STUDIES IN MYCOLOGY 50: 323–335. 2004.
Paraconiothyrium, a new genus to accommodate the mycoparasite
Coniothyrium minitans, anamorphs of Paraphaeosphaeria, and four new
species
Gerard J.M. Verkley1*, Manuela da Silva2, Donald T. Wicklow3 and Pedro W. Crous1
1
Centraalbureau voor Schimmelcultures, Fungal Biodiversity Centre, PO Box 85167, NL-3508 AD Utrecht, the Netherlands;
Fungi Section, Department of Microbiology, INCQS/FIOCRUZ, Av. Brasil, 4365; CEP: 21045-9000, Manguinhos, Rio de
Janeiro, RJ, Brazil. 3Mycotoxin Research Unit, National Center for Agricultural Utilization Research, 1815 N. University
Street, Peoria, IL 61604, Illinois, U.S.A.
2
*Correspondence: Gerard J.M. Verkley, verkley@cbs.knaw.nl
Abstract: Coniothyrium-like coelomycetes are drawing attention as biological control agents, potential bioremediators, and
producers of antibiotics. Four genera are currently used to classify such anamorphs, namely, Coniothyrium,
Microsphaeropsis, Cyclothyrium, and Cytoplea. The morphological plasticity of these fungi, however, makes it difficult to
ascertain their best generic disposition in many cases. A new genus, Paraconiothyrium is here proposed to accommodate four
new species, P. estuarinum, P. brasiliense, P. cyclothyrioides, and P. fungicola. Their formal descriptions are based on
anamorphic characters as seen in vitro. The teleomorphs of these species are unknown, but maximum parsimony analysis of
ITS and partial SSU nrDNA sequences showed that they belong in the Pleosporales and group in a clade including
Paraphaeosphaeria s. str., the biocontrol agent Coniothyrium minitans, and the ubiquitous soil fungus Coniothyrium
sporulosum. Coniothyrium minitans and C. sporulosum are therefore also combined into the genus Paraconiothyrium. The
anamorphs of Paraphaeosphaeria michotii and Paraphaeosphaeria pilleata are regarded representative of Paraconiothyrium,
but remain formally unnamed. Paraconiothyrium species are phylogenetically distant from typical members of the other
coelomycete genera mentioned above.
Taxonomic novelties: Paraconiothyrium Verkley gen. nov., Paraconiothyrium brasiliense Verkley sp. nov.,
Paraconiothyrium cyclothyrioides Verkley sp. nov., Paraconiothyrium estuarinum Verkley & M. da Silva sp. nov.,
Paraconiothyrium fungicola Verkley & Wicklow sp. nov., Paraconiothyrium minitans (W.A. Campb.) Verkley comb. nov.,
Paraconiothyrium sporulosum (W. Gams & Domsch) Verkley comb. nov.
Key-words: Anamorph, biological control, bioremediation, Cyclothyrium, Cytoplea, fungicolous fungus, Microsphaeropsis,
molecular systematics, nuclear ribosomal DNA.
INTRODUCTION
Coniothyrium- or Microsphaeropsis-like coelomycetes are widely dispersed and commonly isolated
from many different habitats. Recently, these fungi
have drawn attention as biological control agents
(Carisse, El Bassam & Benhamou 2001, Carisse &
Bernier 2002a, b, El Bassam et al. 2002), potential
bioremediators (da Silva et al. 2003a, b), and producers of antibiotics (Fukami et al. 2000, Seephonkai et
al. 2002, Tsuda et al. 2003). In the genus Coniothyrium Corda alone, many hundreds of species have
been described on the basis of material found on
plants, and most of these species have never been
critically re-examined or studied in culture. Their
morphology is relatively simple and provides few
diagnostic characters, and the taxonomy has been
primarily based on the host. Occasionally, species
have been described from organisms other than plants
or from soil. In this paper, we present four new species, which were preliminarily identified as either
Microsphaeropsis sp. or Cyclothyrium sp. (a Conio-
thyrium-like genus with stromatic fruiting bodies
accepted by Sutton 1980). They were each isolated
from a single source, one from a heavily polluted
estuarine sediment, and the others from basidiocarps
of a polypore fungus, a soil sample, and fruit of coffee
plants, respectively. No teleomorphs were observed,
and since the fructifications in nature are unknown,
the species had to be described on the basis of their
anamorphic characters as seen in vitro. The sequences
of the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of
nuclear ribosomal DNA were found to diverge, and
morphological differences that were observed in the
fructifications support the idea that the isolates belong
to four distinct species.
The generic disposition of these new species posed
difficulties. Sutton (1980) upheld four genera for the
classification of Coniothyrium-like coelomycetes.
These taxa, Coniothyrium, Microsphaeropsis Sacc.,
Cyclothyrium Petr., and Cytoplea Bizz. & Sacc., were
based on conidiomatal structure, conidiogenesis and
conidium morphology. The morphological plasticity
of coelomycetes, however, often makes it difficult to
determine the most appropriate generic disposition for
323
VERKLEY ET AL.
newly recognized species. In order to gather more
reliable information about the affinities of the new
species and about Coniothyrium palmarum Corda,
Microsphaeropsis olivacea (Bonord.) Höhn., and
Cyclothyrium juglandis (Schum.) B. Sutton, the type
species of Coniothyrium, Microsphaeropsis, and
Cyclothyrium, respectively, we sequenced a part of the
nuclear small subunit (SSU, 18S). So far, Coniothyrium-like anamorphs have been reported for genera in
the Pleosporales, viz., Leptosphaeria Ces. & De Not.,
and Paraphaeosphaeria O.E. Erikss., as well as recently erected segregates of Paraphaeosphaeria, viz.,
Neophaeosphaeria Câmara, M.E. Palm & A.W.
Ramaley and Phaeosphaeriopsis Câmara, M.E. Palm
& A.W. Ramaley (Câmara et al. 2001, 2003). Phylogenetic analyses are placing some Coniothyriumlike coelomycetes in other orders, e.g., in the Mycosphaerella-clade of the Dothideales, and in the
Diaporthales grouping closely to Cryphonectria
(Sacc.) Sacc. & D. Sacc. and Endothia Fr. (Lennox et
al., this volume).
The molecular work presented here shows that the
new species group in a clade with Paraphaeosphaeria
s. str. (Câmara et al. 2001, 2003), and with
Coniothyrium
minitans
W.A.
Campb.
and
Coniothyrium sporulosum (W. Gams & Domsch) van
der Aa, while the type species of Coniothyrium and
Microsphaeropsis reside in different clades, and that
of Cyclothyrium is also remote. Muthumeenakshi et
al. (2001) demonstrated the close relationship between
C. minitans and C. sporulosum on the basis of ITS
sequence analyses. Coniothyrium minitans, a
mycoparasite of world-wide distribution, has been
intensively studied and successfully applied as a
control agent against the economically important
pathogen Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (Campbell 1947,
Whipps & Gerlagh 1992, Sandys-Winsch et al. 1993,
Goldstein et al. 2000, Grendene et al. 2002). From the
phylogenetic point of view, none of the available
generic names can be used for these fungi. We
therefore propose to place them in a new genus,
Paraconiothyrium.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Isolations
The strain CBS 972.95 was isolated with a standard
dilution plate method, using oatmeal (OA) and Czapek
agars (Gams et al. 1998). CBS 109850 was isolated as
described by da Silva et al. (2003a), and CBS 113269
as described by Holler et al. (2002). No data are
available pertaining to the isolation of CBS 100299.
DNA extraction and sequencing
Strains were transferred from agar cultures to 2 mL
liquid medium (2 % malt extract) and incubated on a
rotary shaker (300 rpm) for 3 wk at room temperature.
324
Liquid cultures were transferred to 2 mL tubes, centrifuged and washed twice with sterile water. DNA was
extracted using the FastDNAkit (Omnilabo 6050073,
BIO 101, CA) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. For ITS sequence analysis a part of the
ribosomal RNA gene cluster was amplified by PCR
using primer pairs V9G (De Hoog and Gerrits van den
Ende 1998) and LR5 (Vilgalys and Hester 1990). Part
of the SSU was amplified using primers NS1 and
NS24 (White et al. 1990), or primer pairs NS1/Oli1,
NS3/Oli2, and NS5/NS24 (Hendriks et al. 1989,
White et al. 1990, Hopfer et al. 1993). PCR was
performed in 50 µL reaction volumes, each reaction
containing 10–100 ng of genomic DNA, 25 pM of
each primer, 40 µM dNTP, 1 unit Supertaq DNA
polymerase and 5 µL 10× PCR buffer (SphaeroQ,
Leiden, the Netherlands). PCR was performed in an
Applied Biosystems (Foster City, CA) thermocycler
with the following programme: 1 min 95 ºC, 30× (1
min 95 ºC, 1 min 55 ºC, 2 min 72 ºC) followed by a
final extension of 5 min at 72 ºC PCR products were
cleaned with GFX columns (Amersham Pharmacia,
NJ, 27-9602-01) and analyzed on a 2 % agarose gel to
estimate concentrations. ITS1 and ITS4 (White et al.
1990) were used as internal sequencing primers for the
ITS region. The SSU region was sequenced using the
PCR primers. Sequencing was performed with the
BigDye terminator chemistry (Applied Biosystems)
following the manufacturer’s instructions. The sequencing products were cleaned with G50 Superfine
Sephadex columns (Amersham Pharmacia 17-004101), and separated and analyzed in ABI Prism 3700
DNA Analyzer (Applied Biosystems). Forward and
reverse sequences were matched using SeqMan
(DNAstar Inc., WI).
Phylogenetic analyses
Pairwise and global alignments of consensus
sequences of the ITS region and partial SSU of the
nuclear ribosomal RNA gene array were performed in
Bionumerics 3.0 (Applied Maths, Kortrijk, Belgium).
Where necessary manual adjustments were made.
Parsimony analysis was done with the heuristic search
option in PAUP v. 4.0b10 (Swofford 2002), with the
following parameter settings: characters unordered
with equal weight, random taxon addition, branch
swapping with tree bisection-reconnection (TBR)
algorithm, branches collapsing if the maximum branch
length was zero, maxtrees set at 10 000. Alignment
gaps were treated as missing characters in the analysis
of the ITS dataset, and as fifth base in the SSU
dataset, where they occurred in relatively conserved
regions. Parsimony bootstrap analyses were performed
using the full heuristic search option, random stepwise
addition, and 1000 replicates, with maxtrees set at
100.
BLAST searches in GenBank with SSU sequences
of the newly described species revealed highest similarity to Letendraea helminthicola (Berk. & Broome)
PARACONIOTHYRIUM GEN. NOV.
Weese, Bimuria novae-zelandiae D. Hawksw., Chea
&
Sheridan,
Helminthosporium
spp.
and
Paraphaeosphaeria spp. Additional Pleosporalean
taxa were found in BLAST searches using the SSU
sequences of the following type species of relevant
genera, Microsphaeropsis olivacea, Coniothyrium
palmarum, and Cyclothyrium juglandis, and these
were also added to the SSU dataset. The range of
species selected for the SSU dataset was too diverse
for alignment of the ITS region. BLAST searches with
the ITS sequences of the newly described species
revealed highest similarity to species of
Paraphaeosphaeria, some Coniothyrium spp., and
also Leptosphaeria bicolor, L. taiwanensis, and
Helminthosporium spp. In total 23 sequences were
included in the ITS dataset. Unambiguous alignment
for all sequences was only possible for the 5.8 S gene
and most of ITS 2, and the initial analysis was based
on those genes only, using Massarina lacustris
(AF250831) as outgroup. In a second analysis, the
complete ITS region was included for taxa in the
Paraconiothyrium/Paraphaeosphaeria clade, using
Helminthosporium velutinum Link as outgroup (15
sequences). GenBank accession numbers and corresponding taxon names are given in Figs 1 and 2.
GenBank accession numbers of sequences generated
in this study are given in Table 1. A strain of Helminthosporium velutinum was defined as outgroup for the
ITS dataset, while a sequence of Peziza echinospora
P. Karst. (as P. sylvestris in Harrington et al. 1999)
was used as outgroup for the SSU dataset. The alignments and trees were lodged in TreeBase (accession
SN2133).
Culture studies and morphological analyses
The strains were studied on OA, 3 % malt extract
(MEA, Oxoid), and cornmeal (CMA), and potatodextrose (PDA) agars. Media were prepared according
to Gams et al. (1998). Plates were incubated in the
laboratory in diffuse daylight (ddl, 20 ºC), or in an
incubator under n-UV light (12 h light, 12 h dark) at
15 ºC. Growth characteristics were studied on MEA in
the dark in series of incubators set at different
temperatures (range 6–36 ºC, 3º intervals). Colony
diameter in cultural descriptions was measured at 20
ºC. Colours were described according to Rayner
(1970). Sporulating structures were mounted in water
and examined microscopically. Digital images were
recorded with Nikon Coolpix 995.
RESULTS
Phylogenetic analyses
ITS sequences: The alignment of the ITS region
comprised in total 572 characters. In the initial analysis, 37 characters within insertions/deletions or with
ambiguous position homology were excluded from
this analysis, as were all further constant characters, so
that in total 64 (11 %) characters were included. The
heuristic search resulted in two most parsimonious
trees (MPT) of 107 steps (consistency index (CI) =
0.785, redundancy index (RI) = 0.924, rescaled consistency index (RC) = 0.725, homoplasy index (HI) =
0.215), one of which is depicted in Fig. 1. The other
MPT was identical with the strict consensus tree, and
only differed from the tree in Fig. 1 in that
Paraphaeosphaeria pilleata Kohlm., Volkm.-Kohlm.
& O.E. Erikss. and its sister group collapsed into a
trichotomy. Bootstrap supports over 50 % are indicated in the tree above the branches. The included
Coniothyrium species, the newly described Paraconiothyrium species, and Paraphaeosphaeria species
grouped in a well-supported clade (97 %). Within this
Paraconiothyrium/Paraphaeosphaeria-clade,
three
main groups were found. The first group comprised
two strains of Coniothyrium sporulosum and CBS
132.26, identified as Coniothyrium fuckelii Sacc., as
well as AK9629 Coniothyrium sp., and was supported
in 87 % of the replications. There was 100 % ITS
sequence homology among these four strains, which
most likely all belong to C. sporulosum. A bootstrap
support of 88 % was obtained for a group containing
three Coniothyrium minitans strains which all had
identical sequences. CBS 972.95 and N119
‘Paraphaeosphaeria sp.’ differed from each other by
two base positions, and grouped together with 80 %
support. CBS 109850 was the closest sister taxon to
these two strains, and together they formed a highly
supported clade (86 %). CBS 109850 differed by 5
base positions from CBS 972.95 and N119.
Paraphaeosphaeria michotii (Westend.) O.E. Erikss.
and Paraphaeosphaeria pilleata did not group together in a single clade. Two isolates with very distinct ITS sequences, CBS 113269 and 100299, did not
group closely with the other taxa studied. For example, CBS 113269 differed from CBS 972.95 at 38 base
positions, and from CBS 100299 at 37 base positions
(plus at an eight-base insertion in the ITS1 region of
CBS 100299). The Leptosphaeria and Helminthosporium spp. grouped in a single sister-clade with maximal bootstrap support (100 %). In the second analysis,
the entire ITS region was included for 15 taxa. The
internal
topology
of
the
Paraconiothyrium/Paraphaeosphaeria clade remained unresolved,
but the main groups were the same as in the first
analysis. The bootstrap values over 50 % obtained in
the second analysis are indicated below the branches
of the same groups in Fig. 1.
SSU sequences: The alignment of the SSU of 58 taxa
comprised 1727 characters. In the maximum parsimony analysis, 175 (10 %) informative characters
were included, while constant and autapomorphic
characters were excluded. The heuristic search yielded
1821 MPT’s of 428 steps (CI = 0.523, RI = 0.851, RC
325
VERKLEY ET AL.
= 0.445, HI = 0.477). The strict consensus tree with
bootstrap values of the clades over 50 % is given in
Fig. 2.
Paraconiothyrium
sporulosum
AJ293814 C. sporulosum
AJ293814 Conio.sporulosum
87
91*
AJ293815 C. sporulosum
AJ293815 Conio.sporulosum
AY157492 ‘Coniothyrium sp.’ AK9629
AY157492 Conio.sp.AK9629
AJ293809 Coniothyrium minitans
AJ293809 Conio.minitans
88
AJ293810 C. minitans
Paraconiothyrium
minitans
AJ293810 Conio.minitans
AJ293811 C. minitans
AJ293811 Conio.minitans
CBS 972.95 Paraconiothyrium cyclothyrioides
CBS 972.95 Cycloth.sp.
80
60
AB096264 ‘Paraphaeosphaeria sp.’
AB096264 Paraphaeosph.sp
CBS 109850 / CCT6596 Paraconiothyrium estuarinum
CBS109850 Cycloth.sp.
67*
56
97
86 82*
89*
CBS 100299 Paraconiothyrium brasiliense
CBS100299 Cycloth.sp.
AF250821 Paraphaeosphaeria pilleata
AF250821 Paraph.pilleata
AF250817 Paraphaeosphaeria michotii
AF250817 Paraph. michotii
Paraphaeosphaeria - clade
99*
Paraconiothyrium /
AJ293813 ‘Coniothyrium fuckelii’ CBS 132.26
AJ293813 Conio.fuckelii
CBS 113269 / NRRL 29993 Paraconiothyrium fungicola
MYC-888 Conio.sp.
AF439462 Leptosphaeria taiwanensis
AF439462 Leptosph.taiwanensis
90
79
AF439463 L. taiwanensis
AF439463 Leptosph.taiwanensis
AF439464 L. taiwanensis
AF439464 Leptosph.taiwanensis
55
100
AF455415 Leptosphaeria bicolor
AF455415 Leptosph. bicolor
U04203 L. bicolor
U04203 Leptosph. bicolor
84
97
AF120262 Helminthosporium velutinum
AF120262 Helminthosp.velut
AF145704 H. velutinum
AF145704 Helminthosp.velut
AF145703 H. solani
AF145703 Helminthosp.solani
AF250831 Massarina lacustris
AF250831 Massarina.lacustris
1 change
Fig. 1. One of two most parsimonious trees (MPT) of 107 steps (consistency index (CI) = 0.785, redundancy index (RI) =
0.924, rescaled consistency index (RC) = 0.725, homoplasy index (HI) = 0.215), obtained in PAUP using a heuristic search of
the 5.8 nrDNA- ITS2 region. Numbers above the branches are bootstrap values obtained from 1000 replications and rounded to
the nearest integer, shown only for branches supported by more than 50 %. Numbers with asterisk below the branches in the
Paraconiothyrium/Paraphaeosphaeria clade are bootstrap values (1000 replications) obtained in a heuristic search of ITS15.8S-ITS2, in which only the taxa of this clade were included, using Helminthosporium velutinum (AF145704) as outgroup
(see text).
All four new Paraconiothyrium species grouped with
Coniothyrium minitans and Paraphaeosphaeria
michotii and Paraphaeosphaeria pilleata in a Paraconiothyrium/Paraphaeosphaeria clade with 99 %
bootstrap support. Their sequences were almost 100
% homologous. These taxa were nested within a
highly supported clade (98 %) with Letendraea
helminthicola, Bimuria novae-zelandiae, and the
Helminthosporium species. A Microsphaeropsis
clade could also be identified (96 %), comprising M.
olivacea strains (CBS 401.81, 442.83), representing
the type species of the genus Microsphaeropsis, and
two mutually morphologically indistinguishable
strains of Coniothyrium insitivum Sacc., CBS 157.37
and 100453. These C. insitivum isolates may actually
represent two different taxa, as both SSU and ITS
sequences showed differences (at 4 and 12 base
positions, respectively). The strains representing
326
Coniothyrium palmarum, the type species of the
genus Coniothyrium, CBS 400.71 and 758.73, had
100 % identical ITS and SSU sequences, and grouped
together with pleosporalean taxa considered to belong
to
various
families
(Pleosporaceae,
Phaeosphaeriaceae, Melanommataceae, Leptosphaeriaceae). CBS 194.49 is a sterile strain that was
originally identified as Thyridaria rubronotata (Berk.
& Br.) Sacc., but most likely is a species of Neophaeosphaeria or a closely related genus. Thyridaria
rubronotata (anamorph: Cyclothyrium juglandis, type
species of the genus Cyclothyrium) strains CBS
385.39 (SSU) and 419.85, of which the ITS sequences were identical (no SSU sequence available
for 419.85) also fall within the Pleosporales. The
Pleosporales clade obtained maximal bootstrap
support (100 %) in our analysis, but the SSU sequence of CBS 385.39 was incomplete.
PARACONIOTHYRIUM GEN. NOV.
Strict
AF250820 Neophaeosphaeria filamentosa
AF250825 N. filamentosa
AF250826 N. quadriseptata
CBS 194.49 ‘Thyridaria rubro-notata’
67
100
88
85
90
U04236 Phaeosphaeria nodorum
U43448
U43458
Pleospora herbarum
U05201
U43466 Pleospora beticola
CBS 400.71
CBS 758.73
AF525677
AY161121
Coniothyrium palmarum
Coniothyrium
Setomelanomma holmii
U04238 Cucurbitaria elongata
U04235 Leptosphaeria microscopica
U43453 Ophioshaerella herpotricha
U42481 Cucurbitaria berberidis
AF250823 Phaeosphaeriopsis agavensis
U04205 Leptosphaeria doliolum
70
CBS 401.81 Microsphaeropsis olivacea
CBS 442.83 M. olivacea
CBS 336.78 M. olivacea
CBS157.37 Coniothyrium insitivum
96
Microsphaeropsis
CBS 100453 C. insitivum
CBS 109850 = CCT6596 Paraconiothyrium estuarinum
53
CBS 100299 Paraconiothyrium brasiliense
99
AF250817 Paraphaeosphaeria michotii
AF250821 Paraphaeosphaeria pilleata
CBS 972.95 Paraconiothyrium cyclothyrioides
CBS 147.96 Paraconiothyrium minitans
97
Pleosporales
AF250818 Phaeosphaeriopsis nolinae
AF250822 Phaeosphaeriopsis obtusa
AF242265 Melanomma sanguinarium
U04238 Leptosphaeria maculans
Paraconiothyrium /
Paraphaeosphaeria
CBS 861.71 P. minitans
CBS 113269 = NRRL 29993 Paraconiothyrium fungicola
AY016345 Letendraea helminthicola
98
100
87
AY016338 Bimuria novae-zelandiae
AF120248 Helminthosporium solani
AF120250 H. solani
AF120254 H. velutinum
CBS 385.39 Thyridaria rubronotata/ Cyclothyrium juglandis
CBS 546.94 Roussoëlla hysterioides /Cytoplea sp.
100
99
65
53
75
AY016354 Trematosphaeria heterospora
U42474 Dothidea insculpta
U42475 Dothidea hippophaeos
AY016353 Stylodothis puccinioides
82
100
AY016341 Delphinella strobiligena
AY016342 Discosphaerina fagi
U42476 Botryosphaeria rhodina
U42477 Botryosphaeria ribis
AB041249 Guignardia mangiferae
AB041248 G. mangiferae
AY016348 Phaeotrichum benjaminii
Dothideales
69
95
AY016355 Westerdykella cylindrica
U42483 Herpotrichia juniperi
U42484 Herpotrichia diffusa
AF006309 Peziza echinospora
Fig. 2. Strict consensus tree of 1681 MPT’s of 428 steps (CI = 0.523, RI = 0.851, RC = 0.445, HI = 0.477), obtained in PAUP
using a heuristic search of partial SSU nrDNA. Numbers at the branches are bootstrap values obtained from 1000 replications
and rounded to the nearest integer, shown only for branches supported by more than 50 %.
The lower internal nodes of the Pleosporales clade
were not well-supported. Analysis of an alignment of
5.8 S rDNA and adjacent part of ITS 2 (no tree
shown)
confirmed
the
position
of
Thyridaria/Cyclothyrium as found in the analyses of
the SSU. None of the Coniothyrium-like taxa
investigated here showed affinities to any of the
Dothideales included in the analysis.
Taxonomic part
Paraconiothyrium Verkley, anam. gen. nov.
MycoBank MB500080.
Conidiomata eustromatica, simplicia vel complexa, raro
pycnidialia, cellulae conidiogenae discretae vel integratae,
phialidicae, raro semel ad ter percurrentes; conidia aseptata,
interdum uniseptata, tempore liberationis hyalina, deinde
fusca, glabra vel minute asperata, teleomorphosis
Paraphaeosphaeriae.
Typus: Paraconiothyrium estuarinum Verkley & M. da
Silva sp. nov.
Conidiomata eustromatic, simple or complex, rarely
pycnidial, conidiogenous cells discrete or integrated,
phialidic, sometimes percurrent, conidia aseptate,
sometimes 1-septate, thin-walled, smooth-walled or
minutely warted, hyaline when liberated, later brown,
teleomorph in the genus Paraphaeosphaeria.
Paraconiothyrium estuarinum Verkley & M. da
Silva, sp. nov. MycoBank MB500081. Figs 3, 7,
8.
Conidiomata eustromatica, 0.2–0.5(–1) mm diametro.
Cellulae conidiogenae hyalinae, phialidicae, raro semel
percurrentes, 4–6.5 × 2.5–3.5(–4) µm. Conidia anguste
ellipsoidea vel breviter cylindrica, hyalina, continua,
tempore liberationis hyalina, deinde olivacea vel luteofusca, (3–)3.2–4(–6) × 1.4–1.7(–2) µm (agaro ‘oatmeal’).
Conidiomata mostly submerged in the agar, but also
superficial and in the aerial mycelium, eustromatic,
globose or flattened, dark brown to black, 0.2–0.5(–1)
mm diam, with several merging cavities, ostioles
absent, opening by dissolution of upper cells; co-
327
VERKLEY ET AL.
nidiomatal wall composed of a 30–45 µm thick outer
layer of isodiametric or more flattened cells with
hyaline to reddish brown walls thickened up to 1.5
µm, lined by a 35–60(–75) µm thick inner layer of
textura angularis with cells 3–10 µm diam with
hyaline walls thickened up to 0.5 µm. The surface of
the conidiomatal wall often covered under brown
entangling hyphae. Conidiogenous cells discrete,
assembled into protruding masses of cells, or integrated in very compact conidiophores, ampulliform to
subcylindrical, hyaline, indeterminate, phialidic with
an inconspicuous periclinal thickening and collarette,
later often with a single percurrent proliferation,
mostly 4–6.5 × 2.5–3.5(–4) µm. Conidia narrowly
ellipsoidal or short-cylindrical, straight or slightly
curved, rounded at both ends, 1-celled, with one or
two small, polar guttules, and with thin and smooth
walls that are hyaline at secession, but soon become
olivaceous- or yellowish brown, on OA (3–)3.2–4(–6)
× 1.4–1.7(–2) µm, on MEA (3–)3.2–4.2(–5.8) × 1.4–2
(–2.2) µm (all in diffuse daylight).
Cultural characteristics: Colonies on OA reaching 90
mm diam within 14 d, spreading, with an even, glabrous, colourless margin; immersed mycelium becoming pale mouse-grey, later darkening to olivaceous,
the surface with a diffuse to fairly dense mat of finely
felted to woolly-floccose aerial mycelium, which is
also greyish and near the margin almost pure white,
but later becomes olivaceous-buff throughout the
colony surface; reverse mouse-grey, in the centre
becoming olivaceous-black; complex conidiomata
developing from the centre in radiating rows or in a
more scattered pattern after 5–7 d.
3
4
5
6
Figs 3–6. Conidia from oatmeal agar cultures. 3. Paraconiothyrium estuarinum, CBS 109850. 4. P. brasiliense, CBS 100299.
5. P. cyclothyrioides, CBS 972.95. 6. P. fungicola, CBS 113269. Scale bars = 10 µm
328
PARACONIOTHYRIUM GEN. NOV.
Colonies on CMA reaching 90 mm diam within 14 d,
spreading, with an even, glabrous, colourless margin;
immersed mycelium olivaceous-grey to greyolivaceous, aerial mycelium as on OA; reverse olivaceous-grey to olivaceous-black; scarce, scattered
simple to complex conidiomata which are similar in
structure as those on OA developing from 5–7 d..
Colonies on MEA reaching 80 mm diam in 14 d,
spreading, with an even, colourless to buff, almost
glabrous margin; colony surface almost entirely
covered by a dense mat of woolly aerial mycelium,
which is pale olivaceous-grey to olivaceous-grey, in
the centre olivaceous-black, and near the margin paler
to almost pure white; reverse in the centre mostly
chestnut to sepia, surrounded by umber, cinnamon and
ochreous areas or zones; Conidiomata as on OA
Growth characteristics: Optimum 27 ºC, maximum 33
ºC.
Holotype: Brazil, São Paulo State, Cubatão, Piaçaguera
River, isolated from an estuarine sediment polluted with
industrial discharges, isolate da Silva CCT6596 = CBS
109850, living culture; Herbarium CBS H-10528, dried
culture on oatmeal agar, holotype; also kept metabolically
inactive in frozen and dried state.
surface of the conidiomatal wall covered by 2–3 µm
wide hyphae with dark-brown, smooth walls. Conidiogenous cells discrete or assembled into protruding masses, indeterminate, phialidic, formed from the
inner cells all over the conidiomatal wall, hyaline to
pale yellow, broadly ampulliform to globose, with
distinct periclinal thickening, collarette absent, 4–6 ×
3.5–5 µm; conidia ellipsoid to short-cylindrical,
rounded at both ends, on CMA and MEA also obpyriform (narrowing towards the base), 1-celled, with thin
and smooth walls that are hyaline at secession, but
soon become olivaceous, contents minutely granular
or with a few small polar guttules, conidial mass dark
brown to black; conidia on CMA (3.2–)3.4–4.6(–5.3)
× (2–)2.2–3(–3.6);
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
Additional strains examined: Brazil, São Paulo State,
Cubatão, Piaçaguera River, isolated from an estuarine
sediment polluted with industrial discharges, da Silva
INCQS 40202, 40203, 40204, 40205, 40206, 40207.
Notes: In screening for ability to degrade polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons, the type strain proved a potent
bioremediator, degrading phenanthrene, pyrene,
anthracene and benzo[a]pyrene in relatively high
levels (da Silva et al. 2003 b, 2004).
Paraconiothyrium brasiliense Verkley, sp. nov.
MycoBank MB500082. Figs 4, 9, 10.
Conidiomata eustromatica, simplicia, vulgo complexa,
(0.2–)0.5–2(–3) mm diametro. Cellulae conidiogenae
hyalinae vel pallide luteae, phialidicae, 4–6 × 3.5–5 µm.
Conidia ellipsoidea vel breviter cylindrica, in agaro ‘MEA’
interdum obpyriformia, continua, tempore liberationis
hyalina, deinde olivacea, (3–)3.4–4.6(–5) × (1.8–)2–2.3(–
2.5) µm (agaro ‘oatmeal’).
Conidiomata superficial or immersed in the agar,
eustromatic, dark brown to black, (0.2–)0.5–2 (–3)
mm diam, with a single cavity, more often complex
with several merging cavities, ostioles absent, opening
by dissolution of upper cells; conidiomatal wall composed of a 10–20(–25) µm thick outer layer of texture
angularis with relatively thin, dark brown walls, the
cells 4.5–10 µm diam, lined by a 10–35(–45) µm thick
inner layer of textura angularis–globulosa, the cells
4–12 µm diam with thin, pale yellow to hyaline walls;
Figs 7–14. Cultures on oatmeal (OA) and malt extract agar
(MEA) (diffuse daylight, unless indicated otherwise). 7, 8.
P. estuarinum. 7. CBS 109850, 14 d old culture on OA; 8.
CBS 109850, 14 d old culture on MEA. 9, 10. P.
brasiliense. 9. CBS 100299, 19 d old culture on OA. 10.
CBS 100299, 14 d old culture on MEA. 11, 12. P.
cyclothyrioides. 11. CBS 972.95, 14 d old culture on OA.
12. CBS 972.95, 14 d old culture on MEA. 13, 14. P.
fungicola. 13. CBS 113269, 21 d old culture on OA. 14.
CBS 113269, 7 wk old culture on MEA grown under 12 hrs
nUV (12 hrs dark).
329
VERKLEY ET AL.
on OA (3–)3.4–4.6(–5) × (1.8–)2–2.3(–2.5) µm, on
MEA (2.8–)3.2–4(–4.5) × (1.8–)2–2.4(–3) (all diffuse
daylight).
Cultural characteristics: Colonies on OA reaching 90
mm diam in 14 d, spreading, with an even, glabrous,
colourless margin; immersed mycelium becoming
honey to amber with some citrine or pure yellow,
showing a concentric and radiating pattern, later
darkening to olivaceous or dark brick, lacking aerial
mycelium after 7 d, but later developing some diffuse,
felty grey aerial mycelium; reverse honey to
vinaceous-buff, later also becoming greyish sepia,
where conidiomata develop soon dark brick to brownvinaceous; complex conidiomata developing from the
centre in radiating rows after 5–7 d, black, globose or
flattened, 0.5–2(–3) mm diam, glabrous. Colonies on
CMA reaching of 80–85 mm diam in 14 d, spreading,
with an even, glabrous, colourless margin; immersed
mycelium with radiating and concentric pattern of
umber to rust on an amber to pale luteous background,
later darkening to predominantly olivaceous and
umber, aerial mycelium diffuse, scarce, pale
olivaceous-grey to greenish olivaceous, and some
scattered larger pure white tufts; reverse dark brick to
sepia, surrounded by hazel to isabelline and honey
zones; scattered, simple to complex conidiomata
developing from 7 d, later numerous also at the edge
of the Petri dish, black, 0.2–1(–1.5) mm diam, bearing
numerous grey to white undifferentiated hyphae on
the surface. Colonies on MEA (3 %, Oxoid) reaching
a diam of 72–74 mm in 14 d, spreading, with an even,
colourless to buff, glabrous margin; colony surface
almost entirely covered by a dense mat of woollyfloccose aerial mycelium that remains pure white
except in the centre, where it becomes olivaceousbuff; reverse mostly ochreous, but with fulvous zones
around a rust centre; numerous complex conidiomata
developing from 5–12 d onwards, visible as scattered
black dots on either side of the plate, later developing
also in a submarginal ring, black, covered with a thin
layer of undifferentiated greyish hyphae.
Growth characteristics: Optimum 24 ºC, maximum 33
ºC.
Holotype: Brazil, Patrocinio-Minas Gerais, isolated from
fruit of Coffea arabica, ‘M. Taniwaki 163’, living culture
CBS 100299 (CBS, kept metabolically inactive in freezedried state).
Notes: In Coniothyrium coffeae P. Henn., conidiomata
in planta (twigs) have a well-developed ostiolum,
while the conidia are 5–7.5 × 2.5–3 µm, formed from
cylindrical conidiogenous cells (5–7 × 1.5 µm, Petrak
& Sydow 1927).
330
Paraconiothyrium cyclothyrioides Verkley, sp.
nov. MycoBank MB500083. Figs 5, 11, 12.
Conidiomata eustromatica, simplicia, vulgo complexa, 0.3–
1.2(–1.6) mm diametro. Cellulae conidiogenae hyalinae,
phialidicae, interdum semel vel bis percurrentes, 4.5–8 ×
2.5–4 µm. Conidia breviter cylindrica, continua, tempore
liberationis hyalina, deinde luteo-fusca, (2.5–)3–4.2(–5) ×
(1–)1.2–1.5(–1.8) µm (agaro ‘oatmeal’).
Conidiomata submerged in the agar, or superficial,
eustromatic, with a single cavity, mostly complex,
irregularly globose or flattened, reddish brown to
black, 0.3–1.2(–1.6) mm diam, with several merging
cavities, ostioles absent or poorly differentiated;
conidiomatal wall composed of a 30–75 µm thick
outer layer of isodiametric and irregular cells with
reddish brown walls thickened up to 2 µm, and a 25–
50(–65) µm thick inner layer of textura angularis with
cells 3–10 µm diam with hyaline walls thickened up to
1 µm. The surface of the conidiomatal wall sometimes
clothed by a diffuse network of brown entangling
hyphae. Conidiogenous cells integrated in very
compact conidiophores, rarely discrete in masses of
cells protruding into the cavity, ampulliform to
subcylindrical, hyaline, indeterminate, phialidic,
periclinal thickening and collarette indistinct,
sometimes with one or two percurrent proliferations,
mostly 4.5–8 × 2.5–4 µm. Conidia 1-celled, shortcylindrical, straight or slightly curved, rounded at both
ends, with one or two very small, polar guttules, with
thin and smooth walls which are hyaline at secession,
but soon become yellowish brown, on OA (2.5–)3–
4.2(–5) × (1–)1.2–1.5(–1.8) µm, (2.5–)3–4.8(–6) × (1–
)1.2–1.6(–2) µm on MEA (all diffuse daylight).
Cultural characteristics: Colonies on OA reaching 90
mm diam within 14 d, spreading, with an even, glabrous, colourless margin; immersed mycelium becoming homogeneously ochreous-amber fading to pale
luteous towards the margin, later darkening to umber,
the surface provided with a very diffuse, finely felty
greyish aerial mycelium, occassionally in sectors
darker, Umber to grey-olivaceous; reverse honey to
hazel, underneath above mentioned sectors sepia or
darker. Colonies on CMA reaching a diam of 90 mm
within 14 d, spreading, with an even, glabrous, colourless margin; immersed mycelium with radiating and
concentrical patterns of isabelline to olivaceous over a
greenish olivaceous to honey or pale luteous background, later becoming darker umber, or larger areas
less pigmented, first pale honey to pale luteous, and
later becoming ochreous to fulvous, aerial mycelium
diffuse, moderately developed, woolly-floccose in the
central area, pale olivaceous-grey; reverse pale hazel
to isabelline or honey. Colonies on MEA reaching a
diam of 70–72 mm in 14 d, spreading, with a somewhat ruffled, colourless to buff, glabrous margin;
PARACONIOTHYRIUM GEN. NOV.
immersed mycelium olivaceous to olivaceous-black,
covered by a well-developed, woolly-floccose, pale
olivaceous grey aerial mycelium; reverse mostly bay,
dark brick and brown-vinaceous with irregular to
concentric patterns, abruptly fading to a cinnamon
pale ocreous marginal zone. Conidiomata developing
as single pycnidia or in complexes in aggregations
near the centre, releasing conidial slime in clear droplets after 10–14 d.
Growth characteristics: Optimum 27 ºC, maximum 33
ºC.
Holotype: Papua New Guinea, Central Province, Varirata
National Park near Port Moresby, ex soil sample A.
Aptroot, ‘A 430’, X.1995, living culture CBS 972.95 (CBS,
kept metabolically inactive in frozen and freeze-dried state).
Notes: Sequence AB096264 in GenBank of the isolate
‘N 119’ (Tsuda et al. 2003) was almost identical to the
ITS sequence of CBS 972.95, indicating that it might
be representative of the same species. N119 was
isolated from ‘horse mussel’. We did not receive any
further information regarding this isolate.
Paraconiothyrium
fungicola
Verkley
&
Wicklow, sp. nov. MycoBank MB500084. Figs
6, 13, 14.
Conidiomata eustromatica, simplicia vel complexa, raro
ostiolis papillatis, 0.3–1(–1.5) mm diametro. Cellulae
conidiogenae hyalinae, phialidicae, interdum semel ad ter
percurrentes, 5–7(–9) × 3–5 µm. Conidia ovoidea,
ellipsoidea vel breviter cylindrica, continua vel uniseptata,
tempore liberationis hyalina, deinde rubro-brunnea,
continua (4.2–)4.4–6.2(–7) × (2.7–)3–3.4(–3.6) µm,
uniseptata 7 × 3 µm µm (agaro ‘oatmeal’).
Conidiomata superficial or immersed in the agar,
eustromatic, dark brown to black, clothed with white
hyphal projections, 0.3–1(–1.5) mm diam, simple, or
complex with several merging cavities, sometimes
with papillate ostioles, releasing dark brown to black
droplets of conidial slime; conidiomatal wall covered
by brown etangling 2–4 µm wide hyphae, composed
of a single tissue of textura angularis-globulosa, 30–
125 µm thick, between cavities also with more elongated hyphal cells, the cells 3–6 µm diam with hyaline
to pale yellow walls up to 0.5 µm thick. Conidiogenous cells discrete, rarely assembled into protruding
masses, determinate, phialidic, occassionally indeterminate, proliferating percurrently 1–3 times (only on
PDA dominating), formed from the inner cells all over
the conidiomatal wall, hyaline, subglobose, or broadly
to narrowly ampulliform, sometimes with a relatively
wide elongated neck, with an indistinct periclinal
thickening, collarette absent, 5–7(–9) × 3–5 µm;
conidia one-celled, ovoid, ellipsoid to shortcylindrical, broadly rounded at both ends or slightly
tapering towards one end, some constricted in the
middle, or two-celled, constricted around the euseptum, with up to 0.4 µm thick, smooth walls which are
hyaline at secession, but soon become reddish-brown,
contents vinaceous to olivaceous, minutely granular
with a few small guttules near the poles, conidial mass
dark brown to black; conidia on OA 1-celled (4.2–)
4.4–6.2(–7) × (2.7–)3–3.4(–3.6) µm, 2-celled 7 × 3
µm; on MEA 1-celled (4–)5–6(–7) × (2.7–)3–3.7(–
4.8), 2-celled 6–8 × 4.5–5.2 µm (all ddl); on PDA 1celled (4–)4.5–6(–7) × (3–)3.2–4(–4.3) µm, two-celled
not observed.
Colonies on OA reaching a diam of 65 mm in 21 d,
spreading, with an irregularly undulating or somewhat
ruffled, glabrous, colourless margin; colony surface
with a diffuse coverage of pure white, low, finely felty
or floccose aerial mycelium, immersed mycelium
becomes distinctly glaucous blue-green to dark
herbage green in large concentrical zones or irregular
patches, the remainder buff to rosy-buff; reverse
concolourous, in the centre distinctly rosy-buff to
vinaceous buff. Pycnidia developing on the surface of
the colony from 10 d onwards. Colonies on PDA
reaching a diam of 60–63 mm in 21 d, spreading, with
a somewhat ruffled, glabrous,and colourless margin;
colony surface with a diffuse, pure white, finely felted
aerial mycelium, but around the centre becoming first
citrine, then olivaceous buff to greenish olivaceous;
immersed mycelium long colourless, but in the centre
gradually becoming olivaceous buff to olivaceous;
reverse for the most buff, but in the centre becoming
honey, and then isabelline to hazel. Colonies on MEA
reaching a diam of 35–38 mm in 21 d; restricted and
already elevated in the centre up to 5 mm after 14 d,
with an even or slightly undulating, glabrous buff
margin; colony surface covered by a dense mat of
woolly, pure white to honey or straw to primrose (pale
yellow) aerial mycelium bearing numerous clear to
somewhat yellowish water droplets, reverse brick at
the centre, surrounded by cinnamon and ochreous
zones. Pycnidia developing around the centre of the
colony after 10–14 d.
Growth characteristics:
maximum 30 ºC.
Optimum
21–24
ºC,
Holotype: U.S.A., Georgia, Dougherty Co., swamp area in
Albany Nursery of the Department of Natural resources,
colonist of a resupinate polypore fungus on a branch of
dead hardwood collected by B. W. Horn, isolated by D. T.
W., NRRL 29993 = CBS 113269, living culture; CBS, kept
metabolically inactive in frozen state.
Notes: Bioassay-guided fractionation of the ethyl
acetate extract of solid-substrate fermentation cultures
of NRRL 29993 afforded a new isopimarane diterpenoid glucoside and a mycoparasitic acid analog, both
of which showed potent antifungal activity in disk
assays against Aspergillus flavus Link NRRL 6541
331
VERKLEY ET AL.
and Fusarium verticillioides (Sacc.) Nirenberg NRRL
25457 (N. H. Lee, J. B. Gloer, D.T. Wicklow, unpubl.).
Paraconiothyrium minitans (W.A. Campb.)
Verkley, comb. nov. MycoBank MB500085.
Basionym: Coniothyrium minitans W.A. Campb.,
Mycologia 39: 191. 1947.
In Paraconiothyrium minitans conidiomata are thinwalled pycnidia, the conidiogenous cells are discrete
or integrated (small protruding masses of cells),
enteroblastic, phialidic with a minute periclinal
thickening, but often also percurrently proliferating
once or twice over a small distance, to form
inconspicuous annellations (OA, CBS 861.71).
Paraconiothyrium sporulosum (W. Gams &
Domsch) Verkley, comb. nov. MycoBank
MB500086.
Basionym: Coniothyrium fuckelii var. sporulosum W.
Gams & Domsch, Nova Hedwigia 18: 9. 1969.
≡ Coniothyrium sporulosum (W. Gams & Domsch)
van der Aa, Verh. Kon. Ned. Akad. Wet., tweede
sect., 68: 3. 1977.
DISCUSSION
The SSU and ITS data show that the four new Paraconiothyrium species are part of a distinct phylogenetic lineage within the pleosporalean ascomycetes.
They share this lineage with the genus
Paraphaeosphaeria s. str. as emended by Câmara et
al. (2003), the anamorphs of which need not be formally named but are considered here as representative
of Paraconiothyrium. The shared evolutionary history
of these fungi is also reflected in phenotype, as the
Paraconiothyrium anamorphs (including those of
Paraphaeosphaeria s. str.) show a combination of
morphological characters by which they can be distinguished from typical Coniothyrium, Microsphaeropsis, and Cyclothyrium species. In Paraconiothyrium,
the conidiomata generally are complex, eustromatic
and relatively thick-walled. They may appear as
simple pycnidia, but then they usually lack a welldifferentiated ostiola. In Coniothyrium, the conidiomata are true pycnidia, which may merge in vitro but
then always produce well-developed, sometimes even
papillate ostiola. The most distinctive Coniothyrium
feature is the conidiogenous cells, which are annellidic, i.e., percurrently proliferating after the secession
of each conidium. Coniothyrium conidia are thickwalled and verruculose, with a truncate base and
sometimes a basal frill (Sutton 1980). Microsphaeropsis species are also pycnidial, but their conidiogenous
cells are discrete, Phoma-like phialides, which only
rarely proliferate percurrently. Microsphaeropsis
olivacea, the type species, has pale brown, 1-celled,
thin- and smooth-walled conidia. Sutton (1980) also
332
included species with thick-walled, asperate or verrucose conidia in Microsphaeropsis. In Cyclothyrium
juglandis, the type species of the genus Cyclothyrium
and the anamorph of Thyridaria rubronotata, the
conidiomata are eustromatic and the conidiogenous
cells phialidic as in Paraconiothyrium. However, in
Cyclothyrium the conidiogenous cells are more elongated than in most species of Paraconiothyrium,
whilst the conidia are almost truncate at the base, or at
least are much less rounded at the base than are conidia of Paraconiothyrium. When Petrak proposed the
genus Cyclothyrium, he also transferred Coniothyrium
incrustans (Sacc.) Petr., and Coniothyrium ulmigenum
(Berk.) Petr. to this genus (Petrak 1923). Both names,
however, were later included in the synonymy of
Cyclothyrium juglandis (Petrak & Sydow 1927), while
Cyclothyrium itself was reclassified as a subgenus of
Cytoplea Bizz. & Sacc. No strain is available of the
type species of Cytoplea, Cytoplea arundinacea
(Sacc.) Petr. & Syd. (basionym Coniothyrium arundinaceum Sacc.). Sutton (1980) studied the holotype
of C. arundinaceum and accepted the genus Cytoplea
for species with eustromatic, multiloculate conidiomata and consistently discrete, Phoma-like phialides,
which produce oval to ellipsoid, verrucose to warty,
aseptate conidia. Cytoplea is linked to Roussoëlla
Sacc. of the Didymosphaeriaceae (Hyde et al. 2000),
and the 18S and ITS data for the type species of
Roussoëlla, Roussoëlla hysterioides (Ces.) Höhn.
(CBS 546.94, neotype strain, syn. R. nitidula Sacc. &
Paol.), indicate that this genus is not closely related to
Paraconiothyrium (ITS 1 completely unalignable).
This ITS sequence of R. hysterioides was more similar
to a sequence of Cytoplea hysterioides (AF009811),
and both 18S and ITS sequences suggest a relatively
close relationship to Cyclothyrium/Thyridaria. Barr
(2003) transferred the genus Thyridaria to the Didymosphaeriaceae, but the phylogenetic status of that
family is also still uncertain (Eriksson, Myconet Note
3903, 2004). The conidiogenous cells of Paraconiothyrium fungicola can form elongated necks, a character suggestive of Cyclothyrium, while the papillate
ostioles of P. fungicola appear to point more towards
Coniothyrium and Microsphaeropsis. The new genus
Prosopidicola, which Lennox et al. (this volume)
propose for a Coniothyrium-like fungus isolated from
leguminous weed Prosopis in North America, differs
from Paraconiothyrium and all other Coniothyriumlike genera in its branched conidiophores with percurrently or sympodially proliferating, green-brown
conidiogenous cells provided with an irregular, wartlike, green-brown apical region. Genetically it is also
distinct, having affinities with taxa of the Diaporthales (Lennox et al., this volume).
Câmara et al. (2001) evaluated morphological data
in relation to ITS sequences for nine species of
Paraphaeosphaeria, and identified three lineages,
which were later also confirmed by SSU data (Câmara
et al. 2003). They found that only one species,
Paraphaeosphaeria pilleata, was congeneric with the
type species Paraphaeosphaeria michotii. Thus, only
PARACONIOTHYRIUM GEN. NOV.
two species were retained in Paraphaeosphaeria s.
str.
For
the
other
species
the
genera
Phaeosphaeriopsis and Neophaeosphaeria were
erected. Câmara et al. (2001) gave detailed descriptions of the Coniothyrium ‘sensu lato’ anamorphs, all
of which are formally unnamed, and found that differences in conidiogenesis correlated to a certain degree
with divergences in the sequence similarities among
Paraphaeosphaeria-like ascomycetes. The anamorphs
of Paraphaeosphaeria s. str. were noted as ‘typical of
the genus Microsphaeropsis’, producing smoothwalled, pale brown conidia from inconspicuous phialides with some periclinal thickening (Câmara et al.
2003). The anamorphs of the genus Neophaeosphaeria were described as ‘Coniothyrium-like’, with pigmented aseptate conidia produced from holoblastic,
percurrently proliferating conidiogenous cells with
conspicuous annellations. The anamorphs of
Phaeosphaeriopsis were less homogeneous, producing
either brown conidia from percurrently proliferating,
inconspicuously annellate conidiogenous cells (Ph.
glaucopunctata (Grev.) Câmara, M.E. Palm & A.W.
Ramaley, Ph. obtusispora (Speg.) Câmara, M.E. Palm
& A.W. Ramaley, and Ph. nolinae (A.W. Ramaley)
Câmara, M.E. Palm & A.W. Ramaley), or hyaline,
bacillar conidia from simple phialides (Ph.
amblyspora A.W. Ramaley, Ph. agavensis (A.W.
Ramaley, M.E. Palm & M.E. Barr) Câmara, M.E.
Palm & A.W. Ramaley). Conidiogenesis in the new
species
of
Paraconiothyrium
agrees
with
Paraphaeosphaeria s. str., which is congruent with
our results obtained in the ITS analysis.
Recently, Boerema (2003) mentioned that Coniothyrium species with Phoma-like phialidic pycnidia
are better placed in Microsphaeropsis and, as an
‘example’, he formally proposed the new combination
Microsphaeropsis fuckelii (Sacc.) Boerema for the
anamorph of Leptosphaeria coniothyrium (Fuckel)
Sacc., which was originally described in Coniothyrium. Muthumeenakshi et al. (2001) suggested that C.
sporulosum and C. fuckelii could be conspecific, and
cited Domsch et al. (1980), who had noted that the
conidia of these species were indistinguishable. We
did not sequence any strains of C. fuckelii. The idea
that these species are synonymous needs to be tested
in a study using mutiple strains. It has already been
shown that Leptosphaeria is polyphyletic (Morales et
al. 1995, Dong et al. 1998, Muthumeenakshi et al.
2001, Câmara et al. 2002). It seems likely that many
species described in Coniothyrium and even some
placed in Phoma may actually be akin to (or conspecific with) Microsphaeropsis olivacea. Apart from
reinvestigating taxa by means of examining cultures, it
is important to also sequence before proposing name
changes. Coniothyrium minitans is a case in point.
Based on ITS sequences, Muthumeenakshi et al.
(2001) demonstrated the close relation between C.
minitans (48 strains with 100 % ITS sequence homology) and C. sporulosum (CBS 358.75a) and, in a
distant clade, also between C. cerealis and Ampelomyces quisqualis Ces. and other Phaeosphaeriaceae. No
further Coniothyrium-like fungi were included in their
study. From a morphological perspective, the placement of C. minitans in Coniothyrium is clearly unsatisfactory. On strict morphological grounds, one could
also refer it to Microsphaeropsis because of its
pycnidial fruitbodies and phialidic conidiogenous
cells. This, however, would strongly conflict with the
phylogenetic data. Although the conidiomatal structure and the asperate conidia of C. minitans are aberrant in relation to what is seen in other species in the
Paraconiothyrium/Paraphaeosphaeria clade, we are
obliged to combine C. minitans into Paraconiothyrium, and thus to adopt a wide morphological concept
for this new genus. Coniothyrium sporulosum predominantly forms pycnidial fruitbodies, but otherwise
conforms more consistently with the other Paraconiothyrium spp. Additional molecular work will further
our understanding of the phylogeny within the Paraconiothyrium/Paraphaeosphaeria clade, and this
could ultimately lead to a segregation of more anamorph genera. Paraconiothyrium brasiliense, P.
estuarinum and P. cyclothyrioides were not wellsupported as separate species in the ITS analyses,
even when ITS1 was included. The ITS region contains no strong phylogenetic signal, but in view of the
fact that the widely distributed C. minitans is invariable in ITS sequence (Muthumeenakshi et al. 2001),
the variation seen in ITS sequences among the type
strains of the new Paraconiothyrium species supports
that idea that they are specifically distinct. Nonetheless, these species were described primarily on the
basis of phenotypic characters.
The extent of morphological variation in the Coniothyrium-like anamorphs is still only partly known for
the various groups within the Pleosporales which
contain such anamorphs. The exact phylogenetic
relationships among these groups are still not resolved, and the delimitation of the anamorph genera is
also far from settled at this point. This situation discourages scientists from formally describing interesting new species. The molecular data presented here
are a first important step towards improving the classification of these coelomycetes. By introducing a new
generic name now for Coniothyrium-like anamorphs
of the Paraconiothyrium/Paraphaeosphaeria clade,
we hope to stimulate the formal description of more
species within this interesting and potentially beneficial group of fungi. Researchers in applied fields who
work with different isolates will benefit from an
improved predictive value for their identifications, and
will be able to exchange information more effectively.
333
VERKLEY ET AL.
Table 1. Fungal isolates included for ITS and partial SSU sequence analyses (in alphabetical order of the anamorph names).
Anamorph
Coniothyrium
insitivum
Teleomorph (if known)
ITS
GenBank
SSU
GenBank
AY642516
AY642518
AY642519
AY642513
AY642514
AY642515
Origin
CBS 157.37; Robinia pseudoacacia,
Germany
CBS 100453; Robinia pseudoacacia,
Germany
CBS 147.96; sclerotia of Sclerotinia
sclerotiorum; Netherlands
CBS 861.71; sclerotia of Sclerotinia
trifoliorum; U.K.
CBS 401.81; Juniperus communis,
Switzerland
CBS 442.83; Taxus baccata, Netherlands
CBS 336.78; Picea abies, Germany
CBS 400.71; Chamaerops humilis, Italy
CBS 758.73; Phoenix dactylifera, Israel
CBS 194.49; Ulmus sp., Belgium
AY642521
CBS 385.39; Acer sp., U.K.
AY642528
CBS 546.94 (Neotype); Phyllostachys,
France
CBS 100299; fruit of Coffea arabica,
Brazil*
CBS 972.95; soil, Papua New Guinea*
CBS 109850, CCT6596; marine sediment,
Brazil*
CBS 113269, NRRL 29993; polyporous
fungus, Georgia*
AY642520
Paraconiothyrium
minitans
AY642525
AY642526
Microsphaeropsis
olivacea
AY642517
C. palmarum
Coniothyrium sp.
Cyclothyrium
juglandis
Cytoplea sp.
Neophaeosphaeria sp. (as
“Thyridaria rubronotata”)
Thyridaria rubro-notata
Roussoella hysterioides
Paraconiothyrium
brasiliense
P. cyclothyrioides
P. estuarinum
AY642531
AY642523
AY642529
AY642530
AY642524
AY642522
P. fungicolum
AY642520
AY642527
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
B.W. Horn and A. Aptroot are kindly thanked for collecting
samples. Richard C. Summerbell is kindly thanked for
critical reading of the manuscript, and Arien van Iperen for
isolation and Mieke Starink-Willemse for sequencing
strains.
REFERENCES
Barr ME (2003). The affinities of Thyridaria. Mycotaxon
88: 271–278.
Boerema GH (2003). Contributions towards a monograph
of Phoma (Coelomycetes) - X - Section Pilosa (taxa
with a Pleospora teleomorph) and nomenclatural notes
on some other taxa. Persoonia 18: 153–161.
Câmara MPS, Palm ME, van Berkum P, Stewart EL (2001).
Systematics of Paraphaeosphaeria: a molecular and
morphological approach. Mycological Research 105:
41–56.
Câmara MPS, Palm ME, van Berkum P, O'Neill NR (2002).
Molecular
phylogeny
of
Leptosphaeria
and
Phaeosphaeria. Mycologia 94: 630–640.
Câmara MPS, Ramaley AW, Castlebury LA, Palm ME
(2003). Neophaeosphaeria and Phaeosphaeriopsis,
segregates
of
Paraphaeosphaeria.
Mycological
Research 107: 516–522.
Campbell WA (1947). A new species of Coniothyrium
parasitic on sclerotia. Mycologia 39: 190–195.
334
Carisse O, Bernier J (2002a). Effect of environmental
factors on growth, pycnidial production and spore
germination of Microsphaeropsis isolates with
biocontrol potential against apple scab. Mycological
Research 106: 1455–1462.
Carisse O, Bernier J (2002b). Microsphaeropsis ochracea
sp. nov. associated with dead apple leaves. Mycologia
94: 297–301.
Carisse O, El-Bassam S, Benhamou N (2001). Effect of
Microsphaeropsis sp. strain P130A on germination and
production of sclerotia of Rhizoctonia solani and
interaction between the antagonist and the pathogen.
Phytopathology 91: 782–791.
Domsch KH, Gams W, Anderson T-H (1980). Compedium
of soil fungi Vol. I. Academic Press, London.
Dong JW, Chen WD, Crane JL (1998). Phylogenetic studies
of the Leptosphaeriaceae, Pleosporaceae and some other
Loculoascomycetes based on nuclear ribosomal DNA
sequences. Mycological Research 102: 151–156.
El-Bassam S, Benhamou N, Carisse O (2002). The role of
melanin in the antagonistic interaction between the
apple scab pathogen Venturia inaequalis and
Microsphaeropsis ochracea. Canadian Journal of
Microbiology 48: 349–358.
Fukami A, Nakamura T, Kim YP, Shiomi K, Hayashi M,
NagaiT, Yamada H, Komiyama K, Omura S (2000). A
new anti-influenza virus antibiotic, 10-norparvulenone
from Microsphaeropsis sp FO-5050. Journal of
Antibiotics 53: 1215–1218.
PARACONIOTHYRIUM GEN. NOV.
Gams W, Hoekstra ES, Aptroot A (1998). CBS course of
mycology,
4th
ed.
Centraalbureau
voor
Schimmelcultures, Baarn/Delft.
Goldstein AL, Carpenter MA, Crowhurst RN, Stewart A
(2000). Identification of Coniothyrium minitans isolates
using PCR amplification of a dispersed repetitive
element. Mycologia 92: 46–53.
Grendene A, Minardi P, Giacomini A, Squartini A,
Marciano P (2002). Characterization of the
mycoparasite Coniothyrium minitans: comparison
between morpho-physiological and molecular analyses.
Mycological Research 106: 796–807.
Harrington FA, Pfister DH, Potter D, Donoghue MJ (1999).
Phylogenetic studies within the Pezizales. I. 18S rRNA
sequence data and classification. Mycologia 91: 41–50.
Hendriks L, Goris A, Neefs J-M, Peer Y van de, Hennebert
G, Wachter R de (1989). The nucleotide sequence of the
small ribosomal subunit RNA of the yeast Candida
albicans and the evolutionary position of the fungi
amongst the Eukaryotes. Systematic and Applied
Microbiology 12: 223–229.
Holler U, Gloer JB, Wicklow DT (2002). Biologically
active polyketide metabolites from an undetermined
fungicolous hyphomycete resembling Cladosporium.
Journal of Natural Products 65: 876–882.
Hoog GS de, Gerrits van den Ende AHG (1998). Molecular
diagnostics of clinical strains of filamentous
basidiomycetes. Mycoses 41:183−189.
Hopfer RL, Walden P, Setterquist S, Highsmith WE (1993).
Detection and differentiation of fungi in clinical
specimens using polymerase chain reaction (PCR)
amplification and restriction enzyme analysis. Journal
of Medical and Vetenarian Mycology 31: 65–75.
Hyde KD, Taylor JE, Fröhlich J (2000) Genera of
Ascomycetes from palms. Fungal Diversity Press, Hong
Kong.
Morales VM, Jasalavich CA, Pelcher LE, Petrie GA, Taylor
JL (1995). Phylogenetic relationships among several
Leptosphaeria species based on their ribosomal DNA
sequences. Mycological Research 99: 593–603.
Muthumeenakshi S, Goldstein AL, Stewart A, Whipps JM
(2001). Molecular studies on intraspecific diversity and
phylogenetic position of Coniothyrium minitans.
Mycological Research 105: 1065–1074.
Petrak F (1923). Mykologische Notizen 5. Annales
mycologici 21: 1–69.
Petrak F, Sydow H (1927). Die Gattungen der
Pyrenomyzeten, Sphaeropsideen und Melanconieen. I.
Die phaeosporen Sphaeropsideen und die Gattung
Macrophoma. Feddes Repertorium, Beiheft 42: 1–551.
Rayner R W (1970). A mycological colour chart. Commonwealth Mycological Institute, Kew, U.K.
Silva M da, Cerniglia CE, Pothuluri JV, Canhos VP,
Esposito E (2003b). Screening filamentous fungi
isolated from estuarine sediments for the ability to
oxidize polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. World
Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology 19: 399–
405.
Silva M da, Esposito E, Moody JD, Canhos VP, Cerniglia
CE (2004). Metabolism of aromatic hydrocarbons by the
filamentous fungus Cyclothyrium sp. Chemosphere 57:
943–952.
Silva M da, Umbuzeiro GA, Pfenning LH, Canhos VP,
Esposito E (2003a). Filamentous fungi isolated from estuarine sediments contaminated with industrial discharges. Soil and Sediment Contamination 12: 345–356.
Sandys-Winsch C, Whipps JM, Gerlagh M, Kruse M
(1993). World distribution of the sclerotial mycoparasite
Coniothyrium minitans. Mycological Research 97:
1175–1178.
Seephonkai P, Isaka M, Kittakoop P, Palittapongarnpim P,
Kamchonwongpaisan
S,
Tanticharoen
M,
ThebtarAnonth
Y
(2002).
Evaluation
of
antimycobacterial, antiplasmodial and cytotoxic
activities of preussomerins isolated from the
lichenicolous fungus Microsphaeropsis sp BCC 3050.
Planta Medica 68: 45–48.
Sutton BC (1980). The Coelomycetes. Fungi imperfecti with
pycnidia, acervuli and stromata. Kew: Commonwealth
Mycological Institute.
Swofford DL (2002). Phylogenetic analysis using
parsimony
(PAUP).
Version
4.
Sunderland,
Massachusetts: Sinauer Associates.
Tsuda M, Mugishima T, Komatsu K, Sone T, Tanak M,
Mikami Y, Kobayashi J (2003). Modiolides A and B,
two new 10-membered macrolides from a marinederived fungus. Journal of Natural Products 66: 412–
415.
Vilgalys R, Hester M (1990). Rapid genetic identification
and mapping of enzymatically amplified ribosomal
DNA from several Cryptococcus species. Journal of
Bacteriology 172: 4238−4246.
Whipps JM, Gerlagh M (1992). Biology of Coniothyrium
minitans and its potential for use in disease control.
Mycological Research 96: 897–907.
White TJ, Bruns T, Lee S, Taylor J (1990). Amplification
and direct sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes
for phylogenetics. In: PCR protocols: a guide to methods and applications (Innis MA, Gelfand DA, Sninsky
JJ, White TJ, eds). Academic Press, San Diego, CA,
U.S.A.: 315–322.
335
336
View publication stats