Mycologia, 102(1), 2010, pp. 93–107. DOI: 10.3852/07-190
# 2010 by The Mycological Society of America, Lawrence, KS 66044-8897
Aquatic gilled mushrooms: Psathyrella fruiting in the
Rogue River in southern Oregon
Jonathan L. Frank
INTRODUCTION
Department of Biology, Southern Oregon University,
Ashland, Oregon 97520
Mushrooms with true gills have been observed
fruiting underwater in the clear, cold, flowing waters
of the upper Rogue River on the western flanks of
Crater Lake in Oregon. Aquatic mushrooms first were
observed (by R.A. Coffan) in the North Fork of the
Rogue River in Jul 2005. Specimens were collected
Jul–Sep 2005, 2007 and 2008. These are truly
underwater mushrooms and not mushrooms fruiting
on wood recently washed into the river. They grow in
the main channel, where they are constantly submerged at depths up to 0.5 m. Stipes are erect and
attached to substrates including alluvial gravel, silt
and woody debris. The Rogue River does not run dry;
the habitat is continuously inundated. At the time of
year when these aquatic fungi fruit, the land nearby is
dry and no similar fruiting bodies occur.
Aquatic fungi in freshwater commonly include
members of the Oomycota and Chytridiomycota, as
well as aquatic hyphomycetes that are anamorphic
stages of Ascomycota and Basidiomycota (Shearer et
al 2004, Shearer et al 2007). The ascomycete Vibrissea
truncorum (Alb. & Schwein.) Fr. fruits submerged on
wood in cold running water; its spores are thread-like
and dispersed underwater (Mains 1956, Tylutki 1979).
Other Ascomycota fruit on submerged wood in lakes
in Japan, Thailand and Costa Rica (Minoura and
Muroi 1978, Pinruan et al 2004, Ferrer et al 2008). A
basidiomycete with a smooth hymenium, Gloiocephala
aquatica Desjardin, Martinez-Peck & Rajchenberg,
that forms submerged basidiocarps has been reported
from lakes and ponds in southern Argentina (Desjardin et al 1995). Basidiocarps of 11 species of
homobasidiomycetes occur in marine ecosystems
(Hibbett and Binder 2001). These basidiocarps are
cyphelloid, minute enclosed cups or spheroids. None
are gilled mushrooms.
The aquatic gilled mushrooms from southern
Oregon appear to represent a novel taxon within
the Psathyrellaceae in the large polyphyletic genus
Psathyrella (Smith 1972, Padamsee 2008). Based on
morphological characters and DNA sequences we
propose it as a new species in Psathyrella.
Robert A. Coffan
Department of Environmental Studies, Southern Oregon
University, Ashland, Oregon 97520
Darlene Southworth1
Department of Biology, Southern Oregon University,
Ashland, Oregon 97520
Abstract: A species of Psathyrella (Basidiomycota)
with true gills has been observed fruiting underwater
in the clear, cold, flowing waters of the upper Rogue
River in Oregon. Fruiting bodies develop and mature
in the main channel, where they are constantly
submerged, and were observed fruiting over 11 wk.
These mushrooms develop underwater, not on wood
recently washed into the river. Substrates include
water-logged wood, gravel and the silty riverbed. DNA
sequences of the ITS region and a portion of the
ribosomal large subunit gene place this fungus in
Psathyrella sensu stricto near P. atomata, P. fontinalis
and P. superiorensis. Morphological characters distinguish the underwater mushroom from previously
described species. Fruiting bodies have long fibrillose
stipes with small diameter caps. Immature stages have
a thin veil that is soon lost. Gills lack reddish edges.
Cystidia are ventricose with subacute apices. Spores
were observed as wedge-shape rafts released into gas
pockets below the caps. Underwater gills and ballistospores indicate a recent adaptation to the stream
environment. This particular river habitat combines
the characteristics of spring-fed flows and cold,
aerated water with woody debris in shallow depths
on a fine volcanic substrate. Based on molecular and
morphological evidence we conclude that the underwater mushrooms are a new species, Psathyrella
aquatica. This report adds to the biodiversity of
stream fungi that degrade woody substrates. The
underwater environment is a new habitat for gilled
mushrooms.
Key words: Agaricales, aquatic fungi, ballistospores, Psathyrellaceae, psychrophilic fungi, stream
fungi
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Site.—Submerged basidiocarps were collected underwater
in the Rogue River at 42u519420N, 122u309280W, 900 m
elevatioin, approximately 45 km downstream from Bound-
Submitted 8 Nov 2007; accepted for publication 11 Jun 2009.
1
Corresponding author. E-mail: southworth@sou.edu
93
94
MYCOLOGIA
ary Springs, the predominant source of water for the upper
reaches of the Rogue River in the Rogue River-Siskiyou
National Forest (CES 2006). At this site base flow is relatively
high and constant during the summer. Streamflow data
(1930–1952) from the nearest USGS gauging station
(14327500) 6 km downstream from the site indicate a
mean monthly flow in September of 8.4 (SD, 1.6) cubic
meters per second (cms) (OWRD 2007). The lowest flow
rate recorded 1930–1952 was 5.1 cms, an order of magnitude greater than in nearby streams not fed by springs.
Mean monthly high flow for this gauging station was
25.3 cms. Real-time streamflow data from gauging station
USGS 14330000, 20 km downstream on the main stem of
the Rogue River, showed annual water at 2–14 C with
diurnal fluctuations of 1.5 C in winter and 3 C in summer
(OWRD 2007). Stream water samples, collected 21 Aug
2007, were analyzed for nitrate, total phosphorus and total
organic carbon at Neilson Research Corp., Medford,
Oregon (www.nrclabs.com).
Collection.—Basidiocarps were photographed in the river,
collected and measured in 2005, 2007 and 2008. Some were
photographed in situ; others were collected and transported to the lab without exposure to air. Observations and
measurements were made on fresh specimens. Pilei were
placed over paper to capture spore prints. Specimens were
observed with a Leica MZ75 dissecting microscope and
Leica DMLB compound microscope. Images were captured
with SPOT-RT digital cameras and software. Gill tissue was
stained with Melzer’s reagent and treated with 5% KOH and
H2SO4. Specimens were compared to descriptions in Smith
(1972), Kits van Waveren (1985), Hansen and Knudsen
(1992), Breitenbach and Kränzlin (1995), Gibson (2007)
and Larsson and Örstadius (2008). Terminology of fruitbody characters follows Largent et al (1977). Nonstandardized color names in lowercase are followed by parenthesized
Munsell (1976) alphanumeric color references. Herbaria
abbreviations follow Holmgren and Holmgren (1998).
We used the following general procedure to classify the
underwater mushrooms within genus Psathyrella, which
currently includes 414 species known from North America
(Smith 1972). We described our collections on the basis of
macromorphology, micromorphology, habit, habitat and
DNA sequences. We used the keys of Smith (1972) and
Breitenbach and Kränzlin (1995) and molecular phylogeny
of Padamsee et al (2008) to identify a group of species most
similar to our specimens that we then used for more
detailed morphological comparisons. We also selected
additional species for DNA sequence comparisons on the
basis of morphological characteristics. This iterative approach was employed due to the publication of two large
datasets of Psathyrella DNA during the preparation of this
manuscript (Padamsee et al 2008, Vašutová et al 2008).
Here we use the provisional name, Psathyrella aquatica, to
refer to our collections of underwater mushrooms.
Herbarium specimens were obtained from the University
of Michigan Fungus Collection (MICH) http://www.herb.
lsa.umich.edu/Bioinformatics.htm, from the Oregon State
University Mycological Collection (OSC) http://ocid.nacse.
org/research/herbarium/myco/databases.html, and from
M. Padamsee, University of Minnesota (MIN) (TABLE I). In
addition to P. aquatica a total of 89 collections in 33 species
were examined.
Molecular methods.—DNA was extracted from 12 fresh
pileus or stipe tissues of Psathyrella aquatica and from
herbarium specimens of 28 other Psathyrella species that
were related morphologically (subgenus Psathyrella section
Psathyrella) or by DNA sequences, as compared to the
phylogenetic tree in Padamsee et al (2008) or that were
distributed in Oregon and Washington (TABLE I). Tissue
samples were stored in buffer (0.1 M Tris, 0.3 M NaCl,
0.04 M EDTA) at 4 C, extracted in 2% cetyltrimethyl
ammonium bromide (CTAB) with chloroform. In addition
lyophilized CTAB phenol-chloroform extracts of three
species, P. aff. brooksii (initially identified as P. brooksii),
P. atomata and P. ramicola, were provided by M. Padamsee.
Because the ITS region of the specimen originally identified
as P. brooksii by Padamsee et al (2008) was found to differ by
more than 5% from the P. brooksii holotype we use the
nomenclature P. aff. brooksii to refer to specimen Padamsee
098 (MIN) at the recommendation of M. Padamsee (pers
comm).
DNA was amplified in polymerase chain reactions (PCR)
with fungal primer ITS1F (59-ggtcatttagaggaagtaa-39) and
universal eukaryote primer TW14 (59-gctatcctgagggaaacttc39) (White et al 1990; Gardes and Bruns 1993, 1996). PCR
reactions (20 mL) were performed with 0.6 units GoTaq and
4 mL 53 colorless buffer (Promega), 200 mM each dNTP,
0.3 mM each primer, 2.5 mM MgCl2, and 2 mL undiluted
DNA template. An initial 3 min at 93 C was followed by 30
cycles of 30 s at 95 C, 2 min at 54 C, and 3.5 min at 72 C,
with a final cycle 10 min at 72 C. When necessary shorter
fragments from older herbarium specimens were amplified
with fungal primer pairs ITS1F and ITS4 (59-tcctccgcttattga
tatgc-39) for the ITS and ITS4r (59-gcaatatcaataagcggagga39) and TW14 for the 28S region; 20 mL PCR reactions were
amplified as above with the annealing temperature reduced
to 51 C and the extension time reduced to 2 min. The
primer ITS4r was designed as the reverse complement of
ITS4. PCR products were electrophoresced on 1.5% agarose
gels, stained with ethidium bromide (1 mg/mL) and viewed
under a Kodak EDAS 290 UV transilluminator.
PCR products were purified with QIAquick PCR Purification kits (QIAGEN, Valencia, California), prepared with
BigDye Terminator Ready Reaction Mix 3.1 and sequenced
in an ABI 310 Genetic Analyzer (Applied Biosystems, Foster
City, California) in the Biotechnology Center at Southern
Oregon University. Molecular data were obtained by
sequencing the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region,
including ITS1, the 5.8S ribosomal DNA gene and ITS2,
and part of the 28S ribosomal gene, with forward primers
ITS1F, ITS1 (59-tccgtaggtgaacctgcgg-39), ITS3 (59-gcatcgat
gaagaacgcagc-39) and ITS4r, and reverse primers ITS4,
TW13 (59-ggtccgtgtttcaagacg-39) and TW14.
Sequences were edited with Chromas 1.45 (McCarthy
1998); contigs were assembled in Sequencher 4.7 (Gene
Codes Corp. Ann Arbor, Michigan) and compared to other
fungal ITS and 28S sequences in GenBank with BLAST
(Altschul et al 1990). Clustal X was used to generate
FRANK ET AL: AQUATIC PSATHYRELLA
95
TABLE I. Collections of Psathyrella species examined, with collector, number, herbarium, collection date, state in which
collected (USA), habitat and GenBank numbers for ITS and 28S regions
Psathyrella
species
Collector No./
herbarium
P. aquatica
4 Jul 2005
OR
4 Jul 2005
OR
4 Jul 2005
OR
4 Jul 2005
OR
4 Jul 2005
OR
4 Jul 2005
OR
4 Jul 2005
OR
4 Jul 2005
OR
P. aquatica
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1086)/SOC
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1087/SFSU
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1088)/OSC
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1089)/OSC
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1090)/MICH
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1091)/MICH
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1092)/MICH
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1093)/MICH
J.L. Frank 1334/MICH
14 Aug 2007
OR
P. aquatica
J.L. Frank 1335/MICH
14 Aug 2007
OR
P. aquatica
14 Aug 2007
OR
14 Aug 2007
OR
P. aquatica
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1096)/MICH
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1097)/MICHa
J.L. Frank 1336/MICH
21 Aug 2007
OR
P. aquatica
J.L. Frank 1337/SFSU
21 Aug 2007
OR
P. aquatica
21 Aug 2007
OR
P. aquatica
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth
1100)/MICH
D. Southworth 1101, /MICH
21 Aug 2007
OR
P. aquatica
J.L. Frank 1347/OSC
21 Sep 2007
OR
P. aquatica
J.L. Frank 1348/OSC
21 Sep 2007
OR
P. aquatica
D. Southworth 1261/MICH
4 Sep 2008
OR
P. alluviana
A.H. Sm.
P. alluviana
A.H. Sm.
P. alluviana
A.H. Sm.
P. alluviana
A.H. Sm.
P. alnicola
A.H. Sm.
P. alnicola
A.H. Sm.
P. alnicola
A.H. Sm.
P. alnicola
A.H. Sm.
A.H. Smith 19272/MICHa
30 Sep 1944
OR
A.H. Smith 28232/MICH
25 Oct 1947
OR
Meadow
A.H. Smith 23782/MICH
27 Sep 1946
OR
A.H. Smith 30217/MICH
17 Aug 1948
WA
A.H. Smith 70222/MICHa
6 Sep 1964
ID
On debris, vine
maple forest
On debris of Betula
papyrifera
Under Alnus
A.H. Smith 70223/MICH
6 Sep 1964
ID
Under Alnus
E. Trueblood 162/MICH
7 May 1957
ID
E. Trueblood 2280/MICH
19 Sep 1963
ID
P. aquatica
P. aquatica
P. aquatica
P. aquatica
P. aquatica
P. aquatica
P. aquatica
P. aquatica
Date
State
GenBank
ITS
Habitat
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
Underwater in
Rogue River
GenBank
28S
the
the
EU664989
the
the
EU664990
the
EU664991
EU664994
the
EU259194
EU259195
the
EU259196
the
the
the
the
the
EU259192
EU259193
FJ899609
FJ899627
the
the
the
the
the
the
the
Coniferous forest
near rotting
Populus
96
TABLE I.
MYCOLOGIA
Continued
Psathyrella
species
Collector No./
herbarium
Date
P. alnicola
A.H. Sm.
P. alnicola
A.H. Sm.
P. alnicola
A.H. Sm.
E. Trueblood 2680/MICH
16 Jun 1967
ID
Juniperus
E. Trueblood 1439/MICH
5 Jun 1961
ID
Coniferous forest
E. Trueblood 1458/MICH
5 Jun 1961
ID
Debris along creek,
Salix and Alnus
leaves
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
J.S. Hopple 139/DUKE
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. atomata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. brachycystis
A.H.Sm.
P. aff. brooksii
State
Habitat
NC
GenBank
ITS
GenBank
28S
FJ899610
N.S. Weber 2949/MICH
12 Jun 1972
ID
N.S. Weber 2948/MICH
12 Jun 1972
ID
A.H. Smith 8565/MICH
22 Jun 1938
MI
On damp soil under
Salix along creek
On dirt under Salix
and low herbs
along small stream
On wet soil
A.H. Smith 78106/MICH
15 Sep 1969
MI
On soil under weeds
A.H. Smith 43070/MICH
23 Sep 1953
MI
Grass
A.H. Smith 74433/MICH
4 Jul 1967
MI
On wet soil
A.H. Smith 74436/MICH
4 Jul 1967
MI
On wet soil
C.H. Kauffman/MICH 47963
22 Jul 1912
MI
Lawn
K. McKnight F1009/MICH
30 Jul 1955
UT
Soil in Populus-Abies
forest
K. McKnight F1565/MICH
21 Aug 1956
UT
T. E. Brooks 1605/MICHa
1 Sep 1946
KS
Terricolous
M. Padamsee 098/MIN
3 Jan 2003
WA
EU664992
P. brooksii
A.H. Sm.
P. calvinii
A.H. Sm.
P. calvinii
A.H. Sm.
P. calvinii
A.H. Sm.
T. E. Brooks 1594/MICHa
2 Sep 1946
KS
On wood chips
under Cornus
Terricolous next to
pile of corn cobs
C.H. Kaufman/MICH 11891a
9 Sep 1923
WY
A.H. Smith 34788/MICH
13 Jul 1950
WY
On soil by road
FJ899611
R. Leach 6/MICH
Jan 1944
CA
On sandy soil
covered by grass
along creek
P. candolleana
(Fr.) Maire.
P. carbonicola
A.H.Sm.
P. caudata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. caudata
(Fr.) Quel.
P. caudata
(Fr.) Quel.
J.M. Trappe 19657/OSC
17 Apr 1997
OR
S. Carpenter CH-186/OSC
22 Sep 1980
WA
Smith A.H. 35985/MICH
19 Sep 1950
MI
C.H. Kauffman/MICH 32909
28 Sep 1922
OR
S. Lundell 1770/MICH
29 Sep 1940
Sweden
EU664993
FJ899612
Blow-down area near
dead forest
On dung and debris
near barn
On grassy slope close
to farmyard
EU664995
FRANK ET AL: AQUATIC PSATHYRELLA
TABLE I.
97
Continued
Psathyrella
species
Collector No./
herbarium
Date
State
Habitat
P. coloradensis
A.H. Sm.
P. conopilea
(Fr.) Pearson
& Dennis
P. filamentosa
A.H. Sm.
P. fontinalis
A.H. Sm.
A.H. Smith 51659/MICHa
3 Aug 1956
CO
T. O’Dell 174/OSC
1 May 1990
OR
A.H. Smith 78074/MICHa
13 Sep 1969
MI
On mud flats
A.H. Smith 25644/MICHa
12 Jul 1947
MI
P. fontinalis
A.H. Sm.
P. fontinalis
A.H. Sm.
P. fontinalis
A.H. Sm.
P. gracilis (Fr.)
Quel.
P. cf. gracilis
A.H. Smith 25652/MICH
12 Jul 1947
MI
On black muck in
low area among
elm and ash
Muck
A.H. Smith 28751/MICH
15 Jun 1948
MI
Muck
A.H. Smith 28753/MICH
15 Jun 1948
MI
Muck
S. Pittam 170/OSC
5 Jun 2000
OR
J.L. Frank 1307/SOC
27 Apr 2007
OR
S.M. Zeller/OSC 5951
16 Nov 1921
OR
J.M. Trappe 22479/OSC
3 Dec 1997
OR
A.H. Smith 3563/MICH
12 Aug 1950
WY
W. Gruber 5/MICH
Jan 1944
CA
J.M. Trappe 19674/OSC
4 Dec 1997
OR
A.H. Smith 30388/MICHa
21 Aug 1948
WA
A.H Smith. 29526/MICH
28 Jul 1948
WA
A.H. Smith 29602/MICH
29 Jul 1948
WA
A.H. Smith 29642/MICH
30 Jul 1948
WA
A.H. Smith 30175/MICH
16 Aug 1948
WA
On humus
A.H. Smith 30239/MICH
18 Aug 1948
WA
On debris
A.H. Smith 30241/MICH
18 Aug 1948
WA
On Alnus debris
A.H. Smith 4990/MICHa
2 Jul 1936
MI
A.H. Smith 25280/MICH
23 Jul 1947
MI
A.H. Smith 28182/MICHa
24 Oct 1947
OR
A.H. Smith 18305/MICHa
02 Jun 1942
MI
P. hydrophila
(Fr.) Maire
P. hydrophila
(Fr.) Maire
P. intermedia
(Pk.) A.H.
Sm.
P. intermedia
(Pk.) A.H.
Sm.
P. marcescibilis
(Britz.)
Singer
P. nitens
A.H. Sm.
P. nitens
A.H. Sm.
P. nitens
A.H. Sm.
P. nitens
A.H. Sm.
P. nitens
A.H. Sm.
P. nitens
A.H. Sm.
P. nitens
A.H. Sm.
P. opacipes
A.H. Sm.
P. opacipes
A.H. Sm.
P. oregonensis
A.H. Sm.
P. parvicystis
A.H. Sm.
GenBank
ITS
On debris
GenBank
28S
FJ899628
FJ899613
FJ899614
Terrestrial in oak
woodland
Rotting wood
FJ235146
Under Pseudotsuga
menziesii
On moss in spring
FJ899615
Growing from
rotting wood
FJ899616
FJ899629
FJ899630
FJ899617
On debris
FJ968757
FJ899631
On debris
FJ968757
FJ899632
On rotten conifer
wood
On muck under
aspen
98
TABLE I.
MYCOLOGIA
Continued
Psathyrella
species
P. parvicystis
A.H. Sm.
P. parvicystis
A.H. Sm.
P. parvicystis
A.H. Sm.
P. praeatomata
A.H. Sm.
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. prona (Fr.)
Gillet
P. quercicola
A.H. Sm.
P. quercicola
A.H. Sm.
P. quercicola
A.H. Sm.
P. rainierensis
A.H. Sm.
P. ramicola
A.H. Sm.
P. rogueiana
A.H. Sm.
P. subincarnata
A.H. Sm.
P. subolivacea
A.H. Sm.
P. subolivacea
A.H. Sm.
P. subolivacea
A.H. Sm.
P. superiorensis
A.H. Sm.
P. superiorensis
A.H. Sm.
Collector No./
herbarium
Date
State
Habitat
GenBank
ITS
A.H. Smith 26004/MICH
27 Jul 1947
MI
On mud in roadway
V. Potter 4834/MICH
16 Jun 1948
MI
E.B. Mains 6134/MICH
21 Aug 1941
MT
On & along side of
hardwood limb
On wet soil
A.H. Smith 9-28-69/MICHa
28 Sep 1969
MI
On mud
J.M. Trappe 19678/OSC
17 Apr 1997
OR
L.R. Hesler 19032/MICH
9 Jul 1949
NC
H.C. Beardslee Jr. 683/MICH
19 Jun 1901
OH
A.H. Smith 13859/MICH
29 May 1939
WA
A.H. Smith 14080/MICH
5 Jun 1939
MI
A.H. Smith 14193/MICH
9 Jun 1939
MI
A.H. Smith 14782/MICH
5 Jul 1939
MI
J.B. Flett/MICH 33314
8 Apr 1941
MI
W.B. Cooke 19881/MICH
9 Jun 1947
MI
W.B. Cooke 19882/MICH
9 Jun 1947
MI
A.H. Smith 35271/MICH
29 Jul 1950
WY
A.H. Smith 55689/MICHa
15 Nov 1956
OR
On Quercus stump
A.H. Smith 55690/MICH
15 Nov 1956
OR
On Quercus log
A.H. Smith 55377/MICH
10 Nov 1956
OR
On mossy Quercus
log
A.H. Smith 30929/MICHa
5 Sep 1948
WA
FJ899619
P.B. Matheny 871/WTU
1 Oct 1946
WA
FJ899620
A.H. Smith 55708/MICHa
16 Nov 1956
OR
A.H. Smith 63594/MICHa
21 Jul 1961
MI
A.J. Smith 11042/MICHa
23 Sep 1938
MI
A.J. Smith 4991/MICH
2 Oct 1936
MI
C. Nimke 150/MICH
11 Oct 1971
MI
J.F. Ammirati 2251/MICHa
14 Aug 1968
MI
A.H. Smith 32107/MICH
24 May 1949
MI
GenBank
28S
FJ899618
Horse dung and rich
soil
On manure pile and
soil in farm yard
On straw and dung
pile
On dung and soil in
farmyard
On dung and straw
pile
On grassy area by
road
On manure in apple
orchard
On manure in apple
orchard
On clay soil along
logging road
On mud under Pinus
FJ899621
FJ899633
FJ899623
FJ899634
Scattered, on
Quercus leaves
On chip dirt
Scattered in drying
drainage pond
On humus and
sawdust
FJ899622
FRANK ET AL: AQUATIC PSATHYRELLA
TABLE I.
Continued
Psathyrella
species
P. tenera Peck
P. tenera Peck
P. uskensis
A.H.Sm.
P. velutina (Fr.)
Singer
a
99
Collector No./
herbarium
Date
State
Habitat
GenBank
ITS
GenBank
28S
A.H. Smith 65853/MICH
A.H. Smith 29601/MICH
A.H. Smith 73377/MICH
19 Aug 1962
29 Jul 1948
14 Sep 1966
ID
WA
WA
On mud
On wet earth
On mud
FJ899624
FJ899635
FJ899625
FJ899636
S. Carpenter CH-186/OSC
22 Sep 1982
WA
Mount St Helens
FJ899626
FJ899637
Holotype.
alignments of the 28S region. Alignments were edited
manually with BioEdit (Thompson et al 1997, Hall 1999).
Sequences generated in this study have been deposited in
GenBank (TABLE I). A total of 27 sequences were aligned,
12 that we generated and 15 from GenBank. All were in
Psathyrella sensu stricto Clade A v, except Psathyrella
melleipallida and P. tephrophylla from Clade A iv, which
were used as outgroup (Padamsee et al 2008). All but one
were from North America; the European taxon (an
unidentified species) closest to P. aquatica was included
(Vašutová et al 2008).
Phylogenetic trees built with parsimony and maximum
likelihood with 1000 bootstrap replicates and 1000 jackknife
replicates were generated from 28S sequences using PAUP
4.10b10 (Swofford 2002). Consensus trees with 50%
majority rule were generated with a tree-bisection-reconnection branch swapping algorithm. All characters were
given equal weight; gaps were treated as missing. Concensus
trees were examined to confirm branch positions.
TAXONOMY
Psathyrella aquatica J.L. Frank, Coffan, & Southworth, sp. nov.
FIGS. 1–10
Mycobank: MB511824
Basidiomata 4.5–10 cm alta, immersa. Pileus 0.8–1.5 cm
latus, brunneolus vel brunneigriseus. Basidioporae ellipsoideae, leves, brunneae, 10–14 3 6–8 mm, poro germinali.
Cystidia hymeniales: cheilocystidia pleurocystidiaque similaria, ventricosa, 25–45 3 10–18 mm. Lamellae adnatae.
Stipes textura porrecta.
Macromorphology. Basidiomata (FIGS. 1–4, 6) immersed, 4.5–10 cm tall; pileus 0.8–1.5 cm diam, broadly parabolic to campanulate, light brown to brownish
gray (10YR 7/2–6/1), sometimes with central orangebrown (10YR 5/4) disk, sometimes mottled or striate,
smooth, hygrophanous; pileus context thin above gills,
light tan to orange-brown; odor not distinctive; lamellae
adnate, thin, light tan, densely speckled with dark
brown spores, extending to pileus margin, lamellulae
in two ranks and extending from one-half to onefourth of the radius; stipe 4.0–9.5 cm long, diameter
expanding from 1.0–2.2 mm at apex to 1.8–3.2 mm at
base, white to pale yellow, hollow, lacking annulus,
fibrous, surface fibrillose covered with wefty white to
gray-white mycelium, and with cottony rhizomorphs
and mycelial tomentum emanating from base.
Micromorphogy. Basidiospores (FIG. 7) 10–14 3 6–
8 mm, ave. 12.3 3 6.9 mm, elliptical with a germ pore,
smooth, dark reddish brown in water and in Melzer’s,
fading to gray-brown in KOH and to lilac in H2SO4,
spore print purple-black; basidia (FIG. 8) 4-spored,
clavate, 32–40 3 10–13 mm, hyaline; cheilocystidia
(FIG. 10) 25–45 3 10–18 mm ventricose, apex subacute
to elongate, thin walled, colorless, hyaline; pleurocystidia (FIG. 8, 9) 25–40 3 10–13 mm, ventricose, apex
subacute, scattered, thin-walled, colorless, hyaline;
caulocystidia 32–40 3 10–13 mm, cylindrical to ventricose, in fascicles, apex obtuse; pileipellis cellular,
suprapellis a single layer of spherical to isodiametric,
inflated cells, 25–35 mm diam, on 30–50 3 3–5 mm
peduncles that extend into the pileus trama, clamp
connections absent; pileus trama thin-walled hyphae 8–
15 mm diam, interwoven; stipe hyphae 35–70 3 8–
14 mm, parallel; clamp connections present in mycelium
at stipe base, absent elsewhere.
Habit. Basidiomes were observed in below rapids
and areas of turbulence. Specimens were anchored at
depths up to 0.5 m, most over an area of approximately 200 m2, with two specimens collected 1 km
upstream. The pileus of one specimen was above
water; all others were submerged. One specimen was
growing in an eddy behind woody debris in the main
river channel; all others were in moving water. No
basidiomata were observed in slack water. The lateral
distance from submerged basidiomata to the nearest
stream bank or gravel bar was 20–340 cm. In Aug and
Sep 2007 epigeous fungi, including Collybia sp.,
Russula spp., Alnicola sp. and Lycoperdon sp., were
observed in adjacent terrestrial areas.
Specimens were attached to a substrate of sticks
(FIG. 5) or gravel or embedded in silt (FIG. 1).
Basidiomata often grew out of, or close to, aquatic
mosses (Scleropodium obtusifolium [Jaeg.] Kindb. in
Mac. & Kindb.) and cyanobacteria (Anabaena)
(FIG. 3). The stipe bases of several specimens origi-
100
MYCOLOGIA
FIGS. 1–6. Psathyrella aquatica. 1. Underwater mushroom fruiting in silt near waterlogged wood. 2. Underwater mushroom
with dark spores on gills and gas bubbles on cap and stipe. 3. Mushroom growing with aquatic moss (Scleropodium
obtusifolium) emerging from water. 4. Mushroom with undulating gas bubble under pileus. 5. Stipe initiating growth on
underside of submerged twig. Arrows point to base of developed stipe and to two primordia. 6. Cap lifted above water showing
rafts of spores from burst gas pocket; gills are white after spore discharge.
nated from the underside of a piece of gravel or stick
(FIG. 5, arrow) before curling around to elongate
upward. Gas bubbles were observed on stipes and
pilei (FIG. 2), and gas pockets were trapped beneath
the pilei (FIG. 4). Some underwater mushrooms with
white gills apparently already had shed spores
(FIG. 6), but most retained spores on the gills
(FIG. 2). Basidiospores collected at the water-gas
interface beneath the pileus in some specimens.
When specimens were lifted gently from the water
FRANK ET AL: AQUATIC PSATHYRELLA
101
FIGS. 7–10. Psathyrella aquatica. 7. Basidiospores. 8. Basidium with spores attached, also pleurocystidia. 9. Pleurocystidium.
10. Cheilocystidia. Bars 5 10 mm.
the gas pocket remained intact for a few seconds and
undulated from the movement (FIG. 4). Then the gas
pocket burst open, releasing wedge-shape rafts of
spores that adhered to each other, the stipe and our
fingers (FIG. 6).
Habitat. Aquatic vegetation near the attachment of
the underwater mushrooms included dense beds of
Scleropodium obtusifolium and abundant gelatinous
masses of cyanobacteria, Anabaena sp., with heterocysts. Terrestrial vegetation on surrounding stream
banks was dominated by Pseudotsuga menziesii with
Pinus monticola in the canopy and understory trees,
Alnus rubra, Acer circinatum and Cornus nuttallii.
Upland vegetation and riparian vegetation reached
the water’s edge at all times of the year, including the
late summer during the period of lowest flow.
Organic carbon in the water sample totaled
0.52 mg/L, nitrate measured less than the testing
equipment limit of 0.2 mg/L and total phosphorus
less than 0.05 mg/L. Water temperature during field
observations was 7–13.1 C; ambient air was 23–32.8 C.
Known distribution. Oregon.
Etymology. In reference to the aquatic habitat.
HOLOTYPE: USA. OREGON: Jackson County.
North of Prospect (42u519420N, 122u309280W), underwater in the Rogue River on wood, 8 Aug 2007,
R.A. Coffan (D. Southworth 1097 MICH).
Other specimens examined. See TABLE I.
102
MYCOLOGIA
TABLE II. Maximum identity match to the ITS region of Psathyrella aquatica and classification, according to Smith (1972), of
Psathyrella collections examined
Psathyrella species
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
P.
fontinalis FJ899614
aff. brooksii EU664994
superiorensis FJ899623
atomata FJ899610
superiorensis FJ899622
prona FJ899618
brooksii EU664993
subincarnata FJ899621
alluviana FJ899609
ramicola FJ899620
hydrophila FJ899615
marcescibilis FJ899617
rainierensis FJ899619
uskensis FJ899625
nitens FJ968757
intermedia FJ899616
calvinii FJ899611
tenera FJ899624
cf. gracilis FJ235146
candolleana FJ899612
conopilea FJ899613
velutina FJ899626
Subgenus/section/subsection/series
Length
(b.p.)
Query
coverage (%)
Max
ident (%)
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Psathyrellae
Pannucia/Pannucia/Mixtae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Psathyrellae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Psathyrellae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Psathyrellae
Atomatae/
Pannucia/Pannucia/Mixtae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Tenerae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Tenerae
Psathyrella/Umbonatae
Pannucia/Appendiculatae/Hydrophilae
Candolleana/
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Mesosporae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Tenerae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Mesosporae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Tenerae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Tenerae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Tenerae
Psathyrella/Psathyrella/Psathyrellae/Psathyrellae
Candolleana/
Psathyrella/Subatratae
Lacrymaria/
556
564
402
666
531
455
453
628
507
593
268
445
213
514
540
330
437
491
528
551
414
467
94
90
98
76
94
100
99
81
89
83
100
99
98
98
91
100
100
99
93
84
78
94
99
99
98
98
96
95
95
95
94
94
93
93
93
93
93
92
92
92
92
91
87
85
Molecular analyses.— DNA sequences from eight
specimens of P. aquatica confirmed that only one
species was present; six ITS sequences and three 28S
sequences of P. aquatica specimens were identical.
Sequences of the ITS1 and ITS2 regions, the 5.8S
ribosomal gene and the 28S ribosomal gene from six
specimens of P. aquatica have been deposited in
GenBank (TABLE I).
ITS sequences were obtained from 18 other species
of Psathyrella from 19 herbarium collections (two
collections of P. superiorensis yielded distinct ITS
sequences) and from three lyophilized extracts
(T ABLE II). Sequences of the 28S region were
generated from 12 species.
Of 528 total characters in the phylogenetic alignment of 28S sequences, 490 were constant, 24 were
considered parsimony informative and 14 variable
characters were considered parsimony uninformative.
Both the parsimony and the maximum likelihood
consensus trees generated from our 28S alignment
placed P. aquatica near P. superiorensis (Ammirati
2251, holotype), P. aff. brooksii (Padamsee 098, but
not Brooks 1594, holotype) and P. fontinalis with P.
superiorensis and P. aff. brooksii (Padamsee 098)
closer than P. fontinalis (FIG. 11, TABLE II). Pairwise
analysis of ITS sequences show P. aquatica to be
closer to P. fontinalis and P. aff. brooksii than to P.
superiorensis (holotype) (TABLE II). That two collec-
tions identified by A.H. Smith as P. superiorensis both
from Michigan differed by more than 2% in the ITS
sequence highlights the problems of species identification in Psathyrella. Molecular data show that P.
aquatica is close to several species in series Psathyrellae
and aligns into Clade A v Psathyrella sensu stricto
(Padamsee et al 2008).
Commentary.—Psathyrella aquatica belongs to subgenus Psathyrella based on these characteristics: smooth
unornamented spores; absence of fasciculate hymenial cystidia; not parasitic on Coprinus; glabrous
pileus; absence of granulose veil; pleurocystidia with
wall in neck up to 0.5 mm, apex smooth or with only
finely granular incrustations; cheilocystidia not lecythiform; and veil thin to rudimentary or absent, not
well developed (Smith 1972). Among the 177 species
in subgenus Psathyrella, P. aquatica belongs to section
Psathyrella based on these characters: not coprophilous, subacute to obtuse pleurocystidia and with
spores at least 9–12.5 mm long. Distinguishing between subsections Mesosporae and Psathyrellae depends on basidiospore dimensions in which there is a
slight overlap, with spore length in subsection
Mesosporae 9–12.5 mm and in Psathyrellae 11–17 mm.
A mean basidiospore length of 12.3 mm and extreme
lengths of 10–14 mm place P. aquatica among the 27
species in subsection Psathyrellae. Within subsection
FRANK ET AL: AQUATIC PSATHYRELLA
FIG. 11. Phylogenetic tree using parsimony for 28S data
(with GenBank numbers) showing the position of P.
aquatica in Psathyrella sensu stricto, with 1000 bootstrap
replicates; bootstrap numbers greater than 50% are
included above branches.
Psathyrellae two series, Psathyrellae and Tenerae, are
distinguished by the color of the pileus margin and
gill edges. Species in series Psathyrellae have pink gill
edges, lacking in series Tenerae. Pink tints were not
observed on any specimens of P. aquatica at any stage
from immature with veil still attached to post spore
discharge. Morphology places P. aquatica in series
Tenerae; DNA sequences place P. aquatica in series
Psathyrellae (TABLE II, FIG. 11).
Morphological comparison with closely related species.—
Morphological traits differentiate P. aquatica from
described species in series Psathyrellae (TABLE III).
Among species most closely related based on molecular phylogenetic analysis, P. fontinalis has a glabrescent stipe, longer spore maximum length (16 mm),
longer pleurocystidia, cylindric to clavate caulocystidia and lighter spore color in KOH. Psathyrella
superiorensis has longer pleurocystidia, smaller spores
103
and shorter stipe. Neither P. fontinalis nor P.
superiorensis have been reported outside Michigan.
Psathyrella aff. brooksii differs in having a thick white
fibrillose veil when young and shorter yellow-brown
stipe (M. Padamsee pers comm). Psathyrella atomata
lacks pleurocystidia; P. preatomata has hyaline cells
among the cheilocystidia; and P. gracilis and P.
opacipes have longer, more acute pleurocystidia.
Among species for which no DNA sequences were
obtained, P. filamentosa has clavate to vesiculose cells
along the gill margin with cheilocystidia.
Species in series Tenerae, which are less close to P.
aquatica based on ITS and 28S sequences, similarly
lack pink tints (Smith 1972). In addition there are
other morphological differences. Psathyrella calvinii
has incrustations on stipe hyphae, P. subincarnata has
vinaceous lamellae when young, P. tenera has brachybasidioles and P. alluviana has a rugulose pileus.
Pleurocystidia in P. intermedia are small and infrequent. Both P. uskensis and P. coloradensis are notably
small and fragile, even for this genus.
In subsection Mesosporae, P. nitens and P. rainierensis not only differ by DNA but also have smaller
spores; P. subhepatica has longer pleurocystidia (44–
70 mm). In subgenus Atomatae pleurocystidia are rare
in P. prona. In subgenus Pannucia P. hydrophila has
much smaller spores. Spores of P. brooksii are slightly
larger (12–15 3 7–9 mm) than those of P. aquatica
(10–14 3 6–8 mm); cystidia are subclavate to broadly
ventricose, and the veil of P. brooksii is more or less
well developed and remains attached to the cap.
Pleurocystidia in P. ramicola, subgenus Umbonatae,
are utriform.
Psathyrella aquatica is distinct from the two
Psathyrella species that occur in terrestrial sites along
the Rogue River in southern Oregon (TABLE III).
Psathyrella quercicola in section Fatuae, collected
34 km downriver, has smaller basidiospores; P.
rogueiana in subgenus Candolleana, collected 84 km
downriver, has smaller basidiospores, rare pleurocystidia and clavate to utriform cheilocystidia.
DISCUSSION
In a genus as large as Psathyrella, determining a new
species is complex because species are similar in both
morphology and DNA sequences. Macromorphological characters can be insufficient to identify specimens to species, and micromorphological characters,
especially cystidial shape and the color of gill edges,
are variable. Kits van Waveren (1985) considered the
character of red underlining of gill edges to be
unreliable, although Smith (1972) and Breitenbach
and Kränzlin (1995) used red underlining as a key
character. Vašutová et al (2008) considered cystidial
Spore size
Cystidia
Clamps
Stipe
Suprapellis
cuticle
aquatica
10–14 3 6–8 av.
12.3 3 6.9
2
fibrillose, wefty at base
1 layer, pedicellate
white
4.5–10/0.8–1.5
atomata
11–13(–15) 3
6–7
+
fragile, pulverulent to
glabrous
2–3 layers,
vesiculose
pink
3–5/1–2.5
filamentosa
11–14 3 5.5–7
+
naked, pruinose
near apex
1–2 layers, inflated
cells
white or
pink
2–5/0.5–1.2
fontinalis
11–14(–16) 3
6–7.5 (–8.5)
+
glabrescent
palisade, clavate
pedicellate
pink
gracilis
(10–)11–14
(–15) 3 6.5–8
+
fragile, fibrillose
above glabrous below
palisade, pyriform
and vesiculose to
elliptic
pink
opacipes
(12–)13–16.5 3
6–8
+
glabrescent pruinose
1 layer, vesiculose
or pedicellate
white or
vinaceous
3–7/1–3.5
praeatomata
11–14 (–15) 3
5.5–7
2
naked above, scattered
fibrils below
2–3 layers,
pedicellate and
vesiculose
pink
2–5/0.8–1.5
superiorensis
11–13 3 5.5–6.5
Pl: ventricose, subacute 25–40 3 10–13
Ch: ventricose, subacute 25–40 3 10–18
Ca: +
Pl: absent to rare
Ch: fusoid-ventricose 35–48 3 9–14, acute
to subacute, long neck
Ca: ?
Pl: fusoid ventricose, apex obtuse to
subacute with adhering granules, 43–58 3
10–17
Ch: fusoid ventricose with vesiculose cells
Ca: ?
Pl: Ventricose-elongate, short neck, obtuse
apex to fusoid-ventricose, subacute apex
38–65 3 10–16
Ch: similar or ventricose to clavate 15–26 3
8–12
Ca: +
Pl: subaciculate to fusoid-ventricose, acute
to subacute, neck flexuous 54–75 3 10–16
Ch: Shorter, more obtuse
Ca: +
Pl: fusoid-ventricose, acute to subacute 38–
70 3 9–16
Ch: saccate to clavate 18–26 3 10–15
Ca: +
Pl: Ventricose with neck, subacute, 36–48 3
10–15
Ch: Subfusoid to clavate to fusoid-ventricose
8–12 wide
Ca: ?
Pl: Fusoid-ventricose 50–85 3 10–15 long
neck, obtuse
Ch: smaller or clavate
Ca: ?
+
fibrillose, pallid
above, brown below
1–2 layers,
vesiculose
pink
2–4/0.6–1.4
Psathyrella
species
Height/cap
diam (cm)
(3–)5–10/1–3
6–12/1.5–3.5
MYCOLOGIA
Pl, pleurocystidia; Ch, cheilocystidia; Ca, caulocystidia; +, present; 2, absent; ?, not mentioned.
Gill edge
color
104
TABLE III. Diagnostic characters among described species of Psathyrella in series Psathyrellae including those with close DNA matches to P. aquatica. Data from species
other than P. aquatica from Smith (1972). Spore and cystidia dimensions in micrometers; clamp connections in pileus
FRANK ET AL: AQUATIC PSATHYRELLA
shapes as homoplasic and insufficient to determine
phylogeny. In a test of sorting within the P. gracilis
group Kemp (1985) sent six split collections of P.
gracilis to A.H. Smith and E. Kits van Waveren;
taxonomic agreement was reached on only one.
Padamsee et al (2008) found disagreement between
molecular and morphological information among
several pairs of Psathyrella species.
Studies show the value of molecular data in
determining phylogenetic relationships within genus
Psathyrella (Padamsee et al 2008, Vašutová et al 2008,
Larsson and Örstadius 2008). Our analysis of 28S DNA
sequences placed P. aquatica into Clade A v. Taken
together morphological and molecular evidence support the hypothesis that the underwater mushroom is a
new species of Psathyrella most closely related to P.
fontinalis, P. superiorensis, P. atomata and the P. gracilis
group. Psathyrella aquatica is characterized by a
relatively long fibrillose stipe that is not fragile,
relatively small cap, a thin veil disappearing at maturity,
nonpink gill edges and ventricose pleuro- and cheilocystidia with subacute apices.
The habitat of P. aquatica appears unique among
species of Psathyrella, none of which have been
reported in running water. Most species of Psathyrella
occur in terrestrial habitats, often on dung. However
some, including several in subgenus Psathyrella
section Psathyrellae, are associated with damp or wet
soil, wet or drying muck or the margins of wetlands
where the mycelium might grow underwater (Smith
1972). For example P. filamentosa and P. opacipes
were found in damp habitats or at the edges of
marshes (Smith 1972). Of the six species closest to P.
aquatica, three (P. atomata, P. fontinalis and P.
superiorensis) have been collected from damp habitats
(e.g. muck, drying drainage ponds and damp soil).
The other three (P. aff. brooksii, P. gracilis and P.
ramicola) occur in dry terrestrial habitats on soil or
wood. Although 28s and ITS sequences failed to
separate P. aquatica from P. aff. Brooksii, morphological differences do not justify considering P. aff
brooksii a conspecific specimen. Species in other
subgenera, for example P. typhae (subgenus Pannucia), also grow on wetland plant debris and silt and on
floating matter (Redhead 1979, 1981; Schulz et al
2005). Other Psathyrellaceae, such as Coprinopsis
kubickiae (reported as Coprinus amphibius) and
Coprinellus congregatus (reported as Coprinus alkalinus), have been isolated from submerged wood, but
fruiting bodies were not formed underwater (Anastasiou 1967, Redhead and Traquair 1981).
The spore discharge mechanism remains enigmatic
in Psathyrella aquatica. Spore prints were obtained,
suggesting that basidiospores are discharged as
ballistospores when conditions are appropriate. Fur-
105
thermore basidiospores show the asymmetrically
positioned hilar appendix, a feature compatible with
forcible discharge (McLaughlin et al 1985). The
wedge-shape rafts of spores released by the bursting
gas bubble resemble sections of a spore print
deposited on the gas-water interface beneath the
cap. The ballistospore discharge mechanism involving
a water droplet and a water film could not occur if
gills were totally in contact with water (Money 1998,
Pringle et al 2005). Gas pockets were trapped under
many P. aquatica pilei; a similar bubble was observed
under the hymenophore of Gloiocephala menierii
collected from Carex stems near the mud-air interface
(Redhead 1981, Desjardin et al 1995, Redhead pers
comm). Trapped gases might provide the atmosphere
needed for ballistosporic discharge in underwater
environments.
A fungus growing in a fast flowing stream would
encounter spore dispersal problems because the
current tends to wash spores downstream. Psathyrella
aquatica fruitbodies retain released basidiospores at
the air-water interface of the pileal gas pocket until
disturbed. Even then the spores do not disperse
individually but appear hydrophobic, attracted to
each other or to other hydrophobic surfaces. Desjardin (1995) recognized the problem of underwater
agaric spore dispersal and hypothesized that windinduced water currents or aquatic animals might
disperse spores to nearby vegetation within a lake.
Dispersal by currents in a turbulent stream however
are unidirectional downstream, transporting spores to
different and possibly unsuitable habitats. Adherence
of Psathyrella spores to stipe and gills might counteract currents that would wash the spores downstream.
In addition aquatic invertebrates might graze these
fungi, keeping spores in the same habitat and
dispersing them nearby, even upstream. Retention
of spores near fruitbodies would allow for reinoculation in suitable habitats.
The growth of this fungus on alluvial gravel as well
as on submerged wood suggests that it might obtain
carbon from the film of bacteria, algae and sediment
that collects on the surface of submerged substrates as
well as from decomposing wood. It might obtain
nitrogen from cyanobacteria colonies. The relatively
constant conditions of the aquatic environment
might help to explain the exceptionally long fruiting
period. Growth below 20 C classifies the species as
psychrophilic (Kendrick 2000).
Reproductive isolation could account for speciation
because underwater fruiting would limit opportunities for genetic exchange between aquatic and
terrestrial individuals. Combining evidence from
DNA sequences, morphology and habitat, we conclude that the underwater mushrooms are a new
106
MYCOLOGIA
species, P. aquatica, in Clade A v Psathyrella sensu
stricto (Padamsee et al 2008). The conditions of this
stream are distinctive, although not unique. This
particular river habitat combines the characteristics of
steady spring-fed flows, clear, cold, aerated water with
woody debris in shallow depths on fine volcanic
substrate. This underwater environment is a new
habitat for gilled mushrooms.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This study was supported by National Science Foundation
Grants DEB-0516229 through Research at Undergraduate
Institutions and DBI-0115892 to the Biotechnology Center
at Southern Oregon University. We thank Maj Padamsee for
three lyophilized DNA extracts, a specimen of P. aff.
brooksii, and prepublication access to sequence data; Steven
Jessup for identification of the aquatic moss; David Oline
for discussion of molecular data; Jim Trappe for help with
the Latin description; Patricia Rogers for loan of specimens
from the University of Michigan Herbarium Fungus
Collection; and Lorelei Norvell, David McLaughlin and
two anonymous reviewers for close readings.
LITERATURE CITED
Altschul SF, Gish W, Miller W, Myers EW, Lipman DJ. 1990.
Basic local alignment search tool. J Mol Biol 215:403–
410.
Anastasiou CJ. 1967. Two species of Coprinus from alkaline
lakes. Can J Bot 45:2213–2222.
Breitenbach J, Kränzlin F, eds. 1995. Fungi of Switzerland.
Vol. 4. Lucerne: Mykologia. 368 p.
Cascade Earth Sciences. 2006. Upper Rogue Watershed
Assessment. Upper Rogue Watershed Association, Shady
Cove, Oregon. Online at http://www.upper-rogue.
org. Accessed Oct 2007.
Desjardin DE, Martinez Peck L, Rajchenberg M. 1995. An
unusual psychrophilic aquatic agaric from Argentina.
Mycologia 87:547–550.
Ferrer A, Huzefa AR, Shearer CA. 2008. Lucidascocarpa
pulchella, a new ascomycete genus and species from
freshwater habitats in the American tropics. Mycologia
100:642–646.
Gardes M, Bruns TD. 1993. ITS primers with enhanced
specificity for basidiomycetes—application to the identification of mycorrhizas and rusts. Mol Ecol 2:113–118.
———, ———. 1996. ITS–RFLP matching for identification
of fungi. In: Clapp JP, ed. Methods in molecular
biology, species diagnostics protocols: PCR and other
nucleic acid Methods. Vol. 50. New Jersey: Humana
Press. p 177–186.
Gibson I. 2007. Psathyrella in the Pacific Northwest. Pacific
Northwest Key Council. Online at http://www.svims.
ca/council/Psathy.htm. Accessed Sep 2007.
Hall TA. 1999. BioEdit: a user-friendly biological sequence
alignment editor and analysis program for Windows
95/98/NT. Nucleic Acids Symp Ser 41:95–98.
Hansen L, Knudsen H, eds. 1992. Nordic macromycetes.
Vol 2. Copenhangen: Nordsvamp. 474 p.
Hibbett DS, Binder M. 2001. Evolution of marine mushrooms. Biol Bull 201:319–322.
Holmgren PK, Holmgren NH. 1998. Index herbariorum: a
global directory of public herbaria and associated staff.
New York Botanical Garden’s Virtual Herbarium.
Available at http://sweetgum.nybg.org/ih/
Kemp RF. 1985. Do fungal species really exist? A study of
Basidiomycete species with special reference to those in
Coprinus section Lanatuli. Bull Brit Mycol Soc (Apr
1985): 34–39.
Kendrick B. 2000. The fifth kingdom. Newburyport,
Massachusetts: Focus Publishing. 386 p.
Kits van Waveren E. 1985. The Dutch, French and British
species of Psathyrella. Persoonia 2:1–300.
Largent D, Johnson D, Watling R. 1977. How to identify
mushrooms to genus III: microscopic features. Eureka,
California: Mad River Press. 148 p.
Larsson E, Örstadius L. 2008. Fourteen coprophilous
species of Psathyrella identified in the Nordic countries
using morphology and nuclear rDNA sequence data.
Mycol Res 112:1165–1185.
Mains EB. 1956. North American species of Geoglossaceae.
Mycologia 48:694–710.
McCarthy C. 1998. Chromas 1.45. Southport, Queensland,
Australia: Griffith University.
McLaughlin DJ, Becket A, Yoon KS. 1985. Ultrastructure
and evolution of ballistosporic basidiospores. Bot J
Linnean Soc 91:253–271.
Minoura K, Muroi T. 1978. Some freshwater Ascomycetes
from Japan. Trans Mycol Soc Japan 19:129–134.
Money NP. 1998. More gs than the space shuttle: ballistospore discharge. Mycologia 90:547–558.
Munsell Color. 1976. Munsell book of color (matte finish
collection). Baltimore: Macbeth. 40 pl.
Oregon Water Resources Department. 2007. Surface water
data. Online at http://egov.oregon.gov/OWRD/SW/
index.shtml#Surface_Water_Data. Accessed Aug 2007.
Padamsee M, Matheny PB, Dentinger BTM, McLaughlin DJ.
2008. The mushroom family Psathyrellaceae: evidence
for large-scale polyphyly of the genus Psathyrella. Mol
Phylogenet Evol 46:415–429.
Pinruan U, Sakayaroy J, Gareth Jones EB, Hyde KD. 2004.
Aquatic fungi from peat swamp palms: Phruensis
brunneispora gen. et sp. nov. and its hyphomycete
anamorph. Mycologia 96:1163–1170.
Pringle A, Patek SN, Fischer M, Stolze J, Money NP. 2005.
The captured launch of a ballistospore. Mycologia 97:
866–871.
Redhead SA. 1979. Psathyrella typhae. Fungi Canadenses
133, http://www.cbs.knaw.nl/mycoheritage/
———. 1981. Agaricales on wetland Monocotyledoneae in
Canada. Can J Bot 59:574–589.
———, Traquair JA. 1981. Coprinus sect. Herbicolae from
Canada: notes on extralimital taxa and the taxonomic
position of a low temperature Basidiomycete forage
crop pathogen from western Canada. Mycotaxon 13:
373–404.
———, Vilgalys R, Moncalvo JM, Johnson J, Hopple JS Jr.
FRANK ET AL: AQUATIC PSATHYRELLA
2001. Coprinus Pers. and the disposition of Coprinus
species sensu lato. Taxon 50:203–241.
Schulz MJ, Cahill JF Jr, Currah RS. 2005. In vitro
measurements of the competitive interactions between
two saprobic basidiomycetes on Typha latifolia. Can J
Bot 83:1523–1527.
Shearer CA, Descals E, Kohlmeyer B, Kohlmeyer J,
Marvanová L, Padgett D, Porter D, Raja HA, Schmit
JP, Thorton HA, Voglymayr H. 2007. Fungal biodiversity in aquatic habitats. Biodivers Conserv 16:49–67.
———, Langsam DM, Longcore JE. 2004. Fungi in
freshwater habitats. In: Mueller GM, Bills GF, Foster
MS, eds. Biodiversity of fungi. London: Elsevier
Academic Press. p 513–531.
Smith AH. 1972. The North American species of Psathyrella.
Mem NY Bot Gard 24:1–633.
Swofford DL. 2001. PAUP*: phylogenetic analysis using
parsimony (*and other methods). 4.0. 10th ed. Sunderland, Massachusetts: Sinauer Associates.
107
Thompson JD, Gibson TJ, Plewniak F, Jeanmougin F,
Higgins DG. 1997. The Clustal X windows interface:
flexible strategies for multiple sequence alignment
aided by quality analysis tools. Nucleic Acids Res 24:
4876–4882.
Tylutki EE. 1979. Mushrooms of Idaho and the Pacific
Northwest. Vol. 1. Discomycetes. Moscow, Idaho: University of Idaho Press. 133 p.
Vašutová M, Antonı́n V, Urban A. 2008. Phylogenetic
studies in Psathyrella focusing on sections Pennatae
and Spadiceae—new evidence for the paraphyly of the
genus. Mycol Res 112:1153–1164. doi: 10.1016j.mycres.
2008.04.005.
White TJ, Bruns T, Lee S, Taylor J. 1990. Amplification and
direct sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes for
phylogenetics. In: Innis MA, Gelfand DH, Sninsky JJ,
White TJ, eds. PCR orotocols: a guide to methods
and applications. San Diego: Academic Press. p 315–
322.