molinari (1984)
indicated that the greatest damage is caused by the feeding of young nymphs of T. major on
the flowers. Later eggs are laid on the developing fruits (nectarine), after which subsequent
generations migrate to other flowering plants.
Although Frankliniella species are major pests of many plants T. major was the major
pest in Loquat, in the eastern Mediterranean region, Turkey. Three T. major (1.3%) and one
M. fuscus (25%) male thrips were found, but no males were found of T. tabaci, T.
meridionalis, F. occidentalis (Table 1).
In this study, injury caused by thrips on loquat was 17 %, enough to cause an economic
loss. Orious spp. effectively reduces thrips populations under certain situations
(Ananthakrishnan 1993). There are very few studies determining natural enemies and pests on
loquat is few in Turkey.
192
Table 1. Number of male and female Thysanoptera on loquat trees in the Eastern Mediterranean
Region of Turkey during 2006-2007.
Thysanoptera species
Thrips major
Thrips meridionalis
Thrips tabaci
Melanthrips fuscus
Frankliniella occidentalis
Total
Relative
Total thrips abundance
number
of total
number (%)
231
90.6
9
3.5
6
2.3
5
1.9
4
1.5
255
100
Female
thrips
number
228
9
6
4
4
251
Male Female/Male
thrips
thrips ratio
number
(%)
3
1.3
0
0
0
0
1
25.0
0
0.0
4
1.5
Pomegranate thrips
Five Thysanoptera species were identified (Table 2). F. occidentalis and T. tabaci were found
in every province (Adana, Mersin, Hatay and Osmaniye) and T. major (Adana), P. kellyanus
(Hatay), F. intonsa (Adana) were found in these regions. F. occidentalis was the most
dominant species (up to 241 individuals) (Table 2). This is hypothesized to be because the
pest has a high number of hosts and is well suited to the climate. F. occidentalis was first
found on vegetables and ornamentals in the Mediterranean region in 1993 (Tunç and Göçmen,
1994).
Table 2. Number of male and female Thysanoptera on pomegranate trees in the Eastern
Mediterranean Region of Turkey during 2006-2007.
Thysanoptera species
Frankliniella occidentalis
Thrips tabaci
Thrips major
Frankliniella intonsa
Pezothrips kellyanus
Total
Relative
abundance
Total thrips
of total
number
number (%)
241
94.1
8
3
2
2
256
3.1
1.1
0.7
0.7
100
Female
thrips
number
225
8
3
2
2
240
Male Female/Male
thrips
thrips ratio
number
(%)
7.1
16
0
0
0
0
16
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
6.6
Lublinkhof and Foster (1977) indicated that the highest reproductive rate of F. occidentalis
(95.5 eggs/female) was obtained at 20ºC in laboratory conditions. Another reason for the high
number of F. occidentalis is that some pomegranate orchards are planted with or around other
fruit orchards in the region. P. kellyanus is found on citrus in Turkey and was recorded on
pomegranate trees in this study. Tekşam and Tunç (2007) suggested that based on the
experience in other countries and the increase of invasion and abundance in 2007 this pest
species should be monitored. F. occidentalis populations consisted of 7 % male thrips, T. tabaci,
T. major, P. kellyanus, F. intonsa had no observed male thrips (Table 2). In this study, injury of
thrips on pomegranate is only minor. Orious spp. effectively reduces thrips population under
193
certain situations (Ananthakrishnan, 1993). Studies on determining natural enemies on
pomegranate are very recent, other crop studies have been carried out during the past 15 years, in
Turkey (Mart and Altın, 1992; Öztürk et al., 2005).
In summary, seven Thysanoptera species were identified during 2006–2007 on loquat and
pomegranate grown in the east Mediterranean region of Turkey. F.occidentalis was the species in
both years in pomegranate orchards. Loquat orchards harboured T. major more than other thrips
species. Some Thysanoptera species carry plant viruses. For this reason, more attention should be
given to the knowledge of the biology and ecology of pomegranate and loquat thrips species.
Research is needed into the control of these pests as part of an integrated pest management in
pomegranate and loquat.
Acknowledgements
The authors are very grateful to Prof. Dr. İrfan Tunç, Akdeniz University, Agricultural Faculty,
Plant Protection Department, Antalya, Turkey, for the identification of thrips species and other
help with the research.
References
Ananthakrishnan, T. N. 1993: Bionomics of thrips. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 38: 71- 92.
Anonymous, 2007a: Loquat. http://www.middlepath.com.au/plant/loquat.php.
Anonymous, 2007b: www.tuik.gov.tr/bitkisel appbitkisel.zul
Cravedi, P., Molinari, F., 1984: Thysanoptera injurious to nectarines. Informatore Fitopatologico.
34: 12–16.
FAO, 2003. FAO Agricultural Statistics.
Lublinkhof, J., Foster, D.E., 1977: Development and reproductive capacity of Frankliniella
occidentalis (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) reared at three temperatures. J.Kansas Entomol. Soc.
50: 3, 313–316.
Mart, C., Altın, M. 1992: Determinations of Insect and Mite Species Pomegranate Plantations in
South East Anatolia Region, Turkey. “Türkiye II. Entomoloji Kongresi” Bildirileri, 28-31:
725-735.
Özgüven, A.I., Yılmaz, C., 2000: Güneydoğu Anadolu bölgesinde nar yetiştiriciliği. TUBİTAK
Türkiye tarımsal araştırma projesi yayınları. 15p.
Öztürk, N., Ulusoy, M. R. and Bayhan, E. 2005: Pest and Natural Enemy Species Determined in
Pomegranate Orchards in the Eastern Mediterranean Region, Turkey. Türk. entomol. derg.,
29: 225-235.
Öztürk, N. ve M. R. Ulusoy, 2006: Pests and Natural Enemies Determined in Pomegranate
Orchards in Turkey. I. International Symposium on Pomegranate and Minor Mediterranean
Fruits October 16-19/2006, Adana-Turkey. Acta Hort., (Publishing).
Tekşam, İ., Tunç, İ, 2007: Citrus thrips in Antalya: species composition in 2006: Proceedings of
Second Plant Protection Congress of Turkey. 27-29 August 2007 Isparta- Turkey. p. 74.
Tunç, İ., Göçmen, H., 1994: New greenhouse pests, Polyphagotarsonemus latus and
Frankliniella occidentalis in Turkey. FAO Plant Protec. Bull., 42: 218-220.
194
Two Spotted Mite, Tetranychus urticae, a new pest in persimmon
orchards; approaches to reduce its density
Bu-Keun Chung1, Mitsuhiro Kawashima2, Chuleui Jung2
1Division of Plant Environment, Gyeongnam Agricutural Research and Extension Services,
Jinju 660-370, Korea. 2 School of Bioresource Sciences, Andong National University, Andong
760-749, Korea
Abstract: Oriental persimmon, Diospyros kaki Thunb., endemic to East Asia, is one of the
major fruit crops in Korea. After several decades two spotted mite (TSM) finally emerged
recently as one of the key pest in the orchards. To solve the mite problem we have undertaken
faunal surveys and defined the dominant species. We are identifying and conserving
predators, assessing the status of the mite as a pest in orchards, developing effective miticides
against TSM, and attempting to analyze the fluctuations of populations. The faunal survey of
mites in 2006 in Korea showed that most of the collected tetranychid mites belonged to the
genus Tetranychus, and additional collections of tetranychids made in 2007 were identified as
Tetranychus urticae Koch. Among phytoseiid species collected, Amblyseius eharai was the
most abundant. Most A. eharai were found on the branches in pedicels. In early spring, A.
eharai was abundant before the extension of persimmon leaves, so was considered to be
overwintering on the trees. Seventeen populations of TSM from farmer’s orchards were
monitored. Among these orchards, only 2 were properly managed, 5 farms should have
applied control measures but the farmers had little information on the mite and its damage,
and 10 orchards were not in danger of mite damage. For control of TSM in fields, applications
of spiromesifen 20SC and acequinocyl 15SC showed more than 90% control activity.
Fluctuations of TSM populations may have been caused by pesticide activity and spray,
density of predacious mites, rainfall, and weeds in the persimmon orchards.
Persimmon, Fauna, Tetranychus urticae, Amblyseius eharai, Miticdes, Control strategy
195
Autumn control of aphid pests of tree and bush fruit crops
Jerry Cross1*, Michelle Fountain1, Adrian Harris1and Richard Harrington2
1
East Malling Research, West Malling, Kent, ME19 6BJ, U.K.
2
Rothamsted Research, Harpenden, Herts, AL5 2JQ, U.K.
*jerry.cross@emr.ac.uk
Abstract: The aphid species that are significant pests of tree and bush fruit crops in Europe are almost
all host-alternating. They spend the autumn, spring and early summer on their winter woody tree/bush
fruit host but migrate to a herbaceous host in summer. In the autumn, there is a return migration to the
winter woody host by males and pre-sexual females (gynoparae), the latter producing sexual females
(oviparae) which mate with the males and lay overwintering eggs on the bark. The normal strategy to
control aphid pests is to apply an aphicide in spring shortly after the eggs have hatched to avoid the
subsequent development of damaging colonies, which cause severe curling of leaves on shoots and
stunting. Work on apple, raspberry and blackcurrant is reported, which has shown that good control of
all the important aphid pests of these crops can be achieved by autumn application of an aphicide
timed to kill the returning winged forms before egg-laying occurs. The advantages of autumn
application are that the aphids are vulnerable to direct interception by sprays and that pesticide
residues on fruit due to aphicide application do not occur. Possible methods for gauging the size and
timing of the autumn migrations to rationalise the use of autumn aphicide sprays, including suction
and sex pheromone trapping and surveying the incidence of gynoparae and oviparae on trees in the
autumn, are discussed.
Keywords : Dysaphis plantaginea, Amphorophora ideai, Hyperomyzus lactucae, pirimicarb
Introduction
The aphid species that are significant pests of tree and bush fruit crops in Europe are mostly
host-alternating. They spend the autumn, spring and early summer on their winter woody
tree/bush fruit host but migrate to a herbaceous host in summer. In the autumn, there is a
return migration to the winter woody host by males and pre-sexual females (gynoparae), the
latter producing sexual females (oviparae) which mate with the males and lay overwintering
eggs on the bark (Figure 1). Other important species, e.g. the large raspberry aphid
Amphorophora idaei, also have a migration period in summer or autumn but do not host
alternate. The normal strategy to control aphid pests is to make one or more aphicide
applications in spring shortly after the eggs have hatched to avoid the subsequent
development of damaging colonies, which cause severe curling of leaves on shoots and
stunting.
The objective of this work was to investigate whether as good control of the most
important aphid pests of tree and bush fruit crops could be achieved by autumn application of
an aphicide timed to kill the returning winged forms before egg-laying occurs.
196
Figure. 1. Host alternating life cycle of the rosy apple aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea
Materials and Methods
A data base of over 40 years of weekly records of the numbers of several important tree and
bush fruit aphid pests including rosy apple aphid, apple-grass aphid (Rhopalosiphum
insertum) and currant-sowthistle aphid (Hyperomyzus lactucae) were available from the
network of Rothamsted Insect Survey 12.2m suction traps. The data were used to examine the
timings of the autumn migrations of the different species. It was assumed that the best time to
spray would be towards the end of the autumn migrations of the gynoparae but at the start of
the male migrations so that sprays were applied before egg laying.
Large scale replicated field experiments were conducted in commercial apple,
blackcurrant and raspberry plantations in Kent, SE England examining the efficacy of
different timings of aphicide sprays in the autumn.
Results
Suction trap records indicated that numbers autumn migrants vary greatly from year to year
but for most species the bulk of the autumn migration of gynoparae generally occurs before
week 41 (1st week October) with males migrating mainly after this time (Figure 2).
Sprays of aphicides applied in the trials at different times in the autumn greatly reduced
number of aphids that developed the following spring on apple, blackcurrant and raspberry.
For some aphid species, e.g. the blackcurrant aphid (Figure 3), time of spray application made
little difference to the degree of control though two sprays were better than one, but for other
species e.g. the currant-sowthistle (Figure 3) and large raspberry aphids (Figure 3) the degree
of control depended on the date of application with best control being achieved by sprays in
early October.
197
25
Number caught
20
Virginop,gynop
15
Males
10
5
0
1
3
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
21
23
25
27
29
31
33
35
37
39
41
43
45
47
49
51
Week number
Fig. 2 Suction trap records for the currant-sowthistle aphid (Hyperomyzus lactucae) at Wye in
Kent in 2004
Discussion
Autumn application of aphicides gave good control of all the most important aphid pests of
tree and bush fruit crops. Where timing was critical, the best time of application was in early
October, coinciding with the end of the migration of gynoparae and the start of the migration
of males. The advantages of autumn application are that the aphids are vulnerable to direct
interception by sprays and that pesticide residues on fruit due to aphicide application do not
occur. Possible methods for gauging the size and timing of the autumn migrations to
rationalise the use of autumn aphicide sprays include suction and sex pheromone trapping
and surveying the incidence of gynoparae and oviparae on trees in the autumn.
Acknowledgements
This work was funded by the UK Horticultural Development Council (apple), The
GlaxoSmithKline Growers’ Research Fund (blackcurrant) and through a UK industry and
Defra funded HortLINK project (raspberry).
Reference
Cross, J. V., Cubison S., Harris A. and Harrington, R. (2007).Autumn control of rosy apple
aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea (Passerini), with aphicides. Crop Protection 26 (8): 11401149.
198
Shoots infested / 100 m row
following spring
Blackcurrant aphid (Cryptomyzus galeopsidis)
40
30
20
10
0
Sprays of pirimicarb
25
20
15
10
5
0
on
e
10
+2
N
O
ct
ct
O
10
Se
p+
30
19
+3
0
Se
pt
ct
20
-O
ct
10
-O
30
-S
ep
0
19
-S
ep
Shoots infested / 100 m row following
spring
Currant sowthsitle aphid (Hyperomyzus lactucae )
Sprays of pirimicarb
Eggs / 96 canes in January
Large raspberry aphid (Amphorophora idaei)
150
100
50
nt
re
at
ed
U
20
-O
ct
06
-O
ct
22
-S
ep
08
-S
ep
28
-A
ug
0
Thiacloprid spray
Figure. 3. Numbers of aphids that developed after treatment with aphidices at various times in
the autumn
199
New infestation outbreaks of Panonychus ulmi Koch (Acari:
Tetranychidae) in apple orchards of North-West Italy
Daniele Demaria1*, Marco Pagani2, Graziano Vittone1, Fabio Molinari2
1
CReSO, Consorzio di Ricerca e Sperimentazione per l’Ortofrutticoltura piemontese, via
Falicetto 24, 12030 Manta, Cuneo, Italy.
2
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore di Piacenza, Istituto di Entomologia e Patologia
Vegetale, Via Emilia Parmense, 84 - 29100 Piacenza, Italy.
* daniele.demaria@cresoricerca.it
Abstract. The fruit tree red spider mite, Panonychus ulmi, has been a major pest in almost all fruit
growing regions of the world, due to the negative effects of chemical sprays on natural enemies, until
integrated pest management became widespread. Indeed the reduction of insecticide applications
allowed the biocoenosis of antagonists, to control the red spider mite. In cases of use of certain
insecticides this mite again became a local problem. In 2003 and 2005 in North-West of Italy
inexplicable spread of infestations of this mite both on apple and peach orchards has been recorded.
Our studies conducted in 2006, 2007 and 2008 assessed that Panonychus ulmi Koch (Acari:
Tetranychidae) is still the main species in the orchards of north-west Italy and Amblyseius andersoni
(Acari: Phytoseiidae) is its main antagonist. Hypothesis of an involvement of grass chemical control in
infestation outbreaks of red spider mite was not confirmed and, it seems that it can be excluded as a
cause of red spider mite infestation outbreaks.
Keywords: Panonychus ulmi, apple
Introduction
The fruit tree red spider mite, Panonychus ulmi Koch (Acari: Tetranychidae), has been a
major pest in almost all fruit growing regions of the world, due to the negative effects of
chemical sprays on natural enemies, until integrated pest management became widespread.
Indeed the reduction of insecticide applications allowed the complex of antagonists (mainly
the coccinellid Stethorus punctillum, anthocorid Orius sp. and mites as Amblyseius andersoni
(Acari: Phytoseiidae), the main predator of tetranichids in North-West Italy) to control the red
spider mite. Only in cases of the use of certain insecticides this mite became a local problem
again. In 2003 and 2005 in North-West of Italy infestations of this mite, both on apple and
peach orchards, have been recorded. Our studies conducted in 2006, 2007 and 2008 aimed at
understanding the reasons for these new outbreaks.
Materials and methods
In 2006, two apple orchards and two peach orchards located in a fruit growing area on the
plain and two apple orchards and two peach orchards located in a hilly fruit growing area
were monitored regularly for the presence of the red spider mite and its antagonists. In 2007,
20 farms were monitored for infestation outbreaks. Infestation data for these orchards for the
two years before (2005 and 2006) and intervention information for 2007 have been collected.
The orchards were checked regularly for red spider mite presence and, when present, a sample
was collected.
Twenty-four leaves from each side of six plants per orchard were taken monthly. At the
200
same time, samples of prevalent grass species were taken. Tetranychids and their antagonists
were identified in the laboratory on fresh leaves or on material collected by Berlese funnel
and stored at 4°C in 1/3 alcohol, 2/3 water and a drop of glycerine.
In order to test the influence of herbicide sprays on red spider mite outbreaks,
randomized blocks were established, apart from chemical control sprays (Glufosinate
ammonium, 4-7 l/ha) and monitored for red spider mite infestation after 1-2 weeks. Samples
were taken, as described above, both on trees and grass.
Results
Infestation outbreaks
In 2003 and 2005, red spider mite infestation outbreaks were recorded in many apple and
peach orchards, regardless of spray interventions that are standardized in the fruit growing
area of North-western Italy. The aim of experimentation was to understand the origin of those
outbreaks by monitoring many orchards from the beginning of the season. In 2006 two apple
and two peach orchards were monitored as well as almost 20 orchards in 2007, but no
infestation was recorded regardless of past infestations, spray interventions and presence of
red spider mite eggs during the winter.
Red spider mite and antagonists
The species collected during the surveys was identified: the red spider mite was Panonychus
ulmi Koch (Acari: Tetranychidae), although no large populations were recorded (Table 1). The
main antagonist found out was Amblyseius andersoni Chant, both on trees and grasses,
although they were less numerous on the latter (Table 1). In both 2006 and 2007, the
populations of this phytoseiid were relevant. Less represented were Tideid species found only
in hilly apple orchards in 2006.
Table 1. Red spider mite (P. ulmi) and its antagonists A. andersoni mean number per leaf
collected in many orchards of North-West of Italy during 2008. Each date corresponds to
sampling in a different orchard.
Date
Species
Apple
3 May
Epilobium sp.
Taraxacum officinale
Peach
8 May
Senecio vulgaris
Stellaria sp.
14 May
Apple
30 May
Apple
13 June
Apple
5 July
Apple
Apple
23 Aug Echinocloa crus-galli
Poa pratensis
Apple
25 Set
Apple
201
A. andersoni
0.3
0.4
0
0
0.7
0
0.4
0.5
0
0.8
0.1
3
9.6
0
0.7
P. ulmi
0.3
0
0
0
0
0
0.5
0
0.2
0
2.5
0.2
0.6
0.3
0.1
Role of grass chemical control in infestation outbreaks
Grass chemical control was hypothesized to play a role in red spider mite infestation
outbreaks. A technician of the extension service suggested that chemical control of grass made
under intense sun irradiation condition or just before these conditions could induce outbreaks
of red mite. The hypothesis was that chemicals under the sun evaporates affecting antagonists
of the red spider mite. To assess the validity of this hypothesis randomized plots in two apple
and two peach orchards were sprayed with herbicide just before very warm days in July and
August. Other plots were left untreated. Infestation was recorded in each plot.
Table 2. Red spider mite (P. ulmi) and its antagonists A. andersoni mean per apple leaf in
treated and untreated plots a week after spray.
Chemical control
Un-treated
A. andersoni
0.4a
0.1a
P. ulmi
0.4a
0.2a
Discussion
Unluckily, our studies conducted in 2006 and 2007 did not encounter an infestation outbreak
of red spider mite and this fact confirms the unpredictability of the phenomenon, at least with
current information.
In any case, it was possible to confirm that Panonychus ulmi Koch (Acari:
Tetranychidae) is still the main species in the orchards of north-west Italy and Amblyseius
andersoni is its main antagonist.
Hypothesis of an involvement of grass chemical control in infestation outbreaks of red
spider mite was not confirmed and, from experience, it seems that it can be excluded as a
cause of red spider mite infestation outbreaks.
Acknowledgements
We thank all the farmers and the field technicians involved in the present study. This research
was supported by Regione Piemonte (Italy) within the program: “Programma di ricerca,
sperimentazione e dimostrazione agricola in frutticoltura e orticoltura 2007 and 2008”.
202
Ostrinia nubilalis Hübner (Lepidoptera, Pyralidae) as a threat to apple
Daniele Demaria1*, Graziano Vittone1, Fabio Molinari2
1
CReSO, Consorzio di Ricerca e Sperimentazione per l’Ortofrutticoltura piemontese, via
Falicetto 24, 12030 Manta, Cuneo, Italy.
2
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore di Piacenza, Istituto di Entomologia e Patologia
Vegetale, via Emilia Parmense, 84 - 29100 Piacenza, Italy.
* daniele.demaria@cresoricerca.it
Abstract. Over the last few years, damage to fruits due to the European Corn Borer, Ostrinia nubilalis
Hübner, has been recorded in apple orchards of Piedmont (North-West Italy). Investigations carried
out in 2006 and 2007 aimed to understand the phenomenon, evaluate a better way to monitor the insect
and perhaps modify the pests management strategy to control O. nubilalis. Field surveys confirmed
that the main damage occurs in orchards close to corn fields or, in a few cases, in orchards with the
grass Echinochloa crus-galli. Researches demonstrated that pheromone-baited mesh cone traps are
more efficient than delta sticky traps for monitoring the flight of European corn borer and that in the
Piedmont area the E strain is prevalent. Field surveys confirmed that ECB generally lives and
reproduces on corn, and migrates onto apple trees when the main host plants is harvested. In Piedmont
this happens at the beginning of September, even if damage sometimes appear earlier in August when
high populations of ECB are present. Information collected allowed the extension services to monitor
the pest and modify the pest management strategy.
Keywords : European Corn Borer, Ostrinia nubilalis, apple.
Introduction
Over the last few years, damage to fruits due to the European Corn Borer, Ostrinia nubilalis
Hübner, has been recorded in apple orchards of Piedmont (North-West Italy). Investigations
carried out in 2006 and 2007 aimed at understanding the phenomenon, evaluating a better
way to monitor the insect and possibly modify the apple pest control strategy keeping into
account O. nubilalis.
Materials and methods
Apple orchards are located in the fruit growing area of North-West Italy, which frequently are
proximity with corn fields. Data have been collected in 2006 and 2007 in 5 orchards (Golden
Delicious, Fuji, Red Delicious). During July and August, 50 corn plants have been monitored
weekly for the presence of eggs and larvae of O. nubilalis. TrapTest (Isagro, Milan, Italy) and
Heliothis Trap (Scentry, Billings, Montana, USA) have been placed in both corn fields and
apple orchards to monitor adult flight. Each trap was lured with both Phenyl-AcetAldehyde
(PAA) and E or Z pheromone. PAA was replaced at 15 days interval and the pheromone lure
at 4 week intervals. Two of each combination trap\lure were placed in each field/orchard.
Traps were checked weekly from the second generation in 2006 and from the first in 2007,
until the end of September.
203
Results
Location of the pest
At the end of August 100% of corn plants in field close to orchards were visited at least once
by European Corn Borer (ECB) (Fig. 1). These data suggest that populations are similar to
those that can be found in corn production areas. It must be noted that this percentage is the
sum of first and second generations. Since a third generation can develop, late ripening apple
varieties are the most susceptible. No orchard far from corn fields showed ECB damage,
except for orchards with fully developed Echinochloa crus-galli, a grass that allows ECB to
develop quite high populations, that can move to apple trees and cause relevant damage.
100
100.0
96.0
100.0
80
68.0
60
40
20
0
% of corn
infested
Larvae per
plant
% of corn
infested
09 August 2006
7.0
4.1
3.2
0.7
Larvae per
plant
% of corn
infested
17 August 2006
Larvae per
plant
% of corn
infested
23 August 2006
Larvae per
plant
30 August 2006
Figure 1. Per cent of infested corn plants and mean number of ECB larvae per corn plant.
Monitoring European Corn Borer
In order to assess whether the E or Z strain was prevalent, TrapTest traps were lured with
Phenyl-Acetaldehyde and alternately with the two pheromones. As shown in fig. 2 the
prevalent strain is E as in other corn production areas of Northern Italy.
12
10
8
E strain
6
4
Z strain
2
/0
6
/0
6
11
/1
0
/0
6
04
/1
0
/0
6
27
/0
9
/0
6
20
/0
9
/0
6
13
/0
9
/0
6
06
/0
9
/0
6
30
/0
8
/0
6
23
/0
8
/0
6
16
/0
8
/0
6
09
/0
8
/0
6
02
/0
8
26
/0
7
19
/0
7
/0
6
0
Figure 2. Mean number of European Corn Borer adults caught in apple orchards in 2006 with
two different lures in TrapTest traps.
204
TrapTest and Heliothis traps were placed in both corn fields and apple orchards to understand
the best way to monitor O. nubilalis population. The second gave a better response: higher
number of adults and a well defined generational succession as shown in Figure 3.
14
TrapTest
Heliothis
12
10
8
6
4
2
7
20
0
/0
9/
21
07
/0
9/
/0
8/
20
0
20
0
7
7
7
24
/0
8/
10
/0
7/
27
/0
7/
13
20
0
20
0
7
20
0
7
20
0
7
29
/0
6/
15
/0
6/
01
/0
6/
20
0
7
20
0
7
20
0
/0
5/
18
7
0
Figure 3. Mean number of European Corn Borer adult catches in apple orchards in 2007, with
two different models of traps.
When the pest goes to apple
Since corn dries out starting from the end of August, this period is the mostly likely to induce
ECB to cross to apple. Indeed damage often arises in August with a peak at the end of August
and the beginning of September (Fig. 4).
25
Catch on
20
15
10
Catch on
5
0
19lug
26lug
2ago
9ago
16ago
23ago
30ago
6set
13set
20set
27set
4ott
11ott
Figure 4. Mean number of European Corn Borer adult catches in apple orchards with
Heliothis net traps. The arrow indicates the time of ECB crossing from corn to apple.
205
Discussion
In conclusion we can say that:
• Populations of the European Corn Borer (ECB) in North-West of Italy reach similar
levels to those that can be found in the main corn production areas.
• In the fruit-growing area of Cuneo province the E-strain is prevalent and the Z-strain
is very rare. The best way to monitor the pest are Heliothis net traps baited with both
E-pheromone and Phenyl-Acetaldehyde.
• The problem of damage by ECB on apples can arise when corn fields are close to
apple orchards. Rarely, damage due to ECB has been reported in orchards not close to
corn fields as found at the beginning of the research. It is often confused with codling
moth (Cydia pomonella L.) damage. Sometimes, however, in the presence of fully
developed Echinochloa crus-galli grass ECB can easily reproduce and then move to
apple.
• The end of August is the time of highest risk of ECB crossing from corn (or E. crusgalli) to apple. Indeed, at that time, higher population levels are reported and corn is
harvested. Those are the better condition for migration. As to defence, it seems that the
active ingredients usually sprayed for controlling codling moth are also effective on
ECB.
Acknowledgements
We thank all the farmers and the field technicians involved in the present study. This research
was supported by Regione Piemonte (Italy) within the program: “Programma di ricerca,
sperimentazione e dimostrazione agricola in frutticoltura e orticoltura 2007 and 2008”.
206
Investigations on the occurrence of the quarantine fruit fly species
Rhagoletis cingulata and Rhagoletis indifferens on Prunus avium and
Prunus cerasus in Austria
A. Egartner, N. Zeisner, H. Hausdorf, C. Lethmayer & S. Blümel
AGES, Austrian Agency for Health and Food Safety, Institute of Plant Health,
Spargelfeldstraße 191, A-1220 Vienna, Austria
pflanzengesundheit@ages.at
Abstract: During the growing seasons 2007 and 2008 the occurrence of the two quarantine fruit flies
Rhagoletis cingulata (Loew) and R. indifferens (Curran) was monitored in Austria. R. cingulata
originates from the eastern and R. indifferens from the western part of North America. Both species are
important pests of cherries in North America and potentially in European cherry orchards, causing
severe quality problems after fruit infestation. While R. cingulata mainly infests various Prunus
species, R. indifferens also occurs on Crataegus sp. and on Rhamnus sp.. After the first findings of
American cherry fruit flies in Europe in 1983 in Switzerland, R. cingulata was also detected during
surveys in other European countries, such as the Netherlands, Germany, Hungary, Slovenia and
Croatia. Recent findings of R. cingulata were located near the south-eastern border of Austria while no
findings of R. indifferens were reported from this region until now. The survey in Austria was carried
out in the main cherry production areas and in those areas where high invasion potential was most
probable. Sampling sites were located in variable orchards in the eastern part of Austria, along the
border to Hungary and Slovenia. Fruit flies were baited and caught with yellow panels of the type
Pherocon® AM. Traps were placed in cherry trees to catch adult flies, which emerged under or near the
sampling trees. In 2007, two traps were installed and replaced weekly at each of the seven sampling
sites from May 2nd until 2 weeks after the last seasonal occurrence of the fruit flies. In 2008, the survey
was carried out on 6 cherry production sites including 4 new monitoring sites compared to 2007. Traps
were replaced in fortnight intervals from the end of May in 2008 until 2 weeks after the last seasonal
occurrence of the fruit flies. Identification of the caught individuals was carried out morphologically.
In both years, a high number of European cherry fruit flies (R. cerasi Linné), which is considered an
important cherry pest in Austria, was caught in many traps. In 2007, at each of two of the sampling
sites, 1 individual of R. cingulata was found. No further non-native fruit flies were caught. We
assumed that the captured specimens were separately introduced specimens and that there were no
established populations in the monitoring area during the seasons 2007 and 2008.
Keywords: quarantine pest, Rhagoletis cingulata, R. indifferens, cherry, distribution, Austria
207
Population evolution of Ceratitis capitata (Wied.) in the NE of Spain
and its implications for the establishment of control methods.
L. Adriana Escudero-Colomar1, Mariano Vilajeliu1, Esther Peñarrubia-María1, Lluís
Batllori2
1 IRTA - Estació Experimental Agrícola Mas Badia. Canet de la Tallada, 17134 La Tallada
d’Empordà.
Girona.
adriana.escudero@irta.cat;
mariano.vilajeliu@irta.cat;
esther.penarrubia@irta.cat ; 2 Servei de Sanitat Vegetal. DARP. Aiguamolls de l’Empordà,
17486 Castelló d’Empúries. Girona. lluis.batllori@irta.cat
Abstract: The Mediterranean fruit fly Ceratitis capitata (Wied.) is a worldwide pest that has
increased its populations in the last 10 years in Girona province (NE of Spain, 42º North latitude). The
adult population has been carefully monitored, using dry food based attractants containing three
components, in peaches (2005-2007) and apples (2007) in the two main fruit growing areas of Girona.
One trap per orchard was installed and the captures were registered using SIG technology; interactive
distribution maps were drawn on a weekly basis using two software programs jointly, Hesperides®
and Google map®. An area-wide control project was applied using mass trapping in both areas
hanging 50 traps/ha in each fruit orchard, bated with dry food based attractant of three components.
The project acreage started on 300 ha in 2005 and grew to 774 ha in 2007. Damage level and chemical
treatments were recorded and sanitation methods were applied as a compulsory requirement. Results
showed a seasonal population evolution, with maximum catches at the end of September or early
October in both fruit species studied. The highest population was found in the Northern part of the two
Girona fruit growing areas. SIG technology has enabled us to determine the zones with the highest
population in each area and to choose the control strategy in each orchard. Mass trapping as a control
method on an area-wide basis gave good protection of fruits and in only a few cases it was necessary
to apply reinforcement with chemical spraying. Sanitation measures have proved to be necessary to
complete mass trapping as a control method of the Mediterranean fruit fly. All these results will be
discussed in order to improve the control of Medfly in the Girona fruit area.
Medfly, Ceratitis capitata, Population evolution, Monitoring, Mass trapping, Area-wide control, SIG
208
Preliminary studies about the effect of ‘Candidatus Phytoplasma mali’
on the psyllid Cacopsylla melanoneura (Homoptera: Psyllidae)
Valeria Malagnini1 Federico Pedrazzoli1, Valeria Gualandri1, Flavia Forno1, Alberto
Pozzebon2, Claudio Ioriatti1
1 FEM-IASMA Research Centre, Plant Protection Department, via E. Mach, 1, 38010 San
Michele all’Adige (TN,) Italy; 2 University of Padua, Department of Envronmental Agronomy
and Crop Science, viale dell’Università, 16, 35020 Legnaro, Padova, Italy
Abstract: Cacopsylla melanoneura Föster (Homoptera: Psyllidae), an univoltine psyllid, is a vector
of ‘Candidatus Phytoplasma mali’, the etiological agent of apple proliferation disease (AP), which is a
severe problem in Italian apple orchards. Preliminary studies were conducted about the influence of
‘Ca. Phytoplasma mali’ on the fitness of C. melanoneura. Couples of overwintering adults of the
psyllid collected in the field were exposed to the phytoplasma by feeding on infected and non-infected
apple (Malus domestica L.) (Rosaceae) shoots. The effect of the exposure to the phytoplasma with the
diet was determined by measuring some of the life history traits correlated to the fitness of the
individuals such as longevity of the females, number of eggs laid, egg hatching and development of
larval instars The longevity of AP-exposed adult females was not significantly different to that of
psyllids fed on healthy apple shoots,. However, the AP-exposed females laid significantly less eggs
than unexposed ones, and the eggs produced by AP-exposed females were significantly delayed in
hatching. Moreover, the progeny of AP-exposed females (number of nymphs emerging from eggs laid
on apple shoots) was significantly less numerous than the progeny of unexposed females, while there
were no significant differences in their development to adulthood. Further studies are necessary to
establish whether such differences are due to the presence of AP phytoplasma in the body of the
spyllid or in the plant.
Apple proliferation, Psyllid, Apple, Phytoplasma
209
New insights into management of the white grub, Polyphylla olivieri in
fruit orchards of Iran
Aziz Kharazi-Pakdel, Javad Karimi
Dept. plant protection, Campus of Agriculture and Natural Resources,University of
Tehran,Karaj,Iran Department of Plant protection,Ferdowsi University of Mashhad,
Mashhad,Iran
Abstract: Polyphylla olivieri (Col.,Melolonthidae) is the most destructive white grub in the Iran.This
Scarabaeid has a wide host range including different fruit trees in most part of Iran. Chemical
pesticides is the common for controlling this pest. Considering side effects of this method, application
of biocontrol agent has been considered in management programmes. Among the natural pathogens,
several isolates of entomopathogenic nematodes from both genus of Steinernema and Heterorhabditis
were isolated from third and second larval stages of this pest in Iran. This isolates belonged to
Heterorhabditis bacteriophora, Steinernema carpocapsae and Steinernema glaseri.Laboratory assay
showed that the last species, S.glaseri had the highest mortality potential .The prevalent pathogen of
this melolonthid in Tehran province was Metarhizium anisopliae and after this Beauveria
bassiana.Compatability studies on application of entomopathogenic nematodes and fungi indicated
that application of entomopathogenic nematodes and M.anisopliae can reduce population of this white
grub considerably. In addition to natural pathogens as naturalbiocontrol agents, some isolates of
nematodes were isolated from soil habitats of this pest. Among this, Steinernema feltiae and
Heterorhabditis megidis had the highest virulence compaed with other species .A survey for
characterization and introduction of isolates with high virulence can provid a good alternative in
integrated management of Polyphylla olivieri in future.
White grub, Polyphylla olivieri, Natural Pathogens,Iran
210
First evidence of the walnut husk fly (Rhagoletis completa) in Austria
C. Lethmayer
AGES, Austrian Agency for Health and Food Safety, Institute of Plant Health,
Spargelfeldstraße 191, A-1220 Vienna, Austria. christa.lethmayer@ages.at
Abstract: The walnut husk fly Rhagoletis completa (Tephritidae, Diptera), originating from NorthAmerica, is listed as a quarantine pest on the Annex I/AI (directive 2000/29/EC). As the main host
plants of R. completa are various species of Juglans spp., infestations could become a problem for
walnut production because larval feeding in the mesocarp (nutshell) could also damage the pericarp
and the nut itself. Under certain conditions peaches (Prunus persica) may also be attacked. In
international trade, the major means of dispersal is the transport of infected fruits (containing live
larvae).
In Europe (Switzerland) some specimens were collected in the late 1980s for the first time. During the
last years R. completa also occurred in Slovenia, Italy and Germany, and recently in France (2007).
Due to the fact that there are still no individuals of the walnut husk fly documented for Austria a
monitoring program was started by the Institute of Plant Health (AGES) in 2008. The monitoring took
place in Tyrol, near Innsbruck in private gardens following up on information of the Tyrolean Plant
Protection Service. Sticky yellow traps were used to catch the fruit flies and were set up and recorded
from the end of June at 14-day intervals.
In the first half of July the first individuals were caught and the first presence of R. completa was
demonstrated for Austria. In autumn, fruits that were infested by the walnut husk fly were found in
other regions of Austria (Vienna, Styria, Carinthia), too. Monitoring in other parts of Austria will be
continued in 2009.
Key words: quarantine pest, Rhagoletis completa, walnut, distribution, Austria
211
The occurrence of leaf rollers in Polish apple orchards and possibilities
of their integrated control
Zofia Pluciennik, Remigiusz W. Olszak
Institute of Pomology and Floriculture, Dept of Plant Protection, Pomologiczna 18, 96 – 100
Skierniewice, Poland
Abstract: Leaf rollers constitute the major pests of fruit crops - particularly apple and pear in many
regions with temperate climate. Among a dozen or so species occurring in fruit orchards in Poland
only four are important or even (depending on year) very important. They are: dark fruit-tree tortrix
(Pandemis heparana), summer fruit tortricid (Adoxophyes orana), apple bud moth (Spilonota
ocellana) and european leaf roller (Archips rosanus). The harmfulness of these pests during warm
seasons is particularly serious. Since 2002 an increasing significance of Adoxophyes orana has been
observed which is probably connected with warming of the climate. This complicates the control of
the above leaf roller species as its larvae are present at a different time to those of the others, and
especially the summer generation of larvae of Adoxophyes orana. Several monitoring techniques can
be used to evaluate the occurrence and abundance of Adoxophyes orana, tree inspections used along
with the use of sex-pheromone traps seem to be the most effective ones. Despite of wide host range
Adoxophyes orana prefers to feed on apples, so together with other tortrix species (see above) it is able
to cause serious problems in many orchards. Several pesticides are registered in Poland for chemical
control of these pests in orchards along with IFP programs. These are thiacloprid (Calypso 480 SC),
acetamiprid (Mospilan 20 SP), indoxacarb (Steward 30 WG), metoxyfenozid (Runner 240 SC) and
spinosad (Spintor 480 or 240 SC). The insecticide indoxacarb, metoxyfenozid and spinosad are used
mainly in the summer because they reduce the codling moth population as well. In the case when other
pests (e.g. aphids) occur along with tortrix species, neonicotinoids (thiacloprid and acetamiprid) are
recommended. Since 2006 a few experiments with the new active ingredient rynaxypyr have been
conducted and very promising results for leaf roller control were obtained.
IPM, Leaf rollers, Pomefruit, Control Strategy
212
The control of the Cacopsylla pyri L. (Sternorrhyncha, Psyllidae) in a
pear orchard in the Czech Republic.
Jana Ouředníčková
Research and Breeding Institute of Pomology Holovousy Ltd., Holovousy 1, 508 01, Hořice,
Czech Republic
Abstract: A field trial was conducted in 2008 in the Czech Republic to test the efficacy of kaolin
(aluninosilicate mineral) against over wintered adults of Cacopsylla pyri. It aimed to prevent the
females laying their eggs. Ekol (90% coleseed oil) was also tested in order to suffocate adults and
eggs. In addition, the insecticides Sanmite 20 WP (pyridaben), Insegar 25 WP (fenoxycarb) and
Calypso 480 SC (thiacloprid) were applied to reduce nymphs. These treatments were repeated on the
first and the second generation. Efficacy was compared with an untreated control. Beating tray
samples were taken in both plots (control, treatment) to monitor the density of adults. Egg-laying and
nymph infestation were visually monitored. The Cacopsylla pyri population was not reduced under a
damaging level. This observation might be explained by a high initial infestation level and the
immigration of pear suckers from the untreated control plot. However, during the vegetation period it
was observed that there were lower number of adults, nymphs and eggs on treated trees compared to
the untreated control. The population density was significantly decreased, but not under the economic
threshold (10 eggs or nymphs / 100 leaves). Yield was not decreased and no honeydew and sooty
moulds were observed on the fruits.
Key words: integrated pest management, Cacopsylla pyri, pears, kaolin, oil, insecticides
Introduction
The psylla, Cacopsylla pyri is one of the most significant pests of pear orchards in the Czech
Republic. Increasing populations were caused by emergence of resistant populations due to
intensive use of insecticides and by the eradication of natural enemies (Anthocoridae,
Chrysopidae, Coccinellidae) of the pest, caused by using non-selective preparations (Falta
2008). In order to renew the ecological equilibrium in orchards and increase the efficacy of
insecticides, it is necessary to apply the rules and principles of integrated pest management.
As a sap-feeding insect, C. pyri produces large amounts of honeydew, causing the growth
of sooty mould and black russet on fruits. Pear psylla also serves as a vector for the
phytoplasma organism responsible for Pear decline. In case of heavy and prolonged
infestations, the toxins injected by a pear suckers when they feed can lead to the exhaustion or
even death of the tree (“Psylla shock”) (Michelleti et al. 2005).
The European pear sucker appears in 3-6 generations every year. In February/March the
over wintering adults start to feed and lay eggs. Each female can lay up to 400 eggs over 4-5
weeks. After egg hatch, pear psylla nymphs pass through five development instars.
Control of this pest is very difficult. The most important control is to start with protection
at the beginning of vegetation growth, when there are fewer life stages present. During the
vegetation period all stages are often present and it is difficult to select a suitable product for
control and to predict optimum timing for its application (Michelleti et al. 2005).
Tested product kaolin is an aluminosilicate mineral. Kaolin particles create on plants
coating, which causes visual disorientation of adults, pests insects struggle with moving over
treated surface, and particles fill up suitable places for eggs which leads to reduce feeding and
oviposition (Kocourek and Stará 2007, Pultar 2007). Kaolin does not kill insects but acts as a
213
repellent or barrier against adults (Daniel and Wyss 2004). Ekol (90% coleseed oil) was also
tested in order to suffocate adults and eggs.
Material and methods
The study was conducted in 2008. The research site was in Holovousy village, Czech
Republic. Orchards with main pear varieties “Konference” and “Lukasova” were established
in 1993. The initial infestation level was high. In several preceding years improper control
methods were practised, the population density increased and crops were significantly
damaged by honeydew and, as a result, yields decreased. The research area was divided into
two uniform parts – treated and untreated. Size of experimental area was 1 ha.
Kaolin was tested against over-wintered adults of pear sucker to prevent egg-laying on
the branches and shoots. The first application was done before egg laying (BBCH 51-53).
Altogether there were three treatments of kaolin at intervals 10-14 days. During the snapping
of browses (BBCH 55) followed up two treatments of oil Ekol (coleseed oil) at intervals 12
days. After the leaf flush (BBCH 57), three types of insecticides were applied - Sanmite 20
WP (pyridaben), Insegar 25 WP (fenoxycarb) and Calypso 480 SC (thiacloprid). These
treatments were repeated at the same concentrations against the second generation. Chemical
control ended 25.6.2008 (Table 1).
Table 1. System of treatments against pear suckers in 2008.
Product name
Active ingredient
kaolin
kaolin
kaolin
Ekol
Ekol
Sanmite 20 WP
Insegar 25 WP
Calypso 480 SC
Sanmite 20 WP
Insegar 25 WP
Calypso 480 SC
Al4Si 4O10(OH)8
Al4Si 4O10(OH)8
Al4Si 4O10(OH)8
90% coleseed oil
90% coleseed oil
pyridaben
fenoxycarb
thiacloprid
pyridaben
fenoxycarb
thiacloprid
Dose
/ha
50 kg
25 kg
25 kg
9,0 l
9,0 l
0,75 kg
0,75 kg
0,20 kg
0,75 kg
0,75 kg
0,20 kg
Water
/ha
1000 l/ha
1000 l/ha
1000 l/ha
1000 l/ha
1000 l/ha
400 l/ha
400 l/ha
400 l/ha
400 l/ha
400 l/ha
400 l/ha
Date of
application
8.2.2008
25.2.2008
5.3.2008
4.4.2008
16.4.2008
23.4.2008
1.5.2008
9.5.2008
29.5.2008
10.6.2008
25.6.2008
For establishment of long-term effect of control the monitoring of all developmental
stages continued in both plots. Efficacy was compared with an untreated control. A tractor
mounted sprayer, Tifone Vanguard 1075, was used in the trial.
Beating tray samples were taken to monitor the density and the activity of C. pyri adults.
One sample comprised 25 beatings on 25 branches over a 0.25m2 tray. Eggs-laying and
nymph infestation were visually monitored on 20 randomly chosen clusters of blossoms or
young shoots. These parts of the tree were cut off and observed in the laboratory under a
microscope. Three samples for each evaluation were taken in both plots (control, treatment) at
6 or 7 days after application.
214
Results and discussion
Adults
The kaolin particle film does not kill adults, but acts as repellent or barrier and reduces
feeding and oviposition. Hence, the application of kaolin did not reduce numbers of adults, it
only prevented females laying their eggs. Ekol was ineffective. The best results of adult psylla
control being Calypso 480 SC (biological efficacy was 100% and 81, 25%, first and second
generation respectively). The population reduction of pear sucker when applying Insegar 25
WP was about 60% compared to the control. Sanmite 20 WP was effective only on the second
generation (biological efficacy was 81, 43%). At the end of the growing season the difference
between number of adults in the treated and non-treated plots was 83, 33%.
Eggs
The first kaolin treatment was applied before egg-laying. This precaution put behind and
narrowed period of mass egg-laying. Until the first half of March the number of eggs in
treated plot was low. Air temperature was low (about 5°C) and there was much precipitation
during the second half of March, washing off the kaolin shortly after the application. Because
no more applications were possible the numbers of pear sucker eggs on both plots had risen
by the end of the month. Following two treatments of coleseed oil, the amount off eggs
decreased again. Sanmite 20 WP was not effective against eggs of the first generation, but
very good control on the first and second generations was achieved with Insegar 25 WP with
ovicidal activity (biological efficacy was 97, 4% and 98, 54%) and Calypso 480 SC
(biological efficacy was 73, 83% and 89, 84%). At the end of growing season the difference
between number of eggs in the treated and non-treated plots was 88, 89%.
Nymphs
The highest efficacy was achieved by Calypso 480 SC (82, 29% and 91, 43%). Efficacy of
Insegar differed between generations (83, 15% – 31, 40%). Sanmite 20 WP achieved good
control in the first pear sucker generation (78, 79%). At the end of the growing season the
difference between number of nymphs in treated and non-treated plots was 38, 1%.
During the vegetation period there were lower numbers of adults, nymphs and eggs of
Cacopsylla pyri on the treated trees compared to the untreated control. However, the C. pyri
population did not remain under a damaging level and controls had to be applied on the
second generation as well. This observation might be explained by the high initial infestation
level and the immigration of pear suckers from the untreated control plot.
In general, the population density was significantly decreased, yield was not decreased,
and no honeydew or sooty moulds were observed on the fruits in the treated area. In the
beating tray samples made in the end of growing season there were green lacewings
(Chrysoperla carnea), seven spotted lady beetles (Coccinella septempunctata), bugs from
Anthocoridae family and many species of spiders on all plots.
These treatments will be repeated in a second year. Reducing pear sucker populations at
the end of growing season and presence of beneficial organisms and predators in the pear
orchard are good indicators for the efficacy of the treatments.
In accordance with the results of Daniel and Wyss (2004) there was a high efficacy of
kaolin in the trials conducted in Switzerland. Triple applications of kaolin (30 kg/1000 l)
against over wintered adults before blossom reduced amount of adults as well as amount of
nymphs consequently. Kaolin acts as repellent. Since it is not toxic to beneficial organisms
this product is suitable for organic farming (Daniel and Wyss 2004). Similar results with
kaolin treatments against Cacopsylla pyri are described by Pasqualiny et al. (2002), who
215
achieved a 99 to 100% reduction of eggs and nymphs by two applications in February /
March. Glenn et al. (1999) and Coupard (2001) also showed a significant reduction of eggs
and nymphs. According to Glenn et al. (1999) the adults get heavily coated with kaolin
particles within 24 hours and appeared preoccupied by attempts to remove these particles
from their body, unable to feed or to oviposit.
The coleseed oil Ekol is more effective in use with insecticides. In combination with
spinosad it was recommended for registration against pear suckers in pear orchards (Daniel
and Wyss 2004). The insecticides tested here were able to reduce pear sucker, but there are
very few products for growers to choose from, in the Czech Republic, against psyllids.
Neonicotinoides (Calypso 480 SC) may have a negative influence on beneficial organisms. In
addition the repeated use of products with the same active ingredients or same mode of action
may result in resistant psyllid populations (Falta 2008).
We tested new active ingredients; not only chemical (abamectin, spinosad), but botanical
(azadirachtin) and physically acting products as well. It is advised to insert mechanical as well
as biological (e.g. Anthocoris nemoralis introduction) methods of control to the integrated
pest management against pear suckers.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Czech Ministry of Agriculture - NAZV – project 1G58081
and Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport of the Czech Republic – project 2527112101.
References
Coupard, H. 2001: Etude de l’efficacité du Surround WP (Kaolin) dans la protection
préventive contre le psylle du poirier, Psylla pyri. Rapport annuel, Station
d’Experimentation Arboricole La Pugére.
Daniel, C. & Wyss, E. 2004: Efficacy of different insecticides and a repellent against the
European pear sucker (Cacopsylla pyri). Forschungsinstitut für biologischen Landbau
(FiBL), Switzerland, Organic Eprints: <http://orgprints.org>.
Falta, V. 2008: Lze zvládnout ochranu proti merám na hrušních? Agromanuál, No.3, p. 50-53.
Glenn, D. M. 1999: Hydrophobic particle films: a new paradigm for suppression of arthropod
pests and plant diseases. Journal of Ecomonic Entomology, No.92, p. 759-771.
Kocourek, F. & Stará, J. 2007: Škodlivost mer na hrušních a možnosti ochrany. Zpravodaj
Ovocnářské unie ČR, No.1, p. 15-19.
Lánský, M. et al. 2005: Integrovaná ochrana ovoce v systému integrované produkce,
Metodika. Holovousy: Výzkumný a šlechtitelský ústav ovocnářský Holovousy s.r.o.,
ISBN 80-902636-7-4.
Micheletti, S. & Slater, R. & Gillham, M. 2005: Susceptibility to abamectin of Pear Psylla
populations collected from Spain, Italy and France. Ghent University: Communications
in Agricultural and Applied Biological Science, No.70/4, p. 593 – 599.
Pasqualini, E. et al. 2002: Particle film technology: approach for a biorational control of
Cacopsylla pyri (Rynchota Psyllidae) in Northern Italy. Bulletin of Insectology, No.55, p.
39-42.
Pultar, O. 2007: Kaolin – direction for use. Non – published; verbal information.
216
Geographical distribution and population dynamics of the European
cherry fruit fly, Rhagoletis cerasi (Diptera: Tephritidae) in Greece
N.T. Papadopoulos1, M. Kleopatra1, S. Papanastasiou1, A. Diamantidis1, I. Kounatidis2,
P. Mavragani2, K. Bourtzis3, B. I. Katsoyannos4
1 Laboratory of Entomology and Agricultural Zoology, University of Thessaly Greece,
Phytokou st. N. Ionia (Volos), 58446 Magnisia, Greece ; 2 Department of Genetics,
Development and Molecular Biology, School of Biology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki,
54 124 Thessaloniki Greece ; 3 Laboratory of Applied Zoology and Parasitology, School of
Agriculture, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54 124 Thessaloniki Greece ; 4 Department
of Environmental and Natural Resources, University of Ioannina, 30100 Agrinio, Greece
Abstract: Although the European cherry fruit fly Rhagoletis cerasi L (Diptera: Tephritidae) poses a
major threat to cherry production in Greece, there are only a few studies on its bioecology. Following
extensive fruit sampling (during 2004 – 2008) we studied the geographical distribution of R. cerasi in
several areas all over Greece. Infested fruit samples were collected in the areas of Macedonia
(Thessaloniki, Katerini, Kozani, Halkidiki, Kavala), Thessaly (Trikala, Magnisia, Larissa, Karditsa),
Peloponnesus (Ilea, Achaia), Thrace (Komotini), Crete island (Chania), North Aegean sea (Lesvos
island). In addition to sweet cherries, R. cerasi pupae have been recovered from sour cherries
(Thessaloniki), wild growing cherries (Prunus spp.) (Kozani, Trikala, Magnisia) and Prunus mahaleb
(Trikala). Infestation levels varied greatly among sampling years, areas, and fruit species. Adults
obtained from pupae collected from samples, from all the above areas except Crete, were examined for
infections by the intracellular bacterium Wolbachia, which is known to exist in many European
populations of R. cerasi. All populations were found to be singly infected by the same Wolbachia
strain (wCer1). Pupal diapause termination and adult flight have been studied in a lowland – coastal
(Kala Nera Magnisias) and a highland area (Dafni Kozanis). Considerable differences exist both in
diapause intensity and adult flying period between the two populations. The above data together with
earlier data, collected in our laboratory, were used to construct population models for both areas.
Geographical distribution, Infestation levels, Wolbachia, Diapause termination, Adult flight
217
Population Dynamics and Damage Analysis of Cetonia aurata / Potosia
cuprea in Croatian peach orchards
Josip Razov¹, Bozena Baric², Miklós Tóth³
¹University of Zadar, Department of Mediterranean Agriculture and Aquaculture, Mihovila
Pavlinovica bb, 23000 Zadar, Croatia; ²Faculty of Agriculture, University of Zagreb,
Svetosimunska 25, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia; ³Plant Protection Institute, Hungarian Academy of
Science, Budapest, Pf 102, Hungary, H-1525
Abstract: During some of the last fifteen years in the coastal part of Croatia it was observed that
scarab beetles from the subfamily Cetoniinae caused damage to ripening peaches. With further
analysis it was shown that these species were Cetonia aurata and Potosia cuprea. In 2007 we
monitored their appearance and population dynamics, and we calculated the damage they caused. This
was done in two locations in Zadar, Ravni kotari region. The Csalomon® VARb3k traps with baits
consisting of 100 µl phenethyl alcohol + 100 µl methyl eugenol + 100 µl trans anethol were used. The
total number of trapped beetles from the two locations was 569 Cetonia aurata and 200 Potosia cuprea.
The damage percentage ranged from 0 % up to 7 %.
Key words: Cetonia aurata, Potosia cuprea, peaches, damages, population dynamics, attractant traps.
Introduction
During some of the last fifteen years in the coastal part of Croatia it was observed that scarab
beetles from the subfamily Cetoniinae (Coleoptera, Scarabaeoidea, Cetoniidae) caused
damage to ripening peaches. Several damage reports were received from the farmers. These
beetles have started to make damage not only during flowering, but also during fruit ripening.
It was noticed that they cause damage by biting the fruits and making lesions that way.
Attacked fruits were not acceptable to the market, especially if mould diseases appeared on
the damaged parts, which happened quite often.
The literature data about the damage they cause in Croatia are quite poor. They have been
known as beetles that are attracted to flowers and to ripe and over ripe fruits (Endrödi, 1956;
Miksic, 1965). They have been reported as a fig pest, but almost without any importance
(Bakaric et al., 1989), and as a peach flower and fruit pest, but with a remark that the fruit
wound had been caused by a bird or some other pest (Maceljski, 2002). Very recently they
have been reported as a severe peach fruit pest (Baric et al., 2006).
These beetles cannot be efficiently suppressed with insecticides because they are very
resistant. Most insecticides cannot be applied during flowering without affecting honeybees,
bumblebees or other beneficials. Also, almost no insecticide can be applied during the
ripening period because of the waiting period of the insecticide.
Materials and methods
Locations
The experiments were conducted during 2007 at two locations in Zadar, Ravni kotari area.
The first location was a peach orchard near Skabrnja village, total area 1.5 ha, with the
following peach and nectarine cultivars: Flavorcrest, Glohaven, Elegant Lady, Fayette, Stark
218
Redgold and Caldesi 2000. The rootstock is GF 677. The other location was also a peach
orchard near Prkos village, total area 0.25 ha, some 5 km away, with the following cultivars:
May Crest, Caldesi 2000, Glohaven, Suncrest and Maria Aurelia. The rootstock is also GF
677.
Traps
We used the Csalomon® VARb3k funnel traps, which are light blue, the optimal visual
attractant cue for Cetonia, and contain a floral attractant bait for Cetonia/Potosia. These baits
are composed of 100 µl phenethyl alcohol + 100 µl methyl eugenol + 100 µl trans anethol
(Schmera et al., 2004; Tóth et al., 2005; Vuts et al., 2007). Photos of the trap can be viewed at
www.julia-nki.hu/traps. The traps were set at a sunny place on the peach tree, at about 1.2 –
1.5 m height. We set four traps in Prkos and two in Skabrnja. The traps were set 15 m from
each other, on different rows, on 8 May, and they were taken off on 30 August, which gave a
monitoring period of 114 days. The baits were set on the trap setting date, and changed on 8
June and 6 July.
Monitoring
Traps were inspected twice weekly, when captured insects were collected and identified.
Damage Analysis
The damage percentage was calculated in the following way: we marked 8 trees of each
cultivar, and checked 25 fruits per tree, 8 fruits from the first branch floor, 9 fruits from the
second branch floor and again 8 fruits from the third branch floor, at the time that each
cultivar ripened. Every fruit was visually inspected, and if we noticed damage typical of
Cetonia / Potosia, we considered this as one damaged fruit. All together, we checked 8 trees
and 200 fruits of each cultivar. The assessment dates were as follows: In Prkos on 26 May, 8
June, 2, 11 and 20 July, and 8 August, and in Skabrnja 26 May, 8 and 19 June, 2, 11, 20 and
31 July, and 8 August. We counted the damaged fruits and divided that number with the total
number of inspected fruits to calculate the damage percentage.
Results and Discussion
Population Dynamics
In Prkos Cetonia aurata and Potosia cuprea were found on the first inspection date (11 May).
The peak was reached on the 12 June, but it can be noticed that there are actually 3 peaks
which follow the bait change. It can be seen that the bait attractance diminishes after 30 days.
The last samples were trapped on 20 July (C. aurata) and 3 August (P. cuprea). All together
we trapped 523 C. aurata and 189 P. cuprea. It seems that C. aurata ended its flight earlier
than P. cuprea.
In Skabrnja C. aurata and P. cuprea appeared on the second inspection date, on 14 May.
Here we can barely recognize three peaks of C. aurata, and almost no peaks of P. cuprea..
The catches were small compared to Prkos, but only 2 traps were used. The last samples were
trapped on 11 July of both species. All together we trapped 46 C. aurata and 11 P. cuprea. If
we took into the consideration that with 4 traps we caught 523 pcs. of C. aurata and 189 pcs.
of P. cuprea in Prkos, and with 2 traps we caught 46 pcs. of C. aurata and 11 pcs of P. cuprea
in Skabrnja, we could say that in Skabrnja there were less Cetonia and Potosia that in Prkos.
The total number of trapped beetles from both locations was 569 C. aurata and 200 P. cuprea.
219
No.of captured beetles
120
100
80
C.aurata
60
P.cuprea
40
20
11
/0
18 5/2
/0 00
25 5/2 7
/0 00
01 5/2 7
/0 00
08 6/2 7
/0 00
15 6/2 7
/0 00
22 6/2 7
/0 00
29 6/2 7
/0 00
06 6/2 7
/0 00
13 7/2 7
/0 00
20 7/2 7
/0 00
27 7/2 7
/0 00
03 7/2 7
/0 00
10 8/2 7
/0 00
17 8/2 7
/0 00
24 8/2 7
/0 00
8/ 7
20
07
0
Figure 1. Population Dynamics in Prkos Orchard, 2007
No.of captured beetles
16
14
12
10
8
C.aurata
P.cuprea
6
4
2
11
/0
18 5/2
/0 00
25 5/2 7
/0 00
01 5/2 7
/0 00
08 6/2 7
/0 00
15 6/2 7
/0 00
22 6/2 7
/0 00
29 6/2 7
/0 00
06 6/2 7
/0 00
13 7/2 7
/0 00
20 7/2 7
/0 00
27 7/2 7
/0 00
03 7/2 7
/0 00
10 8/2 7
/0 00
17 8/2 7
/0 00
24 8/2 7
/0 00
8/ 7
20
07
0
Figure 2. Population Dynamics in Skabrnja orchard, 2007
Damage Analysis
There was less damage in Prkos than in Skabrnja. One part of this result is due to only 2 traps
in Skabrnja, comparied to 4 traps in Prkos. Also, the orchard in Skabrnja is much bigger (1.5
ha) than the orchard in Prkos (0.25 ha). The results show the cultivar damage differences in
each orchard. In Prkos, the earliest cultivar, May Crest was attacked the most (3%). Suncrest
was a little bit less damaged (2%). There was no damage at all on nectarine Caldesi 2000 and
peaches Glohaven and Maria Aurelia. The date of the damage assessment on May Crest and
Suncrest when there was damage seen actually follows the catch peaks in the traps, so we can
say that there obviously is a connection between the number and the dynamics of Cetonia and
220
Potosia and damage caused .
In Skabrnja, the biggest damage was on Glohaven peach (7%), little bit less on
Flavorcrest (5%), 4 % on nectarines Caldesi 2000 and Stark Redgold and peach Elegant
Lady, and 3 % on Fayette. In this orchard there was damage on all cultivars. Here we cannot
draw the parallel between the beetle dynamics and damage. When the highest peak was
recorded (26 May), there was no damage observed. At the time of the second peak (22 June),
it could be said that there is a parallel, since at that time we observed the 4 % damage on
Caldesi 2000 (19 June) and 5 % damage on Flavorcrest (2 July). The most attacked cultivar
was Glohaven. The nectarines were less attacked than some peaches.
In small orchards such as the one in Prkos (0.25 ha), with 4 traps we could control the
damage. This is the reason why there was more damage in Skabrnja. Thus, in an orchard of 1
ha we would need about 15 traps to control the damage below the economical threshold.
Acknowledgements
We thank the County of Zadar, The Department of Agriculture, who financially supported the
research and this article.
References
Bakaric, P., Brzica, K., Omcikus, C. 1989: Smokva, Stanica za juzne kulture, Dubrovnik,
Hrvatska.
Baric, B., Razov, J., Kovacic, Z. 2008: Common pests in Croatian peach orchards. – IOBC
wprs Bulletin 37:131 – 133.
Dutto, M. 2005: Coleotteri Cetoniidae D'Italia. Monografie Entomologiche Vol. I, Natura
Edizioni Scientifiche, Bologna, Italy.
Endrödi, S. 1956: Lemezescsápú Bogarak Lamellicornia, Akademia Kiadó, Budapest,
Hungary.
Maceljski, M. 2002: Poljoprivredna Entomologija, Zrinski, Cakovec, Hrvatska.
Miksic, R. 1965: Scarabaeidae Jugoslavije III, Naucno Drustvo Bosne i Hercegovine,
Sarajevo, Bosna i Herzegovina.
Schmera, D., Toth., M., Subchev, M., Sredkov, I., Szarukan, I., Jermy, T., Szentesi, A. 2004:
Importance of visual and chemical cues in the development of an attractant trap for
Epicometis (Tropinota) hirta Poda (Coleoptera:Scarabaeidae) – Crop Protection 23: 939 –
944.
Tóth, M., Imrei, Z., Szarukan, I., Voigt, E., Schmera, D., Vuts, J., Harmincz, K., Subchev, M.
2005: Chemical communication of fruit-and flower- damaging scarabs: results of one
decade's research efforts, Novenyvedelem 41:581-588
Tóth, M., Voigt, E., Imrei, Z., Szarukán, I., Schmera, D., Vuts, J., Harmincz, K., Subchev, M.,
Sivcev, I. 2006: Semiochemical-baited traps for scarab pests damaging fruits and
blossoms. Abstracts of 58th Intl. Symp. Crop Prot., May 23, 2006, Gent, Belgium, pp.
196.
Voigt, E., Tóth, M., Imrei, Z., Vuts, J., Szöllœs, L., Szarukán, I. 2005. A zöld cserebogár és az
aranyos rózsabogár növekvœ kártétele és a környezetkímélœ védekezés lehetœségei.
Damages by Anomala vitis and Cetonia aurata (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae) and
possibilities for environmentally harmless control (in Hung.) Agrofórum 16:63-64.
Vuts, J., Imrei, Z., Tóth, M. 2007: Improving the field activity of the synthetic floral bait in
Cetonia a. aurata and Potosia cuprea (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae: Cetoniinae). Book of
Abstracts, 23rd ISCE Annual Meeting, Jena, Germany, 22-26 July 2007, 101 pp.
221
Spatial patterns and Sampling of predatory mites (Acari:
Phytoseiidae) on apple orchards
J. Raul Rodrigues1, Laura M. Torres2
1 Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo, Escola Superior Agrária de Ponte de Lima, Dep.
Ciências da Planta e do Ambiente, Refóios do Lima, 4990-706 Ponte de Lima, Portugal; 2
Universidade de Trás-os-Montes e Alto Douro, Dep. Protecção de Plantas, Quinta de Prados,
5000-911 Vila Real, Portugal.
Abstract: The spatial distribution of the predatory mites (Acari phytoseiidae), was studied by
applying Taylor’s power law and Iwao’s regression models. Studies were carried out during two
consecutive growing seasons (2003 and 2004) in a two apple orchards (Cvs: Royal Gala and Golden
Smoothee) of Nortwest Portugal. The species present, there was a complex dominated by the
generalist predators Euseius stipulatus (Athias-Henriot) and Kampimodromus aberrans (Oudemans) in
Ponte de Lima and by Amblyseius andersoni (Chant) and E. stipulatus in Braga. The relationship
between mean and variance was studied by Taylor’s power law and Iwao’s regression models. Both
models showed good fit to the data (Taylor R2=97.3%, Iwao R2 = 90.3%, p<0.001), concluding that
the phytoseiid species has an aggretated distribution on vineyard fields. The spatial distribution of
phytoseiids was aggregated, according the Taylor (b = 1.195 ± 0.021; t1,987 = 8.921; d.f. = 88; p
<0.001) and Iwao (b = 1.652 ± 0.058; t1,987 = 11.292; d.f. = 88; p <0.001) coefficients. The Taylor’s
regression coefficients were commons for both places and cultivars, which justifies a common
sampling program for the complex species presents. The optimal sample size (leaves) for phytoseiids
populations with fixed precision levels of 0.15, 0.20 and 0.25 where estimated with Taylor’s regression
coefficients. The results showed that a smaller number of leaves are required for the detection of high
phytoseiids densities and the required sample sizes, increased considerably with increased levels of
precision. A binomial sampling procedure has been developed through the relationship between the
proportion of leaves occupied and the men number of phytoseiids per leaf. The strong significant
relationship between the estimated and observed proportion of occupied leaves (R2 = 87.5%; d.f. = 89;
F = 614.48; p <0,001), makes it possible to use a binomial or presence-absence sampling approach.
Presence-absence sampling is an efficient method for crop management purposes because less time is
needed to process the samples compared with a method where all phytoseiids are counted.
Phytoseiidae, Biocontrol, Sampling methods, Taylor power law, Integrated pest management
222
An inventory of tortricids (Lepidoptera, Tortricidae) in Swedish apple
orchards as a basis for future management strategies
Patrick Sjöberg1, Christer Tornéus2, Birgitta Rämert1, Ylva Hillbur1
1
Department of Plant Protection Biology, SLU Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences,
P.O. Box 102, SE-230 53 Alnarp, Sweden; 2Swedish Board of Agriculture, Plant Protection
Centre, P.O. Box 12, SE-230 53 Alnarp, Sweden
Abstract: Over the last couple of years, growers, researchers, advisors and plant protection companies
have noticed increasing problems with tortricids in Swedish apple orchards. Since the insecticide
Gusathion (azinphosmethyl) has been banned (end of 2008; KemI 2008), a further increase of tortricid
populations can be expected. In order to get a picture of species composition and population densities
among the tortricids, an inventory of seven species, Adoxophyes orana, Archips podana, Archips
rosana, Cydia pomonella, Hedya nubiferana, Pandemis heparana and Spilonota ocellana was made in
11 orchards in southern Sweden (Skåne) in 2008. Population densities were estimated by bud sampling
(April 20-25), pheromone trapping (May 5-September 22) and assessment of fruit damage (September
9-12). In all orchards A. podana was the dominating species followed by A. rosana and P. heparana.
Generally trap catches of C. pomonella were low, but flight activity was recorded over a longer period
of time. Similar flight curves were observed for P. heparana and S. ocellana. Trap catches of H.
nubiferana were very low at all sites. A. orana only occurred in one of the orchards and exhibited two
peaks in flight activity, indicating that there were two generations. Infestation levels of tortricid larvae
were low in bud samples, possibly due to sampling being done too early in the season. Average fruit
damage was 5%, varying from 1.6 to 21%. The inventory will be the basis for development of future
management strategies and forecasting tools.
Key words: Tortricids, pheromone traps, apple orchard, inventory, bud samples
223
Spread of European stone fruit yellows in Piedmont (northwestern
Italy) and presence of Cacopsylla pruni Scopoli in plum and apricot
orchards
Rosemarie Tedeschi1, Daniele Demaria2, Alessandro Cesano1, Federica Tota1, Graziano
Vittone2, Alberto Alma1
1
Università degli Studi di Torino, Di.Va.P.R.A. - Entomologia e Zoologia applicate
all’Ambiente “Carlo Vidano”,Via L. da Vinci 44 - 10095 Grugliasco (TO), Italy.
2
CReSO, Consorzio di Ricerca e Sperimentazione per l’Ortofrutticoltura piemontese, Cuneo,
Italy.
Abstract: In recent years, high percentages of declining plants showing symptoms ascribable to the
European stone fruit yellows (ESFY) disease were recorded in plum and apricot orchards in Piedmont,
north western Italy. Since 2006, visual inspections were carried out in dozens of orchards to assess the
incidence of symptomatic plants in early spring (premature budbreaks) and late summer (yellowing
and leafroll). Surveys with yellow sticky traps and beating tray were carried out from the beginning of
March until the beginning of June to monitor the presence of Cacopsylla pruni and other possible
vectors in the orchards and in the surroundings on wild Prunus species. The presence of “Candidatus
Phytoplasma prunorum” in plum and apricot trees as well as in the insects was ascertained by PCR
and RFLP analyses. The very low C. pruni population density recorded and the presence of “Ca.
Phytoplasma prunorum” in recently planted orchards (1 year old) suggest an early infection possibly
occurring in the nurseries.
Key words: European stone fruit yellows, Cacopsylla pruni, plum, apricot.
Introduction
European stone fruit yellows (ESFY) is one of the most important fruit tree diseases
inducing serious damage in cultivated Prunus species in Europe. It is caused by a
phytoplasma, “Candidatus Phytoplasma prunorum” belonging to the 16SrX phylogenetic
group (Seemüller and Schneider, 2004). The typical symptoms are early foliation at the end of
the winter, yellows and leaf roll in summer, dieback and a more or less rapid decline. Its
prevalence has increased in all Europe in recent years especially after the introduction of
Japanese plums. Carraro et al. (1998; 2001) identified the psyllid Cacopsylla pruni Scopoli as
the vector of this phytoplasma in Italy, while Jarausch et al. (2001), Laviña et al. (2004) and
Fialova et al. (2004) confirmed the vectoring ability of this species in France, Spain and
Czech Republic respectively. Also in Piedmont, northwestern Italy, high percentages of
declining plants showing symptoms ascribable to the ESFY disease were recorded in Japanese
plum and apricot orchards in the last years. For this reason, since 2006, preliminary surveys
to assess the incidence of the disease through the region and the presence of the insect vectors
have been carried out.
Materials and methods
Field surveys
The surveys were carried out since 2006 in differently aged stone fruit orchards located in the
province of Cuneo, Piedmont, north western Italy. Visual inspections were performed in
224
either spring or autumn or in both seasons, in 44 plum orchards and in 7 apricot orchards to
find plants with symptoms resembling phytoplasma infections. Number of symptomatic
plants and quality of the symptoms were noted. Vegetal samples were collected from
symptomatic plants and from trees without symptoms.
Surveys with yellow sticky traps were carried out from the beginning of March until the
beginning of June to monitor the presence of C. pruni and other possible vectors in the
orchards. Three traps/orchard (200x250 mm) were hung and changed every 10 days. Eight
plum orchards and 9 apricot orchards were analysed. C. pruni specimens were removed from
sticky traps using a drop of Bio-Clear (Bio-Optica, Milano, Italy) – a clearing agent of
vegetable origin – and subjected to molecular analysis. Moreover, psyllid samples were
collected with the beating tray method in the orchards and in the surroundings on wild Prunus
species and analysed by molecular tools.
Phytoplasma detection and identification
Plant DNA was isolated from phloem tissue from field-collected branch samples using the
Pure Link TM Plant Total DNA Purification kit (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, USA). Approximately
1 g of fresh plant material was used for each plant. Insect DNA was extracted following a
protocol adapted from Marzachì et al. (1998) and already applied for psyllids (Tedeschi et al.,
2002). Insect and plant DNAs were amplified with a nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR)
firstly with phytoplasma universal primer pair P1/P7 (Schneider et al., 1995) and then with
the AP-group specific primer pair fO1/rO1 (Lorenz et al., 1995) after a 1:40 dilution.
Reaction and cycling conditions were as described in the original papers. PCR amplification
products were analysed by 1% agarose gel electrophoresis, stained with ethidium bromide,
and visualised on a U.V. transilluminator. Moreover, the amplicons were restricted with the
endonuclease RsaI which allows the specific identification of the “Ca. Phytoplasma
prunorum” in RFLP analysis. Seven microlitres of the amplicon were digested with 5 U of
RsaI at 37°C overnight.
Results
Spread of the disease
Different symptoms were observed on plum and apricot plants. We distinguished between
suspected symptoms such as chlorosis without leaf roll or non-chlorotic leaf roll and specific
symptoms such as early foliation in the late winter period and chlorotic leaf roll in the
summer. Ninety percent of the orchards investigated had at least one symptomatic plant (Tab.
1), and 33% of the tested plants were positive to phytoplasmas belonging to the 16SrX group.
RFLP analyses confirmed the presence of “Ca. Phytoplasma prunorum”.
A high correlation was observed between specific symptoms and phytoplasma detection
by PCR, but also, 8.6% of plum tested plants and 55.5% of apricot tested plants with
suspected symptoms were infected. In plum orchards the presence of suspected symptoms is
normally more common in young plants while the incidence of the disease evaluated by
means of specific symptoms remains quite constant during the years. Particularly interesting
is the presence of typical symptoms in 1-year-old plants, supported also by phytoplasma
detection by PCR.
225
Table 1. Presence of suspected (e.g. chlorosis without leaf roll or non chlorotic leaf roll) and
specific symptoms (e.g. early foliation and chlorotic leaf roll) in differently aged plum and
apricot orchards.
Plant age Monitored Monitored
Symptomatic plants
(years)
orchards
plants
Suspected
%
Specific
%
n°.
n°.
n°.
n°.
1
8
469
111
23.7
11
2.3
2-3
18
4779
218
4.6
82
1.7
Plum
4-5
4
184
69
28.8
9
2.7
6-7
5
1771
104
5.9
70
4.0
>8
9
2881
204
7.1
198
6.9
4-5
1
473
1
0.2
0
0
Apricot
6-7
3
1984
4
0.2
21
1.1
>8
3
1772
49
2.8
76
4.3
Insect vectors
During the three years, the number of C. pruni collected with yellow sticky traps on apricot
and plum was always very low (Fig. 1). Five C. pruni specimens collected with yellow sticky
traps and two specimens collected with the beating tray method on cultivated plum plants and
analysed by PCR were negative for “Ca. Phytoplasma prunorum”. Other psyllid species, C.
melanoneura (Förster), C. pulchella (Löw) and Trioza alacris Flor were collected in the
orchards with higher densities, but they always resulted negative for the phytoplasma.
Surveys on wild Prunus species enabled the collection of 57 specimens of C. pruni on P.
spinosa L. and “Ca. Phytoplasma prunorum” was detected in 3 of them.
Figure 1. Mean number of Cacopsylla pruni/orchard collected with yellow sticky traps in
apricot and plum orchards in the years 2006-2008.
Discussion
The present, preliminary research pointed out the widespread presence of “Ca. Phytoplasma
prunorum” in Japanese plum and apricot orchards in Piedmont, a region where the plum
cultivation is consistently increasing. After a long tradition of only European cultivars, new
Japanese cultivars were introduced in the nineties and some of them, e.g. Angeleno, had a
great success because of the belated harvest period and an extremely good keeping quality.
Our results demonstrated that the spread of the disease is not, at this moment, attributable to
the known vector C. pruni, because of its very low population density recorded. Thus specific
control strategies against this psyllid are not necessary now.
226
14.Jun.
06-Jun.
28-May
16-May
7-May
0
14.Jun.
0.1
0
06-Jun.
0.2
28-May
0.2
16-May
0.4
7-May
0.3
26-Apr.
0.6
18-Apr.
0.4
10-Apr.
2008
0.5
0.8
28-Mar.
2007
0.6
26-Apr.
1
2006
Apricot
18-Apr.
2008
19-Mar.
C. pruni
1.2
0.7
10-Apr.
2007
28-Mar.
2006
Plum
1.4
19-Mar.
1.6
Moreover, the detection of “Ca. Phytoplasma prunorum” in very young plants suggests
the role of propagation material in the diffusion of ESFY, and more attention on this aspect is
required in the future. But the psyllid C. pruni should not be underestimated: the spread of
plum cultivation may stimulate the population density of C. pruni, that might became
worrying considering also the relevant inoculum source of the phytoplasma in the region. At
the same time the possibility of other insect vectors should not be excluded. Further attention
should be focused on P. spinosa, which proved to be the favourite host plant (Carraro et al.,
2002), considering also the location of it’s hedges that are often in the surroundings of
cultivated stone fruit orchards.
Acknowledgements
We thank all the farmers involved in the present study and in particular the technician Sergio
Martini for helping with the field work. This research was supported by Regione Piemonte
(Italy) within the program: Programma di ricerca, sperimentazione e dimostrazione Agricola
in frutticoltura e orticoltura - 2008
References
Carraro, L, Loi N. & Ermacora P. 2001. Transmission characteristics of European stone fruit
yellows phytoplasma and its vector Cacopsylla pruni. J. Plant Pathol. 107: 695-700.
Carraro, L., Ferrini F., Ermacora P. & Loi N. 2002. Role of wild prunus species in the
epidemiology of European stone fruit yellows. Plant Pathol. 51: 513-517.
Carraro, L, Osler R., Loi N., Ermacora P. & Refatti E. 1998. Transmission of European stone
fruit phytoplasma by Cacopsylla pruni. J. Plant Pathol. 80: 233-239.
Fialova, R., Navratil M., Valova P. & Kocourek F. 2004. Epidemiology of European stone
fruit yellows phytoplasma in Czech Republic. Acta Hort. 657: 483-487.
Jarausch, W., Jarausch-Wehrheim B., Danet J.L., Broquaire J.M., Dosba F., Saillard C. &
Garnier M. 2001. Detection and identification of European stone fruit yellows and other
phytoplasmas in wild plants in the surroundings of apricot chlorotic leaf roll-affected
orchards in southern France. Eur. J. Plant Pathol. 107: 209-217.
Laviña, A., Sabaté M., Garcia-Chapa M., Battle A. & Torres E. 2004. Occurence and
epidemiology of European stone fruit yellows (ESFY) phytoplasma in France. Acta Hort.
657: 489-494.
Lorenz, K. H., Schneider B., Ahrens U. & Seemüller E. 1995. Detection of the Apple
Proliferation and Pear Decline Phytoplasmas by PCR amplification of ribosomal and non
ribosomal DNA. Phytopathology 85: 771-776.
Marzachì, C., Veratti F. & Bosco D. 1998. Direct PCR detection of phytoplasmas in
experimentally infected insects. Ann. Appl. Biol. 133: 45-54.
Schneider, E., Seemüller E., Smart C. D. & Kirkpatrick B. C. 1995. Phylogenetic
classification of plant pathogenic mycoplasma-like organism or phytoplasmas. In Razin
S., J.G. Tully (eds.). Molecular and Diagnostic Procedures in Mycoplasmology, Vol I, pp.
369-380. Academic Press, San Diego.
Seemüller, E. & Schneider B. 2004. “Candidatus Phytoplasma mali”, “Candidatus
Phytoplasma pyri” and “Candidatus Phytoplasma prunorum”, the causal agent of apple
proliferation, pear decline and European sone fruit yellows, respectively. Int. J. Syst.
Bacteriol. 54: 1217-1226.
Tedeschi, R., Bosco D. & Alma A. 2002. Population dynamics of Cacopsylla melanoneura
(Homoptera: Psyllidae), a vector of apple proliferation phytoplasma in northwestern
Italy. J. Econ. Entomol. 95(3): 544-551.
227
Observations of Rhagoletis cingulata, an invasive species from North
America, on cherry in Germany
Heidrun Vogt1, Kirsten Köppler1, Werner Dahlbender2 & Günter Hensel2
1
Julius Kühn-Institut (JKI), Fed. Res. Centre for Cultivated Plants, Inst. for Plant Protection
in Fruit Crops and Viticulture, Dossenheim, Germany; heidrun.vogt@jki.bund.de
2
Dienstzentrum Ländlicher Raum (DLR) Rheinpfalz, Advisory Service Plant Protection in
Fruit Crops, Oppenheim, Germany
Abstract. Since 2003, the Eastern cherry fruit fly, Rhagoletis cingulata (Loew), an introduced
Tephritid fly from North America, has been observed in Germany in increasing abundance. We present
an overview of the increase in distribution and discuss the consequences for management programs for
sour cherry (Prunus cerasus). Following the identification of a single female in a malaise trap in
Rhineland-Palatinate (central Rhine region) in 1999, a trapping program was conducted near the
original host site and in several cherry growing regions from 2002 onward. In 2003, a few specimens
of R. cingulata were reported on yellow traps in cherry orchards in the Rhineland-Palatinate area.
Since 2004, the number of individuals found in Rhineland-Palatinate cherry growing regions increased
considerably and the species was also found in other Federal states. At the present time, the species
has been collected from nearly all cherry-growing regions of Germany. In Germany, R. cingulata is
emerging 3-4 weeks later than does the European cherry fruit fly, R. cerasi, and mainly attacks sour
cherries. In some years and locations, the Eastern cherry fruit fly has caused more than 20 % damage
in sour cherries, whereas infestation due to R. cerasi in sour cherries usually is of low importance. The
species status has been confirmed by Dr. Allen Norrbom, Systematic Entomology Laboratory,
Agricultural Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, USA.
Keywords: Rhagoletis cingulata, Rhagoletis cerasi, phenology, infestation, host plants
Introduction
The Eastern cherry fruit fly Rhagoletis cingulata (Loew) is a severe pest of cherries, originating from North America. After the record of a single female in 1999 in the middle Rhine
valley (Merz & Niehus 2001), a monitoring program was conducted with yellow traps and
fruit samples. Since 2003 the species has been observed in Germany in increasing abundance
(Lampe & Krauthausen 2005, Lampe et al. 2006, Vogt 2007a & b, Maring &Kirchner 2008)
and thus is a further threat for cherry growing beside the native species, the European cherry
fruit fly R. cerasi.
Material & Methods
Monitoring was done with yellow traps, type Rebell® in all cherry growing regions of Germany. Fruit samples were taken in Rhineland-Palatinate in an extensive production area of
sour and sweet cherries between Mainz and Bingen in the Rhine valley. Cherries were put in
boxes with a grid bottom, so that larvae could leave them for pupation. Pupae were collected
and stored for diapause at 3 to 5° C for 5 to 7 months. For post-diapause development, pupae
were brought to a climate chamber (25 ± 0.5°C / 18 ± 0.5°C, RH 65 ± 5 %, photoperiod
light:dark 16:8 h, 4 to 6 klx). The same procedure was followed for fruit samples from Prunus
mahaleb and Prunus serotina. Emerged adults were determined to species (Carroll et al.
2002). We also checked the wing pattern as it is known to be variable. Characteristics used for
228
the discrimination between R. cerasi and R. cingulata larvae and pupae were the mandibles of
the cephalopharyngeal skeleton (Carroll et al. 2004) and the color of the puparium. The
puparium of R. cingulata is brown, that of R. cerasi is beige. Individuals of R. cingulata were
sent to the Systematic Entomology Laboratory, Agricultural Research Service, US
Department of Agriculture, USA, for species confirmation.
Results
Monitoring with yellow traps
R. cingulata has been detected in the main cherry growing regions of Germany: in BadenWürttemberg, Brandenburg, Bavaria, Hesse, Hamburg, Lower Saxony, North Rhine-Westphalia, Rhineland-Palatinate, Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt and Thuringia, attaining high abundances in some of these regions. It occurs mainly in sour cherry (Prunus cerasus) orchards,
and in areas where Prunus mahaleb and Prunus serotina, its main native host, are present.
The flight peak of the species occurs 3-4 weeks later than that of the European cherry
fruit fly, R. cerasi (Fig. 1). In cherry orchards, late varieties, especially sour cherries like the
economic important variety “Schattenmorellen” are most threatened.
No. of flies on Rebell trap
140
120
R. cerasi
100
R. cingulata
80
60
40
20
08
.0
5.
14
.0
5.
21
.0
5.
29
.0
5.
04
.0
6.
11
.0
6.
18
.0
6.
25
.0
6.
03
.0
7.
09
.0
7.
16
.0
7.
23
.0
7.
30
.0
7.
06
.0
8.
20
.0
8.
0
Fig. 1. Flight activity of cherry fruit flies in 2007 in a sour cherry orchard without insecticide
treatment (Heidesheim F4)
Fruit samples
2004 was the first year in which we provided evidence for R. cingulata infestation in sour
cherries in the Mainz-Bingen area. More than 150 collected pupae had the typical brown
colour and only R. cingulata emerged from these pupae in the following year after diapause.
In 2005 the infestation level in sour cherries from four localities in Rhineland-Palatinate
without insecticide treatment was between 2 and 11 % with a proportion of 7.4 % R. cerasi
and 92.6 % R. cingulata on average (Table 1). In 2006, fruit samples of tart cherries from four
untreated cherry orchards revealed infestation levels due to R. cingulata up to 21 %. One
treatment with dimethoate (which is no longer registered for cherry fruit fly control in
Germany) reduced the infestation level from 21 to 2.4 %. Fruit samples from P. mahaleb in
229
the Mainz-Bingen area from 2008 were infested by both fruit fly species to a level of around
10 % (82.5 % R. cerasi, 17.5 % R. cingulata) in 2008. Up to 6 % of P. serotina fruits from
forests in the Upper Rhine Valley near Mannheim were infested with R. cingulata in 2008. A
low R. cingulata attack of 0.6 % was detected in sweet cherries, Prunus avium (untreated
single tree at a field path) in 2008.
Table 1. Infestation of sour cherries by R. cerasi and R. cingulata at four localities in the
Mainz-Bingen area, 2005
Locality
1 Heidesheim, Heuweg
2 Wackernheim, Rabenkof
3 Heidesheim, Sandgrube
4 Wackernheim
Infestation %
3.5
1.7
11.4
2.2
Proportion %
R. cingulata
No. of pupae R. Cerasi
115
66
211
42
Sum 434
A
12.2
12.1
5.2
0.0
Mean 7.4
87.8
87.9
94.8
100.0
Mean 92.6
B
Fig. 2. R. cingulata wing patterns; left: type A (example from Dossenheim, 2004); right:
type B (example from Rheinhessen 2006) (Photos: JKI Dossenheim)
Table 2. Proportion of R. cingulata adults found in Germany with wing patterns type A or B
(see text for explanation)
Type A
Type B
Dossenheim 2007-2008
8
0
Dossenheim 2004-2006
15
14
Rheinhessen 2004-2006
119
41
Bayern 2006
1
1
BW, Zavelstein 2006
0
1
Thüringen 2005
9
2
Brandenburg 2006
21
1
sum
173
60
percentage
74.2
25.8
Wing pattern
In 74% of the collected individuals of R. cingulata from Germany the anterior arm of the apical band forms an isolated spot (=type A) and in 26% the anterior arm of the apical band is
more or less complete and connected to the posterior apical band (= type B) ( Fig. 2 & Table
230
2). Both wing patterns occurred in all regions.
Discussion
R. cingulata is established in Germany. Date and method of introduction are not known. The
native host plant, P. serotina, introduced to Europe since the 17th century and now widely distributed in hedges, windbreaks and forests, is probably involved, as R. cingulata has been
detected in P. serotina fruits from a forest by the first author and by Holz from windbreak
plants in Brandenburg (personal communication 2007). Genetic studies might help to
elucidate these questions.
As a consequence, cherry fruit fly control is now necessary in the economic important
tart cherry variety „Schattenmorellen“, which was not the case before. Late sweet cherry
varieties are also threatened. The rise in abundance is probably correlated with changes in
insecticide control of cherry fruit fly (no highly effective organophosphates are allowed any
more) and with the increase of abandoned tart cherry orchards, which serve as reservoir.
Furthermore, P. mahaleb, which is used as rootstock for sour cherries, often imbrutes in these
areas and thus is serving as further host plant.
With regard to the control of cherry fruit fly, there are severe problems, as in Germany,
no insecticide is registered for chemical control of cherry fruit fly. Only exceptional permits
for the use of Mospilan (a.i. acetamiprid) have been given. The application dates have to be
carefully adapted as R. cingulata prolongs the infestation period. Actually, no alternatives
exist to chemical CFF control, though research is ongoing on e.g. bait sprays.
Acknowledgements
We thank colleagues from the plant protection service for their cooperation in the trapping
program: Dr. K. Geipel (Freising, Bavaria), U. Holz (Frankfurt/Oder, Brandenburg), E.
Maring (Erfurt, Thuringia), D. Mohr & Dr. G. Palm (Jork, Lower Saxony), G. Sartorius
(Friedberg, Hesse), Dr. H. Saucke (Witzenhausen, Hesse), Dr. A. Trapp (Dresden, Saxony).
We thank Dr. Allen Norrbom, US Department of Agriculture, USA, for the determination of
the species.
References
Carroll, L.E., Norrbom, A.L. Dallwitz, M.J. & Thompson, F.C. 2004 onwards: Pest fruit flies
of the world – larvae. Version: 13th April 2005. http://delta-intkey.com’.
Carroll, L.E., White, I.M., Freidberg, A., Norrbom, A.L. Dallwitz,M.J. & Thompson, F.C.
2002 onwards: Pest fruit flies of the world. Version: 15th July 2005. http://delta-intkey.com’.
Lampe, I. & Krauthausen, H.-J. 2005: Introduction and distribution of the American eastern
cherry fruit fly (Rhagoletis cingulata) in the Rhine Valley, Germany. BCPC Symposium
81, 135-140.
Lampe, I., Dahlbender, W., Harzer, U. Hensel, G. & Krauthausen, H.-J. 2006: Die Amerikanische Kirschfruchtfliege (Rhagoletis cingulata) - Untersuchungen zum Auftreten in
Rheinland-Pfalz. Obstbau 31[8], 414-416. 2006.
Maring, E. & Kirchner, R. 2008: Kirschfruchtfliege: Ist eine sichere Bekämpfung in 2008
möglich? Praxiserfahrungen und Erhebungen in Thüringen. Obstbau 33[3], 130-135.
2008.
Merz, B. & Niehuis, M. 2001: Bemerkenswerte Nachweise von Fruchtfliegen (Diptera: Tephritidae) aus Rheinland-Pfalz (Deutschland). Dipteron 4 (1): 57-64.
Vogt H. 2007a: Short information about an invasive Rhagoletis species in Germany. Editors:
231
Papadopoulos, N. and Kouloussis, N. TEAM Newsletter 4, July 2007: 6-7. Thessaloniki.
Vogt, H., Dahlbender, W. Hensel, G. & Lampe I, 2007b. Ein neues Problem für den Kirschanbau: die Ostamerikanische Kirschfruchtfliege Rhagoletis cingulata (Loew). Entomologentagung Innsbruck, Abstracts. Berichte des naturwissenschaftlich-medizinischen Vereins in Innsbruck, Supplementum 17 , 253.
232
Selectivity of phytosanitary products used on citrus orchards to
Chrysoperla externa (Hagen, 1861) (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae)
Maurício Sekiguchi Godoy1, César Freire Carvalho1, Geraldo Andrade Carvalho1
1
Federal University of Lavras, Department of Entomology, P.O.Box 3037; 37200-000-Lavras
- MG, Brazil
Abstract: The effect of some phytossanitary products used on citrus orchards on Chrysoperla externa
was evaluated. The maximum dosages of thiametoxan, imidacloprid, milbemectin, pyriproxyfen and
spirodiclofen were sprayed on eggs of this chrysopid in a Potter tower, with toxicity evaluations on
this and subsequent development phases. The experiment was conducted at 25±2oC, 70±10% RH and
14-hour photophase in a complete randomized design with six treatments and thirty replicates.
Survivorship of contaminated eggs, larvae, pupae and adults originating from contaminated eggs was
evaluated. Addditonally, number and viability of F1 generation eggs were evaluated. Imidacloprid and
spirodiclofen were statistically different from control with egg viability of 76.7% for both products,
with 96.7% for control. As for thiametoxan, milbemectin and pyriproxyfen, they did not influence egg
survival rate, with 93.3%, 80.0% e 80.0%, respectively. Spirodiclofen received the slightly noxious
(class 2) classification.
Key words: lacewing, insecticide, toxicity.
Introduction
Brazilian citriculture significantly contributes to socio-economic growth, promoting the
generation of indirect and direct jobs, besides its importance as an export product. In this
context, this activity generates annually US$ 1.0 billion in foreign currency and
approximately US$ 5.0 billion of GNP (Abecitrus, 2008). Citrus orchards are distributed over
approximately 700,000 hectares, which favours the incidence of numerous arthropod pests,
which need to be controlled chemically. Neves et al. (2002) reported that a considerable
amount of money is spent with phytossanitary products in this crop, which surpasses expense
for several crops like coffee, corn, soybean and sugarcane.
Large-scale use of insecticides can reach not only the target pests but beneficial
organisms as well, e.g. chrysopids, which are susceptible to several products used in pest
control. Chrysopids are important predators in larval stages and are found in several crops of
economic importance, including cotton, citrus, corn, soybean, alfalfa, tobacco, grape, apple,
rubber and others. They can feed on neonate caterpillars, aphids, scales, mites and several
small arthropods with easily perforated teguments (Souza & Carvalho, 2002). Thus, several
phytossanitary products used on citrus orchards were evaluated for their activity on eggs and
subsequent stages of Chrysoperla externa.
Material and Methods
The experiment
Degrande 1996;
mL of a.i. L-1
(imidacloprid –
was run according to IOBC’s methodology (Hassan et al. 1994; Hassan &
IOBC/WPRS 1992). The evaluated products with dosages expressed in g or
of water were: Actara 250WG (thiametoxan – 0.05), Confidor 700WG
0.07), MilbekNock (milbemectin – 0.008), Tiger 100CE (pyriproxyfen –
233
0.075), Envidor (spirodiclofen – 0.06), and distilled water as control.
Twenty-four d old eggs obtained from an F3 generation of laboratory reared C. externa
were used. The eggs were placed in Petri dishes and sprayed using a Potter tower calibrated to
deliver 1.5±0.5 µL/cm2 at 15 lib/pol2 (unfamiliar unit!). The dishes were left under shade for
two hours for evaporation of excess water on eggs, and individually placed in glass tubes for a
total of 30 eggs per treatment. Eggs were kept in climatic chambers at 25±2oC, 70±10% RH
and 12-hour photophase. Evaluations started two days after the application of the products,
from larval emergence, through pupal formation to adult emergence. Five chrysopid pairs
were formed after emergence on each treatment and kept in PVC cylindrical cages internally
covered by filter paper and closed on the top with plastic film. Larvae were fed ad libitum
with Anagasta kuehniella eggs and adults with brewer’s yeast and honey (1:1). Eggs were
collected from the F1 generation every other day and counted for four consecutive weeks.
Fertility was determined in 96 eggs per treatment, placed individually in plastic trays, covered
by plastic film and kept under the same climatic conditions. The experiment was perormed in
a completely randomized design with six treatments and thirty replicates with fertility
evaluations and survivorship of larvae and pupae. Data obtained from fertility evaluations
were submitted to the Z test at 5% probability (Triola, 2005).
For the larval period, data were subjected to the Kaplan-Meier (Kaplan & Meier,
1958) estimator for the analysis of survivorship. Fertility data were subjected to analysis of
variance and means compared by the Tukey’s test (P≥ 0.05).
Results and Discussion
A survival rate of 76.7% for both imidacloprid and spirodiclofen was observed compared to
96.7% for the control. Rocha (2008) reported fertility of 77.5% in C. externa eggs treated
with these same compounds, as compared to 92.5% in controls, indicating their toxicity for
chrysopid eggs. Some compounds can show ovicide action, interfering with embryonic
respiration (Riedl et al., 1995). There were no significant differences among thiametoxan,
milbemectin and pyriproxyfen as compared to control, with fertility reaching 93.3%; 80.0%
and 80.0%, respectively. There was evidence of some tolerance of C. externa eggs to these
products, which was also reported by Carvalho et al. (2002), Godoy et al. (2004), Bueno &
Freitas (2004) and Ferreira et al. (2006). The lower toxicity of the tested compounds is
possibly associated with the corion which may prevent penetration of some products, thereby
avoiding contamination of the developing embryo.
In relation to the survivorship of subsequent development phases to this insect a
significant difference of the tested products on third instar larvae and pupae was detected, but
not on first and second instar larvae, which had similar tegument alterations for all tested
products and control, resulting in no interference on insect biology and 100% probability of
survivorship (Table 1). No interference of phytossanitary products on subsequent stages after
the egg stage is perhaps associated with their low residue level on corions at hatching time,
reducing contamination of neonate larvae, but Godoy et al. (2004) found deltametrin caused
50% mortality of neonate larvae and interference in subsequent stages, with 62% mortality on
the first instar.
Significant differences were detected in survivorship of third-instar larvae of C.
externa originating from treated eggs, ranging from 68.2 to 95.0 %. Significantly higher
survivorship was observed in treatments with thiametoxan and spirodiclofen, relative to all
others. Only spirodiclofen lasted 4 days for median time change of instar, with all other ones
with not more than 3 days (Table 1). Duration of these stages originated from treated eggs
suggest that there was no “latent effect” as reported by Croft (1990) as the effect expressed in
subsequent stages to the one when the organism was exposed to a chemical product.
234
There was no significant difference in median pupal longevity, corresponding to 12
days, but Rocha (2008) reported significant differences in pupal stage duration in organisms
originated from previously treated stages. These differences may be possibly associated to
other variables like products of distinct chemical group, mode of action, geographic origin of
the insect population under study, dosage, application methods, etc.
Table 1. Median time (MT) in days, and survivorship probability (S) in %,
externa first, second and third instar larvae, and pupae.
Instars
Treatment
1st
2nd
3rd
MT
S
MT
S
MT
S
Thiametoxan
3
100.0
3
100.0
3
92.31
Imidacloprid
3
100.0
3
100.0
3
68.20
Milbemectin
3
100.0
3
100.0
3
68.20
Pyriproxyfen
3
100.0
3
100.0
3
73.90
Spirodiclofen
3
100.0
3
100.0
4
95.00
Control
3
100.0
3
100.0
3
82.50
Log – Rank
0.9996
0.9999
0.0017
(P-value)
of Chrysoperla
Pupa
MT
12
12
12
12
12
12
S
91.30
68.20
72.73
68.18
56.25
83.90
0.2010
Although no differences have been detected among treatments in the pupal stage,
spirodiclofen, pyriproxyfen and imidacloprid showed low probability of survival (56.25%;
68.18% and 68.20%, respectively, Table 1).
The influence of the compounds on female fecundity of the F1 generation revealed a
significant difference for spirodiclofen, 34.69 eggs/female as compared to 49.11 eggs/female
for control. The remaining products showed from 40.94 to 52.59 eggs/female on average,
during the four weeks of evaluations. Reduction in number of eggs layed by females
originating from eggs treated with spirodiclofen may be associated with the mode of action.
This compound is part of the cetoenol group, a molecule derived from tetronic and tetromic
acids which inhibit lipid synthesis with consequent interference in egg production and, in
some cases, on their oviposition capacity. For egg survival rate, no significant difference was
found between spirodiclofen and control (Table 2).
Table 2. Mean1 number (± SE) and F1 Chrysoperla externa fertilility (%).
Treatment
Number of eggs
Fertility
Thiametoxan
40.94 ± 3.09 ab
89.50 ± 0.88 c
Imidacloprid
46.83 ± 2.86 ab
94.33 ± 0.88 b
Milbemectin
51.65 ± 2.52 a
94.42 ± 0.88 b
Pyriproxyfen
52.59 ± 2.67 a
93.33 ± 0.88 b
Spirodicclofen
34.69 ± 3.78 b
95.92 ± 0.88 ab
Testemunha
49.11 ± 2.86 a
99.42 ± 0.88 a
CV (%)
55.32
10.24
1
Means followed by the same letter are not statistically different by Tukey’s test at 5%.
With the results of C. externa mortality during its development plus fecundity and
fertility data obtained, the total efffect (E) of the tested pesticides for the egg stage of this
predator was calculated. Folowing the IOBC methodology, only spirodiclofen was included in
toxicological class 2 (= slightly noxious) in relation to the predator; all other products were
235
included in toxicological class 1 (= non toxic) (Table 3).
Table 3. Percent of Chrysoperla externa egg mortality when treated with insecticides, number
of eggs/day/female, fertility (%), total effect (E).
Dead
Dead Dead
Infertile
M%1 Mc%2 R13
R2%4
E%5
neonate
Treatments
larvae pupae
eggs
larvae
Thiametoxan
2
0
2
3
23.33
0.0
17.55
89.50
24.4
Imidacloprid
7
0
1
0
26.67
4.36
20.07
94.33
12.8
Milbemectin
6
1
1
30.00
8.70
22.13
94.42
8.1
Pyriproxyfen
6
Spirodicclofen
7
Control
1
1
1
26.67
4.36
22.54
93.33
2.9
2
1
4
46.67
3044
15.26
95.92
51.3
3
2
0
23.33
-
20.85
99.42
-
1
Cumulative mortality (%).
Mortality (%) corrected by Abbott (1925).
3
Number of eggs/day/female.
4
Egg fertility (%).
5
Total effect (E) (%) of treatments.
*
IOBC Class of Toxicity, class = 1 non toxic (E%< 30%) and class 2 = slight noxious (30 ≤
E% ≤ 79%) To what does this refer?
2
Conclusion
Imidacloprid and spirodiclofen were the most toxic to C. externa eggs. Thiametoxan,
imidacloprid, milbemectin, pyriproxyfen and spirodiclofen did not influence the subsequent
stages after the application to eggs. Spirodiclofen caused fecundity reduction in adults of the
F1 generation. Thiametoxan, imidacloprid, milbemectin and pyriproxyfen reduced fertility in
the F1 female generation.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to CNPq – Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico
for the financial support.
References
Abecitrus. 2008. Exportações: série histórica. São Paulo. http://www.abecitrus.com.br.
Bueno, A.F. & Freitas, S. 2004. Effect of the insecticides abamectina and lufenuron on eggs
and larvae of Chrysoperla externa under laboratory conditions. BioControl 49: 277-283.
Carvalho, G.A., Carvalho, C.F., Souza, B. & Ulhôa, J.L.R. 2002. Seletividade de inseticidas a
Chrysoperla externa (Hagen) (Neuroptera) Neotrop. Entomol. 31: 615-621.
Croft, B.A. 1990. Arthropod biological control agents and pesticides. New York: Wiley236
Interscience, 723p.
Ferreira, A.J., Carvalho, G.A., Botton, M. & Lasmar, O. 2006. Seletividade de inseticidas
usados na cultura da macieira a duas populações de Chrysoperla externa (Hagen, 1861)
(Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Ciência Rural, 36: 378-384.
Godoy, M.S., Carvalho, G.A., Moraes, J.C., Goussain, M., Morais, A.A. & Cosme, L.V. 2004.
Seletividade de inseticidas utilizados na cultura dos citros para ovos e larvas de
Chrysoperla externa (Hagen) (Neuroptera). Neotrop. Entomol. 33: 639-646.
Hassan, S.A., Bigler, F., Bogenschütz, H., Boller, E., Brun, J., Calis, J.N.M., CoresmansPelseneer, J., Duso, C., Grove, A., Heimbach, U., Helyer, N., Hokkaner, H., Lewis, G.B.,
Mansour, F., Moreth, L., Polgar, L., Samsoe-Petersen, L., Sauphanor, B., Staubli, A.,
Sterk, G., Vainio, A., van de Veire, M., Viggiani, G. & Vogt, H. 1994. Results of the sixth
joint pesticide testing programme of the IOBC/WPRS – Working Group “Pesticides and
Beneficial Organisms”. Entomophaga 39: 107-119.
Hassan, S.A. & Degrande, P.E. 1996. Methods to test the side effects of pesticides on
Trichogramma. In: Parra, J.R.P., Zucchi, R. (eds.). Curso de controle biológico com
Trichogramma. Piracicaba: FEALQ: 63-74.
IOBC/WPRS. 1992. Working Group “Pesticides and Beneficial Organisms”, Guidelines for
testing the effects of pesticides on beneficial organisms: description of test methods.
IOBC/WPRS Bulletin 15: 1-186.
Kaplan, E.L. & Meier, P. 1958. Nonparametric estimation from incomplete observations. J.
Am. Stat. Assoc. 53: 457-481.
Neves, E.M.; Dayoub, M. & Dragone, D.S. 2002. Análise da demanda por defensivos pela
fruticultura brasileira, 1997-2000. Rev. bras. Frut. 24: 694-696.
Riedl, H., Halaj, J.; Kreowski, W., Hilton, R. & Westigard, P. 1995. Laboratory evaluation of
mineral oils for control of Codling moth (Lepidoptera). J. Econ. Entomol. 88: 140-147.
Rocha, L.C.D. 2008. Seletividade fisiológica de inseticidas utilizados em cultura cafeeira
sobre os predadores Chrysoperla externa (Hagen) (Neuroptera) e Cryptolaemus
montrouzieri Mulsant, (Coleoptera). Dr. Thesis in entomology, UFLA, Lavras, 115p.
Souza & Carvalho, 2002. Population dynamics and seasonal occurrence of adults of
Chrysoperla externa (Hagen, 1861) (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae) in a citrus orchard in
southern Brazil. Acta Zool. Hung. Suppl 48: 301-310.
Triola, M.F. 2005. Introdução à Estatística. 9a ed. LTC. Livros Técnicos e Científicos. Editora:
Rio de Janeiro, 656p.
237
First record of the parasitoid Copidosoma varicorne (Nees)
(Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae) in Greece
Petros Damos, and Matilda Savopoulou-Soultani
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Agriculture, Laboratory of Applied Zoology
and Parasitology, 54 124, Thessaloniki, Greece, matilda@agro.auth.gr/damos@agro.auth.gr
Extended abstract
Biological control has been a fundamental element of the Integrated Pest Management
(IPM) concept since its initial definition more than 30 years ago. Region specific and
naturally occurring biological control agents play a significant role in agro-ecosystems. The
objective of this study was to record and observe the impact of native beneficial species on
the overwintering population of the peach twig borer Anarsia lineatella Zeller (Lepidoptera:
Gelechiidae) in IPM orchards. In previous studies we reported the presence of numerous
beneficial arthropods, belonging to different families observed in overwintering sites
(hibernacula) of A. lineatella (Damos and Savopoulou-Soultani 2008a). Substantial mortality
because of parasitic wasps belonging to parasitoids of the family Braconidae was also
reported (Damos and Savopoulou-Soultani 2008b). In this study, we report the mortality of A.
lineatella overwintering larvae caused by the endoparasitoid Copidosoma varicorne
(Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae).
The faunistic survey was conducted in two important regions in central Macedonia of
northern Greece (Veria 40.32oN-0.22.18oE and Velvendo 40.16oN-0.22.04oE). Hibernacula of
overwintering larvae were collected randomly from conventional and IPM peach orchards. All
collected material was transferred to the Laboratory of Applied Zoology and Parasitology of
the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki. Overwintering larvae of A. lineatella were placed at
constant laboratory conditions for development (20oC, 16:8h L:D and 65±5%RH). Individuals
of C. varicorne were reared from overwintering A. lineatella larvae during 2005, 2006 and
2007. A number of dry samples were sent to the Natural History Museum of London for a
confirmative taxonomic identification. This is the first record of C. varicorne in Greece.
Hymenoptera is one of the richest in species groups in the Palaearctic region (Werner
2001, Ghahari et al. 2006), while Copidosomatine encyrtids are well known for their unique
polyembryonic development and larval soldier caste in which a single zygote generates
multiple embryos by clonal proliferation (Zhurov et al. 2004). Comprehensive classification
of Encyrtidae (Trjapitzin, 1989) placed Copidosoma in the tribe Copidosomatini, subtribe
Copidosomatina, together with Paralitomastix Mercet 1921 and Copidosomopsis Girault 1915
(Guerrieri and Noyes 2005).
Species of the genus Copidosoma Ratzeburg 1844 have been recorded as parasites on
more than 20 Lepidoptera families, including members of the Gelechiidae and Tortricidae
(Daane et al. 1993, Guerrieri and Noyes 2005). Encyrtidae species are considered as
important parasitoids and are generally widespread, including species that have the potential
to be used as biocontrol agents of lepidopteran pests (Guerrieri and Noyes 2005). In addition,
species recorded as Paralitomastix varicornis (Mercet 1921) or Encyrtus varicornis Nees by
original designation are synonyms with Copidosoma (Kazmi and Hayat 1998, Guerrieri and
Noyes 2005), while on a recent detailed revision of the European species of Encyrtidae by
Guerrieri and Noyes (2005), the species C. varicornis is also synonymous with C. varicorne
238
which is the valid name. The species has also been recorded as P. varicornis in Northern Italy
as a cause of mortality in overwintering A. lineatella larvae (Molinari et al. 2005), while in
the USA the Encyrtidae Paralitomastix pyralidis (Ashmead) has been recorded as parasitizing
overwintering larvae of A. lineatella (Daane et al. 1993).
Overwintering larval parasitization was especially high during the winter of the year
2006-2007. Moreover, although mortality of A. lineatella larvae due to C. varicorne
parasitization was relatively low (5-15%), the species was present on samples collected from
all different IPM peach orchards in northern Greece. This fact indicates a stable presence of
C. varicorne in peach orchards of northern Greece during the last years. The identification
and evaluation of local natural beneficial species under field conditions should be of special
interest, as part of an overall IPM program.
Key words: Copidosoma varicorne, Paralitomastix varicornis, Anarsia lineatella, Biological control,
IPM
References
Askew R. R., Shaw M. R. 1986. Parasitoid communities: their size, structure
and
development (In: Insect Parasitoids, Eds. J. K. Waage, D. J.Greathead) - 13th
Symp. R.
Entomol.Soc. Lond., London, pp. 225-264.
Daane K. M., G. Y. Yokota, and J. W. Dlott 1993. Dormant-Season Sprays Affect the Mortality
of Peach Twig Borer (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) and Its Parasitoids J.
Econ. Entomol.
86(6): 1679-1685 (1993)
Damos P. and M. Savopoulou-Soultani. 2008a. About the presence of beneficials in
overwintering sites of Anarsia lineatella Zeller (Lep., Gelechiidae) in Northern Greece
peach orchards. IOBC/wprs Bulletin, 35, 44-50.Damos P. and M. Savopoulou-Soultani.
2008b. First record of the endoparasitoid
Dolichogenidea (Apanteles) anarsiae (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) in Greece. In proceedings
of XXIII International Congress of Entomology, 6-12 July, South Africa, Dourban, ICE, pp
1688.
Guerrieri, E. and J. Noyes. 2005. Revision of the European species of Copidosoma
Ratzeburg (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae), parasitoids ofcaterpillars (Lepidoptera).
Systematic Entomology (2005) 30, 97–174.
Horne, P.A. (1990). The influence of introduced parasitoids of the potato moth, Phthorimaea
operculella (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) in Victoria, Australia.
Bull. Entomol.l Res., 80,
159–163.
Kazmi, S.I. & Hayat, M. (1998) Revision of the Indian Copidosomatini (Hymenoptera:
Chalcidoidea: Encyrtidae). Oriental Insects, 32, 287–362. Thompson, W.R. (1954). A
catalogue of the parasites and predators of insect pests. Section 2. Host Parasite
Catalogue.Part 3 Hosts of the Hymenoptera (Calliceratid to Evaniid), pp. 191–
332.Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, Commonwealth Institute of Biological Control,
Ottawa.
Zhurov, V., T. Terzin and M. Grbic. 2004. Early blastomere determines embryo proliferation
and caste fate in a polyemrionic wasp. Nature, 432, 764-769Werner, U. 2001. Hymenopteren
in einem Lalkbuchenwald: Eine Modellgruppe zur untersuchung von Tiergemeinschaften und
ökologischen Raum-Zeit –Mustern. Nikolaus Kopernikus Universität Toruń.
239
Behaviour and biological control of two-spotted spider mite
(Tetranychus urticae) in floricane red raspberry plantations
Alberto Grassi, Romano Maines
Edmund Mach Foundation, IASMA Research Center – Plant Protection Dept., Via E.Mach,1
38010 San Michele all’Adige (TN) - Italy
Abstract: The biology, behaviour and reciprocal relationships of Tetranychus urticae, Neotetranychus
rubi and the phytoseiid mite Amblyseius andersoni were investigated from 1999 to 2007 on floricane
red raspberry in Trentino, Northern Italy. From 2005 to 2007, in a plantation in Mocheni’s Valley the
efficiency against two-spotted spider mite of an A.andersoni local strain and the commercially
available predators Amblyseius californicus and Phytoseiulus persimilis was also evaluated. Two
introduction rates (26 and 52 individuals/m, equivalent to 10.4 and 20.8 individuals/m2) at different
times of release were compared for these two last predators. A.californicus releases, applied before the
middle of June, were more effective than late releases in every year, in comparison with check plots
(no release). The best control result was recorded where the highest dose was introduced. However,
A.californicus didn’t perform as well as A.andersoni in the reintroduction plot. In our trials,
P.persimilis established in the crop with very small populations, probably indicating important
ecological requirements (prey density, release rate, climate under polyethylene rain covers, etc.) for its
establishment. The information we collected was used to produce a two-spotted spider mite
management recommendation scheme for Trentino’s raspberry growers.
Key words: Tetranychus urticae, Neotetranychus rubi, floricane red raspberry, behaviour, biological
control.
Introduction
Tetranychid mites, Neotetranychus rubi (raspberry mite) and particularly Tetranychus urticae
(two spotted spider mite, TSSM) represent key pests on floricane red raspberry cultivated in
Trentino, Northern Italy. Their natural control relies on many indigenous predators, among
which the phytoseiid mite Amblyseius andersoni is the most important and effective.
A deeper knowledge of how this mite system works in our raspberry growing conditions
is crucial to correctly manage TSSM, integrating as well as possible the available preventative
and curative control measures, to recommend to the growers a more sustainable approach.
With this aim, we carried out investigations in Trentino from 1999 to 2007.
Material and methods
Investigations were conducted in two plantations, both cultivated with floricane fruiting red
raspberry cv.Tulameen, and located at Canzolino (500 m a.s.l) and S.Orsola – Mocheni’s
Valley (1150 m. a.s.l).
The efficiency against TSSM of the predatory phytoseiids A.californicus and P.persimilis
(supplied by Koppert Italia S.r.l) and of a local strain of A.andersoni, was evaluated from
2005 to 2007 in non-replicated blocks, 8-16 m long, set up in the S.Orsola plantation. We
compared two introduction rates, 26 and 52 individuals/m of row, equivalent to 10.4 and 20.8
individuals/m2 of the commercially available predators. Amblyseius andersoni was
introduced only in 2005 spring (about 12 individuals/m2) by means of occupied cv. Heritage
240
primocanes collected from another plantation in Mocheni’s Valley and hung on the fruiting
canes of the selected block. Pest and predatory mite populations were recorded both on
fruiting and on vegetative canes by means of visual inspection (under binocular microscope)
of 1 terminal leaflet/2 m of row, at approximately 7-15 d intervals. The density of the TSSM
population was determined by counting the number of motile stages, or estimated according
to a ranking system (Guignard, 1968 unpub.), while the phytoseiids were determined by
counting the number of mites per leaf. The percentage of leaves occupied by the mites was
calculated. Cumulative mite-days/leaf index was also calculated to express the load of TSSM
in the whole season.
The overwintering behaviour of the mites was investigated in both sites inspecting by
visual control or floatation system, samples of 30-40 cm basal portion of fruiting canes and
old dead leaves collected in winter. In S.Orsola plantation, we also inspected (by visual
control with a 10x hand magnifier) spontaneous weeds collected from the alley-rows, to
assess TSSM overwintering females population.
Results and discussion
Overwintering and crop colonization
TSSM overwinters in Trentino’s red raspberry plantations as adult females mainly on various
spontaneous weeds. Neotetranychus rubi (Nr), also widespread on raspberry, often in
association with TSSM, and the indigenous phytoseiid mite Amblyseius andersoni (Aa),
prefer to spend the winter directly on the canes and on old dead leaves on the soil.
At the resumption of growth in spring, N.rubi and A.andersoni can rapidly reach the new
leaves on laterals of the fruiting canes (FC). TSSM normally occurs later. Nr and pollen are
probably an alternative food for Aa at the beginning of the season (Figure 1). Since it
overwinters on weeds, TSSM easily infests the new small vegetative canes (VC) that are
emerging from the soil. The new VC act as a “rearing box” and as a real “lift” to allow the
pest to reach the laterals that develop above soil level on FC later in the season (May/June)
(Figures 1 and 2). A well established and large Aa population is already on leaves when
TSSM reaches the FC, so the pest is easily and rapidly subjected to control (Figure 1).
Demographic rise, summer development of the population and stimulating factors
Starting approximately from the second half of May (pre-bloom or bloom), TSSM usually
begins a progressive demographic rise, that leads the population to peak during harvest
(Figures 1 and 2). The leading factor that induces and regulates this demographic rise is the
progressive increase in temperature. The climate becomes hotter and drier, ideal for the pest,
which speeds up its lifecycle, increases its eggs production and its dispersion on the leaves.
Some agronomic interventions in this fragile moment of the balance, may contribute to
further destabilize it and shifting it to favour TSSM. Nylon rain cover, even if not integral,
modifies the microclimate, increasing the maximum air temperature. Some chemicals (e.g.
etofenprox) cause a disproportionate increase of the pest population (Figure 2 – 2006 year),
that may be due to a probable direct stimulation of reproductive abilities of the mite, and to a
rather persistent toxic action on its indigenous predators.
More and less stable systems
The reaction of the system to this critical moment of the balance is different according to
whether or not the indigenous phytoseiids (A.andersoni) are present. In Table 1 we can
observe that, after its re-introduction, Aa steadily and permanently colonised the crop. The
pest developed every year a smaller population than in the check (no release) plots.
241
The use of commercially available phytoseiids
Are the commercially available predators able to guarantee to the system the same stability in
raspberry fields not endowed with an indigenous Aa population ? Summary data concerning
the trial we carried out in S.Orsola site from 2005 to 2007 reported in Table 2, indicate that
A.californicus early releases (before the middle of June) were more effective every year than
late releases in reducing TSSM on FC in comparison with the control plots. The high rate of
introduction (52 ind./m, or 20.8 ind./m2) was the most effective in 2005. A.californicus
developed a smaller population than A.andersoni on leaves every year. Except for the early
release of a high dose in 2005, results with it were worse than with A.a every year in the reintroduction block. Concerning P.persimilis, we recorded a weak and late establishment only
in 2006 (0.77 motile stages/leaf on FC at the end of August).
TSSM management recommendations
With the information we obtained, a scheme of recommendations for TSSM management on
raspberry has been produced. The presence/absence of indigenous A.andersoni (Aa) is
considered as the main discriminating factor for the control actions to undertake. A
provisional natural control threshold (NCT) is suggested (on terminal leaflets of fruiting
canes, TSSM/Aa motile stages ratio must be ≤ 1). Short periods of moderate NCT exceeding
(up to 3-4 TSSM:1 Aa) are tolerated without interventions. High risks situations for the
prey/predator balance (e.g sudden, continuous and noticeable NCT increases, marked Aa
population failures, TSSM eggs production increase and occurrence of stimulating factors,
etc.) require a release of A.californicus by the middle of June (low or high dose depending on
the risk evaluation) and/or P.persimilis (> 50 individuals/m) if close to harvest. If no or very
few indigenous Aa are detected in the plantation, a massive re-introduction in spring is
suggested. If it is not possible to find an Aa source, the actions described above for a high risk
situation should be undertaken. A prudent threshold of 1 TSSM motile stage/leaflet on fruiting
canes before bloom, is suggested for an acaricide application.
Figure 1. Development of TSSM, N.rubi and A.andersoni at Canzolino site in 1999.
242
Figure 2. Development of TSSM at S.Orsola site.
Table 1. Development of TSSM and A.andersoni in re-introduction plot at S.Orsola site.
S.Orsola site - fruiting canes
CMD/leaf
mean n° of motile
TSSM
stages/leaf
mean % of
occupied leaves
Aa reintrod.block
CMD/leaf
mean n° of motile
stages/leaf
Aa
mean % of
occupied leaves
CMD/leaf
mean n° of motile
check
TSSM
stages/leaf
blocks
mean % of
occupied leaves
note
2005
2006
2007
May June July Aug. May June July Aug. May June July Aug.
24.94
55.62
3.29
0.04 0.33 0.46
0
0
0
0.92 1.25 0.08
0
0.07
ND
2.08 8.33 22.91
0
0
0
29.17 37.55 8.33
0
7.14
ND
107.93
64.67
9.87
0.25 0.29 1.87 3.25 0.26 0.35 0.41 1.93 0.21 0.17 0.21
14.66 18.77 52.11
50
15.65
25
39.03
29.17 68.75 4.16 8.33 21.44 ND
1112
15.79
0.01 0.23 0.98 0.31 0.07 0.25 3.96 53.84 0.08
1.52 11.55 31.63 14.21 3.75 12.55
Aa releases; 2,11,20/5
ND
65
0.2
0.5
ND
100
2.55 0.11 12.55 ND
etofenprox spray; 01/7
hexitiazox spray; 10/4
Table 2. Summary data of the trials with TSSM predatory mites at S.Orsola site.
A.californicus release blocks
check blocks
(no releases)
year cane period
2005
2006
2007
VC
FC
VC
FC
11/5-8/8
23/5-21/8
A.andersoni
reintroduction block
max n°
max n°
tot. n° CMD/
CMD
TSSM/
TSSM/
PH/leaf leaf
/leaf
leaf
leaf
112 4.48 0.36 29 1.75
38
2.15
0.04
22
0.62
early releases (before the middle of June)
late releases (after the middle of June)
26 individuals/m
52 individuals/m
26 individuals/m
52 individuals/m
max n°
max n°
max n°
max n°
tot. n° CMD
tot. n° CMD
tot. n° CMD
tot. n° CMD
tot. n°
TSSM/
TSSM/
TSSM/
TSSM/
PH/leaf /leaf
PH/leaf /leaf
PH/leaf /leaf
PH/leaf /leaf
PH/leaf
leaf
leaf
leaf
leaf
3.89 87 4.33 1.61 47 3.17
1.2
76 3.13 0.49 50 2.75 0.12
0.49
7
0.42
0
18
0.88
0.19
2109 131.28 0.32
373 17.25
12.3 2431 122.88 12.55
4.14
18
0.79
_
_
_
3590 245.75 6.55
_
_
_
1030 77.35
0.82
51
1.75
6.34
885 40.98
4.37
_
_
_
1126
_
_
_
VC 18/4-26/7 137
6.77
0.11
71
3.67
2.17
104
4.64
0.07
_
_
_
FC 18/4-16/7 19
0.69
0.14
4
0.08
0.8
13
0.67
0.03
_
_
_
243
38
1.63
72
0
4.3
_
_
_
_
_
CMD; cumulated mite-days PH;
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
Natural regulation of the rosy apple aphid (Dysaphis plantaginea) in
organic apple orchards
Hazem Dib1, Yvan Capowiez1, Sylvaine Simon2, Benoît Sauphanor1
1
INRA-PSH, Equipe EPI, Domaine St Paul, Site Agroparc, 84914 Avignon Cedex 9, France; 2
INRA, UERI Gotheron, F-26320 Saint-Marcel-lès-Valence, France
Abstract: Rosy apple aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea (Passerini) (Hemiptera: Aphididae), is the most
detrimental aphid species in European organic apple orchards. This study aimed to evaluate the natural
regulation of D. plantaginea and the effect of installing hail nets on this regulation. The study was
carried out during spring 2008 in one experimental apple orchard without pesticide and four organic
commercial apple orchards located in southern France. The density and the diversity of natural
enemies observed in the experimental orchard were higher than those in the organic orchards. The
colonies of D. plantaginea were exploited by a multispecific guild of natural enemies. Hoverflies, lady
beetles and earwigs were the most abundant groups. Hoverflies tended to arrive first, followed by lady
beetles and earwigs. A high level of aphid infestation was observed in two organic orchards,
presumably related to a low level of natural enemies and to a high level of ants. Regarding the effect
of hail nets, the study revealed a positive influence of the hail nets on regulation by earwigs but a
negative influence on the presence of other natural enemies especially lady beetles. To sum up, this
field study indicated that the population dynamic of D. plantaginea was strongly affected by natural
enemies, but not sufficiently to maintain it under the tolerance threshold. So, new management
practices aiming at enhancing this natural regulation need to be found.
Keywords: rosy apple aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea, natural regulation, natural enemy, organic apple
orchard
Introduction
The holocyclic, dioecious rosy apple aphid (RAA), Dysaphis plantaginea (Passerini)
(Hemiptera: Aphididae), is undoubtedly the most injurious aphid species in European organic
apple orchards (Blommers et al., 2004; Cross et al., 2007; Delorme et al., 1997). If left
uncontrolled, this aphid causes a severe leaf deformation and fruit stunting and may reduce
return-bloom (Blommers et al., 2004).
Currently, it appears that the control of RAA is difficult because of the very low
treatment threshold (usually if the pest is detected) which leads to routine treatment (Cross et
al., 2007; Miñarro et al., 2005). New control strategies, which respect organic production
principles, have been developed (e.g. Miñarro and Dapena, 2008) to avoid the negative effects
of pesticides and the development of resistance in aphid populations (Delorme et al., 1997).
Although contradictory and often inconsistent results are reported (Brown and Mathews,
2007; Miñarro et al., 2005; Wyss et al., 1999), biological control, and factors that enhance this
control, remains one of the best solutions to minimise pesticide use (Miñarro et al., 2005).
Thus, this study aimed to determine, to which point, the population dynamic of RAA is
affected by naturally occurring enemies, and to identify predators of importance for
controlling its population. In addition, because the use of hail nets increases in Provence
(southern France), we wanted to study the possible effects of these nets on this regulation,
namely the RAA populations and the abundance and diversity of their natural enemies.
244
Materials and Methods
Study apple orchards
The studies were carried out in four commercial orchards (n°51, 145, 125, and 126), 3.4 ha in
total, managed following organic production rules and located close to Avignon (southern
France). They were planted with three cultivars: Golden Delicious (n°51 and 145), Akane
(n°125), and Royal Gala (n°126). In addition, a 0.23 ha experimental orchard not treated with
insecticides and located in the INRA experimental site in Avignon, was used for this study. It
was planted in 2001 with Granny Smith and Royal Gala cultivars and presented a 5-row per
24 trees design for each cultivar. Four rows of each cultivar were covered with white hail nets
(mesh size: 3×7.4mm) on 17 April 2008, i.e. when RAA and some natural enemies, e.g.
hoverflies, were already present.
Entomological assessments
In each orchard, 50 shoots, among those infested with RAA, were randomly selected and
marked with coloured ribbons. In the experimental orchard, 50 more were marked in the eight
covered rows. The presence of RAA, its natural enemies, and ants were assessed on these
shoots by weekly visual observations, depending on orchard, from 7 April (infestation
beginning) to 3 July 2008 (aphid migration to the secondary host plant: Plantago spp. was
then complete). Aphid infestation was recorded using six classes (A = no aphid; B = 1 to 5
aphids; C = 6 to 25; D = 26 to 50; E = 51 to 125; F > 125). In the same way, the presence of
ants was recorded using four classes (I = 1 to 5 ants; II = 6 to 25; III = 26 to 50; IV > 50).
Aphid and ant numbers that were analysed were the mean number of the recorded classes. In
contrast, presence of the predaceous stages of natural enemies was recorded in exact numbers.
Results and discussion
Existence of natural regulation of RAA
The beginning and the intensity of RAA infestation differed according to orchard (Figure 1).
These differences may be due to differences in site characteristics, surrounding habitat,
cultivar, cultural practices and/or ant and natural enemy presence (Brown and Mathews, 2007;
Miñarro and Dapena, 2008; Stewart-Jones et al., 2008). The abundance and diversity of
natural enemies observed in the experimental orchard were higher than those in the organic
orchards (Figure 1, Table 1). The RAA colonies were exploited by a guild of natural enemies.
Hoverflies (Syrphidae), lady beetles (Coccinellidae), and earwigs (Forficulidae) were the
most abundant groups. Hoverflies arrived first, followed by lady beetles and earwigs. This
sequential arrival may be explained by their lower developmental thresholds: 4, 10, and 6°C
for hoverflies, lady beetles (Dixon et al., 2005), and earwigs (Helsen et al., 1998),
respectively. The latter appears naturally late because of the parental care for eggs and young
nymphs in nests (Helsen et al., 1998). These thresholds could give the hoverflies and earwigs
some advantages over most aphid enemies for their use in augmentation biological control
programs in early spring.
Natural enemy abundance increased progressively from the beginning of the infestation
to peak population phase and reached their maximum at (INRA orchard) or after (organic
orchards) the infestation peak. Thereafter, their abundance decreased following the decline of
RAA population. Hence, the population development of RAA may thus be affected by their
natural enemies -and this would indicate a potential for these enemies to negatively impact
RAA population growth- and/or by the alatae migration, which began at the peak phase of
RAA in our study.
245
Ant
3
200
180
2,5 160
3
NE
(A)
(B)
2,5
140
120
1,5 100
80
1
60
2
1
40
20
0
0,5
200
180
2,5 160
140
2
120
1,5 100
80
1
60
40
0,5
20
0
0
7/7
30/6
23/6
9/6
16/6
2/6
26/5
19/5
5/5
12/5
28/4
21/4
0
7/4
7/7
30/6
23/6
16/6
9/6
2/6
26/5
19/5
5/5
12/5
28/4
21/4
7/4
14/4
0
1,5
14/4
0,5
2
3
3
2,5
(D)**
2
1,5
1
0,5
7/7
30/6
23/6
16/6
9/6
2/6
26/5
19/5
12/5
5/5
28/4
21/4
0
7/4
7/7
30/6
23/6
16/6
9/6
2/6
26/5
19/5
12/5
5/5
28/4
21/4
7/4
(C)*
14/4
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
NE number/shoot
RAA
14/4
RAA & ant number/shoot
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Date
Figure 1. Temporal development (Mean ± SE) of RAA, natural enemy (NE), and ant
populations in each orchard: (A) INRA experimental orchard “without nets”; (B) INRA
experimental orchard “with nets”; (C) organic orchard n°145 “*: similar results found in
orchard n°51”; (D) organic orchard n°125 “**: similar results found in orchard n°126”.
Table 1. Total number of predaceous stages of natural enemies assessed on 50 infested shoots
randomly selected in each studied orchard (pooled numbers of weekly assessments from 7
April to 3 July 2008). (∆): the number is calculated after net installation.
Orchard
Total
Order
Family
INRA
n°51 n°145 n°125 n°126
Uncovered Covered∆
Cantharidae
42
5
3
50
Coleoptera
Coccinellidae
170
11
123 136
36
47
523
Others
5
1
1
7
Dermaptera
Forficulidae
84
142
130
82
218
128
784
Cecidomyiidae
2
11
19
32
Diptera
Syrphidae
280
194
105
162
45
44
826
Others
3
1
4
Heteroptera
56
21
8
3
1
89
Hymenoptera Braconidae
7
3
4
5
19
Neuroptera
Chrysopidae
9
9
5
7
1
31
Spiders
47
22
14
26
14
19
142
Total
705
403
406
443
314
240 2511
Number of assessments
10
8
11
11
10
9
Effect of installing hail nets
This study shows that the RAA population in the net-covered rows was lower than in the
246
uncovered ones. Furthermore, the infestation in the net-covered rows disappeared about 10
days prior to that observed in the uncovered ones. Since the caging conditions (Wyss et al.,
1999) and hail nets (Tasin et al., 2008) have negligible effects on the temperature and relative
humidity within the canopy and thus for RAA development, we can explain our results by the
positive influence of nets on RAA regulation by its natural enemies, especially earwigs (Table
1), despite its late arrival in RAA colonies. Nevertheless, this study revealed a negative
influence of nets on the presence of some natural enemy groups, especially lady beetles.
These nets may form a physical barrier to the insects’ entry (Graf et al., 1999). Hence, only
small-sized insects such as Scymnus spp. lady beetles (personal observation) can pass through
this barrier.
In conclusion, this field study indicates that the population dynamic of RAA was affected
by natural enemies, but not sufficiently to maintain it under the tolerance threshold. Therefore,
new management practices aiming at enhancing this regulation are required.
References
Blommers, L.H.M.; Helsen, H.H.M. & Vaal, F.W.N.M. 2004: Life history data of the rosy
apple aphid Dysaphis plantaginea (Pass.) (Homopt., Aphididae) on plantain and as
migrant to apple. J. Pest. Sci. 77: 155-163.
Brown, M.W. & Mathews, C.R. 2007: Conservation biological control of rosy apple aphid,
Dysaphis plantaginea (Passerini), in Eastern North America. Environ. Entomol. 36(5):
1131-1139.
Cross, J.V.; Cubison, S.; Harris, A. & Harrington, R. 2007: Autumn control of rosy apple
aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea (Passerini), with aphicides. Crop Prot. 26(8): 1140-1149.
Delorme, R.; Auge, D.; Touton, P. & Villatte, F. 1997: Résistance de Dysaphis plantaginea à
divers produits insecticides en France. ANPP-4ème conférence internationale sur les
ravageurs en agriculture, Montpellier 6-7-8 janvier: 45-52.
Dixon, A.F.G.; Jarošík, V. & Honěk, A. 2005: Thermal requirements for development and
resource partitioning in aphidophagous guilds. Eur. J. Entomol. 102: 407-411.
Graf, B.; Höpli, H.U.; Rauscher, S. & Höhn, H. 1999: Hail nets influence the migratory
behaviour of codling moth and leaf roller. Obst-und Weinbau. 135: 289-292.
Helsen, H.; Vaal, F. & Blommers, L. 1998: Phenology of the common earwig Forficula
auricularia L. (Dermaptera: Forficulidae) in an apple orchard. Int. J. Pest Manage. 44
(2): 75-79.
Miñarro, M. & Dapena, E. 2008: Tolerance of some scab-resistant apple cultivars to the rosy
apple aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea. Crop Prot. 27: 391-395.
Miñarro, M.; Hemptinne, J.L. & Dapena, E. 2005: Colonization of apple orchards by
predators of Dysaphis plantaginea: sequential arrival, response to prey abundance and
consequences for biological control. BioControl. 50: 403-414.
Stewart-Jones, A.; Pope, T.W. Fitzgerald, J.D. & Poppy, G.M. 2008: The effect of ant
attendance on the success of rosy apple aphid populations, natural enemy abundance and
apple damage in orchards. Agr. Forest Entomol. 10(1): 37-43.
Tasin, M.; Demaria, D.; Ryne, C.; Cesano, A.; Galliano, A.; Anfora, G.; loriatti, C. & Alma, A.
2008: Effect of anti-hail nets on Cydia pomonella behavior in apple orchards. Entomol.
Exp. Appl. 129: 32-36.
Wyss, E.; Villiger, M. & Müller-Schärer, H. 1999: The potential of three native insect
predators to control the rosy apple aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea. BioControl. 44: 171182.
247
Pest management practices and environment factors affect natural
regulation of the codling moth
Monteiro L. B. 1, Dor C2, Franck P.2, Lavigne C.2, Sauphanor B.2*
1
UFPR, Parana Federal University, DFF, CEP 81831-990, Curitiba, Brazil
2
INRA, UMR 1115 Plantes et Systèmes de culture Horticoles, Agroparc, F-84914 Avignon
Cédex 9, France
*sauphano@avignon.inra.fr
Abstract: Numerous arthropod predators and parasitoids species attack codling moth eggs
and larvae, but these antagonists do not efficiently control the pest in commercial orchards.
Parasitism of diapausing larvae was assessed in 79 apple and pear orchards from Southeastern France (2007-2008). The predation and parasitism of egg masses was investigated on
a sub-sample of 13 orchards in 2008. Diapausing larvae were observed to be parasitize in only
21.0% and 16.4% of orchards in 2007 and 2008, respectively. The mean parasitism rate over
the two years was 3.7 %, 2.3% and 0.8% in the organic and conventional with or without
mating disruption orchards, respectively. It was higher in apple than in pear orchards, for high
than low densities of windbreak hedgerows and for low than for high densities of orchards
surrounding the analysed fields. Six parasitoid species were identified, among which
Ascogaster quadridentata, Pristomerus vulnerator and Perilampus tristis were the most
frequent whatever the management practices. The composition of the parasitoid community
was explained by both local (27%) and landscape factors (16%). On average 12.5% and
54.1% of egg masses exposed to natural antagonists were consumed by predators in July and
August 2008, respectively. The highest predation rates were also recorded in the organic
orchards and close to hedgerows. Egg parasitism was negligible (0.1%). It appears from this
analysis that of egg and larval parasitism, the most frequently described in the literature, has
lower impact on codling moth populations than the predation of eggs. Comparing with
previous analyses in the same area, it appeared that larval or egg parasitism was much more
affected by the protection practices than egg predation.
Key-words: Cydia pomonella, predation, parasitism, apple orchard
Introduction
The codling moth, Cydia pomonella L. is a major pest in apple and pear orchards, damaging a
large part of the world production. It has been controlled by synthesis insecticides that select
resistant populations in conventional and organic production systems as well. New control
techniques have been recently adopted, such as mating disruption, but success is subjected to
biological and environmental factors. Studies on natural regulation of the codling moth by
parasitoids and predators are therefore of economic and ecological interest. This regulation
may be affected by the production or protection practices, and also by the diversity of the
plant species that make up the grass cover of the orchard and the surrounding hedges.
We here assessed how the production system affects the parasitism of diapausing larvae and
the predation and parasitism of eggs of the codling moth in a small agricultural landscape of
the low valley of Durance, in Southern France.
248
Material and Methods
Parasitism of diapausing larvae was observed in 79 apple and pear orchards of a 70 km2 area
near St Rémy de Provence, in southeastern France. Corrugated cardboard traps were placed
on trunks of geo-referenced trees in August 2006 and 2007, and the larvae were harvested in
October of the same year. The larvae were weighed, then placed in individual plastic cups (2
x 2 x 2 cm) and kept in a shelter under natural conditions of temperature, humidity and
photoperiod. The adults of codling moth and parasitoids started to emerge in April 2007 and
2008.
The predation and the parasitism of codling moth eggs were assessed in a sub-sample
13 orchards in this area. Codling moth were allowed to lay eggs on paper sheets that were cut
in 2x1 cm pieces containing on average fifteen 12 hour-old eggs. The cards were fixed on
leaves in the orchards (30 cards per orchard) and exposed to the natural ennemies for three
days. The numbers of parasited and predated eggs were assessed seven days after exposing
them in the orchards, at the start of July and August. The orchards were assigned according to
production system, organic or conventional. In the conventional system, the orchards in
which the codling moth was controlled exclusively with chemical insecticides (conventional)
were also differentiated from those in which mating disruption was implemented, alone or
with reduced pesticides (integrated).
Results
The parasitism of diapausing larvae occurred in 21% and 16.4% of the orchards sampled in
2006 and 2007, respectively. The mean rate of parasitism in these two years, differed
significantly between the production systems (P=0.00051), reaching 3.7%, 2.3% and 0.8%. in
the biological, integrated and conventional system, respectively (Figure 1). When considering
only the orchards where larval parasitism occurred, the production systems did not differ
significantly (Figure 2). Pristomerus vulnerator was the most frequent species in 2006,
followed by Ascocaster quadridentata and the hyperparasitoid Perilampus tristis (Figure 3).
Ascogaster quadridentata was far the most prevalent species in 2007, followed by P. tristis.
The kinetics of emergence of P. vulnerator and P. tristis were closely related to those of C.
pomonella, while A. quadridentata emerged earlier ( Figure 4).
The predation of C. pomonella eggs was significantly higher in organic orchards than in
conventional ones (Figure 5). In August, the mean percentage of cards with predated eggs
reached 64% in the organic orchards and 48% and 42% in the integrated and conventional
orchards, respectively. The predation rate was significantly higher in August than in July.
It was confirmed that Trichogramma cacoeciae was present in this area as a parasite of C.
pomonella eggs, but this occurred only in August in a single egg sheet of a single orchard
under conventional system (ie 3.8% parasitism in this orchard).
Discussion
The presence of several species of parasitoids was detected on C. pomonella diapausing
larvae during the two years of experimentation. The low rate of parasitism indicated that the
regulation C. pomonella was not strongly under the dependence of these organisms. The
larval parasitism occurred more frequently in the organic than in the conventional or
integrated orchards. However, the rate of parasitism no longer differed between the tree
production systems when considering only the ten orchards where diapausing larvae were
parasitized.
In contrast to the low rate of larval or egg parasitism, the rate of egg predation was
249
relatively high in the three production systems, as observed in the previous study on untreated
pear and apple orchards of the same area, and was the highest in the organic system. This
observation raised the question of egg predators as a way of regulation of codling moth
populations under organic or integrated pest management strategies.
Furthermore, both predation and parasitism rates were significantly lower in the orchards
surrounded by large surfaces of conventional orchards in the 100 m buffers. This suggests that
the protection practices in the surroundings may affect the potential of immigration of the
natural enemies towards the orchards.
5
4
%
3
2
1
0
2006
organic
integrated
2007
conventional
Figure 1. Mean parasitism (%) of diapausing larvae of C. pomonella in apple and pear
orchards of Southern France
5
%
4
3
2
1
0
2006
organic
2007
integrated
conventional
Figure 2. Mean parasitism (%) of diapausing larvae of C. pomonella in parasitized orchards
of Southern France
2007
2006
2; 4%
Pimpla 3; 6% Mirax
13; 24%
Perilampus
1; 1%
Trichomma
16; 30%
Ascogaster
27; 30%
Perilampus
17; 19%
Pristomerus
20; 36%
Pristomerus
250
3; 3%
Elodia
43; 47%
Ascogaster
Figure 3. Nature of Cydia pomonella parasitoids in orchards of Southeastern France.
2006
2007
1,0
0,8
frequency
0,6
0,4
,
0,2
0,6
0,4
0,2
50
50
15
50
14
50
13
50
12
10
11
0
50
0
95
0
85
0
75
0
65
0
55
35
0
50
15
00
14
50
12
00
0
11
95
0
80
0
65
0
0,0
50
35
0
0,0
0,8
45
frequency
1,0
Cydia pomonella
Ascogaster quadridentata
Cydia pomonella
Ascogaster quadridentata
Pristomerus vulnerator
Perillampus tristis
Pristomerus vulnerator
Perillampus tristis
Figure 4. Kinetic of emergence of Cydia pomonella and its parasites, in day degrees
60
50
%
40
30
20
10
0
Organic
Integrated
July
Conventional
August
Figure 5. Mean rate of predation (%) of sentinel eggs of Cydia pomonella in 13 orchards
251
A geostatistical approach to evaluate the side effects on non target
species using a non repeated plot.
E. Pasqualini1, M. Melandri2., G. Pradolesi 2., S. Civolani1, V. De Luigi1., G. Burgio1
1DiSTA, (Department of Environmental Science and Technologies), University of Bologna (I)
2 Agronomica R&D - Coop. Terremerse (RA, Italy)
Abstract: A geostatistical approach to evaluate the side effects of insecticides on non target species
using a non replicated treatments. Field research was carried out, in pear orchards in the EmiliaRomagna region (I), to study the side effects on populations of Anthocoris nemoralis F. of three
different strategies to control the first generation of Cydia pomonella L. The strategies were: i) soft =
application of CpGV, ii) OP = application of phosmet and chlorpyrifos and iii) reduced risk =
thiacloprid and methoxyfenozide. These strategies were applied on large single block plots and the
responses on Cacopsylla pyri L. and A. nemoralis F. populations were analysed by means of
geostatistical approach. The A. nemoralis data was collected by means of a grid sampling plan based
on referenced points while C. pyri were sampled as average of mobile instars per each plot. The
population density of C. pyri and A. nemoralis were higher in OP and soft strategies than in the
reduced risk strategy, but the prey/predator population ratio was similar for the three strategies. The
geostatistical monitoring method could be adapted to measure the effects of different products on
some target and non target species populations, also on non replicated large plots or wide areas.
Anthocoris nemoralis, Cacopsylla pyri, Side effects, Geostatistical monitoring
252
The effect of rosy apple aphid and beneficial insect dynamics in an
orchard
Karine Morel, Hubert Defrance, Alan Garnier, Emilie Durand, Maude Le Corre,
Sylvaine Simon
INRA, National Institute for Agricultural Research, UERI Gotheron, F-26320 Saint-Marcellès-Valence, France
Abstract: The natural control of the rosy apple aphid Dysaphis plantaginea, a major pest in European
apple orchards, was studied from 2006 to 2008 in three organic apple orchards planted with Smoothee
2832T®, Ariane and Melrose cultivars. The development of D. plantaginea and the beneficial complex
associated with aphid colonies were visually assessed in the spring, and the effect of the interaction
within the orchard (edge, inner and intermediate areas) was studied. Infestation of orchard edge trees
by D. plantaginea was higher. Beneficial numbers and the predator/prey ratio were also higher in edge
trees in 2007, and 2008. Predatory arthropods that were assessed within infested shoots mainly
comprised Syrphidae, Cecidomyiidae, ladybirds and earwigs, but their proportion differed between
cultivars. It also differed between areas of the orchard: Cecidomyiidae were assessed earlier and also
prevailed in edge areas, whereas Syrphidae prevailed in the inner parts of the orchards. However, even
the most favourable situations did not permit the natural control of D. plantaginea. These results
suggest that the cultivar affects both D. plantaginea and associated predatory arthropods, and that the
management of edge effects through orchard redesign and/or cultural practices deserves to be
considered for the management of the rosy apple aphid in IPM orchards.
Key-words: aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea, predatory arthropod, edge effect, apple orchard
Introduction
The dioecic rosy apple aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea (Passerini) (Hemiptera: Aphididae), is a
major pest in European apple orchards. Due to serious detrimental effects and a high
multiplication rate, the treatment threshold is very low (ca. 1% infested shoots or presence in
French orchards). As early pesticide applications can affect natural enemy populations that
begin to settle and/or to increase in orchards, such applications are not compatible with IPM
strategies. Besides, alternative methods are not available in orchards, despite promising
studies on biological and conservation biological control (Wyss, 1996; Wyss et al., 1999);
pheromones (Fitzgerald et al., 2005); and autumn kaolin applications (Bürgel et al., 2005).
Studies on the natural control of D. plantaginea in European orchards also indicate that the
beneficial complex of natural enemies is generally not able to provide control of this aphid
(Blommers, 1999; Miñarro & Dapena, 2001; Miñarro et al., 2005).
A better understanding of the relationships between the rosy aphid and the beneficial
complex within the orchard is thus necessary for an alternative control of this foliar pest. The
aim of this study is to describe the functional relationships between D. plantaginea and its
natural enemies, for different situations within the orchard.
Materials and methods
Experimental design
The study was carried out from 2006 to 2008 at the INRA experimental site in Saint-Marcel-
253
lès-Valence (South-Eastern France). Three organic orchards, planted with three cultivars
(Smoothee 2832T®, Ariane (scab Vf-resistant) and Melrose) were studied. Orchards were
planted in 2005 at a density of 1000 trees.ha-1; they were lined by mixed hedgerows and
fallow fields. Each orchard had an 8-row per 46 trees design (0.37 ha). No post-bloom
aphicide treatment was applied during the experiment. For assessments of aphid infestation
and natural enemy numbers, each orchard was divided into three areas: edges (end line trees),
intermediate (5 trees adjacent to edge trees within the line) and centre (other trees).
Aphid and arthropod assessments
Visual assessments of tree infestation in each orchard were made at two dates (first symptoms,
infestation peak) (30s per tree) of all the trees in the 4 central rows and of all edge trees. Tree
infestation was recorded using 3 classes: 0 no symptoms; 1 ≤ 10% shoots with symptoms; and
2 >10% shoots with symptoms. The three cultivars were pooled for analyses.
Visual assessments of 80 (2007) to 125 (2008) marked infested shoots per orchard
(Ariane and Melrose cultivars only), were carried out every ten days after bloom and until
aphid migration to its secondary host plant Plantago sp.. Aphid infestation was recorded using
six classes: A no aphid; B 1-5 aphids; C 6-25 aphids; D1 26-50 aphids; D2 51-125 aphids; E
> 125 aphids per shoot, and the presence of predatory stages of natural enemies was recorded
in exact numbers on each shoot.
Results and discussion
Tree infestation within the orchard
At peak infestation, the distribution of trees within symptom classes was different (CHI2 test,
P<0.05) between edge and centre areas for the 3 study years. Edge and intermediate areas
were different in 2007 only. Infestation was higher in edge trees compared to the centre of the
orchard; intermediate areas tended to be similar to edges (Table 1).
Table 1. Infestation according to orchard area (% infested trees, i.e. % (cl1+cl2) trees).
Orchard area
Edge
Intermediate
Center
2006
12-may
23-may
10.4
22.9
7.4
20.4
6.0
10.9
2007
3-may
21-may
58.3
68.8
44.4
51.9
25.4
29.8
2008
5-may
26-may
60.4
75.0
53.7
61.1
40.7
54.6
Potential for natural control
Hoverflies (Syrphidae) prevailed until mid-May among predatory arthropods observed within
D. plantaginea colonies. At the end of the infestation period (end of May), the complex of
beneficial arthropods was more diversified with aphid predators (Coccinellidae, predatory
Cecidomyiidae) and generalist or other predators (earwigs, lacewings, predatory bugs).
254
Differences in the proportion of beneficial taxa (cumulative numbers across the
season) were displayed whatever the cultivar between edge and centre areas (CHI2 test,
P<0.05). Cecidomyiidae were always observed earlier and in higher numbers in edge areas,
whereas, Syrphidae prevailed in the orchard centre. The proportion of beneficial taxa also
differed between cultivars (Figure 1).
(a)
Mean number
per shoot
per shoot
Mean number
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
29-Apr
(b)
2.0
2.0
6-May
13-May
20-May
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
29-Apr
27-May
6-May
13-May
20-May
27-May
Date
(c)
Mean number
per shoot
2.0
1.5
Syrphidae
Cecidomyiidae
Forficulidae
Coccinellidae
Others
1.0
0.5
0.0
29-Apr
6-May
13-May
Date
20-May
27-May
Figure 1. Complex of beneficial arthropods observed in D. plantaginea colonies in 2008: (a)
Ariane centre area; (b) Ariane edge area; (c) Melrose centre area.
first alates in colonies
per shoot
1.5
(1.0)
3.0
125
2.5
100
(1.4)
(0.6)
(1.5)
75
1.0
50
0.5
25
0.0
0
29-Apr
6-May
13-May
20-May
per shoot
2.0
150
150
(0.4)
(0.9)
125
2.0
1.5
(1.5)
1.0
50
0.5
25
0.0
27-May
29-Apr
Date
100
75
(0.1)
Mean aphid number
per shoot
2.5
(b)
first alates in colonies
Mean beneficial
number per shoot
3.0
(0.0) predator/prey ratio
Natural enemies
Aphid
Mean aphid number
Mean beneficial number
(a)
0
6-May
13-May
Date
20-May
27-May
Figure 2. Mean beneficial and aphid numbers for Melrose cultivar in 2008: (a) centre area; (b)
edge area.
Both aphid and beneficial numbers increased at first (Figure 2), as did the
predator/prey ratio. In 2007 and 2008, in the centre areas, the decrease in aphid numbers only
occurred at the migration of D. plantaginea towards its secondary host. In 2008, in the edge
areas (Figure 2b), aphid numbers remained high despite a slight decrease observed before
aphid migration. The predator/prey ratio was similar in all three areas in 2008 and higher at
the plot edges in 2007. No efficient predatory effect on aphids was observed in either year or
cultivar.
Towards integrated management of D. plantaginea
The situation within the orchard has an effect on both aphid infestation and the beneficial
255
guild: infestation was higher at the edges of the orchards and qualitative differences in the
predatory complex were observed between the orchard areas. However, as already stated by
other authors (Blommers, 1999; Miñarro & Dapena, 2001), natural control of D. plantaginea
by natural enemies is unreliable, despite non-disruptive pest management and a diversified
plant environment. The most aphid favourable habitat is observed at orchard edges, which
may support the proposal of redesigning orchards by plant management to enhance pest
control.
Lastly, as the aphid population level that can be tolerated in orchards is very low, the
combining of all existing control methods, including these beneficial augmentative measures
and cultivar susceptibility (Simon et al., 2008), should be used in the integrated management
of D. plantaginea.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Ecoger programme, funded by the French National Agency
for Research. The authors wish to thank the staff members of Gotheron experimental unit in
charge of the training of the orchards.
References
Blommers, L.H.M. 1999: Probing the natural control of rosy apple aphid Dysaphis
plantaginea (Hemiptera: Aphididae). IOBC/wprs Bull. 22(7): 53-56.
Bürgel, K., Daniel, C. & Wyss, E. 2005: Effects of autumn kaolin treatments on the rosy apple
aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea (Pass.) and possible modes of action. J. Appl. Entomol. 129:
311-314.
Fitzgerald, J., Pope, T., Solomon, M., Poppy, G., Jones, A.S. & Wadhams, L. 2005: The use of
the aphid sex pheromone and plant volatiles to enhance control of Dysaphis plantaginea
in apple. IOBC/wprs Bull. 28(7): 395-398.
Miñarro, M. & Dapena, E. 2001: Predators of the rosy apple aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea
(Pass.), in Asturian (NW Spain) apple orchards. IOBC/wprs Bull. 24(5): 241-245.
Miñarro, M., Hemptinne, J.L. & Dapena, E. 2005: Colonization of apple orchards by
predators of Dysaphis plantaginea: sequential arrival, response to prey abundance and
consequences for biological control. Biocontrol 50: 403-414.
Simon, S., Durand, E., Morel, K., Defrance, H. & Sauphanor, B. 2008: Control of Dysaphis
plantaginea in IPM orchards: effect of cultivar and predatory arthropods, in: Proc. XXIII
International Congress of Entomology (Book of Abstracts), Durban, July 6-12 2008:
2032.
Wyss., E. 1996: The effects of artificial weed strips on diversity and abundance of the
arthropod fauna in a Swiss experimental apple orchard. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 60: 4759.
Wyss, E., Villiger, M., Hemptinne, J.L. & Müller-Schärer, H. 1999: Effects of augmentative
releases of eggs and larvae of the ladybird beetle, Adalia bipunctata, on the abundance of
the rosy apple aphid, Dysaphis plantaginea, in organic apple orchards. Entomol. Exp.
Appl. 90: 167-173.
256
Susceptibility of codling moth populations originating from the Czech
Republic to Cydia pomonella granulovirus (CpGV)
Tereza Zichová1,2, Vladan Falta1, František Kocourek1, Jiban Kumar1, Jitka Stará1
1
Department of Entomology, Crop Research Institute, 161 06 Prague, Czech Republic;
2
Department of Plant Protection, Czech University of Life Sciences, 165 21 Prague, Czech
Republic
Abstract: Baculoviruses are very important agents of organic and integrated crop production due to
their favorable ecotoxicological qualities, high selectivity and efficacy. Whereas many European
countries and the USA have been using Cydia pomonella granulovirus (CpGV) products to control
codling moth for many years, registration of CpGV in the Czech Republic is still in progress.
However, in the last six years, populations of the codling moth resistant to CpGV-M isolate were
locally found in some European countries. With regard to this experience, the object of this research is
to evaluate the susceptibility of various codling moth populations in the Czech Republic to CpGV-M
and also to propose a suitable anti-resistance strategy for the Czech Republic. In 2008, the first
monitoring of wild codling moth populations’ susceptibility to CpGV-M was evaluated by laboratory
bioassays. Three wild populations (Prague-Ruzyne, Bulhary and Velke Bilovice) and a reference
(sensitive) laboratory strain were assessed. LC50 in the 7th and 14th day after the infection of the first
larval instar was determined by probit analysis. No decreased sensitivity to the CpGV-M was
demonstrated.
Key words: codling moth, Cydia pomonella granulovirus, resistance, LC50
Introduction
Baculoviruses generally are the major group of arthropod viruses studied for their biological
potential to control pests in agriculture and forestry. Considering their high environmental
stability, virulence, host specificity and lack of any known negative influence on the environment,
non target organisms or human health, baculoviruses are used as efficient bioinsecticides (AsserKaiser et al., 2007). The host range of individual baculoviruses is usually limited to a few
closely related species especially from the insect orders Lepidoptera, Hymenoptera and Diptera.
Cydia pomonella granulovirus (CpGV) (genera Granulovirus) is highly pathogenic for
codling moth (Cydia pomonella, (L.) and its infection results in high mortality of early instar
larvae. Infected larvae succumb within 5-10 days.
In the late 1980s, the first CpGV biopesticide was registered for commercialization and
use in some European countries. CpGV biopesticides are now commercially available in most
European countries, in North America, Argentina, Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa.
In the Czech Republic, the CpGV based biopesticides called Madex (Andermatt Biocontrol
AG, Switzerland) and Carpovirusine (Natural Plant Protection, France) are just being
registered. While in the Czech Republic the registration process is still not finished, Germany,
France, Switzerland, Italy and Netherlands have already reported the occurrence of several
populations of codling moth resistant to CpGV (Jehle, 2008). The selection of resistant
populations is related to applications of only one isolate of CpGV, discovered in 1963 in
Mexico, called CpGV-M. Foreign research institutes and the preparations’ producers are
currently searching for the main reasons for the development of resistance as well as possible
solutions to this situation. Andermatt Biocontrol AG laboratories managed to obtain a virus
257
strain efficient against the resistant codling moth population by subsequently passaging
CpGV-M through the resistant population. The commercial name of this new biopesticide is
Madex Plus. Its efficiency was evaluated not only in the laboratory, but also in field
experiments in selected orchards (Jehle, 2008). The aim of our work was to compare the
sensitivity of selected Czech codling moth populations to CpGV-M in bioassays.
Material and methods
Laboratory strain of codling moth
The neonate larvae of codling moth used to establish 50% lethality concentration (LC50)
values of the CpGV-M were taken from a laboratory strain reared on an artificial diet under
standard conditions of 26°C and a photoperiod of 16:8 h (L:D). The Crimean laboratory strain
of codling moth (Vsesajuznyj Institut Zascity Rastenij, Saint Petersburg, Russia) was used as
susceptible reference.
Field populations of codling moth
The susceptibility of three codling moth field populations to CpGV was tested in laboratory
conditions. For these experiments, the overwintering larvae of codling moth were collected
from July to November 2007 in apple orchard in Velke Bilovice and apple alleys in Bulhary
and Prague-Ruzyne. The Velke Bilovice orchard is located in South Moravia (approximately
153 miles from Prague) in an intensive apple growing farm, following integrated pest
management strategies since 1992. The tested codling moth population came from a 80-ha
plot at a distance of 200m from the plot treated with CpGV. In this orchard, resistance to
insecticides was proved (Stará and Kocourek, 2007). The Bulhary alley is located in South
Moravia along the road near to the village of Bulhary and has never been treated with
chemical pesticides or CpGV. The Prague-Ruzyne alley is located in Prague and belongs to
the Crop Research Institute. This alley is at a distance of 400m from the experimental orchard
treated for several years with CpGV. The overwintering larvae were collected in apples using
paper belt traps and stored for 3-4 months in a climatic chamber at 6°C temperature. At the
beginning of February 2008, the temperature in the climatic chamber was gradually increased
to 20°C. Adult codling moth emerged during April and they were transported into an
ovipositing box situated in the glasshouse with natural light conditions. The branches of apple
trees were placed round the boxes to simulate natural conditions and support the oviposition.
Bioassay
The methodology of bioassays and rearing of adults of wild codling moth populations was
carried out according to Fritsch et al. (2005) and Asser-Kaiser et al. (2007). Neonate larvae
(L1) were placed individually on the surface of the diet prepared from instant premix
(Manduca Premix-Heliothis Premix, Stonefly Industries; USA). Purified and quantified
CpGV-M isolate was mix into the diet in concentrations from 102 to 3x104 occlusion body
(OB)/ml. Twenty to fifty L1 larvae were exposed to each tested concentration of CpGV-M.
Larvae of the laboratory strain were exposed to six concentrations of CpGV-M, larvae of field
populations were exposed to two – four concentrations of CpGV-M depending on the number
of larvae available for the test. One day post infection the dead larvae were removed to avoid
assessing the larvae injured during manipulation from the bioassay. Mortality of larvae in the
bioassay was evaluated symptomatically 7 and 14 days post infection.
Statistical analysis
Corrected mortalities (Abbott, 1925) of the larvae from the laboratory strain of codling moth
were analyzed by probit analysis ( STATISTICA 6.0, StatSoft Inc. 2005). LC50 values, 95%
258
confidence intervals and slopes and intercepts of the dose-response curves were determined.
The sensitivity of wild populations to CpGV-M was evaluated according to comparison of
mortality of the wild population in probit with the confidence intervals of the dose-response
curve of the laboratory strain.
Results and discussion
Laboratory strain of codling moth
The average mortality of codling moth larvae from the laboratory strain one day post infection
(mortality due to manipulation) was 1.25%. In untreated controls, the mortality of larvae 7
and 14 days post infection was 0%. Seven days post infection, CpGV-M had intermediate
efficacy against larvae from the laboratory strain with an LC50 of 5.42x103 OB/ml of diet (95%
confidence limit 3.55 – 8.96 x103 OB/ml, slope 0.95), while 14 days post infection the LC50
was 3.47x102 OB/ml of diet (95% confidence limit 1.73 – 5.69 x102 OB/ml, slope 1.86).
These results correspond to results published by Fritsch et al. (2005) and confirm the
sensitivity of the codling moth laboratory strain to CpGV-M. Asser-Kaiser et al. (2007) stated
LC50 values of ~170 to ~970 OB/ml of the susceptible laboratory and field populations 14
days post infection. These data correspond with our results too.
Field populations of codling moth
The average mortality of codling moth larvae from wild populations from Bulhary, PragueRuzyne and Velke Bilovice one day post infection was 7.05%, 7.35% and 4.75%, respectively.
The mortality in controls without CpGV-M 7 and 14 days post infection was 0%. Mortality of
larvae from wild populations expressed in probit in dependence on log of CpGV-M
concentrations is presented in Figure 1. The low number of codling moth larvae available for
the bioassay did not enable the determination of LC50 values of CpGV-M against wild
populations. However, according to the position of points corresponding to mortality of larvae
from the tested wild populations in Figure 1 with respect to the confidence intervals of
concentration-mortality response curve of the laboratory strain, the sensitivity of wild
populations did not differ significantly from the laboratory strain. In most cases, mortality rate
of wild populations lie inside the confidence interval of the concentration-mortality response
curve of the laboratory strain. According to Schmitt et al. (2008), codling moth larvae
surviving infection by CpGV in concentrations of 104 OB/ml (evaluated 14 days post
infection) can be considered to be resistant. In our experiments, mortality of larvae from the
tested wild populations 14 days post infection by CpGV-M in concentrations 104 OB/ml (log
c 4.00) and 3x104 OB/ml (log c 4.48) reached always 100%. Hence, any tested wild
population did not exhibit decreased sensitivity to CpGV-M. In addition to this, codling moth
populations collected from localities with different management of pests control did not differ
significantly in their sensitivity to CpGV-M. Recently, for the population of codling moth
from the commercial apple orchard in Velke Bilovice, cross resistance to fenoxycarb,
teflubenzuron and phosalone has been detected (Stara and Kocourek, 2007). According to our
results, CpGV-M is efficient against this population and no cross-resistance to CpGV-M and
fenoxycarb, teflubenzuron and phosalone was indicated. Similarly, Schmitt et al. (2008) did
not prove cross-resistance between CpGV and insecticides. Hence, after registration of
biopesticides based on CpGV-M, we can expect high efficacy of these biopesticides against
codling moth populations from the Czech Republic. These biopesticides will be suitable for
use in organic apple orchards as well as in IPM orchards and will serve as a good alternative
to chemical insecticides in orchards with incidence of codling moth populations resistant to
insecticides.
259
14 days bioassay
y = -0.2267+2.0574*x; 0.95 conf.int.
9
8
mortality (probit)
7
6
5
4
3
2
2,0
2,5
3,0
3,5
4,0
4,5
5,0
laboratory strain
Bulhary population
Prague-Ruzyne population
Velke Bilovice population
log c
Figure 1. Comparison of efficacy of CpGV-M tested against sensitive laboratory strain and against the
wild populations from Bulhary, Prague-Ruzyne and Velke Bilovice 14 days post infection.
Acknowledgements
We thank J.A. Jehle for kindly providing the isolate of CpGV-M. The work was supported by
the project of the Ministry of Agriculture of the Czech Republic no. 1G58081 and the
Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic no. MSM 6046070901.
References
Asser-Kaiser, S., Fritsch, E., Undorf-Spahn, K., Kienzle, J. Eberle, K. E., Gund, N. A.,
Reineke, A., Zebitz, C. P. W., Heckel, D. G., Huber, J., Jehle, J.A. 2007: Rapid
Emergence of Baculovirus Resistance in Codling Moth Due to Dominant, Sex-Linked
Inheritance. Science 317: 1916-1918.
Fritsch, E., Undorf-Spahn, K., Kienzle, J., Zebitz, C. P.W., Huber, J. 2005: ApfelwicklerGranulovirus: Erste Hinweise auf Unterschiede in der Empfindlichkeit lokaler
Apfelwickler-Populationen. Nachrichtenbl. Deut. Pflanzenschutzd.,57(2): 29-34.
Jehle, J. A. 2008: The Future of Cydia pomonella Granulovirus in Biological Control of
Codling
Moth.
[online]
[cit.
15
September
2008].
Available
at
http://orgprints.org/13707/01/265-270.pdf.
Schmitt A., Sauphanor B., Jehle J. A., Huber J. 2008: Resistance of Cydia pomonella to
granulovirus: occurrence in Europe and tests on cross resistance with chemical
insecticides.
[online]
[cit.
19
September
2008].
Available
at
http://www.sustaincpgv.eu/pdfs!/Schmitt%20et%20al%20Poster.pdf.
Stará, J., Kocourek, F. 2007: Insecticidal Resistance and Cross-Resistance in Populations of
Cydia pomonella (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) in Central Europe. J. Econ. Entomol. 100(5):
1587-1595.
260
Indicators to assess the environmental impact of protection practices
in apple orchards
Benoît Sauphanor 1, Camille Picard 1, Sylvaine Simon 2, Daniel Plénet 1
1
INRA, UMR 1115 Plantes et Systèmes de culture Horticoles, Agroparc, F-84914 Avignon
Cédex 9, France; 2 INRA UERI Gotheron, F-26320 Saint-Marcel-lès-Valence, France
Abstract: Apple fruit production requires the application of numerous pesticides, mostly targeted
against scab, codling moth and aphids. A Principal Component Analysis of the protection practices in
54 randomized apple orchards of a small production area near Avignon, in south-eastern France,
produced 4 groups of growers relying on the protection strategy against Cydia pomonella: organic
production, exclusive use of mating disruption (MD) against C. pomonella, intensive use of chemical
insecticides (intensive), and a fourth group with both MD and chemicals (intermediate). The
environmental impacts of these management strategies were assessed using two different indicators i)
the environmental impact quotient (EIQ) accumulating the impacts on farmers, consumers and non
human biota ii) I-PHYARBO, a fuzzy expert system focusing on the environmental impact of pesticides.
The outputs of these two indicators strongly differed from each other, the highest environmental
impact being attributed to the organic orchards by EIQ while according to I-PHYARBO organic farming
had the safest protection program. The three other protection systems did not differ strongly from each
other whatever the indicator. This range discrepancy, which is conserved when considering only the
beneficial organisms, is mainly due to the structure of the models. Unlike I-PHYARBO, EIQ assumes
dose proportionality and a strict additivity of the effects of successive treatments, thus attributing high
adverse effects to the organic programs that involve frequent applications of mineral fungicides.
Attention has to be paid to the significance of these indicators, which may become useful tools to
establish the consistency of pest-control strategies and recommendations.
Keywords: Pest management, agri-environmental indicator, EIQ, I-PHYARBO, mating disruption,
organic orchard
Introduction
Apple fruit production requires the application of numerous pesticides, mostly targeted
against scab, codling moth and aphids. Forecasting models, population survey and alternative
control methods are increasingly implemented against these pests, tending to reduce the
number of chemical treatments and the environmental impact of protection practices. There is
at the same time an increasing concern regarding the impact of these practices on the
environment, strongly depending on the toxicity of each pesticide, the dose and technique of
application, the time the active ingredients remain in the soil, and surface and groundwater
contamination. The first approach to assess impacts is the direct measurement on
communities, and vast scientific literature is dealing with the impact of production strategies
on the biotic environment (Hole et al 2005). However these analyses are highly time
consuming, and the relations between agricultural practices and the environment are not
always demonstrated. Different abiotic environmental indicators were thus developed to
assess the risk associated with different protection scenarios (Reus et al., 2002, Devilliers et
al., 2005). Two of them, implemented at the plot level and initially designed for fruit crops,
were used in this study to compare the management strategies of apple growers in south-eastern
France. The first one is the environmental impact quotient (EIQ) accumulating the impacts on
farmers, consumers and non human biota (Kovach et al., 1992). The second one, I-PHYARBO, is a
261
fuzzy expert system focusing on the environmental impact of pesticides (Devilliers et al., 2005).
Material and methods
Indicators. Both EIQ and I-PHYARBO indicators score the potential risk for a treatment program
based on the toxicity of each applied pesticide and measures of potential exposure based on the
half-life, runoff or leaching potential, and pattern of use.
The overall EIQ for each pesticide is the average of three general risk categories, the farm
worker, the consumer, and the ecological component including aquatic organisms, bees, birds,
and beneficial arthropods. The EIQ value of a pesticide application is the product of the active
ingredient index by the rate of application; the EIQ for a crop protection program is the sum of
the values obtained for each pesticide application.
I-PHYARBO is an expert system adapted for fruit crops from the indicator “Ipest” (Van der
Werf and Zimmer, 1998), initially designed for field crops. The four modules of Ipest reflect the
presence of the pesticide and the risk for ground water, surface water and air compartments,
their input variables being pesticide properties and conditions of application. A fifth module on
beneficial arthropods was included in I-PHYARBO. The value of each module is calculated
according to the degree of membership of the input variables to the fuzzy subsets favourable or
unfavourable. The five modules can be considered individually, or aggregated according to
membership to fuzzy subsets and a set of decision rules. Unlike the EIQ, a high value of IPHYARBO means a low environmental impact.
Orchards. The protection practices including the treatment recordings were collected and
described by the way of a direct inquiry in 54 randomized apple orchards of a small
production area near Avignon, and subjected to a Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to
establish a typology of grower strategies.
Results
The PCA designed four groups of orchards relying on the protection strategy against Cydia
pomonella and on the intensity of chemical applications (Figure 1): a first group of seven
orchards under organic fruit production guidelines (Organic), a group of six orchards under
conventional farming with use of mating disruption against C. pomonella and a few chemical
insecticides against other pests (MD), a group of 12 orchards with exclusive use of chemical
insecticides (Intensive), and a last group of 22 orchards using both MD and chemical
treatments against C. pomonella (Intermediate).
Both indicators were able to discriminate the protection programs, despite a high variability
of practices and of indicator values within each of the groups (Figure 2). The outputs of the two
analyzed indicators strongly differed from each other. According to EIQ, the highest
environmental impact was attributed to the organic orchards whereas the three other protection
systems did not differ significantly from each other. According to I-PHYARBO organic farming had
the safest protection program, and the introduction of MD technique also significantly minimized
the environmental impacts when compared to the most intensive system.
262
Figure 1. Protection strategies of apple growers in the study area designed using a PCA analysis
considering the nature and number of treatments or the alternative protection strategies against
the codling moth
Conclusions
I-PHYARBO fits better than EIQ with the observations of biological communities of the same area,
where Organic is the safest system on soil macrofauna (Denoyelle et al 2007), arthropods
(Simon et al 2007) and birds (Bouvier et al 2005). Direct observations on biological
communities seem a good way to validate such indicators, but only a few studies considered
simultaneously the outputs of abiotic indicators and selected field related organisms, which
was the case for carabids, weeds, earthworm, microbial soil activity in Heyer et al (2003). The
range discrepancy observed between the two indicators, which is conserved when considering
only the beneficial organisms, is mainly due to the structure of the models. Unlike I-PHYARBO,
EIQ assumes dose proportionality and a strict additivity of the effects of successive treatments,
thus attributing high adverse effects to the organic programs that involve frequent applications of
mineral fungicides. Particular attention has to thus be paid to the significance of these indicators,
which may become useful tools to establish the consistency of pest-control strategies and
recommendations in fruit production.
263
4500
8
EIQ
I-PHY
4000
7
3500
Tukey
test
6
A
A
A
B
5
2500
I-PHY
EIQ
3000
2000
Tukey
test
C
BC
AB
A
4
3
1500
2
1000
1
500
0
0
IPHY |
Intensive
EIQ |
EIQ |
| MD EIQ | Organic
Intensive Intermediate EIQMD
Organic
Intensive Intermediate
Intensive
IPHY |
MD
Intermediate IPHY
| MD
Intermediate
IPHY |
Organic
Organic
Figure 2. Values of the EIQ (high value= high impact) and of the I-PHYARBO (high value = low
impact) indicators according to protection strategy in 2006 in apple orchards.
References
Bouvier, J.C., Toubon, J.F., Boivin, T., Sauphanor, B. 2005: Effects of apple orchard
management strategies on the great tit (Parus major) in Southeastern France. Environ.
Toxicol. Chem. 24: 2846-2852.
Denoyelle, R., Rault, M., Mazzia, C., Mascle, O., Capowiez, Y., 2007: Cholinesterase activity as
a biomarker of pesticide exposure in Allolobophora chlorotica earthworms living in apple
orchards under different management strategies. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 26: 2644-2649.
Devillers J, Farret R, Girardin P, Rivière JL, Soulas G, 2005: Indicateurs pour évaluer les risques
liés à l’utilisation des pesticides. Tec & Doc, Paris, 278p.
Heyer, W., Hülsbergen. K-J., Wittmann, Ch., Papaja, S., Christen, O. 2003: Field related
organisms as possible indicators for evaluation of land use intensity. Agriculture,
Ecosystems and Environment 98: 453–461.
Hole, D.G., Perkins, A.J., Wilson, J.D., Alexander, I.H., Grice, P.V., Evans, A.D. 2005: Does
organic farming benefit biodiversity? Biological conservation 122: 113-130.
Kovach, J., Petzoldt, C., Degni, J. and Tette, J. 1992: A method to measure the environmental
impact of pesticides. New York's Food and Life Science Bulletin 139: 1-8.
Reus, J., Leendertse, P., Bockstaller, C., Fomsgaard, I., Gutsche, V., Lewis, K., Nilsson, C.,
Pussemier, L., Trevisan, M., van der Werf, H., Alfarroba, F., Blumel, S., Isart, J., McGrath,
D., Seppala, T. 2002: Comparison and evaluation of eight pesticide environmental risk
indicators developed in Europe and recommendations for future use. Agriculture
Ecosystems and Environnment 90: 117-187.
Ricci, B., Franck, P., Toubon, J.F., Bouvier, J.C., Sauphanor, B., Lavigne, C. 2008: The influence
of landscape on insect pest dynamics: a case study in southeastern France. Landscape
Ecology Online 28 November 2008: DOI 10.1007/s10980-008-9308-6.
Simon, S., Defrance, H., Sauphanor, B. 2007: Effect of codling moth management on orchard
arthropods. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environnment. 122: 340-348.
van der Werf, H. M. G. and Zimmer, C. 1998: An indicator of pesticide environmental impact
based on a fuzzy expert system. Chemosphère 36: 2225-2249.
264
Potential new storage rot problems in UK Cox apples
A.M. Berrie, B.E. Ellerker, J.D. Robinson
East Malling Rsearch, East Malling, Kent, ME19 6BJ, UK
Abstract: Recent surveys of rotting in Cox apples in the UK have identified new fungal rots due to
Botryosphaeria obtusa, Basidiomycete fungi and Phomopsis mali causing losses in the orchard and in
store. Only studies on B. obtusa are reported here. B. obtusa causes a brown rot of fruit in the orchard
and in store a purple rot, usually at the stalk end, and with a distinct medicinal smell. The fungus can
invade fruit directly or via wounds. All apple varieties tested were susceptible to B. obtusa, but Cox
was most susceptible. The rot also occurs on pears but at a much lower incidence. Studies on B. obtusa
invasion of wood showed that the fungus did not form cankers on trees or invade wounds, but rapidly
colonised dead 1-3 year-old branches on the tree. Similarly prunings on the ground were also rapidly
colonised by the fungus. Dead apple twigs in orchards are therefore the main source of inoculum.
Botryosphaeria infected apple twigs were present in all orchards examined. B. obtusa was rarely found
on alder or Chamaecyparis twigs and windbreaks do therefore not appear to be a source of the fungus
for apple trees. Monitoring fungal activity on infected twigs showed that conidia were produced all
year round. Studies on B. obtusa rot in store on Cox, Gala and Fiesta showed that rot development was
very slow and secondary spread to healthy fruit unlikely to be significant. Losses in store will
therefore depend on the level of fruit infection in the orchard. Changes in orchard management
practices relating to pulverisation of prunings in the orchard rather than removal and burning have
probably contributed to the increase in incidence of Botryosphaeria.
Botryosphaeria obtusa, Phomopsis mali, Inoculum,
265
Is it possible to predict the aerial concentrations of Venturia inaequalis
ascospores in apple orchards?
Laurent Brun1*, Frédérique Didelot2, Freddy Combe1, Gilles Orain3, Cécile Payen4,
Arnaud Lemarquand3, Luciana Parisi1
1
INRA, UERI, Domaine de Gotheron, 26320 Saint-Marcel-lès-Valence, France ; 2INRA, UMR
PAVE, 42 rue G. Morel, 49071 Beaucouzé Cedex, France; 3INRA, UE Bois l’Abbé – La
Rétuzière, BP 60057, 49071 Beaucouzé Cedex, France; 4DRAF-SRPV, Antenne de Valence, 33
avenue de Romans, BP 2145, 26021 Valence Cedex, France
*lbrun@avignon.inra.fr
Abstract: Daily aerial concentrations of ascospores of Venturia inaequalis, the infectious agent
responsible for apple scab, were observed over four years in apple orchards in the Drôme and Maineet-Loire departments in France. These concentrations were recorded throughout the entire primary
ejection period with Burkard 7-day volumetric spore traps, placed directly on the ground at the interrow level of the orchard. During days with particularly high ejections, i.e., greater than 5% of the total
quantity of ascospores trapped for the year, concentrations of more than 400 ascospores/m3 of sampled
air could be observed in the two regions. Using meteorological data recorded by the weather stations
located near the orchards studied, it was possible to model daily ascospore ejections with two types of
decision support software used on a regular basis in France for agricultural warning systems. However,
these models did not correctly estimate a significant number of large ejections for some of the years. It
would therefore be unrealistic to recommend the use of these modelled values of daily ascospore
ejections for pest control strategies requiring precise details about these quantities, without taking
excessive risks. On the other hand, it seems possible to use these two models to determine the period
(from 1 to 2 months, depending on the year) during which the aerial concentrations of ascospores are
the highest.
Key-words: apple scab, Venturia inaequalis, ascospores, aerial concentrations, modelling
Introduction
Apple scab, caused by Venturia inaequalis (Cooke) G. Wint., is one of the most serious
diseases of apple worldwide. Ascospores released from pseudothecia on overwintered
infected leaves in the leaf litter are the main source of scab primary inoculum (Holb et al.,
2004). In France, the most commonly used disease management strategy to control apple scab
relies on a chemical protection applied during the primary period of ascospore ejections for
any “Mills contamination risk” level, including the “Angers risk” (Olivier, 1986). A total of
15 to 20 fungicide treatments per year may thus be necessary to control the disease, according
to years and regions.
However, it is possible to reduce the chemical protection during this primary period
(Brun et al., 2007). In the case of low-susceptibility cultivars, the integrated control scheme
proposed by Olivier (1986) takes the inoculum present in autumn in the orchard and the
intensity of the ejection of ascospores into account. In the case of Vf-resistant cultivars, it is
recommended to protect high contamination risk periods (only the main period of ascospore
ejections associated with some levels of Mill’s risks have to be protected).
To be able to apply such strategy, it is necessary to determine accurately the main period
of ascospore ejections (from 5 to 95 % of the ascospore stock ejected).
266
Materials & Methods
The aerial concentration of ascospores was assessed with Burkard 7-day volumetric spore
traps (Burkard Manufacturing Co. Ltd., Rickmansworth Hertfordshire, England) installed on
the orchard ground. Monitoring was made for 4 years in organic orchards of the Valence
region (Drôme, France) and in experimental orchards not sprayed against scab in Maine-etLoire (France).
The modelling of ascospore ejections was based on data from weather stations located
near the orchards computed by the 2 softwares used in France by extension advertising
networks:
*Pulsowin® (Pulsonic, Orsay, France), decision aid software intended for use by fruit growers,
and Melchior®, software used by the French Regional Plant Protection Services, 2 similar
softwares based on maturation curves of Lagarde (1988);
*RIMpro® (version 2.0.5; Bio Fruit Advies, Zoelmond, the Netherlands) based on maturation
curve known as the New Hampshire curve (Giraud & Trapman, 2006).
Results & Discussion
In this study, the aerial ascospore traps were placed directly in situ in the orchards during the
entire primary season. Working directly in situ and not on artificial apple leaf litters outside
of the orchard allowed us to take the actual maturation conditions of the perithecia in the
orchard into consideration. By measuring the aerial concentration of ascospores at 45 cm
above the ground, we were able to accurately estimate the inoculum ejected from the leaf
litter that was then deposited on the foliage (Carisse et al., 2007). During days with
particularly high ejections, i.e., greater than 5% of the total quantity of ascospores trapped for
the year, concentrations of more than 400 ascospores/m3 of sampled air could be observed in
the two regions.
Table 1. Differences in day numbers for the 5% and 95% ascospore ejection points between
models and trap measures in Maine-et-Loire en 2004, 2005, 2006 and 2007
La Rétuzière
Total of ejected
5% of the stock
95% of the stock
ascospores
®
6289
2004
RIMpro
1 day B
1 day B
100%
3 days A
Pulsowin®
26 days A
6476
2005
RIMpro®
4 days B
8 days B
100%
Pulsowin®
2 days A
17 days B
®
4753
The same day
2006
RIMpro
21 days B
®
100%
3 days B
Pulsowin
7 days B
6070
4 days B
2007
RIMpro®
17 days A
100%
Pulsowin®
36 days A
22 days A
A: after spore trap; B: before spore trap
Applying specific strategies of treatment in the period between 5 to 95% of the ejections
will only be possible if the discrepancy between the prediction of this period by the model(s)
and biological facts is not too large. Pulsowin® predict 5% of the stock ejected too late
1 year/4 in Maine-et-Loire, and Melchior® and RIMpro® 2 years/4 in the Drôme department
(Table 1 and 2; Figure 1). Pulsowin® and RIMpro® predict the end of important ejections
(95% yet ejected) too early 1 and 2 years/4 respectively in Maine-et-Loire, and RIMpro®
1 year/4 in Drôme (Table 1 and 2; Figure 2).
267
For the Maine-et-Loire Department, the announcement of 5% of the ascospore stock
ejected according to RIMpro® could therefore be used to identify the beginning of the period
of dense ejections. In contrast, the end of the dense ejection period could not be identified
with the models at no risk.
For the Drôme Department, it is therefore not possible to predict the beginning of the
dense ascospore ejection period with these two models. We thus propose, by default, to
consider the ejections as potentially dense as soon as the apple trees have reached the stage of
susceptibility to apple scab (C-C3 Fleckinger stage). On the other hand, it seems that the
announcement of 95% of the ascospore stock ejected according to Melchior® can be used to
detect the end of the dense ejection period in the Drôme at no risk.
Table 2. Differences in day numbers for the 5% and 95% ascospore ejection points between
models and trap measures in Drôme in 2004, 2005, 2006 and 2008.
Total of ejected 5% of the stock 95% of the stock
ascospores
5314
Loriol
RIMpro®
2/3 days A
5 days A
®
2004
Melchior
100%
The same day
21/22 days A
Pulsowin®
100%
The same day
21/22 days A
®
5675
1 day A
3 days B
Gotheron
RIMpro
®
2005
Melchior
100%
3 days B
9 days B
®
6097
RIMpro
2006
2 days A
6 days A
Melchior®
100%
4 days A
8 days A
®
5590
RIMpro
2008
6/10 days B
19 days B
Melchior®
100%
3 days B
2/6 days A
A: after spore trap(s); B: before spore trap(s)
100
Cumulative % ascospores
90
La Rétuzière 2007
80
70
60
50
40
Spore trap (R23 orchard)
30
20
RIMpro® (Biofix on
23/02/07)
10
Pulsowin® (Mild winter
curve; J0 on 20/02/07)
4/6
28/5
21/5
14/5
7/5
30/4
23/4
16/4
9/4
2/4
26/3
19/3
12/3
5/3
26/2
19/2
0
Figure 1: Ascospore ejections according to trap information and models in La Rétuzière
(Maine-et-Loire) in 2007.
268
100
90
Gotheron 2008
Cumulative % ascospores
80
70
60
50
Spore trap n°1 (AB04a orchard)
40
Spore trap n°2 (AB04b orchard)
30
RIMpro® (Biofix on 10/03/08)
20
Melchior® (Cold winter curve; J0
on 10/03/08)
10
31/5
24/5
17/5
10/5
3/5
26/4
19/4
12/4
5/4
29/3
22/3
15/3
8/3
0
Figure 2: Ascospore ejections according to trap information and models in Gotheron (Drôme)
in 2008.
Acknowledgements
The authors acknowledge Claudine Foubert, Christophe Brouard, Sylvain Hanteville, the
students Estelle Dumont, Benjamin Langendorf and Maël Baudin for their contribution to this
work.
References
Brun, L., Didelot, F. & Parisi, L. 2007: Stratégies de protection innovantes contre la tavelure
du pommier : conception, évaluation et intégration en vergers. Innovations
Agronomiques 1: 33-45 (http://www.inra.fr/ciag/revue_innovations_agronomiques).
Carisse, O., Rolland, D., Talbot, B., Savary, S. 2007: Heterogeneity of the aerial concentration
and deposition of ascospores of Venturia inaequalis within a tree canopy during the rain.
European Journal of Plant Pathology 117: 13-24.
Giraud, M. & Trapman, M. 2006: Le modèle RIMpro. Intérêt dans la gestion de la tavelure du
pommier. L’arboriculture fruitière 603: 29-32.
Holb, I.J., Heijne, B., Jeger, M.J. 2004: Overwintering of Conidia of Venturia inaequalis and
the Contribution to Early Epidemics of Apple Scab. Plant Disease 88: 751-757.
Lagarde, M.P., 1988: Une nouvelle approche de la modélisation à partir de l’évolution de la
maturation des ascospores. Adalia 7-8: 14-15.
Olivier, J. M. 1986: La tavelure du pommier, conduite d'une protection raisonnée.
Adalia 1: 3-19
269
Efficiency of association of scab control methods on resistance
durability of apple: the case study of cultivar Ariane
Valérie Caffier1, Frédérique Didelot 1, Gilles Orain2, Arnaud Lemarquand2, Luciana
Parisi3
1
INRA Centre d’Angers-Nantes, UMR PaVé, 42 rue Georges Morel, BP60057, 49071
Beaucouzé cedex, France; 2INRA Centre d’Angers-Nantes, UE Bois l'Abbé-La Rétuzière, 42
rue Georges Morel, BP60057, 49071 Beaucouzé cedex, France; 3current address: INRAUERI – Domaine de Gotheron – 26320 Saint-Marcel-lès-Valence, France
Abstract: The major resistance gene Vf has been deployed in several commercial cultivars. This
resulted in the emergence of virulent isolates of Venturia inaequalis in Europe. In France, isolates
virulent to Vf developed since 1995, mainly in North-West region. To increase the durability of
resistance of Vf cultivars in regions where virulent isolates are not yet present (or present at a low
frequency), it was recommended that leaf litter be destroyed in winter and to apply fungicides at times
of the highest scab risks. These recommendations, however, had not been evaluated experimentally
previously. In 2004, we initiated a project to test these recommendations on cultivar ‘Ariane’, which
has been deployed in France since 2002. Our objective was to evaluate the efficiency of association of
scab control methods to delay the breakdown of Vf. In an experimental orchard planted with ‘Ariane’,
we compared scab development in 3 untreated and 3 treated plots. In untreated plots, scab increased
quickly to 98% of scabbed trees and 35% of scabbed fruits in 2008, showing the high susceptibility of
‘Ariane’ in case of breakdown of its resistance. In treated plots, destruction of leaf litter was performed
each year, and 5 to 9 fungicides were sprayed each spring to cover medium and high risks of scab
development following Mill’s curves. For comparison, about twice the fungicide sprayings were
applied in the same region on susceptible cultivars. In 2008 on the treated plots, 4% of the trees
presented a very low severity of disease, and 0.2% of scabbed fruits were observed. This study shows
the efficiency to associate sanitation and reduced number of fungicide sprayings to complement Vf
resistance and delay its breakdown.
Key words: major resistance, apple scab, Venturia inaequalis, durability of resistance, fungicide,
sanitation
Introduction
Most of the apple cultivars grown in orchards are susceptible to scab, and numerous fungicide
sprays are necessary to control the disease. The use of scab resistant cultivars constitutes one
of the alternatives to fungicide treatments, but presents the disadvantage that breakdown of
resistance can occur, at least in case of major genes.
The major resistance gene Vf has been deployed in several commercial apple cultivars. This
resulted in the selection of virulent isolates of Venturia inaequalis in Europe (Parisi et al.,
1993; Parisi et al., 2004). In France, Vf has been used mainly in the northwest of the country
(in regions: Nord, Normandie and Bretagne). The first virulent isolates on Vf were observed in
1995 on cultivar ‘Judeline’ (Parisi et al., 2000), and developed in the 2000s (Guerin and Le
Cam, 2004), resulting in the susceptibility to scab of ‘Judeline’ in this region. Other Vf
cultivars have been planted in France, but represented a very low acreage. Since 2002, the
percentage of acreage planted with Vf cultivars has increased with the planting of cultivar
‘Ariane’ (Laurens et al., 2005) in the different areas of apple production in France (with 500
ha in 2007).
270
To increase the durability of resistance of Vf cultivars in regions where virulent isolates are
not yet present (or present at a low frequency), it was recommended that leaf litter be
destroyed in winter (Gomez et al., 2007) and to apply fungicides when the the highest scab
risks were found (Olivier, 1986). These recommendations, however, had not been evaluated
experimentally. The aim of this study was to evaluate the efficiency of association of control
methods to increase the durability of Vf in the case of ‘Ariane’, in a region where the
frequency of isolates virulent to Vf was initially low.
Materials and methods
The experimental orchard was planted in 1999 in Loire Valley (Champigné, France), and
comprised 6 plots of ‘Ariane’ (78 trees per plot) surrounded by non-host hedges (for details,
see Didelot et al., same volume).
‘Ariane’ carries the major gene Vg in addition to Vf, but Vg does not increase the
efficiency of resistance, because of the existence of race 6 overcoming Vf + Vg (Parisi and
Lespinasse, 1996). In this orchard, the first symptoms of scab were observed on ‘Ariane’ in
2004 in one plot adjacent to the present experiment.
Since 2005, 3 plots were maintained without any protection against scab and 3 plots were
protected against scab by the association of leaf litter removal and applications of fungicides
in case of moderate and severe Mill’s risks (for details, see Didelot et al., same volume).
From 2005 to 2008, scab was assessed on each tree on a 1 to 9 scale (adapted from
Lateur et al., 1998) according to the % of scabbed leaves in June and September. At harvest,
fruits were sampled randomly on the 4 central rows of each plot and the percentage of
scabbed fruits was evaluated.
Results
Five to 9 fungicide treatments against scab were applied each spring from 2005 to 2008
(Table 1), which covered all periods of medium and high risk. No fungicide was applied after
the end of the discharge of ascospores.
Table 1. Number of scab risks and fungicide treatments from 2005 to 2008 in the
experimental orchard
Year
N° of scab risks* (Mill's curves)
N° of fungicide
Angers/Low
Medium/High
treatments against scab
2005
7
5
6
2006
5
4
5
2007
11
6
6
2008
9
10
9
* Number of risks between susceptible stage of apple and end of projection of ascospores
In untreated plots, a large increase of scab was observed between 2007 and 2008 on
leaves and on fruits (Figure 1), leading to 98% of scabbed trees and 35% of scabbed fruits in
2008. This increase resulted from climatic conditions very favorable to scab. In treated plots,
the increase of scab was slow with 4% of scabbed trees at the end of June 2008 and 0.2% of
scabbed fruits at harvest 2008. On these scabbed trees, less than 5% of leaves were infected,
whereas on untreated plots the mean scab severity corresponded to about 15% of scabbed
271
leaves, with the presence of trees with more than 50% of scabbed leaves (Figure 2).
100
100
A
Untreated
B
Treated
60
40
20
Treated
60
40
20
0
2005
2006
2007
Untreated
80
% of scabbed fruits
% of scabbed trees
80
0
2008
2005
2006
2007
2008
Figure 1. Increase in scab incidence on ‘Ariane’ from 2005 to 2008 for treated (leaf removal +
fungicides) and untreated plots. A: scab on leaves in June; B: scab on fruits at harvest
100
Untreated
% of trees
80
Treated
60
40
20
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
class of scab severity
Figure 2. Comparison of the distribution of scab severity in June 2008 on ‘Ariane’ for treated
(leaf removal + fungicides) and untreated plots; 1: no scab, 5: 25% of scabbed leaves, 7: 50%
of scabbed leaves, 9: >90% of scabbed leaves
Discussion
This study shows that scab quickly increased in untreated plots, showing the high
susceptibility of ‘Ariane’ when virulent isolates of V. inaequalis develop. In case of
breakdown of resistance, ‘Ariane’ should be treated as a susceptible cultivar (e.g. ‘Gala’). In
the 3 untreated plots of our experiment, leaf removal will be performed and fungicide
treatments will be applied in 2009 for all scab risks. This result confirms the importance of
resistance management of Vf apple scab resistant cultivars (cf Trapman, this volume) in order
to delay as much as possible the increase in frequency of virulent isolates.
By contrast, the level of disease on the treated plots remained low, although climatic
conditions were very favourable to scab development. These results show the efficiency of
combining sanitation with reduced number of fungicide sprays to complementt Vf resistance
and delay its breakdown. This experiment was carried out in severe conditions for scab, with a
higher amount of primary inoculum than usually found in commercial orchards. The
combination of control methods resulted in the maintainenance of good efficiency of the Vf
272
resistance, and the number of treatments against scab was reduced to about half the number of
fungicide treatments applied in the same region on susceptible cultivars.
This experiment will continue in the future, in order to evaluate the efficiency of these
practices on the control of disease and resistance durability precisely.
Acknowledgements
We thank Maël Baudin, Florian Blanchet, Christine Boursier, Danièle Chalain, Mélanie
Collin, Pascale Expert, and the team of experimental unit of INRA of Angers for technical
support. This work was carried out with the financial support of the « ANR- Agence Nationale
de la Recherche - The French National Research Agency » under the « Programme
Agriculture et Développement Durable », project « ANR-05-PADD-005, Cedre ».
References
Gomez, C., Brun, L., Chauffour, D. & De Le Vallée, D. 2007: Effect of leaf litter management
on scab development in an organic apple orchard. Agriculture, Ecosystems and
Environment 118: 249-255.
Guerin, F. & Le Cam, B. 2004: Breakdown of the scab resistance gene Vf in apple leads to a
founder effect in populations of the fungal pathogen Venturia inaequalis. Phytopathology
94: 364-369.
Lateur, M., Wagemans, C. & Populer, C. 1998: Evaluation of tree genetic resources as sources
of polygenic scab resistance in an apple breeding programme. Acta Horticulturae 484:
35-42.
Laurens, L., Lespinasse, Y. & Fouillet, A. 2005: A new scab-resistant apple: "Ariane".
HortScience 40: 484-485.
Olivier, J. M. 1986: La tavelure du pommier: conduite d'une protection raisonnée. Adalia 1: 319.
Parisi, L., Durel, C. E. & Laurens, F. 2000: First report on the presence of Venturia inaequalis
race 7 in French apple orchards. IOBC (WPRS) Bulletin 23: 99-104.
Parisi, L., Fouillet, V., Shouten, H. J., Groenwold, R., Laurens, F., Didelot, F., Evans, K.,
Fischer, C., Gennari, F., Kemp, H., Lateru, M., Patocchi, A., Thissen, J. & Tsipouridis, C.
2004: Variability of the pathogenicity of Venturia inaequalis in Europe. Acta
Horticulturae 663: 108-113.
Parisi, L. & Lespinasse, Y. 1996: Pathogenicity of Venturia inaequalis strains of race 6 on
apple clones (Malus sp.). Plant Disease 80: 1179-1183.
Parisi, L., Lespinasse, Y., Guillaumes, J. & Krüger, J. 1993: A new race of Venturia inaequalis
virulent to apples with resistance due to the Vf gene. Phytopathology 83: 533-537.
273
Control of oriental fruit moth, Cydia molesta (Busck), by Isomate OFM
rosso dispensers in peach orchards in Bulgaria – preliminary results
Hristina Kutinkova 1, Jörg Samietz 2, Vasiliy Dzhuvinov 1, Vittorio Veronelli 3, Andrea
Iodice3
1
Fruit Growing Institute, Ostromila 12, 4004 Plovdiv, Bulgaria; e-mail kutinkova@abv.bg
2
Swiss Federal Research Station Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil ACW, Switzerland
3
CBC (EUROPE) Ltd. Via E. Majorana, 2¸ I-20054 Nova Milanese, Milano, Italy
Abstract. Peach is the major fruit in South-East Bulgaria. Its main pest is the oriental fruit moth
(OFM), Cydia molesta Busck. For a long time pest management in stone fruit production in Bulgaria
relied on organophosphate and pyrethroid insecticides. Although originally quite effective, recently
their effectiveness decreased, apparently due to the resistance developed in many pests. Hence,
alternative means of control are urgently needed. The most common environmentally friendly methods
are those related to sex pheromones. Until recently, their use has been limited mainly to monitoring,
aiming at precise timing and reduction of chemical treatments. Mating disruption (MD) presents a
more promising solution, however. The trials on mating disruption in the present study were carried
out with Isomate OFM rosso dispensers (Shin-Etsu, Japan) in an isolated 10-ha peach orchard in 2007
and 2008. Pheromone trap catches were completely inhibited in the MD block whereas they were
numerous in the reference, i.e. conventionally treated orchard. The Isomate OFM rosso dispensers,
installed before the first flight of OFM at the rate of 500 units per ha, efficiently reduced fruit damage
– down to 0.1- 0.2% at harvest. In the reference orchard, with 5-6 insecticide treatments against OFM,
damage still reached 5-6%. The results indicate that mating disruption for control of oriental fruit moth
may be effective in Bulgaria. Its use will be helpful in meeting the requirements of EU for residues
free fruit production.
Keywords: IPM, peach, oriental fruit moth, mating disruption, Isomate OFM rosso dispensers
Introduction
Peach is one of the major fruit species in the south-eastern part of Bulgaria. It provides rapid
recovery of investments due to early bearing and relatively small phytosanitary problems
(Kolev and Jivondov 2000). Its main pest is the oriental fruit moth (OFM), Cydia molesta
Busck. The larvae of early OFM generations damage current season shoot tips; then they feed
in the developing fruitlets and fruits. For a long time pest management in stone fruit orchards
in Bulgaria relied on organophosphate and pyrethroid insecticides. Albeit originally effective,
they caused environmental problems and increasing consumer concerns. Recently their
effectiveness decreased, apparently due to resistance developed in many pests. Therefore,
alternative means of control are urgently needed. The most frequently applied
environmentally friendly methods are those related to sex pheromones. Their use has been
first limited to monitoring, aiming at precise timing and reduction of chemical treatments.
Mating disruption (MD) presents a more promising solution, however though.
Positive results of mating disruption of Cydia (Grapholitha) molesta, have been reported
from South Africa by Barnes & Blomefield (1997), from Italy by Trematerra et al. (2000) and
from Australia by Sexton & Il’ichev (2000). According to the studies of Molinari et al.
(2000), efficacy of synthetic pheromones applied for mating disruption of C. molesta and A.
lineatella was very high. In 74 tests in 1998 and in 119 tests in 1999 damage was below 1%.
274
In the recent investigation of Molinari (2007), confusion methods, involving 300-1000
pheromone dispensers per ha, reduced OFM reproduction in peach orchards provided that the
dispensers had been installed before the start of the first flight. They remained effective
through the second and third generations of the pest. MD proved also to be effective in control
of OFM in peach orchards of Slovenia (Rot & Blazič 2005) and New Zealand (Lo & Cole
2007).
Materials and methods
Trial orchard
The well-isolated, 10-ha commercial orchard near village Chokoba, Sliven region was
established in spring 2005. In the years 2007-2008 a trial on mating disruption (MD) of the
oriental fruit moth (Cydia molesta Busck.) was carried out there with Isomate OFM rosso
dispensers and aimed at the assessment of this method applied for the first time in Bulgaria.
The Isomate OFM rosso dispensers were installed in the trial orchard at the beginning of
April, about the start of OFM flights. The dispensers were hung in the upper third of tree
canopies at a density of 500 pieces per ha. According to the manufacturer, each dispenser is
loaded with a minimum of 240 mg of the OFM pheromone mixture. Against other pests
occurring in the trial plot, only one aphicide treatment was applied each in 2007 and 2008.
Reference orchard
Another orchard of 2-ha in area served as a reference and was treated conventionally. It was
located near the city of Sliven and established in 2003. Twelve treatments (14 active
ingredients) were applied there during each season, to control OFM and other pests. Six of the
treatment applications were timed against oriental fruit moth. The fruit damage by OFM in
this orchard in the years 2004-2006 was about 5%. The economic threshold in Bulgaria is 46% damaged fruits at harvest time.
Indices studied
Monitoring of OFM flights was carried out by sex trapping in both seasons. Three triangular
traps were installed in the trial orchard – they were baited with a standard capsule (Csalomon)
containing orfamone. The traps were installed in the centre and at the edge of the trial orchard
before OFM flights started. For comparison, 2 standard traps were installed in the reference,
conventionally treated orchard. All pheromone traps were checked twice a week.
Early in the season sampling of damaged shoots was carried out on 50 trees, randomly
chosen in the trial plot and in the reference orchard. During the season, sampling for fruit
damage was carried out in the trial and reference plot on 1000 fruits at each sampling. At
harvest, 3000 fruits were sampled in both orchards, to evaluate the final damage rate.
Evaluation of data
Data on catches of male moths in the pheromone traps were considered as totals for each date
of control and presented in a graphical form. The rate of fruit damage by OFM was expressed
as percentage of damaged fruits. Significance of differences in damage rate between the trial
and reference orchard was estimated by use of the Chi-square test.
Results
OFM flight dynamics
In the reference commercial orchard with conventional treatments the first flight of oriental
fruit moth in 2007 began on April 2. In the trial plot two moths were recorded in the
275
pheromone traps on April 5, when the Isomate OFM rosso dispensers were installed. The
flights of the overwintering generation OFM reached their maximum by the third decade of
April and continued with varying intensity, till the end of May (Fig. 1). The flight of the first
summer generation, which overlapped the overwintering one, started at the beginning of June,
reached its maximum in the third decade of June and continued till the end of July. The
second generation began to fly at the end of July and finished at the end of August. The third
generation began at the end of August and finished on October 8. The traps installed in the
reference orchard caught in total 442 moths. In the trial plot, after installation of Isomate
OFM rosso dispensers, no moths were caught in the pheromone traps.
40
30
20
10
0
26
.03
02 .
.04
09 .
.04
16 .
.04
23 .
.04
30 .
.04
06 .
.05
16 .
.05
23 .
.05
31 .
.05
08 .
.06
15 .
.06
22 .
.06
29 .
.06
06 .
.07
13 .
.07
20 .
.07
27 .
.07
03 .
.08
10 .
.08
17 .
.08
24 .
.08
31 .
.08
07 .
.09
14 .
.09
21 .
.09
28 .
.09
05 .
.10
12 .
.10
.
Number of moth caught
50
Figure 1. Captures of OFM in the reference orchard in 2007
In 2008, the first flight of OFM in the reference orchard began on April 4. In the trial plot
no moths were recorded in the pheromone traps till April 10, when the Isomate OFM rosso
dispensers were installed. The flights of the overwintering OFM generation reached its
maximum in the second decade of April and continued till the end of May (Fig. 2). The flights
of the first summer generation, that overlapped the overwintering one, began at the beginning
of June, reached its maximum in the third decade of June and continued till the end of July.
The second generation began at the end of July and finished at the end of August. The flights
of a partial third summer generation began at the end of August and finished on September
19. The traps installed in the reference orchard caught in total 559 moths. In the trial plot, no
moths were caught in the pheromone traps during the whole season.
80
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
01
.04
.
09
.04
.
18
.04
24 .
.04
.
02
.05
.
12
.05
.
19
.05
26 .
.05
.
02
.06
.
10
.06
20 .
.06
.
26
.06
.
03
.07
.
11
.07
17 .
.07
.
25
.07
.
31
.07
.
08
.08
15 .
.08
.
22
.08
.
29
.08
.
05
.09
12 .
.09
.
19
.09
.
26
.09
03 .
.10
.
Number of moths caught
70
Figure 2. Captures of OFM in the reference orchard in 2008
276
Evolution of shoot and fruit damage by OFM during the season
In the reference, conventionally treated orchard, severe shoot damage caused by OFM was
noted at the end of May in both years of study (Table 1). At the same time, no shoots were
damaged in the trial plot, where Isomate OFM rosso dispensers were installed. Damage rates
on shoots were significantly different between the treated plots and the reference orchard on
25 May of both years (Chi-square test, P < 0.01).
First signs of fruit damage were noted in the reference orchard at the end of June of each year.
Starting from the end of June, through August and September, fruit damage rate steadily
increased, reaching 6.2% in 2007 and 6.4% in 2008 at harvest. In the trial plot few damaged
fruits were noted at the end of the season; at harvest it was also negligible: 0.1% in 2007 and
0.2% in 2008. Damage rates were significantly different between the treated plots and the
reference orchard already on 29 June and 29 July 2007, 21 June and 18 July 2008 (Chi-square
test, P < 0.01) and thereafter until harvest in both years of the study (Chi-square tests, P <
0.001).
Table 1. Evolution of shoot and fruit damage by OFM in the Isomate OFM rosso trial plot
and in the conventionally treated reference orchard in two successive years of study
Index
Shoot
damage
[%]
Fruit
damage
[%]
Date
May 5
May 13
May 25
June 9
June 29
July 5
July 29
August 12
September
6
preharvest
at harvest
2007
Trial plot
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Reference
0.1
0.0
0.0
30.0
0.0
1.5
0.0
1.8
4.8
6.2
0.03
0.1
5.3
6.2
-
Date
May 6
May 17
May 25
June 8
June 21
July 5
July 18
August 10
August 23
September
7
preharvest
at harvest
2008
Trial plot
Reference
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.0
0.0
35.0
0.0
1.2
0.0
2.5
4.9
5.2
6.4
0.1
0.2
5.2
6.4
Discussion
In the reference orchard, damage caused by OFM was considerable, in spite of 6 conventional
treatments applied against OFM. It is suspected that the population of OFM in this orchard
has developed resistance to some of the insecticides used. Resistance of OFM to
organophosphate, pyrethroid and carbamate insecticides was detected in Canada by Pree et al.
(1998) and Kanga et al. (1990) and was considered as the main cause of failure of
conventional plant protection. Apparently a similar situation may have occured in Bulgarian
peach orchards.
Application of mating disruption with use of Isomate OFM rosso dispensers significantly
reduced OFM incidence and damage caused by this pest. This is in line with the reports from
other countries (Barnes & Blomefield 1997; Trematerra et al. 2000; Molinari et al. 2000;
Sexton & Il’ichev 2000; Rot & Blazič 2005; Molinari 2007; Lo & Cole 2007) and indicates
that the MD method may be successfully introduced in Bulgarian peach orchards. This new
technology may serve as an alternative means for control of OFM. Its use will be helpful in
277
meeting the requirements of EU for residue free fruit production.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported with a grant of the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) to JS
(project No. IB73A0-110978). Isomate OFM rosso dispensers of Shin-Etsu were kindly
provided by CBC (Europe), Ltd., Milano, Italy.
References
Barnes B.N. & Blomefield T.L. 1997: Goading growers towards mating disruption: the South
African experience with Grapholita molesta and Cydia pomonella (Lepidoptera,
Tortricidae). Bulletin OILB/SROP 20(1): 45-56.
Kanga L.H.B., Pree D.J.; Lier J.L. & van Walker G.M. 1999: Monitoring for resistance to
organophosphorus, carbamate, and pyrethroid insecticides in the oriental fruit moth
(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae). Canadian-Entomologist 131(4): 441-450.
Kolev K., Jivondov A, & Arnaudov V. 2000: Peach, Agriculture Plus, p.1-15.
Lo P.L. & Cole L.M. 2007: Impact of pheromone mating disruption and pesticides on oriental
fruit moth (Grapholita molesta) on peaches. New Zealand Plant Protection 60: 67-71.
Molinari F., Cravedi P., Rama F., Reggiori F., Pane M.D. & Galassi T. 2000: L'uso dei
feromoni secondo il metodo del "Disorientamento" nella difesa del pesco da Cydia
molesta e Anarsia lineatella. GF-2000 Atti Giornate Fitopatologiche, Perugia, 16-20
aprile 2000, volume-primo: 341-347.
Molinari F. 2007: Uno strumento a supporto della difesa di pesco, albicocco e susino: l'uso dei
feromoni su drupacee contro i lepidotteri carpofagi. Informatore-Agrario 63 (13): 53-56.
Pree D.J., Whitty K.J., Driel L. & van; Walker G.M. 1998: Resistance to insecticides in
Oriental fruit moth populations (Grapholita molesta) from the Niagara Peninsula of
Ontario. Canadian Entomologist 130(3): 245-256.
Rot M. & Blazič M. 2005: Zatiranje breskovega zavijaca (Cydia molesta L.) z metodo
zbeganja. Lectures and Papers-Presented at the 7th Slovenian Conference on Plant
Protection, Zrece, Slovenia, 8-10-March 2005: 175-181
Sexton S.B. & Il'ichev A.L. 2000: Pheromone mating disruption with reference to oriental
fruit moth Grapholita molesta (Busck). (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) literature review.
General and Applied Entomology 29: 63-68.
Trematerra P., Sciarretta A. & Gentile P. 2000: Trials on combined mating disruption in
Anarsia lineatella (Zeller) and Cydia molesta (Busck) using CheckMateReg. SF
dispenser. Atti Giornate Fitopatologiche Perugia: 349-354.
278
An integrated approach for reducing fungicide sprays against scab in
organic apple orchards
Imre J. Holb1,2, Barbara Balla1, Ferenc Abonyi1
1
University of Debrecen, Centre for Agricultural Sciences and Engineering P.O. Box 36, H4015 Debrecen, Hungary and 2 Plant Protection Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, P.
O. Box 102, H-1525 Budapest, Hungary
Abstract: The aim of this study was to evaluate scab control efficacy in integrated approaches of i)
three sanitation treatments (fallen leaf removal combined with winter pruning and non-sanitized
control), ii) three onsets of first fungicide sprays (dormant bud, early tight cluster and pink bud stage),
and iii) three final dates for finishing fungicide programs (mid-July, mid-August and mid-September)
in an organic apple orchard on a moderately scab susceptible cultivar, Jonathan. A delay in the onset of
first spray until pink bud stage resulted in higher scab incidences on both leaves (16-21 %) and fruits
(13-15 %) compared with the non-delayed spray treatments (5-8 % and 6-9 %, respectively). Final leaf
and fruit scab incidences increased significantly when sprays were omitted after mid-July compared to
spray treatments finished at mid-August or mid-September. A combination of leaf removal with
pruning resulted in lower scab incidence (5-12 %) compared with the non-sanitized plots (7-15 %)
when spray treatments were finished at mid-August or mid-September. Results on cv. Jonathan
suggested that scab sprays could only be omitted before early tight cluster and after mid-August if leaf
removal and pruning was applied.
Key words: organic production, apple scab, apple, sanitation, pruning, spray omission
Introduction
MacHardy et al. (1993) developed a ‘potential ascospore dose (PAD)’ action threshold in New
Hampshire for delaying the onset of scab fungicide programs in the early spring. With this
action threshold, one to four sprays can be saved at the beginning of the year (MacHardy et
al., 1993; MacHardy, 1996). Action thresholds were also developed for timing of final
fungicide application on the harvest scab threshold (1% fruit incidence) (Scheer, 1992; Holb
et al., 2003). Using this strategy, another two to four sprays are likely to be saved at the end of
the growing season (Scheer, 1992; Holb et al., 2003). Action thresholds were developed in
integrated orchards where PAD dose of V. inaequalis was low. These were not tested in
organic orchards.
Winter pruning and leaf removal of fallen leaves for reducing primary scab inoculum
sources were extensively studied in order to decrease pesticide use in apple orchards (Holb,
2006; Holb et al., 2005). It might be possible that a broad-scale integrated approach including
leaf removal, winter pruning and savings of sprays at both the beginning and the end of the
growing seasons might provide reductions of fungicide use in organic orchards.
The aim of this study was to evaluate scab control efficacy in integrated approaches of i)
three sanitation treatments including fallen leaf removal and its combination with winter
pruning, ii) three onsets of first fungicide sprays, and iii) three final dates for finishing
fungicide programs.
Material and methods
A two-year study (2005 and 2006) was carried out in a 15-ha organic apple orchard in
279
Eperjeske, eastern Hungary. Trees were grafted on M26 rootstock and pruned to spindle
shape. Orchard soil type was brown forest soil. Organic production guidelines (Anon., 1998)
have been applied since the orchard was established in 1996. Leaf wetness duration (hr) was
detected from 10 March until 30 September in both years and apple scab infection periods
were calculated.
The experimental design was a split-plot with the two years as blocks, three sanitation
treatments combined with three onsets of first fungicide spray as main plots and three final
spray dates as sub-plots. Nine equally sized treatments of orchard sanitation practices
combined with first spray application timing were applied as follows: 1) sprays from dormant
bud stage without sanitation; 2) sprays from early tight cluster without sanitation; 3) sprays
from pink bud stage without sanitation; 4) sprays from dormant bud stage with leaf removal;
5) sprays from early tight cluster stage with leaf removal; 6) sprays from pink bud stage with
leaf removal; 7) sprays from dormant bud stage with leaf removal combined with pruning; 8)
sprays from early tight cluster stage with leaf removal combined with pruning; 9) sprays from
pink bud stage with leaf removal combined with pruning. In treatments 4-9, fallen leaves were
collected according to Holb (2006). In treatments 7-9, the upper third of all shoots of a tree
was pruned according to Holb et al. (2005), In treatments 1, 4 and 7, the first spray was
applied at dormant bud stage; in treatments 2, 5 and 8, at early tight cluster stages; in
treatments 3, 6 and 9, at pink bud stages according to the ‘PAD’ action threshold criterion of
MacHardy et al. (1993). Each treatment was replicated three times and each replicate
consisted of a minimum of 330 trees (0.33 ha). Within each main plot, three final spray date
treatments were applied. Final spray date was 1) in mid-September, which followed the final
spray date in the general orchard spray schedule, 2) in mid-August following the ‘foliar scab’
action threshold criterion of Holb et al. (2003) and 3) in mid-July, which was based on the
fact that fruit susceptibility to scab greatly decreases after this date (Schwabe et al., 1984).
Each sub-plot consisted of a minimum of 110 trees.
In spring, the potential ascospore dose (PAD), was calculated in each sub-sub-plot
treatment according to Gadoury and MacHardy (1986). PAD was calculated as the average of
10 replicates for each year and treatment. Disease assessments were made on leaves and fruits
of cv. Jonathan at mid-July, mid-August, and mid-September. Observations were made in five
randomly selected trees. For leaf assessment, disease was assessed on 50 leaves of five
selected twigs. For fruit assessment, 25 typical fruits for the given phenological stage were
observed.
Disease incidences were analyzed by split-split-plot analysis of variance (Statistical
Analysis System v. 8.1; SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC). Then, the nine treatments were
partitioned into pre-planned contrasts including: i) 1, 2 and 3 vs. 4, 5 and 6; ii) 1, 2 and 3 vs.
7, 8 and 9; iii) 1, 4 and 7 vs. 2, 5 and 8; iv) 1, 4 and 7 vs. 3, 6 and 9; v) 1, vs. 2 and 3; vi) 4,
vs. 5 and 6; and vii) 7, vs. 8 and 9. Means were separated by Least Significance Difference
(LSD)-test using LSD0.05 values.
Results and Discussion
The Mills infection periods from mid-March until mid-October were severe on 19 and 16,
moderate on 8 and 6, and low on 7 and 7 occasions (in total 34 and 29) in 2005 and 2006,
respectively. Estimated mean PAD ranged between 5977.1 and 8345.2 ascospores m-2 in the
non-sanitized plots and between 235.7 and 579.0 ascospores m-2 in the sanitized plots.
Analysis of variance of final scab incidence indicated significant differences (P< 0.05)
between the two cultivars, among nine treatments, three final dates of spray applications, and
two years (data not shown). For leaf incidences, when the spray schedule finished in mid-July,
there were no significant differences among sanitation treatments combined with onset of first
280
spray, except one case in 2005 when non-sanitation treatments were compared between sprays
started at dormant bud stage and pink bud stage (Table 1). At final spray dates of mid-August
or mid-September, leaf scab incidence at harvest was significantly lower (P< 0.05) in all
treatments sprayed from dormant bud stage (1, 4, and 7) compared to all treatments sprayed
after pink bud stage (3, 6, and 9) (Table 1). For fruit incidences, at final spray date of midJuly, there were no significant differences in either sanitation treatments or various onsets of
first sprays (Table 2). At final spray dates of mid-August and mid-September, fruit scab
incidence was significantly higher (P< 0.05) in all non-sanitized treatments compared with
corresponding treatments of leaf removal combined with pruning, as well as in the sanitized
plots combined with spray programs started after pink bud stage (6 and 9) compared with
those started at dormant bud stage (4 and 7).
Table 1. Leaf scab incidence (%) of cultivar Jonathan at three final spray dates in nine
treatments of sanitation practices combined with onset of first spray applications in an organic
apple orchard at Eperjeske (Hungary, 2005-2006)
Treatmentsa/Final spray date
mid-July
2005
mid-August
mid-Sept.
mid-July
2006
mid-August
mid-Sept.
NonsanitDorm (1)
14.5
8.3
6.7
14.8
8.1
6.9
NonsanitCluster (2)
16.1
11.4
9.5
17.9
9.9
7.8
NonsanitPink (3)
20.6
14.7
13.5
19.4
12.7
11.4
RemovalDorm (4)
14.2
7.8
6.2
15.1
7.4
6.7
RemovalCluster (5)
14.3
10.4
9.0
14.9
9.2
7.2
RemovalPink (6)
17.1
13.3
12.5
16.9
11.4
10.6
Removal+PruningDorm (7)
13.8
6.8
5.2
15.8
7.5
6.7
Removal+PruningCluster (8)
13.1
9.8
8.6
16.1
8.2
7.1
Removal+PruningPink (9)
16.9
12.9
11.8
16.6
10.7
10.2
LSD0.05
5.93
5.06
4.16
6.09
3.22
2.62
Significance of contrastsb
0.435
0.567
0.802
0.391
0.545
Nons vs. Rem
0.212c
Nons vs. Rem+Prun
0.106
0.246
0.259
0.332
0.096
0.367
Dorm vs. Cluster
0.893
0.071
0.051
0.474
0.120
0.450
Dorm vs. Pink
0.058
0.602
0.001
<0.001
0.001
0.001
NonsDorm vs. NonsClus-Pink
0.144
0.049
0.038
0.011
0.026
0.037
RemDorm vs. RemClus-Pink
0.592
0.180
0.049
0.021
0.041
0.047
Rem+PrunDorm vs. Rem+PrunClus-Pink
0.592
0.695
0.042
0.006
0.044
0.049
a
NonsanitDorm, sprays from dormant bud stage without sanitation; NonsanitCluster, sprays from early tight cluster without sanitation; NonsanitPink, sprays
from pink bud stage without sanitation; RemovalDorm, sprays from dormant bud stage with leaf removal; RemovalCluster, sprays from early tight cluster stage
with leaf removal; RemovalPink, sprays from pink bud stage with leaf removal; Removal+PruningDorm, sprays from dormant bud stage with leaf removal
combined with pruning; Removal+PruningCluster, sprays from early tight cluster stage with leaf removal combined with pruning; Removal+PruningPink,
sprays from pink bud stage with leaf removal combined with pruning.
b
i) Nons vs. Rem = treatments 1, 2 and 3 vs. treatments 4, 5 and 6; ii) Nons vs. Rem+Prun = treatments 1, 2 and 3 vs. treatments 7, 8 and 9; iii) Dorm vs.
Cluster = treatments 1, 4 and 7 vs. treatments 2, 5 and 8; iv) Dorm vs. Pink = treatments 1, 4 and 7 vs. treatments 3, 6 and 9; v) NonsDorm vs. NonsClus-Pink =
treatment 1 vs. treatments 2 and 3; vi) RemDorm vs. RemClus-Pink = treatment 4 vs. treatments 5 and 6; and vii) Rem+PrunDorm vs. Rem+PrunClus-Pink =
treatment 7 vs. treatments 8 and 9.
c
Probability values from analyses of variance. Values in bold represent significance level at P < 0.05.
Table 2. Fruit scab incidence (%) of cultivar Jonathan at three final spray dates in nine
treatments of sanitation practices combined with onset of first spray applications in an organic
apple orchard at Eperjeske (Hungary, 2005-2006)
Treatmentsa/Final spray date
mid-July
2005
mid-August
mid-Sept.
NonsanitDorm (1)
12.4
9.9
9.4
NonsanitCluster (2)
13.3
10.3
9.9
NonsanitPink (3)
15.3
12.9
12.7
RemovalDorm (4)
11.8
8.5
7.7
RemovalCluster (5)
12.8
9.1
8.1
RemovalPink (6)
14.3
12.1
11.7
Removal+PruningDorm (7)
11.5
8.4
7.7
Removal+PruningCluster (8)
12.9
8.9
8.7
Removal+PruningPink (9)
13.7
12.0
11.8
LSD0.05
6.536
2.49
2.44
Significance of contrastsb
c
0.067
0.053
Nons vs. Rem
0.627
Nons vs. Rem+Prun
0.585
0.047
0.034
Dorm vs. Cluster
0.585
0.428
0.402
Dorm vs. Pink
0.190
0.004
0.002
NonsDorm vs. NonsClus-Pink
0.544
0.122
0.116
RemDorm vs. RemClus-Pink
0.505
0.049
0.046
Rem+PrunDorm vs. Rem+PrunClus-Pink
0.544
0.043
0.023
a
For details of treatments see Table 1, footnote a.
b
For details of the treatment comparisons using contrasts see Table 1, footnote b.
c
Probability values from analyses of variance. Values in bold represent significance level at P < 0.05.
281
mid-July
2006
mid-August
mid-Sept.
11.5
12.9
13.9
12.3
11.2
13.9
11.8
13.0
13.1
2.93
8.7
9.8
13.5
8.2
9.4
12.3
8.1
9.1
11.9
2.78
7.3
8.7
13.1
6.9
8.2
11.8
6.7
8.5
11.1
2.80
0.846
0.897
0.698
0.307
0.404
0.948
0.605
0.215
0.036
0.302
0.003
0.137
0.047
0.029
0.226
0.049
0.504
0.002
0.127
0.025
0.048
Potential ascospore dose was reduced below 600 ascospores m-2 orchard floor in all
sanitation treatments and a combination of leaf removal and winter pruning significantly
reduced scab incidence compared with non-sanitized plots. Under such conditions, the first
spray may be delayed until pink bud stage (MacHardy et al., 1993). Despite the low amount
of spring inoculum (PAD < 600 ascospores m-2 orchard floor), spray applications could only
be omitted before early tight cluster due to the low efficacy of scab fungicides in organic
apple production. This resulted in omitting two copper sprays at dormant bud and green tip
stages.
Final leaf scab incidence significantly increased when sprays were omitted after mid-July.
This may also result in a rapid increase of V. inaequalis ascospores on fallen leaves and of
conidia inside bud scales (MacHardy, 1996; Holb et al., 2005). Earlier completion of the
fungicide spray program was also previously shown as the cause of increased storage scab
(MacHardy, 1996). However, scab incidences were similar in spray programs completed in
mid-August or mid-September if a combination of leaf removal with pruning was applied.
This result indicated that one to three sprays may be omitted at the end of the growing season
if sanitation of scab inoculum sources is applied and cultivars are similarly susceptible to scab
as Jonathan. Previous studies, in well-managed integrated orchards, also recommended
omission of two to four sprays at the end of the season (Scheer, 1992; Holb et al., 2003);
however, these studies used highly scab susceptible cultivars without using sanitation
treatments to reduce scab inoculum.
In conclusion, our results indicated that sprays against scab could only be omitted under
Eastern European conditions before early tight cluster stage and after mid-August if removal
of fallen leaves combined with pruning was applied and final leaf scab incidence was <15 %.
References
Anon. 1998: Basic Standards for Organic Production and Processing. Tholey-Theley Press,
NY.
Gadoury, D.M. & MacHardy, W.E. 1986: Forecasting ascospore dose of Venturia inaequalis
in commercial apple orchards. Phytopathology 76: 112-118.
Holb, I.J. 2006: Effect of six sanitation treatments on leaf decomposition, ascospore
production of Venturia inaequalis and scab incidence in integrated and organic apple
orchards. Eur. J. Plant Pathol. 115: 293-307.
Holb, I.J., Heijne, B. & Jeger, M.J. 2003: Summer epidemics of apple scab: the relationship
between measurements and their implications for the development of predictive models
and threshold levels under different disease control regimes. J. Phytopathol. 151: 335343.
Holb, I.J., Heijne, B. & Jeger, M.J. 2005: The widespread occurrence of overwintered conidial
inoculum of Venturia inaequalis on shoots and buds in organic and integrated apple
orchards across the Netherlands. Eur. J. Plant Pathol. 111: 157-168.
MacHardy, W.E. 1996: Apple Scab, Biology, Epidemiology and Management. The American
Phytopathology Society, St. Paul, MN.
MacHardy, W.E., Gadoury, D.M. & Rosenberger, D.A., 1993: Delaying the onset of fungicide
programs for control of apple scab in orchards of low potential ascospore dose of
Venturia inaequalis. Plant Dis. 77: 372-375.
Scheer, H.A.Th., van der, 1992: Management of scab and powdery mildew on apple with
emphasis on threshold values for control of both diseases. Acta Phytopath. Entomol.
Hung. 27: 621-630.
Schwabe, W.F.S., Jones, A.L. & Jonker, J.P. 1984: Changes in the susceptibility of developing
apple fruit to Venturia inaequalis. Phytopathology 74: 118-121.
282
Searching inoculum sources of brown spot of pear
Jürgen Köhl, Lia Groenenboom-de Haas, Helen Goossen-van de Geijn, Richard van
Hoof, Pieter Kastelein, Cees Waalwijk
Plant Research International, Droevendaalsesteeg 1, 6700 AA Wageningen, The Netherlands
Abstract: Stemphylium vesicarium causes brown spot disease on pear and leaf blights in asparagus
and onion. Multiple fungicide applications for disease control are common in infested pear orchards.
The fungus is also able to colonise plant debris saprophytically. The objectives of our study were (1) to
determine the pathogenicity on pear of S. vesicarium isolates from different origins, (2) to develop a
molecular tool for discrimination between isolates pathogenic or non-pathogenic on pear and (3) to
quantify pear-pathogenic populations of S. vesicarium. S. vesicarium was isolated from infected pear
fruits and necrotic leaves of pear, orchard lawn grasses, onion and asparagus. The pathogenicity of 116
S. vesicarium isolates was assessed on detached pear fruits and on leaves. Disease incidence was
similar for isolates from fruits or leaves of pear or from necrotic orchards lawn grasses. Isolates from
asparagus or onion caused no symptoms on pear. AFLP patterns of isolates showed clustering of
isolates originating from pear orchards (either from diseased fruits or from orchard lawns), whereas
onion and asparagus isolates clusters into separate groups. AFLP bands unique for pear-pathogenic S.
vesicarium isolates were sequenced and a quantitative detection was developed based on one of these
unique AFLP bands. The specific quantification of pear-pathogenic populations of S. vesicarium by
TaqMan-PCR is currently used in studies on population dynamics in orchards. Results will be used for
the development of efficient sanitation measures which will reduce the risks of brown spot epidemics.
Stemphylium vesicarium, Pathogenicity, Detection
283
The initiative “Monitoring of Venturia inaequalis virulences”
Andrea Patocchi
Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil ACW, Schloss, P.O. Box 185, 8820 Wädenswil, Switzerland
Since the breakdown of the Vf gene in the central-north part of Europe (Parisi et al. 2004)
breeders have been looking for new resistance sources to introduce in their breeding
programs. Alternative major genes to Vf are available (e.g. Va, Vb, Vbj, Vm, Vr,Vh2, Vh4, Vd,
Vg, Vr2,…) but, with few exceptions (e.g. Vm in the cultivars ‘Murray’ and ‘Rouville’, Crosby
et al., 1992; Vh4 in the cultivar ‘Regia’, Boudichevskaia et al., 2006), they are not exploited
as sources of resistance. For nearly all these R-genes molecular markers suitable for marker
assisted selection (MAS) are available (reviewed in Gessler et al., 2006) and a few advanced
selections that could be readily used in breeding programs are also available (M. Kellerhals
ACW pers. communication).
One of the strategies that can be used to develop apple cultivars with durable apple scab
resistance is the pyramiding of major genes. But which genes are the best suited to produce
such new cultivars? The most interesting genes are those which have not been overcome by
the pathogen. Nevertheless, genes that have been overcome, but with a limited spread of
virulent races, may be used in breeding. To find information on the emergence and geographic
distribution of isolates virulent to specific resistance genes is difficult and time consuming.
Moreover most of the reports found are not up-dated and the correctness of the data are
difficult to verify. In addition comparison of the results from different sources is also difficult
as often different differential hosts have been used in different studies. To improve this
situation the initiative “monitoring of V.inaequalis virulences” has been proposed. The project
foresees: 1) the establishment of a large network of orchards of selected differential hosts; 2)
the yearly scoring of apple scab incidence by the partners participating in the network; 3) the
submission of the data to the curator of the project; and 4) regular publication of collected
data through the homepage of the project.
In the first phase of the project 16 differential hosts possibly carrying a single known
major resistance gene have been selected (Table 1). To coordinate the studies of the V.
inaequalis-Malus pathosystem in the field with those in the laboratory, as far as plant material
was available, the same genotypes proposed by Bus et al. (2009) were chosen. All the plant
material has been centralized at Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil and molecularly tested. The
tests confirmed that all the plant material is “true to type”. Multiplication of the plant material
is ongoing.
Partners currently interested in planting a set of differential hosts are in Germany, Italy,
Belgium, Czech Republic, Austria, Poland, Chile, Canada and New Zealand. However
additional partners are needed. Interested partners are invited to announce their expression of
interest through the homepage of the project (www.vinquest.ch) where details as well as the
status of the project can also be found. Partners participating in the network should note that
this is a long term project and therefore the differential orchards should be maintained as long
as possible. On the other hand the time that yearly has to be dedicated to the project is quite
limited. In fact it will be requested that the partners assess incidence and severity of scab of
each plant once a year at the end of the primary season. Currently a differential host orchard is
composed of 80 plants (16 differential hosts, 5 replications each). After the assessment, the
data will be submitted to the curator of the project by e-mail. First appearance of virulent
isolates will be carefully verified (pictures, verification of the “true to typness” of the infected
284
tree and preparation of single spore cultures). Upon validation of the data, the curator will
summarize the collected information and will publish it through the homepage of the
initiative. The proposed procedure will provide breeders, advisors, farmers and researchers
with up-dated, comparable and validated information on the current geographic distribution of
apple scab virulences.
Table 1: New set of differential hosts (adapted from Bus et al. 2008)
1
2
Host
h0
h1
h2
h3
h4
h5
h6
h7
h8
h9
h10
h11
h12
h13
h14
h15
Accession
‘Gala’
‘Golden Delicious‘
TSR34T15
Q71 (‘Geneva’ x ‘Braeburn)’
TSR33T239
9-AR2T196
‘Priscilla’
M. floribunda 8212
B45 (‘Pacific Beauty’ x M. sieversii GMAL4302-X8)
J34 ‘Gala’ x ‘Dolgo’
A 723-6 (‘Worcester Pearmain’ x PI172623)
M. baccata jackii
Hansen’s baccata #2
‘Durello di Forlì’
‘Dülmener Rosenapfel’
GMAL 2473
R-gene(s) (known)
none known
Vg alias Rvi11
Vh2 alias Rvi2
Vh3.1 alias Rvi3
Vh4 alias Rvi4
Vm alias Rvi5
Vf alias Rvi6
Vf and Vfh alias Rvi6 and 7
Vh8 alias Rvi8
Vdg alias Rvi9
Va alias Rvi10
Vbj alias Rvi11
Vbalias Rvi12
Vd alias Rvi13
Rvi14
Vr2 alias Rvi15
Nomenclature according to Bus et al. 2009.
Currently F1 of M. floribunda 821 carrying only Vfh (alias Rvi7) is not available, as h7 has been temporarily
choose M. floribunda 821.
References
Boudichevskaia, A., Flachowsky, H., Peil, A., Fischer, C., Dunemann F. 2006: Development
of a multiallelic SCAR marker for the scab resistance gene Vr1/ Vh4/ Vx from R127407A apple and its utility for molecular breeding. TGG 2: 186-195.
Bus, V., Rikkerink, E., Aldwinckle, H.S., Caffier, V., Durel, C.-E., Gardiner, S., Gessler, C.,
Groenwold, R., Laurens, F., Le Cam, B., Luby, J. , MacHardy, W., Meulenbroek, B.,
Kellerhals, M., Parisi, L., Patocchi, A., Plummer, K., Schouten, H.J., Tartarini, S., van de
Weg, E. 2009: A proposal for the nomenclature of Venturia inaequalis races. Acta Hort.
814: 739-746.
Crosby, J.A., Janick, J., Pecknold, P.C., Korban, S.S., O.Conner, P.A., Ries, S.M., Goffreda,
J., Voordeckers, A. 1992: Breeding apples for scab resistance: 1945.1990. Fruit Var. J. 46:
145.166.
Gessler, C., Patocchi, A., Sansavini, S., Tartarini, S., Gianfranceschi, L. 2006: Venturia
inaequalis resistance in apple. Crit Rev Plant Sci. 25: 473 - 503.
Parisi, L., Fouillet, V., Schouten, H.J., Groenwold, R., Laurens, F., Didelot, F., Evans, K.,
Fischer, C., Gennari, F., Kemp, H., Lateur, M., Patocchi, A., Thissen, J., Tsipouridis, C.
2004: Variability of the pathogenicity of Venturia inaequalis in Europe. Acta Hort. 663:
107-114.
285
Late winter climatic conditions influence ascospore production and
release in Venturia inaequalis.
Vincent Philion1, Arne Stensvand2, Håvard Eikemo2, David M. Gadoury3
1 Laboratoire de production fruitière intégrée de l’IRDA, Mont-Saint-Bruno, Québec ; 2
Bioforsk Norwegian Inst of Agric & Env Res, Aas 1432, Norway
Abstract: Most fungicide applications targeting apple scab aim to control primary infections caused
by ascospores and spraying is thereby linked to ascospore availability. We investigated the effect of
pre bud break climatic conditions on seasonal patterns of ascospore release. Apple leaves bearing
pseudothecia of Venturia inaequalis were overwintered at orchard sites in 8 countries for up to 3 years.
Leaf samples were collected 2 to 5 weeks before bud break and again at bud break, air dried, and sent
via airmail to Norway. The samples were stored at -18 ºC upon arrival until tested. Disks cut from each
replicate leaf sample were incubated moist at 20 ºC to allow ascospore maturation but prevent
discharge. Matured ascospores were induced to discharge twice a week and enumerated until the
supply was exhausted. The proportion of ascospores ejected was fitted against degree-day
accumulation using logistic regression. The regression intercept (onset maturation), slope (maturation
rate), as well as the absolute number of spores counted differed significantly (P < 0.001, P = 0.05, P <
0.001 respectively) among sites and sampling dates. There was a significant interaction between site
and sampling date, indicating that climatic conditions prior to bud break differentially impacted the
subsequent ascospore availability. Observed differences could perhaps be used to further refine
previously described models of ascospore maturity.
Apple scab, Maturation model, Spray timing
286
Efficacy of fungicides mixtures to avoid apple scab fungus resistance
in integrated apple orchards
Regina Rancane, Maija Eihe
Latvian Plant Protection Research Centre, Lielvardes iela 36/38, Riga, Latvia
Abstract: IOBC guidelines for integrated fruit production prescribe use of forecasting systems in
direct plant protection. In Latvia, LPPRC, model RIMpro for apple scab Venturia inaequalis control
was tested from 2003. Following to FRAC guidelines to reduce the risk of fungus resistance
developing, from 2007 efficacy of fungicides mixtures (Chorus, a.i. cyprodinil + Dithane NT, a.i.
mancozeb; Effector, a.i. dithianon + Candit, a.i kresoxim-methyl) and alternately curative or
strobilurine – protective fungicides use was tested. In all cases the first protective application before
scab ascospores discharge was carried out with Cu product Champion 50. In case of emergency
Effector was used during the secondary scab infection period. Fungicides registered in Latvia for apple
scab control were effective with a mixture of protective/curative or strobilurine products being
alternately used, the exception being the strobilurine Candit (Qo inhibitor) which was used separately,
until fungal resistance appeared in the 3rd season of Candit use. The efficacy of Candit/Effector
mixture was on a level with other treatments and that of the curative product Chorus wasn’t lost after 6
seasons of use when applied no more than 3 times per season. Nevertheless, further strategy of
resistance preclusion has to be considered and what request minimal at-risk products to use separately.
In all cases fungicides applications, even Chorus/Dithane mixture, were more effective if used before
infection and as weather forecasting was not always the number of necessary applications had to
increase. Under Latvia conditions frequently there are three severe scab infection periods during the
total primary infection period, subsequently 3 or 4 fungicides applications being necessary in addition
to the first Champion treatment.
Apple scab, Resistance, Fungicides mixtures, Alternately use
287
Use of the A-scab model for rational control of apple scab
Simona Giosuè1, Riccardo Bugiani2, Tito Caffi3, Gian Franco Pradolesi4, Massimiliano
Melandri4, Tullio Bevilacqua5 , Vittorio Rossi3*
1
Horta Srl, Spin off company of Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Via Emilia Parmense
84, I-29100, Piacenza; 2Servizio Fitosanitario, Regione Emilia-Romagna,Via di Saliceto 81,
I-40128, Bologna; 3Istituto di Entomologia e Patologia vegetale, Università Cattolica del
Sacro Cuore, Via Emilia Parmense 84, I-29100, Piacenza; 4Agronomica R&S, Terremerse
Soc. Coop., Via Cà del Vento 21, I-48012 Bagnacavallo, Ravenna,; 5CAACAF-UIMEC Via
Andrea Costa 87, I-40062, Molinella, Bologna. *vittorio.rossi@unicatt.it
Abstract: A-scab is a dynamic model for Venturia inaequalis primary infections. It simulates
ascospore maturation, ejection, deposition, and infection during the season based on hourly data of air
temperature, rainfall, relative humidity, and wetness duration. A-scab produces a risk index for each
infection period and predicts the time of disease onset. Since the validation works showed that the
model produces accurate and robust predictions, a 3-year (2006 to 2008) experiment was carried out in
order to determine the possibility of using A-scab for scheduling fungicide sprays. Trials were
performed in northern Italy (at Ravenna and Bologna) by comparing: i) untreated control, ii) farming
practice, iii) A-scab recommendations. The disease incidence on both leaves and fruits in the plots
sprayed according to A-scab predictions did not change significantly relative to the farm practice. The
use of A-scab led to a general reduction in the number of fungicide applications..
Keywords: disease modelling, Venturia inaequalis, field trials, apple scab control, fungicide
reduction
Introduction
Apple scab, caused by Venturia inaequalis (Cooke) Wint., is the most important fungal
disease of apple worldwide. It causes repeated infections on leaves and fruits during the
season and it can cause severe yield losses when fungicides are not applied efficiently.
Strategies for applying fungicides have changed greatly in recent decades, from spraying to a
calendar to having a rational schedule based on actual infection risk. Mathematical models
represent a valuable tool for estimating infection risk based on meteorological conditions and
host information.
A-scab is a dynamic simulation model including all the stages of the infection cycle
based on the principles of ‘systems analysis’ (Leffelaar, 1993). It simulates development of
pseudothecia, ascospore maturation, discharge, deposition, and infection during the season
based on hourly data of air temperature, rainfall, relative humidity, and leaf wetness. A-scab
produces a risk index for each infection period and predicts the probable periods of symptoms
appearance (Rossi et al., 2007). In a previous work, A-scab was validated under different
epidemiological conditions with satisfactory results: neither corrections nor calibrations were
necessary to adapt the model to different apple-growing areas (Rossi et al., 2007).
To evaluate model performances for disease control in practice, field trials were planned
in two locations in Emilia-Romagna (North Italy) for three years (2006 to 2008), for
comparing treatments scheduled according to the farming practice, A-scab suggestions, and
an untreated control. In this paper, these field experiments and results are described and
288
discussed.
Materials and Methods
The A-scab model
Model parts (Giosuè et al., 2000; Rossi et al., 2000, 2001, 2003 a and b, 2006 a and b, 2007)
and the general structure with algorithms were described in details in Rossi et al. (2007). The
model follows all the stages of the infection cycle and links the progression from one stage to
another to the influential meteorological conditions. The model starts from overwintering
pseudothecia and accounts for ascospore maturation and dispersal during the primary
inoculum season. A part of these ascospores is deposited on susceptible apple leaves and
cause infection. Finally, symptoms become visible at the end of the incubation period (Fig. 1).
overwintering
pseudothecia
discharge
events
mature
ascospores
air-borne
ascospores
ascospores deposited
on apple leaves
susceptible
host tissues
ascospores
causing infection
infection severity
incubation
scab symptoms
Figure 1 - Conceptual structure of the A-scab model predicting primary infections of Venturia
inaequalis; the infection severity is expressed, for each infection period during the primary
inoculum season, by an index called Riskinf.
The model produces a daily (i) risk index cumulated over each infection period,
n
calculated as: Risk inf = ∑ SRAdis ⋅ IEinf ⋅ HOSTinf ⋅100
i =1
where: SRAdis is the ascospore dose ejected during any discharge event; IEinf is the
proportion of ascospores that cause infection during the infection period; HOSTinf is an index
accounting for host susceptibility.
The model was validated in several Italian apple growing areas by comparing actual data
(ascospore releases, disease onset, disease incidence and severity) to model outputs; it never
requested calibrations or modifications to be adapted to the different areas (Rossi et al., 2007).
Field trials
Field trials were planned to test the possibility of using A-scab for scheduling fungicide
applications compared to the farming practice and an untreated control.
289
Trials were performed at two locations in the districts of Bologna and Ravenna (EmiliaRomagna region), in the period 2006 to 2008. The trials were performed on ‘Imperatore’ and
‘Pink lady’ trees, 14 and 5-year old, at the two locations, respectively. Orchards were
managed according to the common practice, with exception of the fungicide sprays; two
treatments with copper were applied on the entire orchard at bud break (4.5 kg/ha) and green
tip (3 kg/ha) to prevent Nectria cankers. The experimental design was a randomized complete
block design with three replicated plots (7 or 8 plants per plot) for the thesis A-scab and
untreated control; the farming practice was applied on the remaining orchard surface.
Hourly meteorological data of air temperature (°C), relative humidity (%), rainfall (mm),
and leaf wetness (yes or no) were acquired by the Regional Meteorological Service in the
proximity of the experimental orchards. The model was operated each day using the actual
weather data until the current day and weather forecasts for the following three days.
Fungicides against scab were applied according to model outputs: when the Riskinf
calculated using weather forecasts was ≥0.2, a treatment was applied using a protectant or a
curative fungicide, depending on the time of application in relation to the time of the
predicted infection; when the Riskinf calculated using actual data was ≥0.4 an additional
curative treatment was applied as soon as possible, if a protectant fungicide has been applied
before. The protectant fungicides used were Dithianon (1 kg/ha) until blooming and
Tryfloxistrobin (0.22 kg/ha) after this growth stage; the curative fungicide was
Difenoconazole (0.15 kg/ha) + Dithianon (1 kg/ha). In the untreated plots no fungicides
against scab were applied for the entire primary season.
Disease incidence was assessed on leaves and fruits at the end of the primary inoculum
season. These data were angular transformed and analysed using the ANOVA and the Tukey’s
test at α=0.05 to test significant differences among averages. Data concerning the farming
practice were not statistically analysed.
Results and discussion
Disease incidence varied strongly in the two locations and from one year to another (Fig. 2).
Scab did not appear at Bologna in 2007 and reached about 60% of affected fruits in the
untreated control of Bologna in 2008.
The incidence of affected leaves and fruits was always significantly lower in the plots
treated according to A-scab with respect to the untreated control and similar to that obtained
using the farming practice (Fig. 2). At Bologna in 2006, the percentage of affected leaves was
16% on the control and it was significantly reduced to 3.8% using A-scab recommendations
(3 fungicide applications), data on the farming practice were not available as well as the
correspondent number of treatments. Fifty-five percent of scabbed fruits was observed on the
untreated control and 6% in the A-scab plots. Similar results were obtained at Ravenna where
A-scab suggested 6 treatments which reduced significantly disease incidence with respect to
the untreated control on both leaves and fruits (Fig.2); using the farming practice, 1% and 4%
of scabbed leaves and fruits was observed, respectively, but the number of applications was
not registered.
290
Bologna 2006
60
a
40
Bologna 2008
a
Leaves
Fruits
50
Incidence (%)
Bologna 2007
no scab
a
30
20
3
a
na
1
8
5
b
b b
10
10
b
0
Incidence (%)
50
Ravenna 2007
Ravenna 2006
60
Ravenna 2008
a
a
40
a
30
6
na
4
a
20
b
10
Untreated
A-scab
Farming
practice
Untreated
a
10
a
b
b
0
4
13
b
A-scab
b
b
Farming
practice
Untreated
A-scab
Farming
practice
Figure 2 – Incidence of leaves and fruits affected by scab at Bologna and Ravenna in 2006 to
2008 in plots not sprayed against scab, treated according to the A-scab model, and following
the farming practice. Bars with different letters are significantly different at P=0.05 (Tukey’s
Test). Numbers in italics indicate the number of fungicide treatments in the different spray
programs, na means ‘data not available’.
At Bologna in 2007 the disease did not appear: A-scab suggested only one spray while
the farmer performed 8 treatments. At Ravenna the reduction with respect to the control was
significant: 37% of scabbed fruits against 19% using A-scab and 18% in the farming practice,
in this case both methods suggested 4 treatments.
In 2008, weather conditions were more favourable to disease development at Bologna
(58 and 32% of affected fruits and leaves, respectively, on the untreated control) than at
Ravenna (8 and 26% of affected fruits and leaves, respectively, on the untreated control). The
use of A-scab reduced disease incidence significantly in both orchards (Fig. 2) reaching
disease levels similar to those of the farming practice (Fig. 2); the number of treatments was
halved at Bologna (5 and 10 with A-scab and the farming practice, respectively) while at
Ravenna it was reduced by about 25% (10 against 13 with A-scab and the farming practice,
respectively).
In conclusion, the timing of fungicide applications following A-scab, which is able
determine accurately when weather and host conditions are favourable for infection, made it
possible to save about 50% of fungicide sprays with respect to the farming practice (5 against
about 9 on average per primary inoculum season) maintaining the incidence of affected leaves
and fruits at comparable levels.
References
Giosuè, S., Rossi, V., Ponti, I. & Bugiani, R. 2000: Estimating the dynamics of air-borne
ascospores of Venturia inaequalis. EPPO Bull. 30: 137-142.
291
Leffelaar, P.A. 1993: On Systems Analysis and Simulation of Ecological Processes. Kluwer,
London (GB).
Rossi, V., Ponti, I., Marinelli, M., Giosuè, S. & Bugiani R. 2000: A new model estimating the
seasonal pattern of air-borne ascospores of Venturia inaequalis in relation to weather
conditions. J. Plant Pathol. 82: 111-118.
Rossi, V., Ponti, I., Marinelli, M., Giosuè, S. & Bugiani R. 2001: Environmental factors
influencing the dispersal of Venturia inaequalis ascospores in the orchard air. J.
Phytopathol. 149: 11-19.
Rossi, V., Giosuè, S. & Bugiani R. 2003a: Influence of air temperature on the release of
ascospores of Venturia inaequalis. J. Phytopathol. 151: 50-58.
Rossi, V., Giosuè, S. & Bugiani R. 2003b: A model simulating deposition of Venturia
inaequalis ascospores on apple trees. EPPO Bull. 33: 407-414.
Rossi, V., Giosuè, S. & Bugiani R. 2006a: Factors influencing deposition of Venturia
inaequalis ascospores on apple trees. IOBC WPRS Bull. 29: 53-58
Rossi, V., Giosuè, S. & Bugiani R. 2006b: Equations for the distribution of Venturia
inaequalis ascospores versus time during infection periods. IOBC WPRS Bull. 29: 231242.
Rossi, V., Giosuè, S. & Bugiani R. 2007: A-scab (Apple-scab), a simulation model for
estimating risk of Venturia inaequalis primary infections. EPPO Bull. 37: 300-308.
292
Monitoring of Venturia inaequalis strains sensitive to strobilurine
fungicides and occurrence of apple scab on resistant cultivars in the
Czech Republic
Radek Vávra1, Jana Kloutvorová1, Stanislav Boček2, Antonín Svoboda1
1 Research and Breeding Institute of Pomology Holovousy Ltd., Holovousy 1, 508 01 Hořice,
Czech Republic, vavra.vsuo@seznam.cz
2 Mendel University of Agriculture and Forestry in Brno, Zemědělská 1, 613 00 Brno, Czech
Republic
Abstract: Occurrence of apple scab (Venturia inaequalis) on resistant cultivars was investigated in the
Czech Republic however symptoms have never been observed up to the year 2006. Apple scab is
currently recorded in six isolated plantings of resistant cultivars in the territory of the Czech Republic.
Apple scab was founded only on Vf resistant cultivars (Rubinola, Topaz, Rajka, Otava, Melodie etc.)
in all cases indicating that those isolates can be classified as the race 6 or 7. Monosporic isolates of V.
inaequalis were prepared for next testing using plant indicators and distinction using PCR methods.
At the same time, sensitivity of V. inaequalis to strobilurine fungicides was tested in the orchards,
where the chemical treatment against apple scab was ineffective. Leaf samples were collected from 22
commercial orchards, one sample was taken from apple tree solitary growing in natural conditions and
one sample was taken in experimental orchard. A germination of spores in aqueous fungicide solutions
was assessed. A decrease of strobilurine sensitivity of V. inaequalis was observed in several localities.
Key words: VF gene, apple scab, races, strains, Venturia inaequalis
Introduction
Apple scab caused by Venturia inaequalis (Cooke)Wint. is one of the most important diseases
of apples. Scab is controlled mainly by applying chemical preparations at appropriate
intervals during growing season. Plant breeding programs in numerous countries have
atempted to develop resistant varieties to eliminate the most important disease in apple
orchards caused by V. inaequalis. Resistance to apple scab originating from Malus floribunda
clone 821 is the most widely form of resistance used in apple breeding programs. According
to ability to overcome resistance sources used by plant breeders seven races were defined.
Two races virulent to the most-used type of resistance given by Vf gene were founded up
recent time - race 6 in Germany in 1993 (Parisi, 1993) and race 7 in England in 1994
(Roberts, 1994). Vf gene was broken in seven locations within Czech Republic up to the year
2008.
Next attempts is creation the functional growing system in IPM and organic regimes. This
system will play not only environmental in a landscape view but it should be acceptable from
an economic view. The orchard is understood as an agroecosystem with a number of relations
among host plants, pests and predators and where not only direct control treatments are
important. The strengthening of these relations coupled with the use of environment friendly
control methods will result in a higher stability of orchard ecosystem with a lower use of a
"hard" chemicals. As a result of all these attributes the production of the safe and top-quality
fruit production is excepted. V. inaequalis has developed resistance to some key fungicides
including benomyl, dodine, flusilazole and strobilurines (Szkolnik and Gilpatrick, 1969;
Smith et al., 1991; Olaya and Köller, 1999; Palm et al., 2004). Rate of pathogen sensitivity to
fungicides differs in orchards according to treatment regimes in previous years. For a
sustainable fungicide efficacy management, knowledge about changes in the sensitivity of the
293
target pathogen populations is necessary. In our study, preliminary monitoring of sensitivity of
V. inaequalis populations to strobilurine fungicides was made in orchards where chemical
control was not effective. Evaluation of conidia germination in drops of spray liquids of
fungicide Discus was used in our tests.
Material and methods
A) Fungicide sensitivity tests
Sampling
Leaf samples with apple scab lesions were collected from 22 commercial orchards in different
regions of the Czech Republic in years 2007 and 2008. A sensitive population of V. inaequalis
was taken from apple tree solitary growing in natural conditions. This population had never
been exposed to any fungicides. One sample was taken in experimental orchard of RBIP
Holovousy. Samples were kept in refrigerator and processed within 5 days of collection.
Sensitivity tests
The commercial strobilurine fungicide Discus® (kresoxim-methyl; BASF) was used in these
laboratory tests. Eighty microlitres of aqueous fungicide solution (concentration – 0.02%)
were pipetted into depressions on microscope slides. In one variant, only drinking water
without fungicide was used. Conidia of V. inaequalis were transferred from infected leaves
into drops on slides and incubated at 22± 2 °C for 48 h. After that, the number of germinated
spores was counted under a microscope (minimum 500 spores per variant) and the percentage
of germination was calculated.
B) Tests of apple scab virulency on resistant cultivars
Sampling
Samples of leaves were collected from seven ochards with symptoms on resistant cultivars for
determination of pathogenicity in greenhouse experiments and distinction by PCR methods.
Pathogenicity testsEvaluation of patogenicity of apple scab on resistant cultivars was
iniciated after first occurrence of symptoms in the year 2006. Indicating cultivars were grafted
into orchards in main apple growing regions for analyzes of the resistance. The host cultivars
range included Gala (susceptible control), Golden Deliciuos (gene Vg), Priscilla, Prima (gene
Vf), Florina (genes Vg, Vf). Others cultivars and species were used for indicating apple scab
on other forms of resistance (R 12740-7A, OR 45T132, 9AR2T128), (Bénaouf, 1997), (Table
1). Samples of leaves were collected from ochards with symptoms on resistant cultivars for
determination of pathogenicity in greenhouse experiments and distinction by PCR methods.
V. inaequalis on culture plates is grown at this time, so results are not available yet.
Results and discussion
Obtained results of fungicide sensitivity tests are presented in graphs 1-3. Monitoring of
commercial orchards revealed that strobilurine sensitivities of V. inaequalis were not uniform
throughout plantings. The highest spore germination was recorded in case of population from
experimental orchard of RBIP Holovousy. Percentage of germination in drops of spray liquid
with kresoxim-methyl was almost as high as percentage of germination in drops of water
without fungicide. This result was expected, because the resistant population of V. inaequalis
was established purposely in this orchard in previous years. In the contrary, the germination of
294
wild-type population (sample “Lázně Bělohrad”) was almost suppressed in drops with
kresoxim-methyl. The similar results were achieved in case of several commercial orchards.
In these localities, occurrence of apple scab might be caused either by bad treatment term or
way of fungicide application. Eventually, decrease of sensitivity to other fungicides (for
example to DMI fungicides) can not be excluded in these orchards. High percentage of
conidia germination (higher than 50% of germination in water) was recorded in case of five
populations originated from different commercial orchards. This finding indicates that use of
the strobilurine fungicides during following season will led to significant decrease of fruit
quality and strobilurines should be excluded from control in these orchards.
First symptoms on resistant cultivars were recorded in the year 2006 in four locations –
Žernov in Eastern Bohemia, Břasy and Spálené Poříčí in western Bohemia and Buková Lhota
in central Bohemia. Two years later in 2008 were recorded symptoms in other three locations
– Rohozec in southern Moravia, Branice in southern Bohemia and Zvěstov in central
Bohemia. Symptomps of apple scab was founded only on Vf resistant cultivars (Rubinola,
Topaz, Rajka, Otava, Melodie etc.) Overcoming of other forms of resistance was not
recorded. Consequently those isolates can be classified as the race 6 or 7. Monosporic isolates
of V. inaequalis were prepared for distinction of relationship using molecular methods.
Izolations of DNA are in the process.
Graphs 1 – 3: Fungicide sensitivity tests
295
Table 1: Host cultivars and genotypes
296
Cultivar (clone)
Gala
Golden Delicious
Priscilla
Prima
Florina
R12 740-7A
OR45T132
9AR2T128
Behavior
Susceptible
Susceptible
Resistant
Resistant
Resistant
Resistant
Resistant
Resistant
Resistance gene
None
Vg
Vf
Vf
Vf,Vg
Vr
Vm
Vm
Map 1:Locations with occurrence of apple scab on scab resistant cultivars
A – Buková Lhota, B – Zvěstov, C – Branice, D – Břasy , E – Spálené Poříčí,
F - Žernov, G – Střížovice, H – Mnichovo Hradiště, I – Rohozec
F
HG
D
E
A
B
I
C
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the Ministry of Agriculture – project QH 71172
References
Bénaouf, G., and Parisi, L. 1997. Pathogenicity of Venturia inaequalis strains from Malus
floribunda 821: Comparison with race 6 on apple clones. Pages 8-11 in Integrated control
of Pome Fruits Diseases, Vol. XX(9). Dijon, France.
Olaya, G. and Köller, W. 1999. Baseline sensitivities of Venturia inaequalis populations to
the strobilurine fungicide kresoxim-methyl. Plant Dis. 83: 274-278.
Palm, G., Kuck, K-H., Mehl, A., Marr, J. 2004. Aktueller stand der strobilurin-apfelschorfresistenz an der niederelbe. Mitt. OVR 59: 291 – 295.
Parisi, L., Lespinasse, Y., Guillaumes, J., and Krüger, J. 1993. A new race of Venturia
inaequalis virulent to apples with resistance due to the Vf gene. Phytopathology 83:
533-537. Roberts, A.L., and Crute, I., R. 1994. Apple scab resistance from Malus
floribunda 821 (Vf) is rendered ineffective by isolates of Venturia inaequalis from Malus
floribunda . Norw.J.Agric.Sci. 17:403-406.
Szkolnik, M., Gilpatrick, J.D. 1969. Apparent resistance of Venturia inaequalis to dodine in
New York apple orchards. Plant Dis. Rep., 53 : 861-864
Smith, F.D., Parker, D.M., Köller, W. 1991. Sensitivity distribution of Venturia inaequalis to
297
the sterol demethylation inhibitor flusilazole: Baseline sensitivity and implications for
resistance monitoring. Phytopathology, 81, 392-396.
298
Apple Proliferation Phytoplasma in South Tyrol – An Integrated
Approach
Markus Prantl, Robert Wiedmer, Josef Österreicher, Michael Unterthurner
South Tyrolean Extension Service for Fruit- and Wine-Growing, I 39011 Lana, A. Hoferstraße
9/1, Italy
Abstract: In 2000 and 2001 a severe occurrence of apple proliferation phytoplasma was noticed for
the first time in apple orchards in South Tyrol (Italy). At the same time, in 2000 an increased
occurrence of Cacopsylla melanoneura and in 2004 for the first time also a second vector, Cacopsylla
picta, were detected in the orchards. The, in some cases, rather heavy economic losses caused by these
attacks induced all appropriate institutions to look for solutions together with the producers. The
phytoplasma had to be controlled in compliance with the principles of integrated fruit production. The
complete elimination of all infected trees including the roots in combination with chemical control of
the two vectors proved successful and resulted in a considerable reduction in infections in the past two
years.
Keywords: apple proliferation, Cacopsylla melanoneura, Cacopsylla picta
Introduction
South Tyrol is with 18,500 ha the greatest contiguous apple growing area in Europe. This
area has more than 60 million apple trees. Since 2000 one of the major problems has been the
apple proliferation phytoplasma. Phytoplasmas are important phloem-limited, insecttransmitted pathogenic agents. The most important insect vectors transmitting this
phytoplasma are the two psyllids Cacopsylla picta and Cacopsylla melanoneura. C.
melanoneura is widespread in the orchards throughout the whole region and is found
everywhere on apple trees in South Tyrol. It is possible to discover it on the apple trees From
the end of January onwards. The behaviour of the second insect vector C. picta is different. It
was found in South Tyrol for the first time in 2004. This insect infests the orchard during the
blossom period and leaves the trees later in the summer.
The phytoplasma can also be transmitted from one infected tree to another through root
contact and it is also possible to receive infected trees from the nurseries; in 2000 and 2001 a
severe occurrence of infected trees in the “Burggrafenamt”, in the Vinschgau Valley and in the
orchards on the hillsides in the rest of the region was noticed.
The typical and most important symptoms an infected tree shows can be witches’ broom,
red coloured leaves on the whole tree, smaller and less coloured fruits with a poor taste and an
earlier start in the vegetation period than a healthy tree.
Material and methods
The South Tyrolean Extension Service for Fruit- and Wine-Growing has invested a lot of time
in discovering the intensity of the disease in the different parts of the region. One important
evaluation method is counting the symptomatic trees (trees with one or more symptoms) in a
representative number of apple orchards. This has been done every year since 2005. The
orchards in this evaluation were divided into young (second leaf) and older orchards. In this
299
way it was possible to obtain a large number of data and it was easier to observe the course of
the disease in the selected orchards over the years. In particular, the trees in the second leaf
are good indicators for the control strategy against the vectors, because symptomatic trees
must have been infected the year before. In addition we know that nearly all the trees that
were infected with the phytoplasma in the first leaf show symptoms in the second leaf.
The second evaluation technique was monitoring the two insect vectors C. picta and C.
melanoneura. For this reason in spring a large number of insects were collected across the
whole region, to establish the population density of the pests and their life cycles in the
orchards.
Control of the apple proliferation phytoplasma
So far there are no known direct control measures against Candidatus phytoplasma mali. The
first and most important approach to controlling the apple proliferation phytoplasma is to
eliminate the infected trees from the orchards. It is not enough to remove just the part of the
tree above the ground, but also the infected roots have to be eliminated, since the pathogen
can also be transmitted when the roots of two trees grow together. An infected tree produces
small sized and poorly coloured fruits with a poor internal quality and can serve as a source of
inoculum to infect other trees in the orchard. Eradication of all infected trees is a prerequisite
for a successful disease control.
The second approach is trying to eliminate the two insect vectors. This must be done by
using insecticides. The recommended spraying period against C. melanoneura is at budbreak
of the apple trees, and a pyrethroid (active agent etophenprox) was used. In order to control
the second psyllid C. picta two other sprays are necessary: one before and one immediately
after bloom. In this case the recommended active agent is chlorpyrifos. These two psyllids do
not cause direct damage to the trees, but they transmit the phytoplasma, so the tolerance level
is zero.
Results
From 2005 to 2008 the technical staff of the South Tyrolean Extension Service for Fruit- and
Wine-Growing evaluated every year the symptomatic apple trees in more than 150 orchards in
the second leaf. In Table 1 the data from the Gala orchards in the second leaf are shown.
Table 1: Second Leaf Gala Orchards with AP-symptoms (*with 3,000 trees/hectare 0.4%
infestation correspond to 12 trees)
District
Burggrafenamt (BGA)
Vinschgau Valley (VI)
Etsch Valley (ET)
Überetsch (ÜE)
Unterland (UL)
Leifers (LEI)
Eisack Valley (EI)
Mean for South Tyrol
2005
0.7
0.6
0.2
0.5
0.2
0.1
0
0.5
Mean % infestation
2006
2007
1.5
0.18
0.7
0.12
*
0.4
0.07
0.1
0.01
0.1
0.09
0.1
0
0
0
0.8
0.11
2008
0.05
0.09
0
0
0
0
0
0.02
In 2005 0.43% of the trees showed symptoms, in 2006 0.6%, and in 2007 0.15%. In 2008 we
300
detected only 0.02% symptomatic trees. The result of this evaluation indicates that the
average infestation has decreased significantly over the past four years (Table 1).
C. picta prefers trees in the first leaf. We have noticed that the presence of C. picta in this type
of orchard is much higher than in older orchards. The population density of this vector in
orchards in the first leaf decreased significantly in 2007. In the Eisack Valley we have never
found C. picta in an orchard, which may explain the absence of the disease (Figure 1).
7
30
33
33
50
36.4 37.5
50
67
71
76.9
85.7
100
100
93
70
67
67
50
63.6 62.5
50
33
29
23.1
14.3
VI
BGA
ET
ÜE
UL
LEI
EI
VI
2006
BGA
ET
ÜE
UL
LEI
EI
2007
Figure 1: Percentage of second Leaf Orchards on M9 with (in grey) and without Cacopsylla
picta in 2006 and 2007
Conclusion
By following the two approaches mentioned above we have noticed in a large number of
orchards a significant reduction in the population density of the vectors and in the new
infections of apple trees. Only these two approaches together have shown an acceptable result
in our orchards. Just spraying or cleaning is not enough to reduce the number of infected trees
and to protect the healthy ones from an infection.
The target for the future is to reduce the sprays against the insect vectors to a minimum.
This may be possible if the controls are carried out carefully and if the infected trees are
removed as quickly as possible from the orchards. In two districts of the region this has
already been achieved; in the upper Vinschgau Valley and in the Eisack Valley it was possible
to do without spraying before bloom.
301
Development and validation of a rapid method testing of CpGV
susceptibility in codling moth populations
Johannes A. Jehle, Stefanie Schulze
Biotechnological Crop Protection, Department of Phytopathology and Plant Protection,
Agricultursal Service Center Palatinate (DLR Rheinpfalz), Breitenweg 71, 67435 Neustadt a.
d. Weinstrasse
Abstract: In the last five years the phenomenon of emerging resistances of codling moth (Cydia
pomonella) against Cydia pomonella granulovirus (CpGV) has been observed in about 30 orchards in
different European countries. So far, bioassays with the F1 generation of the diapausing CM larvae
have been used for testing CpGV susceptibility. This is labour-intensive and time consuming; results
are only available about 9 months after collection of larvae. Therefore, we were seeking for an
alternative method by performing a direct test on the younger instars during the season. We developed
and validated a more rapid test by optimizing the virus concentration in the bioassay, duration of
bioassay and improvement of diet in order to be able to directly test the susceptibility on second to
fourth instar larvae extracted from apples. By testing more than 3700 larvae extracted from 12000
infested apples from 20 orchards in Germany, Switzerland, The Netherlands, Austria and Italy we
could prove that direct testing is feasible and provide results within 3 weeks after sampling. This new
method allows us to make precise predictions about the status quo in resistance of an examined
population, even if the orchard was treated with CpGV products, pheromones or chemical insecticides,
which, as a matter of course, complicates the identification and determination of a potential resistance.
Codling moth, Cydia pomonella Granulovirus, CpGV, Resistance testing
302
Effect of a growth enhancer Carbon Kick Booster® on mites and
natural mite enemies in apple
Tuomo Tuovinen
Plant Production Research, MTT Agrifood Research Finland, 31600 Jokioinen, Finland
Abstract: The importance of mite pests is increasing in Finnish apple production due to lack of efficient
pesticides and the effect of climate change. Integrated pest management has been successful to enhance
natural control of mites by indigenous OP-resistant phytoseiid mites but rejection of OP-insecticides will
cause increasing problems. Plant derived substances have been successful to restrain pest populations in
greenhouses. Tests with a growth enhancer ‘Carbon Kick Booster®’ containing rape seed oil, emulsifiers
and triacontanol were conducted in the laboratory and field conditions to evaluate its effect on apple rust
mite (Aculus schlechtendali) and fruit tree red spider mite (Panonychus ulmi). In the laboratory 1-2 %
solution killed a majority of the pest mites in 1-4 days. In field tests the results were inconsistent but
comparable to sulphur treatments. Mites of the families Tarsonemidae and Tydeidae were not affected
and in field tests phytoseiid mites survived the enhancer sprayings better than the sulphur sprayings.
Predatory cecidomyid larvae were present in the trees and limited both red spider mite and apple rust
mite population increases in all treatments.
Key words: Phytoseiidae, apple rust mite, fruit tree red spider mite, Aculus schlechtendali, Panonychus
ulmi
Introduction
In the past, the fruit tree red spider mite or the European red mite (ERM) Panonychus ulmi
(Koch) was a serious problem in professional apple orchards in Finland. In the 1980’s, OPresistant predatory mites (Acari, Phytoseiidae) were hardly present in sprayed orchards
(Tuovinen and Rokx, 1991) but in the 1990’s, along with the adoption of IPM, natural control
of ERM has prevailed in many orchards due to OP-tolerant phytoseiid mites (unpublished
data). From 2008 onwards, after the rejection of OP-insecticides in Finland, the success of
natural mite control may be threatened if insecticides which are more harmful to predatory
mites will replace the OP’s. The expected warming of climate, which has actually already
been noticed may lead to better overwintering and even development of one extra generation
of ERM. Recently, the introduction of new apple cultivars which are more susceptible to the
apple rust mite (ARM) Aculus schlechtendali (Nalepa) has increased the importance of this
eriophyid mite in future IPM.
Only few specific acaricides are available for growers and repeated sprayings involve a
risk of developing resistance in ERM and ARM populations. As an alternative approach,
several plant oil based biorational pesticides have been used especially in organic farming,
e.g. in greenhouses (Allen et al., 1993). One product belonging to biorational pesticides,
Carbon Kick Booster® (CKB) (Carbon Kick Ltd., Finland) containing turnip rape seed oil
(90%), emulsifiers (10%) and a small amount of triacontanol, was tested in the laboratory and
open field to evaluate its effect on pest mites and on the natural mite community in apple
trees.
303
Material and methods
Laboratory tests
In the laboratory tests CKB was sprayed as 2.0% and 1.0% solutions, with and without Silwet
Gold® (SG) silicone surfactant (0.05 and 0.025%). Tests were performed by spraying pieces
of apple leaves in a Potter tower using the amounts similar to 300 and 600 l/ha field
sprayings. Leaves were preserved in Petri dishes on moist cotton in a climate room in 25oC
and 60% RH. Assessment of the effect on ARM was made 1, 3 and 6 days after treatment.
Mites were classified mobile if they moved their legs. Henderson-Tilton formula was used to
calculate the effect of sprayings and data were analysed by ANOVA.
Field tests
In 2007, a field test was done at MTT Piikkiö (60o23’N; 22o33’E) by spraying randomly
selected trees with a knapsack mist sprayer with 2.0% CKB + 0.05% SG. Additionally the
whole block was sprayed by azinphosmethyl (5th July) and malathion (13th July) to control
insect pests. In 2008, the similar CKB+SG sprayings were done twice (10th June and 29th
July) and, another treatment with 1.0% sulphur (Kumulus®) was added for comparison at the
same time. The whole block was sprayed once (10th July) by pyrethrum insecticide to control
aphids. Leaf samples were collected and checked before and after sprayings and ARM, ERM
and other mites and insects were counted. Statistical analyses were done by ANOVA using
log-transformed data.
Results and discussion
Laboratory tests
In the laboratory CKB+SG and CKB had a good effect on ARM, whereas the effect of SG
alone was poor when sprayed at lower amount of liquid (Figure 1). After 3 days the results
were similar, but after 6 days the number of mobile mites also in untreated went down.
A
B
60
50
Mobile mites, %
Mobile mites, %
50
60
40
30
20
10
40
30
20
10
a
a
b
b
0
a
a
a
b
CKB
CKB+SG
SG
Untreated
0
CKB
CKB+SG
SG
Untreated
Figure 1. Proportion of mobile individuals of all apple rust mites one day after the treatment in
the laboratory. Amount of liquids: A: comparable to 300 l/ha (CKB 2.0%, SG 0.05%),
B: comparable to 600 l/ha (CKB 1.0%, SG 0.025%), untreated sprayed by water.
Different letters indicate significant differences between treatments within each
experiment (ANOVA, Tukey’s tests, P=0.05).
Field tests
In the field test in 2007 the effect of 2.0% CKB+0.05% SG was variable between cultivars
with a mean effect of 69% on ARM and on ERM 89% compared to the untreated trees
(Henderson-Tilton). In 2008, the first spraying of CKB+SG and Kumulus+SG had moderate
effects on ARM, 67% and 52% (Henderson-Tilton), respectively (Figure 2). The initial ERM
304
200
b
ns
150
EUROPEAN RED MITES / LEAF
APPLE RUST MITES / LEAF
population was low but variable and therefore the effect of the sprayings remained
questionable. The effect of the late July sprayings on both mite species remained insignificant
partly because of the emergence of natural mite enemies (Figures 3 and 5).
ns
ns
a
100
a
50
0
10.6.
16.7.
CKB+SG
Kumulus+SG
8
ns
6
b
4
b
ns
2
a
ns
0
10.6.
Untreated
CKB+SG
16.7.
Kumulus+SG
Untreated
Figure 2. Numbers of mobile apple rust mites and European red spider mites before treatments
and 36 DAT in the field test in 2008. Treatments: CKB 2.0% + SG 0.05%, Kumulus
1.0% + SG 0.05%. Different letters indicate significant differences between treatments
(ANOVA, Tukey’s test, P=0.05).
1.2
2.0
EGGS / LEAF
MOBILE MITES / LEAF
Kumulus+SG sprayings diminished phytoseiid mite and egg numbers in late season compared
to the trees sprayed by CKB+SG and the untreated trees (Figure 3). In spite of the pyrethrin
spraying (10th July) phytoseiid mite numbers grew fast in July-August except in Kumulus+SG
treated trees. The second treatment of CKB+SG in late July may have affected on egg-laying
of phytoseiid mites, however, the noticed differences were not significant.
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
0.9
0.6
0.3
0.0
7.6.
21.6.
CKB+SG
5.7.
19.7.
Kumulus+SG
2.8.
16.8.
7.6.
Untreated
21.6.
CKB+SG
5.7.
19.7.
Kumulus+SG
2.8.
16.8.
Untreated
Figure 3. Observations of mobile phytoseiid mites and phytoseiid eggs in the field test 2008.
The arrows indicate the treatment dates, see Figure 2.
CKB+SG did not have any notable harmful effect on other non-target mites except
Czenspinkia sp. (Acari, Winterschmidtiidae). Kumulus+SG treatments decreased the number
of all non-target mite groups (Figure 4). Besides phytoseiid mites predaceous gall midge
larvae, Feltiella spp. and Arthrocnodax spp. (Cecidomyidae) occurred on leaves in moderate
numbers and it was obvious that these predators diminished the numbers of ARM and ERM in
all treatments (Figure 5).
Oil based biorational pesticides are noteworthy alternatives for conventional or novel
synthetic acaricides although their effect cannot be guaranteed in all circumstances
(Krawchyk and Hull, 2005). Weather conditions may have a great influence on the effect of
CKB, and repeated treatments may be necessary. Variation of the leaf hairiness of cultivars
influences spreading of the spraying solution on the leaf surface where ARM lives; this
problem is less when a silicon adjuvant is used. CKB sprayings did not cause any unwanted
305
effects on plants and it was safe to beneficial predatory mites present in the apple trees, which
is an advantage compared to the sulphur sprayings.
Figure 4. Numbers of mobile mites of the most common non-target mite families in the field
MOBILE MITES / LEAF
4
c
b
b
3
2
b
b
1
b
a
a
a
Tydeoidea
Winterschmidtidae
0
CKB+SG
Kumulus+SG
Tarsonemidae
Untreated
test 2008. Treatments, see Figure 2. Different letters indicate significant differences
between treatments (ANOVA, Tukey’s test, P=0.05).
LARVAE / LEAF
4
3
2
1
0
7.6.
21.6.
CKB+SG
5.7.
19.7.
Kumulus+SG
2.8.
16.8.
Untreated
Figure 5. Observations of predatory cecidomyid larvae in the field test in 2008. Treatments, see
Figure 2.
References
Allen, W.R, Tehrani, B. & Luft, R. 1993. Effect of horticultural oil, insecticidal soap, and filmforming products on the western flower thrips and the tomato spotted wilt virus. Plant
Disease 77: 915-918.
Krawczyk, G. & Hull, L. A. 2005. Use of a new generation of horticultural oils for mite
management in fruit orchards. Bulletin OILB/SROP 28(7): 233-237.
Tuovinen, T. & Rokx, J.A.H. 1991. Phytoseiid mites (Acari: Phytoseiidae) on apple trees and in
surrounding vegetation in southern Finland. Densities and species composition. Exp. Appl.
Acarology 12: 35-46.
306
Biological Efficacy of Botanical Insecticides in Controlling Green
Apple Aphid (Aphis pomi De Geer)
Slobodan Milenković, Snežana Tanasković
Megatrend University, Belgrade, Faculty of Biofarming, Maršala Tita 39, Bačka Topola,
Serbia; University of Kragujevac, Faculty of Agronomy, Cara Dušana 34, 32000 Čačak,
Serbia
Abstract: The effects of the botanical insecticides pyrethrin (Pyros®), rotenone (Rotenone®) and
pyrethrin + rotenone (ShowTop) were monitored in two apple orchards planted with cvs. Granny
Smith and Kožara. The trial was set up according to the EPPO PP1/21(2) Protocol. The insecticides
were applied in each of four rows. Four leaves from each tree were designated as samples for
monitoring the population pressure of Aphis pomi De Geer. The insecticides were applied in June by
spray drift and atomiser. The temperature was 230C and relative air humidity 63%. The pest population
pressure was checked immediately before the treatment and on the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 7th day after
treatment (DAT). The highest efficacious insecticide was Pyros® (83.2%) on 1 DAT followed by
ShowTop (82.8%), whereas Rotenone® was the least effective (67.1%) at controlling A. pomi.
Rotenone® was most effective on 2 DAT (72.1%), with subsequent inspections showing a decrease in
efficacy (67.3% and 44.7%). For Pyros®, further inspection on 2 and 3 DAT registered a decline in
efficacy to 72 – 73%, whereas on 7 DAT it reduced to 55.7%. The inspection on 2 DAT reported the
highest efficacy of ShowTop (84%) and a further decline to 76.4% and 69.5% on 3 DAT and 7 DAT,
respectively.
Key words: apple, pests, Aphis pomi, botanical insecticides
Introduction
Aphids are considered major pests which threaten the quality and yield of fruits. About 250
species of plant aphids harm, both directly and indirectly, cultivated plants worldwide.
Indirect damage caused by aphids as virus vectors is an issue of utmost importance (Harris,
1990). Economically important aphids in Serbian apple orchards include green apple aphid
Aphis pomi De Geer (Dimić, 2000; Petrović-Obradović, 2003), followed by Rhopalosiphum
insertim Walk., Dysaphis devecta Walk., Dysaphis plantaginea Pass. (Petrović-Obradović,
2003) and a new pest in Serbian apple orchards - Aphis spireacola (Petrović-Obradović et al.,
2008). The earlier widespread use of pesticides in controlling aphids in practice was not
documented in scientific research and articles (Milenković et al., 2002). Under Serbian
conditions, preliminary investigations showed the efficacy of azadirachtin in controlling green
apple aphid (Milenković et al., 2001; Milenković et al., 2005). The use of botanical
insecticides for controlling A. pomi in Western Serbia was examined in this study.
Material and methods
The effects of the botanical insecticides pyrethrin (Pyros®), rotenone (Rotenone®) and
pyrethrin + rotenone (ShowTop) were monitored in two apple orchards planted with cvs.
Granny Smith and Kožara. The orchard, located at the 'Vranici' site (Cacak 1), at an altitude of
315m, was planted with cv. Granny Smith in spring 2008. The second site was located at
'Mršinci' (Čačak 2), at an altitude of 235m, and was planted with cv. Kožara in spring 2007.
The trial was set up according to the EPPO PP1/21(2) Protocol. The experimental area
307
comprised 20 apple trees divided into four treatments, each including five trees (five
replicates per treatment). Four leaves were marked on each tree for inspection, i.e. counting
the number of mobile specimens for monitoring the population pressure of A. pomi. The
untreated row (control) was marked likewise.
The insecticides were applied on 6 June 2008, around 19 h, by spray drift (locality 1) and
by atomiser (locality 2). The temperature was 230C and relative air humidity 63%.
The pest population pressure was assessed immediately before the treatment and then on
the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 7th days after the treatment (DAT). The reduction in percentages of
aphid population were calculated by Henderson-Tilton formula.
The recommended concentrations of pyrethrum (Pyros® (0.08%)), (rotenonone
Rotenone® (0.3%)) and pyrethrum+rotenonone (ShowTop (0.5%)) were applied in order to
study initial and residual effects on the green apple aphid. Rotenone and pyrethrum are natural
plant-derived substances. Rotenone has a longer residual life than most botanicals and is
effective for about a week. In organic production, the use of rotenone as an insecticide is
permitted under Regulation EC 2092/91, amended by EC 889/2008 .
Results and discussion
The first inspection, 24 hours after treatment, revealed that the number of aphids increased to
727 in the control, but decreased to 439 (Rotenone®), 179 (Pyros®) and 76 (ShowTop) in all
insecticide treatments (Table 1). A further decrease in aphid numbers was observed 2 DAT,
162, 128 and 31, respectively, in the treated, and 316 aphids in the untreated one.
The third and fourth inspections conducted on 3 DAT and 7 DAT, respectively, showed
that aphid numbers increased to 204 and 268 in the row treated with Rotenone®. The
inspections carried out 3 DAT registered a decline in the number of aphids on trees treated
with Pyros® (128 aphids) and ShowTop (49 aphids). The assessment conducted at 7 DAT
showed an approximately equal number of aphids in both insecticide treatments. The number
of aphids in the control, decreased to 341 (3DAT) and 264 (7DAT).
Table 1. The number of Aphis pomi on apple trees sprayed with botanical insecticides, site 1
(Čačak 1), cv. Granny Smith
Treatments
Aphid
No.
prior to
treatment
s
Aphid number and percent reduction after treatment
Initial effects
Residual effects
1-day
2-day
3-day
7-day
N0
R%
N0
R%
N0
Rotenone®
995
439
67
162 72 204
(rotenone)
Pyros®
793
179
128 72 131
83
(pyrethrin)
ShowTop (pyrethrin +
331
76
31
49
83
84
rotenone)
541
727
316
341
Control
0
N – Number of aphids
R% - Reduction % of aphids calculated by Henderson-Tilton formula
R%
N0
R%
67
268
44
74
171
56
76
49
70
-
264
-
The percent reduction of aphids showed that the most effective insecticide at Čačak (site
1) was Pyros® (83.2%), followed by ShowTop (82.8%) and Rotenone® (67.1%) (Table 2).
Rotenone® showed its highest efficacy at 2 DAT (72.1%) whereupon subsequent inspection
308
there was a decrease in efficacy (67.3% and 44.7%). On 2 and 3 DAT the efficacy of Pyros®
declined (72 – 73%), whereas on DAT 7 it was reduced to 55.7%. The assessment on 2 DAT
reported the highest efficacy of ShowTop (84%) and a further decline to 76.4% and 69.5% on
3 DAT and 7 DAT, respectively.
In the first inspection of the autochthonous cv. Kožara (Table2), 24 h after treatment, the
number of mobile aphids increased to 168 in the control, but decreased in the treated fields for
all insecticides: 16 (Pyros®), 29 (ShowTop) and 38 (Rotenone®). Changes in the aphid
number were not registered on 2 DAT. A further decrease to 11 and 8 was recorded on 3 DAT
and 7 DAT, respectively, following the Pyros® application. There was an increase in aphid
number in the other two insecticides (32 and 36 specimens (ShowTop) i.e. 41 and 50
specimens (Rotenone®), respectively). In the untreated field, the number of mobile aphids
increased to 168 (1 DAT), 172 (2 DAT) and 181 (3 DAT). The inspection conducted on 7 DAT
registered a decrease in aphid number to 152. The decrease was probably due to an increase in
the abundance of predatory entomofauna.
Table 2. The number of Aphis pomi on apple trees sprayed with botanical insecticides, site 2
(Čačak 2), cv. Kožara
Treatments
Aphid No.
prior to
treatments
Aphid number and reduction percentage after
treatment
Initial effects
Residual effects
1-day
2-day
3-day
7-day
N0 R% N0
R%
N0
R%
N0 R%
Rotenone®
157
38
77
38
41
78
(rotenone)
Pyros®
159
16
90
16
11
91
(pyrethrin)
ShowTop (pyrethrin +
165
29
29
32
83
83
rotenone)
165
168
172
181
Control
0
N – Number of aphids
R% - Reduction % of aphids calculated by Henderson-Tilton formula
77
50
67
94
8
94
82
36
76
-
152
-
The percent reduction of aphids at Čačak 2 site showed that on 1 DAT the the most
effective insecticide was Pyros® (90%), followed by ShowTop (83%) and Rotenone®
(76.3%). The efficacy of Rotenone® was highest on 3 DAT (77%), subsequent inspection
showing a decrease (67%). Further inspection on 2 and 3 DAT revealed an increase in the
efficacy of Pyros® to 91 – 94%, whereas on 7 DAT it remained unchanged (94%). The
inspection on 2 and 3 DAT reported high efficacy of ShowTop (83%) and a further decline to
76% (7 DAT).
A comparison of the reduction percentage between the two localities suggested that the
same insecticides showed different efficacy (Fig.1).
309
Day after treatment
Rotenon (R), Pyros (P), ShowTop (ST)
1- spray, 2 - atomiser
ST2
ST1
P2
P1
R2
R1
7
3
2
1
10
30
50
70
90
%
Figure 1. Efficacy of two different spray applications of insecticides against A. pomi.
The differences in efficacy of the insecticides at the two sites most likely resulted from
different methods of application (spray and atomiser). They were manifested through greater
efficacy of the atomiser-applied insecticides at the locality 2. The differences were most
evident (Fig. 1) with Pyros®.
No symptoms of phytotoxicity (russetting, necrosis) to apple leaves were observed
during the trial.
References
Dimić, N. 2000: The most frequent apple antofags in our country. Plant doctor. 28(6): 492504. [in Serbian]
Harris, K.F. 1990: Aphid transmission of plant viruses. In: Mandahar, C. L. (ed): Plant
Viruses, Vol II, C.R.C. Press, Inc.: 177-204.
Milenković, S., Cerović, R. & Glavendekić, M. 2001: Azadirachtin – botanical insecticide.
Book of scientific papers XVI Yugoslav symposium on improvements in fruit and grape
production, 7(2): 87-92. [in Serbian]
Milenković, S., Cerović, R. & Lukić, M. 2005: Resistant cultivars and biological insecticides
in fruit protection. Workshop on Pest and Weed Control in Sustainable Fruit Production,
Skierniewice, Poland, September 1-3, 2005. Abstracts of poster presentation, 45.
Milenković, S., Krnjajić, S. &Tanasković, S. 2002: Apple pests – actual approach in control.
Book of Article, Winter School of Agronomists, Faculty of Agronomy Čačak, 6(6): 117123. [in Serbian]
Milenković, S., Tanasković, S. & Lazić, T. 2005: Azadirachtin – possibilities of use in plant
protection. Horticulture, 149(39): 61-69. [in Serbian]
Petrović-Obradović, O. 2003: Plant aphids (Homoptera: Aphididae) of Serbia. University of
Belgrade, Faculty of Agriculture. 1-153. [in Serbian]
Petrović-Obradović, O., Vukašinović, D., Vučetić, A., Milovanović, P. & Krnjajić, S. 2008:
Aphis spireacola Patch, new apple pest in Serbia. IX Conference on Plant Protection in
Serbia. Zlatibor, 24-28 Novembar 2008. Book of Abstracts, 124-125. [in Serbian]
310
Evolution of apple surface metabolites throughout the season and
codling moth (Cydia pomonella L.) egg-laying behaviour.
Nadia Lombarkia
INRA Unité de Phytopharmacie et Médiateurs Chimiques. Route de Saint-Cyr 78026
Versailles Cedex France, e-mail: nlombarkia@yahoo.fr, derridj@versailles.inra.fr. fax: +
(33) 01.30.83.31.19
Abstract: Cydia pomonella behaviour is related to plant surface metabolites. Among them soluble
carbohydrates (glucose, fructose and sucrose) and sugar alcohols (sorbitol, quebrachitol and myoinositol) influence plant site acceptance and stimulate egg-laying. It is generally observed in orchards
that throughout the season the females shift their egg-laying site whenever a majority of eggs
remaining on the leaf surface. On the variety Granny Smith they first lay eggs in majority on the twigs
and upper side of corymb leaves and then progressively they lay more eggs on the lower side of
corymb leaves and fruits. Our aim is to study the relationship between the chemicals throughout the
season and the behaviour shifts. For both varieties Golden Delicious and Granny Smith, we considered
different plant organs: twigs, leaves, leaf sides, fruit at several growth stages. Within the six metabolite
pattern the concentrations and ratios (ng/cm²) of metabolites vary with the plant organ, leaf side and
the season period. Although quantities are different between the varieties, differences remain
according to the sites and are rather similar: the upper side of corymb leaves is the richest site
throughout the periods. On the twigs, fructose, sorbitol and mannitol increase throughout the periods
but quebrachitol decreases dramatically. Apple surface enriches in sorbitol and grow poorer in
fructose. On the base of our knowledge on the influence of metabolite blend on egg-laying behaviour
we verified a good correlation between them in orchards throughout the season. This study could open
new ways of apple tree protection based on the recognition of the host by the insect.
Surface metabolites, Sugars, Sugar alcohols, Cydia pomonella, Egg-laying
311
Evaluation of integrated management scenarios of the peach treeMyzus persicae system using a crop-pest model
Isabelle Grechi1, Benoît Sauphanor1, Nadine Hilgert2, Michel Génard1, Rachid
Senoussi3, Marie-Hélène Sauge1, Arnaud Chapelet4, Jean-Philippe Lacroze1, Françoise
Lescourret1
INRA, 1Plantes et Systèmes de culture Horticoles, UR 1115, 3Biostatistiques & Processus
Spatiaux, UR 546, 4Unité expérimentale Environnement et Agronomie, UE 1187, Domaine St
Paul, site Agroparc, 84914 Avignon Cedex 9, France, 2Analyse des Systèmes et Biométrie
UMR 729, 2 place Viala, 34060 Montpellier Cedex 1, France
Abstract: Integrated Fruit Production (IFP) calls for an adaptation of production processes to improve
crop quality and environmental safety. This approach gives priority to alternative methods of pest
control. Our study investigates the potential of management scenarios that integrate chemical,
biological (inundative release of Harmonia axyridis ladybirds) and cultural (nitrogen fertilization and
winter pruning) pest control methods for the peach tree-aphid system. We used a modeling approach to
address this question. We defined 108 management scenarios, which were based on theoretical pest
control strategies combined with control variables relative to pest control and cultural practices. Then,
we performed model simulations of these scenarios and studied the relationships between control
variables and model outputs referring to agronomical, economical, sanitary (pest), and sustainability
performance. Results showed that ‘agronomical performance’ was largely controlled by ‘agronomical
practices’, while ‘pest performance’ waslargely controlled by ‘pest control practices’.
Key words: biological control, Harmonia axyridis, chemical control, cultural control, winter pruning,
nitrogen fertilization, green peach aphid, population dynamics, foliage growth, fruit quality.
Introduction
Integrated Fruit Production (IFP) aims to develop more sustainable production systems,
profiting from natural resources and ecological processes of the system in replacement of
agrochemical inputs (Cross et al, 1997). This includes relying on alternative (i.e, natural,
cultural or biological) methods of pest control. These methods aim to reduce pest pressure by
confining trophic exchanges in the “crop-pest-predator” system within adequate levels.
Therefore, IFP calls for an adaptation of agricultural practices that can ensure crop yield while
improving crop quality and environmental safety. Our study investigates the potential of croppest management scenarios that integrate chemical, biological (inundative release of
Harmonia axyridis) and cultural (nitrogen fertilization and winter pruning) pest control
methods for the peach tree Prunus persica (L.) Batsch- Myzus persicae (Sulzer) aphid system.
N fertilization and winter pruning are two major cultural practices used in fruit
production orchards to improve agronomic performances. On the other hand, by manipulating
host plant quality (N content, defensive chemistry) and/or host plant availability (vegetative
growth), they were likely to regulate aphid populations. Consequently, they can modify the
level of aphid damage on the crop and indirectly affect crop performances. A ladybird release
raises the level of predators and insures a top-down control of aphid populations. However
cascading effects of variation in plant resources can extend to this third trophic level and
affect its performances. All these interactions make comprehension difficult for whole system
behaviour in response to management practices. Modeling is a well-adapted tool to analyze a
312
complex system in a general framework and build up effective Integrated Crop-Pest
Management strategies (Getz and Gutierrez, 1982).
Material and methods
Description of the crop-pest simulation model (Figure 1)
Our deterministic model predicts, for an “average” tree and over a 1-year time horizon, (i) the
daily time-course of shoots and fruit dry masses, (ii) the daily time-course of the sizes (in
number of individuals) of an “average” aphid population and ladybird cohorts, and (iii) fruit
quality at harvest. Sub-models [2] and [3] (Figure 1) were respectively developed by Grechi
et al (2008b) and Chen (1997). The global model is fully described in Grechi (2008a).
[1] Peach-aphid interactions as controlled by cultural practices
winter pruning
shoots
(number)
long
shoot
(%)
leaf area
fruit
thinning
emigration
N fertilization
leaf N content
foliage
aphid
population predation
individuals
damages (number)
growth
long
short
shoot shoot
(mass) (mass)
leaf fall
fall
fruits
fruits
fruit quality
(number) (mass)
(RI)
information flow
matter flow
emigration
adults
[2] Fruit quality
state variables
control variables
[3] Biological pest control
L4
L3
L2
L1
ladybird
cohorts
mortality
individuals
(number)
insecticide
application
ladybird
release
[4] Chemical pest control
temperature effect
«average» individual of the tree
[1], [2], [3] and [4]:
the four sub-models
Figure 1. Schematic representation of the “peach-aphid” model and its four sub-models.
Definition of the 108 integrated management scenarios
The management scenarios included four theoretical pest control strategies detailed with
respect to biological and chemical treatments: no treatment (strat1-‘no treatment’), only
chemical treatments (strat2-‘conventional’ and strat3-‘organic farming’1), and both chemical
and biological treatments with high action thresholds for release of ladybirds and application
of insecticides (strat4-‘integrated’). These were combined with (i) control variables relative
to insecticide characteristics (maximal mortality rate for insecticides used at bloom, ins1B, or
during the season, ins1S) and cultural practices (winter pruning intensity, IP, and leaf N
content, NCleaf), and (ii) an uncontrolled variable (aphid inoculum, iniNA).
Definition of the criteria used to evaluate management scenarios
The assessment of a management performance relies on a set of criteria that characterize (i)
‘agronomic’ indices of an average fruit (fruit yield, Yield, refractometric index, RI, and fresh
mass, MFr), (ii) ‘economic’ indices (selling price, SP, and total number of ladybirds released,
TotNLA), (iii) ‘pest’ variables (number of insecticide applications, INS, and total number of
aphids per shoot over a year, TotNA), and (iv) ‘sustainability’ properties (number of long
1
Here ‘organic farming’ is a strategy that is limited to the usage of insecticides authorized according to farming
guidelines. Such insecticides are generally less effective against pests than those used in conventional systems.
313
shoots, NLS, and proportion of long shoots > 30cm, pLS30). They are referred as ‘performance
variables’.
Model simulations and performance analysis of the integrated management scenarios
Model inputs comprise ‘control variables’, which refer to the management practices. They
include ‘agronomic’ (IP, NCleaf) and ‘pest’ (strati,i={1,2,3,4}, ins1B, ins1S) variables. Each
management scenario is characterized by a set of ‘control variables’ and ‘performance
variables’ (computed from model outputs). The performances of the simulated management
practices were investigated via a principal component analysis with instrumental variables
(PCAIV) in correlation plots.
Results and discussion
Results of the PCAIV (Figure 2) showed that ‘agronomic performances’ were largely
1.0
Performance variables
B
0.5
0.5
1.0
Control variables
A
strat3
strat3
strat2
strat2
in1S
ins1S
TotN
TotPR LA
0.0
0.0
IP
IP
PC2
PC2
TotNA
TotPE.arb
iniN
iniPeA
in1B
ins1B
Yield
yield
SP
SP
-0.5
-0.5
PC2
PC2
strat4
strat4
strat1
strat1
INS
INS
Ellipses indicate
variables
relatives to:
N
nGS
LS
RI
RI
MFFr
F
‘agronomical’
control &
performances
newS
pLS30
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
-1.0
-1.0
N
NC
leaf
0.5
1.0
-1.0
-0.5
1.0
1.0
‘pest’
control &
performances
D
‘economical’
performances
0.5
IIPP
-0.5
strat1
strat1
yield
Yield
SP
SP
TotPR
TotN
newS
LA
pLS
30
TotPE.arb
TotNA
-1.0
-1.0
N
NCleaf
strat4
strat4
‘sustainability’
performances
NLS
nGS
RI
RI
FFr
MF
0.0
0.0
iniN
A
iniPe
in1B
ins1B
0.5
INS
INS
PC3
PC3
0.5
ins1S
in1S
strat3
strat3
strat2
strat2
0.0
PC1
PC1
C
-0.5
PC3
PC3
1.0
PC1
PC1
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
-1.0
PC1
PC1
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
PC1
PC1
Figure 2. Correlation plots of ‘control variables’ (A, C) and ‘performance variables’ (B, D) for
the 1-2 (A, B) and 1-3 (C, D) PCAIV components.
controlled by ‘agronomic practices’ (Figures 2A, 2B). NLS, RI and MFr were mainly explained
by Ip whereas pLS30 was largely explained by NCleaf, both factors had a positive effect. To a
lesser extent, Yield and SP were positively correlated to NCleaf. Yield appeared to be negatively
correlated to Ip, while SP provided no clear correlation with Ip due to their nonlinear
relationship (data not shown). Conversely, ‘pest performances’ were strongly controlled by
314
‘pest control practices’ (Figure 2C, 2D). strat1, strat2, strat3, strat4 and ins1S largely
explained the two variables INS and TotNA. On the contrary, ins1B and iniNA explained none
of ‘pest performance’ variables. INS (resp. TotNA) was positively (resp. negatively) correlated
to strat2, strat3 and ins1S, and negatively (resp. positively) correlated to strat1 and strat4. In
spite of peach-aphid interactions, our results did not identify clear interactions between ‘pest’
and ‘agronomic’ variables. Since cultural practices have a partial effect and are generally less
effective at regulating pest population than chemical control methods, their effect on aphid
dynamics can only be expressed under control strategies without an intensive use of
insecticides (e.g., strat1 and strat4). The low effect of ‘pest control’ practices on ‘agronomic
performances’ could be explained by the possible weak effect of aphids on fruit production in
some situations (Grechi, 2008a).
Furthermore, among the 11 management scenarios with high SP values (SP > 150 €/
tree) the four pest control strategies were represented. High values of SP could be reached
with different values of insecticide effectiveness but only with the intermediate pruning
intensity value (IP=0.40) and the highest leaf N content value (NCleaf=3.5). This indicated the
importance of IP and NCleaf in the determination of SP.
Owing to its ability to investigate multiple criteria performances of management
scenarios that integrate several pest control methods, the peach crop-aphid model should be
useful for further IFP implementation. This first analysis already revealed that there was not a
unique profile of environmentally interesting scenarios, and that environmentally safe pest
control strategies could lead to profitable selling prices.
Acknowledgements
This work was partially funded by grants from INRA’s ANR programme, “ECosphère
COntinentale, ECOlogie pour la Gestion des Ecosystèmes et de leurs Ressources”.
References
Chen, X. (1997) Efficacité de Harmonia axyridis (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae) comme agent de
lutte biologique contre Myzus persicae (Homoptera: Aphididae). PhD, Université
d'Avignon et des Pays de Vaucluse. pp 168.
Cross, J.V., Malavolta, C. & Jörg, E. (1997) Guidelines for integrated production of stone
fruits in Europe. IOBC Technical Guideline III. Piacenza, Italy. 23-24 February 1996.
IOBC/WPRS Bulletin, 20, pp 51.
Getz, WM. & Gutierrez, AP. (1982) A perspective on systems analysis in crop production and
insect pest management. Annual Review of Entomology, 27, 447-466.
Grechi, I. (2008a) Agroecological modeling of a “fruit crop-pest” system. Application to the
Integrated Fruit Production. PhD, Centre international d’études supérieures en sciences
agronomiques, SupAgro Montpellier. pp 210
Grechi, I., Hilgert, N., Génard, M. & Lescourret, F. (2008b) Assessing the peach fruit
refractometric index at harvest with a simple model based on fruit growth. Journal of the
American Society for Horticultural Science, 133, 178-187.
315
Modelling codling moth damage as a function of adult monitoring and
crop protection: A survival generalized linear mixed model approach
with time varying covariates
Benoît Ricci1, Olivier Martin2, Pierre Franck1, Jean-François Toubon1, Rachid
Senoussi2, Claire Lavigne1
1
UR1115 Plantes et systèmes de culture horticoles, INRA, F-84000 Avignon; 2 UR546
Biostatistique et processus spatiaux, INRA, F-84000 Avignon
Abstract: The codling moth (Cydia pomonella) is responsible for most insecticide treatments in pear
and apple orchards. In a context of reduction in pesticide use, we aim at better understanding factors
that affect codling moth damage intensity. We modelled the link between the proportion of damaged
fruits and both constant covariables (type of orchard: pear or apple, organic or not, with or without
mating disruption) and time-varying covariables (weekly counts of adults and number of insecticide
treatments). Observations were collected in 40 orchards in south-eastern France. We found that
damage intensity increased with the number of adults trapped. An analysis of the random orchard
effect indicated a certain temporal stability in the risk probability of orchards and a lower risk
probability in orchards surrounded by numerous pomefruit orchards and windbreak hedgerows.
Keywords: codling moth, damage, trap, mixed model, survival analysis
Introduction
Reduction of pesticide use is an important issue for both human health preservation (Lee et
al., 2004) and biodiversity conservation (McLaughlin, 1995). Thus, there is an urgent need to
find alternative solutions for crop protection against pests. Codling moth, the major
worldwide insect pest in apple and pear orchards, is responsible for most insecticide
treatments in European and North American orchards. Despite this intensive insecticide
pressure, codling moth can locally have dramatic impact on production. A major reason is
probably insecticide resistance that occurs both for chemical pesticides and biological agents
(Reyes et al., 2007; Sauphanor, 2006). Codling moth damage is due to fruit perforation by
young larvae. Classical insecticide treatments are therefore targeted towards eggs or young
larvae. In some cases, mating disruption with pheromones is also associated with insecticides
to reduce locally mating and population growth. In this context, two important challenges are
(i) to assess to what extent monitoring codling moth adults provide useful information for
prediction of fruit damage and (ii) to find potential factors (even with partial effect) that may
reduce codling moth damage in orchards.
We addressed these challenges using a statistical approach: we combined survival
methods with generalized linear mixed techniques to model the relationships between the risk
of fruit injury at the orchard level and several constant or dynamic covariables. The dynamic
variables are adult codling moth population densities whose changes a priori parallel damage
risk variations and the number of insecticide treatments applied against codling moth. The
constant effects are the global orchard pest management strategies (organic or conventional,
with or without mating disruption) and the host plant species (apple or pear). To apprehend an
unexplained variability among orchards, we also included a random orchard effect. We
searched for potential environmental factors affecting risk of damage using a regression
316
analysis between random orchard effects and some landscape characteristics known to affect
codling moth population densities (Ricci et al. in press, 2009).
Material and methods
Sampling sites
In 2006 (respectively 2007), we selected 41 (respectively 40) apple or pear orchards by a
stratified random draw of spatial coordinates within an approximately 70 km2 pear and apple
growing area in south-eastern France. Seven orchards were organic in 2006 (six in 2007).
Mating disruption was used in five of these orchards in 2006 and four of them in 2007. In
eight orchards in 2006 and ten in 2007, growers used both chemical treatments and mating
disruption against codling moth. All other orchards were conventional orchards in which
growers used only chemical treatments.
Codling moth trapping, damage observations, and records of insecticide applications
Codling moth population densities were monitored during adult first flight in 2006 and 2007
using delta traps (TRECE® Phérocon® IIB Trap) baited with a mixed codlemone (1mg) and
pear ester (1mg) lure (TRECE® CM/DA Combo). We placed one trap per orchard. Traps were
checked and adults counted weekly from April 19th to June 21st in 2006 and from April 11th to
June 20th in 2007.
Fruit damage intensity (proportion of attacked fruits) caused by the progenies of first
flight adults were assessed once each year in each orchard. Observations were made during
the week following June 21st in 2006 and June 25th in 2007. Codling moth injuries were
recorded by visual inspection of 1000 fruits per orchard distributed over 50 regularly spaced
trees (20 fruits per tree, 10 on each side of the row).
Insecticide treatments target eggs and larvae and thus intend to reduce the risk of fruit
damage for a given level of adult population. We therefore performed farm surveys in 2006
(2007 not available) to collect records of insecticide applications for each orchard.
Modelling codling moth injury
We modelled damage probability as a temporal function of both fixed effects (the number of
adult codling moth in traps and orchards local covariates) and a random orchard effect that
cannot be observed. As the records of insecticide applications were not available in 2007, we
did not consider both years’ data together, and we thus did not model a ‘year’ effect.
Random effects analysis
To test if random effects had a random spatial distribution we checked if their empirical
variogram were within the 98% envelope drawn from 100 permutations of random effects
over orchards. To test for temporal stability of random effects over the two years, we checked
whether their signs remained the same using a permutation test.
To investigate if some landscape characteristics were associated to estimated random
effects, we mapped all pomefruit (pear and apple) orchards and all hedgerows in the study
area. We calculated the ratio of hedgerow length over orchard perimeter (hedgerow
proportion); the proportion of each 100m wide buffer around focus orchards covered by
pomefruit orchards (pomefruit orchards density) and the mean orientation of hedgerows in
150m wide buffers (hedgerow orientation).
We then used a multiple regression to test whether orchard random effects were partly
explained by landscape characteristics which were not initially introduced in the model. The
four explanatory variables were the three landscape variables defined above together with the
orchard area.
317
Results
Codling moth trapping, damage observations, and insecticide applications recordings
The mean total number of codling moth trapped per orchard was 73.3 (N=41; sd=65.1) during
the 10 week period in 2006 and 55.6 (N=40; sd=39.2) during the 11 week period in 2007.
Fruit damage at the end of the first flight period was low: mean percentage of attacked
fruits per orchard was 1.07% (N=41; sd=1.43%) in 2006 and 1.22% (N=40; sd=1.79%) in
2007.
In organic orchards, growers mainly used granulosis virus to control the codling moth
population with a mean of 14.7 (N=7, sd =2.4) applications. Conventional orchards with
mating disruption received a mean of 8.8 (N=8, sd=2.9) insecticide applications. All other
orchards (conventional orchards without mating disruption) received a mean of 11.4 (N=26,
sd=5.3) applications in 2006.
Parameter estimation and significant covariates
Significant covariates in the full model were the same both years. The risk of fruit damage
increased with the number of codling moth in traps. Unexpectedly, neither mating disruption
nor the number of insecticide treatments had a significant effect on the risk of fruit damage.
On the contrary, damage probability was about 1.4 times higher in organic than non-organic
orchards in 2006 and 1.35 times higher in 2007.
Analysis of random effects
Taking into account random orchard effects lead to a large improvement of the model fitting
for both years.
Neither the spatial mapping of these random effects over the study region nor their
empirical variogram revealed any particular spatial pattern for both years. On the contrary, a
certain temporal stability of random effects was evidenced by the permutation test of joint
signs (P= 0.050). Orchards with higher or lower than expected risk tended to remain the same
from one year to the other.
Multiple regression analyses showed that orchard random effects depended on orchards
density and hedgerow orientation but did not depend on the orchard area or on the ratio of
hedgerow length over orchard perimeter. The random effects were lower in orchards
surrounded by numerous pomefruit orchards and by windbreak hedgerows.
Discussion
The number of adults observed in traps was significantly and positively related to the level of
fruit damage both years, indicating that adult trapping provides useful information on the
local harmfulness of codling moths. Traditionally, adult counts were performed using
pheromone traps but the relevance of these counts for predicting fruit damage has been
discussed (Riedl & Croft, 1974). Pheromone traps were more recently discarded because of
their low efficiency in orchards under mating disruption. Our results tend to show that traps
baited with high loaded combined sex pheromone and pear ester lure do provide information
on the local orchard population, either in the presence or not of mating disruption and that
they could be used to assess the risk of fruit damage.
On the contrary, the number of insecticide treatments did not explain variation in codling
moth damage. This could result from the fact that, despite differences in the number of
treatments among orchards, the global insecticide pressure against codling moth is similar.
Granulosis virus which was used by organic farmers has a slightly shorter persistence time
and, indeed, organic farmers applied pesticides with a higher frequency compared to
318
conventional growers. This could explain why our models revealed a significant difference
between organic and conventional orchards instead of a general effect of the number of
treatments.
The large random orchard effects indicate that a great part of variation was not explained
by the available fixed effects that we introduced in the model. This precludes the use of the
model for prediction of fruit damage only from the knowledge of adults and the orchard pest
management strategy. This high variation in the baseline risk between orchards was partially
explained by the characteristics of the landscape surrounding the orchards. Landscape
harbouring windbreak hedgerows and numerous pomefruit orchards were associated with
lower damage. Windbreaks may reduce pesticide drift, therefore increasing insecticide
efficiency, or modify plume dispersion and interact with codling moth monitoring with traps.
Ricci et al. (2009) found that the presence of surrounding orchards had a negative impact on
the density of codling moth diapausing larvae, possibly due to an impact of neighbouring
insecticide treatments. The same effect of neighbouring treatments might be at play here.
Acknowledgement
We are very grateful to TRECE which freely provided traps and lures for the experiments.
References
Lee, W.J., Blair, A., Hoppin, J.A., et al. 2004: Cancer incidence among pesticide applicators
exposed to chlorpyrifos in the agricultural health study. Journal of the National Cancer
Institut 96: 1781-1789.
McLaughlin, A. 1995: The impact of agricultural practices on biodiversity. Agriculture
Ecosystems & Environment 55: 201-212.
Reyes, M., Franck, P., Charmillot, P.J., et al. 2007: Diversity of insecticide resistance
mechanisms and spectrum in European populations of the codling moth, Cydia
pomonella. Pest Management Science 63: 890-902.
Riedl, H. & Croft, B.A. 1974: A study of pheromone trap catches in relation to codling moth
(Lepidopterae: Olethreutidae) damage. Canadian Entomologist 106:525-537.
Sauphanor, B. 2006: Carpocapse des pommes : cas de résistance au virus de la granulose en
vergers biologiques. Phytoma, La Défense des Végétaux, 590: 24-27.
Ricci, B., Franck, P., Toubon, J.F., Bouvier, J.C., Sauphanor, B., Lavigne, C. 2009: The
influence of landscape on insect pest dynamics: a case study in southeastern France.
Landscape Ecology 24: 337-349.
319
A Comparative Study on Auto-Confusion by Exosex2 Gvm-Lb and
Mating Disruption by Isonet-L against European Grapevine Moth,
Lobesia botrana Den.-Schiff. (Lep.: Tortricidae) in Turkey
F. O. Altindisli1, F. Ozsemerci1, P. Hıncal2, A. Derin2, İ. Çınarlı2, G. Pease3, T. Ray3 and T.
Wardley3
1
Plant Protection Research Institute, Genclik Caddesi No: 6, 35040 Bornova, Izmir, Turkey,
Tel. 00 90 232 3880030, Fax. 00 90 232 3741653, e-mail:altindisli@yahoo.com
2
Elit Tarimsal Muhendislik, Besicilik, Sanayi ve Tic. Ltd. Sti. Tibas Vakif Han, No.19/114,
Konak Izmir, Turkey, e-mail:elittarim@gmail.com
3
Exosect Limited, Leylands Business Park Colden Common Winchester SO21 1TH United
Kingdom, e-mail:garry.pease@exosect.com
Abstract: Turkey has more than 300 native grape varieties. Round Seedless (Sultana) is the most
important variety. The Aegean Region is the first by possessing 28% of the vineyard surface in Turkey.
The production area of Sultana seedless is mostly placed in Manisa Province. Bozcaada Island is in the
Marmara Region, in the northwest part of Turkey. The island is very important because of its unique
varieties cultivated such as Çavuş and Karasakız. It has 1000 ha of viticulture. The two regions have
different agro-ecosystems and ecological conditions. Up to now, synthetic pesticide application has
been given priority against European grapevine moth (EGVM), (Lobesia botrana Den.-Schiff.)
(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae), the key pest of grapes in Turkey. However, negative effects of chemical
control on the environment and human health have led up to the necessity of biotechnical methods
against the pest. Among them, the mating disruption technique has been tested against EGVM in
Turkey. Isonet-L dispensers were proved to be as effective as chemical control against the pest. The
objective of this study was to determine in different conditions of Bozcaada Island and Manisa whether
the Exosex2 GVM-LB auto-confusion system for EGVM, reduces mating and subsequent larval damage
to the fruit by comparing with Isonet L, the registered material. By this study, auto-confusion was tested
in Turkey for the first time. The auto-confusion (AC) technique by Exosex2 dispensers (10 mg
pheromone/dispenser) was applied in 17,3 ha and 24,2 ha in Manisa (Aegean Region) whereas it was
applied in 12 ha in Bozcaada Island (Marmara Region) in 2007 and 2008, respectively. Only in Manisa,
classical mating disruption (MD) technique by Isonet L dispensers (172 mg pheromone/dispenser) was
used as a comparative technique in 15 and 6 ha in 2007 and 2008, respectively. Chemical-treated
vineyards were also included in the research as comparison (C) vineyard. At the beginning of first flight
period, 180 Exosex2 dispensers /ha and 600 Isonet L/ha were installed. Exosex2 installation was
repeated at sixty day-intervals. The need and time of chemical applications was decided by means of
Forecasting System against L. botrana in C vineyards. In critical periods when the eggs and larvae of
first, second, third and fourth generations were expected, and just before harvest; 100 bunches per
hectare were controlled in the centre and borders of each AC and MD sampling vineyard, and 100
bunches in each C vineyard separately. Infestation rates were determined. Exosex2 dispensers from both
locations were analysed by GC. In 2007, the pheromone samples were taken from the first application
tablets of both Regions on 31 May 2007. In 2008, the pheromone samples were taken from the second
application tablets of Bozcaada on 13 August and third application tablets of Manisa on 09 October.
The average infestation rate of all AC vineyards in Manisa was calculated as 6.3 % just before harvest
in 2007. In the course of the experiment, 9.6 ha-AC vineyards were treated against L. botrana once,
whereas 6 ha-AC vineyards were treated two times because of the infestation rate was higher than the
threshold of 5%. Fortunately, a 1.7 ha part of AC vineyards did not require any chemical treatment
against the pest and auto-confusion has suppressed EGVM in alone. Moreover, the infestation rates
were still higher than 5% in 30.6% of the entire AC surface (5,3 ha-9 vineyards) at harvest time. In
Manisa, 18.67% part of the entire MD surface had to be sprayed once at least, whereas 13.3% had to be
applied twice in 2007. Average infestation rate of all MD vineyards was calculated as 8% at this time.
320
However, insecticide application has been avoided since the grapes are being harvested. In the last
assessment in 2008, average infestation rate of all AC vineyards was calculated as 4.55% at harvest. In
the course of the experiment, all AC vineyards in Manisa were totally treated against EGVM twice
because of the infestation rates in 3rd generation were higher than the threshold of 5%. In 12% of the
entire AC surface, the infestation rates were still higher than 5% at harvest time. They were only 3
vineyards having a surface of 3 ha, totally. In Manisa, 16.67% part of the entire MD surface had to be
sprayed once in 2008. Average infestation rate of all MD vineyards was calculated as 4.75% at this
time. Only smaller MD vineyard had an infestation rate higher than the threshold at harvest. It can be
concluded that small surface of MD caused higher infestation rate. However, insecticide application has
been avoided since the grapes are being harvested. In comparison vineyard, broad-spectrum insecticides
were applied against L. botrana five times. Infestation rates of the comparison vineyard were always
lower than AC plots during the whole season owing to the sprayings of broad-spectrum insecticides. It
is also usual to apply chemicals against EGVM in the centre of Manisa Province four or five times per
season. No insecticide treatment has been used against any other pest in AC and MD vineyards. The
best effectiveness from Auto-confusion has been obtained in Bozcaada against EGVM. No
complementary treatment has been applied to suppress the pest. Auto-confusion by Exosex2 dispensers
was very effective. In comparison vineyard of Bozcaada broad-spectrum insecticides were applied
against the pest three times. As occurred in the world, it is possible to have some years and some
localities in Turkey, where biotechnical methods are not suitable or successful to control a pest in alone
and require complementary insecticide treatment. Mating disruption technique is also registered in
Turkey on condition that it should be supported by a biological insecticide treatment preferably to
decrease the population density when the infestation rate exceeds 5-6% in the vineyard. By all means,
when compared to chemically controlled vineyards, it can be assumed that Exosex2 dispensers reduced
the number of insecticide applications from 4-5 to 1-2 even in the Aegean Region where population
density is higher, flight period is longer and temperatures are higher than Bozcaada Island. Temperature
is one of the most efficient factors, which affect the efficacy and stability of pheromone in outer
conditions. Average daily temperatures were lower in 2008 when compared with 2007 recorded in
Manisa. Results of weekly Isonet-L weights also reflected this phenomenon by consuming their
pheromone 3 weeks earlier in 2007 when compared to 2008. According to the results of GC analysis, it
was determined that 97.3% of total pheromone amount from Exosex dispensers has been consumed in
Bozcaada, whereas only 84% has been released in Manisa in 2007. Despite the higher temperatures in
Manisa than Bozcaada in summertime, it can be assumed that the stronger winds might be more
effective factor for the emission of pheromone from the dispensers because of lower leaf density in
springtime. On the other hand, only 60% of total pheromone amount from Exosex dispensers has been
consumed in Bozcaada, whereas 76% has been released in Manisa in summertime in 2008. Therefore,
auto-confusion technique can be applied in the vineyards for the control of Lobesia botrana by
installing 180 Exosex2 dispensers/ha three times per season with 60 days interval. However, it must be
combined in the Aegean Region of Turkey with a biological insecticide preferably, if the average
infestation rate of the pest exceeds 5-6% once or twice per season.
Key Words: Lobesia botrana, auto confusion, mating disruption, grape, Turkey
321
Identification of the female sex pheromone of the pear midge,
Contarinia pyrivora
Lakmali Amarawardana1, David Hall1, Jerry Cross2, Michelle Fountain2 and Gunnhild
Jåstad2
1
Natural Resources Institute, University of Greenwich, Chatham Maritime, Kent, ME4 4TB,
U.K.; 2East Malling Research, New Road, East Malling ,Kent ME19 6BJ UK.
Abstract: The pear midge, Contarinia pyrivora (Riley), is a pest of pear fruitlets and the damage
causes severe crop losses. Although it can be controlled by application of insecticide, the timing of
application is crucial as C. pyrivora is present for only a short period in the year. Identification of the
female-produced sex pheromone was undertaken so that it can be used in monitoring and control of
the pest. Late larvae of C. pyrivora were removed from damaged fruitlets and reared in plastic tubes
individually. After sexing, volatiles were collected from both males and females by air entrainment.
Collections were analysed by gas chromatography (GC) coupled to electroantennographic (EAG)
recording from a male antenna, and by GC coupled to mass spectrometry (MS). Male midges showed
EAG responses to two components in collections of volatiles from female. The major and the minor
components were identified as 2,7-diacetoxyundecane and 7-acetoxy-2-undecanone respectively.
Stereoisomers of the synthetic pheromones were separated by HPLC on a chiral phase and the
racemates, individual stereoisomers and binary mixtures were evaluated in field trapping tests. Male
C. pyrivora were attracted to stereoisomer A of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane and to the first eluting
stereoisomer from HPLC fractionation of 7 acetoxy-2-undecanone and these are proposed to
be components of the female sex pheromone. However, results were confused by the presence of
at least one other midge species in the traps and the experiments will be repeated.
Key words: Contarinia pyrivora, pear midge, sex pheromone, electroantennography, traps
Introduction
Pear midge, Contarinia pyrivora (Riley) (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) is a pest of pear fruitlets,
causing crop loss in many countries including Europe, USA and Canada and China. In the UK
it is reported from every county except Scotland (Barnes, 1948). The overwintering pupae end
their pupal stage in mid March and the adults emerge through the soil when flower buds are in
pre-blooming stage. After mating, the females lay eggs (10-30) on buds and a few days later
the eggs hatch. The larvae emerge and start feeding on the fruit pulp and eventually form a
cavity. Attacked fruitlets grow rapidly and get noticeably rounder than normal ones. The
growth is arrested after two weeks and the blackened fruitlets crack and fall. Healthy fruitlets
in the same cluster get affected owing to immense competition for assimilation of nutrients
amongst damaged fruitlets (Barnes, 1948; Alford, 1984). The mature larva leaves the rotting
fruitlets and drops to the soil. It burrows a few centimetres into the soil and weaves a cocoon
in which it overwinters (Alford, 1984).
The pest has only one generation per annum, emergence occurring over a period of
about two weeks in March-April in the UK. C. pyrivora is normally controlled by application
of insecticide at the white bud flowering stage of pear trees when egg laying commences and
when the crop is susceptible to attack. However, different pear varieties reach the critical
growth stage at different times and the pest needs to be carefully monitored to determine
which crops are at risk. This study was carried out to identify the female sex pheromone of C.
322
pyrivora in order to provide a basis for development of improved monitoring and control
strategies.
Materials and methods
Insects
Fruitlets infested with C. pyrivora were collected from a pear orchard at Elmston Farm,
Preston, in Kent during early June 2006. On emergence, mature larvae were collected and
potted individually in tubes containing moistened paper towel. The tubes were stored outdoors
under natural conditions. In 2007, tubes containing pupated midges were incubated at 23°18°C and 16L:8D. Although over 3,000 larvae were collected, only 135 emerged as adults.
Pheromone collection
Newly-emerged midges were placed in a glass vessel (5.3 cm i.d. x 13 cm), and charcoalpurified air was drawn in from one end of the glass chamber and out through a Pasture pipette
(4 mm i.d.) containing Porapak Q (200 mg; 80-100 μm; Waters Associates Inc., USA) held
between two glass wool plugs. Volatiles trapped on the Porapak filters were extracted with
dichloromethane (1.5ml, pesticide grade; Fisher Scientific) and used in the analyses.
Electrophysiological recording
Male antennal responses to female volatiles were analysed by gas chromatography (GC)
linked to electroantennography (EAG) as described by Cork et al., 1990. The GC used was a
HP6890 instrument (Aglilent Technologies) with a flame ionisation detector and fused silica
capillary columns (30m x 0.32mm x 0.25µm film thickness) coated with polar (Supelcowax10, Supelco, USA) and non polar (SPB-1, Supelco, USA) phases. The oven temperature was
maintained at 50°C for 2 min, then programmed at 10°C/min to 250°C and held for 5 min.
Injection was splitless at 220°C and helium was used as carrier gas (2.4 ml/min).
EAG responses were recorded using a portable recoding unit (INR-2, Syntech, The
Netherlands) comprising integrated electrode holders and amplifier. Glass electrodes were
pulled and were filled with electrolyte (0.1 M solution of KCl with 1% polyvinylpyrrolidine).
The tips of the electrodes were broken off so that both antennae of the midge could be
inserted into the recording electrode and the abdomen inserted into the reference electrode.
Signals were amplified and analysed with EZChrom software (Elite v3.0).
Gas chromatograph linked to mass spectrometry
For analyses by GC coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) an HP6890 GC (Agilent
Technologies) and HP 5973 mass selective detector (Agilent Technologies) were used.
Injection was splitless (220°C) with fused capillary columns (30m x 0.25 mm i.d.) coated
with polar and non-polar phases as above. GC retention times were converted to Retention
Indices (RI) relative to those of acetate esters having even number of carbon atoms from 6-20.
HPLC separation of stereoisomers of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane and 7-acetoxyundecane-2-one
HPLC separations were carried out on a Chiralpak AD-H column (150 mm x 4.6 mm i.d.;
Daicel Chemical Industries Ltd.) with a pump (Jasco PU-2080 plus) and UV detector (Jasco
UV-2075 plus) at 210 nm. A volume of 10µl of a racemic mixture (1 mg/ml in hexane) was
separated at a time. The four stereoisomers of synthetic 2,7-diacetoxyundecane (A, B, C, D)
were separated using an isocratic solvent system of 0.5% isopropan-2-ol in hexane at 0.3
ml/min. In initial work isomers B and C were not resolved and were collected together (B+C).
Later, improvements in column conditioning made it possible to separate all four
stereoisomers. The two stereoisomers of synthetic 7-acetoxyundecane-2-one (1 and 2) were
separated by eluting with 1% isopropan-2-ol in hexane at 0.5 ml/min. The stereoisomers were
collected by hand separately into sample vials and quantified by gas chromatography.
323
Field tests
Field trapping tests were carried out with white delta traps (28 cm long × 20 cm sides;
Agrisense, Treforest, UK) HUNG AT 10 M INTERVALS APPROXIMATELY 1 M
ABOVE THE GROUND. The pheromone was dispensed from rubber septa (Z10,072-2;
Sigma Aldrich, Gillingham, UK).
In the first field test, two individual stereoisomers (A and D) and mixed isomers (B+C)
of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane and the two stereoisomers of 7-acetoxyundecane-2-one (1 and 2) at
4 μg loadings were tested alongside racemates of the major and minor components (16
μg/dispenser). The test was carried out at Elmstone Court and Mole End Farms near
Maidstone, Kent, UK, in early March, 2008. Traps were put in the field at the time when pear
buds were green. At each site, three replicates of each treatment were tested in a
RANDOMISED COMPLETE BLOCK DESIGN. TRAPS WERE MONITORED
WEEKLY FROM 4-25 MARCH 2008.
IN A Second field test the four stereoisomers of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane (A, B, C and D)
and the attractive isomer 1 of 7-acetoxyundecane-2-one (4 μg) and binary mixtures of isomers
A and D of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane A and D with 1 in 1:10 ratio (4 + 0.4 μg) were tested
against unbaited control traps. Four replicates were deployed at Elmstone Court and the traps
were monitored from 26 March - 1 April 2008.
Data were transformed to log (x+1) to fit the assumptions of homogeneity of analysis of
variance. The data were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA). If significant differences
(P < 0.05) among treatments were revealed by ANOVA, means were differentiated with the
least significant difference (LSD) test.
Results and discussion
Pheromone identification
0.00600
FID
4000
EAG
Retention Time
Name
0.00575
3500
0.00550
0.00525
3000
0.00475
2500
*
EAG millivolts
FIDVolts
0.00500
0.00450
2000
0.00425
0.00400
1500
0.00375
0.00350
*
12.6
12.8
13.0
13.2
13.4
13.6
13.8
14.0
14.2
14.4
Minutes
14.6
14.8
15.0
15.2
15.4
15.6
15.8
1000
16.0
Figure.1. GC-EAG analysis of volatile collections from female C. pyrivora with male EAG
preparations on non polar GC column. EAG responses are marked with *
Analysis of collections of volatiles from female C. pyrivora by GC-EAG showed two
responses from male midges (Figure 1). These responses were not observed in analyses of
324
collections from male midges. Results were consistent when the experiment was repeated
with the same or a different insect. On the polar column the responses appeared at RI 1477
and 1435 and on the non-polar column at RI 1311 and 1161. GC-MS traces of male and
female volatiles were compared and the active components at the corresponding RI’s were
present only in volatile collections from females and these compounds were assumed to be
components of the female sex pheromone.
The peaks responsible for the EAG responses were explored using the mass
fragmentation pattern and comparison of retention indices with a range of standard
compounds available at NRI. They were identified as 2,7-diacetoxyundecane and 7 acetoxy-2undecanone as the major and the minor components respectively. These two compounds were
synthesised in racemic form and the stereoisomers separated by HPLC on a chiral column.
Field tests
In the first field test, significant numbers of males of C. pyrivora were caught during the
period 13-19 March 2008 with much higher numbers at Mole End (Figure 2).
160
a
Mole End
Elmstone Court
140
Mean catch ± SE
120
100
ab
80
ab
60
b
40
20
c
c
c
c
0
A
B+C
D
1
2
major rac
minor rac
unbaited
Treatment
Figure 2. Mean numbers (± SE) of C. pyrivora males caught at Elmstone Court and Mole
End Farms, Maidstone, with HPLC separated stereoisomers of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane (A, D
and B+C), 7-acetoxyundecane-2-one (1 and 2) and the corresponding racemates (major rac
and minor rac) (13-19 March 2008; 3 replicates at each site; means followed by the same
letter are not significantly different (P>0.05))
Significantly more males were attracted to traps baited with the first and last eluting
stereoisomers of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane (A and D) and the first eluting isomer of 7 acetoxy-2undecanone (1) from the HPLC fractionations (ANOVA after transformation to log(x+1); F =
40.37, df = 7, 14, P < 0.001). Few male midges were attracted to the mixture of the second
and third eluting components of the major component (B+C) or to the second eluting isomer
of the minor component (2). Although the racemic mixture of the major component (major
rac) was unattractive, that of the minor component (minor rac) was not significantly less
attractive than the pure, first-eluting enantiomer (1).
In the second field test, stereoisomer A of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane again attracted male
325
C. pyrivora (ANOVA after transformation to log(x+1); F = 42.98, df = 7, 21, P < 0.001)
(Figure 3). However, in this test isomer C was equally attractive but D was much less
attractive. Traps baited with isomer B caught significantly fewer midges than unbaited traps,
which possibly explains the unattractiveness of the mixture of B+C in the first test.
Enantiomer 1 of the minor component, 7-acetoxy-2-undecanone, was significantly attractive,
although less attractive than A, as previously. Addition of minor component isomer 1 to
major component isomer A did not significantly increase the attractiveness of the latter.
250
a
Mean catch (±SE)
200
a
a
150
100
b
50
c
e
cd
d
D+1
unbaited
0
A
B
C
D
1
Treatment
A+1
Figure 3. Mean number (± SE) of C. pyrivora males caught at Elmstone Court with HPLC
separated stereoisomers of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane (A, B, C and D) and 7-acetoxyundecane-2one (1) and blends of A+1 and D+1 (26 March – 1 April 2008; 4 replicates; means followed
by the same letter are not significantly different (P>0.05)).
A third field trial was carried out from 13-17 April 2008 with the stereoisomers of the
major component, 2,7-diacetoxyundecane (A-D) and binary blends. All treatments caught
similar numbers of midges and closer examination of the catches revealed that at least one
other species was present in addition to C. pyrivora. These were identified as a species of
Resseliella (Keith Harris, personal communication).
In both field tests stereoisomer A of the major pheromone component, 2,7diacetoxyundecane, attracted significant numbers of male C. pyrivora midges. In the first test
stereoisomer D was also attractive, but not in the second test. Only a blend of B+C was
available in the first test and this was unattractive. In the second test these isomers were
tested separately and C was as attractive as A, while traps baited with B caught significantly
fewer than the unbaited trap. Most probably isomer B inhibits attraction and is responsible
for the unattractiveness of the blend of B+C and also the racemic mixture of all four isomers
of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane. In view of the possibility that at least one other species was being
caught in the traps, it is not possible to say whether isomers C and/or D are also attractive to
C. pyrivora. Interestingly, stereoisomer 1 of the minor component, 7-acetoxy-2-undecanone,
was also attractive to male C. pyrivora, although generally not as attractive as A. Moreover,
the racemic 7-acetoxy-2-undecanone was as attractive as isomer 1 with the other enantiomer 2
326
being neither attractive nor inhibitory.
2,7-diacetoxyundecane, has a structure similar to those of pheromone components in
other species of Contarinia, such as 2,12-diacetoxytridecane and 2,11-diacetoxytridecane in
the pea midge, C. pisi (Hillbur et al., 1999, 2000) and 2,10-diacetoxyundecane and 2,9diacetoxyundecane in the swede midge, C. nasturtii (Hillbur et al., 2005). The acetoxyketone,
7-acetoxy-2-undecanone, is an unusual structure previously only found in pheromones of two
other midge species, apple leaf midge, Dasineura mali (Hall and Cross, 2005, Cross and Hall,
2009, Cross et al., 2009) and raspberry cane midge, Resseliella theobaldi (Hall et al., 2009).
Although it is likely that stereoisomer A of 2,7-diacetoxyundecane and enantiomer 1 of
7-acetoxy-2-undecanone are components of the female sex pheromone of C. pyrivora, the
results of the field tests were probably confused by the presence of at least one other species
of midge in the traps, and the trapping experiments will be repeated with careful identification
of the species caught. Furthermore the absolute configurations of the stereoisomers of both
components separated by HPLC remain to be determined.
Acknowledgements
We thank UK Horticultural Development Council and the Worshipful Company of Fruiterers
for funding this work.
References
Alford, D. V. 1984. A Colour Atlas of fruit pests their recognition biology and control, Wolfe,
London, pp.104-111,
Barnes, H. F., 1948: Gall midges of economic Importance. Vol.III Gall midges of Fruit.
Crosby Lockwood, London.
Cork, A., Beevor, P.S., Gough, J.E. & Hall D.R. 1990. Gas chromatography linked to
electroantennography: a versatile technique for identifying insect semiochemicals. In:
Chromatography and isolation of insect Hormones and Pheromones. Eds. A.R.
McCaffery and I.D. Wilson, Plenum Press, London, pp 271-279.
Cross, J. V. & Hall, D. R. 2005. Pheromones. PCT/GB2005/002504.
Cross, J.V. and Hall, D.R. 2009. Exploitation of the sex pheromone of apple leaf midge
Dasineura mali Kieffer (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae): 1. Development of lure and trap.
Crop Protection, 28: 139-144.
Cross, J.V., Hall, D.R., Shaw, P. and Anfora, G. 2009. Exploitation of the sex pheromone of
apple leaf midge Dasineura mali Kieffer (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae): 2. Use of sex
pheromone trap for pest monitoring. Crop Protection, 28: 128-133.
Hall, D.R., Farman, D.I., Cross, J.V., Pope, T.W., Ando, T. and Yamamoto, M. 2009. (S)-2Acetoxy-5-undecanone, Female Sex Pheromone of Raspberry Cane Midge, Resseliella
theobaldi (Barnes). J. Chem Ecol. (in press).
Hillbur, Y., Anderson, P., Arn, H., Bengtsson, M. Löfqvist, J., Biddle, A.J., Smitt, O.,
Högberg, H. -E., Plass, E., Franke, S., & Francke, W. 1999. Identification of sex
pheromone components of the pea midge, Contarinia pisi (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae).
Naturwissenschaften 86:292–294.
Hillbur, Y., El-Sayed, A., Bengtsson, M., Löfqvist, J., Biddle, A., Plass, E., & Francke, W.
2000. Laboratory and field study of the attraction of male pea midges, Contarinia pisi,
to synthetic sex pheromone components. J. Chem. Ecol. 26:1941–1952.
Hillbur, Y., Celander, M., Baur, R., Rauscher, S., Haftmann, J., Franke, S., & Francke, W.
2005. Identification of the sex pheromone of the swede midge, Contarinia nasturtii. J.
Chem. Ecol. 31:1807–1828.
327
Raspberry beetle (Byturus tomentosus) flight monitoring and control
with semiochemical traps
Catherine A. Baroffio, Charly Mittaz
Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil ACW, Centre de recherche Conthey, 1964 Conthey,
Switzerland
Abstract: The raspberry beetle, Byturus tomentosus is a major pest of Swiss raspberries. In 2008, in
the frame of an international cooperation with UK, Norway and France the flight activity of the
raspberry beetle has been monitored for the first time in the Swiss Alps with the semiochemical trap
(floral attractant) and non-sticky funnel trap developed in Scotland by SCRI. Early results show an
irregular attractiveness of the trap. The traps were installed before flowering at the beginning of June
and were immediately attractive for 2 weeks. Then the catch of raspberry beetles decreased till end of
July. A second important flight activity pattern was observed at the end of July and at the beginning of
August. Fruit analysis showed that there was a gradient in the percentage of damaged fruits. Around
the traps the damage was about 1% but the average of the whole plot was 5% in one plot and 9% in the
second one with semiochemical traps. Neighbouring woods with wild Rubus sp. and other wild hosts
near the plot could explain high raspberry beetle populations. This monitoring will continue for three
years.
Key words: Byturus tomentosus, controlling, monitoring, raspberry, soft fruits,
Introduction
The raspberry beetle, Byturus tomentosus (Degeer) is a major pest of Swiss raspberries
especially in the higher altitudes (Antonin, 1984). Both adults and larvae cause damage
(Gordon & al, 1997, Schmid & al. 2006). The adults feed on raspberry and blackberry, more
rarely on Crateagus, apple and pear. Byturus tomentosus has 1 generation per year. There is a
demand for alternative methods to control pests without residues on fresh fruits. The Scottish
Crop Institute (SCRI) developed a new type of trap based on the raspberry flower volatiles
already tested in Scotland and Norway (Birch & al., 2009; Trandem & al., 2009). The aim of
this trial was to test this semiochemical trap in Swiss climatic conditions. The results after one
year are presented and discussed hereafter.
Material and methods
Flight activity monitoring in 2008 was conducted in two locations: Bruson (1060m alt.) and
Nendaz (1300m alt.), with 1 control plot and 2 trial plots. In the control plot in Bruson the
raspberry variety Zeva2 was uncovered (open field plantation) and unsprayed, with white
sticky traps (10/ha) used to monitor flight activity. In both trial plots the variety was Glen
Ample, uncovered and unsprayed. Semiochemical traps and white sticky traps were installed
in the trial plots at the stage 53 (flowers in buds) at the beginning of June: 4 traps in Bruson
and 11 traps in Nendaz with a concentration of 50 traps/ha for the semiochemical traps and
10/ha for the sticky traps.
During the harvest, fruits were scored for presence or absence of larvae. An average of 500
328
fruits was sampled per plot and per control date. An average of 10 fruits per trap (110 fruits
for 11 traps) was extra sampled in the area next to the 11 semiochemical traps. The results
around the traps, in the whole plot and in the control plot allowed analysis of the
semiochemical trap’s efficiency in monitoring flight activity.
Results and discussion
The semiochemical traps were attractive from the beginning of June during the two weeks
before flowering, between stage 53 and 60 (stage 53: flowers in buds; stage 60: first flowers
open). Then the catch decreased till end of July. At that time raspberries are fully flowering.
Raspberry beetles were more attracted to the flowers (Fig.1). A second important catch period
was observed at the end of July and at the beginning of August. During this period, the
raspberry flowering is over and the fruits are ripe. The stage 89 (first ripe fruits) was on the 15
of July.
10
semiochemical traps
Nr. of adults caught per trap
9
white sticky traps
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
09
30
.
09
17
.
9
3.
0
08
19
.
08
06
.
07
21
.
07
07
.
06
23
.
09
.
06
0
Figure 1. Number of adult Byturus caught per trap (semiochemical and white sticky trap) in
Nendaz in 2008. Average of 11 semiochemical traps and 2 white sticky traps.
The white sticky traps are attractive for a shorter period (7 out of 17 weeks) and to a lesser
extent than the semiochemical enhanced traps (Fig.1). The Nendaz plot showed a higher
attack of raspberry beetle (total catch/trap: 41) than the Bruson plot (total catch/trap: 24) but
both plots showed the same temporal flight activity patterns (Fig.2). In comparison the French
results show a different flight activity pattern. The French trial plots were in a warmer and
earlier flowering climate than the Swiss ones. The traps were attractive to raspberry beetles
only before flowering. There was not a second peak of activity in July and August like in
Switzerland (Rivière, 2008).
329
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
Nendaz
Bruson
5
09
30
.
09
17
.
9
3.
0
19
.
08
08
06
.
07
21
.
07
07
.
23
.
09
.
06
0
06
Adults cauught/trap cumulated
45
Figure 2. Cumulated number of adult Byturus caught per trap (semiochemical trap) in Nendaz
and Bruson in 2008. Average of 11 traps in Nendaz and 4 traps in Bruson
The average percentage of damaged fruits was 6.8% in the trial plot with semiochemical traps
and 9.4% in the control plot (Table 1). However, in the fruits sampled immediately around the
semiochemical traps the fruits were less attacked; the average was only 0.9%.
The traps efficiency could be improved with a better positioning of the semiochemical traps in
the plot. The trial 2009 will investigate this question.
Table 1. Damaged fruits in Bruson in % in the control plot (sticky traps), in the trial plot
(semiochemical traps) in the lines between the traps and in each area immediately around the
11 semiochemical traps.
Date
Control Bruson
(sticky traps)
25.07.08
28.07.08
04.08.08
10
11.5
5.2
Trial plot
Bruson (between
semiochemical
traps)
5.2
4.2
4.5
Around traps
Bruson (next to
semiochemical
traps
0.5
1.1
1.2
Conclusions
Semiochemical traps are useful for IPM in raspberries plantations in the mountains. The
semiochemical enhanced traps catch earlier, later and more target pests. A considerable
reduction of the damages on fruits was observed in Bruson compared to the control plot. The
positioning and the concentration (numbers/ha) of the traps must be further studied to reduce
further the amount of fruit damage throughout the plots. The aim of the further experiments is
to optimize the efficiency of the traps for monitoring and/or population reduction and to
define the damage threshold for this new type of trap compared with the standard white sticky
trap currently used in Switzerland.
330
Acknowledgements
We thank the grower in Nendaz P. Loye who let us work in his plot, AgriSense for providing
traps, Delphine Rivière, Cathy Eckert and Philippe Massardier for their advice and
experiences from France. Special thanks to Nina Trandem (Bioforsk) and Nick Birch (SCRI)
for their helpful advise throughout the season
References
Antonin, P. 1984: Le ver des framboises, Byturus tomentosus. Revue suisse Vitic. Arboric.
Hortic. 16: 103-105.
Birch, A.N.E., Gordon, S., Shepherd, T., Griffiths, W., Robertson, G. & Brennan, R. 2009:
Development of semiochemical attractants, lures and traps for raspberry beetle, Byturus
tomentosus at SCRI; from fundamental chemical ecology to testing IPM tools with
growers. IOBC/wprs Bulletin 41: 75-78.
Gordon, S.C., Woodford, J.A.T. & Birch, A.N.E. 1997: Arthropod pests of Rubus in Europe:
pest status, current and future control strategies. Journal of Horticultural Science 72:
831-862.
Rivière, D. 2008: Evaluation de l'impact technique de deux ravageurs de la framboise, la
cécidomyie de l'écorce, Resseliella theobaldi (Barnes) et le ver de la framboise, Byturus
tomentosus (De Geer). Approche de méthodes de lutte potentielle. Enita de ClermontFerrand, mémoire de fin d'étude.
Schmid, A., Hoehn, H., Schmid, K., Weibel, and F. & Daniel C. 2006: Effectiveness and side
effects of glue-traps to decrease damages caused by Byturus tomentosus in raspberry. J.
Pest. Sci 79: 137-142.
Trandem, N., Gordon, S., Birch, N., Ekeland, M. & Heiberg, N. 2009: Mass trapping of
raspberry beetle as a possible control method – pilot trial in Norway. IOBC Bulletin, in
Press.
331
Control of the Plum Fruit Moth, Grapholita funebrana (Treitsch.)
(Lepidoptera, Tortricidae), by false-trail following
Paola Riolo1, Roberto Bruni2, Cappella Luigi1, Rama Franco3 &Nunzio Isidoro1
1
Dipartimento di Scienze Ambientali e Produzioni Vegetali, Università Politecnica delle
Marche, Via Brecce Bianche, 60131 Ancona, Italy; 2IIS "C.Ulpiani", Viale della Repubblica
30, 63100 Ascoli Piceno, Italy; 3Isagro Ricerca s.r.l., Via Fauser 4, 28100 Novara, Italy.
Abstract: Grapholita funebrana (plum fruit moth) is a serious pest in many plum orchards in Italy.
Control of the plum fruit moth using the false-trail following technique or ‘sexual disorientation’ is here
evaluated in two commercial plum orchards for baby-food production, based on a zero pesticide residue
management system. The effectiveness of the false-trail following technique was demonstrated through
experimental trials over two seasons in two orchards located in the Ascoli Piceno Province of the Marche
Region (central-eastern Italy). Specific, biodegradable, pheromone dispensers, known as Ecodian CF™,
were used for each application, with about 2,000/ha. During 2005, three dispenser applications were
carried out, with two in 2006. The evaluation of this technique was through monitoring adult males by
specific synthetic sex pheromone traps and visual inspections for fruit damage. Anarsia lineatella (peach
twig borer), a secondary pest in plum orchards, was also monitored. The efficacy of Ecodian CF™
dispensers was compared with that achieved in commercial plum orchards sprayed with chemical
insecticides or managed with mating disruption techniques. Over the two seasons, the control of the
plum fruit moth in the experimental orchards was as good as or better than that in the check plots.
Key words: Grapholita funebrana, plum fruit, sex pheromone, false-trail following
Introduction
Grapholita funebrana Treitschke (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) (Plum Fruit Moth, PFM) is an
oligophagous species, feeding on the fruits of several hosts typically within the plant family
Rosaceae. PFM is the key pest of plum (Prunus spp.) in most parts of Europe. In Italy, it has
three generations per year (Molinari, 1994), while in many areas of central and eastern
Europe, it has one or two (Vernon, 1971).
Deregulation of many of the insecticides used in the control of this pest along with public
demand for residue-free products, increased the interest for innovative tools in pest
management. Behaviour-modifying pheromones can be used for environmentally safe insect
management and the technique has become one of the most important instruments for
controlling the main pest in the orchards. In the specific situation of plum fruit growing in the
Marche region (central eastern Italy) the main factors hindering its spread are the relatively
high price as compared to insecticide treatments, and additional pests that are partially
controlled by insecticide treatments but not by specific pheromone dispensers. Moreover, in
our conditions, most orchards cover areas of less than 2 ha.
Control of the PFM using the false-trail following technique or ‘sexual distraction’ is here
evaluated in plum orchards for baby-food production, based on a zero pesticide residue
management system. This technique consists of the setting up of several false trails, released
by dispensers loaded with low synthetic sex pheromone dosage, able to compete with those of
wild females and thus distract males in their search for partners (Maini and Accinelli, 2000).
332
This diversion of the male’s activities results in either a decrease in the proportion of mated
females or a delay in mating.
Material and methods
Ecodian CF™ dispenser release rate. During 2006, at every site, four field-aged dispensers
were collected every week and stored at -20°C. Then each dispenser was weighed, dissolved
in 20 ml of tetrahydrofurane containing n-hexadecanol as internal standard, and analysed by
gas chromatography.
Field tests. Experiments were carried out over a two year period (2005 and 2006), in two
commercial plum orchards (Prunus domestica cv Stanley) located in the Ascoli Piceno
Province of the Marche Region (central eastern Italy). Plum orchards were located in
Capodarco (43°11’27.47’’N, 13°45’40.00’’E) and Rubbianello (43°3’39.64’’N,
13°42’55.44’’E) districts. Each experimental orchard was about 1 hectare.
Specific, biodegradable, PFM synthetic sex pheromone dispensers, known as Ecodian
CF™, numbering 2000/ha for a total amount of 18 g. a.i./ha of Z8-dodecenyl acetate and
dodecyl acetate in 1:1 ratio, were used for each application. Two different application
protocols were used: during 2005, three dispenser applications were carried out (March 23-25,
May 16 and July 8-15) while only two dispenser applications were made in 2006 (April 20
and June 27) with the purpose of reducing application costs.
The evaluation of the technique efficacy included: (1) monitoring of specific synthetic
sex pheromone trap catches; (2) visual inspections on 500 fruits at five different locations per
orchards (10 fruits for 10 plum trees) and expresing damage caused by PMF larvae as the
proportion of attacked fruits.
The monitoring sex pheromone traps (Traptest® Isagro) were installed in the field on
March 18 during 2005 and on April 13 during 2006. Trap captures were checked weekly and
sex pheromone dispensers were replaced every 30 days.
The efficacy of Ecodian CF™ dispensers in reducing fruit damage was compared with
that achieved in nearby commercial plum orchards sprayed with conventional insecticides (C)
(ca. 0.80 ha) or managed with mating disruption techniques (MD) (ca. 1.50 ha).
Anarsia lineatella Zeller (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) (Peach Twig Borer, PTB), a
secondary pest in plum orchards, was also monitored.
Results and discussion
Ecodian CF™ dispenser release rate. The pheromone emission significantly decreased over
the field-ageing period. During the first month of ageing, maybe due to air temperature, the
release rate of dispensers placed in the field at the beginning of the summer decreased more
quickly than that of dispensers placed in the field in spring. In the climate conditions of the
Marche region the life time of the dispensers was at least 75-80 days for the first application
(Figure 1).
333
Pheromone rate in the field-aged dispensers
100%
I^ application
90%
II^ application
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Days
Figure 1. Synthetic sex pheromone release rate in the field-aged Ecodian CF™ dispensers,
Capodarco site. The first application was made on April 20 and the second on June 26 2006.
Field experiments. The field trials confirmed the efficacy of the Ecodian dispensers for PFM
control. Over the 2-year study period, in the Ecodian treated plots the percentage of fruit
damage recorded was lower than that in the reference plots. Damage caused by PTB larvae
was also low in the Ecodian treated plots (Table 1).
In the field trials carried out in 2005 and 2006, the Ecodian treatment strongly inhibited
PMF male capture in the sex pheromone traps (Figure 2). The reduction in attraction of sex
pheromone traps, in comparison with catches in neighbouring areas, is considered one of the
easiest tests to indirectly evaluate the efficacy of pheromone based control methods
(Charmillot, 1992).
Three peaks of captures were recorded for G. funebrana in the control plots (Figure 2) and
two for A. lineatella (middle May and end July) in the Capodarco Ecodian treated plot while in
the other site the presence of PTB males in the trap was very low (data not shown).
Table 1. Percentage of fruit damaged by PFM and PTB larvae in the different treatments.
FTFC=false trail following-Capodarco, MDC=mating disruption-Capodarco, FTFR=false trail
following-Rubbianello, CR=conventional insecticides–Rubbianello, - no visual inspection. * On
July 25 a hail storm destroyed over 96% of fruit production.
FTFC
Date
2005-06-02
2005-07-30
2005-08-19
2006-07-16
2006-08-20
PFM
0
0
0.4
0
0
PTB
0
0.2
0.4
0
0.2
MDC
PFM
0.8
0.3
PTB
0.2
0.4
FTFR
PFM
0
0.2
0
0
0
PTB
0
0
0
0
0.1
CR
PFM
0
-*
-*
3
PTB
0
-*
-*
4
Our field trials showed that with Ecodian dispensers, PFM can be controlled effectively
under the climatic conditions of the Ascoli Piceno Province, confirming the results obtained in
other areas (Molinari et al., 2000). Moreover our data suggest that the false trail following
technique may be a feasible way for plum fruit moth control in the plum growing areas of the
334
Average number of PMF males
CR
MDC
FTFR
FTFC
FTFR
FTFC
7/5
4/6
21/5
2/7
18/6
30/7
16/7
28/8
CR
60
56
52
48
44
40
36
32
28
24
20
16
12
8
4
0
PMF trap captures, 2006 year
13/4
23/4
60
56
52
48
44
40
36
32
28
24
20
16
12
8
4
0
13/8
20/5
25/3
9/4
22/4
7/5
17/6
2/6
15/7
1/6
13/8
30/7
MDC
PMF trap captures, 2005 year
Average number of PMF males
Marche region and that, in some conditions, it is possible to use only two Ecodian dispenser
applications with a large reduction of the technique costs.
Figure 2. Trap captures of G. funebrana (PMF) in the different treatments. FTFC=false trail
following-Capodarco; FTFR=false trail following-Rubbianello; MDC=mating disruptionCapodarco; CR=conventional insecticides–Rubbianello.
The peculiar mode of action of the false-trail following method (low pheromone dosage
coupled with high efficacy in small plot size) as well as the possibility to use only two
Ecodian dispenser applications for the control of G. funebrana open new opportunities for a
widespread use of this pheromone based strategy for plum pest control.
Acknowledgements
We are greatly indebted to Provino Murri, Giorgio Murri, Umberto Santoni and Carlo Rosati for
allowing us to make the observations in their orchards and for assistance in data recording and to
G. Caricato, P. Ruggiero and M. Pizzi for their support and help in the work.
References
Charmillot, P. J. 1992: Mating disruption technique to control grape and wine moths: general
considerations. IOBC/WPRS Bulletin 15: 113–116.
Maini, S., Accinelli, G. 2000: Mating disruption-confusion method and sexual distraction:
comparison among different dispenser types for Cydia molesta (Busck) (Lepidoptera:
Tortricidae), Bollettino dell’Istituto di Entomologia “G. Grandi” dell’Università degli Studi
di Bologna 54: 113-122.
Molinari, F. 1994: Notes on biology and monitoring of Cydia funebrana. Bulletin OILB/SROP
18 (2): 39-42.
Molinari, F. Cravedi, P. Rama, F. Reggiori, F. Dal Pane, M. Galassi, T. 2000: L’uso dei
feromoni secondo il metodo del “disorientamento” nella difesa del pesco da Cydia
molesta e Anarsia lineatella. Atti Giornate Fitopatologiche (1): 341–348.
Vernon, J. D. R., 1971: Observations on the Biology and Control of the Plum Fruit Moth. Plant
Pathology 20: 106-120.
335
Eight years of practical experience with mating disruption to control
grape berry moth, Lobesia botrana, in Porto Wine Region
Cristina Carlos 1, Fernando Alves1, Laura Torres2
(1)
Associação para o Desenvolvimento da Viticultura Duriense (ADVID). Qta de Sta Maria •
Godim • P.O. Box 137• 5050-106 Peso da Régua. Portugal. (cristina.carlos@advid.pt);
(2)
CITAB – Centre for the Research and Technology of Agro-Environment and Biological
Sciences, University of Trás-os-Montes and Alto Douro, 5001-801, Vila Real, Portugal
(ltorres@utad.pt)
Abstract: Since 2000 the mating disruption technique has been applied to control Lobesia botrana
(Den. & Schiff.) in the Porto Wine Region. ISONET-L dispensers have been used in plots whose
surface ranged from 3.0 to 25.0 ha. The average percentage of male disorientation for the 8-year
experimental period ranged from 80.5 to 100%, being 100% in 55.5% of the 72 sampling periods
studied. However, the rate of reduction obtained in larval infestation by the pest, even in favourable
conditions (large areas and continuous application), was variable. Some constraints to the technique
have been identified, such as the high biotic potential of the species, the high summer temperatures
and the local orography (high steepness). In this paper, the results are critically discussed and weak
spots are analyzed, as a basis for identifying the real possibilities of the technique in the Porto Wine
Region.
Key words: viticulture, pest management, sex pheromone, ISONET-L dispensers
Introduction
Lobesia botrana (Den. & Schiff.) is a key pest in the Porto Wine Region (PWR), where
considerable losses are being registered, mainly during recent years. In this region, the moth
has three flight periods a year, between the middle of March to the middle of October. Public
demand for residue-free products, have augmented the interest for innovative tools to control
the pest. The mating disruption (MD) technique, which was registered in Portugal for L.
botrana in 2002, seems to be a good alternative to insecticide applications against this
species. In this paper, results obtained with mating disruption to control L. botrana during an
8-year period are critically discussed and weak spots are analyzed, as a basis for identifying
the real possibilities of its use in the Porto Wine Region.
Material and methods
Vineyards
The experiments were carried out from 2000 to 2007 in commercial vineyards located in
PWR (Table 1). Typical vineyards in this region are fragmented into plots of variable size
shape, orientation and varieties. The experimental vineyards were grown on slopes ranging
from 30-50% (in either small terraces or vertically planted rows), had a surface ranging from
3.0 to 25.0 ha and were planted with several varieties (mainly Touriga Franca, Touriga
Nacional, Tinta Barroca and Tinta Roriz).
336
Type and density of dispensers
Pheromone dispensers ISONET-L from SHIN-ETSU Chemical Co., Ltd. with 172 mg (E,Z912:Ac) were installed during March, before the beginning of the first flight period at a density
of 500-700 ha-1, depending on the experimental site (surface, steepness, winds), with a
reinforcement of 10-20% in the 15-20 m of the border and in the top of the hills.
Table 1 − General information about the experimental work carried
Year
Wine-farm
2000
2001
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2005
2006
2006
2006
2007
2007
Seara d'ordens
Seara d'ordens
S. Luíz
S. Luíz
S. Luíz
S. Luíz
D. Matilde
Vallado
Vallado
D. Matilde
Cidrô
Vallado
Cidrô
Surface (ha)
4.0
4.0
3.0
25.0
15.0
16.2
7.1
11.8
11.8
7.1
15.2
19.7
16.7
Altitude
Dispensers/ ha Date of installation
(m)
440
500
13-Mar
440
500
19-Mar
210
650
12-Mar
210
560
19-Mar
210
600
21-Mar
210
560
12-Mar
200
630
23-Mar
150
660
23-Mar
150
700
21-Mar
200
630
22-Mar
610
585
20-Mar
150
560
21-Mar
610
600
20-Mar
Evolution of pheromones in the dispensers
The active ingredient in the dispensers was calculated by collecting samples of 10 dispensers
monthly from March to September, in 2000, 2002 and 2006.
Evaluation of MD efficacy
MD efficacy was evaluated by comparing either pheromone-baited trap catches or grape
infestation, between treated and untreated plots, at a number of “inspection stations” per plot,
depending on plot surface. Pheromone delta traps (AgriSense BCS Ltd.) were installed in the
centre of each plot (control and pheromone-treated plot) and, in some years, also in the border
zones. Afterwards, the percentage of male disorientation was calculated for each weekly
trapping interval. Grape infestation was assessed by inspecting samples of 100 randomly
collected inflorescences or grapes, according to the season, during each of the three
generations of the insect. In addition a sample of 50 to 100 grapes was collected at harvest
and dissected to look for larvae. In the first generation the level of infestation was expressed
as the number of nests per 100 inflorescences, while in the second and in the third generations
it was expressed as the percentage of grapes with at least one berry infested. The total number
of inflorescences plus grapes examined per plot/year was between 1600 and 15, 400
depending on the plot size and the year. Results are expressed as the percentage reduction of
infestation in the MD plot compared with the control for each generation and also at harvest.
Each time the treatment threshold was surpassed a curative insecticide treatment was applied
with either an insect growth regulator or Bacillus thuringiensis, mainly in the second and the
third generations.
337
Results and discussion
Evolution of pheromones in the dispensers
During the three years, the release of pheromone was almost linear from the period when the
dispensers were installed (in the middle of March) until the beginning/middle of August.
During this period the dispensers released about 80% of the pheromone, in 2000 and 2006,
and as much as 93%, in 2002. These results are in accordance with those reported by Moschos
et al. (2004) in Greece, who found that if the temperatures are high during the preceding
period, little pheromone is left in the dispensers during the crucial period of the third
generation -- August in PWR.
MD efficacy
The average percentage of male disorientation for the 8-year period ranged from 80.5 to
100%, achieving 100% in 55.5% of the 72 sampling periods studied, which suggests that
treatment with pheromone almost completely prevented male moths from locating sources of
synthetic sex pheromone. As expected, poor results in the reduction of L. botrana larval
density were obtained in small plots, such as in the Seara d´ordens farm, in both years and in
S. Luiz, in 2001 (Table 2). According to Stockel & Chichignoud (1994), the MD area should
have a minimal of 10 hectares, to avoid the migration of mated females from the neighbouring
vineyards into the MD treated vineyards. In the plots were the technique was applied in more
favourable conditions (larger areas and continuous application), namely the S. Luiz and
Vallado farms, its efficacy in the reduction of L. botrana larval density was variable (Tables 2
and 3), suggesting that other constraints have been involved in this efficacy. The early
exhaustion of the pheromone in the dispensers, related to high temperatures registered during
summer in the region, could be one of the main reasons of the method’s failure, mainly as the
grapevine moth has a long flight period in the region (about 29 weeks, which lasts from
middle March to middle October) (Carlos et al., 2008). However, it must be noted that high
temperatures, such as those that occurred in 2002, 2005 and 2006, could also have hampered
the development of the third generation of the insect, leading to a low infestation level. On the
contrary, when weather conditions are favourable, a high biotic potential could be reached,
leading to high population densities, which enhances the probability of mating even in a
pheromone environment and reduces the effectiveness of MD (Louis & Schirra, 2001;
Moschos et al., 2004).
Table 2. Infestation level (1) by Lobesia botrana and infestation reduction (%) at S. Luiz farm
Year /Generation Control MD interior
2001 1stnd
28
4
2rd
9*
1*
31*
13
3
Harvest
47
55
2002 1stnd
36
13*
2rd
11*
3*
3
6*
2
Harvest
5
3
2003 1stnd
31
5
2rd
13
4
1
0
3
Harvest
52
10
2004 1stnd
71
3
2
47
17
Infestation
red. (%) MD border
86
4
89
1
58
13
0
39
64
18*
73
10*
67
3*
40
1
84
9
69
4
100
1
81
33
96
5
64
15
338
Infestation
red. (%)
86
89
58
17
50
9
50
80
71
69
0
37
93
68
(1)
3rd
Harvest
7*
66
0*
26
100
61
st
2*
53
79
20
expressed as the number of nests/100 inflorescences in the 1 generation, and as the percentage of grape
bunches with at least one berry infested, in the 2nd and the 3rd generations, as well as at harvest. * Plot sprayed
Table 3. Infestation level by Lobesia botrana and infestation reduction (%) at Vallado farm
Year /Generation Control
2005 1stnd
23*
2rd
31*
4
3
Harvest
4
2006 1stnd.
13
2rd
22
2
3
Harvest
6
2007 1stnd
11
2rd
20*
11
3
Harvest
66
(1)
MD
Infestation red.
interior (%)
MD border
4
83
15*
1
97
10*
1
75
4
2
50
11
1
92
5*
3
86
8*
2
0
18
0
100
5
9*
18
15*
0*
100
7*
4*
64
10*
2
97
33
st
Infestation
red. (%)
35
68
0
0
62
64
0
17
0
65
9
50
expressed as the number of nests/100 inflorescences in the 1 generation, and as the percentage of grape
bunches with at least one berry infested, in the 2nd and the 3rd generations, as well as at harvest. * Plot sprayed
The poor results obtained with MD could also be attributable to a deficient distribution of
the pheromone cloud in the vineyards, due to either its high gradient or the presence of
laneways bordered by olive/almond trees around the plots.
In conclusion, the experience with MD at PWR have demonstrated that to effectively
control L. botrana in years of high pest pressure, the technique has to be combined with
insecticides, at least for the third generation. The solution proposed by Moschos et al. (2004):
a second deployment of dispensers just before the beginning of the third flight period, will
greatly increase the costs of the technique, which are already high (around 200 € / ha for MD,
compared with 75-90 € / ha, for an insecticide treatment).
Acknowledgements
Thanks are due to: wine-growers associated to ADVID (Sogevinus Vinhos S.A. Companhia
Geral da Agricultura das vinhas do Alto Douro. Quinta do Vallado Soc. Agr. Lda. Quinta D.
Matilde - vinhos Lda and Soc. Agrícola Quinta da Seara D'ordens Lda.) who made their
vineyards available for the experiments. To Sogevinus Vinhos S.A., CBC (Europe Ltd.) and
Shin-Etsu Chemical Co., Ltd., for supplying the pheromone dispensers. To all ADVID
colleagues, mainly to Jorge Costa and Branca Teixeira for technical support.
References
Carlos, C., Teixeira, B.R.A., Alves, F. & Torres, L. 2008. Análise da curva de voo da traça-dauva, Lobesia botrana (Den. & Schiff.), na Região Demarcada do Douro, em função das somas
de temperaturas. I Congresso Nacional de Produção Integrada / VIII Encontro Nacional de
Protecção Integrada. ESA Ponte de Lima, 20 e 21 de Novembro de 2008. 263-271.
Louis, F. & Schirra, K.J. 2001. Mating disruption of Lobesia botrana (Lepidoptera:
Tortricidae) in vineyards with very high population densities. IOBC wprs Bulletin 24 (2):
339
75-79.
Moschos, T., Souliotis, C., Broumas, T. & Kapothanassi, V. 2004. Control of the European
Grapevine Moth Lobesia botrana in Greece by the mating disruption technique: a threeyear survey. Phytoparasitica 32 (1): 83-96.
Stockel, J. and Chichignoud, C. (1994). La confusion sexuelle contre les tordeuses de la vigne
Lobesia botrana De. & Shiff.. Eupoecilia ambiguella Hb. Vers une nouvelle stratégie de
lutte. Progrés Agricole et Viticole. 111. 15-16
340
Use of Sprayable Pheromone Formulations in Europe.
Enzo Casagrande
AgriSense BCS, Treforest Industrial Estate, Pontypridd CF37 5SU, U.K.
E-mail: enzo.casagrande@agrisense.co.uk
Abstract: Sprayable formulations of pheromones for the mating disruption control of different moth
species offers an innovative alternative to the use of the current dispenser based technologies. While
still assuring the same efficacy as the dispenser systems, the sprayables offer greater flexibility and
ease of use. Applied using standard spray equipment, the sprayables can be combined with other
treatments. The paper will review the technology, efficacy and use strategies of the Checkmate
sprayable technology in Europe.
Key words: Pheromone, mating disruption, sprayable, Checkmate.
Introduction
Sprayable formulations of pheromones for the mating disruption control of different moth
species offers an innovative alternative to the use of the current dispenser based technologies.
While still assuring the same efficacy as the dispenser systems, the Checkmate Flow range
offers greater flexibility and ease of use. Applied using standard spray equipment, the
sprayables can be combined with other treatments. The large number of small pheromone
emission points provides the crop with complete pheromone coverage over the entire crop.
Formulation technology
Encapsulated formulations can contain one or more active pheromones of the insect pest. The
pheromone is contained within the central lumen of the capsule and is released through the
semi-permeable walls over the required time.
Product Range
Microencapsulation technology has been developed for a wide range of pheromones and
pests. Table 1 provides a list of the formulations currently available in Europe.
Table 1. Characteristics of sprayable pheromone formulations available in Europe
Product
Presentation Application Rate
Crop
CheckMate CM-F * #
14.3% a.i.
90ml/ha/15 days
Apples/Pears/Walnuts
(Laspeyresia pomonella) 739ml bottle 180ml/ha/28 days
CheckMate OFM-F *
23.6% a.i.
45ml/ha/15 days
Peaches/Nectarines/
390ml bottle 90ml/ha/28 days
Apples
(Grapholitha molesta)
CheckMate PTB-F
17.89% a.i.
145ml/ha/30 days
Peaches/Nectarines/
461ml bottle
Apricots
(Anarsia lineatella)
CheckMate BAW-F
17.14% a.i.
175ml/ha/30 days
Vegetables
477ml bottle
(Spodoptera exigua)
341
22.00%
CheckMate (Plutella
DBM-F
xylostella) a.i.
449ml
bottle
33ml/ha/30 Crucifers
days
* Registered in Italy
# Registration pending in France
Registrations being submitted in Spain for all
Product Application
The formulations are designed for application using conventional spray equipment. They are
compatible with most other treatments and are therefore easy to tank mix with other products
with a minimum of precautions. This also facilitates their integration with either conventional
insecticides or pheromone dispenser products at different times of the season.
The product can offer either season long control, applying treatments at specific
intervals, or can be timed with different insect generations to complement other control
strategies.
Typical efficacy
The products have been tested over a wide range of conditions over the years. Trials have
demonstrated that the sprayable formulations offer the same or better performance as the
dispenser based technologies.
Various application strategies have been tested with the products applied at different
doses and corresponding intervals. The products can be applied from a low rate at 15 day
intervals to a high rate at 28 days without compromising performance.
Rainfastness
Rainfastness was measured by using a specially made UV fluorescing marked variant of the
Checkmate CM–F formulation. Orchard trees were treated using a conventional sprayer at
higher rates 8-10 times standard field application rate. Leaves were collected and exposed
under artificial rain regimes simulating different rain intensities. A photo camera connected to
a computer with software able to detect the marked capsules counts them on the treated
surface.
The results show that the wash off caused by increasing rain intensity over 60 minutes
led to about 15% wash off at 10mm per hour increasing linearly to 60% wash off at a very
heavy down pour of 40mm per hour. Measuring wash off over a 30 minute interval confirmed
that most of the wash off occurs in the first 30 minutes with. At any given rain intensity, over
three quarters of lost material was removed in the first half hour.
As part of the same experiment the distribution of the formulation on the trees was
assessed. The data confirm the relative distribution of the pheromone capsules on the different
surfaces of the leaves. Using normal spray equipment the study confirmed that the majority of
the pheromone capsules are deposited on the lower surface of the leaves. Using a 10x
standard application rate an average of 47 capsules were found on the lower leaf surface
compared to 12 capsules on the upper leaf surface. The good rainfastness of the product is
probably correlated to the deposition pattern of the microcapsules; the capsules landing on the
upper surface would be easily removed by rain while those on the lower surface would be
protected and more difficult to remove.
CM-F shows good rainfastness under conditions of these trials with circa 50% remaining
even under the most severe conditions. There is a clear correlation between rain intensity and
fastness. Indications are that most of wash off occurs quickly with increasing duration of rain
342
having lesser effects. The good persistence is possibly a correlation between persistence and
deposition pattern with most of lost capsules likely to be those deposited on top of leaves.
Conclusions
The Checkmate Flow formulations offer an innovative alternative for the control of a range of
agricultural pests giving greater flexibility and ease of use compared to other systems. With
the same or better efficacy than other pheromone technologies and application with
conventional spray equipment, the Flows offer easy and flexible integration with other pest
management strategies. Applied at the higher rates, the formulations will last up to 4 weeks
but often the simpler approach has been to use lower rates at shorter intervals integrating them
with other orchard treatments and at the same time minimizing any adverse effects of rains or
bad weather on the performance of the product.
Acknowledgements
I wish to acknowledge the contribution of the following collaborators;
Paolo Balsari and Paolo Marucco, Università di Torino, Grugliasco, Italy.
A. Galliano, Asprofrut, Piemonte, Italy
Gino Angeli and Mario Baldesari, Istituto Agrario San Michele all'Adige, Italy
Stefano Caruso, Consorzio Fitosanitario Provinciale di Modena, Italy
343
Cells responding to pheromone components and plant volatiles could
affect semiochemical based control strategies of insect pests in
agricultural ecosystems
Antonio De Cristofaro1, Gianfranco Anfora2, Giacinto Salvatore Germinara1, Claudio
Ioriatti2,Valerio Mazzoni2, Giuseppe Rotundo1
1 Dept. of Animal, Plant and Environmental Sciences, University of Molise, Via De Sanctis, I86100 Campobasso, Italy; 2 Plant Protection Department, IASMA Research Centre, Via E.
Mach 1, I-38010 S. Michele a/A (TN), Italy
Abstract: Electrophysiological and behavioural responses by several insect pests have been recently
recorded in order to identify plant volatile compounds, and particularly kairomones, involved in the
host-finding process and oviposition site selection. Such compounds have been addressed as
candidates to be used in semiochemical based control strategies since they are potentially able either to
enhance the sex pheromone activity or to monitor female emergence or to interfere on their behaviour.
During similar studies, olfactory cells sensitive both to pheromone components and plant volatiles in
Cydia pomonella antennae were described. In the present paper we analysed single cell recordings
(SCR, surface contact technique) from olfactory neurons of different tortricid moths (C. pomonella, C.
splendana, C. fagiglandana, Pammene fasciana, Lobesia botrana) stimulated by the two categories of
compounds. Cellular types varying from the specific (relatively to the tested compounds) to the highly
generalist ones were identified. The finding of these cells partly supports the observations reported by
various authors about the ability of plant compounds to modulate the biological activity of a
pheromone component. It seems not inappropriate to hypothesize that these “peripheral interferences”
in odour perception could culminate in changeable behavioural responses that should also be of
practical importance when pheromone based control strategies are applied in different agricultural
environments, where they frequently show a variable efficiency.
Kairomones, Olfactory neurons, SCR, Fruit crops, IPM
344
Combining pear ester with codlemone improves management of
codling moth
Alan Knight 1, Janet Haworth 2, Bill Lingren 2, and Vince Hebert 3
1
Agricultural Research Service, U.S.D.A., Wapato, WA;
2
Trécé Inc., Adair, OK;
3
Food and Environ. Quality Lab., Washington State University, Richland, WA.
Abstract: Several management approaches utilizing pear ester combined with codlemone have been
developed in the first 10 years after the discovery of this ripe pear fruit volatile’s kairomonal activity
for larvae and both sexes of codling moth. These include a lure that consistently outperforms other
high load pheromone lures within pheromone-treated orchards, and the use of a microencapsulated
formulation that can improve both mating disruption and the effectiveness of insecticide sprays. Field
studies demonstrating the effectiveness of combining pear ester with codlemone are presented.
Key words: Cydia pomonella, monitoring, mating disruption, apple
Introduction
The adoption of technology utlizing the sex pheromone (codlemone) of codling moth, Cydia
pomonella (L.), for mating disruption (MD) has increased dramatically in recent years
(Witzgall et al. 2008). These tactics have been effective in allowing growers to significantly
reduce their use of insecticides (Knight 2007). However, pest abundance remains a key factor
limting the effectiveness of MD and management programs must still integrate pheromone
use with an array of insecticide sprays when populations exceed thresholds.
Pear ester is a potent karimone attractant for codling moth and action thresholds based on
total and female moth catches in pear ester-baited traps have been developed (Knight and
Light 2005). However, growers using MD in Washington State have widely adopted a combo
lure (Pherocon CM-DA Combo, Trécé Inc., Adair, OK) that is loaded with both pear ester and
codlemone. The use of the two attractants together synergizes the catch of male but not female
moths (Knight et al. 2005). The emission characterisitics and attractiveness of field aged
Combo lures have not previously been reported.
A micro-encapsulated (MEC) formulation of pear ester (DA-MEC, Trécé Inc.) has been
developed and has been effective in improving the performance of insecticides, such as
granulosis virus (Arthurs et al. 2007, Schmidt et al. 2008), and several synthetic insecticides
(Light and Bouyssounouse 2006). DA-MEC has also been evaluated when used alone and in
combination with a MEC pheromone formulation for MD of codling moth in apple and
walnut (Light and Knight 2005). Whether growers can enhance both larval control with
insecticides and pheromone-based MD at the same time with the additional use of DA-MEC
has not previously been considered. Hand-applied dispensers, by a large margin, are the
mostly widely used MD technique (Witzgall et al. 2008). Therefore, seasonal management
programs which add DA-MEC to a series of insecticide and other sprays during the season in
orchards treated with hand-applied dispensers should first be evaluated with this combined
approach.
345
Material and methods
The attractiveness and emission rate of field-aged Pherocon CM-DA Combo lures
Delta traps were divided into two groups ’new’ and ’old’ (n = 10) and baited with Pherocon
CM-DA Combo lures pinned to the inner roof of traps on 28 June 2006. Traps were randomly
spaced 10 m apart in an unsprayed apple orchard. Each week for 10 wks traps were checked,
lures in ’new’ traps were replaced, and traps were re-randomized. Analysis of variance
(ANOVA) with lure type and week as the main factors were conducted with transformed
(square-root) data.
Pherocon CM-DA Combo lures were field-aged inside delta-shaped traps in an apple
orchard from 30 August – 19 October. Lures (n = 3) were collected on day 0 and after 7, 14,
21, 28, and 50 d. Volatile captures onto a polyurethane foam sorbent were run for 2 h with an
airflow of 5L/min using the methods reported by Tomaszewska et al. (2005). Analyses were
conducted with GC/MS using an Alltech EC-Wax column. Recovery of the internal standard,
myristic acid averaged 106.2%. Lure emission rates (mg) are reported per 24 h.
Adding DA-MEC to pheromone-dispenser and insecticide-treated programs
Quadrants (0.2 – 0.4 ha) were established in two apple orchards in 2008. Four treatments were
randomly assigned to each orchard quadrant and included: the use of five insecticide sprays
alone (three sprays of acetamiprid [0.25 kg / 935 L ha -1] followed by two sprays of
spinetoram [0.49 kg / 935 L ha -1] timed 17 d apart and applied with an air-blast sprayer), the
same insecticide sprays but with the addition of 30 ml DA-MEC added per ha, the same
insecticides plus the use of Cidetrak CM pheromone dispensers (Trécé Inc.) applied at 1,000
per hectare, and the same insecticides applied with DA-MEC and the use of Cidetrak CM
pheromone dispensers. Each plot was monitored with a delta trap baited with a Pherocon CMDA Combo lure and fruit injury was sampled prior to harvest (1,200 fruits per plot).
Transformed data were tested with ANOVA.
Results
The attractiveness and emission rate of field-aged Pherocon CM-DA Combo lures
Field-aged lures caught significantly fewer moths than new Combo lures over the 10-wk
study, F 1, 280 = 26.78, P < 0.0001 (Fig. 1). This difference was most pronounced for lures > 2
Combo new lure
Combo aged lure
Moth catch per trap
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Weeks
Figure 1. Comparison of the attractiveness of new
and field-aged Pherocon CM-DA Combo lures.
wks-old. Combo lures released a much higher rate of pear ester than codlemone (Fig. 2).
346
Emission rates of both compounds declined sharply over 14 d and then remained fairly
constant for lures aged 21 - 50 d.
Mg released per day
Pear ester
Codlemone
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
7
14
21
28
50
Days aged in field
Figure 2. Emission rate of pear ester and codlemone
from Pherocon CM-DA Combo lures aged in the field.
Adding DA-MEC to pheromone-dispenser and insecticide-treated programs.
Mean cumulative moth catch per trap and fruit injury both varied significantly among
treatments (Table 1). Pheromone treatments had significantly lower moth catch than the
insecticide only treatment. The use of DA-MEC had a noticeable but not significant effect on
moth catch. The addition of both MD and DA-MEC significantly reduced fruit injury and
plots treated with the combination of both had the lowest level of injury.
Table 1. Seasonal comparison of moth catch and fruit injury
Mean (SE)
Mean (SE) % fruit
Treatment
moth catch
injury
Insecticide
378.5 (2.5)a
10.6 (0.6)a
Insecticide + DA-MEC
225.5 (72.5)ab
3.5 (0.2)c
Insecticide +
131.5 (0.5)b
6.9 (0.6)b
pheromone dispensers
Insecticide + DA-MEC +
87.0 (10.0)b
1.3 (0.0)d
pheromone dispensers
ANOVA: df = 3,7
F = 12.44, P < 0.05 F = 141.0, P < 0.001
Discussion
Pear ester has proven to be a very attractive plant-derived volatile for codling moth,
influencing both larval and adult behaviors (Light et al. 2001, Knight & Light 2001). Pear
ester when used in combination with codlemone has helped to create new and more effective
monitoring and management tools. Future work is focused on developing new action
thresholds using the combo lure and with the use of pear ester in combination with acetic acid
(Landolt et al. 2007). The addition of DA-MEC with various insecticides has suggested that
pear ester can improve control of codling moth, especially with insecticides that are active via
residual contact (Light & Bouyssounouse 2006). Pear ester can also be added to pheromone in
combo dispensers to improve MD (Light & Knight 2005). Further evaluations of seasonal
347
management programs in which pear ester is added regularly to all insecticide sprays in MD
orchards are needed to more fully assess the novel characteristics of this compound.
Acknowledgements
We thank Duane Larson, Brad Christianson, and Chey Temple for their help in conducting these
studies. Jane LePage conducted the lure analyses. Also, special thanks to Randy Brown and
Kelly Zer for their cooperation in using their orchards.
References
Arthurs, S.P., Hilton, R., Knight, A.L., & Lacey, L.A. 2007: Evaluation of the pear ester
kairomone as a formulation additive for the granulovirus of codling moth, Cydia
pomonella (L.) in pome fruits. J. Econ. Entomol. 100: 702-709.
Knight, A.L. 2007: Codling moth areawide IPM. In: Areawide pest management: theory and
implementation, eds. Koul, Cuperius and Elliot: 159-190.
Knight, A.L. & Light, D.M. 2001. Attractants from Bartlett pear for codling moth, Cydia
pomonella (L.), larvae. Naturwissenschaften 88: 339-342.
Knight, A. L. & Light, D.M. 2005: Developing action thresholds for codling moth
(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) with pear ester- and codlemone-baited traps in apple orchards
treated with sex pheromone mating disruption. Can. Entomol. 137: 739-747.
Knight, A.L., Hilton, R. & Light, D.M. 2005: Monitoring codling moth (Lepidoptera:
Tortricidae) in apple with blends of ethyl (E, Z)-2, 4-decadienoate and codlemone.
Environ. Entomol. 34: 598-603.
Landolt, P.J., Suckling, D.M. & Judd, G.J.R. 2007: Positive interaction of a feeding attractant
and a host kairomone for trapping the codling moth, Cydia pomonella. J. Chem. Ecol. 33:
2236-2244.
Light, D. & Knight, A. 2005: Kairomone-augmented mating disruption control for codling moth
in Californian walnuts and apples. IOBC/wprs Bull. 28(7): 335-344.
Light, D. & Bouyssounouse, P. 2006. Walnut trials using the codling moth kairomone, pear esterMEC as an insecticide spray adjuvant. 2006. Proc. 80th Annual Western Orchard Pest &
Disease Management Conference, 11-13 January, 2006, Portland, OR.
Light, D.M., Knight, A.L., Henrick, C.A., Rajapaska, D., Lingren, B., Dickens, J.C.,
Reynolds, K.M., Buttery, R.G., Merrill, G., Roitman, J. & Campbell, B.C. 2001. A pearderived kairomone with pheromonal potency that attracts male and female codling moth,
Cydia pomonella (L.). Naturwissenschaften 88: 333-338.
Schmidt, S., Tomasi, C., Pasqualini, E. & Ioriatti, C. 2008: The biological efficacy of pear ester
on the activity of granulosis virus for codling moth. J. Pest. Sci. 81: 29-34.
Tomaszewska, E, Hebert, V.R., Brunner, J.F., Jones, V.P., Doerr, M. & Hilton R. 2005:
Evaluation of pheromone release from commercial mating disruption dispensers. J. Agric.
Food Chem. 53: 2399-2405.
Witzgall, P., Stelinski, L., Gut, L. & Thomson, D. 2008: Codling moth management and
chemical ecology. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 53: 503-522.
348
Using Insect Behavior to Facilitate Precision Agriculture: Odor-Baited
Trap Trees For Management of the Plum Curculio, Conotrachelus
nenuphar (Herbst) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae)
Tracy C. Leskey1*, Starker E. Wright1, Jaime C. Piñero2, and Ronald J. Prokopy3,†
1USDA-ARS, Appalachian Fruit Research Station, 2217 Wiltshire Road, Kearneysville, WV
25430-2771 USA
2
University of Hawaii at Manoa, College of Trop Agric & Human Resources. 3050 Maile Way,
Honolulu, HI 96822
3
Department of Plant, Soil, and Insect Science, The University of Massachusetts at Amherst,
Amherst, 01003, †Posthumously, d. 14 May 2004
*tracy.leskey@ars.usda.gov
Abstract: Management programs for tree fruit have been developed based on an intensively managed
perennial monoculture with standardized management practices. This design has had unforeseen
consequences for pest management in that horticultural uniformity leads to a homogenous resource
distribution requiring protection on a whole-orchard basis. The ecological foundation of insect
behavior offers a clear opportunity to replace indiscriminate whole-orchard insecticide treatments with
targeted management zones, bringing together the sustainability of IPM and behavioral control with
the efficiency of precision agriculture. Behaviorally active stimuli are presented to attract and retain
pests within a particular location in the orchard to allow for implementation of precise control
strategies, thereby reducing insecticide inputs and increasing sustainability of the cropping system.
The plum curculio, Conotrachelus nenuphar (Herbst), is one of the most destructive direct tree fruit
pests in eastern North America. A novel approach termed the ‘odor-baited trap tree strategy’ (based on
the tenets precision agriculture and insect behavior) has been developed to replace standard wholeorchard insecticide treatments. Select apple trees in the perimeter row are baited with a synergistic
two-component lure comprised of the synthetic host plant-derived volatile benzaldehyde and the
synthetic male-produced aggregation pheromone grandisoic acid in order to aggregate adult activity in
specific perimeter row trees. Then by applying insecticides to these select baited trap trees rather than
the entire perimeter row or whole orchard after petal fall, substantial reductions in the amount of
insecticide applied can be achieved without compromising plum curculio control. Over the course of
four years, comparisons of the trap-tree and perimeter-row treatment strategies have revealed that
these strategies prevented penetration by immigrating populations of plum curculio and resulted in
economically acceptable levels of injury. The trap tree management strategy resulted in a reduction of
~70% total trees being treated with insecticide compared with perimeter row sprays and 93%
compared with standard full block sprays. We currently are working to improve this strategy based on
deploying even more powerful attractants within tree canopies to increase aggregation activity and
reduce the number of required trap trees.
349
Cage test to assess the mating disruptant activity of different
pheromone blends and formulations on Peach Twig Borer (Anarsia
lineatella Zeller) in the orchards
Fabio Molinari(*), Manuela Cigolini(*) , Andrea Iodice(**), Vittorio Veronelli(**)
(*)
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore di Piacenza, Istituto di Entomologia e Patologia
Vegetale, Piacenza, Italy.
(**)
CBC Europe Ltd, Nova Milanese, Italy
Abstract: Mesh cages were used as a method for assessing the disruption of Peach Twig Borer
(Anarsia lineatella Zeller) and Oriental Fruit Moth (Grapholita molesta (Busck)) mating in peach
orchards where different blends of synthetic pheromones and different dispenser formulations have
been applied. The trials carried out in the seasons 2006-2008 showed that this method is easy to apply
for evaluating the effectiveness of MD in the field and gives a reliable feedback allowing fine-tuning
of formulations.
Key words: Peach Twig Borer, Anarsia lineatella, Oriental Fruit Moth, Grapholita molesta, cage test,
pheromone, peach
Introduction
The peach twig borer (PTB), Anarsia lineatella Zeller (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae), is a pest of
peach, almond and other stone fruits where larvae cause damage by tunnelling into shoots and
fruits.
PTB has been increasingly damaging peach cultivation during the last years in Northern
Italy. In this new situation, finding effective control measures is particularly important: reliable
monitoring and forecasting means, research on the efficacy of different pheromone blends and
formulations for mating disruption are required.
In the last few years, the mating disruption method (MD) is increasingly applied
especially in organic and integrated pest management orchards; this method can give good
results in terms of efficacy and has a very low environmental impact; there are still some
problems with the field evaluation of its effectiveness. For this purpose field tests were carried
out in special mating cages to assess the effectiveness of the MD method without the problem
of evaluating the initial density of the insect population in the orchard.
Materials and methods
Field trials assessing the effectiveness of different formulations of synthetic pheromones of
Anarsia lineatella Zeller (PTB) and Grapholita molesta (Busck) (OFM) for mating disruption
(MD) were carried out in the province of Forlì-Cesena in 2006 – 2008.
Dispensers containing single blend (Isonet A and OFM rosso, respectively) and the two
blends mixed (Isonet A/OFM) were used. Trials were carried out in two organic orchards.
Mating cages
Mating cages installed in the orchards consisted of a cubic aluminium structure (side=1.5 m).
Two cages were placed in each plot, one for the Anarsia lineatella trials and the other for the
350
Grapholita molesta trials. Two cages, one for each species, were also installed in another
orchard and used as a control (Fig. 2).
A pagoda trap, baited with 2 three day old virgin females were placed in a container of
wire mesh, which was hung in each cage. Females were free to move and to release their
pheromone, reproducing the natural calling conditions (Fig. 3).
In each trial, ten three day old virgin males were put into each cage in order to simulate a
high population density of the target insect. Catches were recorded 3 – 4 nights after the
introduction of the insects.
Figure 1. Cage test
Figure 2. Position of the cages in the orchards
351
Figure 3. Monitoring trap with 3 day old females
Results
Data were calculated as an average of caught insects/cage. The effectiveness of pheromones
was expressed as percent reduction of catches compared to the untreated control for each
species, Anarsia lineatella and Cydia molesta. As shown in Figure 4, the percent reduction
was calculated for each formulation (Isonet A, OFM rosso and Isonet A /OFM).
Trials conducted for Anarsia lineatella with Isonet A and Isonet A/OFM dispensers,
respectively, showed a reduction in the percentage of catches of 77% and 78% compared to
the untreated control, showing an average catch of about 1 insect per trap.
Trials conducted for Cydia molesta with OFM rosso and Isonet A/OFM dispensers
showed a reduction of 80% compared with the control, suggesting an average catch of 1
insect per trap.
Cage trap catches (average) and their reduction VS control
100
7
6
80.43
5
4
3
2
80.43
80
78.43
76.47
60
40
20
1
0
0
OFM rosso
(OFM)
Isonet A/OFM
(OFM)
Isonet A
(PTwB)
Isonet A/OFM Testimone (OFM)
(PTwB)
Average Captures (trial)
Testimone
(PTWB)
Reduction of captures (%)
Figure 4. Percentage trap catch of Anarsia lineatella and Cydia molesta..........
Conclusions
Three years of trials confirmed that the “mating cages” are a reliable method for assessing the
effectiveness of different products for MD in the field.
The use of cages containing a known number of insects placed in the trial plot allowed us
352
to overcome the fundamental problem of evaluating the initial density of the insect population
in the orchard.
Knowing and evaluating the natural population density in each orchard is almost
impossible; this method allows the evaluation of the tested products and the control under the
same population density, without any interference by changing the natural population. The
major constraint of this method is the unavoidable need of rearing the target insect.
In the trial reported, it has been shown that dispensers containing the two lures of OFM
and PTwB together (Isonet A/OFM) give the same control as separate dispensers containing
the single blend of the target insect ( Isonet A and OFM rosso).
References
Dickler, E. 1982: The distribution of the quarantine pests Anarsia lineatella Zell. and
Grapholita molesta Busck in the Federal Republic of Germany. In: Nachrichtenblatt des
Deutschen Pflanzenschultzdienstes, 34(10): 145-152.
Hathaway, D.O., Tamaki, G., Moffit, H.R. & Burditt, A.K. 1985: Impact of removal of males
with sex pheromone-baited taps on suppression of the peach-twig borer, Anarsia
lineatella (Zellar). In: The Canadian Entomologist, 117:643-645.
Molinari, F. & Zanrei. O. 2004: Studies on some developmental parameters of Anarsia
lineatella Zell reared on artificial diet. In: Integrated Plant Protection in Stone Fruit,
IOBC wprs Vol. 27(1): 29-35.
Natale, D., Molinari, F., Sambado, P. & Cravedi, P. 2005: Preliminary investigation on the
mating behaviour of the peach twig borer, Anarsia lineatella. In: Integrated Fruit
Protection in Fruit Crops, IOBC wprs Vol. 28(7): 391-394.
353
Comparison of different pheromone lures to monitor the flight of
Cydia pomonella
Denis Pasquier, Patrik Kehrli
Station de recherche Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil ACW, CP 1012, CH-1260 Nyon,
Switzerland
Abstract: The control of the codling moth, Cydia pomonella, relies on an accurate understanding of its
biology and phenology. Pheromone trapping is an effective and timesaving technique to follow the
phenology of adults and to estimate the appearance of the different larval instars. In this study we
tested three different pheromone lures for monitoring the flight of C. pomonella. The Tripheron
capsule attracted most males followed by a capsule developed at the University of Neuchâtel and the
unattractive PheroNet capsule. In the future, we recommend the use of the Tripheron capsule for
monitoring the flight of C. pomonella, especially in regions with low population density.
Key words: Pomiculture, insect monitoring, delta traps
Introduction
The codling moth, Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera, Torticidae), is a key pest in European
apple orchards and its control is based on insecticide applications and mating disruption
(Angeli et al., 2007). Both control strategies strongly rely on a profound knowledge of
codling moth population dynamics. The identification of its sex pheromone in 1971 led to the
wide use of pheromone traps for monitoring the flight of C. pomonella (Roelofs et al., 1971;
Charmillot et al., 2000). Pheromone trapping is an effective and timesaving technique to
follow the phenology of adults and to estimate the appearance of the different larval instars.
For the last two decades, the PheroNet capsule has been the most common pheromone lure
used to catch codling moth in Switzerland. However, the number of males trapped has
decreased significantly over the last years as a result of low population densities of C.
pomonella. Thus, a more attractive pheromone lure would be useful to predict the phenology
of the codling moth more accurately. In this paper we compare different pheromone lures with
the aim of identifying a more effective monitoring device.
Material and methods
Three different types of pheromone capsules were tested. The PheroNet capsule (distributed
by Andermatt BioControl) served as a reference. It is charged with 1 mg E8E10-12OH. We
also tested a Tripheron® capsule produced by Trifolio-M GmbH loaded with 1 mg E8E1012OH and 1 mg 12OH as well as a capsule developed by Patrick Guerin at the University of
Neuchâtel comprising 1 mg E8E10-12OH. The three different types of pheromone capsule
were exposed in delta traps and set up in two untreated apple orchards. Both orchards were
situated in the neighbourhood of Nyon (Switzerland) and were about 0.25 ha in size.
Pheromone traps were regularly rotated within orchards in order to minimise local side
effects. Pheromone traps were checked twice a week between May and September 2007.
354
4
b)
20
3
15
2
1
0
Tripheron
Uni Neuchâtel
PheroNet
10
5
Type of pheromone lure
11
/9
28
/8
14
/8
31
/7
17
/7
3/
7
PheroNet
19
/6
Uni Neuchâtel
22
/5
0
Tripheron
5/
6
Mean number of males caught
per date and trap
a)
Number of males caught
per date
Results and discussion
Date
Figure 1. Number of C. pomonella males caught a) per pheromone lure and b) over the season.
Error bars = ± 1 SE.
The capsule Tripheron attracted the highest number of codling moths followed by the capsule
developed at the University of Neuchâtel (Figure 1a). Both types of capsules were effective
over the whole season (Figure 1b). However, PheroNet lures attracted significantly less
codling moths than the other two types of lures.
For the future, we recommend the use of the more attractive Tripheron capsule to
monitor the flight of C. pomonella males. Particularly in regions with low densities of codling
moths this pheromone lure might be a welcome asset for forecasting the phenology of C.
pomonella.
Acknowledgments
We thank Andermatt Biocontrol AG and Patrick Guerin (University of Neuchâtel) for the
supply of pheromone capsules and we gratefully acknowledge Andermatt Biocontrol AG for
funding this study.
References
Angeli, G., Anfora, G., Baldessari, M., Germinara, G.S., De Cristofaro, A. & Ioriatti, C. 2007:
Mating disruption of codling moth Cydia pomonella with high densities of Ecodian sex
pheromone dispensers. Journal of Applied Entomology 131: 311-318.
Charmillot, P.-J., Hofer, D. & Pasquier, D. 2000: Attract and kill: a new method for control of the
codling moth Cydia pomonella. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata 94: 211-216.
Roelofs, W.L., Comeau, A., Hill, A. & Milicevic, G. 1971: Sex attractant of the codling moth:
Characterization with electroantennogram technique. Science 174: 297-299.
355
Effectiveness of mating disruption and granulosis virus against codling
moth in central Bulgaria
Penka Peeva1, Nyonka Velcheva1, Olia Karadjova1, Vittorio Veronelli2, Denis Pasquier3,
Radoslav Andreev4, Katia Radeva5
1
Plant Protection Institute, 35 Panayot Volov str., 2230 Kostinbrod, Bulgaria; 2CBC
(EUROPE) Ltd., Milan Branch, Via E. Majorana, 2, 20054 Nova Milanese (MI), Italy;
3
Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil, CP 1012, 1260 Nyon, Switzerland; 4Agricultural
University, 12 Mendeleev str., 4000 Plovdiv, Bulgaria; 5Agrobioconsult Ltd., 4 Gen. Asen
Nikolov, 1336 Sofia, Bulgaria
Abstract : Due to economical changes, problems of resistance and the parceling of agricultural area,
mating disruption (MD) was studied on its own or in combination with granulosis virus (CpGV)
against the codling moth (CM), Cydia pomonella L., in the region of Plovdiv (Bulgaria). The
effectiveness of MD and CpGV was tested in small orchards with high pest density. Until the 5th of
July 2005, the percentage of CM-damaged fruits was at an acceptable level of 5.1% in the 0.5 ha apple
orchard treated with Isomate C LR® dispensers. The number of trapped CM males was 11 times lower
than in a conventionally treated orchard, which served as a reference. Except for Rhynchites spp. and
Stephanitis pyri, fruit damage by other pests was around the economical threshold. In 2007, Isomate C
plus® dispensers together with the CpGV as Madex® were applied in a 19 years old orchard of 1.3 ha.
Once again, fruit damage by CM was bellow the economical threshold until the beginning of July.
Thereafter, five treatments with chlorpyrifos-ethyl and chlorpyrifos-methyl were made to avoid higher
infestation levels. At pre-harvest, only 1.9% of apples had CM larvae, compared to 17.0% in the
reference orchard that was treated 11 times with conventional insecticides. The combination of MD
and CpGV showed the best results in an 8-year old apple orchard. In this orchard, only 1.5% of apples
were infested with CM larvae at pre-harvest and we detected 1.5 diapausing CM larvae per tree. In the
accompanying reference orchard, the density of hibernating CM larvae was 23-times higher. Overall,
the development of alternative IPM strategies incorporating mating disruption and granulosis viruses
seems to be promising.
Key words: codling moth, mating disruption, granulosis viruses, apple orchards, Bulgaria
Introduction
Codling moth (CM), Cydia pomonella L. (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) is the key pest of the
apples all over the world. It causes extremely severe damage on apple fruits ranging from 6%
to 65% in south western Bulgaria and from 10% to 87-100% in south central part of the
country (Balewsky et al., 1958). In 1980s, integrated pest management programs were
developed in which control of CM was based on the application of insect growth inhibitors
(IGI). In 1995, we received the first indication about the failure of IGI in Bulgarian fruit
protection. Recently, population densities of CM and consequently apple damage increased
sharply in many regions of the country. It has been verified that these insects showed a high
degree of insecticide resistance (Charmillot et al., 2007). The mating disruption (MD)
technique is one of the principal alternatives for controlling resistant CM populations. The
aim of this study was to investigate the effectiveness of MD alone and in a combination with
codling moth granulosis viruses (CpGV) in apple orchards with different levels of CM
infestations. Our results could throw light on the possibilities of “organic” apple production in
356
Bulgaria.
Material and methods
It is well known that mating disruption is more effective when it is applied to large areas that
are well isolated. However, the agricultural land in Bulgaria was parceled out with the
political and economical changes in the 1990s. For this reason, our study has been conducted
in the region in conformity with actual conditions.
Location of orchards
In 2005, a MD trial was carried out in a 17 year old experimental organic orchard (EOO) of
the Agricultural University of Plovdiv. In the previous year no pesticides were applied in the
EOO. The MD treated orchard was compared to an abandoned orchard at Trud, a village near
Plovdiv and a conventionally treated orchard in Plovdiv.
In 2007, the second MD trial was conducted in an experimental conventional orchard of
the Agricultural University of Plovdiv (CO1) and in a private conventional orchard in
Zvanichevo (CO2) (village near the town of Pazarjik in the Plovdiv region). CO1 was planted
in 1988.It is more or less isolated spans 1.3 ha and comprises nine different apple varieties.
Close to CO1 is a vineyard and then mixed orchard with cherry, plume and a 0.5 ha apple that
was used as a treated reference orchard.
CO2 was planted in 1999, is 2.2 ha in size and there are six varieties of apples. CO2 is
well isolated and a mixed orchard (plum, apple, cherry and pear) 600 m away was used as
treated reference orchard.
Mating disruption
In 2005, pheromone dispensers of the type Isomate C LR® (Shin-Etsu Chemical Company
Ltd., Japan) were used. Dispensers were applied on April 21 at the recommended dose of
1000 dispensers per ha. In 2007, Isomate C plus® dispensers from the same company were
used. Dispensers were also applied at the recommended dose of 1000 unit per ha and set up
on April 16. Dispensers were placed in the tree tops.
Granulosis virus and insecticides
During 2007, granulosis virus (Madex® from Andermatt BioContol, Switzerland) was applied
in the two orchards protected with MD in 2007. The application of CpGV at a dose 100ml/ha
started with the hatching of eggs of the first CM generation. Thereafter, CpGV treatments
were repeated fortnightly at half the initial dose (50ml/ha). The first applications were
conducted on April 26 at CO1 and on April 29 in CO2. In the commercial reference orchards,
insecticides and acaricides were applied over the whole season in accordance with pest
pressure.
Assessment of pest control
Pherocone 1C wing traps were placed in MD treated and reference orchards to follow the
dynamic of CM flight. Fruit damage was assessed during the season and at before harvest.
Randomly, 25 to 30 apples were counted per tree, resulting in more than 500 sampled apples
per date. In the middle of June corrugated cardboard bands were placed in orchards.
Pheromone emission
In 2007, randomly selected dispensers in the CO1 were periodically replaced with new ones
and then stored in a refrigerator. In CO2, 20 additional dispensers were set up in the orchard
at the date of the exposure of pheromone dispensers. Every week one of them was recovered
and stored in a refrigerator. Collected dispensers were analyzed by gas chromatography.
Results and discussion
Mating disruption trial 2005
357
No insecticide or acaricide treatments were applied during the season. In the EOO, the level
of fruit damage by CM exceeded the economical threshold at the beginning of July 2005
(Table 1), around ten days after the first CM males were caught in the pheromone traps placed
in the trial orchard. In the insecticide treated reference orchards, fruit damage topped the
economical threshold in June and in the untreated control, fruit damage reached 30 % by the
end of May. In 2005, the number of overwintering CM larvae was significantly lower in the
orchard protected with mating disruption than in the insecticide treated reference orchard
(Table 2). The low level of diapausing CM larvae in the corrugated bands in the untreated
control orchard can probably be explained by the low yield of the apple trees.
Sampling date
Table 1. Fruit damage (%) in the mating disruption trial 2005.
24.5.2005
31.5.2005
08.6.2005
21.6.2005
05.7.2005
Isomate
C LR
Plovdiv
EOO
% of
fruits
damaged
0.71%
1.74%
1.94%
2.16%
5.14%
Treated Untreated
reference reference
orchard
orchard
Plovdiv
Trud *
% of
% of fruits
fruits
damaged
damaged
0.00%
6.25%
0.99%
29.26%
2.05%
~
2.05%
35.70%
1.34%
~
* - very low yield. 86.27% damage before harvest
Table 2: Average number of CM caught and the number of diapausing CM larvae per tree in
the mating disruption trial 2005.
Isomate
Treated
Untreated
C LR
reference
reference
Orchard /
Plovdiv
orchard
orchard
year
EOO
Plovdiv
Trud
2004 2005 2004 2005 2004 2005
Average
number
CM
18.13 2.13 9.13 12.61 ~ 11.57
caught per
trap and
per week
Average
number of
CM larvae
54.86 23.00 63.68 34.43 72.86 12.2
per tree in
corrugated
bands
358
Mating disruption trial 2007
Overall, Madex® was applied 12 times in CO1 and 10 times in CO2. Aphids were treated
twice in CO2, with cypermethrin in the middle of April 2007 and with imidaclorpride at the
beginning of July 2007. In CO1, growers decided to start with additional insecticide sprays on
July 7 when damage exceeded the economical threshold. Until the end of the season, 5
additional treatments with Reldan and Nurele-Dursband were applied. Only one CM was
caught in the pheromone-treated orchard CO1 and none in CO2. In the other orchards, CM
flight started at the beginning of April. First individuals of the second flight were caught at the
end of July and the flight continued until the end of September.
In CO1, the level of damaged apples was about the same as in the previous year when
conventional insecticides were applied, e.g. 27.86% versus 28%. At harvest, only 1.91% of
fruits were attacked by alive or fully developed larvae. As a result of granulosis virus, the
largest proportion of damaged apples (22.65%) was caused by stopped larvae. In CO2,
damage was 14.82%, nearly three times lower than in the insecticide treated reference orchard
(37.43%) but much higher than in the previous year (4%). Once again, the largest proportion
of damage was caused by stopped larvae (13.37%). The number of overwintering CM larvae
was about the same before and after the mating disruption trial, e.g. 14 larvae per band in
2006 and 16 larvae per band in 2007 in CO1. This is in the same order of magnitude (14.93
larvae per band) as in the insecticide treated reference orchard. In CO2, only 1.47 larvae per
band were counted, compared to 35.21 larvae per band in the insecticide treated reference
orchard.
Pheromone emission
The analysis of pheromone dispensers with gas chromatograph revealed that several
dispensers were already empty in the middle of July and nearly all were empty at the end of
August. This indicates that in a very hot summer as experienced in 2007 pheromone emission
begins to decrease in the middle of the summer and that almost no pheromone is emitted at
end of the flight of CM. These results might explain why apple damage increased sharply in
August.
Conclusion
This study has shown that a combined control program of mating disruption and granulosis
virus can be more effective than classical control schemes. However, a prerequisite is a low to
moderate codling moth population. Under high CM pressure, the combined strategy is at least
as effective as classical control. Pheromone-mediated mating disruption is most successful
when pest insects are suppressed to a low level year after year. Future investigations on the
effectiveness of combining MD and CpGV should investigate the preconditions that are
required for these environmentally friendly control techniques to keep the level of codling
moths under the economical threshold.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Pierre-Joseph Charmillot for his introduction to mating disruption and
for his helpful comments and Patrik Kehrli for critical review and correction of the manuscript.
We also thank Vanq Bojilova and Vasil Mihaylov from Regional Service of Plant ProtectionPlovdiv, and Panko Keranov and Ilia Manoilov for placing their orchards at our disposal. Part of
the investigation was funded by 6-th Framework of the EC project PlantProCENTRE contr. №
017367.
359
References
Balewsky, A.D., Vasseff, At.N., Ivanoff, Sp.Chr., Lasaroff, As.W., Zwetkowa, Zw.T. 1958:
Die obstmade – Laspeyresia pomonella L. (Biologie, oekologie und massnahmen zur
bekämpfung und möglichkeiten zur einführung des warndienstes). Institut für
pfianzenschutz-Sofia, Wissenschaftliche Abhaundlungen - Bd. I: 109-158.
Charmillot, P.J., Pasquier, D., Salamin, Ch., Briand, F., Azizian, A., Kutinkova, H., Peeva, P.,
Velcheva, N. 2007: Détection de la résistance du carpocapse Cydia pomonella par
application topique d'insecticides sur des chenilles diapausantes de Suisse, d'Arménie et
de Bulgarie. Revue Suisse Vitic. Arboric. Hortic., Vol.39 (6) 385-389.
360
Control of codling moth (Cydia pomonella) by the means of active
mating disruption, different application systems and varieties
Barbara Schildberger, Lothar Wurm, Eva Vogl, Manfred Kickenweiz
Federal College and Institute for Viticulture and Pomology, Klosterneuburg, Austria,
Department Biology, Wiener Straße 74, 3400 Klosterneuburg
Abstract: Alongside standard systems of mating disruption, the activity of Exosex CM and Ecodian®
under different application systems and on several varieties were tested in 2007 and 2008 at the
research station of the Federal College and Institute for Viticulture and Pomology, Klosterneuburg.
Standard mating disruption techniques usually rely on the introduction of amounts of pheromone
similar to those emitted by natural populations of pest species into the atmosphere. Exosex CM
significantly reduces deployment time and labour costs in the orchards, additionally the flexibility of
integrating this technique with IPM programmes was tested. Ecodian® dispensers were distributed at a
rate of 2000 dispensers/ha. The tube dispensers of pheromone (Exosex CM) were placed in a three
hectare orchard, which was split into three trial fields: one left untreated, one where the first
generation was treated and one in which all generations of codling moth (Cydia pomonella) were
treated. Additionally, in 2008 different application systems were used. Ecodian® was tested on one
hectare and compared with untreated areas. The assessments to quantify efficacy were made visually
on windfall fruits, fruits on the tree and on all fruits at harvest and statistically evaluated. In 2007,
among the fruits sprayed within the IPM system there was an infestation rate by the first generation on
the variety Idared of 0.8%. The second generation treated with Exosex showed an infestation of 13%.
In the biological trial, however, the infestation by the first generation was about 4% and the infestation
by the second generation about 31%. The 2008 results were comparable to those of 2007.
Key words: codling moth, mating disruption, pheromone
Introduction
At the orchards of the research station codling moth (Cydia pomonella) is a serious pest,
which can cause damage of economic relevance. The regions climate is advantageous for two
complete generations of codling moth annually, and in some years even three generations are
seen. This can lead to a very high population density, which needs intensive pest management.
In the last eight years routine application against codling moth was done with the
Carpovirusine formulation granulovirus (CpGV) with an average of eleven applications per
year on the organic orchards. In 2003 and 2007 mating disruption was accomplished. High
pest numbers in the last years have needed additional measures to augment the routine
granulosevirus control. In order to find out about the CpGV-resistance in this orchard, the
Julius Kühn Institute for Biological Control in Germany undertook sensitivity tests with the
larvae. In the laboratory the mortality of newly hatched larvae exposed to different virus
concentrations was determined (Jehle 2008). It was found that the codling moth strain from
these orchards is less sensitive in relation to a sensitive strain of C. pomonella, by around a
factor of ten. Based on this sensitivity data different mating disruption methods were
examined to create an acceptable resistance management strategy.
Several alternative control methods using mating disruption against codling moth were
demonstrated and evaluated in apple orchards in Austria that had been established in 1992.
Alongside standard systems of mating disruption, the activity of the products Exosex CM and
361
Ecodian® in conjunction with different application systems and on several varieties were
tested in 2007 and 2008.
Material and methods
In 2007 the trial was split into two sections. The first experiment included a treatment against
the first generation with the spraying of diflubenzuron, which was applied on 22nd of May to
decimate the outgoing population. The second generation being smaller in size was treated
with Exosex, a mating disruption agent, as an extension to the conventional agent applied to
the 1st generation. The Exosex dispensers were distributed on the 11th of July. In 2008 the
tube dispensers of pheromone (Exosex CM) were assessed again. The trial was split into four
fields, one left untreated (control), one where only the first generation was disrupted, one in
which all generations of codling moth were treated with ExosexCM and additionally with
Carpovirusine (thirteen times) and the last field was treated with compounds which are
registered for use in integrated production (thiacloprid, chlorpyrifos) and also disrupted with
Exosex CM. The Exosex CM is distinguished by the dispenser being impregnated with
codlemon (87.5 mg per ha), which can be located throughout the orchard at a frequency of
just 25 per hectare. Ecodian® dispensers, made of low-cost biodegradable material and easy
to apply, were formulated with 10 mg of codlemone and placed at a rate of 2000
dispensers/ha. Ecodian® was tested on one hectare and one field was untreated. The
assessments were done visually on 300 fruits per variant and variety, by examining pest
damage on apples on windfall fruits, fruits on the tree and on all fruits at harvest followed by
statistical evaluation. Also, pheromone traps were placed to monitor the flight of the codling
moth.
Results and discussion
In 2007 the pheromone traps showed that the flight of codling moth was constant and
comparable to the years 2006 and 2008 (fig.1).
The results in 2007 on Topaz and Gala showed significantly higher rates of damaged fruits
than Idared. The codling moth population was increasing at a significant rate in the ecological
treatment, from 22% fruit injury in the first generation to 38% at harvest with the variety
Idared. However, there was a significant difference between the varieties (Fig. 2).
So, for instance, Topaz showed an infestation of 43% in the ecological treatment, whereas the
infestation in the integrated treatment was 11%. It is well known that the mating disruption
technique does not work well at high population densities (Cardé & Minks, 1995; Neumann,
1997; Casgrande & Jones, 1997), which was also the case in this trial. Conversely, in the trial
with the Ecodian® treatment which was assessed on the 28th of August, only 1.7% damage
was found, which means economical loss (Trautmann, 2008).
In 2008 the numbers of varieties were increased and the highest infestation occurred in
Pilot with 18% damage, followed by Elstar, Gala and Golden Delicious, where the fruit injury
was about 10% (Fig. 3).
362
catches
of moths
Codling moth capture in pheromone traps
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
2006
2007
20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35
per week
Figure 1: codling moth (Cydia pomonella) monitoring
In the organic trials the infestation was higher than in the comparative IPM trial. In the
trials mating disruption success was dependent on moth density, with obvious effects on the
different apple varieties, and also with either the ecological treatment or mating disruption.
The attraction of the codling moth to apple volatile compounds which are known to elicit an
antennal response has been previously tested and differences are known to exist between the
varieties (Corarini et al. 2004).
100
%injured fruits (without windfall fruits)
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
Idared
0
Topaz
Biological trial
Exosex
Integrated production trial
Exosex
Figure 2: results of the final assessment (without windfall fruits)
Our data agree with the existing literature, which has shown that the mating disruption
method is not sufficient alone, since too many fruits will be damaged. Particularly with an
infestation in the previous year higher than 1-2 percent (Galli, 2006) or at an output
population over 2000 larvae per hectare the chances are small that the employment of
pheromone mating disruption alone is sufficient to control codling moth (Mani, 1996) .
363
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
w indfall fruits
injured fruits w ith codling
moth
Pi
lo
t
G
D
Fl
or
in
a
R
ea
nd
a
To
pa
z
El
st
ar
G
al
a
free of damage
variet y
Figure 3: Final damage assessment 2008
Acknowledgements
We thank the Institute for Biological Control of the Julius Kühn - Institute in Germany, for
doing the resistance assessment with our codling moth strain in the frame of the EU-funded
project “SustainCpGV”.
References
Cardé, R., Minks, A. 1995: Control of moth pests by mating disruption: successes and
constraints, Annu.Rev.Entomol. 40: 559-585
Coracini, M. 2004: Attraction of codling moth males to apple volatiles. In: Entomologia
Experimentalis et Applicata, Volume 110 Issue 1 Page 1-10
Galli, P. et al. 2006: Der Apfelwickler, Obstbau; 30, 5, S. 259-290
Jehle, J. 2008: Apfelwicklergranulosevirus – wie geht es weiter?, Obstbau 4/2008:194-198
Mani, E. (1996: Bekämpfung des Apfelwicklers mit der Verwirrungsmethode in der deutschen
Schweiz, Schweizer Zeitschrift für Obst- und Weinbau, 132, 27, S.718-722
Trautmann M. 2008: Welchen Stellenwert hat die Pheromonverwirrung in der
Apfelwicklerbekämpfung? Obstbau 4/2008: 199-202
364
Mating disruption across the peach/apple interface
Peter Shearer, Kris Tollerup, Ann Rucker Rutgers
University, Agricultural Research & Extension Center, Bridgeton, NJ
Abstract: Our hypothesis is that deploying mating disruption against the oriental fruit moth,
Grapholita molesta (Busck), across adjacent peach and apple blocks provides better control than if
applied to only one of the two crops. CheckMate OFM dispensers were applied in mating disrupted
peach blocks and CheckMate CM/OFM Duel dispensers were used in mating disrupted apple blocks.
Where used, mating disruption was in addition to insecticide programs. Results confirm that it is easier
to disrupt oriental fruit moth in peach than codling moth in apple.
Grapholita molesta, Pheromone disruption
365
Exploring the potential for using peripheral treatments with
pheromone dispensers for controlling the grape berry moth
(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) by mating disruption
R.M. Trimble, D.B. Marshall
Southern Crop Protection and Food Research Centre, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada,
4902 Victoria Avenue North, Vineland Station, Ontario, Canada L0R 2E0
Abstract: The potential for using peripheral treatments with hand-applied pheromone dispensers for
controlling Paralobesia viteana (Clemens) by mating disruption was examined in commercial
vineyards in the Niagara peninsula, Ontario, Canada during 2007. Four 1 ha (100 x 100 m)
experimental plots, each separated by 100 m, were established within each of three vineyards. Twentyfive synthetic sex pheromone-baited traps were deployed in each plot on a 20 x 20 m grid to indirectly
measure the effect of pheromone treatments on the mate locating ability of male moths. The
application of 500 dispensers/ha reduced the mean total number of moths trapped by 96% compared to
the untreated control, indicating a high level of mating disruption. Trap catch was reduced by 87%
when 80 or 160 dispensers were applied at intervals of 5 or 2.5 m, respectively, along the periphery of
the 1 ha plots. The results provide impetus for additional research to determine if peripheral treatments
with pheromone dispensers can be used to control P. viteana.
Key words: grape berry moth, Paralobesia viteana, pheromone, mating disruption, peripheral treatment
Introduction
The grape berry moth, Paralobesia viteana (Clemens) is the most important insect pest in
commercial vineyards in eastern North America (Dennehy et al. 1990). Sex pheromonemediated mating disruption can be used to control P. viteana (e.g. Trimble 2007), but there
has been limited adoption of this technique because of the greater cost of using pheromone
compared to using insecticide (Trimble 1997). One potential method of reducing the cost of
mating disruption for controlling P. viteana may be the use of reduced rates of pheromone
dispensers. For example, in Switzerland, Charmillot et al. (1996) disrupted mating of the
European grape vine moth, Lobesia botrana Den. & Schiff. by using peripheral treatments
with pheromone dispensers. The work described in this paper was carried out to explore the
possibility of using peripheral applications of hand-applied pheromone dispensers for
controlling P. viteana.
Material and methods
The effect of three pheromone treatments on the mate-locating ability of male P. viteana was
tested using a randomized-complete-block experimental design in three commercial vineyards
(i.e. blocks) in the Niagara peninsula, Ontario during 2007. The first vineyard (13.5 ha) was
near Jordan, the second (12.8 ha) was near St. Catharines and the third (38.3 ha) was near
Niagara-on-the-Lake. The vineyards were planted with white and red varieties of Vitis vinifera
L. vines spaced at 1.2 m with 2.5–2.7 m between rows of vines. Four 1 ha (100 x 100 m)
experimental plots, each separated by 100 m, were established within each of the three
vineyards.
366
The activity and mate-locating ability of male P. viteana was monitored in each plot
using 25 delta traps (21 x 20 x 12 cm, L x W x H) (Cooper Mill Ltd., Madoc, Ontario) that
were positioned 1 m above the ground on a 20 x 20 m grid prior to first moth flight in the
spring (15 May) (Fig. 1). Each trap was baited with a 9 mm-diameter, natural-rubber sleeve
stopper (Chromatographic Specialties, Brockville, Ontario) loaded with 0.8 mg of Z-9dodecenyl acetate (Z9-12:OAc) and 0.2 mg of (Z)-11-tetradecenyl acetate (Z11-14:OAc)
(Pherobank, Plant Research International, Wageningen, the Netherlands), the major and the
most abundant minor pheromone compound of this species, respectively (Witzgall et al.
2000). Moths were counted and removed from the traps on Monday and Thursday from 22
May until 10 September. Stoppers were changed on 3 and 30 July at the end of the first and
second of the three flights of P. viteana (Fig. 1).
25
Jordan
St. Catharines
Number GBM Trapped per Day
20
Niagara-on-the-Lake
Isomate GBM Plus
pheromone dispensers
applied
15
10
5
be
r
st
em
7
Se
pt
gu
st
30
Au
gu
st
23
Au
gu
st
Au
Au
gu
st
gu
16
2
10
ly
Au
Ju
ly
26
Ju
Ju
ly
19
ly
12
ne
Ju
6
e
28
Ju
e
Ju
n
Ju
n
21
14
Ju
ne
7
M
ay
M
22
31
ay
0
Figure 1. Number of P. viteana trapped per day in control plots at three vineyards in the
Niagara peninsula, Ontario, 2007
Isomate® GBM Plus pheromone dispensers, each containing 221.5 mg of Z9-12:OAc
(Pacific Biocontrol Corp., Vancouver, WA) were deployed after peak trap catch during the
second flight of P. viteana (Fig. 1) on 6 July at the Jordan vineyard, on 11 July at the St.
Catharines vineyard, and on 10 July at the Niagara-on-the-Lake vineyard. A plot received one
of four treatments: 1) pheromone dispensers applied at equal spacing to the entire plot at the
recommended rate of 500/ha; 2) dispensers applied to the periphery of the plot at intervals of
5, or 3) 2.5 m, and; 4) no treatment with pheromone dispensers (i.e. control plot). Dispensers
were attached to the top trellis wire 110–120 cm above the ground within the grape vine
canopy. The deployment of pheromone dispensers to the periphery at a spacing of 5 m was
approximately equivalent to the distance between dispensers when applied to the entire plot at
the 500 dispensers/ha application rate. The total number of moths trapped in a plot before and
367
after the pheromone dispensers were applied was transformed to √(x + 1) and the significance
of treatment on the mean total number of moths trapped was tested using analysis of variance
(ANOVA). The significance of differences between means was tested using the Tukey
multiple comparison test (SAS Institute 2007). The 80 x 80 m area within each experimental
plot containing the grid of 25 delta traps was divided into a “border” and an “interior” zone.
The border zone contained the 16 traps located on the edge of the plot and the interior zone
contained the 9 traps located within the “edge” traps. The total number of moths captured in
each trap in each plot before and after the pheromone dispensers were applied was
transformed to √(x + 1) and the significance of zone on the mean total number of moths
captured was tested using the nonparametric Wilcoxon test (SAS Institute 2007).
Results and discussion
There was no difference in the mean total number of P. viteana trapped in each of the four
experimental plots prior to application of the Isomate® dispensers (treatment, F3,11 = 0.31, P =
0.82; vineyard, F2,11 = 5.77, P = 0.04). After application of the dispensers, however,
pheromone treatment significantly affected the mean total number of moths trapped
(treatment, F3,11 = 5.38, P = 0.04; vineyard, F2,11 = 12.32, P = 0.001) (Table 1).
Table 1. Mean (±SD) total number Paralobesia viteana captured in pheromone-baited traps in
treatment plots before and after application of pheromone dispensers.
Treatment
Control
Periphery–2.5
Periphery–5
Full
Total number trapped
Before application of
dispensers
14.0±10.9a
14.6±8.0a
10.6±4.5a
9.5±11.3a
192
After application of
dispensers
78.8±10.9a
8.9±8.0ab
9.0±4.5ab
2.9±11.3b
539
Note: Moths trapped from 15–18 May to 6–10 July before application of
dispensers and from 6–9 July to 10–18 September after application of
dispensers. There were 25 traps in each treatment plot.
The application of 500 dispensers/ha reduced the mean total number of moths trapped by
96.3% compared to the untreated control, indicating a high level of mating disruption
(Trimble 2007). There was no statistical difference in the mean total number of moths
captured in the control plot and in the plots receiving either of the two peripheral treatments
with pheromone dispensers (Periphery–5 and Periphery–2.5), however, the mean total number
of moths trapped in these plots was reduced by 87% compared to the average number trapped
in the control plots (Table 1). The failure of the multiple comparison test to detect a statistical
difference between treatments with such large differences is likely due to the use of only three
replicates (i.e. vineyards) in the this experiment, and to the large difference in the total
number of moths trapped at each location, i.e., Jordan = 339, St. Catharines = 15 and,
Niagara-on-the-Lake = 185.
There was no difference in the mean total number of moths captured in the peripheral
and interior zones of any of the experimental plots before the application of pheromone
dispensers. After the application of dispensers, there was no between-zone difference in five
of the six plots receiving a peripheral zone treatment, suggesting that the peripheral treatment
368
with pheromone dispensers affected the mate seeking ability of male moths throughout the
entire plot. A between-zone difference in the mean total number of moths captured occurred at
the Jordan vineyard in the plot treated with dispensers at intervals of 2.5 m (Periphery–2.5),
where the mean total number trapped in the border zone (0.7) was 69% smaller (Z = 2.3, P =
0.02) than the mean total number trapped in the interior zone (2.2). This suggests that the
peripheral pheromone treatment had greater affect in the border zone than in the interior zone
of this plot. There was also a between-zone difference in the mean total number of moths
trapped in one of the tree control plots. At the Niagara-on-the-Lake vineyard, the mean total
number of moths trapped in the interior zone (4.1) was 48% smaller (Z = 2.4, P = 0.02) than
the number trapped in the border zone (7.9), suggesting that in this plot, there was greater
between trap competition in the interior zone than in the border zone.
The results of this study demonstrate some potential for using peripheral treatments with
pheromone dispensers for controlling P. viteana by mating disruption. Additional experiments
using greater replication should be undertaken to confirm the current results and increase the
likelihood of detecting significant treatment effects when using peripheral treatments. Any
future experiments should also include the use of tethered, virgin-female moths (Charmillot et
al. 1999) to measure the ability of male P. viteana to locate and mate with sexually receptive
females.
Acknowledgements
We thank three Niagara peninsula grape growers for making their vineyards available for
experimentation and Iris Roman for her able technical assistance.
References
Charmillot, P.J., Pasquier, D., Alipaz, N.J. & Scalco, A. 1996. Study of grape vine moth
Lobesia botrana Den. and Schiff. (Lepid., Tortricidae) behaviour inside and outside a
dispenser belt. J. Appl. Entomol. 120: 603–609.
Dennehy, T.J., Roelofs, W.L., Taschenberg, E.F. & Taft, T.N. 1990. Mating disruption for
control of grape berry moth in New York vineyards. In Behavior-modifying chemicals
for insect management: applications of pheromones and other attractants. Edited by R.L
Ridgway, R.M. Silverstein, and M.N. Inscoe. Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York. pp. 223–
240.
SAS Institute, Inc. 2007. JMP Version 7. SAS Institute Inc., Cary, North Carolina.
Trimble, R.M. 1997. Adoption of mating disruption for controlling the grape berry moth,
Endopiza viteana (Clemens) (Lepidoptera, Tortricidae) in Ontario, Canada. Bull.
IOBC(WPRS) 20: 83–88.
Trimble, R.M. 2007. Comparison of the efficacy of pheromone dispensing technologies for
controlling the grape berry moth (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) by mating disruption. J.
Econ. Entomol. 100: 1815–1820.
Witzgall, P., Bengtsson, M. & Trimble, R.M. 2000. Sex pheromone of grape berry moth
(Lepidoptera: Tortricidae). Environ. Entomol. 29: 433–436.
369
Control of codling moth, Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera
Tortricidae), with EcoTape pheromone dispensers
Federica Trona1, Mario Baldessari1, Gianfranco Anfora1, Valerio Mazzoni1, Enzo
Casagrande1, Claudio Ioriatti2, Gino Angeli1
1Plant Protection Department, FEM Research Center, via E. Mach 1, 38010 San Michele
all’Adige (TN), Italy; 2 FEM-IASMA Research Centre, Plant Protection Department, via E.
Mach, 1, 38010 San Michele all’Adige (TN,) Italy
Abstract: A mating disruption approach using high densities of pheromone point sources has been
developed for codling moth, Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera Tortricidae), control. The EcoTape®
device comprises a continuous adhesive tape integrated with 3-cm length dispensers at a separation of
0.6 m, loaded with 2.5 mg codlemone. Thus, in comparison with standard mating disruption, the
content of dispensers is strongly reduced, whereas the density of point sources is increased (2,000 or
4,000 points/ha), with the purpose of increasing the competition between natural and syntetic sources.
The release rate of new and field aged dispensers, measured directly by solid-phase micro-extraction
(SPME), decreased over time but at the end of the season was still more potent than a calling codling
moth female. Dispensers elicited close-range approaches in a wind tunnel irrespective of their field
age. Traps lured with aged EcoTape dispensers were also able to catch a number of males in the field
throughout the season comparable to that of traps loaded with reference dispensers. The results of field
trials (2004-2007) showed that codling moth control can be obtained applying EcoTape dispensers.
Our experiments demonstrated that EcoTape dispensers are a useful tool for efficient CM control
throughout the season under the climatic conditions of the Trento Province (North Italy) and may
satisfy some of the prerequisites for producing false-trail following effects.
E8,E10-dodecadien-1-ol, Mating disruption, SPME, Wind tunnel, Field trial
370
Two Spotted Mite, Tetranychus urticae Koch, Emergerd as a New Pest
in Persimmon Orchards and Approaches to Their Control
Chung Bu-Keun, Mitsuhiro Kawashima2, Chuleui Jung2
School of Bioresource Sciences, Andong National University, Andong 760-749, Korea
Abstract: Oriental persimmon, Diospyros kaki Thunb., endemic to East Asia is one of the major fruit
crops in Korea. We conducted a faunal survey of mites on persimmon trees in Korea from June to
September 2006, focusing on herbivorous and predacious mites. Mites of Tetranychidae and
Tenuipalpidae were dominantly collected as herbivores, while those of Phytoseiidae and Stigmaeidae
were predominant as predators. All identified tenuipalpid mites were Tenuipalpus zhizhilashviliae
Reck. Most of the collected tetranychid mites were found to belong to the genus Tetranychus. To
clarify the species identity, additional collections of tetraychid mites during summer 2007 on sweet
persimmon were made. The mites were identified as Tetranychus urticae Koch. Four phytoseiid
species, Neoseiulus womersleyi (Schicha), Amblyseius eharai Amitai and Swirski, Phytoseius
(Dubininellus) rubii Xin, Liang and Ke and Typhlodromus (Anthoseius) vulgaris Ehara were collected.
Among them, A. eharai was the most dominant species. Seventeen populations of two spotted mites
(TSM) were observed 3 times per month from May to October to decipher their fluctuations at the site
of individual farmer’s orchard from Sacheon, Sancheong, and Jinju in Gyeongsangnam-do and
Gwangyang, Gurye, and Suncheon in Jeollanam-do. Among them, only 2 sites were [mf1]properly
managed, 5 sites were required to control but the farmers had little information on the mite and its
damage, though 10 orchards were not at risk of infestation. Numbers of TSM on 100 leaves reached
more than 400 at orchards from Sacheon, Okgok, and Muncheok, showing remarkably discolored
leaves.
Persimmon, Tetranychus urticae, Overwintering, Control
371
Observations on the relation between the induction and termination of
diapause in codling moth in Dutch and Belgian populations.
Marc Trapman1, Matty Polfliet2, Herman Helsen3
1 Bio Fruit Advies, Dorpsstraat 31, Zoelmond, the Netherlands, 2 Fruit Consult, Zetten, the
Netherlands,; 3 Applied Plant Research, Wageningen UR, Zetten, the Netherland
Abstract: Effective codling moth (CM) management requires accurate information on the
phenological stage and development of the local CM population to be controlled. Several advisors and
scientists in Europe explain local differences in pheromone trap catches from the hypotheses of
“recalled diapause day length”. According to this hypothesis, individuals in the population remember
the day length at which their diapause was induced, and terminate their diapause the following spring
at the same day length. This would mean that events that have a quantitative impact on parts of the
population shape the phenological development next year. This has the practical consequence that
codling moth phenology is determined at a local scale and regional warning systems cannot provide
the information necessary for local control. The aim of our work was to test if this hypothesis holds for
CM populations in the Netherlands and Belgium. CM collected from orchards in the Netherlands and
Belgium in 2007 consisted for 98% of univoltine individuals. For these individuals we found no
relation between the date we collected them as fully grown larva during summer 2007, and their date
of pupation in 2008. These results mean that the hypothesis of “recalled diapause day length” does not
hold for the almost completely univoltine CM populations in the Netherlands and Belgium. Therefore,
the phenology of our local populations can not be influenced by events in the previous year.
Temperature relations and a normal distribution can be used to describe the spring pupation of a
codling moth population.
Cydia pomonella, Diapause
372
Practical results of a stacked control strategy for codling moth (Cydia
pomonella L ) management
Marc Trapman1, Herman Helsen2, Matty Polfliet3
1 Bio Fruit Advies, Dorpsstraat 31, Zoelmond, the Netherlands; 2 Applied Plant Research,
Wageningen UR, Zetten, the Netherlands; 3 Fruit Consult, Zetten, the Netherlands
Abstract: Codling moth (CM) is an important pest in both organic and integrated apple production in
the Netherlands and Belgium. Control of the pest became more difficult during the past ten years. A
series of biological and chemical plant protection products (PPP’s) is available for the regulation of
CM, but field trials throughout Europe have shown that season long application of the same PPP
provides only 50 to 70% control. Random alternation of products is not likely to improve efficacy.
However, the available PPP’s have different modes of action, and act at different life stages in the CM
biology. When applied with respect to their individual mode of action, and scheduled according to the
local biology of the CM population, the efficacy of PPP’s could be stacked, yielding a technically,
economically and ecologically improved control. This approach was tested in commercial apple
orchards in an extension project in 2007 and 2008. The penology of the CM populations was
calculated with the RIMpro-Cydia model using weather data from on-farm weather stations.
Combinations of pheromone confusion to reduce the total number of eggs deposited, fenoxycarb at
30% rate as an ovicide at the predicted peaks in egg deposition, and granulosis virus at a 50% rate in
periods of predicted peaks in egg-hatching where used on the farms following the Stacked Control
Strategy. Randomly chosen orchards in the same geographic region that did not take part in the
extension project served as control group. In both years CM control in the Stacked Control Strategy
orchards was more effective, and had a lower insecticide input and a lower environmental impact
compared to the control group.
Codling moth, Cydia pomonella, Control strategy, RIMpro-Cydia
373
Biological aspects and predatory capacity of Chrysoperla externa
(Hagen, 1861) (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae) fed on Planococcus citri
(Risso, 1813) (Hemiptera: Pseudococcidae)
César F. Carvalho1, Gerane C. D. Bezerra1, Brígida Souza1, Lenira V. C. Santa-Cecília2
1
Federal University of Lavras, Department of Entomology, P.O. Box 3037, 37200-000-Lavras
– MG, Brazil; 2EPAMIG/CTSM, P.O. Box 176, 37200-000-Lavras – MG, Brazil
Abstract: In the citrus mealybug complex, Planococcus citri is one of the most important pests and its
control is effected by insecticides. The green lacewing Chrysoperla externa is an insect often found in
citrus orchards and is a natural predator of this pest. This work deals with studies on the predatory
capacity and some biological aspects of larvae fed the three instars and adult female of P. citri. The
experiments were conducted at 25±1 oC, 70±10% of RH and 12-hour photophase with four treatments,
represented by the development stages, and 30 replicates in a complete randomized design. It was
found that the total predatory capacity of lacewing larvae was 231.2; 77.9; 32.6 and 21.2 for the three
instars and adult females, respectively. The longevity of second and third instars of green lacewing
larvae was lengthened when fed on adult mealybug females. The pupal stage was longer when it
originated from larvae fed second and third instar larvae and adult females. The immature stage lasted
from 19.8 to 22.9 days, and survivorship for this period was from 78.0 to 91.0%. A reduction in the
number of consumed mealybugs was found in each instar, regardless the lacewing instar, however
both nymphs and adult mealybug females were adequate prey for the larval development of C.
externa.
Key words: citrus, lacewing, biology, predation
Introduction
The citrus mealybug Planococcus citri (Risso) (Pseudococcidae) is found in tropical,
subtropical and temperate regions of the world (Llorens, 1990; Waterhouse, 1998) and is often
reported causing injuries to fructiferous plants, coffee, soybean and ornamentals. Chemical
control is the method most used to control this pest although alternative methods are currently
under investigation. The mealybugs have several natural enemies, crysopids (Neuroptera:
Chrysopidae) among them. These insects are found in several crops of economic interest
feeding on aphids, scales, and eggs, larvae and pupae of Lepidoptera. Biological aspects of
this predator have been studied in Brazil, specially Chrysoperla externa (Hagen), and its
potential as a biological control investigated (Fonseca et al., 2001; Maia et al., 2004; Barbosa
et al., 2006, 2008; Auad et al., 2007). However, development studies of this species and its
efficacy on scale populations reduction are scarce.
The present study deals with biological studies of immature stages and predatory
capacity of C. externa fed on P. citri nymphs and adult females.
Materials and Methods
One hundred C. externa eggs obtained from a stock rearing maintained in the laboratory (F3)
were placed individually in Petri dishes, and kept at 25±1oC, 70±10% RH and 12-hour
374
photophase. The mealybugs were collected on coffee plants cv. Mundo Novo and reared on
potato Solanum tuberosum (L.) cv. Monalisa sprouts. Biological aspects of the immature
stages and predatory capacity of this crysopid were evaluated for each instar by daily
delivering a known number of first, second and third instar nymphs of P. citri and adult
females under several densities (Table 1). The mean number of mealybugs furnished to each
instar of the predator was above its daily consumption capacity. There were four treatments
and 30 replicates under a completely randomized experimental design, with evaluations of the
mean life span and survivorship on each instar and during the stages of larva, prepupa and
pupa, larva-adult period, total predatory capacity.
The lifetime of the immature stages was obtained by punctual estimate given by the
median, and data related to duration and survivorship obtained by the non-parametric method
of Kaplan-Meier, which were compared by the Wilcoxon test (Colosimo & Giolo, 2006). The
interpretations related to the mean lifetime of the first, second and third instars, larval stage
and prepupa, pupa stages and larva-adult period were based on survivorship percent. Analysis
related to the predatory capacity were made by estimating the consumption proportions of
each instar of C. externa in relation to the total nymphs and adults of P. citri furnished.
Table 1. Number of Planococcus citri at different stages furnished to first, second and third
instar Chrysoperla externa larvae. Temperature 25±1oC, 70±10% RH, 12-hour photophase.
Development stages
Number of mealybugs furnished/instar of the predator
of the mealybug
2nd
3rd
1st
1st instar
2nd instar
3rd instar
Adult female
60
120
300
40
15
10
60
25
20
100
40
25
Results and Discussion
The mean lifetime was different for the second and third instars for C. externa larvae fed on
adult female mealybugs, as compared to those fed on nymphs regardless the instar (Table 2).
Gonçalves-Gervásio & Santa-Cecília (2001), in studies with C. externa fed on Dysmicoccus
brevipes (Cockerell) nymphs in all three instars and adult females found duration of 4.2; 3.2;
5.4 and 12.8 days, respectively. Variations detected in the duration of each instar and larval
stage gives evidence of the importance of diet on larval phase, in relation to results obtained
in other studies, supporting results of Principi & Canard (1984) who detected the influence of
food quality on insect development.
Higher survivorship was found in all three larval instars and total larval stage of C.
externa, when fed with first, second and third instar of the prey as compared to being fed on
adult females (Table 2). This may be due to the presence of a powdery secretion covering
mealybug body as well as the hardening of its integument, increasing the difficulty on
chrysopid feeding, as well as the larger size of the prey in relation to the predator. Awadallah
et al. (1975) found that Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens) larvae had mouthparts tangled on wax
secretion of Icerya purchasi (Maskell) nymphs and adults. The secretion by adult females of
P. citri of a jelly substance from lateral ostioles may pose additional difficulties for C. externa
375
feeding. According to Willians (1978), this secretion, produced particularly by adult females,
is a carrier of an alarm pheromone.
Table 2. Mean lifetime (T) in days and survivorship (S) in %, of three larval stage of
Chrysoperla externa fed on Planococcus citri. Temperature 25±1°C, 70±10% RH, 12-hour
photophase.
Predator instar
Stages of the
mealybug
1st
2nd
3rd
Larval stage
T
S
T
S
T
S
T
S
1st instar
3.8
90.0
3.0
100.
0
3.9
98.0
11.1
72.
0
2nd instar
3.8
89.0
3.1
100.
0
3.9
100.
0
11.3
89.
0
3rd instar
3.8
98.0
3.1
100.
0
4.0
100.
0
10.9
89.
0
Adult female
3.9
79.0
6.2
65.0
6.1
69.0
13.8
60.
0
Wilcoxon test
Value of P
0.9629
0.0001*
0.0029*
0.0984
The mean prepupa lifetime did not differ in relation to prey development stage, with a
variation from 3.0 to 3.4 days, but did differ in the pupal stage originated from larvae fed on
second and third stage nymphs and adult females in relation to those fed on first instar
nymphs (Table 3). Survivorship in prepupae did not differ in function of the consumed food,
with a variation of 98.0% to 100%. Nevertheless, there was a reduction in survival rate of
pupae originated from larvae fed on second and third instars and adult females of the
mealybug in relation to those of the first instar (Table 3). Thus, it is important to recognize the
importance of the kind of prey and its development stage on the predator life-cycle. The mean
larva-adult period of C. externa was 19.8 to 22.9 days in function to the stage of P. citri given
to the larvae (Table 3). Results near these (23.8 days) were found by Gonçalves-Gervásio &
Santa-Cecília (2001), with this chrysopid fed on D. brevipes.
376
Table 3. Mean lifetime (T) in days, survivorship (S) in %, of prepupa, pupa and larva-adult of
Chrysoperla externa fed on Planococcus citri. Temperature 25±1°C, 70±10% RH, 12-hour
photophase.
Stages of the
mealybug
Prepupa
Pupa
Period larva to adult
T
S
T
S
T
S
st
3.0
98.0
5.9
100.0
19.8
89.0
nd
3.1
100.0
6.8
58.0
20.9
91.0
rd
3 instar
3.1
100.0
6.0
79.0
22.3
89.0
Adult female
3.4
100.0
7.2
75.0
22.9
78.0
1 instar
2 instar
Wilcoxon test
Value of P
0.0500
0.0004*
0.0014*
Survivorship for the larva-adult period of C. externa when fed with nymphs and adult females
of P. citri were 89%; 91%; 89% and 78%, respectively. Adult females of the prey were related
to lower survivorship of the predator, probably due to larger prey size, the presence of the wax
powdery secretion covering mealybug body and the hardening of the integument.
In relation to predatory capacity, differences were found for total predation of all three
instars and adult females of P. citri as a function of C. externa development stages, lower on
first and higher on third instar. A 30X increase in larva consumption from first to third stage
was detected , when fed on first instar mealybugs, and circa 8X when fed on second and third
instars and adult females of P. citri. It was observed that there was, in general, an increase in
consumption from the second day on of each instar and reduction from the fourth to the fifth
day. This reduction was probably due to a reduction of the insect’s metabolism due to the
proximately of a new ecdysis. Consumption, metabolism and growth have a tendency to reach
a peak at the beginning or close to halftime of each instar and consumption efficiency may
diminish along the stages.
For the chrysopid first stage, there was a higher second-instar mealybug consumption
and lower third instar nymphs and females. Meanwhile, in relation to predation capacity in
second and third stages, there was higher consumption of mealybugs nymphs of the first
instar and lower consumption of those of the third instar and females. As for predatory
capacity, there was a higher consumption of mealybugs of first instar relative to those of third
instars and females of P. citri (Table 4). This is favorable in biological control programs since
first and second instar larvae have greater mobility and capacity for spread on the plants.
Differences in consumption found for all predator instars in relation to mealybug development
stages were due to several factors, the size and density of prey among others, as reported by
Fonseca et al. (2001), when fed C. externa larvae with aphid Schizaphis graminum.
Gravena et al. (1993) observed higher consumption of Parlatoria cinerea Doane &
Hadden eggs than nymphs and adults by C. externa. Yet, Gonçalves-Gervásio & Santa-Cecília
(2001) reported higher consumption of first and second instars relative to third instars and
adult females of D. brevipes. Malleshaiah et al. (2000) detected that C. carnea were active
predators of P. citri, with higher consumption of eggs and nymphs than adults.
377
Table 4. Total consumption during the three instars and adult females of Planococcus citri
by larvae of Chrysoperla externa. Temperature 25±1°C, 70±10% RH, 12-hour
photophase.
Stages of
the
mealybug
Total number of consumed mealybugs/ instars
predator
Total
1st
2nd
3rd
1st instar
6.5
28.5
196.2
231.2
2nd instar
7.9
15.2
54.8
77.9
3rd instar
2.5
5.8
24.3
32.6
Adult
female
1.7
4.9
14.6
21.2
Conclusion
Nymphs of all three instars and adult females of P. citri were, in general, adequate prey for the
development of immature stages of C. externa. Lower survivorship was observed in C.
externa larvae fed on adult females of the mealybug. The development stage of both prey and
predator influenced the number of predated mealybugs.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to CNPq – Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico
for the financial support.
References
Auad, A.M., Carvalho, C.F., Souza, B., Simões, A.D., Oliveira, S.A., Braga, A.L.F. &
Ferreira, R.B. 2007. Potencial de Chrysoperla externa (Hagen) no controle de Bemisia
tabaci (Gennadius) biótipo B em tomateiro. Acta Sci. Agron. 29: 29-32.
Awadallah, K.T., Abou-Zeid, N.A., & Tamafik, M.F.S. 1975. Development and fecundity of
Chrysopa carnea Stephens. Bull. Soc. Entomol. 59: 323-329.
Barbosa, L.R., Carvalho, C.F., Souza, B., & Auad, A.M. 2006. Influência da densidade de
Myzus persicae (Sulzer) sobre alguns aspectos biológicos e capacidade predatória de
Chrysoperla externa (Hagen). Acta Acta Sci. 28: 227-231.
Barbosa, L.R., Carvalho, C.F., Souza, B. & Auad, A.M. 2008. Eficiência de Chrysoperla
externa (Hagen, 1861) (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae) no controle de Myzus persicae (Sulzer,
1776) (Hemiptera: Aphididae) em pimentão (Capsicum annum L.). Ciênc. agrotec. 32:
1113-1119.
Colosimo, E.A. & Giolo, S.R. 2006. Análise de sobrevivência aplicada. I ed., 216p. São
Paulo: Edgar Blucher.
Fonseca, A.R., Carvalho, C.F. & Souza, B. 2001. Capacidade predatória e aspectos biológicos
das fases imaturas de Chrysoperla externa (Hagen) alimentada com Schizaphis graminum
378
(Rondani) em diferentes temperaturas. Ciênc. agrotec. 25: 251-263.
Gonçalves-Gervásio, R.C. & Santa-Cecília, L.V.C. 2001. Consumo alimentar de Chrysoperla
externa sobre as diferentes fases de desenvolvimento de Dysmicoccus brevipes, em
laboratório. Pesq. agropec. bras. 36: 387-391.
Gravena, S., Yamamoto, P.T., & Fernandes, O.D. 1993. Biology of Parlatoria cinerea and
predation by Chrysoperla externa (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). Cientifica 21: 149-156.
Llorens, J.M. 1990. Homoptera I – Cochinilhas de los cítricos y su control biológico.
Valencia, Espanha: Pisa Ediciones, 260 p.
Maia, W.J.M.S., Carvalho, C.F., Souza, B., & Cruz, I. 2004. Capacidade predatória e aspectos
biológicos de Chrysoperla externa (Hagen) alimentada com Rhopalosiphum maidis
(Fitch). Ciênc. agrotec. 28: 1259-1268.
Malleshaiah, B., Rajagopal, K., & Gowda, K.N.M. 2000. Feeding potential of Chrysoperla
carnea (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae) of different stages of citrus mealybug, Planococcus
citri (Hemiptera: Pseudococcidae). Crop Research 20: 126-129.
Principi, M. M., & Canard, M. 1984. Feeding habits. In: Canard, M.; Séméria, Y.; New, T. R.
(Eds.). Biology of Chrysopidae, The Hague: Dr. W. Junk Publisher, p. 76-92.
Waterhouse, D.F. 1998. Biological control of insect pest: Southeast Asian prospects.
Canberra: Aciar Monograph,. 548 p.
Williams, D.J. 1978. The anomalous ant-attended mealybugs (Homoptera: Pseudococcidae)
of Southern Asia. Bull. B. Mus. (Natural History). Entomol. 37: 1-72.
379
Effect of floral strips on the abundance of Hymenopteran parasitoids
in apple and olive organic orchards
Hazem Dib, Gilles Libourel, François Warlop
GRAB “Groupe de Recherche en Agriculture Biologique”, Site Agroparc-BP 1222, 84911
Avignon Cedex 9, France
Abstract: Habitat manipulation techniques improve the availability of resources required by natural
enemies to increase their effectiveness. This study focused on the effects of sown floral strips on
Hymenopteran parasitoid abundance. The experiments were conducted during spring 2007 in one
organic low-input apple orchard and five organic olive orchards located in southern France. The
density and the diversity of parasitic wasps collected from sown floral strips were higher than those
from naturally occurring flora or mowed plants. The family of parasitic wasps of Braconidae was
strongly dominant, followed by Mymaridae, Eulophidae and Pteromalidae. Among the 26 studied
flowering species in the apple orchard, the greatest diversity and density of parasitic wasps were
collected from Potentilla reptans, Achillea millefolium, Trifolium repens and Torilis arvensis. In terms
of the early flowering plants, the most important results were observed in Euphorbia helioscopia,
Senecio vulgaris and Veronica persica. To give an idea of the functional role of these plants, we
studied the parasitic wasps of the diapausing larvae (cocoon) of codling moth Cydia pomonella. We
recorded three emerged species: Ascogaster quadridentata, Pristomerus vulnerator and the
hyperparasite Perilampus fulvicornis. However, none of these species have been observed on the 26
studied plants. Hence, this result may be suggesting that the studied plants do not have a functional
role concerning these parasitoids. These studies may be advantageous for biological control programs
in order to select flowering plant species attracting parasitic wasps specific to fruit pests.
Keywords: conservation biological control, habitat manipulation, floral strips, Hymenopteran
parasitoid, organic orchard, olive, apple, codling moth, Cydia pomonella, cocoon
Introduction
The biological control of herbivorous pests can be improved by habitat manipulation in order
to favour natural enemies, providing suitable microclimates, alternative preys, and floral
resources for adult natural enemies (Landis et al., 2000; Rebek et al., 2005). In particular,
establishing floral vegetation can provide adult parasitic wasps with essential nutrients and
energy, and may improve longevity, fecundity, flight ability, and rates of parasitism in general
(Jervis et al., 1993; Tooker and Hanks, 2000).
Although the availability of flowering plant has important implications for conservation
biological control, little is known of the specific associations between parasitic wasps and
flowering plant species (Jervis et al., 1993). This host-plant fidelity could be used in
biological control programs for selecting plant species that attract parasitoid species (Tooker
and Hanks, 2000).
The present study investigated the influence of floral strips on the abundance and the
diversity of parasitic wasps (entomological role) in apple and olive organic orchards. To give
an idea of the functional role of these strips, we studied the parasitic wasps of the diapausing
larvae of codling moth Cydia pomonella L. (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae), a major worldwide
pest of apple and pear (Mills, 2005).
380
Materials and Methods
Study orchards and floral strips
The studies were conducted during spring 2007 in southern France on five organic olive
orchards, of 0.1 to 3 ha. In addition, one organic low-input apple orchard of 0.62 ha was
surveyed; with 212 trees planted in 9 rows in 2001. In the olive orchards, 1 to 3 floral strips of
100-300m2 were sown using a seed mixture of 49 floral species from autumn 2004 to autumn
2006. In autumn 2003, four floral strips of 1m width each were sown in the apple orchard.
Sampling method
The parasitic wasps were collected into tissue bags using aspirators. In the olive orchards, one
aspiration bag is used per orchard on all the floral strips (2 minutes of aspiration per strip).
Natural flora was considered as controls. One series of aspirations per orchard was performed.
In the apple orchard, we studied the importance of 26 flowering species regarding the
parasitic wasps (Table 1). One aspiration bag is used per species (three replicates per species
and 5 seconds of aspiration per replicate). We chose the mowed plants (without flowers) as
control. Each species was evaluated between three and seven times. The results of flowering
species in apple orchard were compared for significance by a Mann-Whitney U test (P<0.05).
Study the parasitic wasps of the codling moth cocoons
212 corrugated cardboard bands (60 mm diameter) were wrapped around the trunks of apple
trees in June 2006 (1band/tree). They were collected in October 2006 and in March 2007. 294
larvae were recovered. Each of them was put in a tube and observed until adult emergence.
Results and discussion
Hymenopteran parasitoid families
969 parasitic wasps divided into 21 families were collected from both floral strips and
spontaneous flora in the olive orchards. The Braconidae family was the best represented with
306 parasitoid wasps (31.5% of all parasitoid wasps collected), followed by Eulophidae
(16.4%), Mymaridae (14.7%) and Pteromalidae (8.9%). These families were observed in all
the orchards. The remaining families were represented by 4.6% or fewer, each. In the apple
orchard and during the observation period, a total of 1469 parasitic wasps divided into 22
families were collected from the 26 studied flowering species and the mowed plants (control).
The majority of Hymenopteran parasitoids collected belonged to the Braconidae family with
423 parasitoid wasps (28.8%), followed by Mymaridae (22.8%) and Pteromalidae (8.7%).
These families were listed on all flowering species and control and in all the observation
dates. The remaining families were represented by 6.5% or fewer, each.
Braconids, which parasitize a wide range of hosts, are normally the parasitic wasps the
most widespread in Europe. They are considered almost entirely beneficial and many species
have been introduced or conserved in biological control programs (Tooker and Hanks, 2000).
Entomological role of floral strips
This study demonstrates that the density and the diversity of parasitic wasps collected from
sown floral strips were higher than those from spontaneous flora (Figure 1) or mowed plants
(Table 1), as found by similar studies (Jervis et al., 1993; Landis et al., 2000; Rebek et al.,
2005). Floral strips are attractive for adult parasitic wasps which often visit flowers to feed on
floral resources: pollen and/or nectar (Landis et al., 2000; Rebek et al., 2005).
In the apple orchard and among the 26 flowering species studied (Table 1), the greatest
diversity and density of wasps was collected from Potentilla reptans, Achillea millefolium,
Trifolium repens, and Torilis arvensis. In contrast, the lowest results were recorded on
Melilotus officinalis, Malva sylvestris, and Tragopogon pratensis.
381
Strip
(B)
Control
Mean number/strip
Families number
(A)
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
n°1
n°2
n°3
n°4
n°5
Orchard
Strip
Control
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
n°1
n°2
n°3
n°4
n°5
Orchard
Figure 1. Diversity (A) and mean density (B) of Hymenopteran parasitoids collected from
floral strips and spontaneous flora (control) in the five organic olive orchards.
Table 1. Mean (± SE) diversity and density of parasitic wasps per flowering species in the
apple orchard. Means followed by different letters are significantly different (Mann-Whitney
U test, P < 0.05). (n): Number of assessments. (*): Early flowering species.
Latin name
Family
Asteraceae
Achillea millefolium
Boraginaceae
Borago officinalis
Poaceae
Bromus catharticus
Poaceae
Bromus sterilis
Capsella bursa-pastoris * Brassicaceae
Brassicaceae
Cardaria draba
Asteraceae
Carduus tenuiflorus
Asteraceae
Coreopsis tinctoria
Crepis sancta *
Asteraceae
Asteraceae
Crepis vesicaria
Euphorbia helioscopia *
Euphorbiaceae
Rubiaceae
Galium aparine
Malvaceae
Malva sylvestris
Fabaceae
Melilotus officinalis
Plantaginaceae
Plantago lanceolata
Poaceae
Poa trivialis
Rosaceae
Potentilla reptans
Rosaceae
Sanguisorba minor
Senecio vulgaris *
Asteraceae
Asteraceae
Sonchus oleraceus
Taraxacum officinale *
Asteraceae
Apiaceae
Torilis arvensis
Tragopogon pratensis *
Asteraceae
Fabaceae
Trifolium repens
Veronica persica *
Scrophulariaceae
Fabaceae
Vicia sativa
Control (mowed plants)
In terms of the early flowering plants, the
382
Diversity
Density/species
n
7.00 ± 1.56 (a,b)
9.55 ± 3.34 (a)
3
2.71 ± 0.51 (d)
2.95 ± 1.18 (c)
7
5.67 ± 0.90 (c)
3.66 ± 0.85 (c)
3
4.17 ± 0.73 (c)
3.16 ± 0.82 (c)
6
2.50 ± 0.29 (d)
1.83 ± 0.32 (c,d)
4
5.00 ± 0.72 (c)
4.61 ± 0.52 (b)
6
6.40 ± 0.41 (b)
3.53 ± 0.31 (c)
5
6.67 ± 0.68 (b)
3.44 ± 0.69 (c)
3
3.34 ± 0.36 (c)
2.28 ± 0.40 (c)
7
4.50 ± 0.29 (c)
2.66 ± 0.41 (c)
4
4.43 ± 0.90 (c)
3.95 ± 1.01 (c)
7
6.33 ± 1.48 (b,c)
5.33 ± 1.60 (a,b)
3
2.00 ± 0.59 (d)
1.11 ± 0.41 (d)
3
2.33 ± 1.36 (d)
1.11 ± 0.79 (d)
3
4.60 ± 0.83 (c)
2.80 ± 0.66 (c)
5
3.50 ± 0.42 (c)
2.22 ± 0.40 (c)
6
9.40 ± 1.27 (a)
17.00 ± 5.71 (a)
5
4.40 ± 0.69 (c)
3.00 ± 0.60 (c)
5
4.14 ± 0.89 (c)
3.57 ± 1.00 (c)
7
3.60 ± 0.69 (c)
2.53 ± 0.92 (c)
5
3.71 ± 0.55 (c)
2.43 ± 0.39 (c)
7
8.67 ± 1.71 (a)
4.44 ± 1.31 (b)
3
1.57 ± 0.42 (d)
1.14 ± 0.46 (d)
7
8.00 ± 1.02 (a)
7.11 ± 2.65 (a)
3
4.00 ± 1.00 (c)
3.33 ± 1.08 (c)
4
4.83 ± 0.85 (c)
4.16 ± 1.01 (b,c)
6
1.64 ± 0.20 (d)
0.66 ± 0.09 (d)
11
most important performance was remarked
with Euphorbia helioscopia, Senecio vulgaris, and Veronica persica. Establishing these
species, which start to flower early in the season in the orchards, is very important to attract
the natural enemies and to develop their populations to satisfactory levels. These levels may
be able to control the pests which arrive early, e.g. the rosy apple aphid (Wyss, 1995).
The popularity of P. reptans among the flowering species studied may be explained by its
floral characteristics, such as the yellow colour, the depth of corolla tube and the floral odours
which are effective attractants of parasitic wasps (Patt et al., 1997; Wäckers, 1994).
Many species of parasitic Hymenoptera should be able to reach the nectar in the flowers
because they do not have mouthparts specifically adapted to extract pollen or nectar. Thus,
they must feed on flowers with open structures, namely exposed nectaries and anthers, which
are easily accessible to wasps of different sizes and with generalized mouthparts (Patt et al.,
1997; Tooker and Hanks, 2000). The excellent examples of these plants in our study are A.
millefolium, T. repens and T. arvensis. Flowers of several species of Fabaceae and Asteraceae
have more concealed anthers and nectaries excluding some wasp species (Jervis et al., 1993).
This fact could explain our results on T. pratensis and M. officinalis.
Functional role of floral strips (parasitism of the codling moth cocoon)
A total of 23 Hymenopteran parasitoids emerged from 294 larvae (parasitism rate: 7.82%).
Three emerged species were recorded; two primary parasitoids Ascogaster quadridentata
“Braconidae” (60.9%) and Pristomerus vulnerator “Ichneumonidae” (8.7%), and a
hyperparasitoid Perilampus fulvicornis “Perilampidae” (30.4%). These parasitoid
assemblages are similar to those reported previously (Mills, 2005).
Finally, it is notable that none of these species have been observed on the 26 studied
plants or mowed plants (control). Hence, this result may suggest that the studied plants do not
have a functional role concerning these parasitoids.
These findings support the concept that floral sources availability in orchards may be
improving the parasitoids efficiency as biological control agents. This requires a judicious
selection of flowering species to attract parasitoids specific to pests. Thus, it would appear
that the functional role of flowering plants needs to be addressed in further studies.
References
Jervis, M.A.; Kidd, N.A.C.; Fitton, M.G.; Huddleston, T. & Dawah, H.A. 1993: Flowervisiting by hymenopteran parasitoids. J. Nat. Hist. 27: 67-105.
Landis, D.A.; Wratten, S.D. & Gurr, G.M. 2000: Habitat management to conserve natural
enemies of arthropod pests in agriculture. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 45: 175-201.
Mills, N.J. 2005: Selecting effective parasitoids for biological control introductions: Codling
moth as a case study. Biol. Control. 34: 274-282.
Patt, J.M.; Hamilton, G.C. & Lashomb, J.H. 1997: Foraging success of parasitoid wasps on
flowers: the interplay of insect morphology, floral architecture and searching behaviour.
Entomol. Exp. Appl. 83: 21-30.
Rebek, E.J.; Sadof, C.S. & Hanks, L.M. 2005: Manipulating the abundance of natural enemies
in ornamental landscapes with floral resource plants. Biol. Control. 33: 203-216.
Tooker, J.F. & Hanks, L.M. 2000: Flowering plant hosts of adult Hymenopteran parasitoids of
Central Illinois. Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 93 (3): 580-588.
Wäckers, F.L. 1994: The effect of food deprivation on the innate visual and olfactory
preferences in the parasitoid Cotesia rubecula. J. Insect. Physiol. 40: 641-649.
Wyss, E. 1995: The effects of weed strips on aphids and aphidophagous predators in an apple
orchard. Entomol. Exp. Appl. 75: 43-49.
383
Side effect of selected insecticides on Aphidius colemani, Aphidoletes
aphidimyza and Neoseiulus cucumeris as model species of natural
enemies
Jitka Stará1, Josef Havlík2, Kamil Holý1, František Kocourek1
1
Department of Entomology, Crop Research Institute, 161 06 Prague, Czech Republic;
2
Department of Plant Protection, Czech University of Life Sciences, 165 21 Prague, Czech
Republic
Abstract: Side-effects of selected insecticides on model species of natural enemies, Aphidius
colemani, Aphidoletes aphidimyza and Neoseiulus cucumeris were tested in laboratory conditions.
Methoxyfenozide (Integro), indoxacarb (Steward 30 WG), pyridaben (Sanmite 20 WP), acetamiprid
(Mospilan 20 SP), azadirachtin A (NeemAzal T/S) and spinosad (Spintor 480 SC) were tested against
adults of A. colemani and larvae of A. aphidimyza. Propargite (Omite 570 EW) and Cyperkill 25 EC
(cypermethrin) were also tested against adults of N. cucumeris,. Mortality of tested species after 24 or
48 hours of exposure to residues of insecticides was evaluated. For insecticides with a low toxic effect,
the effect on fecundity of A. colemani was tested. Methoxyfenozide had low toxic effect on all three
insect species, causing mortality after 24 hours from 4.6% to 29.8%. Similarly, indoxacarb caused
mortality after 24 hours from 11.1% to 25%. However, higher mortality of A. colemani was found
after 48 hours of exposure to residues of methoxyfenozide and indoxacarb. Acetamiprid was highly
toxic to A. colemani (100% mortality), medium toxic to A. aphidimyza (48.1% mortality) and no effect
was found to N. cucumeris (2.3% mortality). Similar results were obtained with NeemAzal T/S.
However, low toxicity to A. colemani was found when pure azadirachtin A was tested instead of
formulated product NeemAzal T/S. In general, N. cucumeris exhibited the lowest sensitivity to all the
insecticides. In contrast to this, A. colemani was highly sensitive to most of the insecticides.
Key words: Aphidius colemani, Aphidoletes aphidimyza, Neoseiulus cucumeris, insecticides, sideeffect
Introduction
The success of integrated pest management (IPM) in orchards is closely connected with
support of beneficial organisms in the environment. In order to protect habitats within and
adjacent to agricultural areas, side-effect testing on nontarget organisms is required for
registration of pesticides in the European Union (Council of the European Union, 1996).
Hence, for most of the registered insecticides, selectivity to natural enemies of pests is
declared. However, some of the insecticides are not entirely selective to some species of
beneficial insects. Knowledge about the selectivity of insecticides is usually incomplete or the
selectivity depends on the used rate of the insecticide. Repeat application of such less
selective insecticides can lead to erosion of IPM.
The target of our study was to characterize side effects of new types of insecticides on
selected species of natural enemies that is on the parasitic wasp Aphidius colemani, the
predatory mite Neoseiulus cucumeris and the predatory gall midge Aphidoletes aphidimyza.
Material and methods
Aphidius colemani
384
The IOBC procedure (Candolfi et al., 2000) was used in our experiment to test side-effects of
insecticides Integro (methoxyfenozide), Steward 30 WG (indoxacarb), Sanmite 20 WP
(pyridaben), Mospilan 20 SP (acetamiprid), NeemAzal T/S (azadirachtin A), azadirachtin A
and Spintor 480 SC (spinosad) on the parasitic wasp A. colemani. Wasps were held in groups
of ten per replication. After treatment of glass plates, one-day-old wasps were exposed to dry
residues of insecticides for 48 hours. The wasps were fed with honey via a cotton wool wick.
Mortality of A. colemani wasps was evaluated after 24 and 48 hours. Effect of azadirachtin A
and Integro as low toxic products were tested on fecundity of A. colemani. After 48 hours of
exposure to dry residues of insecticides, the surviving wasps were sexed and females were
introduced individually onto bean plants with defined numbers of nymphs of Aphis fabae. At
the time of parasitism, most of the aphids (at least 80%) were last instar. Fecundity per female
wasp was calculated after 14 days as the number of mummified aphids per female and
compared with untreated controls.
Aphidoletes aphidimyza
Side-effects of Integro (methoxyfenozide), Steward 30 WG (indoxacarb), Mospilan 20 SP
(acetamiprid), NeemAzal T/S (azadirachtin A) and Spintor 480 SC (spinosad) against A.
aphidimyza were tested in bioassay. Filter-paper was treated with insecticides and placed into
Petri-dishes. Larvae of A. aphidimyza in groups of ten per replication were introduced into
Petri-dishes, fed by Acyrthosiphon pisum and exposed to fresh residues of insecticides for 24
hours. After this period, mortality was evaluated.
Neoseiulus cucumeris
Side-effects of Integro (methoxyfenozide), Steward 30 WG (indoxacarb), Sanmite 20 WP
(pyridaben), Mospilan 20 SP (acetamiprid), NeemAzal T/S (azadirachtin A), Cyperkill 25 EC
(cypermethrin) and Omite 570 EW (propargite) were tested in bioassay. Filter-paper was
treated with insecticides and placed into macro titre-plates. Mites in groups of ten per
replication were introduced into the plates and exposed to fresh residues of insecticides for 24
hours. After this period, mortality of mites was evaluated.
Perfekthion (dimethoate) was used as a reference insecticide with high toxicity in the
experiments with A. colemani and A. aphidimyza. All the insecticides were tested at rates
registered for use in orchards or fields.
Statistical analysis
Corrected mortalities (Abbott, 1925) of the tested insects were calculated. XL-STAT program
was used to evaluate the side effects of insecticides on A. colemani fecundity by ANOVA. In
this case, fecundity per female was transformed as Nt = log (N + 1*10-6), where N is number
of mummified aphids per female.
Results and discussion
Side-effects of insecticides on mortality of A. colemani, A. aphidimyza and N. cucumeris
In general, A. colemani was highly sensitive to most of the tested insecticides (Figure 1). In
contrast to this, N. cucumeris exhibited the lowest sensitivity to most of the insecticides
(Figure 2). New classes of insecticides represented by methoxyfenozide and indoxacarb had
usually low toxicity. According to Anonymus (2006), inconsistent results were obtained when
side-effect of indoxacarb was tested on A. colemani. In our experiments, low mortality of A.
colemani was found after 24 hours of exposure to residues of indoxacarb, but the mortality
considerably increased after 48 hours of exposition. Takahashi et al. (2005) found high
385
toxicity of spinosad to A. colemani. We confirm this result in our experiments. On the other
hand, spinosad was not toxic to A. aphidimyza. Various side-effects were found for
acetamiprid, which was highly toxic to A. colemani, medium-toxic to A. aphidimyza and was
not toxic to N. cucumeris (Figure 1 and 2).
24h
48h
di
ac
et
am
ip
rid
m
et
ho
at
e
sp
in
os
ad
py
az
r id
ad
ab
ira
en
ch
tin
az
fo
ad
rm
ir a
.
ch
tin
m
pu
et
ox
re
yf
en
oz
id
e
in
do
xa
ca
rb
mortality %
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
insecticide
N. cucumeris
A. aphidimyza
py
rid
ab
en
ira
ch
tin
m
fo
et
rm
ho
.
xy
fe
no
zi
de
in
do
xa
ca
rb
pr
op
ar
gi
te
sp
in
os
ad
az
ad
di
m
et
ip
am
ac
et
ho
at
e
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
rid
mortality %
Figure 1. Mortality of A. colemani after 24 and 48 hours of exposure to dry residues of
insecticides
insecticide
Figure 2. Mortality of A. aphidimyza and N. cucumeris after 24 hours of exposure to residues
of insecticides
Different toxicity was found, when NeemAzal T/S (azadirachtin A formulated) and
azadirachtin A were tested against A. colemani. While azadirachtin A was not toxic to A.
colemani, the formulated product NeemAzal T/S based on azadirachtin A was highly toxic
(Figure 1). Low toxicity of NeemAzal T/S was found to N. cucumeris, while medium-toxicity
was found to A. aphidimyza.
386
Side-effects of insecticides on fecundity of A. colemani
Based on the results from the side-effect testing of insecticides on mortality of A. colemani,
Integro (methoxyfenozide) and azadirachtin A were selected as the only two insecticides with
low toxicity to test their side-effect on fecundity of A. colemani. The Anova model (F(2,46) =
4.076; p = 0.024) showed differences in fecundity of A. colemani. When the fecundity in
methoxyfenozide, azadirachtin and control treatments was compared by Tukey´s post hoc
comparison, the fecundity in methoxyfenozide treatment was reduced significantly (p=0,018).
In contrast to this, any effect of azadirachtin A on fecundity of A. colemani was not proved.
According to Spollen and Isman (1996), a significant negative effect of azadirachtin A on
fecundity of N. cucumeris was detected. In contrast to this, no effect of azadirachtin A on
fecundity of Orius laevigatus was found (Angeli et al., 2005). Concerning methoxyfenozide,
any data about the effect on fecundity of A. colemani has not recently been published.
According to our results, Integro (methoxyfenozide) and Steward (indoxacarb) proved to
be suitable pesticides for using in integrated pest control programmes as low toxic products.
Acknowledgements
The work was supported by the project of the Ministry of Agriculture of the Czech Republic
no. 1G58081.
References
Abbott, W.S. 1925: A method of computing the effectiveness of an insecticide. J. Econ.
Entomol. 18: 265-267.
Angeli, G. 2005: Side-effects of pesticides on the predatory bug Orius laevigatus
(Heteroptera: Anthocoridae) in the laboratory. Biocontrol Science and Technology 15(7):
745-754.
Anonymus 2006: Effets sur les organismes utiles par famille [online]. 2006 [cit. 2009-28-01].
available at http://e-phy.agriculture.gouv.fr/ecoacs/liste action 01.htm/.
Council of the European Union 1996: Commission Directive 96/12/EC of 8 March 1996
amending Council Directive 91/414/EEC concerning the placing of plant protection
products on the market. Official Journal of the European Communities L65: 20-37.
Candolfi, M.P., Blümel, S., Forster, R., Bakker, F.M., Grimm, S., Hassan, S.A., Heimbach, U.,
Mead-Briggs, M.A., Reber, B., Schmuck, R., Vogt, H. 2000: Guidelines to evaluate sideeffects of plant protection products to non-target arthropods. IOBC, BART and EPPO
Joint Initiative. IOBC/wprs, Gent: 158 pp.
Takahashi, Y., Kojimoto, T., Nagaoka, H., Takagi, Y., Oikawa, M. 2005: Tests for evaluating
the side effects of chlorothalonil (TPN) and spinosad on the parasitic wasp (Aphidius
colemani). Journal of Pesticide Science 30(1): 11-16.
Spollen, K.M., Isman, M.B. 1996: Acute and sublethal effects of a neem insecticide on the
commercial biological control agents Phytoseiulus persimilis and Amblyseius cucumeris
(Acari: Phytoseiidae) and Aphidoletes aphidimyza (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae). Journal of
Economic Entomology 89(6): 1379-1386.
387
Avian biodiversity: impacts of pest management strategies and
landscape in South-Eastern French apple orchards
Jean-Charles Bouvier, Julia Agerberg, Benoît Ricci, Claire Lavigne
Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, UR1115 Plantes et Systèmes de culture
Horticoles, Site Agroparc, 84914 Avignon, France
Abstract: In French apple orchards, the predominant conventional management strategy has resulted
insecticide resistance in major pests like codling moth and an increased frequency of environmentally
harmful insecticide applications. Organic agriculture as well as IPM represent alternatives to this
situation.
Impacts on the avifauna of three different management strategies (organic, conventional and
integrated) were studied during three years in 15 commercial apple orchards. These orchards were
situated around Avignon and had similar contexts in terms of local and landscape features.
Our results show that the avifauna differ significantly among the three management strategies with
abundances of 46, 30.3 and 7.6 individuals/ha for the organic, integrated and conventional orchards
respectively; species richness of 18.1, 14 and 7.6 breeding species/ha respectively and Shannon
diversity indexes of 3.8, 3.3 and 2.6 respectively. The functional structure of bird communities is also
affected, with a lesser proportion of insectivores in conventional orchards than in other orchards.
Phytosanitary and environmental factors taken together explain 52% of the variability of the
composition of bird communities. Phytosanitary treatments and local environment of the orchards had
a similar explanatory power of 11% while environment at the landscape scale explained approximately
19% of the variability.
We have demonstrated an important impact of phytosanitary practices on all parameters used to
describe bird communities. These results highlight the influence of fruit production on avian
biodiversity and its consequences in terms of protection of species of agronomical or patrimonial
interest.
Key words: Avian biodiversity, Apple orchard, Management strategy, Landscape
Introduction
In France, apple orchards constitute the main fruit culture covering about 54 000 ha. The most
widespread management method, which is referred to as the conventional strategy, involves
the exclusive use of chemical pesticides. Although pesticides allowed a significant increase in
productivity, their intensive use was associated with negative externalities such as the
development of insecticide resistances in the codling moth (Cydia pomonella), the major pest
of apple orchards, and undesirable environmental impacts due to considerable potential for
exposure of wildlife to frequent pesticides spraying. Organic and integrated pest management
(IPM) strategies represent alternatives to this situation. Both strategies involve alternative
practices such as insect mating disruption (saturation of an area with synthetic female
pheromone) and the application of granulosis virus against codling moth. The aim of this
study is to provide an integrated assessment of the environmental impact of farming practices
in apple orchards from South Eastern France using bird communities as bioindicators. In this
analysis, we attempted to dissociate the effects of pest management strategies on bird
communities from effects of landscape elements surrounding the orchards.
388
Material and methods
Study Area and apple orchard selection
Impacts of pest management strategies on the avifauna were studied during three years from
2003 to 2005 in 15 commercial apple orchards around Avignon, of which 5 were organic, 5
under an IPM strategy and 5 conventional. These orchards had an average area of 0.8 ha and
were chosen so that the three management strategies shared similar local and landscape
features that might influence bird communities. Management strategies were characterized at
the orchard level by analyses of the treatment calendars that were implemented in each of the
studied orchards.
Bird data
They were recorded using a point count method with 20 min visits between mid April and mid
May. Point counts were performed within 5 h after sunrise during the dawn peak in bird
activity and were carried out under good weather conditions (windy and rainy days were
excluded). All nesting birds heard and seen were recorded within each orchard and its
surrounding hedgerows. For each species, the maximum count of individuals from the two
visits was used. Bird counts were used to calculate the following parameters for each studied
orchard: bird abundance (the number of birds per orchard), species richness (the number of
species per orchard), and Shannon diversity indice (H = - ((ni / N) x Log2 (ni / N)), where ni is
the relative abundance of species i and N is the bird number of the orchard). These
parameters were also calculated within ecological guilds such as insectivorous, granivorous,
omnivorous and prey birds per orchard.
Landscape description
At the local scale, the following elements of focus orchards were recorded on the field:
hedgerow presence / absence, structure (height, length), and flora species richness; ditch
presence / absence. From these observations we calculated the maximal height of hedgerows,
the difference between maximal and minimal height of hedgerows, the average ratio length of
the hedgerow / perimeter of the orchard, calculated as the mean of these ratios on all the
hedgerows surrounding the orchard, the number of ditches, the average species richness of
hedgerows flora weighing individual hedgerow values by hedgerows lengths.
In a second step, we characterised the landscape context surrounding the orchards within 200
m wide buffers. For this purpose, focus orchards were mapped on a GIS (Arcview 9.1.) and
surrounding hedgerows, others orchards, wooded and open areas, and habitations were
mapped from 2004 aerial photographs (source IGN). From these features, we calculated the
proportions of buffer areas covered with either orchards, wooded area, open areas or
habitations (no dimension) and the ratio of the hedgerow length over buffer area (1/m).
Statistical analysis
Statistical analysis of data was performed using R (package Vegan). ANCOVA analyses were
performed to compare both numbers of pesticides treatments and bird parameters among
management strategies within years and across years. To investigate the part of the variation
in bird communities that was explained (1) by the pesticide applications, (2) by focus
orchards local characteristics and (3) by surrounding landscape features, we performed partial
Canonical correspondence analyses (CCA) using the package Vegan.
389
Results and discussion
Apple orchard pest management strategies
Pesticide applications were mostly targeted towards two fungal diseases, apple scab (Venturia
inaequalis) and powdery mildew (Podosphaera leucotrida), and an insect pest, the codling
moth. Chemical pesticides were never used in organic orchards. Compared to conventional
orchards, the adoption of mating disruption in IPM orchards resulted in a decreased number
of applications of neurotoxic insecticides that are known to have a high environmental impact.
Nevertheless, the mean number of annual neurotoxic insecticide applications in orchards
under IPM protection did not differ statistically from that in conventional orchards (Figure 1).
25
neurotoxic insecticides
microbiological insecticides + oils
20
chemical fungicides
mineral fungicides
15
10
5
0
organic
IPM
conventional
Figure 1. Annual pesticide applications in organic, IPM and conventional apple orchards
(mean number ± SD)
Apple orchard management strategies and bird biodiversity
Global bird community differed among the management strategies with abundances of 46,
30.3 and 7.6 individuals/ha for the organic, integrated and conventional orchards respectively
(LSMeans comparisons: organic vs IPM P=0.0959, organic vs conventional P=0.0008 and
IPM vs conventional P=0.0568); species richness of 18.1, 14 and 7.6 breeding species/ha
respectively (LSMeans comparisons: organic vs IPM P=0.0664, organic vs conventional
P=0.0001 and IPM vs conventional P=0.0160), and Shannon diversity indexes of 3.8, 3.3 and
2.6 respectively. The functional structure of bird communities was also affected, with a lesser
proportion of insectivores in conventional orchards than in other orchards. An increase in bird
abundance and diversity has been recorded in other studies in orchards (Genghini et al., 2006)
as well as in cereal fields under organic management, and sometimes under IPM, compared to
conventional ones (Chamberlain et al., 1999; Freemark and Kirk, 2001; Beecher et al., 2002).
These results show the positive effects of organic and IPM agriculture on bird communities
and their functional structure. These effects could be attributed to the different pest
management strategies, i.e. the type of chemicals and the number of applications that can
affect bird communities and reproduction of insectivorous species through both a reduction of
food resources and a direct toxicity of pesticides (Walker, 1983; Bouvier et al., 2005;
Boatman et al., 2006).
Variance partitioning for bird community composition
However, other factors, and in particular the landscape characteristics of the studied orchards
may influence the composition of bird communities. In the present study, studied parameters
explained 52% of the variability of the composition of bird communities. Among the total
390
variability, phytosanitary treatments and local environment of the orchards had a similar
explanatory power of about 11% while environment at the landscape scale explained about
19% of the variability. Year and interactions explained 11% of the total variability.
In conclusion, we showed that bird communities were both more abundant and more
diverse in organic than conventional orchards, communities from IPM orchards being
intermediate. Bird communities were also largely influenced by the landscape context of the
orchards, which confirms the need to be cautious in the choice of orchards for comparisons of
management strategies.
Acknowledgements
This work was carried out with the financial support of the « ANR- Agence Nationale de la
Recherche - The French National Research Agency » under the « Programme Agriculture et
Développement Durable », project « ANR-06-PADD-59000122, Gedupic ». We wish to thank
the farmers who allowed access to their orchards and provided information on pesticides use.
We would like to thank Kati L. Kemp for useful comments.
References
Beecher, N.A., Johnson, RJ, Case, R.M., Brandle, J.R. & Young, L.J. 2002: Agroecology of
birds in organic and nonorganic farmland. Conserv. Biol. 16: 1620-1631.
Boatman, N.D., Brickle, N.W., Hart, J.D., Milsom, T.P., Morris, A.J., Murray, A.A., Murray,
K.A. & Robertson, P.A. 2004: Evidence for the indirect effects of pesticides on farmland
birds. Ibis 146: 131-143.
Bouvier, J.C., Toubon, J.F., Boivin, T. & Sauphanor, B. 2005: Effects of apple orchard
management strategies on the great tit (Parus major) in southeastern France. Environ.
Toxicol. Chem. 24: 2846-2852.
Chamberlain, D.E., Wilson, J.D. & Fuller, R.J. 1999: A comparison of bird populations on
organic and conventional farm systems in southern Britain. Conserv. Biol. 88: 307-320.
Freemark, K.E. & Kirk, D.A. 2001: Birds on organic and conventional farms in Ontario:
partitioning effects of habitat and practices on species composition and abundance. Biol.
Conserv. 101: 337-350.
Genghini, M., Gellini, S. & Gustin, M 2006: Organic and integrated agriculture: the effects on
bird communities in orchard farms in northern Italy. Biodiv. Conserv. 15: 3077-3094.
Walker, C.H. 1983: Pesticides and birds-Mechanisms of selective toxicity. Agri. Ecosystem.
Environ. 9: 211-226.
391
Is the distribution of beneficial arthropods influenced by mixed
hedgerows
Jean-François Debras1, Rachid Senoussi2, René Rieux1, Elise Buisson3, Thierry Dutoit3
1 INRA, UR 1115, Plantes et systèmes de culture horticoles, F-84000 Avignon, France 2
INRA, UR 546, Biostatistique et processus spatiaux, F-840000 Avignon, France 3 Université
d’Avignon et pays de Vaucluse, IUT, UMR CNRS IRD IMEP, site Agroparc, B.P. 84911
Avignon, cedex 9, France
Abstract: Farming intensification in recent decades has led to an alarming level of degradation and
loss of wildlife and its hedgerow habitat. The relationship between biodiversity and ecosystem
functioning has emerged as a central issue in ecological sciences, but the situation regarding hedgerow
function as a potential source of biological control agents against agricultural pests remains poorly
understood. We evaluated possible effects of the arthropod community in a neighbouring hedge on the
distribution of the pest psylla Cacopsylla pyri L. (Hemiptera: Psyllidae) in a pear orchard Pyrus
communis L. over three consecutive years (1999 - 2001). We measured the diversity of the arthropod
community in the hedge and in the orchard at increasing distances from the hedge using Shannon
index of diversity, and the Hellinger distance and Mahalanobis index to highlight dissimilarities
between population distributions. Our results showed a convergence between predator populations in
the orchard and the hedgerow during Psylla proliferation. There was a decreasing diversity gradient as
distance from the hedge increased. Beneficial arthropod exchanges occurring between the mixed
hedgerow and the pear orchard during the pest proliferation period suggest that field border
management can be used in an integrated pest management strategy aimed at reducing insecticide use.
Mixed hedge, Cacopsylla pyri, IPM, Arthropod Community, Shannon index of diversity
392
Changes of entomophauna in orchards under different pest
management regimes
Vladan Falta, Jitka Stará, Fratišek Kocourek
Crop Research Institute, Department of Entomology, Drnovská 507, Prague 6, 161 06, Czech
Republic
Abstract: Integrated fruit production is facing problems with intensive pesticide use accompanied by
the reduction of nature enemies in agroecosystems. This results in outbreaks of pests with high
reproductive potential (aphids, psyllids, leaf midges, etc.).The side effect of plant protection products
on the diversity of beneficials, as well as, the effect of pest control on selected pests (mining
Lepidoptera, codling moth) were evaluated in different pest control regimes (conventional, integrated,
biological ). Insects were sampled before and after each application using the limb jarring method.
During the first season (2006) fewer Heteroptera species (cca 10x) and Forficula auricularia nymphs
(3x) were found in conventional and IPM variant in comparison with biological regime. In the 2nd
experimental year (2007) this effect was very similar with a higher total number of Hymenoptera
species (x 1.5) sampled in biological regime. In contrast, ladybirds, lacewings and Cantharidae species
showed relatively stable abundance. Direct influence of particular treatments on entomophauna was
not so evident when the number of individuals before and after applications was collected. In spite of
this, the preliminary results suggest that a shift in insect populations develops, although this process is
relatively slow and more apparent changes may be expected during the next experimental seasons. As
far as the direct efficiency of control of mining Lepidoptera species is concerned the most effective
appears to be IPM with the use of selective insecticides. Codling moth was successfully controlled in
conventional and IPM variants, and in the biological regime with applications of CpGV.
IPM, Entomophauna, Orchards, Agroecosystems, Natural enemies
393
Arthropods and mycorrhizal fungi associated to the rhizosphere of
grapevine in Sicily
A. Martorana, L. Torta, G. Lo Verde, E. Ragusa, S. Burruano, S. Ragusa Di Chiara
Dipartimento S.En.Fi.Mi.Zo., Sezione di Patologia vegetale e Microbiologia agraria, Sezione
di Entomologia, Acarologia e Zoologia Università di Palermo
Abstract: To evaluate the variation of AM fungi and arthropod populations and their possible
interactions in mycorrhizosphere of grapevine in Sicily, a research in different tillage systems was
carried out: the first data on the endomycorrhizal fungi and arthropods are reported. One vineyard in
Palermo in state of neglect and two vineyards in Alcamo (TP), one organically managed and the other
traditionally managed, were investigated during 2007. The index of root mycorrhization (IM) and the
whole population of both AM fungi and arthropods were evaluated. The IM was similar in soils
traditionally and organically managed: high in winter and in spring and lower in summer; the vineyard
in state of neglect, during all seasons, showed IM variable values. In all Sicilian vineyards the highest
number of spores was detected in winter, whereas in spring AM populations decreased. With respect to
the arthropods low Shannon’s index (H’) was observed in all soils, while the BSQ values were found
higher in vineyards traditionally and organically managed.
Arthropods, AM fungi, Grapevine, Sicily
394
Mixed deciduous hedgerows as sources of anthocorids and other
predators of pear psyllids in the UK
Csaba Nagy1, Jerry Cross1, Martin Luton2, Caroline Ashdown2
1
East Malling Research, New Road, East Malling, Kent ME19 6BJ UK
2
WorldwideFruit, Acorn House, 68-69 John Wilson Business Park, Harvey Drive, Chestfield,
Whitstable, Kent CT5 3QT UK
Abstract: Anthocorid predatory bugs are the key natural enemies of pear sucker but they often
migrate into orchards too late and/or in too small numbers to affect adequate natural control of pear
sucker populations. A 4 year study began at East Malling Research in 2008 to develop conservation
biocontrol methods to maximise anthocorid populations and other natural enemies of pear sucker in
the spring. Part of this study is to identify woody species and species mixes for hedgerows/windbreaks
that act as sources of pear psyllid natural enemies, especially early in the season. Three established
hedgerows with a range of plant species compositions and structures adjacent to pear orchards in
Kent, UK were identified and characterised. The aim was to identify species mixes that maximise
anthocorid populations in the spring and foster their migration into pear orchards when pear sucker
populations start to increase. The arthropods were beat sampled from the woody species and sweep
net sampled from stinging nettles at 3-4 week intervals from April to September.
A large data base comprising more than 30,000 individuals, sampled and identified from 24
plant species, was constructed but not yet analysed. However, some trends in the data are obvious. 1)
The largest numbers of anthocorids were found on hawthorn, goat willow and stinging nettle in the
early season, while on downy birch, grey willow, stinging nettle, hazel, black alder, goat willow, field
maple, blackthorn, rose and sycamore late in the growing season. 2) In the early growing season the
highest numbers of anthocorids were found on the same plants that had the highest numbers of
psyllids. 3) Later on, anthocorids were present mostly on plant species that had high numbers of
aphids. 4) A large number of other predatory arthropods (mostly Miridae, Araneae, Dermaptera,
Neuroptera, Cantharidae, Coccinellidae) also potential predators of pear psyllids were found on the
hedge plants. 5) Cacopsylla pyri (L.) was discovered to be the most dominant psyllid species in the
pear orchards, not Cacopsylla pyricola (Foerster), as previously reported for the UK.
Key words: Anthocoridae, Psyllidae, Aphididae, hedgerows, natural enemies, biocontrol, pear sucker
Introduction
Pear sucker is a devastating pest of pears which is currently out of control and causing serious
widespread damage in many commercial pear orchards in the UK. Nymphs suck sap from
leaves and fruits, excreting honeydew which turns black with sooty mould. This contaminates
the foliage and fruits, ruining the crop. Attacks weaken the trees which suffer from severe
depletion in fruit buds the following year or may even be killed. The pest transmits ‘pear
decline’, a debilitating phytoplasma-caused disease of young trees. In the past, the dominant
pear sucker species in the UK was known to be Cacopsylla pyricola (Foerster), whereas
Cacopsylla pyri (L.) was considered dominant in other European countries (Ossiannilson,
1992).
Anthocorid predatory bugs (especially Anthocoris nemoralis (Fabricius)) are the key
predators of pear sucker (Solomon et al., 2000). If the pesticide programme allows them to
survive, they can naturally regulate populations of the pest (Solomon et al., 1989; 2000).
However, only few anthocorids are able to overwinter in pear orchards because of the lack of
395
sufficient food or shelter. Anthocorids migrate into pear orchards from early April. This
migration is responsible for the major part of their population found during summer. If the
early season influx is inadequate and/or too late, pear sucker populations increase to
damaging levels in advance of those of anthocorid predators (Solomon et al., 2000).
Adjacent habitats including hedgerows and windbreaks can promote abundance of
insect predators in adjacent orchards, but little is known about the significance of certain
woody hedgerow species for conservation biological control. Hedgerows and windbreaks are
the source of anthocorids in the spring (Solomon et al., 2000). To sustain anthocorids and
other beneficial invertebrates, hedgerows must provide alternative, early season prey (e.g.
psyllids, aphids and gall midge larvae) and shelter. Previous research has shown that early in
the growing season anthocorids concentrate on a particular host plant. During the time that
willow is flowering, Anthocoris nemorum (L.) and A. nemoralis occur on it in very large
numbers (Anderson, 1962). The flowering period is usually late March or early April, and
anthocorids leave the willow after only a week or so. Solomon et al. (1999) showed that
various herbaceous flowering plants attract anthocorids and can be used to enhance predator
populations in orchards. Sigsgaard & Kollmann (2007) showed that hedgerows containing
flowering hawthorn or elderberry and herbaceous layers with stinging nettle held high
numbers of anthocorids in the spring. It is likely that mixed hedgerows provide, in succession,
a range of alternative prey, pollen and nectar sources in early spring.
In 2008 a study at East Malling Research aimed to develop conservation biocontrol
methods to maximise anthocorid populations and other natural enemies of pear sucker in
spring. Part of this 4 year study is to identify woody species and species mixes for
hedgerows/windbreaks that act as sources of pear psyllid natural enemies.
Material and methods
Three established hedgerows with a range of species compositions and structures adjacent to
pear orchards in Kent, UK were identified and characterised (Site 1: Robert Mitchell
Partnership, ‘Fermors’ pear orchard, NGR TQ 568 536; Site 2: Robert Mitchell Partnership,
‘Widows’ pear orchard, NGR TQ 670 562; Site 3: Adrian Scripps Ltd, ‘Saxby’s’ pear orchard,
NGR 686 412). The arthropods were beat-sampled from 23 woody species (field maple (Acer
campestre L. – ACE CAM), sycamore (Acer pseudoplatanus L. – ACE PSE), black alder
(Alnus glutinosa (L.) – ALN GLU), grey alder (Alnus incana (L.) – ALN INC), downy birch
(Betula pubescens Ehrh. – BET PUB), butterfly bush (Buddleja davidii Franch. – BUD DAV),
sweet chestnut (Castanea sativa Miller – CAS SAT), hazel (Corylus avellana L. – COR
AVE), hawthorn (Crataegus monogyna Jacq. – CRA MON), common ash (Fraxinus excelsior
L: – FRA EXC), holly (Ilex aquifolium L. – ILE AQU), European honeysuckle (Lonicera
periclymenum L. – LON PER), apple (Malus domestica Borkh. – MAL DOM), sweet cherry
(Prunus avium L. – PRU AVI), blackthorn (Prunus spinosa L. – PRU SPI), pear (Pyrus
communis L. – PYR COM), pedunculate oak (Quercus robur L. – QUE ROB), rose (Rosa sp.
– ROS SP.), white willow (Salix alba L. – SAL ALB), goat willow (Salix caprea L. – SAL
CAP), grey willow (Salix cinerea L. – SAL CIN, black elder (Sambucus nigra L. – SAM
NIG), European cranberrybush (Viburnum opulus L. – VIB OPU) and sweep net sampled
from stinging nettles (Urtica dioica L. – URT DIO)) at 3-4 week intervals from April to
September. One sample consisted of 10 beats for woody plant or 10 sweeps for nettles. The
collected arthropods were sorted into taxa and stored in 70% ethanol before identification.
396
Results and discussion
A large database comprising >30,000 individuals identified from 24 plant species has been
constructed and started to be analysed. Some trends in the data are obvious.
1) From the total of 8 anthocorid species collected, A. nemorum and A. nemoralis were
the most abundant. The other 6 species (Anthocoris confusus Reuter, Orius niger (Wolff),
Orius laevigatus (Fieber), Orius majusculus (Reuter), Orius laticollis (Reuter) and Orius
vicinus (Ribaut)) were found in lower numbers (Table 1). The largest numbers of
overwintered adult anthocorids were found on hawthorn, goat willow and stinging nettle early
in the season (Figure 1). Mostly, A. nemoralis was found on hawthorn and goat willow, while
A. nemorum was found on stinging nettle (Table 1). Later in the growing season, grey willow
and goat willow were the most frequent hosts for A. nemoralis; downy birch, hazel, stinging
nettle, field maple, grey willow, black alder, blackthorn, rose, sycamore and goat willow were
good sources for A. nemorum; while Buddleia was host to more Orius species (Figure 3, Table
1).
Orius sp.
(nymph)
Orius sp.
(adult, female)
O. vicinus
(adult)
O. laticollis
(adult)
O. majusculus
(adult)
0.5
0.5
1.0
1.0
1.0
2.0
3.5
13.5
1.5
2.5
1.5
3.0
1.0
1.5
6.0
0.7
1.5
6.0
1.0
4.0
8.3
1.0
12.4
1.0
O. laevigatus
(adult)
O. niger
(adult)
A. confusus
(adult)
11.0
5.5
8.0
1.7
16.5
A. nemoralis
(nymph)
4.5
2.5
10.0
2.0
10.5
1.0
0.5
8.5
2.5
1.5
5.0
5.0
0.5
2.5
2.5
1.3
0.5
1.5
2.5
5.4
7.7
1.7
11.2
9.0
A. nemoralis
(adult)
A. nemorum
(nymph)
ACE CAM
ACE PSE
ALN GLU
ALN INC
BET PUB
BUD DAV
CAS SAT
COR AVE
CRA MON
FRA EXC
ILE AQU
LON PER
MAL DOM
PRU AVI
PRU SPI
PYR COM
QUE ROB
ROS SP.
SAL ALB
SAL CAP
SAL CIN
SAM NIG
URT DIO
VIB OPU
A. nemorum
(adult)
Table 1. Mean numbers of anthocorid species collected from the plants.
0.3
9.0
1.0
1.0
10.0
1.0
2.0
0.5
0.3
0.5
0.5
1.0
0.5
0.25
0.5
0.5
1.0
0.5
0.2
0.3
0.2
0.5
3.5
1.0
0.3
0.4
1.0
1.0
0.5
2.7
0.5
0.5
1.0
7.1
5.3
0.2
1.0
0.8
0.2
1.5
0.5
3.4
6.3
0.2
0.3
0.6
0.2
0.6
0.3
1.2
0.5
0.2
0.2
1.8
2) Of the 24 plants studied, 16 are host to some psyllid species (marked with * in Table
2). A total of 24 psyllid species were found (Table 2), 19 were associated with 15 of the
studied plants (Rhinocola aceris (L.): field maple and sycamore; Psylla alni (L.) and
Baeopelma foersteri (Flor): black- and grey alder; Chamaepsylla hartigii (Flor): downy birch;
Cacopsylla melanoneura (Foerster) and Cacopsylla peregrina (Foerster): hawthorn;
Psyllopsis fraxinicola (Foerster) and Psyllopsis fraxini (L.): common ash; Cacopsylla mali
(Schmidberger): apple; Cacopsylla pruni (Scopoli): blackthorn; C. pyri and C. pyricola: pear;
Cacopsylla ambigua (Foerster), Cacopsylla brunneipennis (Edwards) and Cacopsylla
moscovita (Andrianova): goat- and grey willow; Bactericera curvatinervis (Foerster): white-,
397
goat- and grey willow; Bactericera salicivora (Reuter): white willow; Trioza remota Foerster:
pedunculate oak; Trioza urticae (L.): stinging nettle (Ossiannilsson, 1992)).
In the early growing season the greatest numbers of psyllid adults were found on pear
(22.2), stinging nettle (18.6), hawthorn (16.0) and field maple (11.0), while nymphs were on
hawthorn (31.0) and goat willow (7.7) (Figure 2). Later in the growing season common ash,
grey willow, apple and blackthorn also became good sources of psyllids (Table 2). On the
pear trees, six psyllid species were found with C. pyri dominant (42.8), followed by C.
pyricola (7.5) and C. melanoneura (2.8) (Table 2). Previously, C. pyricola was reported as the
dominant pear sucker in the UK.
0.5
2.0
4.3
T. urticae
T. remota
C. pyricola
1.5
C. pyri
0.5
C. pruni
2.0
C. peregrina
C. melanoneura
1.0
C. mali
2.0
C. ambigua
11.0
P. alni
P. fraxinicola
19.0
P. fraxini
R. aceris
ACE
CAM*
ACE
PSE*
ALN
GLU*
ALN
INC*
BET
PUB*
BUD
DAV
CAS
SAT
COR
AVE
CRA
MON*
FRA
EXC*
ILE
AQU
LON
PER
MAL
DOM*
PRU
AVI
PRU
SPI*
PYR
COM*
QUE
ROB*
ROS
SP.
SAL
ALB*
SAL
CAP*
SAL
CIN*
SAM
NIG
URT
DIO*
VIB
OPU*
C. brunneipennis
Table 2. Mean numbers of most common psyllid species on the plants (adults and nymphs).
1.0
0.3
0.3
1.0
0.5
0.5
3.0
0.2
0.8
2.0
0.8
1.5
73.5
33.0
2.0
1.0
2.0
0.5
0.5
1.3
0.5
52.0
6.3
2.0
3.0
0.5
3.5
1.5
7.5
1.0
3.0
0.5
0.5
0.3
0.8
0.5
0.5
3.5
0.5
2.0
0.5
0.5
4.5
0.3
1.5
1.0
0.8
2.8
0.2
2.5
1.0
3.0
4.5
1.0
42.8
4.0
3.0
0.5
0.5
0.2
5.3
0.2
6.1
6.0
2.0
3.7
2.5
0.3
0.7
1.7
0.2
0.2
7.5
1.0
0.5
0.4
0.4
0.3
0.3
0.5
0.3
114.4
0.5
1.0
Rare species omitted (B. foersteri: black alder (1.0), C. hartigii: downy birch (1.0), C. moscovita: grey willow
(0.3), B. salicivora: white willow (0.5), B. curvatinervis: grey willow (1.3) and field maple (0.5), Trioza
398
centranthi (Vallot): black alder (1.0), Trioza galii Foerster: pear (0.2) and stinging nettle (0.2), Trioza sp.: grey
willow (0.3), Cacopsylla sp.1: sweet chestnut (0,5), and Cacopsylla sp.2: goat willow (0.2).
VIB OPU
URT DIO
SAM NIG
SAL CIN
SAL CAP
SAL ALB
ROS SP.
QUE ROB
PYR COM
PRU SPI
22-May
PRU AVI
MAL DOM
LON PER
ILE AQU
02-May
FRA EXC
CRA MON
COR AVE
BUD DAV
BET PUB
ALN INC
ALN GLU
ACE PSE
CAS SAT
15-Apr
10
8
6
4
2
0
ACE CAM
mean abundance/sample
3) The highest numbers of aphids were found on sycamore (943.5), downy birch
(457.5), field maple (339.0), blackthorn (291.5), rose, (176.0), grey willow (135.3), stinging
nettle (105.0), hazel (94.8), white willow (90.5) and black alder (78.0) (Figure 4). .
4) A large number of other predatory arthropods, which may also be important predators
of pear psyllids (mostly Miridae, Araneae, Dermaptera, Neuroptera, Cantharidae,
Coccinellidae) were found on the hedgerow plants.
VIB OPU
URT DIO
SAM NIG
SAL CIN
SAL CAP
SAL ALB
ROS SP.
QUE ROB
PYR COM
PRU SPI
PRU AVI
MAL DOM
LON PER
NYMPH
ILE AQU
FRA EXC
CRA MON
CAS SAT
BUD DAV
BET PUB
ALN INC
ALN GLU
ACE PSE
COR AVE
ADULT
40
32
24
16
8
0
ACE CAM
mean abundance/sample
Figure 1. Mean numbers of the overwintered anthocorid adults on plants during the early
season (15-April – 22-May).
VIB OPU
URT DIO
SAM NIG
SAL CIN
SAL CAP
SAL ALB
ROS SP.
QUE ROB
PYR COM
PRU SPI
PRU AVI
MAL DOM
LON PER
NYMPH
ILE AQU
FRA EXC
CRA MON
CAS SAT
BUD DAV
BET PUB
ALN INC
ALN GLU
ACE PSE
COR AVE
ADULT
20
16
12
8
4
0
ACE CAM
mean abundance/sample
Figure 2. Mean numbers of psyllids on plants during the early season (15-April – 22-May).
Figure 3. Mean numbers of the new anthocorid generation on plants (adults: 16-June – 03September; nymphs: 22-May – 03-September).
399
VIB OPU
URT DIO
SAM NIG
SAL CIN
SAL CAP
SAL ALB
ROS SP.
QUE ROB
PYR COM
PRU SPI
PRU AVI
MAL DOM
LON PER
ILE AQU
FRA EXC
CRA MON
COR AVE
CAS SAT
BUD DAV
BET PUB
ALN INC
ALN GLU
ACE PSE
ACE CAM
mean abundance/sample
990
792
594
396
198
0
Figure 4. Mean numbers of aphids on plants during the whole season (15-April - 03September).
During the early season, the highest numbers of anthocorids were on hawthorn, goat
willow and stinging nettle (Figure 1). These plants are hosts of some psyllids that were
present on these plants from the beginning of the sampling period. Hawthorn is the main host
of C. melanoneura and C. peregrina and nymphs were also collected from this plant. Goat
willow was the host of numerous psyllids species, but C. ambigua and C. brunneipennis were
found in greater numbers. Stinging nettle was the host of T. urticae, the psyllid collected in
the largest number in this study (Table 2).
Aphid numbers were very low at the beginning of the growing season, and we suggest
that psyllid eggs and nymphs may be among the most important prey for anthocorids in the
early spring. During the second half of the season the anthocorids seemed to follow the
growing aphid numbers, until late May when they are likely to be contributing to growth of
anthocorid populations. It appears that the planting of strategic hedgerow species may
increase the number of anthocorids available to predate psyllids in pear orchards. Future work
will improve our understanding of these complex predator-prey relationships.
The dominant pear sucker species in the UK has been known C. pyricola, whereas C.
pyri is considered to be dominant in other European countries (Ossiannilsson, 1992). In this
study of three pear orchards, two had much higher numbers of C. pyri than C. pyricola (Table
2). Hence, the European C. pyri seems to have a more important role in British pear orchards
than previously reported. This has implications for our understanding of pear sucker
population dynamics and the formulation of Integrated Pest Management strategies.
Acknowledgements
We thank Michelle Fountain and Adrian Harris helping in project organisation. We also thank
Elke Groll and Vanesa Alaiz Fuertes for insect sorting. This work is funded by many industrial
partners, growers and research councils under a Defra HortLINK project.
References
Anderson, N.H. 1962: Bionomics of six species of Anthocoris (Heteroptera: Anthocoridae) in
England. – Trans. Ent. Soc. London 114: 67-95.
Ossiannilsson, F. 1992: The Psylloidea (Homoptera) of Fennoscandia and Denmark. – Fauna
Ent. Scand. 26: 1-346.
Sigsgaard, L & Kollmann, J. 2007: Beneficial effects of hedgerow plants for insect predators
in adjacent orchards – the value of pollen and nectar to Anthocoris nemorum (L.). –
IOBC/WPRS Bull. in press.
Solomon, M.G., Cranham, J.E. Easterbrook, M.A. & Fitzgerald, J.D. 1989: Control of pear
400
psyllid, Cacopsylla pyricola, in South East England by predators and pesticides. – Crop
Protect. 8: 197-205.
Solomon, M.G., Fitzgerald, J. & Jolly, R. 1999: Artificial refuges and flowering plants to
enhance predator populations in orchards. – IOBC/WPRS Bull. 22(7): 31-37.
Solomon, M.G., Cross, J.V., Fitzgerald, J.D., Campbell, C.A.M., Jolly, R.L., Olszak, R.W.,
Niemczyk, E. & Vogt, H. 2000: Biocontrol of pests of apples and pears in northern and
central Europe – 3. Predators. – Biocontrol Sci. Technol. 10: 91–128.
401
Species diversity, dominance and frequency of leaf - eating
Lepidoptera in plum biocenose in West Bulgaria
Nyonka Velcheva
Plant Protection Institute, 35 P. Volov str., 2230 Kostinbrod, Bulgaria
E mail: nyonkavelcheva@gmail.com
Abstract: The mating disruption technique is one of the most selective methods of controling Cydia
funebrana Tr. and is under development in Bulgaria. In this connection, a pre- study was carried out to
follow the dynamics and density of the leaf-eating and fruit-surface damaging lepidopteran larvae in
an abandoned plum orchard of mixed varieties in Sofia region. Species belonging to eleven families
were found during the eight years of observations. Permanent inhabitants in the plum biocenose were
larvae of Gelechiidae, Tortricidae and Geometridae with index of constancy c=100. The next by
frequency of occurrence were species of Coleophoridae and Noctuidae (c=87.50), followed by
Yponomeutidae (c=75), Lycanidae (c=50), Lymantriidae and Pieridae (c=25). The rarest were
individuals of families Ypsolophidae, Chimabachidae and Lasiocampidae with c=12.50. In 1998 and
2002 the dominant species of all collected lepidopterian larvae was Recurvaria nanella (Denis &
Schiffermüller, 1775) and Anarsia lineatella (Zeller, 1839) in 1999. Operophtera brumata (Linnaeus,
1758) dominated in complex of external lepidopteran larvae in 2000 and 2005, Neusphaleroptera
nubilana (Hübner, 1799) in 2003, Hedia nubiferana (Haworth, 1811) in 2006 and Argyresthia spp. in
2007. Specimens belonging to 35 genera and 47 species were identified altogether. In spite of very rich
biodiversity, the density of leaf-eating and fruit-surface damaging lepidopteran larvae was above
economical threshold only during three of the eight years of investigation, so we consider it possible to
develop plant protection programs for biological production of plum fruits in West Bulgaria.
Key words: Leaf-eating Lepidoptera, Plum orchard, West Bulgaria
Introduction
The mating disruption technique for controlling Cydia funebrana Tr. is under development in
Bulgaria. In this connection, a pre-study was carried out to follow species diversity and
densities of the surface lepidopteran larvae in plum orchard with aim to evaluate the most
dangerous species which we have to monitor carefully and manage with ecologically safe
methods.
Materials and methods
Our survey was conducted from the end of March to the end of October in an abandoned
plum orchard of mixed varieties in Sofia region of West Bulgaria, Pancharevo, 595 a. s. l.,
42o49′N, 23023′ E in 1998, 1999, 2000, 2002, 2004, 2005, 2006 and 2007. The methods of
sampling, rearing, identification of species and used coefficients were described in earlier
publications (Velcheva, 2005; Velcheva & Peeva, 2005, 2006; Peeva, Velcheva, 2009).
Results and discussion
Species belonging to thirteen families were found altogether in abandon plum orchard in
Sofia region during the eight years observations. Permanent inhabitants in the plum biocenose
402
were larvae of Gelechiidae, Tortricidae and Geometridae with index of constancy c = 100.
The next highest frequency of occurrence were species of Coleophoridae and Noctuidae
(c=87.50), followed by Yponomeutidae (c=75), Lycanidae (c=50), Lymantriidae and Pieridae
(c=25). The rarest were individuals of families Ypsolophidae, Chimabachidae and
Lasiocampidae with c=12.50.
During the years of the investigation we observed a change in the dominance of species.
In 1998 and 2002 the dominant species of all collected lepidopterian larvae was Recurvaria
nanella (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775), in 1999- Anarsia ineatella (Zeller, 1839).
Operophtera brumata (Linnaeus, 1758) dominated in the complex of surface larvae in 2000
and 2005, Neusphaleroptera nubilana (Hübner, 1799) in 2003, Hedia nubiferana (Haworth,
1811) in 2006 and Argyresthia spp. (mainly A. pruniella (Clerck, 1759) in 2007.
Family Tortricidae was the richest of species (Table 1). Hedia nubiferana Hw.
predominated in 1998 with index of dominance c= 48.15, in 1999, the pest was in same
abundance as Neusphaleroptera nubilana Hb. The last mentioned leafroller dominated in all
of the rest years of observations (Table 1). The other frеquent representative of leafrollers in
the plum biocenose were Anciyis achatana Den.&Schiff. and Hedya pruniana Hbn (Table 1).
These two leafroller species were typical for plum biocenose and were rare inhabitants in
apple orchards, where 21 species were registered in abandoned apple orchard situated in the
same region of our country (Velcheva, 2005; Peeva, Velcheva in press).
Table 1. Index of dominance and constancy of the species of external leaf-eating and fruitsurface damaging Tortricide in plum biocenose of abandon orchard.
Species Tortricidae
Neusphaleroptera nubilana (Hübner, 1799)
Indeces of
dominance
constacy
100
34.25
Hedia nubiferana (Haworth, 1811)
24.46
100
Anciyis achatana,(Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
8.56
75
Hedya pruniana (Hübner, 1799)
7.34
100
Spilonota ocellana (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
4.59
62.5
Acleris rhombana (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
3.98
37.5
Archips crataegana (Hübner, 1799)
2.45
50
Archips xylosteana, Linnaeus, 1758)
2.45
62.5
Ptycholoma lecheana (Linnaeus, 1758)
2.14
62.5
Archips rosana (Linnaeus, 1758)
2.14
37.5
Pandemis cerasana (Hübner, 1786)
2.14
37.5
Pandemis heparana (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
1.83
37.5
Archips podana (Scopoli, 1763)
0.61
12.5
Exapate congelatella (Clerck, 1759)
1.83
25
Acleris variegana (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
0.31
12.5
Nonidentified
0.92
25
Lecheva (1999) identified 18 geometrid species in plums orchards in Bulgaria. During our
investigation we identified ten species belonging to this family with very high dominance of
403
Operophtera brumata L. (Table 2).
Table 2. Index of dominance and constancy of the geometrid species in plum biocenose.
Species Geometridae
Operophtera brumata, (Linnaeus, 1758)
Erranis defoliaria (Clerck, 1759)
Indeces of
dominance constacy
100
74.23
75
10.31
Alsophila aescularia (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
Agriopis marginaria (Fabricius 1776)
Rhinoprora chloerata (Mabille, 1870)
4.12
3.61
2.06
33.33
12.5
25
Alsophila aceraria (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
1.03
12.5
Apocheima pilosaria (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
1.03
12.5
Agriopis bajaria (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
Licia hirtaria (Clerck, 1759)
Gymnoscelis rufifasciata (Haworth, 1809)
Nonidentified
0.52
0.52
0.52
2.05
12.5
25
12.5
The winter moth was not only the predominant geometrid pest, but also the most
constant geometrid inhabitant in abandon plum orchard. It was present during all vegetation
seasons of the study (Table 2). Alsophila aceraria (Den. & Schiff.), Agriopis bajaria (Den. &
Schiff.), Licia hirtaria (Cl.) and Gymnoscelis rufifasciata (Haworth, 1809) were found during
one vegetation season in very low density, so we may conclude that the appearance and
development of these species depend in very high degree of the meteorological factors of
particular year. This is the first finding of G. rufifasciata Hw. to feed on plums for our
country.
Nine were the species of Noctuidae on plums trees (Table 3). The ten species Xestia cnigrum (Linnaeus, 1758) was present with only egg masses in the tree crown. The richest
complex was in 2002, when seven species were identified. In the same year we found the
largest number of Noctuidae and in an apple orchard (Velcheva, Peeva, 2005). The peculiar
for this year was very high temperature in February – 5.08oC above the norm.
404
Table 3. Index of dominance and constancy of the noctuid species in plum biocenose.
Species of Noctuidae
Eupsila transversa (Hufnagel, 1766)
Indices of
dominance constacy
50
21.67
18.33
63
15
25
13.33
50
10
50
Diloba caeruleocephala (Linnaeus, 1758)
8.33
25
Orthosia cruda (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
3.33
12.5
Orthosia munda (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
3.33
12.5
Amphipyra pyramidea (Linnaeus, 1758)
Nonidentified
1.67
5
12.5
Orthosia cerasi (Fabricius, 1775)
Conistra vaccinii (Linnaeus, 1761)
Orthosia gracilis (Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775)
Cosmia trapezina (Linnaeus, 1758)
Larvae of family Gelechiidae were rather numerous -19.4% of all collected individuals but
was represented only with four species Recurvaria nanella ([Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775),
Anarsia ineatella (Zeller, 1839), R. leucatella (Clerck, 1759) and Dichomeris derasella
(Denis & Schiffermüller, 1775). This is the record of D. derasella Den. & Schiff. on plums for
our country.
We identified only Coleophora hemerobiella (Scopoli, 1763), Coleophora
coracipennella (= nigricella) (Hubner, 1796) on plums. Perhaps there are more species as we
had numerous non-emerged and unidentified specimens. Diurnea fagella (Denis &
Schiffermüller, 1775) was the only Chimabachidae; Ypsolopha asperella (Linnaeus, 1761)
and Satyrium pruni (Linnaeus 1758) were the only representatives of Ypsolophidae and
Lycanidae, respectively.
In spite of very rich biodiversity, the density of leaf-eating and damaging surface of
the fruits lepidopteran larvae was above economical threshold during only three of the years in 2000 and 2002 in April, and in 2007 in May. So, they are not a big threat to the fruit of
plums and only need careful observations and forecasting. Biological insecticides are
effective against most of the species in warm spring, so we consider developing plant
protection programs for biological production of plum fruits possible in West Bulgaria.
References
Lecheva, Iv. 1999: Geometrid moths (Lepidoptera:Geometridae)- species, diversity, damage
and population dynamics in orchards. Doctor of Science thesis, 319 p.
Velcheva, N. 2005: Dynamics of pest tortricidae species in apple orchards of Sofia region.
Agricultural University Scientific Works, Plovdiv, vol. L, book 6, 7-12.
Velcheva, N. & Peeva, P. 2005: Noctuidae (Lepidoptera) in apple orchards. I. Species
diversity and dynamics. Plant sci. vol. 42, 6: 556-561.
Velcheva, N. & Peeva, P. 2006: Studies on the composition and dynamics of the
Lepidopterian families in trophic relations with apples in Sofia district. Plant Sci.,
vol. XLIII, 6, 494-498.
405
Hazelnut quality and sensory evaluation in organic and conventional
growing systems
V. Cristofori 1, B. Pancino 2, C. Bignami 3, E. Rugini 1, S. Gasbarra 4
Dipartimento di Produzione Vegetale, Università della Tuscia, Via S. Camillo de Lellis snc,
Viterbo, Italy; 2 Dipartimento di Economia Agroforestale e dell’Ambiente Rurale, Università
della Tuscia, Via S. Camillo de Lellis snc, Viterbo, Italy; 3 Dipartimento di Scienze Agrarie a
degli Alimenti, Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia, Via Amendola 2, Pad. Besta, Reggio
Emilia, Italy; 4 Centro di Formazione e Assistenza allo Sviluppo (Ce.F.A.S.) - Azienda
Speciale CCIAA, Viale Trieste 127, Viterbo, Italy
1
Abstract: Consumer acceptance of organic products requires the association of the production system
with directly perceivable quality attributes. Up to now, organically grown hazelnuts have been scarcely
characterised for specific quality traits. Nuts of two Italian hazelnut cultivars, ‘Tonda Gentile Romana’
and ‘Tonda di Giffoni’, grown in conventional and organic systems, were evaluated for technological
traits, kernel chemical composition and sensory profile. Organic nuts showed a slightly lower oil and
starch content, a lower incidence of total saturated fatty acids and a higher content of oleic acid in
comparison to conventional ones. Crude protein content in the kernel was higher in organic nuts in
‘Tonda di Giffoni’. In both cultivars, the organic regime has positively influenced the content of
polyphenols in the kernel. Sensory evaluation revealed differences associated with the growing system
for the attributes of colour and oiliness of roasted kernels. The organic samples were the most
appreciated for both cultivar.
Key words: Corylus avellana L., nut traits, chemical composition, quality, sensory evaluation
Introduction
During the last few years, Italian hazelnut growers have expressed a growing interest in the
exploitation of indigenous varieties and in organic growing systems. This is common in the
Monti Cimini hazelnut district (Central Italy) where both conventional and organic methods
of production have been applied to the Italian cultivar “Tonda Gentile Romana”. Furthermore,
consumers and food industry are becoming increasingly concerned about how, where and
when foods are produced, and this has led to an increased consumer interest in organically
grown fruits including nuts.
Currently nut quality is still identified with some morphological, physical and chemical traits
requested by the food industry, which processes about 90% of production (Garrone and
Vacchetti, 1994). Nevertheless a wider meaning of quality has been suggested based on the
potential effect of some chemical components on taste, nutritional and health properties and
on the storability of nut and processed products (Bignami et al., 2005; Kornsteiner et al.,
2006; Cristofori et al., 2008). Since the influence of growing system on taste and chemical
composition of fruits and vegetables has been often highlighted (Worthington V., 2001; Peck
et al., 2006), but up to now organic dry fruits have been scarcely characterised, the quality of
organic versus conventional nuts of the Italian cultivars “Tonda Gentile Romana” and “Tonda
di Giffoni” has been examined by analysing their chemical composition and sensory
attributes.
406
Material and methods
Samples
Nuts of ’Tonda Gentile Romana‘ (TGR) and ’Tonda di Giffoni‘ (TG), grown in conventional
(con) ad organic (org) systems were sampled from two different farms located in the same
area of the Monti Cimini hazelnut district (Central Italy). Immediately after harvest, the nuts
were dried to 5% moisture content, in the same manner as the current post-harvest treatments
applied in commercial production, and then stored at –20 °C until analysed.
Nut traits and kernel composition
Nut and kernel weight, width, thickness and height, and shell weight were recorded on subsamples of 50 nuts for each cultivar. Nut and kernel shape and seed/nut ratio were then
calculated. Oil in the kernel was determined by the Soxhlet method. Soluble sugars, organic
acids, starch and fatty acid composition were analysed by gas-liquid chromatography (GLC)
according to Cristofori et al. (2008). Total phenolic content was determined according to the
Folin-Ciocalteu’s procedure, calibrating against gallic acid (Scalbert et al., 1989). All analyses
were performed in duplicate.
Sensory Evaluation
Roasted nuts were examined for their sensory profile by a panel including 15 members of the
department staff and students trained on sensory evaluation of dry fruits. The evaluation was
carried out in an equipped room, where anonymous samples were submitted to the panelists.
The most important visual and taste descriptors: colour; roundness; shape regularity;
peelability; taste intensity; aroma intensity; sweetness; oiliness; were evaluated. The assessors
were requested to indicate the intensity of each attribute by placing a vertical line on an 11 cm
unstructured scale line with anchored terms at both ends. The scores were then quantified as
the distance from the origin and the vertical line.
Statistical analysis
Analysis of variance was performed to estimate the effects of cultivar, growing system and
their interaction using the SYSTAT MGLH procedure (Wilkinson, 1998). The least significant
difference (LSD α=0.05) for the comparison of the means was then calculated.
Results and discussion
Nut traits and kernel composition
Significant differences among growing systems were observed for the nut traits with the
exception of nut shape and kernel/nut ratio. ‘TG org’ was characterised by the highest
kernel/shell ratio (Table 1). The nuts of both cultivars collected in the organic farm showed a
higher incidence of defects, mainly empty nuts and shrivelled kernels (data not reported).
The oil and crude protein content were not significantly affected by growing systems and
cultivar (Table 2). Significant differences in fatty acid composition were observed between
growing systems for stearic (C18:0), oleic (C18:1) and linoleic (C18:2) acids (Table 2). The
main fatty acid was oleic acid (C18:1) whose content was higher in nuts collected in the
organic farm for both cultivar.
The soluble sugar content did not significantly differ among cultivars and growing
systems, while starch was almost double in organic nuts in comparison to conventional ones
(Table 3). The content of total organic acids was significantly higher in TG independent of the
growing system (Table 3). The polyphenol contents in the kernel agreed with those found in
previous research (Cristofori et al., 2008; Kornsteiner et al., 2006) and differed between
growing systems in both cultivars, showing higher contents in the organic nuts, with values of
407
3.13 and 2.82 g GAE kg-1 d.w. respectively in “TGR org” and “TG org” (Table 3).
Table 1. Nut traits of TGR and TG obtained in organic and conventional growing systems
Nut weight
Kernel
Shell
Nut shape Kernel %
CULTIVAR
weight (g)
(g)
weight
TGR con
1.98
0.93
1.06
1.02
46.21
TGR org
2.48
1.20
1.39
1.05
45.94
TG con
2.19
0.96
1.24
0.95
44.13
TG org
2.28
1.08
1.26
0.98
46.49
l.s.d. (α= 0.05)
Effects
Cultivar (C)
Growing system (GS)
C x GS
n.s.
0.10
0.14
n.s.
0.04
0.07
n.s.
0.05
0.08
0.04
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
1.59
Table 2. Oil, fatty acids, and crude proteins (N x 6.25). Interaction C x GS not significant.
Crude
Oil
Fatty acids
proteins
-1
(mg 100mg
CULTIVAR
TGR
TG
Con
Org
66.84
64.82
66. 84
65.18
C
5.71
5.54
5.92
5.33
C 18:0
C 18:1
2.39
2.60
2.73
2.26
82.58
82.03
80.58
84.03
C 18:2 C 18:3
8.09
8.93
9.53
7.49
0.072
0.085
0.075
0.081
20.38
16.35
17.68
19.83
0.007
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
l.s.d. (α = 0.05)
Effects
Cultivar (C)
Growing system (GS)
(mg 100mg-1
d.w.)
(%)
d.w.)
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
0.28
n.s.
0.96
n.s.
0.99
Table 3. Contents of starch, soluble sugars, organic acids (mg mg100g-1 d.w.) and
polyphenols (g GAE kg-1 d.w.) in the kernel. Interaction C x GS not significant.
CULTIVAR
TGR
TG
Con
Org
Cultivar (C)
Growing system (GS)
Starch
1.42
1.44
1.81
1.04
n.s.
0.15
Total soluble
Total organic
sugars
acids
5.27
0.43
5.19
0.62
5.01
0.51
5.46
0.54
l.s.d. (α = 0.05)
n.s.
0.10
n.s.
n.s.
Polyphenols
2.83
2.60
2.45
2.98
n.s.
0.24
Sensory analysis
The general appreciation expressed by the panelists showed differences related to the cultivar
and growing system, with the organic samples being preferred for both cultivars (Table 4).
The perceived differences for roundness, shape regularity and peelability were mainly related
408
to the cultivar, while the difference of colour and oiliness was dependent on the growing
system, with organic nuts being characterized by a lesser colour and higher oiliness (Table 4).
Since the oil content was similar in both growing systems, other factors, such as the seed
texture, should be involved in the higher perception of oiliness. Sweetness, aroma and taste
intensity did not differ among treatments (data not shown).
Table 4. Sensory profile of roasted kernels. Interaction C x GS not significant.
CULTIVAR
TGR
TG
Con
Org
Effects
Cultivar (C)
G
i
Colour
Roundness
Shape
regularity
Peelability
Oily
Global
preference
38.9
43.8
48.2
34.4
59.1
46.0
51.3
53.8
53.5
42.4
45.0
50.9
37.2
61.8
49.7
49.3
41.3
43.2
38.6
45.9
53.4
59.6
51.6
61.4
n.s.
57
5.7
52
l.s.d. (p = 0.05)
(GS)
n.s.
87
7.1
8.9
7.3
Acknowledgements
This work was partially supported by Ce.F.A.S. (Special company of the Chamber of
Commerce of Viterbo – Italy).
References
Bignami C., Cristofori V., Troso D., Bertazza G., 2005. Kernel quality and composition of
hazelnut (Corylus avellana L.) cultivars. Acta Hort., 686: 477-484.
Cristofori V., Ferramondo S., Bertazza G., Bignami C., 2008. Nut and kernel traits and
chemical composition of hazelnut (Corylus avellana L.) cultivars. J. Sci. Food Agric.,
88: 1091-1098.
Garrone W., Vacchetti M, 1994. La qualità delle nocciole in rapporto alle esigenze
dell’industria dolciaria. Acta Hort., 351: 641-648.
Kornsteiner M., Wagner K.H., Elmadfa I., 2006. Tocopherols and total phenolics in 10
different nut types. Food Chem., 98: 381-387.
Peck G., Andrews P.K., Reganold J.P., Fellman J. K., 2006. Apple orchard productivity and
fruit quality under organic, conventional, and integrated management. HortScience, 41,1,
99-107
Scalbert A., Monties B:, Jnin G., 1989. Tannins in wood: comparison of different estimation
methods. J. Agric. Food Chem., 5: 1324-1329.
Wilkinson L., 1998. SYSTAT, version 8.0. SPSS, Chicago.
Worthington V., 2001. Nutritional quality of organic versus conventional fruits, vegetables
and grains The Journal of Alternative and complementary Medicine., 7, 2: 161-173.
409
Flash grazing of hogs in apple orchards for pest management
D. Epstein, M. Grieshop
Michigan State University, Department of Entomology, D. Rozeboom, Michigan State
University, Department of Animal Science B18 NFSTC, East Lansing, Michigan, 48824, USA
Abstract: A project to develop and evaluate an orchard system for Upper Midwest (USA) fruit
growers that integrates rotational swine grazing for control of insect and disease pests, while
enhancing profit potential through sales of organic pork was investigated in 2007-2008. The impact of
hog grazing on aborted apples for control of one of the most serious pests of organic apples,
Conotrachelus nenuphar, was evaluated most extensively. The number of June Drop apples for two
cultivars, Idared and McIntosh, was quantified as a mean of ca. 123 apples per tree for both years.
Forty-seven percent of field-collected, aborted apples in 2008 had at least one C. nenuphar oviposition
scar, and 15.7% of drops contained viable larvae. Twenty-seven two-month old Berkshire hogs (Ca.
20-30kg), grazed prior to predicted emergence of C. nenuphar larvae, consumed over 98% of dropped
apples in 0.4ha plots in 2007. In 2008, 24 two-month old Berkshire hogs consumed over 99% of
dropped apples. Hogs were rotated among 3 grazed plots, spending 2-3 days in each grazed plot per
week for three weeks. A controlled feeding experiment demonstrated that ingestion of C. nenuphar
larvae in apples by pigs was 100 percent lethal to the larvae. Spring egg-laying injury from C.
nenuphar in 2007, prior to start of grazing, was 11% in grazed plots, 8% in non-grazed. Summer C.
nenuphar feeding injury, following the start of grazing in 2007, was 4.9 fold higher in non-grazed
control plots (p=2.081E-13). Spring C. nenuphar oviposition injury in 2008 was 8.7% in non-grazed
plots and 4.1% in grazed plots (p=7.763E-05). Summer C. nenuphar feeding injury was 3.4 fold
higher in non-grazed plots in 2008 (p=1.326E-05). Rooting of young hogs (under 45kg) in the tree row
soil, as they foraged through the orchard, averaged 4-6 inches in depth. Rooting by hogs larger than
45kg resulted in some exposure of tree roots and some destruction of sod in the drive rows. Overall,
the health status of all animals was acceptable, and did not require the use of any pharmaceuticals.
Apple pulp and discarded whole apples were provided continuously, about 450 kg per day since
weaning, providing over 50% of their daily food intake. Anecdotal observation in 2007 suggested
superior weed control and improved nutrient availability resulted from hog grazing/rooting. Data
collected during the 2008 season on weed growth, nutrition, and control of codling moth (Cydia
pomonella) and apple scab (Venturia inaequalis) will be reported on in this paper.
Conotrachelus nenuphar, Hogs, Apple, Rotational grazing
410
The sterile insect technique as a component of area-wide integrated
pest management.
Andrew Jessup, Marc Vreysen
Insect Pest Control Sub-programme, FAO/IAEA Agriculture and Biotechnology Laboratory,
IAEA Laboratories, A-2444 Seibersdorf, AUSTRIA
Abstract: The benefit of integrated pest management (IPM) when applied on an area-wide (AW)
basis is that all habitats are treated. Such programmes are successful if the pest is suppressed to below
economic or environmental thresholds and its re-establishment is prevented. Apart from horticultural
production areas AW-IPM programmes often impact urbanised and native vegetation areas and
waterways. The requirement for the protection of humans, fauna and flora and their communities and
eco-systems demands the use of biologically sensitive technologies in AW-IPM programmes. The
sterile insect technique (SIT) is a form of biological control which uses releases of sterile mass-reared
insects to suppress wild populations of the same species. Desired outcomes from SIT include a
reduction in the use of toxic pesticides, improved production, quality and marketability of produce
where only the target pest species is affected. To date a wide range of insect pests has been targeted,
successfully, by SIT in diverse regions of the world but SIT is most effective when used as a
component of AW-IPM programmes. SIT is recognised as a component of internationally accepted
systems approaches to pest management. For example the FAO / International Plant Protection
Convention’s International Standards for Phytosanitary Measures (ISPM) numbers 3, 9, 18 and 26
have provision for the transport or deployment of sterile insects for SIT purposes. In this paper we will
discuss the requirements for a thorough understanding of the biology and behaviour of the target pest
and its interaction with the geography, climate and host flora of an area under pest management and
the means by which SIT can be an essential component to AW-IPM.
Pests, Sterile insect technique, Area-wide, Integrated pest management
411
Softpest: a website on the usage of pesticides & biocontrol agents in
soft fruits
Christian Linder1, Janet Allen2, Catherine Baroffio3, Agata Broniarek-Niemiec4, Victoria
Brookes5, Jerry Cross6, Cathy Eckert7, Rudolf Faby8, Bruno Gobin9, Alberto Grassi10,
Adrian Harris6, Barbara Łabanowska4 Emilie Lascaux11, Carlo Malavolta12, Vincent
Michel3, Slobodan Milenkovic13, Thilda Nilsson14 Paivi Parikka15, Klaus Paaske16, JeanJacques Pommier17, Daniele Prodorutti10, Lene Sigsgaard18, Arne Stensvand19, Christer
Torneus20, Nina Trandem19, Tuomo Tuovinen15, Gábor Vétek21
Station de recherche Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil ACW, CP 1012, 1260 Nyon 1; 2ADAS
UK Ltd, Pibworth Cottage, Aldworth, Reading, Berks RG89RU, UK; 3Agroscope ChanginsWädenswil ACW, Centre de recherche Conthey, 1964 Conthey , 1964 Conthey, Switzerland;
4
Research Institute of Pomology, Pomologiczna 18, 96-100 Skierniewice, Poland;
5
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, 6947 #7 Highway, PO Box 1000, Agassiz, British
Columbia V0M 1A0, Canada; 6East Malling Research, New Road, East Malling Kent ME19
6BJ, UK; 7DLT, Centre Ctifl de Lanxade, BP 21, 24130 La Force, France; 8V.B.O.G.
Langfoerden. Spredaer Str. 2, 49377 Vechta, Germany; 9pcfruit, Fruittuinweg 1, 3800 SintTruiden, Belgium; 10IASMA Research Center – Plant Protection Department, Via E. Mach, 1 –
38010 San Michele all’Adige (TN), Italy; 11Koppert France, 147 Avenue des Banquets, ZI
Puits des Gavottes, 84300 Cavaillon, France; 12Regione Emilia-Romagna, Assessorato
Agricoltura, Viale Silvani 6, 40122 Bologna, Italy; 13Fruit Research Institute Čačak, Kralja
Petra I/9, Serbia; 14HS Malmöhus, Borgeby Slottväg 13, 239 91 Bjärred, Sweden; 15MTT
Agrifood Research, Plant Production Research, Jokioinen 31600, Finland; 16Danish Institute
of Agricultural Sciences, Dpt of IPM, DK-4200 Slagelse, Denmark; 17Hortis Aquitaine, 24140
Douville, France; 18Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Dpt of Ecology - Zoology
Group, Thorvaldsensvej 40, 1871 Frederiksberg C, Denmark; 19Bioforsk, Plant Health and
Plant Protection Division, Høgskoleveien 7, 1432 Ås, Norway; 20Swedish Board of
Agriculture, Plant Protection Centre, P.O. Box 12, 230 53 Alnarp, Sweden; 21Corvinus
University of Budapest, Faculty of Horticultural Science, Department of Entomology, Villányi
út 29–43., 1118 Budapest, Hungary
1
Abstract: The usage of plant protection products and biocontrol agents in soft fruit production has
always been an important subject for the IOBC/WPRS Working Group "Integrated Protection of Fruit
Crops" Study Group "Soft Fruits". The usage of pesticides and biological control methods varies
considerably between countries and it is very difficult to get a good overview on the range of products
that are applied or in development in soft fruits. In order to share and facilitate the flow of
information, the Study Group "Soft Fruit" initiated a survey on the availability and usage of active
ingredients and biocontrol agents in the different European countries in 2007. First, the most
important pests and diseases in strawberry and raspberry production were identified. Then members of
the different countries listed available products on the domestic market and indicated their usage in
the field. So far 15 countries have contributed to the survey. The received data are accessible on the
website http://www.any3.ch/IOBC/Softpest/index.html.
Key words: Insecticides, fungicides, biological control, database
412
Introduction
Since the first meeting of the IOBC Study Group "Soft Fruits" in Vienna in 1997, the
availabilty and usage of pesticides in soft fruit production has often been the subject of heated
debates at our workshops (Jörg 1998; Gajek & Jörg 2003; Gallie et al. 2003; Umpelby 2003).
During a discussion round at the Dundee meeting in 2001, participants agreed to creat and
maintain a database specific to soft fruits. This database should cover disesases, pests, weeds
as well as chemical, biological and other non-chemical control methods (Umpelby 2003).
However, it was not until 2007 at the East Malling meeting that the Study Group members
decided to provide the basis for the development of a database on the usage of pesticides and
biological control agents (=BCAs) in soft fruits. The approach of the Study Group "Soft
Fruits" is briefly presented in the following chapter.
Approach
Members from 14 IOBC/WPRS (West Palearctic Regional Section) countries as well as one
representative from Canada have chosen to focus their first efforts on strawberries and
raspberries. In a first step, a series of key pests and diseases have been identified. Then
members of the different countries listed available products on the domestic market and
indicated their usage in the field. In 2008, a worksheet circulated among a limited numbers of
key collaborators in each country who verified the validity of the collected data. Data have
been compiled and are now available on the website Softpest:http://www.any3.ch/IOBC/Softpest/index.html
Table 1. Information on active ingredients and BCAs are available for the following crops,
pests and disesases on the Softpest website (state December 2008).
Crops
Strawberry
Raspberry
Pests
Aphids
Miridae
Tarsonemids
Tetranychids
Thrips
Vine Weevil
Anthonomus
Aphids
Byturus
Cane midge
Tetranychids
Diseases
Botrytis
Colletotrichum
Phytophtora
Podosphaera
Botrytis
Cane diseases
Phytophtora
The website allows retrieval of information by crops, pests, disesases, active ingredients
and/or BCAs (Table 1). Data are displayed in a simple table giving an overview of what is
applied in the participating countries (Figure 1). Currently, more than 140 pesticides or BCAs
are listed. The full list of collaborators and additionnal information on pesticides' and BCAs'
special usage or restrictions can also be found on the website.
413
Figure 1. Table of results obtained on the Softpest website for the query "Strawberry –
Tarsonemids"
Perspectives
In the near future, the Study Group intends to integrate more countries, crops, pests and
diseases in the database. However, it should be noted that the website does not intend to
replace national pesticides lists. The website should simply facilitate the exchange of
information among scientists, advisory services and everybody interested in the availability
and usage of pesticides and BCAs in soft fruits.
References
Jörg, E. 1998: Pesticide availability in European soft fruit production. Integrated Plant Protection
in Orchards "Soft Fruits" IOBC/WPRS Bulletin 21 (10): 5-15.
Gajek, D. & Jörg, E. 2003: Status of Integrated Production of Soft Fruit in Europe. Integrated
Plant Protection in Orchards "Soft Fruits" IOBC/WPRS Bulletin 26 (2): 1-6.
Galli, P., Gündel, L., Jörg, E. & Harzer, U. 2003: Minor uses in soft fruit crop protection in
Germany. Integrated Plant Protection in Orchards "Soft Fruits" IOBC/WPRS Bulletin 26
(2): 73-80.
Umpelby, R. 2003: Open Forum: discussion on effect of changing pesticide usage and
availability on soft fruit pest and disease management. Integrated Plant Protection in
Orchards "Soft Fruits" IOBC/WPRS Bulletin 26 (2): 81-85.
414
Organic Raspberry Production in Serbia
Slobodan Milenković1, Snežana Tanasković2, Dušica Sretenović2
1
Megatrend University, Belgrade, Faculty of Biofarming, Bačka Topola, Maršala Tita 39,
sloboento@yahoo.com 2University in Kragujevac, Faculty of Agronomy, Cara Dušana 34,
Čačak, Serbia
Abstract: In Serbia, the first raspberry plantings maintained according to the organic production
procedure were established in 1999. So far, the production has reached some 3,000 t/yr. This programme
is promising, provided strict observance of regulations EC 2092/91, EC 834/2007 and EC 889/2008 is
performed. Organic production plantings are established in well-drained, loose soils containing high
quantity organic matter. The incorporation of 20 t/ha of manure into the soil is a regular cultivation
practice. Considering the control of diseases and pests, the following control measures are applied:
setting up plantings on suitable terrains, application of appropriate cultivation practices, healthy
planting material, and application of sulphur and copper fungicides. The control and monitoring of
pests was aided by the use of visual inspections (Rebell traps and Moerick vessels) and pheromone
traps (monitoring of Resseliella theobaldi). The incidence of gray mold caused by Botrytis cinerea is a
major problem in seasons with high rainfall rates. Unfortunately, efficient biological fungicides on
raspberry have not yet been registered.
Key words: raspberry, organic production, Serbia
Introduction
Raspberry production in Serbia is largely concentrated in central and western parts, the total
raspberry production ranging from 40,000 – 75,000 tons. According to the available data, it is
estimated that the total annual export of organically produced raspberry in Serbia amounts to
3,000 t, which accounts for 5% of the total raspberry production.
The first organic raspberry plantings were registered in 1999. Five years later, the
production amounts to some 3,000 t. During the recent period, no appeals have been lodged
regarding the observance of the regulations, which supports the assertion that this programme
is prospective provided that all requirements strictly conform to EC 2092/91, EC 834/2007
and EC 889/2008. The programme, which is similar to the traditional manner of production,
presupposes the appropriate selection of the region for growing (the upland regions) and
highly conscientious producers who are willing to co-operate on this project (Mišić et al.,
2004).
Environmental Conditions
Temperate-to-mountain climate characterized by a moderately warm summer and a moderately
cold winter is most suitable for raspberry production. Meteorological indicators point to a rather
sub-humid climate. The data suggest that the annual precipitation rate ranges from 750 – 960
mm, 550 mm of which is over the period of vegetative growth. Mean annual air temperature is
100C, mean air temperature over the vegetative period is 15.30C, the sum of the active air
temperatures exceeds 3,2000C, and the cloudiness rate is 58% (Petrović and Milošević, 2005).
The appropriate selection of a terrain suitable for raspberry growing is utterly important,
as raspberry develops sturdy but nonetheless shallow root system accompanied by a multitude
415
of canes. Raspberry will fare best in deep, moderately cold, medium hard, well-drained soils
of the above-mentioned soil types. This fruit species is not susceptible to slightly acid soil
types (except to extremely acid soils), and the most suitable soils are pH 5 - 6 which consist 8
– 10 mg P2O5 and 18 - 20 mg K2O per 100 g of aerated soil with about 5% of humus.
Specific Conditions
Raspberry is grown on small private households, i.e. 0.10 – 0.30 ha in size. About 90% of the
crop is intended for freezing, whereas the remainder is realized on the fresh market or is
processed. The vicinity of cold storage plants and other processing facilities enables freezing
and storage of produced raspberries and other small fruit crops (Nikolić et al., 2008).
In raspberry areas of Serbia, raspberry performs best at altitudes between 400 and 800 m,
but it is also successfully grown at 200 – 1,000 m. On the sites lying at an altitude of 800 m,
with the annual precipitation of 900 mm (with half the amount of rainfall during the growing
season), raspberry favours most northwest and northeast exposures. With the increase of
altitudes (over 800 m) southern exposures are preferred. Pre-cultivation of leguminous plants,
maize and small grains are favourable for a raspberry planting, whereas potato, tomato and
small fruits (raspberry, blackberry and others) are not preferred, being the potential hosts to
some highly damaging fungal diseases (cane blight, root rot).
Nursery Material
Raspberry has been successfully propagated via in vitro micropropagation, an essential stage
in the worldwide approved scheme (OEOO/EPPO, 1998, PM 4/10) of healthy raspberry
planting material production. The buds from the root cuttings of the virus-free planting
material have been used as the initial explants. The aseptic culture has been established on the
Murashiga and Skoog medium. The rooted plants have been planted in the peat: zeolite = 2:1
substrate and acclimatised under a glasshouse “mist” system. This method of raspberry
propagation under completely controlled conditions accompanied by the continuous testing
for the presence of viruses and Phytophthora spp. under in vitro and ex vitro conditions
enables the obtainment of healthy planting material (Milenković et al., 2006).
Soil Cultivation
The inter-row cultivation is performed by disking, and in-row cultivation is carried out
manually, by hand hoeing and weeding. An increase in the organic matter content in the soil is
the key precondition for achieving the basic principle of organic agriculture. The conversion
period is used maximally in order to increase the content of organic matter in the soil by
applying manure, compost, green manure and other measures. The incorporation of 1 t of
manure results in the soil enrichment by: 10 kg N, 5 kg P2O5 and 10 kg K2O. The manure
application rate is limited to 170 kg N/ha annually due to the possibility of N leaching.
Manure application rates are 10-30 t/ha. Humus content in the soils of typical production
regions ranges from 2.5 to 4%. The incorporation of 20 t of manure every year (respecting
maximum permissible pure nitrogen incorporation rate of 170 kg per hectare) is
recommended as a regular measure for increasing the organic matter content and maintaining
fertility.
Green Manure
An increase in the soil organic matter and improvement in its structure are also achieved
through green manuring. The procedure involves planting, growing till the blooming stage
and eventual ploughing of herbaceous plants into the soil. The plants are grown as pre-crops,
intercrops or after-crops. Barley, common vetch, lupine and alfalfa are cultivated as pre-crops.
416
Autumn-planted after-crops are as follows: oil seed rape, a mixture of hairy vetch, rye grass
and clover, a mixture of hairy vetch and winter barley. The green material is shred and
ploughed into the soil at the blooming stage. In the orchards on sloping terrain plants of
spontaneous flora are maintained; these plants are reaped and the remains are spread along the
inter-row space.
Pests and Diseases
In Serbia, the most serious raspberry diseases caused by pathogenic fungi are: gray mold
(Botrytis spp.) on fruits, cane blight (Leptosphaeria coniothyrium) on the trunk, midge blight,
raspberry leaf spot (Sphaerulina rubi), and phytophthora root rot (Phytophthora fragariae vаr.
rubi). Spur blight has been most commonly attributed either to the pathogen Didymella
applanata or low winter temperatures. Raspberry root rot has been observed almost in all
productive regions (Milenković and Sretenović, 2006). It is manifested in sudden wilting of
plants, often during harvest. Various pathogenic fungi such as Fusarium spp., Alternaria spp.,
Phoma spp., and Leptospheria coniothyrium develop on the spots where the periderm has
been modified and vascular tissue radially damaged by the larvae of raspberry cane midge.
Small raspberry aphid, Aphis idaei van der Goot, is a pest widely spread in all raspberry
growing regions in Serbia. Large raspberry aphid, Amphorophora idaei, is sporadically found,
its population pressure being low. Raspberry fruit worm, Byturus tomentosus F. is not a
serious raspberry pest in Serbia, mainly populating higher terrains. Raspberry gall midge
Lasioptera rubi Heeger is largely controlled by pruning. Raspberry cane midge, Resseliella
(Thomasiniana) theobaldi Barnes (Diptera, Cecidomyiidae) causes dieback of raspberry canes
(Milenković, 2005). The results of research at East Malling Research (UK) have provided
successful utilization of the pheromone traps for the monitoring of this pest (Cross and Hall,
2006). Strawberry blossom weevil, Anthonomus rubi Hrbst., is the most serious pest in the
region of Arilje, our largest raspberry growing region.
The experiences of raspberry producers in Switzerland show the beneficial effect of
compost dressings (40 l/ 1 m) which ensure high yields, general improvement of a planting
and substantially reduced employment of control measures (Weidmann, 2005).
Direct Control Measures
More recent practice in Serbia has relied on the application of copper and sulphur-based
chemicals for the reason of incomplete registration system. Over 2004 – 2005 chemicals
based on natural pyrethrin (in the control of leaf aphids and strawberry blossom weevil) and
the toxin Bacillus thuringiensis (in the control of damaging moths) have been applied for
experimental purposes. Monitoring of raspberry fruit worm Rebell bianco traps have been
used successfully. Raspberry pests are an important problem; therefore there is a case for
importing biologically based insecticides and parasitoids, and damaging insect predators.
The principal conception of the organic production prevails recommending that
producers primarily focus on the application of all other available measures (growing resistant
cultivars, application of appropriate cultural practices, physical measures and introduction of
beneficial living organisms, etc.) which will ensure lowering of the pressure of damaging
agents to an acceptable level. The application of the stated chemicals is recommended in
extreme cases, when the situation really requires such measures.
Biological Control Measures
Biological measures for controlling harmful organisms include fostering of development and
planned introduction of beneficial organisms into a raspberry planting. The root rot of
raspberry, as already underlined, is a serious cultivation-related problem. The use of compost
and the employment of growing practices in elevated rows contribute to the maintenance of
417
optimum moisture regime in the zone around the root system. The beneficial fungus
Trichoderma spp. is an antagonist (development inhibitor) of Phytophthora fragariae var.
rubi and is used combined with manure and compost.
The biological equilibrium and the prevention from insect damage in a raspberry planting
are enhanced by ladybirds, common green lacewings, parasitic Cecidomyiidae, hoverflies,
parasitic wasps and predatory mites.
References
Cross, J. & Hall, D. 2006: Sex pheromone of raspberry cane midge. In: Trandem, N.
Cross,V.J. Linder, C (eds.), IOBC wprs Bulletin. Integrated Plant Protection in Fruit
Crops. Integrated Soft Fruit Production. Proceedings of Workshop on Integrated Soft
Fruit Production. Stavanger, Norway 5-7 October. 29(9): 105-109.
Milenković, S. 2005: Raspberry pests and diseases in Serbia. Program and abstracts of COST
863 Euroberry, WG3 1st meeting – Approaching Sustainability in Berry Production,
Wageningen, The Netherlands, 17.
Milenković, S., Leposavić, A., Ružić, Đ. & Paunović, S. 2006: Introduction of certification in
propagation of planting material of soft fruits in the Republic of Serbia. Proceeding of a
Workshop on Integrated soft fruit production, Stavanger, Norway, 5-7 Oct, 2005.
IOBC/WPRS Bulletins, 29: 49-54.
Milenković, S. & Sretenović, D. 2006: Monitoring of Soft Fruit Mother Plantings Aimed at
Control of Phytophthora fragariae, causal agent of Root Rot. Agriculturae Conspectus
Scientificus, 71 4: 141-148.
Mišić, P., Tešović, Ž., Stanisavljević, M., Milutinović, M., Nikolić, M. & Milenković, S.
2004: Raspberry in Serbia and Montenegro – the past, present and future. Yugoslav fruit
growing, 38, 145-146, 5-22. [in serbian]
Nikolić, M., Ivanović, M., Milenković, S., Milivojević Jasminka & Milutinović, M. 2008: The
State and Prospects of Raspberry Production in Serbia. Proc. IX Intl. Rubus and Ribes
Symp. Acta Horticulturae 777: 243-249.
Petrović S., Milošević T. 2005: Raspberry from Serbia. University of Kragujevac. Faculty of
Agronomy, Čačak, pp. 1-256.
Stanisavljević, M., Leposavić, A., Milenković, S., & Petrović, S. 2003: Biological and
pomological features of new raspberry varieties and raspberry selection, Yugoslav fruit
growing, 37: 133-134, 123-129. [in serbian]
Weidmann, G. (editor) 2005: The Organic Cultivation of Bush Berries. FiBL and OACC, pp.
28.
418
Is organic hazelnut cultivation profitable?
Barbara Pancino, Valerio Cristofori
Dipartimento di Economia Agroforestale e dell’Ambiente Rurale, Università della Tuscia, Via
San Camillo de Lellis, Viterbo, Italy; Dipartimento di Produzione Vegetale, Università della
Tuscia, Via S. Camillo de Lellis, Viterbo, Italy.
Abstract: In order to analyze the economic results of hazelnut cultivation in an organic regime, the
two methods of production commonly used in the Monti Cimini hazelnut district (central Italy) were
used. These systems of production, due to the different levels of input that they require, can be
considered to be “extensive” and “intensive”. Costs and productive values were evaluated for the two
techniques and, afterwards, a comparison with conventional management was carried out, referring to
a standard method of production which allows average yields of 2.7 t/ha to be achieved. The
examination of the costs of production for these systems highlighted a substantial homogeneity in
variable costs, although remarkable variations were observed in the different categories (raw materials,
mechanization, work). On the contrary, the produce which can be sold varies greatly according to the
different orchard management forms. A comparison of gross margins showed that the results achieved
by conventional management is intermediate between those of the two organic techniques. This result
justifies the contrasting opinions of hazelnut producers on the relative convenience of the two
management forms. The only certainty is that, because of public aid, organic hazelnut production is
able to guarantee better economic results.
Key words: Corylus avellana L., cultural account, organic agriculture
Introduction
In the last fifteen years, that is to say since organic agriculture has been given rules and aid,
supporters and opposers of organic management have presented their views through debates
which involve environmental, technical and, of course, economical aspects. Hazelnut
cultivation in the intensive hazelnut production area of Monti Cimini is no exception and,
even if a good number of farmers have decided to switch to organic management, the debate
on the efficiency of the productive technique and the economical convenience, as compared to
the conventional regime, is still open.
This paper contributes to this debate by focusing on two main topics: the cultivation
characteristics of organic hazelnut in the area of Monti Cimini, and the evaluation of the
economic results of organic management and its comparison with conventional production.
The organic hazelnut cultivation in Monti Cimini
In the Monti Cimini district, there are about 10,000 hazelnut farms covering almost 18,000
hectares and producing 40,000 tons of hazelnuts. The number of organic hazelnut farms is 350
with a area share of organic farming of about 13%.
As far as the territorial localization of organic hazelnut cultivation is concerned, a very
high presence in border areas of the district emerges. Such a presence becomes lower
progressively towards the areas which are more specialized and which characterize the core of
the district.
419
During the last years, a remarkable technical evolution concerning all aspects of the
agronomical management of organic hazelnut plantations, that is to say from soil
management, to pruning, to fertilisation and defence, has taken place. In general, organicallymanaged cultivation requires an integrated technical-agronomical practice, which has the aim
of keeping the plant in an harmonic condition in terms of vegetative vigour and allows a
better resistance to possible environmental adversities (Caporali, 2003). In the Monti Cimini
area, it is possible to identify two different techniques for organic management of hazelnut
orchards, which are called “extensive” and “intensive” and are characterized by different level
of inputs and, obviously, by a different yield. In particular, the yield of the “extensive”
technique ranges between 1.2 and 1.8 ton/ha, while the yield of the “intensive” technique
varies between 2.2 and 2.6 ton/ha. The extensive or the intensive technique is chosen by the
farmer on the basis of his predisposition towards innovation, of territorial suitability and of
the mechanization limits due to soil characteristics.
Hazelnut prices and economic results
With particular reference to the last decade, hazelnut prices have shown an extremely
uncertain trend, mainly due to the Turkish hazelnut production. Indeed, the amount of Turkish
hazelnuts on the market, 5 to 6 times the Italian production on the average, depends on factors
which are hardly predictable, such as climate conditions and political choices made by the
sector’s institutions (Dono and Franco, 2001).
Obviously, the price of organic hazelnuts is directly linked to the conventional hazelnut
price, as can be seen in figure 1, in which the monthly trend of the conventional hazelnut
price is shown and the average price at the beginning of the harvesting (SeptemberNovember) is compared to the organic one.
.
Figure 1. Prices (€/kg) of conventional and organic “Tonda Gentile Romana”.
420
It can be seen that the latter is 15-20% higher and that this difference rises as the
conventional hazelnut price lowers. It is important to highlight that such premium price is
effective only at the beginning of the harvest, while, during the following months,
conventional hazelnuts, following the market trend, can undergo further price reductions or, in
some cases, such as in 1997-98 and 2000-01, they can even reach a higher price than organic
hazelnuts
In order to estimate the economic result of organic hazelnut cultivation, the two different
techniques which are employed (extensive and intensive) were considered. Afterwards, in
order to compare results with the conventional management, a representative technique (Dono
and Franco, 2003) was considered. In normal conditions, the latter allows average yields of
2.7 t/ha, with a yield of unshelled product slightly higher (42%) than the one which can be
obtained with an organic management (40%).
The data elaboration (table 1) highlights a substantial homogeneity of variable costs,
which are slightly higher than 1,000 €/ha for all the considered techniques. Comparing the
organic techniques, the extensive one is characterized by a raw material cost which is 45%
lower, but a greater number of workers is needed due to the less efficient harvesting modality.
The comparison between conventional and intensive organic techniques shows that in the
organic management the raw material costs are 20% higher, as a consequence of the higher
price of the technical tools, whereas the mechanization costs are slightly lower, due to both
the small number of interventions and the shorter amount of time dedicated to harvesting,
which is linked to the lower yield.
Table 1. Comparison of the economic results of different productive techniques
(€ per hectare) – Year 2007
Organic
Organic
“extensive” “intensive” Conventional
Yield (ton/ha)
1.5
2.4
2.7
Price (€/kg)
2.45
2.45
2.25
Product value
3,675
5,880
6,075
Organic support
550
550
0
CAP payment
240
240
240
Revenues
4,465
6,650
6,315
Labour costs
765
700
665
Mechanization costs
130
150
185
Inputs costs
140
250
205
Variable costs
1,035
1,100
1,055
Gross margin
3,430
5,550
5,260
On the contrary, according to the different types of management, the yield which can be
sold varies in a substantial way. As the table shows, it depends on the product value as well as
on the aid which is given to organic farms.
Comparing the gross revenues of the three processes, it can be observed that the
conventional management result is positioned between the results obtained with the two
organic techniques. This result justifies the contrasting opinions among hazelnut farmers on
the opportunity of adopting one management technique or the other. The only certainty is that
only public aid allows the organic hazelnut production to achieve better economic results.
Conclusions
421
The organic hazelnut production in the Monti Cimini district represents a phenomenon which
cannot be overlooked. Yet, after a period of fast development, the choice of converting to
organic production has shown a progressive slowdown. This evolution represents the
consequence of different phenomena: firstly, technical aspects, such as the possibility of
facing with success the phytopathological attacks; secondly, market conditions, such as the
risk of demand saturation and the consequent loss of a satisfactory premium price; thirdly, the
policy evolution, in particular the uncertainty concerning the stability of public aid.
This research addressed in depth such aspects, making some of them clearer: the
evolution of organic hazelnut prices, the definition of production techniques and yields, the
market situation and, above all, the comparison of the economic results of conventional and
organic techniques. On the other hand, other important issues remain unresolved: the demand
evolution, the future policy directions concerning agro environmental measures, the
experimentation and availability of phytosanitary products allowed in order to fight different
pathologies.
Nevertheless, even if the conducted research allowed to obtain remarkable results
concerning the knowledge on the sector and the identification of possible strategies for its
competitive growth, one fundamental element in the analysis of organic hazelnut production
cannot be ignored: the individual attitude towards innovation and respect for the environment.
Indeed, the refusal of the organic “challenge” is often a conservative attitude regarding
traditions and behaviours which are part of the cultural background of farmers, and in general
of the entire population of the Monti Cimini area.
Acknowledgements
Study carried out within the MiPAAF project FRUMED.
References
Caporali, F. 2003: Agricoltura e Salute – La sfida dell’agricoltura biologica. Editeam sas,
Cento (FE).
Dono, G. & Franco, S. 2001: Impact of agricultural policies on Italian hazelnut farms. Acta
Hort. 556:65-72.
Dono, G. & Franco, S. 2003: Le determinanti dei risultati economici delle aziende
nocciolicole dei Monti Cimini. Proceedings of the II National Congress on Hazelnut,
Giffoni (SA).
Letardi, A., Lumaca, P., Grandi, C. & Dominicis, L. 2001: Analisi della filiera ortofrutticola
biologica del Lazio. ENEA, Roma.
Regione Lazio 2000: Reg. CE n.1257. 2000/2006 Rural Development Regional Plan, Roma.
422
Further observation on hazelnut yielding and fruit quality under
organic and conventional management.
Alessandro Roversi , Gian Luca Malvicini.
Institute of Fruit Growing, Catholic University S.C., 29100 Piacenza – ITALY
alessandro.roversi@unicatt.it
Abstract. In some previous contributions, our Institute has pointed out some difficulties in the organic
management of filbert orchards. A further two years of investigation showed that the main negative
aspect of organic management is the high rate of nuts affected by bugs. Therefore another important
problem is the reduction in productivity.
To validate the conclusions of previous works, the comparison between organic and conventional
management was carried on in three typical hazelnut orchards named “Alta Langa”, “Langa” and
“Monregalese”. In these areas conventional and organic orchard management were chosen to record
productivity and nut quality traits. In the years 2007-08, both total and average (t/Ha) production were
recorded for each hazelnut orchard, and 3 kg samples of nuts were taken from whole nut yielding.
Each sample was studied through the standard marketing surveys. In particular fruit and kernel weight,
Curculio holes, fruit empty and insect kernel damage percentage, has been considered. The results
were statistically analyzed through conventional-organic comparisons, and tested with the "t" test.
Keywords : Hazelnut yielding, fruit quality, organic management, bug kernel.
Introduction
Starting from 2002 our Institute began to be make comparative observations on hazelnut
orchards conventional or organic managed, in three different locations. The first year only
yielding was recorded instead in the following years also the fruit quality was considered.
From the published results (Roversi & Sonnati, 2006; Roversi & Castellino, 2007; Roversi,
Ughini, Malvicini & Sonnati, 2008) clearly appears an important lack in yielding and a lesser
quality of nuts obtained in organic managed hazelnut orchards. In particular the insect
damaged kernel percentage results were significantly higher with organic management than
conventional one. Also the percentage of kernel without any defects and so suitable for agroindustry purposes, was higher for the nuts obtained in conventional orchard.
Year after year, the difference between the quality of nuts obtained between organic and
conventional, decreases and becomes often not significant. One district (Monregalese) seems
more suitable for hazelnut orchard organic managed. Unfortunately the loss in yield was not
improved.
In order to resolve the cause of low yield and the lower nut quality of the organic
management a further 2 years of observations and analysis was done.
Material and methods
In 3 typical hazelnut orchard areas, Alta Langa, Langa and Monregalese, a conventional
managed and an organic managed orchard were chosed. For each district the orchards are
under the same climatic and soil conditions, and plots of similar age (20-25 years) were
considered for observations and fruit sampling. The main difference between organic and
conventional management was that use of any pesticide, chemical fertilizers and hormonal
423
suckers control was prohibited according to the “Protocol of Production for organic hazelnut
orchards”.
In 2007-08, average production (t/ha) was recorded for each orchard, and 3 kg samples of
nuts were taken from the total nut production. Each sample was studied through the standard
marketing surveys as shown in the tables. Defects of fruits we considered, Curculio holes,
while for the kernel the percentage of mouldy, shrivelled, whitened, rancid, undersized and
twin were considered, both for the nuts produced in organic and in conventional orchards.
Because its value was not as high and the difference between location and orchard
management were not so high, they were summarized and considered together as total
defects. Because among the different defects fruit empty and kernel whitened were the most
frequent, they were considered separately and presented only as figures. Bug damage is not
considered in this total. The data was statistically analyzed by ANOVA and conventionalorganic were compared using a "t" test.
Results and Conclusions
Yielding
Generally speaking, the yield was higher in the Monregalese district for both years and
independently from orchard management. As observed in the previous 5 years (Roversi,
Ughini, Malvicini & Sonnati, l.c) the organic orchard yielding is lesser (cfr. Fig. 1) than
conventional. In 2007 the minimum production was 25.8 % (Alta Langa) and the maximum
reached 84 % for Langa orchards. In the second year (2008), the results showed a similar lack
of production (32.7 % to 64.8 % for Alta Langa and Langa respectively). Because the supply
of mineral fertilizers is prohibited in organic orchards. The lack of production could be
explained by poor nutritional status of their plants. In fact, in the organic hazelnut orchards,
the use of only organic fertilizers could not satisfy the plants nutritional needs.
Fruit quality
Fruit weight
The fruit weight ranged from a minimum of 1.9g (conventional orchard in 2008, in
Monregalese district), to 2.6g in the same district. ANOVA (data not reported) shows that fruit
weight was significantly affected by location and year.
The difference between fruit weight obtained in orchards with different management regimes,
were not significant, with the exception of Alta Langa and Langa, in 2008, when the nuts
obtained from conventional orchards were significantly higher than those obtained by organic
production.
On the contrary in the Monregalese area the weight of nuts produced in 2008 was
significantly (p ≤ 0.007) higher in the organic (2.04 g) than in the conventional orchard (1.89
grams).
This was also observed in 2003 (Roversi & Sonnati, l.c.), 2004 (Roversi & Castellino, l.c.)
and 2006 (Roversi et al) and suggests that Monregalese could be an area in which organic
management will be suitable without negative influence on the weight of nuts.
Kernel weight
The kernel weight value (see table 2-4) was between 0.84g (in Monregalese for conventional
production, in 2008) and 1.14g (Monregalese conventional production in the previous year).
The kernel weight values were not significantly influenced by the different managements.
424
Kernel fruit ratio
The kernel fruit ratio percentage was variable between years and less so in 2007 than in the
following year. The kernel fruit ratio is higher in the conventional than in the organic
production orchard, but all the difference between percentages were not significant. The
values recorded in Langa appear high in both years for nuts obtained in the conventional
orchard.
Insect damage
Damage due to insects (2007-2008) was less than in the previous 4 years (cfr. Roversi,
Ughini, Malvicini, Sonnati) with the noticeable exception of the organic management for
Monregalese in 2008. In particular, in the first year of fruit analysis the percentage of kernels
with insect damage was zero in Alta Langa and very poor in the other 2 other districts. There
was no significant difference between the nuts from organic and conventional production. In
the following year, the percentage was higher in the organic production than in the
conventional, but significantly only in Alta Langa. In particular the values were: 0.3 % for
conventional production and 14.7 % for the organic. Unfortunately, the active substances of
natural origin are (Guidone & Tavella, 2007) ineffective against curculio and so this damage
is one of the most important problem of hazelnut organic management.
Total defects
The total defects were higher for the organic production in Alta Langa and Langa, in 2007 and
2008, but not significantly. In Monregalese in both years of observation, the total percentage
of damage was higher in the conventional production, but not significant. The percentage of
empty fruit could be influenced by mineral nutrition and floral biology (Roversi, et al., l.c.).
Kernel without any defects
From a commercial point of view, kernel fruit ratio, it is very important and could determine
the price of the product stock.
Generally the percentage of kernel without defects is higher in the product obtained from
conventional orchards but significant only for Alta Langa in 2008, with the value of 96.44%
and 71.44 % respectively. In the Monregalese district, there was no significant difference
between organic and conventional production..
Tables and graphs
Tab. 1 – Values of some fruit parameters for Alta Langa production, as related to management
and years.
Parameters
Fruits Weight
Kernel weight
Kernel/fruit ratio
Bug
Total defects
Without any defects
g
“
%
“
“
“
Con
2007
Org
p
Con
2008
Org
p
2.48
1.14
45.35
.00
9.40
90.60
2.45
1.12
45.56
.00
10.73
89.27
.824
.939
.935
.571
.571
2.30
1.10
46.56
.31
3.25
96.44
2.15
1.05
45.81
14.67
13.89
71.44
.006
.108
.703
.025
.073
.000
Tab. 2 – Values of some fruit parameters for Langa production, as related to management and
years.
425
Parameters
2007
Org
Con
p
Con
2008
Org
Fruits Weight
g
2.12
2.08
.325
2.16
2.03
Kernel weight
“
1.03
.93
.132
1.02
.90
Kernel/fruit ratio
%
48.42
44.75
.041
47.10
44.30
Bug
“
.00
2.06
.256
.83
2.22
Total defects
“
11.25
18.53
.087
5.51
8.21
Without any defects “
88.75
79.40
.078
93.66
89.57
Tab. 3 – Values of some fruit parameters for Monregalese production, as related to
management and years.
g
“
%
“
“
“
.018
.873
.199
.572
.350
.214
Con
2007
Org
p
Con
2008
Org
p
2.55
1.14
44.06
.57
18.98
80.45
2.42
1.10
44.21
.00
8.96
91.04
.461
.571
.540
.391
.074
.054
1.89
.84
44.56
.43
10.22
89.35
2.04
.095
46.35
1.85
9.96
88.19
.007
.352
.472
.220
.919
.681
Parameters
Fruits Weight
Kernel weight
Kernel/fruit ratio
Bug
Total defects
Without any defects
p
Fig. 1 – Nut average yield (tons/ha) as related to location, orchard management and year.
2,5
bio
con
2
1,5
1
0,5
0
2007
2008
2007
2008
2007
2008
Alta Langa
Alta Langa
Langa
Langa
Monregalese
Monregalese
426
Fig. 2 - Percentage of empty fruits as related to years and orchard management, in Alta Langa district.
%
10
con
org
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
.522
.224
2007
2008
Fig. 3 - Percentage of empty fruits as related to years and orchard management, in Langa district.
%
10
con
org
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
.278
.243
2007
2008
Fig. 4 - Percentage of empty fruits as related to years and orchard management, in Monregalese district
%
10
con
org
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
%
.815
.258
2007
2008
Fig. 5 - Percentage of whitened kernel as related to years and orchard management, in Alta Langa district.
10
con
org
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
.111
.066
2007
2008
427
%
Fig. 6 - Percentage of whitened kernel as related to years and orchard management, in Langa district.
10
con
org
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
%
.150
.901
2007
2008
Fig. 7 - Percentage of whitened kernel as related to years and orchard management, in Monregalese
district.
10
con
org
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
.483
.020
2007
2008
Conclusions
Fruit and kernel weight appear generally higher, but not significantly, for conventional
production than organic one. Just in the Monregalese district, in 2008, the results of organic
management are better than conventional, but significantly only for fruit weight.
There was no effect on the kernel fruit ratio.
In contrast with previous years the insect damage was higher in the kernels obtained in
organic orchards but not significant.
With time (years) net differences in quality/yield between the two management practices
tend to disappear.
The percentage of kernels without defects, and so suitable for agro-industry purposes, are
higher for the fruit obtained in conventional orchard for the all locations and years, with the
exception of Monregalese in 2007.
Differences in production could be due to factors other than conventiona and organic
management.
References
Franco S., Pancino B. and Ferrucci D., 2005. Production and marketing of organic hazelnuts:
the case of “Tonda Gentile Romana”. Acta Hort., 686, pp.565-572.
Guidone L., Tavella L., 2007, Lotta alla cimice del nocciolo, problema ancora da risolvere.
L’Informatore Agrario, 24, pp. 72-74.
Malvicini G.L., Roversi A., Marino A., 2008, On the quality of hazelnut plants obtained by
mounding layer. 7th International congress on hazelnut, Viterbo, 23-27 June (in press).
Roversi A., 2002, Esigenze nutrizionali e concimazione del nocciolo. Atti II Convegno
428
Nazionale sul Nocciolo, Giffoni Valle Piana, 5 Ottobre: 28-42.
Roversi A., Sonnati C., 2006, Nocciole biologiche: qualità o difficoltà? Frutticoltura, 2, pp.
64-67.
Roversi A., Castellino L., 2007, Further Investigations on Hazelnut Yielding in Conventional
and Organic Management. Nucis Newsletter, 14, pp. 10-13.
Roversi A., Ughini V., Malvicini G.L., Sonnati C., 2008, Nocciolo convenzionale, più qualità
e resa rispetto al bio. L’Informatore Agrario, 25, pp.40-43.
Roversi A., 2008, Observations on the mineral elements annually uptake by the yielding of
hazelnut orchard. VI International ISHS Symposium on Mineral Nutrition of Fruit
Crops, 19-23 may, Faro (in press).
Roversi A., Malvicini G.L., 2008, Leaf diagnostic in hazelnut orchards under organic and
conventional management. VI International ISHS Symposium on Mineral Nutrition of
Fruit Crops, 19-23 may, Faro (in press).
429
Codling moth proof hail nets
B. Sauphanor1, G. Severac2, L. Romet3, E. Esberard4, J.F. Toubon1, S. Maugin1
1 INRA, UMR 1115 Plantes et Systèmes de culture Horticoles, Agroparc, F-84914 Avignon
Cédex 9, France ; 2Chambre d’Agriculture du Vaucluse ; 3Groupe de recherche en
agriculture biologique, Agroparc, F-84911 Avignon Cedex 9, France ; 4INRA, UEEAA
Agroparc, F-84914 Avignon Cédex 9, France
Abstract: Single row hail nets (3x7.4mm) modified to wrap up whole tree canopies, named
Alt’Carpo, were evaluated as a way of control of orchard lepidopteran pests. A two years study was
conducted in a 10 rows experimental apple orchard in Southern France, together with large field trials
in commercial orchards. The experimental orchard was insecticide free in year 1 and pesticide free in
year 2. Eight rows were protected with the nets, two rows were unprotected. The nets allowed an 80%
reduction of fruit injury when compared to the unprotected rows, which suffered over 70% codling
moth injury. However this efficacy was lower than in commercial orchards, especially those covered
with 2.2x5.4mm nets in which fruit injury did not exceed 0.1%. The outer females, issuing from
unprotected rows, were proved able to lay eggs on leaves or apples touching the 3x7.4mm nets. Virgin
females or synthetic lures baited traps poorly captured wild or marked and released males under the
nets, while the traps placed in unprotected rows captured over 30% of the released males. Moreover,
significant rates of males released under the nets were captured outside while only 1 out of 300 males
released in the control rows was observed to pass through the net, proving the need for flying over the
canopy for sex encounter. Despite the known alteration of communities in protected crops, no
significant effect of the net was observed on rosy aphid and scab injuries on leaves or fruits. The
agronomic, economic and environmental consequences of replacing chemical insecticides by synthetic
barriers are discussed.
Protected crop, Cydia pomonella, Mating behaviour, Environmental impact, Pest and disease
management
430
Building up, management and evaluation of orchard systems: a fouryear experience in apple production
Sylvaine Simon1, Benoît Sauphanor2, Sophie Buléon1, Johanny Guinaudeau1, Laurent
Brun1
1
INRA (National Institute for Agricultural Research), UERI Gotheron, F-26320 SaintMarcel-lès-Valence, France; 2 INRA, UMR 1115 PSH-EPI, Agroparc, F-84914 Avignon Cédex
9, France
Abstract: Three apple orchard systems were planted in 2005 to assess agronomic and environmental
effects of different pest management regimes: organic farming (OG), conventional supervised (SV)
and low-input (LI) systems. Three apple cultivars presenting different susceptibility to scab were
planted in each system: Ariane (Vf-resistant), Melrose (low-susceptibility) and Smoothee 2832T®
(susceptible), creating nine « system x cultivar » situations. Decision rules were defined within the
framework of each system, and their possible interactions were integrated. Starting from planting, the
survey included pest and disease assessments, and agronomic and environmental parameters. The OG
system was the slowest to produce commercial yield, whereas the SV one showed the highest
performances. Although globally low, pest and disease fruit damage at harvest was the highest in the
OG system. The treatment frequency index (TFI) was the highest in the SV system, and in Smoothee
plots within each system. Two-fold more treatments were applied in any SV plot and in Smoothee OG
compared to Melrose LI. The LI system presented the lowest TFI and the lowest environmental impact
of pesticides calculated by the I-phyARBO fuzzy expert system. Apart from Smoothee, I-phyARBO in the
OG system scored between LI and SV. From the first four years of the experiment, the importance of
the cultivar in the management of the orchard diseases (and to some extent pests) is outlined whatever
the system, with a high variation in the number of treatments. This experimental design proved to be a
functional tool permitting the conception of decision rule patterns, and also to assess the agronomic,
environmental and economical performances of the systems.
Key words: orchard system, apple, decision rule, agronomic evaluation, environmental evaluation,
pest and disease management
Introduction
Apple production, which ranks first among fruit tree production in France, largely relies on
the recurrent use of pesticides to control a high number of pests and diseases. Such pesticide
applications have detrimental effects on the environment (Aubertot et al., 2005) and on
human health. Many studies have focused on the development of alternative methods to avoid
the use of chemicals against one target pest or disease. However, only two experimental
designs located in the U.S.A (Reganold et al., 2001; Peck et al., 2006) and in Switzerland
(Bertschinger et al., 2004) address the global pest and disease complex through system
approaches that include various pest and disease management regimes. The aim of our
research programme was to assess the agronomic performances and the environmental impact
of different apple systems within the frame of conventional and organic agricultures. The
designing, planting and evaluation of apple orchards aiming at such purposes started in 2005
in an experimental INRA (National Institute for Agricultural Research) unit in Southern
France.
431
Material and methods
Experimental systems and experimental design
The three studied systems (Table 1) were mainly defined by their pest and disease
management regimes: organic farming (OG), conventional supervised (SV) and low-input
(LI) systems. Three apple cultivars presenting different levels of susceptibility to scab were
planted in each system: Ariane (Vf-resistant), Melrose (low-susceptibility) and Smoothee
2832T® (Golden mutant, susceptible), creating nine « system x cultivar » situations. Decision
rules were defined within the framework of each system, and their possible interactions were
integrated. The orchards were planted in January 2005 under similar soil, climate and
environmental conditions. Except in the OG system which excluded synthetic inputs for
fertilization and thinning, cultural practices other than protection were similar in the three
systems.
Assessments
Starting from planting, the survey included pest and disease assessments, agronomic and
environmental parameters or indices:
- yield, fruit quality, fruit damage at harvest;
- the treatment Frequency Index (TFI) = Σ(1, n) [dose of compound applied / registered dose]
for each of the n treatments of the orchard during the season;
- IphyARBO fuzzy expert system (Sauphanor et al., 2008);
- earwig (Forficulidae) abundance (numbers of earwigs observed in 10 traps per system), as
an indicator of the effects of pest management on a natural enemy arthropod community.
Table 1. Experimental systems and their main principles
Systems
General background
Specific strategies
Organic1
Low input2
Fruit production / evolving framework
Management
Minimise
of bottlenecks
pesticides
Always preferred
Always preferred
Always used
Always used
Alternative methods
Sanitation practices,
mechanical and
labour input
Decision rules to apply Local conditions,
pesticides based on:
treatment thresholds
if usable
Pesticide choice
Organic registered
compounds
Local conditions,
treatment thresholds
as available
Selective compounds
1
Supervised3
Efficiency &
performance
NO unless no other way
NO unless cost<other
methods or for
resistance management
Regional conditions,
treatment thresholds
if consistent
Highly efficient
compounds
European regulations (EEC 91/2092, appendices and modifications); 2IOBC guidelines;
3
French IPM National guidelines (National Apple Board) as specific frameworks of the
systems beside French regulations.
Results and discussion
Agronomic performances
The OG orchards were the slowest to set fruits. The SV system produced the highest yield in
2007 but adverse conditions (frost) at the chemical thinning period lowered yield in 2008
(Figure 1). Fruit damage due to pest and disease remained low at harvest (although it may
vary according to years), which attests to the efficacy of the experimented pest and disease
management regimes. Pest and disease fruit damages were similar for both LI and SV systems
432
50
75 77 78 81 81 84 85 87 87 % 1st grade fruits
40
30
2008
2007
2006
20
Plot
SV Smoothee
SV Melrose
SV Ariane
LI Smoothee
LI Melrose
LI Ariane
OG Smoothee
0
OG Melrose
10
OG Ariane
Commercial yield (t/ha)
whereas the highest values were observed in the OG system.
Figure 1. Cumulative yield and average percent 1st grade fruits (2006-2008 period)
Environmental impact
The mean TFI was the highest in the SV system, and in Smoothee plots within each of the
systems. Two-fold more treatments were applied in any SV plot and in Smoothee OG
compared to Melrose LI. The LI system displayed the lowest environmental impact as
measured by TFI (Figure 2) or IphyARBO (data not presented).
Mean TFI (2006-2008)
40
Microbiological
insecticides
30
Others compounds
20
Mineral fungicides
10
PIRRP products*
SV Smoothee
SV Melrose
SV Ariane
LI Smoothee
LI Melrose
LI Ariane
OG Smoothee
OG Melrose
OG Ariane
0
Plot
*The French « Plan Interministériel de Réduction des Risques liés aux Pesticides » has listed 47 compounds to be banned by
the end of 2009 because of their harmfulness (http://www.ecologie.gouv.fr/Plan-interministeriel-de-reduction.html).
Figure 2. Mean Treatment Frequency Index (TFI) according to categories of compounds
Earwigs were seldom observed in the SV system whereas both OG and LI presented high
numbers from May onwards, with similar patterns for these latter systems (Figure 3).
433
100
80
OG
60
LI
40
SV
20
1-Nov
1-Oct
1-Sep
1-Aug
1-Jul
1-Jun
1-May
0
1-Apr
Mean number per trap
Earwig abundance (2008)
120
Date
Figure 3. Earwig abundance in 2008
From the first years of experiment, the importance of the cultivar in the management of
orchard diseases (and to some extent pests) is outlined whatever the system, with a high
variation in the number of treatments. This experimental design proved to be a functional tool
permitting: i) the conception of decision rule patterns based on various degrees of integrated
pest and disease management; and ii) the assessment of the agronomic and environmental
performances of the studied systems through a longitudinal survey of various parameters.
Other tools and measures, including economical performance, Life Cycle Assessment and soil
and aerial communities, will be developed or continued in collaboration with partner research
teams, for a global assessment of the systems.
Acknowledgements
This work was partly supported by the Ecoger and the ADD-GEDUPIC programs funded by
the French National Agency for Research. Dispensers for mating disruption in the OG and LI
systems were provided by Sumi Agro France. The authors wish to thank the staff members of
Gotheron unit in charge of the management of the orchards.
References
Aubertot, J.N., Barbier, J.M., Carpentier, A., Gril, J.J., Guichard, L., Lucas, P., Savary, S.,
Savini I. & Voltz M. (éditeurs) 2005: Pesticides, agriculture et environnement. Réduire
l'utilisation des pesticides et limiter leurs impacts environnementaux. Expertise
scientifique collective, synthèse du rapport, INRA et Cemagref (France), 64 p.
Bertschinger, L., Mouron, P., Dolega, E., Höhn, H., Holliger, E., Husistein, A., Schmid, A.,
Siegfried, W., Widmer, A., Zürcher, M. & Weibel, F. 2004: Ecological apple production:
a comparison of organic and integrated apple-growing. ISHS Acta Hort 638: 321-332.
Peck, G.M., Adrews, P.K., Reganold, J.P. & Fellman, J.K. 2006: Apple orchard productivity
and fruit quality under organic, conventional, and integrated management. Hortscience
41(1): 99-107.
Sauphanor, B., Picard, C., Simon, S. & Plenet, D. 2008: Indicators to assess the environmental
impact of protection practices in apple orchards. In: IOBC, Book of Abstracts, VII
International Conference on Integrated Fruit Production, Avignon, France, 28-30 October
2008.
Reganold, J.P., Glover, J.D., Andrews, P.K., Hinman, H.R. 2001: Sustainability of three apple
production systems. Nature 410: 926-930.
434
Effect of different type row mulches on the success of biological
control of strawberry tarsonemid mite
Tuomo Tuovinen1, Isa Lindqvist1, Pirjo Kivijärvi2
1 Plant Production Research, MTT Agrifood Research Finland, 31600 Jokioinen, Finland; 2
Plant Production Research, MTT Agrifood Research Finland, Karilantie 2 A, 50600 Mikkeli,
Finland
Abstract: Organic experimental strawberry fields were established to study the effect of mulching
materials on growth, yield, fruit quality and mites. Black plastic, flax fibre mat, fresh green mass,
barley straw, buckwheat husks, pine woodchips and birch woodchips were used for mulching.
Strawberry tarsonemid mite was recorded in the autumn of the planting year and biological control of
mites was started in the spring by introduction of Neoseiulus cucumeris which kept the strawberry
tarsonemid mite under control. Small numbers of Anthoseius rhenanus and Euseius finlandicus were
also introduced, but these species were rarely found afterwards in folded leaf samples. In the third
year, one release of N. cucumeris took place at the beginning of June. In late August strawberry
tarsonemid mite population growth was unacceptable in black plastic and barley straw mulches
whereas in green mass and buckwheat husk mulches the mite was controlled by predatory mites
during the whole season. Faster vegetative growth in green mass and buckwheat husk mulches in
organic farming is proposed to enhance biological control of strawberry tarsonemid mite.
Strawberry, Organic farming, Organic mulches, Phytonemus pallidus, Phytoseiidae, Neoseiulus
cucumeris
435
The OrganicA Project: Organic Disease Management in Orchards
with ‘Newer’ Cultivars
L. Berkett1, M. Garcia2, R. Moran3, H. Darby1, R. Parsons1, J. Hayden1, T. Bradshaw1,
S. Kingsley-Richards1 and M. Cromwell1
1
Dept. of Plant & Soil Science, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405 USA; 2University
of Arkansas, Fayetteville, AR 72701 USA; 3University of Maine, Monmouth, ME 04259 USA
Abstract: Although there is significant interest in organic apple production in the New England
region of the USA, there are few certified organic orchards, in part, because of disease challenges
associated with ‘McIntosh’, the predominant cultivar grown in the region. However, recent shifts in
consumer preference for ‘newer’ cultivars have led to the planting of different apple cultivars which
have different disease susceptibility. A long-term research project was initiated in 2006 to examine the
opportunities and challenges of organic apple production within the two production systems growers
are using to change to new cultivars: planting a new orchard with young trees purchased from a
nursery and/or “top-grafting” an established, older orchard to new cultivars. The cultivars being
studied in replicated plots in each orchard system are: ‘Zestar!’, ‘Ginger Gold’, ‘Honeycrisp’,
‘Macoun’, and ‘Liberty’, a scab-resistant cultivar. Both orchard systems are being managed with
approved, organic practices and materials. Standard foliar disease assessments for apple scab, caused
by Venturia inaequalis, and other diseases are being conducted to determine differences in disease
incidence and severity among the cultivars. Based on initial foliar disease assessments during the
establishment years of the orchards, ‘Honeycrisp’ appears more resistant to apple scab than the other
scab-susceptible cultivars ‘Zestar!’, ‘Ginger Gold’, and ‘Macoun’, but appears more susceptible to
cedar apple rust, caused by Gymnosporangium juniperi-virginianae, than ‘Liberty’ and ‘Zestar!’.
‘Macoun’ and ‘Zestar!’ exhibited a higher incidence of necrotic leaf spots than the other
cultivars. This research is on-going and will document disease challenges and the economic costs,
returns, and risks associated with these five cultivars being grown under organic production practices
within the two orchard systems.
Key words: Organic apple production, apple scab, cedar apple rust, apple diseases, integrated pest
management
Introduction
Although there is significant interest in organic apple production in the New England region
of the USA, there are few certified organic orchards, in part, because of disease challenges
associated with ‘McIntosh’, the predominant cultivar grown in the region. However, recent
shifts in consumer preference for ‘newer’ cultivars have led to the planting of different apple
cultivars which have different disease susceptibility. A long-term research project was
initiated in 2006 to examine the opportunities and challenges of organic apple production
within the two production systems growers are using to change to new cultivars: planting a
new orchard with young trees purchased from a nursery and/or “top-grafting” an established,
older orchard to new cultivars (Berkett et al., 2007) Reported herein are results of disease
assessments conducted over the ‘establishment years’ of the five cultivars in the two apple
production systems which are being investigated.
436
Material and methods
Two orchards, located at the University of Vermont Horticultural Research Center in South
Burlington, Vermont, USA, are involved in this research project (Figs. 1, 2, 3). Orchard 1 is
an orchard planted in April 2006 with ‘Ginger Gold’, ‘Liberty’, and ‘Macoun’, and ‘Zestar!’
on Bud. 9 rootstock and ‘Honeycrisp’ on M.26; cultivars are arranged in a completely
randomized design with three-tree replications. Orchard 2 was an existing orchard planted in
1988 with ‘McIntosh’ and ‘Liberty’ trees on M.26 rootstock which was ‘top-grafted’ in April
2006 to the same five cultivars. Since the original cultivar (i.e., original ‘McIntosh’ or
‘Liberty’ interstock) may affect growth of the new ‘top-grafted’ scion, a randomized
complete block experimental design, with two-tree replications, was used to block any effect
on new scion growth.
Environmental conditions within the orchards were monitored with a Davis Vantage Pro
Wireless Weather Station (Davis Instruments Corp.) and primary scab infection periods were
determined using “revised” Mills criteria (MacHardy & Gadoury, 1989), with the exception
that all wetting periods including those starting at night were used in infection period
determinations. In 2006, 2007, and 2008, there were six primary infection periods of varying
durations per growing season and numerous secondary infection periods during the remainder
of each growing season.
In each of the three growing seasons, multiple applications of lime sulfur and/or sulfur
at standard label rates were used for disease management. In 2006, a combination of liquid
lime sulfur and sulfur was applied on June 22 and July 1 and sulfur on July 14. In 2007,
seven sprays of liquid lime sulfur and five sprays of sulfur were applied. Eight liquid lime
sulfur and five sulfur applications were made in 2008. Due to the small size of the trees in
2006, sprays were applied with a Rears 'Nifty Fifty' Hydraulic Handgun Sprayer (Rears
Manufacturing Inc., Eugene, OR) mounted on the three-point hitch of a small tractor. Sprays
were applied in a sufficient volume of water to achieve near-drip conditions, and the volume
was increased during each season as foliage emerged. Beginning in 2007, all sprays were
applied with a Rears Pak-Blast airblast sprayer in a sufficient volume of water to achieve
near-drip conditions. Travel speed and water rates differed between the two orchards because
of tree size and foliage density differences.
Disease incidence of apple scab (Venturia inaequalis (Cooke) Wint.), cedar apple rust
(Gymnosporangium juniperi-virginianae Schwein.) and necrotic leaf spots, which resembled
frogeye leaf spots caused by the black rot fungus (Botryosphaeria obtusa (Schwein.)
Shoemaker), was assessed on all leaves on two vegetative terminals per tree on at least five
three-tree replications per cultivar in Orchard 1 and on four vegetative terminals per tree on
eight two-tree replications per cultivar in Orchard 2 in August of each year. Analysis of
variance and mean comparisons using Tukey’s HSD Test (P ≤ 0.05) were performed on the
data. Since the orchards are in the ‘establishment phase’, no apples were produced in 2006
and 2007, with a very minimal crop being produced in 2008. Future disease evaluations will
include fruit.
Results and discussion
Results are presented in Tables 1, 2, 3 and 4. Based on these initial foliar disease assessments
during the establishment years of the two organic apple orchards, ‘Honeycrisp’ appears more
resistant to apple scab than the other scab-susceptible cultivars ‘Zestar!’, ‘Ginger Gold’, and
‘Macoun’, but appears more susceptible to cedar apple rust, caused by Gymnosporangium
juniperi-virginianae, than ‘Liberty’ and ‘Zestar!’. ‘Macoun’ and ‘Zestar!’ exhibited a higher
incidence of necrotic leaf spots than the other cultivars.
437
This research is on-going and will document disease challenges along with the overall
economic costs, returns, and risks associated with these five cultivars being grown under organic
production practices within the two orchard systems.
Figure 1. Orchard 1 - Planted with five cultivars in 2006
Figure 2. Orchard 2 - An eighteen year old orchard was “top-grafted” with five cultivars in
2006.
Figure 3. Orchard 2 - 2008 growth in “top-grafted” orchard.
438
Table 1. 2006 Orchard 1 - Percent Vegetative Terminal Leaves Infected, August 9-11, 2006
Scab
Rust
Necrotic Leaf Spot
41.3 a
25.6 a
Ginger Gold
5.4 bc
2.7 c
13.5 b
Honeycrisp
3.8 c
0.0 d
0.3 c
Liberty
3.1 c
28.4 b
1.5 c
Macoun
10.8 a
34.1 ab
0.7 c
Zestar!
10.2 ab
Numbers within columns followed by the same letter do not differ significantly, Tukey’s HSD
Test (P ≤ 0.05)
Table 2. 2007 Orchard 1 - Percent Vegetative Terminal Leaves Infected, August 7, 2007
Scab
Rust
Necrotic Leaf Spot
0.3
24.8 ab
Ginger Gold
2.3 b
0.0
39.9 a
Honeycrisp
2.3 b
0.0
14.7 b
Liberty
2.2 b
0.9
25.2 ab
Macoun
8.9 a
0.2
14.5 b
Zestar!
6.5 ab
Numbers within columns followed by the same letter do not differ significantly, Tukey’s HSD
Test (P ≤ 0.05)
Table 3. 2007 Orchard 2 - Percent Vegetative Terminal Leaves Infected, August 8-14, 2007
Scab
Rust
Necrotic Leaf Spot
0.4
35.5 a
Ginger Gold
10.2 bc
0.1
36.6 a
Honeycrisp
7.1 c
0.0
17.9 b
Liberty
9.4 bc
0.8
18.6 b
Macoun
20.8 a
0.1
12.6 b
Zestar!
14.2 ab
Numbers within columns followed by the same letter do not differ significantly, Tukey’s HSD
Test (P ≤ 0.05)
Table 4. 2008 Orchard 2 - Percent Vegetative Terminal Leaves Infected, August 20-26, 2008
Scab
Rust
Necrotic Leaf Spot
11.2 a
39.6 a
Ginger Gold
15.1
0.6 c
22.2 ab
Honeycrisp
14.7
0.0 d
7.1 b
Liberty
14.6
1.2 bc
8.6 b
Macoun
25.0
2.1 b
5.4 b
Zestar!
20.1
Numbers within columns followed by the same letter do not differ significantly, Tukey’s HSD
Test (P ≤ 0.05)
Acknowledgements
Major funding for this project is from a grant from the USDA Integrated Organic Program.
References
Berkett, L.P., Garcia, M.E., Moran, R. E., Parsons, R. L., Darby, H. M., Hayden, J. P.,
Bradshaw, T.L., Kingsley-Richards, S. L. and Cromwell, M. L. 2007: OrganicA
439
Project. http://www.uvm.edu/organica/
MacHardy, W.E. & Gadoury, D.M. 1989: A revision of Mill’s criteria for predicting apple
scab infection periods. Phytopath. 79:304-310.
440
Investigation on survival and viability of cankers of Nectria galligena
following removal from apple trees and pulverisation on the orchard
floor
A M Berrie1, B E Ellerker1, K Lower1, G Saunders2
1
East Malling Research, East Malling, Kent, ME19 6BJ, UK
2
FAST, Crop Technology Centre, Brogdale Farm, Brogdale Road, Faversham, Kent, ME13
8XZ, UK
Abstract: The risk of pulverised excised canker prunings to apple trees was evaluated in two orchard
trials. Cankers (Nectria galligena) on one year shoots were collected from apple trees cv. Gala in two
orchards and distributed among sprout net bags. Cankers on two, three or older wood were similarly
collected and pulverised with a tractor-trailed standard orchard pulveriser before placing in sprout net
bags. Both sets of bags were pegged out in two orchard sites, either in the tree row or the grass alley
way between trees in February 2005. The bags were sampled at monthly intervals and the state and
viability of the cankers assessed. The pruned out cankers whether pulverised or unpulverised
continued to produce perithecia for at least 16 months after removal from the trees. Conidia were only
found in the first two samples. Perithecia were produced more abundantly on pruned out cankered one
year shoots. Pulverised prunings decayed more rapidly in the grass alley way than in the tree row. This
study shows that pulverised canker prunings could be a source of inoculum of N. galligena and hence
a risk to apple trees for more than a year after pulverising.
Key words: Apple, canker, Nectria galligena, prunings, pulverisation
Introduction
Canker, caused by the fungus Nectria galligena, is one of the most important diseases of
apple and pear. The fungus attacks trees in the orchard, causing cankers and die back of young
shoots, resulting in loss of fruiting wood and increasing pruning costs. Nectria also causes a
fruit rot that can result in significant losses as high as 10% or more in stored fruit. The fungus
produces two spore types, conidia in the spring and summer and ascospores in the autumn and
winter. These enter shoots and branches on the tree through wounds, either natural such as
leaf scars or artificial such as pruning wounds. Thus inoculum and points of entry on the tree
are available all year round and the only limiting factor is rain, which is essential for spore
production, spread, germination and infection. Autumn leaf fall is usually the main infection
period and wet autumns are usually followed by a high incidence of shoot dieback due to
canker the following spring and summer. Currently canker is controlled by a combination of
cultural methods to remove canker lesions and the use of protectant fungicides. Effective
fungicides are limited. Generally copper fungicides are used at autumn leaf fall and before
bud-burst to protect leaf scars and bud-scale scars and carbendazim is applied during the
spring and summer.
Up until the 1970s it was normal orchard practice to remove and burn prunings, eliminating
any pruned out cankers. However, most prunings, including cankers, are now pulverised in
the tree alley ways. The effect of this practice on canker survival and viability and risk to
apple trees is not clear. Previous studies by van der Scheer (1981) and Swinburne and Souter
(1984) have indicated a minimal risk. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect
441
of pulverising on survival and viability of canker prunings on the orchard floor and the
potential risk to apple trees.
Materials and methods
Site
Two orchard sites were selected for the study. One orchard site was located at Rocks Farm,
East Malling (TL161) and consisted of a solid block of cv Gala on M9 rootstock, planted in
1999. The second orchard was located at Elverton Farm, Teynham (Marsh Gala) and
consisted of Gala with Cox pollinators both on M9 rootstock. In both orchards canker had
been a significant problem since planting.
Collection and preparation of cankers
The orchard (TL161) was visited in February 2005. Approximately 110 cankered one year old
shoots were collected from the Gala trees in each of four pairs of rows and placed in black
sacks, giving a total of about 440 cankered shoots. Similarly approximately 110 cankered two,
three, four and older wood was collected from each of the same rows and placed in black
sacks, giving a total of around 440 lumps. At least 10 one-year old cankered shoots were
placed in each of 44 sprout nets, giving four replicates of 11 nets. These were then placed
back out in the orchard, in the tree row of each of 4 rows, 11 bags per row. The bags were
held in place with metal pins and the positions noted so that they could be relocated for future
sampling. The older cankers were spread out on a concrete pad and pulverised by a tractortrailed standard orchard pulveriser twice, in two different directions. All pulverised prunings
were then collected up and divided into four equal replicate lots. Each lot was then divided up
into 11 sprout nets, giving 44 in total. These were then placed back out in the orchard, in the
tree row in each of four rows, 11 bags per row. The bags were held in place with metal pins
and the positions noted so that they could be relocated for future sampling. A similar
procedure was followed for canker collection in the second orchard (Marsh Gala) as that at
East Malling. One-year old cankers and mature cankers were laid out in sprout nets in the
orchard, but were placed in the grass alley way rather than the tree row.
Assessments
Initially at monthly intervals the orchards were visited and the state of the cankers assessed in
terms of decay. One of the labeled bags containing pieces of canker from the pulverised wood
was collected from each replicate in the orchard. In the laboratory each canker piece was
examined carefully for signs of conidial masses or perithecia. Where present they were
checked for spores. Estimates were made of numbers of fruiting bodies present. Cankers on
one-year old pruned wood were similarly collected and similarly assessed.
Results and discussion
Rain fall was frequent throughout the period of the study at both sites such that conditions
were favourable for canker sporulation throughout the spring and early part of the summer
with conditions becoming less favourable in July and August which were exceptionally hot in
2005.
Unpulverised one-year cankered shoots
Netted samples of one-year old cankered shoots and pulverised cankers on older wood were
collected from the orchard and checked for sporulation at roughly monthly intervals from
March 2005 until July 2005. Thereafter samples were collected and examined at longer
intervals until June 2006 (Table 1). The netted one-year shoots from TL161 mostly retained
442
their bark throughout the assessment period. The dead wood was rapidly colonised by various
saprophytic fungi, including Botryosphaeria and Diaporthe which were present on many of
the twigs examined from the first assessment in March 2005 onwards. By the final assessment
in June 2006 the shoots were becoming very dry, rotted and easily broken, although the
original cankered area was still obvious and perithecia easily visible. On average more than
60% of cankers were sporing at each sampling. Perithecia containing mature or immature
ascospores were present in abundance on these cankered shoots at each sampling. This is
surprising as perithecia are normally associated with mature cankers rather than those on
young shoots. Conidia were present in samples checked in April and May 2005 but were not
observed in subsequent samplings. The results for netted one-year shoots from Marsh Gala
were similar to those for East Malling. Assessments were only continued up to October 2005
as later samples could not be located in the orchard. In contrast to the East Malling site
conidia were present in samples up to the final assessment in October 2005. Perithecia
however, were usually more abundant.
Pulverised older cankers
The netted pulverised cankers from TL161 had mostly been debarked during the pulverising
process and as with the one year shoots by June 2006 were becoming very dry and colonised
by various saprophytic fungi. The original cankered areas were less easily distinguished with
time. Initially most perithecia or conidia observed were associated with the barked areas of
the prunings, but in later samplings perithecia were equally found on debarked areas also.
Numbers of cankers observed with conidia or perithecia present were on average half of that
recorded on the one year old unpulverised prunings (Table 1). Conidia were only recorded on
samples collected in April 2005. Perithecia were recorded on the pulverised prunings at every
sampling and 43% of cankers were still producing perithecia 16 months after pulverising
(Table 1). The netted pulverised cankers from Marsh Gala had mostly been debarked during
the pulverising process. In contrast to the TL161 site, the netted samples had been placed in
the grass alleyway. Consequently at each sampling the pulverised prunings were much wetter,
were more colonised by saprophytic fungi and generally decaying more rapidly. It was also
noted that the grass was rapidly growing over the netted samples, increasing the general decay
of the wood. This more rapid decay was reflected in the incidence of perithecia found on the
prunings which was usually less than half of that found on pulverised prunings at the TL161
site. At the last sampling in December 2005 perithecia were found on less than 10% of
cankers (Table 1). Conidia were only observed on cankers during the first two samplings in
March and April 2005.
General discussion and conclusions
It is clear from this study that pruned out cankers pulverised or unpulverised can produce
perithecia for at least 16 months after being removed from the trees. The cankers continued to
produce conidia for a much shorter period of time, but it is the perithecia that pose the risk to
canker infection on trees as ascospores can be shot out from perithecia during wet weather
similar to the release of scab ascospores from fruiting bodies (pseudothecia) surviving on leaf
litter. These ascospores of N. galligena then can be carried by air currents up to infect trees.
Perithecia were produced more abundantly on pruned out cankered young shoots. These are
often just dumped in the tree row rather than the alleyway and left unpulverised. Decay of
prunings appears to take place more slowly in the tree row. Pulverised prunings left in the
grass alleyway appeared to decay more rapidly and were also overgrown by the grass. Despite
this perithecia could still be found almost twelve months after the pulverising.
443
Previous studies by van der Scheer (1981) and Swinburne and Souter (1984) have indicated a
minimal risk from cankered prunings dumped in the grass alleyway. However, this study
shows that pulverised cankers can continue to pose a threat to apple trees for more than a year
after pulverising. Ideally in areas where conditions favour canker it would be desirable to
return to the practice of collecting prunings and burning to minimise the risk. This however,
may not be practical. The best alternative would be to dump all prunings, including young
shoots, in the grass alleyway and pulverise. Decay is more rapid and repeated mowing of
prunings would increase the break down.
Table 1 Percentage of cankers with perithecia present on one-year-old unpulverised wood or
on pulverised older wood at various sample dates from orchard sites at East Malling (TL161)
or Teynham (Marsh Gala) in 2005 or 2006
Wood
age
Orchard
site
TL161
East
One-year- Malling
old
Marsh
Gala
Teynham
TL161
East
Pulverised
Malling
older
Marsh
cankers
Gala
Teynham
Mar
2005
Apr
2005
Date cankers sampled and assessed
May Jun Jul / Oct
Dec
2005 2005 Aug 2005 2005
2005
27.8
40.6
36.1
57.9
66.7
73.5
88.9
54.5
61.6
0
10.0
46.7
33.3
27.8
57.1
-
-
-
5.3
4.5
28.6
26.3
39.0
84.0
32.4
26.7
43.3
0
1.3
5.1
10.7
14.4
11.2
8.3
-
-
Mar
2006
Jun
2006
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the Horticultural Development Council for funding the
project.
References
Scheer, h A van der, 1981. Effect of chipping of loppings on canker incidence in Cox apple
trees. Mededelingen van de Faculteit Landbouwweten- schappen Rijksuniversiteit Gent
46: 799-803
Swinburne, T R & Souter, R D 1984 Tests show pulverising is safe. Grower 101: 16.
444
Inventory of European canker in southern Sweden and Nectria
galligena as a soil pathogen.
Boysen Bengt
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Sweden
Abstract: In recent years pomme fruit growers in southern Sweden have reported that they have been
experiencing severe outbreaks of European canker and the problem seems to be increasing. The
growers mainly import new trees from nurseries in Belgium or Holland. Soon after the trees have been
planted the trees are heavily affected by canker disease. To assess the extent of the outbreaks a survey
has been started which will include orchards from all parts of the Scania province. In swedish fruit
orchards it is a common management practice to leave pruned branches containing canker on the
orchard floor and cut them into small pieces with a heavy duty lawn mower. The wood chips
eventually get incorporated into the soil and the fungus might infect the trees via the roots. We are
currently conducting experiments investigating the canker fungus’ ability to survive in soil and infect
apple tree roots.
European canker, Nectria galligena, Apple, Soil pathogen, Integrated control
445
Integrating scab control methods with partial effects in apple
orchards: the association of cultivar resistance, sanitation and reduced
fungicide schedules.
Frédérique Didelot1, Valérie Caffier1, Maël Baudin1, Gilles Orain2, Arnaud
Lemarquand2, and Luciana Parisi3
1
INRA Centre d’Angers-Nantes, UMR PaVé, 42, rue Georges Morel, BP60057, 49071
BEAUCOUZE cedex, France2 INRA Centre d’Angers-Nantes, UE Bois l'Abbé-La Rétuzière,
42, rue Georges Morel, BP60057, 49071 BEAUCOUZE cedex, France3 current address:
INRA-UERI – Domaine de Gotheron – 26320 SAINT-MARCEL-LES-VALENCE, France
Abstract: To preserve the environment, consumer health and reduce the economic impacts of apple
scab, it is crucial to improve disease control while reducing the number of treatments and the impact
of fungicide spraying. To reach this goal, the planting of cultivars with partial resistance to the disease,
associated with an integrated control strategy, may be an attractive alternative. However, to decrease
the risks for growers, cultivars with a high partial resistance level are required, and several methods of
control must be associated. The application of such a strategy must be simple and reliable. The
thresholds for chemical spraying must be defined and validated, taking into account the cultivar
resistance level and the sanitation practices applied. Since 2006, we have studied within an
experimental orchard the association of the cultivar 'Reine des Reinettes' (which presents good partial
resistance) with:
1 A sanitation practice: reduction of leaf litter.
2 A chemical schedule: fungicide spraying only if a medium or high Mill’s risk is recorded or
expected.
The results obtained in 2006 and 2007 showed that, with only 5 to 6 sprayings per season (on
average, twice as many sprays were applied in conventional orchards in the Loire Valley), scab control
was efficient with less than 2% of scabbed fruits.
Key words: partial resistance, apple scab, control strategy, sanitation practices, fungicide treatments,
Venturia inaequalis.
Introduction
Repeated fungicide treatments against apple scab reduce the auxiliary fauna and can favour
the development of some pests (Sauphanor et al., 2005). Moreover, resistance to several
active ingredients has appeared in Venturia inaequalis populations (Parisi et al., 1994; Köller
et al., 2004; Köller et al., 2005). It is, therefore, crucial to improve disease control while
reducing the number of treatments and the impact of fungicide spraying.
The alternatives to intensive chemical control are numerous (Carisse & Dewdney, 2002).
In our study we focus on the association of three methods with partial effects: sanitation;
partial resistance; and Integrated Pest Management (IPM) adapted to partial resistance.
Sanitation has been used in several countries for many years, and its efficiency in
reducing scab epidemics is recognized (Sutton, et al., 2000; Holb, 2006; Gomez et al., 2007).
One of the best results seems to be obtained by removing of the autumn leaf litter.
Partially resistant apple cultivars show low levels of disease, confirmed by recent data
(Brun et al., 2008). In this work, the old French cultivar ’Reine des Reinettes’ appeared to be
of very low susceptibility: without fungicide protection, the level of scab incidence on fruits
446
and leaves was significantly lower on ‘Reine des Reinettes’ than on ‘Gala’ (a cultivar
susceptible to scab). In 2003, characterized by dry climatic conditions the disease didn't
develop on 'Reine des Reinettes'. However, when climatic conditions are favourable for scab,
partial resistance must be combined with other control methods.
Schedule recommendations for low susceptibility cultivars were established in 1980’s
(Olivier, 1986; Lefeuvre, 1995), but fungicide resistances, that don’t allow applying curative
treatments with the majority of active ingredients, rendered difficult the practical application
of these recommendations. A way to take into account the current fungicide resistance context
is to apply some preventive treatments and when necessary choose “stop-applications” of
contact fungicides.
In this study, we combined partial resistance ('Reine des Reinettes', X2640) and sanitation
(removal of the autumn litter) with an adapted fungicide schedule on an experimental orchard.
The efficiency for control of apple scab was studied for two years (2006, 2007). The aim was
to be able to recommend reliable methods limiting the number of sprays.
Material and methods
The orchard.
The orchard in the Loire Valley (France), was planted in 1999 and restructured in 2005, when
3 of the plots were over grafted in order to obtain 6 monoculture plots of 'Reine des
Reinettes'. Each plot (810 m²) contains 6 rows of 13 trees surrounded by non host plant hedge.
The distance between plants within the row is 1.25 m and 4 m between the rows. The orchard
contains 16 plots of which 6 are used for this trial: 3 treated plots and 3 untreated plots of
'Reine des Reinettes'.
Treatments and assessments.
Leaf litter was removed in autumn 2005 and 2006 from the treated plots only. The fungicide
schedule was based on Olivier's model of treatment threshold (Lefeuvre, 1995), and the plots
were protected by a “stop-spray” or a curative fungicide application when the moderate and
severe Mill’s risks (Mills & Laplante, 1951) were detected with the Pulsowin 3.1 software
(Pulsonic, Orsay, France). However, preventive treatments were applied in case of forecast of
a rainy period when a high ascospore stock was present. The 78 trees of each plot were
observed on 12-06-2006 and on 6-06-2007. The scabbed trees (from 1 lesion observed) were
counted. At harvest around 26 Kg of apples per row (for the rows 2 to 5 per plot) were picked,
and the percentage of scabbed fruits was assessed. After harvest the percentage of scabbed
leaves (25 to 42 shoots per plot) was observed and the quantity of inoculum was calculated
(Gagoury & MacHardy, 1986), in October 2005, 2006 and 2007.
Results
In 2006 and 2007, the number of fungicide applications was 5 and 6, respectively. This level
is half of the number of sprays applied in commercial plots of susceptible cultivars in the
INRA experimental station for the two years (Table 1).
In June 2007, the percentage of scabbed trees remained under 15% in treated plots, while
in untreated plots it reached 74% (Figure 1-A). At harvest, the incidence on fruits was 1.0 and
0.2% in 2006 and 2007 respectively (Figure 1-B). In untreated plots this number was around
3.5% for the two years.
Table 1: Number of fungicide sprays applied in 2006 and 2007 in the experimental and
commercial plots (average) of the experimental station
447
2006 2007
5
6
11
14
55
57
60%
40%
20%
0%
2006
Ø
2007
Treated Plots
Ø
4.0%
B
% of scabbed
leaves in autumn
A
80%
% of scabbed fruits
at harvest
% of scabbed trees
in June
Experimental plots
Average commercial plots
% of reduction
3.0%
2.0%
1.0%
Ø
0.0%
2006
2007
25%
C
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
2005
2006
2007
Untreated Plots
Figure 1: Development of disease in treated and untreated plot (cv 'Reine des Reinettes'), A and B : Ø Statistically significant effect of the treatments (logistic modelling).
In 2005, before the beginning of the trial, the level of disease in autumn (figure 1-C) was
higher in treated plots than on untreated plots (9.9% and 5.3% of scabbed leaves,
respectively). This order was reversed in 2006 and 2007. The incidence reached 21% of
scabbed leaves in 2007, while this number remained under 10% in treated plots.
Discussion
The disparities of disease levels between the untreated plots were very important. This
variability was very pronounced at harvest 2007, where no fruit was scabbed in one of the
three treated plots. This fact explains the lack of significant effect of treatments in spite of the
high differences in average scab incidence on fruits between the two modalities. Nevertheless,
during the two years, the attacks of scab on leaves and fruits were limited in all treated plots.
The incidence remained very low and constant in contrast to the results observed in untreated
plots. The number of unhealthy fruits remained tolerable for commercialisation with a
quantity of fungicide treatments strongly reduced compared to the quantity applied on average
in commercial orchards of Loire Valley.
We can conclude that cv 'Reine des Reinettes' showed a good level of partial resistance,
and that the chemical spraying schedule associated with sanitation was very efficient to
enhance this partial scab resistance during these 2 years. The association of these three
methods showed good efficacy, even in difficult conditions (climatic conditions in 2007 were
favourable to scab).
In the future we will try to reduce the number of fungicide applications. For this goal, the
Mill's contamination threshold (Mills & Laplante, 1951) for application decision can be
modified: as Olivier and Lefeuvre proposed, if the autumn inoculum is low, only the severe
Mill's threats will be treated. The schedule strategy will be based on these recommendations.
448
Acknowledgments
We thank Christine Boursier, Danièle Chalain, Mélanie Collin, and Pascale Expert, and the
team of experimental unit of INRA of Angers for technical support.
References
Brun, L., Didelot, F. & Parisi, L. 2008: Effects of apple cultivar susceptibility to Venturia
inaequalis on scab epidemics in apple orchards. Crop Protection. 27: 1009-1019.
Carisse, O. & Dewdney, M. 2002: A review of non-fungicidal approaches for the control of
apple scab. Phytoprotection. 83: 1-29.
Gadoury, D.M. & Mac Hardy, W.E. 1986: Forecasting ascopore dose of Venturia inaequalis in
commercial apple orchards. Phytopathology 76: 112-118.
Gomez, C., Brun, L., Chauffour, D. & De Le Vallée, D. 2007: Effect of leaf litter management
on scab development in an organic apple orchard. Agriculture Ecosystems and
Environment. 118: 249-255.
Holb, I.J. 2006: Effect of six sanitation treatments on leaf litter density, ascospore production
of Venturia inaequalis and scab incidence in integrated and organic apple orchards.
European Journal of Plant Pathology. 115 : 293-307.
Köller, W., Parker, D.M., Turechek, W. W. & Avila-Adame, C. 2004: A two-phase resistance
response of Venturia inaequalis populations to QoI fungicides Kresoxim-methyl and
trifloxystrobin. Plant Disease. 88 : 537-544.
Köller, W., Wilcox, & W.F.Parker, D.M.. 2005: Sensitivity of Venturia inaequalis populations
to anilinopyrimidine fungicides and their contribution to scab management in New York.
Plant Disease. 89 : 357-365
Lefeuvre, M. 1995: Lutte raisonnée contre la tavelure du pommier: Validation d’un modèle
d’aide à la décision. Memory, ENSH-ENITHP Angers, France
Mills, W.D. & Laplante, A.A. 1951: Diseases and insects in the orchard. Cornell Extension
Bulletin 711.
Olivier, J.M. 1986: La tavelure du pommier, conduite d'une protection raisonnée. Adalia. 1: 319.
Parisi, L.; Guillaumes, J. & Wuster, G. 1994: Sensitivity to fenarimol of Venturia inaequalis
strains from French orchards. Agronomie 14 : 387-394
Sauphanor, B., Bouvier, J. C., Boisneau, C., Rieux, R., Simon, S., Capowiez, Y. & Toubon,
J.F. 2005: Impacts biologiques des systèmes de protection en vergers de pommiers.
Phytoma 581: 32-36.
Sutton, D.K., MacHardy, W.E. & Lord, W.G. 2000: Effects of shredding or treating apple leaf
litter with urea on ascospore dose of Venturia inaequalis and disease buildup. Plant
Disease. 84: 1319-1326.
449
Application of thermotherapy and chemotherapy in vitro for
elimination of some viruses infecting fruit trees and small fruits
Mirosława Cieślińska
Research Institute of Pomology and Floriculture, Virology Laboratory, Pomologiczna 18, 96100 Skierniewice, Poland
Abstract: In vitro culture is known currently as a technique used to eliminate viruses from plants. In
this study thermotherapy and chemotherapy in vitro were applied to eliminate ACLSV and PNRSV
from myrobalan, PNRSV from ‘Empress’ plum, PDV from ‘Early Rivers’ sweet cherry, ACLSV from
apple ‘Jonagold’ and pear 'Pierre Corneille', and RVCV from 'Norna' raspberry. Shoots were placed in
a growth chamber where the temperature was raised gradually to 36oC and kept at this level for 4
weeks for thermotherapy. Chemotherapy was conducted using 10-100 mg l-1 Virazole® (ribavirin)
applied into the proliferation medium. Combining both methods was also used. ELISA assays for
ACLSV, PNRSV and PDV were conducted one year after therapy. The rooted raspberry plants were
planted in a greenhouse and observed for possible RVCV symptoms. Thermotherapy in vitro was
highly effective for PNRSV and ACLSV elimination but it was not efficient for obtaining PDV-free
sweet cherry and RVCV-free raspberry. Efficiency of chemotherapy varied depending on
concentration of Virazole®, virus and species of infected plant. Virazole® at concentration 25-100 mg
l-1 was effective in eliminating ACLSV from myrobalan and PNRSV from plum but was not successful
in eliminating PNRSV from myrobalan and PDV from sweet cherry shoots. Combining thermotherapy
and chemotherapy contributed to elimination of all studied viruses from most treated shoots.
Keywords: in vitro culture, thermotherapy, chemotherapy, ACLSV, PNRSV, PDV, RVCV
Introduction
In vitro culture is known not only as a method of micropropagation of plant material and
maintenance of gene bank accessions but currently as a technique used for eradicating viruses
from plants. Thermotherapy, chemotherapy, shoot-tip culture, micrografting or combinations
of these methods in vitro are useful tools for elimination of different viruses from fruit trees
(Cieślińska, 2002; Cieślińska, 2007; Cieślińska and Zawadzka, 1999; Deogratias et al., 1989;
Hansen and Lane, 1985; Howell et al., 2001; Gella and Errea, 1998; Manganaris et al., 2003;
Snir and Stein, 1985; Spiegel et al., 1993; Stein et al., 1991).
The objective of the present work was to use thermotherapy and chemotherapy in vitro
and combinations of these both methods to eliminate Apple chlorotic leaf spot virus (ACLSV)
from apple ‘Jonagold’, pear 'Pierre Corneille', and myrobalan, Prunus necrotic ring spot virus
(PNRSV) from myrobalan and ‘Empress’ plum, Prune dwarf virus (PDV) from ‘Early Rivers’
sweet cherry and Raspberry vein chlorosis virus (RVCV) from 'Norna' raspberry.
Material and methods
The study was done on ‘Jonagold’ apple and ‘Pierre Corneille’ pear infected with ACLSV,
myrobalan infected with a complex of ACLSV and PNRSV, ‘Empress’ plum infected with
PNRSV, ‘Early Rivers’ sweet cherry infected with PDV, and ‘Norna’ raspberry infected with
RVCV. The infection of the fruit trees was confirmed by positive reaction in enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) using specific antisera. RVCV presence in raspberry plant was
450
verified by observation of characteristic symptoms and the results of biological indexing.
The apical and axillary buds isolated from infected trees were put in the tubes and
multiplied using Murashige and Skoog (MS) (1962) medium with the addition of 0.25 µM l-1
indole-3-butyric acid (IBA), 2.5 µM l-1 6-benzylaminopurine (BA), 30 g l-1 sucrose and
solidified with 7 g l-1 of agar. The cultured shoots were placed in a growth chamber at under a
day/night temperature regime of 24/21oC with a 16 h photoperiod.
Temperature was gradually increased from 24oC to 36oC over a week and kept at 36oC
for the following four weeks in the course of thermotherapy . Untreated shoots (control) were
maintained at 22oC. After thermotherapy the surviving shoots were transferred to MS rooting
medium with addition of 2 mg l-1 IBA, and 4-5 weeks later they were potted in a greenhouse.
Chemotherapy was conducted using Virazole® (ribavirin) (ICN Pharmaceuticals, Inc., USA),
a synthetic broad-spectrum antiviral nucleoside (1-ß-D-ribofuranesyl-1,2,4-triazole-3carboxamide), added into the proliferation medium at concentrations of 10, 25, 50 and 100
mg l-1. Four weeks after initiating the experiment, shoot tips (1cm long) were excised and
transferred to a Virazole®-free medium and one month later to the rooting medium. Rooted
plantlets were potted in greenhouse. Combining of the both methods, thermotherapy and
chemotherapy was also used. DAS-ELISA assays for ACLSV, PNRSV and PDV were
conducted one year after therapy (Clark et al., 1976). Shoots of healthy and infected plants of
the same species maintained in vitro were used as the negative and positive controls. The
rooted raspberry plants were planted in a greenhouse and observed for possible RVCV
symptoms.
Results and discussion
Depending on the plant species the survival rate of the shoots treated with thermotherapy was
67-100%,. Virazole® at concentrations 10-25 mg l-1 did not affect significantly the survival
rate but 50-100 mg l-1 of this compound was phytotoxic for pear, plum and raspberry shoots,
especially when combined with thermotherapy (Figure 1).
35
apple
pear
raspberry 30
30
25
myrobalan
plum
sweet cherry
25
20
20
15
15
10
TV100
TV50
TV25
TV10
T
V100
V50
V25
V10
TV100
TV50
TV25
TV10
T
V 100
V 50
0
V 25
0
V 10
5
Control
5
Control
10
Figure 1. Effect of thermotherapy (T) and Virazole® (V 10-100 mg l-1) on survival rate of
apple, pear, raspberry and Prunus sp. shoots
These shoots showed chlorosis and apical necrosis and most of them died during the therapy.
Survival rate of shoots depended on species and cultivar of plants and a kind of virus. It is
451
known that pome fruit trees tolerate heat better than stone fruit trees (Gella and Errea, 1998;
Stein et al., 1991). The use of alternating temperature 28oC/38oC in thermotherapy in vitro for
18-20 days was less harmful to shoots and in many cases allowed elimination of PNRSV from
peach (Spiegel et al., 1995).
Deogratias et al. (1989) showed that all shoots of 'Noire de Meched' sweet cherry infected
with ACLSV, treated with 32-34oC for three weeks, died at the end of the treatment period.
However, in the same experiment 30% of 'Van 2D' sweet cherry shoots infected with PDV
and PNRSV survived thermotherapy. 90-100% of apricot shoots infected with ACLSV, 70%
of sweet cherry shoots with PDV and PNRSV and 42-90% of peach shoots with PNRSV and
ACLSV survived thermotherapy (Gella and Errea, 1998).
Thermotherapy effect strongly depended on species of treated shoots (Table 1). High
temperature enabled elimination ACLSV from 24% of pear 'Pierre Corneille', 67% of apple
‘Jonagold’ and myrobalan shoots. Thermotherapy was also effective in elimination of PNRSV
from myrobalan and plum (58% and 50%, respectively), but it was not successful method of
PDV and RVCV elimination.
Table 1. Effect of in vitro treatment on the elimination of viruses in apple, pear, Prunus sp.
and raspberry shoots.
0/25
16/24
Number of virus free plants/number of tested plants
PDV
RVCV
ACLSV
PNRSV
sweet raspberry
pear
myrobalan myrobalan plum
cherry
0/35
0/30
0/30
0/30
0/25
0/25
8/33
16/24
14/24
15/20
0/25
0/22
6/25
15/25
21/23
13/13
23/35
24/30
25/29
8/8
10/27
16/26
23/26
18/21
0/27
0/26
0/26
0/21
10/26
12/24
7/10
8/8
0/25
0/25
0/22
0/14
0/21
3/18
10/12
5/5
10/25
18/22
15/15
12/12
14/26
18/26
20/24
0/0
14/25
20/22
19/19
15/18
16/25
17/22
19/19
18/18
22/22
20/20
10/10
2/2
0/25
3/25
8/21
14/15
3/19
13/17
8/9
1/1
Treatment
apple
Control
Thermotherapy
Virazole® [mg l-1]
10
25
50
100
Thermotherapy +
Virazole® [mg l-1]
10
25
50
100
Depending on the period of heat treatment, it was possible to eliminate PNRSV, ACLSV
and PDV from shoots of several Prunus sp. fruit trees shoots (Barba et al., 1992; Deogratias et
al., 1989; Gella and Errea, 1998; Snir and Stein, 1985; Stein et al., 1991). However it was
difficult to eliminate ACLSV and PPV from apricot shoots using thermotherapy (Llácer,
1995). Janečkova (1995) eliminated complex of Apple mosaic virus, Apple stem grooving and
ACLSV from apple cultivars by combination thermotherapy in vivo with the segment bud
cultures in vitro. In this study, thermotherapy was not an effective method for RVCV
elimination from raspberry. Baumann (1982) produced raspberry plants free from RVCV by a
combination of thermotherapy and meristem tip culture and Sobczykiewicz (1986) by
meristem tip culture alone.
Efficiency of chemotherapy varied depending on virus, species of infected plant and
452
concentration of Virazole®. This compound was effective in elimination of PNRSV from
‘Empress’ plum – the higher the concentration the greater the chemotherapy efficiency.
Independent of concentrations of Virazole®, chemotherapy was not effective in elimination of
PNRSV from myrobalan and PDV from ‘Early Rivers’ sweet cherry. Deogratias et al. (1989)
showed that Virazole® at concentration 25, 50 and 100 mg l-1 was effective in eliminating
ACLSV from 50-100% of Prunus mahaleb shoots. However, in the same experiment it was
necessary to apply 50 and 100 mg l-1 of this compound to eliminate PNRSV and PDV. It was
possible to obtain RVCV-free raspberry shoots after using Virazole® in concentrations of 50
and 100 mg l-1. No symptoms of vein chlorosis were observed for two years whereas
raspberry plants still infected with RVCV were stunted and showed chlorosis of the minor
veins. Phytotoxic influence of Virazole® on apple, pear, Prunus sp. and raspberry shoots was
observed with increasing concentration of this compound. Most treated shoots showed
chlorosis and necrosis and finally died at the end of the therapy. Some phytotoxity of higher
Virazole® concentrations was observed by Deogratias et al. (1989) on cherries in the course
of elimination of PDV, PNRSV and ACLSV, and Hansen and Lane (1985) who treated apple
shoots to eliminate ACLSV. Combining thermotherapy and chemotherapy contributed to
elimination of all studied viruses from most treated shoots.
Acknowledgements
The author would like to thank Mrs. Dorota Starzec for her excellent technical assistance
References
Baumann G. 1982. Elimination of heat-stable raspberry viruses by combining heat treatment
and meristem culture. Acta Hort. 129:11-13.
Barba M., Martino L., Lauretti F. 1992. Comparison of different methods to produce virus
free stone fruits. Acta Hort. 309: 385-392.
Cieślińska M. 2002. Elimination of Apple Chlorotic Leaf Spot Virus (ACLSV) from pear by
in vitro thermotherapy and chemotherapy. Acta Hort. 596: 481-484.
Cieślińska M. 2007. Application of thermo- and chemotherapy in vitro for elimination of
some viruses infecting Prunus sp. fruit trees. J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. Vol. 15: 117-124.
Cieślińska M., Zawadzka B. 1999: Preliminary results of investigation on elimination of
viruses from apple, pear and raspberry using thermotherapy and chemotherapy in vitro.
Phytopathol. Pol.17: 41-48.
Clark M.F., Adams A.N., Barbara D.J. 1976. The detection of plant viruses by enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Acta Hort. 67: 43-49.
Deogratias J.M., Dosba F., Lutz A. 1989. Eradication of prune dwarf virus, prunus necrotic
ringspot virus and apple chlorotic leaf spot virus in sweet cherries by a combination of
chemotherapy, thermotherapy, and in vitro culture. Can. J. Plant Pathology 11: 337-342.
Gella R., Errea P. 1998. Application of in vitro therapy for Ilarvirus elimination in tress
Prunus species. J. Phytopathology 146: 445-449.
Hansen J., Lane W.D. 1985. Elimination of apple chlorotic leaf spot virus from apple shoot
culture by Ribavirin. Plant Disease 69: 134-135.
Howell W.E., Eastwell K.C., Li T.S.C. 2001. Heat treatment, chemo therapy and hydroponic
culture for obtaining virus-free trees of sweet cherry. Acta Hort. 550: 455-457.
Janečková M. 1995. Eliminace viru jabloni kombinaci termoterapie in vivo se segmentovymi
pupenovymi kulturami in vitro. Vedeckie Prace Ovocnarskie 14: 45-50.
453
Llácer G. 1995. Virus, viroids and mycoplasma diseases of apricot. Acta Hort. 384: 511-520.
Manganaris G.A., Economou A.S., Boubourakas I, Katis N. 2003. Production of virus-free
plant propagation material from infected nectarine trees. Acta Hort.. 616: 501-505.
Murashige T., Skoog F. 1962. A revised medium for rapid growth and bioassay with tobacco
tissue culture. Physiol. Plant. 15: 473-497.
Snir I., Stein A. 1985. In vitro selection and elimination of prunus necrotic ring spot virus in
sweet cherry (Prunus avium). Riv. Ortiflorofrutt. It. 69: 191-194.
Sobczykiewicz D. 1986. Elimination of heat-stable raspberry vein chlorosis virus by meristem
culture. Acta Hort. 186: 47-49.
Spiegel S., Frison E.A., Converse R.H. 1993. Recent Developments in Therapy and VirusDetection Procedures for International Movement of Clonal Plant Germ Plasm. Plant
Disease 12: 1176-1180.
Spiegel S., Stein A., Tam Y. 1995. In vitro thermotherapy of rosaceous fruit trees. Acta Hort.
386: 419.
Stein A., Spiegel S., Faingersh G., Levy S. 1991. Responses of micropropagated peach
cultivars to thermotherapy for elimination of Prunus necrotic ring spot virus. Ann. Appl.
Biol. 104: 267-276.
454
In vivo antagonism of Acremonium byssoides endophyte in Vitis
vinifera, towards Plasmopara viticola
Gaetano Conigliaro, Valeria Ferraro, Alessandra Martorana, Santella Burruano
Dipartimento S.En.Fi.Mi.Zo., Sezione di Patologia vegetale e Microbiologia agraria,
Università di Palermo, Viale delle Scienze 2, 90128 Palermo. gaeconigliaro@unipa.it
Abstract: The endophytism of Acremonium byssoides in Vitis vinifera was recently ascertained in
Sicily. In particular, the hyphomycete was observed in leaves of three vine cultivars (Regina Bianca,
Catarratto and Insolia). Moreover, in the leaves of cultivar Insolia inoculated with P. viticola, the A.
byssoides showed an antagonistic activity (hyperparassitism and antibiosis) towards asexual and
sexual structures of the oomycete.
In spring 2002 and 2007 “Insolia” vines, infected by the endophyte, suffered repeated attacks by P.
viticola, that lasted until the formation of gamic structures of pathogen. The aim of our researches was
to ascertain in vivo the effect of A. byssoides on viability of oospores, the only means of P. viticola
overwintering. The “mosaic spotted” leaves were collected in October from vines colonized (cv.
Insolia) or not (cv. Catarratto) by A. byssoides and exposed to natural climatic conditions. The
oospores viability was assayed by germination tests.
The differentiated oospores in endophyte-free leaves showed the highest mean germination value,
whereas the other ones were degenerated and did not germinate at all.
This study shows that the interaction between A. byssoides, V. vinifera and P. viticola could assume a
determinant role to contain the mildew infections in our environment.
Key words: grapevine, endophytism, antagonism, downy mildew
Introduction
Recent studies confirmed the endophytism of Acremonium byssoides in symptomless leaves
of different cultivars of Vitis vinifera (Regina Bianca, Catarratto, Insolia). Moreover, in leaves
of cv. Insolia inoculated in vitro with Plasmopara viticola, the endophyte inhibited the
pathogen infection by invading mycelium (Fig. 1a), sporangiophores (Fig. 1b), sporangia and
sexual spores (Fig. 1c) of the oomycete (Burruano et al., 2008).
a
b
Figure 1. a) P. viticola mycelium invaded by A. byssoides; b) sporangiophores bridled by the
endophyte hyphae; c) hyphomycete insightful a gamic structure of the oomycete.
In spring 2002 and 2007, natural infections of P. viticola were detected on plants of cv.
455
c
Insolia, lasting during summer and autumn until the formation of the pathogen gamic
structures. In order to define new defensive strategies against downy mildew primary
infections, an investigation was carried out to ascertain in vivo the A. byssoides effect on
viability of oospores, the only overwintering structures of P. viticola.
Materials and methods
In the 30th October of each year (2002 and 2007) leaves with numerous “mosaic spots” were
harvested from vines colonized (cv. Insolia) or not (cv. Catarratto) by A. byssoides and
growing in Palermo and S. G. Jato, respectively. Foliar fragments 1 cm2 wide were obtained.
The occurrence of P. viticola spores within the mesophyll was detected by stereomicroscopy,
whereas their nuclear stage was assessed using DAPI (4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole)
fluorochrome (Burruano et al., 2000). Foliar fragments were put to overwinter under
environmental climatic conditions (Burruano et al., 1989).
The germinative efficiency was evaluated by means of germination assays from February
to April-May. In particular, every 15 days foliar fragments were taken for manual isolation of
spores. Some spores were treated with DAPI while the remaining ones were put to germinate
into drops of water in moist chamber at 20 ± 2° C. For each test the oospore viability was
daily checked by counting the germinated oospores; at the end of germination phase, the total
number of oospores was counted to calculate the germination percentage (Burruano et al.,
2000).
Results
In 2002, at the harvest, the spores showed three different nuclear stages (oogonia, oospheres
and oospores; fig. 2a; 2b and 2c) with different percentage in relation to the tested cultivar. In
particular, oogonia 42.3%, oospheres 33.5% and oospores 17.9 % were observed in A.
byssoides-free grapevines (cv. Catarratto; Fig. 3a), while oogonia 65.3%, oospheres 16.6%
and oospores 11.6% in plants colonized by the hyphomycete (cv. Insolia; Fig. 3b). Moreover
in both cases degenerated spores (fig. 3d) were occasionally detected.
a
b
c
d
Figure 2. Nuclear stage of P. viticola spores: a) oogonia; b) oosphera;
degenerated spore.
c) oospora; d)
The nuclear staining showed a different dynamic of the nuclear stages in examined
samples. In endophyte-free fragments, in fact, the uninucleate spore percentage varied
between 7 and 18.1 from February to March and strongly reduced in the following months
(Fig. 3a). On the contrary, in the colonized leaves, the mononucleate oospores detected at the
harvest degenerated, in fact their amount reached 100% already at the second assay (Fig. 3b).
In 2007 the percentages of the nuclear stages at the harvest were the following in
endophyte-free leaves: 42.4% of oogonia, 13.4% of oospheres and 28.8% of oospores (Fig.
4a); whereas in the colonized ones oogonia were 64.2%, oospheres 10.5% and uninucleate
456
oospores 3.3% (Fig. 3b). In the first case, the high amount of mononucleate oospores detected
in February (29.1%) reduced at first assay of March (10.5%) and increased in the two
following ones (17.7 and 18.0% respectively), reaching the lowest value (6.5%) in the last
assay (Fig. 4a). In fragments colonized by the endophyte instead the mononucleate oospores
amount was very low, ranging from 8.4% (first test on February) to 0% (in April); at the same
time the degenerated and endophyte-invaded spores increased continuously (Fig. 4b).
As regards the germination assay, in 2002 the oospores of endophyte-free cultivar
(Catarratto) germinated constantly reaching the highest value (18.1%) in March (Fig. 2a). In
contrast no germination occurred in A. byssoides colonized fragments (cv. Insolia; Fig. 2b). In
2007, the germination tests showed a similar trend: oospores of Catarratto leaves during all
tests reached the highest percentage in March (15.4%), whereas the oospores of Insolia didn’t
germinate (Fig. 4 a-b).
a
b
Figure 3. Percentage of gamic structures and oospores germination observed in Catarratto (a)
and Insolia (b) in October-May 2002-03.
a
b
457
Figure 4. Percentage of gamic structures and oospores germination observed in Catarratto
(a) and Insolia (b) in October-April 2007-08.
Conclusions
Our researches demonstrated in vivo the antagonism activity of A. byssoides towards the
oomycete gamic structures. In fact, as regards the endophyte colonized leaves, the constant
decreasing of the uninucleate spores, the increasing of the degenerated ones and total lack of
germination confirmed the antibiosis and hyperparassitism activity of endophyte against the
pathogen (Burruano et al., 2007). A. byssoides can be considered one of the extrinsic factors
that influence the maturation of P. viticola spores. In southern and island environments,
characterized by hot and dry climate, the primary infections of P. viticola occur during MayJune, causing 2-3 infective cycles until the middle of July. Usually the infections start again at
the first autumnal rains, with “mosaic spots” which sporulate regularly and allow the
differentiation of gamic structures, assuring the pathogen survival (Burruano et al., 2006). In
these environments, hence, the interaction between A. byssoides and P. viticola could have a
decisive role in the containment of P. viticola primary and secondary infections.
References
Burruano, S., Di Graziano, M., Faretra, F., Nalli, R. & Pennisi, A. 1989: Indagini sulla
germinazione delle oospore di Plasmopara viticola in aree geografiche differenti.
Phytopath. medit. 28: 85-89.
Burruano, S., Conigliaro, G. & Laviola, C. 2000: Ulteriori osservazioni sull’evoluzione
nucleare delle strutture gamiche di Plasmopora viticola. Micol. It. 2: 32-38.
Burruano, S., Conigliaro, G., Lo Piccolo, S., Alfonzo, A. & Torta L. 2006: Plasmopara
viticola: three decades of observation in Sicily. 5th International Workshop on grapevine
downy and powdery mildew, San Michele all’ Adige Italy 18-23 June 2006.
Burruano, S., Conigliaro, G., Lo Piccolo S. & Torta L. 2007: Oospore di Plasmopara viticola:
dinamica di maturazione e possibile antagonismo di Acremonium byssoides. Micol. It. 2:
53-59.
Burruano, S., Alfonzo, A., Lo Piccolo, S., Conigliaro, G., Mondello, V., Torta, L., Moretti, M.
& Assante G. 2008: Interaction between Acremonium byssoides and Plasmopara viticola
in Vitis vinifera. Phytopath. medit. 47: 122-131.
458
Preliminary investigation on the endophytic communities in Olea
europaea L. in Sicily
Valeria Ferraro, Gaetano Conigliaro, Livio Torta, Santella Burruano, Giancarlo
Moschetti
Dipartimento S.En.Fi.Mi.Zo., Sezione di Patologia vegetale e Microbiologia agraria,
Università di Palermo, Viale delle Scienze 2, 90128 Palermo. santella@unipa.it
Abstract: An investigation was carried out in order to study the composition of the endophytic
community of olive (Olea europaea L.) in Sicily (Italy). One olive-yard in San Cipirello (Palermo)
and another one in Racalmuto (Agrigento) were sampled, similar for plant age, cultivars and
agricultural management. Isolation assays were carried out on samples collected from each locality in
spring, summer and autumn during both 2007 and 2008.
Numbers of fungal and bacterial isolates differed between the sampled sites. Prevailing fungal genera
in almost all samplings were Alternaria, Cladosporium, Diplodia, Phoma, Septoria, Stemphylium and
its teleomorph Pleospora. Isolation frequencies were dependent on the sampling site. Our preliminary
results show a constant composition of endophytic assemblage of O. europaea in Sicily, even if the
degree of infection varies depending on both geographical and environmental factors. Further studies
will be carried out in order to complete fungal and bacterial identification and to analyse the
interactions between endophytes, host and environment.
Key words: Olea europaea, fungi, bacteria, endophytism.
Introduction
Endophytes are microorganisms living all or part of their life-cycle asymptomatically inside
plants, even though, after incubation or a latency period, they may cause diseases
(Rakotoniriana et al. 2008). They may establish a variety of interactions with their hosts,
ranging from mutualism to commensalism and antagonism (Schulz and Boyle 2005). The
stability or the variability of the asymptomatic interaction depends on numerous factors such
as environmental stresses, host senescence, endophyte virulence and host defense response
(Schulz et al. 1999). Endophytic infection may result in advantages to the host plant such as
enhanced vegetative growth, drought tolerance, higher resistance to insects and herbivores
and protection against pathogens (Rakotoniriana et al. 2008).
Many studies have been carried out on endophytes of agricultural crops, particularly on
endophytic fungi, considering their assemblages in planta, interactions with host plants,
production of secondary metabolites, and potential in biological control of pests and diseases
(Wang et al. 2007).
This research was undertaken in order to investigate the composition of endophytic
microflora of O. europaea L. in Sicily and to evaluate its variability in time and space.
Materials and methods
One olive-yard in San Cipirello (Palermo, Northern Sicily) and another one in Racalmuto
(Agrigento, Southern Sicily) were investigated. Similar plant age, cultivars (Biancolilla,
Nocellara del Belice) and agricultural management were studied at both sites. In both sites
healthy trees were present together with plants showing different degrees of foliar chlorosis,
459
sometimes associated with necrotic spots and withering twigs starting from their apex.
In 2007 and 2008 seasonal epidemiological investigations were carried out to evaluate
the incidence of both symptoms and its devolopment. At the same time, samples of both
asymptomatic and symptomatic organs were randomly collected and processed within 24 h.
Prior to surface sterilization, leaves and twigs were thoroughly washed in running tap
water to remove dust particles from their surfaces and dried with blotting-paper. Thereafter,
leaves were surface sterilized (5 min 5% NaClO, 1 min and 30 s 95% EtOH, 1-3 min 5%
H2O2, rinse in H2O), small segments of approximately 2 × 2 mm were cut and sets of sevennine segments per leaf were plated in Petri dishes containing 2% malt extract agar (MEA). As
regards twigs, after flame-sterilization and decortication, segments of approximately 2 × 2
mm were sterilely cut and placed on 2% MEA in Petri dishes; seven fragments were plated
per dish. All the dishes were incubated at 20 ± 1 °C. Fungi and bacteria growing out from the
plant fragments were individually subcultured on 2% MEA and 1.5% Plate Count Agar
(PCA), respectively. The efficacy of the foliar sterilization procedure was ascertained
following the method of Schulz et al. (1998).
The overall colonization rate (CR) was calculated as the total number of tissue segments
yielding ≥1 isolate divided by the total number of tissue segments incubated. The isolation
frequency (IF) of a single endophyte was calculated as the number of segments from which
the endophyte was isolated divided by the total number of segments incubated per organ ×
100. The species diversity was calculated by the Shannon index, and two-way ANOVA was
used to test whether there were significant differences (P < 0.05) in CR between different
seasons and localities. All statistics were calculated with Microsoft Excel for Windows
version 2003.
Fungal isolates were identified on the basis of both macro- and microscopic features, by
means of an appropriate atlas (Barnett 1965; Watanabe 2002) and identification keys
(Goidanich 1994). Bacterial identification was carried out by microscopic observation and
physiological tests (Scortichini 1995).
Results and discussion
A total of four epidemiological assays were carried out from spring 2007 to spring 2008. In
the olive-yard of S. Cipirello, chlorosis incidence varied strongly over the course of the year,
reaching the lowest value (12.8%) in spring 2007 and the highest (97.9%) in the following
summer; the incidence of twigs withering increased progressively from 6.4% (first assay) to
46.8% in autumn, then decreasing to 36.2%. In Racalmuto incidences of the two
symptomatologies showed the same trend, reaching the highest value in spring 2008 (89.2%
chlorosis, 90.8% twigs withering) (Fig. 1a). Correlation between symptoms was medium (R=
0.45) in the first case and high in the second one (R=0.96).
The numbers of isolated endophytes were different in relation to the sampling site and
season. The overall colonization rates of endophytes were always higher in leaves than in
twigs; the CR of leaves reached the highest value in autumn 2007 in S. Cipirello (0.78) and in
the spring of the same year in Racalmuto (0.92); in twigs the highest CR occurred in spring
and autumn 2007, respectively (Fig. 1b). No significant differences in CR between different
seasons and localities were observed. In plants of S. Cipirello the Shannon index showed a
similar diversity in endophytic assemblages of twigs and leaves (H'=0.95), whereas in
Racalmuto species diversity was higher in leaves (H'=0.97) than in twigs (H'=0.88).
Endophytic assemblages in olive-trees showed a similar composition at both sites.
460
100
Incidence (%)
80
60
40
20
0
Spring 2007 Summer 2007 Autumn 2007
Chlorosis Sc
Twigs withering Sc
Spring 2008
Chlorosis Ra
Twigs withering Ra
(a)
Colonization Rate
1
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
0
Spring 2007 Summer 2007 Autumn 2007 Spring 2008
CR leaves Sc
CR leaves Ra
CR twigs Sc
CR twigs Ra
(b)
Figure 1. a) Seasonal incidences of foliar chlorosis and withering twigs in San Cipirello (Sc)
and Racalmuto (Ra); b) colonization rates of endophytes in different tissues of O. europaea
collected in different seasons in San Cipirello (Sc) and Racalmuto (Ra).
All fungal isolates (Table 1) were divided into 56 morphological groups, 33 of which
were identified at genus level, whereas 19 were unidentified due to sterility and the remaining
4 (2 Ascomycetes and 2 Coelomycetes) due to contamination or death of cultures.
Considering both the incidence and the IF% of each endophyte, the most common genera
were Alternaria, Cladosporium, Phoma, and Septoria followed by Camarosporium spp.,
Stemphylium and its teleomorph Pleospora. Fungal genera commonly associated with foliar
symptoms were Alternaria, Cladosporium and Phoma, followed by Septoria, Diplodia and
Camaropsorium. Endophytic bacteria were detected mainly from twigs. Two genera were
identified so far: Bacillus spp. and Pseudomonas spp.
Even if the IF of the detected endophytes varied with organ (organ specificity or
preference), season and sampling site, our results show a certain degree of recurrence of some
genera in tissues of the host species. This could suggest a characteristic endophytic
community of O. europaea with a relatively constant composition regarding the prevalent
genera. Moreover, leaves seemed to harbour a more diverse fungal assemblage. Further
studies will be carried out in order to complete fungal and bacterial identification at the
species level and to investigate the interaction between endophytic microorganisms, host and
environment.
461
Tab. 1. Isolation frequencies (%) of endophytes detected in twigs (T) and leaves (L) of O. europaea in San Cipirello (Sc) and Racalmuto (Ra).
Spring 2007
Endophytes
Acremonium spp.
Alternaria spp.
Ascochyta spp.
Aspergillus variecolor
Aureobasidium pullulans
Botrytis cinerea
Botryosphaeria spp.
Camarosporium spp.
Candida spp.
Cephalosporium spp.
Chaetomium sp.
Cladosporium spp.
Coniothyrium spp.
Cylindrocephalum spp.
Dichomera sp.
Diplodia spp.
Emericella variecolor
Epicoccum spp.
Fumago spp.
Gloeosporium spp.
Penicillium spp.
Pestalotia spp.
Phlyctaena spp.
Phoma spp.
Phomopsis spp.
Pleospora spp.
Preussia sp.
Rhizoctonia spp.
Rhynchophoma spp.
Septoria spp.
Sooty moulds
Sporotrichum spp.
Stemphylium spp.
Sterile mycelia
Bacillus spp.
Pseudomonas spp.
Unidentified bacteria
Sc
Summer 2007
Ra
Sc
Autumn 2007
Ra
Sc
Spring 2008
Ra
Sc
Ra
T
1.5
1.5
6.1
9.2
6.1
26.1
-
L
54.1
3.5
3.5
1.2
25.9
1.2
3.5
-
T
3.5
1.5
2.5
6.0
0.5
1.5
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.5
2.0
0.5
-
L
56.8
2.4
4.0
12.0
1.6
0.8
1.6
0.8
1.6
-
T
1.7
2.3
0.6
0.3
0.6
0.3
6.7
4.1
1.5
L
32.6
0.6
0.2
3.4
2.3
0.5
0.8
0.2
4.4
1.6
0.2
0.3
1.0
0.2
0.2
1.0
19.2
T
0.6
5.0
1.9
1.2
L
1.6
0.5
0.5
0.5
1.6
1.1
65.9
T
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.7
L
50.5
0.3
0.3
13.7
0.9
0.6
0.9
0.3
0.3
0.3
14.6
T
2.2
11.5
2.2
3.7
7.5
1.5
0.7
3.0
4.5
0.7
4.5
2.2
L
15.1
0.8
4.2
5.9
7.1
1.3
5.5
2.5
0.4
0.8
1.7
2.5
24.4
T
3.2
1.3
0.6
0.6
11.0
L
14.6
3.2
0.5
0.2
57.3
T
1.1
0.7
0.4
0.7
L
1.5
2.2
0.4
1.5
0.7
2.6
0.4
5.2
1.1
37.2
-
-
7.5
2.5
8.5
3.2
-
1.8
0.6
-
31.8
-
22.5
1.7
14.3
-
10.5
0.7
462
References
Goidanich, G. 1994: Manuale di patologia vegetale. Vol.II, Edagricole.
Rakotoniriana, E.F., Munaut, F., Decock, C., Randriamampionona, D., Andriambololoniaina,
M., Rakotomalala, T., Rakotonirina, E.J., Rabemanantsoa, C., Cheuk, K., Ratsimamanga,
S.U., Mahillon, J., El-Jaziri, M., Quetin-Leclercq, J. & Corbisier, A.M. 2008: Endophytic
fungi from leaves of Centella asiatica: occurrence and potential interactions within leaves.
Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 93: 27-36.
Schulz, B., Guske, S., Damman, U. & Boyle, C.1998: Endophyte-host interactions. II
Defining symbiosis of the endophyte-host interaction. Symbiosis 25: 213-227.
Schulz, B., Römmert, A.K., Aust, H.-J. & Strack., D. 1999: The endophyte-host interaction: a
balanced antagonism? Mycol. Res.103: 1275-1283.
Schulz, B. & Boyle, C. 2005: The endophytic continuum. Mycol. Res. 109: 661-686.
Scortichini M. 1995: Malattie batteriche delle colture agrarie. Ed agricole.
Wang, B., Priest, M.J., Davidson, A., Brubaker, C.L., Woods, M.J. & Burdon, I.J. 2007:
Fungal endophytes of native Gossypium species in Australia. Mycol. Res. 111: 347-354.
Watanabe, T. 2002: Pictorial atlas of soil and seed fungi. Morphologies of cultured fungi and
key to species. CRC Press.
463
Population variability of strawberry powdery mildew (Podosphaera
aphanis) in different geographical regions
Nick Harvey, Angela Berrie, Xiangming Xu
Plant Pathology, East Malling Research, New Road, East Malling, Kent, ME19 6BJ, UK
Abstract: Strawberry powdery mildew, caused by Podosphaera aphanis, is one of the most important
diseases worldwide. Mildew lesions were sampled from a number of cultivars at several sites in the
UK; a limited number of lesions was also sampled from China, the USA, Italy and Israel. SSR markers
were developed and used to genotype sampled isolates for determining population variability; the ITS
region of 20 samples selected from different countries was sequenced. Both SSR and ITS data
indicated that there were significant differences between samples from the USA and the other
countries. In the UK, there was significant population differentiation between mildew samples from
different cultivars at the same sites, or between mildew samples from the same cultivar at different sites.
Keywords: rDNA ITS, SSR, population differentiation, strawberry, powdery mildew
Introduction
Powdery mildew, caused by Podosphaera aphanis Braun & Takamatu (= Sphaerotheca
macularis (Wallr.:Fr.) Lind = S. humuli (DC.) Burrill), can infect leaves, leaf petioles, flower
trusses, flowers and fruit, and is a serious disease of strawberries (Fragaria x ananassa)
(Miller et al. 2003; Blanco et al. 2004; Amsalem et al. 2006). Increasingly, both June-bearing
and everbearing strawberries are being grown under protection, which has led to more severe
epidemics than under open field conditions (Xiao et al. 2001). Lack of cultivars with durable
resistance necessitates routine applications of fungicides. Breeding for durable resistance to
mildew is hampered by observations that resistance is not consistent over time or vary greatly
with environmental conditions (Mcnicol and Gooding 1979; Nelson et al. 1995).
Population variability of powdery mildews in general has been little studied due to the fact
that there is insufficient fungal genomic DNA of suitable quality for molecular analysis
because of its obligate biotrophic nature. Molecular markers can be used to quantify fungal
population variation in relation to host and geographical location for studies of fungal
population genetics, ecology and evolution (Xu 2006; Bonin et al. 2007; Dutech et al. 2007).
Such information can then be used to infer the underlying evolutionary forces acting on the
population and, hence, to estimate the likely spread of new traits, such as virulence or
fungicide insensitivity, into the population. For example, molecular techniques were used to
investigate sources of overwintering inoculum (Miazzi et al. 2003; Cortesi et al. 2005; Núñez
et al. 2006) and mating types (Peros et al. 2005) in grape powdery mildew, and race structure
in apple mildew (Urbanietz and Dunemann 2005).
Currently, there is limited knowledge on population variability of strawberry powdery
mildew. In one study, differences in the sensitivity to control agents and in the ITS sequences
between a small number of mildew samples from Italy and Israel were assessed (Pertot et al.
2007). The two sampled populations responded similarly to those tested control agents and
were nearly identical (99-100% similar) based on sequence analyses of a 359 bp fragment of
the ITS 1 and 2 region and 6 random fragments totalling 2800 bps. Another study suggested
that there were no indications of significant isolate × cultivar (race-specific) interactions but
isolates appeared to differ considerably in their virulence (Xu et al.).
464
This paper reports a study aiming to determine population variability of P. aphanis in
relation to host cultivars and geographical regions in the UK. In addition to samples from the
UK, a number of mildew samples were also obtained from China, the USA, Israel, and Italy.
Several SSR markers were developed; but only two were successfully used to genotype filed
samples. Based on the SSR results, a number of mildew samples were selected from different
regions for ribosomal DNA ITS sequencing for further comparison.
Materials and Methods
Sampling mildew isolates:
It was not possible to sample mildews based on a hierarchical design, i.e. from many cultivars
at many sites, because (1) very few common cultivars were grown at different sites and (2)
powdery mildew may not have developed on those varieties of interest at all sites. Instead, the
following sampling plan was used to sample leaves with mildew lesions in the UK from June
to August 2006: samples were obtained form (1) cv. Elsanta (the most popular June-bearer) at
six sites, and (2) several cultivars at two sites (Table 1). Many samples were also obtained
from a single site in California, USA, and Qingdao, China in May-June 2007. In addition, a
few samples were also obtained from Italy (Trentino) and Israel (Volcani Centre).
In order to remove plant DNA whilst increase mildew DNA, a leaf disc (diameter of 0.5
cm) with a single lesion was cut in the field and placed immediately into a centrifuge vial
containing 2 ml of 95% ethanol. The vials were then shaken manually for 10-20 seconds and
kept under ambient conditions for 24 h before the disc was removed and the vial was left open
for ethanol to evaporate. For Italian and Israeli samples, leaves with lesions were taken, dried
under ambient conditions and shipped. Discs with a lesion were then cut out from these dried
leaf samples and treated with ethanol as described.
DNA extraction
600μl cell lysis solution (5mM TRIS, 10mM EDTA, 0.5% SDS) and 5 μl of 20 mg/ml
proteinase K was added to each dried sample vial. Tubes were incubated overnight at 55ºC
and vortexed vigorously for 1 min. After samples were cooled to room temperature, 200 μl of
ice-cold protein precipitation solution (3 M ammonium acetate) was added and tubes
centrifuged at 13000 rpm for 10 min. The supernatant was decanted and mixed with 600 μl
isopropanol, and precipitate centrifuged at 13000 rpm for 10 min. The pellet was washed in
70% ethanol and again centrifuged at 13000 rpm for 10 min. The pellet was air-dried and resuspended in 50μl water.
SSR isolation and sample genotyping
Development of microsatellites followed an enrichment protocol previously developed for
fungi (Harvey 2006), which produces a 30-40% enriched library. The enrichment led to
development of six SSR primer pairs that produced unambiguous polymorphic markers in
initial mildew screens. PCR annealing temperature is 60°C for all six primer pairs. However,
only two pairs (coded SM4 [(GT)9] and SM10 [(AC)18]) produced consistent band patterns
for field samples whilst others produced many null alleles. Each forward PCR primer was
tagged with a different fluorescent dye: SM4F [6FAM-CTAGCTTTGCAACACTCGAGGT]
(SM4R
[TGTAGGTATTGGGAAAAGTCGG]),
and
SM10F
[6FAMCCTGGCTAACAACAGACGATAA]
(SM10R
[TTCACATGTAGACCATCCTTGC]).
Fluorescently labelled products were analysed on a semi-automated ABI 3100 sequencer.
Data were collected and allele sizes determined using GENESCAN and GENOTYPER
software (Applied Biosystems).
465
ITS sequencing
The ITS regions of 20 mildew samples, selected from different regions, were sequenced. The
universal primers Ek18F (AGAGGAAGTAAAAGTCGTAACAAG) and Ek28R
(ATATGCTTAAGTTCAGCGGG) were used to PCR across the entire ITS1 and ITS2 regions
from at least 3 distant samples from each country. Bands were cut from gels, cloned and
sequenced, and the sequences matched to the GenBank database using the BLASTN program
(http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/blast).
Data analysis
A total of 484 samples were screened for SM4 and SM10. In many cases, two alleles were
recorded at the same locus on a single leaf disc sample; this was assumed to have resulted
from two fungal genotypes that colonised the same disc. In a few cases, two alleles were
recorded at two SSR loci; only two fungal genotypes were assumed to be present, randomly
selected from possible four genotypes. Any alleles with an overall frequency less than 1%
were excluded.
A single population was defined as samples from a single combination of site and cultivar.
Analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) was used to test whether were significant
differences in fungal populations among the UK, China and the USA, among the six sites in
the UK (cv. Elsanta), and among cultivars at the same site. The significance of population
differentiation was based on 10,100 permutations. Pairwise comparisons of populations
(based on GST) were assessed on the basis of 1023 permutations. Arlequin version 3.1
(Excoffier and Schneider 2005) was used to carry out these analyses. Relationships among
fungal populations were further examined with cluster analysis using UPGMA (Sneath and
Sokal 1973) with MEGA software (Tamura et al. 2007). Nei’s DA index (Nei et al. 1983) was
mj
⎞
1 r ⎛⎜
used as a genetic distance measure for cluster analysis: D A = ∑ ⎜1 − ∑ xij y ij ⎟⎟ , where xij
r j =1 ⎝
i =1
⎠
and yij are the frequency of the ith allele at the jth locus in the two populations respectively,
and r and mj is the total number of loci and number of alleles at the jth locus, respectively. DA
is less affected by the diversity within populations than GST is.
All ITS sequences from the selected mildew samples were compared with those of
Sphaerotheca or Podosphaera in GenBank before being included in further analysis.
Relationships among the sequences were analysed using MEGA4 (Tamura et al. 2007) based
on aligned 479 bp. Four sequences from GenBank were included in the analysis: DQ139429
(P. pannosa isolate from host Prunus laurocerasus), DQ139433 (P. pannosa isolate from host
Rosa sp.), AB026136 (P. aphanis from host F. grandiflora in Japan- (Takamatsu et al. 2000))
and AF073355 (P. aphanis from host F. x ananassa (= F. grandiflora) in Victoria, Australia (Cunnington et al. 2003)). Both parsimony and neighbour joining analyses were performed
with inserts and deletions included.
Results
General summary of SSR data
Of 484 mildew samples screened, 390 produced reliable band patterns for SM4 and SM10.
There were 44 and 39 samples where two different alleles were present in the same sample for
SM4 and SM10, respectively. Of these 83 samples, 13 had two different alleles for both SM4
and SM10: 12 were from cv. Elsanta at three sites in the UK. For SM4, there were four
different alleles, representing 13, 20, 21 and 23 repeats. For SM10, there were six different
alleles, representing 9, 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16 repeats; the first two alleles only occurred in a
few samples and hence were excluded from further statistical analysis.
Table 1 gives the summary of allele frequencies for 15 populations. For SM4, the
466
predominant allele is B (20 repeats), with an overall frequency of 77%. This was true across
all populations except the samples from California and cv. Yixiang of China. This is the only
allele detected in four populations (Table 1): two from China and two from the UK. Allele A
(14 repeats) was found mostly in the samples from California; alleles C (21 repeats) and D
(22 repeats) were found mostly in samples from cv. Elsanta at Ullingswick in the UK and cv.
Yixiang of China, respectively (Table 1). For SM10, the predominant allele is B (14 repeats)
across all populations, with an overall frequency of 84%. In five populations, only allele B
was detected (Table 1). In three populations, only a single allele was detected at both SM4
and SM10: cvs. Fenxiang and Qinxiang (China), and on plants of trial 1159 at Wisbech (UK).
All six Italian samples had the same genotype for SM4 and SM10 (BB) as did those 23 Israeli
samples (BD).
Table 1 Summary of origins of strawberry powdery mildew (P. aphanis) samples and allele
frequencies of the two microsatellite loci
Location
SM4
SM10
No
Region
Cultivar
Longitud
samples A B C D A B C D
Latitude
e
USA
Chandle
17
0.94 0.06 0.00 0.00 0.18 0.76 0.06 0.00
California
r
China
Fenxian
23
0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00
Qingdao
g
Qinxian
21
0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00
Qingdao
g
Qingdao Yixiang
39
0.00 0.49 0.00 0.51 0.00 0.95 0.00 0.05
UK
51:17:06
0:16:28E
37
0.27 0.73 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.86 0.11 0.03
Ightham Elsanta
N
51:17:06
0:16:28E
29
0.07 0.93 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00
Ightham
Opal
N
51:17:06
0:16:28E
32
0.00 0.94 0.00 0.06 0.00 0.94 0.06 0.00
Ightham
Pearl
N
52:28:37 0:21:47
Peterboro
32
0.06 0.94 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.94 0.06 0.00
Elsanta
N
W
ugh
51:48:50
0:16:07E
35
0.03 0.97 0.00 0.00 0.09 0.86 0.06 0.00
Takely Elsanta
N
52:08:37 2:35:37
Ullingswi
46
0.00 0.80 0.20 0.00 0.00 0.80 0.20 0.00
Elsanta
N
W
ck
51:15:08
West
0:21:14E
32
0.09 0.91 0.00 0.00 0.16 0.66 0.19 0.00
Elsanta
N
Peckham
52:37:15
0:09:58E
40
0.20 0.75 0.05 0.00 0.05 0.75 0.18 0.03
Wisbech Elsanta
N
52:37:15
Wisbech T1159a
0:09:58E
12
0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00
N
52:37:15
Wisbech T1276a
0:09:58E
26
0.94 0.06 0.00 0.00 0.18 0.76 0.06 0.00
N
52:37:15
Wisbech T931a
0:09:58E
31
0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 0.00
N
a
: Breeding lines not commercially released yet.
467
AMOVA
AMOVA indicated significant (P < 0.001) differences among samples from China, the UK
and the USA (P < 0.001), accounting for 23.8% of the total variation. Separate AMOVA for
Chinese samples showed that samples from cvs. Fenxiang and Qinxiang differed (P < 0.001)
from samples from cv. Yixiang. Similarly, samples from three cultivars at Ightham or four
cultivars at Wisbech in the UK differed significantly (P < 0.001), both accounting for about
8.3% of the total variation. However, there were no significant differences between samples
from Ightham and Wisbech. Mildew samples from cv. Elsanta differed significantly (P <
0.001) among the six sites in the UK, accounting for 5.0% of the total variation. Samples from
China (cv. Yixiang) and the USA differed significantly from all other populations based on
pairwise comparison of GST. The dendrogram based on DA is shown in Fig. 1. California
isolates appeared to be most distant from all other isolates whilst isolates from the UK and
China are well mixed together.
Figure 1. A dendrogram derived from a cluster analysis of molecular data of two SSR loci
depicting the observed differences between 15 populations of P. aphanis using the UPGMA
method (Sneath and Sokal 1973). The optimal tree with the sum of branch length = 0.655 is
shown, with branch lengths (next to the branches) in the same units as those of the
evolutionary distances used to infer the phylogenetic tree. Phylogenetic analyses were
conducted in MEGA4 (Tamura et al. 2007) using the Nei DA genetic distance (Nei et al.
1983).
ITS analysis
Since SSR results suggested significant genetic differences among isolates from the USA,
China and the UK, 20 samples were selected for sequencing of the rDNA ITS region to
confirm these differences. All the samples produced a sequence of either 588 bp or 589 bp,
which closely matched Sphaerotheca or Podosphaera in GenBank. The topology produced is
the same for both distance and parsimony-based analyses using the neighbour joining
468
algorithm (Fig. 2). Outgroup sequences comprised two GenBank sequences - DQ139429 and
DQ139433 (both P. pannosa). Two GenBank sequences (AB026136 and AF073355 – both P.
aphanis from Japan and Australia, respectively) formed an ingroup with the new sequences,
relative to the outgroup sequences.
All strawberry samples formed a single well-supported group, with the exception of the
three Californian samples and AF073355 (Fig. 2). These differences represent two transitions
and a single base insertion or deletion. Among the main strawberry group, one sequence (the
same as AB026136) existed in 12 samples, including samples from the UK, China, Israel and
Italy. Five other sequences also existed in this group, each consisting of two unique
substitutions, with the China P2 sample also having a unique single base deletion. California
P5 has 2 unique substitutions.
UK Kent
Italy
Israel
China
93
27
19
Italy
AB026136 (P. aphanis from strawberry, Japan)
China
Italy
UK
China
UK Cambridgeshire
Israel
Israel
UK Herefordshire
Israel
UK Kent
UK
UK Cambridgeshire
California P6
California P6
California
AF073355 (P. aphanis from strawberry,
21
95
DQ139429 (P. pannosa)
DQ139433 (P.
)
0.001
Figure 2. A bootstrapped neighbour joining tree produced from 479 bp of the ITS1 and ITS2
sequences from strawberry mildew (P. aphanis). Sample names specify the location from
which the sample was isolated.
469
Discussion
Both SSR and ITS sequencing data suggested that there were significant differences in samples
from different countries, particularly those from the USA compared with those from Eurasia (the
UK, Italy, China and Israel). Nevertheless, there were one or more UK populations that were
not significantly different from the California population in pairwise comparisons. However, the
present finding has to be treated with caution because (1) only two SSR markers were used and
(2) only a limited number of samples were from China, the USA, Israel and Italy. Based on a
limited number of samples, Italian and Israeli samples of strawberry powdery mildew were
shown to be nearly identical (Pertot et al. 2007).
There is some evidence for fungal adaptation to host cultivars. In the UK, at both sites there
were significant differences in the mildew samples from different cultivars. Similarly, the
Chinese populations from two cultivars at the same field were identical in the two loci but
differed from the third population on a different cultivar at the same site. Mildew samples from
the two UK sites also did not differ significantly, indicating that adaptation to host cultivars takes
place at the two sites but has not led to appreciable population differentiation yet between them.
However, a recent study indicates the lack of strong race-specific interactions between
strawberry cultivars and powdery mildew (Xu et al. 2008). Therefore, such adaptation to host
cultivars may have not lasted long enough to result in any significant consequences on fungal
pathogenicity. Alternatively, the lack of race-specific interactions could also have resulted from
regular introduction of new cultivars, leading to short co-adaptation time. Research with more
samples and/or more molecular markers is needed to further our understanding on this. There is
also some evidence of genetic differentiation among different regions based on the mildew
samples from cv. Elsanta in the UK. This could result from genetic drift and/or founder effect.
ITS sequences have been used consistently as an accurate tool for differentiating between
populations and species of certain fungi in situations where classical morphology cannot be
utilized. For the well-defined powdery mildew taxa identified using morphology or host
range, the differences in rDNA ITS sequences are always identical or within 99% similar
within each taxa (Saenz and Taylor 1999; Hirose et al. 2005; Cook et al. 2006; Kiss et al.
2006; Inuma et al. 2007). In the present study, there was more than 99% similarity in the ITS
sequence among P. aphanis samples with one common sequence occurring in 12 of 20
samples, suggesting there were from a same taxa. Similarly, in a study with a limited number
of samples, several P. aphanis samples from Israel and Italy were shown to have an identical
ITS sequence whereas other pairs showed 99% sequence similarity (Pertot et al. 2007). As in
the present study, they found the identical ITS sequences between their strawberry samples
and those from strawberry in Japan - AB026136 (Takamatsu et al. 2000). However, it was also
recently suggested that morphologically indistinguishable powdery mildews that differ in one
to five single nucleotide positions in their ITS region can be considered as different taxa with
distinct host ranges (Jankovics et al. 2008). Based on this judgement, mildew from China and
the USA could be considered as a separate species. Further studies are necessary to resolve
this taxonomy issue, particularly by cross-inoculation studies.
Acknowledgements
This work was funded by the UK Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra)
– Project Number: HH3228SSF. We thank Dr Baohua Li and Dr Hai Su for sampling mildew
samples in China and California, USA, respectively.
470
References
Amsalem L., Freeman S., Rav-David D., Nitzani Y., Sztejnberg A., Pertot I. & Elad Y. 2006:
Effect of climatic factors on powdery mildew caused by Sphaerotheca macularis f. sp
fragariae on strawberry. European Journal of Plant Pathology 114: 283-292
Blanco C., de los Santos B., Barrau C., Arroyo F.T., Porras M. & Romero F. 2004:
Relationship among concentrations of Sphaerotheca macularis conidia in the air,
environmental conditions, and the incidence of powdery mildew in strawberry. Plant
Disease 88: 878-881
Bonin A., Ehrich D. & Manel S. 2007: Statistical analysis of amplified fragment length
polymorphism data: a toolbox for molecular ecologists and evolutionists. Molecular
Ecology 16: 3737-3758
Cook R.T.A., Henricot B., Henrici A. & Beales P. 2006: Morphological and phylogenetic
comparisons amongst powdery mildews on Catalpa in the UK. Mycological Research
110: 672-685.
Cortesi P., Mazzoleni A., Pizzatti C. & Milgroom M.G. 2005: Genetic similarity of flag shoot
and ascospore subpopulations of Erysiphe necator in Italy. Applied and Environmental
Microbiology 71: 7788-7791
Cunnington J.H., Takamatsu S., Lawrie A.C. & Pascoe I.G. 2003: Molecular identification of
anamorphic powdery mildews (Erysiphales). Australasian Plant Pathology 32: 421-428
Dutech C., Enjalbert J., Fournier E., Delmotte F., Barres B., Carlier J., Tharreau D. & Giraud
T. 2007: Challenges of microsatellite isolation in fungi. Fungal Genetics and Biology 44:
933-949
Excoffier L. & Schneider S. 2005: Arlequin ver. 3.0: An integrated software package for
population genetics data analysis. Evolutionary Bioinformatics Online 1: 47-50
Harvey N. 2006: Characterization of six polymorphic microsatellite loci from Ampelomyces
quisqualis, intracellular mycoparasite and biocontrol agent of powdery mildew.
Molecular Ecology Notes 6: 1188-1190
Hirose S., Tanda S., Kiss L., Grigaliunaite B., Havrylenko M. & Takamatsu S. 2005:
Molecular phylogeny and evolution of the maple powdery mildew (Sawadaea,
Erysiphaceae) inferred from nuclear rDNA sequences. Mycological Research 109: 912922.
Inuma T., Khodaparast S.A. & Takamatsu S. 2007: Multilocus phylogenetic analyses within
Blumeria graminis, a powdery mildew fungus of cereals. Molecular Phylogenetics and
Evolution 44: 741-751
Jankovics T., Bai Y., Kovács G.M., Bardin M., Nicot P.C., Toyoda H., Matsuda Y., Niks R. &
Kiss L. 2008: Oidium neolycopersici: intraspecific variability inferred from amplified
fragment length polymorphism analysis and relationship with closely related powdery
mildew fungi infecting various plant species. Phytopathology 98: 529-540
Kiss L., Khosla K., Jankovics T., Niinomi S., Braun U. & Takamatsu S. 2006: A
morphologically ill-founded powdery mildew species, Pleochaeta indica, is recognized
as a phylogenetic species based on the analysis of the nuclear ribosomal DNA sequences.
Mycological Research 110: 1301-1308
McNicol R. & Gooding H. 1979: Assessment of strawberry clones and seedlings for
resistance to Sphaerotheca macularis (Wall ex Frier). Horticultural Research 19: 35-41
Miazzi M., Hajjeh H. & Faretra F. 2003: Observations on the population biology of the grape
powdery mildew fungus Uncinula necator. Journal of Plant Pathology 85: 123-129
Miller T.C., Gubler W.D., Geng S. & Rizzo D.M. 2003: Effects of temperature and water
vapor pressure on conidial germination and lesion expansion of Sphaerotheca macularis
f. sp fragariae. Plant Disease 87: 484-492
Nei M., Tajima F. & Tateno Y. 1983: Accuracy of estimated phylogenetic trees from
471
molecular data. Journal of Molecular Evolution 19: 153-170
Nelson M.D., Gubler W.D. & Shaw D.V. 1995: Inheritance of powdery mildew resistance in
greenhouse-grown versus field-grown California strawberry progenies. Phytopathology
85: 421-424
Núñez Y., Gallego J., Ponz F. & Raposo R. 2006: Analysis of population structure of Erysiphe
necator using AFLP markers. Plant Pathology 55: 650-656
Peros J.P., Troulet C., Guerriero M., Michel-Romiti C. & Notteghem J.L. 2005: Genetic
variation and population structure of the grape powdery mildew fungus, Erysiphe
necator, in southern France. European Journal of Plant Pathology 113: 407-416
Pertot I., Fiamingo F., Amsalem L., Maymon M., Freeman S., Gobbin D. & Elad Y. 2007:
Sensitivity of two Podosphaera aphanis populations to disease control agents. Journal of
Plant Pathology 89: 81-92
Saenz G.S. & Taylor J.W. 1999: Phylogeny of the Erysiphales (powdery mildews) inferred
from internal transcribed spacer ribosomal DNA sequences. Canadian Journal of Botany
77: 150-168
Sneath P. & Sokal R. (1973) Numerical Taxonomy. Freeman, San Francisco
Takamatsu S., Hirata T. & Sato Y. 2000: A parasitic transition from trees to herbs occurred at
least twice in tribe Cystotheceae (Erysiphaceae): evidence from nuclear ribosomal DNA.
Mycological Research 104: 1304-1311
Tamura K., Dudley J., Nei M. & Kumar S. 2007: MEGA4: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics
Analysis (MEGA) software version 4.0. Molecular Biology and Evolution 24 1596-1599
Urbanietz A. & Dunemann F. 2005: Isolation, identification and molecular characterization of
physiological races of apple powdery mildew (Podosphaera leucotricha). Plant
Pathology 54: 125-133
Xiao C.L., Chandler C.K., Price J.F., Duval J.R., Mertely J.C. & Legard D.E. 2001:
Comparison of epidemics of Botrytis fruit rot and powdery mildew of strawberry in large
plastic tunnel and field production systems. Plant Disease 85: 901-909
Xu J.P. 2006: Fundamentals of fungal molecular population genetic analyses. Current Issues
in Molecular Biology 8: 75-90
Xu X.-M., Robinson J. & Simpson D. 2008: Interactions between isolates of powdery mildew
(Podosphaera aphanis) and cultivars of strawberry, Fragaria x ananassa. IOBC Bulletin
472
Evaluation of fruit genetic resources for disease resistance
David Szalatnay, Kaspar Hunziker, Brion Duffy, Jürg E. Frey, Markus Kellerhals
Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil, P.O. Box,, CH-8820 Wädenswil, Switzerland
.
Abstract: A field survey throughout Switzerland established an inventory of fruit genetic resources.
The decentralised collections network was subsequently completed and the characterization of the
accessions is ongoing. Considering international standards, guidelines for the phenotypic description
of the fruit genetic resources were developed and practically applied. Apple accessions from the Swiss
pool of genetic resources were tested for fire blight (Erwinia amylovora) resistance in the greenhouse.
Results of the fire blight screening confirm significant differences between accessions. Additionally,
the accessions were analysed with SCAR markers surrounding a QTL for fire blight tolerance.
Moreover, young trees of 600 accessions were planted to evaluate their scab (Venturia inaequalis) and
powdery mildew (Podosphaera leucotricha) resistance in a field trial. The project aims at defining
accessions useful for cultivation as standard trees for cider and juice production and that are an
important landscaping and ecological factor. Promising accessions are being used for breeding.
Key words: fruit genetic resources, fire blight, Erwinia amylovora, breeding, apple
Introduction
In close collaboration with NGO’s the Swiss government is supporting and implementing
structures for a sustainable conservation and utilization of plant genetic resources. The
national campaign plant (NCP) is coordinated by the Swiss Commission for the conservation
of plant genetic resources (www.cpc-skek.ch). Kellerhals and Egger (2004) reported about a
field inventory carried out to detect as many still existing Swiss fruit genetic resources as
possible. This inventory allowed subsequently a complete and safe conservation of fruit
genetic resources in Switzerland. 2800 accessions were selected for long term conservation or
further testing.
Here we report on the characterization of the rich fruit genetic resources in order to allow
for their use in fruit-growing and breeding. Around 800 accessions are being described and
scientifically photographed within the project. Further evaluation of selected accessions
includes the testing of 600 apple accessions for their scab and mildew susceptibility in the
field, the testing of 160 apple and pear accessions for their fire blight susceptibility in the
quarantine glasshouse and the molecular characterization of at least 250 apple and 250 cherry
accessions with SSR-markers.
Fire blight is one of the most serious disease and causes great losses in pome fruit
cultivation. It is also a threat for genetic resources collections (Peil et al., 2004). Among the
Malus genetic resources a broad range of resistance levels towards fire blight can be found
(Aldwinckle et al., 1976). Since fire blight first appeared in Switzerland in 1989, it has
steadily spread from the original epicentre in the north-eastern cantons to the south-western
regions (Duffy et al., 2005). In 2007, the so far most significant outbreak took place and
several of the decentralised genebank collections suffered from losses. A wide range of
molecular markers related to different disease resistance genes or QTL’s is nowadays
available for apple scab, mildew and fire blight resistance (Calenge et al., 2005, Khan et al.,
2007). In this study we included molecular markers related to a fire blight resistance QTL.
473
Materials and methods
The screening of heritage varieties for relative fire blight tolerance was conducted in the
quarantine glasshouse of ACW in Wädenswil. Scion material was grafted onto M9 rootstock.
In spring 2007 and 2008, trees were planted in plastic deep-pots 60 from Stuewe & Sons
(Corvallis, US) with a length of 35.5 cm and diameter of 7 cm and then grown in the
glasshouse for several weeks prior to inoculation. For each variety, 6 to 10 replicate trees were
inoculated by puncturing the distal tip of shoots 15-30 cm long with a syringe containing an
E. amylovora solution of 106 cfu/ml. In 2007 strain CFBP1430 (INRA, France) and in 2008
strain FAW 611 (ACW, Switzerland) was used. Disease development was evaluated weekly
for three weeks by measuring the expansion of the necrotic lesion from the shoot tip in
relation to the total shoot length. Artificial fire blight infections were performed in 2007 and
2008 each with 40 different accessions, including heritage varieties still grown for apple juice
and cider production, and with commercial standard varieties. 39 apple accessions tested in
2008 were analysed for the presence or absence of molecular markers flanking a fire blight
resistance QTL which was described by Calenge et al. (2005) and Khan et al. (2007). The
two SCAR markers AE 10-375 and GE-8019 were used to spot accessions that carry both of
these markers and conclusively also the fire blight resistance QTL. Molecular analysis was
performed according to methods described by Frey et al. (2004).
Results
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
Baumanns Rtte. (9)
Aargauer Jägerapfel
(8)
London Pepping (7)
Bramleys Sämling (9)
Gala (8)
Bänziger (9)
Ananas Rtte. (6)
Bühlers
Erdbeerapfel (8)
Leuenapfel (9)
Ontario Rtte. (8)
Melchnauer
Sonntagsapfel (8)
Goldrtte. v. Blenheim
(7)
Osnabrücker Rtte. (7)
Sternapi (9)
Södliapfel (9)
Chüsenrainer (9)
Kanada Rtte. (5)
Oberdiecks Rtte. (9)
Glockenapfel (9)
Holzapfel/ Russiker
(8)
Winterzitrone (8)
Stäfner Rosen (8)
Kaiserapfel (8)
Waldhöfler (8)
Danziger Kantapfel
(9)
Schweizer
Orangenapfel (9)
Niederhelfenschwiler
Beeriapfel (9)
Heimenhofer (9)
Schneiderapfel (9)
0
Ohio Rtte. (9)
length of necrosis / lenght of inoculated shoot (%)
The results of fire blight testing in the glasshouse revealed a wide range of tolerance and
susceptibility among the apple accessions tested in 2007 and 2008 (results with 30 out of
totally 40 accessions tested in 2008 are presented in Fig. 1).
Figure 1: fire blight glasshouse screening of 30 traditional apple cultivars with ‘Gala’ as
standard, year 2008 (Scoring 3 weeks after inoculation, Number of plants in brackets, bars
represent standard deviation).
Some accessions displayed good resistance whereas others displayed no resistance and
were highly susceptible. The apple variety ‘Schneiderapfel’ was highly resistant in our trials.
Unfortunately ‘Schneiderapfel’ is a triploid cultivar and can therefore hardly be used in
breeding as a parent. Other cultivars such as Ohio Reinette and Danziger Kantapfel are being
used in crosses to develop new apple cultivars with high fruit quality and increased fire blight
474
70
60
50
Week 1
40
Week 2
Week 3
30
20
10
all cultivars
2008
all cultivars
2007
Heimenhofer
2008
Heimenhofer
2007
Chüsenrainer
2008
Chüsenrainer
2007
Schneiderapfel
2008
Schneiderapfel
2007
Gala 2008
0
Gala 2007
Length of necrosis / lenght of inoculated shoot (%)
tolerance. Comparison of the fire blight test results with the same accessions performed in
2007 and 2008 revealed a satisfactory reliability of the test, although two different E.
amylovora strains had been used Fig. 2.
Figure. 2: comparison of fire blight glasshouse screening with selected cultivars tested in
2007 and 2008 (Scoring 1, 2 and 3 weeks after inoculation).
Both SCAR markers AE and GE and therefore the resistance QTL was present in 4 out of
39 tested accessions, namely Dettighofer, Bernecker Wildling, Schweizer Orangenapfel and
Sternapi. These accessions had an average necrosis length of 39.8 % of the total shoot length
compared to 44.5 % for the average of the accessions carrying none ore only one of the
flanking SCAR markers.
Discussion
Forsline and Aldwickle (2002) have screened the USDA Apple Collection at Geneva N.Y.
(USA) including apple germplasm from Asia and Europe for natural occurrence of fire blight.
Considerable variability in resistance was observed in seedlings from almost all collections of
all species. For fire blight no major resistance genes were found. However, recently Peil et al.
(2007) reported evidence for a major fire blight resistance gene of Malus robusta. Dondini et
al. (2004) found QTLs linked to fire blight in pear and Calenge et al. (2005) and Khan et al.
(2007) found major additive QTLs for fire blight resistance based on work with two related
apple progenies. While testing selected accessions for markers flanking the Fiesta LG7 QTL
(AE and GE) in our study we detected only a slight difference in susceptibility or resistance,
respectively, between the group of accessions carrying the flanking SCAR markers and the
group not carrying them or only one of them. However, planned work with a larger number of
accessions might show more conclusive results. The information on the differential resistance
and susceptibility of the Swiss apple and pear genetic resources is important for breeding and
for replanting traditional varieties. This will enable informed decision making as to which
varieties to replant and which to avoid due to fire blight susceptibility. Further tests are
needed to confirm these results under natural disease pressure especially related to flower
infection.
475
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge financial support for the project NCP 03-21 by the National Campaign
Plants (NCP), a Swiss Federal Office for Agriculture’s program and for the collaboration with
the NGO Fructus (www.fructus.ch) and all the other project partners. Moreover, we
acknowledge support by Beatrice Frey for the molecular analysis.
References
Aldwinckle, H.S., Way, R.D., Livermore, K.G., Preczewski J.L. & S.V. Beer, 1976: Fire blight
in the Geneva apple collection. Fruit Var. J. 30: 42-55.
Calenge, F, Drouet, D, Denance, C, Van de Weg, W.E., Brisset, M.N., Paulin, J.P. & Durel,
C.E. 2005: Identification of a major QTL together with several minor additive or
epistatic QTLs for resistance to fire blight in apple in two related progenies. Theor. Appl.
Genet. 111: 128-135.
Dondini, L, Pierantoni, L., Gaiotti, F., Chiodini, R., Tartarini, S., Bazzi, C. & Sansavini, S.,
2004: Identifying QTLs for fire-blight resistance via a European pear (Pyrus communis
L.) genetic linkage map. Mol. Breed. 14: 407-418.
Duffy, B., Schärer, H.J., Bünter, M., Klay A.. & Holliger, E., 2005. Regulatory measures
against Erwinia amylovora in Switzerland. EPPO Bulletin 35: 239-244.
Forsline, P.L. & Aldwinckle, H.S. 2002: Natural occurrence of fire blight in USDA apple
germplasm collection after 10 Years of observation. Acta Hort. 590: 351-357.
Frey, J.E., Frey, B., Sauer, C. & Kellerhals, M. 2004: Efficient low-cost DNA extraction and
multiplex fluorescent PCR method for marker-assisted selection in breeding. Plant
Breeding 123: 554-557.
Kellerhals, M. & Egger, S. 2004. Inventory on fruit genetic resources in Switzerland. Acta
Hort. 663: 585-588.
Khan, M.A., Durel, C.E., Duffy, B., Drouet, D., Kellerhals, M., Gessler, C. & Patocchi, A.
2007: Development of molecular markers linked to the 'Fiesta' linkage group 7 major
QTL for fire blight resistance and their application for marker-assisted selection.
Genome, 50: 568-577.
Peil, A., Richter, K., Höfer, M., & Hanke, V. 2004: Beschreibung des Feuerbrandbefalls im
Versuchsfeld des Institutes für Obstzüchtung der BAZ im Jahr 2003. Erwerbsobstbau 46
(6): 141-148.
Peil, A., Garcia-Libreros, T., Richter, K., Trognitz, F.C., Trognitz, B., Hanke, M.V. &
Flachowsky H. 2007: Strong evidence for a fire blight resistance gene of Malus robusta
located on linkage group 3. Plant Breeding 126: 470-475.
476
Activity of Physpe (laminarin) in control of strawberry diseases
Beata Meszka1, Anna Bielenin1
1
Research Institute of Pomology and Floriculture, Skierniewice, Poland bmeszka@insad.pl
Abstract: Strawberry plants are susceptible to many pathogens, such as Botrytis cinerea,
Mycosphaerella fragariae and Sphaerotheca macularis. Phytochemicals are intensively used to limit
pathogen infections on strawberry plantations in Poland. Resistance problems, residues in fruits and
protection of the environment require alternative strategies. In the present study the efficacy of Physpe
(laminarin) in control of main strawberry diseases in field conditions was tested. Experiments were
conducted in 2006 and 2008. Laminarin reduced B. cinerea infection by approximately 50 to 80 %,
depending on the experimental site. Its effectiveness in reduction of leaf spot symptoms was about
50% and almost 80% in reduction of powdery mildew. The use of Physpe in program with fungicides
sprays could be acceptable for commercial use and gives possibilities to reduce the number of
chemical treatments against main strawberry diseases.
Keywords: strawberry, grey mould, leaf spot, powdery mildew, control strategy, laminarin
Introduction. Grey mould (Botrytis cinerea), leaf spot (Mycosphaerella fragariae) and
powdery mildew (Sphaetotheca macularis) are the most important strawberry diseases in
Poland. Severity of these diseases depends on susceptibility of strawberry cultivars (Muller,
1965), weather conditions (Jarvis, 1964) and level of inoculum. Some strawberry cultivars
commonly planted in Poland, like Senga Sengana, Kent, Malling Pandora, Kama are seriously
affected by M. fragariae and others, Elsanta, Marmolada, Honeoye and Camarosa, by S.
macularis (Meszka and Bielenin, 2007, Łabanowska et al., 2004). The most susceptible
cultivars to grey mould are Senga Sengana, Marmolada and Pegasus cultivars. Control of
strawberry diseases has still been based mainly on chemicals, but resistance problems,
residues in fruits and protection of the environment require alternative strategies (Aziz et al.,
2003). They involve biological agents as antagonists of pathogens or activation of plant
defense mechanism using elicitors, such as laminarin (Physpe). Laminarin (linear β- 1,3
glucan) is a product extracted and purified from the brown alga Laminaria digitata (Aziz et
al., 2003). Application of this compound causes a stimulation of the natural resistance of
plants against diseases.
The aim of this research was to evaluate Physpe (laminarin) efficacy for control of
main strawberry diseases in field conditions.
Materials and methods
Physpe was tested on commercial strawberry plantations in 2006 and 2008. The experiment
was conducted on Kent and Senga Sengana cultivars for grey mould and leaf spot control and
Marmolada for powdery mildew control. Depending on disease, different standard fungicides
were used: piraclostrobin+boscalid (Signum 33 WG) and folpet (Folpan 80 WG) against grey
mould, tetraconazol (Domark 100 EC), tiophanat methyl (Topsin M 500 SC) and
trifloxystrobin (Zato 50 WG) against powdery mildew and leaf spot. Tested product - Physpe
and standards, Domark 100 EC and Folpan 80 WG, were applied in two programmes: I - 3treatments during blossom and II - 6 treatments (3 during blossom and 3 before harvest).
Other standard fungicides were used only during blossom. Applications were made at 5-7
477
days intervals, using a motor knapsack sprayer at 600 l/ha. The biological effectiveness of
control of strawberry leaf spot and powdery mildew was evaluated based on the number of
affected leaves (100 leaves in each of four replications) and intensity of disease symptoms,
using 6-degree scale, for leaf spot evaluation: 0- healthy leaf, 1- (up to 1% of leaf surface with
spots), 2- (1-5%), 3- (5-20%), 4- (20-50%) and 5- (above 50%) and for powdery mildew: 0healthy leaf, 1- (up to 10% of leaf surface with spots), 2- (10-20%), 3- (20-50%), 4- (50-80%)
and 5- (above 80%). Grey mould infestation was evaluated during harvest, based on the
number of affected fruits, both in field and after 5 days of storage at 4.5°C. One hundred fruits
from each from four replicates, were randomly sampled from each plots, twice during the
harvest. The total yield was calculated for each plot.
Results and discussion
In 2006, Physpe used at two doses, 1.0 and 2.0 l/ha, gave good control of all tested diseases.
The intensity of grey mould on the non-protected strawberry plants of Kent cv. was medium
and total number of infected fruits, in the field and after storage in 4,5°C, was 21.5%. The
effectiveness of laminarin in control of grey mould was 80% and 89%, respectively, for the
two doses (Figure 1a). In 2008 the grey mould on the control strawberry plants of Senga
Sengana cv. was observed on 11-44% of fruits, depending on the location (Figure 1b). The
effectiveness of Physpe used at 1.0 l/ha in control of grey mould was from 60-90% after 3
treatments and from 83-97% after 6 treatments, depending on the plantation (Figure 1b).
Additional 3 applications of Physpe before harvest increased effectiveness only, when the
severity of grey mould was high. Yield obtained from plots treated with Physpe was about 1535% higher than from control plots and the same as from plots treated with standard
fungicides. Effectiveness of Physpe in control of grey mould was similar as all standard
fungicides on plantation I were lower than standards on plantation II and the same as Folpan
80 WG but lower than Signum 33 WG on plantation III (Figure 1b). Aziz et al. (2003) noted
that laminarin reduced the development of B. cinerea on grapevine by approximately 50 and
75%, depending on the dose used. Laminarin has also protected tobacco from soft rot disease,
Erwinia carotovora (Klarzyński et al., 2000).
In our study Physpe gave good control of strawberry diseases. In 2006 it effectively
reduced leaf spot (59%) and powdery mildew (69%), when intensity of both diseases was
high. On control plants 58% of leaves were affected by M. fragariae and 54% by S. macularis
(Table 1).
In 2008, the severity of powdery mildew was lower. On untreated plants symptoms
were observed on 36% of leaves (Table 1). Tested product showed good efficacy in control of
disease on cv. Marmolada, ~80% after 3 treatments and 81% and 89% (depending on
location) after 6 treatments. Laminarin, as showed by Aziz et al.(2003), also reduced the
severity of downy mildew of grapevine (P. viticola). They noted that compound used at 0.51.0 g/l reduced the percentage of affected leaf surface from 28% on control plants to 7% on
laminarin treated plants.
In 2008 the intensity of leaf spot on the non-protected strawberry plants of Senga
Sengana cv. was medium to high, 47% and 74% of affected leaves, respectively for I and II
location. Physpe treatments reduced leaf spot severity by 50% (Table 1). The results of
several studies indicated that laminarin could be effective against a wide spectrum of plant
pathogens.
478
Figure 1. Efficacy of Physpe in control of grey mould on strawberry of Senga Sengana cv.
a)
2006 season
b
Per cent of affected fruits
25
21
20
a15 a
a
10
4,4
5
2,4
1,8
0
2006
Control
b)
Physpe 1.0 l/ha
Physpe 2.0 l/ha
piraclostrobin+boscalid
2008 season
II
Per cent of affected fruits
I
b a
50
40
a
30
20
10
0
III location
c b
a
a
a
44,3
a
c b b
a
a b ab
20,2
17,5
11
7,7
1,1 0,3 0,2 0,6 0,3
2,7 3,9 1,4
5,2 3,4
2,5
0,06 1,5
2008
Control
Physpe 3 sprays
Physpe 6 sprays
piraclostrobin+boscalid
folpet 3 sprays
folpet 6 sprays
Conclusions
1.
Physpe showed good effectiveness in control of grey mould and powdery mildew and
reduced intensity of leaf spot symptoms.
2.
Efficacy of Physpe was not evidently increased with higher spray frequency.
3.
The use of Physpe in control of strawberry diseases can enable the reduction of
chemical control in strawberry protection programmes.
References
Aziz A., Poinssot B., daire X., Adrian M., Bezler A., Lambert B., Joubert JM., Pugin A. 2003:
Laminarin elicitis defense responses in grapevine and induces protection against Botrytis
cinerea and Plasmopara viticola. Molecular Plant-Microbe Inter. 16: 1118 – 1128.
479
Jarvis W.R. 1964: The effect of some climatic factors on the incidence of grey mould of
strawberry and raspberry fruit. Hort. Res. 3: 65-71.
Klarzyński O., Plesse B., Joubert J.M., Yvin J.C., Kopp M., Kloareg B., Fritig B. 2000: Linear
β-1,3-glucans are elicitors of defense responses in tobacco. Plant Physiol. 124: 10271037.
Muller H.W.K. 1965: The present state of grey mould (Botrytis cinerea) control in strawberry
growing. R.A.M.44: Part. 8, s. 408.
Łabanowska B. H., Meszka B., Bielenin A., Olszak R. 2004: A field evaluation of disease and
insect resistance of several strawberry cultivars in Poland. Acta Horticulturae 649: 255258.
Meszka B., Bielenin A. 2007: Zróżnicowanie podatności nowych odmian truskawki na
choroby pochodzenia grzybowego. Prog. Plant Prot./Postępy w Ochronie Roślin. 47:
203-206.
480
Table 1. Efficacy of Physpe in control of strawberry leaf spot and powdery mildew
Rate
per 1 ha
Fungicide
Powdery mildew
Leaf spot
Percent of
Percent of
Effectivene
Effectivenes
affected
affected
ss in %
s in %
leaves
leaves
12 July 2006
30
June
2006
Control
57.5 c
-
54.3 c
-
Physpe
1.0 l
(3 sprays during blossom + 3
before harvest)
Domark 100 EC-standard
0.6 l
(3 sprays during blossom)
I location;
assessment:
23.4 b
59.3
17.1 b
69.0
0.1 a
99.8
10.1 a
81.0
Control
47.2 d*
1 July 2008
Physpe
1.0 l
20.1 c
(3 sprays during blossom)
Physpe
1.0 l
23.6 c
(3 sprays during blossom + 3
before harvest)
Domark 100 EC-standard
0.6 l
11.0 ab
(3 sprays during blossom)
Domark 100 EC-standard
0.6 l
9.4 a
(3 sprays during blossom + 3
before harvest)
Zato 50 WG- standard
0.25 kg
17.8 bc
(3 sprays during blossom)
Topsin M 500 SC –standard
2.5 l
24.0 c
(3 sprays during blossom)
II location;
assessment:
22 June 2008
Control
Physpe
(3 sprays during blossom)
Physpe
(3 sprays during blossom + 3
before harvest)
Domark 100 EC-standard
(3 sprays during blossom)
Domark 100 EC-standard
(3 sprays during blossom + 3
before harvest)
Zato 50 WG- standard
(3 sprays during blossom)
Topsin M 500 SC –standard
(3 sprays during blossom)
17 July 2008
-
36.1 b
57.4
7.6 a
78.9
50.0
6.9 a
80.9
76.7
3.7 a
89.8
80.1
3.1 a
91.4
62.3
5.3 a
85.3
49.2
3.5 a
90.3
10 July 2008
73.6 c
-
36.8 d
-
1.0 l
42.3 b
42.5
8.1 c
78.0
1.0 l
34.4 b
53.3
3.9 ab
89.4
0.6 l
14.5 a
80.3
2.5 a
93.2
0.6 l
11.9 a
83.8
2.1 a
94.3
0.25 kg
18.7 a
74.6
3.0 ab
91.8
2.5 l
34.2 b
53.5
5.4 b
85.3
* Means in columns followed by the same letter do not differ at 5% level of significance
according Newman-Keuls test
481
Prediction of Xanthomonas arboricola pv. pruni infection on peaches
Riccardo Bugiani1, Simona Giosuè2, Ceredi Gianni 3, Vittorio Rossi2*
1
Servizio Fitosanitario, Regione Emilia-Romagna, Via di Saliceto 81, 40128 Bologna, Italy; 2
Horta Srl, Spin off company of Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Via E. Parmense 84,
29100 Piacenza, Italy; 3 Istituto di Entomologia e Patologia vegetale, Università Cattolica
del Sacro Cuore, Via Emilia Parmense 84, 29100 Piacenza, Italy; APOFRUIT Italia, Soc.
Coop. Agricola, Pievesestina di Cesena, Forlì (Italy).
Abstract. X. arboricola pv. pruni (Xap) is present on Prunus spp. in some European countries, and it
is listed as an A2 quarantine pest by EPPO; its importance in Northern Italy has increased in the last
decade. An empiric model predicting Xap infection has been developed in late ‘90s. Occurrence of the
first seasonal infection was monitored in peach orchards of Romagna, in 1992 to 2008, and compared
to model predictions: an infection was predicted when there were at least 3 successive rainy days, with
temperature between 14 and 19°C; symptom’s onset was expected after one to four weeks of
incubation. Xap symptoms appeared in 10 out of 17 years; first seasonal symptoms become visible
between 19 May and 12 July. These infections were always correctly predicted by the model, with an
average incubation period of three weeks. Five infection periods were predicted by the model that did
not result in actual infection. In five years the disease did not appear at all. In four of these years the
model did not predict infection all season long, while in one year it wrongly predicted two possible
infection periods. Sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of the model showed that one would have
somewhat more confidence in predictions of non-infections than in predictions of infections. In a
practical use of the model, this would led to some unjustified alarms.
Keywords: disease modelling, bacterial spot, weather, infection period, validation
Introduction
Bacterial spot of stone fruits, caused by Xanthomonas arboricola pv. pruni (since now cited
as Xap) occurs in most countries where stone fruits are grown. Xap is present on Prunus spp.
in some European countries, and it is listed as an A2 quarantine pest by EPPO. It is more
common and most severe in areas where stone fruits are grown in light, sandy soils and the
environment is humid or moist and warm during the growing season. The most common hosts
include peach and nectarine, Japanese plum, apricot and almond (Ritchie, 1995). Bacterial
spot symptoms were observed on both peach leaves and fruits as necrotic spots and
watersoaked respectively, while on plum twigs cankers were also described.
According to the traditional description of disease cycle on peach, the pathogen invades
twigs via fresh leaf scars in autumn. These infections are then expressed as cankers in spring
or as black tip in the following winter, or in the early spring. Overwintering bacteria
associated with these symptoms are believed to be the most important inoculum for primary
infections. However bacteria may overwinter in terminal buds; in Ontario (Canada) both
terminal and axillary buds have been reported as overwintering sites for Xap (Dhanvantari,
1971). Xap have also been detected in epiphytic association with both twigs and buds on
peach or plum (Shepard and Zehr, 1994). The bacterium was found on all sypmtomless organs
sampled during a 13-month period during 1984-85; therefore, the pathogen can persist yearround on surfaces of both peach and plum trees, even in absence of symptoms of bacterial
spot.
The occurrence of infection depends entirely on the environmental conditions. Frequent
482
periods of moisture during late bloom to a few weeks after petal fall are very conducive to
primary infection on fruits and leaves of peach or nectarine. Wind-driven rain may increase
disease severity. Similar environmental conditions throughout the growing season allow for
the continuation of secondary infections, while few infections occur during hot dry conditions
(Ritchie, 1995). Battilani et al. (1999) found that infection occurs when three or more rainy
days occur with air temperature of 14 to19°C.
The increasing prevalence of the bacterial spot in North Italy induced to verify the
possibility of using the simple rule of Battilani et al. (1999) for predicting infection periods of
Xap.
Materials and methods
Model description
A simple empiric model predicting Xap infection was developed from a 3-year study carried
out in two peach orchards located southeast of lake Garda in the Veneto region (North Italy)
in late ‘90s (Battilani et al., 1999). An infection period is predicted when there are at least
three successive rainy days, with air temperature between 14 and 19°C; symptom’s onset is
expected after one to four weeks of incubation.
Data collection
Occurrence of the first seasonal infection of Xap was monitored in peach orchards located in
Romagna (North Italy), in 1992 to 2008. Starting from bud break, plants were carefully
inspected at least once per week to observe the first seasonal appearance of disease
symptoms.
Weather data were supplied by the regional agrometeorological network for the nearest
automatic station (not farer than 15 km); from the year 2001 the regional network supplied
interpolated data for the grids (5x5 km wide) which comprised the considered orchards
(Bottarelli and Zinoni, 2002). The model was ran for each orchard using the weather data as
input variables, the occurrence of any infection periods between bud break and first seasonal
Xap onset was determined, as well as the correspondent period of expected appearance of the
disease symptoms (Fig. 1).
Model validation
Total model predictions were distinguished in: i) accurate infections, when a predicted
infection corresponded to the actual appearance of the disease in the orchard; ii) accurate noninfections, when the model did not predict an infection and no disease appeared in the
orchard; iii) wrong infections, when the model predicted an infection but the disease did not
appear; iv) wrong non-infections, when the model did not predict an infection that actually
occurred. All the possible combinations of observed (O) versus predicted (P) infections were
organized in a 2x2 contingency table, where the two groups O-,P- (no observed and no
predicted infection) and O+,P+ (yes observed and yes predicted infection) were the right
estimates, while the two groups O-,P+ and O+,P- were the wrong ones.
Sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of the model predictions were evaluated by means of
the Bayesian analysis (Yuen and Hughes, 2002). To asses the advantages rising from the
model in practice, the probabilities that an infection period result or not in a Xap infection
were determined as P(O+,P+) and P(O-,P-) following Madden (2006), and compared with the
correspondent prior probabilities, P(O+) and P(O-), respectively.
483
T (°C) - Rain (mm)
25
20
15
10
5
0
1
8
15 22
March
29
5
12 19
April
26
3
10
17 24
May
31
Figure 1. Air temperature (T) and rainfall registered in the peach orchard of Villanova, year
2006: z is an infection period predicted by the model,
is the expected period of disease
appearance, T is the first seasonal onset of Xap symptoms.
Results and discussion
Symptoms of Xap appeared in 10 out of 17 years; first seasonal symptoms become visible
between 19 May and 12 July (Table 1). These infections were always correctly predicted by
the model, with an average incubation period of three weeks (minimum 10 days, maximum 29
days); in 1996, two infection periods (15 and 28 May) were associated with the disease onset
of 12 July (Table 1). Five infection periods (two in 1995, one in 1996, 1997, and 2002) were
predicted by the model that did not result in actual infection (Table 1).
In five years (1993, 1999 to 2001, and 2003) the disease did not appear at all. In four of
these years the model did not predict infection all season long, while in one year (1999) it
wrongly predicted two possible infection periods on 22 May and 21 June. In 2004 and 2007,
the disease did not appear in the considered orchards all season long, but traces of Xap
symptoms were observed in neighbouring orchards at the end of May; in both cases the model
predicted only one infection period in early May.
Comparison between predicted infection periods and observed disease symptoms (Table
2) showed that the model had very high sensitivity, because it correctly predicted all the actual
infections, giving a true positive proportion TPP=1. The model also showed low specificity,
because 7 out of 20 predicted infection periods were wrong because the disease did not
appear, giving a false negative proportion of FPP=0.64. Overall accuracy of the model, which
considers accurate versus total predictions, was high (=0.71) while the Youden’s index, which
is the difference TPP-FPP was low (J= 0.36) because FPP was high (=0.64). Likelihood ratios
of infection (LR (+)=TPP/FPP=1.57) and no infection (LR(-)=FNP/TNP=0) showed good
accuracy, because an accurate model has, in general, large LR(+) (above 1) and small LR(-)
(close to 0) (Madden 2006).
The prior probability of an infection to be predicted without the model was P
(O+)=13/24=0.54. Using the model, the predicted posterior probability of an infection when
one is predicted raised to P(P+,O+)=0.65, which is higher than the prior probability. The
probability of no infection was P(O-)=11/24=0.46, while the correspondent posterior
probability was P(P-,O-)= 1.00. Therefore, the probability that there will not be an infection
when an infection is not expected is more than two-fold increased compared to the prior
484
probability of a non-infection when no model is used. Finally, the posterior probability of an
infection given that a non-infection is predicted is P(P-,O+)=0, meaning that there is no
probability that a random unknown observation is actually an infection when a non-infection
is predicted by the model.
In conclusion, this validation work showed that the model predicting infection periods of
Xap of peaches is accurate and robust. Because of the properties of the model and the prior
probability of an infection, one would have somewhat more confidence in predictions of noninfections than in predictions of infections. In a practical use of the model, this would led to
some unjustified alarms.
Table 1. Peach orchards considered for monitoring the epidemics caused by Xanthomonas
arboricola pv. pruni, and comparison between the first seasonal onset of the disease and the
infection periods predicted by the model.
Year
Location
Variety
First seasonal
Xap onset
Predicted infection
periodsd
Days of
incubatione
1992
Alfonsine
Elegant Lady
19 May
30 April
19
c
-
1993
Alfonsine
Elegant Lady
No
-
1994
Alfonsine
Elegant Lady
5 July
13 June
22
1995
S. Alberto
Elegant Lady
3 July
10 May / 19 May / 6 June
27
a
12 July
3 May / 15 May / 28 May
28 / 15
1996
Ravenna
Several
1997
Ravenna
Several
12 June
7 May / 2 June
10
1998
Ravenna
Several
23 June
25 May
29
1999
Villanova
Elegant Lady
No
22 May / 21 June
-
2000
Villanova
Elegant Lady
No
-
-
2001
Villanova
Elegant Lady
No
-
-
2002
Villanova
Elegant Lady
10 June
4 May / 12 May
29
2003
Villanova
Big top
No
-
-
b
2004
Villanova
Big top
31 May
5 May
26
2005
Villanova
Big top
8 June
18 May
21
2006
Villanova
Big top
25 May
29 April
26
b
2007
Villanova
Big top
25 May
5 May
20
2008
Ravenna
Several
1 June
20 May
12
a
observations were carried out in a varietal collection of peaches; b the disease did not appear
in the considered orchard but in the neighbouring ones; c the disease did not appear all season
long; d last day of a predicted infection periods: in italic the infection periods that resulted in
actual disease onset; e number of days elapsing between a predicted infection period (in italic)
and the first seasonal disease onset
485
Table 2 – Comparison between Xap infections predicted by the model and observed in the
orchards of Tab. 1, and correspondent properties of the model.
Predicted
Observed
Yes
No
(P+)
(P-)
Likelihood
Total Accuracy
ratio
(LR)
Posterior
probability
(P)
Yes
(O+)
13
0
b
TPP =1.00 FNP =0.00
13
0.71e
LR(+)
=1.57
P(P+,O+) P(P+,O-)
=0.65
=0.35
No
(O-)
7
4
FPPc=0.64 TNPd=0.36
11
0.36f
LR(-)
=0.00
P(P-,O+) P(P-,O-)
=0.00
=1.00
Total
a
20
4
24
a
True Positive Proportion (sensitivity); b False Negative Proportion; c False Positive
Proportion; d True Negative Proportion (specificity); e overall accuracy: (11+4)/24; f Jouden’s
index (J): TPP-FPP
References
Battilani, P., Rossi, V. & Saccardi A. 1999: Development of Xanthomonas arboricola pv.
pruni epidemics on peaches. Journal of Plant Pathology 81: 161-171.
Bottarelli, L. & Zinoni, F. 2002: La rete meteorologica regionale. Il divulgatore, 5: 13-17.
Dhanvantari, B.N. 1971: Overwintering sources of inoculum of bacterial spot of peach (X.
pruni) in Southwestern Ontario. Proc. Can. Phytopathological Society 37: 21-30.
Madden, L.V. 2006: Botanical epidemiology: some key advances and its continuing role in
disease management. European Journal of Plant Pathology 11: 3-23.
Ritchie, D.F. 1995: Bacterial spot. In: APS Press (ed.). Compendium of stone fruit diseases,
pp 50-52. The American Phytopathological Society, U.S.A.
Shepard, D.P. & Zehr, E.I. 1994: Epiphytic persistence of Xanthomonas campestris pv. pruni
on peach and plum. Plant Disease 78: 627-629.
Yuen, J.E. & Hughes, G. 2002: Bayesian analysis of plant disease prediction. Plant Pathology
51: 407-412.
486
Monitoring of virus and phytoplasma diseases by laboratory
diagnostic methods (DAS-ELISA, PCR, RT-PCR) in apple and pear
after sanitation process
Luboš Talácko
Research and Breeding Institute of Pomology Holovousy Ltd., Holovousy 1, 50801 Hořice,
Czech Republic
Abstract: Sanitation of apple cultivar (‘Rubinstep’) and pear cultivars (‘Astra’, ‘Bohemica’, ‘David’,
‘Elektra’, ‘Erika’) was carried out by in vitro thermotherapy and chemotherapy. In the course of
sanitation, the plant material was periodically tested to verify the suitability of selected methods. The
presence of pathogens in selected initial trees was detected by PCR, RT-PCR and DAS-ELISA before
the beginning of sanitation in 2005. Twenty clones of apple cultivar ‘Rubinstep’, 20 clones of pear cv.
‘Elektra’, 19 clones of pear cv. ‘Erika’, 20 clones of pear cv. ‘Astra’, 20 clones of pear cv. ‘Bohemica’,
and 12 clones of pear cv. ‘David’ were tested after chemotherapy in years 2007-2008. Fifteen clones of
pear cv. ‘Elektra’, 6 clones of cv. ‘Lada’ and 10 clones of cv. ‘Rubinstep’ were tested after
thermotherapy in 2008. The occurrence of viruses Apple chlorotic leaf spot virus (ACLSV), Apple
stem grooving virus (ASGV), Apple stem pitting virus (ASPV), Apple mosaic virus (ApMV) and
phytoplasmas Candidatus ‘Phytoplasma pyri’ (CPP) and Candidatus ‘Phytoplasma mali’ (CPM) were
monitored. The clones, which remained infected with viruses or phytoplasmas after therapy, were later
discarded. Those in vitro clones that proved to be pathogen-free after repeated testing were further
multiplied and in vitro rooted. The results presented here are preliminary.
Key words: sanitation, thermotherapy, chemotherapy, apple, pear, ApMV, ACLSV, ASPV, ASGV
Introduction
Apple chlorotic leaf spot virus (ACLSV) and Apple stem grooving virus (ASGV) both occur
frequently in rosaceous fruit trees. Infection is often latent, although several economically
important diseases are associated with the viruses (Németh 1986). Field grown fruit trees are
affected by many pathogens of viral nature. Some of these pathogens are well identified and
characterized (Németh 1986). Apple chlorotic leafspot virus (ACLSV), Apple stem groowing
virus (ASGV), Apple stem pitting virus (ASPV) and Apple mosaic virus (ApMV) are common
viruses affecting cultivated species of the Malus genus and other species of the Rosaceae
family (Németh 1986; Knapp et al. 1998; Desvignes et al. 1999; Polák & Zieglerová 2001).
Certification schemes of European and Mediterranean Plant Protection Organisation
(EPPO) have been established in Europe to guarantee the two requirements that propagative
material must meet and maintain troughout the different steps of production: trueness of plant
cultivar type and sanitary status. Among the patogens main consideration is given to viruses,
phytoplasmas and viroids because they are transmitted in propagative way and cannot be
eliminated by pesticide treatments (Barba 1998). Sanitation by thermotherapy and
chemotherapy is the most common way to obtain healthy plant material for the first step of
certification scheme for fruit trees (pre-basic material).
487
Material and methods
Thermotherapy
Actively growing shoot tips of apple and pear cultivars were cut from shoots sprouting in
laboratory conditions for in vitro culture initiation. This initial plant material was disinfested
with mercuric chloride (0.15 %) for 1 min. and rinsed with sterile distilled water. Explants
were cultured in Erlenmeyer flasks each with 25 ml of MS medium (Murashige & Skoog
1962) gelled with agar (0.7 %). The heat treatment was applied after one month of cultivation
on the same MS medium but with 1.5 mg.l-1 BAP for multiplication. The cultures were placed
in a heat chamber, where the temperature was raised gradually to 34 or 39° C. Between 5 and
31 day of thermotherapy, according to growth vigour and viability of particular explant, the
apical part of the axis about 1-2 mm in length comprising the apical meristem plus one or two
leaf primordia, which developed during the high temperature period, was transferred to a
fresh multiplication MS medium with 1.5 mg.l-1 BAP and returned to standard growth
conditions in a growth chamber.
A period of about 6 months was necessary to obtain well-established actively growing
cultures of particular clones. Then several leaves from each in vitro cultivated clone were
sampled and tested by RT-PCR for the abovementioned viruses and by PCR for phytoplasmas
Candidatus ‘Phytoplasma pyri’ and Candidatus ‘Phytoplasma mali’. Those in vitro clones that
proved to be virus-free by RT-PCR testing were further multiplied and in vitro rooted. In vitro
clones with positive results of testing were discarded (Paprstein et al. 2008).
Chemotherapy
The chemotherapy was carried out on MS medium (Murashige & Skoog, 1962) with
ribavirin. Thermolabile antiviral ribavirin (Duchefa, Biochemie B.V.) in concentration 200
mg.l-1 was filter sterilized (25 mm, Acrodisc Syringe Filter 0.2 μm, Pall Gelman, USA) and
added to the medium after autoclaving. Explants were sampled from actively growing in vitro
culture and submerged to medium with ribavirin. Flasks with explants were placed to the
cultivation room with the same conditions as for induction of multiplication. Twenty apical
shoot tips (2 – 4 mm) were sampled from every cultivar after one month, cultivated and tested
for viruses ApMV, ACLSV, ASGV and ASPV (Paprstein et al. 2008).
Testing
The presence of viruses in selected initials tree was detected by ELISA and RT-PCR before
the beginning of sanitation. Virus pathogens ApMV, ACLSV, ASGV were detected by ELISA
and ACLSV, ASGV and ASPV were tested by RT-PCR. Candidatus 'Phytoplasma pyri' and
Candidatus 'Phytoplasma mali' were tested by PCR.
The virus detection was done by RT-PCR. The extracts of total RNA were obtained and
transcribed using a commercial kit (Qiagen). The products of transcription by ASGV, ASPV
and ApMV were amplified by 35 cycles, by ACLSV by 39 cycles in a thermocycler (Kundu
2002). The phytoplasma detection was done by PCR. The extracts of total DNA were
obtained using a commercial kit. The DNA of phytoplasma was amplified by 35 cycles in a
thermocycler. PCR products were diluted with sterile distilled water (1:39) prior to
amplification by nested-PCR using R16F2/R2 (Gundersen & Lee 1996) and fU5/rU3 (Lorenz
et al. 1995) primer pairs. Final R16F2/R2 amplicons (10 μl) were digested with RsaI and BfmI
16 hours at 37°C. Products of PCR and RT-PCR were visualized by Sybrgreen under
ultraviolet light on agarose gel.
488
Results and discussion
Results of testing of initial field-grown trees before beginning of therapies are summarized in
Table 1. During testing of initial plant material, ACLSV was detected by ELISA in apple
cultivar ‘Rubinstep’ and by RT-PCR in pear cultivar ‘Bohemica’. ASGV was detected by RTPCR in apple cultivar ‘Rubinstep’ and pear cultivars ‘Elektra’, ‘Erika’ and ‘Lada’. ASPV was
detected by RT-PCR in apple cultivar ’Rubinstep’ and pear cultivars ‘Astra’, ‘David’,
‘Elektra’ and ‘Lada’. Candidatus 'Phytoplasma pyri' was proved by PCR in cultivar ‘Elektra’.
Table1. Results of virus detection in initial field grown trees before sanitation by thermo – and
chemotherapy (+ positive, - negative, n - not tested)
cultivar
ApMV
ACLSV
ASGV
ASPV
CPM/
CPP
ELISA/
RT-PCR
ELISA/
RT-PCR
ELISA/
RT-PCR
ELISA/
RT-PCR
PCR
-/n
+/-
-/+
n/+
-
-/n
-/n
-/n
-/n
-/n
-/n
-/- /+
-/-/-/-/-
-/-/-/-/+
-/+
-/+
n/+
n/n/+
n/+
n/n/+
+
-
apple
Rubinstep
pear
Astra
Bohemica
David
Elektra
Erika
Lada
The numbers of negative clones after chemotherapy and thermotherapy are summarized in Table
2. Cultivar ‘Bohemica’ had 16 clones (80 %) negative from 20 beginning clones after
chemotherapy, cultivar ‘Astra’ had 16 clones negative (80 %) and cultivar ‘David’ had 6 clones
negative (50 %) from 12. Cultivar ‘Elektra’ had 14 clones (70 %) negative from 20 tested,
cultivar ‘Erika’ had 17 (89.4 %) negative from 19 tested. In the case of apple cultivar
‘Rubinstep’, all 20 clones were free of tested viruses after chemotherapy.
Table 2. Number of negative clones of apple and pear cultivars after chemotherapy and
thermotherapy (in parentheses percentage of negative clones)
Chemotherapy
Number of clones
Cultivar
Total Negative
Bohemica
Astra
David
Elektra
Erika
20
20
12
20
19
16 (80.0)
16 (80.0)
6 (50.0)
14 (70.0)
Cultivar
Thermotherapy
Number of clones
Elektra
Lada
Rubinstep
Total
Negative
15
6
10
7 (46.7)
2 (33.3)
6 (60.0)
17 (89.4)
20
Rubinstep
20
(100.0)
The best results of chemotherapy were achieved in the case of apple cultivar ‘Rubinstep’, where
100 % of clones were negative after sanitation. The best results of thermotherapy were noted
489
also in the case of apple cultivar ‘Rubinstep’.
The results show, that the system of therapy presented in this paper was partially successful.
The mixed infection of three viruses ACLSV, ASGV and ASPV was completely eliminated by
chemotherapy from apple cultivar ‘Rubinstep’. By thermotherapy, only ACLSV was
completely eliminated from all clones of cultivar ‘Rubinstep’. The remaining viruses were
eliminated only in 60 % of total amount of clones.
Other results show, that the elimination of viruses from some cultivars can be difficult. It
is often associated with mixed infections, which are difficult to eliminate (da Camara
Machado et al. 1998, Knapp et al. 1995).
With exception of cultivar ‘David’, comparison of both methods of sanitation proved that
chemotherapy was more efficient. The success of virus elimination by chemotherapy in
cultivar ‘David’ was only 50 %.
After sanitation process, the presence of ApMV was identified in cultivars ‘Astra’, ‘David’
and ‘Elektra’. However this virus was not identified in initial field-grown trees. This result can
be caused by low concentration of virus in initial plant material. The more sensitive method RTPCR detected ApMV in in vitro cultures after sanitation process.
Table 3. Number of clones with occurrence of viruses and phytoplasmas in clones of apple and
pear cultivars after sanitation process
Cultivar
Chemotherapy
Astra
Bohemica
David
Elektra
Erika
Rubinstep
Thermotherapy
Elektra
Lada
Rubinstep
Tested
CPM/ Negative
ApMV ACLSV ASGV ASPV
clones
CPP
clones
20
20
12
20
19
20
4
1
2
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
2
0
0
4
4
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
16
16
6
14
17
20
15
6
10
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
4
4
5
0
4
0
0
0
7
2
6
The results show, that both methods of sanitation were efficient. It is necessary to repeat the
testing to exclude the possibility of latent virus infection. Laboratory methods and testing on
woody indicators will be used for following testing of this material.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by The Ministerium of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech
Republic (MSM2527112101).
References
Barba, M. 1998: Virus certification of fruit tree propagative material in Western Europe. In:
Hadidi A (Ed) Plant virus disease control. St. Paul, Minnesota.
490
Cieslinska, M. 2002: Elimination of Apple chlorotic leaf spot virus (ACLSV) from pear by in
vitro thermotherapy and chemotherapy. Acta Hortic. 596: 481 – 484.
da Camara Machado, A.; Mendonca, D.; Lopes, M.S.; Knapp, E.; Hanzer, V.; Arthofer, W.;
Katinger, H.; Laimer de Camara Machado, M. 1998: Phytosanitary improvement of fruit
tree species: diagnostic strategies in virus-indexing of in vitro plants. Acta Hortic 596: 481484.
Desvignes, J.C.; Boye, R.; Cornaggia, D.; Grasseau, N. 1999: Virus diseases of fruit trees.
Editions Centre technique interprofessionel des fruits et legumes, Paris.
Gundersen D. E., Lee I.-M. 1996: Ultrasensitive detection of phytoplasmas by nested-PCR
assays using two universal primer sets.- Phytopathologia Mediterranea, 35: 144-151.
Knapp, E.; Hanzer, V.; Weiss, H.; da Camara Machado, A.; Wang, Q.; Weiss, B.; Katinger, H.;
Laimer da Camara Machado, M. 1995: Distribution of apple chlorotic leaf spot virus in
apple shoots cultivated in vitro. Acta Hort. 386: 187-194.
Knapp, E.; Hanzer, V.; Mendonca, D.; da Camara Machado, A.; Katinger, H.; Laimer da Camara
Machado, M. 1998: Improved virus detection in rosaceous fruit trees in vitro. Plant Cell
Tissue Organ Cult 52: 3-6.
Kundu, J.K. 2002: The application of RT-PCR assay for the detection of Apple stem pitting virus
and Apple stem grooving virus in four apple cultivars. Plant. Protection Sci., 38: 13-17.
Lorenz, K.H.; Schneider, B.; Ahrens, U.; Seemüller, E. 1995: Detection of apple proliferation
and pear decline phytoplasmas by PCR amplification of ribosomal and nonribosomal DNA.
Phytopathology, vol. 85: 771-776.
Murashige, T.; Skoog, F. 1962: A revised medium for rapid growth and bioassays with tobacco
tissue cultures. Physiol. Plant. 15: 473 – 497.
Németh, M. 1986: Virus, mycoplasma and rickettsia diseases of fruit trees. Martinus Nijhoff / Dr.
W. Junk Publishers, Dordrecht, Boston, Lancaster.
Paprstein, F., Sedlak, J., Polak, J., Svobodova, L., Hassan, M., Bryxiova, M. 2008: Results of in
vitro thermotherapy of apple cultivars. Plant Cell Tiss Organ Cult 94: 347-352.
Polák, J.; Zieglerová, J. 2001: Distribution of Apple stem grooving virus in apple trees in Czech
Republic. Plant Protect. Sci., 37: 1-4.
491
Eutypa dieback as an important disease in red currant (Ribes rubrum)
and gooseberry (Ribes uva-crispa) in the Netherlands
Marcel Wenneker1, Peter Vink2, Ilse Heurneman3, Marcel van Raak3, Anne Sophie van
Bruggen3
1 Applied Plant Research, Research Unit Fruit, Wageningen University & Research Centre,
P.O. Box 200, 6670 AE Zetten, the Netherlands; 2 Applied Plant Research, Research Unit
Flower Bulbs, Wageningen University & Research Centre, P.O. Box 85, 2160 AB Lisse, the
Netherlands; 3 Plant Protection Service, P.O. Box 9102, 6700 HC Wageningen, the
Netherland
Abstract: Over decades, growers in the Netherlands have problems with a disease that causes dying
branches and stem cankers in red currant. For many years it was assumed that this disease was related
to fungi such as Nectria cinnabarina, Phomopsis spp. and the insect Synanthedon tipuliformis.
However, recently it was found by Applied Plant Research and the Plant Protection Service that the
causal organism is the fungus Eutypa lata. The disease is considered of major economic importance,
especially as red currant growing is rapidly expanding in the Netherlands. E. lata was identified with
three detection methods (visual, plating and DNA). Symptoms of Eutypa do not usually appear until
currant plants are at least three to four years old. These cankers are always associated with old pruning
wounds. Eventually, the entire branch is killed. High disease incidences and annual losses of 10% 30% of the productive branches are reported. In some cases entire fields have to be replanted. Eutypa
is well known as one of the most destructive diseases of grapes. The importance of this disease in
currant growing was not known. Research is focusing on the evaluation of control measures; e.g.
chemical and biological control treatment of pruning wounds, and disease management such as
sanitation practices. Also, the epidemiology of Eutypa is studied. Recently, high densities of
ascospores of Eutypa were found in a spore trap placed in a red currant field in the Netherlands. In the
subsequent field survey, fruiting structures (stromata) and ascospores were found on dead infected red
currant wood.
Eutypa lata, Canker, Control strategies, Currants
492
Chlorantraniliprole (DPX-E2Y45, Rynaxypyr®) (Coragen®20SC and
Altacor®35WG) - a new diamide insecticide for control of codling
moth (Cydia pomonella) and other top fruit Lepidopteran pests
Andrea Bassi1, Axel Dinter2, Kristin Brugger3, Niels-Martin Frost4, John Wiles5, Jean
Luc Rison6
1DuPont Italy Srl, Via Piero Gobetti 2/C, 20063 Cernusco sul Naviglio (MI) Italy, 2DuPont
de Nemours Deutschland (GmbH), DuPont Str. 1, D-61352 Bad Homburg v.d.H.,
Germany,3E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company, Wilmington, Delaware 19898, USA,
4DuPont Denmark, 5Du Pont (UK) Limited, Wegwood Way, Stevenage, Hertfordshire, SG1
4QN, UK, 6Du Pont de Nemours (France) SAS, ERDC, 24, Rue du Moulin, Nambsheim, F68740
Abstract: Chlorantraniliprole (DPX-E2Y45, Rynaxypyr®) is a new compound from DuPont
belonging to a new class of selective insecticides (anthranilic diamides) featuring a novel mode of
action (group 28 in the IRAC classification). By activating the arthropod ryanodine receptors it
stimulates the release and depletion of intracellular calcium stores from the sarcoplasmic reticulum of
muscle cells causing impaired regulation, paralysis and ultimately death of sensitive species.
Extensively tested in the field since 2002, it is registered in the USA, Australia, Canada, China and it
is close to market introduction in all the main top fruit producing countries. The product general
features have been presented in previous, referenced papers. It has very low toxicity for mammals
(both acute and chronic), high biological activity on the sensitive species with strong ovi-larvicidal
efficacy and good residual properties, excellent performance on codling moth and other chewing pests,
stability of performance across the different climatic and farming conditions, no cross-resistance
detected to any existing insecticide and minimal impact on pollinator and beneficial arthropod species.
Published studies indicate that chlorantraniliprole may have significant mating disruptive effects on C.
pomonella adults when both males and females are exposed to the residues equivalent to the
recommended field rate. This paper focuses on the product features that best fit IFP (Integrated Fruit
Protection) criteria and may enhance IFP options while ensuring higher efficacy standards. After
reviewing some toxicity data, examples from field/semi-field and laboratory tests are provided
regarding comparative performance assessment, minimal impact on beneficial arthropods and bees and
a possible reduction in the number of applications versus current standards.
Insecticide, Chlorantraniliprole, Rynaxypyr®, Ryanodine receptor, Beneficial arthropods, Mating
disruption, Codling moth, Bees
493
No evidence in codling moth for cross-resistance between chemical
insecticides and Cydia pomonella granulovirus
Annegret Schmitt1, Isabella Bisutti1, Benoît Sauphanor2, Johannes A. Jehle3, Jürg
Huber1
1 JKI, Institute for Biological Control, 64287 Darmstadt, Heinrichstr. 243, Germany;
annegret.schmitt@jki.bund.de ; 2 INRA, Agroparc, 84914 Avignon, France; 3 DLR
Rheinpfalz, Laboratory for Biotechnological Crop Protection, Breitenweg 71, 67435
Neustadt/Wstr., Germany
Abstract: Codling moth larvae from 23 orchards located in five European countries were tested for
their susceptibility/resistance to the Cydia pomonella granulovirus (CpGV-M) in standardized
laboratory bioassays. Farmers observed in several of these populations reduced susceptibility to
CpGV-M treatment. For each C. pomonella strain, the percentage of larvae surviving CpGV-M
concentrations of 104 to 106 OB/ml were calculated 14 days after start of the trial and used for
prediction of percentage of resistant individuals in the collected population. The mortality was
corrected using Abbott’s formula, with the average mortality determined in the controls of all 14-day
trials performed (mortality due to other reasons than virus). In general, the results from the bioassays
were in accordance with the observations in the field. Most orchards from which the farmer reported
failure of the CpGV-M treatment contained resistant codling moth populations. The percentage of
resistant individuals in a population ranged roughly from 30 to 90%. However, in some apparently
susceptible populations there were also hints for the presence of a very small fraction of resistant
individuals. Several of these European populations were tested for susceptibility to eight insecticides
including different classes of insect growth regulators and neurotoxic compounds. High mortality was
recorded to most insecticides, independent of resistance to CpGV. A reduced susceptibility to
azinphos, diflubenzurone, and tebufenozide was recorded in several populations. Overall, there was no
indication for the occurrence of cross-resistance between CpGV-M and insecticides in the tested
populations.First laboratory tests showed that populations of C. pomonella resistant to CpGV-M were
susceptible to new CpGV strains. This study was funded by the EU, CRAFT project 32857; Further
information can be found under www.sustaincpgv.eu.
Codling moth, Cydia pomonella Granulovirus, Chemical insecticides, Resistance
494
Can delayed flight activity serve as an indicator for insecticide
resistance?
Patrik Kehrli, Denis Pasquier, Pierre-Adrien Roux
Station de recherche Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil ACW, CP 1012, CH-1260 Nyon,
Switzerland
Abstract: Together with the codling moth, Cydia pomonella, the summer fruit tortix moth,
Adoxophyes orana, is a major pest insect in apple orchards of western Switzerland. Whereas
codling moth developed simple, cross and multiple resistances to various classes of
insecticides over the last decade, A. orana seemed to be still susceptible to these pesticides.
However, since 2004, fruit growers indicate more and more failures of conventional control
schemes against summer fruit tortix moths. Using laboratory bioassays we established that A.
orana shows resistance to insect growth regulators and to insect growth inhibitors. This
resistance becomes manifest in the slower development of A. orana larvae. Field observations
showed that the flight of resistant moth populations is delayed. Delayed flight activity might
therefore serve as a reliable indicator of insecticide resistance in summer fruit tortix moths. In
conclusion, the key to successfully managing insecticide resistance is to reduce selection
pressure. This can by achieved by incorporating cultural, biological and pheromonal control
practices, by minimising the use of insecticides and by the alternate use of insecticides with
different modes of action.
Key words: Torticidae, pomiculture, pesticide use, resistance management
Introduction
The summer fruit tortix moth, Adoxophyes orana F. v. R. and the codling moth, Cydia
pomonella (L.) (both Lepidoptera, Torticidae), are the two major pest insects in apple
orchards of western Switzerland. The first resistant C. pomonella was detected in 1996 and
since then several other cases have been discovered all over the country (Charmillot et al.,
2005). In some populations the effectiveness of commonly used insecticides is nearly zero
and these insects evolved cross-resistance to nearly all insecticide classes applied (Ioriatti et
al., 2007; Reyes et al., 2007). As a consequence, mating disruption and granulosis viruses were
successfully implemented as alternative control strategies against codling moth. In orchards
where these two strategies have been implemented, insecticides are regaining their efficiency
(Charmillot et al., 2007). Whereas codling moth developed simple, cross and multiple
resistances to various classes of insecticides, A. orana seemed to be still susceptible to these
pesticides. However, over the past years fruit growers indicated more and more failures of
conventional control schemes against summer fruit tortix moths (Charmillot et al., 2005;
Salamin et al., 2007).
In this paper we study the efficacy of commonly applied insecticides against A. orana
using field observations and laboratory bioassays.
495
Material and methods
Laboratory bioassays
In 2005, larvae of A. orana were collected in different orchards in the canton Vaud,
Switzerland. Three years later, another 140 larvae were collected in a pear orchard in the
Valais, Switzerland. In all these orchards, fruit growers indicated the failure of commonly
used insecticides. These larvae were exposed to eight different insecticides (chlorpyrifosmethyl, fenoxycarb, tebufenozide, methoxyfenozide, hexaflumuron, lufenuron, Spinosad and
indoxacarb). Untreated leaves of apple and pear were dipped for about one minute in a solution
containing an insecticide dose that kills 99 % of individuals of our susceptible A. orana strain
(Figure 1a). After dipping, leaves were placed under a ventilated hood for drying. Three to four
of these leaves were put in a small plastic container of 20x20x15 mm together with one collected
A. orana larva. Containers were stored in a climate chamber (25°C, 70% RH, 18/6 h D/N) and
after one week, the mortality of exposed larvae was assessed.
Field observations
The flight of A. orana was studied by the use of pheromone traps. Traps were exposed in
apple and pear orchards in western Switzerland and they were assessed every one to two
weeks.
Results and discussion
Susceptible strain
Valais 2008
Vaud 2005
Chlorpyrifos-methyl (DD=5ppm)
Indoxacarb (DD=2ppm)
Spinosad (DD=0.5ppm)
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Fenoxycarb (DD=5ppm)
Tebufenozide (DD=200ppm)
Lufenuron (DD=30ppm)
Methoxyfenozide (DD=3ppm)
Figure 1. Efficacy of different active ingredients applied to larvae of A. orana at a discrimination
dose of 99% mortality (=DD), b) males caught by pheromone traps in the Vaud in 2005 and c) in
the Valais 2008.
496
a)
Historical flight
100
20
Number of males caught
Percents of males caught
Valais (no indications of resistance)
Valais (indications of resistance)
b)
Vaud 2005
80
60
40
20
0
15
10
5
0
1.5
31.5
30.6
30.7
29.8
28.9
1.5
31.5
30.6
30.7
29.8
28.9
Figure 2. Males of A. orana caught by pheromone traps in a) the Vaud in 2005 and b) the Valais
in 2008.
Tested larvae of A. orana showed an increased resistance to insect growth regulators and
insect growth inhibitors (Figure 1). Besides, moths were caught significantly latter in orchards
where moths had reduced insecticide susceptibility (Figure 2). This might be explained by an
adaption of A. orana to the usual application scheme or by a slower development of resistant
larvae.
In conclusion, we believe that a delayed flight activity can serve as a first indicator for
identifying insecticide resistant moth populations. Early detection of insecticide resistance is
of paramount importance for implementing integrated management schemes, such as the
adoption of cultural, biological and pheromonal control practices, the reduction of insecticide
use and the alternate use of insecticides with different modes of action.
References
Charmillot, P.-J., Pasquier, D. & F. Briand. 2005: Résistance du carpocapse Cydia pomonella aux
insecticides. Revue Suisse de Viticulture Arboriculture et Horticulture 37:123-127.
Charmillot, P.-J., Blanc, G. & Pasquier, D. 2006: Premier cas de résistance en Suisse de la
tordeuse de la pelure capua (Adoxophyles orana) aux insecticides. Revue Suisse de
Viticulture Arboriculture et Horticulture 38: 87-93.
Charmillot, P.-J., Pasquier, D., Salamin, C., Briand, F., Ter-Hovannesyan, A., Azizian, A.,
Kutinkova, H., Peeva, P. & Velcheva, N. 2007: Détection de la résistance du carpocapse
Cydia pomonella: Tests d'insecticides sur des chenilles diapausantes de Suisse, d'Arménie et
de Bulgarie. Revue Suisse de Viticulture Arboriculture et Horticulture 39: 385-389.
Ioriatti, C., Tasin, M., Charmillot, P. J., Reyes, M. & Sauphanor, B. 2007: Early detection of
resistance to tebufenozide in field populations of Cydia pomonella L.: methods and
mechanisms. Journal of Applied Entomology 131: 453-459.
Reyes, M., Franck, P., Charmillot, P.-J., Ioriatti, C., Olivares, J., Pasqualini, E. & Sauphanor, B.
2007: Diversity of insecticide resistance mechanisms and spectrum in European populations
of the Codling moth, Cydia pomonella. Pest Management Science 63: 890-902.
Salamin, C., Charmillot, P.-J. & Pasquier, D. (2007) Nouveau cas de résistance aux insecticides
de la tordeuse de la pelure capua (Adoxophyes orana). Revue Suisse de Viticulture
Arboriculture et Horticulture 39, 179-183.
497
Cydia pomonella (Lep: Tortricidae) resistance and cross-resistance to
various classes of insecticides in Central Europe
František Kocourek
Crop Research Institute, Department of Entomology, Drnovská 507, Prague 6, 161 06, Czech
Republic
Abstract: Insecticide bioassays were used to investigate resistance of Cydia pomonella (L.) to
insecticides with various types of active ingredients. The efficacy baselines of selected insect growth
regulators (fenoxycarb), insect growth inhibitors (diflubenzuron, teflubenzuron), organophoshorous
insecticides (phosalone) and neonicotinoids (thiacloprid) against the eggs, first- and fifth-instars larvae
of sensitive laboratory strains of codling moth were determined. The lethal concentration ratio
quantified the relation between the efficacy of selected insecticides against fifth-instar larvae found by
topical application and against first-instar larvae found by diet-treated bioassay. According to
concentration-mortality baseline, 50% lethality concentration values and 90% lethality concentration
values were determined for all the tested insecticides. The bioassay was used to monitor the resistance
of codling moths collected in 2003 – 2005 in two apple orchards with different intensities of chemical
control. Resistance ratios to the tested insecticides were determined for both field populations of
codling moth. For the population of codling moth from an apple orchard in Velké Bílovice, crossresistance to fenoxycarb, teflubenzuron and phosalone was detected after the topical application of
insecticides to fifth-instar larvae. The population of codling moth from Prague-Ruzyn was slightly
resistant to phosalone and teflubenzuron. No resistance to diflubenzuron was detected in either tested
population.This work was funded by the Czech Science Foundation, the Czech Republic, grant
522/04/P181. Partial funding was also obtained from the Ministry of Agriculture, the Czech Republic,
project 0002700603.
Cydia pomonella, Resistance, Insecticides
498
Efficacy of clothianidine against the strawberry root weevil
(Otiorhynchus ovatus) on strawberry plantations.
Barbara H. Łabanowska
Institute of Pomology and Floriculture, Department of Plant Protection, Pomologiczna 18,
96-100 Skierniewice, e-mail:Barbara.Labanowska@insad.pl
Abstract: The strawberry root weevil (Otiorhynchus ovatus) feeds on roots and, therefore, it is a very
dangerous pest on older strawberry plantations. The efficacy of two clothianidine formulations (Apacz
50 WG (clothianidine 50%) and TI 435 1 GR (CAGR 8; Santana 1 GR) (clothianidine)) were tested
against the strawberry root weevil on strawberry plantations. Both insecticides belong to neonicotinoid
group. Granular formulation (TI 435 1GR) incorporated into soil at the rate of 10 and 15 kg/ha in the
spring, before strawberry blossom, reduced significantly the number of weevil larvae. In two trials TI
435 1 GR applied at the higher rate (15 kg/ha) decreased the number of larvae by 72%. The efficacy of
this insecticide used at the lower rate (10 kg/ha) against weevil larvae was 61.3 and 78.7%. Results
obtained with TI 435 1 GR were similar to those obtained with standard insecticide – Diazinon 10 GR
(80 kg/ha). Apacz 50 WG applied as a spray treatment at the rate of 0.15 and 0.20 kg/ha before
strawberry blossom reduced weevil larvae by 74.5 - 99.6%. Apacz 50 WG applied at the rate of 0.15
and 0.20 kg/ha just after strawberry harvest reduced the pest abundance by 72.1-96.3%. Reduction of
the pest at this time is very important because after harvest adults of the strawberry root weevil feed on
leaves and females lay eggs. The results obtained with Apacz 50 WG were similar or better than those
obtained with standard the insecticides; Diazinon 10 GR or Dursban 480 EC (chlorpyrifos).
Keywords: Strawberry root weevil, Otiorhynchus ovatus, strawberry, neonicotinoids, clothianidine,
Apacz 50 WG, TI 435 1 GR (Santana 1 GR), chemical control
Introduction
The strawberry root weevil (Otiorhynchus ovatus) is a very important pest causing great
losses on strawberry plantations in many regions of Poland as well as in other countries
(Penman and Scott, 1976, Łabanowska, 1994). The larvae live and feed on strawberry roots.
The level of pest population is higher on older plantations than on young ones. The largest
damage is caused by older larvae, from the end of April until the beginning of June, when
they need the most food. The infested plants are weakened, their leaves are smaller and many
plants dry out. The adults feed on leaves mainly in July, whilst females lay eggs on the soil
surface under plants. Insecticides containing chlorpyrifos and diazinon could be applied as
spray-treatments to control the pest before strawberry planting or after harvest (Łabanowska
and Olszak, 2003, Łabanowska, 1994), and acetamiprid as Mospilan 20 SP could be used after
harvest to control adults. The experiments to find biological control for the strawberry root
weevils are carried out in many countries (Wilson et al., 1999, Tkaczuk et al., 2005).
Materials and methods
Experiments were conducted in 2004-2005 at the Research Institute of Pomology and
Floriculture in Skierniewice, in central Poland. They were carried out on commercial
strawberry plantations, cv. Senga Sengana in a randomized block design with four replicates.
Plot sizes ranged from 10.5 m2 to 50 m2. The spray-treatments were applied before strawberry
blossom or after fruit harvest, when adults were feeding on leaves and females laid eggs.
499
Apacz 50 WG was used as foliar and soil spray-treatment at the rate of 750 l/ha solution. A
knapsack motor sprayer ‘Stihl’ was used for spraying. The granule insecticide was
incorporated by hand into the soil near the plants, in the strawberry rows only. The efficacy of
treatments was estimated in June or early July by counting larvae, pupae and adults (weevils).
After spring treatments larvae were counted in the same year, but if they were applied after
harvest, the larvae were counted in the following year, at the end of harvest. Six plants per
plot, i.e. 24 per treatment were removed with soil. The roots and sieved soil were checked for
the pest’s presence. Data was transformed according to the formula y=log(x+1), where x is the
number of specimens and analysed using analysis of variance. Significant differences of
means were tested with Duncan’s multiple range “t” test at 0.05 significance level.
Results and discussion
Control of the strawberry root weevil in the spring
Clothianidine as Apacz 50 WG (0.15 and 0.20 kg/ha) applied as a spray before blossom of
strawberry reduced the number of larvae under plants by 74.5%; 86.7% and 98.5%,
depending on the insecticide rate and experiment (Tab. 1). The efficacy of clothianidine was
much higher than acetamiprid (Mospilan 20 SP) as a reference insecticide. These results
confirmed the data obtained earlier with Apacz 50 WG used against the Colorado beetle
(Wachowiak and Mrówczyński, 2005). Clothianidine as TI 435 1 GR (10 and 15 kg/ha)
applied before blossom of strawberry, reduced the pest abundance by 61.3 – 72.4%, similarly
as a reference insecticide, Diazinon 10 GR.
Control after harvest
Clothianidine containing Apacz 50 WG used as a spray-treatment of plants and soil after
harvest as well as granular formulation TI 435 1 GR used to the soil near the plants after
harvest, reduced the number of pest in the following year. Apacz 50 WG (0.15-0.20 kg/ha)
efficacy was estimated as 72.1% - 96.3% but TI 435 1 GR (10 and 15 kg/ha) showed 75.3 –
77.1% reduction of the pest. The results with clothianidine were similar to those obtained with
reference insecticides – Dursban 480 EC and Pyrinex 480 EC (chlorpyrifos) and other
neonicotinoids as imidacloprid, thiacloprid and thiametoxam in the control of the strawberry
root weevil (Łabanowska 2007, Łabanowska, Olszak 2003). Clothianidine will be useful to
control of strawberry root weevil on strawberry in IPM programme.
Conclusions
Apacz 50 WG and TI 435 1 GR (Santana 1 GR, CAGR 8) containing clothianidine applied as
foliar and soil treatments before blossom of strawberry or after fruit harvest showed good
control of the strawberry root weevil (Otiorhynchus ovatus) on strawberry plantations.
The results obtained with clothianidine were similar to data obtained with standard substances
(diazinon, chloropyrifos and acetamiprid).
500
Table 1. Efficacy of clothianidine (Apacz 50 WG and TI 435 1 GR) applied in spring against
the strawberry root weevil
No. of larvae, pupae and Efficacy
adults per plant
in %
a. Mokra Lewa, Dates: of spray-treatment – 5.05, of counting – 16-28.06.2004
Check
8.5 c*
Apacz 50 WG*
0.15
0.1 a
98.47
Apacz 50 WG*
0.20
0.03 a
99.63
Mospilan 20 SP
0.60
1.6 b
80.74
b. Złota, Date of spray-treatment – 7.05.2004; Date of counting – 8.07.2004
Check
11.9 d
Apacz 50 WG*
0.15
3.0 b
74.53
Apacz 50 WG*
0.20
1.6 a
86.67
Mospilan 20 SP
0.60
5.6 c
52.76
c. Skierniewice, Date of soil-treatment – 21.05.2004; Date of counting – 6-7.07.2004
Check
2.9 b
TI 435 1 GR**
10.0
1.1 a
61.31
TI 435 1 GR**
15.0
0.8 a
72.39
Diazinon 10 GR
80.0
0.6 a
80.06
Insecticide
Rate kg/ha
Table 2. Efficacy of clothianidine (Apacz 50 WG and TI 435 1 GR applied after harvest of
strawberries against the strawberry root weevil
No. of larvae, pupae and Efficacy
weevils per plant
in %
a. Złota, Date of treatment – 22.07.2004; Date of counting – 8.07.2005
Check
0.85 b
Apacz 50 WG*
0.20
0.03 a
96.30
TI 435 1 GR**
15.0
0.20 a
76.29
b. Czyżew, Date of treatment - 22-26.07.2005; Date of counting - 10-11.07.2006
Check
35.84 b*
72.06
10.01 a
0.15
Apacz 50 WG* Apacz
74.21
9.24 a
0.20
50 WG
75.33
8.84 a
10.0
TI 435 1 GR**
77.11
8.20 a
15.0
TI 435 1 GR
59.35
14.57 a
80.0
Diazinon 10 GR
Dursban 480 EC
2.5
8.92 a
75.12
Pyrinex 480 EC
2.5
10.31 a
71.23
* spray-treatment; ** soil-treatment ***Number followed by the same letter do not differ at
P= 0.05, according to Duncan’s t-test
Insecticide
Rate l/kg/ha
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank Elżbieta Paradowska, Małgorzata Tartanus, Bożena Pawlik and
Stanisław Lesiak for their technical help in conducting the experiments.
501
References
Łabanowska B.H., 1994: Effectiveness of chemical control of strawberry weevil
(Otiorhynchus spp.) in strawberry plantations. J. Fruit and Ornam. Plant Res. 2/4:
157-164.
Łabanowska B.H., Olszak R.W., 2003: The soil pests and their chemical and biological
control on strawberry plantations in Poland. IOBC wprs Bulletin, Vol.26 (2) 2003.:93-99.
Łabanowska B. H., 2007. Control of strawberry root weevils in strawberry plantations (in
polish with English summary). Prog. Plant Protection/Post. Ochr. Roślin, Vol. 47 (1):
284-288.
Tkaczuk C., Łabanowska B. H., Augustyniuk-Kram A. 2005: The potential of
entomopathogenic fungi and nemathodes against strawberry root weevil Otiorhynchus
ovatus L. (Coleoptera, Curculionidae). Insect Pathogens and Insect Parasitic Nematodes
IOBC/wprs Bulletin Vol. 28(3): 173-177.
Penman D. R.. & Scott R. R., 1976. Impact of black vine weevil, Otiorhynchus sulcatus (F.),
on blackcurrants and strawberries in Canterbury. N.Z.J.Expt. Agric. 4:381-384.
Wachowiak H., Mrówczyński M. 2005. Skuteczność chlotianidyny (Apacz 50 WG) w
zwalczaniu stonki ziemniaczanej. Prog. Plant Protection/Post. Ochr. Roślin 45, 2: 1167 1170.
Wilson M., Nitzsche P., Shearer P. W. 1999. Entomopathogenic Nematodes to control Black
Vine Weevil (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) on Starwberry. J. Econ. Entomol. 92, 3: 651657.
502
Trials for the development of alternative control strategies against the
codling moth (Cydia pomonella) in pome fruits in Austria in 2007
C. Lethmayer, H. Hausdorf, J. Altenburger
AGES, Austrian Agency for Health and Food Safety, Institute of Plant Health,
Spargelfeldstraße 191, A-1220 Vienna, Austria. christa.lethmayer@ages.at
Abstract: The development of future alternative control strategies against the codling moth, Cydia
pomonella (Tortricidae, Lepidoptera), is an important subject for the pome fruit production both
nationally and internationally. The reasons are not only the increasing resistance of C. pomonella
against plant protection products including virus products, but also the expiration of the authorization
of important plant protection products especially for integrated production.
In Austria great problems are expected from 2008 onwards due to the loss of the most commonly used
organophosphate insecticide against the codling moth at present. Therefore, in 2007 control trials
against the codling moth also suitable for integrated production were carried out by the Institute of
Plant Health (AGES) in coordination with the chambers of agriculture of Lower Austria and Styria.
Trials were conducted according to the EPPO-guideline PP 1/7(3) comprising 8 variants including one
untreated control. Four plant protection products with Fenoxycarb, Methoxyfenozid, Chlorpyrifos and
Indoxacarb as active ingredients were used in different numbers of applications and combinations.
The untreated control plots showed very high infestation levels (66% infestation). Although the other
treatments resulted in different efficacy levels in the reduction of the pest, the economic damage
threshold (1% infestation) was exceeded in every treatment.
Because the infestation levels of the codling moth and resistance problems increased during the last
years it can be concluded that more effective control strategies have to be developed to ensure the
quality and quantity of pome production for the future.
Key words: Cydia pomonella, pomefruit, control strategy, IPM
503
Microencapsulation and PBO: a tool in resistance management of the
green peach aphid
Emanuele Mazzoni1, Carlotta Gobbi2, Ferdinando Pavesi1, Valerio Borzatta2, Piero
Cravedi1
1
Istituto di Entomologia e Patologia vegetale - Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore –
Piacenza – Italy – emanuele.mazzoni@unicatt.it
2
ENDURA – Research and Development Department – Ravenna – Italy.
Abstract. Insecticide resistance can be a serious threat to the application of Integrated Pest
Management. The Green Peach-Potato Aphid, Myzus persicae (Sulzer) is a serious pest in peach
orchards. Insecticide treatments have selected many populations that have different degrees of
insecticide resistance due to different resistance mechanisms. These resistance mechanisms can
interfere with many classical insecticide classes, but, fortunately, till now, there is no clear evidence
for resistance to neonicotinoids. The severity of this problem is also increased by the reduction of the
available active ingredients that can lead to an abuse of a single group of insecticides. Many
populations of M. persicae, both in Italy and in Europe, over-express a carboxylesterase (E4/FE4) that
reduces in various degrees the efficacy of several insecticides by hydrolysis and/or by sequestering.
Recently, many authors have demonstrated that piperonylbutoxide (PBO) can efficiently interfere with
esterase activity overcoming insecticide resistance. Several microencapsulated products (in polyurea
or cyclodextrin) with PBO and various active ingredients have been tested in laboratory bioassays
against a susceptible and against an esterase resistant population of M. persicae. A comparison was
done with the commercial formulated products alone or mixed with PBO.
The results achieved with the different formulation are discussed in term of increased mortality,
application rate as well as offsprings reduction.
According to the results, the use of these types of microencapsulation together with PBO could be an
interesting tool to be included in resistance management strategies against the green peach-potato
aphid.
Key words: esterases, resistance management, piperonyl-butoxide.
Introduction
The green peach-potato aphid, Myzus persicae (Sulzer), is a serious pest in peach orchards
and in many herbaceous crops because:
• its population abundance grows rapidly above the economic thresholds;
• it transmits plant viruses;
• it is resistant to many insecticide treatments.
Many M. persicae populations have resistance mechanisms that can interfere with
many insecticides classes even if, till now, there is no clear and absolute evidence for
resistance to neonicotinoids (Nauen & Denholm, 2005; Foster et al., 2008). The severity of
this problem is increased by the reduction of the available active ingredients, potentially
leading to the abuse of single insecticides. For the above reported reasons insecticide
resistance is a serious threat to successful application of Integrated Pest Management in
agricultural crops and any tool and/or strategy trying to overcome resistance have to be
exploited.
Many populations of M. persicae over-express a carboxylesterase (E4/FE4) that
reduces the efficacy of several insecticides by hydrolysis and/or by sequestration (Devonshire
504
et al., 1998). Recently, it has been demonstrated that the synergist piperonylbutoxide (PBO)
can efficiently interfere with esterase activity in M. persicae, overcoming insecticide
resistance (Bingham et al., 2008).
The aim of the work is to evaluate the efficacy of different microencapsulated
insecticides together with PBO against resistant M. persicae populations.
Materials and methods
Insects
M. persicae populations used in the present study were originally collected in peach orchards
in Emilia-Romagna (Northern Italy) then maintained as colonies of parthenogenetic females
for several years on pea seedlings (cv “Meraviglia d’Italia”) at 21 °C and 16:8 L:D
photoperiod, without any selection pressure with insecticides. Before use in bioassays the
populations were sub-cloned from a single winged female and a few specimens of the
progeny assayed for total esterase activity and acetylcholinesterase insensitivity according to
a protocol previously described (Devonshire et al., 1992; Mazzoni & Cravedi, 2002). The
biomolecular tests to asses the presence or absence of the mutation in the paratype sodium
channel gene producing the “kdr” phenotype conferring target-site resistance to pyrethroids
have been performed according to Cassanelli et al. (2005).
Bioassays
A series of different insecticide products, listed in tables 1 & 2, have been tested in leaf-dip
bioassays in comparison with a commercial formulation alone or mixed with PBO against an
esterase resistant strain (without “MACE” or “kdr” mutations). A few tests, for comparison,
have been carried out also using a susceptible strain and a “kdr” strain. Mortality data
recorded 24 hours after the treatment were analyzed using probit analysis.
Table 1. Microencapsulated products containing “bifentrin” (PU= polyurea; CD=
cyclodextrin).
Product
EN32-2/16
EN32-2/16/P
EN32-2/17
EN32-2/20
EN32-2/21
a.i.
PBO
Ratio
capsule
(%)
(%) (a.i.:PBO) type
10
PU
10
50
1:5
PU
8.8 19.9
9.9
7.4
17
1 : 2.3
1 : 2.3
CD
CD
CD
Results and discussion
The bioassay procedure adopted did not allow the insect to reach a total mortality applying
commercial formulations of both insecticides against the resistant aphids but the efficacy,
above all against the “kdr” strain, has been increased by a “tank mix” with PBO. Much more
interesting results have been achieved with micro-encapsulation in polyurea and above all in
cyclodextrin. Indeed for both active ingredients a good reduction of the LC50 has been
recorded using cyclodextrin microencapsulation in comparison with the corresponding
commercial formulation: 250 times lower in the case of bifentrin and 90 times in the case of
α-cypermethrin (Graphs 1 – 2). Moreover a lower number of offspring was produced by
505
females surviving the highest concentrations (data not shown).
Table 2. Microencapsulated products containing “α-cypermethrin” (PU= polyurea; CD=
cyclodextrin).
Product
EN32-1/40
EN32-1/52
EN32-1/36
EN32-1/37
EN32-1/46
a.i.
PBO
(%)
(%)
6.1 23.8+6.1
1.3 6.4+19.3
7.8
11.7
7.4
18.3
27.6
18.4
Ratio
capsule
(a.i.:PBO) type
1 : 4.9 PU
1 : 19.8 PU
1 : 2.4
1 : 2.4
1 : 2.5
CD
CD
CD
Graph 1. LC50 of α-cypermethrin products estimated using “probit analysis”. In the case of
cyclodextrin products the LC50 is reduced more than 90 times in comparison with the
commercial formulation.
Conclusions
Although a small scale experiment, some of the microencapsulated products used
demonstrated properties overcoming esterase resistance, improving the performance against
“kdr” strains and allowing a reduction in application doses. The use of microencapsulation
together with PBO could be an effective tool to be considered in resistance management
strategies against the green peach-potato aphid. The evaluation of different active ingredients
is in progress.
506
Graph 2. LC50 of bifentrin products estimated using “probit analysis”. In the case of EN322/21 (cyclodextrin) the LC50 is reduced more than 250 times in comparison with the
commercial formulation.
References
Bingham G., Gunning R.V., Delogu G., Borzatta V., Field L.M. & Moores G.D 2008:
Temporal synergism can enhance carbamate and neonicotinoid insecticidal activity
against resistant crop pests. Pest Manag. Sci. 64: 81–85.
Cassanelli S., Cerchiari B., Giannini S., Bizzaro D., Mazzoni E. & Manicardi G. 2005: Use of
the RFLP-PCR diagnostic test for characterizing MACE and KDR insecticide resistance
in the peach potato aphid Myzus persicae. Pest Manag. Sci. 61: 91-96.
Devonshire, A.L., Devine, G.J. & Moores, G.D. 1992: Comparison of microplate esterase
assays and immunoassay for identifying insecticide resistance variants of Myzus persicae
(Homoptera: Aphididae). Bulletin of Entomological Research 82: 459-463.
Devonshire A.L., Field L.M., Foster S.P., Moores G.D., Williamson M.S. & Blackman R.L.
1998: The evolution of insecticide resistance in the peach-potato aphid, Myzus persicae.
Phil. Trans. Royal. Soc. London Series B – Biological Sciences 353: 1677–1684
Foster S. P., Cox D., Oliphant L., Mitchinson S. & Denholm I. 2008: Correlated responses to
neonicotinoids insecticides in clones of the peach-potato aphid, Myzus persicae
(Hemiptera: Aphididae). Pest. Manag. Sci. 64: 1111–1114.
Mazzoni E. & Cravedi P. 2002: Analysis of insecticide-resistant Myzus persicae (Sulzer)
populations collected in Italian peach orchards. Pest Manag. Sci. 58: 975-980.
Nauen R. & Denholm I. 2005: Resistance of insect pests to neonicotinoid insecticides: current
status and future perspective, Arch. Insect Biochem. Physiol. 58: 200–215.
507
Susceptibility to abamectin of pear psylla, Cacopsylla pyri (L.)
(Hemiptera: Psyllidae) in pear orchards of north-east Spain
Xavier Miarnau1,2, Miquel Artigues 2, Maria José Sarasúa 1,2
1 Universitat de Lleida. Departament de Producció i Ciència Forestal. Av. Rovira Roure, 191,
25198 Lleida, Spain; 2 Centre UdL-IRTA de R+D. Departament de Protecció de cultius. Av.
Rovira Roure, 191, 25198 Lleida, Spain
Abstract: Cacopsylla pyri (L.) (Hemiptera: Psyllidae) is a key pest of pear orchards in the fruit
growing area of north-east Spain. Chemical control is the most common method used against pear
psylla, but the number of insecticides registered to control it has been reduced in the last years.The
high selection pressure with abamectin, applied repeatedly over the whole area, can result in the
appearance of resistance, as has happened with other products. With the aim of monitoring future
changes in the susceptibility of C. pyri to abamectin, we used topical application bioassays in adults,
and residual application in nymphs to obtain current data on the susceptibility in the area. We collected
15 populations from different orchards in Lleida, Huesca and Girona, where heavy use of insecticides
(including abamectin) is the common practice. The bioassays were carried out from October 2004 to
September 2006. To check the evolution of abamectin treatments in the last years we analyzed the
records of the treatments from the different orchards. We obtained the current data, LC50 and LC90 of
all the populations (adults and all instars nymphs). No evidence of a high level of resistance has been
found. However there are a few populations that presented a lower susceptibility, as well in adults as
in nymphs. The populations with the lowest level of susceptibility in nymphs were the same that
presented the lowest level of susceptibility in adults and they came from the fields with the highest
number of insecticide applications.
Cacopsylla pyri, Pear psylla, Abamectin, Resistance, Bioassays, Treatment records
508
Plant infusions to limit the development of pests or diseases : results on
Aphis pomi
Sophie-Joy Ondet
GRAB, Groupe de Recherche en Agriculture Biologique. Site Agroparc, 84911 Avignon cedex
9, France
Abstract: We started research on physiomedicalism in 2003, in order to limit the development of
pests or diseases in an environment-friendly manner. The potential of indigenous medicinal plants is
largely explored and used for human and veterinary medicines, but lately work has started to look at
their potential for providing pesticides for use on cultivated plants. Our preliminary tests target has
been Aphis pomi in apple orchards. To ensure the feasibility of growers using them in the future our
preparations are home-made, from dry medicinal plants. From the literature, six plants were selected
and then tested to see if they would limit the development of Aphis pomi : Artemisia absinthium L.,
Artemisia vulgaris L., Saponaria officinalis L., Mentha x piperata L., Salvia officinalis L., Tanacetum
annuum L. The best results of 2006 and 2007 trials were obtained with the infusions of Mentha x
piperata and Artemisia vulgaris. Results are discussed.
Organic farming, Physiomedicalism, Plant infusions, Aphis pomi
509
Comparison of susceptibility and nychtemerals rhythms between
reared insects of Mediterranean fruit fly (Ceratitis capitata) and wild
population of Algeria treated with a fenthion insecticide.
Salah Oukil1,2, Renè Causse2
1 INRAA Laboratoire de Protection des Végétaux CRP Mahdi Boualem BP 37 Baraki 16210
Alger, Algérie; 2 UMR- INRA/ UAPV. Ecologie des invertébrés, 84914 Avignon Cedex 9,
France
Abstact: Fenthion toxicity was studied with topical application and lethal dose LD 50 and DL 80
were assessed on various C.capitata Wiedemann populations. Toxicity was lower in wild individuals
than in reared insects, among which individuals irradiated at 90 Gy gamma ray were significantly
more susceptible. A nychthemeral variation in the susceptibility to this insecticide was characterized,
with some peculiarities related to the origin of the insects and the LD considered.
Ceratitis capitata, Tephritidae, Wild population, Insecticide, Fenthion, Irradiation, Lethal dose,
Nychthemeral variation.
510
Preliminary resistance screening of abamectin on pear psylla
(Hemiptera: Psyllidae) in Northern Italy
S. Civolani S1, R. Peretto1, C. Chieco 1, M. Chicca1, M. Leis1, E. Pasqualini2
1 Department of Biology and Evolution - University of Ferrara (Italy); 2 DiSTA (Department
of Agroenvironmental Science and Technologies) - University of Bologna (Italy)
Abstract: Civolani S.1, Peretto R.1, Chieco C.1, Chicca M.1, Leis M.1, Pasqualini E.2 1 Department
of Biology and Evolution - University of Ferrara (I) 2 DiSTA (Department of Agroenvironmental
Science and Technologies) - University of Bologna Preliminary resistance screening of abamectin on
pear psylla (Hemiptera: Psyllidae) in Northern Italy . In northern Italy (Emilia-Romagna Region),
integrated pest management (IPM) has been adopted for several years to control pear psylla,
Cacopsylla pyri L. (Hemiptera: Psyllidae), a relevant pest of pear (Pyrus spp.) orchards. After the
outlawing of amitraz in 2005, the most common active ingredient now used for control is abamectin, a
mixture of avermectin B1a and avermectin B1b. After the development of C. pyri resistance to
different active ingredients in several European growing areas, an evaluation using a range of
laboratory tests (topical application on adults, spray application on eggs, leaf dip test on young and old
larvae) were carried out during 2007 and 2008 to assess C. pyri susceptibility to abamectin, using
populations of this pest which had been obtained, from several orchards where a range of control
strategies were being applied. The results are discussed.
Cacopsylla pyri, Abamectin, Resistance, Pear
511
Strategies and timing of protection practices against Cydia pomonella
in apple orchards
Daniel Plénet1, Camille Picard1, Jean-François Toubon1, Olivier Martin2, Rachid
Senoussi2, Benoît Sauphanor1
1
INRA, UMR 1115 Plantes et Systèmes de culture Horticoles, Agroparc, F-84914 Avignon
Cedex 9, France ; 2INRA, Unité Biostatistique et processus spatiaux, Agroparc, F-84914
Avignon, France
Abstract: The understanding of actual farmer practices is essential to identify the constraints for the
adoption of new integrated pest management strategies. From data collected in 2006 in 71 randomised
pear and apple orchards in a small production area in south France, our objective was to comprehend the
management practices against codling moth (Cydia pomonella L.). We first investigated the timing and
frequencies of insecticide applications in relation with national and regional recommendations. The
orchards were classified according to three management strategies: conventional with major use of
chemical insecticides, MD associating mating disruption with chemical pesticides and organic orchards.
For each plot and day, the probability of applying an insecticide was described by a logistic model taking
into account the main variables that influence farmers’ decisions to make the application. The protection
strategies significantly affected the number of insecticides applied against C. pomonella, the application
frequencies during the risk periods of each generation of the pest and the choice of active ingredients.
Farmers followed the application guidelines more closely within MD protection strategy.
Key words: Cydia pomonella, pesticide management practices, application frequency, mating
disruption, organic orchards, timing of spray application.
Introduction
Codling moth (Cydia pomonella L.) is a major pest of apple and pear orchards. Pest
management practices against C. pomonella were analyzed according to three protection
strategies as described by Simon et al., 2007: conventional (Conv) based on a major use of
chemical insecticides, mating disruption (MD) associated with chemical insecticides and
organic (Organic) production based on a large use of microbiological control of codling moth
with granulosis virus (CpGV). The timing and frequency of insecticide spray applications
during the three generations of codling moth were investigated by logistic modelling in
relation with national and regional guidelines. We also examined the alternations of active
ingredients to reduce the selection of insecticide resistance (Boivin et al, 2005).
Material and methods
Sources of data
Data were collected in 2006 in 71 randomised apple and pear orchards in a small production
area near Avignon, in south eastern France. The schedules of pesticide applications were
recorded by inquiry and fruit damages were assessed by visual inspection of 1000 fruits per
orchard in early July (end of G1).
Six risk periods (Fig. 1) were defined according to the rate of egg hatching of each of the
three generations of C. pomonella in this area according to Boivin et al. (2005).
512
Proportion of larvae emergence
Generation 2
Generation 1
1
High
Risk
G1
0.8
Generation 3
High
Risk
G2
High
Risk
G3
0.6
0.4
Low
Risk
G2
Low
Risk
G1
0.2
Low
Risk
G3
0
16/04
06/05
26/05
15/06
05/07
25/07
14/08
03/09
23/09
Days of year 2006
Figure 1. Risk periods related to the egg hatching of the three generations of C. pomonella.
Modelling
In each orchard k at day d, the probability for a farmer to apply an insecticide P (Insecticide)
was modelled using a logistic function that integrated variables that influence farmers’
decisions such as the risk period, the tree species and the history of previous dates of pesticide
applications.
with
P (Insecticide = 1/Hd) = exp(gd) / [1+exp(gd)]
gd = a0 + θ*S + β1*Δt1d + β2*Δt2d + β3*Δt3d + β4*Δt4d + β5*Δt5d + β6*Δt6d
where S is tree species and Hd is the treatment history of the orchard, meaning that Δtjd
measured the part of elapsed time within risk period j since the last insecticide application and
present time d. Model parameters were afterward rendered in terms of mean time lag between
treatments with an estimation of their confidence intervals at α = 95 %.
Results and discussion
Application number
Number of insecticide applications
The number of insecticide applications against C. pomonella was affected by the protection
strategy in apple, but not in pear orchards. MD strategy significantly reduced the number of
insecticide applications (41%) when compared to conventional orchards (Fig.2).
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
F = 19.23 ***
F = 1.35 ns
A
A
B
Conv
MD
Organic
Apple
Apple
Conv
MD
Organic
Pear
Pear
Figure 2. Numbers of insecticide applications against C. pomonella in apple and pear orchards.
Timing of insecticide applications
The mean time lag between two applications was expected to increase in low risk periods
513
according to the national recommendations. The model indicated that (i) in conventional and
organic orchards, the application frequencies did not significantly differ between high risk and
low risk periods and (ii) in MD orchards, the application frequencies correctly followed the
recommendations, apart from the high risk period G3 corresponding to fruit harvest (Fig. 3).
Mean time between applications
40
Generation 1
35
LR-G1
30
HR-G1
Generation 2
LR-G2
$
$
HR-G2
MD
25
20
15
Conv
10
5
HR-G3
Organic
0
16/04
06/05
LR-G3
Generation 3
26/05
15/06
05/07
25/07
Days of year 2006
14/08
03/09
23/09
Figure 3. Mean and confidence intervals of time lag between treatments for each risk period ($
precise values exceeded 70 days).
% of insecticide applications
Alternation of active ingredients
The alternation of insecticide classes in apple orchards (Fig. 4) was very limited in conventional
(85% organophosphates, mostly azinphos-methyl and chlorpyriphos-ethyl) and in organic
orchards (92% granulosis virus (CpGV)).
100%
80%
others
granulosis virus
pyrethroids
organophosphate
60%
40%
20%
0%
Conv
MD
Organic
Figure 4. Alternation of insecticide classes in apple orchards according to protection strategies
Fruit damage
Fruit damage was lower in MD than in organic and conventional orchards, where 50% and 38%
orchards, respectively, had more than 2% infested fruits (Fig. 5).
514
100%
Classes of
fruit damages
% per classe
80%
> 2.0%
0.3 to 2.0%
< 0.3%
60%
40%
20%
0%
Conv
MD
Organic
Figure 5. Fruit damage by C. pomonella in apple orchards according to protection strategies.
Conclusions
The number of insecticides applied against C. pomonella was significantly affected by the
host plant species and by the protection strategy.
Conventional orchards received over 12 treatments against this species, mostly
organophosphates, and no relation was found between the application timing and the intensity
of pest damage risk. However the conventional protection strategy did not completely prevent
the fruit infestation, due to the widespread occurence of insecticide resistance in this area.
Similarly, the 15 CpGV applications (frequency of 6-9 days) did not prevent fruit damage
in organic orchards also due to CpGV resistance in this area (Sauphanor et al., 2006).
Mating disruption allowed a 41% reduction of insecticides applied against C. pomonella,
with satisfying protection in the orchards of our sample. In these orchards, farmers also better
alternated the active ingredients and adapted the timing of applications to risk periods.
The understanding of farmer practices is an essential issue to identify the determinants to
the adoption of integrated pest management strategies. Constraints were linked to windy or
rainy climatic conditions and to spatial separation between orchards (Kaine and Bewsell,
2008), in addition to time consuming technical acts such as thinning and harvesting.
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by INRA ECOGER program (‘Eco des Vergers’ project) and
French National Research Agency program (‘Gedupic’ project).
References
Boivin, T., Chadoeuf, J., Bouvier, J-C., Beslay, D., Sauphanor, B. 2005: Modelling the
interactions between phenology and insecticide resistance genes in the codling moth Cydia
pomonella. Pest Management Science 61: 53-67.
Kaine, G., Bewsell, D. 2008: Adoption of Integrated Pest Management by apple growers: the role
of context. International Journal of pest Management 54: 255-265.
Sauphanor, B. et al 2006. Carpocapse des pommes : cas de résistance au virus de la granulose en
verger biologique. Phytoma 590: 24
Simon, S., Defrance, H., Sauphanor, B. 2007: Effect of codling moth management on orchard
arthropods. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 122: 340-348.
515
Insecticide resistance of Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera:
Tortricidae) eggs and first larval instars in Spanish field populations
Marcela Rodríguez, Dolors Bosch, Tânia Marques, Jesús Avilla
Department of Crop and Forest Sciences, and Center UdL-IRTA for R+D, University of
Lleida, Av. Rovira Roure 191, 25198 Lleida, Spain
Abstract: To know the efficacy of insecticides on Codling moth (Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera:
Tortricidae)) Spanish field populations of this insect were collected from orchards with heavy damage
and the mortality caused by the LC90 of a susceptible strain (S_Lleida) was recorded. Five ovicides
and 7 larvicides were tested on eggs and first instar larvae (L1), respectively, from field populations.
Commercial and technical products were used for L1 and eggs, respectively. Eggs were topically
treated (0.1 µl/egg) and L1 were exposed to semiartificial diet treated on its surface (2 µl/cm2). Every
insecticide showed an efficacy significantly lower than its efficacy for S_Lleida for at least one
population. The majority of the field populations were significantly less sensitive to the insecticides
than S_Lleida was (96 % and 70% for ovicides and larvicides, respectively). Fenoxycarb and
thiacloprid were the most effective ovicides, and lambda cyhalothrin, alpha cypermethrin and
chlorpyrifos-ethyl were the most effective larvicides. For three field populations, an inverse
relationship between the efficacy of azinphos-methyl and chlorpyriphos-ethyl was observed.To know
the role played by detoxification mechanisms, esterase (EST), mixed-function oxidase (MFO) and
glutathione-S-transferase (GST) activity was evaluated on L1. Seventy percent of field populations
showed a MFO activity significantly higher than the susceptible one, but only one of them also
showed higher EST and GST activity.
Cydia pomonella, insecticide resistance, field populations, eggs, L1, detoxication enzymatic activity.
516
Molecular detection of pest resistance to insecticides
Myriam Siegwart, Juliette Goussopoulos, Jérôme Olivares
PSH – Ecologie de la Production Intégrée, INRA Site Agroparc, 84914 Avignon Cedex 9,
France.
Abstract : Insecticide resistance occurs at three levels in insects : i) stopping penetration through barrier
tissues ii) conjugation, storage, and metabolisation in internal tissues iii) modification of the molecular
target site. The detection of these biological adaptations is often realized by the use of bioassays. This
technique allows characterizing the resistance level of a population to a given compound, but is not
informative on the mechanism. Therefore, it limits the potential of investigation and resistance
management becomes more difficult. Molecular detection can be useful, enabling the identification of
target mutations, and the modifications in the expression or the structure of detoxifying enzymes.
Acetylcholine esterase and the sodium channel are two important molecular targets of organophosphosphates (OPs), carbamates and pyretroids, respectively. The study of gene sequences allows the
development of molecular tools in order to screen field populations.
We have already developed some molecular tools to detect pyrethroid resistance in Cydia
pomonella. We are now investigating the molecular structure of target sites in other pest species,
including Cydia molesta aiming to define new molecular tools for resistance detection. The first results
are presented and discussed.
Key words: resistance, insecticides, molecular detection, acetylcholine esterase, sodium channel
Introduction
Insecticide resistance involves three main mechanisms in insects i) reducing the penetration
through barrier tissues ii) insecticide conjugation, storage, and metabolisation in internal
tissues iii) modification of the molecular target of the insecticide. The detection of these
biological adaptations is usually obtained using biotests, which allow the determination of the
resistance levels to the different compounds, regardless of the mechanism. This technique
requires numerous insects at a defined developmental stage for each insecticide tested.
Molecular detection may therefore be an interesting tool, allowing a genotype characterization
at the individual insect level and making it easy to identify target mutations, expression or
structural modifications of detoxification enzymes that may or may not lead to cross
resistances.
This study focused on the codling moth Cydia pomonella and the oriental fruit moth
Cydia molesta. The acetylcholine esterase and sodium channel sequences of the first species are
already published whereas those of the second are not. Firstly, we developped routine molecular
tests to detect kdr mutations in the sodium chanel of codling moth field populations. We then
tried to identify mutations on two molecular targets of insecticides in C. molesta.
Material and methods
Insects
Three C. pomonella populations were collected in treated orchards with different insecticide
programs (reduced treatments for 1, 2 or 3 years). A fourth population originating from an
untreated experimental orchard was considered as a reference.
Acethylcholine esterase gene was sequenced in six C. molesta individuals, one coming
517
from a susceptible reference strain and five from treated orchards expected to host OPresistant populations.
Routine molecular tests in C. pomonella
The genetic variability of a 169 bp fragment in the sodium channel gene was analysed by
PCR-RFLP. This fragment encompasses the mutation L1014F which is linked with pyrethroid
resistance (Brun-Barale et al., 2005).
Rapid genomic DNA extraction was obtained from an adult leg with 10% Chelex 100
(Bio-rad) solution and 10mg/ml proteinase K (Walsh et al. 1991). After a five-fold dilution,
this extract was used as a DNA template for PCR amplifications.
PCR amplifications were carried out in a 12 µl reaction volume containing, 1X GoTaq
buffer (Promega), 200µM of each dNTPs, 0.208µM of each fluorescent labelled or not CPNa
F forward primer (5’-TAGAGAGCATGTGGGATTGC-3’), 0.416µM of reverse primer CPNa R (5’AATTTCGTAGCCCTTGATCG-3’) (Franck et al. 2007), 1.5 mM of MgCl2, 0.1 mg/ml of BSA,
0.75 Unit of GoTaq and 2µl of DNA template. Thermal conditions were as follows: 94°C for
3min, followed by 35 cycles of 94°C for 30s, 55°C for 60s and 74°C for 45s.
A quantity of 5 µl of the PCR product was subsequently digested with 1 unit of the
restriction enzyme Tsp509I (NEB) in 25 µl reaction volume at 65°C for 16 hr. Using a licor
IR4200 sequencer , 62 samples could be run in one acrylamide-bisacrilamide (6.5%) gel.
Characterization of the mutations
900 pb of acethylcholine esterase and 1343 pb of sodium channel genes were sequenced for
the first time in oriental fruit month, in order to find mutations potentially involved in OP or
pyrethroid resistance.
Total DNA extraction from oriental fruit moth was based on hexadecyl-trimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) protocol by Murray & Thompson (1980). Adult were ground in
200µl of proteinase K (0.3 mg/ml) and incubated over night at 56°C. Lysis occured at 65°C
during 1 hour by adding 300µl of lysis buffer (TRIS-HCl 200mM, EDTA 50mM, NaCl 2M,
CTAB 2%) and 100µl of sarcosyl 5%. Proteins were precipitated and separated by
chlorophorm-isoamylalcohol (24:1) treatment. Nucleic acids were precipitated at -20°C after
adding one volume of isopropanol. DNA pellet was washed in ethanol and resuspended in
60µl of miliQ water. PCR amplifications were carried out in a 25 µl reaction volume
containing, 1X GoTaq buffer (Promega), 200µM of each dNTPs, 0.4µM of each primer :
ACE 1S (5’-CCCAGACCTGTTGAAAGCTG-3’) and ACE 1R (5’-TGCTCTCTGGTAATGCCTACG-3’)
for ace-1 or Super KdrF(5’-GGCCGACAGTTAATTTACTCATC-3’) and Intron 2 SKdr R (5’GCAATCCCACATGCTCTCTA-3’) following by Kdr mol F (5’-GGTGGAACTTCACCGACTTC-3’) and
CgD 2 (5’-CAAGGCTAAGAAAAGGTTAAG-3’) (Brun-Barale et al., 2005) for para voltagedependant sodium channel, one Unit of GoTaq and 2µl of DNA template. Thermal conditions
were as follows: 94°C for 3min, followed by 35 cycles of 94°C for 30s, 55°C for 60s and
74°C for 2min. ACE 1S, ACE 1R primer were designed on codling moth cydpom-ace1
sequence, noted in the GenBank database under the reference DQ267977 (Cassanelli et al.
2006). Super Kdr F and intron 2 SKdr R primer were designed on codling moth sodium
channel gene (AY763097). Kdr mol F primer was found on the C molesta sequence
determined previously, and CgD 2 is defined by Brun-Barale (2007).
PCR fragments obtained (1080 pb for ace-1, 1245 pb (super Kdr F/intron 2 Skdr R) and
250 pb (Kdr mol/CgD 2) for para) were purified after visualisation from 1% agarose gel with
the QIAquick® Gel Extraction Kit and directly sequenced (Genome expess). Data analysis
were performed with the BioEdit free software.
518
Results and discussion
PCR-RFLP diagnostic test
Table 1 shows the proportion of kdr mutations found in four populations of C. pomonella
subjected to different crop protection programs.
Table 1. Proportion of C. pomonella individuals carrying a kdr mutation in the sodium
channel
susceptible
trt stop 3 year ago
trt stop 2 years ago
trt stop 1 years ago
% individuals
ss
sr
rr
93.5
6.5
86.0 14.0
80.0
2.0
82.3 17.7 2.2
Number of
individuals
46
50
55
45
The kdr mutation was present in the four C pomonella populations, even in the absence
of selection pressure (6.5% heterozygotes in the susceptible population). So, the fitness cost
of this mutation is presumably low making resistance management difficult, as attested by the
high rate of mutation several years after relaxing the chemical protection. Due to the
widespread nature of the kdr mutation, the use of pyrethroids against this species may rapidly
lead to the selection of homozygous resistant individuals.
Sequence analysis
Sodium channel : Using primers designed for C. pomonella we successfuly amplified part of
the sodium channel gene in C. molesta and sequenced it. Few differences were detected
between these two tortricidae in exons (11 mutations), but sequenced introns showed many
differences in size and composition compared to C. pomonella. Protein sequences were
strictly similar in susceptible codling moth and oriental fruit moth.
Acetylcholine Esterase : The same method was used for this gene. A longer part of ace-1
sequence was obtained. No differences of sequence were found among the five individuals
sequenced. 77 point differences were found between the DNA sequences of C. molesta and C.
pomonella, 3 of them being responsible of protein variation (Figure 1). These 3 amino acids
are well conserved in other species. They are presumably not involved in the enzyme
conformation and activity.
519
*
Figure 1. Alignment of protein sequences of C. molesta (consensus sequence of 5 individuals)
and C. pomonella (Cassanelli et al. 2006) resistant cydpom-ace1 allele. *MACE mutation (F290
in Torpedo AChE)
The discovery of these sequences initiated the research into mutations in resistant
populations.
Acknowledgements
We would like to acknowledge Alan Knight for providing us with wild populations of C.
pomonella. We thank Pierre Franck and Benoit Sauphanor for critical review of the manuscript.
References
Brun-Barale, A., Bouvier, J.C., Pauron, D., Berge, J.B., Sauphanor, B. 2005: Involvement of a
sodium channel mutation in pyrethroid resistance in Cydia pomonella L, and development
of a diagnostic test. Pest Management Science 61(6): 549-554.
Cassanelli, S., Reyes, M., Rault, M., Manicardi, G.C., Sauphanor, B. 2006: Acetylcholinesterase
mutation in an insecticide resistant population of the codling moth Cydia pomonella (L.).
Insect Biochemistry and Molecular Biology 36: 642-653.
Franck, P., Reyes, M., Olivares, J., Sauphanor, B. 2007: Genetic differentiation in the codling
moth: comparison between microsatellite and insecticide resistant markers. Molecular
Ecology 16(17): 3554-64.
Murray, M.G., Thompson, W.F. 1980: Rapid isolation of high molecular weight plant DNA.
Nucleic Acids Res 8: 4321-25.
Walsh, P.S., Metzger, D.A., Higuchi, R. 1991: Chelex (R)100 as a medium for simple extraction
of DNA for PCR-based typing from forensic material. Biotechniques 10: 507.
520
New isolates of CpGV overcome virus resistance of codling moth
Daniel Zingg
Andermatt Biocontrol AG, Stahlermatten 6, 6146 Grossdietwil, Switzerland
Abstract: Since 2004 codling moth (Cydia pomonella) populations with resistance towards the
Mexican isolate of Cydia pomonella granulovirus (CpGV) have been found in Austria, France,
Germany, Holland, Italy and Switzerland. In the following years Andermatt Biocontrol developed
Madex Plus and several other new virus isolates, which can overcome the resistance. The new isolates
were selected on virus resistant codling moth populations in the laboratory. The virus isolates were
tested on sensitive and virus-resistant codling moth populations in laboratory bioassays and in field
trials. All tested new virus isolates showed a good efficacy on sensitive codling moth larvae
comparable to or better than the Mexican isolate. Also all the new virus isolates gave good control of
Mexican isolate-resistant codling moth populations. Andermatt Biocontrol is thus able to offer
products based on new virus isolates that present the solution against virus resistance.
Codling moth, Cydia pomonella, Granulovirus, CpGV, Resistance, New isolates
521
Evaluation of technical scenarios for the peach-brown rot system using
a virtual fruit model simulating quality and storage potential
Caroline Gibert1, Pierre Rouet1, Claude Bruchou2, Gilles Vercambre1, Michel Génard1,
Daniel Plénet1, Philippe Nicot3, Joël Chadœuf2, Françoise Lescourret1
INRA, 1Plantes et Systèmes de culture Horticoles, UR 1115, 2Biostatistiques & Processus
Spatiaux, UR 546, Domaines St Paul, Site Agroparc, 84914 Avignon Cedex 9, 3Pathologie
Végétale, UR 407, Domaine St Maurice, BP 94, 84143 Montfavet Cedex
Abstract : Improving fruit quality while reducing pesticide and water use supports both consumers’
requirements and environmental and health concerns. This objective promotes some alternative
technical scenarios that use more cultural than chemical control for pest management. Our study
focused on the peach-brown rot system (Monilinia laxa). It aims at determining sets of cultural options
providing an optimal trade-off between revenue build-up, consumers’ requirements and environmental
impacts. We used a modelling approach to simulate technical scenarios by using a virtual fruit model
describing the seasonal changes in peach fruit quality traits during final swelling under the influence
of climatic, biotic and cultural factors. We defined 243 virtual scenarios based on agronomical and
epidemiological inputs (time and intensity of thinning, irrigation, cultivar choice and disease control).
Virtual scenarios were evaluated on a multi-criteria profile of performance integrating storage
potential, organoleptic and environmental factors, according to different objectives of profitability,
water saving and no pathogen entry (cuticular crack) on fruits. Scenarios including water stress during
final swelling are promising while requiring an evolution of market standards.
Key words : brown rot, cuticular crack, fruit quality, irrigation, modelling, peach, profitability,
thinning, storage potential, water saving.
Introduction
Integrated fruit production (IFP) objectives are to produce high quality fruits in an
economically sustainable way by minimizing pesticides and resources use to preserve both
health and the environment (Cross & Dickler, 1994). The question of the reduction of
pesticides points out the necessity to study the interactions between fruit-trees and pests under
the influence of cultural practices in order to find some alternatives for pest management. But
how can we design technical scenarios integrating agronomical and environmental
considerations? A modelling approach is well adapted in a first step to evaluate a large range
of production systems to better target an experimental stage. Moreover, the complexity of
fruit quality profiling also requires this approach to represent underlying processes, their
interactions and the influence of environmental (climatic or biotic) and cultural variations
(irrigation and crop load) on their expression. We focused our work on the peach-brown rot
system (M. laxa). Thinning and irrigation are the main cultural practices modifying peach
fruit growth (Naor et al., 1997). By using and improving an existing virtual fruit model
(Lescourret & Génard, 2005), we constructed various technical scenarios reflecting various
cultural practices and evaluated them on their ability to provide a correct trade-off by
considering a multi-criterion profile of quality. Results are presented.
Materials and methods
Description of the integrated virtual fruit predicting outputs of agronomical interest
522
(quality and storage potential)
The virtual peach fruit model simulates the seasonal changes in several peach fruit quality
traits during the final swelling of a “mean” fruit on the shoot-bearing-fruit (Lescourret &
Génard, 2005). The model runs at a daily time step. It was developed by integrating three
existing process-based models describing fruit dry mass growth, sugar accumulation and
water accumulation, respectively (Figure 1). It was improved by integrating (i) the variation
of fruit surface conductance and its components (cuticle, stomata and cuticular cracks) in
relation with the fruit growth (this variable being implicated in fresh mass and sugar content)
and (ii) an epidemiological function predicting the storage potential according to fruit
growing conditions and the inoculum pressure of M. laxa. The integrated model is fully
described in Gibert (2007).
Figure 1. General scheme of the modified virtual peach fruit mo del. External variables are
underlined arrows indicate data flows and dashed lines represent feedback information
(adapted from Lescourret and Génard, 2005).
Construction of 243 virtual technical scenarios
Virtual technical scenarios were developed to reflect various cultural practices (cultivar
choice, time and intensity of thinning, irrigation level, disease control). These agronomical
and epidemiological factors were described through a parameter characterising the
susceptibility to cuticular cracking (SCC), the fruit dry mass at thinning (FDMT), the
shoot:fruit ratio (fruit crop load, FLC), the sequences of leaf and stem water potentials (IL)
and the inoculum density (ID). For each factor, three distinct levels were applied to simulate
contrasted situations, that is altogether 243 virtual scenarios detailed in Table 1. Irrigation
levels were considered to vary with the fruit crop load (Naor et al., 1997) when water was
limited.
523
Table 1. Details about the construction of the 243 virtual technical scenarios.
Agronomical and
epidemiological
Levels of variation
factors
Susceptibility to
cuticular cracking
Low
Moderate
High
(SCC)
Fruit dry mass at
Small
Median
Large
thinning (FDMT)
Low
Intermediate
Normal
Fruit crop load (FCL)
Water stressed
Water stressed
Well
Irrigation level (IL)
during pit
during final
irrigated
hardening
swelling
Low
Moderate
High
Inoculum density (ID)
Definition of multi-criteria profile of performances
The five quality traits of interest were studied at harvest for each virtual scenario: the
sweetness index (SI; Kulp et al., 1991), the flesh dry matter content (FDMC), the ratio of
flesh per fruit fresh mass (FFFM), the cuticular crack density (CCD) indicative of shrivelling
during storage, the fruit fresh mass which corresponds to a commercial grade and the
probability of fruit infection by M. laxa. These two later variables were associated into the
revenue calculation (R; €/tree). Each quality traits were separated into four classes described
by colours in Table 2.
Table 2. Description of classes for quality traits constituting the profile of performances
Classes
Quality traits
Very low
Low
Intermediate High
Sweetness index (%, SI)
≤ 5.5
5.5 < ≤ 6.5 6.5 < ≤ 7.5 > 7.5
Flesh dry matter content (%, FDMC)
≤ 10
10 < ≤ 12.5 12.5 < ≤ 15 > 15
Flesh per fruit fresh mass ratio (%, FFFM)
90 < ≤ 92.5 92.5 < ≤ 95 > 95
≤ 90
>9
Cuticular crack density (%, CCD)
3<≤6
6<≤9
≤3
Revenue (€/tree, R)
0
0 < ≤ 100 100 < ≤ 200 > 200
Evaluation of scenarios according to distinct objectives: profitability, water saving and no
pathogen entry
We analysed and classified the different scenarios by considering the profile of performances
at harvest in relation with distinct objectives corresponding: (i) to the present market
standards or profitability, which only consider the fruit commercial grade, (ii) to a will of
water saving or (iii) to an avoid of the chemical protection by deciding to produce fruits
presenting no cuticular crack, that is no pathogen entry.
524
Results and discussion
Results of the evaluation of the scenarios according to the distinct objectives mentioned above
are presented in Table 3. The most beneficial scenarios corresponded to what is currently done
and recommended: big commercial grade that is very interesting in terms of revenue for
growers, irrigation restricted during a short period (pit hardening) and a lot of applications of
fungicide to control the disease pressure. Fruits from these scenarios present a poor quality
profile: big size, slightly sweetened and presenting a short shelf life (very high CCD). In
comparison, an other set of cultural options only differing by a long but moderate water
restriction during the final swelling leads to a better trade-off for the fruit quality profile. It
improved the sweetness index, the flesh dry matter content and its post-harvest shelf life.
Moreover, this scenario could be very attractive for producers and consumers since they
contribute to water saving. Fruits without any cuticular crack required a normal crop load, to
choose small fruit at thinning date, and a water restriction during the final swelling. Although
they are no lucrative nowadays (commercial grade out of standards), this scenario produced
fruits of good quality (high SI, FDMC, FFFM). Moreover, it could be adopted to a large range
of situations of production, i.e. different cultivar susceptibility to cracking and various
inoculum densities. Such scenarios, though economical in terms of water use and fungicides
while preserving fruit quality and environment, do not meet the present standards but could be
considered in the future, in case of segmentation of supply proposed to consumers by retailers
(Parker, 1993), or for technical practices based on IFP guidelines.
The model presented here gave the opportunity to evaluate several technical scenarios on their
profile of agronomical performances according to a large point of view combining the present
market standards, which only consider the fruit commercial grade and IFP requirements that
include the consumers’ satisfaction and environmental concerns.
Table 3. Virtual scenarios selected for their adequacy with objectives of profitability, water
saving and fruits presenting no cuticular crack (no pathogen entry)
Inputs
Criteria of performances
Objectives
SCC ID FDMT IL FCL SI PDMC FFFM CCD R
Profitability
Water saving
No pathogen
entry
Acknowledgements
This work was funded by grants from INRA’s departments “EA” and “SPE” and region
PACA. This research was supported by grants from program # 12-E/2003 CV 300099 and an
‘Irriqual’ program # FP6-FOOD-CT-2006-023120.
525
References
Cross, J. & Dickler, E. (1994). Guidelines for integrated fruit production of pome fruits in
Europe, 2nd edition IOBC/WPRS Bulletin, 17, 1-8.
Gibert, C. (2007). Cuticular crackoccurrence on peach fruit (Prunus persica (L.) Batsch) in
relation with cultural practices. Outcomes on quality and brown rot development. PhD,
Université d’Avignon et des Pays de Vaucluse, ED 380 “Sciences et Agronomie”, pp154.
Kulp K., Lorenz K. & Stone M. (1991). Functionality of carbohydrate ingredients in bakery
products. Food Technology, 45, 136-142.
Lescourret, F. & Génard, M. (2005). A virtual peach fruit model simulating changes in fruit
quality during the final stage of fruit growth. Tree Physiology, 25, 1303-1315.
Naor, A., Hupert, H., Greenblat, Y., Peres, M., Kaufman, A. & Klein, I. (1997). The effect of
irrigation and crop load on stem water potential and apple fruit size. Journal of
Horticultural Science & Biotechnology, 72, 765-771.
Parker, D. (1993). Retail price response to quality characteristics of fresh peaches by store
type. Agribusiness, 9, 205-215.
526
Codling moth (Cydia pomonella L.) egg-laying behaviour on host and
non-host Malus sp. and leaf surface metabolites.
Nadia Lombarkia and Sylvie Derridj.
INRA, UMR 1272 PISC : Insect Physiology Signalisation and Communication, Route de
Saint-Cyr, 78026 Versailles Cedex France.
Abstract: Cydia pomonella (C. pomonella) is the main pest of Malus domestica (M. d.). Malus
floribunda (M. f.) which is used in orchards to cross pollinate trees, shows no C. pomonella damage.
We observed on single trees without any alternative that 60 % of females may lay eggs on M. d. (41
eggs) vs. 0 % on M. f.. After collecting and analyzing, by gas chromatography, leaf surface
metabolites, we were able to test the known active metabolite pattern on females to confirm the tree
observations. Acceptance and egg-laying was reduced by the M. f. metabolite pattern. The gravid
female behavior was observed on trees in no-choice controlled conditions. On both Malus. sp. females
preferred to land on the upper side of corymb leaves and on the fruits. Then females generally
remained on the site where they had landed. The behavioural difference to both Malus sp. was
observed at the stage of ovipositor scanning, which was linked to egg-laying. Scanning was
dramatically reduced on M. f. and the locomotion speed was lower. Host and non-host characters
belonged to the egg-laying stage and non volatile metabolites.
Key words: Cydia pomonella, Malus domestica, egg-laying, sugars, behaviour.
Introduction
For some Lepidoptera species the correct choice of the host plant by the female is critical. The
female has to choose the food source of her offspring without any direct access to feeding
sites of larvae which are relatively immobile after hatching (Renwick and Chew, 1994;
Schoonhoven et al., 1998).
C. pomonella is one of the most important insect pests in orchards, especially in apple
(M. d.) production. However, there is no damage to M. f. used as a source of pollen in
orchards. An egg-laying stimulating blend including glucose, fructose, sucrose, sorbitol,
quebrachitol and myo-inositol has already been identified from the surface of apple
(Lombarkia and Derridj, 2002). The ratios between these metabolites within the blend are
mainly responsible for the resistance of an apple tree cultivar (X65-11) to C. pomonella egglaying (Lombarkia and Derridj, 2008). This poses the questions: i) where is the localized M. f.
resistance, ii) what is the metabolite blend concerned, iii) at which behavioural step is
resistance perceived by the moth?
Material and methods
Collect of leaf surface metabolites and chemical analysis in GC-FID
Metabolites were collected on both Malus sp. during the egg-laying periods at twilight at the
period of maximum egg-laying for the second flight. The collecting process consisted of
spraying ultra-pure water on leaves and fruit (Fiala et al., 1990). Four replicates per species
consisting of one cluster per tree were sampled. A cluster composed of four leaves for M. d.
and six for M. f.. The collecting method was the same as described in Lombarkia and Derridj
(2008).
527
Egg-laying behaviour on artificial substrate
The six metabolite blends at similar concentrations to those that occur on the corymb leaves
of both Malus sp. were presented in no-choice conditions to single gravid female per cage.
Cages were lined with nylon cloths impregnated with ultra-pure water (control), see method
by Lombarkia and Derridj (2002).
Apple trees
Both Malus sp. were two years old, two meters high, cultivated in greenhouse, and tested at
the stage J “growth of fruits” following Baggiolini stages. A single tree was used for each
Malus sp.. M. d. Reine des Reinettes variety was used for behavioral observations. It is
codling moth susceptible. M. f. (Baugène clone) is a good pollinating variety (INRA Angers
1985) and resistant to scab.
Behavior observations
The behavioral observations on trees were carried out in a climatic chamber: 23 ±2°C, 70
±10% (r.h.) and 16:8 (L:D). The egg-laying of C. pomonella starts just after the scotophase
(Lombarkia, 2002). We fixed the beginning of the scotophase at 1700 h, so that tree
physiology corresponded to the insect egg laying. The duration of the observation was fixed at
one hour of darkness from 1700 to 1800 h, during which more than 1/3 of females layed eggs
on the tree. During the observation periods, the climatic chamber was lit with red light (60
W). On each species five gravid females having already laid eggs during 48 hours in boxes
were released together, in no-choice conditions, on a single tree placed in a large mesh (1
mm) cage (1.5 m x 1.5 m x 3 m). Females were released on four successive days from 1700 to
1800 h solar time. Ten minutes before the beginning of the experiment, the tree was
transferred from the greenhouse to the climatic chamber for the observation and after the
insect test placed back in the greenhouse. A tape recorder (Pearlcorder S 928) with cassettedeck (TDK, MC-60) was used to record the female behavior. The data processing was carried
out on a laptop. Different behavioral parameters were directly recorded or calculated:
walking, stopping, ovipositor scanning while walking, ovipositor scanning while stopping,
locomotion speed, distance covered.
Statistical analysis
Means of speed of locomotion were compared by Mann-Whitney test (P < 0.05). The χ² test
was used to compare the proportions of soluble carbohydrates and sugar alcohols (within each
group) between the two Malus sp. The comparison of the proportions of egg-laying females
was made using the χ² test (P < 0.05). The Mann-Whitney test (P < 0.05) was used to compare
the number of eggs laid per female on each substrate.
Results and discussion
Leaf surface metabolites and chemical analysis in GC-FID
Chemical analyses of the M. f. metabolite pattern showed a difference from M. d. (Derridj et
al., 1999). Opposite ratios between the two chemical groups gathering three soluble
carbohydrates (61.7 ±11.9) on M. d. vs. (29.9 ±2.7) on M. f. and of the three sugar alcohols
(38.3 ±11.9) on M. d. vs. (70.1 ±2.7) on M. F.. Furthermore, M. f. metabolites were higher
than M. d. (ratio: 8).
Egg-laying on artificial substrate
A blend of six synthetically produced M. f. metabolites showed a reduction of egg-laying
behaviour (10 ±0.00) and stimulation (0.8 ±0.5) vs. M. d. (43.3 ±2.8 and 10.3 ±3.3) and the
water control (50 ±1.8 and 6.7 ± 1.6). These results suggest that the non-acceptance for egg-
528
laying on M. f. could be related to higher ratios and concentrations of sugar alcohols.
Egg-laying behaviour on trees
Four main sequential behaviors of females were highlighted:
Landing on the apple tree surface, Visiting (staying on a site), exploring the site by
walking, stopping, ovipositor scanning while walking or stopping, Acceptance or nonacceptance for egg-laying.
n = 40
100%
16
% 53
31 %
%
18%
25%
89%
14 3%
%
13%
44%
LANDING
Other sites
Fruit
11%
83
%
VISITING
Lower side of corymb leaves
Upper side of corymb leaves
Figure 1: Malus sp. tree sites for landing and then visiting after landing by females (%).
The upper side of the corymb leaves and fruits were the preferred sites for landing and then
visiting for both Malus sp. (Figure 1). 66.7 % of females which layed eggs scanned with their
ovipositor while walking vs. 22.2% which did not lay eggs. Their speed of locomotion was
also higher (0.6 ± 0. vs. 0.3 ± 0.03).
The stimuli, which generated the egg-laying, may have been perceived by receptors on the
legs and the ovipositor by scanning while walking. The examination of the plant surface by
ovipositor scanning in C. pomonella is necessary for the egg-laying. In Acrolepiopsis
assectella (Acrolepiidae) and Plutella xylostella (Plutellidae) examination of the plant surface
by the antennae and the ovipositor before the egg-laying are typical (Justus and Mitchell,
1996; Thibout and Auger, 1996). Spencer (1996) observed that Plutella xylostella
(Plutellidae) examines the surface with the ovipositor only after meeting stimuli for egglaying with its tarsi or its antennae.
In addition to primary metabolites, other cues are available on the plant surface, (E,E)-αfarnesene, in particular, influence landing and egg-laying of codling moth (Bengtsson et al.,
2001; Ansebo et al., 2004; Witzgall et al., 2005).This study shows that on M. f., which is a
non host plant, C. pomonella lands in the same way as on its host plant. The non-host is
perceived in contact with plant surface, before scanning with the ovipositor. This may mean
that there is a deterrent detected by legs or there is no positive stimulation for ovipositor
scanning. The lower locomotion speed on M. f. may mean there is a deterrent effect. Results
with the synthetically produced blend of the M. f. surface highlighted the importance of non
volatile primary metabolites in ovipositor scanning behavior and confirmed their early effect
at the acceptance stage. These behavioral observations may help in recognizing new methods
for apple tree protection based on surface metabolites and the plant resistance.
529
References
Ansebo L, MDA Coracini, M Bengtsson, I Liblikas, M Ramirez et al. 2004: Antennal and
behavioural response of codling moth Cydia pomonella to plant volatiles. J.Appl.
Entomol. 128: 488-493.
Bengtsson M, A-C Bäckman, I Liblikas, MI Ramirez, A-K Borg-Karlson et al. 2001: Plant
odour analysis of apple: antennal response of codling moth females to apple volatiles
during phenological development. J. Agric. Food Chem. 49: 3736-3741.
Derridj, S., I. Cabanat, E. Cochet, P. Couzi, N. Lombarkia & B.R. Wu 1999: Incidence des
métabolites présents à la surface des organes du pommier sur le comportement de Cydia
pomonella (Lepidoptera, Tortricidae); A.N.P.P. 5ème conférence internationale sur les
ravageurs en agriculture. Montpellier, 7-8-9 décembre, II, p279-286.
Fiala V., C. Glad, M. Martin, E. Jolivet & S. Derridj 1990: Occurrence of soluble
carbohydrates on the phylloplane of Maize (Zea mays L.): variations in relation to leaf
heterogeneity and position on the plant. New Phytol. 115: 609-615.
Justus K.A. & B.K. Mitchell 1996: Oviposition site selection by the diamondback moth,
Plutella xylostella (L.) (Lepidoptera, Plutellidae). J. Insect Beh. 9: 887-898.
Lombarkia N. 2002: Influence de métabolites présents à la surface des organes du pommier
sur la ponte du carpocapse Cydia pomonella L. (Lepidoptera, Tortricidae). Application à
l’étude de la résistance du pommier au ravageur. Thèse doctorat. Université Rennes 1,
Rennes, France.
Lombarkia N. & S. Derridj 2002: Incidence of apple and leaf surface metabolites on Cydia
pomonella oviposition. Entomol. Exper. et Applic. 104: 79-87.
Lombarkia N. & S. Derridj 2008: Resistance of apple trees to Cydia pomonella egg-laying
due to leaf surface metabolites. Entomol. Exper. et Applic. 128(1): 57-65.
Renwick J.A.A. & F.S. Chew 1994: Oviposition behaviour in Lepidoptera. Ann. Rev.
Entomol. 39: 337-400.
Schoonhoven L.M., T. Jermy & J.J.A. Van Loon 1998: Host–plant selection: when to accept a
plant. In: Insect-Plant Biology. From Physiology to Evolution. Ed. Chapman & Hall,
156-193.
Spencer J.L. 1996: Waxes enhance Plutella xylostella oviposition in response to sinigrin and
cabbage homogenates. Entomol. Exper. et Applic. 80: 165-173.
Thibout E. & J. Auger 1996: Oviposition stimulants from the leek for the specialist moth
Acrolepiosis assectella. Entomol. Exper. et Applic. 80 : 101-104.
Witzgall P, L Ansebo, Z Yang, G Angeli, B Sauphanor & M Bengtsson 2005: Plant volatiles
affect oviposition by codling moths. Chemoecology 15: 77-83.
530
Apple resistance to arthropod herbivores: genetic basis and
modification by environmental factors
Karsten Mody1, Sibylle Stoeckli1, Cesare Gessler2, Silvia Dorn1
1 ETH Zurich, Institute of Plant Sciences / Applied Entomology, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland
2 ETH Zurich, Institute of Integrated Biology / Plant Pathology, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland
Abstract: Arthropod herbivores reduce the quantity and quality of apple yield. Resistant apple varieties
hold promise to increase the sustainability of pest management in orchards, but little is known on the
genetic basis of apple resistance to most arthropod herbivores. Knowledge on the apple genome and
QTL (quantitative trait locus) analysis is now facilitating the identification of gene regions associated
with resistance. 160 F1-progeny plants of a cross of the apple varieties 'Fiesta' and 'Discovery' were
surveyed at three different sites in Switzerland. Herbivore infestation per genotype as a measure of
resistance was quantified for the apple aphids Dysaphis plantaginea, Dysaphis cf. devecta and Aphis
pomi, the apple rust mite Aculus schlechtendali, and the codling moth Cydia pomonella. The influence of
the environmental factor 'drought stress' on apple resistance to a chewing and a sap-feeding herbivore
(caterpillar; aphid) was studied in laboratory experiments considering different intensities of pulsed
drought stress. Significant QTLs for resistance to D. plantaginea, D. cf. devecta, A. schlechtendali, and
C. pomonella were detected. SSR alleles associated to the QTLs may be applied to identify and breed
resistant apple cultivars. Environmental factors such as within-canopy variation in climate, and
neighbourhood-effects affected herbivore distribution in the field. In the laboratory, pulsed drought stress
resulted in non-monotonic resistance responses of apple trees. Low-stress plants showed the highest and
high-stress plants the lowest resistance. The studies revealed the genetic basis of apple resistance to
different arthropod herbivores and the modifying influence of environmental parameters that may
impede QTL detection.
Key words: Apple Malus x domestica, aphids, caterpillars, deficit irrigation, host plant resistance,
individual tree genotypes, interactions, pest management, QTLs, pulsed drought stress
Introduction
Apple (Malus x domestica Borkh.) is the most relevant fruit crop in the temperate region.
Arthropod herbivores have a negative impact on the quantity and quality of apple yield and
require control. The use of resistant apple cultivars may help to limit insecticide input and to
increase the sustainability of pest management in apple orchards. Host plant resistance has a
genetic basis, and increasing knowledge on the apple genome and QTL (quantitative trait
locus) analysis helps to identify gene regions associated with resistance (Liebhard et al.,
2003). QTL-based approaches to determine and characterize host-plant resistance against
insects are commonly used in annual crops, however detailed analysis of the genetic basis of
arthropod resistance in apple has received little attention (Bus et al., 2008; Stoeckli et al.,
2008a). Contrary to diseases like scab or mildew, the variability in susceptibility to arthropod
pests is generally low between the main apple cultivars. The detection of QTLs of minor
effect is impeded by natural microsite-dependent variation of population density, additional to
environmental parameters modifying or masking the expression of plant resistance.
Within-tree variation in the distribution of leaf- (Unsicker & Mody, 2005) or fruitdamaging arthropods (Stoeckli et al., 2008b) has to be considered for sampling protocols
aiming at quantifying the field resistance of particular tree genotypes. Effects of microsite- or
management-dependent tree growth characteristics, and of the position of the studied
531
genotypes within an orchard in relation to other genotypes (neighbourhood effects) may also
interfere with the characterization of the genetic basis of a genotype’s resistance.
Water availability is an environmental parameter of paramount importance for plant
growth and development. Temporary drought events are characteristic for many parts of the
world, and frequency and intensity of extreme drought is predicted to increase in the future
(Christensen et al., 2007). Water deficit may cause drought stress, which may have strong
effects on plant resistance to arthropod herbivores. However, the influence of drought stress
on plant resistance is not easily predictable, as both decreasing and increasing plant resistance
as a consequence of drought stress has been observed (Huberty & Denno, 2004). Future
studies, for example on stress intensity, are needed to better understand the effects of the
environmental parameter drought stress on plant resistance (Mody et al., 2009).
The goals of the presented studies were (1) to elucidate the postulated genetic basis of
apple resistance to different species of arthropod herbivores by QTL analysis, and (2) to
assess genotype-independent factors influencing the distribution of pest insects and plant
resistance in the field and in the laboratory.
Material and methods
QTL analysis and field experiments
Resistance QTLs were investigated in the field in a segregating F1 cross of the apple varieties
'Fiesta' and 'Discovery' (Stoeckli et al., 2008a; 2009a,b). Progeny plants representing 160
genotypes were surveyed at three different sites in Switzerland (cantons Ticino, Valais and
Zurich). Herbivore infestation per genotype as a measure of resistance in the field was
quantified in two consecutive years for the rosy apple aphid (Dysaphis plantaginea), the leafcurling aphid (Dysaphis cf. devecta) and the green apple aphid (Aphis pomi), for the apple rust
mite (Aculus schlechtendali), and for the codling moth (Cydia pomonella). QTL analyses
based on herbivore infestation data were carried out with MapQTL® 4.0 (van Ooijen et al.,
2002). The genetic linkage maps for both 'Fiesta' and 'Discovery' (single parent maps), used in
QTL analysis, were calculated with 251 apple genotypes and were already published
(Liebhard et al., 2003). Kruskal–Wallis tests and interval mapping (IM) were used for QTL
analysis. Logarithm of odds (LOD) threshold values were determined by 1000-foldpermutation tests at a significance level of 95% (genome-wide).
The same trees were also investigated to assess the possible importance of within-tree
variation in herbivore distribution, of tree growth characteristics and of neighbourhood effects
for the quantification of infestation by different apple pest arthropods. Within-tree variation of
codling moth infestation was characterized based on a survey of 40’000 apples from 12
sectors of each of the 160 different apple genotypes, considering canopy aspect (north, east,
south, and west) and canopy height (bottom, middle, and top) (Stoeckli et al., 2008b). Effects
of shoot growth characteristics on aphid population development were repeatedly studied for
population growth of the green apple aphid in sleeve cages attached to 200 apple trees of
different genotype (Stoeckli et al., 2008c). Neighbourhood effects were assessed for apple
aphids and rust mites by quantifying the relationship between infestation levels of
neighbouring trees (Stoeckli et al., 2008a; 2009a).
Laboratory experiments on the effects of drought stress on plant resistance
Drought stress effects on apple resistance to a chewing and a sap-feeding herbivore
(Spodoptera littoralis caterpillars; Aphis pomi aphids) were studied in laboratory experiments
considering control conditions and two intensities of pulsed drought stress (Mody et al.,
2009). 'Control' plants were maintained in constantly humid soil, 'low stress' plants were
watered for the first time when leaves started drooping (about one week after start of the
experiment), and 'high stress' plants before irreversible necrosis occurred. Herbivore
532
experiments started after approximately three weeks of stress, i.e. 3 – 4 drought cycles for
high stress plants and 6 – 7 drought cycles for low stress plants. Plants were watered during
herbivore feeding to simulate different natural stress conditions with alternating dry and wet
periods and insect feeding on plants that had previously been stressed, but were not while
feeding actually occurred. As measures of resistance, plant acceptability (S. littoralis feeding
preference in arena experiments; resistance by antixenosis) and plant suitability (S. littoralis
growth rate and A. pomi population development; resistance by antibiosis) were quantified.
Results and discussion
QTLs for herbivore resistance in apple
We identified QTLs for herbivore resistance in apple. The detected QTLs highlight the genetic
basis of arthropod resistance in apple. Apple genotypes amplifying QTL-relevant markers
differed significantly from genotypes not amplifying the markers for the aphid species D.
plantaginea and D. cf. devecta (Stoeckli et al., 2008a), the rust mite A. schlechtendali
(Stoeckli et al., 2009a), and the codling moth C. pomonella (Stoeckli et al., 2009b) (Fig. 1).
The detected markers may facilitate the breeding of resistant apple cultivars by marker
assisted selection. They may also be used for screening existing cultivars for resistance to
important pest arthropods.
Environmental factors related to apple infestation by arthropod pests in the field
In the field, additional environment-effects on herbivore distribution were identified. The
infestation of apple fruits by the codling moth varied within apple tree canopies for first but
not second generation larvae, with north-facing apples showing lower infestation than southor east-facing fruits (Stoeckli et al., 2008b). Population growth of the green apple aphid was
positively related to the length and growth of apple shoots (Stoeckli et al., 2008c).
Neighbourhood effects appeared to influence the infestation of apple trees by the rosy and the
green apple aphids, but not by the leaf-curling aphid and the rust mite (Stoeckli et al., 2008a;
Stoeckli et al., 2009a). These genotype-independent determinants of herbivore distribution
may mask QTLs, and they may help to explain difficulties in QTL detection for the studied
herbivore species.
Herbivore infestation (mean ± SE)
24
Identified QTL marker
present
20
***
absent
**
16
12
8
***
4
*
0
D. plantaginea
Ō
FiestaÕLG 17
E33M35-0269
D. cf. devecta
Ō
FiestaÕLG 7
E32M39-0195
A. schlechtendali
Ō
FiestaÕLG 7
E35M42-0146
C. pomonella
Ō
DiscoveryÕLG 10
Z19-350
Figure 1. A significantly lower herbivore infestation was found for the subpopulation of the F1
apple cross amplifying the marker closest to the QTL compared to the apple genotypes not
533
amplifying the marker. Herbivore infestation was analyzed by Mann-Whitney U-test. Herbivore
species, parent and linkage group (LG), closest marker to the QTL, and P-value (* P<0.01,
** P<0.001, *** P<0.0001) are presented (data assembled from Stoeckli et al., 2008a; 2009a,b).
Experimental drought stress and apple resistance
Water stress treatments had a strong, non-monotonic effect on feeding preference and
performance of the caterpillars and on performance of the aphids (Mody et al., 2009). Plants
experiencing low water stress were less attractive to the caterpillars (repeated measures
ANOVA, F2,58=25.0, P<0.0001), indicating increased resistance by antixenosis, and they were
also less suitable for development of caterpillars (ANOVA, F2,84=8.2, P<0.001) than either
control or high stress plants (Fig. 2), pointing to an increased resistance by antibiosis. Aphid
population development was also lowest on plants experiencing low water stress (ANOVA,
F2,33=9.3, P<0.001), but the best performance was detected for nonstressed control plants
(Fig. 2).
The study on drought stress underlines the important role that the intensity of pulsed
drought stress plays in mediating interactions between herbivores and their host plants, and it
helps to resolve the still existing conflicting evidence of both beneficial and detrimental
effects of drought stress on plant resistance to insect herbivores (Mody et al., 2009). The
study also suggests that non-monotonic plant responses to pulsed drought stress may be more
strongly considered as means of cultural pest control. In particular for crops that show no
reduced yield under moderate water stress, a controlled application of pulsed deficit irrigation
may help to reduce crop damage by increased crop plant resistance to insect herbivores
(Daane & Williams, 2003).
Water stress treatment
Caterpillar preference
C
LS
HS
Caterpillar performance
Aphid performance
N=30
N=26
N=12
N=30
N=29
N=12
N=30
N=30
N=10
0
1
2
3
4
Consumed leaf mass
(mg dry mass)
5 0
0.04 0.08 0.12 0.16
Relative growth rate
(g g-1 day-1)
0
100
200
300
400
Number aphids
Figure 2. Herbivore responses to stress treatments (mean ± 1 SE) as measure of plant resistance
(caterpillar: L3-L5 larvae of Spodoptera littoralis; aphid: Aphis pomi). Caterpillar preference:
feeding preference in bioassays conducted with leaves still attached to plant in arena
experiments. Caterpillar performance: relative growth rates obtained while feeding on an
experimental tree over seven days. Aphid performance: aphid population growth in 14 days on
an experimental tree. Water stress treatments: C: control, nonstressed plants; LS: low stress; HS:
high stress.
534
Acknowledgements
We thank Andrea Patocchi, Muhammad Awais Khan, Giovanni Broggini and Hans Jansen for
helpful support in QTL analysis; Markus Kellerhals, Mauro Jermini and Danilo Christen for
access to the study orchards; Davide Gobbin for PCR amplification of SSR markers; Michelle
Schmocker, Christoph Rohrer and Sandra Noser for help with fieldwork; Daniela Eichenberger
for work on drought-stress effects; Hans-Rudolf Roth, Werner Eugster and Massimo Merlini for
statistical consulting; Joel Meier and Hansjoerg Kull for useful advise on survey design.
References
Bus, V.G.M., Chagne, D., Bassett, H.C.M., Bowatte, D., Calenge, F., Celton, J.M., Durel, C.E.,
Malone, M.T., Patocchi, A., Ranatunga, A.C., Rikkerink, E.H.A., Tustin, D.S., Zhou, J., &
Gardiner, S.E. 2008: Genome mapping of three major resistance genes to woolly apple
aphid (Eriosoma lanigerum Hausm.). Tree Genetics & Genomes, 4: 223-236.
Christensen, J.H., Hewitson, B., Busuioc, A., Chen, A., Gao, X., Held, I., et al. 2007: Regional
climate projections. Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of
Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change (ed. by S. Solomon, D. Qin, M. Manning, Z. Chen, M. Marquis, K.B.
Averyt, M. Tignor & H.L. Miller), pp. 847-940. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
United Kingdom, and New York, USA.
Daane, K.M. & Williams, L.E. 2003: Manipulating vineyard irrigation amounts to reduce insect
pest damage. Ecological Applications, 13: 1650-1666.
Huberty, A.F. & Denno, R.F. 2004: Plant water stress and its consequences for herbivorous
insects: a new synthesis. Ecology, 85: 1383-1398.
Liebhard, R., Koller, B., Gianfranceschi, L., & Gessler, C. 2003: Creating a saturated reference
map for the apple (Malus x domestica Borkh.) genome. Theoretical and Applied Genetics,
106: 1497-1508.
Mody, K., Eichenberger, D., & Dorn, S. 2009: Stress magnitude matters: different intensities of
intermittent water stress produce non-monotonic resistance responses of host plants to insect
herbivores. Ecological Entomology, 34: 133-143.
Stoeckli, S., Mody, K., Gessler, C., Patocchi, A., Jermini, M., & Dorn, S. 2008a: QTL analysis
for aphid resistance and growth traits in apple. Tree Genetics & Genomes, 4: 833-847.
Stoeckli, S., Mody, K., & Dorn, S. 2008b: Influence of canopy aspect and height on codling
moth (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) larval infestation in apple, and relationship between
infestation and fruit size. Journal of Economic Entomology, 101: 81-89.
Stoeckli, S., Mody, K., & Dorn, S. 2008c: Aphis pomi (Hemiptera: Aphididae) population
development, shoot characteristics, and antibiosis resistance in different apple genotypes.
Journal of Economic Entomology, 101: 1341-1348.
Stoeckli, S., Mody, K., Patocchi, A., Kellerhals, M., & Dorn, S. 2009a: Rust mite resistance in
apple assessed by quantitative trait loci analysis. Tree Genetics & Genomes, 5: 257-267.
Stoeckli, S., Mody, K., Gessler, C., Christen, D., & Dorn, S. 2009b: Quantitative trait locus
mapping of resistance in apple to Cydia pomonella and Lyonetia clerkella, and of two
selected fruit traits. Annals of Applied Biology, 154: 377-387.
Unsicker, S.B. & Mody, K. 2005: Influence of tree species and compass bearing on insect
folivory of nine common tree species in the West African savannah. Journal of Tropical
Ecology, 21: 227-231.
van Ooijen, J.W., Boer, M.P., Jansen, R.C., & Maliepaard, C. 2002: MapQTL 4.0. Software for
the calculation of QTL positions on genetic maps. Plant Research International,
Wageningen, NL.
535
Peach breeding for multiple resistances to pests and diseases
contributes to integrated fruit production
T. Pascal1, P. Lambert1, J.L. Poëssel1, V. Decroocq2, M.H. Sauge3
1 INRA, UGAFL, BP 94 - 84143 Avignon-Montfavet Cedex (France) 2 INRA, IBVM, UMR
GDPP, Virologie, BP81, 33883 Villenave d’Ornon (France) 3 INRA, UPSH, Domaine St Paul,
Site Agropar
Abstract: In spite of the worldwide decline in peach production, a constant stream of new varieties
are being provide to fruit growers. For the greater part most of these new varieties being produced by
private peach breeders, and as a consequence very few are selected on the basis of their resistance to
pests or diseases, while the demand of consumers continues to be directed towards a quality fruit
product which is free of pesticide residues. Within the framework of one INRA multidisciplinary
group (Avignon-Bordeaux), we have developed for several years a wide applied breeding program
aiming at improving the resistance of the peach tree to three of its main enemies: the green peach
aphid (Myzus persicae), peach powdery mildew (Sphaerotheca pannosa var. persicae) and sharka
disease (Plum Pox Virus). This work is globally conducted in a research context oriented towards
varietal innovation including fruit quality and durable resistances building. In this way, two
complementary approaches have been preferentially held for respectively improving the genetic gain
by time unit and a better understanding of peach-enemies relationships. First, a genetic approach
integrating the quantitative trait loci or major genes mapping for the development of molecular
assisted selection. Second, a functional approach (i) leaning on the study of the insect behaviour and
the plant metabolites involved in the resistance to M. persicae (ii) coupled to a candidate-genes
research mainly developped for PPV resistance. Whole of first results and perspectives are discussed.
Prunus persica, Myzus, Powdery mildew, Sharka, Genetic linkage map
536
GEP, a tool to help decision making for pest control advisers in Lleida
(Spain)
Manel Ribes-Dasi1, Ramon Torà2, Jesús Avilla3
1 Departament d’Engynieria Agroforestal, Universitat de Lleida, Av. Rovira Roure 191,
25198 Lleida, Spain. 2 Servei de Sanitat Vegetal, Generalitat de Catalunya, Av. Rovira Roure
191, 25198 Lleida, Spain. 3 Department of Crop and Forest Sciences, and Center UdL-IRTA
for R+D, University of Lleida, Av. Rovira Roure 191, 25198 Lleida, Spain
Abstract: GEP is a new tool developed by the University of Lleida, IRTA and the Catalan Plant
Protection Service to furnish Pest Control Advisers (PCAs) with up-dated information on the spatial
distribution of pests in the fruit growing area of Lleida. It is the consequence of the work carried out
since 1998, which has been regularly presented in the IOBC WG meetings. The Pest Control Advisers
maintain and check the net of pheromone traps, send the results to the Plant Protection Service and the
UdL, and receive back the processed information within 3 days. The system has been improved by the
use of Google EarthTM maps.
GEP, Advisory system, Spatial distribution
537
MRV-Carpocapsa: a phenological model as decision support system
for Codling Moth (Cydia pomonella L.) in Emilia-Romagna (Italy) Effectiveness assessment in 1998-2008.
Alda Butturini1, Rocchina Tiso1, Mauro Boselli1, Simona Giosuè2, Giovanni Burgio3
1
Servizio Fitosanitario Regione Emilia-Romagna, via di Saliceto 81, 40128 Bologna, Italy;
2
Horta Srl, Spin off company Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, via Emilia Parmense 84,
29100 Piacenza, Italy; 3DiSTA Entomologia agraria Università degli Studi di Bologna, viale
G. Fanin 50, 40127 Bologna, Italy.
Abstract: A warning Service for pests and diseases of the most important crops was set up in EmiliaRomagna region (Italy) in 1997. Integration of information obtained by forecasting models and fields
surveys is used to develop warnings concerning the risk of pest/disease attack. For the control of
Cydia pomonella is available a phenological time–distributed delay model. Biological parameters were
defined in 1991 in lab-trials. On the basis of hourly temperature, the model can simulate the
development of the first and second generation. It gives as output the cumulating percentages of egglaying, egg-hatching, pupation and adult emergence as well as the age structure of the population. The
model has been fully tested over 1992-1998 and therefore has been effectively used for ten years in
Emilia-Romagna to optimize control strategies in IPM.
From the first application in 1998, it was executed steadily a quality control of simulated data by
their comparison to that observed in orchards. As the pheromone traps do not always describe
population dynamics properly, it has been chosen to assess the oviposition activity.
Weekly field observations were carried out over 1998 – 2008 in an untreated orchard near
Bologna.
The eggs were examined for the exact phase of embryonic development determination. Then the
egg laying dates were estimated taking into account of specific degree-days for each embryonic phase.
Results from the comparison between the simulated data and those observed in field are reported.
Altogether, actual and simulated oviposition curves agree fairly well over the last eleven years despite
the different climatic condition recorded in this period.
Key words: Cydia pomonella, phenological model, warning Service
Introduction
Warnings for Cydia pomonella control in the IPM orchards of the Emilia-Romagna region are
based on the integration of information obtained by a phenological time–distributed delay
model, named “MRV-Carpocapsa”, and field surveys.
The phenological trend of the target stages such as eggs and larvae, otherwise difficult to
obtain using field surveys, is more precisely reported by the model on a daily basis. This
information is particularly useful for establishing the most appropriate protection measures and
their timing. The reliability of the simulated data is one of the main requirements for an efficient
warning service using forecasting models. That is why, from the first model application in 1998,
a quality control of simulated data has steadily been executed by their comparison to that
observed in orchards.
Monitoring focused on the oviposition activity as the pheromone traps do not always describe
population dynamics properly. Besides the eggs represent the target stage, along with neonate
larvae, for chemical and biological applications.
538
Materials and methods
Model description
The MRV-Carpocapsa model includes a time distributed delay model (Manetsch,1976). Such
a model is suitable to describe the flux of individuals belonging to the same population
through the different phenophases. Each individual in a cohort goes through a series of stages
and sub-stages at different times so as to simulate the variability due to genetic factors, food,
microclimate and so on. In other words, it can describe the age class distribution and genetic
variability of poikilothermal organism populations. The model is based on temperature
response at each development stage. The underlying relationship between temperature and
development rate is implemented with the non-linear Logan’s function for eggs, larvae and
pupae (Logan et al., 1976). A linear equation is used for female adults. Furthermore, the
fecundity rate, as a function of age, is expressed by a modified Bieri’s function (Bieri et al.,
1983). The number of the sub-stages representing the dispersal in time of the individuals
coming out a given stage, or coefficient H, is calculated as the ratio of the squared
permanence-time in a given stage and its variance. The model does not take into account any
mortality factor, only the natural death of adults
All of the biological parameters were defined in 1991 through individual-based
laboratory experiments at a different constant temperature (4-6 temperatures between 12,6°C
and 34°C) and under controlled conditions as close as possible to those found in nature
(Butturini et Al., 1992).
The model can simulate the development of the first and second generation on the basis
of measured hourly temperature. The calculations start at the beginning of the year with a
cohort of overwintering larvae. At each hourly time-step, the instantaneous development of
each stage and the fecundity are calculated. A 'delay’ is then assigned to the calculated
development, therefore simulating the variability due to the above factors. At the end of each
day, the model outputs the cumulative percentages of individuals that have already reached a
given stage (egg-laying, newborn larvae, pupating larvae and emerging adults) and the
percentages of the individuals that are still in each development stage (egg, larva, pupa,
adult).
The model has fully tested for the first and second generations in the period 1992-1998 in
several areas of Emilia-Romagna, by comparing both predicted flight and oviposition with the
actual data obtained respectively by pheromone traps and field sampling on fruits (Tiso et al.,
1999).
Quality control methodology
Field observation - Data were collected in the period 1998 – 2008 from an abandoned pear
and apple orchard near Bologna (Italy). A random sample of a hundred fruit cluster was
monitored weekly during the whole first and second generation to compare actual egg-laying
with the analogous simulated data. As the embryogenesis has usually already begun at the
time of sampling, eggs were closely examined for white, red ring and black head stages
determination.
Egg-laying dates were estimated taking into account of specific degree-days for each
embryonic phase (Wyniger,1956).
Data analysis - To make comparison with the model possible the following were
calculated:
- the total number of field observed eggs (back calculated egg-laying) per generation. The
end of the generation was determined at the date of last egg-laying or when a clear decrease
of catches and egg-laying occur. It did not take into account any case in which the number of
eggs was less than 20 per generation.
- the cumulated percentage of egg-laying on each date
539
- the differences between the cumulated percentages of actual and predicted egg-laying
(expressed in days, + and – sign respectively indicating an anticipation or a delay of the
simulation)
Results and discussion
In order to interpret the distribution of the differences (in days) between the cumulative
percentages of simulated and actual egg-laying, the first and second generation set data (132 and
142 respectively) was displayed with a Box-and-Whisker plot (Fig.1).
The results show some differences between the two generations of the insect: for the first
generation, there is a greater dispersion of data and greater frequency of simulated data giving
early times compared to those observed; for the second generation, there is a prevailing time-lag
with the simulated data compared to observed data.
Observation-simulation pairs of data for each generation were tested using Pearson’s
correlation coefficient (Fig.2). The values of Pearson coefficient are 0.902 for the first
generation and 0.946 for the second generation. The results show that there is significant
correlation (P < 0.01) between simulated and observed data for both generations.
The period between 1998 and 2008 revealed weather trends which, at times, deviated
considerably from the norm. In the years 2000 and 2007, for example, fifty percent of
cumulative egg-laying in the first generation was very early (May 13th and May 9th ,
respectively), whereas in the year 2004 a considerable time-lag was observed (May 31st). The
graph in Fig. 3 shows that the model is capable of representing field-data satisfactorily even in
abnormal years.
The results were good owing to the significant correlation between the simulated data and
observed data for both generations of the insect. They were particularly satisfactory in view of
the greatly-differing climatic conditions in the years in which the work was carried out. This
highlights even further the good forecasting capacity of the model.
Table 1. Difference in days between
observed and simulated data
generation
1st
2nd
142
Number of data set 132
5
-1
median
-15
-13
min
23
6
max
5.95
-1.47
mean
7.848 4.322
SD
+ and – signs indicating an anticipation
or a delay of the simulation
1st gen
2nd gen
Fig. 1 Box-and-Whisker plot - Difference(days)
between observed and simulated data
540
1st gen
S = 44,7819+0,646*x; 0,95 Int.Conf.
200
190
180
Predicted (days)
170
160
150
140
130
120
110
100
100
110
120
130
140
150
160
170
180
190
200
Observed (days)
2nd gen
S = 41,8508+0,7934*x; 0,95 Int.Conf.
240
230
Predicted (days)
220
210
200
190
180
170
160
160
170
180
190
200
210
220
230
240
Observed (days)
Fig. 2b. - Correlation between predicted and observed data for the first and second generation
541
2008
2007
2006
2005
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
Figure 3. 50% egg-laying - Comparison between the model (white dot) and the observations
(black dot) for the first and second generation
References
Bieri M., Baumgärtner J., Bianchi G., Delucchi V., Von Arx R., 1983: Development and of
pea aphid (Acyrtosiphon pisum Harris) as affected by constant temperatures and pea
varieties. Mitt Schweiz. Ges. 56: 163-171.
Butturini A., Tiso R., De Berardinis E., 1992: Influenza della temperatura sullo sviluppo di
Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera:Tortricidae). Boll. Ist. Ent. “G. Grandi” Univ.
Bologna 47: 123-134.
Logan J.A., Wollkind D.J., Hoyt S.C., Tanigoshi L.K. 1976: An analytic model for description
off temperature dependent rate phenomena in arthropods. Environ. Entomol. 5:11331140.
Manetsch T.J., 1976: Time–varying distributed delays and their use in aggregative models of
large systems. IEEE Trans. Sys. Man. Cybern., 6: 547-553.
Tiso R., Butturini A., 1999: Un modello fenologico per Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera:
Tortricidae) nella difesa delle pomacee in Emilia – Romagna. Frustula Entomologica,
XXII, 113-120.
Wyniger R.,1956: Über die Wirkung von abiotischen Faktoren auf die Entwicklungsvorgänge
im Apfelwicklerei. Mitt. Schweiz. Ent. Ges. XXIX 1, 41-57.
542
9-Aug
2-Aug
26-Jul
19-Jul
12-Jul
5-Jul
28-Jun
21-Jun
14-Jun
7-Jun
31-May
24-May
17-May
10-May
3-May
1998
26-Apr
Years
2004
Development of a dynamic population model as a decision support
system for Codling Moth (Cydia pomonella L) management
Marc Trapman1, Herman Helsen2, Matty Polfliet3
1 Bio Fruit Advies, Dorpsstraat 31, Zoelmond, the Netherlands, 2 Applied Plant Research,
Wageningen UR, Zetten, the Netherland; 3 Fruit Consult, Zetten, the Netherlands
Abstract: In 2004 RIMpro-Cydia was developed as a dynamic population model that simulates the
within-year biology of a local codling moth population. The model is meant to be used by growers and
advisors to optimize the control of codling moth populations in organic and integrated managed
orchards. The model is based on literature data and unpublished research data. Fractional boxcar trains
are used to mimic the dispersion in the developmental processes. The model is run in real time on the
data input of local weather stations, starting on 1 January. The output of the model was compared with
the results of field observations in four years in untreated orchards. The progress in egg deposition as
predicted by the model was in general agreement with the field data. The start of the egg deposition
period was predicted well. The end of the egg deposition period was predicted when, in the field,
about 10% of the eggs were still to be laid in some years. There was no consistency in the relation
between cumulated pheromone trap catches and the cumulative egg deposition as calculated from the
field data.
Codling moth, Cydia pomonella, Simulation model
543
Impact of flower strip establishment in apple orchards on natural
enemy populations
Jennifer De Almeida1, Daniel Cormier2 & Éric Lucas1
1
Département des Sciences biologiques, Université du Québec à Montréal, C.P. 8888 Succ.
Centre-ville, Montréal, Qc, Canada H3C 3P8; 2Institut de recherche et de développement en
agroenvironnement, 3300, rue Sicotte, C.P. 480, Saint-Hyacinthe, Qc, Canada J2S 7B8
Abstract. Composite flower strips were established in 2006 in three commercial apple
orchards in Quebec. Strips were composed of the Canadian goldenrod (Solidago canadensis)
and the common yarrow (Achillea millefolium), two native plants known to attract beneficial
organisms. The aim of the project was to reduce pesticide application treatments directed
against orchard pests, more specifically the European red mite (Panonychus ulmi), the twospotted spider mite (Tetranychus urticae), the green apple aphid (Aphis pomi), the European
apple sawfly (Hoplocampa testudinea), the tarnished plant bug (Lygus lineolaris) and the
white apple leafhopper (Typhlocyba pomaria). In the present trial, populations of potential
natural enemies of these pests were monitored in 2008, using sticky white traps, in both
control and managed areas. The most common predator species were Coccinellidae,
Syrphidae, Neuroptera (Chrysopidae and Hemerobiidae) and Aranea. Results varied
according to the species of natural enemy, the treatment (control versus floral strip) and the
distance to the flower strip.
Key words: habitat management, Achillea millefolium, Solidago canadensis, Aranea, Chrysopidae,
Coccinellidae, Hemerobiidae, Syrphidae, predator.
Introduction
Habitat management in agriculture can provide alternative food (preys, hosts, pollen, nectar),
refuges, oviposition and breeding sites to natural enemies (Altieri, 1994; Andow, 1991). Such
management practices aim to increase the diversity and abundance of natural enemies in order
to control pests and consequently reduce insecticide applications. Several studies deal with
pest management in apple orchard but no one treatment was sufficient to efficiently control
pest populations (Brown & Glenn, 1999; Wyss, 1996). In this study, we chose to establish in
apple orchards a flower strip composed of two native plants which have been reported to
attract beneficial organisms. The goal is to increase significantly the abundance of natural
enemy populations and to establish permanently a biodiversity able to reduce apple’s
damages.
We hypothesize that the management of a flower strip will increase the abundance of
natural enemies in apple orchard.
Material and methods
Flower strips
Strips of composite flower were established perpendicularly to apple trees rows in 2006 in
three commercial apple orchards in Quebec (Canada) (45N; 71O). Flower strips (2m x 20m)
were composed of Canada goldenrod (Solidago canadensis) and common yarrow (Achillea
millefolium). Each orchard contained two or four flower strips. Each managed area (with
flower strip) was paired to an unmanaged area (control) for comparison, and had similar apple
544
tree age, size, rootstock and variety. Buffer zones of 10 to 15m were established on each side
of the treatment areas to minimize edge effect.
Sampling of natural enemies
Natural enemy populations were monitored weekly from May to September in 2008 in the
two central apple tree rows, with a sticky white trap hung (150cm from ground level) on each
of the two apple trees located at 0, 10 and 30m from the treatment areas. Two traps were also
placed 50cm above the ground within each flower strip and control treatments. Sticky white
traps were kept in an icebox until the identification of insects in the laboratory. The main
groups monitored were composed of Syrphidae, Coccinellidae, Chrysopidae and
Hemerobiidae adults, and Aranea immature and adults. A paired t-test was used to compare
managed and unmanaged areas at each distance from the treatment.
Results
Natural enemies assemblage
In 2008, 1868 individuals of natural enemy were collected on sticky white traps. The mean
number per trap and per week was significantly higher at 0m in managed areas (0.772 adults)
than in control areas (0.544) (df = 7; T = -1.960; P = 0.0454).
Mean abundance per trap per week
Syrphidae
Syrphidae constituted the most important family of natural enemies with 1224 captured
adults. They were more abundant within the control (1.508 adults/trap/week) than within the
flower strips (0.844 adults) (df = 6; T = 2.483; P = 0.0238) (Fig. 1).
2,0
*
1,6
1,2
flower strip
control
0,8
0,4
0,0
within
0m
10m
30m
Figure 1. Mean abundance per trap and per week of Syrphidae adults captured on sticky white
traps in three commercial apple orchards. * indicates statistically different values by Paired Ttest (P≤ 0,05).
Coccinellidae
Coccinellidae was the second most important family of recovered natural enemies with 389
individuals belonging to more than 10 species. Four species represented 83% of all
Coccinellidae captured. They were more abundant within the flower strips (mean of 0.554
adults/trap/week) than within the control (mean of 0.336 adults) (df = 6; T =
-2.604; P =
0.020) (Fig. 2).
545
Mean abundance per trap per week
0,7
*
0,6
0,5
0,4
flower strip
0,3
control
0,2
0,1
0,0
within
0m
10m
30m
Figure 2. Mean abundance per trap and per week of Coccinellidae adults captured on sticky
white traps in three commercial apple orchards.
Aranea and Neuroptera
No differences were observed between managed and unmanaged areas concerning the
abundance for both Aranea and Neuroptera captured on sticky white traps.
Discussion
Our study shows that management of a flower strip has a significant positive impact on
natural enemies. They were more abundant in managed orchards, near the flower strip, than in
unmanaged area. However, this impact was restricted to the edge (<10m) of the orchard.
Results about impact of such management techniques differ according to the studies,
revealing either floral diversity increases natural enemy’s abundance (Kinkorova &
Kocourek, 2000), or has no significant effect on natural enemies (Prokopy, 2003; SteffanDewenter & Leschke, 2003).
Syrphidae were significantly more abundant on the control groundcover than in the
flower strip. Nevertheless, no difference was observed at any distance in the orchard between
treatments. Our results contradict previous studies which noted that abundance of Syrphidae
increased with flower density and proximity (Kohler et al., 2008; Pontin et al., 2006).
Coccinellidae were more abundant in the flower strip than in the control, confirming that
A. millefolium and S. canadensis efficiently attract theses predators. They may be attracted by
pollen and nectar from these plants (Spellman et al., 2006; Price et al., 1980). In spite of this
attractiveness, no effect was observed within the orchard.
Concluding, samplings have to be continued during the next years in order to establish 1)
if the impact would be confirmed and increased, 2) if the impact would spread in the entire
orchard or be restricted to the vicinity of the strips.
Acknowledgement
This work was funded by Conseil pour le Développement de l’Agriculture du Québec and
supported by Club Agroenvironnemental de l’Estrie and Horticulture Indigo. Special thanks to
Spencer Mason, Mr and Mme Mason and Martin Hutchison.
References
Altieri, M. 1994: Biodiversity and pest management in agroecosystems. Food Products Press,
546
New-York 185 p.
Andow, D.A. 1991: Vegetational diversity and arthropod population response. Annual Review
of Entomology 36: 561-586.
Brown, M.W. & Glenn, D.M. 1999: Ground cover plants and selective insecticides as pest
management tools in apple orchards. Journal of Economic Entomology 92, 4: 899-905.
Kinkorova, J. & Kocourek, F. 2000: The effect of integrated pest management practices in an
apple orchard on Heteroptera community structure and population dynamics. Journal of
Applied Entomology 124: 381-385.
Kohler F., Verhulst J., van Klink R. & Kleijn D. 2008: At what spatial scale do high-quality
habitats enhance the diversity of forbs and pollinators in intensively farmed lanscapes?
Journal of Applied Ecology 45: 753-762.
Pontin D.R., Wade M.R., Kehrli P. & Wratten S.D. 2006: Attractiveness of single and multiple
species flower patches to beneficial insects in agroecosystems. Annals of Applied
Biology 148: 39-47.
Price W.P., Bouton C.E., Gross P., McPheron B.A., Thompson J.N. & Weis A.E. 1980:
Interaction among three trophic levels: influence of plants on interactions between insect
herbivores and natural enemies. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 11: 41-65.
Prokopy, R.J. 2003: Two decades of bottom-up, ecologically based pest management in a
small commercial apple orchard in Massachusetts. Agriculture, Ecosystems and
Environment 94: 299-309.
Spellman B., Brown M.W. & Mathews C.R. 2006: Effect of floral and extrafloral resources on
predation of Aphis spiraecola by Harmonia axyridis on apple. BioControl 51:715-724.
Steffan-Dewenter I. & Leschke K. 2003: Effects of habitat management on vegetation and
above-ground nesting bees and wasps of orchard meadows in Central Europe.
Biodiversity and Conservation 12: 1953-1968.
Wyss, E. 1996: The effects of artificial weed strips on diversity and abundance of the
arthropod fauna in a Swiss experimental apple orchard. Agriculture, Ecosystems and
Environment 60: 47-59.
547
COSMOS, a spatially explicit model to simulate the epidemiology of
Cosmopolites sordidus in banana fields.
Fabrice Vinatier1, Philippe Tixier1, Christophe Le Page2, Pierre-François Duyck2,
Claude Bruchou3 & Françoise Lescourret4
1
CIRAD, UPR 26, B.P. 214, F-97285, Le Lamentin, Martinique, France; 2CIRAD, UPR
GREEN, 254 Phayathai road, Pathumwan, 10330, Bangkok, Thailand; 3 INRA, Unité
Biostatistique et Processus Spatiaux, UR 0546, Domaine St. Paul, Site Agroparc, Avignon
Cedex 9, 84914, France; 4 INRA, Unité Plantes et Systèmes de Culture Horticoles, UR 1115,
Domaine St. Paul, Site Agroparc, Avignon Cedex 9, 84914, France
Abstract : A stochastic individual-based model called COSMOS was developed to simulate the
epidemiology of Cosmopolites sordidus in banana fields, based on simple rules of local movement of
adults, egg-laying of females, development and mortality, and infestation of larvae inside the banana
plants. The biological parameters of the model were estimated from literature. The model was
validated at the small-plot scale. Simulated and observed distributions of attacks were similar in
twelve out of 18 plots (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test). An exhaustive sensitivity analysis using the Morris
method, showed that dispersal and demographic parameters of adults were the most influent
parameters.
Keywords: Banana weevil; Curculionidae; Individual-based model; Life-history traits; Musa,
West Indies
Introduction
Understanding the epidemiology of pests is of special importance for designing innovative
control systems. The spatial component of epidemiology is crucial to understand the spread of
damage from a localized inoculum or when pest dispersal is limiting (Winkler and Heinken,
2007).
In this work, we took as case study Cosmopolites sordidus (Coleoptera: Curculionidae)
(Germar. 1825), a major pest of banana cropping systems. This tropical insect has a long
development time and life span, low mortality rate and limited dispersal abilities. Larvae bore
into corm of banana plants (Gold et al., 2001). Based on these characteristics, we chose (i) a
spatially explicit approach to understand how local movements influence spatial distribution
and damage of this pest in a homogeneous habitat, (ii) an individual-based approach assumed
to help explaining observed population patterns, considering that different behaviours at the
individual level allow the emergence of population level properties (Grimm and Railsback,
2005).
As sensitivity analyses are key steps of modelling processes, we performed an exhaustive
sensitivity analysis using the Morris method to ascertain the importance of each biological
parameter, in relation to their level of uncertainty as indicated by the literature.
Material and methods
According to the COSMOS model, the adults disperse with stochastic movement in a field
that is figured by a grid with one plant per cell. Females lay eggs on banana plants according
to the phenological stage of plants and to density-dependence, and larvae emerging from these
eggs bore into the corm of the plants. Stage duration of juveniles and phenologic stages of
548
banana plant are temperature-dependent. Plants pass through three distinct stages: maiden
sucker, preflowering, post-flowering until harvest. Just before flowering, a new sucker of the
mother plant is selected and grows simultaneously in the same cell. Delay between two
consecutive harvests, corresponding to a cropping cycle, is approximately 200 days.
Damage caused by C. sordidus on banana plants was measured on 18 plots during two
cropping cycles at the station of the CIRAD, Neufchâteau, Guadeloupe. At harvesting of the
first and second cropping cycles, damage caused by larvae inside the corm was evaluated for
each banana plant, separately.
For each of the 18 plots used for model evaluation, the model was initialized using
populations of individuals distributed in the plot, estimated according to the attacks recorded
at the end of the first cycle for each plant, i.e. the attacked circumference. Then, the model
simulated the epidemiology of C. sordidus during the second cropping cycle.
We used the Morris (1991) method to evaluate sensitivity of the model. Twenty biological
parameters of the insect were tested. According to the Morris method, the mean μ and the
standard deviation σ of the absolute values of the elementary effects of each parameter are
used as sensitivity measures to ascertain parameter importance.
For each plot used for model evaluation, smoothed distributions of attacks were plotted using
the 100 replicates of each simulation, and compared to observations. Each replicate of
simulation was compared to observations using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (Mellin et al.,
2006). We defined the index Iks as the ratio of significant ks tests (P < 0.05) over the 100
replicates of a simulation.
Results
Model evaluation
Distributions of simulated attacks were not significantly different from observations for 12
plots out of 18 (Iks>0.75) and for three plots, Iks was between 0.50 and 0.75. For the three
last plots, Iks was under 0.50 (Figure 1)
0.12
P lot 1
Probability density of plants
0.10
= 82 %
IksIks
=0.82
P lot 4
Iks=0.98
= 98 %
Iks
P lot 17
Iks=0.00
=0%
Iks
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00
0.12
P lot 8
0.10
Iks==0.94
Iks
94 %
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.00
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Circumference attacked (in cm)
Observations (cycle 1)
Observations (cycle 2)
S imulations (cycle 2)
Fig. 1. Observed and simulated distribution of banana damage for an example of 4 plots
infested by C. sordidus in Guadeloupe.
549
Sensitivity analysis
Eight parameters played a significant role in the magnitude of mean and standard deviation of
the distribution of attacks: dispersal parameters (DC1, DC2), demographical parameters (FH,
MRL, ML and PE), threshold density effect (DE) and diameter of gallery (G; Fig. 2). The part
of DC1, DC2 and DE was more important in the explanation of standard deviation of attacks
than in that of the mean.
(a)
(b)
PE
1.5
1.5
PE
MRL
MRL
DE
1.0
FH
σ
σ
1.0
FH
G
G
DC2
DC1
0.5
0.5
DE
ML
0.0
0.0
ML
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
0.0
0.5
µ
1.0
1.5
µ
Fig. 2. Analyses of the COSMOS model sensitivity to biological insect parameters using the
Morris method, focusing on two main parameters of the distribution of attacks: (a) Mean, (b)
Standard deviation.
Table 1: Model parameters of importance in sensitivity analyses
Description
Code
Range used for
sensitivity analyses
PE
0.33-0.68
Larva
Mortality Rate for larvae
Diameter of gallery (in cm)
MRL
G
0.32-0.64
0.8-1.2
Adult
Number of individuals necessary for density-dependent effect on fecundity
Number of eggs per week per female for groups of less than 20 females
Proportion of individuals moving to the next row every 3 time steps (%)
Proportion of individuals moving to the second row every 3 time steps (%)
Maximal lifespan of adult stage (days)
DE
FH
DC1
DC2
ML
10-33
1.7-3.2
1.5-6.6
0-3
520-900
Egg
Proportion of eggs removed by predators
Discussion and conclusions
With an IBM that includes local movements and individual variability of aging and mortality,
according to tests performed for a wide range of levels of attack at initialization, including
low levels of attack, we reproduced, with good accuracy, levels and distribution of attacks of
C. sordidus to banana plants. Thus, we estimate that COSMOS reflects real population trends
and is an interesting tool to predict the epidemiology of C. sordidus at the field scale.
The basic principles of the epidemiology of C. sordidus were successfully integrated in
the COSMOS model. Further steps should involve integration in this model of management
practices able to influence the epidemiology of this pest and to contribute to Integrated Pest
Management (Huffaker and Gutierrez, 1999, p. 682), such as the use of resistant varieties,
traps and biological control agents, as suggested by Gold et al. (2001). Furthermore, to design
550
IPM schemes at the farm scale, the next step will be to scale up the model to a group of fields
and to account for interfaces between fields.
References
Gold, C.S., Pena, J.E. and Karamura, E.B., 2001. Biology and integrated pest management for
the banana weevil Cosmopolites sordidus (Germar) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae).
Integrated Pest Management Reviews, 6:79-155.
Grimm, V. and Railsback, S.F., 2005. Individual-based Modeling and Ecology
Princeton University Press, New Jersey, 480 p.
Huffaker, C.B. and Gutierrez, A.P., 1999. Ecological Entomology. Wiley, New York, 756 p.
Mellin, C., Ferraris, J., Galzin, R., Kulbicki, M. and Ponton, D., 2006. Diversity of coral reef
fish assemblages: Modelling of the species richness spectra from multi-scale
environmental variables in the Tuamotu Archipelago (French Polynesia).
Ecological Modelling, 198:409-425.
Morris, M.D., 1991. Factorial sampling plans for preliminary computational experiments.
Technometrics, 33:161-174.
Winkler, E. and Heinken, T., 2007. Spread of an ant-dispersed annual herb: An individualbased simulation study on population development of Melampyrum pratense L.
Ecological Modelling, 203:424-438.
551
Effects of thermoperiodic conditions on the developmental rate of
codling moth larvae of resistant and non-resistant strains to chemical
and viral (CpGV) insecticides.
Ana Scomparin1, Marc Saudreau2, Hervé Sinoquet2, Benoit Sauphanor3, Marie Berling4,
Odair Fernandes1, David G. Biron2
1
Departamento de Fitossanidade, FCAV/UNESP, Rod. Prof. Paulo D. Castellane, 14884-900,
Jaboticabal, SP, Brazil; 2UMR 547 PIAF, INRA-UBP, 234 avenue du Brézet, 63100 ClermontFerrand, France; 3Unité PSH, Equipe Ecologie de la Production Fruitière Intégrée, INRA,
Agroparc, 84914 Avignon Cédex 9, France; 4Ecole des Mines d’Alès Centre LGEI, 6 avenue
de Clavières, F. 30319 Alès Cedex France.
Abstract: The developmental rate of codling moth, Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae),
is supposed to be directly proportional to air temperature between the lower and upper developmental
thresholds. However, some review papers suggest that insect species have a higher developmental rate
when reared in thermoperiodic conditions as compared with constant temperatures. Thus, in this study,
the developmental rate and the zero temperature threshold of codling moth for the larval stage were
determined in thermoperiodic conditions for strains resistant and non-resistant to chemical and viral
(CpGV) insecticides. Two methods were used to determine the zero development temperature for the
four C. pomonella strains: (i) the x-intercept method and (ii) the thermal unit test. Our study supports
the “thermoperiod hypothesis” and suggests that the effect of thermoperiod on the developmental rate
of C. pomonella larvae should be taken into account in the development of phenological models.
Keywords : thermoperiod, codling moth, developmental rate, insecticide resistance
Introduction
The development of poïkilotherms is highly constrained by temperature. For insects, most
studies about the relationship between temperature and developmental rate have been
conducted in laboratory experiments using constant temperatures. Less well understood is the
form of the relationship that best describes variation in developmental rate with thermoperiod
(i.e. daily fluctuations in temperature). Some review papers suggest that insect species have a
higher developmental rate when they are reared in thermoperiodic conditions as compared
with constant temperatures (Howell & Neven, 2000). For the codling moth, Cydia pomonella
(L.) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae), the “thermoperiod hypothesis” seems to be corroborated by
some physiological time data obtained for non insecticide resistant strains (El Idrissi, 1980;
Howell & Neven, 2000).
The codling moth is a worldwide pest at the larval stage in apple and pear orchards that
requires frequent control treatments. The relationship between temperature and developmental
rate of codling moth has been evaluated in a number of studies. The developmental rate of C.
pomonella is supposed to be directly proportional to air temperature between the lower and
upper developmental thresholds of 9.7-10°C and around 32-35°C, respectively, with a
maximum developmental rate at approximately 30°C. To test the “thermoperiod hypothesis”,
the developmental rate and the zero temperature threshold of codling moth were determined
for the larval stage in thermoperiodic conditions for strains resistant and non-resistant to
chemical and viral (CpGV) insecticides.
552
Material and methods
Insect material
The codling moths used in the study were descendants of eggs taken from the PSH INRA
Avignon strains. Four strains were used: (i) Sv (susceptible strain), (ii) Rdfb (resistant to
diflubenzuron), (iii) RΔ (resistant to deltamethrin), RGv (resistant to C. pomonella
granulovirus).
Experimental setup
For each strain and for the following synchronous thermoperiods 10°C:15°C, 15°C:20°C,
20°C:25°C, 25°C:30°C with a constant photoperiod (L16:D8) and a constant relative
humidity (70 %) , a minimum of one hundred neonate larvae were individually placed in (i.e.
cups containing larval diet (Stonefly heliothis diet, Ward’s, New York, USA). Air temperature
in chambers and temperature in microhabitats (i.e. cups) were monitored at 6-minute intervals
with stand-alone data loggers (Hobo U8, Onset Computer Corporation, Bourne, U.S.) and
thermocouples connected to a CR21X datalogger (Campbell Scientific, Logan, U.K.),
respectively. Each day, all larvae were checked for pupation.
Data analysis
For each thermoperiod, the observed mean temperature was used to compare our results with
those obtained with a constant temperature regime. Finally, two procedures were used to
determine the zero development temperature for the four C. pomonella strains: (i) the xintercept method i.e. an extrapolation of the best-fit linear approximation of the reciprocal of
development time (1/di where di is the time for the development) and (ii) the thermal unit test.
The thermal units (TU) were determined by using the equation TU = di X (ti-b) where di is the
development time, ti is the temperature of insect rearing and b is the base temperature. Thus,
according Howell & Neven (2000), the correct b value should give the same number of TU at
each thermoperiod as long as the rearing thermoperiods used were between the lower and upper
temperature thresholds.
Results and discussion
Table 1 gives for each strain the mean and median development times. Many significant
differences were observed between strains at each thermoperiod and between thermoperiods
for each strain (see Table 1). The zero temperature threshold of development (T0) obtained
with the x-intercept (xi) and the thermal unit (TU) are Sv (T0 (xi)= 11.99°C; T0 (TU)=
11.54°C), Rdfb (T0 (xi)= 11.48°C; T0 (TU)= 11.93°C), RΔ (T0 (xi)= 10.34°C; T0 (TU)=
10.74°C) and RGV (T0 (xi)=11.57°C; T0 (TU)= 11.28°C). Our results suggest for the T0 a
significant difference between strains. A priori, the resistance status to insecticides could be a
reason for such differences, but in the literature the T0 has been reported to be as low as 8.0
or as high as high as 13.3 °C (Ammari El Idrissi, 1980; Williams & McDonald, 1982;
Piticairn et al., 1991; Butturini et al., 1992; Howell & Neven, 2000; Kührt et al., 2006).
The x-intercept and thermal unit methods are probably not the best methods to determine
the T0 for any insect species since the assumption of linearity between temperature and rate of
development is not true for low and high-end temperatures (Schoolfield et al., 1981; Shaffer &
Table 1. Physiological development time of resistant- and non-resistant codling moth larvae
strains to chemical and viral (CpGV) insecticides at different thermoperiods
553
Thermoperiod
(12:12)
(°C)
15:20
20:25
25:30
Strains Caterpillar
(N)
Mean ± SD
(Days)
Median
(Days)
41
Sv
109
Rdfb
105
41,6 ± 4,8
c*
48,9 ± 6,1 a
RΔ
RGV
Sv
Rdfb
126
105
100
89
44,4 ± 5,1 b
38,9 ± 4,1 d
23,3 ± 2,1 b
26,0 ± 5,1 a
43
38
23
26
RΔ
RGV
113
24,7 ± 4,2 b
24
100
23,1 ± 2,0 b
23
Sv
103
15,4 ± 2,4 c
15
Rdfb
101
17,3± 1,8 a
17
RΔ
102
17,7 ± 4,2 a
17
RGV
102
14,5 ± 1,7 c
14
49
* : Value with common letters were not significantly different at p ≤ 0,05
(Kolmogorov- Smirnov two sample test).
0,08
Sv
rdfb
RΔ
RGV
0,06
Howell & Neven 2000
Kuhrt et al., 2006
0,05
Butturini et al., 1992
Pitcairn et al., 1991
Rate of Development (days‐1)
0,07
Idrissi 1980
0,04
0,03
0,02
0,01
0
17,6
21,9
27,7
Average Temperature (°C)
Figure 1. Developmental rate (days-1) of PSH INRA Avignon strains and for the strains of some
other researchers as a function of mean daily temperature observed during the thermoperiods.
Gold, 1985; Georges et al., 2005). Fig. 1 shows the development rates of our strains
compared with other strains from literature data. Thermoperiods had a major effect on the
development rate in comparison to literature data obtained with constant temperature regimes
with the same daily mean and with a similar experimental design as Ammari El Irdrissi (1980)
(see Fig. 1). Regardless of the strains, for two thermoperiods (i.e. 20-25°C, 25-30°C), ), the
development rate was higher (i.e. a shorter development time) compared with literature data
(see Fig. 1).
554
Our study supports the “thermoperiod hypothesis” suggesting that insect development
times decrease under thermoperiodic conditions compared with constant temperature regimes
with the same daily mean. Finally, our study suggests that a non-linear model of codling moth
development will be more appropriate to determine the zero temperature threshold associated
with insecticide resistance status in codling moth populations and should be used in
phenological models.
Acknowledgements
We thank Sandrine Maugin for technical assistance. A. Scomparin was supported by a
scholarship provided by UNESP/Jaboticabal (FUNEP) of Brazil and D.G. Biron by a Haigneré
fellowship of INRA. This work was funded by MICCES program of INRA.
References
Ammari El Irdrissi, M.A. 1980: Etudes biocoenotiques comparées en verger de pommier au
Maroc et influence de la température sur la fécondité et le développement du carpocapse
(Laspeyresia pomonella L., Lepidoptera: Tortricidae), dans une perspective de protection
intégrée. Thèse, Université d’Aix Marseille. 246p.
Butturini, A., Tiso, R. & Berardinis, E.D. 1993: Influence of temperature on the development of
Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae). Boll. Ist. Entomol. 47:123–134.
Georges, A., Beggs, K., Young, J.E. & Doody, J.S. 2005: Modelling development of reptile
embryos under fluctuating temperature regimes. Physiol. Biochem. Zool. 78:18-30.
Howell, J.F. & Neven, L.G. 2000: Physiological development time and zero development
temperature of the codling moth (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae). Environ. Entomol. 29:766-772.
Kührt, U., Samietz, J., Höhn, H. & Dorn, S. 2006: Modelling the phenology of codling moth:
Influence of habitat and thermoregulation. Agric. Ecosyst. Envir. 117:29-38.
Pitcairn, M.J., Pickel, C., Falcon, L.A. & Zalom, F.G. 1991: Development and survivorship of
Cydia pomonella (L.) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) at ten constant temperatures. Pan-Pac.
Entomol. 67:189-194.
Shaffer, P. L. & Gold, H.J. 1985: A simulation model of population dynamics of the codling
moth, Cydia pomonella. Ecol. Model. 30:247–274.
Schoolfield, R.M., Sharpe, P.J.H. & Magnuson, C.E. 1981: Non-linear regression of biological
temperature-dependent rate models based on absolute reaction-rate theory. J. Theor. Biol.
87:719-731.
Williams, D.G. & McDonald, G. 1982: The duration and number of the immature stages of
codling moth, Cydia pomonella (L.) (Tortricidae: Lepidoptera). J. Aust. Ent. Soc. 21:1-4.
555
Raspberry cane midge (Resseliella theobaldi): 3 years of flight
monitoring in Swiss raspberry crops and control trials
Catherine A. Baroffio, Charly Mittaz
Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil ACW, Centre de Recherche Conthey, 1964 Conthey,
Switzerland
Abstract: The raspberry cane midge Resseliella theobaldi is a major pest of Swiss raspberries. The
midge population dynamics have been studied for 3 years in the Valais region using a sex pheromone
identified and synthesised by EMR and NRI. Four generations were observed in the low altitude and
three in the mountains. Based on these observations and in order to find a substitute to diazinon, the
only registered insecticide, an efficacy trial was conducted in 2008. Besides diazinon, two insecticides
were tested. Only thiacloprid and diazinon showed a significant difference compared to control. The
trial will be repeated in 2009.
Key words: Soft fruits, raspberry, monitoring, Resseliella theobaldi
Introduction
Resseliella theobaldi (Barnes) is a major pest of Swiss raspberries (Antonin, 1998; Baroffio,
2007). It belongs to the gall midge family, Cecidomyiidae, 2 to 2,5 mm long and reddish
brown. Cane withering is due to splits in the canes, to the egg laying in the splits, to the larvae
feeding on the cortex of the canes and to the secondary fungi infection in the splits. Damages
due to the midge blight are detectable in primocanes fruiting raspberries in July (violet spots).
In the summerfruiting raspberries, damages are detectable only in the second year with
fruiting canes withering (Nilsson, 2008; Rivière, 2008).
The sex pheromone of Resseliella theobaldi has been identified by EMR und NRI and
has proved to be useful for pest monitoring. Jerry Cross coordinated the monitoring trial
(EMR, UK) in nine European countries between 2006 and 2008 to compare the flight
phenology under different climates (Cross, 2009). In order to find a substitute to diazinon, the
only registered insecticide, an efficacy trial was conducted in 2008 in Switzerland.
Materials and methods
The monitoring trial has been realized between 2006 and 2008 in two Swiss locations:
Bruson (1060 m high) uncovered (open field plantation) (Glen Ample, HimboTop and Zeva2)
and Ardon (480 m high) covered with agryl in winter (Glen Ample and Heritage). On each
site, two pheromone traps were deployed in the centre of the culture, separated by at least
30m. Traps were baited with a standard lure and replaced every month. Sticky base was
replaced every week. Males were caught and counted on the sticky base every week from
April to October during three years. Traps, lure and base were supplied by East Malling
Research and Agralan (UK).
The first year of the efficacy trial was realized in 2008 in Ardon. Four different
treatments were applied on the 2nd June with four replicates each on Heritage. Per replicate,
10 canes were examined and the number of larvae in the natural splits was scored 24 days
556
after treatment. The treatments were: thiacloprid, spinosad, diazinon and no treatment (Table
1).
Results and discussion
Monitoring trial
The flight pattern shows four generations in Ardon (480 m.) and three in Bruson (1060 m.)
(Fig.1). In both plots, population level increased during the three years (2006-2008).
ARDON 2006-2008
Nr midges / trap
2000
1500
1000
500
28
4
29
8
27
5
28
8
26
9
25
4
23
5
22
0
20
7
19
1
17
7
16
4
14
9
13
6
12
1
10
7
93
0
Julian date
2006
2007
2008
BRUSON 2006-2008
Nr midges /trap
2000
1500
1000
500
30
2
26
1
24
7
23
2
21
9
20
5
19
0
17
6
16
2
14
8
13
5
12
0
10
5
0
Julian date
2006
2007
2008
Figure 1. Pheromone trap catches of midges in the two fields Ardon (480 m.) and Bruson
(1060 m.) during 3 years (2006 – 2008).
In the lower altitudes, the peak for first generation catch was between 30 April and 7 May.
The second-generation peak was between 28 May and 4 June. The midge cycle is longer in
Bruson at 1060 m. a.s. The first generation peak was between 14 May and 20 May. There
were 50 days between the two peaks. The second-generation peak was between 24 June and 8
July. This information will allow finding the optimal date for a chemical treatment.
557
Efficacy trial
The treatment made in Ardon on the 2 June 2008 was 2 days before the second generation
peak. The canes in the control plot had an infestation of 3 larvae per cm split. Diazinon and
thiacloprid treatments gave significantly different results from those of the control plot with
respectively 0.2 and 0.4 larvae per cm split in cane (Tab.1)
Table 1. Results of the efficacy trial in Ardon 2008. Average of 4 replications for each treatment. (Fisher LSD / p 95%)
Products
Active ingredients
Concentrations
Control
Alanto
Audienz
Diazinon
Thiacloprid 40%
Spinosad 44%
Diazinon 25%
0.02 %
0.02 %
0.1%
Results:
Nr larvae/cm split
3.01a
0.44b
0.76ab
0.23b
Conclusions
The pheromone traps are a good indicator for estimating the presence and the quantity of
midges flying in the raspberry culture. The traps will help to determine the right treatment
window to be as efficient as possible to target the highest midge number.
The first year of the efficacy trial showed the interesting alternative to diazinone with
thiacloprid. Trials will be continued in 2009.
Acknowledgements
We thank the grower in Ardon, B.Huber who let us work in his plot, Agralan for providing
traps, Delphine Rivière, Cathy Eckert and Philippe Massardier for their advice and
experiences from France and Jerry Cross who coordinates this project.
References
Antonin, P., Baillod, M., Boureille, J., Linder, C. & Mittaz, C. 1998: La cécidomyie de
l'écorce du framboisier Resseliella theobaldi (Barnes). Revue suisse Vitic. Arboric,
Hortic. 30: 195-200.
Baroffio C., 2007: Culture des framboises. Maladies et ravageurs. In: Guide des petits fruits
2007. Ed. Fruit Union Suisse, 6302 Zoug. 125 pp.
Cross J. & al., 2009: Monitoring raspberry cane midge, Resseliella theobaldi, with sex
pheromones traps. IOBC Bulletin in Press.
Höhn, H., Neuweiler, R. & Höpli, HU. 1995: Integrierte Schädlingsregulierung bei
Himbeeren. Schweiz.Z.Obst-Weinbau 13: 308 - 310
Nilsson, T., 2008: Raspberry cane midge (Resseliella theobaldi (Barnes)), biology, control
methods and monitoring. Master project SLU Arnarp.
Rivière, D. 2008: Evaluation de l'impact technique de deux ravageurs de la framboise, la
cécidomyie de l'écorce, Resseliella theobaldi (Barnes) et le ver de la framboise, Byturus
tomentosus (De Geer). Approche de méthodes de lutte potentielle. Enita de ClermontFerrand, mémoire de fin d'étude.
558
Management of Oriental Fruit Moth and Codling Moth with spray
application of microencapsulated sex pheromone
Daniele Demaria1*, Manuela Cigolini2, Graziano Vittone1, Fabio Molinari2
1
CReSO, Consorzio di Ricerca e Sperimentazione per l’Ortofrutticoltura piemontese, via
Falicetto 24, 12030 Manta, Cuneo, Italy.
2
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore di Piacenza, Istituto di Entomologia e Patologia
Vegetale, via Emilia Parmense, 84 - 29100 Piacenza, Italy.
* daniele.demaria@cresoricerca.it
Abstract. Codling moth (Cydia pomonella L.) and Oriental Fruit Moth (Grapholita molesta (Busck))
are the main pests of apples and peach, respectively. Various formulations of synthetic sex pheromones
of both species have been developed in order to manage these pest in apple and peach orchards. The
most common use of sex pheromones has been with hand-applied dispensers, but their application is
labour intensive and growers are interested in alternative approaches. Two sprayable
microencapsulated formulations of sex pheromone have recently been commercialized. They can be
applied either alone or mixed with different chemicals. Our studies, conducted in 2007 and 2008,
showed that this method was very effective for both codling moth and oriental fruit moth and achieve
the same results as insecticides and hand-applied pheromone dispensers.
Keywords: sprayable sex pheromone, Oriental Fruit Moth, Grapholita molesta, Codling Moth, Cydia
pomonella, peach, apple
Introduction
Codling moth (Cydia pomonella L.) and Oriental Fruit Moth (Grapholita molesta (Busck))
are the main pests of apple and peach, respectively. Various formulations of synthetic sex
pheromones of both species have been developed in order to manage these pests in apple and
peach orchards. The most common use of sex pheromones has been with hand-applied
dispensers, but their application is labor intensive and growers are interested in alternative
approaches. Two sprayable microencapsulated formulations of sex pheromone have recently
been commercialized. It is important to understand the suitability of the new technique since
it has, in theory, a useful versatility.
Materials and methods
Apple
The apple orchard (2001, Golden Delicious) is located in Busca (CN) in North-West of Italy.
It is 9.5 hectares and it has been divided into 3 plots: one (1.4 ha) was sprayed with the microencapsulated pheromone (Check Mate CM-F, Suterra) starting before the first flight, while the
second (0.8 ha) started before the second flight as indicate in Figures 3 and 5. The third plot
(7.3 ha) was protected with pheromone dispensers (Isomate CLR, Shin-Etsu). In 2007, an
ovicide (Flufenoxuron, 30/4) and a larvicide (Azinfos-metil, 17/7) were applied on the first
generation in the whole orchard. In 2008, an ovicide (Flufenoxuron, 10/5) and a larvicide
(Azinfos-metil 2/7) were applied in the whole orchard.
Peach
The 2007 peach orchard (2001, Big-Top) is located in Manta (CN) in North-West of Italy. It is
4 ha divided into two plots: one (1 ha) was sprayed with the micro-encapsulated pheromone
559
(Check Mate CM-F, Suterra), while the other was protected with two larvicides as indicated in
Figure 1. The 2008 peach orchard (2002, Summer Rich) is located in Villafalletto (CN) in
North-West of Italy. It is 8 ha divided in two plots: one (1 ha) was sprayed with the microencapsulated pheromone (Check Mate CM-F, Suterra) and, in the rest, dispensers for mating
disruption (Isomate CLR, Shin-Etsu) were applied (Figure 2). The ovicide Teflubenzuron was
applied in both plots at the end of April.
The rule of interventions
The dose of spray pheromone is 100ml/ha, interventions are scheduled with an interval of 15
days. The rule applied in case of rain is to repeat the treatment at half dose (50ml/ha) if the
rain falls in the first 10 days since spray application, if after 10 days to apply the next at full
dose.
Results
Peach
The curves of male catches and the sprays applied are reported in Fig. 1 for 2007 and in Fig. 2
for 2008. No damage at harvest was recorded in both years. Microencapsulated sex
pheromone of G. molesta has been applied in a half peach orchard whereas in the other half
the usual integrated pest management was applied.
Figure 1. Mean number of Oriental Fruit Moth adult males in nectarine orchards close to
experimental plots and interventions made in 2007. No damage at harvest was recorded in
either plot.
560
Figure 2. Mean number of adult males of codling moth per trap caught in peach orchards
close to experimental plots and interventions made in 2008. No damage at harvest was
recorded in either plot. The two 1\2 dose applications of spray pheromone were applied
according to the rule that, in case of rain earlier than 10 days from last spray, spray was
repeated at half dose.
Apple
Microencapsulated sex pheromone of C. pomonella was applied in an apple orchard following
two different schedules: in the first, sprays were applied starting before the first flight and in
the second, sprays were applied starting before the second flight. In both cases, sprays were
applied at a fifteen days interval, resulting in a total of 10-11 interventions in the first
schedule and 7-8 in the second. In the other part of the orchard, Isomate dispensers were
applied before the first flight. The curves of male catches and sprays applied are reported in
Fig. 3 for 2007, and in Fig. 4 for 2008. No damage at harvest was recorded in both years.
Figure 3. Mean number of adult male of codling moth catch in apple orchards near
experimental plots and interventions made in 2007.
561
Figure 4. Mean number of adult male of codling moth catch in orchards near experimental
plots and interventions made in 2008. No damage at harvest was recorded in each of three
plots.
Discussion
Our studies, conducted in 2007 and 2008, showed that this method is very effective for both
codling moth and oriental fruit moth and gives the same results as insecticides and handapplied pheromone dispensers, although the pest population was low in both years.
The starting period in peach orchards can be just prior to the second flight, since the first
generation usually causes little damage. In northern Italy this schedule permits saving 2-3
sprays. Moreover, the end of this generation is well defined and easy to identify with both
trapping and with forecasting models.
The starting period in apple orchards is not yet defined and the two options (initiate with
first or second generation) are open, since both gave good results. It must be noted that the
possibility of starting with the first generation allows coverage of the whole season, but it
could be very expensive.
The intervention interval of 15 days seems to be suitable along with the rule applied: it
allows avoidance of rain wash-out and is still sustainable by fruit-growers. Research on the
rain-fastness and the persistence is still being done.
In conclusion, this technique looks very promising due both to its versatility and the
possibility of protecting crops until harvest taking into account economic convenience in
relation to the number of interventions. It must be reported that its versatility has to be
managed by the aid of the extension service since the product is not an insecticide as might be
mistakenly believed by fruit-growers.
Acknowledgements
We thank all the farmers and the field technicians involved in the present study. This research
was supported by Regione Piemonte (Italy) within the program: “Programma di ricerca,
sperimentazione e dimostrazione agricola in frutticoltura e orticoltura 2007 and 2008”.
562
Isomate C plus dispensers as alternative means for control
of codling moth, Cydia pomonella (L.), in apple orchards of Bulgaria
Hristina Kutinkova 1, Jörg Samietz 2, Vasiliy Dzhuvinov 1, Vittorio Veronelli 3,
Andrea Iodice3
1
Fruit Growing Institute, Ostromila 12, 4004 Plovdiv, Bulgaria; e-mail: kutinkova@abv.bg
2
Swiss Federal Research Station Agroscope Changins-Wädenswil ACW, Switzerland
3
CBC (Europe) Ltd., Milano, Italy
Abstract. In the years 2006-2008, trials on the control of codling moth (CM) by mating disruption
(MD) using Isomate C plus dispensers were carried out in an isolated 1-ha apple orchard in South-East
Bulgaria. Dispensers were hung in the upper third of tree canopies at a density of 1000 pieces per ha
before CM flights started. Dynamics of CM flights was monitored by pheromone traps installed in the
trial plot and in a conventionally treated reference orchard. Fruit infestation was periodically assessed
till harvest time. Hibernating population of CM was estimated in autumn by counting diapausing CM
larvae in corrugated cardboard bands. In each of the years, Isomate C plus dispensers completely
inhibited CM captures in pheromone traps in the trial plot. Fruit damage remained at low levels till late
July and increased slightly only in August. At harvest the percentage of damaged fruits was below 1%.
The hibernating population also stayed at low level. In the reference orchard, in spite of numerous
chemical treatments, the final fruit damage was high (5.5-28.4%), apparently due to resistance of CM
to insecticides. It has been concluded that mating disruption may serve as an alternative means for
control of codling moth in Bulgarian apple orchards. Contrary to reports from other countries, this
study has shown that good results from MD can be obtained even on a small-size plot, if isolated from
external sources of infestation and if initial CM population is low.
Keywords: IPM, apple, codling moth, mating disruption, fruit damage, Isomate C plus dispensers
Introduction
Codling moth (CM), Cydia pomonella L. (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) is a key pest of Bulgarian
pome fruit orchards. Most of recently applied insecticides have a large spectrum of action, so
that they eliminate the beneficial entomo- and acarofauna, thus provoking the multiplication
of other pests. Moreover, control of CM by conventional methods, in spite of numerous
treatments applied, is often ineffective. In Bulgaria, the damage caused by codling moth in
apple orchards has steadily increased. In 2008, in most of conventionally treated orchards in
South Bulgaria fruit damage due to CM exceeded 25%. This has been apparently due to the
development of resistant CM strains. Populations resistant to organophosphates and
pyrethroids have been detected by testing diapausing CM larvae collected in some orchards in
South Bulgaria (Charmillot et al., 2007). Therefore, the implementation of non-chemical
methods for management of this pest is an urgent need. Mating disruption (MD) is one of the
alternative means of control. Isomate-C dispensers, emitting synthetic CM pheromones, were
released by Shin-Etsu (Japan) as early as in 1989 and then improved and successfully applied
in many countries (Veronelli & Iodice 2004). Positive results obtained in trials carried out in
Central-South Bulgaria were reported in a previous paper (Kutinkova et al. 2009).
Material and methods
Trial orchard
563
In the years 2006-2008, trials were carried out in a well-isolated, 1-ha apple orchard in the
village Glufishevo, Sliven region, South-East Bulgaria. The orchard was established in 1999.
In three consecutive years the dispensers were installed in April, before the expected start of
flight of CM. They were hung in the upper third of tree canopies at a density of 1000 pieces
per ha. According to the manufacturer, each dispenser is loaded with a minimum of 190 mg of
the codling moth pheromone mixture.
Against other pests, only one acaricide treatment was applied in 2006 and two aphicide
treatments in 2007 and 2008 as follows: phenpyroximat against mite Panonychus ulmi Koch
on August 8, 2006 and thiamethoxam against aphids on May 23, 2007 and on May 25, 2008.
Reference orchard
A 4.8-ha orchard located in the same area, near the city of Sliven, established in 1990 served
as a conventionally treated reference. Fourteen treatments (21 active ingredients) were applied
there during the 2006 and 2007 seasons, to control CM, leaf miners, leaf rollers, aphids and
mites. Thirteen of them (19 active ingredients) were timed against codling moth. In 2008
seventeen treatments (24 active ingredients) were applied; fifteen of them (22 active
ingredients) were supposed to have an action against CM. The insecticides used included
methoxyphenozide, triflumuron, cipermethrin with chlorpyriphos-ethyl and fenitrothion in all
three years of the study and additionally alpha-cipermethrin in 2006, esfenvalerate in 2007
and deltamethrin in 2008.
Indices studied
Monitoring of CM flights was carried out by sex trapping. Two CM pheromone traps were
installed in the trial orchard – 1 triangular traps baited with a standard capsule (Pheronet OP72-T1-01) containing 1 mg codlemone and 1 triangular trap baited with 20 mg codlemone in
2006 and 2 triangular traps baited with a standard capsule (Pheronet OP-72-T1-01) containing
1 mg codlemone in 2007 and 2008. In the reference orchard, 2 triangular traps were placed.
All traps were installed prior to the beginning of flight of CM and then checked twice a week.
Fruit damage by CM was evaluated on samples of 1000 to 2000 fruits periodically during
the season and on 3000 fruits before and at harvest. Sampling was always carried out in the
reference orchard and in the trial plot at the same dates.
In June, 40 corrugated cardboard band traps (8 at the border and 32 inside) were attached
to the tree trunks in the trial plot and in the reference orchard. They were recovered in
autumn, after harvest, in order to count the hibernating population of CM.
Elaboration of data
Data on catches of male moths in the pheromone traps were considered as totals for each date
and presented in a graphical form. Rate of fruit damage by CM was expressed as percentage
of damaged fruits. Significance of differences in damage rate between the trial reference
orchards was estimated by use of Chi-square tests. Significance of differences between mean
values of diapausing larvae between the orchards and years was evaluated using the t-test.
Results
CM flight dynamics
In 2006, the first flight of CM in the reference orchard appeared on May 2, whereas no moths
were recorded in the pheromone traps that were installed in the trial plot two weeks before.
The flights of the overwintering generation reached their maximum by the fourth week of
May (Fig. 1) and remained considerable till the end of June. The flights of the second
generation, which overlapped the first one, started in the first week of July, reached its
maximum at the end of July, then decreased till mid-August and finished on September 9. In
the trial plot the sex pheromone traps have not caught any moth during the season. The traps
installed in the reference orchard caught 128 moths in total.
564
C. pomonella flight Sliven 2006-2008
45
No. of moths caught per trap
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
Sep
18
Se
p
08
Au
g
29
Au
g
2008
2007
2006
19
Jul
Au
g
09
Date
30
Jul
20
Jul
10
Jun
30
Jun
20
Jun
10
Ma
y
Ma
y
Ma
y
Ma
y
31
21
11
01
21
Ap
r
0
Figure 1. Captures of male Codling moth, Cydia pomonella, per pheromone trap in the reference
orchard 2006-2008
In 2007, the first flights of codling moth in the reference orchard appeared on April 30,
whereas no moths were recorded in the pheromone traps in the trial plot. The flight of the
overwintering generation of CM reached its maximum in the second week of May and after
the second week of June (Fig. 1) The flight of the second generation, which did not overlap
the first one, started in the first week of July, reached its maximum during the second week of
July, decreased in August and finished on September 14. In the trial plot the standard sex
traps have not caught any moth during the 2007 season. At the same time the traps installed in
the reference orchard caught in total 283 moths.
In 2008, the first flights of codling moth in the reference orchard appeared on April 25,
whereas no moths were recorded in the pheromone traps installed before in the trial plot. The
flight of the overwintering generation of CM reached its maximum in the first week of May
(Fig. 1) and continued through May and June. The flight of the second generation, which
overlapped the first one, started by the end of June, reached its maximum during the second
week of July, then decreased in August. A small peak appeared at the end of August. It was
probably due to a partial third generation, but this was not well documented yet. The last
flights were recorded on September 12. Traps installed in the reference orchard caught in total
359 moths. In the trial plot no moths were caught during the 2008 season.
Fruit damage by CM
In the trial plot, where the Isomate-C plus dispensers were installed, no damage of fruits due
to CM was noted till July in the years 2007 and 2008 and even till the beginning of August in
2006 (Table 1). Then fruit damage stayed at a low level, reaching finally 0.4-0.7% at harvest.
In the reference orchard, located in the same regions and treated with a conventional
protection programme the first signs of damage to fruitlets were noted already in June, then
the rate of damage successively progressed, reaching very high values at harvest. It is worth
565
noting that the final rate of damage increased in consecutive years – from 5.5% in 2006,
through 14.8% in 2007 and as much as 28.4% in 2008.
Table 1. Evolution of fruit damage (% of fruits infested by CM) and number of hibernating
CM larvae in corrugated paper bands in autumn, in particular years of study
Date
June 1
2006
Trial
0.0
Reference Date
0.5
June 9
2007
Trial
0
June 15
0.0
1.5
June 25
0
3.5
July 13
0.0
1.8
July 5
0
Aug 4
0.0
2.4
July 29
Aug 23
0.05
4.1
Sept 14
0.35
5.2
Oct 2
0.40
damage
0.35
preharvest
damage at
0.40
harvest
hibernating
larvae
0.125
per tree
5.5
5.2
5.5
2.175
2008
Trial
0
Reference
June 21
0
3.7
0.0
July 18
0
2.6
0.2
5.8
Aug 10
0.3
10.5
Aug 12
0.3
9.8
Aug 23
0.4
14.5
Sept 6
0.4
13.2
Sept 7
0.6
23.8
0.5
14.8
0.4
13.2
0.5
14.8
Oct 3
0.7
damage
0.6
preharvest
damage at
0.7
harvest
hibernating
larvae
0.425
per tree
Oct 3
damage
preharvest
damage at
harvest
hibernating
larvae
per tree
0.225
Reference Date
0.8
June 8
4.575
0.6
28.4
23.8
28.4
9.025
Infestation rates in 2006 were significantly different between the treated plot and the
reference orchard from the second check on 15 June till harvest (Chi-square tests, P < 0.001).
In 2007, they were significantly different between the treated plot and the reference orchard
already at the first control in June (Chi-square test, P=0.014) and, except for July 5, thereafter
until harvest (Chi-square tests, P<0.001). In 2008, fruit damage rates were significantly
different between the treated plot and the reference orchard already at the first control in June
(Chi-square tests, P=0.002) and thereafter until harvest (Chi-square tests, P<0.001).
Overwintering population of CM
In autumn 2006, i.e. after the first season of MD treatment, only 0.125 larvae per tree were
found in corrugated cardboard bands in the trial orchard. At the same time in the reference
orchard the overwintering population of CM reached 2.175 larvae per tree (Table 1). In the
successive years (2007 and 2008) the level of overwintering population of CM in the trial plot
increased slightly, stayed below the economical threshold, however. At the same time the
population of diapausing larvae of CM in the reference, conventionally treated orchard
increased rapidly in successive years, reaching in autumn 2008 the value more than 4 times
higher than in autumn 2006.
The populations were significantly different between treated plot and reference orchard
(t-test, P<0.001) as well as between the years 2006 and 2007 in the reference orchard (t-test,
P<0.001). In the treated orchard there was no difference in the overwintering population
between 2006 and 2007 (t-test, P=0.24). In 2008, the hybernating CM populations were
significantly different between treated plot and reference orchard (t-test, P <0.001) as well as
between the years 2007 and 2008 in both treated plot and reference orchard, respectively
(t-test, P<0.001).
566
Discussion
The results obtained in this study confirm the findings of Charmillot et al. (2007) that
resistance of codling moth to insecticides is a serious problem in Bulgaria. The conventional
chemical control of CM is getting ineffective. Increasing intensity of CM flights as well as
increased fruit damage and diapausing CM larvae population in the conventionally treated
orchard – in spite of numerous chemical treatments – do indicate that the problem of
resistance is aggravating.
Results obtained with mating disruption were very positive. Isomate C plus dispensers of
Shin Etsu effectively inhibited flights of CM as well as fruit damage and the size of the
hibernating CM population. The results obtained are in line with those reported by Gut et al.
(1992), Gut and Brunner (1998), Judd et al. (1996), Barnes & Bloomefield (1997), Charmillot
et al. (1997), Waldner (1997) and Zingg (2001). They also confirm our previous reports
(Kutinkova et al. 2009). It is worth noting that in our study the positive results with the MD
method were obtained in a rather small orchard lot (1 ha). Apparently, isolation from external
sources of infestation and the initial level of CM pressure are more important factors than the
orchard size. It has been concluded that mating disruption may be successfully applied as
alternative means for controlling codling moth in apple orchards of Bulgaria. Implementation
of this method should result in reduction of the use of chemical insecticides, thus minimising
environmental pollution and improving fruit quality.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported with a grant of the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) to JS
(project no. IB73A0-110978). Isomate C plus dispensers of Shin-Etsu were kindly provided
by CBC (Europe), Ltd., Milano, Italy.
References
Barnes B.N. & Blomefield T.L. 1997. Risultati preliminari con la confusione sessuale del
tortricide ricamatore, Tortrix capensana, nei meleti del Sud-Africa. Difesa delle Piante 20
(1/2): 49-53.
Charmillot P-J., Pasquier D., Dorsaz L., Keimer C., Herminjard P., Olivier R. & Zuber M.
1997. Lutte par confusion contre le carpocapse Cydia pomonella L. en Suisse en 1996 au
moyen des diffuseurs Isomate-C Plus. Revue Suisse Vitic. Arboric. Hortic. 29 (2): 91-96.
Charmillot P-J., Pasquier D., Salamin C., Briand F., Azizian A., Kutinkova H., Peeva P. &
Velcheva N. 2007. Détection de la résistance du carpocapse Cydia pomonella par
application topique d'insecticides sur des chenilles diapausantes de Suisse, d'Arménie et
de Bulgarie. Revue Suisse Vitic. Arboric. Hortic. 39 (6): 385-389.
Gut L.J. & Brunner J.F. 1998. Pheromone-based management of codling moth (Lepidoptera:
Tortricidae) in Washington apple orchards. J. Agric. Entom. 15 (4): 387-405.
Gut L.J., Brunner J.F. & Knight A. 1992. Mating disruption as a control for codling moth and
leaf rollers. Good Fruit Grower 43 (5): 56-60.
Judd G.J., Gardiner M.G, & Thomson D. 1996. Commercial trials of pheromone-mediated
mating disruption with Isomate-CReg. to control codling moth in British Columbia apple
and pear orchards. J. Entom. Soc. British Columbia 93: 23-34.
Kutinkova H., J. Samietz, Dzhuvinov V, Charmillot P.-J., Veronelli V. 2009. Mating disruption
of codling moth, Cydia pomonella L., using Isomate C plus dispensers in apple orchards
of Bulgaria. IOBC/wprs Bull. [in press]
Veronelli V. & Iodice A. 2004. The use of Shin Etsu mating disruption system in Italy.
IOBC/wprs Bull 27 (5): 63-65.
567
Waldner W. 1997. Three years of large-scale control of codling moth by mating disruption in
the South Tyrol, Italy. Bull. OILB/SROP 20 (1): 35-44.
Zingg D. 2001. Mating disruption in Switzerland. Bull. OILB/SROP 24 (2): 65-69.
568
A field unit for automatic monitoring of insect behaviour
Federica Trona1, Gianfranco Anfora1, Roberto Oberti2, Ezio Naldi2, Claudio Ioriatti1,
Gino Angeli1
1Plant Protection Department, FEM Research Center, via E. Mach 1, San Michele all’Adige
(TN), Italy; 2Institute of Agricultural Engineering, University of Milano, via Celoria 2,
Milano, Italy
Abstract: The aim of this work was the development of a field unit for automatic recording and
related data analysis of insect orientation towards an attractive pheromone source. Currently the
evidence of male behaviour under mating disruption is still speculative, due to the difficulty to conduct
field observations which unequivocally show the operative mechanisms. This monitoring system
provides behavioural data, in order to optimize the effectiveness of control strategies based on
semiochemicals. Specifically, the unit records frequencies of the visits, temporal dynamics and
trajectories around the attractive source. The operating principle of the unit is based on the acquisition
and real-time analysis of near infrared images relative to an area of 80 x 80 cm around the source; the
functioning is fully autonomous and remotely controlled via GSM network. We chose as study model
the behaviour of codling moth, Cydia pomonella (L.), in an apple orchard managed with mating
disruption (Isomate C Plus, 1000/ha). The operation of the unit was verified by analysing the approach
of the males toward three different attractive sources: a standard monitoring lure (1 mg of E8,E10dodecadien-1-ol), an Isomate CP Plus dispenser and two calling females. The infrared camera was
placed in the middle of a field tunnel. For each trial 10 virgin, 2-3-day-old males were released. The
recordings went on for 2 days, from 7.00 pm to the midnight.
Cydia pomonella L., Mating disruption, Pheromone, Infrared camera
569
Correlation between maturity of female R. cerasi, oviposition, larval
development and ripeness of cherries
Kirsten Köppler1, Barbara Féjoz2, Heidrun Vogt1
1
Julius Kühn-Institut (JKI), Federal Research Centre for Cultivated Plants, Institute for Plant
Protection in Fruit Crops and Viticulture, Schwabenheimer Str. 101, 69221 Dossenheim,
Germany; kirsten.koeppler@jki.bund.de
2
University of Heidelberg, Zoological Institute, Im Neuenheimer Feld 230, 69120 Heidelberg,
Germany
Abstract: The European cherry fruit fly Rhagoletis cerasi L. (Diptera: Tephritidae) is the most serious
pest in European cherry production. The control of the pest is difficult, especially against the
background of EU wide reduction programs for broad spectrum insecticides. To find alternative
control measures, the biology and behaviour of the fly must be known in more detail. One option to
control the pest might be bait sprays, which have to be applied repeatedly during the main infestation
period. To achieve the optimal efficacy and with respect to the costs, timing and number of
applications are important questions. For this reason we investigated the correlation between the
maturity of female R. cerasi by analysing the ovary status of flies caught with yellow sticky traps,
oviposition, larval development and ripeness of host fruits (varieties Sam, Van and Hedelfinger) by
measuring colour, sugar content as well as solidity, recorded as pressure resistance.
The 1st fly was trapped on May 9, whereas the 1st ripe eggs after dissection of ovaries were found on
May 13. According to the cherry variety, the first deposited eggs were detected between May 28 and
June 2. During this time, the cherries turned their colour from green to yellow/orange, pressure
resistance ranged between 4.0 and 6.3 kg/cm2 and sugar content between 8.4 and 13.8 °Brix. Newly
deposited eggs were found until mid of July, whereas 3rd instars occurred from mid of June until
mid/end of July, depending on cherry harvest and variety.
Key words: Rhagoletis cerasi, Tephritidae, Diptera, phenology, oviposition
Introduction
The European cherry fruit fly Rhagoletis cerasi is the main pest in cherry orchards in Europe,
causing fruit damage and yield losses (Vogt, 2002, Daniel & Wyss, 2003). In Germany, the
broad spectrum insecticides lebaycid and dimethoate were registered until 2004 and 2007,
respectively for conventional farming. In 2008, acetamiprid could be used with an annual
exemptional permission (§ 11 PflschG), but with varying success. In organic and integrated
cherry production no control at all was possible until 2006. Since 2006 ‘Spruzit Neu’ (a.i.:
pyrethrines and rape seed oil; W. Neudorff GmbH KG, Emmerthal, Germany) is registered
against sucking and biting insects in cherries, whereas side effects of this insecticide are used
against cherry fruit fly. As its persistence is rather short, this may limit the efficacy from case
to case. Hence, there is an urgent need to develop alternative strategies for all, conventional,
integrated and organic cherry growers, which can also include origins of infestation, like back
yard cherry trees. For environmentally sound control strategies, the biology as well as the
behaviour of the pest species must be known in detail. Since the use of broad spectrum
insecticides, research on biological and behavioural aspects of R. cerasi was set in the
background. Different authors worked on different biological questions in the 30’s, and the
60’s to the 80’s, repectively (Boller, 1964, Boller, 1966 a, Boller & Remund, 1983, 1987,
570
Fimiani, 1984, Katsoyannos et al., 1986, Skaar, 1999 etc.). Therein they tried to answer
questions about phenology in form of a forecasting model, life tables or dispersal, but many
aspects were not worked out. Open questions are e.g. the correlation of penology of flies and
their host fruits, development of ovaries, oviposition and fruit ripening parameters or duration
of oviposition. This knowledge is especially important for more selective control strategies.
One environmentally sound control strategies could be bait sprays with natural derived
insecticides. Bait sprays as a combination of food baits, mainly proteins and sugar, and low
amounts of insecticides are only applied on parts of the canopy. As the known natural derived
insecticides as pyrethrines and neem are not persistent for a long time, applications must be
repeated for several times. To find the optimal application time and necessary replications,
more information about the pest is needed.
In this study, the correlation between the phenology of flies, the development of ovaries,
oviposition and ripening process of cherries were worked out. The main aim was to achieve a
better understanding for e.g. bait spray application to reach a high efficacy with low side
effects and to reduce costs for material and man power.
Material and Methods
Laboratory: To provide an age scale of flies according to their ovary development, 800 pupae
were used. These pupae were obtained from field-collected infested cherries in 2007, kept
under room conditions (20 to 25 °C) for two months and transferred into the cold room (3 to 5
°C) for approximately six to eight months. For post-diapause development, pupae were
brought to a climate chamber (25 ± 0.5 °C / 18 ± 0.5 °C, RH 65 ± 5 %, photo period light :
dark 16:8 h, 4 to 6 klux). Adults were sorted according to their hatching date to provide a
defined age and kept in BioQuip cages (30 x 30 x 30 cm plastic cages; “Bug Dorm-1”,
BioQuip Products, Rancho Dominquez, CA, USA). Aside from the availability of water, flies
were fed with sucrose and brewer’s yeast (Diana Bierhefe, Spezialfuttermittel M. Diekmann,
Versmold-Bockhorst, Germany), ratio 4:1 by weight as dry food. Ovaries of female flies of a
defined age (N=10 for age classes of 1 to 30 days) were dissected and classified according to
their ovary development: 1 = ± no visible development, 2 = unequal vesicles, 3 = ripe eggs.
Field: Adult flies were trapped with yellow sticky Rebell® traps (Andermatt Biocontrol AG,
Grossdietwil, CH) from May 5 to August 29 in 2008 at the cherry orchard in Dossenheim and
transferred (N = 10 ♀ at maximum according to the number of trapped flies) into 70 % EtOH
three times a week. These flies were dissected and classified the same way as the laboratory
flies. Traps were placed in the southern part of the trees at an approximate height of 2 m in
three different cultivars with N = 5 in each case (Sam, Van and Hedelfinger).
Parallel to the trapping of flies, cherries were harvested (N = 50) and controlled for eggs
using a microscope (magnification: 10x) and different larval stages while opening the cherries
(N = 100) and putting them into salt water (10 %) for at least 1 hour. Larvae could then be
collected from the water surface and approximately classified according to their length into
1st, 2nd and 3rd instars. Another 10 cherries per cultivar were harvested for measuring their
colour, using a RAL® Design Colour Fan ( RAL Dt. Inst. f. Gütesicherung u. Kennzeichnung
e.V., Sankt Augustin, Germany), their sugar content [°Brix] using a Hand Held °Brix
Refractometer (RHB-32 ATC, 0-32 °Brix) as well as their solidity recorded as pressure
resistance [kg/cm2] with a Digital Penetrometer PCE-PTR 200 (PCE Group, Meschede,
Germany).
Results and Discussion
Laboratory: The ovary dissection of the laboratory flies showed that females are one to four
days old in stage 1 (± no visible development), four to nine days in stage 2 (unequal vesicles)
571
and 10 days and older with ripe eggs (stage 3) at the defined temperature in the climate
chamber. A preoviposition period of approximately 10 days was already shown in different
studies (Wiesmann, 1933, Boller, 1966 b). The main reason of dissecting flies of the defined
age was to provide an age scale for the flies trapped in the field.
Field: To ease the demonstration of the results, different cherry cultivars were combined. The
main results are listed in Table 1.
First flies were trapped in the cherry cultivar Hedelfinger on May 9 and the last fly was
trapped in the same cultivar on August 8. After dissection of trapped flies, ripe eggs were
found from May 13 until the end of the trapping period in August. According to the results of
the laboratory flies, cherry fruit flies must have been emerged at least six days earlier at the
orchard than the first trap catch. Following, it is unlikely to trap the first flies in an orchard
with yellow traps and control strategies have to be adapted to this fact. In contrast to mature
flies in the field, eggs were found in the cherries 19 days past the first trap catch of a female
fly, on May 28. This can either mean, that there are flies with ripe eggs in the field but the
cherries are not attractive enough, not in the appropriate stage for oviposition or the sample
size of 50 cherries per cultivar was not big enough to reach a high probability to find the first
eggs. Newly deposited eggs were found in the cherries until July 11, although ripe fruits were
available until mid / end of July and flies with ripe eggs were detected until August, as
mentioned before. The oviposition into ripe cherries will probably result in a loss of a part of
the offspring. But the conclusion of Levinson & Haisch (1984), that R. cerasi has a marked
preference for oviposition into unripe fruits, can not be confirmed completely. Beside an
oviposition peak at the end of May until mid of June in all cultivars, when cherries have been
still in their ripening process, the cultivar Hedelfinger, showed a second oviposition peak into
ripe dark red or black fruits at the end of June / beginning of July. Accordingly, comparing the
colour of cherries with the newly deposited eggs, a specific colour does not seem to be the
key factor for oviposition. First eggs were found, when cherries started to turn their colour
from green to yellow at the end of May 2008 and last eggs were found in highly ripe cherries
of a dark red to black colour mid of July 2008. This corresponds to some extend with studies
of e.g. Haisch & Levinson (1980) and Levinson & Haisch (1982), that increasing ovopisition
takes place in spheres with a higher contrast to the background and not the colour itself. Also
Boller (1969) and Prokopy (1969) showed for R. cerasi, that dark coloured small spheres are
preferred over those of lighter colours. Additionally, Katsoyannos (1979) highlighted that hue
discrimination may also be involved in the selection of oviposition site. Beside these findings
for oviposition, the preference of yellow colour in small to medium size panels or X-shaped
rectangles must be kept in mind (Boller, 1969, Prokopy, 1969, Prokopy & Boller, 1971).
3rd instar larvae, which could leave the host fruits for pupation occurred in cherries from
June 11, when the cherries were reddish to dark red until July 16 in very ripe fruits.
Following, immigration of larvae into the soil was a process of more than four weeks in
Dossenheim in 2008.
The sugar content of cherries during oviposition and larval development revealed
increasing values from 6.2 °Brix at minimum in the cultivar Sam at the end of May to 22.9
°Brix in the cultivar Hedelfinger June 14. Newly deposited eggs were found with values
between 8.4 in the cultivar Sam and the mentioned maximum value in Hedelfinger. Hence,
newly deposited eggs as well as larvae of different stages occurred in the cherries during a
strongly varying sugar content. It means that the cherry fruit fly larvae have a wide tolerance
of sugar content in the host fruits and sugar content in its range in ripening cherries does not
to be an important factor for neither oviposition nor larval development.
Measuring the solidity of cherries was not possible before May 28 for Van and Sam,
respectively and for Hedelfinger before June 2. The cherries have been to hard for the
measurement device. Following, the first measurement of solidity corresponds with the first
eggs. The highest solidity (6.3 kg/cm2) was found in the cultivar Van at the end of May.
572
Before this date no eggs were found. It decreased permanently during the ripening process
depending on the cultivar around one or below 1 kg/cm2. The solidity of cherries seem to be
more significant for initialization of oviposition than the other mentioned features. But, to
find a definite solidity threshold and a real correlation between solidity and oviposition,
laboratory trials as a choice test should be undertaken.
The results implicate, that depending on the mode of action of alternative control
strategies (prevention of maturation or killing of flies), these strategies have to be applied at
different periods in fly phenology. For some control measures, a control immediately after the
first trap catches is useful or it won’t be enough to control the pest at the beginning of the
oviposition period when the cherries turn their colour from green to yellow or reddish. In the
case of an incomplete harvest of cherries the oviposition in almost ripe or ripe cherries must
be kept in mind to prevent the development of a new generation in the following season.
Table 1. Overview about main phonological parameters of R. cerasi in correlation to the host
fruit ripening process
Time scale
Parameter
trapped ♀
ripe eggs after
dissection of ♀
deposited eggs in
cherries
3rd instars in cherries
colour of cherries
sugar content [°Brix]
solidity [kg/cm2]
May
June
July
August
5–10–15–20–25–30–4–9–14–19–24–29–4-9-14-19-24-29-3-8
6.2
6.3
22.9
0.6
References
Boller, E. F. 1964: Auftreten der Kirschenfliege (Rhagoletis cerasi L.) und Prognose mittels
Bodentemperaturen im Jahre 1963. Schweiz. Z. Obst- Weinbau 100: 53-58.
Boller E. F. 1966a: Drei Jahre Erfahrung in der Zeitprognose für die Kirschenfliegenbekämpfung mittels Bodentemperaturmessung. Schweiz. Z. Obst- Weinbau 102: 63-67.
Boller E. F. 1966b: Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Eiablage und Fertilität der Kirschenfliege
Rhagoletis cerasi L. – vorläufige Mitteilung. Mitt. Schw. Ent. Ges. 3 und 4: 193-202.
Boller, E. F. 1969 : Neues über die Kirschenfliege : Freilandversuche im Jahre 1969. Schweiz.
Z. Obst- Weinbau 105: 566-572.
Boller, E. F. & Remund, U. 1983: Dix années d’utilisation de données sur les sommes de
températures journaliéres pour la prévision des vols de Rhagoletis cerasi et d’Eupoecilia
ambiguella au nord de la Suisse. Bull. OEPP 13 (2): 209-212.
Boller, E. F. & Remund, U. 1986: Qualitative and quantitative life-table studies in Rhagoletis
cerasi in Northwest Switzerland. Proc. CEC / IOBC Int. Symp. Rom, 7-10 April: 25-34.
Daniel, C. U. & Wyss, E. 2003: Neue Wege zur Regulierung der Kirschfruchtfliege
Rhagoletis cerasi in der biologischen Süßkirschenproduktion. In: Bernhard Freyer
(Hrsg.) Beiträge zur 7. Wissenschaftstagung zum Ökologischen Landbau. Ökologischer
Landbau der Zukunft. Februar 2003, Wien, Universität für Bodenkultur, 541-542.
Fimiani, P. 1984: Phenological observations on European cherry fruit fly (Rhagoletis cerasi
L.) in the south areas. Proc. CEC / IOBC ‘ad.hoc meeting’ Hamburg, 23 August: 169573
173.
Haisch, A. & Levinson, H. Z. 1980: Influences of fruit volatiles and colouration on
oviposition of the cherry fruit fly. Naturwissenschaften 67: 44.
Katsoyannos, B. I. 1979: Zum Reproduktions- und Wirtswahlverhalten der Kirschenfliege.
Rhagoletis cerasi L. (Diptera: Tephritidae). Dissertation Nr. 6409 ETH Zürich, 180 pp.
Katsoyannos, B. I., Boller, E. F. & Benz, G. 1986: Das Verhalten der Kirschenfliege,
Rhagoletis cerasi L., bei der Auswahl der Wirtspflanzen und ihre Dispersion. Mitt.
Schweiz. Entomol. Ges. 59: 315-335.
Levinson, H. Z. & Haisch, A. 1982: Optical and chemosensory stimuli involved in host
recognition and oviposition of the cherry fruit fly Rhagoletis cerasi. L. Proc. CEC/IOBC
Int. Symp. Athens / Greece 16 -19 Nov. 1982: 268-275.
Levinson, H. Z. & Haisch, A. 1984: Optical and chemosensory stimuli involved in host
recognition and oviposition of the cherry fruit fly Rhagoletis cerasi. Z. Angew. Entomol.
97: 85-91.
Prokopy, R. J. 1969: Visual responses of European cherry fruit flies – Rhagoletis cerasi L.
(Diptera, Trypetidae). Polskie Pismo Entomologiczne 39: 539-566.
Prokopy, R. J. & Boller, E. F., 1971: Response of European cherry fruit Fly to coloured
rectangles. J. Econ. Entomol. 64: 1444-1447.
Skaar, E. 1999: Adult emergence and swarming activity of the cherry fruit fly, relay to
meteorological factors (Preliminary project results). IOBC wprs Bull. 22 (11): 75-80.
Vogt, H. 2002: Expertenkolloquium Kirschfruchtfliege. BBA Dossenheim, 27.-28. Nov. 2001.
Nachrichtenblatt Deut. Pflanzenschutzdienst 54, 77-79.
Wiesmann, R. 1933: Untersuchungen über die Lebensgeschichte und Bekämpfung der
Kirschfliege Rhagoletis cerasi Linné. Landw. Jahrb. Schweiz 47: 711-760.
574