Sustainable Tree Management for Charcoal Production ... - Pisces
Sustainable Tree Management for Charcoal Production ... - Pisces
Sustainable Tree Management for Charcoal Production ... - Pisces
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong><br />
<strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong><br />
Acacia Species in Kenya<br />
Acacia Pocketbook<br />
June 2012<br />
Prepared <strong>for</strong> PISCES by Practical Action Consulting East Africa
Although this research is funded by DFID, the views expressed in this<br />
report are entirely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent<br />
DFID’s own policies or views. Any discussion of their content should<br />
there<strong>for</strong>e be addressed to the authors and not to DFID.<br />
Authors: Nellie M. Oduor (Kenya Forestry Research Institute - KEFRI),<br />
Wairimu Ngugi and Tameezan wa Gathui (Practical Action<br />
Consulting East Africa - PAC EA).<br />
Editors: Ewan Bloomfield and Katie Wel<strong>for</strong>d (PAC UK); Hannah Wanjiru<br />
(PAC EA).<br />
Cover images: Main: Acacia polyacantha woodlot at 2½ years (spacing<br />
2.5 x 2.5 metres) in Rarieda, Nyanza (Wairimu Ngugi/PAC).<br />
All images: Practical Action Consulting, unless otherwise stated.<br />
Abbreviations<br />
ACTS African Centre <strong>for</strong> Technology Studies<br />
DFID Department <strong>for</strong> International Development<br />
FAO Food and Agriculture Organisation<br />
g/cm3 Grams per cubic metre<br />
KFS Kenya Forest Service<br />
KEFRI Kenya Forestry Research Institute<br />
kj/g Kilojoules per gram<br />
Ksh Kenya shilling<br />
PAC Practical Action Consulting<br />
PISCES Policy Innovation Systems <strong>for</strong> Clean Energy Security<br />
UK United Kingdom<br />
UN United Nations<br />
US$ United States Dollar<br />
Acknowledgements<br />
This publication was prepared through a participatory process led by PAC and KEFRI<br />
through the Policy Innovation Systems <strong>for</strong> Clean Energy Security (PISCES) project. PAC<br />
and KEFRI appreciate various stakeholders who have shared their practical experiences<br />
on feedstock management <strong>for</strong> charcoal production. We also thank various stakeholders<br />
<strong>for</strong> their collaboration especially Dr. Joseph Githiomi (Centre Director, KEFRI Forest<br />
Products Research Centre Karura); Kenya Forest Service (KFS), PAC UK, Practical Action<br />
Regional Office <strong>for</strong> East Africa and International Network on Gender and <strong>Sustainable</strong><br />
Energy (ENERGIA – Kenya Network).<br />
2 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong><br />
Contents<br />
Acknowledgements 2<br />
Acronyms and Abbreviations 2<br />
Introduction 4<br />
Species Selection <strong>for</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 5<br />
Species choice in Kenya 5<br />
Suitable woody species <strong>for</strong> woodfuel in Kenya 6<br />
Characteristics of Acacias 6<br />
Calorific value of wood 7<br />
<strong>Tree</strong> Farming and <strong>Management</strong> Practices 8<br />
Basic inputs <strong>for</strong> tree farming 8<br />
Seed collection and storage 8<br />
Certified seeds 9<br />
Farm preparation 9<br />
Seed treatment and sowing 10<br />
Steps in seedling planting 10<br />
<strong>Tree</strong> management practices 11<br />
<strong>Tree</strong> harvesting techniques, tools and implements 12<br />
Processing Technologies 14<br />
Methods of charcoal production 14<br />
Casamance kiln 14<br />
The half orange kiln 14<br />
The meko kiln 15<br />
The drum kiln 15<br />
How to use the drum kiln 16<br />
Gender equity <strong>for</strong> sustainable charcoal production 17<br />
References 18<br />
Appendices 20<br />
Appendix 1: List of KEFRI Regional Centres and Sub Centres 20<br />
Appendix 2: List of KEFRI Approved <strong>Tree</strong> Seed Stockists 21<br />
<strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 3
Introduction<br />
This publication shares in<strong>for</strong>mation on tree growing and management <strong>for</strong> sustainable<br />
charcoal production. It focuses on Acacia species with emphasis on Acacia<br />
polyacantha and Acacia xanthophloea. Both species are native to a majority of<br />
the arid and semi-arid areas in Kenya, including parts of Bondo, western Kenya,<br />
where Practical Action is undertaking much of its work on sustainable charcoal.<br />
The publication also highlights the importance of promoting gender equity as a vital<br />
component <strong>for</strong> supporting grassroots communities to achieve sustainable charcoal<br />
production through fair sharing of resources and benefits by both men and women.<br />
The publication has been developed through a participatory process led by PAC and<br />
KEFRI through PISCES project. It seeks to support implementation of the current<br />
charcoal policy and compliance requirements and is part of a series of publications<br />
developed by PISCES to create awareness on the Forest (<strong>Charcoal</strong>) Rules, 2009.<br />
<strong>Charcoal</strong> is a key bioenergy resource and source of energy in Kenya, providing<br />
82 percent of urban and 34 percent of rural household energy, employment<br />
and income <strong>for</strong> over 700,000 people who support over two million dependants.<br />
Demand <strong>for</strong> charcoal is fast increasing due to population growth, increased<br />
urbanization and the development of cottage industries.<br />
<strong>Charcoal</strong> is produced from trees grown in <strong>for</strong>ests, woodlands, bush lands,<br />
grasslands, farmlands and plantations. Although the Energy and Forestry Policies<br />
and Acts have recently legalized sustainable charcoal production, numerous<br />
challenges still affect the industry, while its true value is not adequately captured<br />
in national economic statistics. Increased charcoal consumption and the use of<br />
traditional kilns have resulted in increased destruction and depletion of national<br />
tree resources. For example every tonne of charcoal produced through a traditional<br />
kiln depletes approximately 0.1 hectare of woodland. An efficient kiln would require<br />
only 0.05 hectares <strong>for</strong> every tonne of charcoal produced, a 50% saving. This<br />
calls <strong>for</strong> tree growing aimed at sustainable on-farm / community level charcoal<br />
production and widespread adoption of efficient wood conversion technologies.<br />
<strong>Tree</strong> growing <strong>for</strong> charcoal production at the farm / community level involves<br />
both men and women in different roles and responsibilities and with different<br />
levels of access to and control over production resources including land, water,<br />
labour and financial inputs. Men and women also have different levels of access<br />
and control over benefits derived from charcoal production. This necessitates<br />
awareness creation and in<strong>for</strong>mation sharing on the need <strong>for</strong> gender equity as a<br />
vital component of promoting sustainable charcoal production.<br />
Species Selection <strong>for</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong><br />
<strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong><br />
Species choice in Kenya<br />
Species selection, climatic conditions, tree growth rate and management<br />
practices are some of the most critical factors in sustainable charcoal<br />
production. Generally, all species of wood can be carbonized to produce<br />
charcoal. However, the quality of charcoal varies from species to species and<br />
the method of carbonisation.<br />
Species that produce high quality charcoal include Casuarina equisetifolia, Acacia<br />
mearnsii, Acacia polyacantha, Acacia xanthophloea, Acacia spectabilis, Eucalyptus<br />
camaldulensis, Leuceana leucocephala, Tectona grandis, Sesbania sesban and other<br />
Acacia and Combretum species. These species are preferred mostly because they<br />
produce heavy charcoal that burns <strong>for</strong> a long time, making it economical to use.<br />
Characteristics of tree species which are suitable <strong>for</strong> wood fuel production<br />
• Grow quickly, yield a high volume of wood quickly, and require minimum<br />
management time.<br />
• Coppice or sprout well from shoots.<br />
• Have dense wood with low moisture content.<br />
• Produce little and non-toxic smoke.<br />
• Produce wood that splits easily and can easily be transported.<br />
• Produce wood without thorns.*<br />
• Yield other products or services <strong>for</strong> the household.<br />
• Produce wood that does not spit or spark when burning.<br />
Source: Hines and Eckman (1993)<br />
*However there are many thorny tree species that are suitable <strong>for</strong> woodfuel production,<br />
<strong>for</strong> example Acacia polyacantha and Acacia xanthophloea, among others.<br />
A farmer with 6 – 10 hectares of land can produce charcoal on a sustainable<br />
basis by harvesting a hectare every year <strong>for</strong> a rotation age of six years. Every<br />
year one hectare will be harvested and similarly one hectare planted with the<br />
same tree species.<br />
4 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 5
Suitable woody species <strong>for</strong> wood fuel in Kenya<br />
Acacia brevispica<br />
Acacia bussei<br />
Acacia drepanolobium<br />
Acacia gerardii<br />
Acacia hockii<br />
Acacia lahai<br />
Acacia mellifera<br />
Acacia nilotica<br />
Acacia nubica<br />
Acacia reficiens<br />
Acacia senegal<br />
Acacia seyal<br />
Acacia tortilis<br />
Acacia xanthophloea<br />
Afzelia quanzensis<br />
Albizia amara<br />
Albizia anthelmintica<br />
Balanites aegyptiaca<br />
Barleria spinisepala<br />
Bauhinia taitensis<br />
Boscia angustifolia<br />
Combretum apiculata<br />
Combretum brownii<br />
Combretum constrictum<br />
Combretum hereroensii<br />
Combretum molle<br />
Commiphora africana<br />
Terminalia spinosa<br />
Sources: Kareko, K. K. and Githiomi, J. (2000); Barklund, E. and Palmstiema, M. (2005).<br />
Characteristics of Acacias<br />
Commiphora schimperi<br />
Croton dichogamus<br />
Dalbergia melanoxylon<br />
Euclea divinorum<br />
Grewia bicolor<br />
Grewia plagiophylla<br />
Grewia similis<br />
Grewia vilosa<br />
Maytenus species<br />
Olea europaea variant africana<br />
Prosopis juliflora<br />
Prosopis pallida<br />
Tarchonanthus camphoratus<br />
Terminalia brownii<br />
Acacia is a pod-bearing group of shrubs and trees that tend to be thorny, hence<br />
they are also known as thorn-trees. Acacias are also known as wattles, including<br />
the yellow-fever acacia and umbrella acacias. There are roughly 1,300 species of<br />
Acacia worldwide, about 960 of which are native to Australia, with the remainder<br />
spread around the tropical to warm temperate regions of both hemispheres,<br />
including Africa, southern Asia, and the Americas.<br />
One of the fastest growing thorn trees is Acacia xanthophloea, a large tree that<br />
is 15 to 25 metres tall with a growth rate of 1 to 1.5 metres per year. The bark<br />
is smooth, slightly flaking and yellow to greenish-yellow. It is found in semievergreen<br />
bushland and woodland in areas with a high groundwater table and<br />
sandy soils. The species can withstand cold and is found at altitudes ranging<br />
from 600 – 2100 metres. One cubic metre of Acacia xanthophloea wood<br />
produces three bags of charcoal.<br />
Acacia polyacantha is a large deciduous tree that grows up to a height of 3.5 to<br />
20 metres; the bark is yellow-brown and inclined to be thick or peeling in thick,<br />
corky flakes and loose strips. It grows in wooded grasslands, woodlands and<br />
bushlands, thriving in sites with high groundwater table and alluvial soils with a<br />
good mix of clay and sand. The species grows from sea level to an altitude of<br />
1800 metres and does well with a mean annual rainfall of 300 - 1000 millimetres.<br />
Calorific value of wood<br />
The calorific value <strong>for</strong> wood ranges from 3.5 to 5 kilojoules per gram (kj/g) and<br />
<strong>for</strong> charcoal it ranges between 5 to 9 kj/g. Calorific value is the amount of heat<br />
produced by the complete combustion of a fuel. The value is used to determine<br />
the efficiency and effectiveness of different types of fuels. Calorific value is<br />
measured in units of energy per quantity of fuel, e.g. kg/g, while density of wood<br />
is the weight of wood per volume, e.g. grams per cubic metre (g/cm 3 ).<br />
Calorific value of wood and charcoal from selected tree species<br />
Species Density of the wood<br />
(g/cm 3 )<br />
Calorific value of wood<br />
(kj/g)<br />
Calorific value of<br />
charcoal (kj/g)<br />
Acacia mearnsii 0.775 3.7 7.4<br />
Acacia nilotica 0.624 4.9 7.3<br />
Acacia polyacantha 0.467 4.0 6.5<br />
Acacia xanthophloea 0.532 4.4 7.9<br />
Casuarina equisetifolia 0.820 5.0 7.7<br />
Commiphora africana 0.331 4.8 6.9<br />
Commiphora baluensis 0.541 4.4 6.6<br />
Commiphora campestris 0.388 4.2 6.9<br />
Eucalyptus grandis 0.790 4.5 7.5<br />
Eucalyptus maculata 0.603 – 7.4<br />
Grevillea robusta 0.530 – 7.2<br />
Markhamia lutea 0.356 – 8.1<br />
Senna spectabilis 0.337 – 8.0<br />
Terminalia brownii 0.445 4.6 7.3<br />
Terminalia orbicularis 0.685 5.1 5.9<br />
Prosopis juliflora 0.891 4.9 7.9<br />
Prospopis pallida 0.834 4.9 7.8<br />
Source: Oduor, Nellie M. (2005).<br />
6 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 7
<strong>Tree</strong> Farming and <strong>Management</strong> Practices<br />
Basic inputs <strong>for</strong> tree farming<br />
• Land and water.<br />
• Labour <strong>for</strong> land preparation.<br />
• <strong>Tree</strong> nursery (establishment and management).<br />
• Labour <strong>for</strong> tree planting, weeding and management.<br />
• <strong>Tree</strong> protection.<br />
Generally, trees require minimum inputs after planting compared to agricultural<br />
crops. However, weeding and protection against grazing, trampling and browsing<br />
by animals and trespass or destruction by humans is important <strong>for</strong> optimum yields.<br />
Other factors which affect successful establishment are fire, pests and diseases.<br />
Labour inputs <strong>for</strong> plantation establishment and management (especially <strong>for</strong> Acacia species)<br />
Activity Labour input in person days / hectare<br />
Clearing and land preparation 20<br />
Raising and transporting seedlings 4<br />
Planting 15<br />
Weeding and maintenance 24<br />
Source: Jurvélius, M. (1997).<br />
Seed collection and storage<br />
Flowering of most Acacias is dependent on the rains. The seeding period occurs<br />
approximately six months after flowering. On average Acacia xanthophloea<br />
produces 24,000 to 30,000 seeds per kilogramme while Acacia polyacantha<br />
produces 15,000 seeds per kilogramme.<br />
Tips on seed collection and storage<br />
• Collect mature brownish pods from the crowns of standing trees by shaking<br />
the branches to release the pods.<br />
• Split the pods by hands to obtain small quantities of seeds.<br />
• Store mature and properly dried seeds in airtight containers at room<br />
temperature <strong>for</strong> up to one year.<br />
Certified seeds<br />
Certified tree seeds are recommended <strong>for</strong> best germination results. Seed<br />
certification is a legally sanctioned and internationally recognized system <strong>for</strong><br />
quality control of seed multiplication and production. Certification ensures that<br />
tree growers have access to high quality seeds and propagating materials of<br />
known genetic identity and purity, with high germination rates and freedom from<br />
weed seeds. KEFRI, through its <strong>Tree</strong> Seed Programme is mandated to produce<br />
tree seeds that are collected from selected and approved tree sources. Certified<br />
tree seeds can be obtained from KEFRI Regional Centers and Sub-Centers<br />
distributed in Kenya as listed on Appendix 1. KEFRI has also contracted treeseed<br />
stockists in Kenya as listed on Appendix 2.<br />
Acacia Species Local price<br />
(Ksh)<br />
Approximate price per kilogramme of certified Acacia seeds<br />
Export price<br />
(US$)<br />
Acacia Species Local price<br />
(Ksh)<br />
Export<br />
price (US$)<br />
Acacia brevispica 1000 40 Acacia nilotica 800 40<br />
Acacia drepanolobium 1000 40 Acacia nubica 600 40<br />
Acacia elatior 1200 40 Acacia polyacantha 1500 40<br />
Acacia gerrardii 1000 40 Acacia reficiens 800 50<br />
Acacia hockii 800 40 Acacia senegal 1500 40<br />
Acacia lahai 600 40 Acacia seyal 1500 40<br />
Acacia mangium 1000 150 Acacia sieberiana 1000 40<br />
Acacia mearnsii 800 40 Acacia tortilis 1500 40<br />
Acacia melanoxylon 1000 50 Acacia xanthophloea 3000 40<br />
Acacia melifera 1500 50 Acacia zanzibarica 800 50<br />
Source: KEFRI (2010).<br />
8 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 9
Farm preparation<br />
• Site selection: Most Acacias are accustomed to drought in their native habitat<br />
and should be planted in areas with well-drained soil. If the soil is not well<br />
drained, the Acacia can be planted on a gentle slope or hill top. The majority<br />
of Acacias can grow in acidic, neutral or alkaline soils. For optimum growth,<br />
plant the Acacias in full sunlight.<br />
• Land preparation: Start land preparation be<strong>for</strong>e the onset of the rains to<br />
remove weeds. Weeds inverted during ploughing dry up and decompose,<br />
adding nutrients to the soil. Proper soil preparation ensures the soil surface<br />
and hard pans are broken to improve water infiltration, soil aeration and easy<br />
root penetration into the soil substrate.<br />
Seed treatment and sowing<br />
• Acacia seeds can be sown in seedling trays or directly in the field. To achieve<br />
high germination and seedling survival rates, establish the tree nursery or sow<br />
the seeds directly during the rainy season.<br />
• Pre-sowing treatment:<br />
• Nick the seed coat at the cotyledon end using a knife or any other sharp tool<br />
and sow immediately;<br />
or<br />
• Soak the seed in hot water, cool overnight and sow the next morning.<br />
• When sowing cover the seeds with a thin layer of sand and keep moist (water<br />
the seedling trays / beds during dry spells). Under ideal conditions germination<br />
occurs within 5 to 15 days <strong>for</strong> Acacia xanthophloea and 10 to 21 days <strong>for</strong><br />
Acacia polyacantha. The expected germination rate <strong>for</strong> mature, healthy and<br />
properly treated seed is 40% to 90% <strong>for</strong> Acacia xanthophloea and 60% to<br />
90% <strong>for</strong> Acacia polyacantha.<br />
Seedling planting and management<br />
• Start tree planting at the beginning of the long rains i.e. after approximately<br />
100 millimetres of steady rainfall.<br />
• Transplant seedlings after they have grown to the 2-leaf stage from seedling<br />
trays or nursery beds into nursery bags filled with a mixture of five parts river<br />
sand and one part compost (ratio of 5:1).<br />
• Spacing is the most important aspect in the establishment of <strong>for</strong>est plantations<br />
because it correlates to the success of the <strong>for</strong>est plantation in terms of<br />
maintenance, stand stability, quality of wood and investment. For short<br />
rotation <strong>for</strong>estry <strong>for</strong> charcoal production, a minimum of 2 metres by 2 metres<br />
spacing is recommended. Clear felling is recommended <strong>for</strong> tree rows that are<br />
more closely spaced (e.g. 1 metre by 1 metre) because the remaining trees if<br />
selectively harvested would be too weak or unstable to remain upright.<br />
Steps in seedling planting<br />
Step 1 Make a hole measuring 45 centimetres wide by 45 centimetres<br />
deep. Separate the top soil from the subsoil when digging the hole.<br />
Step 2 Mix the top soil with manure.<br />
Step 3 Place the seedling inside the hole and cover with the mixture of top<br />
soil and manure.<br />
Step 4 Gently firm the soil all around the roots.<br />
Step 5 After planting use the subsoil to make a basin <strong>for</strong> water retention<br />
around the seedling.<br />
Step 6 Water the seedling.<br />
• To achieve high survival rates tree seedlings should be planted during the rainy<br />
season when watering is not necessary. However, if possible watering should be<br />
done immediately after planting. If there is no rainfall during the first week after<br />
planting, watering is necessary <strong>for</strong> achievement of a survival rate of over 70%.<br />
• Beating up or replanting to replace any dead seedlings should be done either<br />
during the following planting season or when there is enough moisture build<br />
up in the soil.<br />
10 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 11
<strong>Tree</strong> management practices<br />
• Weeding: During the first two years, Acacias can be intercropped with<br />
agricultural crops such as maize, beans, groundnuts and chilli pepper. Besides<br />
reducing the cost of weeding this will ensure the trees benefit from weeding<br />
while the crops will in turn benefit from the nitrogen fixing qualities of Acacias.<br />
Regular spot weeding of 1 metre diameter around the seedling should be<br />
carried <strong>for</strong> trees that are not intercropped with agricultural crops to remove<br />
excessive vegetation until the trees <strong>for</strong>m a canopy.<br />
• Pests and disease control: Acacias contain organic compounds which act<br />
as natural repellents that defend / protect them against pests and grazing<br />
animals. The thorny nature of most Acacias is also a defence mechanism<br />
against browsing by animals. Some of the insect pests affecting trees in arid<br />
and semi-arid regions include termites, defoliators, sap suckers, seed and<br />
wood borer.<br />
• Coppicing: Leaving a short stump of a felled tree to encourage re-growth<br />
is known as coppicing. Re-growth from a cut tree stump or the base of a<br />
damaged stem is known as a ‘coppice’.<br />
To manage a coppice, select about four dominant branches and remove the<br />
other smaller/weaker branches. These can further be reduced to two or three<br />
branches within the year.<br />
Example of a coppicing Acacia polyacantha<br />
(Nellie M. Oduor, KEFRI)<br />
Labour inputs <strong>for</strong> plantation establishment and management (especially <strong>for</strong> Acacia species)<br />
Activity Labour input in person days / hectare<br />
Clearing and land preparation 20<br />
Raising and transporting seedlings 4<br />
Planting 15<br />
Weeding and maintenance 24<br />
Source: Jurvélius, M. (1997).<br />
Selected pests of Acacia species and control measures<br />
Host Pest Nature of attack Control measures<br />
Acacia nilotica Brichiduis baudoni Seed borer BHC fumigation<br />
Acacridium melanorhodon Defoliator Diazinon<br />
Pediosus species Seed borer BHC fumigation<br />
Acacia polyacantha Oemida gahani Wood borer Correct pruning<br />
Acacia seyal<br />
Acacia xanthophloea<br />
Triozastus baghaasi Wood borer BHC preservative<br />
Acacia tortilis Sphadasmus species Wood borer Diazinon<br />
Source: adapted from Muok et al., 2007.<br />
Bruchidius longipennis Defoliator BHC preservative<br />
Tips on pests and diseases control<br />
• Carefully read and follow the label precautions and directions <strong>for</strong> all<br />
pesticides, fumigants, preservatives and other chemicals applied <strong>for</strong><br />
disease and pests control.<br />
• For further in<strong>for</strong>mation / assistance on tree pests and diseases control<br />
contact KEFRI Regional Centres and Sub-Centres, KFS County and<br />
Zonal Offices and authorised <strong>for</strong>estry and agricultural extension agents.<br />
12 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 13
<strong>Tree</strong> harvesting techniques, tools and implements<br />
Handling both Acacia xanthophloea and Acacia polyacantha requires the use of<br />
protective gear (e.g. boots and hand gloves) due to the thorny characteristics<br />
of these species, particularly the tops of Acacia xanthophloea and stems of<br />
Acacia polyacantha. <strong>Tree</strong> harvesting should be done using methods, tools and<br />
implements that minimise damage to the surrounding site and soil.<br />
Tools and implements <strong>for</strong> harvesting wood<br />
Description of tool or implement Purpose of tool or implement<br />
Wheel barrow Transportation of wood<br />
2-man crosscut saw (5-6’)* Wood cutting<br />
Professional bow saw, 36”* Wood cutting<br />
Logging axe Cutting of wood<br />
Whetstone Metal (tools) sharpening<br />
Machete, rake Clearing of biomass, branches<br />
Metal file, 6-10” Saw and other sharpening<br />
Safety helmet Head protection<br />
Steel toed safety boots Leg and feet protection<br />
First aid kit First aid<br />
Pair of working gloves Protection of hands<br />
Ladder Pollarding of branches of thorny trees<br />
*For harvesting plantation grown wood.<br />
Source: Adapted from Jurvélius, M. (1997).<br />
General rules <strong>for</strong> sustainable harvesting of <strong>for</strong>est plantations<br />
1 Harvest using methods that minimise damage to the planted site and surrounding soil.<br />
2 • Use chainsaws <strong>for</strong> big trees. For small trees use bow saws, cross-cut saws or handsaws.<br />
• Cut trees as low as possible and carefully control the felling direction<br />
(e.g. from uphill to the road into existing gaps).<br />
• Minimise the number of logging pathways and amount of movement inside the plantation.<br />
• Suspend logging during wet periods.<br />
3 • The use of animals such as donkeys to ferry harvested trees is ideal to minimise damage to the soil on<br />
steep slopes.<br />
• The use of a small farm tractor is possible on gentle slopes.<br />
• A portable sawmill can be used to saw up cut logs at the harvesting site.<br />
4 Stream side buffer strips of at least 20 metres on either side of the stream should be maintained.<br />
Source: Adapted from Maua, J. and Ngazi, J. (2009).<br />
Processing Technologies<br />
Methods of charcoal production<br />
The three most common methods of charcoal production are earth kilns,<br />
masonry kilns and metal kilns.<br />
• Earth kilns are of various types but the most common are the traditional earth<br />
kiln, improved earth kiln and the Casamance kiln.<br />
• Masonry kilns are usually of the beehive and half orange type; they are<br />
recommended <strong>for</strong> charcoal conversion in areas where fuelwood is available<br />
<strong>for</strong> prolonged periods, such as in large-scale land clearing or in fuelwood<br />
plantations.<br />
• Metal kilns include the drum kiln, meko kiln and Mark V type.<br />
Casamance kiln<br />
The kiln has a chimney at the back and air-lets or channels at the side. The wood<br />
is cut into pieces measuring 0.5 metres long which are arranged upright and<br />
covered, first with grass or foliage and then soil be<strong>for</strong>e lighting. Carbonisation<br />
takes 2-3 days depending on the size of kiln.<br />
Left: Wood arranged upright <strong>for</strong> Casamance kiln<br />
(Nellie M. Oduor, KEFRI)<br />
Right: Lighting the Casamance kiln after covering the<br />
wood. The metal chimney is visible at the back of the<br />
kiln (Nellie M. Oduor, KEFRI).<br />
14 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 15
The half orange kiln<br />
The kiln is made of brick and covered <strong>for</strong> protection from rain. The wood is<br />
packed inside the kiln through a doorway, which is then sealed halfway up.<br />
The wood is lit and once it has caught fire the doorway is completely sealed.<br />
Carbonisation takes 2 to 3 days depending on the size of kiln.<br />
Left to right: Wood arranged tightly inside the half orange kiln, and sealing the door way of the kiln<br />
(Nellie M. Oduor, KEFRI).<br />
The meko kiln<br />
A new meko kiln belonging to Masanga Women Group<br />
in Madiany, Bondo (PAC).<br />
This is a modified drum that has two<br />
chambers and two metal doors; the<br />
inner chamber is <strong>for</strong> carbonization<br />
while the outer chamber is <strong>for</strong> firing.<br />
The wood is cut into pieces measuring<br />
0.8 metres long and packed into the<br />
modified drum kiln. After closing the<br />
doorway of the inner chamber the<br />
wood in the outer chamber is lit and<br />
the kiln’s metal door is closed. The<br />
carbonization process takes 10 hours<br />
while cooling takes 3 hours.<br />
The drum kiln<br />
The drum kiln is made from an ordinary<br />
oil drum. The kiln has a removable lid<br />
and a detachable metal ring which<br />
joins the lid to the drum. The ring has<br />
an adjustable screw which tightens the<br />
lid to the drum. The drum is modified<br />
by welding a short metal pipe that<br />
acts as a chimney onto the drum.<br />
The bottom side of the chimney has a<br />
diameter of 6 centimetres. A separate<br />
metal grill is constructed to fit inside<br />
the bottom of the kiln. The metal grill<br />
prevents fuelwood from touching the<br />
bottom of the drum, thus providing<br />
air circulation within the kiln during the<br />
process of carbonisation.<br />
A drum kiln with feedstock (KFS).<br />
The carbonization process takes 6 to 12 hours giving a charcoal recovery rate of<br />
32% to 38% which is 3 to 4 times more than recovery from the traditional earth<br />
kiln. the drum kiln has a capacity of 0.4 cubic metres of wood and yields about<br />
3/4 of a bag of charcoal. It is most suitable <strong>for</strong> domestic charcoal production<br />
using small diameter stems or tree branches.<br />
16 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 17
How to use the drum kiln<br />
(Nellie M. Oduor, KEFRI).<br />
Step 1 Cut the wood into pieces measuring 80<br />
centimetres in length and split thicker logs into<br />
pieces measuring 6 to 10 centimetres in diameter.<br />
Step 2 Place the metal grill inside the kiln and stack<br />
dried wood onto the metal grill until the kiln is<br />
fully loaded.<br />
Step 3 Close the loaded drum with the lid which has a<br />
firing door and cover the kiln with soil, leaving<br />
the firing door uncovered.<br />
Step 4 Stack small pieces of wood at the firing section<br />
and light the kiln. Allow the wood pieces at the<br />
lighting section to burn until the wood inside<br />
the drum catches fire and the chimney starts<br />
emitting smoke.<br />
Step 5 Cover the firing door with soil.<br />
Step 6 Remove the chimney when clear blue smoke<br />
is emitted thus indicating the wood is fully<br />
carbonized.<br />
Step 7 Seal the chimney holder with grass and soil.<br />
Leave the drum to cool <strong>for</strong> 12-24 hours be<strong>for</strong>e<br />
removing the charcoal.<br />
Gender equity <strong>for</strong> sustainable charcoal production<br />
The aim of promoting gender equity is to ensure fair sharing of resources and<br />
benefits by both men and women involved in charcoal production, including<br />
raising tree seedlings, and the distribution and marketing process, particularly<br />
at the small-scale community level.<br />
The key issues to address in promoting gender equity in the charcoal sector<br />
include:<br />
• Cultural attitudes and barriers that inhibit women’s participation in decision<br />
making processes at the household and community levels. These barriers<br />
limit women’s access to and control over tree production resources such as<br />
land and labour. They also inhibit women’s ability to use and benefit from tree<br />
resources. For instance, due to the prevailing land tenure system in many<br />
Kenyan communities land is traditionally owned by men. Women have user<br />
rights to land but these rights are often determined by husbands or male<br />
relatives. This inhibits women’s access to land and water <strong>for</strong> tree production.<br />
Similarly, women have limited access to tree tenure.<br />
• Access to financial resources and credit <strong>for</strong> charcoal entrepreneurship<br />
determines the level of men and women’s participation in the charcoal sector.<br />
Land is often used as collateral <strong>for</strong> loan facilities. Lack of land ownership<br />
there<strong>for</strong>e limits women’s ability to access credit <strong>for</strong> investing in charcoal<br />
enterprise.<br />
• Gender roles and responsibilities at the community and household levels,<br />
which determine the division of labour thus impacting on men’s and women’s<br />
relationship to natural resources, e.g. access to labour <strong>for</strong> tree growing,<br />
charcoal production and marketing.<br />
Strategies <strong>for</strong> promoting gender equity in the charcoal sector include:<br />
• Awareness raising and in<strong>for</strong>mation sharing on the need <strong>for</strong> gender equity as a<br />
vital component of sustainable tree management <strong>for</strong> charcoal production;<br />
• Lobby and advocacy at the community and national levels to increase<br />
women’s access to and control over tree and charcoal production resources;<br />
• Establishment of small-scale revolving funds and credit facilities <strong>for</strong> charcoal<br />
producers to support resource poor farmers, especially women.<br />
18 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 19
References<br />
Barklund, E. and Palmstiema, M. (2005). <strong>Charcoal</strong> production and processing<br />
in Kenya: opportunities <strong>for</strong> improving supply. A RELMA and KEFRI Report.<br />
ESDA -Energy <strong>for</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> Development Africa (2005). National <strong>Charcoal</strong><br />
Survey: Exploring the potential <strong>for</strong> a sustainable charcoal industry in Kenya. A<br />
product of the Kenya <strong>Charcoal</strong> Working Group. June 2005. Pgs 74<br />
Delahunty, A. (2011). Gender Equity, <strong>Charcoal</strong> and the Value Chain in Western<br />
Kenya. PISCES Working Brief. Centre <strong>for</strong> African Studies, University of<br />
Edinburgh.<br />
ENERGIA – Kenya Network (2012). National Training Workshop on<br />
Mainstreaming Gender in Energy Projects in Kenya. Workshop Report. Practical<br />
Action East Africa Regional Office.<br />
FAO Forestry Paper 63, (1985). Industrial <strong>Charcoal</strong> Making. Mechanical Wood<br />
Products Branch, Forest Industries Division. Food and Agriculture Organisation<br />
(FAO) Forestry Department. FAO UN Rome 1985. www.fao.org/docrep<br />
Hines D.A. and Eckman, K. 1993). Indigenous multipurpose trees of Tanzania:<br />
uses and economic benefits <strong>for</strong> people. ISBN 0-9697075-0-9<br />
http://agritech.tnau.ac.in/seed_certification<br />
http://www.kefri.org/seed.aspx<br />
Jurvélius, M. (1997). Labour-intensive harvesting of tree plantations in the<br />
southern Philippines. Forest Harvesting Case-Study 9. Food and Agriculture<br />
Organization of The United Nations Bangkok, Thailand, 1997 http://www.fao.org/<br />
docrep/x5596E/x5596e00.htm#Contents<br />
Kareko, K. K. and Githiomi, J. (2000). National Arrangements and Capacity to<br />
Collect Wood Energy In<strong>for</strong>mation and Statistics: The Kenyan Scenario. Paper<br />
presented at FAO/UNEP Regional Workshop on Wood Energy In<strong>for</strong>mation in<br />
Africa, 23rd – 27th October, 2000 in Nairobi, Kenya.<br />
KEFRI (2010). Revised Seed Catalogue: Kenya Forestry Seed Centre. KEFRI Leaflet.<br />
KEFRI (2006). <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> using Improved Earth, Portable Metal, Drum<br />
and Casamance Kilns. KEFRI, Forest Products Research Centre, Karura.<br />
Maua, J., and Ngazi, J. (2009). Growing Acacia xanthophloea and Acacia<br />
polyacantha <strong>for</strong> charcoal in Madiany Division, Siaya County. A KEFRI Report.<br />
Mugo, F. and Ong, C. (2006). Lessons of eastern Africa’s unsustainable charcoal<br />
trade. ICRAF Working Paper no. 20. Nairobi, Kenya. World Agro<strong>for</strong>estry Centre<br />
Muok, B.O., Kimondo, J., and Omondi, W. (2007). Dryland Forestry Handbook<br />
<strong>for</strong> Kenya (2nd Edition). KEFRI.140p.<br />
Oduor, N. (2005). Calorific values of species as wood fuel and charcoal. A KEFRI<br />
Report.<br />
Republic of Kenya (2002). Study on Kenya’s Energy Demand, Supply and Policy<br />
Strategy <strong>for</strong> Households, Small Scale Industries and Service Establishments.<br />
Ministry of Energy, Nairobi, Kenya. Report submitted by KAMFOR Company<br />
Limited. September 2002. Pgs 133.<br />
Shanmughavel P. and Francis, K. (2001). Bioproductivity and nutrient<br />
cycling in bamboo and acacia plantation <strong>for</strong>ests. Bio-resource Technology,<br />
Volume 80 Issue1. October 2001, Pages 45-48, ISSN 0960-8524, 10.1016/<br />
S0960-8524(01)00060-8. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/<br />
S0960852401000608)<br />
State of Environment (2004). State of Environment Report. National<br />
Environment <strong>Management</strong> Authority, Kenya.www.nema.go.ke<br />
Theuri, K. (2002). Woodfuel Policy and Legislation in Kenya. A paper presented<br />
during the Regional Workshop on Woodfuel Policy and Legislation held at ICRAF,<br />
Nairobi, Kenya.<br />
20 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 21
Appendices<br />
Appendix 1:<br />
List of KEFRI Regional Centres and Sub Centres<br />
Regional Centres Sub-Centres Centre Director/<br />
Officer in Charge<br />
Telephone<br />
Contacts<br />
Muguga Mr E. Mwanza 0722-157414<br />
0724-259781/2<br />
0722-157414<br />
0722-386677<br />
Nyeri Dr. J. Lelon 0715-786844<br />
Karura Dr. J. Githiomi 020-2011628<br />
020-2011629<br />
0733-764726<br />
0722-496795<br />
Kitui Dr. N. Kamiri 044-22311<br />
044-22626<br />
0722-983238<br />
Kibwezi Mr. D. Muchiri 0721-700352<br />
Garissa Mr. B. Kigwa 0722-427231<br />
Bura Mr. Kimondo 0735-333809<br />
Londiani Dr. J Cheboiwo 052-64028<br />
0722-464469<br />
Marigat Mr. M. Welimo 0720-531655<br />
Turbo Mr. W. Atie 0722-480506<br />
Lodwar Mr. S. Ndungu 0720-143776<br />
Maseno Dr. R. Nyambati 0573-51164<br />
0713-687975<br />
Kakamega Mr. J. Maua 0721-601497<br />
Ramogi Mr. G. Wasonga 0729-779478<br />
Kuja River Mr. Ajuka 0726-561105<br />
Gede Mr. T. Mbuvi 0202386358<br />
0722-809951<br />
E-mail &<br />
Postal Address<br />
cdmuguga@kefri.org<br />
P.O. Box<br />
20412,00200,<br />
Nairobi<br />
cdkarura@kefri.org<br />
P.O. Box<br />
64636-00620,Mobil<br />
Plaza,<br />
Nairobi<br />
cdkitui@kefri.org<br />
P.O. Box 892, Kitui<br />
cdlondiani@kefri.org<br />
P.O. Box 382,<br />
Londiani<br />
cdgede@kefri.org<br />
P. 0. Box 1078-<br />
80200,<br />
Malindi<br />
Appendix 2:<br />
List of KEFRI Approved <strong>Tree</strong> Seed Stockists<br />
Company & Address Contact Person Telephone No.<br />
1 Kenya Farmers Association (KFA)<br />
P.O. Box 353, Kisii<br />
2 Alpha Agrovet<br />
P.O. Box 402, Othaya<br />
3 Maliki Agrovet<br />
P.O. Box 612, Njoro<br />
4 Menengai Agrovet<br />
P.O. Box 360, Nakuru<br />
5 Science Products<br />
P.O. Box 4946, Kisumu<br />
6 Greenland Agro<strong>for</strong>estry Nursery<br />
P.O. Box 1197, Thika<br />
7 Zayuni Farmcare<br />
P.O. Box 70, Shimba Hills<br />
8 Kinango Farm Care<br />
P.O. Box 70, Kinango<br />
9 Kiboko Forestry and Wildlife Reserves Glitd.<br />
P.O. Box 12 Machakos<br />
10 Suba Green Forest Initiative,<br />
P.O. Box 111-40100, Kisumu<br />
11 Snow Agrovet,<br />
P.O. Box 309, Kitui<br />
12 Adindi <strong>Tree</strong> Seeds & Organic Gardening Supplies<br />
P.O. Box 2383, Kisumu<br />
13 Sifuyo Youth Empowerment Centre,<br />
P.O. Box 31, Ukwala<br />
14 Kithimani Agrovet<br />
P.O. Box 1356, Kitui<br />
15 Atlas Pharmaceuticals<br />
P.O. Box 1507 Ukunda<br />
Mr. Yona Orao &<br />
Mr. Isaiah Otieno<br />
0721231238<br />
0725237654<br />
Mr. Justus Mukere 0721897380<br />
Mr. Harens Chazima 0712973398 or<br />
0723236804<br />
Mr. Zadock Munala 0724851302 or<br />
0512214087<br />
Mr. Moses M. Oduor 0721250752<br />
Mr. Charles Nyanjui 0728480907<br />
22 <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> <strong>Sustainable</strong> <strong>Tree</strong> <strong>Management</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Charcoal</strong> <strong>Production</strong> 23<br />
Mr. Titus M.<br />
Mutonga<br />
Ms. Anyango<br />
Blandina Mukhwasi<br />
0721905236<br />
0727121398 or<br />
0736830594<br />
Major Charles Masai 722807907<br />
Mr. Julius Aduwo 0725636337<br />
Mr. Titus M. Katheke 0717168496<br />
0710817504<br />
Ms. Beatrice<br />
Odhiambo<br />
Mr. Stephen O.<br />
Awour<br />
0735535268<br />
0714808397<br />
0701008374<br />
Mr. Tommy M. Muli 0725548742<br />
0711227770<br />
Ms Judith Mumbua<br />
Kitusa<br />
0722480012
KEFRI’s mandate is to conduct research in <strong>for</strong>estry,<br />
collaborate with other research bodies within and outside<br />
Kenya carrying out similar research, liaise with other<br />
organisations and institutions of higher learning in training<br />
on matters of <strong>for</strong>estry research, and disseminate research<br />
findings. Its mission is to enhance the social and economic<br />
welfare of Kenyans through user-oriented research <strong>for</strong><br />
sustainable development of <strong>for</strong>ests and allied natural<br />
resources. www.kefri.org<br />
Practical Action Consulting is the dynamic consulting<br />
arm of international development and technology charity<br />
Practical Action. Sharing over 40 years of international<br />
expertise, Practical Action Consulting provides<br />
independent and professional consulting in the use of<br />
technology <strong>for</strong> poverty reduction to governments, NGOs,<br />
aid agencies and the private sector.<br />
www.practicalaction.org/consulting<br />
KFS is a public institution established under the Forests<br />
Act, 2005, with a mandate to contribute to the growth of<br />
the natural resource sector by enhancing development,<br />
conservation and management of all <strong>for</strong>est resources<br />
in Kenya. Among other activities, the Service promotes<br />
community involvement in <strong>for</strong>est conservation and<br />
management through Community Forest Associations,<br />
licensing of various activities and ventures, and<br />
conservancy management. www.kenya<strong>for</strong>estservice.org<br />
Through action research, the PISCES project is contributing<br />
to innovation and providing new policy-relevant knowledge<br />
on bioenergy – leading to better practices and widening<br />
energy access to the rural poor in East Africa and South<br />
Asia. It is the energy Research Programme Consortium<br />
funded by the UK’s DFID, whose members include ACTS<br />
(lead), Kenya; PAC-UK, Eastern Africa, and Sri Lanka; the<br />
University of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania; M.S. Swaminathan<br />
Research Foundation, India; and the University of<br />
Edinburgh, UK. For more in<strong>for</strong>mation contact project<br />
manager Bernard O. Muok at b.muok@acts.or.ke and visit<br />
www.pisces.or.ke