Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ruth KIEW
Forest Research Institute Malaysia,
52109 Kepong, Selangor (Malaysia)
ruth@frim.gov.my
Kiew R. 2007. — Notes on Vietnamese Begonia (Begoniaceae), including three new species.
Adansonia, sér. 3, 29 (2) : 229-238.
Abstract
Several extra-Vietnamese names have been misapplied to Vietnamese Begonia
species. For those included by Gagnepain in Flore générale de l’Indo-Chine, Be-
gonia aptera is B. acetosella Craib and B. rex is B. sizemoreae Kiew; B. rupicola and
B. wallichiana are new species, here named B. phamiana Kiew and B. glutinosa
Key words Kiew, respectively. Four included by Hô. in Cây Cô Viêt Nam whose identity
Begoniaceae, cannot be verified, namely, B. decora, B. grandis, B. martabanica and B. masoni-
Begonia,
Vietnam, ana are excluded from the checklist of begonias from Vietnam. Begonia poilanei
new species. Kiew, a striking new species with ornamental potential, is also described.
Résumé
Notes sur les Begonia (Begoniaceae) du Vietnam, incluant trois nouvelles espèces.
Plusieurs noms de taxons non vietnamiens ont été utilisés de façon erronée
pour des Begonia vietnamiens. Concernant les espèces inclues par Gagnepain
dans la Flore générale de l’Indo-Chine, Begonia aptera est B. acetosella Craib et
B. rex est B. sizemoreae Kiew ; B. rupicola et B. wallichiana sont de nouvelles
espèces, nommées ici B. phamiana Kiew et B. glutinosa Kiew, respectivement.
Mots clés Concernant les espèces inclues par Hô. dans Cây Cô Viêt Nam, B. decora,
Begoniaceae, B. grandis, B. martabanica et B. masoniana sont exclues de la liste des bégonias
Begonia,
Vietnam, du Vietnam. Begonia poilanei Kiew, une nouvelle espèce ayant un potentiel
espèces nouvelles. ornemental est décrite.
ADANSONIA, sér. 3 • 2007 • 29 (2) © Publications Scientifiques du Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle, Paris. www.adansonia.com 229
Kiew R.
Hô., Cây Cô Viêt Nam. 1: 743, fig. 2065 (1991), Cây slightly rhomboid in outline, 12-16 × 12-13 mm,
Cô Viêt Nam. 1: 588, fig. 2351 (1999). densely downy, styles 3, free, bifurcating and lyre-
Species in fructu Begonia bonii Gagnep. optime congruens, sed shaped, spirally twisted at the apex. Fruits downy,
habitu erecto (nec rhizomato), foliis minoribus 4-8 × 3‑5 cm oval in outline, 12-16 × 12-13 mm; wings 3, equal,
(nec 7-11 × 5-7 cm) et inflorescentiis brevioribus 2-3 cm 3-4 mm wide or sometimes slightly unequal with
longis (nec usque 20 cm) differt. Sect. Reichenheimia. the longer wing c. 5 mm wide, very thinly fibrous
Typus. —Vietnam, Lang Son (Massif du Cai Kinh, route with a conspicuous network of veins, locules 3,
de Thanh-moi au col de Dao-ben), 5.X.1917, Bois s.n. placentas 1 per locule with two short side branches,
(serres du Muséum) (holo-, P barcode P00539150; iso-, dehiscing between the locules and wings.
P barcodes P00539151, P00539152).
Other material examined. — Vietnam. Lang Son Remarks
(Thanh Moi), 18.VII.1916, Bois s. n. (P). The name “Begonia wallichiana” has had a tortuous
history and is in fact correctly applied to a Brazilian
Description species (Doorenbos 1975). The Himalayan species
Annual, cane-like herb densely covered in downy to which this name was also applied is now cor-
viscid hairs on stems, petioles, lower leaf surface, rectly known as B. minicarpa H.Hara (Hara 1972),
upper and lower surface of the midrib and veins, but the latter species bears no resemblance to the
inflorescences and pedicels, in the dried state appear- Vietnamese one. It is a small begonia that grows to
ing minutely and densely pubescent. Rhizome short, 22 cm tall, has lanceolate triangular leaves attenu-
erect stems to 50 cm tall, robust and 3-6 mm thick, ate to the apex with a short petiole to 2 cm long.
internodes 2.5-5.2 cm long, nodes constricted, pale The capsule too is small (to 4 mm long) and it has
green, becoming reddish; branches c. 4.5 cm long, unequal wings, the larger 4-5 mm wide and the
pale green, zigzag. Stipules caducous, lanceolate, smaller two 2-3 mm wide. The Vietnamese taxon
c. 2 mm long. Leaves oblique; petioles 3-7 cm long; is clearly not this species. It is a new species.
laminas more or less asymmetric, broadly ovate, This is a very distinct species by the combination
4‑8 × 3-5 cm, basal lobe c. 2 cm long, bright green of its cane-like habit, its relatively small leaves and
above, pale beneath, base cordate, margin shallowly fruits with three more or less equal, rounded wings.
dentate-crenate, apex shortly acuminate; venation It is the only Vietnamese begonia reported to have
palmate-pinnate with 2 pairs of veins at the base, 2 viscid hairs, hence the species epithet. The type
pairs along the midrib and 2 veins in the basal lobe, was grown from seed collected by D. Bois from
veins very fine, in dried state scarcely prominent “Cai Kin route de Thanh-moi au col de Deo-ben”
beneath. Inflorescences axillary, cymose, 2-3 cm in December 1908 (last digit not clearly legible).
long, erect, few-flowered (with up to 3 male flowers Among the Vietnamese species with short stems
and one female flower), protandrous, male flowers to 50 cm tall that are not succulent (i.e. that ex-
above, with a single female flower below; peduncle cludes species in sect. Parvibegonia), it superficially
downy. Bracts like the stipules, lanceolate, 1-3.5 × resembles Begonia boisiana Gagnep., but its leaves
1.5 mm long. Flowers pale pink, pedicels 5-20 mm are much more oblique and unequal and, more
long. Male flowers with pedicels 10-15 mm long, importantly, it differs in its fruits that have three
tepals 4, outer two oval, c. 8 × 7 mm, outside downy equal wings (in B. boisiana they are conspicuously
with viscid hairs; the interior two narrowly obo- unequal). In addition, Gagnepain (1921) consid-
vate-linear, c. 5 × 3 mm, androphore c. 1 mm long, ered differences in stigma morphology important
stamens c. 20, filaments longer than the anthers, – his B. wallichiana has lyre-shaped stigmas while
anthers elliptic, c. 1 mm long, locules lateral, not B. boisiana has suborbicular ones. Begonia boisiana,
reaching the top of the connective. Female flow- which has fruits with three locules each with two
ers with pedicels 7‑12 mm long, tepals 5, slightly placentas, belongs to sect. Petermannia.
glandular outside, 5-6 × 2.5-3.5 mm, the inner In its fruits with three equal wings, three locules
ones smaller than the outer ones; ovary orbicular or each with a single placenta, it falls within sect.
B A
Fig. 1. — Begonia glutinosa Kiew: A, habit; B, male flower; C, stigmas; D, transverse section of fruit. Bois s.n. Scale bars: A, B, 15 mm;
D, 5 mm.
have been H.H.Pham based on his family name, This group of succulent begonias in sect. Parvi
Pham – hence the species epithet. However, for begonia includes extremely variable species, which
the sake of consistency in the scientific literature, vary both within a lifetime and between populations
he is cited as Hô. in the text and as the scientific (Kiew [2005] has detailed this for Begonia integri
authority. folia Dalziell and B. variabilis Ridl. in Malaysia).
The Vietnamese species in this section do not appear of B. rex (the difference in leaf shape between these
to be either common or widespread. For example, two species is clearly shown in Tebbitt 2005: pl. 89),
B. integrifolia, a widespread species distributed from and that have a very hairy leaf margin, hairy upper
India to Peninsular Malaysia, in Vietnam is known surface of the lamina with hairs 5-10 mm long and
only from Bà Ria-Vung Tâu, Mont Dinh (Pierre have conspicuous deep crimson tertiary venation in
s.n., P), Ban Hoa, Mont Chua (Pierre s.n., P) and the centre and outer part of the lower leaf surface – this
Île de Khon, Me Kong (Thorel s.n., P). last feature can be seen even in the dried leaf.
Begonia phamiana is readily distinguished from Balansa 3765 is a well-grown specimen (its laminas
Vietnamese specimens of B. integrifolia, the other measure 14 × 14.5 cm), which necessitates some
species in sect. Parvibegonia in Vietnam with asym- modification to the original description in Kiew
metric leaves, by its narrower laminas up to 11 × (2004) and also enables description of the fruit.
5.5 cm (compared with broadly ovate laminas 6‑7 × The ratio of petiole to lamina length is variable,
6-6.5 cm in B. integrifolia) and the attenuated leaf i.e. longer or shorter than the lamina and there
apex (compared with the broadly acute one in is also variation in whether the basal lobes of the
B. integrifolia). It is in fact more similar to B. geoffrayi lamina overlap or not (this can vary even on the
from Cambodia in leaf shape (narrowly ovate with same plant); and the inflorescence is either mono-
an attenuate apex), except that B. geoffrayi has much chasial or dichasial (the latter is seen in the Balansa
larger leaves (up to 18.5 × 10 cm) and the capsule specimen that has four fruits on a single infructes-
wings are pointed and the longest is up to 11 mm cence). These characters therefore cannot be used
long, compared with the rounded ones of B. phami- to distinguish B. sizemoreae from B. rex.
ana, where the longest wing is c. 7 mm long. The fruit is the typical splash cup of sect. Platy-
According to label data, this species flowers and centrum: the capsules are (8-)15-18 mm long and
fruits in June, July and August. (23-)30-37 mm wide with pedicels 13-20 mm long
and the large fibrous wing is 17-25 mm wide and
Distribution the two shorter, thinner wings (5-)7-9 mm wide.
Cambodia (Île du Pic) and South Vietnam (Bà The tips of the wings are rounded.
Ria-Vung Tâu [Île de Côn Dao]). Begonia sizemoreae is one of the most beautiful
Vietnamese begonias and it is becoming popular
Habitat in cultivation (Kiew 2004). Hô. (1991, 1999) cor-
Locally common, in shaded, humid conditions rectly noted Begonia rex Putz. only as cultivated in
below the tree canopy, on soil with humus, close Vietnam. Begonia rex should therefore be excluded
to the river bed. from the list of indigenous Vietnamese species.
Distribution
4. Begonia sizemoreae Kiew Endemic in Vietnam, known only from Hà Tây
(Mont Ba Vi).
Gardens Bulletin Singapore 56: 95 (2004).
Begonia rex auct. non Putz.: Gagnepain in Lecomte, Flore B. Names excluded from the begonia flora
générale de l’Indo-Chine 2: 1112 (1921). of Vietnam
Remarks Begonia decora auct. non Stapf: Hô., Cây Cô Viêt Nam
1: 579, fig. 2314 (1999).
Gagnepain (1921) based his description of Begonia
rex on Balansa 3765 (P). This specimen is typical of
B. sizemoreae in its leaves that have densely hairy peti- Remarks
oles and laminas that are more rounded than those Hô. (1999) recorded Begonia decora from Vietnam
but did not cite a specimen or locality. Begonia decora Hô.’s drawing was based comprises a single detached
is a narrow endemic confined to a few mountains leaf and infructescence, which is too incomplete to
peaks in Peninsular Malaysia (Kiew 2005). It is identify with certainty.
extremely unlikely to occur in Vietnam. This spe-
cies should therefore be excluded from the begonia
flora of Vietnam. Because Hô. does not cite speci- 4. Begonia masoniana Irmsch.
mens, it is not possible to know what he meant
by this taxon. Begonia masoniana auct. non Irmsch.: Hô. (B. “massoni-
ana”), Cây Cô Viêt Nam 1: 584, fig. 2333 (1999).
thick, covered in a network of fibrous roots. Leaves stem and produces one or two broadly ovate leaves,
one per plant, sometimes two, not oblique; peti- a basal tuber, and fruits with three unequal wings.
oles densely hairy when young, 6.5‑12 cm long, Begonia poilanei differs from B. sinuata in its larger
slender to 2 mm diam. in the dried state; laminas leaves with a cordate base and in its uniseriate hairs.
symmetric, broadly ovate, 6.5-14.5 × 7-17 cm, in In contrast, B. sinuata has leaves up to 8 × 8 cm
the dried state with a conspicuous reddish band with a rounded or truncate base and its hairs are
c. 3-5 mm wide along the secondary and tertiary stellate. Among Vietnamese begonias, stellate hairs
veins, with scattered uniseriate hairs 0.75-1 mm are unique to B. sinuata. Begonia sinuata belongs to
long, thinly papery in the dried state, base equal, sect. Parvibegonia and has ovaries with two locules
cordate, sinus wide, basal lobes 1.75-4 cm long, each with two placentas.
margin denticulate and ciliate, apex shortly acumi- Begonia harmandii Gagnep. is also similar in habit
nate, acumen to 7.5 mm long, venation palmate in that it is stemless and has tubers and sometimes
with 4 pairs of veins, tertiary veins conspicuous and has only one leaf. However, it differs in its oblique
perpendicular or at 45° to the secondary veins, on leaf that is longer than wide, its inflorescences that
the lower surface secondary veins with uniseriate are racemose and its fruits with three equal, hairy,
hairs c. 3-4 mm long and even the smallest veins rounded wings. It is placed in sect. Reichenheimia
with hairs 1-1.5 mm long, in the dried state veins on account of its single placenta per locule.
slightly impressed above and slightly prominent be- Begonia poilanei that has a three-locular ovary with
neath. Flowers not known. Infructescences axillary, two placentas per locule belongs to sect. Diploclin-
cymose panicles, erect, above the leaves, 12‑26 cm ium and conforms to the Doorenbos et al. (1998)
long, peduncles 11.5-23 cm long, branching 3 Group III of this section in the plant being tuber-
or 4 times, distally with up to 4 fruits. Bract pair ous, having a reduced stem with one or two sym-
ovate, c. 2 × 1 mm, persistent. Fruits with slender metric leaves, an axillary inflorescence and styles
hair-like pedicels 12-14 mm long, capsules 6-12 × persisting in the fruit. Begonia cavaleriei H.Lév. is
16‑23 mm, glabrous, wings 3, unequal, thinly fi- the only other Vietnamese begonia in this section
brous, dehiscing between the locules and wings, but it differs in having peltate leaves.
longer wing 10-13 mm wide, slightly falcate and Two specimens, one from Cambodia (Martin
tapering to a point, smaller two wings rounded, M244, P, sterile) and the other from Thailand (Larsen
sometimes broadly acute, 4-5 mm wide, locules et al. 1003, P, with male and female flowers) are
3, placentas 2 per locule, styles 3, free to base, very similar to B. poilanei in having one symmetric
bifid, branches lyre-shaped and spirally twisted, ovate leaf with the same dimensions, coloration and
1.5-2 mm long, persistent. Seeds broadly barrel- indumentum. They differ in that both these speci-
shaped, c. 0.25 mm long, collar cells c. ¾ of the mens have leaves with the base without a wide sinus,
seed length. the margin being deeply serrate, the apex strongly
acuminate with an acumen to 2 cm long, and the
Remarks venation being palmate-pinnate. The fertile Thai
As Poilane noted on the herbarium label, this is a specimen has a similar inflorescence and ovary, the
very pretty plant (“très jolie”) with foliage as attrac- latter with unequal, thinly fibrous wings, the longer
tive as any in cultivation. He described the leaves one being slightly falcate, and with three styles with
as tawny brown along the veins against a green lyre-shaped branches. However, the Thai specimen
background and being darker green beneath, the has one placenta per locule, which would place it
peduncles are sable yellow with flowers varying in sect. Reichenheimia; in contrast, B. poilanei, has
from pale to bright pink. two placentas per locule and so belongs to sect.
Very few Asian begonias have symmetric, non- Diploclinium (though one placenta may be poorly
oblique leaves. The only one in Vietnam is Begonia developed). Until more material from these three
sinuata Wall. ex Meisn., which in common with countries is available, it is uncertain whether they
this new species is stemless or has only a very short belong to one or two taxa. Presently, B. poilanei is
Fig. 2. — Begonia poilanei Kiew: A, habit; B, fruit with persistent stigmas; C, transverse section of fruit. Poilane 19824. Scale bars:
A, 15 mm; B, 3 mm; C, 2 mm.