NAAS Rating: 4.54
PRINT ISSN: 0974-1712
Peer Reviewed Journal
ONLINE ISSN: 2230-732X
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURE,
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
VOL. 15 (SPECIAL ISSUE), AUGUST 2022
Editor-In-Chief
Amitava Rakshit, Ph.D (IIT-Kharagpur)
Special Issue on
“Advances in Soil and Crop research for a Sustainable Food System”
Released on the Occasion of International Conference on Advances in Agriculture and
Food System towards Sustainable Development Goals (AAFS2022)
22-24th August, 2022
JOINTLY ORGANIZED BY
All India Agricultural Students
Association, New Delhi
University of Agricultural Sciences,
Bangalore
Indian Council of Agricultural
Research, New Delhi
Guest Editors
Dr. Ashish Khandelwal
Scientist (Ag Chemicals), Division of Environment
Science
ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute
New Delhi-110012
Director of Education
University of Agricultural Sciences
Bangalore-560065
Dr. K.C. Narayanaswamy
Dr. Basave Gowda
Dr. Renu Singh
Dr. Tapas Paul
Mr. Vivek Saurabh
Principal Scientist
Division of Environment Science,
ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute
New Delhi 110012
Assistant Professor
Bihar Animal Sciences University
Patna 800014
Registrar
University of Agricultural Sciences
Bangalore-560065
Ph.D. Scholar,
Division of Food Science and Postharvest Technology
ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute
New Delhi 110012
Venue: University of Agricultural Sciences, Bangalore, India
Published by
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
https://aaeb.in/
About the Journal
International Journal of Agriculture Environment and Biotechnology (IJAEB) is the scientific journal of the AAEB, New Delhi, published quarterly
in English (March, June, September, and December) and is edited by an international group of eminent researchers. It is indexed in CAB, CABI, ICI,
NAAS and others.
IJAEB is an open access, peer-review scholarly publication since 2008 that allows readers to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, and link
to the full texts of its articles, or use them for any other lawful purpose, according to HYPERLINK "https://doaj.org/"DOAJ. The journal is available
at HYPERLINK "http://www.ijaeb.com" www.ijaeb.com. It is available in electronic journal (Online ISSN: 2230-732X) and printed (Print ISSN:
0974-1712 ).
IJAEB publishes original Research Articles, Scientific Notes and critical reviews of from every field of Agricultural sciences, plant science, animal
science and environmental sciences. Scope of the journal includes, Agronomy, Agricultural Engineering, Plant physiology, Plant protection, Animal
science, Agricultural extension, Agricultural economics, Food science and technology, Soil and water sciences, Irrigation science and technology
and Environmental science. Submission is welcomed from all agro ecologies over the world The editorial process is a double-blind peer reviewing.
Editorial Office checks format, composition, and completeness, which is a requirement to continue the editorial process.
You can also submit your research manuscript online
https://ijaeb.com
Kindly Send:
Demand Draft/Cheques in favour of NEW DELHI PUBLISHERS Payable at New Delhi
Subscription rate 2022
India (INR `)
International (USD $)
Print
` 4500
$ 400
Print + Online
` 4950
$ 450
• IJAEB follows Ethical guidelines of Committee on Publication Ethics
https://ijaeb.com/journal/ethicalstandards
• IJAEB uses double-blind review which follows COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers
https://ijaeb.com/journal/ethicscommittee
• IJAEB strictly follows Advanced Plagiarism Detection Software and archived in Creative Commons
https://ijaeb.com/home/reviewpolicy
• Citation count of IJAEB can be seen at Google Scholar Citation
https://scholar.google.co.in/citations?hl=en&btnA=1&user=cGw28QEAAAAJ
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences (NAAS) Rating: 4.54
Abstracting and Indexing
IJAEB (International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology) is Abstracted and Indexed in following organizations:
• CAB
• CABI
• CrossRef
• Directory of Research Indexing
• EBSCO Host
• Global Impact Factor
• Google Scholar
• ProMusa
• Electronics Journals Library
• Open University of Malaysia
• ProQuest
• Indian Citation Index
• Research Bib
• SCHOLAR-CNKI
• Scientific Information Centre of IOCB ASCR
• Sfx.scholarsportal
• WorldCat
• The National Library of Finland
• Ulrich Directory
• Journal Index
• WZB –Berlin Social Science Center
• University of Saskatchewan
• Index Medicus for WHO South East Asia
• Vytautas Magnus University
• GIGA (German Institute of Global and Area Studies), Hamburg
• Institute of European and American Studies, Academia Sinica
• University of Wollongong-New South Wales, Australia
Printed by
NEW DELHI PUBLISHERS
90, Sainik Vihar, Near Lakshmi Narayan Mandir, Mohan Garden,
New Delhi – 110059 (INDIA)
Email: ndpublishers@rediffmail.com Website: www.ndpublisher.in
EDITORIAL BOARD INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURE, ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD
Dr. Panjab Singh, FNAAS, FIAS, FNIE
Ex Secretary, Dept. of Agriculture Research and Education
(DARE) and Director General
Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR). Ex VC,
(BHU, Varanasi) INDIA
Dr. H.B. Singh
FNAAS, F.P.S.I., F.I.C.N., F.I.S.M.P.P., F.B.R.S
Professor, Mycology and Plant Pathology
Institute of Agricultural Sciences
BHU, Varanasi, INDIA
Prof. S.N. Puri, FNAAS
Vice Chancellor
Central Agricultural University, Imphal, INDIA
Prof. Tapash Dasgupta
Dean
IRDM Faculty Centre School of Agriculture and Rural
Development, Ramakrishna Mission Vivekananda
University, Narendrapur Campus, PO Narendrapur
West Bengal, INDIA
Dr. Kusumakar Sharma, FNAAS
Former Assistant Director General, HRD Indian Council of
Agricultural Research (ICAR); New Delhi, INDIA
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Dr. Amitava Rakshit, PhD(IIT-KGP)
FSES, FTWAS.Nxt (Italy), FBiovision.Nxt (France), FCWSS, FSBSRD
Institute of Agricultural Sciences, BHU, Varanasi, INDIA
E-mail: amitavar@bhu.ac.in
Scopus ID: 8092521000; ORCID ID: 0000-0002-9406-8262; Researcher ID: E-3080-2015
EXECUTIVE EDITORIAL BOARD
Dr. Osama Abd El-Salam Shalaby
Plant production Department
Desert Research Center, Cairo, EGYPT
E-mail: o.a.shalaby@gmail.com
Dr. Valasia Iakovoglou
Academic Director
Mediterranean College, GREECE
E-mail: viakovoglou@yahoo.com
Dr. Sampson R Hopkinson
Alabama A & M University, USA
E-mail: sampson.hopkinson@aamu.edu
Dr. Ahmed Mansour Mohamed Mansour
Zagazig University, EGYPT
E-mail: amansour@zu.edu.eg
Dr. A.K. Singh
Department of Extension Education, Institute of
Agricultural Sciences, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi,
INDIA
E-mail: singharun61@rediffmail.com
Dr. Keshavulu Kunusoth
University of California
USA
E-mail: keshava_72@yahoo.com
Dr. Ibrahim Ortas
University of Cukurova, TURKEY
E-mail: iortas@cu.edu.tr
Dr. Rajib Karmakar
Department of Agriculture, Government of W.B., INDIA
E-mail: rajibc183@rediffmail.com
Dr. Babarinde S. A.
Department of Agronomy, Ladoke Akintola University of
Technology, NIGERIA
E-mail: samdelani@yahoo.com
Dr. Jamilur Rahman
Sher-e-Bangla Agricultural University, BANGLADESH
E-mail: jamilsau@yahoo.com
Dr. Binoy Sarkar
International Lecturer, Lancaster Environment Centre
Room No. B535 (LEC1), Lancaster University,
Lancaster, UK
E-mail: b.sarkar@lancaster.ac.uk
Dr. Leonardo Fernandes Fraceto, FRSC
Associate Professor
Institute of Science and Technology of Sorocaba
São Paulo State University – Unesp
Sorocaba - São Paulo – BRAZIL
E-mail: leonardo.fraceto@unesp.br
TECHNICAL EDITORS
Dr. Debashis Dutta
Project Directorate for Farming Systems
Research, Modipuram, Meerut, U.P. INDIA
E-mail: debashisdutta74@yahoo.co.in
Dr. Anil Bhatt
Assistant Professor, Agricultural Economics
Division of Agricultural Economics and Statistics, FoA,
SKUAST-Jammu,
INDIA
E-mail: drbhatanil@gmail.com
Dr. P. Raha
Institute of Agricultural Sciences,
BHU, Varanasi, INDIA
E-mail: priyankar_raha@yahoo.com
Dr. Birinchi K Sharma
Department of Mycology and Plant Pathology,
Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, INDIA
E-mail: birinchi_ks@yahoo.com
Dr. Neelesh Sharma
Division of Veterinary Clinical Medicine & Jurisprudence,
Faculty of Veterinary Science & Animal Husbandry,
SKUAST-J, R.S. Pura, Jammu, INDIA
E-mail: drneelesh_sharma@yahoo.co.in
Dr. Zahra Arzani
Faculty of Geography, Islamic Azad University
Tehran, IRAN
E-mail: zarzjani@yahoo.com
Dr. Malay Kumar Bhowmik
Rice Research Station, Govt. of W.B.
INDIA
E-mail: bhowmick_malay@rediffmail.com
Dr. Akshaya Gupte
N.V. Patel College of Pure and Applied Science,
Vallabh Vidyanagar, Gujarat, INDIA
E-mail: akshaya_gupte@hotmail.com
Dr. M. Senapathy
Department of Rural Development and Agricultural
Extension, College of Agriculture
Wolaita Sodo University,
ETHIOPIA
E-mail: mspathy9@gmail.com
Dr. Padmanabh Dwivedi
Institute of Agricultural Science,
Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, INDIA
E-mail: pdwivedi25@rediffmail.com
Dr. M.M. Sharma
ICRISAT, Patancheru, Andhra Pradesh, INDIA
E-mail: murli.sharma@cigiar.org
EDITORIAL BOARD
Dr. Shyamal K. Ghose
Department of Genetics BCKVV, Mohanpur,
West Bengal, INDIA
E-mail: shyamalghose@hotmail.com
Dr. Marcelo Huarte
Huarte International Agricultural Consulting Owner
14 de julio 2735(7600), Mar del Plata - ARGENTINA
Dr. Ranjan Bhattacharya
Indian Agricultural Research Institute
New Delhi, INDIA
Science & Animal Husbandry,
E-mail: ranjan_vpkas@yahoo.com
Dr. Soumendra Chakraborty
Uttar Banga Krishi Viswavidlaya, Pundibari,
West Bengal, INDIA
E-mail: soumendra1@gmail.com
Dr. Vikas Kumar
Department of Agriculture,
Vivekananda Global University, Jaipur,
Rajasthan, INDIA
E-mail: vkskumar49@gmail.com
Dr. Dhiman Mukherjee
Uttar Banga Krishi Viswavidyalaya
West Bengal, INDIA
E-mail: dhiman_mukherjee@yahoo.co.in
Dr. N. Kumaravadiel
Tamil Nadu Agricultural University
Coimbatore, INDIA
E-mail: kumaravadiveln@yahoo.com
Dr. Alireza Haghighi Hasanalideh
Central and West Asian Rice Center (CWARC),
IRAN
E-mail: haghighi.ag@gmail.com
MANAGING EDITOR
Chanchal Mukherjee
editor@ijaeb.com
Contents
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
VOL. 15, NO. 2 (SPECIAL ISSUE), JULY 2022
Role of Multispectral Vegetation Indices in Precision Agriculture – A Review
277
Moncy S Akkara, A.R. Pimpale, S.B. Wadatkar and P.B. Rajankar
Three-Dimensional Printing in Food Process Engineering: A Prospective and Retrospective Analysis
287
Amrutha, G. and Bhagyashree N Patil
A Study on Novel Approach to Sustainable Indian Agriculture - Precision Farming
299
Shwetha U.N. and Nitin S. Gupta
Study of Heterosis, Residual Heterosis and Inbreeding Depression in Two Crosses of Tomato
307
Sangamesh Nevani and O. Sridevi
A Critical Study on the Present Status and Scope of Natural Farming in the State of Andhra Pradesh,
India
313
B. Srishailam, V. Sailaja and S.V. Prasad
Influence of Preservatives and Biodegradable Nano Silver Film on Post-harvest Life of
Jasminum sambac Cv. “Mysuru Mallige”
321
Keerthishankar, K., Yathindra, H.A., Mutthuraju, G.P. and Tanveer Ahmed
Organic Manure and Fertility Level Affects the Flowering, Yield and Quality Attributes of Okra under
Heavy Clay Soil of Southern Rajasthan
329
Hemraj Meena, Kavita, A., Nirmal Kumar Meena, Rajesh Sharma, Ashok Kumar and Rahul Chopra
Bioactive Compounds of Turmeric Powder Affected by Grinding Method and Feed Temperature
337
M.N. Dabhi, P.R. Davara, H.P. Gajera, Nirav Joshi and Parth Saparia
Physical and Functional Properties of Extruded Snack Products Prepared by Blending of Defatted
Peanut Flour with Corn Flour
347
P.R. Davara, Mohit H. Muliya, M.N. Dabhi and V.P. Sangani
Effect of Blanching on the Quality of Green Peas During Freezing
V.P. Sangani, A.N. Dalsaniya and P.R. Davara
359
Physical Properties of Fresh Turmeric Rhizomes (Var. Salem)
369
Ravina Parmar and Mukesh N. Dabhi
Development of Palm Sugar Substituted Yoghurt
379
L. Vijay, N. Karthikeyan, G. Kumaresan and C. Pandiyan
Assessment of λ-irradiation Impact on Physiological and Sensory Characteristics of Peanut Kernels
(Arachis hypogaea L.) as a Function of Moisture Content
385
D.K. Gojiya, D.M. Vyas and A.M. Joshi
Efficiency and Effectiveness of Mutagenic agents (Gamma rays and Ethyl Methane Sulphonate) on
Bougainvillea spp.
393
Anita Hosalli, Seetharamu, G.K., Shivapriya, M., Amreen Taj, Gangadhar, B.N., Rajiv Kumar and
Anjaneya Reddy
Influence of Ozone Treatment on Carbohydrate Content of Wheat (Triticum aestivum) during
Bulk Storage
401
Shingala Abhishaben M., M.N. Dabhi, P.J. Rathod and Rathod Ravikumar R.
Effects of Process Parameters on Rice Based Extruded Snack Food
407
P.S. Sapariya, V.P. Sangani and P.R. Davara
Monitoring and Regulating Climatic Condition of Polyhouse for Successful Off-season Grafting of
Citrus Fruits Using Internet of Things Platform
417
Ritu Raj Lamsal, Mamta Bhattarai, Umesh Acharya and Pablo Otero
Climate Resilient Practices Adopted in Flood and Drought Prone Areas of Siwan District, Bihar
423
Harsha, B.R., Krishna Bahadur Chhetri, Nandeesha, C.V., Anuradha Ranjan Kumari,
Shivam Chaubey, Arun Kumar and Ratnesh Kumar Jha
Moisture Dependent Physical Properties of Psyllium Seeds for Different Varieties
427
Nirav U. Joshi and Mukesh N. Dabhi
Management of Plutella xylostella on Cauliflower Crop Through Novel Group of Insecticides
437
Abhijith, N., Tirupati Murali Krishna, Kaarumanchi Kiran Kumar and Kayam Devaki
Study on Drying Characteristics of Simarouba glauca Leaves
445
S.S. Bhuva and Darshan, M.B.
Growth and Yield of Gobhi Sarson as Influenced by Irrigation and Nutrient Management Practices
under Conservation Tillage
Hemali Bijani, Sanjay K. Sharma and Devanshi Baghla
455
Impact of Heat Units and different Pruning Months on Growth and Flowering of
Jasminum grandiflorum
461
Khanchana, K. and M. Jawaharlal
Assessing Socio-economic Vulnerability for Development: Evidence from Ahmednagar, Maharashtra
467
P Seenivasan., Ananthan P.S., Neha W. Qureshi and Shivaji Argade
Effect of Organic Manures on Germination and Growth of Snake Gourd (Trichosanthes cucumerina L.)
477
Suriya, R. and P. Madhanakumari
Comparative Analysis of Performance of Different Fodder Crops Under Pigeonpea Based
Intercropping System (1:2)
481
Rajashree, B.M. Dodamani, P.S. Rathod, D.H. Patil, A. Amaregouda and Sahana
Effect of Subsurface Draiange on TSS and SAR in Saline Vertisol Under TBP Command Area
485
Sahana, Veeresh, H., Narayana Rao, K., Bhat, S.N., Polisgowdar, B.S. and Rajashree
Genetic Variability of Determinate F4 Progenies for Yield Attributes of Indian Bean
[Lablab purpureus (L.) Sweet]
489
Pooja C. Bhimani, K.G. Modha and V.B. Darji
Feasibility of Vacuum based Cooling System for on Farm Cooling of Milk
495
Gaurav Sharma, Amandeep Sharma, Pranav Kumar Singh, Narender Kumar and Gopika Talwar
A Study on Marketing Channels and Marketing Efficiency of Capsicum in Mid-Hills of
Himachal Pradesh
503
Parul Barwal, Subhash Sharma, Diksha Bali, Chinglembi Laishram and Parveen Kashyap
Evaluation of Biopesticides Against Callosobruchus maculatus Fabricius in Chickpea Under Stored
Conditions
509
Amrutha Valli Sindhura Kopparthi and Praveenbhai Harjibhai Godhani
Phenotypic Correlation Between Morphological and Yield Related Traits of Rice (Oryza sativa L.)
515
G. Babithraj Goud, D. Saida Naik, R. Abdul Fiyaz, M.M Azam, S. Narender Reddy and B. Balaji Naik
Utilization of Bamboo and Wooden Resources for Development of Contemporary Products:
An Approach for Climate Change Mitigation and Revenue Generation
521
M.S. Sankanur, T.R. Ahlawat, R.P. Gunaga, A.D. Chaudhary, Archana Mahida and Vrutti Patel
Estimation of Genetic Parameters of Willow (Salix spp.) Clones for Leaf Traits
Anchal, J.P. Sharma, Tushal, Aman Mahajan and Shikha Thakur
527
Incidence and Dispersion of Plant Parasitic Nematodes in Cauliflower Growing Regions of Tamil Nadu
533
Arun, A., Shanthi, A. and Shandeep, S.G.
Assessment of the Impact of Genetically Modified Cotton (Bt Cotton) on Soil Microbial Ecosystem
541
Sivaji Mathivanan
Effect of Integrated Weed Management Practices on Flowering, Yield and Economics of African
Marigold (Tagetes erecta L.) cv. Arka Bangara-2
551
Mallikarjun Hebbal, Munikrishnappa, P.M., Seetharamu, G.K., Kalyanamurthy, K.N.,
Rajiv Kumar, Shivanna, M., Rajeshwari, R. and Raghunatha Reddy
Impact of Integrated Weed Management Strategies on Growth and Yield of African Marigold
(Tagetes erecta L.) cv. Arka Bangara-2
557
Mallikarjun Hebbal, Munikrishnappa, P.M., Kalyanamurthy, K.N., Seetharamu, G.K.,
Rajiv Kumar, Shivanna, M., Rajeshwari, R. and Somashekhar, S.
Phytochemical Analysis, HPTLC Profile, and In-vitro Antioxidant and Antibacterial Activity of
Cyperus rotundus L. Rhizome Extracts
567
Radhakrishnan Naveenkumar, R.P. Raman, Saurav Kumar, Anisha, V. and Chandan, G.M.
Cryobiotechnological Tool: Cryopreservation of in vitro Grown Shoot tips of Grape
(Vitis vinifera L.) cv. Fantasy Seedless
579
Suhasini, S.C., Kulapati Hipparagi, Satish Pattepur, Gollagi, S.G. and Sanjivreddi G. Reddy
Online Mode of Education and Constraint in Diploma Agriculture College, ICAR - Krishi Vigyan
Kendra Bidar, Karnataka
583
Sunilkumar, N.M., Rakesh Varma, Akshaykumar and Ningadalli Mallikarjun
Morphological and Biochemical Markers for Dry Root Rot (Macrophomina phaseolina (Tassi) Goid)
Resistance in Brinjal
587
Sherly, J.
Impact of Climate Change on Water Requirement and Yield of Tomato Over different
Agro-climatic Zones of Tamil Nadu
595
Guhan Velusamy, Geethalakshmi Vellingiri, Bhuvaneswari Kulandhaivelu, Senthilraja Kandasamy and
Kowshika Nagarajan
Analysis of Resource Use Efficiency and Constraints of Gram Production in Gadchiroli District
601
Asha B. Kayarwar, Rohma Ansari, N.T. Bagde and S.N. Suryawanshi
Process Analysis of Production of Fertilizer and Determining Loss due to Failure to Meet the
Specification
Rohma F. Ansari, Asha B. Kayarwar, S.N. Suryawanshi and N.T. Bagde
607
Morphological Characterization of Roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa L.) Germplasm for Qualitative Traits
613
N. Hari Satyanarayana, S. Mukherjee, K.K. Sarkar, V. Visalakshmi and S.K. Roy
Effect of Moisture Stress on Wheat Crop by IW/CPE Approach on Water Requirement and
Water Use Efficiency
619
Rahul Ashok Pachore and Sachin Babaji Deore
Induction of Seed Dormancy and its Impact on Seed Quality in Groundnut (Arachis hypogaea L.)
627
Parashivamurthy, R. Siddaraju and Hariah, M.S.
Effect of different Moisture Content on the Physical Characteristics of Dill Seeds
(Anethum graveolens L.)
633
Vidushi Mehta, R.F. Sutar and Chandani Popalia
Development and Characterization of Environment Friendly Starch and Protein Based
Packaging Materials for Food Applications
637
Gurpreet Singh, Sivakumar, S., Chawla, R. and Viji, P.C.
Artificial Intelligence Based Grading System for Mango Fruit- A Review
641
Kshitiy V. Vibhute, P.P. Patil and A.K. Rupnar
Studies on Effect of Organic Manures and Seed Priming on Growth and Seed Yield in Paddy
(Oryza sativa L.)
647
Siddaraju, R., Sumalata, B. and Parashivamurthy
Pseudomonas Species Potential for Organophosphorus Degradation
Priya Borad, Manisha Chaudhari, Khyati Harkhani and Anish Kumar Sharma
653
From
Dr. Amitava Rakshit PhD (IIT-KGP)
FSES, FTWAS.Nxt (Italy), FBiovision.Nxt (France), FCWSS, FSBSRD
Department of Soil Science & Agricultural Chemistry
Institute of Agricultural Science, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi-221005, INDIA
E-mail: amitavabhu@gmail.com
Voice: 05422-6701604 (O), +91-9450346890 (M), Fax: +91-542-2368465
EDITORIAL
Food and agriculture position today at a junction. The three challenges – feeding a mounting population,
providing a livelihood for farmers, and shielding the environment – must be tackled together if one need to
make sustainable progress in any of them. But making headway on this triple challenge is always a difficult
job, as creativities in one sphere can have unintended penalties in another. Nevertheless, advancement has
often come with social and ecological costs, including water insufficiency, soil degradation, ecosystem stress,
biodiversity damage, declining fish stocks and forest cover, and high intensities of greenhouse gas releases.
The productive prospective of our natural assets base has been dented in numerous places round the globe,
negotiating the forthcoming luxuriance of the planet. Looking forward, the track to comprehensive prosperity
is evidently manifested by the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Disabling the multifarious challenges
that the world faces necessitates transformative action, approving the philosophies of sustainability and
attempting the core grounds of poverty and hunger to leave no one behind. This special issue attempted to
address themes like sustainable transformation in agriculture and food production system, recent advances
in aquaculture for food and nutritional security, innovation in global & regional agricultural education
towards youth empowerment, climate change resilient agriculture, post-harvest technology for responsible
consumption, global and regional policy transformation in greater detail.
Sincerely
Amitava Rakshit, PhD
Institute of Agricultural Sciences, BHU, Varanasi, India
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 277-285, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.1
Role of Multispectral Vegetation Indices in Precision
Agriculture – A Review
Moncy S Akkara1*, A.R. Pimpale1, S.B. Wadatkar1 and P.B. Rajankar2
Department of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, CAET, Dr. PDKV Akola, Maharashtra, India
Associate Scientist, MRSAC, Nagpur, Maharashtra, India
1
2
*Corresponding author: moncysakkara@gmail.com (ORCID ID: 0000-0002-8436-3663)
Paper No. 986
Received: 01-06-2022
Revised: 26-06-2022
Accepted: 09-07-2022
ABSTRACT
Globally, the rising population and exhausting natural resources necessitate the monitoring and
management of resources in the best possible way. Precision agriculture deals with the precise supply of
agricultural inputs according to the actual crop requirements, thus making the most out of the agricultural
practice. The traditional method of field scouting is labor-intensive and time-consuming. The ability to
automate the collection, processing and implementation of data increased with new technology viz. GIS,
GPS, and remote sensing. Remote sensing can act as a rapid and precise information-gathering technique
on spatial variability within the field and temporal variability along long time series. Multispectral
vegetation indices were developed to characterize vegetation based on its canopy reflectance. Hence, crop
monitoring can be done by using vegetation indices as a surrogate for agronomic parameters. Inferences
from crop monitoring based on the vegetation indices can be used for precision agricultural practices
and thus achieve better agricultural management. The remote sensing technique with its rapidity and
repeatability has got huge potential in analyzing the conditions of soil and vegetation, ultimately leading
to applications in sustainable crop and soil management. The paper explores the role of remotely sensed
vegetation indices in precision agriculture.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm Concepts of precision agriculture.
mm Basics of Remote Sensing.
mm Major Vegetation indices and their application.
mm Scope and limitations of using multispectral vegetation indices in precision agriculture.
Keywords: Vegetation Indices, Remote Sensing, Precision agriculture, Spatial variability, Crop
management
With the increasing food demands of the evergrowing world population and deplenishing natural
resources, viz. water, the supply, and quality of
water became a major concern which is even
capable of challenging food security. The situation
gains huge gravity in arid and semi-arid regions
which were water-sensitive already. Besides, the
agriculture sector has now been transformed into
a whole new industry which is even regarded as
the silver line of the economy. This changed the
outlook on agriculture and necessitated the need
for adopting cultivation practices that ensures
better yield and economic returns. Like any other
industry, the commercialization of agriculture arises
the need for minimizing the inputs and maximizing
the profit through maximizing the crop yield. With
new-age technologies, farmers get various options
to maximize their profit. Market-oriented cultivation
practices by anticipating or delaying cropping,
How to cite this article: Akkara, M.S., Pimpale, A.R., Wadatkar, S.B.
and Rajankar, P.B. (2022). Role of Multispectral Vegetation Indices in
Precision Agriculture – A Review. Int. J. Ag. Env. Biotech., 15(Special
Issue): 277-285.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Akkara et al.
selling carbon credits to industry, and precision
agriculture are a few examples.
in soil properties and crop productivity owing to
their complex arrangement of landscapes and soils.
This opens up wide scope for precision agriculture
(Tanriverdi 2006).
Deplenishing water resources along with increased
environmental consciousness also accelerated the
shift to precision agriculture. Initiatives by several
governmental and non-governmental organizations
to increase awareness of achieving a greener safer
environment is also notable in stressing the need
to lessen chemical fertilizers and pesticides in
agriculture.
Precision agriculture renders information for better
decision making in agricultural management,
provides more accurate farm records, reduces
input cost via increased application efficiency,
improves crop yield, increases profit margin, and
reduces pollution, thereby, promoting improved
management of agriculture leading to better yield
and better economic returns (Arnold et al. 1999).
Variability in crop yield is due to the spatial
and temporal variability of several factors viz.
soil fertility, landscape, climate, etc. Hence, sitespecific management is essential for sustainable
agricultural production. The application of remote
sensing technology in agriculture helps to identify
the spatial variability within a field and temporal
variability along a long time series quickly and
reliably. The paper reviews the context of using
remotely sensed vegetation indices in precision
agriculture.
Precision Agriculture
Concerning irrigation water management, variability
within the field can be described by defining zones
of difference in total plant available water (TPAW).
For higher TPAW gradient over a short distance
needs the collection of more soil samples. Though
sampling requirements in comparison to a uniform
grid can be reduced by using crop yield patterns to
determine soil samples, practically, differences in
crop yield patterns may not be directly influenced
by TPAW variability (Post et al. 1988; Tanriverdi
2006).
Precision agriculture involves using the information
on site variability to effectively manage the sites.
It’s a combination of several tools viz. GPS, GIS,
RS, VRT, and sensor-controlled automatization. It
facilitates awareness of the site-specific, practical,
and profitable management practices among
the agricultural input suppliers, growers, and
processors (Lowenberg-DeBoer et al. 2002).
A major reason for the difficulty in precision
agriculture is the time consumed during
conventional data collection methods, especially in
large field areas. Besides, it cannot be carried out
simultaneously. Limitations to precision agricultural
practices can be overcome with the combined
application of advanced techniques viz. GIS, GPS,
and RS.
The relationship between climatic factors and crop
production can be of first-order level (Huggin and
Alderfer 1995). Hence, precision agriculture mainly
focuses on management based on spatial variability
in a standard to fine climactic conditions.
For precision agriculture, sensing systems for
different factors viz. soil, crop, disease, and
environmental factors are jointly used with a
positioning system (Stafford et al. 1997). A large
quantity of data can be analyzed at a faster rate and
with more accuracy using remote sensing and GIS.
Furthermore, it helps in the frequent monitoring
of crops. GIS maps can be created using remote
sensing and GPS which can be utilized for better
resource management. Yield mapping refers to the
graphical representation of the quantity of the crop
yield on a space and time scale in a map outline
using appropriate sensors, GPS hardware, and
GIS software. Yield maps help farmers to identify
locations within fields where the yield can be
improved or inputs can be adjusted to maximize
profit along with environmental quality. As the
Conventional farming is based on the general
assumption that fields are homogenous and hence,
treated monotonously. More information on the
spatial variability enables site-specific treatment.
Thus precision agriculture can effectively reduce
the impacts of agricultural inputs such as chemical
fertilizers and pesticides on the environment along
with increasing crop production.
There would be no need for precision agriculture
if the fields were uniform due to the high capital
cost involved in it. Usually, large agricultural fields
are more observed with spatial variability both
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
278
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Role of Multispectral Vegetation Indices in Precision Agriculture – A Review
recommendations for input and farm profitability
depend on crop yield, yield mapping has got a huge
role in precision agriculture.
Differential Global Positioning System (DGPS)
receivers. Also, it updates its working conditions
to the users.
GPS can be used to precisely study the spatial
variability of soil and crop and thus monitor the
micro and macro scales of spatial variability in
agricultural conditions. Besides, it can generate
the architecture of agricultural land viz. field
boundaries, field acreage, the disease-affected
region, irrigation systems, roads, etc (Sahu et al.
2019).
GIS:
Often regarded as the brain of precision agriculture,
GIS creates a georeferenced map, and data on
position and attributes are stored. A high volume
of data can be processed within a short period
using GIS. Furthermore, GIS acts as a decision
management tool combining data with agricultural
knowledge and producing spatially variable
recommendations on agricultural inputs. Thus,
users can efficiently utilize their resources.
Remote Sensing
Remote Sensing acts as a spatial information source.
Remote Sensing is the method to collect information
on objects without being in physical contact with
them (Diker 1998; Seyhan 2004). Data is collected by
measuring the reflected or emitted electromagnetic
radiation from the land surface since it is strongly
linked to the surface parameters viz. soil moisture
content and vegetation. Thus, these parameters
can be derived from reflectance measurements.
Reflectance is the ratio of the amount of light
reflected from the plane to the irradiance to that
plane (Suits 1983).
Raster GIS characterizes the spatial variability of
a field by partitioning the whole area into regular
grid cells while vector GIS makes use of points,
lines, and polygons. Statistical analysis is used by
many researchers to better identify and represent
the relationship between agricultural production
and spatial factors (Mulla and Schepers 1997).
GIS-derived spatial variability maps have got
applications in guiding agricultural inputs viz.
fertilizer, pesticides, water, etc. by analyzing
corresponding factors viz. soil organic carbon
content, bulk density, soil profile water retention,
etc. Besides, GIS maps can be used to assess
environmental health viz. ambient air pollution
study (Sahu et al. 2019).
Components of a remote sensing system are
carrier platform, remote sensors, control, and
positioning systems, data transmission system, and
data preprocessing system that is included under
the three broad classes viz. ground base system,
spatial foundation system, and remote sensing
data storage system (Yin et al. 2019). Instruments
used for collecting data in remote sensing are
called remote sensors and it is usually placed on
aircraft and satellites (Diker 1998). Remote sensors
are broadly classified as imaging and non-imaging.
Imaging instruments gives two -dimensional image
of features under observation while non-imaging
instruments viz. spectroradiometers measure
radiation intensity across a wavelength range of
very narrow wavebands. Spectroradiometers can
finely differentiate characteristics leading to better
interpretation of remotely sensed images and
selection of spectral bands for prospect remote
sensing imaging devices. These instruments can be
used to measure reflected and emitted radiation at
immensely small intervals of wavelength with high
spectral and temporal resolution. It can be utilized
to collect ground truth data (Neale 1983).
GPS
Global Positioning System (GPS) is a satellitebased free navigation system that is developed
and maintained by the US. Radio signals from
satellites are collected by the receivers which are on
the ground and then it is converted to the position
data (Bernhardsen 1992). Position data covers all
the three dimensions viz. latitude, longitude, and
elevation. Hence, GPS helps in obtaining locationspecific values for any parameter. GPS supports
GIS by geo-referencing both input data and
recommendations.
GPS performance has two modes. A single receiver
mode collects data on timing which is then
converted to position while a differential mode has
got two receivers, one stationary and the other on
the mobile GPS instrument. Accuracy of positions
can be improved up to the range of 1 m using
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
279
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Akkara et al.
Remote sensing using a satellite platform provides
consistent, comparable, and cost-effective data of
high spatial resolution even from long time series
(Foley et al. 1998). Free access to multispectral
and visible data is an added advantage of certain
satellite platforms. Satellite remote sensing allows
the collection of data on large agricultural fields
at frequent intervals. It can be used to monitor
agricultural and hydrological conditions of any land
surface. The number of bands obtained by remote
sensing is increasing as high-resolution spectral
instrumentation is used, and the bandwidth is
narrowing (Honkavaara et al. 2013).
in the tissue and to some extent, affected by leaf
structure (Tanriverdi 2006).
Reflectance spectra obtained from plants vary with
plant variety, growth stage, the moisture content in
tissue, and other intrinsic characteristics (Chang et
al. 2016). Morphological and chemical traits of the
surface of leaves or organs are another determinant
factor of spectral reflectance (Zhang and Kovacs
2012).
Reflectance measurements can be used for
determining chlorophyll content in leaves which can
be related to the nitrogen grade of the vegetation
(Thomas and Oerther 1972). Spectral reflectance
from plants in the thermal infrared region (800014000 nm) can be directly linked to its temperature
and hence, can be used for stomata dynamics
assessment (Xue and Su 2017). The variances and
changes in the green leaves of plants, as well as
canopy spectral properties from remotely sensed
photos, are used to analyze vegetation information.
The major advantage of remote sensing over
conventional mapping techniques is that it can
derive complex relationships even from an aerial
view (Grenzdorffer 1997). Remotely sensed data has
got direct and indirect applications. Sensor captured
images can be directly used for any purpose or
information is derived from the image and then
this information is used for any management
purpose (Frazier et al. 1997). Remotely sensed data
from terrestrial vegetation have got applications
in the broader fields of agriculture, biodiversity
conservation, environmental monitoring, forestry,
urban green infrastructures, etc.
Data required in precision agriculture, for sitespecific management can be categorized into three
classes. Conditions that are constant throughout
the season viz. soil properties are classified as
information on seasonally stable conditions and
hence, it has to be measured only at the beginning
of the season whereas information on seasonally
variable conditions is the class of dynamic conditions
throughout the season viz. moisture content of the
soil, diseases and pest infestation of crop and
therefore, it has to be monitored throughout the
cropping season. The third class is the information
to identify the factors for yield spatial variability
and to develop a management strategy, which
determines the causes of the variability as it is
comprehensive of the first two categories. Remote
sensing can be used to acquire all the three categories
of information for the successful implementation of
precision agriculture (Moran et al. 1997).
Remote sensing in precision agriculture
C o n ve n t i o n a l m e t h o d s o f t a k i n g g r o u n d
measurements of various vegetation parameters
viz. leaf area, biomass, etc. are expensive and
tiring. Remote sensing methods utilize the spectral
reflectance of vegetation and soil to obtain their
attributes.. It is based on the fact that any surface
reflects, absorbs, or transmits incident light. The
length of the growing season was found to be
irrelevant since the fresh and green leaves accounted
for similar reflectance spectra (Sinclair et al. 1971;
Neale 1983).
Remote sensing has got applications in terms
of both macro and micromanagement in the
field of agriculture such as vegetative cover
estimation, canopy temperature monitoring, stress
identification, water deficit determination, irrigation
scheduling along with yield prediction (Mulla 2013).
Remote sensing of vegetation is majorly based on the
ultraviolet (10 to 380 nm), visible (450-750 nm), and
the near and mid-infrared (850-1700 nm) regions of
light spectra (Rahim et al. 2016; Cruden et al. 2012).
The wavelength spectrum responded differently to
leaf characteristics– visible light was absorbed by
pigments, the NIR region was affected by internal
leaf structure and the wavelength spectrum beyond
that was influenced by the concentration of water
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Direct application of remote imagery gained
popularity with the advances in technology like
GPS and sensors leading to better affordability
280
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Role of Multispectral Vegetation Indices in Precision Agriculture – A Review
and availability. The real-time position can be
superimposed on the remotely sensed imagery
using GPS and any point within the photograph can
be accessed. And thus, variability in soil and crop
can be analyzed and managed directly from images.
Vegetation indices derived from remote sensing
are the most effective but simple algorithms to
quantitatively and qualitatively analyze vegetation
cover along with vigor and its growth dynamics.
There is no single mathematical expression for
defining every vegetation indices. Since each of
them is tailored to suit specific applications and
is derived from visible and non-visible spectra,
their applicability depends on the platforms and
instruments involved (Xue and Su 2017). Indices
developed from near and mid-infrared regions
can represent various characteristics of plants
viz. pigments, water content, sugar content,
carbohydrate content, protein content, aromatics,
etc. apart from proxy quantification of growth and
vigor (Foley et al. 1998). Multispectral vegetation
indices derived from the reflectance of the canopy
in comparatively broader wavebands can be used
to monitor the vegetative growth corresponding to
climatic variables (Hatfield and Pinter 1993).
Another major direct application of remote
sensing in precision agriculture is the extraction
of management zones from remote sensing
imagery-derived vegetation indices maps using
GIS software. When integrated with variable rate
sprayer equipment, site-specific requirements are
met with the help of real-time sensors, leading to
reduced groundwater contamination and improved
nutrient use efficiency (Schepers and Francis 1998).
The indirect application includes the preparation
of a base map with different layers of information
using GIS, soil mapping across the field, use of
remotely sensed vegetation parameters in crop
simulation models, identifying location and factors
causing crop stresses viz. diseases, insects, and
weeds, improving soil sampling strategies with
remotely measured soil and plant parameters. Soil
salinity areas can be mapped using remote sensing
data (Basso et al. 2004).
Ratio Vegetation Index (Jordan 1969) is a simple
ratio index with high sensitivity to vegetation
and a strong link to plant biomass. Hence, RVI is
commonly used for the estimation and monitoring
of green biomass, especially when vegetation
coverage is very dense. In sparse vegetation
conditions, they are susceptible to atmospheric
effects leading to poor representation of biomass.
Difference Vegetation Index or the Environmental
Vegetation Index (Richardson and Weigand 1977)
are used to monitor the ecological environment of
vegetation and is highly sensitive to soil background
changes.
Vegetation Indices
Vegetation indices are in general, either ratios
or linear combinations of spectral reflectance
corresponding to different wavelengths obtained
from radiometer bands. They can give better
correlations with vegetation parameters viz.
plant height, green leaf area index, leaf chlorosis
fraction, the water content in leaves, vegetation
cover percent, and wet and dry biomass, than the
individual bands. (Bausch and Neale 1987). Hence,
vegetation indices were introduced to monitor and
analyze these agronomic parameters.
Vegetative growth at any stage can be monitored
using the Normalized Difference Vegetation
Index (Rouse et al. 1973) and Perpendicular
Vegetation Index (Richardson and Wiegand
1977). Besides, PVI can efficiently eliminate soil
background effects. Major applications of PVI are
LAI calculation, surface vegetation parameter(grass
yield, chlorophyll content) inversion along with
crop identification and classification (Kaufman
and Tanré 1992; Wenlong 2009). Adjustments have
to be done to combat sensitivity to soil brightness
and reflectivity.
Vegetation cover can be estimated from vegetation
indices derived from the reflectance of the canopy.
This estimated vegetation cover can be used instead
of measured vegetation cover (Moran et al. 1994).
Thus, crop monitoring can be done which can be
used for improved management through precision
agriculture. The water deficit of any plant at any
growth stage can be estimated from crop monitoring
based on reflectance measurements. Thus, water
management can be done which is the major part
of agricultural crop management.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
The most widely used vegetation index is the
NDVI, even used in local and global assessments of
vegetation and is highly sensitive to green vegetation.
Furthermore, NDVI requires remote sensing
281
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Akkara et al.
calibration due to its sensitivity to atmosphere,
cloud and cloud overcast, leaf canopy brightness
and shadow, soil brightness, and soil color. NDVI
is correlated to canopy photosynthesis along with
canopy structure and LAI. Many researchers have
correlated NDVI with Leaf Area Index (Xue and
Su 2017).
from regions of interest becomes difficult in such
areas due to the variations in soils, weeds, cover
crops, and vegetation of interest, especially when
a single plant has got different vegetation indices
because of spatial variability. Image processing steps
viz. filtering and denoising get complicated if the
vegetation indices of the study crop are similar to
that of other crops. However, a simplistic vegetation
index algorithm can give simple but effective tools
to quantify the vegetation status on the land surface
(Hoffmann et al. 2015; Xue and Su 2017).
Several modifications were done on NDVI in an
attempt to increase the ability to derive better
interpretations. Soil Adjusted Vegetation Index
(Huete 1988) and Modified Soil Adjusted Vegetation
Index (Qi et al. 1994) minimizing the effect of soil
background are examples. Concerning the low noise
level, SAVI was suggested as a better vegetation
indicator among other basic vegetation indices. In
an attempt to optimize the L factor in SAVI, the
MSAVI was developed with a variable correction
factor, L. This L varies with canopy cover and soil
type. A Modified Normalized Vegetation Index (Liu
and Huete 1995) integrates both atmospheric and
soil adjustment factors.
The spectral resolution of remotely sensed data used
for the extraction of vegetation indices is yet another
challenge to be addressed. Though vegetation
indices developed from broader wavebands can
identify various stress, they cannot recognize
the exact factors causing a specific type of stress.
Hence, physiological stresses viz. water and nutrient
shortage are better correlated with narrow-band
indices like Water Band Index, Normalized Pigment
Chlorophyll Ratio Index, Canopy Chlorophyll
Content Index, and Photochemical Reflectance Index
(Basso et al. 2004).
Stress related Vegetation Index (Gardener 1983) and
Cubed Ratio Index (Thenkabail et al. 1994) were
developed from the Mid-InfraRed Band. Visible
Atmospherically Resistant Index (VARIgreen) is
another example of vegetation index being in a
strong relationship with measured vegetation cover
(Gitelson et al. 2001).
Spatial resolution and orbit period of satellite
platforms are the two major concerns in the
precision agriculture applications viz. nutrient
and water management. Also, the use of a large
number of sensors can make the whole process
expensive for long time series. The unavailability
of satellite data on cloudy days due to the inability
of passive sensors to penetrate through clouds is
another concern. Though this issue can be partially
rectified by the usage of airborne platforms and
Unmanned Aerial Vehicle platforms, it has got its
share of drawbacks. The airborne remote sensing
method requires air crafts and pilots and hence
can be expensive. However, Unmanned Aerial
Vehicle platforms have got high temporal and
spatial resolution (sub-meter resolution). It makes
use of affordable aircraft and camera payloads from
visible to thermal infrared and also, 3D LIDAR,
and thus, a better alternative platform for assessing
plant growth and vigor, irrigation scheduling,
evapotranspiration modeling, etc (Xue and Su 2017).
Though few researchers found that measured
vegetation cover represents the vegetation cover in
a better way than the estimated vegetation indices,
the practical difficulties involved in a measuring
method viz. time required to complete a data set,
possible crop damage, usage of instruments for the
entire growing season has to be considered. Hence,
using vegetation indices over measured vegetation
cover has got advantages like lesser time, lesser
cost, minimum labor requirements, and large data
availability, especially in larger areas (Tanriverdi
2003).
Scope and Limitations of Vegetation Indices in
Precision Agriculture
As vegetation indices are developed from single
or limited bands, lack of sensitivity in acquiring
data, especially from heterogeneous canopies viz.
horticultural tree plantations, might be counted
as a shortcoming. Extraction of vegetation indices
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Less developed countries don’t much prefer
precision agriculture tools since their smaller
agricultural areas and their corresponding cost
of agricultural inputs doesn’t signify the use of
precision agriculture. The initial cost involved in
282
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Role of Multispectral Vegetation Indices in Precision Agriculture – A Review
CONCLUSION
using precision agriculture techniques is more in
small field areas. Hence, conventional farming
techniques are found to be more affordable than
precision agriculture techniques in improving the
management of agriculture. However, the scattered
nature of these agricultural fields necessitates field
use planning. Furthermore, precision agriculture
offers better results in terms of time, labor, and data
availability. It would be better to determine the field
size for which precision agriculture is significant
considering factors such as water supply and cost
of precision agriculture (Tanriverdi 2006).
Remote sensing acts as a spatial information source
based on the spectral reflectance from vegetation
and soil. It has got direct and indirect applications
in precision agriculture. The use of vegetation
indices to quantify spatial variability within the field
and thus manage crops and resources is one such
application. Vegetation indices are extracted from
the reflectance data obtained from the remotely
sensed images. Generally, Vegetation indices are
developed from the reflectance measurements from
NIR and red bands, combined in various ways. The
major advantage of remote sensing in agriculture is
its non-destructive nature along with its accuracy
and swiftness. Near real-time data obtained from
remote sensing helps in actively managing the
inputs and thus maximizing yield and economic
returns. Vegetation indices derived from remotely
sensed data can identify crop stress conditions
to a large extent. As each vegetation index was
developed to address a different concern, judicious
use of vegetation indices is necessary to point out
the crop conditions along with underlying factors.
High cost in image acquisition, coarse spatial
resolution, and insufficient temporal and spectral
resolution are the major limiting factors of the
use of satellite images in precision agriculture.
Major limitations can be overcome by increasing
the spatial, spectral, and temporal resolution of
remotely sensed data. Free access to high-resolution
data is now made available by various agencies
like USGS earth explorer while freeware like QGIS
is available for the processing of satellite data. As
the technology develops, the availability, reliability,
resolution, and cost-effectiveness of the remote
sensing images are expected to improve further
and will lead to better interpretation of vegetation
indices on the spatial and temporal variability of
crop and soil. The importance of providing accurate
and relevant information at a faster pace and low
cost is needless to emphasize, for the effective use
of remotely sensed vegetation indices in precision
agriculture. Thus, just like in every other sector,
remote sensing applications become the need of an
hour in the agriculture sector.
Technological illiteracy among the farmer
community might give rise to the hesitation in
adopting advanced technology like precision
agriculture. Inadequate knowledge and technical
expertise in analysis and decision making using
a computer at both local and regional levels are
probably the major constraints in the success of
precision agriculture (Sahu et al. 2019).
Requirements for successfully using remotely
sensed data in precision agriculture are the high
spatial resolution (preferably, not more than 10 m),
frequent coverage, timely availability, low cost, and
integration with expert systems (Tanriverdi 2003:
Sahu et al. 2019). Precision agriculture tools (GIS,
GPS, and remote sensing) together can provide a
complete data set that is accurate to use in precision
agriculture, especially in heterogeneous or large
agricultural areas. For the best outcome from
precision agriculture, potential limiting factors to
crop profitability must be identified and addressed.
Poor aeration, Soil water availability, and weed
pressure are a few examples of limiting factors. A
better understanding of spatial variability in yield
and factors responsible for it, both environmental
and managemental, will give a finer idea of bestsuited site-specific agricultural operations. With
the better correlations evolved between these
factors and yield, improved spatially variable
recommendations can be obtained (Tanriverdi
2006). Integrating remotely sensed data with
crop simulation models has a huge prospect in
agriculture applications (Basso et al. 2004). Rapid
mapping of insect infestation, treatment logging by
variable-rate spray operators, and pattern study of
disease spread are a few of the aspects which can
be incorporated into precision agriculture with the
help of remote sensing (Sahu et al. 2019).
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
REFERENCES
Arnold, E.J., Rickman, D. and Samuelson, D. 1999. Precis. Agric.
pp. 1-2, http://www.ghcc.msfc.nasa.gov/precisionag.
283
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Akkara et al.
Basso, B., Cammarano, D. and Vita, P.D. 2004. Remotely
Sensed Vegetation Indices: Theory and Applications for
Crop Management. Ital. J. Agrometeorol., 1: 36-53.
Kaufman, Y.J. and Tanre, D. 1992. Atmospherically Resistant
Vegetation Index (ARVI) for EOS-MODIS. IEEE Trans.
Geosci. Remote Sens., 30(2): 261–270.
Bausch, W.C. and Neale. C.M.U. 1987. Crop coefficients
derived from reflected canopy radiation: a concept. Trans.
ASAE, 30: 703-709.
Liu, H.Q. and Huete, A. 1995. Feedback-based modification
of the NDVI to minimize canopy background and
atmospheric noise. IEEE Trans. Geosci. Remote Sens., 33(2):
457–465.
Bernhardsen, T. 1992. Geographic Information Systems.
Arendal, Norway: Viak IT, pp. 1-318.
Lowenberg-DeBoer, J., Blumhoff, G. and Mclntyre, J. 2002.
Precision farming profitability, http://www.agriculture.
purdue.edu/ssmc/.
Chang, L., Peng-Sen, S. and Liu Shi-Rong. 2016. A review of
plant spectral reflectance response to water physiological
changes. Chin. J. Plant Ecol., 40(1): 80–91.
Moran, M.S., Clarke, T.R., Inoue, Y. and Vidal, A. 1994.
Estimating crop water deficit using the relation between
surface-air temperature and spectral vegetation index.
Remote Sens. Environ., 32: 125-141.
Cruden, B.A., Prabhu, D. and Martinez, R. 2012. Absolute
radiation measurement in venus and mars entry
conditions. J. Spacecr. Rockets, 49(6): 1069–1079.
Mulla, D.J. 2013. Twenty-five years of remote sensing in
precision agriculture: Key advances and remaining
knowledge gaps. Biosyst. Eng., 114(4): 358–371.
Diker, K. 1998. Use of geographic information management
systems (GIMS) for nitrogen management. Ph. D. Thesis,
Department of Chemical and Bioresource Engineering,
Colorado State University, Spring 1998.
Mulla, D.J. and Schepers, J.S. 1997. Key processes and
properties for site-specific soil and crop management.
The State of Site-Specific Management for Agriculture.
American Society of Agronomy, Madison, WI. pp.1-18.
In F.J. Pierce and E. J. Sadler (eds.)
Foley, W.J., McIlwee, A., Lawler, I., Aragones, L., Woolnough,
A.P. and N. Berding. 1998. Ecological applications of
near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy - A tool for rapid,
cost-effective prediction of the composition of plant
and animal tissues and aspects of animal performance.
Oecologia, 116(3): 293–305.
Neale, C.M.U. 1983. Monitoring corn development using
reflected radiation. Master Thesis, Department of
Agricultural and Chemical Engineering, Colorado State
University, Fort Collins, CO.
Frazier, B.E., Walters, C.S. and Perry, E.M. 1997. Role of remote
sensing in site-specific management. In: F.J. Pierce and
E.J. Sadler. The State of Site-Specific Management for
Agriculture. ASA-CSSA-SSSA.
Post, D.F., Mack, C., Camp, P.D. and Suliman, A.S. 1988.
Mapping and characterization of the soils at the University
of Arizona Maricopa Agricultural Center. Proc. Hydrology
and Water Resources in Arizona and Southwest, ArizonaNevada Academy of Science, 18: 49-60.
Gitelson, A.A., Merzlyak, M.N. and Chivkunova, O.B. 2001.
Optical properties and nondestructive estimation of
anthocyanin content in plant leaves. Photochem. Photobio.,
74(1): 38–45.
Qi, J., Chehbouni, A., Huete, A.R., Kerr, Y.H. and Sorooshian,
S. 1994. A modified soil adjusted vegetation index. Remote
Sens. Environ., 48(2): 119–126.
Grenzdorffer, G. 1997. Remote sensing and G1S for a sitespecifıc farm management. In: Stafford, J.Y. (ed.). Precis.
Agric., 2: 687-695. Bios Scien. Pub., Oxford OX4 İRE, UK.
Rahim, B.A.H.R., Lokman, B.M.Q. and Harun, S.W. 2016.
Applied light-side coupling with optimized spiralpatterned zinc oxide nanorod coatings for multiple optical
channel alcohol vapor sensing. J. Nanophotonics, 10(3).
Article ID 036009.
Hatfield, J.L. and Pinter, P.J. 1993. Remote sensing for crop
protection. Crop Prot., 12(6): 403-413.
Hoffmann, H., Nieto, H., Jensen, R., Guzinski, R., Zarco-Tejada,
P.J. and Friborg, T. 2015. Estimating evapotranspiration
with thermal UAV data and two-source energy balance
models. Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 12(8): 7469–7502.
Richardson, A.J. and Weigand, C. 1977. Distinguishing
vegetation from soil background information. Photogram.
Eng. Remote Sens., pp. 43.
Honkavaara, E., Saari, H. and Kaivosoja, J. 2013. Processing
and assessment of spectrometric, stereoscopic imagery
collected using a lightweight UAV spectral camera for
precision agriculture. Remote Sens., 5(10): 5006–5039.
Rouse Jr., J.W., Haas, R., Schell, J. and Deering, D. 1974.
Monitoring vegetation systems in the great plains with
erts, NASA Special Publication, 351: 309.
Sahu, B., Chatterjee, S., Mukherjee, S. and Sharma, C. 2019.
Tools of precision agriculture: A review. Int. J. Chem. Stud.,
7(6): 2692-2697.
Huete, A.R. 1988. A soil adjusted vegetation index (SAVI).
Remote Sens. Environ., 25(3): 295–309.
Huggin, D.R. and Alderfer, R.D. 1995. Yield variability within
a long-term corn management study: Implications for
precision farming. In: Proc. Site-Specific Management for
Agricultural Systems. P.C. Robert, R.H. Rust, W.E. Larson
(eds.). Agron. J., pp. 417-426.
Schepers, J.S. and Francis, D.D. 1998. Precision agriculture—
what’s in our future. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal., 29(1114): 1463-1469.
Seyhan, I. 2004. RS & GIS (Remote Sensing & Geographical
Information Systems). pp. 4, http://www.mta.gov.tr/
RSC_WEB/rsgis.html
Jordan, C.F. 1969. Derivation of leaf area index from quality
of light on the forest floor. Ecology, 50(4): 663–666.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
284
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Role of Multispectral Vegetation Indices in Precision Agriculture – A Review
Sinclair, T.R., Hoffer, R.M. and Scheiber, M.M. 1971.
Reflectance and internal structure of leaves from several
crops during a growing season. Agron. J., 63: 864-868.
Thomas, J.R. and Oerther. G.F. 1972. Estimating nitrogen
content of sweet paper leaves by reflectance measurements;
Agron. J., pp. 11-13.
Stafford, J.V., Ambler, B. and Bolam, H.C. 1997. Cut width
sensors to improve the accuracy of yield mapping
systems. Precis. Agric., 2: 23-53.
Wenlong, X.D.L. 2009. Vegetation index controlling the
influence of soil reflection. http://www.paper.edu.cn/
releasepaper/ content/200906-376.
Suits, G.H. 1983. The nature of Electromagnetic Radiation.
Manual of Remote Sens., 1: 37-60.
Xue, J. and Su, B. 2017. Significant Remote Sensing Vegetation
Indices: A Review of Developments and Applications. J.
Sens., pp. 1-17.
Tanrıverdi, C. 2003. Available water effects on water stress
indices for irrigated corn grown in sandy soils. Ph.
D. Thesis, Department of Chemical and Bioresource
Engineering, Colorado State University, Fall 2003.
Yin, N., Liu, R., Zeng, B. and Liu, N. 2019. A review: UAVbased Remote Sensing. In IOP Conference Series:
Materials Science and Engineering. 490(6).
Tanriverdí, Ç. 2006. A Review of Remote Sensing and
Vegetation Indices in Precision Farming. J. King Saud
Univ. Eng. Sci., 9(1): 69-76.
Zhang, C. and Kovacs, J.M. 2012. The application of small
unmanned aerial systems for precision agriculture: a
review. Precis. Agric., 13(6): 693–712.
Thenkabail, P.S., Ward, A.D and Lyon J.G. 1994. Impacts
of Agricultural Management Practices on Soybean and
Corn Crops Evident in Ground-truth Data and Thematic
Mapper Vegetation Indices. Trans. ASAE. 37(3): 989-995.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
285
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 287-297, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.2
Three-Dimensional Printing in Food Process Engineering:
A Prospective and Retrospective Analysis
Amrutha, G.* and Bhagyashree N Patil
Department of Agricultural Process Engineering, Dr. Panjabrao Deshmukh Krishi Vidyapeeth, Akola, Maharashtra, India
*Corresponding author: amruthagnirmalyam@gmail.com (ORCID ID: 0000-0002-8767-2840)
Paper No. 987
Received: 31-05-2022
Revised: 28-06-2022
Accepted: 07-07-2022
ABSTRACT
Three-dimensional printing technology is a novelty which is going to usher the new aeon of localised
manufacturing by promising to transfigure food formulation as well as manufacturing process. As
compared to the food manufacturing processes based on robotics, three-dimensional food printing
combines both the 3D printing and the technique of digital gastronomy to fabricate food products with
personalization in shape, texture, color, even nutrition and flavor. This brings up artistic proficiencies to
fine dining and extend personalization capabilities to industrial culinary sector. 3D printing is a technology
which uses a number of additive manufacturing techniques for food product fabrication. The objective of
the study is to analyse various printable materials, printing platforms, and the food printing mechanisms.
This study also provides a better insight towards the different advantages and limitations of food product
fabrication using 3D food printing. This study is done to analyse and summarise published papers and
articles relating to 3D printing, its impact on food process engineering and also to provide an insight
to the direction of its future. The printing technique comprising of extrusion based and inkjet printing
and binder jetting. From this technology review, it’s clear that the food printing may exert a significant
influence on various types of food processing, which allow designers/users to manipulate/customize
forms and materials with enhanced and unprecedented capability.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm Different materials that can be used for 3D food printing were discussed.
mm Technologies adopted for printing were reviewed.
mm Advantages and limitations of food customization were analysed.
Keywords: 3D food printing, printing platforms, multi-materials, extrusion-based printing, sintering
technology
Food, consisting essentially of protein, carbohydrate,
fat and other nutrients used in the body of an
organism, being any substance that is eaten,
drunk or taken into the body to sustain life. Food
products are rapidly evolving, so there is an
increasing demand for its manufacturing field to
follow up the novel practices and tools to work
effectively. About 15-25% of people over 50 years
of age endure from swallowing difficulties. Pureed
foods not only overcome this difficulty but also
provides the necessary nutrition to them, but
most of them are unpleasing and unappetizing.
Customization has been marked as the driving
force to hamper conventional ways to produce and
deliver food. There is an expanding market demand
for mass customization on colors, textures, shapes,
nutrition flavors etc., which covers many of the
food products including customized ice creams,
cakes, coffees, hamburgers and biscuits. Most of
the food structuring techniques are developed
for mass production. Personalized foods are
How to cite this article: Amrutha, G. and Patil, B.N. (2022). ThreeDimensional Printing in Food Process Engineering: A Prospective and
Retrospective Analysis. Int. J. Ag. Env. Biotech., 15(Special Issue): 287297.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Amrutha and Patil
generally designed by specially trained artisans
using methods, which involves assembling of
prefabricated parts to meet customer demands.
But producing a small number of such pieces are
not at all economical (Sun et al. 2015a). So, in order
to achieve mass customization economically, an
innovative technology to design and fabricate food
is necessary.
and lifestyle by flawlessly integrating nutrition
and enables manufacturing of customized
foods (Rodgers 2016). Usually dehydrated raw
materials are preferred for 3D printing to evade
the deterioration of raw/fresh ingredients (Nachal
et al. 2019). The 3D printers have an ability to
use dehydrated foods or can dehydrate the foods
after printing. This makes 3D printing technology
convenient for producing space foods as compared
to the traditional processing methods where it
requires longer nutritional stability (Terfansky and
Thangavelu 2013). By altering or eliminating or
decreasing the protein, fibre, vitamin, cellulose and
fat contents, and by introducing some functional
compounds including carotenoids and anthocyanins
to give desired functions, with relative ease, 3D
printing technology can produce personalized food
for pregnant women and athletes (Dankar et al.
2018). These printed foods with upgraded taste and
visual appeal are suitable not only to elderly people
and patients with paralysis, Parkinson’s disease
and stroke but also for children and teenagers with
specific nutritional needs (Portanguen et al. 2019;
Hamilton et al. 2018). In fact, 3D printing facilitates
fabrication of customized foods, having both health
promoting as well as enjoyment factors (Severini
and Derossi 2018).
Three-dimensional food printing, established since
1980’s, alias additive layer manufacturing, is a novel
technology which unites additive manufacturing,
numerical control technology, computer technology,
material science technology and precision drive
technology to produce custom designed 3D food
objects in a layer-by-layer fashion without object
specific moulding, tooling or human intervention
(Yang et al. 2019). Thus, this technique can enhance
production efficiency and decrease manufacturing
cost for personalized food product fabrication.
Also, it has its advantages on food structure
personalization, broadening food raw material
source, shortening of food supply chain and
customized nutrition (Godoi et al. 2016; Chen 2016).
This food printing, an automated manufacturing
technique, has achieved increased attention for its
unique ability to make complex geometric structures,
allowing mass production with environment as
well as economic benefits, leans on layer-by-layer
deposition (Perez et al. 2019). The object designs are
made by Computer Aided Design (CAD) software
and the food printer is generally connected to a
computer system through a USB cable. The products
are fabricated on the basis of 3D models and can
be structured into any shape in theory. 3D printers
are robotics-based machines that can be used
fabricate objects through additive manufacturing.
In this, printers take only the essential matter
in powder or filament, and liquid forms, which
the printer then melts or solidifies to obtain the
objects final shape, instead of defining shape by
eliminating excess raw materials. This process holds
great scope for manufacturing as it exceptionally
amends all the supply chain dynamics, eliminate
the need for economies of scale and also reduces
cost, energy consumption, time, and transportation
requirements.
This study systematically reviews about the 3D
printing technology, in detail, applied to food
process engineering. The review provides insights
about the available printing materials, functional
ingredients used in printable food formulas, food
printing platforms, printing recipes and various 3D
printing technologies. Also, it explores the relative
advantages of this technique in maintaining quality
of 3D printed foods and features prospects of future
research.
AVAILABLE PRINTING MATERIALS
The available materials for food printing are
categorised in to three; natively printable materials,
non- printable traditional food materials and
alternative ingredients (Sun et al. 2015a).
Natively printable materials
Natively printable materials are the materials that
can be smoothly extruded from a syringe and
which shows the ability to maintain their shape
after deposition and no further post processing
In food processing industry, the 3D printing
technique satisfies the need of consumers in
accordance with their occupation, age, gender
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
288
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Three-Dimensional Printing in Food Process Engineering...
et al. (2010) conducted an investigation and found
out one particular recipe that can print complex
3D models and maintains their shape even after
deep frying.
is required after printing. These materials include
hummus, cake frosting, hydrogels, chocolate and
soft cheese (Dankar et al. 2018). The highlight of
such materials is that the food products made by
them can be personalized fully for nutritional value,
taste and texture. Although, majority of them are
not treated as main courses so these are generally
reserved for space as well as medical applications.
Certain formulations including protein pastes
doesn’t retain their shape easily so it requires
further processing to improve nutrition absorption
and taste (Cohen et al. 2009; Lipton et al. 2010; Sun
et al. 2015b).
Alternative ingredients
These ingredients extracted from fungi, insects,
lupine, algae and seaweeds are the emerging
sources of fibre and protein. Combination of
extrudable icing, soft cheese and insect powders
were utilized as printing materials for making tasty
pieces and shaping food structures in the ‘Insects Au
Gratin’ project (Southerland et al. 2011). Agricultural
as well as food processing residues can be used
as sources of eco-friendly printing materials, by
converting the residues in to enzymes, biologically
active metabolites and food flavor compounds.
In short, including alternative ingredients to 3D
printing would benefit in creating healthier food
products (Sun et al. 2018).
Non printable traditional materials
The foods which are consumed by people on daily
basis such as rice, fruits and vegetables, meat etc. are
not generally printable in nature. In order to make
them capable for extrusion, additives (hydrocolloids)
can be added and also it can be utilized by many
culinary fields. Using gastronomic tricks, certain
semi solid and solid food items have been already
altered to become printable but when it comes to
the entire list, it’s really difficult to modify and
test. Fabricating an element set by using a limited
number of ingredients assuring high degree of
freedom on flavor and texture is the only potential
solution. Concentration of xanthun gum, gelatin
and certain other hydrocolloids are fine tuned to
obtain a great range of textures (Cohen et al. 2009).
A greater number of traditional edibles requires post
deposition processing (baking or steaming) after
printing, but it finally result to a non-homogenous
texture. So, in order to modify cooking recipes for
printing as well as post deposition cooking, Lipton
3D FOOD PRINTING TECHNOLOGIES
Food pieces are created in a layer-by-layer fashion
using food printing, which doesn’t need any
high energy source for completely extracting
liquid components from food composition. After
deposition, the layers need not be fully solidified
but the layers should process adequate rigidity
and strength to hold up their own and subsequent
layer’s weight without remarkable deformation or
change in shape. The standard of food items, which
are fabricated using food printing technology rely
on the process and planning instead of people’s
skill. A comparison between 3D food printing
technologies is shown in Table 2.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1: (a) Selective laser sintering (b) Selective hot air sintering
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
289
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Amrutha and Patil
Table 1: Overview of various food materials successfully printed using extrusion-based 3D-printing
Class
Material
Additive
References
Protein
Turkey meat and scallop
Transglutaminase
Lipton et al. 2010
Cereal dough snack with yellow
mealworm powder
Sodium chloride
Wang et al. 2017
Severini et al. 2018
Fish surimi gel
Lipids
Bacon fat
Lipton et al. 2010
Chocolate
Godoi et al. 2016
Le Tohicet al. 2018
Cheese
Carbohydrates
Lemon juice gel
Potato starch
Lipton et al. 2010
Mashed potato
Potato starch
Derossi et al. 2017
Fruit snack
Pectin
Yang et al. 2018a
Smoothie
Fish collagen
Severini et al. 2018
Pectin
Agar, alginate,glycerol,
lecithin
Lille et al. 2018
Pea protein
Kim et al. 2018
Hydrocolloids
Baking cookies
Chuanxing et al. 2018
Fruit snack
Skim milk powder
Selective sintering technology
Extrusion based food printing techniques depends
on continuous flow of ink in layer-by-layer manner,
usually heavily concentrated colloidal inks. Based
on the ability of a material to form gel or to achieve
paste consistency, the total solids can range from
5-50% concentration. When a pressure gradient
ΔP through a length of l is applied, the ink starts
flowing through the nozzle. Thus, according to Eq.
1, a radially changing shear stress (τr) is developed,
where r denotes the radial position within nozzle
(Godoi et al. 2016). At the centre of nozzle wall
(r=R), velocity is zero, and at centre (r=0), velocity
is maximum (Lewis 2002). The absolute aim of this
method is to obtain the output of food extrusion
cooking with customized nutrition control and
digitalized design.
Selective sintering technology is a technique that
generally uses a power laser or hot air as a source to
selectively bind the particles in powder form layer
by layer and finally to a 3D structure. In order to
sinter NesQuik powders and sugars, TNO’s food
jetting printer used laser and thus built 3D objects
(Gray 2010). The material, which is sintered forms
the product part while the remaining un-sintered
powder provides support to the structure. A low
velocity hot air stream is used to melt and sinter a
bed of sugar by the CandyFab (2007). The created
powder bed is heated to a temperature which is
just lower than the melting point of that material
so as enable fusion to the preceding layer and to
reduce thermal distortion. Both hot air and laser
sintering processes enables to rapidly build food
items in a short span of time without any further
curing. However, their limitation is that they are
only appropriate for fat-based materials and sugar,
having relatively low melting point, and also as it
involves so many variables, machine structure as
well as the fabrication processes will be complicated
(Sun et al. 2018).
τr =
…(1)
Extrusion based food printers are badly limited by
material choices, delamination due to temperature
fluctuation and long fabrication time but these
printers are of compact size and low maintenance
cost (Sun et al. 2018). Table 1 gives an idea of various
food materials that can be printed using extrusionbased 3D Printing.
Extrusion based 3D Printing
The process of forcing solid/semi solid/liquid
materials via die opening for fabricating objects with
required cross-section is extrusion (Sun et al. 2018).
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
r ∆P
2l
Melting Extrusion
Materials in the form of powder, filament and paste
290
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Three-Dimensional Printing in Food Process Engineering...
are generally considered as the suitable materials for
melting extrusion. In order ensure printability, it is
necessary to control temperature during printing
of fat or sugar rich pastes. Chocolate, the most
commonly used edible ink because of its melting
properties, can be fed to the reservoir of printer
either in powder form or in paste like/melted
form (Mantilal et al. 2020). Edible filaments are
rarely produced and printed. Goyanes et al. (2015)
created various filaments, which contains caffeine or
paracetamol in a water-soluble polymer appropriate
for 3D printing into different pharmaceutical dosage
forms. If the filament production is followed by
fused deposition modelling (FDM), then the post
processing procedures which is generally required
for food printing can be avoided. In food processing
applications, it’s believed that the food grade
filaments will find its usage in the confection of
packaging of foods (Godoi et al. 2019).
difficulties. This temperature control is utilized for
making many economic machines including HFE for
fruit printing (Molitch-Hou 2014), hot melt extrusion
(HME) for printing chocolate (Choc Edge 2014),
room temperature extrusion (RTE) for printing (Alec
2015; Molitch-Hou 2014).
Binder Jetting
In this technology, every single layer of powder
is uniformly distributed across the platform of
fabrication, and then a liquid binder sprays to
join two consecutive layers (Sachs et al. 1992). In
order to stabilize powder material and reduce
disturbance occurs due to binder dispensing, a layer
of water mist should be sprayed before fabrication.
Sugar Lab in 2013 utilized different flavor binders
and sugar for fabricating sculptural cakes which
are complex in nature for special events and the
fabrication utilized 3D System’s color jet printing
technique (3D Systems 2013). Binder jetting provides
fast fabrication with low material cost, but at the
same time, it suffers from high machine cost and
rough surface finish (Sun et al. 2015a). Also, in most
cases it requires post processing, including curing
at increased temperature, for strengthening the
bonding.
Hydrogel Forming Extrusion (HFE)
It is the method of extruding hydrocolloid solutions
in to a gel/polymer setting bath with the help of
a vibrating nozzle, syringe pipette, jet cutter and
similar apparatus. Diameter of these gel droplets
should be in the range of 0.2-5 mm and the key to
form stable shapes in HFE is controlling solution’s
temperature (Sun et al. 2018).
Fig. 3: Powder bed binder jetting
Inkjet Printing
Commercialization of Inkjet printing technology in
food printing had done by the company FoodJet
(FoodJet 2019). Inkjet printing uses an array of
pneumatic membrane nozzle-jets which dispenses
a stream of droplets of food ink onto cookies,
biscuits, cupcakes, and pizza bases (Kruth et al.
2007). Two types of inkjet printing methods are
Fig. 2: HFE
This process exclusively depends on the gel forming
mechanism and the rheological behaviour of
polymer. Serizawa et al. (2014) created an edible gel
3D printer using a dispenser and syringe pump for
producing soft foods for those who have swallowing
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
291
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Amrutha and Patil
Table 2: Comparison of 3D food printing technologies
Sintering technology
Melting extrusion
Binder jetting
Inkjet printing
Materials
Low melting powder
Food polymers
such as sugar, NesQuik (chocolate)
or fat.
Powder such as starch, sugars, Low viscosity materials
flavors, corn flour and liquid (paste or puree)
binder
Platform
1. Motorized stage
1. Motorized stage
1. Motorized stage
1. Motorized stage
2. Sintering unit
2. Heating unit
2. Powder bed
2. Inkjet printhead
3. Powder bed
3. Extrusion device
3. Inkjet print-head for binder 3. Thermal control unit
jetting
Printing
resolution
Powder size: 100 μm
Nozzle dia: 0.5-1.5 mm Nozzle dia ≤ 50 μm
Fabricated
products
Food-grade art objects, Customized chocolates Sugar cube in full color
toffee shapes
Customized cookies, Benchtop food paste shaping
Pros
1. Better printing
quality
Better printing quality
Nozzle dia ≤ 50 μm
Powder particle ≥ 100 μm
2. Complex design
1. Cost effective
1. More material choices
2. Fast fabrication
2. Better printing quality
3. Full color potential
4. Complex design
Cons
1. Expensive platform
Low printing quality
2. High power
consumption
1. Slow fabrication
1. Slow fabrication
2. Expensive platform
2. Expensive print-head
3. Expensive platform
3. Limited materials
4. Limited materials
Machine
Food jetting printer
Choc Creator
Chefjet
Foodjet
Company
TNO
Choc Edge
3D systems
De Grood Innovations
Sun et al. 2015b; Godoi et al. 2019.
there: Continuous Ink-Jet Printing (C-IJP) and
Drop-on-Demand Inkjet Printing (DoD-IJP). In
the former, ink is dispensed continuously through
a piezoelectric crystal vibrating at a constant
frequency. The later, DoD-IJP, ink is ejected out
from heads under pressure exerted by the valve.
In DoD-IJP the printing rates are slower than that
of C-IJP systems, but the precision and resolution
of produced images are higher. However, DoD-IJP
requires the use of an electrically conducting fluid
which limits the application in food customization.
materials which don’t have enough mechanical
strength to hold a 3D structure. Therefore, it is
rather used for printing drawings over flat surfaces
as surface filling or Image decorations (Pallottino
et al. 2016). Grood and Grood (2011) had created
DoD-IJP to lay edible liquid onto food surfaces to
create appealing images. The FoodJet printer uses
pneumatic membrane nozzle jets to dispense edible
drops onto a moving object to form an appealing
surface (FoodJet 2019).
PRINTING QUALITY ASSESSMENT
There are generally two important parameters by
which the printing quality of a final 3D product
is judged. They are shape fidelity and mechanical
properties. The criteria for evaluating the printing
quality are explained in Table 3.
Shape Fidelity
He et al. (2019) illustrated that except from printing
parameters including printing distance, air pressure
and feed rate, lattice area (A) and line distance (D)
will also have an impact on gel lattice’s printing
quality. The optimum condition for printing can
Fig. 4: Inkjet printing
In general, inkjet printing deals with low-viscosity
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
292
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Three-Dimensional Printing in Food Process Engineering...
Table 3: Criteria for printing quality evaluation
Printing Quality Score
Description
5
The paste should pass through nozzle smoothly. Shape should be supported with excellent
precision. Printed and designed size should have a deviation less than 2%. There should not be
any distortion of layer-by-layer structure.
4
The paste should pass through nozzle smoothly. Printed and designed size should have a
deviation should be in the range of 2-5%. The layer which is distorted is within 5% of the entire
layer-by-layer structure.
3
The paste should pass through nozzle. Printed and designed size should have a deviation should
be in the range of 5-15%. The layer which is distorted is within 5-15% of the entire layer-by-layer
structure.
2
The paste should pass through nozzle but the shape get collapse while printing or the collapse
within 30 minutes after printing the complete shape.
1
Because of low viscosity, the printed shape will not be able to support the shape or the paste could
not flow through the nozzle because of high viscosity.
Liu and Ciftci 2020.
also be evaluated by observing the filament material
shape extruded from nozzle. The optimum gelation,
characterized by an evenly extruded filament
in a smooth surface and in three dimensions is
illustrated in Fig. 5. It is possible to observe the
liquid like behaviour of ink and droplet formation
at the end of nozzle at stages of under gelation. A
stiff filament with cracks all over its length can be
observed when the ink is in over gelation stage. In
a lattice structure, Ouyang et al. (2016) exemplified
that the printability and circularity level of internal
square areas can be correlated. The quality of
printing of gel-like inks can be evaluated using
Eq. 2 and 3. It has been observed that if Pr=1, ideal
gelation is obtained and if Pr<1or Pr>1, it is the stage
of under gelation and over gelation respectively.
Circularity, C =
2
Pr = π ∗ 1 = L
4 C 16 A
…(2)
…(3)
Mechanical Properties of a 3D Printed Object
Texture analyser helps to measure hardness test of
solid food objects and the Texture Profile Analysis
(TPA) of semihard materials. The mechanical
properties of 3D printed food structures, made
of gels or purees or such soft materials can be
evaluated using TPA. The important attributes to
be generally calculated for gel like systems are
adhesiveness, chewiness, springiness, hardness
and gumminess (Rosenthal 2010). The mechanical
properties of gellan gum, guar gum, xanthan gum,
hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, locus bean gum,
methylcellulose and gelatin were analysed by
Kim et al. (2017) and found that the hardness of
samples significantly increases by increasing the
concentration. The impact of starch addition in
the 3D construct made of lemon juice gels were
observed by Yang et al. (2018a, b). The higher starch
content results in notable increase of gumminess
and hardness as a result of heavily compacted
network bore by starch molecules.
TPA fails when it comes to hard materials. In those
cases, texture analyser can be used for measuring
hardness of freeze dried or oven dried protein rich
3D printed structures (Lille et al. 2018). The snap
Fig. 5: Schematic demonstration of filament quality. At
the left end, 3D lattice is shown emphasising the internal
square shape, which can be transformed into the printability
parameter at three levels (Pr < 1, Pr = 1 and Pr > 1)
(Ouyang et al. 2016)
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
4π A
L2
293
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Amrutha and Patil
quality of printed chocolate objects has been studied
by Mantihal et al. (2020) and found the importance
of supports on snap force, with the help of texture
analyser.
fabricated products (Sun et al. 2015c). Using multimaterials and multi-printheads are a new solution
to mould food materials under multi scale into
fascinating edible structures.
MULTI-MATERIAL AND MULTIPRINTHEAD
ADVANTAGES AND LIMITATIONS OF
FOOD PRODUCT FABRICATION WITH
3D PRINTING
There is a need of multi-printheads in the food
printing sector for maintaining homogeneity as
majority of printers have only one print head for
extruding mixture of materials, which makes it
difficult to control the distribution of materials
within a layer. In this, platform controller activates
each print head and thus gives information to
individual layers and also controls its feed rate.
Researchers had adopted multiple print heads Fab@
homeTM printers and created products including
chocolate, muffins, cookie doughs, processed cheese
etc. When it comes to multi-material printing, it is
applicable only for a limited number of materials.
Gray, (2010) solved this limitation by proposing the
concept of electrospinning for producing multiple
sub-components of food at a large scale.
(a)
Three-dimensional food printing has widely noticed
by food enthusiasts all over the world as it has made
so many hitherto impossible things possible. This
technology made production of food seamless and
fast. The major advantage is that it made possible
to design the food so as to meet the concerns of
individual related to their requirements and health
conditions effectively and also it digitally manage
the quality and quantity of food. In addition to this,
it helps to reduce the waste output and improves
sustainability of environment. This technology
becomes eco-friendly and healthy since it converts
various ingredients such as leaves from beets or
insects, algae-based proteins into tasty food items. It
also can utilize animal proteins which are developed
in the laboratory or vegetable proteins to make
meat substitutes that has high nutritional value and
health benefits for intake.
In spite of these advantages, this technology faces
certain constraints in fabricating 3D foods such
as high cost of the printing machine, material
suitability for printing, less embodiment of foodsafe printing components, and lack of printing
firmware (food based) and software applications
(Kewuyemi et al. 2021). The advantages, limitations
and suggestions for future work are explained in
the following sub-heads.
(b)
Fig. 6: Multi-material food design and fabrication system (a)
Multi-material food designs (b) Actual printed cookies
In spite of using multi printheads, it is really
difficult to make a single platform for printing food
types. Another approach to this is to create a macro
material matrix with the help of mixing technique.
This matrix enables to sustain homogeneity of
material supply within each layer. This mixing
technique can be agitated or static and can enable
different material composition and making several
material supply combinations (Nachal et al. 2019).
Static mixing focusses on the force between the feed
and force of friction between mixer’s structure and
the material. Agitated mixing provides better scope
for changing the appearance and composition of
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Available firmware and slicing software
In order to communicate the mechanical path of a
3D model, various printers with a firmware (builtin) and slicing software are used and it helps in
accurate layer by layer deposition of materials.
The mostly used slicing software packages, such
as Repetier-Host, Slic3r, Cura, Slimplify3D and
Rhinoceros 3D, in order to circulate the planned
mechanical route instructions and conditions of
processing to 3D food printers are programmed
for thermoplastic polymer printing. The elastic
nature of printing material can result in certain
inconsistencies in printing during deposition or after
294
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Three-Dimensional Printing in Food Process Engineering...
Marketing of 3D Printed Foods
the printing process. A digital 3D model solid phase
(30g/100g), processing a doubles percentage volume
fraction from 36% to 69% in wheat alternated with
succulent insect printed snack has been reported.
It is important to optimize the available slicing
software for printing processes or a lasting way of
creating slicing application packages for fabricating
3D foods (Guo et al. 2019).
This is an attractive technology of food preparation
and personalization engineered in pre-defined
layers. The adaptability of processing various
raw materials and increasing need of food items,
fabricated using this technology are the key driving
forces to industrial growth to attain an expected
global 3D food printing market size of 1015.4 million
US dollars in 2027 (Emergen Research 2021). Food
Ink, is emerged as the first pop-up restaurant to
provide meals made using 3D printers. Barilla,
is the first Italian company, which developed the
prototype of 3D printer for pasta (Savastano et al.
2018). Its spinout has introduced an E-commerce
service, through which customers can order
customized printed pasta online. This platform
is auspicious for promoting large market share
for novel 3D printed foods. Traditional cuisine
with prior familiarity plays a crucial role in the
sustainability of biomodified printable substrates
(Kewuyemi et al. 2021). Furthermore, the printed
healthy snacks have been accepted on the basis of
their sensory attributes (Krishnaraj et al. 2019).
3D Extrusion Printer Selection and Cost
Implication
The development of 3D printing applications is
limited by the factors such as the prohibitive cost,
inflexibility of component-parts and proprietary
restrictions (Cohen et al.2009). But, the onset of
RepRap open-source 3D printing machines has
substantially overcome these challenges. Most of
these printers are either uses a cartesian or delta
configuration, and the cost is in the range of 1606650 US dollars (Carolo, 2020). Recently, there are
dedicated edible desktop printers including Foodbot
3D printers (China), byFlow Focus 3D printer
(Netherlands), Natural Machines Foodini (Spain)
etc. (Lansard 2021).
CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK
Design of extrusion mechanism
3D food printing has proved its ability on making
personalised chocolates or fabricating simple
homogenous snacks. Anyhow, these applications
are still basic with limited internal structures or
monotonous textures. It is important to develop a
systematic way to examine the printing materials,
platform design, printing technologies and their
influences on food fabrication. Meanwhile, the food
designing process should be structured to encourage
user’s creativity, the fabrication procedure should
be quantified to achieve consistency in fabrication
results, and a simulation model should be developed
to combine design and fabrication with nutrition
control. With the evolution of an interactive open
web-based user interface, 3D food printers can
become part of an ecology system, where networked
machines can order new ingredients, prepare
favourite food item on demand and even collaborate
with doctors to develop/customize healthier diets.
Generally, the food printing extrusion mechanisms
works on the basis of syringe driven (stepper motor
or air pressure) or screw (driver: stepper motor)
systems. A syringe’s fusion consisting of a piston,
tightly connected with a hose, which supplies
compressed air for driving the loaded feed in a
barrel(plastic) is depicted in the study of Liu and
Cift, (2020). This kind of setup becomes a successful
manipulation approach for 3D food printing.Guo et
al. (2019) found out that the syringe-based printing
system possess simple fluid characteristics with
low pressure at the outlet of nozzle and high shear
rate but the screw-based systems exhibit complex
fluid characteristics with backflows between screw
flight and barrel walls and a high shear rate. The
existing printing systems can be upgraded from
current batch-printing cycles to make remote food
grade holding tanks of stainless steel, regulated over
a set of conditions such as relative humidity and
temperature for suitability of different food systems
(Lanaro et al. 2017).
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
This study reviews about different food printing
technologies, the various available printing
materials, advantages and limitations of food
product fabrication with 3D printing. From this
295
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Amrutha and Patil
technology review, it can be seen that food printing
may exert a significant influence on various types
of food processing, which allow designers/users
to manipulate/customize forms and materials
with enhanced and unprecedented capability. This
adaptability, applied to domestic catering or cooking
service, can improve efficiency to provide high
quality, freshly prepared food items to consumers,
deliver personalized nutrition and enable users to
develop new flavors, textures and shapes to create
entirely new eating experiences.
An introduction to the principles of 3D food printing.
Fundamentals of 3D Food Printing and Applications.
Godoi, F.C., Prakash, S. and Bhandari, B.R. 2016. 3D Printing
Technologies Applied for Food Design: Status and
Prospects. J. of Food Engineering, 174: 44-54.
Goyanes, A., Wang, J., Buanz, A., Martı´nez-Pacheco, R.,
Telford, R., Gaisford, S. and Basit, A.W. 2015. 3D printing
of medicines: engineering novel oral devices with
unique design and drug release characteristics. Molecular
Pharmaceutics.
Gray, N. 2010. Looking to the future: Creating novel foods
using 3D printing. http://www.foodnavigator.com/
Science-Nutrition/Looking-to-the-future-Creating-novelfoods-using-3Dprinting. Last Accessed 23 Dec 2021
REFERENCES
Grood, J.P.W. and Grood, P.J. 2011. Method and Device for
Dispensing a Liquid (Google Patents).
3D Systems. 2013. 3D systems acquires the Sugar Lab,. http://
www.3dsystems.com/de/pressreleases/3d-systemsacquires-sugar-lab. Last Accessed 22th Dec. 2021.
Guo, C., Zhang, M. and Bhandari, B. 2019. Model building
and slicing in food 3D printing processes: A Review.
Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 18
(4): 1052–69.
Alec. 2015. Pasta maker Barilla to show off its 3D pasta printer
at the Milan EXPO 2015. 3ders.org http://www.3ders.org/
articles/20150505-pasta-maker-barilla-to-show-off-its-3dpastaprinter-at-the-milan-expo-2015.html. Last Accessed
17th Dec. 2021.
Hamilton, C., Alan, G. and Panhuis, M. 2018. 3D printing
vegemite and marmite: redefining “breadboards”. J. of
Food Engineering, 220: 83-88.
CandyFab. 2007. The CandyFab project. Available at http://
wiki.candyfab.org/Main Page. Last Accessed 14th Dec.
2021.
He, C., Zhang, M. and Fang, Z. 2019. 3D printing of food:
pretreatment and post-treatment of materials. Critical
Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition.
Carolo, L. 2020. Top 10 open-source 3D printers. https://
all3dp.com/2/open-source-3d-printer-designs/, Accessed
March 20, 2021.
Kewuyemi, Y.O., Kesa, H. and Adebo OA. 2021. Trends in
functional food development with three-dimensional
(3D) food printing technology: prospects for value-added
traditionally processed food products. Critical Reviews in
Food Science and Nutrition.
Chen, Z. 2016. Research on the impact of 3D printing on the
international supply chain. Advances in Materials Science
and Engineering, pp. 1–16.
Kim, H.W., Bae, H. and Park, H.J. 2018. Reprint of:
Classification of the printability of selected food for 3D
printing: Development of an assessment method using
hydrocolloids as reference material. J. of Food Engineering,
220: 28–37.
Choc Edge. 2014. Choc Creator. http://chocedge.com/,
Accessed Dec 2014
Chuanxing, F., Qi, W., Hui, L., Quancheng, Z. and Wang,
M. 2018. Effects of pea protein on the properties of
potato starch-based 3D printing materials. Int. J. of Food
Engineering.
Kim, H.W., Bae, H. and Park, H.J. 2017. Classification of the
printability of selected food for 3D printing: development
of an assessment method using hydrocolloids as reference
material. J. of Food Engineering, 215: 23-32.
Cohen, D.L., Jeffrey, I.L., Cutler, M., Coulter, D., Vesco, A. and
Lipson, H.2009. Hydrocolloid printing: a novel platform
for customized food production. In: Proceedings of solid
freeform fabrication symposium (SFF’09), 3–5 August
2009, Austin, TX, USA.
Krishnaraj, P., Anukiruthika, T., Choudhary, P., Moses, J. and
Anandharamakrishnan, C. 2019. 3D extrusion printing
and post-processing of fibre-rich snack from indigenous
composite flour. Food and Bioprocess Technology, 12(10):
1776–86.
Dankar, I., Haddarah, A., Omar, F.E.L., Sepulcre, F. and Pujola,
M. 2018. 3D printing technology: The new era for food
customization and elaboration. Trends in Food Science &
Technology, 75: 231–42.
Kruth, J.P., Levy, G., Klocke, F. and Childs, T.H.C. 2007.
Consolidation phenomena in laser and powder-bed based
layered manufacturing. CIRP Annuals - Manufacturing
Technology, 56:730-759.
Derossi, A., Caporizzi, R., Azzollini, D. and Severini, C. 2017.
Application of 3D printing for customized food. A case
on the development of a fruit-based snack for children.
J. of Food Engineering, 220: 65–75.
Lanaro, M., D. Forrestal, S. Scheurer, D. Slinger, S. Liao, S.
Powell, and M. Woodruff. 2017. 3D printing complex
chocolate objects: Platform design, optimization and
evaluation. J of Food Engineering, 215:13–22.
Emergen Research. 2021. 3D Food Printing Market Size to
Reach USD 1,015.4 Million in 2027. Accessed March 21,
2021.
Lansard, M. 2021. Food 3D printing: 7 food 3D printers
available in 2021. https://www.aniwaa.com/buyersguide/3d-printers/food-3dprinters/. Accessed March 20,
2021
Food Jet: Retrieved 2019 from. 2019 https://www.foodjet.com.
Godoi, F.C., Bhandari, B.R., Prakash, S. and Zhang, M. 2019.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
296
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Three-Dimensional Printing in Food Process Engineering...
Le Tohic, C., O’Sullivan, J.J., Drapala, K.P., Chartrin, V.,
Chan, T., Morrison, A.P. and Kelly, A.L. 2018. Effect of
3D printing on the structure and textural properties of
processed cheese. J. of Food Engineering, 220: 56–64.
Sachs, E., Cima, M. and Williams, P. 1992. Three-dimensional
printing: rapid tooling and prototypes directly from a
CAD model. J. Manufacturing Science Engineering, 114(4):
481–488.
Lewis, J.A. 2002. Direct-write assembly of ceramics from
colloidal inks. Current Opinion in Solid State and
Materials Science.
Savastano, M., Amendola, C. and D’Ascenzo, F. 2018. How
digital transformation is reshaping the manufacturing
industry value chain: The new digital manufacturing
ecosystem applied to a case study from the food industry,
Lecture Notes in Information Systems and Organization.
In Network, smart and open, eds.
Lille, M., Nurmela, A., Nordlund, E., Metsa¨-Kortelainen, S.
and Sozer, N. 2018. Applicability of protein and fiber-rich
food materials in extrusion-based 3D printing. J. of Food
Engineering.
Serizawa, R., Shitara, M. and Gong, J. 2014. 3D jet printer of
edible gels for food creation. In: Proceedings of SPIE Smart
Structures and Materials: Nondestructive Evaluation and
Health Monitoring, San Diego, 9–13 Mar 2014.
Lipton, J., Arnold, D., Nigl, F., Lopez, N., Cohen, D., Norén,
N. and Lipson, H. 2010. Mutli material food printing with
complex internal structure suitable for conventional postprocessing. In: 21st Annual International Solid Freeform
Fabrication Symposium - an Additive Manufacturing
Conference, SFF 2010, 809–815.
Severini, C. and A. Derossi. 2018. Could the 3D printing
technology be a useful strategy to obtain customized
nutrition. J. of Clinical Gastroenterology, 50: S175–S8.
Liu, L. and Ciftci, O. N. 2020. Effects of high oil compositions
and printing parameters on food paste properties and
printability in a 3D printing food processing model. J. of
Food Engineering.
Severini, C., Derossi, A., Ricci, I., Caporizzi, R. and Fiore,
A. 2018. Printing a blend of fruit and vegetables. New
advances on critical variables and shelf life of 3D edible
objects. J. of Food Engineering, 220:89–100.
Mantihal, S., Kobun, R. and Boon-beng, Lee. 2020. 3D food
printing of as the new way of preparing food: A review.
Int. J. on Gastronomy and Food Science, 22: 100-260.
Southerland, D., Walters, P. and Huson, D. 2011. Edible 3D
printing. In: Proceeding of NIP & Digital Fabrication
Conference, Society for Imaging Science and Technology,
pp. 819–822.
Molitch-Hou M. 2014. The 3D fruit printer and the raspberry
that tasted like a strawberry. 3D printing industry.
https://3dprintingindustry.com/news/3d-fruit-printerraspberry-tastedlikestrawberry-27713/, Accessed Sept
2016
Sun, J., Peng, Z., Yan, L. K., Ful, Y. H. J., Hong, G. S. 2015a. 3D
food printing—An innovative way of mass customization
in food fabrication. Int. J. of Bioprinting, 1(1): 27–38.
Sun, J., Peng, Z., Zhou, W., Fuh, J. Y. H., Hong, G. S. and Chiu,
A. 2015b. A Review on 3D printing for Customized Food
Fabrication. Procedia Manufacturing, 1: 308–319.
Nachal, N., Moses, J. A., Karthik, P. and Anandharamakrishnan,
C. 2019. Applications of 3D Printing in Food Processing.
Food Engineering Reviews, 11(3): 123–41.
Sun, J., Zhou, W., Huang, D. and Yan, L. 2018. 3D food
printing: perspectives. Polymers for Food Applications.
Ouyang, L., Yao, R., Zhao, Y. and Sun, W. 2016. Effect of
bioink properties on printability and cell viability for 3D
bioplotting of embryonic stem cells. Biofabrication.
Sun, J., Zhou, W., Huang, D., Fuh, Y.H. and Hong, G.S.
2015c. An overview of 3D printing technologies for food
fabrication. Food Bioprocess Technology, 1: 308-319.
Pallottino, F., Hakola, L., Costa, C., Antonucci, F., Figorilli,
S., Seisto, A. and Menesatti, P. 2016. Printing on food or
food printing: a review. Food and Bioprocess Technology,
9: 725-733.
Terfansky, M.L. and Thangavelu, M. 2013. 3D printing of
food for space missions. AIAA SPACE 2013 Conference
and Exposition.
Perez, B., Nykvist, H., Brogger, A.F., Larsen, M.B. and
Falkebory, M.F. 2019. Impact of macronutrients printability
and 3D printer parameters on 3D-food printing: a review.
Food Chemistry, 287: 249-257.
Wang, L., Zhang, M. and Yang, C. 2017. Investigation on fish
surimi gel as promising food material for 3D printing. J.
of Food Engineering, 220: 01–108.
Yang, F., Guo, C., Zhang, M., Bhandari, B. and Liu, Y. 2019.
Improving 3D printing process of lemon juice gel based
on fluid flow numerical simulation. Food Science and
Technology, 102: 89-99.
Portanguen, S.P., Tournayre, J., Sicard, T., Astruc, and Mirade,
P.S. 2019. Toward the design of functional foods and
biobased products by 3D printing: A review. Trends in
Food Science and Technology, 86: 188–98.
Yang, F., Zhang, M., Bhandari, B. and Liu, Y. 2018a.
Investigation on lemon juice gel as food material for 3D
printing and optimization of printing parameters. Food
Science and Technology.
Rodgers, S. 2016. Minimally processed functional foods:
Technological and operational pathways. J. of Food Science,
81(10): R2309–19.
Rosenthal, A.J. 2010. Texture profile analysis - how important
are the parameters. Journal of Texture Studies.
Yang, F., Zhang, M., Prakash, S. and Liu, Y. 2018b. Physical
properties of 3D printed baking dough as affected
by different compositions. Innovative Food Science and
Emerging Technologies.
Sachs, E., Cima, M. and Cornie, J. 1990. Three dimensional
printing: rapid tooling and prototypes directly from a
CAD model. CIRP Annuals-Manufacturing Technology,
39: 201–204.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
297
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 299-306, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.3
A Study on Novel Approach to Sustainable Indian Agriculture Precision Farming
Shwetha U.N.* and Nitin S. Gupta
Department of Floriculture and Landscape Architecture, Dr. PDKV, Akola, Maharashtra, India
*Corresponding author: shwethaun0@gmail.com (ORCID ID: 0000-0002-3214-5509)
Paper No. 988
Received: 23-05-2022
Revised: 28-06-2022
Accepted: 04-07-2022
ABSTRACT
Precision farming which is also regarded as site-specific management is reported as emerging approach
that recognizes site-specific differences within-field and adjusts management action accordingly. Precision
farming utilize the advanced technologies for efficient crop production and to minimize environmental
impact caused due to over-usage of inputs. It is necessary to reduce the use of inputs by providing
prescribed quantity and to increase the crop yield. Precision farming involves various tools such as Global
Positioning System (GPS), Geographic Information System (GIS), Remote Sensing etc. for recording the
precise data and making decision according to the stored data. In India, it is high time to adopt precision
farming which leads to sustainable agriculture due to depletion of natural resources. It is stated that
precision farming has scope for its adoption in small scale farms after considering its advantages and
economics. The main purpose of this review is to understand the concept of precision farming and gaining
knowledge about its adoption, economics, merits and obstacles.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm Precision farming should reach all the farmers and its implementation helps to overcome the depletion
of natural resources and protection of environment.
Keywords: Precision farming, Site-specific management, Environmental impact, Adoption, Economics
Million years ago, man started agriculture
as a profession and used basic resources like
soil, water and air to strengthen his land and
increased the agricultural productivity. These
natural resources were degraded due to enormous
increase in population and rapid industrialization
and urbanization (Shanwad et al. 2004). Thus,
innovation in agriculture is necessary to meet
the demand and also due to use of technology
and impacts of green revolution, degradation in
environment is evident which should be reversed
through sustainable farming. The advancement of
technology and irrigation system lead to increase
in productivity but at the same time higher use of
agriculture inputs are not beneficial in increasing
productivity. The management of all resources is
essential for sustainability. Its high time to utilize
all modern tools by combining the Information
Technology and Agriculture Science because of
need for maximizing the input use efficiency, poor
availability of labors and to improve economic and
environmentally sustainable production. Before
agriculture mechanization farmers used to monitor
and fix the problems in the field mechanically but in
recent days farmers are unable to adjust variabilities
regarding yield potential, topography, nutrient
deficiencies etc. (Robert et al. 2019). This necessitates
the role of precision farming which is application
of technologies and principles to manage variability
linked with all aspects of agricultural production
How to cite this article: Shwetha, U.N. and Gupta, N.S. (2022). A
Study on Novel Approach to Sustainable Indian Agriculture - Precision
Farming. Int. J. Ag. Env. Biotech., 15(Special Issue): 299-306.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Shwetha and Gupta
for improving both production and environmental
quality.
outcomes: increased profitability and sustainability,
improved product quality, effective and efficient pest
management, energy, water and soil conservation
and surface and ground water protection. In others
words, it is digital agriculture involving very large
farm level mapping, comprehensive database
creation on required resources generated through
space-based inputs and field observation and
making a detailed plan of work for maximizing the
yield and reducing cost of inputs using decision
support system.
Precision farming has emerged as current research
topic at the end of 20 th century all over the
world (Hermann 2001). It is an integrated crop
management system that meets the crop need in
small areas within field. Precision farming can
provide technology for eco-friendly agriculture
and is more useful for famers having small land
holding in developing countries by supply of
minimum inputs and receiving profitable outcome
(Hakkim et al. 2016). Precision farming can be
achieved by use of appropriate technologies for
management and decision making. Adoption of
precision farming technologies varies according to
geography and technology used. Precision farming
is more adopted in developed countries and there
is requirement for overall adoption in large scale.
However, the developing information technologies
along with digitalization of agriculture sector are
making adoption possible by increasing the degree
of precision, expanding the applications, lowering
the cost of inputs and easing the data processing.
The profitability and efficiency of technologies will
lead to the adoption of precision farming, also
there is need for involvement of both public and
private sectors in extension process for transferring
the technology. The objective of our study is to
provide basic information about precision farming
and help out the new generation to be aware of
this technology.
Precision farming based on global positioning
system (GPS) is the management of spatial and
temporal variability at a sub-field level to improve
economic returns and reduce environment impact.
It involves both art and science to utilize advanced
technologies for increasing crop production
and minimize environmental impact. Precision
agriculture is often defined by technologies that
enable it and referred to as GPS (Global Positioning
System) agriculture or variable rate farming
or site-specific management (Patil et al. 2013).
Generally precision farming is more feasible in
large scale production. Variabilities in precision
farming includes yield potentials, topography, soil
characteristics, nutrient demands, biotic and abiotic
stresses, cultivar selections, tillage practices and
irrigation scheduling. Precision farming mainly aims
to manage and distribute inputs on a site-specific
basis rather than applying same amounts of inputs
through field. It starts by noting the variations
occurring in crop/ soil properties within the field,
mapping and later management actions are taken as
consequence of continuous investigation of spatial
variability within that field (Rains et al. 2009). This
recognizes, locates, quantify and records which can
be managed by use of specific amounts of inputs
at specific locations with the actual crop needs
for small areas within a field. By understanding
and dealing with natural variability found within
a field can increase efficiencies through precision
farming and better decision can be made about crop
production aspects.
Precision Farming
Precision farming is generally defined as an
information and technology-based farm management
system to identify, analyze and manage variability
within fields for optimum profitability, sustainability
and protection of land resource. The most suitable
definition for precision farming in the context of
Indian farming scenario could be precise application
of agricultural inputs based on soil, weather
and crop requirement to maximize sustainable
productivity, quality and profitability (Singh, A. K.
undated).
It is good to have better farm management practices
before adopting precision farming because farmers
should use information effectively. Both devices and
information tend to increase returns to farmers.
Maximum economic return can be achieved
through precision farming compared to traditional
One generic definition is the kind of agriculture
that increases the number of decisions per unit area
of land per unit time with associated net benefits.
Precision farming is a comprehensive approach to
farm management and has following goals and
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
300
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
A Study on Novel Approach to Sustainable Indian Agriculture - Precision Farming
agriculture because in precision farming the
field is divided into various management zones
based on factors like soil pH, yield rates, pest
infestation etc. and these zones are managed by
application of required inputs using precision
farming tools whereas in traditional farming field
is treated as a homogenous area with whole field
management practices and inputs are supplied
uniformly throughout the field (Singh, A. K.
undated). Precision farming can be summarized
as technology that allows a farmer to follow sitespecific management which is of doing right thing,
in the right place, in the right time and in right way
(Pierce and Nowak 1999). Precision faming provides
a way to automate site-specific management using
information technology, thereby making site specific
management practical in commercial agriculture.
Precision farming gained wide scope in production
of major food grain crops like rice, wheat and also
in high profit-making horticultural crops.
system and better investment in research to provide
new solutions to novel problems. Due to limiting
availability of natural resources, the adoption of
precision farming is necessary. Precision farming
potentiality is conceptualized through reduced use
of water, fertilizers, herbicides and pesticides besides
farm equipment for ecological and environmental
benefits. Therefore, the adoption of newly emerged
technology is one of the keys in future to increase
agriculture productivity. There is a need to convert
green revolution to evergreen revolution which
can be achieved from precision farming where sitespecific problems can be recognized within fields
and management actions are managed accordingly.
Basic Steps in Precision Farming
The variability in the field can be determined using
the technologies, managing them with the use of
agronomic practices and finally evaluating the
outcomes. The three basic steps are explained in
detail (Shanwad et al. 2004).
Need for Precision Farming
The food production system of our country is
majorly profited by Green Revolution in 1960’s by
making India self-sufficient. This was achieved due
to high input application, increase in fertilization,
irrigation, pesticides, higher use of high yielding
varieties, increasing cropping intensity and increase
in agricultural mechanization. Green revolution
has made our country self sufficient but potential
productivity of Indian high yielding varieties are
lowest compared to world’s crop yield level (Patil
and Bhalerao 2013). The green revolution is also
correlated with adverse impact on ecology. India’s
natural resources are degrading day by day with
high input applications and it is reducing the
originality of land. Major concern in agricultural
growth and development are decline in the total
productivity, diminishing and degrading natural
resources (Healthy land and quality water both are
becoming limited), stagnating farm incomes, lack of
eco-regional approach, declining and fragmented
land holdings, limited employment opportunities
in non-farm sectors and global climate variation.
1. Assessing variation
The challenges faced by global food system will
likely to increase in future. This can be minimized
immediately with the modern technologies and
knowledge with sufficient will and investment.
But it necessitates more radical changes to food
Management of variability is possible if the
variability is assessed critically. Managing variability
also includes both spatial and temporal variability.
For example, the management of potassium and
phosphorus is convenient because the temporal
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
The first and critical step in precision farming is
assessing variation. To manage the variability, one
should know about assessing it. Without proper
assessment it is difficult to manage the variations.
There is variation in elements and operations
affecting the crop yield in accordance with space
and time. Quantifying and determining variability
of elements and operations by knowing the effect
of different combinations for spatial and temporal
variation is a huge challenge in precision farming.
Techniques for assessing both spatial and temporal
variation are available but they can proceed
simultaneously. Temporal variation is different in
different time which need observations at crop
growth and development over growing season and
this also includes spatial variability. Some variables
are produced in space than time, making them
more convenient to modern forms of precision
management.
2. Managing variability
301
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Shwetha and Gupta
2. Yield monitoring and mapping
variation of these nutrients is low. Likewise,
management of nitrogen is difficult because the
temporal variation is high. According to the assessed
condition within field, farmers can implement
agronomic practices which should be site-specific
and accurate. Site-specific management can be
effectively done with the use of various technologies
making it easy and economical.
2. Environment
Yield monitors are used to record yield data
and create yield maps when linked with GPS.
Yield monitors include several components like
different sensors, data storage device, user interface
and task computer (controls integration and
interaction of above components). Yield monitors
are important because yield data will enable to
decide the management practices to be considered
and to decide the effect of managed inputs such
as fertilizers, seeds, agrochemicals and cultural
practices (tillage and irrigation). Yield data of
many years should be collected and considered for
evaluation because yield data of single year cannot
give adequate information as it may get affected by
weather parameters along with field factors.
3. Technology
3. Geographic Information System (GIS)
3. Evaluation:
Immediately after management it is important to
evaluate the condition of field and outcomes. There
are three important issues regarding evaluation of
precision farming:
1. Economics
The analysis of profitability of precision agriculture
involves the value that comes from application of
data than from the use of the technology. Low usage
of agrochemical, higher nutrient use efficiency and
increased input efficiency are regarded as benefit
to environment. As precision farming involves
the application of technologies and agronomic
principles for spatial and temporal variability
management, transfer of technology to farmers
is essential. The technology transfer differs for
individual farms because of change in the problems
related to each farm.
GIS is hardware and software of computers and
comprises of procedures that are designed to support
the collection, storage, recovery and analysis of
attributes and data of location to produce respective
maps (Hakkim et al. 2016). It gained importance in
agriculture for storing layers of information which
include yield data, soil survey maps, rainfall, crops,
soil nutrient levels and pests (Singh, A. K. undated).
The recorded data can be displayed through visual
perspective for interpretation. Other than storage
and display of data, GIS can be used to evaluate
present and alternative management by combining
and manipulating data layers to produce an analysis
of management scenarios. After analyzing the
information can be used to compare and understand
the relationships between the various factors
affecting a crop on specific site.
Tools in Precision Farming
1. Global Positioning System (GPS) receivers
A GPS is a network of satellites and receiving devices
that helps the users to record positional information
while in motion at any time. This helps farmers by
providing the exact position of field information
such as soil type, pest occurrences, weed invasion,
waterholes, boundaries, obstructions and crop
measurements to be mapped (Singh, A. K. undated).
This will locate specific spots in field which helps
farmers to apply inputs in specific quantity to an
individual field based on performance criteria and
previous input applications. This system consists of
light or sound guiding panel, antenna and receiver.
While purchasing GPS, differential correction
should be checked so that the signals could match
the satellite signals in particular field.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
4. Grid soil sampling and variable rate
fertilizer (VRT) application
Grid soil sampling increases the intensity of soil
sampling and uses the same principles of soil
sampling. Soil samples are collected in a systematic
grid includes location information that allows
the data to be mapped. An application map of
nutrient requirement is created through grid soil
sampling. For each soil samples the crop nutrient
needs are interpreted after analyzing the grid soil
samples in laboratory. Variables rate technologies
are automatic and applied to numerous farming
302
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
A Study on Novel Approach to Sustainable Indian Agriculture - Precision Farming
7. Identifying a precision agriculture service
provider
operations. Control computer, locator and actuator
are three components of variable rate applicator. The
fertilizer application map is plotted using the entire
set of soil samples. According to the application
map that is loaded into a computer mounted on a
variable rate fertilizer spreader and a GPS receiver,
the amount and kind of fertilizer product is applied
to specific-site through product-delivery controller.
This enables the land to get specific amounts of
fertilizers at proper time (Hakkim et al. 2016).
The farmers are advised to consider the availability
of custom services when making decisions about
adopting site-specific crop management. Agricultural
service providers or trained extension workers
can offer a variety of precision farming services
to farmers (Singh, A. K. undated). Intensive soil
sampling, mapping and variable rate applications
of fertilizer and lime are most common custom
services. These custom services can decrease the cost
and increase the efficiency of precision farming by
providing capital costs for specialized equipment
over more land and by using the skills of precision
agriculture activities (Hakkim et al. 2016).
5. Sensor technologies and remote sensing
Sensor technologies such as electromagnetic,
conductivity, photoelectricity and ultrasound are
one of the important tools of precision farming used
to measure soil properties and plant fertility/ water
status including humidity, vegetation, temperature,
texture, structure, physical character, nutrient
level, vapor, air etc. Remote sensing technology
is useful tool for collecting numerous information
simultaneously from a distance without laboratory
analysis (Hakkim et al. 2016). These data are used
to differentiate crop species, locate biotic and abiotic
stress conditions, identify weeds, monitor drought,
soil and plant conditions. Near-Infrared images
are recorded in electronic cameras that are highly
associated with healthy plant tissue. Location, extent
and component of crop stress can be determined
with the help of remotely-sensed images. A spot
treatment plan that optimizes the use of agricultural
chemicals is developed and implemented by using
these images. Eventhough more information is
gathered by remote sensing technology it is difficult
to find key management factor because of varying
field conditions such as timing and amount of
nitrogen fertilizer application, timing and period of
mid-season drainage and timing of harvest.
8. Rate controller
The devices designed to control the delivery rate
of chemical inputs such as fertilizers and pesticides
are rate controllers. These rate controllers monitor
the speed of the tractor/sprayer traveling across the
field, as well as the flow rate and pressure (if liquid)
of the material, making delivery adjustments in realtime to apply a target rate. Rate controllers have
been available for some time and are frequently
used as stand-alone systems.
Elements of Precision Farming
Mainly there are three elements in precision farming
(Robert et al. 2009):
1. Information
Basic information or data is foremost needed for
further proceedings in precision farming. In modern
farming, collection of accurate data at proper timing
by farmers is necessary for successful management.
This information consists of crop characteristics,
response of hybrids, soil properties, fertilizer
requirements, weather predictions, weed and pest
populations, plant growth responses, harvest yield,
post-harvest processing and marketing projections.
Farmers must be capable of finding, analysing,
and using the available information at each step in
the crop system. With the advancement and easy
availability of data in recent years makes it possible
to get within the requirement period. Data can be
extracted from internet which is more accessible
and quickly updated.
6. Precision irrigation in pressurized systems
GPS based controllers are used for controlling the
irrigation machines for commercial use in sprinkler
irrigation. Wireless communication and sensor
technologies are being developed to monitor soil
conditions to achieve higher water application
efficiency and utilization by crop (Hakkim et al.
2016).
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
303
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Shwetha and Gupta
2. Technology
Adoption in Small Scale Agriculture
Farmers should know about the adaption of
new technologies for their operations. Personal
computers can be used to store the data of past years
and is accessed whenever required. These personal
computers will organize, analyse and manage the
data. Computer software including spreadsheets,
databases, geographic information system (GIS) and
other application software are readily available and
easy to use. Global positioning system (GPS) can
be used by farmers and agricultural consultants for
locating position of field. Geographic information
system (GIS) creates a field map by using the data
recorded by Global positioning system (GPS) to
assess the impact of farm management decisions.
The leading issue for agricultural scientist is
feasibility of precision farming in small farms.
The main point to be noted in precision farming
is understanding the variability in the field and
characterization of precision farming by variable
management. At least two types of variability are
observed, one is within-field variability and the other
is between-field variability or regional variability
(Shibusawa 2000). Each field is considered as unit on
a map in case of between-field variability whereas
with in- field variability focuses on a single field and
cultivated with one plant variety. Considering the
kind of variability is essential for precision farming
in small farms. Precision farming should mean
improved farm management no matter the farms
are large or small. Ultimately, it should give higher
economic return with a reduced environmental
impact. Some low cost and low technology tools
may be proved to be useful for small scale farms
of developing countries (Mandol and Basu 2009).
Sensor technology is used to monitor soil properties,
crop stress, growth conditions, yields or postharvest processing are either available or under
development and this instant information can
be used to control operational inputs. Precision
farming uses three general technologies: Crop, soil
and positioning sensors – these include both remote
and vehicle-mounted, “on-the-go” sensors that
detect soil texture, soil moisture levels, crop stress,
disease and weed infestations while the tractor
travels along the field. Machine controls – these are
used to guide field equipment and can vary the rate,
mix and locate water, seeds, nutrients, or chemical
applications. Computer-based systems – these
include GIS maps and databases that use sensor
information to prescribe specific machine controls.
Possible variable rate applications on a single
small farm depends on understanding capacity,
knowledge and skills of farmer. As the land size
increases, precision farming should coordinate
with different types of land use and many farmers
having diverse motivations. Precision farming
offers the possibility of developing a new kind of
industry in view of development in rural area that
includes small farms and local companies by fusing
agriculture to various kinds of industrial activity.
Hence, it is understandable that the size of farm
in adoption of precision farming does not matter
provided it depends on management strategy.
3. Decision support or management
For best management prescriptions of crop
production system, combination of traditional
management practices and precision farming tools
helps farmers. Most of the times it is difficult to
understand the decision support system. Building
databases based on the relationships between input
and potential yields, refining analytical tools and
increasing agronomic knowledge at the local level
are yet to be accomplished. Agricultural researchers
opined that decision support system is the least
developed area in precision farming. Diagnostic
and database development will eventually replace
technologies as the real benefit of precision farming
(Robert et al. 2009).
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Economic Studies of Precision Farming
The adoption of precision farming involves intensive
capital investment and leads to greater expenditures
on machinery and equipment as well as for access to
information. Precision farming increases the quality
of marketed goods. Product quality can be in two
forms such as intrinsic and extrinsic quality. Intrinsic
quality comprises of color, appearance, protein
content, pesticide residue content, sugar content,
starch content etc. Extrinsic quality is associated
with production practices, origin or related aspects
of the production process. Economic results of
adoption of variable rate application methods
304
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
A Study on Novel Approach to Sustainable Indian Agriculture - Precision Farming
Automations using Guidance Systems: Direct
economic benefits are achieved using automated
unmanned systems (reduced labour costs) and
reduced impact on the environment (reduction
of machinery pass frequency and reduction of
soil compaction) (Thomas and Georgios 2017).
depends on the type of crop, field size and type
of agriculture. Precision farming profitability is
important for implementation of these technologies.
The benefits from precision farming are related
to optimization of inputs, improvement of
management and quality of work, crop yield
improvements, minimizing cost through improved
process control, reducing content of agrochemicals
to the environment, environmental quality and
business risk (Robert et al. 2019). None of the
technologies adopted does not provide a total
solution until and unless it is used extensively for
commercial purpose. The coordination between
private and public sectors can lead to the economic
growth of precision farming by developing and
implementing technologies, market development
responsibility and customer satisfaction. Economic
studies related to profitability are nuclear and noncomparable.
Obstacles in Adopting Precision Farming
Common obstacles for adoption of precision
farming in developing countries like India are as
follows (Shanwad et al. 2004):
Culture and perceptions of the users.
Small farm size.
Lack of success stories.
Heterogeneity of cropping systems and market
imperfections.
Landownership, infrastructure and institutional
constraints.
Merits of Precision Farming
Lack of local technical expertise.
Knowledge and technical gaps among farmers.
Agronomical perspective: Use agronomical
practices by looking at specific requirement
of crop.
Data availability, quality and costs.
Technical perspective: Allows efficient time and
management.
CONCLUSION
Precision Farming could be a solution to threats
associated to low agricultural productivity and
environmental impact. In developing countries, it
has not reached every farmer due to lack of transfer
of technology and unclear economic framework.
Indian farmers with the help of public and private
sectors will be able to adopt this technology as
well as can deal with the severe problems faced
by them such as low outputs, depletion in water
levels, increasing cost of inputs only if they are
trained about technologies and providing detailed
information about precision farming. Precision
farming can be adopted in various fields such as
agriculture, horticulture and livestock production
which will help farmers to increase their economic
returns and making India self-sufficient in food
production.
Economical perspective: Increases crop yield,
quality and reduces cost of production by
efficient use of farm inputs, labor, water etc.
Environmental perspective: Ecofriendly practices
in crop.
Managing spatial variability for decision making:
Precision farming provide complete field
related information through direct sampling.
Management of environmentally sensitive areas:
By calculating the greenhouse gas emissions
due to mechanized operations, they can limit
emissions to the environment.
Precise nutrient applications: Yield maps can be
used to alter fertilizer applications that suits
current soil characteristics.
Precise pesticide application: Specific amounts of
pesticides are applied to specific site and it also
prevent overlapping during spraying by the use
of light bar guidance system. This will reduce
the use of inputs and decrease adverse effect
on environment.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
REFERENCES
Hermann Auernhammer. 2001. Precision farming — the
environmental challenge. Comput. and Electron. in
Agriculture, 30: 31-43.
305
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Shwetha and Gupta
Hakkim Abdul, V. M., Joseph Abhilash, E., Ajay Gokul, A. J.
and Mufeedha, K. 2016. Precision Farming: The Future
of Indian Agriculture. J. of Appl. Biol. Biotechnol., 4(06):
068-072.
Robert Finger, Scott, M. Swinton, Nadja El Benni, and
Achim Walter. 2019. Precision Farming at the Nexus of
Agricultural Production and the Environment. Annu. Rev.
Resour. Econ., 11: 313–35.
Mondal, P. and Basu, M. 2009. Adoption of precision
agriculture technologies in India and in some developing
countries: Scope, present status and strategies. Prog. in
Nat. Sci., 19: 659-666.
Shanwad, U.K., Patil, V.C. and Honne Gowda, H. 2004.
Precision Farming: Dreams and Realities for Indian
Agriculture. Map India Conference 2004.
Shibusawa, S. 2000. Environmentally friendly agriculture
and mechanization trend in Japan: Prospects of precision
farming in Japan. Proceedings International Symposium
on Farm Mechanization for Environmentally-Friendly
Agriculture, Seoul, Korea. The Korean Society for
Agricultural Machinery, pp. 53-80.
Pierce, F. and Nowak, P. 1999. Aspects of precision agriculture.
In D. L. Sparks (ed.), Adv. Agron. pp. 1-86.
Patil Shirish, S. and Bhalerao Satish, A. 2013. Precision
farming: The most scientific and modern approach to
sustainable agriculture. Int. Res. J. of Sci. & Eng., 1(2): 21-30.
Singh, A.K. Precision farming. Academia, 6: 166-174.
Rains Glen, C. and Thomas Daniel, L. 2009. Precision Farming
An Introduction.
Thomas Koutsos and Georgios Menexes. 2017. Benefits from
the adoption of precision agriculture technologies. A
systematic review. Conference Paper.
Robert “Bobby” Grisso, Mark Alley, Dan Brann and Steve
Donohue. 2009. Precision Farming: A Comprehensive
Approach. Virginia Tech., pp. 442-500.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
306
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 307-312, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.4
Study of Heterosis, Residual Heterosis and Inbreeding
Depression in Two Crosses of Tomato
Sangamesh Nevani* and O. Sridevi
Department of Genetics and Plant Breeding, College of Agriculture, University of Agricultural Sciences, Dharwad Karnataka, India
*Corresponding author: nevanisangu73@gmail.com (ORCID ID: 0000-0001-6641-233X)
Paper No. 989
Received: 25-05-2022
Revised: 30-06-2022
Accepted: 08-07-2022
ABSTRACT
Heterosis, which is hybrid vigour that results in an increase in fruit yield with early development and
higher quality, is one of the most essential approaches to improve yield and quality attributes. Heterosis
is a natural phenomena in which the physical and functional traits of hybrid offspring of genetically
heterogeneous individuals improve over time. The goal of this research is to find out how much hybrid
vigour and inbreeding depressions, as well as residual heterosis, are present in two tomato crosses (DMT2 LINE-38 and LINE-33-1 LA-1). A population of two crosses was assessed with 14 parameter test of
generation mean analysis. The significant and negative heterosis (heterobeltiosis) was depicted for days
to first harvest in cross I with negative inbreeding depression, which indicates desirable earliness found
in those families. The heterosis, as well as inbreeding depression was observed in the desired direction
in cross I and II for fruit yield per plant and for quality viz., pericarp thickness, pH of fruit juice and TSS
indicating possibilities to get the desired segregants in a further breeding program.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) is one of the most important solanaceous vegetable crops all over
the world. It was introduced in India by English traders of East India company in 1822 (Kalloo 1988).
The tomato originated in a wild form in Ecuador, Peru, and Bolivia of South America (also known as
the center of diversity of wild tomato). Globally, it is grown in an area of 5.02 million hectares with the
production of 170.75 million tonnes and productivity of 33.99 tonnes per hectare (FAO, 2020). China,
India and USA are the major tomato producing countries. In India, it is grown in an area of about
0.88 million hectares with production of 18.74 million tonnes and the average productivity is about
21.24 tonnes per hectare. The important tomato growing states are Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka and
Madhya Pradesh. In Karnataka, tomato is grown on an area about 0.06 million hectares with production
of about 2.13 million tonnes with the productivity of about 31.54 tonnes per hectare (Anon., 2019).
Keywords: Generation mean analysis, Heterosis, Heterobeltiosis, Residual heterosis, Inbreeding
depression
Tomato is consumed year-round and its importance
is mainly derived in two forms: used as a fresh
vegetable as well as an important source for the
processing industry. At present time, superior
quality and adequate quantity of vegetables for
commercial agro-processing are not being grown
sufficiently. Cultivation of tomatoes began to
decline during the last few years, which requires
conventional and scientific efforts to increase
the production per unit area to compensate for
the shortfall in the cultivated area. Many local
farmers grow average yielding varieties, which are
characteristically low yielding and of poor quality
for the traits such as high-water content, poor
color and low Brix content against the increasing
How to cite this article: Nevani, S. and Sridevi, O. (2022). Study of
Heterosis, Residual Heterosis and Inbreeding Depression in Two
Crosses of Tomato. Int. J. Ag. Env. Biotech., 15(Special Issue): 307-312.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Nevani and Sridevi
demand at the local and international levels for
superior quality. To overcome these problems, the
development of high yielding and superior quality
varieties of tomato is imperative in the cultivation
to meet the total market demand. Since the 1980s,
the emphasis of new cultivar development has been
focused on the production of F1 hybrids (Grandillo et
al. 1999). Generally, hybrids are preferred over pure
line varieties in tomatoes due to their superiority
in terms of yield as well as the quality of fruit.
Hybrid breeding technology is greatly applied in
cross-pollinated crops and is limited in autogamous
crops due to the strict genetic makeup of the plant
and floral biology. Commercial exploitation of
heterosis in self-pollinated crops has been limited
owing to technical difficulties involved in hybrid
seed production. Tomato is a self-pollinated crop
with hermaphrodite flower and can be easily
emasculated for crossing technique, therefore it has
a suitable mechanism to produce hybrid seed at a
commercial scale. However, it adds a higher labour
cost to the total production cost.
but a great amount of information is still needed
for the understanding of the genetics of fruit yield,
yield attributing traits, and quality parameters
of this crop. The purpose of this study was to
estimate the heterosis of yield-related traits as well
as inbreeding depression and residual heterosis
in the F2 generation. The experimental material is
constructed in such a way that the estimation of
the heterosis, inbreeding depression, and residual
heterosis effect in a respective generation is possible.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experimental material comprises of two crosses,
each representing six generations (P 1, P2, F1, F2,
B1, and B2) were raised in a compact family block
design in field trials. Two crosses were derived
from four parents viz., DMT-2, LINE-38, LINE-33-1
and LA-1 with hand emasculation and pollination.
Observations for the different traits under study
were recorded on randomly selected and tagged
plants from each experimental unit and each
replication i.e., five plants from each P1, P2, and F1
and 300 hundred plants from each F2 generation
and 120 plant for back cross generation was
recorded. The mean of F1 hybrids and F2 generation
over replication were utilized for the estimation
of heterosis, inbreeding depression, and residual
heterosis.
Heterosis increases yield and quality in many crops
and vegetables and it has been intensively used
in plant breeding. The identification of superior
parental combinations that provide high heterosis
for yield and quality is the most important factor in
hybrid development. Heterobeltiosis is useful in the
identification of promising cross combinations for
the improvement of the crop through conventional
breeding strategies. It may lead to an increase in
yield, reproductive ability, adaptability to general
vigour, different biotic and abiotic stresses and
also improve fruit quality. Contrarily, inbreeding
depression leads to decreased fitness and vigour
due to the expression of lethal and sublethal alleles
which are generally masked under heterozygosity.
It leads to increased homozygosity and fixation of
undesirable recessive genes in F2 and successive
generations, while in the case of heterosis, favorable
dominant genes of one parent are masking the effect
of harmful recessive genes of another parent.
1. Estimation of Heterosis. Heterosis expressed as
a percent increase or decrease of F1 hybrid over its
better parent value (BP) and mid parent heterosis
(MH) was computed using the following formulae.
1. Heterosis over better parent (Heterobeltosis) HB
(%). The heterosis over better parent was calculated
as per the Fonseca and Patterson, (1968).
HB ( % ) ==
BP
× 100
Where, F1 = Mean value of F1 hybrid i.e. F1
BP = Mean performance of better parent.
2. Mid parent heterosis MH (%). The heterosis over
average of two parents was calculated as per the
Meredith and Bridge, (1972).
Molecular, genetic, and physiological mechanisms
underlying this phenomenon are not well understood
yet (Birchler et al. 2010). The demand for tomatoes
is increasing day by day but their production and
quality is affected by many diseases, stresses and
many other factors. A considerable amount of
important work has already been done in this crop,
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
F1 − BP
MP ( % ) ==
F1 − MP
MP
× 100
Where, MP = Mean performance of two parents
308
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Study of Heterosis, Residual Heterosis and Inbreeding Depression in Two Crosses of Tomato
3. Estimation of inbreeding depression (ID %).
Inbreeding depression was computed by using the
following formula,
Inbreeding depression (%) = =
fruit (4.99 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1), pericarp thickness
(0.50 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1), number of locules (0.55
% in DMT-2 × Line-38), total soluble solids (0.80 %
for DMT-2 × Line-38 and 0.65 % in Line-33-1 × LA1), pH of fruit juice (0.30 % in DMT-2 × Line-38).
F2 − F1
× 100
F2
Similarly significant and positive heterosis over
mid parent was observed for plant height (6.37 %
in Line-33-1 × LA-1), primary branches per plant
(0.25 % in DMT-2 × Line-38), number of clusters
per plant (2.47 % in DMT-2 × Line-38), number of
fruits per cluster (0.27 % in DMT-2 × Line-38 and
0.42 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1 ), number of fruits per
plant (9.72 % in DMT-2 × Line-38 ), average fruit
weight (13.26 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1 ), polar length
of fruit (5.61 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1 and 2.91 % in
DMT-2 × Line-38), equatorial length of fruit (4.59 %
in DMT-2 × Line-38 and 3.56 % in Line-33-1 × LA1), pericarp thickness (0.69 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1
and 0.64 % in DMT-2 × Line-38), number of locules
per fruit (0.78 % in DMT-2 × Line-38 and 0.42 % in
Line-33-1 × LA-1), total soluble solids (1.02 % in
DMT-2 × Line-38 and 0.85 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1),
pH of fruit juice (0.41 % Line-33-1 × LA-1 and 0.4
% in DMT-2 × Line-38) and yield per plant (0.50 %
in DMT-2 × Line-38 and 0.47 % in Line-33-1 × LA1). The positive and significant heterosis over mid
parent as well as better parent found undesirable for
days 1st harvest in the above mentioned crosses but
their magnitude were very less could be neglected.
Significant and negative heterosis over better parent
observed in days to 1st harvest (-2.19 % in DMT-2
× Line-38), primary branches per plant (0.3 % in
Line-33-1 × LA-1). Significant negative mid parent
heterosis was not observed for any characters.
4. Estimation of Residual Heterosis (%). The
residual heterosis from F2 generation was worked
out as per the formula given below:
Residual heterosis =
F2 − BP
BP
× 100
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The results observed for heterosis over mid parent
and better parents, residual heterosis as well as
inbreeding depression for 14 traits are summarizes
in Table 1.
The measurement of heterosis over mid parent
is of academic importance for studying genetics
of heterosis but has limited practical usefulness.
On the other hand, the heterosis measured over
better parent is of much practical importance. The
commercial exploitation of heterosis is considered
to be an outstanding application of principles of
genetics into the field of plant breeding. Heterosis
has been successfully exploited in many crops like
tomato, bajra, maize, bitter gourd, sorghum, castor,
cotton, bottle gourd and many other vegetable
crops. In present study, heterosis over mid as well
as better parents, Residual heterosis and inbreeding
depression was estimated (Table 1).
The heterosis over better parent (heterobeltiosis) for
different traits was ranging from -2.19 to 9.26 % and
highest heterobeltiosis was recorded in average fruit
weight (9.26 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1), mean-while
heterosis over mid parent ranges from -1.21 to 13.26
%. The highest heterosis over mid patent recorded
in average fruit weight (13.26 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1).
Heterosis in desirable direction for various traits in
tomato was reported by several research workers
such as Shekar et al. (2010), Shankar et al. (2013),
Kumar et al. (2018), Madhavi et al. (2018) and
Barragan et al. (2019), for total fruit yield per plant;
Joshi et al. (2015), Zengin et al. (2015) and Kumar
et al. (2018) for plant height, fruit yield, number of
fruits plant, fruit length and average fruit weight
and for earliness (days to 1st harvest); Kumar et al.
(2018).
For the character days to 1st harvest the low scoring
parent was taken as better parent. The degree of
heterosis over better parent as well as mid parent
varied from cross to cross for all the 14 characters.
Residual heterosis is the amount of heterosis shown
by F 2 and subsequent segregating generations.
Residual heterobeltiosis and economic heterosis in
F2 generations was estimated as the percentage of
deviation of generation mean of F2 from better parent
Significant and positive heterosis over better parent
observed for plant height (9.22 % in DMT-2 × Line38 and 7.22 % in Line-33-1 × LA-1), number of fruits
per plant (7.5 % in DMT-2 × Line-38), polar length of
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
309
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
310
8.84**
4.62 ± 2.24
5.20 ± 2.21
-2.19** ± 0.69
0.1 ± 0.69
-41.02**
892.47**
-1.49 ± 0.62
-1.47 ± 0.50
DMT-2 × Line-38
Line 33-1 × LA-1
DMT-2 × Line-38
Line 33-1 × LA-1
DMT-2 × Line-38
Line 33-1 × LA-1
* **
-0.3 ± 0.09
1.91 ± 1.13
21.07**
4.42 ± 1.43
1.37 ± 1.16
4.99 ± 0.88
29.01**
7.04**
3.54 ± 0.9
1.99** ± 0.73
DMT-2 × Line-38
Line 33-1 × LA-1
DMT-2 × Line-38
Line 33-1 × LA-1
DMT-2 × Line-38
Line 33-1 × LA-1
**
**
3.04 ± 1.62
5.61** ± 0.8
Line 33-1 × LA-1
1 ± 0.94
**
13.82**
3.56** ± 1.04
4.59** ± 1.49
2.91** ± 1.03
DMT-2 × Line-38
Equatorial length
of fruit (mm)
Polar length of
fruit (mm)
*
*
7.29**
0.52**± 0.09
0.34 ± 0.06
**
6.41**
16.8**
0.50 ± 0.12
**
0.23** ± 0.07
0.69** ± 0.11
0.64** ± 0.08
0.14 ± 0.17
1.06 ± 0.19
**
38.64**
7.15**
0.12 ± 0.25
0.55* ± 0.22
0.42* ± 0.2
0.78** ± 0.21
Number of
locules
1.46 ± 0.87
4.02 ± 0.92
**
36.32**
11.64**
0.37 ± 1.12
0.92 ± 1.18
1.8 ± 1.02
2.47* ± 1
Number of
clusters
Thickness (mm)
Pericarp
-0.02 ± 0.05
0.29 ± 0.1
**
-4.82**
6.87**
**
7.72 ± 2.46
**
0.15 ± -0.12
-0.1 ± 0.06
0.25* ± 0.11
Primary
branches per
plant
9.22** ± 2.39
6.37** ± 2.28
Crosses
**
*
0.54 ± 0.1
Line 33-1 × LA-1
2.71 ± 2.41
-1.21 ± 0.67
DMT-2 × Line-38
, Significant at 5 and 1 % levels, respectively
Inbreeding
depression
Residual
Heterosis
Better Parent
heterosis
Mid parent
heterosis
Inbreeding
depression
Residual
Heterosis
Better Parent
heterosis
Mid parent
heterosis
Plant height
(cm)
Days to 1st
harvest
Crosses
0.64** ± 0.09
0.89 ± 0.06
**
6.16**
4.37**
0.65 ± 0.13
**
0.80** ± 0.08
0.85** ± 0.10
1.02** ± 0.07
TSS (0 brix)
0.05 ± 0.12
0.04 ± 0.09
18.04**
10.36**
0.15 ± 0.15
0.22 ± 0.12
0.42** ± 0.13
0.27** ± 0.1
Number of
fruits per
clusters
0.09 ± 0.08
0.3 ± 0.11
*
33.78**
13.40**
0.13 ± 0.09
0.30** ± 0.10
0.41**± 0.09
0.4** ± 0.08
pH of fruit
juice
2.27 ± 2.41
8.14 ± 5.06
**
9.98**
2.95
2.88 ± 3.18
7.5* ± -2.97
2.42 ± 2.7
9.72** ± 2.45
Number of
fruits per plant
0.36** ± 0.11
0.43** ± 0.11
6.24**
4.23**
0.24 ± 0.15
0.31 ± 0.16
0.47** ± 0.12
0.50** ± 0.13
Yield per
plant (kg)
2.5 ± 5.3
1.45 ± 2.92
5.66
19.19**
9.26 ± 5.49
3.1 ± 3.23
13.26*± 5.18
5.31 ± 2.82
Average fruit
weight (g)
Table 1: Estimates of heterosis over mid parent (MP), heterobeltiosis (BP), reidual heterosis (RH) and inbreeding depression (ID) for 14 characters in two
crosses of tomato
Nevani and Sridevi
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Study of Heterosis, Residual Heterosis and Inbreeding Depression in Two Crosses of Tomato
and standard check value respectively Residual
heterosis was found positive and significant for
most of the traits except number of fruits per plant
of cross I and average fruit weight of cross II with
the range of -41.02-892.47. Similar findings were
observed by Damor et al. (2021) and Kumar and
Singh (2016).
harvesting, plant height, number of fruits per plant,
number of fruits per cluster, average fruit weight,
polar and equatorial length, number of locules,
TSS, pH of fruit juice, and yield per plant showed
the highest and significant heterosis in the desired
direction; however, residual heterosis was observed
for the majority of the characters. In most of the
crosses, heterobeltiosis/heterosis over midparent
was substantial for main traits, showing the
importance of hybrids for commercial crop genetic
gain exploitation. The presence of overdominant
gene activity is represented by estimations of
substantial inbreeding depression with significant
heterosis. The F 2 generation’s estimates of low
inbreeding depression show a decrease in mean.
Low inbreeding depression, on the other hand, lets
the breeder to produce pure lines by using long
selfing cycles. More emphasis on hybrid breeding
can be made to improve self-pollinated crops by
adding more male sterility and apomictic genes.
In the present study, either low or moderate amount
of inbreeding depression (ID) in desirable direction
was found in most of the traits. The inbreeding
depression in two crosses was within the range of
-1.49 % to 8.14 %. The character which manifested
low heterosis in F1 also showed low inbreeding
depression in F 2. The significant and negative
heterosis found in days to 1st harvest (-1.49 % in
DMT-2 × Line-38 and -1.47 % in Line-33-1 × LA1) indicating that F1’s matured earlier than their
respective F2’s.
It is desirable to have highly significant and
positive heterosis over better parent with low
inbreeding depression for traits like fruit yield
and its component characters such as plant height,
number of clusters per plant (Line-33-1 × LA-1),
number of fruits per cluster (DMT-2 × Line-38 and
Line-33-1 × LA-1), number of fruits per plant (Line33-1 × LA-1), average fruit weight (DMT-2 × Line-38
and Line-33-1 × LA-1), equatorial length of fruit
(Line-33-1 × LA-1), number of locules (Line-33-1 ×
LA-1). The magnitude of inbreeding depression in
the present investigation varied from cross to cross
indicating influence of genetic constitution of cross.
Similar results were found by Singh et al. (1996)
and Kumar and Singh (2016) reported considerable
inbreeding depression in the F 2 generation for
plant height, days to 1st harvest, fruit length and
width and fruit yield per plant; Dagade et al.
(2015) observed significant inbreeding depression
for number of fruits per plant, fruit yield per plant
and total soluble solids; Avidokos et al. (2021) found
high degree of inbreeding depression for pericarp
thickness and number of locules per fruit.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors wish to express immense thanks
to UGC NF-PWD, Govt. of India, for providing
Fellowship for conducting the experiment.
REFERENCES
Anonymous, 2019, National Horticulture Board Database
2019, NHB, Gurgaon, pp. 177-185.
Avidokos, I.D., Tagiakas, R., Tsouvaltzis, P., Mylonas, I.,
Xynias, I.N. and Mavromatis, A.G. 2021. Comparative
evaluation of tomato hybrids and inbred lines for fruit
quality traits. Agron., 11: 609.
Barragan, O.G., Benitez, A.L., Herrera, S.A.R., Maas, J.N.E.,
Ramos, D.M.H. and Rico, J.S.G.J.A. 2019. Studies on
combining ability in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.).
Agron. Res., 17(1): 77–85.
Birchler, J.A., Yao, H., Chudalayandi, S., Vaiman, D. and Veitia,
R.A. 2010. Heterosis. The Plant Cell, 22(7): 2105-2112.
Dagade, S.B., Barad, A.V., Dhaduk, L.K. and Hariprasanna,
K. 2015. Estimates of hybrid vigour and inbreeding
depression for fruit nutritional characters in tomato, Int.
J. Environ. Sci. Technol. (Tehran)., 4(1): 114 – 124.
Damor, H., Patil, K., Pusarla, S., Shiwani and Pandya, P. 2021.
Heterosis, Residual Heterosis and Inbreeding Depression
Study in Tomato [Solanum lycopersicum (L.)]. Biological
Forum – An Int. J., 13(4): 565-570
CONCLUSION
Plant breeding has achieved tremendous success in
the development of hybrid cultivars, particularly
in self-pollinated crop plants. For fruit yield,
earliness, and quality attributes, the examination
of available tomato germplasm demonstrated
a considerable heterotic influence. Days to first
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
FAO, 2020. World Food and Agriculture - Statistical Yearbook
2020.
Grandillo, S., Zamir, D. and Tanksley, S.D. 1999. Genetic
improvement of processing tomatoes: A 20 years
perspective. Euphytica, 110: 85–97.
311
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Nevani and Sridevi
Kalloo, G. 1988. Breeding for quality and processing attributes
in vegetable breeding. Vol. 3, CRC press. INC Boca Raton.
Florida, pp. 62.
Shankar, A., Reddy, R.V.S.K., Sujatha, M. and Pratap, M.
2014. Development of superior F1 hybrids for commercial
exploitation in tomato, (Solanum lycopersicum L.). Int. J.
Farm Sci., 4(2): 58-69.
Kumar, C. and Singh, S.P. 2016. Heterosis and inbreeding
depression to identify superior F1 hybrids in tomato
(Solanum lycopersicum L.) for the yield and its contributing
traits. J. Appl. Nat. Sci., 8(1): 290 – 296.
Shekhar, L., Prakash, B.G., Salimath, P.M., Hiremath, C.P.,
Sridevi, O. and Patil, A.A. 2010. Implication of heterosis
and combining ability among productive single cross
hybrids in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.). Ele. J. Plant
Breed., 1(4): 706-711.
Kumar, C. and Singh, S.P. 2016. Heterosis and inbreeding
depression to identify superior F1 hybrids in tomato
(Solanum lycopersicum (L.)) for the yield and its contributing
traits. J. of Appl. and Natu. Sci., 8(1): 290 – 296.
Singh, A., Singh, P.K., Dixit, J., Gautam, J.P.S. and Singh,
D.N. 1996. Heterosis and inbreeding in tomato. J. Res.,
8(1): 89-90.
Kumar, K., Sharma, D., Singh, J., Sharma, T.K., Kurrey, V.K.
and Minz, R.R. 2018. Combining ability analysis for yield
and quality traits in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.). J.
Pharmacogn Phytochem., 7(6): 1002-1005.
Zengin, S., Kabas, A., Oguz, A., Eren, A. and Polat, E.
2015. Determining of general combining ability for
yield, quality and some other traits of tomato (Solanum
lycopersicum L.) inbred lines. Akdeniz üniversitesi ziraat
fakültesi dergisİ., 28(1): 1-4.
Madhavi, Y., Reddy, R.V.S.K. and Reddy, C.S. 2018. Combining
ability studies for growth and quality characters in tomato
(Solanum lycopersicum L.), Int. J. Curr. Microbiol. App. Sci.,
7(10): 2287-2291.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
312
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 313-320, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.5
A Critical Study on the Present Status and Scope of Natural
Farming in the State of Andhra Pradesh, India
B. Srishailam*, V. Sailaja and S.V. Prasad
Department of Agricultural Extension Education, S.V. Agricultural College, Tirupati, Acharya N.G. Ranga Agricultural University,
Andhra Pradesh, India
*Corresponding author: sribathini15@gmail.com (ORCID ID: 0000-0001-9475-1873)
Paper No. 990
Received: 26-05-2022
Revised: 29-06-2022
Accepted: 09-07-2022
ABSTRACT
Natural Farming is a chemical-free alias traditional farming method. It is considered as agroecology based
diversified farming system which integrates crops, trees and livestock with functional biodiversity. In
India, Natural farming is promoted as Bharatiya Prakritik Krishi Paddhati Programme (BPKP) under
centrally sponsored scheme- Paramparagat Krishi Vikas Yojana (PKVY). Government of Andhra Pradesh
expanded zero budget natural farming in 2015. Andhra Pradesh’s Department of Agriculture appointed
Rythu Sadhikara Samstha (RySS) to oversee the Climate Resilient Zero Budget Natural Farming program.
RySS, a state-run research institute, was established to train farmers and promote farmer-to-farmer
learning. The state launched ZBNF as a pilot program with over 700 villages and approximately 40,650
farmers in 2016 (RySS 2019). As of March 2020, approximately 623,300 farmers were enrolled in Andhra
Pradesh’s ZBNF program and the total amount of land cultivated under ZBNF was almost three percent
of total net sown area in the state (181,600 hectares). By 2027, Andhra Pradesh plans to expand ZBNF
to all 6 million farmers and 8 million hectares. The ZBNF program is funded by the national and state
government through Paramparagat Krishi Vikash Yojana and Rashtriya Krishi Vikash Yojana programs,
as well as other partners, including the Azim Premji Philanthropic Initiative, the International Fund for
Agricultural Development, and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. The cost to RySS to transition one
farmer to ZBNF is approximately 25,550 INR (348 USD), where 73 percent of the cost is dedicated to
capacity building. Recent agricultural graduates are also stationed in a village for two years as Natural
Farming Fellows where they lease land and practice ZBNF to demonstrate its viability to nearby farmers.
Natural Farming Fellows adapt ZBNF’s core elements to local conditions and help to attract youth to the
program. Women’s self-help groups are instrumental in scaling up ZBNF. As of 2019, more than 161,000
women’s self-help groups were mobilizingfarmers to adopt ZBNF, preparing farming plans, marketing
ZBNF locally, and monitoring farmers’ progress. RySS relies on women’s self-help groups to identify
landless farmers to participate in kitchen gardens etc.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm To know the present status of natural farming in the state and as well as different stakeholders
engaged in the practice of natural farming promotion in the state. Benefits as well as constraints
faced by the natural farming farmers and what are the condition to be set up to increase the area of
natural farming in the state.
Keywords: Chemical free farming, Debt free farmers,
Natural farming fellows, Women SHGs, BPKP-PKVY How to cite this article: Srishailam, B., Sailaja, V. and Prasad, S.V.
(2022). A Critical Study on the Present Status and Scope of Natural
Farming in the State of Andhra Pradesh, India. Int. J. Ag. Env. Biotech.,
15(Special Issue): 313-320.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Srishailam et al.
Government of Andhra Pradesh expanded zero
budget natural farming in 2015. Andhra Pradesh’s
Department of Agriculture appointed Rythu
Sadhikara Samstha (RySS) to oversee the “Climate
Resilient Zero Budget Natural Farming” program.
RySS, a state-run research institute, was established
to train farmers and promote farmer-to-farmer
learning. The state launched ZBNF as a pilot
program with over 700 villages and approximately
40,650 farmers in 2016 (RySS 2019). As of March
2020, approximately 623,300 farmers were enrolled
in Andhra Pradesh’s ZBNF program (almost 10.5
percent of all farmers in Andhra Pradesh), and
the total amount of land cultivated under ZBNF
was almost three percent of total net sown area
in the state (181,600 hectares) (Khurana and
Kumar 2020). By 2027, Andhra Pradesh plans
to expand ZBNF to all 6 million farmers and 8
million hectares (RySS 2019). The ZBNF program
is funded by the national and state government
through Paramparagat Krishi Vikash Yojana and
Rashtriya Krishi Vikash Yojana programs, as well
as other partners, including the Azim Premji
Philanthropic Initiative, the International Fund for
Agricultural Development, and the Bill & Melinda
Gates Foundation (Mishra 2018; RySS 2019). The
cost to RySS to transition one farmer to ZBNF is
approximately 25,550 INR (348 USD), where 73
percent of the cost is dedicated to capacity building
(RySS 2019). Farmers do not receive a subsidy from
the government to adopt ZBNF (Gupta and Jain
2020). ZBNF’s rapid expansion in the state can be
attributed to the program’s extensive network of
fellows to recruit and train farmers, along with its
strategic linkage with women’s self-help groups.
In each village where the program is active, 50
Community Resource Persons (CRPs), who have
previously been identified as “champion farmers”
for their success with ZBNF, train other farmers in
their community, provide marketing support, and
collect data for RySS (RySS 2019).
scaling up ZBNF. Millions of women in self-help
groups across Andhra Pradesh collectively invest
their own savings, loans, and government grants
into their communities (Deshmukh-Ranadive 2004).
As of 2019, more than 161,000 women’s self-help
groups were mobilizingfarmers to adopt ZBNF,
preparing farming plans, marketing ZBNF locally,
and monitoring farmers’ progress (RySS 2019).
RySS relies on women’s self-help groups to identify
landless farmers to participate in kitchen gardens
or lease land (Gupta and Jain 2020). Women’s selfhelp groups are also a source of financial capital
for farmers during their transition to ZBNF (Gupta
and Jain 2020). ZBNF is promoted as a solution
to the farmer debt crisis and environmental
degradation in Andhra Pradesh and throughout
other states in India as well. Himachal Pradesh is
promoting ZBNF under the state-sponsored scheme,
“Prakritik Kheti Khushal Kisan” (Department
of Agriculture Himachal Pradesh). ZBNF is also
practiced in Karnataka, Kerala, Haryana, and
Gujarat (Khurana and Kumar 2020), and continues
to attract international attention as a burgeoning
agroecological movement.
Pillars of ZBNF
Concerning soil fertility, soil microbes play an
important role, they involve in a nutrient cycle like
C & N cycle which are required for plant growth
(Lazarovits 1997).
1. Jivamrita/Jeevamrutha
Microorganisms play an important role in the
conversion of unavailable forms of nutrients to
available form in the plant root zone. The microbes
present in jeevamrutha helps non-available form
to dissolved form when it is inoculated into the
soil. It also helps as antagonism to (biological
control) pathogens (Glick & Bashan, 1997). PGPR,
cyanobacteria, and Solubilizing Bacteria (PSB),
mycorrhizal fungi, Nitrogen-fixing bacteria are
some important microbes present in the product
(Chen et al. 1995). it requires 20 kg cow dung, 5-10
l urine, 2 kg dicot flour are well mixed and this
add-in irrigation tank at regular intervals of 15 days
until the soil is enriched or spray 2001 of jeevamruth
twice in a month. It provides nutrients, microbial
population, and helps to prevent fungal and
bacterial plant diseases. It requires only 1st three
Recent agricultural graduates are also stationed
in a village for two years as Natural Farming
Fellows where they lease land and practice ZBNF
to demonstrate its viability to nearby farmers.
Natural Farming Fellows adapt ZBNF’s core
elements to local conditions and help to attract
youth to the program (Gupta and Jain 2020).
Women’s self-help groups are instrumental in
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
314
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
A Critical Study on the Present Status and Scope of Natural Farming in the State of Andhra Pradesh, India
years cycle after that system that self-sustaining.
According to Mr. Palekar, only one cow is needed
for 30 acres of land that should be a local desi cow
not imported Jersey or Holstein because of imported
cow dung and urine contains more pathogens and
desi cow dung contains 300 to 500 crores of effective
beneficial microbes.
By their root nodules fixes atmospheric N into the
soil which helps N supply to crops. From these
residues retention on the surface of soil increases
the microbial degradation process and liberation
of N from nitrification. It also supplies organic
matter to the soil which contains many micro and
macronutrients. Improves seed germination without
soil plowing, reduce soil temperature in extreme
condition, and increase soil temperature during
winter. It conserves soil moisture by reducing
evaporation loss of water from the soil layer and
retains water for a longer time.
4. Whapasa –aeration
The main concern here is conserving water and the
precise application of water-based on crop water
requirement. Application of water in alternative
furrows because of all roots of plants not absorb
efficiently, younger horizontal and vertical roots
absorb more amount of water than older one and
nutrients by older roots. In soil, out of soil mineral
and organic matter, there is an equal proportion of
water and air present. If a higher amount of water
application leads to hold air space in the soil and
plant suffers oxygen deficiency it may lead to cause
death of plants except water-loving plants like
rice. The soil aeration also an important parameter
to plant growth so application interval should be
longer.
Pest management in ZBNF
Crops are damaged by pests and diseases about
most of the yield loss by weeds followed by pests
and diseases. Controlling of this loss is also a big
challenge in natural farming. Plant extractions are
used to make a compound that kills or controls the
pest population in the crop field. Some of plant
protections are made by using a mixture of butter
milk, cow milk, pepper powder, neem seed and
green chilli (Palekar 2016). Some research papers
found some naturally extracted chemical-free
compounds are explained below. They are—
2. Bijamrita
It is composed of 20 l water, 5 kg cow dung,
5l urine 50 g lime, and a hand full of soil are
thoroughly and store in a tank. It is used as a seed
treatment, contains naturally occurring beneficial
microorganisms. Research studies showed that
inoculating with bijamrith to protect the crop from
harmful soil-borne pathogens and young seedlings
roots from fungus and soil-borne and seed-borne
diseases also help to produce IAA and GA3
(Sreenivasa et al. 2010).
1. Agriastra
3. Acchadana/Mulching
It consists of local cow urine (10l), tobacco leaves
(1 kg), green chili (500 g), local garlic (500 g), and
neem leaves pulp crushed in cow urine (5l) store it
in a cool place. Take 2l per 100l of water and spray
Mulching is of three types followed, they are straw
mulch, soil mulch, and live mulch. The growth of
cover crops like legumes helps to reduce the weed
population and increases water infiltration capacity.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
315
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Srishailam et al.
on crops. It effectively controls the pests like Leaf
Roller, Stem Borer, Fruit borer, Pod borer.
marginal farmers (owning or renting less than 2.5
acres), approximately 20 percent were small farmers
(2.5 to 5 acres), and the remaining percentage were
large farmers (more than 5 acres) (Gupta et al.
2020). In Karnataka, approximately 72 percent of
ZBNF farmers surveyed owned less than 10 hectares
(Khadse et al. 2018). On average, ZBNF farmers
received more education than non-ZBNF farmers.
Forty-two percent of non-ZBNF farmers surveyed
in Gupta et al. (2020) did not receive any formal
schooling, compared to only 20 percent of ZBNF
farmers (Gupta et al. 2020). Based on a survey of 60
farmers in Andhra Pradesh, one study concluded
that education has a positive, statistically significant
impact on farmers’ perception of ZBNF (Sarada and
Kumar 2018). A small proportion of women relative
to men adopt ZBNF, although more than 161,000
women’s self-help groups form the foundation of the
program (RySS 2019). Gupta et al. (2020) found that
4 and 7 percent of conventional and ZBNF farmers
surveyed, respectively, were women. Women in
Andhra Pradesh typically participated in the ZBNF
program by selling inputs, marketing to other
farmers in the community, and monitoring farming
plans (RySS 2019; Tripathi et al. 2018). Studies did
not observe significant differences between ZBNF
and non-ZBNF farmers by caste. Scheduled Caste
and Scheduled Tribe farmers represent the smallest
share of ZBNF farmers, followed by the general or
Other Backward Class (Gupta et al. 2020; RySS 2019).
2. Brahmastra
It is 2nd way to control the pest population in natural
farming, it can be made by collecting different
plant leaves like neem leaves, custard apple leaves,
lantern camellia leaves, guava leaves, pomegranate
leaves, papaya leaves, and white datura leaves
are crushed and boiled with urine finally make
filtration. After filtration, the extractant can store
for longer use. It is most effective against all of the
sucking pests, pod borer, fruit borer, etc.
3. Neemastra
By using 5 l of local cow urine, 5 kg cow dung, 5
kg neem leaves 5 kg of neem pulp mixed well, and
keep to airtight for 24 hours for fermentation. After
the fermentation process is ready to use. Mainly
controls sucking pests & Mealy Bug.
ZBNF ADOPTION
Partial adoption: Some farmers reduce the risks
associated with adopting ZBNF by experimenting
with only a subset of ZBNF practices, most
commonly jeevamrutham and beejamrutham
(Gupta et al. 2020). This incremental adoption of
ZBNF practices is referred to as a vertical transition
(Gupta et al. 2020) and also as stacking (especially
when there are two or more practices implemented
at the same time). Some farmers also choose to
adopt ZBNF on only a portion of their land. RySS
expects that a farmer will typically adopt ZBNF
on a quarter of their landholding in the first year,
half of their landholding in the second year, and
complete adoption during the third year—a process
described as a horizontal transition (Gupta et al.
2020; RySS 2019). As a result, the land area under
ZBNF adoption is lower than the total amount of
land associated with farmers in the ZBNF program.
Reasons for adoption: Farmers primarily chose to
adopt ZBNF to reduce the cost of cultivation (Bishnoi
and Bhati 2017; Biswas 2020; Khadse et al. 2018;
Khurana and Kumar 2020; Mier y Terán Giménez
Cacho et al. 2019; Münster 2017). Since ZBNF does
not require chemical inputs, overall input costs
decrease dramatically, thereby reducing the need
for credit to purchase chemical inputs. One farmer
stated that costs were so low that he was no longer
concerned with achieving a certain yield to return a
profit (Bishnoi and Bhati 2017). Khurana and Kumar
(2020) conducted focus groups with 142 farmers
across five districts and found that 100 percent of
farmers surveyed felt their costs decreased under
ZBNF (Khurana and Kumar 2020). In a concurrent
survey of 40 farmers, 90 percent of farmers believed
costs decreased under ZBNF, and 10 percent felt that
costs remained the same as in conventional farming
(Khurana and Kumar 2020). In the Prakasam district
Farmer characteristics: Farm size and education are
the most predictive farmer characteristics for ZBNF
adoption. Most ZBNF farmers have small to medium
sized landholdings (Gupta et al. 2020; Khadse et al.
2018). The Council on Energy, Environment, and
Water (CEEW) surveyed 581 farmers (254 ZBNF, 327
non-ZBNF) in six districts in Andhra Pradesh. More
than 70 percent of ZBNF farmers surveyed were
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
316
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
A Critical Study on the Present Status and Scope of Natural Farming in the State of Andhra Pradesh, India
of Andhra Pradesh, farmers held diverging views
on the cost impacts of ZBNF (Sarada and Kumar
2018). Forty-five percent of farmers surveyed in
Prakasam believed that ZBNF did not reduce costs
relative to conventional farming, and 42 percent
believed ZBNF did reduce costs. The remaining
13 percent were undecided (Sarada and Kumar
2018). The results in Prakasam were likely different
from the aforementioned studies due to changes
in labor costs. In Karnataka, farmers primarily
adopted ZBNF due to health benefits (presumably
from reduced exposure to chemicals), followed
by food self-sufficiency, environmental reasons,
and reduced costs and debt (Khadse et al. 2018).
Other motivations for adopting ZBNF in Karnataka
included economic independence from corporations
and spiritual reasons (Khadse et al. 2018).
Case Study
A College Lecturer turns into a Profitable Natural
Farming Farmer- A successful case of Reddy
Mahalakshmanudu at Vadlamuru Village, Agiripally
Mandal, Krishna District, and Andhra Pradesh State.
Name: Mr. Reddy Mahalakshmanudu
Village: Vadlamanu
Mandal: Agiripally
District: Krishna
Contact No: 9640727329
Education: M.Ed
Mr Reddy Mahalakshmanudu, a college lecturur who
turned in a progressive Natural farming farmer.
Barriers to adoption: Research has shown that
barriers to ZBNF adoption include time and labor
constraints, access to cows, land access, and tenant
farmer arrangements (Bhattacharya 2017; Galab et
al. 2019a; Khurana and Kumar 2020). Small farmers
noted that ZBNF input preparation is time and
labor intensive (Galab et al. 2019a; Gupta et al. 2020;
Khurana and Kumar 2020; Reddy et al. 2019). Gupta
et al. (2020) concluded beejamrutham required the
most labor out of all ZBNF inputs due to manual
seed coating and hand-mixing of ingredients
(Gupta et al. 2020). The Centre for Study of Science,
Technology, and Policy (CSTEP) surveyed 120
farmers and reported that each acre of paddy under
ZBNF required 60 hours of work from men, 800
hours from women, and 10 hours of bullock labor,
compared to 110 hours of work from men, 530
hours from women, and 40 hours of bullock labor
per non-ZBNF acre (CSTEP 2020). Studies found
that large farmers were less likely to adopt ZBNF
due to labor and time constraints, as the increased
costs to hire labor affected their profitability (Das
2020; Gupta et al. 2020; Khurana and Kumar 2020).
One author claimed ZBNF was not profitable for
farmers owning more than five acres (Das 2020).
Although ZBNF’s farmer-tofarmer network helps to
fill knowledge gaps on implementation, knowledge
about how to prepare and use bio-pesticides (e.g.,
neemastra, agniastra, brahmastra) is still a constraint
to adoption (Galab et al. 2019a; Sarada and Kumar
2018).
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Training & Motivation
His father and other villagers were basically farmers
practicing conventional method of farming. His family
they observed wiping out of their mango orchard
due to indiscrimiate use of chemical and low income
from orchard and even from other crops. In mango,
they were facing the problem of stem and leaf falling,
no fruit bearing and uneven ripening along with
reduced production. He highlighted that the soil
condition was deteriorating, as the soil turned harder
and soil organisms were disapperaing. Mr Reddy
Mahalakshmudu is well educated person and knew the
value of soil and had respect towards agriculture made
him to meet his friend Srinivas Rao, who was working
has a Community Resource Person (CRP) under Rythu
Sadhikara Samstha (RySS) in his village. Discusing with
his friend he decided to practice natural farming in
2016. The training programme of Sri Subhash Pallekhar
motivated his towards natural farming and there he
learned all the preparation methods of natural farming
inputs like Jeevamrutham, Beejamrutham, Neemastra,
Gana Jeevamrutham etc.
Adoption of natural farming practices and
achievements
Initially he started natural farming in his 4 acres of land,
317
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Srishailam et al.
he incured losses in his early stage but he continued
because natural farming had a positive effect on his
family health. After 3 years, his field started earning
well and then he brought extra 5 acres of land as lease
to continue natural farming along with his 4 acres of
land. He prepare his input himself and expressed it
as nor difficult neither labour intenstive. He prepares
beejamritham, ghanajivamritham, jeevamritham,
Gokrupa amrutham, mulching, growth regulators
(fish amino acid, egg amino acid, botanical extract,
sapthdanya kashayam, etc,.), and kashayams for pest
management. Low cost input substition, like he uses
overriped mangoes (which has no market value)
instead of jaggery in jeevamritham, use of waste plaste
bottle with lure (saves moneys from Rs 10-15 and use
of bananas to ripe Managoes evenly). Better use of by
products, used in selling and also in preparation of
natural farming inputs in his field. His farm serves as
a model farm for not only the farmers of his village
but also the farmers of nearby villages and officials too.
a amount of money to his income. He is awarded as
best farmer from Krishna district by Rythu Nastham
Foundation, 2018. Mr Reddy Mahalakshmanudu success
story is an inspiration to other, who would like to earn
good profits in Agriculture and respect in society. He
stated that by providing good market facilities for
the natural produce and recognising natural farming
farmers will leads to adopt natural farming by all
farmers of the state.
Challenges to adopt ZBNF
Natural farming is eco-friendly sustainable to the
environment maintains good health of soil, plant
as well as human beings by increasing beneficial
microbial population, chemical-free nutrients supply
to plants and toxic-free food supplies to consumers
(man and animals). But still, farmers are not going
to adapt this technology due to some lacunas so the
govt, researchers, scientist and extension workers
should think about major challenges to success this
zero budget natural farming technology in a large
area, and according to authors view some of the
major challenges are listed below.
Table 1: Comparison between Natural
and Conventional Farming by Mr. Reddy
Mahalakshmanudu
Parameters
Natural
Farming
Conventional
Farming
Crop
Mango Paddy Mango Paddy
Cost of
51,000
cultivation (in `)
25,000
74,000
23,000
Production
(Quintals)
30
20
15
18
Gross returns
(in `)
2,40,000 93,500
70,000
28,000
Net returns (in `) 1,99,000 68,500
24,000
5,000
B:C ratio
0.95
1.2
4.71
3.74
1. The labor requirement is increased compared
to conventional farming.
2. The demand for animal manure is high.
On a national scale, the number of cattle in
India could not support this level of manure
application.
3. With the demand and consumption pattern
constantly changing when it comes to highvalue products.
4. Better technology and high investment
are required on farmland. Well developed
heavy machinery, implements are not used
in natural farming due to it creates soil
compaction even there is no use of tractors
in it.
Benefits
He expressed that by practicing natural farming in his
farm, he got profits and notable increase in production
of crops by 10 per cent then conventional farmers.
Enhanced quality of vegetables and improved the shelf
life of mango and taste of rice has improved double
fold. He is an innovative farmer, as he tries practicing
new thing in his farm for better yield and incocme,
for example; he tried grafting in a mango tree with
17 varities of mangoes. He sells his mangos and other
vegetables to the local officials and school teachers
and other public representatives, this has gained good
recognition. There no issue regarding marketing,
as he does direct marketing of his produce without
middlemen to the consumers of cities and towns like
Visakapatnam, Vijaywada, Hyderabad, Benguluru
etc (Whatsapp group with his consumers to promote
and sell his produce). He rears his indigenious cows
naturally, sells their milk at good price and this adds
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
5. Weakened agricultural market infrastructurethere is no value of natural products in large
scale areas even the price also similar to
chemically produced products.
6. N o s c i e n t i f i c va l i d a t i o n - m i c r o b i a l
composition, efficiency, and impact of
jivamrith, bijamrith, bramhastra, dashaparni
kashaya not yet tested and there is no
scientific data on it.
318
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
A Critical Study on the Present Status and Scope of Natural Farming in the State of Andhra Pradesh, India
7. Hybrid varieties, not permitted-continuously
increasing global population food is scarce to
all populations. Even by using chemicals, we
are not reaching our food production target,
without hybrids, it is impossible to reach the
target.
6. Scheme for cattle and other live stock
farmers far the purpose of it maintaince and
marketing of live stock produce.
7. Ensure the availability of natural farming
inputs in all villages under Rythu Barosa
Kendras it will be help full for initial period
farmers to get good yields
8. Promotion of ZBNF on a large scale without
scientific validation and under the political
influence- no scientific data on crop yield.
8. More training and demonstration respect to
crop specific will be given to natural farming
farmers and also teach the techniques of
preparation of natural farming inputs.
9. Pest management is difficult- different cropspecific weeds, diseases, insects are damaging
to crop drastically, by using natural products
its control is not satisfactory to farmer’s level.
9. Increase the availabilty of Non Pesticides
Management shops in all villages and
aslo give some financial assistance for the
managers of NPMs
10. Quality planting material and other proven
techniques like GMO’s are not considered in
ZBNF.
10. Need to create special marketing channel far
the natural farming inputs that will fletch
to get more profits to the natural farming
farmers. It will also motivate other farmers
also to take up natural farming.
11. Criticizes other agroecological and organic
farming techniques.
12. Non-availability of indigenous cow, it
contains Millions of beneficial microbes and
pathogen-free dung.
CONCLUSION
13. As ZBNF adapted in India by Mr. Subash
Palekar is not adopted in his own state
Maharashtra.
Zero budget farming is environmentally friendly.
Savings on the cost of seeds, fertilizers, and
plant protection chemicals have been substantial.
Because of continuous retention of crop residues
replenishment the soil fertility, it helps to maintain
the soil health. Other thing is that management
of pest and diseases is a key component in zero
budget natural farming crop production systems.
Successfully control pests in ZBNF, it is essential to
understand the interactions of different components
in a specific ecosystem. The new system of farming
has free debt trap of farmers and it has instilled
in them a renewed sense of confidence to make
farming an economically viable venture. The
challenges and opportunities are two parameters
that show the systems lacunas to researchers,
scientists, and extension workers and benefits to
adopters, and policy intervention is necessary to
make the success.
Suitable Suggestions for Improving Natural
Farming in Andhra Pradesh State
1. Essential to recognise the natural farming
farmers and thay need special programmes
for there welfare and stability.
2. Creating Brand value to the natural farming
produce and also location specific brand
identity will be needed like geographical
Indication in natural farming for the produce.
3. Marketing will be major issue to the natural
farming farmers it need to be resolved most
priority basis and special price for the natural
farming produce willbe ensured.
4. Hand holding support from the government
side will need to the natural farming farmers
in initial periods.
5. The state department of agriculture and
others related institutes of agriculture like
SAUs and KVKs, ATMA, DAATTC, will
focus more on natural farming involvement
will be needed.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
319
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Srishailam et al.
REFERENCES
Ahmed, K. 2018. Taking agroecology to scale: the Zero Budget
Natural Farming peasant movement in Karnataka, India,
The J. Peasant Stud., 45(1).
https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ahmedabad/
pm-modi-natural-farming-farmers-burning-cropresidue-7675909/)
https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/roadmapfor-india-natural-farming-ambitions-nirmala-fmbudget-7788054/
https://spnfhp.nic.in/SPNF/en-IN/spnf.aspx
https://www.niti.gov.in/natural-farming-niti-initiative.
Khurana, A. and Kumar, R. 2022. Evidence (2004-20) on
holistic benefits of organic and natural farming in India,
Centre for Science and Environment, New Delhi.
Khurana, A. and Kumar, V. 2020. State of organic and natural
farming: Challenges and possibilities, Centre for Science and
Environment, New Delhi
Rajesh K Rana and Singh, R. 2018. Restoring human and
environmental health through creative natural farming
practices, Agri-Innovators: The Torch Bearers of Brighter
Agriculture, ICAR-ATARI, Zone-I, Ludhiana, India, pp.
19-24.
The Economic Survey. 2019. https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/
economicsurvey/2019-20.
Source: Answer to a question in Lok Sabha
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
320
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 321-328, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.6
Influence of Preservatives and Biodegradable Nano Silver
Film on Post-harvest Life of Jasminum sambac Cv. “Mysuru
Mallige”
Keerthishankar, K.1*, Yathindra, H.A.1, Mutthuraju, G.P.2 and Tanveer Ahmed3
Department of Floriculture and Landscape Architecture, College of Horticulture, Bengaluru, India
Department of Entomology, College of Horticulture, Mysuru, India
3
Department of Agriculture Economics, College of Horticulture, Mysuru, India
1
2
*Corresponding author: keerthishankar55@gmail.com (ORCID ID: 0000-0002-6280-7585)
Paper No. 991
Received: 22-05-2022
Revised: 24-06-2022
Accepted: 01-07-2022
ABSTRACT
Experiment was carried out in the Department of Floriculture and Landscape Architecture, College of
Horticulture Mysuru during 2019-2021 to find out the effect of chemical preservatives and biodegradable
nano silver film on post-harvest life of Jasminum sambac cv. Mysuru Mallige. The experiment was laid
out in Factorial Completely randomized Design (FCRD) with 15 treatment and two replications. The
periodical observations recorded every 12 hrs from 0 hrs to 36 hrs. were physiological loss of weight,
freshness index and shelf-life. Results of this experiment envisaged that flowers which are treated with
5 per cent boric acid and packed in 60 micron biodegradable nano silver film recorded less physiological
loss of weight with maximum fragrance index and shelf-life of the flower.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm Jasmine (Jasminum spp.) is one of the most fragrant flowers belongs to the family Oleaceae and flowers
have a great economic value in India and mainly used as loose flower for making garland and oil
extraction. Among the commercial species of jasmine, Jasminum sambac Ait. commonly known as
Arabian jasmine, Tuscan jasmine, Mogra and Bela. There have several cultivars like Motia, Double
Mogra, Single Mogra, Gundu Mallige, Bela, Khoya, Madanbana, Ramabana and Mysuru Mallige.
Among these cultivars, Mysuru Mallige (Mysuru Jasmine) being associated with the city of Mysuru,
patronized by the wodeyar of the kingdom of Mysuru because of its flower fragrance. The Mysuru
Jasmine has got Geographical Indication status (GI under Registration of Protection Act 1999) under
agriculture commodity (69th G.I. Product of India) by Govt. of India during 2007-08 for its unique
fragrance and flowering characters and commonly cultivated in Mysore and Mandya regions of
Karnataka.
Keywords: Jasmine, Preservatives, Nano silver film, Shelf-life
Mysuru Mallige flowers are highly perishable in
nature and got good demand in local market as well
as outside market like Kerala, Tamilnadu, Mumbai
etc. One of the major problems faced by grower are
lack of suitable packaging technology for export. The
flowers are very delicate and show signs of wilting
with abrupt loss of fragrance within 24 -36 hours
after harvest. Under normal condition, jasmine
flowers do not retain for more than a day and show
a sign of browning or rotting of petals on the second
day of harvest with an abrupt loss in fragrance.
Krishnamoorthy (1990) reported that packaging is
a fundamental tool for post-harvest management
How to cite this article: Keerthishankar, K., Yathindra, H.A.,
Mutthuraju, G.P. and Ahmed, T. (2022). Influence of Preservatives
and Biodegradable Nano Silver Film on Post-harvest Life of Jasminum
sambac Cv. “Mysuru Mallige”. Int. J. Ag. Env. Biotech., 15(Special Issue):
321-328.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Keerthishankar et al.
of highly perishable commodities and adequate
packaging protects the produce from physical,
physiological and pathological deterioration during
transport and marketing, enhancing their shelf-life
by retaining their attractiveness. So, standardization
of post-harvest techniques to extend shelf-life of
Mysuru Mallige flowers will helpful to famers to
exploit distant market. Keeping this in mind, a
study was under taken to enhance the post-harvest
life of Mysuru Mallige.
packing and at 12th, 24th, and 36th hr after harvesting
of flowers and expressed as percentage. Freshness
score were recorded based on scale, the score was
expressed on 1 to 10 (Isac, 2015) and average was
calculated. Shelf-life of the flower was measured
as time taken to wilt 50% of flowers. The resulted
data were statistically analyzed using the method
of Panase and Sukhatme (1967).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The result obtaining with respect to Physiological
loss in weight, Freshness index and Shelf life of
Mysuru Mallige flowers are presented in the table
2, 3 and 4 respectively.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was carried out in the Department of
Floriculture and Landscape Architecture, College of
Horticulture Mysuru during 2019-2021 to find out the
effect of chemical preservatives and biodegradable
nano silver film on post-harvest life of Jasminum
sambac cv. Mysuru Mallige. The experiment was
laid out in Factorial Completely randomized Design
(FCRD) with two replications and two factors:
Different preservatives at different concentration
and different thickness of biodegradable nano silver
film. The first factor comprised of five treatments
viz., T1: Boric acid at 4 per cent, T2: Boric acid at
5 per cent, T3: Silver nitrate at 0.2 per cent, T4:
Silver nitrate at 0.3 per cent and T5: Water spray
(Control) and second factor contains 3 treatments
viz., B1: 40-micron Nano silver film, B2: 60-micron
Nano silver film and B3: 70-micron Nano silver film.
500g of uniform size, freshly harvested flowers
buds are used for each treatment and observation
like physiological loses of weight (PLW), freshness
score and shelf-life were recorded during storage
of flowers at 24 hours of intervals.
Physiological loss in weight of the flowers (%)
The data on physiological loss in weight of the
flower (%) as influenced by different preservatives
and biodegradable packaging materials and their
interaction effects are presented in Table 2.
Chemical preservatives (T)
Among different chemical preservatives, the
minimum physiological loss in weight of the flowers
(1.02 per cent, 1.87 per cent and 2.52 per cent) was
recorded in 5 per cent boric acid (T2) and maximum
physiological loss in weight of the flowers (4.50 per
cent, 6.31 per cent and 7.26 per cent) was recorded
in T5 i.e., water spray at 12, 24 and 36 hours after
imposing the treatments respectively during
2019-20. Similarly, during 2020-21, the minimum
physiological loss in weight of the flowers (0.94 per
cent, 1.83 per cent and 2.45 per cent) was recorded in
T2 i.e., spray of 5 per cent boric acid and maximum
physiological loss in weight of the flowers (4.45 per
cent, 6.26 per cent and 7.24 per cent) was recorded
in water spray (T5, control) at 12, 24 and 36 hours
after imposing the treatment respectively. Pooled
data revealed that, spray of 5 per cent boric acid
(T2) recorded minimum physiological loss in weight
(0.98 ± 0.06 per cent, 1.85 ± 0.03 per cent and 2.49
± 0.05 per cent) and maximum physiological loss
in weight of the flower (4.47 ± 0.04 per cent, 6.29 ±
0.04 per cent and 7.25 ± 0.01 per cent) was recorded
in T5 i.e., water spray at 12, 24 and 36 hours after
imposing the treatment respectively.
Table 1: Freshness score details
Freshness index
Score
Original colour/ fresh flower
1
Partial fading of original colour
2
Complete fading of original colour
3
1 to 10% brown
4
11 to 15% brown
5
16 to 30% brown
6
30 to 50% brown
7
51 to 75% brown
8
76 to 90% brown
9
All brown
10
Biodegradable packaging material (B)
Physiological loses of weight was calculated by
subtracting fresh weight of flowers at the time of
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Among the different thickness of biodegradable
322
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Influence of Preservatives and Biodegradable Nano Silver Film on Post-harvest Life...
Table 2: Effect of different preservatives and biodegradable packaging material on
physiological loss in weight (%)
Treatments
2019-20
12 hrs. 24 hrs.
36 hrs.
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
1.29
1.02
3.22
2.87
4.50
0.05
0.13
2.09
1.87
4.50
4.23
6.31
0.04
0.12
2.99
2.52
5.58
4.85
7.26
0.04
0.12
B1
B2
B3
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
2.84
2.34
2.57
0.04
0.10
4.13
3.45
3.82
0.03
0.09
5.01
4.29
4.62
0.03
0.09
T1B1
T1B2
T1B3
T2B1
T2B2
T2B3
T3B1
T3B2
T3B3
T4B1
T4B2
T4B3
T5B1
T5B2
T5B3
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
1.36
1.21
1.31
1.39
0.75
0.93
3.38
3.06
3.21
3.16
2.53
2.92
4.91
4.14
4.46
0.08
0.23
2.28
1.92
2.08
2.11
1.65
1.83
4.81
4.03
4.65
4.55
3.95
4.20
6.90
5.72
6.32
0.07
0.20
3.24
2.80
2.94
2.92
2.23
2.42
5.90
5.21
5.64
5.27
4.35
4.92
7.72
6.86
7.20
0.07
0.20
2020-21
24 hrs.
36 hrs.
12 hrs.
Preservatives (T)
1.27
2.07
2.94
1.28 ± 0.01
0.94
1.83
2.45
0.98 ± 0.06
3.16
4.46
5.55
3.19 ± 0.04
2.76
4.17
4.78
2.81 ± 0.08
4.45
6.26
7.24
4.47 ± 0.04
0.05
0.04
0.04
—
0.13
0.12
0.13
—
Biodegradable packaging material (B)
2.73
4.11
4.96
2.79 ± 0.08
2.30
3.43
4.24
2.32 ± 0.02
2.51
3.74
4.57
2.54 ± 0.04
0.04
0.03
0.03
—
0.10
0.09
0.10
—
Interactions
1.35
2.23
3.17
1.36 ± 0.01
1.21
1.93
2.77
1.21 ± 0.00
1.26
2.04
2.90
1.29 ± 0.03
1.27
2.07
2.87
1.33 ± 0.09
0.68
1.62
2.17
0.72 ± 0.05
0.87
1.80
2.32
0.90 ± 0.04
3.27
4.80
5.87
3.33 ± 0.08
3.03
4.03
5.17
3.05 ± 0.02
3.17
4.55
5.60
3.19 ± 0.03
2.97
4.50
5.22
3.07 ± 0.14
2.50
3.88
4.28
2.51 ± 0.02
2.80
4.13
4.83
2.86 ± 0.08
4.80
6.95
7.68
4.85 ± 0.08
4.10
5.67
6.83
4.12 ± 0.03
4.44
6.17
7.20
4.45 ± 0.01
0.08
0.07
0.08
—
0.23
0.21
0.22
—
12 hrs.
Pooled Mean
24 hrs.
36 hrs.
2.08 ± 0.02
1.85 ± 0.03
4.48 ± 0.02
4.20 ± 0.04
6.29 ± 0.04
—
—
2.97 ± 0.03
2.49 ± 0.05
5.57 ± 0.03
4.81 ± 0.05
7.25 ± 0.01
—
—
4.12 ± 0.01
3.44 ± 0.02
3.78 ± 0.06
—
—
4.99 ± 0.03
4.27 ± 0.03
4.60 ± 0.04
—
—
2.26 ± 0.04
1.93 ± 0.01
2.06 ± 0.02
2.09 ± 0.03
1.63 ± 0.02
1.82 ± 0.02
4.80 ± 0.00
4.03 ± 0.00
4.60 ± 0.07
4.53 ± 0.04
3.92 ± 0.05
4.17 ± 0.05
6.93 ± 0.04
5.69 ± 0.04
6.24 ± 0.11
—
—
3.20 ± 0.05
2.78 ± 0.02
2.92 ± 0.03
2.90 ± 0.03
2.20 ± 0.05
2.37 ± 0.07
5.88 ± 0.02
5.19 ± 0.03
5.62 ± 0.03
5.24 ± 0.04
4.32 ± 0.05
4.88 ± 0.06
7.70 ± 0.02
6.85 ± 0.02
7.20 ± 0.00
—
—
T1: Boric acid at 4 per cent; T2: Boric acid at 5 per cent; T3: Silver nitrate at 0.2 per cent; T4: Silver nitrate at 0.3 per cent; T5: Water spray;
B1: 40-micron Nano silver film; B2: 60-micron Nano silver film; B3: 70-micron Nano silver film.
packaging material, flowers which are packed in
60 micron nano silver film (B2) recorded minimum
physiological loss in weight (2.34 per cent, 3.45 per
cent and 4.29 per cent) and maximum physiological
loss in weight (2.84 per cent, 4.13 per cent and 5.01
per cent) of the flower was recorded in 40 micron
nano silver film (B1) at 12, 24 and 36 hours after
imposing the treatment respectively during 2019-20.
Similarly, during 2020-21, the flowers which were
packed in 60 micron nano silver film (B2) recorded
minimum physiological loss in weight (2.30 per
cent, 3.43 per cent and 4.24 per cent). Maximum
physiological loss in weight (2.73 per cent, 4.11
per cent and 4.96 per cent) was recorded in B1 i.e.,
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
40 micron nano silver film at 12, 24 and 36 hours
after imposing the treatment respectively. Pooled
data revealed that, minimum physiological loss in
weight of the flower (2.32 ± 0.02 per cent, 3.44 ±
0.02 per cent and 4.27 ± 0.03 per cent) was recorded
in B2 (60 micron biodegradable nano silver film)
whereas maximum physiological loss in weight of
the flower (2.79 ± 0.08, 4.12 ± 0.01, and 4.99+ 0.03
per cent) was recorded in 40-micron biodegradable
nano silver film (B1).
Interaction (T × B)
Interaction effect was significant on physiological
loss in weight (%) at 12, 24 and 36 hours after
323
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Keerthishankar et al.
imposing the treatment in both the season i.e., 201920 and 2020-21.
different chemical preservatives and biodegradable
packaging material and their interaction effects
during 2019-20 and 2020-21 are presented in Table 3.
The interaction results showed that, T2B2 (spray
of 5 per cent boric acid and packed in 60 micron
biodegradable nano silver film) recorded minimum
physiological loss in weight of the flower (0.75
per cent, 1.65 per cent and 2.23 per cent) followed
by T2B3 i.e., 0.93 per cent, 1.83 per cent and 2.42
per cent. Maximum physiological loss in weight
(4.91 per cent, 6.90 per cent and 7.72 per cent) was
recorded in T5B1 interaction (water spray and flowers
are packed in 40 micron biodegradable nano silver
film) at 12, 24 and 36 hours after imposing the
treatment respectively during 2019-20. During 202021, flowers which are treated with 5 per cent boric
acid and packed in 60 micron biodegradable nano
silver film (T2B2) recorded minimum physiological
loss in weight (0.68 per cent, 1.62 per cent and 2.17
per cent) followed by T2B3 (0.87 per cent, 1.80 per
cent and 2.32 per cent). Interaction of T5B1 (water
spray and storage in 40 micron biodegradable
nano silver film) recorded maximum physiological
loss in weight of the flower (4.80 per cent, 6.95 per
cent and 7.68 per cent) at 12, 24 and 36 hours after
imposing the treatment respectively. Pooled mean
revealed that, T2B2 (Spray of 5 per cent boric acid and
packed in 60 micron biodegradable nano silver film)
interaction recorded minimum physiological loss in
weight (0.72 ± 0.05 per cent, 1.63 ± 0.02 per cent and
2.20 ± 0.05 per cent) and maximum physiological
loss in weight (4.85 ±0.08 per cent, 6.93 ± 0.04 per
cent and 7.70 ± 0.02 per cent) was recorded in T5B1
interaction (water spray and flowers are packed at
40 micron biodegradable nano silver film).
Chemical preservatives (T)
The treatment consisting of boric acid spray at 5 per
cent (T2) recorded maximum freshness index score
of 9.52, 8.33 and 4.78. Whereas minimum freshness
index (8.00, 5.60 and 2.09) was recorded in T5 (Water
spray) at 12, 24 and 36 hours after imposing the
treatment respectively during 2019-20. Among
the different spray of chemical preservatives, the
maximum freshness index score (9.56, 8.37 and 4.82)
was recorded in spray of 5 per cent boric acid (T2)
and minimum freshness score (8.03, 5.54 and 2.04)
was recorded in T5 i.e., water spray at 12, 24 and
36 hours after imposing the treatment respectively
during 2020-21. Pooled data revealed that, spray
of 5 per cent boric acid (T2) recorded maximum
freshness index score (9.54 ± 0.03, 8.35 ± 0.03 and
4.80 ± 0.03) and minimum freshness score (8.02 ±
0.02, 5.57 ± 0.04 and 2.07 ± 0.04) was recorded in
T5 i.e., water spray at 12, 24 and 36 hours after
imposing the treatment respectively.
Biodegradable packaging material (B)
Flowers packed in 60 micron biodegradable nano
silver film (B2) recorded maximum freshness index
score (9.01, 7.40 and 3.95), whereas 40 micron
biodegradable nano silver film (B 1 ) recorded
minimum freshness index (8.74, 6.55 and 2.85) at
12, 24 and 36 hours after imposing the treatment
respectively during 2019-20. Among the different
thickness of biodegradable packaging material,
flowers which are packed in 60 micron nano silver
film (B2) recorded maximum freshness index score
of 9.03, 7.40 and 3.96. Minimum freshness index
score (8.75, 6.56 and 2.86) was recorded in 40 micron
nano silver film (B1) at 12, 24 and 36 hours after
imposing the treatment respectively during 2020-21.
Pooled data revealed that, B2 i.e., flowers packed in
60 micron biodegradable nano silver film recorded
maximum freshness index score (9.02 ± 0.01, 7.40
± 0.00 and 3.96 ± 0.01) and minimum freshness
index score (8.75 ± 0.01, 6.56 ± 0.01 and 2.86 ± 0.01)
was recorded in 40 micron nano silver film (B1) at
12, 24 and 36 hours after imposing the treatment
respectively.
Boric acid is an anti-senescence agent, increases
water balance in flower, delay the ethylene
production, minimizes the physiological loss of
weight and phenol accumulation. Similar results
were also obtained by Jawaharlal et al. (2012) and
Mukhopadhyay et al. (1980) in jasmine. Nano silver
film has most effective bactericidal property against a
wide range of pathogenic microorganism, including
bacteria, yeasts, fungi and viruses (Marttinez et
al. 2012) Thus, it also increases shelf-life of flower
without altering physical characteristics (Emamifar
et al. 2010).
Freshness Index (10 point scale)
The data on freshness index as influenced by
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
324
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Influence of Preservatives and Biodegradable Nano Silver Film on Post-harvest Life...
Table 3: Effect of different preservatives and biodegradable packaging material on freshness index (10 point scale)
12 hrs.
2019-20
24 hrs. 36 hrs.
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
9.32
9.52
8.58
9.02
8.00
0.03
0.09
7.62
8.33
6.23
7.11
5.60
0.07
0.19
4.06
4.78
2.63
3.43
2.09
0.05
0.15
B1
B2
B3
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
8.74
9.01
8.91
0.02
0.07
6.55
7.40
6.99
0.05
0.15
2.85
3.95
3.39
0.04
0.12
T1B1
T1B2
T1B3
T2B1
T2B2
T2B3
T3B1
T3B2
T3B3
T4B1
T4B2
T4B3
T5B1
T5B2
T5B3
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
9.27
9.40
9.30
9.33
9.67
9.57
8.53
8.63
8.57
8.80
9.20
9.07
7.77
8.17
8.07
0.05
0.15
7.30
7.90
7.67
7.90
8.70
8.40
5.83
6.83
6.03
6.40
7.60
7.33
5.30
5.97
5.53
0.12
0.34
3.50
4.60
4.07
4.53
5.00
4.80
2.10
3.30
2.50
2.63
4.27
3.40
1.50
2.60
2.17
0.09
0.27
Treatments
2020-21
24 hrs.
36 hrs.
12 hrs.
Preservatives (P)
9.32
7.66
4.10
9.32 ± 0.00
9.56
8.37
4.82
9.54 ± 0.03
8.58
6.20
2.58
8.58 ± 0.00
9.02
7.16
3.47
9.02 ± 0.00
8.03
5.54
2.04
8.02 ± 0.02
0.03
0.07
0.05
—
0.08
0.20
0.14
—
Biodegradable packaging material (B)
8.75
6.56
2.86
8.75 ± 0.01
9.03
7.40
3.96
9.02 ± 0.01
8.93
6.99
3.40
8.92 ± 0.01
0.02
0.05
0.04
—
0.06
0.15
0.11
—
Interactions
9.27
7.33
3.55
9.27 ± 0.00
9.40
7.93
4.65
9.40 ± 0.00
9.30
7.70
4.10
9.30 ± 0.00
9.37
7.95
4.57
9.35 ± 0.03
9.70
8.73
5.05
9.69 ± 0.02
9.60
8.43
4.85
9.59 ± 0.02
8.53
5.80
2.05
8.53 ± 0.00
8.63
6.80
3.25
8.63 ± 0.00
8.57
6.00
2.45
8.57 ± 0.00
8.80
6.45
2.67
8.80 ± 0.00
9.20
7.65
4.30
9.20 ± 0.00
9.07
7.37
3.45
9.07 ± 0.00
7.80
5.25
1.45
7.79 ± 0.02
8.20
5.90
2.55
8.19 ± 0.02
8.10
5.47
2.13
8.09 ± 0.02
0.05
0.12
0.08
—
0.14
0.34
0.24
—
12 hrs.
Pooled mean
24 hrs.
36 hrs.
7.64 ± 0.03
8.35 ± 0.03
6.22 ± 0.02
7.14 ± 0.04
5.57 ± 0.04
—
—
4.08 ± 0.03
4.80 ± 0.03
2.61 ± 0.04
3.45 ± 0.03
2.07 ± 0.04
—
—
6.56 ± 0.01
7.40 ± 0.00
6.99 ± 0.00
—
—
2.86 ± 0.01
3.96 ± 0.01
3.40 ± 0.01
—
—
7.32 ± 0.02
7.92 ± 0.02
7.69 ± 0.02
7.93 ± 0.04
8.72 ± 0.02
8.42 ± 0.02
5.82 ± 0.02
6.82 ± 0.02
6.02 ± 0.02
6.43 ± 0.04
7.63 ± 0.04
7.35 ± 0.03
5.28 ± 0.04
5.94 ± 0.05
5.50 ± 0.04
—
—
3.53 ± 0.04
4.63 ± 0.04
4.09 ± 0.02
4.55 ± 0.03
5.03 ± 0.04
4.83 ± 0.04
2.08 ± 0.04
3.28 ± 0.04
2.48 ± 0.04
2.65 ± 0.03
4.29 ± 0.02
3.43 ± 0.04
1.48 ± 0.04
2.58 ± 0.04
2.15 ± 0.03
—
—
T1: Boric acid at 4 per cent; T2: Boric acid at 5 per cent; T3: Silver nitrate at 0.2 per cent; T4: Silver nitrate at 0.3 per cent; T5: Water spray;
B1: 40-micron Nano silver film; B2: 60-micron Nano silver film; B3: 70-micron Nano silver film.
Interaction (T × B)
acid and packed in 60 micron biodegradable nano
silver film (T2B2) recorded maximum freshness index
score of 9.70, 8.73 and 5.05 followed by T2B3 (Spray
of 5 per cent boric acid and packed in 70 micron
biodegradable nano silver film) (9.60, 8.43 and 4.85).
Interaction of T5B1 (water spray and flowers are
packed in 40 micron biodegradable nano silver film)
recorded minimum freshness index score of 7.80,
5.25 and 1.45 at 12, 24 and 36 hours after imposing
the treatment respectively. Pooled mean revealed
that, T2B2 (spray of 5% boric acid and packed in 60
micron biodegradable nano silver film) interaction
recorded maximum freshness index score (9.69
± 0.02, 8.72 ± 0.02 and 4.83 ± 0.04 and minimum
freshness index score (7.79 ± 0.02, 5.28 ± 0.04 and
The interaction results noted that, T2B2 (Spray of
5 per cent boric acid and packed in 60 micron
biodegradable nano silver film) interaction recorded
maximum freshness index score (9.67, 8.70 and
5.00) followed by the treatment includes spray
of 5 per cent boric acid and packed in 70 micron
biodegradable nano silver film (T2B3) i.e., 9.57, 8.40
and 4.80. Minimum freshness index of 7.77, 5.30 and
1.50 was recorded in T5B1 interaction (Water spray +
flowers are packed in 40 micron biodegradable nano
silver film) at 12, 24 and 36 hours after imposing the
treatment respectively during 2019-20. During 202021, flowers which are treated with spray of 5% boric
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
325
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Keerthishankar et al.
1.48 ± 0.04) was recorded in flowers are sprayed
with water and packed in 40 micron biodegradable
nano silver film (T5B1) interaction at 12, 24 and 36
hours after imposing the treatment respectively.
life (38.27 hrs) was recorded in 40 micron nano
silver film (B1) during 2019-20. During 2020-21,
the flowers which are packed in 60 micron nano
silver film (B2) recorded maximum shelf-life of the
flower (40.20 hrs) whereas minimum shelf-life of
the flower (38.31 hrs) was recorded in B1 i.e., 40
micron nano silver film. Pooled mean data indicated
that, maximum shelf-life of the flower (40.14 ± 0.08
hrs) was recorded in B2 (60 micron biodegradable
nano silver film) whereas minimum shelf-life of the
flower (38.29 ± 0.03 hrs) was recorded in 40 micron
biodegradable nano silver film (B1).
Boric acid proved effective by registering higher
levels of moisture, relative water content, lowest
rates of PLW. This, in turn reduces solute leakage
from flowers, indicating increased membrane
integrity of flowers. All these factors proved
effective in retaining freshness index of flowers
(Jawaharlal et al., 2012 in jasmine). Similar results
were also obtained by Maruthamuthuchandran
et al., (2018) and Mukhopadhyay et al., (1980) in
jasmine. Flowers packed in 60 micron nano silver
film are capable of modifying the atmosphere in the
packs and thus allowing the flowers to be stored for
long hours without affecting the freshness (Tavakoli
et al. 2017). These results are in close agreement
with the findings of Madaiah and Reddy (1994) and
Mukhopadhyay et al., (1980) in jasmine.
Table 4: Effect of different preservatives and
biodegradable packaging material on shelf-life (hrs)
Treatments 2019-20
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
Shelf-life (hrs)
The data on shelf-life (hrs) of the flowers as
influenced by different spray chemical preservatives
and biodegradable packaging material and their
interaction are presented in Table 4.
B1
B2
B3
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
Chemical preservatives (T)
Among the different spray of chemical preservatives,
the maximum shelf-life of the flower (43.05 hrs) was
recorded in T2 (Spray of 5 per cent boric acid) and
minimum shelf-life of the flower (33.59 hrs) was
recorded in T5 i.e., flowers were treated with only
water spray during 2019-20. During 2020-21, the
maximum shelf-life of the flower (43.14 hrs) was
recorded in treatment where flowers were treated
with 5 per cent boric acid and minimum shelf-life
(34.07 hrs) was recorded in water spray (T5- control).
Pooled data revealed that, spray of 5 per cent boric
acid (T2) recorded maximum shelf-life (43.09 ± 0.06
hrs) and minimum shelf-life (34.04 ± 0.06 hrs) was
recorded in T5 i.e., water spray.
T1B1
T1B2
T1B3
T2B1
T2B2
T2B3
T3B1
T3B2
T3B3
T4B1
T4B2
T4B3
T5B1
T5B2
T5B3
S. Em. ±
C.D@5%
Biodegradable packaging material (B)
Among the different thickness of biodegradable
packaging material, flowers which are packed
in 60 micron nano silver film (B2) was recorded
maximum shelf-life (40.08 hrs) and minimum shelfPrint ISSN : 0974-1712
2020-21
Mean
Preservatives
42.35
42.04
42.20 ± 0.07
43.05
43.14
43.09 ± 0.06
37.37
37.33
37.35 ± 0.02
39.55
40.08
40.02 ± 0.09
33.59
34.07
34.04 ± 0.06
0.14
0.15
0.40
0.44
Biodegradable packaging material
38.27
38.31
38.29 ± 0.03
40.08
40.20
40.14 ± 0.08
39.11
39.16
39.14 ± 0.04
0.11
0.12
—
0.31
0.34
—
Interactions
41.25
41.42
41.33 ± 0.12
42.50
42.58
42.54 ± 0.06
42.10
42.13
42.12 ± 0.02
41.50
41.58
41.54 ± 0.06
44.15
44.28
44.22 ± 0.09
43.50
43.55
43.53 ± 0.04
36.45
36.20
36.33 ± 0.04
37.40
37.48
37.44 ± 0.18
37.05
37.12
37.08 ± 0.06
39.00
39.13
39.07 ± 0.05
40.20
40.40
40.30 ± 0.09
39.45
39.50
39.48 ± 0.14
33.15
33.23
33.19 ± 0.06
34.18
34.27
34.23 ± 0.06
33.45
33.52
33.48 ± 0.05
0.24
0.26
—
0.70
0.76
—
T1: Boric acid at 4 per cent; T2: Boric acid at 5 per cent; T3: Silver
nitrate at 0.2 per cent; T4: Silver nitrate at 0.3 per cent; T5: Water
spray; B1: 40-micron Nano silver film; B2: 60-micron Nano silver
film; B3: 70-micron Nano silver film.
326
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Influence of Preservatives and Biodegradable Nano Silver Film on Post-harvest Life...
Shelf-life (hr's)
45.00
40.00
35.00
30.00
25.00
20.00
15.00
10.00
5.00
0.00
T1B1 T1B2 T1B3 T2B1 T2B2 T2B3 T3B1 T3B2 T3B3 T4B1 T4B2 T4B3 T5B1 T5B2 T5B3
Fig. 1: Effect of different preservatives and biodegradable packaging material on shelf-life (hrs)
Interaction (T × B)
optimum humidity and proper balance of CO2
and O2 concentration which interns slows down
the process of respiration and evapotranspiration
and ultimately reduced the PLW and enhances
shelf-life of flower. Nano silver film has potential to
minimizes the microbial load (Marttinez et al. 2012).
Thus, it also increases shelf-life of flower without
altering physical characteristics (Emamifar et al.,
2010). Boric acid also improves water balance, threeto-six-fold increase in activity of peroxidase and
catalase, maximum accumulation of carbohydrates
and retaining freshness index and shelf-life of
flower by delaying wilting (Jawaharlal et al., 2012).
The potential of boric acid in prolonging postharvest life of flowers has also been reported by
Mukhopadhyay et al., 1980 and Karuppaiah et al.,
2006 in jasmine.
Interaction effect was significantly influenced on
shelf-life of the flowers in both the season i.e., 201920 and 2020-21.
The interaction results shows that, T2B2 (spray of
5 per cent boric acid and packed in 60 micron
biodegradable nano silver film) interaction recorded
maximum shelf-life of the flower (44.15 hrs)
followed by T2B3 i.e., (43.50 hrs) and minimum
shelf-life of the flower (33.15 hrs) was recorded in
T5B1 interaction (water spray + flowers are packed
in 40 micron biodegradable nano silver film) during
2019-20. During 2020-21, the flowers which are
treated with 5 per cent boric acid and packed in
60 micron biodegradable nano silver film (T2B2)
recorded maximum shelf-life (44.28 hrs) followed
by T2B3 (43.55 hrs). Interaction of T5B1 (water spray
+ flowers are packed in 40 micron biodegradable
nano silver film) was recorded with minimum shelflife of the flower (33.23 hrs). Pooled mean shows
that, flowers sprayed with 5 per cent boric acid and
stored in 60 micron biodegradable nano silver film
(T2B2) recorded with highest shelf-life (44.22 ± 0.09
hrs) and lowest shelf-life of the flower (33.19 ± 0.06
hrs) was recorded in T5B1 interaction (water spray
and flowers are packed at 40 micron biodegradable
nano silver film).
REFERENCES
Emamifar, A., Kadivar, M., Shahedi, M. and SoleimanianZad, S. 2010. Evaluation of nanocomposite packaging
containing Ag and ZnO on shelf-life of fresh orange juice.
Innov. Food Sci. Emerg. Technol., 11: 742-748.
Isac, X.A. 2015. Blossoming and fragrance testing of jasmine
(Jasminum sambac ait.) for fresh flower utility and essential
oil extraction, Ph.D. Thesis, Tamil nadu Agric. Uni.,
Coimbatore.
Jawaharlal, M., Thamaraiselvi, S.P. and Ganga, M., 2012,
Packaging technology for export of jasmine (Jasminum
sambac Ait.) flowers. J. Hortl. Sci., 7(2): 180-189.
Boric acid act as anti-oxidant, improving water
balance, delayed ethylene production during
storage of flowers (Karuppaiah et al. 2006 in
jasmine). Similar results were also obtained by
Yathindra et al. (2018) in jasmine. Maintenance of
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Karuppaiah, P., Ramesh K.S. and Rajkumar, M. 2006, Effect
of different packages on the post-harvest behavior and
shelf-life of jasmine (Jasminum sambac). Int. J. Agric. Sci.
2(1): 447-449.
327
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Keerthishankar et al.
Krishnamoorthy, S. 1990, Packaging of horticultural crops.
Packaging India, pp. 17-20.
Mukhopadhyay, T.P., Bose, T.K., Maiti, R.G., Misra, S.K. and
Biswas, J. 1980. Effect of chemicals on the post-harvest
life of jasmine flowers. National Seminar on Production
Technology of commercial Flower Crops, Tamil Nadu
Agric. Univ., Coimbatore, pp. 47–50.
Madaiah, D. and Reddy, T.V. 1994. Influence of polyethene
packaging on the post-harvest life of tuberose cv. Single
florets. Karnataka J. Agric. Sci., 7(2): 154-157.
Panse, V.S. and Sukhatamane, P.V. 1967. Statistical methods for
agricultural workers, ICAR, New Delhi, pp. 152-155.
Marttinez-A.A., Lagaron, J.M. and Ocio M.J. 2012,
Development and characterization of silver based
antimicrobial ethylene- vinyl alcohol copolymer (EVOH)
films for food-packaging application. J. Agric. Food Chem.,
60: 5350-5359.
Tavakoli, H., Rastegar, H., Taherian, M., Samadi, M. and
Rostami, H. 2017. The effect of nano-silver packaging in
increasing the shelf-life of nuts: An in vitro model. Ital. J.
Food. Saf., 6(4): 6874-6885.
Maruthamuthuchandran, R., Jawaharla, M., Natarajan, N.
and Easwarn, E. 2018. Effect of hexanol and boric acid
on shelf-life of jasmine (Jasminum sambac Ait.) cv. Gundi
malli. Int. J. Chem. Stud., 6(5): 3069-3071.
Yathindra, H.A., Keerthishankar, K., Rajesh. A.M.,
Harshavardhan, M., Mutthuraju, G.P. and Mangala, K.P.
2018. Packaging technology for extending shelf-life of
jasmine (Jasminum sambac cv. Mysuru Mallige) flowers. J.
Pharmacognosy and Phytochemi., Sp3: 257-259.
Mukhopadhyay, T.P., Bose, T.K., Maiti, R.G., Misra, S.K. and
Biswas, J. 1980. Effect of chemicals on the post-harvest
life of jasmine flowers. National Seminar on Production
Technology of commercial Flower Crops, Tamil Nadu
Agric. Univ., Coimbatore, pp. 47–50.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
328
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 329-336, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.7
Organic Manure and Fertility Level Affects the Flowering,
Yield and Quality Attributes of Okra under Heavy Clay Soil of
Southern Rajasthan
Hemraj Meena1, Kavita, A.1, Nirmal Kumar Meena2*, Rajesh Sharma3, Ashok Kumar3
and Rahul Chopra4
Department of Vegetable Science, College of Horticulture and Forestry, Jhalawar, Rajasthan, India
Department of Fruit Science, College of Horticulture and Forestry, Jhalawar, Rajasthan, India
3
Department of Basic Science, College of Horticulture and Forestry, Jhalawar, Rajasthan, India
4
Department of Natural Resource Management, College of Horticulture and Forestry, Jhalawar, Rajasthan, India
1
2
*Corresponding author: nirmalchf@gmail.com (ORCID ID: 0000-0003-1528-2664)
Paper No. 992
Received: 23-05-2022
Revised: 27-06-2022
Accepted: 02-07-2022
ABSTRACT
The present experiment was conducted to find out the effects of organic manures and different dose
of inorganic fertilizers on yield and quality of okra cv. Varsha Upkar. The experiment consisted of 21
treatment combinations with four organic manures (control, 15 t FYM. ha-1, 5 t vermicompost. ha-1, 5 t
poultry manure. ha-1) and three fertility levels (control, 75% RDF and 100% RDF) in Factorial Randomized
Block Design (FRBD) with three replications. The results showed that the application of poultry manure
5t/ha significantly found superior which took minimum days to first flower appearance (38.90), days to
50 percent flowering (44.70), maximum number of fruits per plant, fruit weight (18.28g), yield parameters
(385.99 g/plant), chlorophyll content and crude protein. Further, 100% RDF and combined application
(100% RDF + poultry manure 5 t/ha) were also exhibited better results of flowering, yield and biochemical
parameters.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm Poultry manure is a good source of organic manure for okra plant growth and yield.
mm Application of poultry manure significantly enhanced the number of flowers and fruits per plant.
mm Poultry manure found suitable in enhancing the yield of okra.
mm Biochemical traits of okra fruits such as chlorophyll and protein also influenced by the application
of poultry manure.
Keywords: Okra, poultry manure, inorganic, chlorophyll, crude protein
Vegetables are the protective food and consumed
worldwide due to their numerous health benefits.
Okra (Abelmoscus esculentus L.) is an important
vegetable, belongs to the family Malvaceae and
grown in tropical and subtropical tracts globally as
well as in India (Akanbi 2002). This is cultivated for
its edible green seed pod. Okra is a good source of
vitamins, calcium, potassium, and other minerals. It
has been reported that okra contains good amount
of potassium, sodium, calcium, iron zinc and other
elements (Adekia et al. 2019). Due to its high iodine
content, consumption of okra is good for the control
of goiter. In India, okra is cultivated over an area of
5.11 lakh ha area with production of 62.1 lakh MT
(NHB, 2018-19). In Rajasthan, it is grown extensively
How to cite this article: Meena, H., Kavita, A., Meena, N.K., Sharma,
R., Kumar, A. and Chopra, R. (2022). Organic Manure and Fertility Level
Affects the Flowering, Yield and Quality Attributes of Okra under Heavy
Clay Soil of Southern Rajasthan. Int. J. Ag. Env. Biotech., 15(Special
Issue): 329-336.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Meena et al.
in the district of Sirohi, Bundi, Jodhpur, Sikar,
Jhalawar, Nagaur, Bharatpur and Jhunjhunu and
covers around 5.71 thousand hectares area with
annual production of 49.68 thousand metric tonnes.
Horticulture & Forestry, Jhalrapatan city, Jhalawar
during kharif season, 2019-20. The present experiment
was conducted on okra crop cv. Varsha Uphar.
Treatments Details
Despite of popularity among stakeholders, okra
produces fewer yields under soil condition of
Southern Rajasthan. Being highly black cotton and
heavy soil, the productivity of okra is very less. The
soil of southern humid parts of Rajasthan contains
high soil pH (8.0 to 9.5) and low organic matter
content. Soil organic matter is a crucial factor in
soil for sustainable crop production (Agboola 1990).
Improper use of chemical fertilizers declined the soil
fertility and leached out the nutrients from the soil.
Besides, continuous use of inorganic fertilizers also
changed the physical and chemical status of soil
thus resulting in reducing fertility level and poor
crop production. Use of organic manures, poultry
manures, vermicompost and farm yard manure
enriches organic matter content subsequently
enhances yield and quality attributes in various
vegetables (Sameera et al. 1995). Poultry manure
is an excellent organic fertilizer, is concentrated
source of nitrogen and other essential nutrients.
It has direct effect on plant growth. It is well
documented that it is an excellent source of fertilizer
and increased nutrient uptake (Abusaleha 1992). In
addition to that, organic manures also positively
improve the health of soil as well as ecosystem. The
use of chemical fertilizers in an integrated manner
with organic manures could enhance the yield and
productivity of crops with minimum disturbance of
soil. In the climate changing scenario, the judicious
use of chemical fertilizers with organic manures is
need of the hour for sustainable crop production
(Chowdhury et al. 2014). Among the nutrient N, P
and K are the essential nutrients which are needed
for growth, flowering and fruiting (Solangi et al.
2005). However, these studies are insufficient to
validate the existing findings under humid zone of
Southern Rajasthan. This study was investigated
to find out the impact of various organic manures
and fertility level on Okra yield and biochemical
attributes under heavy clay soil.
The treatments manures viz. FYM, Poultry manures
and vermicompost were applied in the soil before
sowing of seeds. The inorganic manures N:P:K in
the various levels viz. control, 75% RDF and 100%
RDF were applied through urea, di-ammonium
phosphate (DAP) and murate of potash (MOP)
respectively. The recommended dose of NPK for
okra crop was 60:32:30 kg ha-1, respectively. For
each fertilizer treatment combination, the NPK
dose were calculated and applied timely. Full
dose of phosphorus and potassium and half dose
of nitrogen are applied as basal dose just before
sowing and rest half dose of nitrogen was applied
in two splits i.e. 30 and 45 days after sowing.
The details of treatments combinations are given
underneath:Treatment
Treatment Combination
Notation
1
O0
Control
I2
100% RDF
O2
FYM 15 tons/ha
O4
Vermicompost 5 tons/ha
O6
Poultry manure 5 tons/ha
I1O2
75% NPK + FYM 15 tons/ha
I1O4
75% NPK + Vermicompost 5 tons/ha
I1O6
75% NPK + Poultry manure 5 tons/ha
I2O2
100% NPK + FYM 15 tons/ha
I2O4
100% NPK + Vermicompost 5 tons/ha
I2O6
100% NPK + Poultry manure 5 tons/ha
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
MATERIALS AND METHODS
I1
75% RDF
O1
FYM 7.5 tons/ha
O3
Vermicompost 2.5 tons/ha
O5
Poultry manure 2.5 tons/ha
I1 O1
75% NPK + FYM 7.5 tons/ha
I1O3
75% NPK + Vermicompost 2.5 tons/ha
I1O5
75% NPK + Poultry manure 2.5 tons/ha
I2O1
100% NPK + FYM 7.5 tons/ha
I2O3
100% NPK + Vermicompost 2.5 tons/ha
I2O5
100% NPK + Poultry manure 2.5 tons/ha
The number of days taken for plants to first
flowering in each plot and replication was recorded
and expressed in days. The number of days taken
for 50 per cent of flowering in each plot was
Location
The present experiment was conducted at farm
of Department of Vegetable Science, College of
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Sl.
No.
330
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Organic Manure and Fertility Level Affects the Flowering, Yield and Quality Attributes...
recorded and expressed in days. The number of fruit
of five tagged plants was counted and the average
was worked out. Fruit weight was calculated
by weighing with electronic weighing machine.
The estimated yield per plant was calculated by
multiplying fruit weight with total number in a
individual plant.
The days taken for 50 per cent flowering exhibited
highly significant variation over control with
application of organic and inorganic manures. The
application of organic manures significantly affected
the days taken to 50 percent flowering over control.
Minimum days taken for 50 per cent flowering was
recorded in O6 (44.70) and it was found statistically
at par with treatment O5 (46.06), O3 (46.64), O4
(46.81), and O2 (47.04), whereas maximum days
taken for 50 per cent flowering was recorded in
control with 50.69. Further, the application of
inorganic fertilizer exhibited significant result over
control. Minimum days were taken for 50 per cent
flowering was recorded in I 2 (100% RDF) with
45.13 and maximum in control with 49.24. The
combination of organic and inorganic fertilizers
also exhibited significant variation over control. The
treatment O6I2 (100% RDF + PM@ 5 ton) showed
minimum days to 50% flowering over control
i.e., 39.97 and 57.00, respectively. Days to first
flower appearance is also an important trait which
determines its flowering and earliness. Addition
of poultry manure makes reproductive booster
nutrients and helps them to restore thus the early
flowering and 50% flowering was observed in the
treatment. Our research findings are in agreement
with previous studies by (El-shakweer et al. 1998;
Sanwal et al. 2007).
Chlorophyll and Crude Protein Content
Chlorophyll content in leaves was measured as per
method suggested by Sadasivam and Manickam
(1997) and expressed in mg/100g.
The amount of protein in okra fruit was calculated
in per cent. The formula used for calculating the
protein is as under:
Protein % = Nitrogen% × 6.25
This is based on the assumption that plant protein
contains 16 per cent nitrogen. Estimation of nitrogen
was done by colorimetric method as suggested
by Snell and Snell (1949) using the Spectronic-20
(Model SL-177).
Statistical Analysis
The experimental data are to be recorded during the
course of investigation for various characters under
study with appropriate statistical analysis (Panse &
Sukhatme 1985) along with suitable interpretation.
Fruit Yield and Quality Parameters
The result presented reflects that fruit weight showed
significant variation (Table 2). The application of
organic manures increased significantly the fruit
weight over control. Maximum fruit weight was
recorded in O6 (18.28), and it was found statistically
at par with O4 i.e., 18.02 whereas minimum fruit
weight was found in control (13.79). Similarly, the
application of inorganic manures also increased the
fruit weight significantly over control. Maximum
fruit weight was recorded in I2 (100% RDF) with
20.11 g and minimum in control with 12.44 g.
The interaction effect of organic and inorganic
manures also showed significant effect on fruit
weight over control. Maximum fruit weight 21.61
g was recorded in treatment O4I2 (100% RDF + VC
5 ton) over control with 9.14 g. A perusal of data
regarding to fruit yield per plant presented and
revealed that fruit yield per plant was significantly
affected by the application of different organic
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Days Taken to Flower Appearance
The data recorded for days to first flower
appearance was influenced by application of
organic and inorganic manures over control, which
showed significant variation over control (Table 1).
Minimum days to first flower (38.90) were recorded
in treatment O6, whereas maximum was recorded
in control (44.53). Similarly, the application of
inorganic manures with treatment I2 (100% RDF)
took minimum days to first flower appearance
with 40.70 over control with 43.29. Further, the
application of organic manures with inorganic
manures minimized the number of days to first
flower appearance over control. Minimum days to
first flower appearance was recorded in treatment
O 6I 2 (100% RDF + PM@ 5 ton) with 34.87 and
maximum in control (47).
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
331
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Meena et al.
manures and fertility levels. The application of
organic manures significantly increased the fruit
yield per plant over control. Maximum fruit yield
per plant was recorded in O6 (385.99), and it was
found statistically at par with O4 (381.57) and O5
(361.90), whereas minimum fruit yield per plant
was found in control (277.06). Further, inorganic
manures also played an important role in increasing
the fruit yield per plant. Maximum fruit yield per
plant was recorded in I2 (100% RDF) i.e., 430.99g
and minimum in control i.e., 243.75g. Results
with respect to interactive effect of organic and
inorganic showed that maximum fruit yield per
plant (462.33g) was recorded in treatment O6I2 (100%
RDF + PM 5 ton) and it was found statistically at
par with treatment O4I2, O2I2, O5I2 and O3I2 while
minimum was recorded in control (173.34 g). The
result of present study has with respect to estimated
fruit yield has been presented which reflects that
fruit yield q/ha showed significant variation. The
increased yield and yield attributes with poultry
manure might be because of rapid availability and
utilization of nitrogen for various internal plant
processes for carbohydrates production. Later
on these carbohydrates undergo hydrolysis and
get converted in to reproductive sugars which
ultimately helped in increasing yield. Singh and
Srivastava (1970) reported that high carbohydrates
content due to application of poultry manure might
be attributed to balanced C:N ratio and increased
activity of plant metabolisms. These results are in
accordance with the findings of Naidu et al. (2002)
and Islam et al. (2012). The increased balanced
C: N ratio might have increased the synthesis of
carbohydrates with ultimate improvement in yield
and yield attributes Chander et al. (2005), Kondappa
et al. (2009), Sharma et al. (2009) and Yadav and
Yadav (2010). The application of 100 per cent RDF
resulted in the highest and significantly more values
of yield and yield attributes. These findings are
similar of those Garhwal et al. (2007), Vennila and
Jayanthi (2008a), Sharma et al. (2009) in okra crop.
The reason for enhancement in yield attributes could
again be ascribed to the role which might have been
played by the nutrients supplied to the plants.
The quality yield depends on several management
factors such as fertilizers and nutrient management,
water, light, etc. but the role of fertilizers and
nutrients is crucial and important in determining the
fruit quality as well as yield. It is relevant to mention
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
here that adequate supply of nitrogen to plants
not only promotes the manufacture of food but
also its subsequent partitioning in skin. Similarly,
phosphorus play a unique role in laying down the
floral primordial. Potassium facilitates translocation
of photosynthates towards various organs of plant
body (Marschner 1995). The application of NPK
favoured the metabolic and auxin activities in
plant and ultimately resulted in increased fruit
size, number of fruits per plant and yield per plant
(Garhwal et al. 2007).
Biochemical Parameters
A critical examination of the data pertaining to
chlorophyll content in leaves has been presented
in table. Chlorophyll content in leaves was
significantly affected by application of different
organic manures. The treatment O6 (PM 5 ton)
was recorded significantly higher chlorophyll
content (0.82 mg g-1) in leaves and it was found
statistically at par with treatment O4 (0.79), whereas
lower chlorophyll found in control (0.66 mg/100
g). Further, application of inorganic manures also
showed significant effect over control on chlorophyll
content in leaves. The treatment I2 (100% RDF)
resulted in significantly higher chlorophyll content
(0.92 mg g -1) in leaves and lower in control I0
with (0.60 mg g-1). However, the interactive effect
of organic and inorganic manures also recorded
significant effect on chlorophyll content in leaves
over control. Maximum chlorophyll (1.05 mg g-1)
was found in O6I2 (100% RDF + PM 5 ton) and
minimum in control O6I0 (0.52 mg g-1) respectively
but O4I2 was found statistically at par with O6I2.
Leaf chlorophyll content is major parameter which
imparts greenness to the leaf as well as also acts as
reservoir of pigment for pod development. Plant
chlorophyll is directly correlated with nutrient
assimilation and better photosynthesis process. The
organic manures enhance the vegetative flushes,
which favors more photosynthesis along with
some important micro and macro nutrient such
as iron and Mg. The interactions of these minerals
is a complex phenomenon but directly indirectly
involved in photosynthetic processes (Senjobi et
al. 2010).
It is evident from data in Table that crude protein
exhibited significant variation over control with
application of organic and inorganic manures.
332
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Organic Manure and Fertility Level Affects the Flowering, Yield and Quality Attributes...
Table 1: Effect of organic manure and inorganic fertilizer level on days to first flower appearance of okra cv.
Varsha Uphar
Treatments
I0 (Control)
I1 (75% RDF)
I2 (100% RDF)
Mean
I
O
I×O
O0
(Control)
47.00
44.00
42.60
44.53
SE m ±
0.43
0.66
1.15
O1 FYM
7.5 Tons/ha
45.60
42.47
42.83
43.63
O2 FYM
O3 VC
15 Tons/ha
40.67
44.27
42.10
42.34
2.5 Tons/ha
42.97
41.50
40.83
41.77
O4 VC
5 Tons/ha
44.47
41.47
41.37
42.43
O5 PM
2.5 Tons/ha
41.87
41.73
40.33
41.31
C.D. (p=0.05)
1.25
1.91
3.30
O6 PM
5 Tons/ha
40.47
41.37
34.87
38.90
Mean
43.29
42.40
40.70
42.13
Data represents the mean value of Factor I (organic manure) and Factor-II (Inorganic RDF) and their interactions. (FYM-Farm Yard Manure;
VC-Vermicompost; PM-Poultry Manure).
Table 2: Effect of organic manure and inorganic fertilizer level on days to 50 per cent flowering of
okra cv. Varsha Uphar
Treatments
I0 (Control)
I1 (75% RDF)
I2 (100% RDF)
Mean
I
O
I×O
O0
(Control)
57.00
48.10
46.97
50.69
SEm ±
0.54
0.83
1.43
O1 FYM
7.5 Tons/ha
51.17
48.20
46.70
48.69
O2 FYM
15 Tons/ha
46.30
49.47
45.37
47.04
O3 VC
2.5 Tons/ha
47.80
45.87
46.27
46.64
O4 VC
5 Tons/ha
49.77
45.73
44.93
46.81
O5 PM
O6 PM
2.5 Tons/ha
46.87
45.57
45.73
46.06
C.D. (p=0.05)
1.55
2.37
4.10
5 Tons/ha
45.77
48.37
39.97
44.70
Mean
49.24
47.33
45.13
47.23
Data represents the mean value of Factor I (organic manure) and Factor-II (Inorganic RDF) and their interactions. (FYM-Farm Yard Manure;
VC-Vermicompost; PM-Poultry Manure.
Table 3: Effect of organic manure and inorganic fertilizer level on fruits weight (g) of okra cv. Varsha Uphar
Treatments
O0
O1 FYM
7.5 Tons/ha
11.64
14.71
19.73
15.36
O2 FYM
15 Tons/ha
14.58
17.38
20.30
17.42
O3 VC
2.5 Tons/ha
11.67
20.37
19.64
17.23
O4 VC
5 Tons/ha
12.66
19.79
21.61
18.02
O5 PM
I0 (Control)
I1 (75% RDF)
I2 (100% RDF)
Mean
(Control)
9.14
12.65
19.59
13.79
SEm ±
2.5 Tons/ha
12.76
19.63
19.53
17.31
C.D. (p=0.05)
I
0.15
0.43
O
0.23
0.66
I×O
0.40
1.15
O6 PM
5 Tons/ha
14.60
19.86
20.38
18.28
Mean
12.44
17.77
20.11
16.77
Data represents the mean value of Factor I (organic manure) and Factor-II (Inorganic RDF) and their interactions. (FYM-Farm Yard Manure;
VC-Vermicompost; PM-Poultry Manure.
Maximum crude protein was recorded in O6 (2.21),
whereas minimum crude protein was found in
control (1.68). Further, maximum crude protein
was recorded in 100% RDF with 2.46. Results with
respect to interactive effect of organic and inorganic
showed that maximum crude protein (2.74) was
recorded in treatment 100% RDF + PM 5 ton and it
was found statistically at par with treatment 100%
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
RDF + VC 5 ton, 100% RDF + FYM 15 ton, 100%
RDF + PM 2.5 ton. The protein content is composed
of several amino acids which are influenced with
field management, nutrients, and environmental
factors. The composition of protein also helps in
judging the quality produce and this is one of the
important index for quality trait among biochemical
parameters. The soil application of organic manures
333
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Meena et al.
Table 4: Effect of organic manure and inorganic fertilizer level on fruits yield per plant (g) of
okra cv. Varsha Uphar
Treatments
I0 (Control)
I1 (75% RDF)
I2 (100% RDF)
Mean
I
O
I×O
O0
(Control)
173.34
250.72
407.11
277.06
SEm ±
6.44
9.85
17.06
O1 FYM
7.5 Tons/ha
225.05
296.92
412.87
311.61
O2 FYM
15 Tons/ha
250.83
353.87
431.01
345.24
O3 VC
2.5 Tons/ha
227.17
404.46
421.25
350.96
O4 VC
5 Tons/ha
285.02
403.85
455.85
381.57
O5 PM
2.5 Tons/ha
253.36
405.82
426.52
361.90
C.D. (p=0.05)
18.43
28.15
48.77
O6 PM
5 Tons/ha
291.46
404.19
462.33
385.99
Mean
243.75
359.97
430.99
344.90
Data represents the mean value of Factor I (organic manure) and Factor-II (Inorganic RDF) and their interactions. (FYM-Farm Yard Manure;
VC-Vermicompost; PM-Poultry Manure.
Table 5: Effect of organic manure and inorganic fertilizer level on chlorophyll content in leaves (mg/100g) of
okra cv. Varsha Uphar
Treatments
I0 (Control)
I1 (75% RDF)
I2 (100% RDF)
Mean
I
O
I×O
O0
(Control)
0.52
0.64
0.82
0.66
SEm ±
0.008
0.01
0.02
O1 FYM
7.5 Tons/ha
0.54
0.69
0.85
0.69
O2 FYM
15 Tons/ha
0.59
0.71
0.94
0.75
O3 VC
2.5 Tons/ha
0.57
0.77
0.88
0.74
O4 VC
5 Tons/ha
0.65
0.73
1.00
0.79
O5 PM
2.5 Tons/ha
0.61
0.79
0.91
0.77
C.D. (p=0.05)
0.021
0.03
0.05
O6 PM
5 Tons/ha
0.67
0.75
1.05
0.82
Mean
0.60
0.73
0.92
0.75
Data represents the mean value of Factor I (organic manure) and Factor-II (Inorganic RDF) and their interactions. (FYM-Farm Yard Manure;
VC-Vermicompost; PM-Poultry Manure.
Table 6: Effect of organic manure and inorganic fertilizer level on crude protein content (%) of
okra cv. Varsha Uphar
O0
O1 FYM
O2 FYM
O3 VC
O4 VC
O5 PM
O6 PM
I0 (Control)
I2 (100% RDF)
Treatments
(Control) 7.5 Tons/ha
15 Tons/ha
2.5 Tons/ha
5 Tons/ha
2.5 Tons/ha
5 Tons/ha
Mean
1.33
1.34
1.36
1.45
1.54
1.63
1.65
1.47
I1 (75% RDF)
1.71
1.75
1.78
1.82
1.87
1.93
2.25
1.87
1.99
2.12
2.71
2.34
2.72
2.61
2.74
2.46
Mean
1.68
1.74
1.95
1.87
2.05
2.06
2.21
1.94
SEm ±
C.D. (p=0.05)
I
0.01
0.05
O
0.02
0.08
I×O
0.05
0.14
enhances root microbial activity and nutrient
assimilation along with cation exchange capacity.
The mineralogy of soil alters the plant physiology
and its catabolic and anabolic reactions. Certain
enzymes helps I synthesis of amino acids due
to higher assimilate and a strong source sink
relationship. The highest value of crude protein
in okra pod in our study, might be due to positive
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
impact of poultry manure in soil as well as in
plants which favours the more synthesis of amino
acids thus increased protein content. Soremi et al.
(2017) reported that poultry manure change the soil
fertility status that resulted in whole biochemical
composition of soil as well plants. This also releases
organic acids and increase organic content into
the soil which retain the loss of various nutrients.
334
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Organic Manure and Fertility Level Affects the Flowering, Yield and Quality Attributes...
Our results are in agreement of previous studies
by Trupiano et al. (2017) and Imasuen and Aisien
(2015). The significant influence of NPK fertilization
on N, P, K and protein content in fruits appeared to
be due to improved nutrient both in the root zone
and the plants system because nutrient in the plant
directly related to its availability in the feeding zone
and the growth of the plant. The protein content in
fruits is infact a manifestation of nitrogen content.
The increase in nitrogen content in fruits resulted
in higher protein content in fruits. These results are
in close conformity with findings of Yadav (2001),
Maheswari and Haripriya (2007) and Premshekhar
and Rajashree (2009). The higher content in fruits
seems to be higher functional activity of roots
for longer duration under the treatment. The
increase in N, P and K content in fruit due to
adequate fertilization have also been observed
by Nanthakumar and Veeragavathatham (2003)
and Selvi et al. (2004). The accumulation of higher
protein content in the fruits might be correlated
with the increased activity of nitrate reductase
which helped in synthesis of certain amino acids
and proteins. These results are also corroborated
by the findings of Yadav et al. (2006) and Garhwal
et al. (2007) in okra crop.
Integrated nitrogen management in okra (Abelmoschus
esculentus (L.) Moench) hybrids. Haryana J. Horti. Sci.,
36(1&2): 129-130.
Imasuen, A.A. and Aisien, M.S.O. 2015. Helminth parasites
of Silurana tropicalis from the Okomu National Park, Edo
State, Nigeria. Nigerian J. Parasitol., 36(1): 61-66.
Islam, M.M., Majid, N.M., Karim, A.J.M.S., Jahiruddin, M.,
Islam, M.S. and Hakim, M.A. 2012. Integrated nutrient
management for tomato-okrastem amaranth cropping
pattern in homestead area. J. Food, Agric. & Environ., 9(2):
438-445.
Kondappa, D., Radder, B. M., Patil, P.L., Hebsur, N. S. and
Alagundagi, S.C. 2009. Effect of integrated nutrient
management on growth, yield and economics of chilli
(cv. Byadgi Dabbi) in a vertisol. Karnataka J. Agric. Sci.,
22: 438-440.
Maheswari, T.U. and Haripriya, K. 2007. Comparative
performance of hot pepper (Capsicum annum L.) cv. K2
with organic manures and inorganic fertilizers. Res. Crops.,
8(3): 761-764.
Marschner, H. 1995. Mineral nutrition of higher plants.
Academic Press, London.
Naidu, A.K., Kushwah, S.S. and Dwivedi, Y.C. 2002. Influence
of organic manures, chemical and bio-fertilizer on growth,
yield and economics of brinjal. South Indian Hortic., 50(7):
370-376.
Nanthakumar, S. and Veeragavathatham, D. 2001. Effect
of integrated nutriet management on yield and quality
attributes of brinjal (Solanum melongena L.) cv. Palur-1.
South Indian Horti., 49(special): 195-198.
CONCLUSION
Premsekhar, M. and Rajashree, V. 2009. Influence of organic
manures on growth, yield and quality of okra. American
– Eurasian J. Sustainable Agric., 3(1): 6-8.
In conclusion it was observed that the treatment
O6 5 t poultry manure/ha most suited to okra crop
cv. Varsha Uphar which enhanced the flowering
parameters and yield. The combination of poultry
manure and 100% RDF and solely 100% RDF
found best for overall yield and quality under hard
clay soil. However, further investigation need to
elucidate the mechanism and mineralogy under
such soil conditions.
Sameera, D.L., Shankaraiah, V. and Srihari, D. 2005. Effect of
packaging and storage on organic manures grown okra
(Abelmoschus esculentus L. Moench). J. Res. ANGRAU,
33(4): 30- 35.
Selvi, D., Thiageshwari, S., Santhy, P. and Kannan, B.R. 2004.
Fruit yield and nutrient uptake by brinjal due to integrated
nutrient management in an inceptisol. J. Maharashtra Agric.
Univ., 29(2): 220-223.
Senjobi, B.A., Peluola, C.O. Senjobi, C.T., Lawal, I. O., Ande,
O.T. and Salami, B.T. 2010. Performance of Cochorus
olitorius as influenced by soil type and organic manure
amendments in Yewa North Local Government Area,
Ogun State. African J. Biotechnol., 9(33): 5309-5312
REFERENCES
Chander, G., Naveen, D. and Sharma, R.P. 2005. Effect of
vermicompost, farm yard manure and chemical fertilizers
on yield, nutrient uptake and soil fertility in Okra
(Abelmoschus esculentus) onion (Allium cepa) Sequence in
wet Temperate Zone of Himachal Pradesh. J. Indian Soc.
Soil Sci., 57(3): 357-361.
Sharma, R.P., Datt, N. and Chander, G. 2009. Effect of
vermicompost, FYM and chemical fertilizers on yield,
nutrient uptake and soil fertility in okra [Abelmoschus
esculentus (L.) Moench] – onion (Allium cepa) sequence in
wet temperate zone of Himachal Pradesh. J. Indian Society
of Soil Sci., 57(3): 357-361.
El- Shakweer, M.H.A., El-Sayed, E.A. and Ewees, M.S.A. 1998.
Soil and plant analysis as a guide for interpretation of the
improvement deficiency of organic conditioners added
to different soil in Egypt. Communication Soil Sci. Plant
Anal., 29: 206-208.
Singh, K. and Srivastava, O.P. 1970. Effect of organic manure
on soil fertility as showed by nutrition availability and
yield response in potato. Proc. Int. Sympt. Soil Fert. Eval.,
New Delhi, 1: 815-820.
Garhwal, O.P., Fageria, M.S. and Mukherjee, S. 2007.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
335
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Meena et al.
Singh, V. and Pandey, M. 2006. Effect of integrated nutrient
management on yield of and nutrient uptake by onion
and on soil fertility. J. Indian Soc. Soil Sci., 54(3): 365-367.
Yadav, O.S. 2001. Effect of nitrogen sources and bio-fertilizers
on growth, yield and quality of cow pea (Vigna unguiculata
(L.) Walp). M.Sc. (Ag.) Thesis, Rajasthan Agricultural
University, Bikaner.
Trupiano, D., Cocozza, C., Baronti, S., Amendola, C., Vaccari,
F.P., Lustrato, G. and Scippa, G.S. 2017. The effects of
biochar and its combination with compost on lettuce
(Lactuca sativa L.) growth, soil properties, and soil
microbial activity and abundance. Int. J. Agron.
Yadav, P., Singh, P. and Yadav, R.L. 2006. Effect of organic
manures and nitrogen levels on growth, yield and quality
of okra. Indian J. Hortic., 63(2): 215-217.
Vennila, C. and Jayanthi, C. 2008. Effect of integrated nutrient
management on yield and quality of okra. Res. Crops.,
9(1): 73-75.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
336
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 337-345, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.8
Bioactive Compounds of Turmeric Powder Affected by
Grinding Method and Feed Temperature
M.N. Dabhi1*, P.R. Davara1, H.P. Gajera2, Nirav Joshi1 and Parth Saparia1
AICRP on Post-Harvest Engineering and Technology, Processing and Food Engineering Department, College of Agricultural
Engineering and Technology, Gujarat, India
2
Department of Biotechnology, Junagadh Agricultural University, Junagadh, Gujarat, India
1
*Corresponding author: mndabhi@jau.in (ORCID ID: 0000-0002-0062-5970)
Paper No. 993
Received: 21-05-2022
Revised: 23-06-2022
Accepted: 06-07-2022
ABSTRACT
The turmeric used as a ground powder. Turmeric grinding is carried out in grinding mill. During grinding
operation the temperature inside the grinding mill increases. The bioactive compounds along with their
biological activity and stability depends on the grinding temperature. High temperature during grinding
reduced the bioactive compounds along with their biological activity and stability. Four grinding methods
and two feed temperature were chosen on the hypothesised mechanisms of reduction in temperature
during the grinding. The effects of grinding temperature and feed temperature on the phenolic content,
flavonoid content, antioxidant activity and curcumin content of turmeric ground powder were studied.
Antioxidant activity, flavonoid content, curcumin content and phenolic content increased with decrease
in grinding temperature. The temperature inside the grinding chamber at the end of grinding of 3 kg
sample of turmeric reached to 43 °C for traditional grinding, and this was reduced to 18.33 ⁰C for coolant
circulation with low temperature feed. This reduction in grinding temperature resulted in the highest
phenol content (3.13%), flavonoid content (1.43%), and antioxidant activity (59.31%) for coolant circulation
with low feed temperature. Chilled water circulation with low temperature feed resulted the highest
curcumin content (2.48%). This bioactive compound were significantly differed with grinding method
as well as feed temperature.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm The article focuses on the effect of both moisture content and variety on the physical properties of
psyllium seeds
mm The moisture content and variety both had a significant effect on the physical properties of psyllium
seeds
mm The size, thousand seed weight, angle of repose, coefficient of static friction and terminal velocity
were increased while bulk density, true density and porosity were decreased as the moisture content
was increased
Keywords: Turmeric powder, low temperature grinding, curcumin, flavonoid, phenolic, antioxidant
activity
The origin of genus Curcuma from the Zingiberaceae
family lies in the Indo-Malayan Region spreading in
the tropics of Asia to Africa and Australia (Pusglove
1968). Turmeric powder, generally used as a spice,
food preservative, colouring agent, is obtained by
grinding turmeric rhizome of Curcuma longa L.
Turmeric compounds possess anti-inflammatory,
anti-HIV, antibacterial, antioxidant, anti-diabetes,
and anti-carcinogenic activities (Park Chang Yang,
Kyo-Yeon Lee, Khalid Gul, M. Shafiur Rahman,
How to cite this article: Dabhi, M.N., Davara, P.R., Gajera, H.P., Joshi,
N. and Saparia, P. (2022). Bioactive Compounds of Turmeric Powder
Affected by Grinding Method and Feed Temperature. Int. J. Ag. Env.
Biotech., 15(Special Issue): 337-345.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Dabhi et al.
Ah-Na Kim, Jiyeon Chun, Hyun-Jin Kim & SungGil Choi 2019). The important active compounds
of turmeric are curcumin which may be in the
form of dihydrocurcumin, demethoxycurcumin,
and bisdemethoxycurcumin which are important
for most of the turmeric’s beneficial effects
(Prathapan, Lukhman, Arumughan, Sundaresan,
& Raghu 2009). Curcumin has property of antiinflammatory activity. Curcumin is an effective
inhibitor for reactive oxygen-generating enzymes
like lipoxygenase/cyclooxygenase, xanthine
dehydrogenase/oxidase, and inducible nitric oxide
synthase (Lin, Pan & Lin-Shiau 2000). Metabolism
activity of Curcumin reduces it through an NADPH
dependent curcumin reductase consequential in a
dihydrocurcumin. Dihydrocurcumin again reduces
through an NADPH-dependent dihydrocurcumin
reductase bring about in a tetrahydrocurcumin
(THC) (Aggarwal, Deb, and Prasad, 2015, Khopde,
Priyadarsini, Guha, Satav, Venkatesan, P., & Rao
2000).
1963), depending on the oil and moisture content,
consequently, it loses a substantial portion of its
volatile oil. The fat in spices poses extra problems
and is an important consideration in grinding.
By circulating water or air around the mill,
temperature reduction can possible, but it is not
that effective. Though cryogenic grinding is very
costly. Low temperature grinding techniques
can also be easily available for small mills than
cryogenic grinding. It was also found that the colour
and other properties of the low temperature grind
material were not changed, and the flavour and
nutrients of the medicines were not lost. From the
statements above, there seems enough justification
for low temperature grinding of turmeric to obtain
a high quality product. Theoretically, though low
temperature grinding of turmeric is better than
ambient grinding, the available literature is scanty
to support the above justification. Hence, in the
present study, efforts were made to develop low
temperature grinding technique for turmeric.
Ancillary metabolites of plant metabolism, phenolic
compounds can chelate metallic ions, scavenge
free radicals during oxidative stress, and increase
antimicrobial activities (Pereira et al. 2009). Bioactive
compounds frequently store in the plant in lesser
quantities and sometimes in specific cells (Finley
2005). In the middle of them certainly are recognized
as phenolic, flavonoids, and essential oils, which
have a wide range of biological activities such as
antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, anti-aging, antibacterial, anti-tumor, and other functions (Karimi,
Jaafar, & Ahmad, 2013; Oskoueian, Abdullah,
Hendra & Karimi, 2011).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Grinding methods
Dried turmeric rhizome of Salem variety was
purchased from local market. Turmeric powder
was prepared by different grinding methods viz.
L0 = Ambient grinding, L1 = Grinding with ambient
temperature water circulation through jacket, L2=
Grinding with chilled water circulation and L3=
Grinding with coolant circulation. The temperature
inside the grinding chamber at the end of grinding
were noted. The powder were collected. Ground
powder of turmeric rhizome obtained by various
treatments through low temperature grinding mill
was packed carefully, stored to room temperature at
dark, dry and hygienic place and opened at the time
of analysis only. Self-sealing zip lock transparent
plastic bags were used for packing after cooling the
powder to room temperature. Care was taken not to
allow air inside. Additional wrapping of ordinary
transparent plastic cover was also followed.
Consumer demand for healthier products having
less synthetic additives is motivating for research to
discover substitute sources of natural antioxidants.
Natural antioxidants like phenolic and flavonoid
compounds are available in plants and they
are appealing a great deal of responsiveness
due to amassed confirmation suggesting that
they may inhibit chronic conditions, such as
cancer, atherosclerosis, and neurological diseases
(Marinova, D., Ribarova, F. & Atanassova, M. 2005).
Biochemical parameters of turmeric powder
obtained through different treatments were
determined by using standard protocols. All the
samples with triplicates were analysed at a time for
determination of a particular parameter.
In the traditional grinding of spices, frictional heat
is generated in the grinder. The grinding process
increases the product temperature to a high
level in the range of 42-95°C (Pruthi and Mishra
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
338
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Bioactive Compounds of Turmeric Powder Affected by Grinding Method and Feed Temperature
Preparation of low temperature feed
Total flavonoid content
Pre-weighted turmeric rhizome were packed
in self-sealing zip lock transparent plastic bags.
Additionally, packing was wrapped by an ordinary
transparent plastic cover. Packed rhizomes were
kept in freezer at -10° ± 2° overnight, the day before
grinding. Besides that, feed was withdrawn from
the freezer at the time of grinding only and once
withdrawn, placed at feed hopper immediately.
Each packet of the rhizome involved half the
amount of decided sample size, which allowed one
half of the sample to be in the freezer instead of the
feed hopper while grinding. Care was taken to feed
the other half well before completion of the first half
size of sample in the feed hopper.
Aluminium chloride colorimetric method was used
to determine total flavonoid content of turmeric
powder, as given by Chang et al. (2002). Quercetin
was used for preparation of calibration curve.
Different diluted quercetin standard solutions
(10, 25, 50 and 100 µg/ml) were prepared in 80%
ethanol. The sample was also extracted in ethanol.
From each tube, 0.5 ml aliquot was pipetted out
in separate test tubes. Then 1.5 ml of 95% ethanol
followed by 0.1 ml of 10% aluminium chloride and
0.1 ml of 1 M potassium acetate was added to each
tube. Total volume in each tube was made up to 5
ml by adding 2.8 ml distilled water. For preparation
of blank solution, aluminium chloride solution
was substituted by the same amount of distilled
water. After incubation at room temperature for 30
minutes, absorbance was measured at 415 nm by
UV-Visible spectrophotometer (Thermo Scientific,
GENESYS 50). The quantity of flavonoid was then
expressed in mg equivalent of quercetin by using
the following equation.
Total phenol content
The phenol content of the turmeric powder was
estimated as per the method given by Malick and
Singh (1980). 0.1 g of turmeric powder (weighed
to the nearest 0.0001 g) was extracted in 10 ml of
80% ethanol. Centrifugation was done and, the
supernatant was collected. Then 0.1 ml of aliquot
was pipetted out into a test tube and was evaporated
to dryness. After drying, the residue was dissolved
in 1 ml of distilled water. Then 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, and 1
ml of working standard into a series of test tubes was
pipetted out and the total volume of each was made
up to 1 ml using distilled water. 1 ml of distilled
water in a test tube was set for a blank solution. 0.5
ml of Folin-Ciocalteau reagent was then added to
each tube including blank. After three minutes, 2
ml of 20% Na2CO3 solution was added to each. The
solution was mixed thoroughly and was placed in
a boiling water bath for exactly one minute. After
cooling to room temperature, colour was read at 650
nm using a UV-Visible spectrophotometer (Thermo
Scientific, GENESYS 50). At last, the percentage of
total phenol was calculated by preparing a standard
curve of catechol. The following formula was used.
Total flavonoid (%) =
V = Volume of sample extract (ml)
W = Weight of sample extracted (mg)
Antioxidant activity
The aluminium chloride colorimetric method was
used to determine the total flavonoid content of
turmeric powder, as given by Chang et al. (2002).
Quercetin was used for the preparation of the
calibration curve. Different diluted quercetin
standard solutions (10, 25, 50, and 100 µg/ml)
were prepared in 80% ethanol. The sample was
also extracted in ethanol. From each tube, 0.5 ml
aliquot was pipetted out in separate test tubes.
Then 1.5 ml of 95% ethanol followed by 0.1 ml
of 10% aluminium chloride and 0.1 ml of 1 M
potassium acetate was added to each tube. The
total volume in each tube was made up to 5 ml by
adding 2.8 ml distilled water. For the preparation
of the blank solution, aluminium chloride solution
was substituted with the same amount of distilled
water. After incubation at room temperature for 30
…(1)
Where, GF = Graph factor
OD = Optical density
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
…(2)
Where, C = Concentration of sample extrapolated
from calibration curve (mg/ml)
Total phenol (%) =
GF × OD × Total volume (ml) × 10 –6
Sample aliquot (ml) × Sample Weight (g)
C ×V
× 100
W
339
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Dabhi et al.
minutes, absorbance was measured at 415 nm by a
UV-Visible spectrophotometer (Thermo Scientific,
GENESYS 50). The quantity of flavonoid was then
expressed in mg equivalent of quercetin by using
the following equation:
temperature inside the grinding chamber will rise.
It is necessary to reduce the grinding temperature.
In this different treatment, grinding method affects
significantly on the value of temperature inside
the grinding chamber at the end of grinding. The
highest temperature (41.17°) was found for the
grinding treatment L 0. Significantly, the lowest
temperature (19.17°) was found for the grinding
treatment L3. The effect of feed temperature (p<0.05)
on the same parameter was also found significant
(Table 1). The significant highest value found was
35.75° for ambient temperature feed (T 0). The
value in case of low temperature feed (T1) was
significantly lowest, i.e. 34.08°. In addition to that,
the interaction effect of grinding method and feed
temperature (L*T) on the value of temperature
inside the grinding chamber at the end of grinding
was found non-significant.
DPPH scavenging effect (%) =
A control – A test
× 100
A control
…(3)
Curcumin content
The curcumin content of the turmeric powder was
estimated as per the method given by Geethanjali
et al. (2016). 1 g of the turmeric powder was
accurately weighed and transferred into 500 ml
round bottle flask. 75 ml acetone was added up to
the mark. It was refluxed for 1.5 hour, after which
it was filtered and made up to 200 ml with acetone.
From this further 1ml was taken and made up to
100ml adding acetone in a standard flask. The UV
spectral reading for this solution was recorded
under 420 nm using UV-Visible spectrophotometer
(Thermo Scientific, GENESYS 50). A UV spectrum
for standard curcumin was recorded. The obtained
absorption value of turmeric powder samples was
compared with the standard value of curcumin.
The percentage curcumin in samples was calculated
using the formula:
Curcumin (%) =
Ds × As
× 100
100 × Ws × 1650
Table 1: Effect of grinding method temperature
inside grinding chamber at the end of grinding
Grinding method (L)
…(4)
Ambient temperature grinding (L0)
41.17
Chilled water circulation (L2)
22.50
Ambient temperature water
circulation (L1)
35.17
Coolant circulation (L3)
19.17
S. Em±
0.4787
C. D. at 5%
1.4352
Feed temperature (T)
where, Ds - sample dilution volume (i.e., 200*100 =
20000 ml); Ws - sample weight (g); As - absorbance
of the sample; 1650 - standard value calculated by
experts.
Ambient temperature feed (T0)
35.75
Low temp. feed (T1)
34.08
S. Em±
0.3333
C. D. at 5%
0.9994
Interaction (L*T)
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
The observed data were subjected to analysis of
variance (ANOVA) using Factorial Completely
Randomized Design at 5% level of significance
(p<0.05).
S. Em±
0.6667
C. D. at 5%
NS
C. V%
3.307
Number of replications, n=3
The mean values (n=3) for this parameter for all
the treatments are graphically presented in the
following figure (Fig. 1(a)). It varied from 43.00°
for treatment combination L 0 T 0 to 18.33° for
treatment combination L3T0. This shows the effect of
circulation of liquid around the grinding chamber
and temperature of feed material.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Temperature inside the grinding chamber at
the end of grinding
Turmeric is used as ground powder. During
grinding operation, heat will be generated and hence
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Temperature inside
grinding chamber
at the end (°)
Effect
340
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
10
0
30
0.50
[VALUE]
8.06
[VALUE]
8.38
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
8.38
8.40
8.40
8.40
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
8.38
8.40
[VALUE]
8.38
[VALUE]
8.06
20
1
[VALUE]
1.43
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
[VALUE] [VALUE]1.39
1.43
1.43
1.39
[VALUE]
1.43
0.00
0.00 1.00
Ambient
Ambient
Ambient
Ambient
Chilled Chilled
CoolantCoolant
grinding
circulation
0.00
grinding
temp. temp.
water water
circulation
water
circulation
water circulation
Ambient Ambient
Chilled Coolant
0.50
circulation
grinding circulation
temp.
water circulation
water
circulation
(d)circulation
total flavonoid content
0.00
Ambient
temp. feed
feed
Ambient
temp.Low
feedtemp.
Low
temp. feed
Chilled
water
(d) total flavonoid
content
circulation
circulation
Coolant
circulation
2.44
Ambient
2.35
Ambient
(d) total flavonoid
grinding
temp. content
water
(d) total flavonoid content
2.44
3
2.23
(c) total phenol content
2
Low temp. feed
2.48
2.35
59.31
55.11
[VALUE]
55.11
[VALUE]
53.47
[VALUE]
53.47
[VALUE]
40
30
20
temp. water
water
(c) total phenol content
circulation
circulation
3
Coolant
circulation
Cucumin content (%)
40
50
(c) total phenol
content
Ambient
Chilled
(c) total phenol content
49.16
[VALUE]
50
[VALUE]
Antioxidant activity (DPPH scavenging %)
Ambient
grinding
60
60
49.16
[VALUE]
Ambient
temp.temp.
feed feed
Low temp.
feed feed
Ambient
Low temp.
0
[VALUE][VALUE]
1.15 1.15
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
1.15
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
1.15
1.25
1.25
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
1.25
[VALUE]
1.25
1.39
1.39
3.13
circulation
1.00
0.50
0.50 1.50
2.48
2.41
water
Ambient temp. feed
2.33
2.41
temp. water
circulation
circulation
(c) total
phenol content
Antioxidant activity (DPPH scavenging %)
3.13
[VALUE]
2.49
2.49
3.01
2.49
[VALUE]
2.00
[VALUE][VALUE]
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
2.00
2.00 [VALUE]
grinding
1.50 1.00
1.00
2.00
2.33
2.22
1
AmbientAmbient
AmbientChilled
ChilledCoolant
Coolant
Ambient
grinding
temp.
circulation
grinding
temp.
waterwater
waterwater
circulation
circulation
circulation
Ambient circulation
Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
circulation
Ambient temp. feed
Low temp. feed
(b) moisture content
2.00 1.50
1.50
2.37
2.23
0
Total flavonoid content
QE/g content
of extract)
Total(mg
flavonoid
(mg QE/g of extract)
0
59.31
[VALUE]
2
0
Low temp. feed
Ambient
temp. feed
Lowfeed
temp. feed
Ambient
temp. feed
Low temp.
2.00 2.00 (b) moisture content
Cucumin content (%)
1
[VALUE]
1
1
[VALUE]
2
2.00
2
Ambient temp. feed
2
flavonoid
(mgofQE/g
of extract)
Total Total
flavonoid
contentcontent
(mg QE/g
extract)
(b) moisture content
3.13
3.13
[VALUE]
3.01
[VALUE][VALUE]
3.01
3.01 [VALUE]
2.49
[VALUE] [VALUE][VALUE]
Total phenol
Total phenol
contentcontent
(mg/g) (mg/g)
Total phenol content (mg/g)
Total phenol content (mg/g)
3
3
[VALUE]
(b) moisture
content content
(b) moisture
circulation
Ambient
Ambient
temp.temp.
feed feed Low Low
temp.temp.
feed feed
Ambient temp. feed
Low temp. feed
(a) temperature
inside the grinding chamber
4
3
3
8.06
water
circulation
circulation
water
circulation
(a) temperature inside
the grinding
chamber
4
7.66
[VALUE]
8.06
[VALUE]
Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
temp.
water circulation
water Ambient
circulation Chilled
Ambient
Coolant
circulationtemp.
grinding
water
circulation
Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
temp.
water
circulation
water
circulation
Ambient Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
circulation
grinding
water
(a) temperature
inside
thetemp.
grinding
chamber
(a) temperature
inside
the grinding
chamber circulation
(a) temperature
inside the grinding chamber
4 4
7.66
[VALUE]
7.66
[VALUE]
1
Ambient
0grinding
Ambient
grinding
0
7.66
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
9
8
Ambient
temp. feed
Low temp.Low
feed temp. feed
Ambient
temp. feed
7
6
5
94
83
72
61
50
Ambient
Ambient
ChilledChilled
CoolantCoolant
4
Ambient
Ambient
grinding
temp. temp.
water water
circulation
grinding
circulation
3
water water
circulation
circulation
2
circulation
circulation
2.37
2.22
0
Moisture content
(%w.b.)
Moisture
content (%w.b.)
Moisture
content (%w.b.)
Moisture content
(%w.b.)
18.33
21.67
[VALUE]
18.33
[VALUE]
18.33
3
2
1
0
0
Ambient
Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
Ambient
Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
grinding
circulation
grindingtemp.temp. waterwater
circulation
waterwater
circulation
circulation
circulation
circulation
10
10
18.33
0
[VALUE]
20
[VALUE]
30
30 10 10
20
21.67
[VALUE]
33.67
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
33.67
33.67
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
40
40 20 20
39.33
50
50 30
30
9
8
7
6
5
49
8
3
7
2
6
15
04
Low
feed
Lowtemp.
temp.
feed
21.67
21.67
33.67
[VALUE]
39.33
[VALUE]
[VALUE]
Bioactive Compounds of Turmeric Powder Affected by Grinding Method and Feed Temperature
Ambient
temp.feed
feed
40 Ambient
temp.
[VALUE]
Temp. inside grinding chamber at end (℃)
40
39.33
[VALUE]
50
39.33[VALUE]
inside
grinding
at end (℃)
Temp. insideTemp.
grinding
chamber
at endchamber
(℃)
Temp. inside grinding chamber at end (℃)
50
Ambient temp. feed
Low temp. feed
Ambient temp. feed
Low temp. feed
Ambient temp. feed Low temp. feed
Ambient temp. feed
Low temp. feed
2
(d) total flavonoid content
1
0
Ambient
0
grinding
10
Ambient
Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
temp.
water
circulation
water
circulation
Ambient Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
circulation
0
grinding
grinding
temp.
water
water
(e) Antioxidant
activitycirculation
Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
temp. water
water
circulation
circulation
circulation
Ambient
Ambient
Chilled
Coolant
grinding
circulation
circulation
temp. water
water
circulation
circulation circulation
(f) Curcumin content
Fig. 1: Effect of various
treatments on (a) temperature inside the grinding chamber
and (b) Moisture content, (c) Total phenol
(e) Antioxidant activity
(f) Curcumin content
content, (d) Total flavonoid content, (e) Antioxidant activity (f) Curcumin content in turmeric powder
(e) Antioxidant activity
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Number of replications, n = 3
341
(f) Curcumin content
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Dabhi et al.
The fall in temperature in grinding chamber
becomes substantial with the change in grinding
method compared to the change in feed temperature
keeping the grinding method same, especially
when jumping to chilled water and coolant
circulation methods from ambient temperature
water circulation. Possibly, resting of considerable
amount of time in the feed hopper increased the
temperature of low temperature feed, which in
turn diminished its effect to some extent. This may
be due to continuous absorption of heat generated
during grinding operation. Additionally, lowering
the temperature of liquid and circulating around the
grinding chamber results in appreciable falling of
final temperature inside the grinding chamber. That
was caused by absorption of more amount of heat
generated during grinding operation due to increase
in the value of difference in temperature between
grinding chamber and circulating liquid around.
decrease the loss of moisture in surrounding by
evaporation. However, a decrease in the value of
moisture content was observed in ground powder
compared to the moisture content of turmeric
rhizome (8.59%) for all the treatments. That might
be due to the loss of moisture at higher temperatures
generated during the grinding operation.
Total phenol content
A significant difference (p<0.05) was observed in
the phenol content of turmeric powder for different
grinding methods (Table 2). The lowest value (1.91
mg/g) was found for the treatment L0 while the
treatment L3 was found to have the highest value
of total phenol (3.08%) in powder. Additionally,
the effect of feed temperature on the value of total
phenol was also found significant (p<0.05). The
value found in the case of low temperature feed (2.66
mg/g) was higher than that of ambient temperature
feed (2.46 mg/g). Instead of that, the interaction
effect of grinding method and feed temperature
(L*T) on the value of total phenol content of ground
powder was found non-significant at the same level
of significance.
Moisture content
The grinding method affects significantly the
value of moisture content of ground product
at a 5% level of significance. The lowest value
(7.33%) was found for the grinding treatment L0
while the grinding treatment L3 exhibited higher
percentages of moisture (8.31%). The effect of feed
temperature on the value of moisture content was
also found significant (p<0.05). The values found
were 7.70% and 8.13% for ambient temperature
and low temperature feed, respectively. In addition
to individual effects, the interaction effect of the
grinding method and feed temperature (L*T) on the
same parameter was found non-significant.
Graphically presentation of the mean values (n=3) of
total phenol of ground powder for all the treatments
is given in Fig. 1(c). The figure shows that the value
of total phenol of ground powder increases when
moving from treatments involving no circulation to
coolant circulation treatments. Values ranged from
a minimum of 1.83% for the control treatment (L0T0)
to a maximum of 3.13% in treatment combination
(L3T1).
Turmeric having a higher content of phenolic
compounds has been intensively studied (Braga,
Leal, Carvalho, & Meireles, 2003; Prathapan,
Lukhman, Arumughan, Sundaresan, & Raghu,
2009). During grinding, different temperatures
create different thermal gradients that induce
varying stresses, resulting in the liberation of
phenolic. Therefore, different phenolic compounds
are available at different temperatures. An increase
in total phenol of ground powder with moving
from left to right in the graph might be due to the
fall in the value of temperature inside the grinding
chamber at the end of the grinding operation. As
higher temperature causes degradation of phenolic
compounds, it decreases total phenol content in
ground powder.
The mean values (n=3) of moisture content of
ground powder for all the treatments are graphically
presented in the following figure (Fig. 1(b)). The
figure reveals that the value of moisture content of
ground powder increases when moving from left
to right, i.e. treatments involving ambient grinding
to ambient, chilled water, and coolant circulation
treatments. Values varied from a minimum of 7.00%
for ambient grinding with ambient water circulation
and low temperature feed (L1T1) to a maximum of
8.40% for the treatment combination L3T1.
An increase in moisture content of ground powder
might be attributed to the condensation of moisture
with low temperature inside the grinding chamber.
Further, lower temperature of ground powder might
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
342
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Bioactive Compounds of Turmeric Powder Affected by Grinding Method and Feed Temperature
Table 2: Effect of grinding method and feed temperature on bioactive compounds of turmeric powder
Anti-Oxidant
Flavonoids content
Activity
(mgQE/g)
(%)
Curcumin
content (%)
1.91
1.12
48.15
2.30
Ambient temperature water circulation (L1) 7.76
2.41
1.24
52.69
2.27
8.26
2.84
1.36
55.00
2.44
Coolant circulation (L3)
Effect
Phenol
M. C. (%w.b.) content
(mg/g)
Without liquid circulation (L0)
7.33
Chilled water circulation (L2)
Grinding method (L)
8.31
3.08
1.42
57.92
2.39
S. Em±
0.0766
0.0685
0.0167
0.7269
0.0435
C. D. at 5%
0.2296
0.2053
0.05
2.1792
0.1304
Feed temperature (T)
Ambient temperature feed (T0)
7.70
2.46
1.27
52.62
2.30
8.13
2.66
1.31
54.62
2.40
S. Em±
0.0541
0.0484
0.0118
0.5140
0.0307
C. D. at 5%
0.1623
0.1452
0.0354
1.5409
0.0922
Low temp. feed (T1)
Interaction (L*T)
S. Em±
0.1083
0.0969
0.0236
1.0279
0.0615
C. D. at 5%
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
C. V%
2.3694
6.5555
3.1779
3.3317
4.5302
Number of replications, n=3.
Total flavonoid content
(L 0T 0) to maximum of 1.43 mg QE/g extract in
coolant circulation with low temperature feed (L3T1).
Grinding method affects significantly (p<0.05) on the
value of total flavonoid content of ground product
(Table 2). The lowest value (1.12 mg QE/g extract)
was found for the grinding method without liquid
circulation (L0) while the highest (1.42 mg QE/g
extract) for the method involving coolant circulation
around the grinding chamber (L3). The effect of
feed temperature on the value of total flavonoid
was also found statistically significant (p<0.05).
The values found in case of ambient feed and low
temperature feed were 1.27 and 1.31 mg QE/g
extract, respectively. Besides that, the interaction
effect of grinding method and feed temperature
(L*T) on total flavonoid content of ground powder
was found non-significant at the same level of
significance.
Increase in total flavonoid of ground powder with
moving from ambient grinding with ambient
temperature feed to coolant circulation grinding
with low temperature feed might be due to the
decrease in the elevation of temperature inside the
grinding chamber at the end of grinding operation.
As flavonoids are the largest group of phenolic
compounds (naturally occurring) (Sulaiman and
Balachandran, 2012), higher temperature engenders
degradation of flavonoids and it decreases total
flavonoid content in ground powder.
Antioxidant activity
Table 2 shows that grinding method affects
significantly on the value of antioxidant activity
of ground (p<0.05). The lowest value (48.15 %)
was found for the treatment L0, while the highest
(57.92 %) for the treatment L3. The effect of feed
temperature on the value of the same parameter
was also found statistically significant (p<0.05).
The value found in case of low temperature feed
(54.26%) was significantly higher with that of
ambient temperature feed (52.62%). Conversely,
the interaction effect of grinding method and feed
The mean values of total flavonoid of ground
powder for all the treatments are graphically shown
in the following figure (Fig. 1(d)). Figure indicates
that the value of total flavonoid of ground powder
increases when moving from treatments involving
ambient grinding to ambient water, chilled water
and coolant circulation treatments. Values ranged
from minimum of 1.09 mg QE/g extract for ambient
grinding with ambient temperature feed treatment
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
343
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Dabhi et al.
temperature (L*T) on the value of antioxidant
activity was found non-significant.
flavonoid content are significantly, curcumin may
be available in the form of dihyrocurcumin or
tetrahydrocurcumin, hence its content have not been
observed significant effect.
The mean values of antioxidant activity of ground
powder for all the treatments are graphically
demonstrated in the Fig. 1(e). It shows that the
value of antioxidant activity of ground powder
increases when moving from treatments involving
no circulation to ambient, chilled water and
coolant circulation treatments. Values ranged from
minimum of 47.14 % DPPH scavenging for control
treatment (L0T0) to maximum of 59.31 % DPPH
scavenging in treatment combination L3T1.
The mean values (n=3) of curcumin content
of ground powder for all the treatments are
graphically demonstrated in the Fig. 1(f). It shows
that the values ranged from minimum of 2.22 % for
treatment L1T0 to maximum of 2.48 % for treatment
combination L3T1.
It has been reported that curcumin in turmeric
exhibit antioxidant activity by preventing lipid
peroxidation in various cells including erythrocytes,
liposomes and macrophages. In addition, the
presence of phenolic groups in the structure of
curcumin explains its ability to react with reactive
oxygen species and reactive nitrogen species
(Trujillo et al. 2013).
Lowering of grinding temperature increases the
antioxidant power and hence antioxidant activity
in relation to the concentration of the secondary
metabolites (Tuba & Gulcin, 2008). The same reason
of increase in grinding chamber temperature can
be concluded for decrease in DPPH scavenging per
cent when moving from right to left in the graph. As
phenolics are the largest group of phytochemicals
which account for most of the antioxidant activity
in plants (Sulaiman and Balachandran, 2012),
degradation of phenolic compounds at higher
temperature also caused decrease in antioxidant
activity percentages in ground turmeric powder.
The pattern of increase in antioxidant of ground
powder is the same as total flavonoid content
of ground powder. Tanvir et al. (2017) reported
that presence of antioxidant flavonoids inhibit or
interrupt the substrates’ oxidation even at low
concentrations, and hence it prevents oxidation by
the pro-oxidants. Phenolics and flavonoids are nonenzymatic antioxidants that inactivate pro-oxidants
due to reaction. Oxidative stress plays a major
role in the pathogenesis of various diseases such
as haemorrhage and shock, myocardial ischaemia,
neuronal cell injury, hypoxia and cancer.
CONCLUSION
In summary, the results of this study demonstrated
that grinding temperature affects the moisture
content, antioxidant activity, phenol content, and
curcumin content in turmeric powder. The ideal
grinding method is grinding with coolant circulation
resulting in significantly the highest moisture
content, phenol content, flavonoid content, and
antioxidant activity which was superior to ambient
grinding for the better bioactive compounds in
turmeric powder.
The ambient grinding of turmeric at high
temperatures led to the significant reduction of
antioxidant activity, phenol content, and flavonoid
content. These changes were abridged through with
circulating the coolant in the jacket of the grinding
chamber and hence by reducing the grinding
temperature at the end of grinding. The findings
of this study will be helpful for the reduction of
the grinding temperature without the cryogenic
principle. The results will also help retain curcumin,
phenolic, flavonoids, and antioxidant activity during
turmeric grinding.
Curcumin content
Curcumins are sensitive to high processing
temperatures and are thus degraded during intense
and/or prolonged thermal treatment (Prathapan et al.
2009). It was observed that grinding method affects
non-significantly (p<0.05) on the value of curcumin
content of ground product. The lowest value (2.23%)
was found for the treatment (L0) while the highest
(2.24 %) for the method involving treatment L2.
As the anti-oxidant activity, phenol content and
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This study was carried out under the Research
Project of ICAR-AICRP on Post-Harvest Engineering
and Technology, Junagadh Centre.
344
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Bioactive Compounds of Turmeric Powder Affected by Grinding Method and Feed Temperature
REFERENCES
Mallick, C.P. and Singh, M.B. 1980. Plant enzymology and
Histoenzymology. Kalyani publishers, New Delhi.
Aggarwal, B.B., Deb, L. and Prasad, S. 2015. Curcumin differs
from tetrahydrocurcumin for molecular targets, signaling
pathways and cellular responses. Molecules, 20(1): 185-205.
Marinova, D., Ribarova, F. and Atanassova, M. 2005. Total
phenolics and total flavonoids in Bulgarian fruits and
vegetables. J. Univ. Chem. Technol. Metallurgy, 40: 255–260.
Braga, M.E., Leal, P.F., Carvalho, J.E. and Meireles, M.A.
2003. Comparison of yield, composition, and antioxidant
activity of turmeric (Curcuma longa L.) extracts obtained
using various techniques. J. Agric. Food Chem., 51(22):
6604-11.
Oskoueian, E., Abdullah, N., Hendra, R. and Karimi, E. 2011.
Bioactive compounds, antioxidant, xanthine oxidase
inhibitory, tyrosinase inhibitory and anti-inflammatory
activities of selected agro-industrial by-products. Int. J.
Mol. Sci., 12: 8610–8625.
Chang, C., Yang, M. and Wen, H. 2002. Estimation of total
flavonoid content in propolis by two complementary
colorimetric methods. J. Food Drug Anal., 10: 178–182.
Park Chang Yang, Lee Kyo-Yeon, Gul Khalid, Shafiur Rahman
M., Kim Ah-Na, Chun Jiyeon, Kim Hyun-Jin, and Choi
Sung-Gil. 2019. Phenolics and antioxidant activity
of aqueous turmeric extracts as affected by heating
temperature and time. LWT-Food Sci. Technol., 105: 149-155.
Finley, J.W. 2005. Bioactive compounds and designer plant
foods: The need for clear guidelines to evaluate potential
benefits to human health. Chron. Horticult., 45: 6–11.
Pereira, D.M., Valentao, P., Pereira, J.A. and Andrade, P.B.
2009. Phenolics: from chemistry to biology. Molecules,
14(6): 2202–2211.
Geethanjali, A., Lalitha, P. and Jannathul, F.M. 2016. Analysis
of Curcumin Content of Turmeric Samples from Various
States of India. Int. J. Pharm. Chem. Res., 2(1): 55-62.
Prathapan, A., Lukhman, M., Arumughan, C., Sundaresan,
A. and Raghu, K.G. 2009. Effect of heat treatment on
curcuminoid, colour value and total polyphenols of fresh
turmeric rhizome. Int. J. Food Sci. Technol., 44(7): 1438–1444.
Hendra, R., Ahmad, S., Sukari, A., Shukor, M.Y. and
Oskoueian, E. 2011. Flavonoid analyses and antimicrobial
activity of various parts of Phaleria macrocarpa (Scheff.)
boerl Fruit. Int. J. Mol. Sci., 12: 3422–3431.
Pruthi, J.S. and Mishra, B.D. 1963. Physical, chemical and
microbial changes in curry powdes during drying, milling
and mixing operations. Spice Bulletin, 3(8): 9-13.
Karimi, E., Jaafar, H.Z.E. and Ahmad, S. 2013. Antifungal,
anti-inflammatory and cytotoxicity activities of three
varieties of Labisiapumilabenth: From microwave
obtained extracts. BMC Complement Altern Med., 13: 1–10.
Pusglove, J.W. 1968. Tropical Crops: Dicotyledons 1,
Dicotyledons 2; Longmans: London, UK.
Khopde, S.M., Priyadarsini, K.I., Guha, S.N., Satav, J.G.,
Venkatesan, P. and Rao, M.N.A. 2000. Inhibition of radiationinduced lipid peroxidation by tetrahydrocurcumin:
Possible mechanisms by pulse radiolysis. Biosci. Biotechnol.
Biochem., 64: 503–509.
Trujillo, J., Chirino, Y.I., Molina-Jijon, E., AndericaRomero, A.C., Tapia, E. and Pedraza-Chaverri, J. 2013.
Renoprotective effect of the antioxidant curcumin: recent
findings. Redox Biol., 17(1): 448-56.
Tuba, A.K. and Gülçin, İ. 2008. Antioxidant and radical
scavenging properties of curcumin. Chem. Biol. Interact,
174(1): 27–37.
Lin, J.K., Pan, M.H. and Lin-Shiau, S.Y. 2000. Recent studies
on the biofunctions and biotransformations of curcumin.
BioFactors, 13(1–4): 153–158.
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
345
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology
Citation: IJAEB: 15(Special Issue): 347-358, August 2022
A
E
A
B
ASSOCIATION FOR AGRICULTURE
ENVIRONMENT AND BIOTECHNOLOGY
DOI: 10.30954/0974-1712.03.2022.9
Physical and Functional Properties of Extruded Snack
Products Prepared by Blending of Defatted Peanut Flour with
Corn Flour
P.R. Davara*, Mohit H. Muliya, M.N. Dabhi and V.P. Sangani
Department of Processing and Food Engineering, College of Agricultural Engineering and Technology, Junagadh Agricultural
University, Junagadh, Gujarat, India
*Corresponding author: pareshdavara@yahoo.com (ORCID ID: 0000-0002-2209-3186)
Paper No. 994
Received: 23-05-2022
Revised: 27-06-2022
Accepted: 06-07-2022
ABSTRACT
Extruded snack products were prepared by blending of corn flour and defatted peanut flour using
twin screw extruder. The flours were mixed and added with water put for conditioning prior to the
extrusion cooking. The combined effects of feed moisture content, defatted peanut flour content, die head
temperature and screw speed on the important physical (expansion ratio) and functional (water absorption
index, water holding capacity and water solubility index) properties of extrudates were studied. The
Response Surface Methodology (RSM) was used in designing the experiment. Since, the defatted peanut
flour is poor in starch content, the flour content restricted the gelatinization and limited the expansion of
the product. Defatted peanut flour was found to be suitable for the preparation of extruded snacks with
the appropriate blending corn flour as a base material. The optimum treatment condition was found as
13% feed moisture content, 26% defatted peanut flour, 135 °C die head temperature and 250 rpm screw
speed for the production of extruded product by blending of defatted peanut flour with corn flour.
HIGHLIGHTS
mm Utilization of defatted peanut flour in extrusion cooking.
mm Physical and Functional properties of extrudates.
mm Optimization of extrusion cooking conditions.
Keywords: Extruded product, Defatted peanut flour, Extrusion cooking, Functional properties
Extrusion cooking has been used increasingly
in the production of food and food ingredients
such as breakfast cereals, baby foods, flat breads,
snacks, meat and cheese analogues and modified
starches, etc. (Ding et al. 2004). Extrusion has gained
popularity due to its versatility, cost of processing
and high production rate. A very wide variety of
products are possible by changing the ingredients,
the operating conditions of the extruder and the
shape of the dies. Extrusion has lower processing
costs and higher productivity than other cooking
or forming processes (Fellows, 2000). Due to lower
moisture content, the shelf life of extruded products
are enhanced significantly. Further, this products
are nutritionally rich and are microbiologically safe
(Pathak and Kochhar 2018).
The combination of high temperature and high shear
in extrusion cooking can be used as an effective
cooking method to transform raw ingredients into
ready-to-eat snack products. The acceptability
and nutritional quality of the final product is
not only determined by feed ingredient, but also
manipulation of extrusion parameters including
How to cite this article: Davara, P.R., Muliya, M.H., Dabhi, M.N. and
Sangani, V.P. (2022). Physical and Functional Properties of Extruded
Snack Products Prepared by Blending of Defatted Peanut Flour with
Corn Flour. Int. J. Ag. Env. Biotech., 15(Special Issue): 347-358.
Source of Support: None; Conflict of Interest: None
Davara et al.
feed moisture, screw speed, screw configuration,
and temperature. Feed moisture has been found to
be the main parameter in governing the texture of
extrudates because it substantially influences the
rheological properties of the molten starch. Moisture
acts as a plasticizer, which reduces the viscosity and
mechanical energy dissipation during extrusion. The
effect of screw speed on the quality of extrudate is
complex and highly dependent on temperature. A
higher screw speed results in greater mechanical
energy, or frictional heat, which leads to an increase
in product temperature. The combination of shear
and temperature can lead to a change in rheological
properties of the melt and therefore affect the
texture of extrudate (Choton et al. 2020).
defatted peanut flour was purchased from Nutrinity
Foundation, Junagadh. It was available in the
vacuum packed bag in the fine powder form.
Proximate composition of raw materials
The biochemical characteristics viz. moisture
content, carbohydrate, protein, fat and ash content,
of the corn flour and defatted peanut flour were
determined as per the standard procedures.
Moisture content was determined by oven drying
method according to AOAC (2005). Carbohydrate
content of the prepared flour was determined by
Phenol Sulphuric acid method for total carbohydrate
(Nielsen 2010). Protein content of raw flour as
well as extruded product was determined by
Microkjeldahl method AOAC (1965). Fat content of
the composite flour in the sample was determined
by Soxhlet extraction method described by AOAC
(1965). All analysis are expressed as the mean (±SD)
of triplicate analysis. Ash content of the flour was
determined using muffle furnace as described by
AOAC (2005).
Successful production of ready-to-eat snack
products requires close control of many extrusion
parameters including feed moisture, feed rate,
barrel temperature, screw speed and barrel
temperature. These process variables determine the
transformation of raw materials during processing,
which then influence the rheological properties of
plasticizer melt in the extruder. Understanding
the relationships between the ingredients is quite
necessary to achieve desired product quality
targets and to develop new products (Forsido and
Ramaswamy 2011).
Experimental design
The Response Surface Methodology (RSM) is an
empirical statistical modelling technique employed
for multiple regression analysis using quantitative
data obtained from properly designed experiments
to solve multivariable equations simultaneously. It
was used for designing of the experiment (Myers,
1976; Khuri and Cornell, 1987; Montgomery,
2001). A four-factor five-level Central Composite
Rotatable Design (CCRD) with quadratic model was
employed to study the combined effect independent
variables on different response variables. The levels
as selected for the independent parameters along
with their coded and actual values are presented
in Table 1 and the treatment combination are given
in the Table 2.
At present human are becoming more and more
health conscious thus incorporating of ingredients
in snack products becoming necessary. Hence, the
focus of this research was to enhance the nutritional
and functional properties of extrudates for the
development of snack product. To achieve that,
specific blends of defatted peanut flour and corn
flour subjected to twin-screw extrusion process
under identical set of processing parameters with
the objective of testing the feasibility of defatted
peanut flour in the production of extruded product.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The second order polynomial coefficients were
calculated by using the software package Design
Expert version 10 (STAT-EASE Inc., Minneapolis,
MN, USA) to estimate the responses of the
dependent variable.
Raw materials
The corn grains required for the research work was
obtained from the local market of Junagadh city.
The corn grains were cleaned manually to remove
all impurities and then coarse grinded using stone
mill. The flour was then sieved to obtain uniform
particle size flour. The flour was then packed in
polyethylene bag and stored in refrigerator. The
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Extruded product preparation
Extrusion trials were performed using a co-rotating
twin-screw extruder (Basic Technology Pvt. Ltd.,
348
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Physical and Functional Properties of Extruded Snack Products Prepared by Blending...
Table 1: Independent parameters and their coded and actual values employed for the preparation of extruded
product
Sl. No.
Parameters
Code
1
2
3
4
Feed moisture content (% w.b.)
Peanut flour (%)
Die head temperature (°C)
Screw speed (rpm)
(X1)
(X2)
(X3)
(X4)
-2
10
10
90
100
-1
13
20
105
150
Coded levels
0
+1
16
19
30
40
120
135
200
250
+2
22
50
150
300
Table 2: Matrix of experimental central composite rotatable design for preparation of extruded products
Coded variables
Treatment No.
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
T10
T11
T12
T13
T14
T15
T16
T17
T18
T19
T20
T21
T22
T23
T24
T25
T26
T27
T28
T29
T30
X1
X2
X3
X4
-1
1
-1
1
-1
1
-1
1
-1
1
-1
1
-1
1
-1
1
-2
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-1
-1
1
1
-1
-1
1
1
-1
-1
1
1
-1
-1
1
1
0
0
-2
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-1
-1
-1
-1
1
1
1
1
-1
-1
-1
-1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
-2
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-1
-1
-1
-1
-1
-1
-1
-1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
-2
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
Uncoded variables
DPF
FMC
(X1) % (w.b.)
(X2) (%)
13
20
19
20
13
40
19
40
13
20
19
20
13
40
19
40
13
20
19
20
13
40
19
40
13
20
19
20
13
40
19
40
10
30
22
30
16
10
16
50
16
30
16
30
16
30
16
30
16
30
16
30
16
30
16
30
16
30
16
30
DHT
Screw speed
(X3) (°C)
105
105
105
105
135
135
135
135
105
105
105
105
135
135
135
135
120
120
120
120
90
150
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
(X4) (rpm)
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
250
250
250
250
250
250
250
250
200
200
200
200
200
200
100
300
200
200
200
200
200
200
FMC, feed moisture content, DPF, defatted peanut flour, DHT, die head temperature.
Kolkata, India). Prior to use the extruder, it was
kept in the running condition without feeding the
material. It is necessary for removal material residue
deposited in the barrel assembly. After cleaning of
barrel, the heating system of twin screw extruder
was kept in the on condition for a duration till the
required temperatures were attained at different
sections. The round hole die of 3 mm diameter
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
was used for preparing the extruded product. 300
gram of composite flour prepared by blending
of corn flour and defatted peanut flour was fed
and extrusion was carried out with different
processing variables. The cutter speed was adjusted
appropriately. The extruded product was collected
in a tray and dried using laboratory tray drier at
60 °C temperature for 1 hour to reduce moisture
349
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Davara et al.
Effect of feed moisture content, defatted peanut
flour, die head temperature and screw speed on
response variables
content up to 2-3% (w.b.) from product. Then
product was packed in zipped lock plastic bags and
put under storage at room temperature for future
analysis.
The treatment-wise data regarding various physical
and functional characteristics of extruded products
prepared by blending of DPF and corn flour is
presented in the Table 4.
Physical, functional and mechanical properties
The ratio of diameter of extruded and the diameter
of die was used to express the expansion of extruded
(Fan et al. 1996). The Water Solubility Index (WSI)
and Water Absorption Index (WAI) were measured
using a technique developed for cereals (Ding et
al. 2006). The Water Holding Capacity (WHC) was
calculated using the formula given by Deshpande
and Poshadri (2011).
Expansion ratio
The effect of feed moisture content, defatted peanut
flour, die head temperature and screw speed on
expansion ratio of extrudates is presented in the
Table 4. while the response surface plots are shown
in the Fig.1. ER increased with an increase in the
DPF and FMC up to its minimum level i.e. 10%
and 10% (w.b.), respectively. Similarly, another
probability for increased in expansion ratio with
increase the FMC up to its maximum level i.e. 22
% (w.b.) and DPF up to its minimum level i.e. 10%.
Further, the ER increased with an increase the DHT
up to its maximum level i.e. 150 °C and FMC is up
to 10% (w.b.). The ER also increased with an increase
the screw speed up to its maximum level i.e. 300
rpm and FMC up to its minimum level i.e. 10%
(w.b.). It can also be observed that the ER increased
with an increase in the DPF up to its minimum level
i.e. 10% and DHT up to its maximum level i.e. 150
°C. The interaction of DPF and screw speed showed
that the ER increased with increase the screw speed
up to its maximum level i.e. 300 rpm and DPF up to
its minimum level i.e. 10 %. DHT and screw speed
at its maximum level i.e. 150 °C and 300 rpm, gave
the highest ER of 2.30 mm/mm. Banerjee et al. (2003)
also studied expansion ratio decreased with increase
in moisture content. Ding et al. (2004) also studied
higher barrel temperature increased the extrudate
expansion. Liu et al. (2000) observed screw speed
had no significant effect on expansion ratio. Suknark
et al. (1997) studied as amylase content of starch
increased, the expansion ratio increased.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
The statistical analysis of the experimental data was
carried out to observe the effect of selected process
parameters on the various responses. The obtained
data were subjected to analyse for graphical
representation, analysis of variaance (ANOVA)
and multiple regrassion using the software Design
Expert version 10 (Anderson and Whitcomb, 2005).
The three-dimensional (3D) response surface plot
were generated by keeping one variable constant
at the centre point and varying the other two
variables within the experimental range. The
effect and regression coefficients of individual
linear, interaction terms and quadratic terms were
determined from the ANOVA table. The significance
of all the terms in the polynomil equation was
judges statistically by computing the F-value at a
probability (p) value of 0.001, 0.01 and 0.05.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Proximate composition of raw materials
The biochemical characteristics of the corn flour
and defatted peanut flour selected for the study are
presented in the Table 3.
Table 3: Biochemical characteristics of corn flour and defatted peanut flour.
Sl. No.
1
2
3
4
5
Characteristic
Moisture content % (w.b.)
Carbohydrate (%)
Protein (%)
Fat (%)
Ash (%)
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
Corn flour
8.62±0.23
72.35±2.73
9.55±0.39
5.71±0.27
1.64±0.04
350
Defatted peanut flour
5.64±0.09
23.59±0.57
61.98±0.77
3.96±0.19
4.76±0.17
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Physical and Functional Properties of Extruded Snack Products Prepared by Blending...
Table 4: Physical and functional characteristics of extruded product prepared by blending of defatted peanut
flour and corn flour
Treatment
No.
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
T10
T11
T12
T13
T14
T15
T16
T17
T18
T19
T20
T21
T22
T23
T24
T25
T26
T27
T28
T29
T30
Control
FMC (X1) %
(w.b.)
13
19
13
19
13
19
13
19
13
19
13
19
13
19
13
19
10
22
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
13
Independent variable
DPF
DHT
Screw speed
(X2) (%)
20
20
40
40
20
20
40
40
20
20
40
40
20
20
40
40
30
30
10
50
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
—
(X4) (rpm)
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
250
250
250
250
250
250
250
250
200
200
200
200
200
200
100
300
200
200
200
200
200
200
250
(X3) (°C)
105
105
105
105
135
135
135
135
105
105
105
105
135
135
135
135
120
120
120
120
90
150
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
135
ER
(mm/mm)
2.59
2.54
1.79
1.69
2.98
2.61
1.80
1.80
2.80
2.58
1.76
1.71
3.05
2.67
1.89
1.87
2.10
2.54
3.25
1.65
1.53
2.35
2.04
1.81
1.69
2.12
2.00
2.04
1.93
1.95
2.82
Responses
WSI
WAI
WHC
(%)
10.55
4.46
11.23
7.48
18.02
13.85
16.50
12.13
8.60
5.88
12.11
8.65
18.85
14.52
14.00
11.66
13.27
10.44
5.38
8.17
9.34
18.37
7.46
11.25
7.97
7.10
13.07
10.11
9.07
9.76
4.78
(%)
401.21
388.56
357.41
375.10
482.32
475.65
402.57
389.53
412.32
417.21
389.65
377.68
498.56
465.23
378.65
407.21
399.65
372.32
428.70
373.73
372.12
501.23
456.36
445.10
406.65
431.27
413.93
412.11
436.05
426.56
435.93
(g/g)
5.25
5.23
4.26
4.62
5.79
5.61
4.22
4.34
5.46
6.58
4.42
4.09
6.11
5.73
4.83
5.05
3.14
4.52
5.80
3.98
4.83
5.24
6.21
5.21
4.66
3.87
4.43
4.48
4.47
4.39
5.22
ER, expansion ratio, WSI, water solubility index, WAI, water absorption index, WHC, water holding capacity.
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
DHT up to its maximum level i.e. 150 °C and DPF
up to its minimum level i.e. 10%. At this interaction
WSI was expected to be increased up to 23.31%.
WSI was reported to be maximum (10.84%) for
the interaction of DPF (30%) and screw speed (300
rpm). For the interaction of DHT and screw speed,
the WSI was increased (21%) with an increase in
DHT and screw speed up to its maximum level
i.e. 150 °C and 300 rpm, respectively. Kadan et al.
(2003) also reported WSI increased with an increase
in extrusion temperature. Ding et al. (2004) also
evaluated increasing feed moisture content results
lower WSI.
Fig. 2 represents the effect of feed moisture
content, defatted peanut flour level, die head
temperature and screw speed on water solubility
Index. The highest WSI (15.74%) was observed for
the interaction of DPF at 30% and FMC at 10%.
WSI was observed to be increased up to 23.01%
with an increase the DHT up to its maximum level
i.e. 150 °C and FMC up to its minimum level i.e. 10
% (w.b.). The interaction effect of FMC and screw
speed showed that the WSI increased up to 17.18%
with an increase in the FMC and screw speed up
to its minimum level i.e. 10% (w.b.) and 100 rpm,
respectively. WSI increased with an increased in the
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
351
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Davara et al.
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Expansion ratio
3.25
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Expansion ratio
3.25
1.53
1.53
X1 = A: Feed M.C.
X2 = C: Die head temp.
Actual Factors
C: Die head temp. = 120
D: Screw speed = 200
Actual Factors
B: Defatted peanut flour = 30
D: Screw speed = 200
Expansion ratio
5
4
3
2
1
5
4
Expansion ratio
X1 = A: Feed M.C.
X2 = B: Defatted peanut flour
3
2
1
10
10
10
12
20
12
14
150
14
16
30
16
18
40
B: Defatted peanut flour (%)
20
138
126
18
A: Feed M.C. (%wb)
A: Feed M.C. (%wb)
114
20
102
22
50 22
90
C: Die head temp. (°C)
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Expansion ratio
3.25
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Expansion ratio
3.25
1.53
1.53
X1 = B: Defatted peanut flour
X2 = C: Die head temp.
X1 = A: Feed M.C.
X2 = D: Screw speed
Actual Factors
B: Defatted peanut flour = 30
C: Die head temp. = 120
Actual Factors
A: Feed M.C. = 16
D: Screw speed = 200
5
4
Expansion ratio
4
Expansion ratio
5
3
2
1
300
3
2
1
150
260
10
12
10
220
14
126
20
180
16
138
D: Screw speed (rpm)
18
140
20
A: Feed M.C. (%wb)
22
114
30
C: Die head temp. (°C)
102
40
100
B: Defatted peanut flour (%)
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Expansion ratio
3.25
50 90
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Expansion ratio
3.25
1.53
1.53
X1 = B: Defatted peanut flour
X2 = D: Screw speed
X1 = C: Die head temp.
X2 = D: Screw speed
Actual Factors
A: Feed M.C. = 16
C: Die head temp. = 120
Actual Factors
A: Feed M.C. = 16
B: Defatted peanut flour = 30
5
5
4
Expansion ratio
Expansion ratio
4
3
2
1
300
260
10
B: Defatted peanut flour (%)
300
260
220
114
180
D: Screw speed (rpm)
126
D: Screw speed (rpm)
140
40
1
102
180
30
2
90
220
20
3
C: Die head temp. (°C)
50 100
140
138
150
100
Fig. 1: Effect of feed moisture content, defatted peanut flour, die head temperature and screw speed on expansion ratio
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
352
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Physical and Functional Properties of Extruded Snack Products Prepared by Blending...
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
18.8486
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
18.8486
4.46
4.46
X1 = A: Feed M.C.
X2 = B: Defatted peanut flour
Actual Factors
B: Defatted peanut flour = 30
D: Screw speed = 200
25
20
15
10
5
0
10
10
12
30
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
Actual Factors
C: Die head temp. = 120
D: Screw speed = 200
X1 = A: Feed M.C.
X2 = C: Die head temp.
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
150
10
14
20
138
12
16
40
20
50
114
18
18
B: Defatted peanut flour (%)
126
14
16
30
A: Feed M.C. (%wb)
102
20
A: Feed M.C. (%wb)
22
C: Die head temp. (°C)
90
22
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
18.8486
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
18.8486
4.46
4.46
X1 = B: Defatted peanut flour
X2 = C: Die head temp.
X1 = A: Feed M.C.
X2 = D: Screw speed
30
30
Actual Factors
A: Feed M.C. = 16
D: Screw speed = 200
25
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
Actual Factors
B: Defatted peanut flour = 30
C: Die head temp. = 120
20
15
10
5
0
300
10
260
12
25
20
15
10
5
0
150
10
138
20
220
14
16
140
20
A: Feed M.C. (%wb)
22
126
30
180
18
D: Screw speed (rpm)
114
40
102
B: Defatted peanut flour (%)
100
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
18.8486
50
C: Die head temp. (°C)
90
Design-Expert® Software
Factor Coding: Actual
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
18.8486
4.46
4.46
X1 = B: Defatted peanut flour
X2 = D: Screw speed
30
Actual Factors
A: Feed M.C. = 16
B: Defatted peanut flour = 30
25
20
15
10
5
0
300
10
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
30
Water Solubility Index (WSI)
Actual Factors
A: Feed M.C. = 16
C: Die head temp. = 120
X1 = C: Die head temp.
X2 = D: Screw speed
260
20
25
20
15
10
5
0
150
100
138
220
30
140
126
180
40
B: Defatted peanut flour (%)
140
50
180
114
D: Screw speed (rpm)
220
C: Die head temp. (°C)
102
260
90
100
D: Screw speed (rpm)
300
Fig. 2: Effect of feed moisture content, defatted peanut flour, die head temperature and screw speed on water solubility index
Table 5: Constraints, criteria and output for numerical optimization of extruded snack food
Variables
Constraint
Goal
Importance
Optimum value
Feed moisture content % (w.b.)
In the range
3
13
Defatted peanut flour (%)
Maximum
3
26
Die head temperature (°C)
In the range
3
135
Screw speed (rpm)
In the range
3
250
Responses
Constraint
Goal
Importance
Predicted value
Experimental
Deviation (%)
value
Expansion ratio (mm/mm)
Maximum
3
2.51
2.26
9.96
Water solubility index (%)
Maximum
3
16.47
16.51
-0.243
Water absorption index (g/g)
Maximum
3
5.24
4.27
18.51
Water holding capacity (%)
Maximum
3
467.38
473.44
-1.30
Print ISSN : 0974-1712
353
Online ISSN : 2230-732X
Davara et al.
Water Absorption Index (WAI)
was observed up to 10% and 150°C, respectively
which yielded the WHC of 566.22%. The interaction
of DPF at 10% and screw speed at 300 rpm yielded
the highest WHC of 479.86%. Similarly, the WHC
was found to be increased up to 526.84% for the
interaction of DHT at 150°C and screw speed at
100 rpm. For all the above conditions further rise
the independent variables decreased the response
variables. Banerjee et al. (2003) also reported the
rise in the WHC with an increase in the moisture
content as well as temperature.
The effect of feed moisture content, defatted peanut
flour, die head temperature and screw speed on
WAI is graphically presented in the Fig. 3. From
the graphs it could be observed that the WAI was
increased up to 6.24 g/g with an increase in the DPF
level up to its minimum level i.e. 10% and FMC
up to 18% (w.b.). The interaction of DHT (150°C)
and FMC (15.80%) gave the maximum WAI of 5.38
g/g. The WAI was increased up to 6.04 g/g with
an increase in the screw speed up to its maximum
level i.e. 300 rpm and FMC up to 19% (w.b.). The
DPF with its minimum level of 10% and DHT
with its maximum level of 150°C increased the
WAI up to 7.09 g/g. The interaction of DPF and
screw speed showed that WAI was increased with
increase the DPF up to its minimum level i.e. 10%
and screw speed up to its maximum level i.e. 300
rpm. At this interaction of DPF and screw speed,
the WAI increased the up to 7.97 g/g and 7.29 g/g,
respectively. The interaction of DHT (150°C) and
screw speed (300 rpm) gave the highest WAI of