This initially unpromising title belies its real value, as anyone who
is familiar with lichenicolous fungi will discover. There have been a
number of keys to, and compilations on, lichenicolous fungi published
over the past twenty years that have brought this overlooked field to
a wider audience (HAWKSWORTH, 1983; CLAUZADE, DIEDERICH & ROUX,
1989). These works have not been able to deal with the many
uncertainties in taxonomic position of the species and it has been
HAFELLNER and his team in Graz that have steadily resolved a large
number of these problematic taxa. The present work is another
excellent, thorough and invaluable contribution. It is probably best
summarized by the authors themselves when they describe the study as a
`revision of the lichenicolous pyrenomycetes with hyaline, non-septate
ascospores'.
Introductory material is brief: there is an outline of the taxonomic
problems surrounding the lichenicolous taxa assigned to these genera,
most of whose species are not associated with lichens, as well as a
history of the usage of these genera. This is followed by a fairly
detailed discussion of the taxonomic characters and their value, the
ecology and host specificity of the species treated in the revision.
The taxonomic part includes a survey of the orders in which the
treated taxa are included, following the classification provided by
Edn 8 of the Dictionary of the Fungi. A key is provided to all known
non-lichenized lichenicolous fungi with a hyaline or dark pigmented
excipulum and hyaline, aseptate ascospores. This does not include all
the species covered in the work, e.g. Lichenochora aprica and
Zwackhiomyces calcariae, for these are 1-septate; it also includes one
genus, Sarcopyrenia, which is not mentioned again by the authors. A
useful feature of the key is that significant characters are
underlined. This is followed by accounts of the thirteen genera
included: Biciliopsis, Guignardia, Gyrophthorus, Physalospora and
Thamnogalla are covered briefly and the remainder are dealt with in
more detail.
The first and unsurprising result is that neither Guignardia nor
Physalospora is considered to contain any lichenicolous taxa: both
these genera are more plant-pathogenic or found on substrata more
typical of fungi. The lichenicolous species formerly assigned to these
genera are now distributed across seven genera including one new to
science, Telogalla. There is a useful discussion on the systematic
position of the parasite of Thamnolia Thamnogalla which concludes
that it seems closest to the Stictidaceae in the Ostropales. However,
the authors do not propose this definitively. One of the longstanding
uncertainties mentioned above is the genus Paralaestadia, for which
the authors establish the correct author citation, `(Sacc. & D. Sacc.)
Vain.' and typify it on Verrucaria verrucicola Wedd. This does,
though, have a peculiar consequence in that this species was never
formally combined into the genus Paralaestadia, but this is possible
under the ICBN. The other consequence is that, based on the authors'
examination of Verrucaria verrucicola Wedd., Paralaestadia is
identical to Lichenochora and, as such, becomes an earlier
synonym. They have rightly proposed the conservation of the latter
name. The other species in Paralaestadia, P. fimbriatae Vain., is
found to be identical to the coelomycete Lichenosticta alcicornaria,
and thus the authors effectively dispose of any lingering doubts over
the value of the genus.
The status of Obryzum and, up till now, its single species,
O. corniculatum, has never been clear and it has been regarded as
somewhat anomalous. In the present work not only is the genus accepted
but a new species, O. friesii, is added and its distinctness confirmed
by the retention of the family Obryzaceae. They reject Eriksson's view
that the genus should be placed in the Gnomoniaceae since the asci of
Obryzum lack the chitinoid ring in the ascus apex that is
characteristic of the latter family. The genus Telogalla is here
introduced for a gall-forming lichenicolous fungus that occurs on
Xanthoria parietina. This is established for Guignardia olivieri and
is placed in the Verrucariaceae, on the face of it, perhaps, an
unexpected position but the hyaline exciple is, as the authors point
out, not that unusual a feature in the family. Also unexpected is the
transfer of one Physalospora species to Zwackhiomyces, a
lichenicolous, dothidealean genus with 1-septate ascospores. HOFFMAN &
HAFELLNER have broadened the definition of the genus to include
species with aseptate (or usually aseptate) ascospores since in all
other respects Physalospora lecanorae is consistent with
Zwackhiomyces.
Even within the section on excluded taxa the surprises continue, with
the lichenicolous `Laestadia' conductrix and `Laestadia' solorinae
being transferred to Epibryon, a genus mainly containing bryicolous
fungi. The detailed discussion associated with these species explains
the biological and morphological reasons for these transfers.
The revision is completed with references and an index to taxa (not
entirely complete as there is no entry for Spolverinia, for
instance). It is well illustrated with some fine line-drawings and a
set of micrographs of variable quality at the back. It should be said,
however, that these are notoriously difficult organisms to section.
As the title suggests, this work is entirely in German except for a
summary in English, but because it is a valuable contribution, for
those interested in lichenicolous fungi it is well worth making the
effort to read it.
J.C. David
Bibliography of Systematic Mycology vol. 7