Mycol. Res. 107 (4): 485–494 (April 2003). f The British Mycological Society
485
DOI: 10.1017/S0953756203007585 Printed in the United Kingdom.
First records of ectomycorrhizal Cortinarius species
(Agaricales, Basidiomycetes) from tropical India and their
phylogenetic position based on rDNA ITS sequences
Ursula PEINTNER1*, Meinhard M. MOSER#, K. Agretious THOMAS2 and P. MANIMOHAN2
1
Institute of Microbiology, University of Innsbruck, Technikerstrasse 25, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
Department of Botany, Calicut University, Kerala, 673 635, India.
E-mail : ursula.peintner@uibk.ac.at
2
Received 17 April 2002; accepted 13 February 2003.
Three new Cortinarius species, Cortinarius conopileus, C. keralensis, and C. phlegmophorus spp. nov., are described from
Kerala State in southern India. This is the first record of ectomycorrhizal Cortinarius spp. in the tropical part of India.
In addition to distinct morphological characters, the comparative analysis of rDNA ITS sequences of the collections
from India and morphologically similar species support the recognition of these taxa as new species. Phylogenetic
analyses demonstrate that the three Indian Cortinarius spp. belong to both larger subclades of the genus Cortinarius,
clade/cortinarius and clade/telamonia. As supported by morphological and molecular data, C. phlegmophorus belongs
to Cortinarius subgen. Myxacium sect. Defibulati. Based on classical morphological characters, both C. keralensis and
C. conopileus are representatives of subgen. Telamonia. However, C. conopileus belongs to clade/obtusi, which is a
well-supported subclade of clade/cortinarius. Thus, in contrast to classical taxonomy, the clade/obtusi represents an
independent evolutionary origin of telamonioid taxa. This result is also reflected by the distinct morphological characters
of taxa of clade/obtusi, namely the lamellar trama with ellipsoid inflated hyphae and the presence of cystidia. In contrast,
C. keralensis is a typical member of clade/telamonia. Within/telamonia, only relationships of closely related taxa are
resolved due to the low genetic divergence found in ITS sequences. Based on morphological and molecular criteria,
C. keralensis is a distinct taxon of sect. Saturnini.
INTRODUCTION
The ectomycorrhizal genus Cortinarius occurs predominantly in temperate to subarctic-alpine climates
in both Hemispheres. Until the recent past it had been
postulated (Singer et al. 1983) that ectomycorrhizas
are the exception in the tropics. In the last two decades quite a lot of information has been accumulated,
demonstrating that several ectomycorrhizal genera are
well represented in the tropics (e.g. Russulales, Boletales ; Fassi & Moser 1991, Buyck et al. 1996, Buyck
& Horak 1999, Henkel, Aime & Miller 2000). Moreover, ectomycorrhizal associates of leguminous host
trees in the genus Dicymbe (Caesalpiniaceae) have
been studied extensively in the Guyana’s Pakaraima
Mountains (Henkel et al. 2000, Henkel 2001, Henkel,
Terborgh & Vilgalys 2002). However, the occurrence
of Cortinarius in tropical areas is indeed rather the
exception. A few species are described from Brazil
(Singer et al. 1983) and Mexico (Murrill 1912), several
* Corresponding author.
# Deceased; see Mycological Research 107 (4): 506–508 (April
2003).
(partly undescribed) species are known from Congo
(Beeli 1928, unpubl. collections from Mme. GoossensFontana), and several Cortinarius spp. occur in Guyana
(unpubl. species of Terry Henkel). In the latter two
cases, these Cortinarius spp. are associated with leguminous plants. All other reports of Cortinarii in
tropical areas are from mountainous habitats. From
tropical India, as yet no representatives of this genus
were known. Here three taxa from southern India, assumed to be associated with Hopea, Dipterocarpaceae,
are described. Dipterocarpaceae are reported to be
ectomycorrhizal in Malaysia and the Philippines
(Watling 1994, 1995). Moreover, in vitro synthesis has
been achieved between ectomycorrhizal fungi and
root organs of tropical Dipterocarp species (Louis &
Scott 1987), but as yet no Cortinarii have been reported
in association with this plant family.
In Kerala State, the climate is equable and varies
little from season to season. The temperature normally ranges 24–37.5 xC in the plains and 10–32 x in
the hills. The state gets its due share of both the southwest as well as the north-east monsoons, and the rainfall is heavy, averaging around 3000 mm p.a. In the
Ectomycorrhizal Cortinarius species from tropical India
Cortinariaceae, all three new species, as well as the
recently described monotypic agaric genus Anamika
(Thomas et al. 2002) were from a single locality in the
Wayanad District of Kerala State. Floristically this
locality is a transitional zone between wet evergreen
and teak (deciduous) forests. All the collections were
from a riverbank where the riparian flora is predominantly evergreen. Several plants of this locality, including the Hopea spp. and other trees with which these
agarics are thought to be associated, are endemic to
peninsular India. In addition to the endemics, elements
or relatives of the Sri Lankan, Madagascarian, African,
and Malayan biotas are also seen in this region.
Due to the special habitat of these new Cortinarius
species, we attempted to clarify their phylogenetic
position. We used nuclear ribosomal DNA sequences
of the internal transcribed spacers (ITS-rDNA) to investigate the taxonomic position of these taxa. These
sequences have proved to be most useful for molecular
systematics of Cortinarius (Rogers & Ammirati 1997,
Høiland & Holst-Jensen 2000, Seidl 2000, Moser et al.
2001, Peintner et al. 2001) and related genera (Aanen
et al. 2000, Moncalvo et al. 2000, 2002). For the phylogenetic placement of these species, numerous sequences
are available for comparison in GenBank or in the
Cortinarius database in Rytas Vilgalys’ laboratory
(Duke University, Durham, NC). Our goal was to
report three new taxa and to address the question
of the phylogenetic relationships between these and
morphologically similar Cortinarius spp.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Macro- and microscopical characterisation
Colours of basidiomes are described based on the
codes of Kornerup & Wanscher (1978). The specimens
were examined by standard microscopic techniques
in 3% KOH. Microscopic data were documented
by video prints produced with a Sony video camera
SASC-C350P and a Sony video printer UP 910. All
measurements were on prints at 2900r. For statistical
evaluation, 35 spores were measured. If not otherwise
stated values are given as min-max. Single extraordinarily high or low values are in brackets.
For scanning electron microscopy (SEM), dried
fragments of lamellae were rehydrated in 25 % ammonia solution for 1 h, dehydrated in 70 % aqueous
ethanol for 1 h, fixed in pure 1,2-dimethoxy-methane
for 1.5 h and then immersed in pure acetone for at
least 2 h. After critical-point drying, they were mounted on aluminium porters and sputtered with gold.
Micrographs were prepared using a Zeiss DSM-950
SEM.
Molecular techniques
In order to establish the phylogenetic relationships of
the three new Cortinarius spp., ITS-rDNA sequences
486
Table 1. Species used in this study with their GenBank ITS sequence
accession nos. When available, reference collection numbers are
given. About half the sequences were generated in earlier studies
(Liu et al. 1997, Aanen et al. 2000, Høiland & Hoist-Jensen 2000,
Seidl 2000, Peintner et al. 2001).
Species
Cortinarius
C. acutovelatus
C. acutovelatus
C. acutus
C. albocanus
C. alnetorum
C. alnetorum
C. atrocoeruleus
C. cedriolens
C. cinereobrunneus
C. collinitus
C. conopileus (holotype)
C. decipiens
C. evernius
C. helvelloides
C. heterosporus
C. hinnuleus
C. hinnuleus
C. keralensis (holotype)
C. laniger Fr.
C. laniger
C. leucopus
C. lividoochraceus
C. miniatopus
C. mucifluus
C. mucosus
C. muscigenus
C. obtusus
C. paleaceus
C. paleaceus
C. paveleckii
C. phlegmophorus (holotype)
C. porphyroideus
C. porphyroides
C. pseudosalor
C. pulchellus
C. pulchellus
C. saturninus
C. trivialis
C. umbilicatus
C. umidicola
C. urbicus
C. vanduzerensis
Hebeloma
H. circinans
H. fastibile
H. mesophaeum
Collection
IB19980108
IB19930722
IB19980137
Halling5832
IB19920217
IB19970382
IB20000132
IB20000045
IB19630258
IB19890462
IB19990302
IB19740451
IB19930140
IB19960139
IB19930113
IB19990305
IB19740251
IB19990511
IB19630078
IB19960258
IB19940186
IB19980139
IB19990308
IB19960086
IB20000025
IB19980189
IB19890415
IB19970431
IB19940036
GenBank
accession no.
AY083174
AY083175
AF325578
AF325599
AY083176
AY083177
AY083178
AY083179
AF325600
AY083181
AY083187
AY083180
AJ236077
AY083182
AF268894
AY083183
AY083184
AY083188
AF325591
AF325592
AF325593
AF325565
U56029
AF182795
AF182801
AY083185
AJ238035
AF389156
AJ236078
AF325564
AY083186
AF325576
AF325577
AF182792
AF389155
AY083192
AY083189
AJ236066
U56032
AY083191
AY083190
AF182794
AF124716
AF325643
AF126100
were prepared from the type material of each taxon.
Sequences of morphologically similar taxa were used
to investigate the phylogenetic relationship. They were
either created for this study, or retrieved from GenBank or from the Vilagalys Cortinarius database. The
fungal collections used are listed in Table 1, with their
GenBank accession nos. In order to distinguish between names of clades and names of taxa, clade names
are marked with a slash and not written in italics (e.g.
clade/telamonia).
U. Peintner and others
DNA was isolated from dried herbarium material
following standard protocols (Zolan & Pukkila 1986).
Primers used for the ITS region were ITS1 and ITS4
(White et al. 1990). Amplifications were carried out
in a 25 ml reaction mix under standard conditions
(Vilgalys & Hester 1990) in a Perkin-Elmer 9600 thermocycler (Perkin-Elmer, Foster City, CA).
Sequencing was performed using fluorescent dye
terminator chemistries following the manufacturer’s
instructions (Perkin-Elmer) on automated sequencers
(ABI 373A, ABI 377, Perkin-Elmer, Norwalk, CN).
Sequence chromatograms were compiled with Sequencher software version 2.0 (Gene Codes, Ann Arbor,
MI) or Sequence Navigator (Perkin-Elmer, Foster
City, CA). Sequences were submitted to GenBank, and
alignments are deposited in TreeBASE (http://www.
treebase.org/treebase//) under study accession no. S799
and the matrix accession no. M1265.
Phylogenetic analyses
The three Cortinarius spp. would be expected to belong
to different subgenera based on morphological characters and classical systematics. Therefore, we divided the
analyses into three steps : First, to place the sequences
in a broader phylogenetic context, BLAST searches
were made in GenBank. Then, the ITS sequences of
the three taxa from India were manually added to the
alignment of the large Vilgalys Cortinarius database
in the data editor of PAUP* 4.0b8 (Swofford 1998).
The relationships of the new taxa were first assessed
by a fast bootstrap analysis (Felsenstein 1985) of the
large dataset. Based on these results, the final analysis was restricted to 35 ingroup species of Cortinarius
(42 sequences), and three Hebeloma spp. as an outgroup. The alignment for this large data matrix with
45 sequences was 840 characters long. Areas of ambiguous alignment and gapped areas were excluded;
thus 461 characters remained for analysis : 288 characters were constant, 43 were parsimony uninformative,
and 130 characters were parsimony informative. The
exluded areas are indicated in the TreeBASE file.
Phylogenetic analyses were performed with maximum parsimony (MP) and maximum likelihood
(ML) in PAUP* 4.0b8 (Swofford 1998). MP was used
to search for optimal trees, with maxtrees set to 20 000
and employing the default PAUP* settings (i.e. mulpars=on and steepest descent not in effect). MP analysis was conducted with a step matrix giving transitions
twice the weight of transversions. Analyses were carried out with tree-bisection-connection (TBR) branch
swapping, and with gaps treated as ‘ missing ’. Most
parsimonious trees (MPT) were found with starting
trees obtained by stepwise addition, using 100 replicates holding one tree at each step, and saving only
ten trees with score f1. In a second heuristic search
these MPT were used as starting trees and swapped
with a reconnection limit of ten. To evaluate branch
robustness of trees generated by parsimony-based
487
methods, bootstrap analyses (Felsenstein 1985) were
applied. Bootstrap analyses were conducted using 1000
replications, carried out with random addition sequences, each with ten replicates and TBR branch
swapping.
The program Modeltest version 3.06 (Posada &
Crandall 1998) was used to choose an optimal model
of DNA substitution. The ML analysis under the
GTR+G model was performed with six substitution
types and a user-specified substitution rate matrix,
nucleotide frequencies A=0.26153, C=0.22576, G=
0.20619, T=0.30652, proportion of invariable sites=0,
rate heterogeneity following the discrete gamma approximation with four categories and a shape parameter a=0.30743. The heuristic search with TBR
branch swapping used the first MPT as starting tree. In
addition, one hundred bootstrap replicates were run
with ML, starting tree(s) obtained via stepwise addition, random addition sequence, one replicate, one
tree held at each step during stepwise addition and
TBR.
In a second step of analysis, we separately analysed
each of the new Cortinarius species with their most
closely related species. With this approach, more informative characters could be included in the analysis.
The data matrix created for the phylogenetic analysis
of C. keralensis was restricted to 27 sequences (22 taxa).
375 out of the 840 nucleotide positions were excluded,
of the remaining 465 characters 337 characters were
constant, 51 variable characters were parsimony uninformative, and 77 characters were parsimony informative. Most parsimonious trees were searched with the
settings described above.
For the phylogenetic placement of C. conopileus, a
data matrix with 819 nucleotide positions was created
for the seven sequences. After exclusion of areas with
gaps or ambiguous alignment, 585 nucleotide positions
remained for analysis : 495 characters were constant,
49 variable characters were parsimony uninformative
and 41 characters were parsimony informative. An
exhaustive search was carried out.
The data matrix created for C. phlegmophorus included ten ingroup taxa ; two collections of C. paveleckii were used as outgroup. The alignment was 840
nucleotide positions long. After the exclusion of areas
with gaps, 610 nucleotide positions were used for analysis : 504 characters were constant, 32 variable characters
were parsimony uninformative, and 74 characters were
parsimony informative. An exhaustive search was
carried out.
TAXONOMY
Cortinarius (subgen. Myxacium) phlegmophorus K. A.
Thomas, M. M. Moser, Peintner & Manim., sp.
nov.
(Figs 1, 4–7)
Etym. : phlegmophorus (Greek), slime bearing.
Ectomycorrhizal Cortinarius species from tropical India
488
Figs 1–3. Basidiomata. Fig. 1. Cortinarius phlegmophorus. Fig. 2. C. conopileus. Fig. 3. C. keralensis. Bar=1 cm.
Pileo 20–60 mm lato, conico-convexo, dein plano-convexo,
interdum late umbonato, glutinoso, hygrophano, primo obscure brunneo, dein griseo-aurantiaco vel brunneo-aurantiaco,
glabro, sicco ruguloso. Lamellis adnatis primo griseo-violaceis,
interdum obscure violaceis, maturitate pallide brunneis acie
pallidiore sive albidula, serrulata sub lente, subconfertis
vel confertis, usque ad 5 mm latis, lamellulis praesentibus,
stipite 45–75r5–10 mm, cylindraceo, fere aequali vel attenuato apicem versus, compacto dein fistuloso, superficie griseoviolaceo vel obscure violaceo, aetate brunneo-aurantiaco
vel griseo-brunneo, obtecto e velo glutinoso, abido-fibrillosofloccoso, carne albida odore insignificante, sporis in cumulo
brunneis. Basidiosporis 10.5–14.5r6–8 mm, amygdaliformibus usque limoniformibus, verrucosis, basidiis (2)–4-sporigeris, 32–48r10–14 mm, clavatis, cheilocystidiis 13–55r
9–32 mm vesiculosis, clavatis. Fibulis absentibus.
Typus: India: Kerala State : Wayanad District, Ponkuzhy,
ad terram, sparsis vel gregariis, sub Hopea (Dipterocarpaceae)
28 Oct. 1998, A. Thomas T344 (IB19990308 – holotypus).
Pileus 20–60 mm diam, conico-convex becoming planoconvex, sometimes with a broad blunt umbo, margin
somewhat incurved, becoming decurved, slightly appendiculate when young, becoming entire with maturity,
sometimes eroded or fissile; surface viscid when wet,
initially dark brown (6F8, 7F8), turning brown (6E8,
7E8), at the centre and almost greyish orange (5B3) or
brownish orange (5C3, 6C4) towards margin, hygrophanous and becoming grayish orange (5B3), glabrous, smooth, becoming dry and wrinkled. Context in
pileus white, up to 5 mm thick at the centre. Lamellae
adnate, initially violet grey (16D2) or sometimes dull
violet (16D3), later light brown (6D6), subcrowded
to close, up to 5 mm wide, with lamellulae of different
lengths, edges white or paler than the sides, finely
lacerate under a lens. Stipe 45–75r5–10 mm, central,
cylindric, almost equal or tapering apically, solid,
becoming fistulose; surface violet gray (16D2) or dull
violet (16D3) when young, changing to brownish
orange (5C3) or greyish brown (5D3) with maturity,
covered with a glutinous white, fibrillose-floccose veil.
Context white to whitish. Odour not distinctive. When
the basidiomata mature, the pileus consistently and
naturally becomes detached from the stipe and falls
down. Spore print greyish brown to light brown
(6D4). Basidiospores 10.5–14.5r6–8 mm, average (av)
¡standard deviation (SD)=12.2¡0.9r6.8¡0.5 mm,
Q=1.5–2.0, av¡SD=1.8¡0.1, vol.=217–408 mm av¡
3
SD=299¡56 mm , amygdaliform to sublimoniform with
apicular callus, yellowish brown, thin- to slightly thickwalled, strongly verrucose with irregular warts, apiculus smooth, with suprahilar pseudoplage. Basidia (2)–
4-spored, 32–48r10–14 mm, clavate, sterigmata up to
6.5 mm long. Edge of lamellae crowded with baloonshaped, thin-walled, colourless cheilocystidia, 13–55r
9–32 mm. Pleurocystidia none. Lamellar trama regular,
hyphae in lateral stratum with a diameter of 2–9 mm,
in mediostratum up to 24 mm, thin-walled, sometimes
faintly encrusted, colourless. Pileus surface with a gelatinous layer of 2–5 mm wide, repent, thin-walled
sometimes encrusted, colourless hyphae. Epicutis consisting of two to three layers of colourless, 6–10 mm
wide hyphae. Hypocutis with ellipsoid-inflated hyphae
at the base, segments 20–45 (–60)r11–25 mm, in upper
part nearly colourless, in deeper layers brown encrusted,
partly with platelets, followed by a strongly pigmented
layer of hyphae with a diam of 5–9 (–10) mm, encrusted with platelets, with some dark brown oleiferous hyphae. Stipe context composed of 2–24 mm wide
parallel hyphae, thin-walled, colourless, with some
oleiferous hyphae (brown content). Stipe cortex composed of 6–13 mm wide hyphae, encrusted, pale yellow
to colourless, covered by a gelatinous layer consisting
of 2–4.5 mm wide colourless hyphae. Clamp connections
not observed in any tissue.
U. Peintner and others
Fig. 4. Basidiospore of Cortinarius phlegmophorus (SEM).
Bar=2 mm.
Figs 5–6. Cortinarius phlegmophorus (holotype). Fig. 5. Basidiospores. Bar=10 mm. Fig. 6. Cheilocystidia. Bar=20 mm.
Habitat : On the ground, attached to underground
roots, scattered or sometimes in groups of two in the
vicinity of Hopea spp. (Dipterocarpaceae), Meiogyne
pannosa (Annonaceae) and Cansjera rheedii (Opiliaceae).
Other specimens examined: India : Kerala State : Wayanad
District, Ponkhuzy, 31 Oct. 1999, A. Thomas T344b
(IB19990309).
Cortinarius (subgen. Telamonia) conopileus K. A. Thomas, M. M. Moser, Peintner & Manim., sp. nov.
(Figs 2, 8–11)
Etym. : conopileus (Latin), conical pileus.
489
Fig. 7. Longitudinal section through the pileus surface of
Cortinarius phlegmophorus (holotype) : (a) gelatinous layer ;
(b) epicutis ; (c) hypocutis ; and (d) uppermost layer of trama
with oleiferous hyphae. Bar=60 mm.
Pileo 4–15 mm lato, primo fere campanulato, conico vel
conico-convexo, dein convexo usque plano-convexo umbone
obtuse acuteve praedito, hygrophano, brunneo vel pallide
brunneo, sicco griseo-aurantiaco, glabro, iove udo leviter
translucente striato, lamellis adnatis usque adnexis, brunneoaurantiacis, dein pallide brunneis, confertis, lamellulis praesentibus, usque ad 2 mm latis, acie plus minusve erosa (sub
lente) ; stipite 25–60r1.5–3 mm, tereto, apice leviter attentuato, brunneo-aurantiaco usque pallide brunneo, glabro.
Odore non significante. Basidiosporis 6–8.5 (–10)r3.5–
4.5 mm, elongatis, ellipsoideis usque subamygdaliformibus,
punctatis (subtiliter verrucosis), basidiis 25–32r6–9 mm, clavatis, tetrasterigmatis, cheilocystidia 11.5–51.5r4.5–15.5 mm
frequentis, clavatis, vesiculosis, rarior lageniformibus vel
fusoideis, trama lamellarum e hyphis ellipsoideo-inflatis, segmentis 30–60r15–28 mm, fibulis praesentibus.
Typus: India: Kerala State : Wayanad District, Ponkuzhy,
ad terram in silvis, fasciculatis vel dispersis, sub Hopea
(Dipterocarpaceae), 28 Oct. 1999, A. Thomas T341b
(IB19990302 – holotypus).
Pileus 4–15 mm diam, initially almost campanulate,
conic or conic-convex, becoming convex to planoconvex, with a blunt to almost pointed umbo ; surface
dark brown (6F8, 6F7) or brown (6E8) towards the
centre, brown (6E7) or light brown (6D6, 6D7) elsewhere, hygrophanous and eventually entirely turning
grayish orange (5B3), glabrous, dull, faintly translucently striate when moist, margin decurved, entire to
almost crenate, sometimes fissile. Lamellae adnate to
adnexed, brownish orange (6C6) becoming light brown
(6D7), close, up to 2 mm wide, with lamellulae of 3
lengths; edge pale, scalloped or eroded under a lens.
Stipe 25–60r1.5–3 mm, central, terete, slightly tapering apically, solid ; surface brownish orange (6C6)
Ectomycorrhizal Cortinarius species from tropical India
490
an epicutis of hyphae between (2–) 3–6 (–7.5) mm,
thick, almost colourless to yellow brown, encrusted
with granules to platelets ; in hypocutis hyphae inflated
up to 15–20 mm diam, yellow brown, encrusted. Pileal
context consisting of parallel 2–25 mm thick hyphae,
pale yellow to yellowish brown, faintly encrusted. Stipe
cortex consisting of hyphae of 2–7.5 mm diameter,
colourless to pale yellowish brown, faintly encrusted.
Hyphae of the stipe context 2–16.5 mm wide, parallel,
faintly encrusted, yellowish to yellowish brown. Clamp
connections present on all hyphae.
Habitat : on the forest floor, mostly in clusters or
scattered, attached to small subterranean roots, probably mycorrhizal with nearby trees : Hopea sp. (Dipterocarpaceae), Meiogyne pannosa (Annonaceae) and
Cansjera rheedii (Opiliaceae).
Other specimen examined : India : Kerala State : Wayanad
District, Ponkuzhy, 17 Oct. 1999, A. Thomas T341
(IB19990302); 31 Oct. 1999, A. Thomas T341c (IB19990304).
Fig. 8. Basidiospores of Cortinarius conopileus (SEM).
Bar=2 mm.
Cortinarius (subgen. Telamonia) keralensis K. A. Thomas, M. M. Moser, Peintner & Manim., sp. nov.
(Figs 3, 12–14)
Etym. : keralensis (Latin), pertaining to Kerala.
Figs 9–11. Cortinarius conopileus. Fig. 9. Basidiospores of
IB19990302 (paratype). Fig. 10. Basidiospores of IB19990302
(holotype). Bar=10 mm. Fig. 11. Cheilocystidia. Bar=20 mm.
to light brown (6D7). Odour not distinctive. Basidiospores 6–8.5 (–10)r3.5–4.5 mm, av¡SD=7.6¡0.3r
4.2¡0.1, Q=1.5–2.2, av¡SD=1.8¡0.1, vol.=44–
102 mm3, av¡SD=72¡11 mm3, slender amygdaliform
to subfusoid, yellowish brown, slightly thick-walled,
punctate. Basidia 25–32r6.9 mm, 4-spored, clavate,
sometimes with yellowish content, deformed with age,
sterigmata up to 4.5 mm long. Cheilocystidia 11.5–
51.5r4.5–15.5 mm, numerous, versiform, clavate to
vesiculose, fusoid or sublageniform, thin-walled, colourless, sometimes faintly encrusted. Pleurocystidia none.
Lamellar trama regular, hyphae in lateral stratum
2.5–6 mm wide, in the mediostratum up to 28 mm
thick, ellipsoid-inflated, segments 30–60r15–28 mm,
walls very pale ochraceous, buff, to pale yellowish
brown, some hyphae finely encrusted. Pileipellis with
Pileo 15–80 mm lato, primo subgloboso, dein convexo, margine primo incurvato, maturitate saepe depresso, sicco, hygrophano, in statu humectato unicolore obscure brunneo,
margine subtiliter translucente striato, in statu sicco brunneoaurantiaco, glabro, lamellis late adnatis vel dente decurrentibus, cinnamomeo-brunneis vel leviter obscurioris, subconfertis
usque confertis, lamellulis praesentibus, usque ad 7 mm latis,
acie pallidiore. Stipite 35–65r5–13 mm, apice leviter attenuato, basin versus leviter inflato, albida, apice basique interdum griseo-purpuream tincto, cortina abundate, zonam
annuliformem formante, interdum peronato. Carne pallide
brunnea. Odore non significante. Sporis in cumulo ferrugineis. Basidiosporis 7.5–10r4–5 mm, amygdaliformibus,
verrucosis, basidiis 25–47.5r6.5–10 mm, clavatis usque subcylindraceis, (2)–4-sporigeris, cheilocystidiis praesentibus,
13–54.5r4.5–13 mm, clavatis, interdum lageni- vel uteriformibus.
Typus: India : Kerala State : Wayanad District, Ponkuzhy:
in silvis ad terram in fasciculis vel dispersis, sub Hopea spp.
(Dipterocarpaceae), Calophyllum sp., Meiogyne sp., 2 Sept.
1999, A. Thomas T118 (IB19990305 – holotypus).
Pileus 15–80 mm diam, initially subspherical, becoming
convex, with or without a central depression when
mature, margin incurved when young, becoming decurved, almost entire, at times becoming fissile, surface
dark brown when moist, (7F6, 7F7, 8F6, 8F7), unicolorous, slowly becoming brownish orange (6C6 or
6D6) smooth and glabrous, hygrophanous, faintly
translucently striate and slightly lubricous when moist.
Context in pileus pale brown. Lamellae broadly adnate
to adnate with a decurrent tooth, cinnamon brown
(6D6) or slightly darker, subcrowded to close, to 7 mm
wide, with lamellulae of 3 lengths; edges paler than
the lamellar faces or white, finely torn. Stipe 35–65r
6–13 mm, central, terete, slightly tapering apically and
U. Peintner and others
491
mostly clavate, sometimes utriform or lageniform,
thin-walled, hyaline, sometimes encrusted. Without
pleurocystidia. Lamellar trama regular, hyphae in subhymenium 1.5–3 mm wide, in lateral stratum 4–8 mm
wide, in mediostratum 11–16–24 mm wide and inflated,
thin-walled, yellowish brown, slightly encrusted. Epicutis consisting of hyphae of 4–8 mm diam, pale brown,
not or slightly encrusted. Hypocutis hyphae up to 12 mm
thick. Pileus context hyphae 2–24 mm wide, inflated,
parallel to interwoven, thin-walled, encrusted, yellowish brown. Stipe context of 2–20 mm wide hyphae, parallel, thin-walled, faintly encrusted, colourless to pale
yellow. Stipe cortex of 2–7.5 mm wide hyphae, thinwalled, pale yellow to almost colourless. Veil hyphae
2–4 mm. Clamp connections present on all hyphae.
Habitat : on the forest floor, in clusters or scattered,
under Hopea spp. (Dipterocarpaceae), Calophyllum sp.
(Clusiaceae), Meiogyne sp. (Annonaceae) and Cansjera
rheedii (Opiliaceae).
Fig. 12. Basidiospores of Cortinarius keralensis (SEM).
Bar=2 mm.
Other specimens examined: India : Kerala State : Wayanad
District, Ponkuzhy, 17 Oct. 1999 A. Thomas T118b
(IB19990306); 28 Oct. 1999, A. Thomas T118c (IB19990307).
RESULTS
Figs 13–14. Cortinarius keralensis (holotype). Fig. 13. Basidiospores. Bar=10 mm. Fig. 14. Cheilocystidia. Bar=20 mm.
with a slight swollen base, solid. Surface somewhat
white, apically and sometimes basally with a purplish
gray (13C2) shade, initially with a well developed veil
which leaves annular remnants sometimes with a
fibrillose-peronate sheath but not a volva. Context pale
brown. Without distinctive odour. Spore print rustbrown (6E8). Basidiospores 7.5–10r4–5 mm, av¡SD=
8.8¡0.6r4.5¡0.2 mm, Q=1.7–2.1, av¡SD=1.9¡0.1,
vol.=68–130 m3, av¡SD=94¡14 mm3, elongate almond-shaped, punctate verrucose, yellowish brown,
thin to slightly thick-walled. Basidia 25–47.5r6.5–
10 mm, subcylindric to clavate, (2)–4 spored, mature
basidia sometimes contain yellowish brown plasmatic
pigment, sterigmata up to 4.5 mm long. Lamella-edge
heteromorphous to almost sterile with numerous
cheilocystidia. Cheilocystidia 13–54.5r4.5–13 mm,
The parsimony analysis of the large dataset including
43 ITS sequences of all Cortinarius spp. treated resulted
in 3370 MPT with tree length of 397 steps, a consistency index (CI) of 0.6121, a retention index (RI) of
0.7858 and a rescaled consistency index (RC) of 0.4810
(Fig. 15). The phylogenetic analysis with maximum
likelihood resulted in the MLT with a xln likelihood
of 2718.47573., which is in agreement with the MPT.
Based on both phylogenetic analyses, the ingroup
clade representing the genus Cortinarius is supported
with bootstrap values of 100%, the given outgroup
clade is Hebeloma. Within the genus Cortinarius, one
major clade is supported by higher bootstrap values
(f70%) and congruent with all MPTs and the MLT :
clade/cortinarius. Within clade/cortinarius, three monophyletic groups are well resolved (bootstrap values
>60 %) : clade/obtusi (i.e. subgenus Telamonia sect.
Obtusi ), clade/defibulati (i.e. subgen. Myxacium sect.
Defibulati) and clade/myxacium (i.e. subger. Myxacium
sect. Myxacium). The latter two clades have sistergroup
relationships. The basal clade/telamonia recovered by
MP analysis is not supported by bootstrap analyses
and represents a basal polytomy in the MLT. This
group is characterised by short branches in both analytical approaches, closely related taxa fall into wellsupported clades (e.g. C. atrocoeruleus and C. decipiens)
but basal relationships are not resolved.
The Cortinarius taxa from tropical India fall into
both subclades of the genus Cortinarius, clade/telamonia and clade/cortinarius. Cortinarius keralensis has an
independent position within the /telamonia clade, and a
close relationship to C. saturninus or to any other included taxon can be excluded based on molecular data.
C. conopileus belongs to clade/obtusi. C. phlegmophorus
Ectomycorrhizal Cortinarius species from tropical India
Fig. 15. One of the 3370 most parsimonious trees resulting from the analysis of 42 ITS sequences. Bold branches are
present in the strict consensus tree. Bootstrap values higher than 50 % are shown above the respective branches,
asterisks* stand for bootstrap values >50. The three new Cortinarius spp. (bold) belong to three different clades:
C. phlegmophorus is basal to clade/defibulati, C. conopileus belongs to clade/obtusi and C. keralensis has an isolated
position within clade/telamonia.
492
U. Peintner and others
has an independent, basal position in clade/defibulati.
Based on these results, separate analyses were carried
out for each species from India.
The MP analysis carried out with the second dataset
created for C. keralensis yielded 494 MP trees with a
tree length of 250 steps, CI=0.672, RI=0.624, RC=
0.419. After reweighting characters by maximum value
of rescaled consistency indices, 37 MPT were found
with a tree length of 141.30376 steps, CI=0.8618,
RI=0.8132, RC=0.7008 (not shown). The best fitting
ML model selected by Modeltest was the GTR+G+I
model (number of substitution types=6, nucleotide
frequencies: A=0.26450, C=0.20990, G=0.21110,
T=0.31450, proportion of invariable sites=0.44,
gamma shape parameter=0.7315. The ML search resulted in 2 ML trees with xln likelihood=1995.484
(not shown). There is no conflict between the tree
resulting from ML analysis and the MPT. Basal relationships were not better resolved with this smaller
dataset than in the analysis of the large dataset. Relationships of closely related species could be resolved
in all three analytical approaches (e.g. C. atrocoeruleus – C. decipiens), demonstrating that C. keralensis
is not closely related to any of the involved taxa.
The analysis of the data matrix created for C. phlegmophorus resulted in four MP trees with a tree length
of 130 steps, CI=0.8846, RI=0.9272, RC=0.8202
(tree not shown). During the exhaustive search,
654729075 trees were evaluated. The tree topology is
identical with the one resulting from the large dataset
(Fig. 15): C. phlegmophorus has in isolated position
in the clade/defibulati.
The exhaustive search of the clade/obtusi evaluated 945 trees. The score of the best tree was 102. One
tree was retained with CI=0.9314. HI=0.1373, RI=
0.8814, RC=0.8209 (tree not shown). As already resulting from the large dataset (Fig. 15), the clade/obtusi
falls into two subclades, clade/acuti and clade/obtusi.
Cortinarius conopileus has an independent position in
the subclade/acuti.
DISCUSSION
Based on molecular and morphological data, Cortinarius conopileus fits well in Cortinarius subgenus Telamonia sect. Obtusi subsect. Acuti (Moënne-Loccoz,
Reumaux & Henry 1990). This is corroborated by the
shape of the basidiomata, by the colours, by the presence of numerous clavate to vesiculose or fusoid cheilocystidia and by the typical structure of the lamellar
trama consisting of wide, ellipsoid inflated hyphae. It
differs from all other taxa of this group in the slender
amygdaliform, often subfusoid spores with an average
Q-value of 1.8. The independent position within the
Acuti is also supported by molecular data. Clade/obtusi
is a well supported subclade of clade/cortinarius. Thus,
in contrast to classical taxonomy, the clade/obtusi represents an evolutionary origin independent of taxa
493
belonging to clade/telamonia, which is also reflected by
morphological characters (basidiome habit, lamellar
trama, cystidia).
Other phylogenetic rDNA analyses (Høiland &
Holst-Jensen 2000, Peintner et al. 2001) suggest that
the clade/telamonia (without /obtusi) is a natural
group, a result supported also by our MP analysis, but
not by our MLT. Within /telamonia, relationships of
closely related taxa are resolved by analysis of ITS
sequences, however, no larger groups can be resolved
due to the low genetic divergence found in ITS sequences. Based on morphological criteria, C. keralensis
is a typical Telamonia, belonging to sect. Saturnini.
This section circumscribes species with larger or medium sized basidiomes with medium to chocolate
brown colours, dark red brown to chocolate lamellate,
a white veil and medium sized ellipsoid spores (MoënneLoccoz, Reumaux & Henry 1990). Macro- and microscopically the most closely related species seems to be
C. saturninus, which differs in the somewhat darker
colours, red brown to chocolate lamellae and different
ITS sequences. Other similar taxa are C. castaneus and
C. assiduus. C. castaneus is smaller with darker colours
and occurs mostly with conifers. C. assiduus differs by
a thin, fugaceous veil, violaceous lamellae when young
and a raphanoid smell (Mahiques, Ortega & Bidaud
2001).
Based on both morphological and molecular data
C. phlegmophorus can be assigned to subgen. Myxacium. The lack of clamp connections places it in sect.
Defibulati (Moser 1969). As shown in our study and
other phylogenetic rDNA analyses (Seidl 1999), sects
Myxacium and Defibulati are sistergroups within subgen. Myxacium, and both represent an independent
evolutionary lineage. Morphologically, C. phlegmophorus is somewhat reminiscent of C. pseudosalor, but
differs in the brighter, more orange-brown pileus, and
the slightly smaller and narrower spores. The results
of the ITS data analysis confirm the distinctness of
the two taxa.
Our morphological and phylogenetic analyses demonstrated that the three Indian Cortinarius spp. belong
to three different clades, each of them constituting an
independent evolutionary lineage. This result disproves
the hypothesis of geographically determined radiating
clades of Cortinarius related to geographic isolation,
the establishment of mycorrhizal interactions, and host
specifity. The geological history of peninsular India
could indicate a possible origin of these endemic taxa
from Gondwanan ancestors. Peninsular India is a part
of the Gondwanaland landmass, with a geological lineage of great antiquity. It is assumed that the Indian
Plate of Gondwanaland detached itself during Middle
Eocene and moved northwards from its original position near Madagascar in southern latitudes to crash
against Laurasia in the northern tropical latitudes
during the late Cretaceous (Ahmadullah & Nayar
1986). The Indian Plate was subjected to different climatic stresses during this transition, resulting in the
Ectomycorrhizal Cortinarius species from tropical India
impoverishment of its flora and the preservation of
a few endemic taxa in the mountain systems of Peninsular India (Raven & Axelrod 1974, Ahmadullah &
Nayar 1986). Thus, these three new Cortinarius species
could have independently evolved from Gondwanan
relict species. However, other possible evolutionary
scenarios like long-distance spore dispersal cannot be
excluded, although such a possibility is remote because
of the endemic nature of the host trees.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Rytas Vilgalys for the opportunity to work in his laboratory, and Martin Kirchmair and Konrad Eller (University of
Innsbruck) for preparing the SEM pictures. This work was partly
supported by an Erwin Schrödinger Auslandsstipendium (J1821BIO) from the Austrian Science Foundation (FWF) to U.P.
REFERENCES
Aanen, D. K., Kuyper, T. W., Boekhout, T. & Hoekstra, R. F. (2000)
Phylogenetic relationships in the genus Hebeloma based on ITS1
and 2 sequences, with special emphasis on the Hebeloma crustuliniforme complex. Mycologia 92: 269–281.
Ahmadullah, M. & Nayar, M. P. (1986) Endemic Plants of the Indian
Region. Vol. I. Botanical Survey of India, Calcutta, India.
Beeli, M. (1928) Contribution à l’étude de la flore mycologique du
Congo VI. Fungi Goossensiani. Bulletin de la Société royale de
Botanique de Belgique 61 : 78–108.
Buyck, B. & Horak, E. (1999) New species of Russula (Basidiomycotina) associated with Anisoptera (Dipterocarpaceae) in Papua New
Guinea. Australian Systematic Botany 12: 727–742.
Buyck, B., Thoen, D. & Watling, R. (1996) Ectomycorrhizal fungi
of the Guinea Congo region. Proceedings of the Royal Society of
Edinburgh 104B: 313–333.
Fassi, B. & Moser, M. (1991) Micorrize nelle foreste naturali
nell’Africa tropicale e nei Neotropici. Funghi, Piante e Suolo 1991:
157–202.
Felsenstein, J. (1985) Confidence limits on phylogenies. An approach
using bootstrap. Evolution 39 : 783–791.
Henkel, T. W. (2001) Ecology and systematics of ectomycorrhizal
fungi associated with Dicymbe (Caesalpiniaceae) in Guyana. PhD
thesis, Duke University, Durham, NC.
Henkel, T. W., Aime, M. C. & Miller, S. L. (2000) Systematics of
pleurotoid Russulaceae from Guyana and Japan, with notes on
their ectomycorrhizal status. Mycologia 92: 1119–1132.
Henkel, T. W., Terborgh, J. & Vilgalys, R. J. (2002) Ectomycorrhizal
fungi and their leguminous hosts in the Pakaraima Mountains of
Guyana. Mycological Research 106: 515–531.
Høiland, K. & Holst-Jensen, A. (2000) Cortinarius phylogeny and
possible taxonomic implications of ITS rDNA sequences. Mycologia 92: 694–710.
Kornerup, A. & Wanscher, J. H. (1978) Methuen Handbook of
Colour. 3rd edn. Methuen, London.
Liu, Y. J., Rogers, S. O. & Ammirati, J. F. (1997) Phylogenetic relationships in Dermocybe and related Cortinarius taxa based on
nuclear ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacers. Canadian
Journal of Botany 75 : 519–532.
Louis, I. & Scott, E. (1987) In vitro synthesis of mycorrhizas in root
organ cultures of tropical Dipterocarp species. Transactions of the
British Mycological Society 88: 565–568.
Mahiques, R., Ortega, A. & Bidaud, A. (2001) Cortinarius assiduus
(Telamonia, Firmiores), nouvelle espece de la zone mediterraneene
494
de la Pininsule Iberique. Bulletin de la Federation Mycologique
Dauphine-Savoie 162: 41– 47.
Moënne-Loccoz, L., Reumaux, P. & Henry, R. (1990) Atlas des
Cortinaires, Vol. 2. Federation Mycologique Dauphine-Savoie,
Valpress, Annecy-Seynod.
Moncalvo, J.-M., Lutzoni, F. M., Rehner, S. A., Johnson, J. &
Vilgalys, R. (2000) Phylogenetic relationships of agaric fungi based
on nuclear large subunit ribosomal DNA sequences. Systematic
Biology 49: 278–305.
Moncalvo, J.-M., Vilgalys, R., Redhead, S., Johnson, J. E., James,
T. Y., Aime, M. A., Hofstetter, V., Verduin, S. J. W., Larsson, E.,
Baroni, T. J., Thorn, R. G., Jacobsson, S., Clemençon, H. & Miller, O. jr (2002) One hundred and seventeen clades of euagarics.
Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 23: 357–400.
Moser, M. (1969) Über einige kritische oder neue Cortinarien aus der
Untergattung Myxacium Fr. aus Smoland und Halland. Friesia
9: 142–150.
Moser, M., Ladurner, H., Peintner, U. & Kirchmair, M. (2001)
Gymnopilus turficola a new species of Gymnopilus (Agaricales) from
sub-arctic palsa mires and its phylogenetic relationship based on
ITS sequences. Nordic Journal of Botany 21 : 321–327.
Murrill, W. A. (1912) Agaricaceae of tropical North America.
Mycologia 4: 72–83.
Peintner, U., Bougher, N. L., Castellano, M. A., Moncalvo, J.-M.,
Moser, M. M., Trappe, J. M. & Vilgalys, R. (2001) Multiple origins
of sequestrate fungi related to Cortinarius (Cortinariaceae). American Journal of Botany 88: 2168–2179.
Posada, D. & Crandall, K. A. (1998) Modeltest: testing the model
of DNA substitution. Bioinformatics 14: 817–818.
Raven, P. H. & Axelrod, D. (1974) Angiosperm biogeography and
past continental movements. Annals of the Missouri Botanical
Garden 61: 529–573.
Seidl, M. T. (1999) Systematic studies in Cortinarius (Agaricales,
Cortinariaceae) subgenus Myxacium, sections Defibulati and Myxacium in Western North America. PhD thesis, University of
Washington.
Seidl, M. T. (2000) Phylogenetic relationships within Cortinarius
subgenus Myxacium, sections Defibulati and Myxacium. Mycologia
92: 1091–1102.
Singer, R., Araujo, I. & Ivory, M. H. (1983) The ectotrophically
mycorrhizal fungi of the neotropical lowlands, especiall Central
Amazonia. Beihefte zur Nova Hedwigia 77: 1–339.
Swofford, D. L. (1998) PAUP*4.0: phylogenetic analysis using parsimony (*and other methods). Version 4.0b1. Sinauer Associates,
Sunderland, MA.
Thomas, K. A., Peintner, U., Moser, M. M. & Manimohan, P. (2002)
Anamika, a new mycorrhizal genus of Cortinariaceae from India
and its phylogenetic position based on ITS and LSU sequences.
Mycological Research 108: 245–251.
Vilgalys, R. & Hester, M. (1990) Rapid genetic identification
and mapping of enzymatically amplified ribosomal DNA from
several Cryptococcus species. Journal of Bacteriology 172:
4238– 4246.
Watling, R. (1994) Ectomycorrhizal fungi in the Palaeotropics.
Mycologia Helvetica 2: 129–138.
Watling, R. (1995) Ectomycorrhizal fungi associated with members
of the Dipterocarpaceae in Peninsular Malaysia – I. Journal of
Tropical Forest Science 7: 657–669.
White, T. J., Bruns, T., Lee, S. & Taylor, J. (1990) Amplification and
direct sequencing of fungal RNA genes for phylogenetics. In PCR
Protocols: a guide to methods and applications (M. A. Innis, D. H.
Gelfand, J. J. Sninsky & T. J. White, eds): 315–322. Academic
Press, New York.
Zolan, M. E. & Pukkila, P. J. (1986) Inheritance of DNA methylation
in Coprinus cinereus. Molecular and Cellular Biology 6 : 195–200.
Corresponding Editor: S. A. Redhead